YouTube2Text

Jacek Bartosiak & zespół S&F o wojennym przemówieniu premiera Tuska w Sejmie i perspektywie wojny — Transcript

by Strategy&Future · 9,107 words · 1,477 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:16I encourage you to read my latest text
  2. 0:18on Strategy and Future and to read the
  3. 0:20Weekly Brief, which we publish every
  4. 0:22Saturday. You can find the link to the
  5. 0:24texts in the video description. Good
  6. 0:37morning. Good morning, or actually good
  7. 0:39evening, as I am recording this on
  8. 0:41Thursday evening, September 17, 2026.
  9. 0:43This is Jacek Bartosiak, Strategy and
  10. 0:45Future. With me are the team: Albert
  11. 0:47Świdziński, Marek Stefan, and Marek
  12. 0:49Budzisz. Hello, gentlemen.
  13. 0:51Good morning. We are recording this one
  14. 0:53day before publication. On the day that
  15. 0:57Prime Minister Donald Tusk gave a
  16. 0:59speech in the Sejm regarding the risk
  17. 1:01of escalation, conflict, or effectively
  18. 1:03dragging Poland into a war, be it
  19. 1:05hybrid or otherwise. He did not rule
  20. 1:09out the possibility of a drone and
  21. 1:10missile attack on the territory of the
  22. 1:12Republic. He suggested, or according to
  23. 1:14some, even said it outright. It depends
  24. 1:16on how you listen. I mean, it depends
  25. 1:18on how you listen, that intelligence
  26. 1:20services from various countries are
  27. 1:22presenting him with a consistent
  28. 1:24picture: that Poland and the entire
  29. 1:25eastern flank, meaning states helping
  30. 1:27Ukraine, could be dragged into this
  31. 1:29missile and drone campaign. Especially
  32. 1:31since the Russians have gained the
  33. 1:33advantage and want to finish the war.
  34. 1:35Tusk said winter is meant to destroy
  35. 1:37Ukraine, they will strike
  36. 1:38infrastructure, specifically road
  37. 1:40crossings, cutting Ukraine off from its
  38. 1:42strategic depth and rear support. So we
  39. 1:45must be mentally prepared. Every Pole
  40. 1:47must be prepared for the fact that
  41. 1:49things could go various ways. He
  42. 1:50suggested it directly, right? Services,
  43. 1:52the military, the alliance, and so on,
  44. 1:55and so forth. And so, many things and
  45. 1:57questions arise that I would like to
  46. 1:59ask. This time I will brief the matter
  47. 2:05because, with the Polish state framing
  48. 2:07the issue this way, a whole range of
  49. 2:09strategic questions will immediately
  50. 2:11arise, the answers to which will
  51. 2:12determine what happens next regarding
  52. 2:14our relations with the North Atlantic
  53. 2:16Alliance and the Baltic states. Here,
  54. 2:21Prime Minister Tusk also clearly stated
  55. 2:23that we will stand in solidarity. And
  56. 2:25our relations with Ukraine as well. And
  57. 2:29here, Prime Minister Tusk also railed
  58. 2:31against those who in any way undermine
  59. 2:33aid to Ukraine or attack Ukraine in any
  60. 2:36way, while also criticizing those who
  61. 2:38believe this is not our war. It was
  62. 2:42truly a speech like one I have never
  63. 2:44heard before. Well, no wonder. We have
  64. 2:47had peace for some 80 years now. I
  65. 2:50really felt...Especially since at
  66. 2:54Strategy and Future we have been
  67. 2:55talking about this for several months
  68. 2:57—and I would like to say this very
  69. 2:59clearly, because in my opinion, our
  70. 3:01elites still do not understand this,
  71. 3:03even if they receive the intelligence
  72. 3:05data—that after what Iran did to the
  73. 3:09Americans, Israel, and American allies
  74. 3:11in the Gulf, it was an obvious
  75. 3:13realization that the Russians
  76. 3:15understood that isolating only the
  77. 3:17Ukrainian-Russian war without the
  78. 3:19threat of horizontal escalation, or
  79. 3:21through a scalable threat of horizontal
  80. 3:23escalation, put Russia in a difficult
  81. 3:25wartime situation. That is why it has
  82. 3:27been struggling with this war for so
  83. 3:29many years, right? And it is also
  84. 3:31taking hits. It allowed for the
  85. 3:33building of new technology industries
  86. 3:34in Ukraine, consolidation, and calm
  87. 3:36assistance, even if initially meted out
  88. 3:38like medicine when it came to military
  89. 3:40equipment, and that was a mistake. In
  90. 3:44my opinion, the second factor that
  91. 3:46caused the structure of affairs to
  92. 3:47trend toward the scenario mentioned by
  93. 3:50Prime Minister Tusk is the stance of
  94. 3:51the United States this year. You see,
  95. 3:57the Americans 'flirtation with the
  96. 3:59Russians led to a situation in the
  97. 4:01minds of the Russians—and that is how
  98. 4:03I see it—which led me to the
  99. 4:05conclusions I spoke about a few months
  100. 4:07ago, that the threshold for an Article
  101. 4:095 response and the threshold for
  102. 4:11cohesion is potentially shifted much
  103. 4:13higher than the Russians could have
  104. 4:15feared a year, 2 years, or three years
  105. 4:17ago regarding the alliance's cohesion,
  106. 4:19because the Americans are positioning
  107. 4:21themselves as intermediaries in the
  108. 4:23conflict between Europe and Russia. By
  109. 4:28manipulating Europeans' sense of
  110. 4:29security, they want to be the brokers
  111. 4:32and decide the fate of Europe. In other
  112. 4:35words, American troops have no
  113. 4:37intention of participating in any war,
  114. 4:39provided the Russians scale it down
  115. 4:42accordingly. So, on one hand, it will
  116. 4:45expose the Europeans 'inability to deal
  117. 4:47with a security crisis, but at the same
  118. 4:49time, it will not force the Americans
  119. 4:51into a general war. Yes. For which, by
  120. 4:53the way, they have no appetite, nor the
  121. 4:55forces, nor the ground troops. In other
  122. 4:57words, the Americans, with their
  123. 4:59pilgrimages to Moscow and attempts to
  124. 5:01subordinate Ukraine's interests for the
  125. 5:03sake of a grand deal, have also created
  126. 5:06a structural situation where the
  127. 5:07Russians may be interested, may feel
  128. 5:09they have a green light for a drone and
  129. 5:12missile war of some controlled scale
  130. 5:14and intensity, which will demonstrate
  131. 5:16the weakness of Poland and the Baltic
  132. 5:18states, their inability to respond, and
  133. 5:20will, of course, divide risks and
  134. 5:22cohesion as well. For some, this will
  135. 5:24already be war; for others, it will not
  136. 5:26be war. We will say it already is.
  137. 5:28Those in the West will explain that it
  138. 5:29is not yet. They will call for
  139. 5:31restraint. And the third element. Our
  140. 5:33weakness, that is, poor military
  141. 5:35procurement, a lack of defensive
  142. 5:37capabilities against drones, and a lack
  143. 5:39of our own capabilities to respond via
  144. 5:42deterrence through punishment. Also
  145. 5:44encourages Russia to strike at this
  146. 5:46soft spot. Yes, it is an asymmetrical
  147. 5:48exploitation of the very niche where we
  148. 5:50are weak. It is practically begging for
  149. 5:52it. So, one could say that this is what
  150. 5:55the situation boils down to. Some
  151. 5:56consolation is that the North Atlantic
  152. 5:58Alliance formally exists. Because if it
  153. 6:00didn't exist, and there were only such
  154. 6:02agitated, general moral declarations
  155. 6:04from European leaders that we won't
  156. 6:06allow war in Europe and so on, I would
  157. 6:08be certain that the Russians would do
  158. 6:10it. There is still some uncertainty due
  159. 6:12to the existence of this North Atlantic
  160. 6:14Alliance, and here, for the first time,
  161. 6:16Jacek Bartosiak will say that it is
  162. 6:18very good that it exists, because it
  163. 6:20does complicate the Russians'
  164. 6:22calculations. But here I will move on
  165. 6:25to the second part of the briefing
  166. 6:27before Poland. Very difficult decisions
  167. 6:30, because now, since Prime Minister
  168. 6:32Tusk says so, we should have our own
  169. 6:34reaction scenario. Adopting and
  170. 6:36developing what the reaction to such
  171. 6:38Russian behavior should be is not easy.
  172. 6:41There are no good answers here because,
  173. 6:43well, how can we respond? Well, by
  174. 6:46preventing it. I think that will be
  175. 6:48difficult. Given how poorly Poland has
  176. 6:50managed so far. It might be difficult.
  177. 6:52Well, what about greater industrial
  178. 6:54cooperation with Ukraine so the
  179. 6:56Ukrainians can show us how to defend
  180. 6:57against these drones? Well, firstly,
  181. 6:59it’s late, the hour is late, and
  182. 7:01secondly, the Ukrainians are struggling
  183. 7:03against these new jet ones. And they
  184. 7:05are also struggling against ballistics.
  185. 7:08Well, what else can we do? Well, we can
  186. 7:10ask the alliance. Well, as I said, the
  187. 7:12alliance will not respond through
  188. 7:14deterrence or punishment; it will hold
  189. 7:16us back. We don't have significant
  190. 7:18capabilities ourselves, although
  191. 7:19something will have to be done. Well,
  192. 7:21if, for example, a strike is carried
  193. 7:23out, say 100 drones fly into Poland,
  194. 7:25well, something will have to be done.
  195. 7:28Something will have to be done beyond
  196. 7:30appeals, because every loud appeal will
  197. 7:32only weaken that cohesion, which Prime
  198. 7:34Minister Tusk appealed for. His actual
  199. 7:36actions—that we will pointlessly
  200. 7:38appeal to allies while being unable to
  201. 7:40do anything ourselves, neither
  202. 7:42defending against it nor responding—
  203. 7:44will show the weakness of the alliance
  204. 7:46and the weakness of cohesion every day,
  205. 7:48losing a sense of direction, while the
  206. 7:50Americans still won't cross that
  207. 7:51threshold to enter the war, and the
  208. 7:53role of the Americans will increase.
  209. 7:55This means the Americans will get cards
  210. 7:57they didn't have in talks with the
  211. 7:59Russians. And this is a very dangerous
  212. 8:01situation here. I hope our leaders will
  213. 8:03grasp this, understand that right now
  214. 8:05the role of the Americans is not at all
  215. 8:07helpful for avoiding war in this
  216. 8:09structural setup. And it is a very
  217. 8:11dangerous situation, while at the same
  218. 8:13time the Polish state is objectively
  219. 8:15unprepared, yet it must have some
  220. 8:17strategies. I am curious about your
  221. 8:19opinion. Maybe let's have a
  222. 8:21brainstorming session too. What should
  223. 8:23this strategy be? Should we respond
  224. 8:25adequately and proportionally, or not?
  225. 8:27Should we coordinate with Ukraine and
  226. 8:29respond? Maybe, um, what is it, what
  227. 8:32can be taken? Because I will point out
  228. 8:36to you and our listeners: every appeal
  229. 8:38for even more in the event of such a
  230. 8:40strike on Poland, every additional
  231. 8:42appeal from Prime Minister Tusk, from
  232. 8:44our leaders to America or Western
  233. 8:45Europe for some help to get them to do
  234. 8:48something about these Russians, stop
  235. 8:50doing that, it will erode the deterrent
  236. 8:52power of the North Atlantic Alliance
  237. 8:54every day and deepen the security
  238. 8:55crisis even further. Who’s first?
  239. 8:59Marek Budzisz. Please. It seems to me
  240. 9:06that we should pay attention here to a
  241. 9:08few fundamental events that have taken
  242. 9:16place over the last week, which, in my
  243. 9:18opinion, quite fundamentally change the
  244. 9:20strategic map. First of all, we are
  245. 9:26dealing with
  246. 9:27And Marek, I will add, I'm sorry, I'm
  247. 9:29sorry, I rarely do this, but I forgot
  248. 9:31to say important things. And today we
  249. 9:33also had a statement by the Canadian
  250. 9:35Prime Minister, who was distancing
  251. 9:37himself from the United States, wanting
  252. 9:39to, well, in some form, join the
  253. 9:40European Union. This causes the
  254. 9:42Americans to potentially want to teach
  255. 9:44Europe a lesson, that it is unable to
  256. 9:46provide for its own security, and they
  257. 9:48may be interested in letting the
  258. 9:50Russians do something after all. I'm
  259. 9:52sorry, that, that is exactly what I
  260. 9:54wanted to talk about. You beat me to it
  261. 9:56a little bit.
  262. 9:56I'm sorry.
  263. 9:57No worries. No, it's not a race, is it?
  264. 10:01I mean, Trump's peace mission,
  265. 10:05regardless of how we evaluate it, has
  266. 10:08certainly ended in failure. That is the
  267. 10:11first fact. This is evidenced by
  268. 10:16Zelensky's statements, who speaks of
  269. 10:18the impossibility of achieving a
  270. 10:20win-win situation and the still
  271. 10:22unresolved issue of Donbas, which I
  272. 10:24understand as a refusal to withdraw
  273. 10:26Ukrainian forces to the administrative
  274. 10:28line. Such a withdrawal, especially in
  275. 10:32the current situation, where on at
  276. 10:34least two operational directions the
  277. 10:36Ukrainian side is on the offensive,
  278. 10:38would be all the more difficult. But in
  279. 10:41a similar spirit, commanders of
  280. 10:43Ukrainian corps spoke two days ago,
  281. 10:45both Biletsky, Prokopenko, and
  282. 10:48Obolensky. These are people who will
  283. 10:53decide the future of Ukraine at least
  284. 10:55to the same extent as the political
  285. 10:57class. And Biletsky conceptualized this
  286. 11:03Ukrainian theory of victory, saying
  287. 11:05that Ukraine must survive until April,
  288. 11:08and then the chance of victory will
  289. 11:10grow. I am not deciding if he is right;
  290. 11:15I am describing it as a fact. This
  291. 11:19means that if we do not have the
  292. 11:21prospect of a negotiated exit from the
  293. 11:23war, then we have, in turn, an
  294. 11:25escalation prospect, and an escalation
  295. 11:27on the part of the Russian Federation.
  296. 11:32I wrote a large piece about this, which
  297. 11:34I published on Monday. It actually
  298. 11:38contains all the theses that Prime
  299. 11:40Minister Tusk also mentioned, but I do
  300. 11:42not talk to the Prime Minister.
  301. 11:44Therefore, this is an independent, so
  302. 11:46to speak, assessment. I will reveal the
  303. 11:51material here. I wrote it last Saturday
  304. 11:53, and it was intended for a meeting
  305. 11:55that took place on Monday at the
  306. 11:57National Security Bureau. I could not
  307. 12:01participate in that meeting because I
  308. 12:03was in Zielona Góra, but I wrote the
  309. 12:05material and then published it, because
  310. 12:07I have always maintained and still
  311. 12:09maintain that public opinion must be
  312. 12:11informed, so we will have a high
  313. 12:13probability of an escalation scenario
  314. 12:15on the part of the Russian Federation.
  315. 12:19Because that is how Russia wants to win
  316. 12:21the war, by cutting off Ukraine.
  317. 12:25Meaning we can expect attacks on
  318. 12:27logistics and on critical
  319. 12:32infrastructure, not only in the western
  320. 12:34part of Ukraine but also in neighboring
  321. 12:36countries. I believe that the
  322. 12:38probability of such a scenario is
  323. 12:40significantly higher than before. And
  324. 12:42that is, as it were, the first fact.
  325. 12:45This is the outlook for the current
  326. 12:47winter. The second fact I wanted to
  327. 12:52draw attention to is a fatal strategic
  328. 12:54mistake that occurred recently. This is
  329. 12:57not only a declaration by the Prime
  330. 12:59Minister of Canada, but an enthusiastic
  331. 13:01reaction from the Brussels bureaucracy,
  332. 13:06Ms. von der Leyen, who is not fit for
  333. 13:09the position she holds, regarding this
  334. 13:11kind of proposal for closer ties
  335. 13:13between Canada and the European Union.
  336. 13:18If such an alliance were to occur, it
  337. 13:20would change the security situation of
  338. 13:22the United States. And significantly so
  339. 13:27. And significantly so.
  340. 13:28In a way, in a way...
  341. 13:30It turns out that Canada cannot choose
  342. 13:31its alliances, just like Ukraine.
  343. 13:33Of course it can't. Of course it can't,
  344. 13:37because even the theoretical
  345. 13:38possibility that the paths of Europe,
  346. 13:41broadly understood, and the United
  347. 13:43States will diverge—well, if Canada
  348. 13:45is on the side of the European camp,
  349. 13:47that means the American sanctuary no
  350. 13:49longer exists. Not only in terms of
  351. 13:55vulnerability to missile attacks, but
  352. 13:57also in terms of a land invasion. And
  353. 14:00that is a strategic revolution. The
  354. 14:04Americans certainly will not reconcile
  355. 14:07themselves to such a situation, as if
  356. 14:09three economic "Grossräume"—using
  357. 14:11Carl Schmitt’s terminology, Marek and
  358. 14:13I were just writing a chapter about
  359. 14:15this in our book—were created: the
  360. 14:17Chinese one with its periphery, and the
  361. 14:20American one, where the Americans would
  362. 14:22lose the Canadian-European periphery
  363. 14:24along with Canada, its raw materials,
  364. 14:26and access to the Arctic.
  365. 14:32Of course, therefore, what happened
  366. 14:34this week is essentially...For some
  367. 14:36reason, it was welcomed with joy by the
  368. 14:39European media. It reminds me a bit of
  369. 14:44the joy of a turkey before Sunday
  370. 14:46dinner. And that is because it
  371. 14:53obviously weakens the alliance, the
  372. 14:55Atlantic ties, and creates a temptation
  373. 14:57for the current American political
  374. 14:59class to teach the Europeans a lesson.
  375. 15:04And the third trend, which I consider
  376. 15:06very disturbing. We are, of course,
  377. 15:09dealing with belligerent statements
  378. 15:11from representatives of the Russian
  379. 15:13administration or the ruling camp. We
  380. 15:16had the statement from Patrushev. We
  381. 15:18have a series of very belligerent
  382. 15:20declarations from Lavrov. In his
  383. 15:22message, we also have statements from
  384. 15:24Putin. These are, in my view,
  385. 15:29non-standard statements, and they lead
  386. 15:31me to this observation or conclusion. I
  387. 15:38believe that the Russian political
  388. 15:40elite—because their perception
  389. 15:42matters here, not objective facts,
  390. 15:44meaning how they perceive reality—
  391. 15:46thinks that Europe will continue to
  392. 15:48struggle to save Ukraine, and that this
  393. 15:50attempt at...isolating Ukraine by the
  394. 16:00Russian Federation could lead to an
  395. 16:02increase in European involvement. I
  396. 16:10think that is also how they interpreted
  397. 16:12Minister Sikorski's declaration,
  398. 16:14delivered in Kyiv, regarding the
  399. 16:16superiority of European aviation and
  400. 16:19NATO. I want to draw attention to this,
  401. 16:23which Minister Sikorski actually
  402. 16:25emphasized in a post, I believe today,
  403. 16:28claiming that this advantage is tenfold
  404. 16:30. This directly leads to the thesis
  405. 16:39that the Russians may believe that
  406. 16:41Poles and other Europeans have begun to
  407. 16:43consider the issue of establishing
  408. 16:45no-fly zones in order to build a
  409. 16:47sanctuary in Western Ukraine where the
  410. 16:49civilian population, pushed out of
  411. 16:51major cities by Russian attacks, can
  412. 16:53take shelter. Therefore, I believe that
  413. 17:03the Russians are convinced of an
  414. 17:05escalation readiness on the part of
  415. 17:06European states and, in their typical
  416. 17:08fashion, are thinking, in my opinion,
  417. 17:18of carrying out a preemptive strike,
  418. 17:20which they traditionally treat as a
  419. 17:22form of defense against expected
  420. 17:23aggression. Uh, this makes the entire
  421. 17:29situation a threatening, dangerous, and
  422. 17:32essentially hopeless one. In my view,
  423. 17:40we are facing either greater aggression
  424. 17:42from the Russian Federation if their
  425. 17:44diagnoses are confirmed, or lesser
  426. 17:46aggression if they are not and the
  427. 17:48scenario of isolating Ukraine is
  428. 17:50pursued. Either way, some form of
  429. 17:58escalation from the Russian Federation
  430. 18:00awaits us as a border state, one which
  431. 18:03is essentially key to Ukraine's
  432. 18:04survival. And that is how I interpret
  433. 18:09these statements by Prime Minister Tusk
  434. 18:11. The clear terror displayed by the
  435. 18:15head of our government also leads me to
  436. 18:17assess that he is aware of how poorly
  437. 18:19prepared we are. And I would like to
  438. 18:23draw attention to something that has
  439. 18:24not happened until now. Specifically,
  440. 18:27today an alarm was declared in one of
  441. 18:30the provinces, and sirens wailed in two
  442. 18:32cities, Rzeszów and Lublin. This means
  443. 18:37the authorities themselves already
  444. 18:39assess the situation as much more
  445. 18:41serious, meaning we will be entering,
  446. 18:43step by step, a state of, I would say,
  447. 18:46heightened readiness.
  448. 18:49Well, those sirens you mentioned are
  449. 18:51symbolic in the sense that people
  450. 18:56living in those areas are receiving
  451. 18:58notifications. And what are they
  452. 18:59supposed to do with that notification?
  453. 19:01This perfectly shows the state of,
  454. 19:03unfortunately, the Polish state's lack
  455. 19:05of preparation in the area of civil
  456. 19:07defense, shelters, and so on. I don't
  457. 19:09want to delve into this topic now,
  458. 19:10because I wanted to draw attention to
  459. 19:12something else.
  460. 19:12It's also worth, excuse me,
  461. 19:14you are muted. Jacek.
  462. 19:16It is also worth remembering what date
  463. 19:17it is today. The Russians love such a
  464. 19:19situation.
  465. 19:20Of course. Yes, yes, absolutely. Let's
  466. 19:23just remember to try to talk not about
  467. 19:25the diagnosis or a description of the
  468. 19:27situation. I don't deny the team the
  469. 19:30right to say that, but let's try to
  470. 19:32think about what to do, what the issue
  471. 19:34is.
  472. 19:37I would also like to relate what you
  473. 19:38outlined at the beginning to recent
  474. 19:40events, which in my opinion should be a
  475. 19:42clear point of reference for us. Namely
  476. 19:48, what happened recently in US-Saudi
  477. 19:50relations, also surrounding the clash
  478. 19:52with the Houthis, very well shows the
  479. 19:54position American policy finds itself
  480. 19:56in right now. You mentioned the
  481. 20:00isolation of Poland, right? That we are
  482. 20:05, or could potentially be, in such a
  483. 20:07danger of being isolated the moment the
  484. 20:09Americans and Russians have a free hand
  485. 20:11and talk about the security status of
  486. 20:13our region. That is exactly what
  487. 20:18happened between the Americans and the
  488. 20:20Houthis, who were supposed to meet.
  489. 20:28United States representatives and the
  490. 20:30Houthis in Oman reportedly communicated
  491. 20:32after the success of their offensive,
  492. 20:34where they captured practically the
  493. 20:36entire Yemeni coast along the Red Sea,
  494. 20:38taking full control of the Bab
  495. 20:39al-Mandab, that they would not attack
  496. 20:41American or Israeli ships. Our
  497. 20:52agreements from the previous year
  498. 20:54remain in effect, but Saudi ships are
  499. 20:55very much a target that we will
  500. 20:57continue to aim at. Yes. And the
  501. 21:02Americans reportedly agreed to this.
  502. 21:08Which perfectly shows that Washington
  503. 21:10is currently in a phase of its policy
  504. 21:11where the scenario you described as
  505. 21:13hypothetical for Poland is perhaps
  506. 21:15currently being realized in the Middle
  507. 21:17East with regard to Saudi Arabia. A
  508. 21:23state which, let us recall, has been a
  509. 21:25long-time client of the United States,
  510. 21:27buying massive amounts of
  511. 21:29state-of-the-art American weaponry. And
  512. 21:33this clash with the Houthis also shows
  513. 21:35another thing very well. Namely, even
  514. 21:39if we expect some support or help from
  515. 21:41allies, no one will help someone who is
  516. 21:43not able to help themselves. And Saudi
  517. 21:48Arabia perfectly demonstrates this. Yes
  518. 21:52, meaning the appeals from Mohammed bin
  519. 21:54Salman to Donald Trump to send air
  520. 21:55support and help bomb the Houthis were
  521. 21:57met with a refusal, right? Because
  522. 22:02Saudi Arabia is simply incapable of
  523. 22:03carrying out these types of operations
  524. 22:05effectively on its own and dealing with
  525. 22:07the Houthis. So what is happening right
  526. 22:11now on the Saudi Arabia, Yemen, Houthi
  527. 22:13front is very telling. It means that
  528. 22:17very detailed notes should be taken on
  529. 22:19this in Warsaw by our political
  530. 22:20decision-makers. I must point out that
  531. 22:25the rotational American presence and
  532. 22:26our strong attachment to the alliance
  533. 22:28with the States and their opinion may
  534. 22:30act as a major restraint on our
  535. 22:31scenario or manual on how to react. The
  536. 22:35Americans will be interested in keeping
  537. 22:37things quiet and showing the
  538. 22:38helplessness of the Europeans. To react
  539. 22:43.
  540. 22:43Can't hear you, Albert? I can't hear
  541. 22:45you.
  542. 22:45Now they can't hear me either.
  543. 22:47Better now.
  544. 22:48Okay. This doesn't just concern the
  545. 22:50Americans, what you're talking about,
  546. 22:52but concerns all our allies, because we
  547. 22:54have become dependent, we don't
  548. 22:56actually possess independent
  549. 22:57capabilities, and we don't think about
  550. 22:59the possibilities of self-defense, but
  551. 23:02rather perceive ourselves as an
  552. 23:06appendage, that is, an appendix of the
  553. 23:09alliance. Yes. Now you are muted.
  554. 23:11Yes. An add-on, yes. And the only way
  555. 23:14to ensure our security is the
  556. 23:16fulfillment of alliance guarantees.
  557. 23:23Then we will be heavily burdened by the
  558. 23:25fear that our excessive assertiveness
  559. 23:27will be perceived as aggressive
  560. 23:29behavior, and because of this, we will
  561. 23:31either not try to implement it at all,
  562. 23:33fearing how it will be judged by other
  563. 23:35capitals, or it will take a limited
  564. 23:37form precisely because we will fear
  565. 23:39abandonment, knowing deep down that we
  566. 23:41are close to it anyway. Prime Minister
  567. 23:48Tusk said as much openly in his speech.
  568. 23:50He said it, while simultaneously
  569. 23:52stating that the credibility of the
  570. 23:54alliance must not be undermined; he
  571. 23:56said quite openly that many capitals
  572. 23:57have no desire for
  573. 23:58realizing alliance commitments.
  574. 24:01He said, he said it openly.
  575. 24:03However, you know, moving on, I think
  576. 24:05there is no point in dwelling on or
  577. 24:07summarizing the situation any longer—
  578. 24:09it has been summarized sufficiently. It
  579. 24:11is worth saying that we are talking
  580. 24:13about hybrid scenarios. Yes, it seems
  581. 24:17unlikely that Russia would have the
  582. 24:19capacity, even in the event of a
  583. 24:21collapse of the Ukrainian state, to
  584. 24:23manage or stabilize that state while
  585. 24:25requiring such large Russian resources
  586. 24:28that it would be hard to imagine
  587. 24:29mounting a full-scale aggressive
  588. 24:31operation. So we are talking about
  589. 24:36hybrid scenarios. And it is clear what
  590. 24:38we are unlikely to succeed at and what
  591. 24:41makes no sense, that is, deterrence by
  592. 24:43denial makes no sense. First of all,
  593. 24:45because we will not be able to
  594. 24:46implement it effectively. I do not know
  595. 24:48if these jet drones are that much of a
  596. 24:50game changer here, because non-jet ones
  597. 24:52were flying out before and they were
  598. 24:53flying too. However, denial, first of
  599. 24:56all, cannot be implemented, and
  600. 24:57secondly, even if they were shot down,
  601. 25:00the effect of those attacks would be
  602. 25:02achieved in some way anyway. So we are
  603. 25:05not talking about effective denial at
  604. 25:07the most direct level, nor about the
  605. 25:09effects. So punishment remains,
  606. 25:11regardless of what goal we would
  607. 25:12ultimately like to achieve. It seems to
  608. 25:15me that our goal should be independent
  609. 25:17management of escalation, even through
  610. 25:19drawing allies into a war, that is,
  611. 25:21through entrapment. And this is
  612. 25:26important not only because well, we
  613. 25:30want to set or dictate the pace of
  614. 25:33these potential operations, or
  615. 25:34proactively force an alliance reaction.
  616. 25:41But also because, if we wanted to
  617. 25:42engage in a dialogue with the Russians,
  618. 25:44we still have to demonstrate that
  619. 25:46discussions about our affairs must be
  620. 25:48conducted with us, and not through
  621. 25:50Washington, which will be Russia's
  622. 25:52preferred way of solving this problem.
  623. 25:55However, here we return to this, so
  624. 25:57this is what I think we should be doing
  625. 25:59, that is, deterring through punishment
  626. 26:01, and perhaps even disproportionately,
  627. 26:03only here we return to the problem of
  628. 26:05capabilities that we do not possess.
  629. 26:08Setting aside the fear of abandonment,
  630. 26:10we are afraid that this will be the
  631. 26:12result if we counter-escalate ourselves
  632. 26:14, and frankly, this could put a noose
  633. 26:16around our necks, meaning we could
  634. 26:18bring trouble upon ourselves this way.
  635. 26:21Beyond these psychological and
  636. 26:23strategic factors, we also lack the
  637. 26:25actual capabilities, as these assets we
  638. 26:28possess are, to a greater or lesser
  639. 26:30extent, controlled by the Americans,
  640. 26:32who certainly won't be interested in
  641. 26:34escalation.
  642. 26:38I have a doubt about that. I have this
  643. 26:42doubt because, let's put ourselves in
  644. 26:44the Russians 'shoes again. They will be
  645. 26:48interested in setting a scale of
  646. 26:49conflict that suits them. Meaning,
  647. 26:53parameterizing the terms of this hybrid
  648. 26:55conflict with Poland to push the limits
  649. 26:57of reaction, of the alliance, and of
  650. 26:59the risk for the Russians. Therefore,
  651. 27:05we must be cautious—and that is the
  652. 27:07difficulty, you know, with deterrence
  653. 27:09by punishment—because there could be
  654. 27:11provocations that the Russians might
  655. 27:13use, and that would tie the hands of
  656. 27:14Polish politicians more than it would
  657. 27:16mine. Because I have a certain
  658. 27:20temperament; I would strike back
  659. 27:22immediately, organize industry, and so
  660. 27:24on, but the point is that the Russians
  661. 27:31are very good at these provocations and
  662. 27:33later legitimizing them, blowing them
  663. 27:35up into circumstances where they can
  664. 27:37then bomb us with drones, claiming it's
  665. 27:39just a response to our prior escalation
  666. 27:41.
  667. 27:44Then, because you’re talking about
  668. 27:46brinkmanship, you respond to their
  669. 27:48brinkmanship by perhaps overscaling,
  670. 27:50aiming for an instant escalation to
  671. 27:52draw the rest in—entrapment.
  672. 27:56How to achieve the entrapment of the
  673. 27:57rest? Well, by having our drones fly
  674. 27:59over Orzysz, where the Americans are
  675. 28:01stationed.
  676. 28:02You know, to avoid normalizing this
  677. 28:04over a longer period of time. I'm just
  678. 28:07thinking out loud, but you see, because
  679. 28:09then you quickly overscale the response
  680. 28:11.
  681. 28:13They don't have the capacity either for
  682. 28:14, you know, excessive escalation,
  683. 28:16except for, well, continued hybrid
  684. 28:18attacks. They won't invade with their
  685. 28:20army now; they lack the capability for
  686. 28:21that.
  687. 28:21But some kind of terror, you know,
  688. 28:23crossing the Rubicon, they can—they
  689. 28:24can just do that, and they might.
  690. 28:25Yes, they might. That’s what I’m
  691. 28:27talking about, but I’m just saying
  692. 28:29that you then respond by overscaling,
  693. 28:30right? No.
  694. 28:31But what to do? What about escalation?
  695. 28:33What would you do now? Well, if you
  696. 28:34said that and went to the Chancellery
  697. 28:36of the Prime Minister right now. He is
  698. 28:37going to Ukraine tonight.
  699. 28:39Right now you can't afford a reaction,
  700. 28:41but I'm talking about a reaction to a
  701. 28:42specific hybrid attack by the Russians
  702. 28:44that hits our territory. Do you respond
  703. 28:47by escalating, hitting a power plant,
  704. 28:49leading to a very quick escalation so
  705. 28:51that everyone has an interest in
  706. 28:53suppressing it, or—or—
  707. 28:56Albert, to lead to escalation, you need
  708. 28:58to have the capabilities in
  709. 29:00capabilities, well yes, of course.
  710. 29:03Because we are theorizing a bit.
  711. 29:05Only since we don't have
  712. 29:10the entrapment capability is more of a
  713. 29:12theoretical option than a real one, I
  714. 29:14believe; I mean, we don't have the
  715. 29:16capacity for such a strong response to
  716. 29:19potential Russian aggression. Because
  717. 29:24what does a strong response mean? It
  718. 29:26means a sustained response, a response
  719. 29:32adequate to the scale of the Russian
  720. 29:34Federation's use of force and a
  721. 29:36response that is perhaps executed over
  722. 29:38a longer time sequence with the
  723. 29:45capability of moving up the escalation
  724. 29:47ladder. we do not have this kind of
  725. 29:49capability.
  726. 29:49But Marek, there is also the issue, no,
  727. 29:52it's not about adequacy,
  728. 29:53not just verticality,
  729. 29:54because there is also the issue of not
  730. 29:56normalizing the salami strategy,
  731. 29:58because I'm also talking about that,
  732. 30:00and there's also the issue of not just
  733. 30:02I am only referring to the entry issue.
  734. 30:04I believe that this is an option beyond
  735. 30:06our reach.
  736. 30:07Well yes, all the allies are spread too
  737. 30:09thin, but in general there is also a
  738. 30:11problem that it is not just about
  739. 30:12verticality. Pay attention, if the
  740. 30:14Russians, for example, strike us
  741. 30:16through Ukrainian territory with a
  742. 30:18hundred jet drones, where are we
  743. 30:19supposed to respond? At the Kaliningrad
  744. 30:22Oblast, at Russia proper, at Pskov, at
  745. 30:24Belarus, or send them through Ukraine?
  746. 30:27This is a very serious matter, they
  747. 30:29should be thinking about this right now
  748. 30:31, here in Aleje Ujazdowskie.
  749. 30:33I mean, I think Jacek, if I may, that
  750. 30:36they in Aleje Ujazdowskie should be
  751. 30:38thinking about something completely
  752. 30:40different, at least at this phase.
  753. 30:47namely, they should finally start
  754. 30:49thinking about a certain consistency of
  755. 30:51the narrative regarding the growing
  756. 30:53threat and the consistency of policy,
  757. 30:55both in the internal dimension and in
  758. 30:57the allied dimension. I mean, what do I
  759. 31:03have in mind? I mean, you cannot talk
  760. 31:06about a growing threat and at the same
  761. 31:08time conduct internal policy that,
  762. 31:10objectively speaking, weakens the unity
  763. 31:12of the threatened state. I mean, this
  764. 31:17is inconsistent and it also weakens the
  765. 31:19willingness to engage and make
  766. 31:21sacrifices on the part of the society,
  767. 31:23which sees this inconsistency. However,
  768. 31:27it must be admitted that for the first
  769. 31:29time today, both Kosiniak-Kamysz, the
  770. 31:31deputy prime minister and minister, and
  771. 31:33others, and Prime Minister Tusk himself
  772. 31:35, were a bit frightening and said it is
  773. 31:38high time to say so, right? And there
  774. 31:40was even a series of other people,
  775. 31:41General Struzik, you know, people from
  776. 31:43the government or, you know, from the
  777. 31:45circles of power started talking about
  778. 31:47what actually happened there. As I
  779. 31:49think,
  780. 31:50Jacek, I notice that they started
  781. 31:52talking and the tone of these
  782. 31:53statements has changed. However, a
  783. 32:01response to a real threat must be a
  784. 32:03non-rhetorical response, it must mean
  785. 32:05not devastating public institutions,
  786. 32:07which is happening all the time,
  787. 32:09because these institutions will be
  788. 32:11tested anyway in a situation of growing
  789. 32:14threat. Therefore, they must be
  790. 32:19resilient, they must be credible, and
  791. 32:21they must be trustworthy. And this
  792. 32:23trust must be granted to them by the
  793. 32:28entire population or the entire society
  794. 32:30. This implies a necessity. We can also
  795. 32:33escalate this reaction. We can dampen
  796. 32:39internal disputes in connection with
  797. 32:41the external threat, which should
  798. 32:43translate into speeding up procedures
  799. 32:45in a number of matters, even ones as
  800. 32:47basic as clarifying who will command
  801. 32:49and what is the mode of determining the
  802. 32:51commander-in-chief in a wartime
  803. 32:53situation. But there are so many of
  804. 32:58these areas, aren't there? We have been
  805. 33:00talking about this for years. This is
  806. 33:01the first, first step. If the threat
  807. 33:05continues to grow, in mature
  808. 33:07democracies, in a situation of
  809. 33:09escalating threat, a government of
  810. 33:11national unity is formed. Not because
  811. 33:15it sounds good, but precisely to
  812. 33:19silence disputes, declare a truce, and
  813. 33:22mobilize resources. And if that finally
  814. 33:26proves impossible for some reason,
  815. 33:28because the conflict is already so deep
  816. 33:31that nothing can be done, then one
  817. 33:33forms at least a government. I will say
  818. 33:38right away that, in my opinion, the
  819. 33:40conflict will intensify because the
  820. 33:42Americans will manipulate it. There
  821. 33:44will be a base, there won't be a base.
  822. 33:46There will be,
  823. 33:46we will have a crisis,
  824. 33:47there won't be a base and there will be
  825. 33:49, they will support,
  826. 33:51there will be a crisis next year around
  827. 33:53the parliamentary elections. The
  828. 33:59problem with the current government is
  829. 34:01that it sees this threat also as an
  830. 34:03opportunity for political opponents,
  831. 34:05both internal and external, to resolve
  832. 34:07internal struggles, and that will limit
  833. 34:09our capabilities and our commitment. If
  834. 34:20this diagnosis is correct, then to be
  835. 34:22honest, there is no mature policy that
  836. 34:25could be recommended, because it will
  837. 34:27always be insufficient, it will be
  838. 34:29contested, it will not mean the
  839. 34:30mobilization of full resources, it will
  840. 34:33be burdened by a crisis in allied
  841. 34:34relations, and it will be perceived by
  842. 34:37a significant part of society as an
  843. 34:39element of political maneuvering.
  844. 34:45internal. In this sense, there is no,
  845. 34:47there is no good, there is no good
  846. 34:49model. And in this sense, basically,
  847. 34:53the importance of non-governmental,
  848. 34:55social factors is growing. I do not
  849. 35:00rule out that this is the time that
  850. 35:02people having some influence on public
  851. 35:04opinion should use, because a
  852. 35:05well-functioning government should do
  853. 35:07something else. Meaning it should in an
  854. 35:12accelerated manner eliminate
  855. 35:14ambiguities and legislative barriers.
  856. 35:17That can be done in a few days. It
  857. 35:21should launch the entire B segment,
  858. 35:23which we have been talking about. the
  859. 35:24potential, the potential of the private
  860. 35:26Polish sector.
  861. 35:27Of course, we have been talking about
  862. 35:29this for at least a year; it should
  863. 35:31move away from the current procurement
  864. 35:33model. Moreover, there are tools for
  865. 35:35this; there is this urgent operational
  866. 35:37requirement formula. Well, when one
  867. 35:41moves away from the tender system and
  868. 35:43buys off-hand, well, when is this
  869. 35:45urgent operational requirement
  870. 35:48it would have a slightly deterrent
  871. 35:50character in its own way, because the
  872. 35:52Russians would see that there is total
  873. 35:54deregulation, and, well, only interest
  874. 35:56groups in Poland will not allow it.
  875. 35:57Simply put.
  876. 35:58Well yes, but that is what it comes
  877. 36:00down to.
  878. 36:01But in other words, in other words, I
  879. 36:03would also like to—maybe this is a
  880. 36:05good moment for an appeal—if Prime
  881. 36:07Minister Tusk is right and we are
  882. 36:09heading toward war, for those Polish
  883. 36:11entrepreneurs listening to us who have
  884. 36:13sufficient capital, organization, will,
  885. 36:16and so on, to be ready to set up
  886. 36:17high-tech industries if war breaks out,
  887. 36:20because deregulation will happen
  888. 36:22automatically with the delegitimization
  889. 36:24of existing state structures. Yes. Just
  890. 36:27as it happened in Ukraine, and for them
  891. 36:29to think about it, to calculate it for
  892. 36:31themselves—those who want to, of
  893. 36:32course—because in my opinion, this is
  894. 36:34the path that will happen if something
  895. 36:36like that occurs, or at least it should
  896. 36:38. Um, that's why
  897. 36:39only, I wasn't heading toward the kind
  898. 36:41of war that could cause that, like in
  899. 36:43Ukraine. For now, they are heading, it
  900. 36:45is within the continuum, they are
  901. 36:46heading toward the intensification of
  902. 36:48further hybrid operations, and that
  903. 36:50will not cause such a sense of shock,
  904. 36:52in my opinion, just as it didn't cause
  905. 36:53it in Ukraine.
  906. 36:54You may, you may be right. I hope, I
  907. 36:56don't know, maybe I
  908. 36:58I hope you are right, but
  909. 37:00you know, I hope I am right, but you
  910. 37:02may be right. That's how it should be,
  911. 37:04right? Well, I don't know what could
  912. 37:06cause a greater need. Well, that would
  913. 37:08confirm the theory I mentioned recently
  914. 37:10, that Eugeniusz Kwiatkowski wrote in "
  915. 37:12Disproportions," that thousands of
  916. 37:14small interests do not allow for
  917. 37:16changes in Poland that are required by
  918. 37:18the circumstances, right, geopolitical
  919. 37:20ones, external to the country. Will
  920. 37:23there be some shock? And now the
  921. 37:25question is: will it be a shock that
  922. 37:28paralyzes us, or a shock that mobilizes
  923. 37:30us? Because I believe some shock will
  924. 37:36occur, and we should make efforts to
  925. 37:38ensure it is a mobilizing shock,
  926. 37:39because such things also happen. States
  927. 37:44are subject to crisis situations, and
  928. 37:46quite a lot can be done here quite
  929. 37:48quickly, well for instance scaling the
  930. 37:56production that is already being
  931. 37:58carried out in Ukraine. One of the
  932. 38:03Ukrainian enterprises producing Bars
  933. 38:05missiles declares capabilities at the
  934. 38:11level of producing a thousand such
  935. 38:13systems. These are not very complicated
  936. 38:16structures. Monthly, they formed a
  937. 38:20company with German firms, as I
  938. 38:22understand it, in order to produce key
  939. 38:24components. This most likely concerns
  940. 38:27engines. I'm not saying which company
  941. 38:30it is either, because its name is not
  942. 38:32being disclosed. Well, and such
  943. 38:34companies must be created in Poland. We
  944. 38:37must quickly acquire retaliatory strike
  945. 38:40capabilities
  946. 38:42on a mass scale. On a serious, mass
  947. 38:48scale, because that is the deterrent
  948. 38:50element, and that is the element of
  949. 38:52deterrence by punishment, which we also
  950. 38:54simply do not have today, so I believe
  951. 38:57quite a lot of these steps can be taken
  952. 38:59. I am not even mentioning civil
  953. 39:05defense, I am not mentioning all that
  954. 39:07we have been discussing for years. It's
  955. 39:12also worth mentioning this and delving
  956. 39:14deeper into this thread, because
  957. 39:16recently in Finland, the largest civil
  958. 39:18defense exercises since World War II
  959. 39:20took place, involving over 2,000 people
  960. 39:22, from primary school students to
  961. 39:24retirees, and it's a country of a
  962. 39:26completely different scale than Poland.
  963. 39:34The fact that regarding shelters and
  964. 39:36real civil defense, rather than just
  965. 39:38understood as the fire department
  966. 39:40buying extra equipment with public
  967. 39:42money, nothing has really been done
  968. 39:44over the last four years. This is that
  969. 39:50entire segment of non-military affairs.
  970. 39:52The diagnosis, because here, you know,
  971. 39:55everyone knows it de facto. The problem
  972. 39:57is what to do in this situation, right?
  973. 39:59Meaning, what decisions to make,
  974. 40:01because well, for example, we still
  975. 40:05have to talk. I have two questions for
  976. 40:08you. Well, we've said it, right:
  977. 40:09deregulation here, launching the
  978. 40:11problem of deterrence through Ukraine,
  979. 40:13but okay, Prime Minister Tusk is going
  980. 40:16to Ukraine. So what? Is this a new
  981. 40:18opening with Ukraine, especially since
  982. 40:20he castigated those who criticize
  983. 40:21Ukrainians and so on? Did he also say
  984. 40:23there would be cooperation in the field
  985. 40:25of counter-systems, right? Or
  986. 40:27technological cooperation? And what
  987. 40:29does that mean? What to do with Ukraine
  988. 40:31? What to do with the Baltic states? He
  989. 40:33was threatening now that we will help
  990. 40:34the Baltic states. Well, specifically
  991. 40:36how will we help?
  992. 40:37That is exactly what he said, that one
  993. 40:39cannot say we will not help.
  994. 40:40Ah, I see. Fine.
  995. 40:42Okay then. But wait a moment, and okay.
  996. 40:45And so what? And there will be strikes
  997. 40:46on the Baltic states. And what are we
  998. 40:48doing?
  999. 40:48What should we do?
  1000. 40:50But we should preventively deploy or or
  1001. 40:56organize exercises. Together with our
  1002. 41:01allies on all key strategic islands in
  1003. 41:03the Baltic Sea. From Hiiumaa and
  1004. 41:08Saaremaa to Bornholm, through Gotland
  1005. 41:10and the Åland archipelago, which
  1006. 41:12cannot remain neutralized. We must move
  1007. 41:16away from that, and the Finns must
  1008. 41:18finally swallow it. Uh, so this kind of
  1009. 41:21let's remind everyone that according to
  1010. 41:23the treaty after the First World War,
  1011. 41:25it is impossible to have military bases
  1012. 41:27there on the Åland Islands, such
  1013. 41:28numerous thousands of islands between
  1014. 41:30Sweden and Finland in the Gulf of
  1015. 41:32Bothnia, that's what that bay is
  1016. 41:34but this treaty was concluded because
  1017. 41:36at the end of the First World War,
  1018. 41:38there was a war between the Finns and
  1019. 41:40the Swedes for control of the Åland
  1020. 41:41Islands. And whoever controls these
  1021. 41:45islands poses a direct threat to
  1022. 41:47Stockholm. And that was a result, so to
  1023. 41:50speak, forced by the Swedes. But let's
  1024. 41:53leave history aside. I think we could
  1025. 41:57point out, perhaps we should as
  1026. 41:59Strategy and Future create a whole
  1027. 42:01sequence of actions that should be
  1028. 42:03taken, graduating our reaction and our
  1029. 42:05response. But one thing won't change—
  1030. 42:14we live in a democratic state, and the
  1031. 42:16mechanisms of power can either
  1032. 42:18facilitate our reaction and preparation
  1033. 42:20, broadening our range of capabilities,
  1034. 42:23or they can diminish them. And until we
  1035. 42:33untie this Gordian knot at the level of
  1036. 42:35state policy, all our advice will
  1037. 42:37remain more or less theoretical. I
  1038. 42:43emphasize, we will be put to some test,
  1039. 42:45we don’t yet know how large or
  1040. 42:47intense, and our state apparatus must
  1041. 42:49withstand it. It would also be good if
  1042. 42:53it were more efficient than it is today
  1043. 42:55.
  1044. 43:00Alright, but how do we convince allies
  1045. 43:02in the Baltic states to show up
  1046. 43:03properly as well? Yes. We won't
  1047. 43:07convince the Americans, no way,
  1048. 43:08especially since, in my opinion, the
  1049. 43:10Americans will further instrumentalize
  1050. 43:12this situation. My theory is that the
  1051. 43:14Americans going in first will
  1052. 43:16absolutely not happen from the start,
  1053. 43:18because they won't go in first anywhere
  1054. 43:20. The Americans might even be pleased
  1055. 43:22with this low-scale aggression against
  1056. 43:24Europe.
  1057. 43:25Prime Minister Tusk touched on this
  1058. 43:27somewhat by stating that if we don't
  1059. 43:29demonstrate determination, others won't
  1060. 43:31move either. But you won't get anyone
  1061. 43:33to go in first there. As I suspect,
  1062. 43:36this...You explain to allies: this is a
  1063. 43:42huge lesson for the future, for
  1064. 43:44generations to come, that it's crucial
  1065. 43:46to set the pawns in place before
  1066. 43:48economic shifts in given years change
  1067. 43:50political attitudes. And those
  1068. 43:54Americans should have been sitting on
  1069. 43:56their hands right near Tartu, or Dorpat
  1070. 43:58, since 2015, since the Warsaw summit.
  1071. 44:03Daugavpils and Rezekne too. Simply put.
  1072. 44:05Well, that's why it was easy for Poland
  1073. 44:07to give Article 5 guarantees. It's much
  1074. 44:09harder for Ukraine, because the
  1075. 44:11situation was such that nothing
  1076. 44:12indicated that the U.S. would actually
  1077. 44:13implement them.
  1078. 44:14But we are talking about history, and
  1079. 44:16we're saying we shouldn't have been so
  1080. 44:19foolish to believe in Article 5
  1081. 44:20throughout all those years after 2015.
  1082. 44:24Even though we had been talking about
  1083. 44:26it for at least five years. He’s
  1084. 44:28right.
  1085. 44:29Our entire pool of experts thought we
  1086. 44:31were wrong.
  1087. 44:31Moving forward. And now, fine. But
  1088. 44:34regarding drone and missile strikes. I
  1089. 44:36understand you want an effect in
  1090. 44:38Lithuania, Marek, so that Polish troops
  1091. 44:40are stationed not in Kaliningrad or
  1092. 44:42Marijampolė, to keep the Kaliningrad
  1093. 44:44and Grodno regions in check. Yes, so
  1094. 44:46that it wouldn't be checked or held at
  1095. 44:48bay through combat. To respond to a
  1096. 44:52drone strike, you need the capability
  1097. 44:54to recognize that the strike is
  1098. 44:56happening at all. And we don't have
  1099. 45:01that capability today, as evidenced by
  1100. 45:03the discovery of that drone on the
  1101. 45:05beach in Jarosławiec, which ended up
  1102. 45:07there. Deus ex machina. Uh, I won’t
  1103. 45:13mention that I urged General Bodnar a
  1104. 45:15year ago to go to Kyiv, uh, to meet
  1105. 45:17with a company making acoustic
  1106. 45:19detectors, well, because he didn't find
  1107. 45:21the time, as you know, official duties
  1108. 45:23must be tended to. So when there is,
  1109. 45:27when there is such a scale of delays,
  1110. 45:30our prescriptions are very interesting
  1111. 45:32and, and look nice. It’s just that
  1112. 45:34some things cannot be done. You have to
  1113. 45:36take the systems that are available.
  1114. 45:38They aren't perfect, they aren't ideal,
  1115. 45:41they aren't even the most
  1116. 45:42technologically advanced, but they
  1117. 45:44exist. And those others, the perfect
  1118. 45:46ones, either don't exist or we have to
  1119. 45:48wait years for them. And that is the
  1120. 45:53discussion we’ve been having for
  1121. 45:55years, having with our great strategic
  1122. 45:57minds who believe that American toys
  1123. 45:58are the only option. Of course,
  1124. 46:03that’s true. Only nobody, nobody is
  1125. 46:05selling them to us. And if the
  1126. 46:08Americans came up with the idea to
  1127. 46:10agree to sell them to us, they still
  1128. 46:12wouldn’t produce them until 2030 or
  1129. 46:14'31 at the earliest. So we are talking
  1130. 46:18about a post-war perspective, not, not,
  1131. 46:21not today. Well, today you have to take
  1132. 46:23what is available. And what is
  1133. 46:26available is primarily, first and
  1134. 46:28foremost, Ukrainian solutions,
  1135. 46:30secondarily Turkish ones, and thirdly
  1136. 46:32perhaps, well, that would require
  1137. 46:35better relations, Israeli ones. I
  1138. 46:38don’t see any other options. If there
  1139. 46:42are no tools, then all theories about
  1140. 46:44response are theories par excellence
  1141. 46:46detached from reality. And that means
  1142. 46:52the only thing we will be testing is
  1143. 46:53our endurance. Meaning, will we
  1144. 46:57withstand intensifying Russian attacks
  1145. 47:00as a society, as a state? Remember,
  1146. 47:05remember that the Foreign Minister and
  1147. 47:07the whole group of techno-enthusiasts
  1148. 47:09claim that our F-35s are capable of
  1149. 47:12penetrating, destroying, launching
  1150. 47:14JASSMs, and generally all that,
  1151. 47:17but ours, meaning the three we have,
  1152. 47:19I don’t know how many, six or eight
  1153. 47:21have arrived, I think. Well yes, but
  1154. 47:22that means we have no answer, because
  1155. 47:24what you said, Marek, is a matter of a
  1156. 47:26year, not the next two or three months,
  1157. 47:28so that’s not an answer either. So
  1158. 47:30there is no, our resilience will be
  1159. 47:32tested
  1160. 47:34and our endurance. And one of the key
  1161. 47:38elements of testing that resilience is
  1162. 47:40the durability of the political system,
  1163. 47:43because the obvious intention of the
  1164. 47:45Russians will be to deepen divisions
  1165. 47:47and exploit various peace parties, etc.
  1166. 47:49, various idiots. They have done that
  1167. 47:56many times and succeeded. Do you think,
  1168. 47:59do you think Marek, that a decision was
  1169. 48:01made in the Kremlin for Operation X to
  1170. 48:03be launched against Poland? I believe
  1171. 48:06that a decision was made in the Kremlin
  1172. 48:08regarding an escalation scenario
  1173. 48:10against Ukraine.
  1174. 48:11Explain what you mean by Operation X.
  1175. 48:16Well, I just came up with a code name
  1176. 48:18for concrete aggression against Poland,
  1177. 48:20of course scalable and measured, so as
  1178. 48:22not to trigger a general war in Europe,
  1179. 48:25but enough to highlight all those
  1180. 48:26deficiencies, those asymmetric
  1181. 48:28imperfections, right? Uh, well, well,
  1182. 48:32well, because what happened is that in
  1183. 48:34France, there’s, you know, Macron’s
  1184. 48:37sudden meeting with the intelligence
  1185. 48:39chiefs. The Italian Prime Minister is
  1186. 48:41talking about it. Tusk is talking about
  1187. 48:43it in the Sejm. Uh,
  1188. 48:44Germany is also talking about it. The
  1189. 48:47biggest takeaway is that this is not an
  1190. 48:49existential threat, and I wouldn't
  1191. 48:51count on the state surviving, but
  1192. 48:53rather, I’d count on getting
  1193. 48:55face-planted onto the asphalt as a tool
  1194. 48:57for sobering up. Well, that could be
  1195. 49:00the upside. Yes, once again we are
  1196. 49:01talking about existential threats, we
  1197. 49:03are talking about the continuation of
  1198. 49:05hybrid warfare. That is actually
  1199. 49:06interesting, it is actually an
  1200. 49:08interesting thing, Albert, because if
  1201. 49:10that's the case, aren't the Russians
  1202. 49:12calculating that too? Meaning, even if
  1203. 49:14they reach a certain tipping point,
  1204. 49:16okay, they do it, and what will the
  1205. 49:18reaction be? Or, well, they might be
  1206. 49:21afraid too—maybe they’re
  1207. 49:22overestimating us—but they might fear
  1208. 49:24that if they do it, we’ll pull
  1209. 49:26ourselves together, to put it
  1210. 49:27colloquially. We’ll draw conclusions,
  1211. 49:29if they push it too far. Just like that
  1212. 49:31. Yes.
  1213. 49:32That’s why it will be boiling the
  1214. 49:34frog. Besides, we aren’t the target;
  1215. 49:36the target is Ukraine. To win against
  1216. 49:38Ukraine, you have to isolate it. To
  1217. 49:40isolate it, you have to attack
  1218. 49:43logistics, the grid, i.e., power
  1219. 49:45transmission networks, and so on. You
  1220. 49:48have to do it effectively and also
  1221. 49:50intimidate those who might help Ukraine
  1222. 49:52and provide them with the means to
  1223. 49:55fight. In this context, the provinces
  1224. 50:00east of the Vistula are the most
  1225. 50:02vulnerable, and therefore, our
  1226. 50:03authorities should place great emphasis
  1227. 50:06on preparing these provinces. But I
  1228. 50:10also don't know what can be done in
  1229. 50:12such a short time. You can’t just
  1230. 50:14suddenly build shelters, right? So that
  1231. 50:19people have somewhere to go when they
  1232. 50:21get another RCB alert, because since I
  1233. 50:23have family in the Lublin region, I
  1234. 50:25know how that’s simply treated, right
  1235. 50:27? People get these alerts and what,
  1236. 50:30what are they supposed to do? Like,
  1237. 50:33that in itself shows, right, that...
  1238. 50:37the fiction of it all,
  1239. 50:39right?
  1240. 50:41Like I said, either there is endurance,
  1241. 50:43or if you want to suddenly speed things
  1242. 50:45up, you’ll end up with two ends of
  1243. 50:47the spectrum.
  1244. 50:51Exactly, either endure what Marekisz
  1245. 50:53was saying, or you trigger a rapid
  1246. 50:55escalation, not to slowly boil the frog
  1247. 50:57, but to turn up the heat immediately,
  1248. 50:59before the Europeans fully realize how
  1249. 51:02much they shouldn't and don't want to
  1250. 51:04take part in some mess here. But, of
  1251. 51:08course, the latter is extremely risky.
  1252. 51:13No one will take it, it’s extremely
  1253. 51:15risky, but the question is whether the
  1254. 51:17circumstances that will arise in the
  1255. 51:19coming months won't actually make such
  1256. 51:21a stronger escalation seem, from the
  1257. 51:23Russian point of view, something that
  1258. 51:29might appear desirable. Well, take note
  1259. 51:32, next year we have elections in France
  1260. 51:34, we have elections in Italy, right?
  1261. 51:37This is the worst moment for all these
  1262. 51:39countries to make any radical decisions
  1263. 51:41. Like, oh please, we're sending our
  1264. 51:43boys to the eastern flank, right?
  1265. 51:45Mers is wavering. There is talk of
  1266. 51:47Chancellor Tausz, right? Meaning a
  1267. 51:48change of chancellor. And perhaps also
  1268. 51:51snap elections. We talked about Germany
  1269. 51:55in detail recently, so there's no point
  1270. 51:57in going into that here, right? But
  1271. 52:01there are really a lot of these
  1272. 52:03circumstances, plus, of course, winter,
  1273. 52:06which for Ukraine will again be a very,
  1274. 52:08very difficult experience. So,
  1275. 52:14it's also an interesting observation by
  1276. 52:16Western media and commentators in
  1277. 52:18general, because Poland appears there
  1278. 52:20as some great monster that will unleash
  1279. 52:22the hussars and is generally preparing
  1280. 52:24for war. I don't know if the citizens
  1281. 52:28of the Republic of Poland realize that
  1282. 52:30in the centers of command,
  1283. 52:32everyone is placing their hope in us.
  1284. 52:34Hope in us. So, really, take note, just
  1285. 52:36as they placed hope in the Ukrainians
  1286. 52:38—that they would hold back the
  1287. 52:40Russians so they could continue to live
  1288. 52:42their lives, driving Volkswagens to
  1289. 52:44McDonald’s—they will soon be
  1290. 52:46placing their hope in us. Do you
  1291. 52:48understand what that means? Yes.
  1292. 52:51Well, Jacek, it’s like this: today in
  1293. 52:54Ukraine there are 110 brigades,
  1294. 52:56weakened, tired, but still fighting.
  1295. 53:00Poland is capable of fielding 25
  1296. 53:02brigades. I'm not judging whether this
  1297. 53:05is a good army or a bad one. I assume
  1298. 53:08it's very good. Germany, France, and
  1299. 53:12Great Britain, in my opinion, if they
  1300. 53:14were able to field 10 brigades, that
  1301. 53:16would be a good result. And so we
  1302. 53:21effectively have an answer regarding
  1303. 53:23the war scenario. And here, by the way,
  1304. 53:27a comment—I checked Twitter, look,
  1305. 53:29because it flashed that there is a huge
  1306. 53:31Ukrainian attack on Moscow right now.
  1307. 53:33Several hundred Ukrainian drones are
  1308. 53:35flying toward Moscow. Yes, it's already
  1309. 53:38in the Moscow air space, several
  1310. 53:39hundred, and missiles will be flying,
  1311. 53:42because the Ukrainians also have to
  1312. 53:44escalate. I am also pointing that out.
  1313. 53:46The Ukrainians, the Ukrainians promise
  1314. 53:48that by this year, even before winter,
  1315. 53:49they will have ballistic missiles that
  1316. 53:51will reach Moscow, right? And they will
  1317. 53:53bomb each other on a mass scale. Yes.
  1318. 53:57This causes the threat of an escalation
  1319. 54:00scenario to rise very seriously,
  1320. 54:02including to the level of using
  1321. 54:03tactical nuclear weapons, because both
  1322. 54:10states participating in the war will
  1323. 54:12escalate. Only differently, of course,
  1324. 54:16both Ukraine will escalate and Russia
  1325. 54:18will escalate. Russian escalation also
  1326. 54:21means, in my opinion, attacks on
  1327. 54:23neighboring states, primarily Poland.
  1328. 54:28We do not have a response system, do we
  1329. 54:30? Neither entrapment is in play,
  1330. 54:33therefore, nor deterrence by punishment
  1331. 54:36. Well, because for that, please, you
  1332. 54:39have Kaliningrad,
  1333. 54:42but we didn't build that, Albert. Well,
  1334. 54:44simply put, in my opinion, we didn't
  1335. 54:46build it. Maybe I am overly critical in
  1336. 54:48assessing our capabilities.
  1337. 54:50No, no.
  1338. 54:52So we will be tested, we will be tested
  1339. 54:54, and our resilience will be put to the
  1340. 54:57test. Well.
  1341. 55:01And we must endure this, but use it as
  1342. 55:03a certain impulse for action. And not
  1343. 55:08as a reason to, I don't know, contest
  1344. 55:10reality. An impulse for action, both in
  1345. 55:15the scope of state policy, internal
  1346. 55:17policy, institutional order, not
  1347. 55:19destroying institutions, mobilizing
  1348. 55:22resources, activating segment B,
  1349. 55:24deregulation, and initiating
  1350. 55:26preparation of the population for
  1351. 55:28crisis situations. Even a few months,
  1352. 55:33uh, is already something. I don't claim
  1353. 55:37that this is an optimal amount of time,
  1354. 55:39but it is more than a few days, and
  1355. 55:41these few months must be used. A
  1356. 55:44scenario if Ukraine holds out. The
  1357. 55:50fundamental question is whether we and
  1358. 55:53our political class are proponents of
  1359. 55:55increased involvement, for example, by
  1360. 55:57establishing no-fly zones over Western
  1361. 55:59Ukraine, because I think this is being
  1362. 56:01discussed and cannot be ruled out. This
  1363. 56:07scenario of involvement is a sort of
  1364. 56:09entrapment formula, because we won't
  1365. 56:11establish such zones ourselves. It
  1366. 56:15could only be possible in a situation
  1367. 56:17where the air forces of our allies
  1368. 56:18would get involved in it. I consider
  1369. 56:23that relatively unlikely, but perhaps
  1370. 56:25it is worth doing. Why is this
  1371. 56:28important? Well, because if Ukraine
  1372. 56:31does not survive, then those 110
  1373. 56:33brigades will not survive. Not in the
  1374. 56:36sense that Russia will occupy all of
  1375. 56:38Ukraine, but it will change the
  1376. 56:39political regime, which is already very
  1377. 56:41weakened in Ukraine. Then those 110
  1378. 56:44brigades and that production potential
  1379. 56:49for new military technologies that is
  1380. 56:52in Ukraine, not 100%of course, but in
  1381. 56:54part the Russians will certainly take
  1382. 56:56over and use and turn against the West.
  1383. 57:02I remind you, which is not a great
  1384. 57:04secret after all, how the Russian
  1385. 57:06fronts were organized, where NKVD
  1386. 57:08divisions went in the second line, and
  1387. 57:10those who were on the first line didn't
  1388. 57:12have much of a choice. Therefore, they
  1389. 57:18had to advance. Even in the Donbas,
  1390. 57:23they took and recruited those Russian
  1391. 57:25or Ukrai or Russian-speaking, but
  1392. 57:27citizens of Ukraine, and that is a very
  1393. 57:30likely scenario, very likely, so this
  1394. 57:32time is shrinking and should be used
  1395. 57:34well in my opinion. We are using it
  1396. 57:39poorly for now, well, maybe some
  1397. 57:41sobriety will come now. But Marek, you
  1398. 57:44are speaking in the context of
  1399. 57:45Ukraine's collapse, you are talking
  1400. 57:47about the collapse of the entire state
  1401. 57:49and regime change.
  1402. 57:51I am talking about the collapse of the
  1403. 57:52already very weakened Zelensky
  1404. 57:54government
  1405. 57:55and internal chaos, internal fighting.
  1406. 57:58Exactly as it was in the 17th century
  1407. 57:59before the Treaty of Pereyaslav and
  1408. 58:01around it. Yes. Warring factions,
  1409. 58:03having different views. Disintegration,
  1410. 58:05special services are already shooting
  1411. 58:07at each other in Ukraine. Also, well,
  1412. 58:10maybe not so much the services as
  1413. 58:12special units controlled by those
  1414. 58:14services, but that makes no difference.
  1415. 58:16It is the same thing. Consequently,
  1416. 58:20that will still cause chaos on our
  1417. 58:22border. I won't even describe it,
  1418. 58:24because we are already accused of
  1419. 58:26scaring people anyway. However, well,
  1420. 58:30there are no easy and quick solutions
  1421. 58:32here. What can be done quickly is
  1422. 58:36actually related to legislation, the
  1423. 58:38legal order, and internal policy. I
  1424. 58:42mean, if we enter a crisis phase being
  1425. 58:44so deeply divided and conflicted, we
  1426. 58:47won't withstand it. I mean, I am a
  1427. 58:49pessimist here. I mean, if we continue
  1428. 58:54the current policy, where the Ministry
  1429. 58:57of Justice, sorry, the Ministry of
  1430. 58:59Justice is devastating public
  1431. 59:01institutions, lowering the level of
  1432. 59:03social trust in the state, well, we
  1433. 59:05have no chance of surviving this test
  1434. 59:07for the simple reason that resilience
  1435. 59:09means acting to increase trust of the
  1436. 59:18public in public institutions, because
  1437. 59:20otherwise, we will have to deal with
  1438. 59:22chaos. Well, how on one hand can you
  1439. 59:25think that, I don't know, courts are
  1440. 59:27politicized and do not guarantee
  1441. 59:29justice, and on the other hand, listen
  1442. 59:31to recommendations regarding, I don't
  1443. 59:33know, staying at home and preparing for
  1444. 59:36a crisis situation, which are issued by
  1445. 59:38representatives of a government that is
  1446. 59:40also in a large part responsible for
  1447. 59:42what is happening in internal politics?
  1448. 59:45It is internally contradictory and must
  1449. 59:48be broken. I don't know if Donald
  1450. 59:49Tusk's government is capable of doing
  1451. 59:51that. The previous government was not
  1452. 59:55able to do it, which was, by the way,
  1453. 59:57the constant subject of our criticism.
  1454. 1:00:02So here, our political class does not
  1455. 1:00:04give many reasons for satisfaction for
  1456. 1:00:06now. It is busy with its own affairs
  1457. 1:00:10and I fear that it will stay that way.
  1458. 1:00:12That, by the way, is also nothing new.
  1459. 1:00:16In 1939, we had plenty of proof of that
  1460. 1:00:18, and in the following years, and I
  1461. 1:00:21fear that history is repeating itself
  1462. 1:00:23in this sense. Well, we shall see. So,
  1463. 1:00:30maybe that's enough, gentlemen. Marek
  1464. 1:00:32Stefan, Albert Świciński, Marek
  1465. 1:00:35Budzisz, Jacek Bartosiak. Stay with us,
  1466. 1:00:37dear listeners. Strategy and Future,
  1467. 1:00:40just as promised many years ago. it
  1468. 1:00:44lets you sit in the front row of the
  1469. 1:00:46systemic war being fought over the
  1470. 1:00:47future of Eurasia and the entire global
  1471. 1:00:49order. From AI to kinetic warfare, from
  1472. 1:00:54geoeconomics to geopolitics, from
  1473. 1:00:56Poland to the Western Pacific, the war
  1474. 1:00:59in Ukraine, the Gulf wars, our future.
  1475. 1:01:02You will find all of this here at
  1476. 1:01:04Strategion Future. Thank you, gentlemen
  1477. 1:01:06. Thank you very much. P

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Jacek Bartosiak & zespół S&F o wojennym przemówieniu premiera Tuska w Sejmie i perspektywie wojny by Strategy&Future, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 9,107 words across 1,477 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.