유시민 "훗날 인간 이재명에게 미안할까봐…" — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00An overwhelmingly fun show.
- 0:05I will pray and pray that this doesn't
- 0:08become a controversial broadcast. Well,
- 0:12what the heck. We’re starting now.
- 0:21Wednesday Chaos. We’re back with
- 0:28Wednesday Chaos after a long time.
- 0:31Everyone has such grave expressions on
- 0:34their faces. Let’s go meet them.
- 0:37First, let’s welcome Director Hwang
- 0:40I-doo with a round of applause.
- 0:42Yes, hello. I’m Hwang I-doo, a
- 0:45director keeping the Roh Moo-hyun
- 0:46Foundation until Writer Rhyu Si-min
- 0:48returns.
- 0:48Yes. Why are you so nervous today? Just
- 0:52tense. Yes. Anyway, you’re okay,
- 1:00right?
- 1:02Are you okay?
- 1:03Yes. Please do your part well today. If
- 1:07things get overheated on one side,
- 1:09please splash some literal cold water
- 1:11on it immediately.
- 1:12I’ll go with literal water first.
- 1:13Yeah. You can’t just leave. You have
- 1:16to stay until the end. Thank you. And,
- 1:19oblivious to the atmosphere, he’s
- 1:22joined us as well. Let’s welcome
- 1:25reporter Min Dong-ki with applause.
- 1:28Hello. I’m Min, and I’m not nervous
- 1:31at all.
- 1:31Wow, that’s impressive.
- 1:33Yes.
- 1:34Can’t you read the room? Or is your
- 1:38heart just...
- 1:41I let it go for the talk.
- 1:43Oh, you’ve given up? That’s right.
- 1:45Yes. In a state of resignation. Yes,
- 1:48thank you. And we have someone joining
- 1:51Wednesday Chaos for the first time. I
- 1:54often think this person is quite pure.
- 2:00Let’s welcome reporter Hong Sa-hun
- 2:02with applause.
- 2:03Yes, nice to meet you. I’m Hong
- 2:05Sa-hun.
- 2:05Yes. I think this is your first time on
- 2:08Wednesday Chaos. Yes.
- 2:10What was your mindset when you agreed
- 2:12to come?
- 2:13I’m always in charge of visuals,
- 2:15anyway. Yes.
- 2:17Right. Please say lots of silly things
- 2:19like that today.
- 2:21Plus, I have to play the role of
- 2:23Catcher in the Rye.
- 2:24Yes.
- 2:25Oh. I don’t know if I’ll be a
- 2:27catcher or a hunter.
- 2:27No need to be a hunter.
- 2:29Oh.
- 2:30Yes.
- 2:30Anyway.
- 2:31I’ll handle my own role.
- 2:33Understood. Yes. Please take good care
- 2:36of us. And now, let’s invite
- 2:39today’s special guest. He’s
- 2:44suddenly become a controversial figure.
- 2:46That fact alone made my heart ache. I
- 2:50felt ashamed of myself for avoiding
- 2:56that controversy.
- 2:59Hmm. Actually, I don’t really need
- 3:02him right now. But I hated the fact
- 3:06that he was being treated as a
- 3:09controversial figure.
- 3:12So for the first time in my life, I
- 3:15invited him despite not needing him
- 3:19today. Let’s welcome the
- 3:21controversial figure, Writer Rhyu
- 3:23Si-min, with applause.
- 3:25Hello. I’m Rhyu Si-min. Yes, yes.
- 3:28It’s been a while.
- 3:29Do you feel burdened?
- 3:30Yes. No. It’s not that.
- 3:31Should we sell some books before we go?
- 3:32Ah, you need to sell a lot of books.
- 3:34You really should sell a lot. Yes.
- 3:37I heard "Travels in European Cities" is
- 3:40out.
- 3:41After "Das-B-I-Da" aired, I went on
- 3:44that European trip the very next day
- 3:46and came back on the weekend.
- 3:49Yes. And actually, this book should
- 3:51have been out at the beginning of the
- 3:52year.
- 3:53But it got delayed by about 6 months
- 3:55because of work on "Since There is Love
- 3:56, It Disappears."
- 3:58This part here is Madrid and Barcelona.
- 4:00Portugal.
- 4:01Yes, the book covering Lisbon and Porto
- 4:04in Portugal just came out, and I
- 4:06usually come here whenever a new book
- 4:09of mine is released.
- 4:11That’s right, brother Pippi.
- 4:14Brother Lee.
- 4:15Brother Lee, yes.
- 4:24Isn't that funny?
- 4:26You can just laugh. Yes. If I don't
- 4:29laugh like this, I can't find a way to
- 4:32go on. Yes. So, the trip you just took
- 4:35wasn't related to this book, right?
- 4:37This was already done.
- 4:38Yes. I left after seeing this book off
- 4:41to the printers.
- 4:42I went to see some small towns in
- 4:46France and Spain. I’d only been to
- 4:49big cities for so long.
- 4:50Yes.
- 4:51I went to see if I could write about
- 4:54smaller towns, too.
- 4:55I see. You dropped a bombshell before
- 4:59leaving for Europe.
- 5:00Yes.
- 5:02Were you able to travel with a calm
- 5:05mind? Well, you check your emails while
- 5:08traveling, right? Yes.
- 5:09And I saw emails from producers wanting
- 5:11to work with me if I started a YouTube
- 5:12channel.
- 5:13Producers.
- 5:14Emails from professionals saying they
- 5:17wanted to work on that.
- 5:20I got several emails like that. So I
- 5:22wondered what was going on.
- 5:25Apparently, some critic went on a
- 5:26broadcast and said I was launching a
- 5:28YouTube channel this week or next.
- 5:31I didn't even know.
- 5:32But that’s not true.
- 5:33Yes. That is not me. I have no such
- 5:35plans. I sent replies saying that to
- 5:36everyone.
- 5:37Oh, is that so?
- 5:38Yes. I don't know why they do that.
- 5:39So, many people seem to believe it, but
- 5:43it’s not true then.
- 5:44If Kim Ou-joon was going to say
- 5:46something like that, he would have done
- 5:48it on his own channel as a joke.
- 5:49Ah.
- 5:50We joked back and forth about me
- 5:52starting a channel if I get cut from
- 5:54the show. People really do make a full
- 5:57course meal out of a single side dish.
- 5:59Oh, really?
- 6:00Ah.
- 6:02That's a good expression. Isn't it? Ah,
- 6:04so that's not true. Yes.
- 6:06Yes. There are many people who just
- 6:09critique based on rumors floating
- 6:10around.
- 6:11Yes.
- 6:11I understand.
- 6:13Hey, lighten up your face a bit. Why do
- 6:14you look so shadowed?
- 6:17This is the happiest I've ever been.
- 6:18Yes. It breaks my heart to see Writer
- 6:24Rhyu Si-min treated this way. I mean,
- 6:27it’s only natural that someone like
- 6:29writer Rhyu Si-min gets criticized, and
- 6:30honestly, I have a few things to
- 6:32criticize him about today too. Me too.
- 6:34Choi Ok gets plenty of heat too, so
- 6:35it’s not just me.
- 6:36Yeah, you guys talk about it like
- 6:38you're talking about someone else. But
- 6:40compared to me, being treated like an
- 6:43armed insurgent or a treasonous force
- 6:46is just—honestly, I think that’s a
- 6:50real problem. And he was just serving
- 6:55as the chairman of the Roh Moo-hyun
- 6:58Foundation, right? Right?
- 7:01I was deeply saddened by how
- 7:04mercilessly he was targeted regarding
- 7:08that as well. But even when I say
- 7:12that it breaks my heart, I get
- 7:14criticized too. People tell me to "get
- 7:16a grip."
- 7:17Hmm. Ah, it really breaks my heart.
- 7:20Well, there’s no need to let it break
- 7:21your heart. Because hoping that people
- 7:25will accept or interpret your words and
- 7:29actions exactly as you intended is just
- 7:34being greedy. That’s not how it works
- 7:38. Sometimes they might, but generally,
- 7:40people are just going to interpret
- 7:42things however they want.
- 7:45Yeah. So, if you’re in criticism or
- 7:48journalism, getting cursed at is just
- 7:51the default setting. It’s a constant.
- 7:53A constant.
- 7:54I see.
- 7:54Yeah. So, there’s no need to get hurt
- 7:56by that. That’s just normal.
- 7:58Yeah.
- 7:59If three or four people out of a
- 8:01hundred understand your point, that’s
- 8:03enough. That's how—
- 8:05Right. But I think the point Choi Ok is
- 8:08making is that those who get hurt
- 8:10aren't bothered by the criticism or
- 8:12attacks against Rhyu Si-min.
- 8:14Uh-huh. You can at least argue back
- 8:16against criticism or attacks.
- 8:18Hmm.
- 8:19But what I’ve witnessed so often is
- 8:21just pure mockery.
- 8:22Hmm.
- 8:23That’s what’s truly heartbreaking.
- 8:25But all of that stems from me, doesn't
- 8:28it?
- 8:29Hmm.
- 8:31If I hadn’t offered my criticism,
- 8:33none of that would have happened. Since
- 8:36everything stems from my own words and
- 8:39actions, I—and Reporter Hong
- 8:42Sang-hoon, you get cursed at sometimes
- 8:45too, right?
- 8:47Plenty.
- 8:47I—that’s what I think. I think all
- 8:49of this—
- 8:50If we fear that, we're essentially dead
- 8:52. Hmm. Because all of this stems from
- 8:55me, from my own acts and words, if I
- 8:58can’t handle it—If I feel bitter or
- 9:01get a headache over it, then I
- 9:03shouldn’t be doing it in the first
- 9:05place.
- 9:07Well, hearing you say that is a huge
- 9:09relief.
- 9:10And it's really cool, but I saw that
- 9:12fishing show and you said you hadn't
- 9:14slept for a few days.
- 9:17I was so stressed out.
- 9:18You seemed to be under a lot of stress.
- 9:20Just let it go.
- 9:21Yeah. I couldn't sleep well the night
- 9:25before.
- 9:26It wasn't because I was being
- 9:28criticized.
- 9:29I was just very worried about the
- 9:30President.
- 9:31Oh, is that so?
- 9:32Yes. That’s why I couldn't sleep.
- 9:34It’s not like I can't sleep because
- 9:36people are bashing me over some
- 9:38criticism I made.
- 9:39That’s not it.
- 9:41Well, back when we were doing 'Dasomeda
- 9:42', I was there with you in the waiting
- 9:43room. You mentioned it back then,
- 9:46didn't you? You talked about it on the
- 9:47air, of course, but you also said you
- 9:49asked about 20 people around you if it
- 9:51was okay to bring it up.
- 9:53They all said don't do it. "You'll be
- 9:55the one to get hurt." I knew I would
- 9:57get hurt, of course. I'm taking a lot
- 9:58of heat right now, aren't I? It's
- 9:59natural that I got hurt. It's natural.
- 10:01But there was one person who said I had
- 10:03to do it.
- 10:04That even if it was just me, I had to
- 10:05speak up. So you said you made up your
- 10:06mind because of that person.
- 10:07You have to cut that person off.
- 10:08That's why I said it.
- 10:09You have to cut that person off. The
- 10:10person who told you to do it. Earlier.
- 10:13That’s the mastermind. I’m curious
- 10:15who that is, too. That.
- 10:16You have to cut them off
- 10:17unconditionally. Someone like that.
- 10:18What’s their last name? What are
- 10:19their initials? They are a truly
- 10:21wonderful person. That person is a
- 10:23wonderful person, and...
- 10:25They’ve been working hard for
- 10:27President Lee Jae-myung since the early
- 10:29days when people started demonizing him
- 10:31. They even contacted me personally ten
- 10:35years ago, earnestly asking me to help
- 10:38Lee Jae-myung.
- 10:41Yes. That’s the kind of person they
- 10:43are, and they were the only one who
- 10:45said, "Even if it's hard for you,
- 10:46please speak up for the President and
- 10:48the country."
- 10:49Well, that person doesn't care about me
- 10:50very much then.
- 10:51I guess so. Really.
- 10:54I mean, they care about the President,
- 10:55but they just used you, Rhyu Si-min,
- 10:57completely. Well, they asked me to do
- 11:00it, knowing it would be hard. That’s
- 11:02how much they care about the President.
- 11:05Yes. While listening to that, I thought
- 11:07, "That person is truly a great person.
- 11:08" That’s what I thought.
- 11:11And I was grateful to everyone who told
- 11:12me not to do it. Those people care
- 11:14about me more than they care about
- 11:16President Lee Jae-myung.
- 11:17Ah.
- 11:17Yes. I remember being in that waiting
- 11:22room, thinking that even though you,
- 11:25Rhyu Si-min, aren't the type to be
- 11:28afraid of being attacked or criticized,
- 11:31it would still be difficult; but I
- 11:34wondered if closing your eyes and
- 11:37keeping your mouth shut would lead to a
- 11:40better result. But it didn't seem like
- 11:44the outcome would improve just by
- 11:46staying silent. So, I’m sorry, but
- 11:48even if it hurts, you have to speak up.
- 11:51Hmm. This.
- 11:52They don't really care about me.
- 11:54So you were here.
- 11:56Then, let me ask you a question. So, I
- 12:01want to ask, has anything actually
- 12:05improved because of that? What do you
- 12:09mean? I did an "ABC Theory" segment on
- 12:11the Mae-bul Show, didn't I?
- 12:13Yes. It's not just because it was the
- 12:16Mae-bul Show, but I still think it was
- 12:19a very good broadcast at the time. Even
- 12:22now, because the situation back then
- 12:25was very chaotic.
- 12:27Hmm.
- 12:28What kind of situation was it? People
- 12:31wearing "pro-Lee" armbands were
- 12:34labeling anyone who supported Lee
- 12:36Jae-myung as "anti-Lee" at will.
- 12:40And they were insulting, criticizing,
- 12:43and acting violently toward those
- 12:46people. That’s what happened during
- 12:48the Park Geun-hye era, like the "
- 12:49Jin-Park"(true pro-Park) checkers.
- 12:50But I found that very hard to accept
- 12:52and it was extremely confusing.
- 12:56In that situation, Writer Rhyu Si-min
- 12:59appeared and analyzed the phenomenon in
- 13:02his own words. I think it was very
- 13:05meaningful. But this time, appearing on
- 13:08Das Veida to talk about "Introduction
- 13:10to Architecture"...I’m very skeptical
- 13:14about what kind of meaning that had. It
- 13:17was just noisy.
- 13:19I’m skeptical that it served any
- 13:21public interest for our nation.
- 13:24Hmm. That is a preview of what will
- 13:26happen within the Democratic Party in
- 13:29the future. In political jargon, this
- 13:31is called political restructuring.
- 13:33Yes.
- 13:33Political restructuring. Chief Hong
- 13:36Ik-pyo mentioned in a media interview
- 13:39that besides remodeling, there is also
- 13:41redevelopment.
- 13:43Yes. So, there is small-scale political
- 13:46restructuring. Then there is
- 13:48medium-scale political restructuring.
- 13:50And there is large-scale, comprehensive
- 13:52political restructuring.
- 13:53Yes. What I call remodeling is taking
- 13:56the Democratic Party as a base and
- 13:59adding new elements, much like Casa
- 14:02Batlló in Barcelona. It was someone
- 14:06else’s house, but they asked Gaudí
- 14:09to renovate it, so Gaudí did the
- 14:12renovation.
- 14:14The house wasn't originally built by
- 14:16Gaudí.
- 14:16But it turned into a very wonderful
- 14:19house.
- 14:20Yes. Likewise, we can take the existing
- 14:23Democratic Party and add new elements
- 14:25to build a better, more impressive
- 14:28house, different from the past. This is
- 14:30small-scale restructuring. To do that
- 14:33...
- 14:33You have to pull in elements that
- 14:35weren't originally in the Democratic
- 14:37Party, like taking a pillar from
- 14:39another house or stripping parts, so
- 14:41the other house changes slightly too.
- 14:43Yes. Secondly, what I called
- 14:47redevelopment isn't just that; it's
- 14:49building a new house. Redevelopment is.
- 14:54To build a new house, you must tear
- 14:56down the existing one, discard some
- 14:59materials, reuse others, and mix them
- 15:01with new ones brought from elsewhere.
- 15:05That’s different from the old house.
- 15:07That is different from remodeling. It
- 15:09is medium-scale restructuring. This is
- 15:12it.
- 15:14It’s more like absorbing small
- 15:16parties or peeling off parts of other
- 15:19large parties. Then there's
- 15:22redevelopment, which means changing the
- 15:23entire neighborhood, right? Hmm.
- 15:25That’s like changing the entire
- 15:26landscape of Korean politics.
- 15:28It’s a massive undertaking. Yeah.
- 15:31There are three ways of restructuring,
- 15:34and we usually expected a small-scale
- 15:37restructuring. Like expanding the
- 15:40outreach, building upon the Democratic
- 15:42Party foundation. Like remodeling or
- 15:45adding an extension to a house; they
- 15:47really thought about that, but it seems
- 15:49the President is thinking about the
- 15:51second or third option. I was talking
- 15:54about the reality. I was talking about
- 15:57the reality, and because meaningful
- 15:59actions only appeared when he had the
- 16:01second or third option in mind,
- 16:03Especially the disparagement, mockery,
- 16:06and attacks on President Moon Jae-in,
- 16:08Lumping together the "Moon-lovers" and
- 16:11"elderly supporters," and grouping news
- 16:14outlets, even talk shows, and critics
- 16:16like me into a single faction to attack
- 16:19them ideologically, morally, and
- 16:21politically for over six months—this
- 16:24is unimaginable unless it's a project
- 16:27to tear something down. All of this.
- 16:30So, I said it seems like they’re
- 16:32doing at least the second option,
- 16:34reconstruction, or redevelopment—and
- 16:35redevelopment is even harder.
- 16:38So some critics and media say he's
- 16:41acting like the owner, but that’s not
- 16:44it.
- 16:45I believe he could do redevelopment.
- 16:47I believe he could also do
- 16:48reconstruction.
- 16:49Yes.
- 16:49And of course, he could do an extension
- 16:51, too.
- 16:51Hmm. If that is accepted by the people,
- 16:53it can succeed.
- 16:54Hmm.
- 16:55And if the times demand it, it could be
- 16:57meaningful.
- 16:58Hmm.
- 16:58But let's look at what the current
- 17:00situation actually is. Is the
- 17:02Democratic Party a party with so many
- 17:04problems that it needs reconstruction?
- 17:06Not at all. It’s different from the
- 17:08Democratic Party in 2002. Back then,
- 17:10with the New Politics National Congress
- 17:12, they tried to replace the candidate
- 17:14after picking one, and they didn't even
- 17:17use the government subsidies for the
- 17:18campaign, right? It’s not a party
- 17:21like that anymore. The Democratic Party
- 17:23is a party that firmly supported
- 17:24President Lee Jae-myung, holds an
- 17:26overwhelming majority of seats, and is
- 17:28the leading party in the National
- 17:29Assembly. Yeah.
- 17:30If the supporters perceive that the
- 17:33party must be reconstructed or else,
- 17:35then you can go ahead and reconstruct
- 17:37it. You should.
- 17:39Hmm.
- 17:39But that’s not the case right now. So
- 17:40what I'm saying is, while you can do
- 17:42reconstruction or redevelopment,
- 17:44Hmm.
- 17:46It has to be in a situation where it's
- 17:48necessary, and the public must perceive
- 17:50that need for it to be successful. In
- 17:53my view, right now, neither
- 17:54reconstruction
- 17:56nor redevelopment—meaning neither
- 17:58medium-scale nor large-scale,
- 17:59comprehensive restructuring—will
- 18:01succeed. That’s exactly what I wanted
- 18:03to say. It seems like the president is
- 18:05trying to do this. Too many things are
- 18:08happening that can't be explained
- 18:10otherwise.
- 18:10Hmm.
- 18:11That judgment still stands.
- 18:13Yes. I think it’s almost certain.
- 18:16That’s how you see it.
- 18:17I’m saying everything is possible.
- 18:20Take Representative Kim Jong-dae, for
- 18:22example, 20 years ago when the Uri
- 18:23Party was formed, they pushed for
- 18:25redevelopment.
- 18:26Why block this redevelopment now?
- 18:27Criticism. Let’s look at Rhyu Si-min.
- 18:29From the special prosecutor on North
- 18:31Korean remittances to the founding of
- 18:33the Uri Party, the early Roh Moo-hyun
- 18:34administration was chaotic. Professor
- 18:36Kang Jun-man, the spiritual mentor who
- 18:39helped create President Roh,
- 18:41started criticizing President Roh. Kang
- 18:43Jun-man asked why he was doing "
- 18:45redevelopment." He argued it betrayed
- 18:47the people who supported him, and who
- 18:49criticized Professor Kang the most? It
- 18:51was Rhyu Si-min. He said, "The
- 18:53president is fighting reforms, fighting
- 18:55the media, and bleeding against the
- 18:56establishment, yet Professor Kang is
- 18:58opposing him based on regionalism.""The
- 19:00president hates regionalism most, and
- 19:02that is exactly the deep-rooted evil."
- 19:03That’s how he fought back.
- 19:04No, that’s not it. I wasn't
- 19:05criticizing him. If it sounded that way
- 19:08, I expressed it poorly.
- 19:10In politics, everything is possible.
- 19:12You do what you must.
- 19:13Right. Yes.
- 19:14It did sound like a criticism, though.
- 19:15Is that so?
- 19:20That’s how I heard it.
- 19:21Ah, try to sound more upbeat then. More
- 19:23upbeat.
- 19:23I didn’t mean to criticize, you can
- 19:25do it, but
- 19:27It won't be seen as necessary, it will
- 19:30be hard to prove, people won't accept
- 19:33it, and the current method won't work.
- 19:36That. Hmm. The party will be shattered,
- 19:40the coalition will collapse.
- 19:42I warned about it because it’s highly
- 19:45likely to end in a disastrous result.
- 19:48It’s not that such things are
- 19:50forbidden in politics. Anyone can do it
- 19:52.
- 19:52So, in your view, the chances of it
- 19:55succeeding are low. Yes. I see it as
- 19:57almost zero.
- 19:58Then why do you think President Lee
- 20:00Jae-myung is trying to do it? I haven't
- 20:02reached a conclusion on that yet. Since
- 20:05I don't have other information, I’m
- 20:07just deducing from the visible facts.
- 20:11As for the motives, we can’t read
- 20:14minds, so I can’t speak to that yet.
- 20:18Hmm.
- 20:18I’m just describing the situation
- 20:20based on what’s visible.
- 20:21Yes. So, you’ve judged that they seem
- 20:24to be attempting a reconstruction or
- 20:26perhaps a redevelopment, and you’re
- 20:28confident there’s no error in that
- 20:30judgment, right? As of now.
- 20:33Yes, looking at various things—the
- 20:35appointments, for instance.
- 20:39And the way the issue of prosecution
- 20:41reform is being handled, as well as the
- 20:44president's own words—there are just
- 20:46too many things that wouldn't happen if
- 20:49they didn't have that mindset. Well
- 20:52then, to narrow it down, let’s take
- 20:54the appointments for example.
- 20:58What specific appointments would lead
- 21:00you to believe they are thinking about
- 21:02reconstruction or redevelopment?
- 21:05There are many such appointments. Uh.
- 21:08Why, we all know them, don't we?
- 21:10What do you mean, I don't know?
- 21:11Starting with the Minister of Personnel
- 21:13Management.
- 21:14And the recent issue with Lee Byung-tae
- 21:16from KAIST, that "New Right" figure.
- 21:18The same goes for In Yo-han.
- 21:19Couldn't that just be seen as an
- 21:21expansion? Well, it could be a
- 21:23redevelopment.
- 21:24You don't need those kinds of people
- 21:25for an expansion. Such people.
- 21:27Ah, don't be like that.
- 21:30I think Writer Rhyu is right on that
- 21:32point, actually.
- 21:33Oh, just stay out of it. Why are you
- 21:35blowing this out of proportion?
- 21:37Expansion. I mean, has President Moon
- 21:40Jae-in ever said anything like this? Ah
- 21:44, he once said that he uses far more
- 21:47people from our side and that people
- 21:49are making too big a deal out of the
- 21:51one or two he hired from the other side
- 21:54.
- 21:55Some media outlets were even writing
- 21:57strange articles saying, "If you give
- 21:59all the positions to the conservatives,
- 22:00what about the people who helped you
- 22:02get elected?" But what "giving
- 22:04everything" are they talking about?
- 22:06Among the current cabinet members, are
- 22:07there any others besides Minister Song
- 22:09from our side? Well, there probably are
- 22:10a few. It's not a stretch; they mostly
- 22:13maintain the mainstream stance, keeping
- 22:16the fundamental values and principles,
- 22:18but the point is that this alone isn't
- 22:20enough. So, as long as those values
- 22:22aren't compromised, the goal is to cast
- 22:25a wider net for talent and expand the
- 22:27playing field. He overwhelmingly hired
- 22:29people from the Democratic Party side.
- 22:32That’s only natural. He is a
- 22:33president from the Democratic Party.
- 22:35And he did bring some people in from
- 22:37the other side. Many of those brought
- 22:39in have settled in quite well.
- 22:41Yes.
- 22:42But there are also many cases where
- 22:43they caused trouble. Like Mr. Lee
- 22:45Byung-tae, or even though he wasn't
- 22:47appointed, the controversy over Lee
- 22:49Hoe-chang, and there are various other
- 22:52such examples. But it's not like we're
- 22:55complaining, "Why aren't you giving
- 22:57positions to our people instead of
- 22:59bringing in others?" It’s just that
- 23:02when they hire someone, people wonder
- 23:04why they were brought in.
- 23:06Why bring them in?
- 23:07It doesn’t seem like they were
- 23:08brought in just because they are good
- 23:09at their jobs.
- 23:09Hmm.
- 23:10Hmm. That’s why people are suspicious
- 23:13. Regarding those appointments.
- 23:16I mean, when you bring in people needed
- 23:18for expansion, everyone applauds, but
- 23:20aren't those people unnecessary for
- 23:22expansion?
- 23:23Hmm.
- 23:24There’s a lot of that.
- 23:25So, I think it’s better if I explain
- 23:28that part myself.
- 23:29You know, the talk about house rabbits
- 23:31and wild rabbits.
- 23:32Of course, who would object to
- 23:33expanding our reach to wild rabbits?
- 23:35It’s clearly the path we should take,
- 23:37and something worth
- 23:37applauding. Yes. It’s also the spirit
- 23:39of the Maebul Show.
- 23:40But shouldn't we avoid bringing in
- 23:42wolves instead of wild rabbits and
- 23:43having them eat all the house rabbits?
- 23:45That's a bit of a stretch.
- 23:46That’s too much—come on.
- 23:49Go ahead, you speak first.
- 23:54I was trying to tone it down, but
- 23:56you’re making it worse. Wolves,
- 23:59seriously?
- 24:00What do you mean, "eat them"?
- 24:01There aren’t even any wolves there,
- 24:02where would wolves come from?
- 24:03Who did he ever eat?
- 24:06He just went off on his own, like a
- 24:07wild animal.
- 24:07Exactly. He tripped over his own feet.
- 24:10Please, strike that "wild animal"
- 24:11remark from the record. And moving on
- 24:16to something bigger, there's the issue
- 24:18of prosecution reform.
- 24:19Oh, are we moving on already?
- 24:20Prosecution reform.
- 24:20Well, there are various political
- 24:22situations. This
- 24:23It’s the hottest topic right now.
- 24:24Because it’s the hottest.
- 24:27But since you brought up the
- 24:28prosecution, before we discuss
- 24:30prosecution reform—
- 24:33Hmm.
- 24:33There’s something that makes me very
- 24:35sad. I mean, how many times have I
- 24:37talked about the prosecution on the
- 24:39Maebul Show alone? And how many times
- 24:42did I discuss it back when I was on KBS
- 24:44?
- 24:44Yes.
- 24:45Yet, I have never once been pressured
- 24:50by comments before.
- 24:52Hmm.
- 24:53But I’m saying the exact same things
- 24:55I said back then. Now, I’m receiving
- 24:58an incredible amount of pressure.
- 25:00Are you whining about it?
- 25:01No, I’m not whining. It’s that if
- 25:03my opinions had changed, people’s
- 25:05evaluations of me might change, right?
- 25:08But the same people who wanted
- 25:10prosecution reform are now attacking me
- 25:13, even though my stance hasn't changed.
- 25:17I find that very confusing.
- 25:18Well, there are many people who don't
- 25:20want prosecution reform. It’s already
- 25:21a public—
- 25:22I don’t mean people like those in the
- 25:24People Power Party camp.
- 25:25I mean even among those who claim to
- 25:27support President Lee Jae-myung.
- 25:29There are many, right now.
- 25:31I’m saying that it wasn’t like that
- 25:32before.
- 25:32Exactly. Why? Because they know the
- 25:34President doesn't want it.
- 25:36Yes, they act out like that.
- 25:37Yes. The reason prosecution reform
- 25:40hasn't happened for over a year is that
- 25:42the President doesn't want the complete
- 25:44separation of investigation and
- 25:46indictment. We are already past the
- 25:47time when we should have reached that
- 25:49conclusion. People try to avoid looking
- 25:53at the truth by looking through broken
- 25:55glasses, or taking them off entirely,
- 25:58because they're afraid of facing what
- 26:00the President and his subordinates—
- 26:02the Minister of Justice or the Senior
- 26:05Secretary for Civil Affairs—are
- 26:07actually doing. We've reached this
- 26:10point because the President didn't want
- 26:12it otherwise; there is no other way to
- 26:14explain it. That’s why those who are
- 26:18certain the President doesn't want
- 26:20change continue to advocate for keeping
- 26:22investigative powers with the
- 26:24prosecution under the name of "
- 26:26supplementary investigation," even in
- 26:28the public media sphere. I believe we
- 26:32must face that fact and accept it as
- 26:35reality.
- 26:36Why? How can we accept that? Exactly.
- 26:39Even before the election, when Lee
- 26:40Jae-myung was a presidential candidate,
- 26:42he personally suffered tremendously at
- 26:44the hands of the prosecution.
- 26:46That’s why he advocated for
- 26:48prosecution reform and made it a
- 26:50campaign pledge. In your view, Writer
- 26:52Yoo,
- 26:53has President Lee's thinking changed,
- 26:55or do you think he never had the will
- 26:57to begin with?
- 26:59I won't even go there. Whether he made
- 27:01that pledge without any real intent or
- 27:03if he meant it sincerely but changed
- 27:04his mind after becoming president, I
- 27:06won't question that.
- 27:07Right.
- 27:08If you look at what happened in the
- 27:10year since he took office, those two
- 27:11legislative notices could not have been
- 27:14issued without the President's approval
- 27:16. That is
- 27:17Well, we
- 27:18Hmm.
- 27:18What
- 27:19Exactly.
- 27:19Why are you acting like you don't know?
- 27:23The President ordered it. I believe
- 27:25there is no other explanation for it.
- 27:28And because he was pressured by public
- 27:31opinion, he boldly adjusted the
- 27:33Investigative Agency bill in March. But
- 27:36the President didn't judge it as, "I
- 27:38listened to public opinion and did a
- 27:39good job," but rather, "I couldn't do
- 27:41what I wanted.""I lost." That seems to
- 27:43be his judgment. That’s why the Prime
- 27:46Minister's Office formed a task force,
- 27:48spent about 1.7 billion won over a year
- 27:50, and then
- 27:50didn't even submit a government
- 27:52proposal and just folded it. If the
- 27:53President had decided it needed to be
- 27:54done, he would have had a proposal
- 27:56submitted. He prevented a proposal from
- 27:57being submitted. I also see this as
- 27:59something the President blocked. And
- 28:00even now, some lawmakers are currently
- 28:03trying to keep parts of it alive
- 28:05by introducing a bill to amend the law
- 28:06to leave some investigative authority
- 28:08with the prosecution under the name of
- 28:09"supplementary investigation." Holding
- 28:11press conferences and doing all these
- 28:12things—I think they are doing it
- 28:14because they know the President's
- 28:15thoughts.
- 28:16So that is how you see it. Hmm.
- 28:17But regarding what our reporter said
- 28:19earlier, I think we need to correct
- 28:21this.
- 28:23I looked up a few things Lee Jae-myung
- 28:25said about the prosecution before he
- 28:28took office, and
- 28:30Yes.
- 28:30Investigative authority should not be
- 28:32granted solely to the police. There
- 28:33have been times when concerns were
- 28:35raised regarding that. Yes. There were.
- 28:38Yes. I think that needs to be corrected
- 28:40, yes. If that is true, look at
- 28:42what’s happening yesterday and today:
- 28:45Democratic Party lawmakers on the
- 28:48Legislation and Judiciary Committee are
- 28:51officially opposing the abolition of
- 28:54investigative authority. They have
- 28:56publicly stated that this should not be
- 28:58passed.
- 28:59Given the composition of the committee,
- 29:01the prosecution reform bill to abolish
- 29:02investigative authority cannot pass if
- 29:04that's the case. Now.
- 29:07So, while we hear about these things
- 29:09through the media, this is what I find
- 29:11important. I believe a president can
- 29:13decide that it's better to leave some
- 29:15investigative authority with the
- 29:16prosecution. I do.
- 29:17Yes.
- 29:19They can make that judgment. Right, the
- 29:22election pledge. They made that pledge
- 29:27in the 2022 presidential election, when
- 29:29they lost, and again when they won this
- 29:31time. But after becoming president,
- 29:33seeing the situation, they might judge
- 29:35that since the police are becoming too
- 29:37powerful and lack other checks, it
- 29:39would be better to keep some authority
- 29:40for these reasons. If so, they should
- 29:44ask the public for their understanding.
- 29:48They should come out and say, "Actually
- 29:51, I made this pledge, but due to these
- 29:53issues, I think it would be better to
- 29:55proceed with these conditions." They
- 29:59should have handled it responsibly. But
- 30:01look at how the president has acted.
- 30:04They had the Justice Minister and the
- 30:06Prime Minister do it, which is how it's
- 30:07been handled so far. The president has
- 30:09handled this issue in a Machiavellian
- 30:10way. Make your subordinates take the
- 30:12blame for unpopular things. That’s
- 30:13something straight out of "The Prince."
- 30:15And take credit for popular things
- 30:17yourself. It’s all in there. But
- 30:19that’s a method of governance from a
- 30:22time before even print media existed,
- 30:24and it doesn't fit this era. This could
- 30:27also be related to reconstruction or
- 30:29redevelopment projects. That is how I
- 30:32see it.
- 30:33Author.
- 30:34Hmm. Today's broadcast. What would you
- 30:43like to see this broadcast accomplish
- 30:46in our society after it airs? These
- 30:49points you are making.
- 30:50Everything discussed.
- 30:51Yes.
- 30:52It’s about facing reality. There is a
- 30:54book among Lee Jae-myung’s
- 30:56bestsellers titled "In the End, It Is
- 30:58the People."
- 30:59Yes. In the end, the people do it. I
- 31:02believe this is a very misguided
- 31:04judgment, harmful to both the
- 31:06individual and the nation, but only by
- 31:09accepting facts as they are can the
- 31:12people eventually do something. To
- 31:15complete reforms like the prosecution
- 31:19reform, or to steer our politics and
- 31:22political parties in a more rational
- 31:25direction, I believe it's only possible
- 31:29if citizens see all that's happening
- 31:32for exactly what it is and why it's
- 31:35occurring.
- 31:36Mm. So, from your perspective, does
- 31:40President Lee Jae-myung...Is he heading
- 31:45down the wrong path? Well.
- 31:47Actually, I won't call it the wrong
- 31:49path.
- 31:49President Lee Jae-myung has chosen a
- 31:51certain route, a certain path.
- 31:52Mm.
- 31:53He made a choice, and I respect that
- 31:55choice.
- 31:55I respect it, but...
- 31:57It's an extremely dangerous choice.
- 31:59Mm.
- 32:00Both for him and for society. And I do
- 32:03want to say that it's very difficult to
- 32:05succeed using the methods he has
- 32:07employed so far. But I have no
- 32:09intention of telling the President this
- 32:11. Because I don't think he chose that
- 32:15path out of ignorance; the President
- 32:17reviewed everything based on his own
- 32:19standards and chose his path. But I
- 32:23foresee that his choice will end in
- 32:25failure.
- 32:26Actually, that's exactly what I was
- 32:28about to ask you. Are you saying that
- 32:31in your view, he is heading toward
- 32:32failure?
- 32:33Yes. That's different from calling it
- 32:35the "wrong path," right?
- 32:35Yes. So, you mean...
- 32:38From Rhyu Si-min’s perspective, the
- 32:40path President Lee is taking is one
- 32:43that won't succeed—he’s heading
- 32:45toward failure. And you wish for the
- 32:48public to realize this quickly so it
- 32:49doesn't end in failure. So that the
- 32:51public might help correct it. Out of
- 32:54good intentions, yes.
- 32:55Then, if you have such good intentions
- 32:57for him to succeed, aren't you someone
- 33:00who had a relationship of trust with
- 33:02the President? I wouldn't know for sure
- 33:06, but couldn't you meet him personally
- 33:08to discuss this, to avoid conflict and
- 33:11lead things in a better direction? I
- 33:14have this critical awareness.
- 33:16Mm. Yes.
- 33:17Do younger people like Hwang Hee-do
- 33:19here also share this sense of awareness
- 33:20?
- 33:20I have a very strong sense of this.
- 33:22You’re absolutely with me on this.
- 33:24Yes. I agree with you.
- 33:25What do you think? Doesn't that sound
- 33:27perfectly reasonable? Right? Some...
- 33:29I think that if you're someone like
- 33:31Rhyu Si-min,
- 33:33you should consider that method.
- 33:36Exactly. Meeting in private, that would
- 33:38be a "secret channel."
- 33:38Why would that be a secret channel?
- 33:40It's just communication. There are
- 33:41official lines and official channels,
- 33:43but...
- 33:43How, for example...
- 33:44Are you saying that YouTubers who claim
- 33:46they communicate with the President
- 33:48daily are doing the same thing?
- 33:50That's not the same thing. Look here.
- 33:53Conservative commentators also meet him
- 33:55publicly. Why would that be a secret
- 33:57channel? For instance, if two people
- 34:00meet and trade favors, that's a problem
- 34:02. But when Rhyu Si-min meets the
- 34:06President, it’s not for personal
- 34:08interests, is it?
- 34:09If Hwang Hee-doo, for instance, asked
- 34:11for a meeting with the president at the
- 34:13Blue House, would you meet with him?
- 34:15Of course, I would.
- 34:17Oh, really?
- 34:17Yes.
- 34:18Well, for me, it's more like this.
- 34:24Actually, since the Moon Jae-in
- 34:26administration, whenever they asked for
- 34:29my opinion on an issue, yes. I would
- 34:32share my thoughts.
- 34:33Yes.
- 34:34I don't go out of my way to say, "You
- 34:36shouldn't do this" or "You must do that
- 34:39." I’m living my own life, after all.
- 34:41Oh, that’s true.
- 34:42For me, it’s really about writing and
- 34:44the occasional critique. That’s my
- 34:46way of relating to the world.
- 34:48It’s how I exist. Yes, it’s how I
- 34:52live within this world. I live my life
- 34:54according to my own rules.
- 34:58Actually, people often misunderstand
- 35:00this; when President Roh Moo-hyun was
- 35:03in office, I was an election campaigner
- 35:05.
- 35:07Yes.
- 35:07Because I was an campaigner, I had
- 35:08responsibilities that came with that
- 35:10role.
- 35:10Hmm. So, I always spoke and acted from
- 35:13that position. With President Moon
- 35:15Jae-in, I’ve mentioned my "Darth
- 35:17Vader" days. Under President Moon, I
- 35:19was just an intermittent volunteer or a
- 35:22volunteer who occasionally offered
- 35:24policy advice. Occasionally. So, I
- 35:27didn't hold responsibility for that
- 35:29administration.
- 35:31Right.
- 35:31I did my part from the outside. It's
- 35:33the same for a Lee Jae-myung
- 35:34administration. Regarding President Lee
- 35:36Jae-myung, my role is just someone who
- 35:39supported him as a politician in the
- 35:41public sphere.
- 35:42Right.
- 35:43I’m not a campaigner, an aide, or a
- 35:45subordinate.
- 35:47So, when do I respond? I respond to
- 35:49consultations when asked for my opinion
- 35:51on a certain issue. During the Moon
- 35:54administration, it happened exactly
- 35:55once. When President Moon was gathering
- 36:00opinions from many people on whether or
- 36:02not it was a good idea to appoint Cho
- 36:04Kuk, he contacted me as well.
- 36:07Yes.
- 36:08And I responded with my advice. Based
- 36:12on my judgment and reasoning, I said
- 36:14that I thought it would be better in
- 36:16many ways to go ahead with the
- 36:18appointment.
- 36:19I don't think he made the appointment
- 36:20just because I said so. I assume many
- 36:22others gave him conflicting opinions.
- 36:26President Lee Jae-myung, since becoming
- 36:28president, has never asked for my
- 36:30opinion on any issue.
- 36:31Right.
- 36:32So why would I go meet him to discuss
- 36:34things?
- 36:35Oh, I see. Well, of course.
- 36:38I admit it’s unfair of me to place
- 36:41such a heavy burden on you, writer.
- 36:45That is true. No. And in a way, I
- 36:48understand why you’d feel that way.
- 36:50However,
- 36:51Even a small person like me worries
- 36:54constantly about the country going in
- 36:56the wrong direction. Even you, speaking
- 37:00out and facing criticism here, are
- 37:01doing so out of concern for our country
- 37:03, aren't you? So, I was expressing my
- 37:07desire that perhaps you could meet and
- 37:11talk with a bit more sense of
- 37:13responsibility. You see the President
- 37:18in public settings. You hear what he
- 37:21says. Right? You see how he makes
- 37:24decisions. You have to judge based on
- 37:26that.
- 37:27Hmm. So, I personally felt this through
- 37:31everything the President said and did
- 37:34in public, and as someone who supported
- 37:38the politician Lee Jae-myung, my
- 37:41critiques were not made for President
- 37:44Yoon to hear, but for the citizens to
- 37:48hear.
- 37:49Our book right now is speaking to the
- 37:52citizens.
- 37:53To the citizens.
- 37:54Yes. I see that as our duty, and to say
- 37:57we should meet and talk is actually
- 37:59ignoring the President's role. That’s
- 38:02how I see it. I don’t believe
- 38:04communication is happening. And I have
- 38:06no intention of meeting to talk. I’m
- 38:08not making these critiques for the
- 38:10President to hear, either. I am telling
- 38:14the citizens about the facts I see and
- 38:16the reality I perceive, and based on
- 38:19this, I’m saying that if the people
- 38:21don't step up to correct things, there
- 38:24is no other way to fix them. That is
- 38:28what I am talking about now.
- 38:29If I may be so bold as to step out of
- 38:31line,
- 38:32You should step out of line. Today, you
- 38:35and I, anchor Choi, are communicating
- 38:38back and forth. On air.
- 38:41That’s true.
- 38:42But the time when I truly understand
- 38:45you the most and realize what concerns
- 38:47you are facing is during the
- 38:49conversations we have before the
- 38:51broadcast starts.
- 38:53Hmm.
- 38:54So I do understand a lot. Ah, so
- 38:56that’s the struggle you’re dealing
- 38:57with. In that context, public
- 39:00communication is extremely important.
- 39:03And since you are a writer, Mr. Rhyu,
- 39:06I think the way you communicate with
- 39:08citizens is also valid, but you have
- 39:11been emphasizing on air that things
- 39:13seem to be heading in the wrong
- 39:15direction.
- 39:16Hmm. Heading toward failure.
- 39:18Yes. If you’ve judged that things are
- 39:21heading toward failure,
- 39:22Hmm. I think that even your method of
- 39:25communication
- 39:26might be worth changing for once. I
- 39:27think there’s a need for a variation.
- 39:29Then there would be two foreseeable
- 39:32outcomes. One is that you might
- 39:36discover, "Oh, I was a bit harsh in my
- 39:39judgment," or you might actually be
- 39:42able to persuade them.
- 39:45Don't believe in such things.
- 39:48Modern politics doesn't work like that.
- 39:50Modern politics—
- 39:52That is the job for those who
- 39:53participated in the process of making a
- 39:55president as campaign workers, aides,
- 39:57or staffers. It is not my job.
- 40:00That is what I think.
- 40:01The reason I say this is because I
- 40:03often feel that there is real power in
- 40:05words. I have a very regretful
- 40:08confession to make.
- 40:11People always criticized and hated on
- 40:13the "Moon-Jo-Teol-Le-U" group. And they
- 40:16accused Rhyu Si-min of being anti-Lee
- 40:17Jae-myung. I was one of those who were
- 40:19truly furious about that.
- 40:20Ah, I see. "Rhyu Si-min is anti-Lee,
- 40:24dreaming of the revival of the pro-Moon
- 40:27faction." That’s nonsense. I even
- 40:29spoke out about it publicly,
- 40:32I fought tooth and nail.
- 40:33But as this kept building up,
- 40:37I actually started to wonder if it
- 40:39could be true.
- 40:41Ah, the power of words. So I looked
- 40:44into the past conversations between
- 40:47Rhyu Si-min and Lee Jae-myung before he
- 40:50became president.
- 40:52I searched for what kind of things they
- 40:54said to each other.
- 40:55There were quite a few. Those kinds of
- 40:57things.
- 40:57I looked into it, and whenever
- 41:00President Lee faced a crisis, Rhyu
- 41:03Si-min always helped him in his own way
- 41:06. For example, there were times when
- 41:08the demonization was severe, right?
- 41:09Back then, he even gave him chances to
- 41:12clarify things on his show. But when he
- 41:15gave him those chances, President Lee
- 41:18took it the wrong way. But even that,
- 41:21they later resolved through
- 41:23conversation and accepted it; it was
- 41:25great to see. It’s a relationship
- 41:27built on trust. Hmm, honestly. You
- 41:30asked if there was an issue with
- 41:31emotional regulation, didn't you?
- 41:33You've been receiving a lot of attacks
- 41:34lately, right? There are audio files of
- 41:37arguments circulating, and rumors about
- 41:38him grabbing people by the collar, lots
- 41:40of things. If you look at the
- 41:43circumstances one by one, they are
- 41:45understandable, but in my view, as a
- 41:47presidential candidate, doesn't he have
- 41:48a flaw in his ability to regulate
- 41:50emotions? I want to ask Mr. Rhyu how he
- 41:53would react if his mother were
- 41:54assaulted and hospitalized. Just once.
- 41:56See, he reacts so nastily like this.
- 42:00That’s his weakness.
- 42:02I made a fatal mistake; he was actually
- 42:04trying to give me an opportunity, but I
- 42:06thought, "Why is he saying this at New
- 42:08Year's?"
- 42:08I felt hurt.
- 42:09Yes. I was disappointed. But that was a
- 42:11misjudgment on my part.
- 42:12Didn't you snap in anger then?
- 42:13I didn't snap, I asked him right there.
- 42:15You did snap. See, I told you that you
- 42:18shouldn't speak so nastily.
- 42:19That is a clear lack of training. A
- 42:21lack of discipline; I really think that
- 42:22advice was right.
- 42:23Yes. I admit it. And even when he was
- 42:28about to be taken in by the prosecution
- 42:32, Rhyu Si-min comforted him and
- 42:35encouraged him in his own way.
- 42:38Representative Lee Jae-myung is an
- 42:39important person. Even if, by any
- 42:41chance, a warrant is issued and he goes
- 42:44to the detention center, he must apply
- 42:46for a review of the legality of the
- 42:47detention, request bail, and continue
- 42:49to fight legally. And I don't think he
- 42:51should step down from his position as
- 42:52party leader. He should run from inside
- 42:54the prison too. He should approve
- 42:55documents from prison too. This is a
- 42:56battle of nerves. Basically, if you
- 42:57lose the power struggle, your formation
- 42:59collapses at that moment, so the best
- 43:01resources in the political arena will
- 43:03now go out under the name of party
- 43:04leader Lee Jae-myung. That's what was
- 43:06said, and I see that as a signal. Just
- 43:08back him up, Jae-myung. Just do it. It
- 43:10was good, wasn't it? That relationship.
- 43:12Of course. I supported it fervently.
- 43:13Exactly.
- 43:14I supported it hard and had high
- 43:16expectations.
- 43:16So if you did it then, why can't you do
- 43:17it now, that's what I'm asking.
- 43:19That all happened in the public arena,
- 43:20right?
- 43:20It was in the public arena. That's true
- 43:22. I can confirm that back then he was a
- 43:24party leader, but now he is the
- 43:26President.
- 43:27So it's different.
- 43:28How is it the same?
- 43:29It's not the same at all. Why ignore
- 43:31politics back then? Well, since Mr.
- 43:34Hwang is the best at online matters,
- 43:36Lee Jae-myung is a president who is
- 43:38very savvy online, right? Yes.
- 43:40Right. But for the past year since he
- 43:43took office, you know the activities of
- 43:45the so-called Lee Jae-myung supporters
- 43:47online.
- 43:48The President couldn't possibly be
- 43:49unaware of that.
- 43:50He must know everything.
- 43:51In my feeling,
- 43:53The basic concept is instilling hatred.
- 43:56I perceive the core of the activities
- 43:59of the so-called online pro-Lee faction
- 44:01as inciting hatred toward those they
- 44:04want to eliminate. Am I being too
- 44:06sensitive? What do you think? No.
- 44:08Actually, I have collected a lot of
- 44:10data from the "Lee Jae-myung Can Do It"
- 44:12gallery on DC Inside.
- 44:13There’s also a Lee Jae-myung fan cafe
- 44:14, right?
- 44:15Yes. I gathered a lot of that material,
- 44:17and from two years ago, specifically
- 44:19from '24, there were massive attacks on
- 44:21the pro-Roh and pro-Moon factions, and
- 44:24they attacked former President Roh
- 44:26Moo-hyun beyond belief.
- 44:27It was a total mess, and that's why
- 44:29when I came out last time, most
- 44:30Democratic politicians talked about the
- 44:32spirit of Roh Moo-hyun, and they all
- 44:34did that. But are they unaware of these
- 44:36problems? It makes no sense. I've
- 44:37talked to a few people about it too.
- 44:38That this kind of thing is happening.
- 44:40But they all ignored it. But in fact,
- 44:42you don't necessarily have to spend all
- 44:44your time online like me to know this;
- 44:46it all gets circulated through word of
- 44:47mouth. It's been neglected for a long
- 44:50time, but recently, politicians
- 44:51suddenly started using a "both-sides"
- 44:53argument, telling both sides to stop.
- 44:55That's why I was so angry.
- 44:57I actually felt quite hurt by that, too
- 44:58. That is also true. Now, there is
- 45:01content that I edited out entirely from
- 45:03the space.
- 45:05You edited all of that out?
- 45:06There must be a reason for the editing.
- 45:08Because it was all edited out, the
- 45:09President...
- 45:09I had my reasons for that, too. Looking
- 45:11at it...
- 45:13Many people criticized me for saying
- 45:15that the President seemed overly
- 45:17confident.
- 45:19But I explained a few reasons why I
- 45:21came to that judgment. But here is the
- 45:25most serious point: among many of
- 45:27President Lee Jae-myung's actions—not
- 45:30just his words, but his actual deeds—
- 45:32I believe they are all related to
- 45:34redevelopment and reconstruction
- 45:36projects, where he constantly tries to
- 45:39place his own people in every key
- 45:41decision-making position.
- 45:44So, what happened? If you look closely,
- 45:47he made the Democratic Party's Seoul
- 45:49mayoral primary unfair. The President
- 45:52promoted Jeong Bong-ju on social media,
- 45:54making it an unfair primary. The
- 45:57President supported him, didn't he?
- 45:59You should really cycle through some
- 46:00other opinions on this.
- 46:02Oh, I don't necessarily agree with
- 46:04everything you're saying, either. I
- 46:06mean...
- 46:07No, but that's something a President
- 46:09shouldn't do. Usually.
- 46:11You shouldn't do that. You shouldn't,
- 46:13and in the Gyeonggi Province
- 46:15gubernatorial primary, he ran around
- 46:17calling it a "Myung-pick," yet the Blue
- 46:19House took no action regarding any of
- 46:20those candidates. I mean, we...
- 46:22If we take action, you'll just say
- 46:23we're interfering again.
- 46:24That's not right. The Blue House Office
- 46:25of Civil Affairs should have stopped
- 46:27them from using the "Myung-pick" label;
- 46:28that’s unacceptable. Well, the Blue
- 46:30House didn't actively intervene in that
- 46:32specific manner. But there have been
- 46:34many instances of such intervention. It
- 46:35was an open secret that Representative
- 46:37Jo Jeong-sik would run for the second
- 46:39half of the National Assembly
- 46:40speakership.
- 46:40Yet, he appointed that politician as a
- 46:43special advisor for political affairs.
- 46:45And that special advisor eventually
- 46:47became the National Assembly speaker
- 46:48through an election held among
- 46:49lawmakers. He effectively installed his
- 46:50"Myung-pick" as the National Assembly
- 46:52speaker. He tried to install a "
- 46:53Myung-pick" for Seoul mayor too, but
- 46:54failed. He also installed a "Myung-pick
- 46:57" as party leader. While the President
- 46:59didn't explicitly say "don't run" to
- 47:01Jung Chung-rae, he went beyond simple
- 47:03well-wishes on social media multiple
- 47:05times to promote him for Prime Minister
- 47:08. Furthermore, many Democratic
- 47:11politicians—whether they are true
- 47:13loyalists or just claiming to be—
- 47:15along with spokespeople and
- 47:17commentators, have openly stated that
- 47:19Jung Chung-rae should not run. Things
- 47:23like this simply shouldn't be done.
- 47:24This isn't about legal issues, but
- 47:26politically, these actions are
- 47:28inappropriate. A President is someone
- 47:31who benefits the party and the
- 47:33government by faithfully and
- 47:34competently performing their duties as
- 47:36head of the executive branch; they
- 47:38should not be someone who maneuvers to
- 47:41place their preferred people in key
- 47:43positions within the party and the
- 47:45National Assembly. This undermines his
- 47:48own authority, and a democratic leader
- 47:50—a President is both the head of the
- 47:53executive branch and a political leader
- 47:55. A leader shouldn't act like this. I
- 48:00wonder why the President is so
- 48:02persistently trying to install his own
- 48:04people in key positions; perhaps it's
- 48:07related to some kind of reconstruction
- 48:09or redevelopment plan, though I’m not
- 48:12sure which. But no one knows what that
- 48:16is. He seems to have a certain
- 48:19development in mind, but instead of
- 48:21explaining his vision, showing a
- 48:23blueprint of the new house and
- 48:24neighborhood, and getting consent, he
- 48:27is forcing it through the power of the
- 48:29presidency. That’s why I find this so
- 48:32incredibly unsettling. Regardless of
- 48:33whether it’s right or wrong, it’s
- 48:35clearly heading toward inevitable
- 48:36failure. Let’s assume he succeeds in
- 48:38effectively installing his hand-picked
- 48:40person as the head of the ruling party.
- 48:42It’s actually easy to see what would
- 48:44happen next. But does the President not
- 48:48know this? Or are his aides unaware of
- 48:51it? It’s just pathetic. So,
- 48:55I’ve actually been deeply worried
- 48:56about the President for quite a while
- 48:58now. I’m still worried, but now
- 49:00I’ve found some peace of mind. I’ve
- 49:02come to accept it. Ah, so this is how
- 49:04it goes. There’s no turning back. It
- 49:05will be hard to return now. I have to
- 49:08accept this reality. And based on
- 49:11accepting this reality, as someone who
- 49:14critiques these things, I want to tell
- 49:18the citizens that since I’m not even
- 49:21a party member and have no way to act,
- 49:26Democratic party members, supporters,
- 49:28and citizens who have supported Lee
- 49:30Jae-myung until now should contemplate
- 49:32what they must do from their own
- 49:34perspectives.
- 49:35Yes.
- 49:35Yes. It’s time to stop ignoring
- 49:38reality, stop thinking "it can't be,"
- 49:40and instead accept this as the reality
- 49:42and consider our individual roles based
- 49:44on that foundation. That’s what I’m
- 49:46saying right now. Yes, exactly.
- 49:48So, you’ve made a judgment based on a
- 49:51certain phenomenon, but there is always
- 49:54room for overinterpretation and concern
- 49:57.
- 49:58That’s true. There is always room for
- 49:59concern. I’m just saying this is my
- 50:01perspective. Yes. I think it would be
- 50:03good for you to judge for yourselves.
- 50:05On that point, regarding what you asked
- 50:07earlier about whether I’d meet them
- 50:08if they reached out, I don’t want to
- 50:10meet them just to show off a watch or
- 50:12anything like that; I actually have
- 50:13clear tasks I want to resolve. I
- 50:15believe there are urgent matters the
- 50:17party, government, and Blue House need
- 50:19to address, and I’ve tried persuading
- 50:21them internally for the past seven
- 50:22years, but since it didn’t work,
- 50:24I’ve now turned to the public.
- 50:25In that context, I wanted to share my
- 50:28thoughts with the citizens on how to
- 50:30deal with issues like digital democracy
- 50:32. Regarding the cyber insurrection.
- 50:34Yes, that’s correct. I mean, those
- 50:36aspects are fine, but I'm not so sure
- 50:37about that. I don't know if the
- 50:40president really contacts those
- 50:42YouTubers, but since many people brag
- 50:44about it, official channels should
- 50:47obviously exist. In any case, the
- 50:49president is the highest authority.
- 50:51They are the person with the most power
- 50:53. If a private line of communication to
- 50:55the president is opened like that,
- 50:57would those people keep quiet?
- 51:00There’s no way word wouldn't get out.
- 51:02It’s not good for the president
- 51:04either. That kind of approach. That’s
- 51:07exactly why we say that "secret lines"
- 51:09should not exist. That is also a form
- 51:12of power.
- 51:14I mean, unofficial lines to the
- 51:15president can exist. This isn't an
- 51:18absolute rule, but thinking back to
- 51:20President Roh Moo-hyun, there were
- 51:23people without any official titles or
- 51:25positions.
- 51:26There were about one or two groups.
- 51:28Hmm. If the president was about to do
- 51:31something with a high risk of failure.
- 51:34Like when something major came up, then
- 51:36Yes.
- 51:36They would contact the secretary's
- 51:37office.
- 51:38Who did?
- 51:38People outside.
- 51:40They would contact the head of the
- 51:41secretary's office.
- 51:42And say something like, "We'd like to
- 51:44see so-and-so,""Could you tell him?" If
- 51:49they said that, the secretary would
- 51:50report it to the president and arrange
- 51:52a dinner if he agreed. I went there a
- 51:54couple of times myself. When you go,
- 51:56it’s a sort of "red team."
- 51:57Hmm. They were just people with no
- 52:00official titles, but they were folks he
- 52:01had known since his old political days.
- 52:03People he trusted deeply.
- 52:04Yes.
- 52:05When you go there, you give him nothing
- 52:06but bitter advice. I went a few times
- 52:08and said, "Don't do that.""Don't do
- 52:09this.""Just do this."
- 52:11It’s like what President Roh said
- 52:12when he stepped down. "When I meet Rhyu
- 52:15Si-min,""He doesn't like what I do, so
- 52:19he often gives me a lot of bitter
- 52:21advice.""Of course, wouldn't I be the
- 52:25same?""But, but what I really wanted to
- 52:30express my gratitude for today is that
- 52:34he stood by me during my most difficult
- 52:39times.""Just as you all did.""A friend
- 52:46in need is a friend indeed, and a
- 52:48politician who endures during hard
- 52:50times is a true politician." Rhyu
- 52:52Si-min nagged too much, I guess.
- 52:54So later on, he would just do things
- 52:56secretly without telling me.
- 52:57Ah.
- 52:58Without consulting me. Because he knew
- 52:59I'd say it wouldn't work. Exactly.
- 53:01Hmm. He was that kind of person, and in
- 53:04President Moon Jae-in’s case, when
- 53:06there was a truly difficult decision to
- 53:09make, the presidential office would
- 53:11contact people who could give their
- 53:13pure, disinterested opinions and listen
- 53:16to them. I think those things are
- 53:18perfectly fine.
- 53:19But I actually know a little bit about
- 53:22it. It’s about what kind of
- 53:24expressions, gazes, tones, and
- 53:26behavioral patterns people have when
- 53:28they suddenly get close to the center
- 53:30of power. Power brings about a dopamine
- 53:34storm.
- 53:35So,
- 53:37People who have experienced being near
- 53:39major power, like the presidency, many
- 53:41times don't get a dopamine storm just
- 53:42from meeting the president or getting a
- 53:44call from them. "Ugh, annoying.""Why
- 53:46are they calling again?" they say.
- 53:48Yes. But for those who haven't, even
- 53:51just receiving a call from the
- 53:52presidential chief of staff triggers a
- 53:54dopamine storm. So, there are specific
- 53:57expressions and tones unique to such
- 53:59people. I can see it when I look at
- 54:01them.
- 54:01Yes. And even though I don't know who
- 54:03they are referring to, they go on air
- 54:05and comment that I've become twisted
- 54:06because I didn't receive a call from
- 54:08the president.
- 54:11They make those kinds of comments.
- 54:15It’s pathetic, really. Yes. Well,
- 54:18there’s no need to talk about people
- 54:19like that, or their assessments.
- 54:20Ah, please don't use them separately.
- 54:22Writer, since you mentioned President
- 54:24Roh Moo-hyun, let me ask you just one
- 54:27thing about that.
- 54:29It’s been a little over a year since
- 54:31President Lee Jae-myung took office.
- 54:34Yes. Because of that, there is
- 54:37criticism directed at you. Back when
- 54:41President Roh Moo-hyun was pushing for
- 54:43the KORUS FTA, progressive
- 54:45intellectuals—
- 54:47The elites—
- 54:49Opposed it vehemently. Looking back,
- 54:53wasn't President Roh right? Isn't
- 54:56Writer Rhyu Si-min making that same
- 54:58mistake now? Such—
- 55:02Well, one could see it—
- 55:03Many people point that out.
- 55:04You could see it that way. You could,
- 55:06but—
- 55:07The issues are different; didn't
- 55:09reporter Hong Sang-hoon mention that?
- 55:12What?
- 55:14It’s not like he promised not to sign
- 55:16the KORUS FTA and then signed it anyway
- 55:18.
- 55:19It’s not like he promised not to
- 55:20deploy troops to Iraq and then did it
- 55:22anyway.
- 55:22Hmm. Those were—
- 55:26Those were newly emerging issues in
- 55:29foreign or trade policy, but the
- 55:31current issue of prosecutorial reform
- 55:33is something he promised to do but
- 55:35didn't. That’s a completely different
- 55:37dimension. Furthermore, whenever
- 55:40President Roh had a policy to discuss,
- 55:43he personally explained his vision and
- 55:46the necessity for it. But regarding the
- 55:50delay in prosecutorial reform,
- 55:51President Lee Jae-myung has never given
- 55:53a proper explanation.
- 55:55He did.
- 55:55What did he do?
- 55:57I mean, saying he has to minimize
- 55:58damage to the public.
- 56:00Does that even make sense? Is that the
- 56:01scale of the problem we’re dealing
- 56:03with? So, I mean, one can certainly
- 56:06make that comparison in their critique.
- 56:10That’s fine. It’s fine, but what
- 56:12I’m saying isn't that President Lee
- 56:14Jae-myung is wrong, but that it is too
- 56:17dangerous.
- 56:17He is going to fail.
- 56:18He will fail.
- 56:19Hmm.
- 56:20Hmm. That is what I’m saying. No, my
- 56:24question is, Lee Jae-myung clearly
- 56:27knows that the prosecution's monopoly
- 56:30on power is incredibly dangerous, and
- 56:33as a victim himself,
- 56:36he must know very well that he needs to
- 56:38address this to ensure the regime can
- 56:40be re-established and continued.
- 56:42I haven't found the answer to why that
- 56:44is, but he did use the term "structural
- 56:46majority" when he met with President
- 56:48Moon Jae-in. Yes. That is a term that
- 56:51cannot actually hold up. In a
- 56:53democratic election, we choose a
- 56:56president and elect lawmakers every
- 56:59four years,
- 57:01so creating a structure that guarantees
- 57:03a majority is fundamentally impossible.
- 57:05So, there’s something currently in
- 57:06the president's mind.
- 57:08Some kind of model.
- 57:09Yes, something,
- 57:10but since the president hasn't
- 57:13explained what that is, we can't see it
- 57:16clearly. If we look at the most
- 57:18definitive attempt to build such a
- 57:20structure,
- 57:22it was the merger of the parties.
- 57:23In 1990.
- 57:26The Democratic Justice Party, Kim
- 57:29Jong-pil's New Democratic Republican
- 57:31Party, and Kim Young-sam's
- 57:33Reunification Democratic Party merged
- 57:36to create a giant party with over 70%of
- 57:39the seats. Looking at the regional
- 57:41composition, by combining the TK, BK,
- 57:43and Chungcheong regions,
- 57:45they created a structural majority.
- 57:47Yes. But that fell apart right in the
- 57:48next general election. In democratic
- 57:51elections where popular sovereignty is
- 57:54realized, the very idea of creating a
- 57:57structure to hold a majority is an
- 58:00impossible concept. I don't know what
- 58:04meaning President Lee Jae-myung
- 58:06intended by saying "structural majority
- 58:09," but I believe the president has a
- 58:11plan for reconstruction or
- 58:13redevelopment that he hasn't revealed
- 58:16yet, backed by a team beneath him. You
- 58:19don't just say things like that without
- 58:20something behind it. But the planning
- 58:22level of that team is quite poor. The
- 58:24quality is just too low. So I think the
- 58:28president is currently heading down a
- 58:30path with extremely high risk and a
- 58:31high probability of failure; it’s
- 58:33impossible to explain the president's
- 58:35words and actions consistently without
- 58:37viewing it this way. That's why I'm
- 58:40making this inference, and I believe we
- 58:43might be able to figure out what it is
- 58:46once more words and actions that reveal
- 58:49the president's thinking emerge. Oh,
- 58:52what frustrates me is that, of course,
- 58:54one can't be sure that everything you
- 58:57say, Mr. Writer, is correct. Of course.
- 58:59Right. There is a lot of criticism like
- 59:00that. "Writer Rhyu Si-min thinks only
- 59:01he is right." There's a lot of
- 59:03criticism like that.
- 59:03Well, everyone says what they believe
- 59:05is right; is there anyone who says what
- 59:06they're saying is wrong?
- 59:07Oh, this is exactly what I think.
- 59:10Yes, everyone argues based on what they
- 59:12think is right. Where would you find a
- 59:14crazy person who argues, "I'm wrong"?
- 59:16Exactly. Yes. Look, the way I see it,
- 59:19the issue of security investigation
- 59:21authority has reached a critical
- 59:24turning point that could completely
- 59:26reverse the direction we’ve been
- 59:29heading in all this time.
- 59:30If that path is diverted, it’s not
- 59:32just a matter of losing interest;
- 59:33it’s highly likely that people will
- 59:35turn their backs entirely. If the
- 59:37supporters do that, I believe that
- 59:38re-electing the current administration
- 59:40will be completely out of the question.
- 59:43Why? Even I would find it baffling, and
- 59:45the President must know perfectly well
- 59:48that if this happens, re-election
- 59:50becomes impossible.
- 59:53That’s the part I can’t wrap my
- 59:54head around; the election is still four
- 59:57years away. Yet,
- 59:59It’s honestly laughable how the
- 1:00:01President makes ambiguous remarks on
- 1:00:04social media that require
- 1:00:05interpretation.
- 1:00:07Then, a battle over those
- 1:00:08interpretations erupts.
- 1:00:10In a democratic government, this
- 1:00:11shouldn't be happening. In a democracy,
- 1:00:13the President must clearly state their
- 1:00:15thoughts on any issue or agenda.
- 1:00:18Without leaving room for interpretation
- 1:00:19. But looking at it now, when the
- 1:00:21President posts something like "
- 1:00:23Ministry pig" on social media,
- 1:00:25spokespeople come out to explain what
- 1:00:27it means, while some claim it’s
- 1:00:29targeting Yoo Si-min, and others say
- 1:00:32it’s the Chosun Ilbo.
- 1:00:34It’s chaos. A complete commotion.
- 1:00:36Oh, so it was the Chosun Ilbo.
- 1:00:39Fine, let’s say that’s the case.
- 1:00:42What’s happening now is a game to
- 1:00:45figure out the President's true
- 1:00:46intentions—the President’s
- 1:00:48communication shouldn't be like this.
- 1:00:51It implies that something is being
- 1:00:53hidden. The President has consistently
- 1:00:58made ambiguous remarks that those
- 1:01:02claiming to be "pro-Lee" use as a
- 1:01:07weapon to attack those who aren't. This
- 1:01:12kind of behavior should not happen in a
- 1:01:15democracy. Even this, I feel like
- 1:01:18something is off right now. Something
- 1:01:20is wrong. And it's not just a minor
- 1:01:23issue; something is going very, very
- 1:01:25wrong. That’s what I’m feeling
- 1:01:28right now. Yes. Hmm.
- 1:01:30Since you mentioned that something
- 1:01:32feels "off," and since everyone here
- 1:01:34has expertise in media, I’d like to
- 1:01:36touch on that for a moment.
- 1:01:39Watching the media lately, I find this
- 1:01:43whole phenomenon truly strange. Even
- 1:01:47when Yoon Suk-yeol was allegedly
- 1:01:49involved in insurrection, the media
- 1:01:51didn't unite to criticize him as one.
- 1:01:54Back then, they were even quoting his
- 1:01:56remarks and broadcasting them. But now,
- 1:01:59people who are neither insurrectionists
- 1:02:03nor criminals, like Yoo Si-min and, say
- 1:02:07, Kim Ou-joon,
- 1:02:09Jung Chung-rae,
- 1:02:10people like Jung Chung-rae are being
- 1:02:12criticized by every media outlet, every
- 1:02:15commentator, and every YouTuber.
- 1:02:17Well, not everyone, but almost all of
- 1:02:19them.
- 1:02:19Almost all of them are criticizing them
- 1:02:22with one single voice. Rep. Jung
- 1:02:26Chung-rae might be a target for
- 1:02:29criticism since he’s a lawmaker
- 1:02:31eyeing the party leadership, but author
- 1:02:34Rhyu Si-min is a private citizen. But
- 1:02:38almost all of them are united,
- 1:02:40criticizing him with one voice. I find
- 1:02:43this truly bizarre. And what makes it
- 1:02:46go beyond bizarre to actually scary?
- 1:02:49They even criticize those who don't
- 1:02:52join them in hating the Rhyu Si-min
- 1:02:54they're attacking.
- 1:02:56So, the viewpoint that everyone who
- 1:02:57isn't on our side is an enemy.
- 1:02:58This is where it gets scary. The first
- 1:03:00part is, "I find it strange." The
- 1:03:02second part is, "It’s a bit scary."
- 1:03:03It’s not that I don’t want to be
- 1:03:05criticized.
- 1:03:06I’m just curious how this can even be
- 1:03:08interpreted. To our older generation—
- 1:03:10I’m sorry, but I have to leave early,
- 1:03:11so I just want to say one thing:
- 1:03:13they’re even making accusations of
- 1:03:14embezzlement regarding the Roh Moo-hyun
- 1:03:16Foundation now. That’s not criticism.
- 1:03:18But if I say that makes no sense, they
- 1:03:20put me in the same category and attack
- 1:03:22me too. I’ve been thinking lately
- 1:03:23that this feels like part of some
- 1:03:25orchestrated setup. Having been active
- 1:03:28in the party for a long time, I
- 1:03:30remember hearing things back in 2019,
- 1:03:32people attacking author Rhyu Si-min in
- 1:03:35this exact same way. Identity politics.
- 1:03:39They’d say, "Why defend the
- 1:03:40government so much? As an elder in
- 1:03:42society, you should offer some harsh
- 1:03:43advice." Those same people who
- 1:03:44criticized him then—Now they go on
- 1:03:46broadcasts and ask why he’s offering
- 1:03:47harsh advice to the government. It's
- 1:03:49the same people. From my perspective,
- 1:03:51it’s just baffling. So, what’s the
- 1:03:53reason? Actually, these days, apart
- 1:03:55from other reasons, there’s the
- 1:03:57YouTube view count—they constantly
- 1:03:59curse him for being washed up, while
- 1:04:01raking in views. "Oh, Rhyu Si-min is
- 1:04:03washed up."
- 1:04:04If he’s washed up, why keep talking
- 1:04:05about him?
- 1:04:05Because if I curse him, my views go up.
- 1:04:07The views go up massively, don't they?
- 1:04:08Yes. So, I think I’ll try it too.
- 1:04:15That’s the last thing I wanted to say
- 1:04:16before I head out.
- 1:04:17Everyone talked about Lee Jun-seok when
- 1:04:19he was truly "washed up," right? They
- 1:04:21don’t anymore. Because he really is
- 1:04:23washed up.
- 1:04:23The views don't come in. They don't.
- 1:04:25So I’m not talking about him.
- 1:04:26Ah, so that’s why I’m getting this
- 1:04:28flak.
- 1:04:28Yes.
- 1:04:29So, there’s really no reason to be
- 1:04:30hurt by this. If this were just
- 1:04:32happening in the comments, you could
- 1:04:35assume there are coordinated forces at
- 1:04:37work, but it’s not just the comments
- 1:04:40—these are people from Maebul. All of
- 1:04:42them. The very people who worked
- 1:04:47together at Maebul for so long.
- 1:04:48So they failed to expand their circle.
- 1:04:50I don’t think they are engaging in
- 1:04:53journalism. This is—
- 1:04:55You know those YouTube channels run by
- 1:04:57mainstream media outlets? They’re
- 1:05:00even worse.
- 1:05:01It’s very severe. It’s blatant.
- 1:05:02But the reason they are worse is simple
- 1:05:04. I figured since they're latecomers,
- 1:05:06they're just trying to boost their view
- 1:05:08counts.
- 1:05:09I didn't think they were getting that
- 1:05:10many views. Even if I try.
- 1:05:11But they actually get a lot. They—I
- 1:05:14mean, one time, I felt like this...
- 1:05:18This is a really serious problem
- 1:05:20because there was a time when President
- 1:05:22Lee Jae-myung achieved various
- 1:05:24diplomatic successes abroad.
- 1:05:26So, it was a time when there were so
- 1:05:28many people who really needed to be
- 1:05:30covered from a journalistic perspective
- 1:05:31.
- 1:05:32That...
- 1:05:33I once took a look at those YouTube
- 1:05:35thumbnails. On my screen, on my
- 1:05:37computer screen.
- 1:05:38Yoo Si-min, Jung Chung-rae, Cho Kuk,
- 1:05:39Choi Kang-wook...
- 1:05:41There were about eight thumbnails of
- 1:05:43writer Yoo Si-min on one screen.
- 1:05:45It was scary.
- 1:05:45Shouldn't I be getting paid too? There.
- 1:05:47So, this is clearly something that's
- 1:05:48gone quite wrong. Why is it like this?
- 1:05:50In my view, there are many reasons, but
- 1:05:53the biggest one is commercial.
- 1:05:55Is it that profitable? I...
- 1:05:57I don't think this is right.
- 1:05:58Yeah. But traditionally, outlets like
- 1:06:01Chosun, JoongAng, and Dong-A remain
- 1:06:03neutral between the conservative camp
- 1:06:04and the democratic camp, even when
- 1:06:06there's an internal conflict.
- 1:06:08Right. Yeah.
- 1:06:10And then outlets we usually call
- 1:06:11progressive, like Hankyoreh or OhmyNews
- 1:06:14...
- 1:06:15Basically, while they lean toward the
- 1:06:17democratic and progressive camp, they
- 1:06:19stay neutral regarding internal
- 1:06:20factions within the progressive side.
- 1:06:23They've generally done that until now,
- 1:06:25haven't they?
- 1:06:25But now, if you look, without any
- 1:06:27distinction...
- 1:06:28There was even a poll asking if my
- 1:06:30remarks were right or if they helped
- 1:06:32the Democratic Party. Wow, even that...
- 1:06:34Looking at the Media Tomato poll, I was
- 1:06:36surprised to see it was split 50/50
- 1:06:38among progressives. I was shocked; I
- 1:06:40didn't think the agreement rate would
- 1:06:42be that high. It’s a surprising thing
- 1:06:45. The fact that a poll was conducted on
- 1:06:47the words of a critic whose content
- 1:06:48isn't even well-known, and it came out
- 1:06:5050/50, means the problem is serious.
- 1:06:52That's how the situation is, and even
- 1:06:54looking at the Democratic Party's
- 1:06:55national convention, the leading
- 1:06:56candidates are neck and neck. If you
- 1:06:58look at the polls now, there's no big
- 1:07:00difference. But when you look at the
- 1:07:02media, it’s all commentators.
- 1:07:04Hmm.
- 1:07:05Almost...
- 1:07:069 to 1.
- 1:07:06Around 99 to 1.
- 1:07:08It's completely Kim Min-seok.
- 1:07:09That's right.
- 1:07:10Then how do we explain this gap? The
- 1:07:14neutrality within camps, or at least
- 1:07:17the neutrality of progressive media
- 1:07:19that traditional outlets or YouTube
- 1:07:22journalists used to maintain, has all
- 1:07:24been broken.
- 1:07:27They don't even stay neutral between
- 1:07:28the factions within the Democratic
- 1:07:30Party. This...
- 1:07:31How should we view this phenomenon? So,
- 1:07:33I was pondering that, and the word "
- 1:07:35mercenary" came to mind. It's just so,
- 1:07:37so strange. I don't think it's quite 99
- 1:07:40to 1. It feels more like 95 to 5. When
- 1:07:44I look online, about five out of 100...
- 1:07:47Are still doing it fairly.
- 1:07:49But institutional media is almost
- 1:07:52entirely on the opposite side. Uh.
- 1:07:54We might be the ones who are wrong.
- 1:07:56Exactly.
- 1:07:56That’s right. That’s why I tend to
- 1:07:59be quite self-critical. So,
- 1:08:02the vast majority are heading in a
- 1:08:04different direction than me.
- 1:08:07So, I leave open the possibility that
- 1:08:09only I am wrong.
- 1:08:10Right. I look very carefully at what
- 1:08:13they say.
- 1:08:14I watch a lot, too.
- 1:08:16Especially when it concerns me, I watch
- 1:08:19, but I really can't agree. And there's
- 1:08:23nothing worth listening to. That’s
- 1:08:25why I find it painful.
- 1:08:27What is there to say when people go to
- 1:08:29dozens of places a week to speak?
- 1:08:31That’s why you get criticized a bit.
- 1:08:34If you turn it on, the same people
- 1:08:36repeat the same thing over and over.
- 1:08:38Mainstream media.
- 1:08:39Starting from YouTube, yes. Yes. From
- 1:08:42critical programs to YouTube channels,
- 1:08:44about 20 people take up more than 90%of
- 1:08:46the space, saying the same things or
- 1:08:48saying one thing yesterday and another
- 1:08:50today. Isn't that how it’s going
- 1:08:53right now? Watching it like this,
- 1:08:56I find some of them really scary. Among
- 1:08:58those critics. You know, there’s that
- 1:09:01story in the New Testament. Jesus said,
- 1:09:03"Let anyone among you who is without
- 1:09:05sin be the first to throw a stone at
- 1:09:06her." And it says no one threw a stone,
- 1:09:09right?
- 1:09:09Hmm. But the person who throws the
- 1:09:12stone first.
- 1:09:13Hmm.
- 1:09:13And the one who keeps throwing until
- 1:09:15the end.
- 1:09:15Hmm.
- 1:09:15Those kinds of critics are scary. When
- 1:09:17I see those people pop up, I just
- 1:09:19change the channel immediately. It’s
- 1:09:22too scary. There is no forgiveness.
- 1:09:23Forgiveness.
- 1:09:24There is no forgiveness.
- 1:09:25Really, "Let anyone without sin be the
- 1:09:27first to throw a stone at her." If that
- 1:09:29happens, there are those who throw
- 1:09:30first and those who throw until the
- 1:09:31very end. There are quite a few people
- 1:09:33like that. Yes. There are also many who
- 1:09:35don’t even know what they’re saying
- 1:09:37. And there are some who make a whole
- 1:09:39feast out of just one side dish. Ah.
- 1:09:41That's right.
- 1:09:42There are also people who criticize
- 1:09:43just by repeating what others said. Yes
- 1:09:45.
- 1:09:45It’s really...
- 1:09:48Ah.
- 1:09:48I watch them too. Wondering if
- 1:09:50there’s anything worth hearing. But,
- 1:09:52it was hard to bear while watching.
- 1:09:54No, not just about me, but criticism in
- 1:09:56general.
- 1:09:56Yes. I feel the same way. Yes.
- 1:09:58Well, it can't be helped. That’s how
- 1:10:01the world is.
- 1:10:01Yes. But I think when this broadcast
- 1:10:04airs, a lot of such criticism will pour
- 1:10:07out again.
- 1:10:09A smear campaign.
- 1:10:10Ah, the smear will be, "You, Rhyu
- 1:10:13Si-min, drew a Venn diagram and
- 1:10:16blabbered on." But wait? "You were the
- 1:10:20first one to throw a stone." I think
- 1:10:22there will be a lot of such criticism.
- 1:10:25I’m not throwing stones; I’m
- 1:10:27accepting the President's choice. I
- 1:10:30accept that the President intends to go
- 1:10:32down that path. I don’t say it’s
- 1:10:35morally wrong or politically
- 1:10:38incorrect or anything like that. I only
- 1:10:40say it will fail.
- 1:10:41Hmm.
- 1:10:42And it’s too dangerous.
- 1:10:43Hmm. It’s not just harmful to him,
- 1:10:46but it will break the hearts of the
- 1:10:49camp that helped elect President Lee
- 1:10:52Jae-myung and his many supporters.
- 1:10:55That’s the point I’m making.
- 1:10:56Throwing stones means you’re hoping
- 1:10:58for their ruin, wishing for them to
- 1:10:59fail. I mean, like when President Roh
- 1:11:00Moo-hyun was being investigated by the
- 1:11:01prosecution after leaving office,
- 1:11:02saying things like… "Repent through
- 1:11:04death"—that’s throwing stones.
- 1:11:06Yeah. That.
- 1:11:09What I want is this. I want to show
- 1:11:13citizens the reality as I see it, have
- 1:11:15them see it for themselves, create new
- 1:11:18public opinion, and have the president
- 1:11:20see that and adjust his course.
- 1:11:24Do you think that public opinion will
- 1:11:25form? Well,
- 1:11:26I have to try. If it doesn’t work,
- 1:11:27then so be it. Right now,
- 1:11:31I’m not saying this to fight someone
- 1:11:34or win anything. I’m just…
- 1:11:38I have these thoughts and this sense of
- 1:11:41crisis, and if many others feel the
- 1:11:43same way, then change might happen. It
- 1:11:47might happen. Maybe it won’t, but if
- 1:11:50I’m wrong, then no change will come,
- 1:11:52and that would be the right outcome.
- 1:11:55Even if I’m right, change might still
- 1:11:57not happen. Yeah.
- 1:11:59But I’m just speaking up because I
- 1:12:01don’t want to feel the remorse of
- 1:12:03standing by and watching the president
- 1:12:06head down that path.
- 1:12:08I dislike those feelings.
- 1:12:10So I’m just speaking my mind. I’m
- 1:12:12not trying to win. How could I possibly
- 1:12:14win a fight against a sitting president
- 1:12:16who has only been in office for a year?
- 1:12:18Yeah.
- 1:12:19I’m just expressing myself.
- 1:12:21Yeah.
- 1:12:21My thoughts. Because if I don't express
- 1:12:24them, I’ll regret it later. Yeah.
- 1:12:25Yes. I have no desire to win. I’m
- 1:12:29just talking. Yeah.
- 1:12:30Yeah.
- 1:12:32Then, after this broadcast, the best
- 1:12:35outcomes I could hope for are one of
- 1:12:38two things. Since you, as the writer,
- 1:12:41saw it as a path to failure.
- 1:12:43Either that path is corrected, or he
- 1:12:47succeeds in a way that proves you, Rhyu
- 1:12:50Si-min, wrong.
- 1:12:51That would be even better.
- 1:12:53That I was wrong.
- 1:12:54Yeah.
- 1:12:54Uh. That the president succeeded with
- 1:12:58the support of everyone. That…Whether
- 1:13:00it was his policies, his reconstruction
- 1:13:02efforts, or anything else, he succeeded
- 1:13:04. Then I would have no regrets. Good
- 1:13:06for him. Actually, regardless of
- 1:13:08President Lee Jae-myung’s political
- 1:13:11choices, I have always been a person
- 1:13:14who roots for his life.
- 1:13:16Yeah.
- 1:13:16Yes. Looking at his life, which is now
- 1:13:20over 60 years, I always feel a desire
- 1:13:23to support him. Even back when I
- 1:13:26supported him through my critiques,
- 1:13:28that was always the feeling. It’s the
- 1:13:31same now. I have an ongoing desire to
- 1:13:33support the life of the person Lee
- 1:13:34Jae-myung, and I hope he does well. I
- 1:13:36hope I'm wrong, I fail miserably, get
- 1:13:38criticized, and my books don't sell.
- 1:13:41I hope I get all the hate, and the
- 1:13:44President succeeds, proves us wrong,
- 1:13:47shakes up South Korean politics, builds
- 1:13:50a stable majority, and even wins
- 1:13:52re-election. I really hope my thinking
- 1:13:55is wrong.
- 1:13:56Yes.
- 1:13:57I hope the President's vision and
- 1:13:58thoughts
- 1:13:59are right,
- 1:14:01and not only right, but understood by
- 1:14:03the public and successful in reality. I
- 1:14:06don't mind if I fail.
- 1:14:07Yes. That’s the mindset I’m
- 1:14:09speaking from.
- 1:14:10It's not about saying, "I must win
- 1:14:11because I'm right." Thinking like that
- 1:14:13...
- 1:14:13Ah,
- 1:14:14what would I even win?
- 1:14:15What would I gain? I...
- 1:14:16That's just one point. Ah, what's the
- 1:14:19point of winning? I can't even win, how
- 1:14:21would I?
- 1:14:22Yes. You don't start a fight to win,
- 1:14:25after all. It's not about fighting to
- 1:14:27win,
- 1:14:27Yes.
- 1:14:28since the President's motto was "In the
- 1:14:30end, it’s the people."
- 1:14:31Yes.
- 1:14:32It looks like "In the end, it’s me"
- 1:14:35right now, but I do hope the President
- 1:14:38returns to "In the end, it’s the
- 1:14:41people." If I happen to be right.
- 1:14:43Understood. Ah,
- 1:14:47our publisher brought the book today,
- 1:14:48though we only touched on it briefly.
- 1:14:51In fact, it seems author Rhyu Si-min
- 1:14:53has led a boycott against his own book
- 1:14:56today. That seems to be the summary.
- 1:14:59European City Travels 3.
- 1:15:01Right. If it sells too much, I’ll get
- 1:15:02criticized for being a capitalist.
- 1:15:04Sell it moderately. People would say
- 1:15:06I’m just busy making money. Not
- 1:15:08selling well might actually be a decent
- 1:15:10message, too. How was it for you today,
- 1:15:13reporter?
- 1:15:14I’m a bit dizzy.
- 1:15:15Dizzy.
- 1:15:16The intention behind the words was
- 1:15:17clear, though. Choi Ok-ssi,
- 1:15:18That’s right. Still, what I was
- 1:15:20worried about was...that you might just
- 1:15:27vent your frustrations about President
- 1:15:30Lee Jae-myung or his government. Of
- 1:15:34course, you aren't that type of person,
- 1:15:35and there’s no reason to. In any case
- 1:15:37, I always root for Lee Jae-myung as a
- 1:15:39human being. Even when I judge that he
- 1:15:43is going down a path that might lead to
- 1:15:46failure, a dangerous path, or sometimes
- 1:15:49the wrong path, my support for his life
- 1:15:52,
- 1:15:53remains unchanged.
- 1:15:54I don’t think that will ever change.
- 1:15:55It really is.
- 1:15:56You know how it is.
- 1:15:57Understood. Isn't having someone
- 1:15:59continue to speak up like this a part
- 1:16:01of the diversity our society needs?
- 1:16:03In the end,
- 1:16:05since diversity is what makes Korean
- 1:16:07society robust, I think you should keep
- 1:16:10doing this role, even if you get
- 1:16:13criticized and hit by stones. That’s
- 1:16:15what I think.
- 1:16:15Reporter, you’re practically giving
- 1:16:18me a job. What I believe in is this:
- 1:16:22Whether a perspective or logic of
- 1:16:25criticism is right or wrong, or valid
- 1:16:27or not, is not determined by public
- 1:16:30opinion polls or majority votes.
- 1:16:34That’s how I see it. So, just because
- 1:16:37one person expresses a different
- 1:16:38opinion,
- 1:16:40silencing them is just as bad as
- 1:16:42silencing everyone else, simply because
- 1:16:45that one person’s view is different.
- 1:16:48This comes from John Stuart Mill’s "
- 1:16:50On Liberty," and it’s a quote I truly
- 1:16:52love.
- 1:16:53If people only lived by saying things
- 1:16:55proven to be always right, everyone
- 1:16:56would have to keep their mouths shut.
- 1:16:58Hmm.
- 1:16:59The reason we talk to each other is
- 1:17:04because no one knows the absolute truth
- 1:17:07, so we converse under the premise that
- 1:17:11we are always prone to errors, entirely
- 1:17:15or partially.
- 1:17:17Hmm. That’s why we talk.
- 1:17:19Yes.
- 1:17:19A society that allows for that is a
- 1:17:21free society.
- 1:17:22Yes.
- 1:17:23Yeah. So, because I have that belief, I
- 1:17:26have no regrets. Even if after this
- 1:17:30broadcast, for about ten days, every
- 1:17:32media outlet
- 1:17:33runs a series calling it "Rhyu
- 1:17:35Si-min’s reckless remarks,"
- 1:17:37Yes.
- 1:17:37Yeah. It still doesn’t prove that I
- 1:17:41or my views are wrong. That’s how I
- 1:17:43think as I move forward.
- 1:17:44I see. Understood.
- 1:17:45Yeah. But honestly,
- 1:17:47lately, I don't feel any joy.
- 1:17:49Ah, that...
- 1:17:50That’s a very frightening thing to
- 1:17:51say.
- 1:17:51Hmm.
- 1:17:52I think it’s frightening, too. I
- 1:17:54honestly never, ever imagined a time
- 1:17:56like this would come.
- 1:17:59After we finished off Yoon Suk-yeol
- 1:18:01back then, I really thought the world
- 1:18:03we expected and hoped for would unfold.
- 1:18:06Of course, you could say that world is
- 1:18:07unfolding, but...
- 1:18:08You were naive. Human society isn’t
- 1:18:10that simple. Yes. Right.
- 1:18:13Ah, the fact that this kind of world
- 1:18:15has come—it’s just no fun. For one
- 1:18:18thing, regarding whatever I do, I think
- 1:18:20,
- 1:18:21Should I really keep staying in this
- 1:18:22field? I actually have thoughts like
- 1:18:24that.
- 1:18:26Although I don’t know how this
- 1:18:28broadcast will be edited and aired, and
- 1:18:31perhaps this might be a hollow
- 1:18:33sentiment, regarding your broadcast
- 1:18:36today, Writer Rhyu, for this to lead to
- 1:18:39productive discussion in our society, I
- 1:18:42believe other YouTube channels and
- 1:18:45media outlets dealing with this need to
- 1:18:48address the points properly. But they
- 1:18:51will probably
- 1:18:53be ready to mock and criticize again.
- 1:18:56Then this will
- 1:18:58likely flow into a very exhausting kind
- 1:19:00of debate, and now...
- 1:19:03It can’t be helped.
- 1:19:04Yes. I know it can’t be helped, but
- 1:19:06still, I felt hope seeing that level of
- 1:19:10sympathy in the News Tomato opinion
- 1:19:13poll. And adding to that, following up
- 1:19:16on Reporter Hong Sung-hoon’s point,
- 1:19:19there are people around me who think
- 1:19:22like Reporter Hong. And what they think
- 1:19:26is—these are supporters who really
- 1:19:28want prosecution reform, who impeached
- 1:19:31two presidents and overcame a national
- 1:19:34crisis—they think,
- 1:19:36How can they be this incompetent?
- 1:19:38Wow, but I really can't remember the
- 1:19:39prosecution part. Hmm.
- 1:19:40They seem to have that kind of mindset.
- 1:19:43But what if this broadcast airs?
- 1:19:46And what if it leads to, say,
- 1:19:50reinforcing those kinds of thoughts?
- 1:19:53What I’m saying is, we have to make
- 1:19:55the President do it, even if they don't
- 1:19:57want to. That’s how we have to
- 1:19:58approach it.
- 1:19:59The President doesn't seem to want to
- 1:20:01do it,
- 1:20:02so how can we make them do it? That’s
- 1:20:05what we need to think about. Democracy
- 1:20:08is party politics. I mean, back in
- 1:20:11President Kim Dae-jung's time, it was
- 1:20:13Kim Dae-jung’s Democratic Party. Ever
- 1:20:16since the national primary system and
- 1:20:18the party member system were introduced
- 1:20:20after President Roh Moo-hyun, it has
- 1:20:22been the Democratic Party’s President
- 1:20:23Roh and the Democratic Party’s
- 1:20:25President Moon. And when it’s the
- 1:20:27Democratic Party’s President Lee
- 1:20:29Jae-myung, both the President and the
- 1:20:30party are strong. If the party is
- 1:20:32controlled by the President, it
- 1:20:33collapses. It must not be controlled by
- 1:20:36the President. The moment the
- 1:20:38Democratic Party accepts the control of
- 1:20:41a President in power, the party begins
- 1:20:44to disintegrate. If the Democratic
- 1:20:47Party loses its identity and dissolves
- 1:20:49in Korean politics, there is no
- 1:20:51tomorrow. From then on, everything is
- 1:20:54chaos. That is why I think President
- 1:20:56Lee Jae-myung’s vision is very
- 1:21:00dangerous and likely to fail. Well,
- 1:21:04let's just say it's dangerous, don't
- 1:21:07emphasize the "very."
- 1:21:09It is very dangerous.
- 1:21:10Understood. It just became even more
- 1:21:12dangerous now. So...
- 1:21:13Yes. Many people are worried about the
- 1:21:17editing today, so I will edit it so I
- 1:21:20don't appear.
- 1:21:25Right. Then it should turn out quite
- 1:21:27clean, I suppose.
- 1:21:28I think I'll only be on for about 25
- 1:21:30minutes.
- 1:21:30Then what did I even appear for? Yes.
- 1:21:33If we can't even embrace this level of
- 1:21:36diverse voices, how can we move on to
- 1:21:38reconstruction or redevelopment? That
- 1:21:40is a fair point. Yes.
- 1:21:41Understood. I already said that. Why do
- 1:21:43you keep bringing that up?
- 1:21:45I’m just worried you might do it.
- 1:21:45Right now...
- 1:21:46When we aren't even doing it ourselves.
- 1:21:47Don't be nervous, Mr. Choi. Yes.
- 1:21:49Understood. Well then, let’s wrap
- 1:21:52things up here for today. No matter
- 1:21:55what kind of feedback we get, we will
- 1:21:58humbly accept it as an experience.
- 1:22:01Thank you all three for joining us.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of 유시민 "훗날 인간 이재명에게 미안할까봐…" by [팟빵] 최욱의 매불쇼, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 13,087 words across 2,340 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.