It Wasn't A Hoax After All — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Hannah, do you remember all the fear
- 0:02around the world ending in 2012?
- 0:05>> I mean, I wouldn't say it was uh
- 0:06particularly prevalent in my community,
- 0:08but I mean, there's always sort of
- 0:10people getting a bit concerned, aren't
- 0:12they?
- 0:12>> Yeah, they're always concerned about
- 0:13things, but the 2012 one really stuck
- 0:16out. There were great memes. It became a
- 0:18whole thing. Like, General Motors made
- 0:20commercials where their Silverados drove
- 0:23around in post-apocalyptic places, and
- 0:26the Jell-O company made commercials that
- 0:28aired here in America, not here in in
- 0:30New Zealand. But, they aired commercials
- 0:32in America where a team of people made a
- 0:34sacrifice of Jell-O pudding to the Mayan
- 0:37gods to stop the end of the world from
- 0:40happening.
- 0:40>> Remind me, what was the big concern?
- 0:42What how were people worried it was
- 0:43going to end?
- 0:44>> So, supposedly,
- 0:46on December 21st, 2012,
- 0:50the Mayan calendar
- 0:53would end.
- 0:54And so, the Mayans, they built this
- 0:56calendar that was really mathematically
- 0:58very interesting. Because it's so old,
- 1:01it felt kind of magical. And if you
- 1:04looked at it, uh well,
- 1:06if you didn't look at it very closely,
- 1:08you could claim that it ended
- 1:12in 2012. So, what did they know that we
- 1:15don't? Is the end of the world coming?
- 1:17And like, it could be pinpointed to the
- 1:1921st of December, 2012.
- 1:21>> Well, as a small civilization, they knew
- 1:23some stuff.
- 1:24>> They did, but they didn't know when the
- 1:26world was going to end. Because, as we
- 1:28all know now, the world did not end in
- 1:312012. But, what today's episode
- 1:34presupposes is
- 1:37maybe it did.
- 1:39>> [gasps]
- 1:40[music]
- 1:44>> This episode is brought to you by Cancer
- 1:46Research UK.
- 1:47>> Our bodies are incredible machines,
- 1:50whirring away making more and more DNA
- 1:52to build the proteins that keep us
- 1:54alive.
- 1:54>> In fact, in the last minute, your body
- 1:56has made over 200 million new cells and
- 2:00enough DNA to stretch to the moon and
- 2:02back.
- 2:03>> To the moon and back? That's so much DNA
- 2:05that if you compared it to the size of
- 2:07the cell it fits into, that would be
- 2:10like squeezing the London underground
- 2:12into a suitcase.
- 2:13>> By the age of 50, you have copied almost
- 2:166 trillion miles of DNA. But every time
- 2:19that your body copies DNA, it risks
- 2:21making mistakes and over time those
- 2:23mistakes can accumulate and that
- 2:25collection of errors can lead to cancer.
- 2:28>> But incredibly, Cancer Research UK
- 2:30scientists can spot these errors and by
- 2:33finding them, they've helped double UK
- 2:35cancer survival over the last 50 years
- 2:38and are driving even more discoveries
- 2:40that could tackle over 200 types of
- 2:42cancer.
- 2:43>> For more information about Cancer
- 2:44Research UK, their research and
- 2:46breakthroughs and how you can support
- 2:48them, visit
- 2:48cancerresearchuk.org/restiscience.
- 2:57What a cliffhanger.
- 3:00>> [laughter]
- 3:00>> All right. So, first of all, let's talk
- 3:01about the the origin of the entire thing
- 3:04in the first place. I moved to London in
- 3:072012. All right. So, we were both in the
- 3:09same country at that time. We were both
- 3:11in the UK and I remember everyone
- 3:13buzzing about it, but it was sort of a
- 3:15joke. Um there there were books and
- 3:17music. There were entire albums that
- 3:19were all themed around the end of the
- 3:20world is happening.
- 3:21>> Mhm.
- 3:22>> I even have a belt buckle. I bought a
- 3:24belt buckle off of a street vendor in
- 3:26London that says 2012 end of the world.
- 3:29I don't have it with me. I wish I did. I
- 3:31I will I will send you a photo of it. I
- 3:33thought, okay, either this is a great
- 3:36way to say goodbye to the universe or
- 3:38it's going to be really funny next year.
- 3:41>> [laughter]
- 3:42>> And of course, I didn't really believe
- 3:44the world was going to end, but here's
- 3:46here's where it all began. The Mayan
- 3:48uh civilization existed in Mesoamerica
- 3:52in the Yucatán Peninsula from there
- 3:55all the way southwest to the Pacific
- 3:58Ocean. From like 2000 BC all the way to
- 4:021697.
- 4:04In 1697 they all decided, "Yeah, this
- 4:07was pretty good. Let's move somewhere
- 4:09else." Just kidding. The Spanish Empire
- 4:11colonized the Mesoamerican region. There
- 4:14was a lot of fighting and bad things and
- 4:16the last Mayan city fell in 1697.
- 4:20>> And the Spanish the Spanish had steel of
- 4:22course which we've spoken about before
- 4:24while the Mayans were fighting with
- 4:25obsidian.
- 4:26>> The You're right. The Mayans did not
- 4:28have steel, but they did have a really
- 4:30cool calendar. To be fair, it may not
- 4:32have completely been theirs. It may have
- 4:35come from the Olmecs who preceded them
- 4:37that were kind of in the little I I keep
- 4:39thinking of it as the armpit of
- 4:41Mesoamerica, but it's not at all. It's
- 4:43actually like the
- 4:46top of the foot of Mexico.
- 4:48Anyway,
- 4:49>> But it's like the crook the crook of the
- 4:51elbow maybe?
- 4:52>> Well, no, it's more like It's if
- 4:54Mexico's my arm
- 4:56>> Yeah. Make world maps with your body,
- 4:58Michael.
- 4:58>> got like the Tabasco down here, the
- 5:02Yucatán Peninsula up here. The Olmecs
- 5:04were here, the Mayans were here. They
- 5:06were chilling out. Look at all of them.
- 5:08>> Can I just say surprisingly beefy guns
- 5:11there, Michael. I enjoyed that.
- 5:12>> Are you If this surprises you, I don't
- 5:14know what your expectations for me were,
- 5:16but
- 5:17the point is
- 5:19Mayan mythology stated that the gods
- 5:21created three other worlds before this
- 5:24one.
- 5:24>> Mhm.
- 5:24>> And this one was good, so they kept it.
- 5:28But the first three they didn't like.
- 5:30And the third world, the last one before
- 5:33this one began, lasted 13 baktuns.
- 5:37A baktun was a unit of time that the
- 5:40Mayans created that lasted 394 years
- 5:44approximately. So 13 of them were 5,125
- 5:50years, more or less. You know, the we if
- 5:53you if you've watched the podcast for a
- 5:55while, you know that we've talked about
- 5:56time and calendars and how no one really
- 5:59knows what time it is. But, people who
- 6:02wanted to predict the end of the world,
- 6:04they certainly were confident. And they
- 6:06said, "Now, wait a second. If if the
- 6:08previous world lasted 13 bak'tuns, then
- 6:12maybe this one will only last that long
- 6:15as well."
- 6:16And as it turns out, the the Mayan
- 6:19creation stories give a creation date
- 6:22for the world, which in the Gregorian
- 6:24calendar was
- 6:26the 11th of August, 3114
- 6:29BC.
- 6:30>> I feel like there's a lot of
- 6:32that [laughter]
- 6:33that raises a lot of questions. The idea
- 6:35that it's like actually on the 11th of
- 6:36August, very specific there. Just all of
- 6:39creation came into being. You know,
- 6:41where was the first How? What happened?
- 6:43>> Well, that's the that's what's so great
- 6:45about the Mayan calendar. It was like
- 6:47really specific. It was base 20. They
- 6:50discussed dates not just by saying, "Oh,
- 6:54you know, in the beginning." Or
- 6:56"A thousand days is a year to the Lord."
- 6:59They just said things like, "Here's this
- 7:01exact number." And you can do the math
- 7:03with it and go, "Wow, okay. So, the
- 7:05world began on August 11th, 3114 BC." If
- 7:10this fourth world lasts as long as the
- 7:14the one before it, then it should last
- 7:175,125
- 7:19years, which means it will end on the
- 7:2121st of December, 2012.
- 7:25Now,
- 7:25>> of ways,
- 7:26>> Nope.
- 7:27>> in a lot of ways, I think that it would
- 7:28have been a good time for the world to
- 7:30end. Certainly if you're British, you
- 7:31know, it was
- 7:33the Olympics had just been held in
- 7:35Britain. We'd had the
- 7:37the Diamond Jubilee that year as well of
- 7:40of of Elizabeth. It was uh our economy
- 7:43[clears throat] was doing all right. We
- 7:44were sort of recovering from from from
- 7:46the financial crash. It was before
- 7:48Brexit came along.
- 7:50I think that was from That was really
- 7:52the glory days. That was really That was
- 7:54really when we peaked. I got a dog, you
- 7:56know? That was there.
- 7:57>> Oh, no, really?
- 7:59>> Yeah.
- 7:59>> Well, yeah, I mean, I I I completely
- 8:01agree. And so, I feel really fortunate
- 8:03that I moved to the UK in 2012. Like, I
- 8:06remember flying in, and I I I got to
- 8:10Heathrow, and it was full of people
- 8:12wearing purple suits who were there to
- 8:14help me.
- 8:15They They told me exactly what train to
- 8:17take, and cuz they were They were They
- 8:19were there for all the tourists coming
- 8:21in for the Olympics. And I got to go to
- 8:23some Olympic events, and there was all
- 8:25the excitement about the Diamond
- 8:26Jubilee. It was really, really great.
- 8:28But, hold on a second. Did the Mayans
- 8:30actually say that this world, the fourth
- 8:33world, ours, will only last 13 baktuns,
- 8:37like the one before? They never did.
- 8:40They never, ever did. But, in 1966,
- 8:44a guy named Michael D.
- 8:47Stevens? No. Michael D. Coe.
- 8:51Michael D. Stevens is me. I just wanted
- 8:53to say it was really cool to read.
- 8:55>> What does the D stand for?
- 8:56>> Mine stands for David.
- 8:57>> Oh.
- 8:59I sort of desperately wanted it to be
- 9:01something really unusual.
- 9:02>> But, you know what? I I actually asked
- 9:04>> Danger. That's what it should have been.
- 9:06>> I Googled myself yesterday, funny
- 9:09enough, and Google's AI, Gemini, like,
- 9:12tried to answer my question, and it
- 9:13said, "Oh, yeah, Michael Stevens from
- 9:15Vsauce." And in parentheses, "Michael J.
- 9:17Stevens." And I'm like, "No, no, no,
- 9:19what?
- 9:20I'm not Michael J. Stevens. Where are
- 9:22you getting that?"
- 9:23>> I am I think you should change it change
- 9:25your name to Michael
- 9:27Danger Stevens. I think that's what the
- 9:29D should stand for.
- 9:30>> I think I won't, because Michael David
- 9:34Stevens is an anagram of I'm the cave
- 9:40devil's sand.
- 9:42You can take all the letters in my name
- 9:44and rearrange it to that sentence.
- 9:46>> That's good.
- 9:46>> And that's good. Michael Danger Stevens,
- 9:48I haven't checked, but it's probably not
- 9:51as cool.
- 9:51>> Yeah.
- 9:52>> You can't spell cave devils with with
- 9:54only one V. Come on, Hannah.
- 9:56>> I know. I'm sorry.
- 9:56>> Um
- 9:57>> Say sorry. Carry on. Okay, Michael
- 9:59Michael D. Coe. Go on.
- 10:01>> Yeah, Michael D. Coe. So, in 1966, he
- 10:05wrote in his book The Maya, {quote}
- 10:08"There is a suggestion that Armageddon
- 10:11would overtake the degenerate peoples of
- 10:13the world and all creation on the final
- 10:15day of the 13th baktun. Thus, our
- 10:18present universe would be annihilated
- 10:20when the great cycle of the long count
- 10:22reaches completion."
- 10:25And people read that, and it kind of
- 10:29grew in popularity as like a thing
- 10:31people knew. The X-Files did an episode
- 10:33about it, and it started getting
- 10:36referenced in songs, and I think people
- 10:39kind of thought it sounded cool and
- 10:40decided not to look any deeper into it
- 10:43because there was no suggestion from the
- 10:45Mayan at all that our current world
- 10:48would be only exactly 13 baktun long. In
- 10:52fact, if you look at what they wrote, uh
- 10:55you can find that they talk about dates
- 10:58way far in the future. They talk about
- 11:00things that happen in the year 4000 and
- 11:02so on. Um in fact, their entire culture
- 11:05was very much about looking for promises
- 11:09of continuation.
- 11:10That things were going to keep going.
- 11:13They were definitely not looking for the
- 11:15end, which is like a kind of more of a
- 11:17um
- 11:18a more recent or or western obsession.
- 11:20Ooh, the end of the world. When's that
- 11:22going to come? I think it's going to
- 11:23come soon. Ooh, that's exciting. And
- 11:25that, you know, we we globbed onto that.
- 11:28I I love that idea, too, because I think
- 11:30it made me think about Stonehenge and
- 11:32how
- 11:33if it helped people
- 11:37notice the winter solstice
- 11:40that was a really
- 11:42powerful thing to observe because every
- 11:45day for the last few months the days
- 11:48have been getting shorter and shorter.
- 11:50The sun is spending less and less time
- 11:53shining on you and that could be
- 11:55terrifying
- 11:56if you were an early human but then
- 11:59there's this day where it's like oh
- 12:02this was the it's going to get better
- 12:04from now on.
- 12:04>> The time.
- 12:05>> The sun is going to be up longer
- 12:07tomorrow.
- 12:07>> Mhm.
- 12:09>> You know, hallelujah. They wouldn't have
- 12:10said hallelujah but they would have said
- 12:12whatever, you know, it would it could
- 12:13have been really exciting and so I mean
- 12:15that was probably the
- 12:16>> I suddenly realized I don't know nearly
- 12:18enough about Stonehenge. Is it I know
- 12:20that it's sort of about the the solstice
- 12:22and sort of paganism and so on but what
- 12:24happens? How does it How does it mark
- 12:26the the winter solstice?
- 12:28>> I'm not sure there's any agreement
- 12:30completely on this but it might be that
- 12:32some of the stones align with the sun on
- 12:35that day. Of course day-to-day the sun's
- 12:38position in the sky at the same time is
- 12:41you know, not that different. It all
- 12:44adds up to something pretty significant
- 12:46but I don't think there's enough of a
- 12:48consensus on exactly why Stonehenge was
- 12:51made. It probably had multiple purposes
- 12:53over time.
- 12:55But if we imagine that it was related at
- 12:58in in any way to to observing, marking
- 13:02or predicting cycles in in astronomy
- 13:05then it kind of makes sense. There's
- 13:07like celebrating the cycles, not the
- 13:10ends, not the apocalypse. And and that I
- 13:13think is what the Mayans were doing too.
- 13:15>> I really like that idea actually that
- 13:17for for almost all of human history time
- 13:21hasn't been this linear thing. It we
- 13:24haven't seen it as like you're moving
- 13:26forward. We currently have this insane
- 13:28obsession with the future in a way that
- 13:31people just didn't. Exactly as you
- 13:33described, it was cyclical, right? Birth
- 13:35and death, spring and summer, you know,
- 13:37night and day.
- 13:39Uh and I think that actually, especially
- 13:41when death was so much more regular part
- 13:43of life, um I think that actually it
- 13:46it's really easy to get trapped into the
- 13:49modern way of thinking, but that wasn't
- 13:50true, right? Just people did not think
- 13:53about time as as a linear thing.
- 13:56>> That's right. It is a historical anomaly
- 13:58to think of time so linearly and to
- 14:01think about time as a thing that
- 14:04contains a past that is different, that
- 14:07is a foreign country. That is an
- 14:09incredibly modern idea. And it's not
- 14:12even hard to see why. It wasn't even
- 14:14that long ago that the tools you used
- 14:16every day were exactly the same tools
- 14:19your grandparents used.
- 14:20>> Mhm.
- 14:21>> But today, the tools, the technology,
- 14:24the television shows that my Gen X wife
- 14:27watched are completely alien to
- 14:30millennial me. Like it's we may as well
- 14:33be from different planets. And we're not
- 14:35that different in age. Whereas it used
- 14:37to be that like you just had the cycles
- 14:39of seasons and you always cut the wheat
- 14:42the same way, you traveled at the same
- 14:44speeds. Explosion and change that marked
- 14:47Oh, the past is was really different and
- 14:49the future therefore will be really
- 14:51different. That's really a modern idea.
- 14:53And so of course in 1966, you've got
- 14:56people writing about Oh, the end of the
- 14:58world. It was predicted. And it became
- 15:01this huge thing. And then
- 15:03nothing happened.
- 15:05>> [laughter]
- 15:06>> Nothing happened.
- 15:07>> The world continues to exist and it has
- 15:10been for 14 years since.
- 15:13But in another way,
- 15:16I think there's an argument to be made
- 15:18that the world did end in 2012. Or at
- 15:22least a new world began, a fifth world.
- 15:25And here's here's the evidence I have to
- 15:28support this.
- 15:29>> Okay.
- 15:30>> No,
- 15:31the Earth is still here, humans did not
- 15:34go extinct, but
- 15:36the world before 2012 was a very
- 15:39different one
- 15:41than the world since.
- 15:42>> This is an extraordinary claim, Michael.
- 15:44This is going to require extraordinary
- 15:45evidence.
- 15:46>> It does. And spoiler alert, I don't have
- 15:49it.
- 15:49>> [laughter]
- 15:50>> In fact, this entire this entire project
- 15:53was an exercise in biased researching
- 15:56and
- 15:58uh confirmation bias. You're like,
- 16:00"Okay, how can I somehow prove that 2012
- 16:03was a special year?" Some of them are
- 16:05pretty convincing. Others I just I tried
- 16:08to finagle the way I was wording it to
- 16:10make 2012 work. But I think it's really
- 16:13I think it's really interesting to see
- 16:14how this all happens.
- 16:15>> Okay, so so you you've started backwards
- 16:17here, basically. You've started with I
- 16:19wanted to I wanted to prove that the
- 16:20world ended in 2012. What evidence can I
- 16:23collect? Okay, this is great. This is I
- 16:25like this as a as a sort of
- 16:26psychological experiment in in
- 16:27confirmation bias. This is good. Go
- 16:29ahead.
- 16:29>> Exactly. It's great because first of
- 16:31all, what do you do? You can Google
- 16:32search
- 16:34significant events in 2012 or statistics
- 16:38that make 2012 look important, and you
- 16:41find a bunch. Google doesn't say,
- 16:44"Well, it's not any more important than
- 16:45any other year." No, it goes, "You
- 16:47wanted that? Here you go." And so you're
- 16:50immediately getting confirmation of
- 16:52exactly what you want to find. So I
- 16:54think some of these are actually pretty
- 16:56legit. For example, when was it
- 17:01in the United States and the UK that we
- 17:04crossed the threshold where the majority
- 17:07of people had a smartphone?
- 17:10>> Right.
- 17:12That is a new era.
- 17:13>> Not when were smartphones invented, when
- 17:15did it become if not having one meant
- 17:17you were in the minority? We We had
- 17:19moved to a world where the majority, the
- 17:22norm, is having a smartphone.
- 17:24>> Wait, what year did they come out? What
- 17:25year were they released?
- 17:27>> It depends on how you define a
- 17:28smartphone.
- 17:29>> Let's say Let's say iPhone. Let's say
- 17:31the iPhone.
- 17:32>> The The first iPhone was announced in
- 17:34January of 2007.
- 17:36>> Okay, so
- 17:37it comes out in 2007.
- 17:40More than half.
- 17:44>> [snorts]
- 17:45>> I mean, look, the point here is that
- 17:462012 is the turning point, right? So,
- 17:48I'm going to guess 2012.
- 17:49>> You're right. You are exactly correct.
- 17:53>> That's incredible. That it took 5 years
- 17:55for that to happen.
- 17:56>> It took 5 years. I mean, when you look
- 17:59at these kind of statistics, you notice
- 18:01that there are There's a lot of people
- 18:02who adopt quickly. And if you're a young
- 18:04person, especially, it's kind of
- 18:06everyone you know, but there are,
- 18:08especially older people that adopt
- 18:10things so much more slowly.
- 18:12It does take longer than you think for
- 18:14things that feel a bit ludicrous to
- 18:15actually even become a majority thing.
- 18:18So, in 2012,
- 18:20smartphone penetration crossed that 50%
- 18:23mark. Different question,
- 18:25when, in what year,
- 18:29were half of Americans and Brits on
- 18:32social media, at least one platform?
- 18:34>> [sighs]
- 18:36>> Okay, let's think. Right, so
- 18:38Facebook was
- 18:41started in like 2002, I think 2003,
- 18:44around about then?
- 18:45>> Yeah, I joined in 2004.
- 18:49>> Yeah, something like that. Me too.
- 18:50>> Cuz I was a college student, and it was
- 18:52only available to us.
- 18:53>> Hey, me too. Same.
- 18:56>> What was some of the early social
- 18:57networks?
- 18:58>> Friends Reunited, remember that one?
- 19:00>> Facebook was founded in 2004.
- 19:02>> Founded in 2004. Right, okay.
- 19:05Um
- 19:05>> In fact, in fact, not to brag, but I'm
- 19:08pretty sure I'm like Facebook user
- 19:10number 9,000 or something. I'm not even
- 19:13kidding. Um because I It started in
- 19:172004. I entered college in 2004, and you
- 19:20needed a not only an a .edu email
- 19:22address, but you needed to be in college
- 19:25at one of just a few institutions to get
- 19:26in, and I went to U Chicago, which was
- 19:29included.
- 19:30>> Wow.
- 19:30>> So, I joined, and yeah, a few years ago
- 19:33I was able to look this up. Maybe you
- 19:35still can. You can look up your actual
- 19:37number of when you joined, and I was I
- 19:40was definitely like under 20,000.
- 19:42>> Oh, that's that's pretty cool. That's
- 19:44pretty cool.
- 19:44>> That was pretty cool. When do you think
- 19:47the majority of people, so more than
- 19:49half of Americans and Brits were at
- 19:52least on one social media platform. I'm
- 19:54also including MySpace.
- 19:56>> So, I think here I think it's
- 19:58I mean, it's not 2012, is it? Is it
- 20:002012?
- 20:02>> It's 2012.
- 20:05Okay? So, as you can see, this is a this
- 20:08is an inflection point. This is a a a a
- 20:11threshold being crossed. No, social
- 20:14media and smartphones didn't start in
- 20:162012, but it became the norm. It became
- 20:19the world that we lived in now. You
- 20:21couldn't say it was a minority or a
- 20:22niche thing anymore. All right, but then
- 20:26here's something different. At what
- 20:28point did digital media sales
- 20:31surpass
- 20:33physical media sales?
- 20:35>> Are we talking here about sort of
- 20:36movies,
- 20:38songs, that kind of thing?
- 20:40>> Yeah, we're talking about buying songs,
- 20:42movies, any kind of multimedia
- 20:44digitally, either, you know, one-off or
- 20:46through a subscription. When did that in
- 20:48total bulk dollars surpass physical
- 20:51media sales, DVDs, CDs?
- 20:54>> Michael, is it 2012?
- 20:55>> It's 2012.
- 20:57>> I'm noticing a pattern going on here.
- 21:00Right.
- 21:01>> to the digital world.
- 21:03>> Wow.
- 21:04>> Slowly over time, but it became where
- 21:07most of us were in 2012.
- 21:09>> Wow.
- 21:10>> Side note, most of us, by us I mean
- 21:13people in the Western world. Okay? This
- 21:16is actually a really fun statistic. I
- 21:17I'd like to see what you what you think.
- 21:19It might be the case that half of
- 21:21Americans had a smartphone by 2012. When
- 21:24did half of the humans on the planet
- 21:28Earth have a cell phone, a smartphone?
- 21:32>> So, the thing is is that actually
- 21:34I think it probably happened quite
- 21:35quickly. So, I I mean I've spent quite a
- 21:37lot of time in
- 21:39Kenya, for example. And the thing about
- 21:41sub-Saharan Africa is they sort of
- 21:43leapfrogged
- 21:45um
- 21:46technology, you know? Like they may not
- 21:48have had credit cards, but they did have
- 21:51mobile money, right? Mobile phones. And
- 21:55and I think smartphones, too, are are I
- 21:57think way more prevalent than you might
- 21:59expect. I I have a feeling in the back
- 22:01of my mind there's this statistic which
- 22:03is more people around the world have
- 22:05access to a smartphone than to a than to
- 22:07a toilet.
- 22:08>> The way I heard it was that more humans
- 22:10on Earth own a smartphone than a
- 22:12toothbrush. And in many ways a
- 22:15smartphone is just how you connect not
- 22:18only with other people for your own
- 22:20safety, but also for work, but a
- 22:23toothbrush is kind of like, you know,
- 22:25you can get by in the modern world
- 22:27without a toothbrush
- 22:28>> Agree.
- 22:29>> before you can get away with not having
- 22:32internet connectivity. And for a lot of
- 22:33the world, a smartphone is internet
- 22:35connectivity. They don't have a like a
- 22:36computer room or a big gaming PC or
- 22:38something or even a laptop. Smartphones
- 22:41are so much more portable.
- 22:44But, when was it that the entirety of
- 22:47the human population
- 22:49alive was
- 22:51majority smartphone owners? It has
- 22:54happened.
- 22:54>> I reckon later than the Western world. I
- 22:57reckon
- 22:5820
- 23:0016? 18?
- 23:02>> Later.
- 23:03>> Is it going?
- 23:05>> 2023.
- 23:06>> Really?
- 23:08>> Yeah.
- 23:08>> Wow, that is interesting. The 2023 was
- 23:12the halfway point and now more people
- 23:14have smartphones than toothbrushes.
- 23:16>> Yeah.
- 23:16>> Wow, that is a steep curve.
- 23:18>> Now social media became a majority
- 23:21thing. And this this one's almost more
- 23:23important to me cuz it feels like, okay,
- 23:26yeah, having a smartphone, what do you
- 23:27do with it though? Maybe you just text
- 23:29people. But when it comes to actually
- 23:32belonging to an online social network,
- 23:36when did the human population cross 50%?
- 23:3950% of us, more than half of us, were
- 23:42suddenly living part-time
- 23:45online in social networks on the
- 23:47internet.
- 23:52>> So I do know that there was a point when
- 23:54Facebook was running out of customers.
- 23:57Running sort of chasing growth because
- 23:59it goes back to what you were saying
- 24:00about the the sort of obsession with
- 24:02time as a linear thing, that the future
- 24:04should be different from the past.
- 24:06And so they started adopting this
- 24:09strategy of essentially creating
- 24:13internet
- 24:14connectivity in places like sub-Saharan
- 24:16Africa purely
- 24:19so so that they could get new customers.
- 24:21They were like, if we invest in the
- 24:22infrastructure, more customers will be
- 24:23there. There's more eyeballs. Facebook
- 24:25can be the the homepage of the internet
- 24:27essentially. Um so I know that that's
- 24:30what they were deliberately doing.
- 24:33And I think if there was sort of an
- 24:35aggressive drive for it. So it happened
- 24:37in 2012 for the Western world. Social
- 24:39media Do you know what? I think it's
- 24:41later than the smartphone thing. I think
- 24:43it's I think it's like
- 24:452024 [snorts]
- 24:47is my guess.
- 24:48>> It was before 50% smartphone
- 24:51penetration. Yeah, 2020.
- 24:53>> Wow.
- 24:55>> And when kind of makes sense because you
- 24:57don't need a smartphone to be on social
- 24:59media. You can you can have a Facebook
- 25:01account that you only access once a week
- 25:03in an internet cafe.
- 25:04>> Yeah, true.
- 25:04>> So, so yeah, 2020 is when we estimate
- 25:07that
- 25:09our species became a majority part-time
- 25:12online
- 25:13superorganism.
- 25:16Now, those facts are cool, but they kind
- 25:18of like show just how shaky my whole the
- 25:20world as we knew it ended in 2012
- 25:23argument is that I have to be like,
- 25:24well, if you don't count everyone, if
- 25:26you just count
- 25:28the United Kingdom and America, 2012
- 25:31comes out to be a special date. But
- 25:32that's fine. Today we're we're just
- 25:35we're just yapping, okay?
- 25:37>> I'm I'm okay I'm okay with this though,
- 25:38because I think on these on these topics
- 25:41that you're describing, essentially it's
- 25:44like
- 25:45they
- 25:47it's an unstoppable train.
- 25:49And I think that the biggest pins fall.
- 25:53Like, you know, when America falls
- 25:55with a new technology, often the rest of
- 25:57the world will come with it. Just it's
- 25:59sort of a matter of time. I'm with you.
- 26:01I I I I'm okay I'm okay with the fact
- 26:03that this is like this is a really key
- 26:05turning point. I you've persuaded me. My
- 26:07confirmation bias says yes.
- 26:09>> All right, one more question on this
- 26:11topic, and it is when do you think it
- 26:13was the case
- 26:14that
- 26:15we crossed a threshold where
- 26:18more than half of Americans got their
- 26:21news digitally?
- 26:26>> Is it 2012?
- 26:28>> [laughter]
- 26:28>> It's 2012. Yeah. Now, that means that
- 26:32they may have just been reading the New
- 26:34York Times, but they were reading it
- 26:36digitally.
- 26:36>> online
- 26:37>> Online. It doesn't mean that they were
- 26:39getting it all from social media. That
- 26:41didn't happen until later. In fact, I
- 26:42don't even know if it's still a majority
- 26:44yet. But yeah, it was a huge it was a
- 26:47huge jump. Okay, so so we can actually
- 26:49go on and on with little statistics like
- 26:51that. The last one I wanted to mention
- 26:53doesn't really fit, but it's so close.
- 26:57I'm going to put another log on my fire
- 26:58while you think about this because now
- 27:00you know the answer is not 2012.
- 27:02When was peak
- 27:05viewership of linear television? Here's
- 27:09what I mean. Watching things on a screen
- 27:11that were being broadcast to you that
- 27:14you were watching at the same time as
- 27:16everyone else. So, that means cable
- 27:18television counts. That means broadcast
- 27:21television counts, but not streaming.
- 27:23When did that peak that people were
- 27:24watching stuff for the most part of the
- 27:27day
- 27:28all together?
- 27:29>> So, cuz this is you're not asking here
- 27:32about I mean, viewing figures would be a
- 27:34sort of uh
- 27:36a kind of a cul-de-sac here because
- 27:39um
- 27:40you're not talking about one particular
- 27:43show had a really high viewership. And
- 27:44I'm I mean, I'm pretty sure that like
- 27:46a Super Bowl quite recently holds the
- 27:49record for most people watching
- 27:50simultaneously or the Queen's funeral or
- 27:52something. And so, then I think it's
- 27:54much earlier. I think it's I think it's
- 27:57much earlier than the digital
- 27:59revolution.
- 28:02Or maybe maybe I don't. Maybe I just
- 28:04think it's the '90s. Maybe I think it's
- 28:05the '90s.
- 28:06>> Okay, well that's not a that's not a bad
- 28:08guess because I think that there are two
- 28:11things to consider. One is bulk number
- 28:14of viewers and the other is percentage
- 28:17of available eyeballs watching.
- 28:21So, look at something like the the
- 28:24finale of the television show MASH.
- 28:26>> Right. Okay.
- 28:27>> Okay, that was huge. In fact, it was it
- 28:31was watched by so many people. I'll tell
- 28:33you when did it happen. It happened in
- 28:36>> '80s.
- 28:37>> On February 28th of 1983,
- 28:41the television show the long-running
- 28:43television show MASH ended and its last
- 28:45episode was a 2-and-1/2 hour special.
- 28:48Fantastic show, by the way. I think like
- 28:51the writing is just incredible.
- 28:53>> Mhm.
- 28:53>> I could sit here and quote MASH to you
- 28:55for the whole rest of our time.
- 28:57>> nothing about it. I don't really know
- 28:59what the cast is. I don't know I
- 29:00couldn't pick out anyone who was in it
- 29:02out of a lineup, but I do know what
- 29:04happened in that finale.
- 29:06>> [laughter]
- 29:06>> Rin- Exactly. I mean, that's kind of
- 29:09That's kind of where I think we're going
- 29:10to go in this conversation.
- 29:12>> Yeah.
- 29:12>> You You still are kind of a part of it.
- 29:15>> It infiltrated popular the popular
- 29:17psyche, right? It's and it's still
- 29:19there. Even though it happened before I
- 29:21before I was born or certainly before I
- 29:22was conscious.
- 29:23>> And it's still It's still a really good
- 29:25show. In fact, funny enough, I've never
- 29:27actually talked about this, but when I
- 29:28was
- 29:29first making Vsauce videos in the very
- 29:31early years of Vsauce, I was watching a
- 29:33lot of MASH and a lot of the episode
- 29:35ideas came from things that I was
- 29:38inspired to think about because of MASH.
- 29:40Like, there's an episode where Hawkeye,
- 29:43Alan Alda, creates this like fake person
- 29:46in order to get things like done. He He
- 29:48says, "Oh, you know, I forget who it
- 29:50was." Like a sergeant he made up. He
- 29:51says, "Oh, a sergeant said it's okay."
- 29:53And then it turns out that like people
- 29:54need this fake character to exist
- 29:57because it gives them hope. And so, he
- 29:59has to stage a whole like death of the
- 30:02sergeant because he can't keep the lie
- 30:04going, but he doesn't He doesn't want to
- 30:05ever tell people that that person didn't
- 30:06exist. And I'm like, "Wow, sometimes
- 30:09there are lies that we need."
- 30:11Anyway,
- 30:12I love the show and a lot of other
- 30:14people did because in 1983, so many
- 30:17people tuned in to watch the final
- 30:20episode simultaneously, by the way. This
- 30:22isn't like a thing where they like, "Oh,
- 30:24I'll stream it next week." No, they all
- 30:25had to tune in, stop what they were
- 30:26doing.
- 30:2852%
- 30:31of Americans alive on that day
- 30:34were watching
- 30:36the MASH finale.
- 30:37>> That's incredible. That is incredible.
- 30:38>> That's incredible.
- 30:39>> Yeah.
- 30:40>> To be fair, more people watched the um
- 30:45the Chiefs-Eagles Super Bowl Super Bowl
- 30:4859, I believe it was. But that's only
- 30:50because the the American population has
- 30:52gotten so much larger than it was in
- 30:541983 that even the most viewed American
- 30:58broadcast is still was still viewed by a
- 31:01smaller percentage of available people
- 31:05than the MASH finale was.
- 31:08Um but then if you look at if you look
- 31:10at the percentage of people watching an
- 31:12individual program, of course it goes
- 31:14down after 8 1983. There's so many more
- 31:17options.
- 31:18Cable television comes around, home
- 31:22media viewing with you know VHS
- 31:25and later [clears throat] DVD becomes a
- 31:27thing. People can time shift what they
- 31:29watch. They're not all watching it at
- 31:30the same time. Basically after
- 31:34Seinfeld and ER in the '90s,
- 31:37linear television where everyone watches
- 31:39together has just plummeted.
- 31:44When was the peak? And and let me
- 31:46describe what I mean by this. By peak, I
- 31:49mean
- 31:50there was a a time where if you surveyed
- 31:52people and asked them how many hours do
- 31:54you spend per day watching linear TV, a
- 31:59shared storytelling amongst you and your
- 32:03your your your fellow citizens.
- 32:05When did people watch the most linear TV
- 32:08every day?
- 32:10You said the '90s and you're wrong.
- 32:12>> I'm wrong? Is it late '80s?
- 32:14>> Nope.
- 32:14>> Is it later?
- 32:15>> Yep.
- 32:16>> Is it?
- 32:17Linear TV, really?
- 32:20>> Yep.
- 32:20>> When?
- 32:21>> 2010.
- 32:23>> No!
- 32:24Really?
- 32:25>> Yep.
- 32:26>> What?
- 32:26>> Well, keep in mind that we had American
- 32:29Idol in the early 2000s. There was a
- 32:32real golden age of television at that
- 32:35time. So, Breaking Bad was a show that a
- 32:38lot of people watched as appointment
- 32:41viewing.
- 32:42Because you couldn't really easily
- 32:43stream it for the 2010-2011
- 32:47television season, for the first time in
- 32:50decades,
- 32:51viewership of linear TV was lower.
- 32:54And then in 2012, our magic year, it
- 32:57continued going down. So, I could say
- 32:592012 was when it stopped being an
- 33:01aberration and became, this is the way
- 33:03it's going. Two years in a row now it's
- 33:06dropped and it's just dropped ever
- 33:08since. Now we're all watching out of
- 33:10time with each other, out of sync with
- 33:12each other, and we have so many more
- 33:14options that that nowadays you can just
- 33:16be like, "Oh, hey, have you heard of
- 33:19Squirtle Town?" And someone's like, "No,
- 33:21I literally have not even heard of that
- 33:22show." And you're like, "Oh, I I spend
- 33:24every night watching it." And we're
- 33:26we're really spread apart. Whereas,
- 33:29decades ago, if you just randomly
- 33:31knocked on someone's door, one out of
- 33:33three of them were watching Mary Tyler
- 33:35Moore.
- 33:36The Cosby Show was a thing that you
- 33:39could bring up at work and everyone had
- 33:41watched it, literally. But today, if I'm
- 33:44even like, "Hey, so what do you guys
- 33:46think of Succession?"
- 33:48More than half of the people are like,
- 33:49"Haven't seen it."
- 33:50>> So, I think that I I think about this
- 33:51quite often actually, uh partly because
- 33:53I still make linear TV.
- 33:55>> [laughter]
- 33:56>> Clinging on, baby. Well, okay, I think
- 33:58two things about this. One is that um
- 34:01I think some people get quite down on
- 34:02linear TV and like, "Oh, well, no one's
- 34:04watching it. No one's watching it." And
- 34:06actually, I just don't think that that
- 34:08is true. Because when you compare
- 34:11who is watching linear TV to who is
- 34:14watching stuff on the internet, right?
- 34:16It's like vastly different. So, you
- 34:18know, I'll have a program, I'll put a
- 34:19program out on BBC 2 or whatever.
- 34:22Watching live, couple of million people
- 34:24will watch it live. Imagine if I did a
- 34:26stream on YouTube.
- 34:29You imagine if I did a YouTube stream
- 34:31and I got 2 million people logging on to
- 34:33sort of to watch. It would be wild. I
- 34:37mean even the biggest YouTubers like
- 34:39would struggle to pull in numbers like
- 34:41that. So I think for starters it's sort
- 34:42of the kind of baseline that you're
- 34:44thinking about when it comes to sort of
- 34:46describing Linus Tech Tips is always in
- 34:47the past, you know, back to like the
- 34:49past being different to the future and
- 34:51not to what else is out there. But the
- 34:53other thing I think though about that
- 34:55idea that all of our attention is sort
- 34:57of fragmented, there's no single town
- 34:59square anymore. No single sort of
- 35:01cultural touchstone that has embedded
- 35:03itself into all of our psyches
- 35:04simultaneously. I think that celebrities
- 35:07are really different to to what they
- 35:09were before. I think there's some people
- 35:12who um
- 35:1310 years ago, 15 years ago, apparently
- 35:15in 2010 would have been household names,
- 35:20right? Would have been mega mega mega
- 35:22stars. And now actually
- 35:25I mean they're still living the same
- 35:26life, right? They're still making the
- 35:28same shows, still doing the same thing,
- 35:30still getting to do all the the stuff,
- 35:32but like they get to live a life that is
- 35:34more private because they're not getting
- 35:37mobbed the entire time. There's not the
- 35:38cultural cut-through that that you get
- 35:41in quite the same way.
- 35:43>> Yeah. Oh, definitely. Yeah, it feels
- 35:45like there are fewer Tom Cruises
- 35:49>> Mhm.
- 35:50>> and there are fewer Mel Gibsons and
- 35:54Marlon Brandos and there are a lot more
- 35:56Michael Stevensons.
- 35:58>> Yeah.
- 35:58>> Okay.
- 35:59>> Everyone's become you, Michael.
- 36:01>> [laughter]
- 36:02>> But people who are like phenomenally
- 36:03well known to a smaller to to to their
- 36:05own group of people. It's not like
- 36:07you're that small actually, but you
- 36:08know.
- 36:09>> Like when I'm recognized in public, it's
- 36:11by like one one person and their friends
- 36:13are all like who?
- 36:14>> [laughter]
- 36:14>> And they all have to like learn who I am
- 36:17because there was one but that's how
- 36:18fractured they are even within the
- 36:19friend group. Only one of them knows
- 36:22what Vsauce is. So there's today we've
- 36:25got an enormous amount of like cult
- 36:27celebrities but very few blockbuster
- 36:31monoculture celebrities like a Michael
- 36:34Jackson. Now, to be fair, the entire
- 36:37notion of a monoculture is controversial
- 36:40because there are still moments that we
- 36:42all share in some way. I think Taylor
- 36:45Swift is arguably for the for for for a
- 36:47lot of the world someone that we're all
- 36:49familiar with. Look at the launch of
- 36:51Barbie and Oppenheimer. Okay, that was
- 36:54that was a thing we all shared. The
- 36:55Titan submarine imploding or at least
- 36:58disappearing, that like brought us all
- 37:01together. And sports continue to bring
- 37:04us all together. The most viewed
- 37:06broadcasts are sporting events. It
- 37:09There's There's something there. I don't
- 37:10even know what it is. Tell us in the
- 37:11comments what you think. Well, what does
- 37:13it mean that it's more like news events
- 37:17that bring us together at the same time
- 37:20but it used to be fictional stories. It
- 37:22used to be MASH and ER and Seinfeld and
- 37:26Friends and now it's what's going to
- 37:29happen, who's going to win, um who's
- 37:31going to slip up in this political
- 37:33debate. People tuned in to watch the
- 37:35Hillary-Trump debate in in huge numbers
- 37:38that they don't tune in altogether to
- 37:40watch Big Bang Theory.
- 37:42>> See, this is This is the thing I think.
- 37:44I actually think the blockbuster
- 37:45celebrities, the Michael Jacksons, the
- 37:47Taylor Swifts, right? I think that they
- 37:48have always existed throughout history,
- 37:50you know, like Byron or I don't know
- 37:53Gilgamesh or whatever. Like all of these
- 37:54people in history have the kind of cut
- 37:56through these megastars. I don't know
- 37:57why I used that as an example, but
- 37:58anyway.
- 37:59>> That's a hilarious I'm just imagining
- 38:01someone going, "Oh my gosh,
- 38:04Teresa, that's Gilgamesh.
- 38:06Quick, let's get a stone carving
- 38:08together."
- 38:09>> [laughter]
- 38:10>> Yeah, and anything like walk and talk,
- 38:12guys. Walk and talk. But
- 38:13I think it's more like the
- 38:16the sort of the
- 38:17the sort of people who are who are not
- 38:19megastars, you know, like Angela Rippon,
- 38:21right? Maybe you don't know Angela
- 38:23Rippon. It's or like Michael Parkinson,
- 38:25right? Like people who were household
- 38:27names, um and yet were not, I don't
- 38:30think, mega stars, like ordinary people
- 38:33doing a job in the public sphere. The
- 38:35thing is is that actually, going back to
- 38:37your Stonehenge comment from earlier, I
- 38:39do sort of think that what we're doing
- 38:41is returning to a much more natural
- 38:44state of being in
- 38:47compared to the history of humanity,
- 38:49right? Because what we used to do is we
- 38:51used to have little clusters, we used to
- 38:52have little communities, and then
- 38:54there'd maybe be a mega star here and
- 38:55there where the news would get real
- 38:57cut-through. You know, a a king dies,
- 38:59that news would get real cut-through,
- 39:00everybody would know about it. Maybe
- 39:02something sporting, if the equivalent is
- 39:05old wars, right? Like wars and football
- 39:08and kind of
- 39:08>> [snorts]
- 39:08>> simultaneous way to like act out your
- 39:10your
- 39:11natural violence. You'd sort of hear
- 39:13about all of that. But but actually,
- 39:15this idea of like localized communities
- 39:17is is a very human thing. The only thing
- 39:19is, now we are localized by topic, not
- 39:22by geo- geography.
- 39:25>> You basically just said my conclusion
- 39:28for this episode.
- 39:29>> No, I love it. I love it because we're
- 39:33so much alike, Hannah, because yeah,
- 39:34I've I've I've looked into this kind of
- 39:36stuff for years, and I just got sick of
- 39:39the whole like, "Ooh, our attention
- 39:41spans, and we're all just looking at
- 39:42screens." And I'm like, I get it, but
- 39:43there's more to it than that. And I
- 39:46think that in a lot of ways we are
- 39:48returning
- 39:49to
- 39:51the way we used to be before the modern
- 39:53world happened.
- 39:53>> Mhm. [snorts]
- 39:54>> That not only are you're right, we're in
- 39:57smaller groups, but also we have in a
- 40:00lot of ways that freedom of association
- 40:03that we lost in the modern world. The
- 40:05Dawn of Everything, fantastic book to
- 40:08read. And And Deirdre Barrett wrote
- 40:09Supernormal Stimuli.
- 40:11Um she
- 40:12speaks also about this, which is that
- 40:15people used to be
- 40:17way more free in a specific way before
- 40:22land ownership. You're in nomadic groups
- 40:24that are small. If you have a problem
- 40:26with people in your group, you just go.
- 40:28>> [laughter]
- 40:29>> And in The Dawn of Everything, this is
- 40:31discussed really deeply. That freedom
- 40:34people had to just do their own thing.
- 40:37And that lasted a long time. I mean,
- 40:38even into the modern world, the the
- 40:40pilgrims were like, "Hey, we want to
- 40:42have church in a different way.
- 40:44There's other land we can go to where
- 40:45you cannot do anything about it.
- 40:47>> See ya, Europe.
- 40:48>> That's not true anymore.
- 40:50Uh good luck. If you want to go form a
- 40:52new country where you do religion in
- 40:54some way that's completely disallowed by
- 40:57any other government where are you going
- 40:59to go? Today, we almost have that in
- 41:02some different form now where you can
- 41:04say, "You know what? I'm really into
- 41:06extreme body modification. Hey, look.
- 41:09I'm already on a forum. I'm already
- 41:11within a subreddit or
- 41:14um
- 41:15a Facebook group where everyone is more
- 41:18like me. And I was able to find them and
- 41:20escape. And I can be here and yet um no
- 41:23one can stop me. It doesn't make me feel
- 41:25isolated. So, we've changed.
- 41:27>> what's nice about this, Michael, is that
- 41:29um I I don't know whether
- 41:31>> [laughter]
- 41:32>> our lovely listeners {slash} viewers
- 41:34have noticed that we've started doing
- 41:36this thing where you prepare an episode
- 41:37and I have no idea what's coming up and
- 41:39vice versa. I don't know if they've
- 41:41noticed. Um but that idea that I just
- 41:43stole Michael's conclusion was not
- 41:45rehearsed, everybody.
- 41:46>> No, it wasn't. Yeah, we're doing a thing
- 41:48where we I I don't know what Hannah's
- 41:49going to do in in the next episode, but
- 41:52you know, I look forward to it and I
- 41:53will react appropriately. However,
- 41:58even though I think that in a lot of
- 42:00ways social media, the internet, digital
- 42:03lives are immigration to this like
- 42:07different world. It's It's not a utopia,
- 42:09but it's also not a dystopia. I just
- 42:11think of it as a heterotopia. It's
- 42:14another place. Our immigration to this
- 42:17heterotopia, this other place, has given
- 42:20us
- 42:22new ways to be active, new ways to to to
- 42:26learn about the world and associate with
- 42:27people. So, it's made us more like like
- 42:30more human, but less
- 42:34humus. [snorts]
- 42:36Where humus means dirt. Like the
- 42:38physicality is gone.
- 42:39>> Yeah.
- 42:40>> I can I can share stories with people
- 42:43who think the way I do, and I can agree,
- 42:46and we can we can
- 42:48you know, commune in a certain sense,
- 42:50but I can't smell them.
- 42:52I can't hug them. I can't see the pores
- 42:55on their skin when they
- 42:58just do little micro expressional
- 43:01reactions to what I say.
- 43:03I can't like a lot of my communication
- 43:06with them will be disentrained from
- 43:09time. It'll be oh, they sent me a
- 43:10message. I'm going to read that when I
- 43:12have time.
- 43:13And I don't know what the consequences
- 43:15of losing that are.
- 43:17But it used to be that not only would
- 43:19you could you say stuff and your body
- 43:21language and and the temperature of the
- 43:23room and all of this was shared between
- 43:26you and who was listening,
- 43:28but it it it also kind of disappeared.
- 43:31Like exactly what I said
- 43:34was was only in our memories after it
- 43:36was said. But now, what that person on
- 43:38the forum said to me last week, I've got
- 43:41a screenshot of it. It's right there
- 43:43with a timestamp and everything for
- 43:44everyone to see and for me to to look
- 43:46at. That
- 43:48that's a big change, and I don't know
- 43:50how I feel about that. I don't know how
- 43:53that makes us different now than of
- 43:55course we were when we were
- 43:58pre-modern people.
- 44:01But that documentation
- 44:03it's called the documentality of society
- 44:06is definitely a new thing, not a return.
- 44:10>> What was it you said? More human, less
- 44:12human?
- 44:12>> So humus means um the earth. In fact,
- 44:16that's probably where the word human
- 44:17comes from. It comes from like we are
- 44:19from the earth. We are from dirt, right?
- 44:21We are humus.
- 44:23That's like that a a really nice kind of
- 44:25it's a kind of dirt. It's kind of soil.
- 44:28>> to the chickpea snack or um I'm joking.
- 44:30>> It it might be.
- 44:32>> I'm taking
- 44:32>> I wish I wish it didn't sound so much
- 44:34like hummus. Humus is spelled with just
- 44:37one m.
- 44:38>> [snorts]
- 44:38>> Here's the thing about it, right? I
- 44:40think that's such a good description.
- 44:41>> Sorry,
- 44:42I just want to interrupt cuz I need to
- 44:44say this, too. Humus is the Latin word
- 44:46for ground or earth. And so uh by by
- 44:50immigrating to these digital
- 44:52heterotopias, we have become more human
- 44:57in the like pre-modern sense of having
- 45:00the freedom of association in smaller
- 45:02groups, but at the same time we lost the
- 45:05grounding and the earth of it, the
- 45:07physicality.
- 45:09>> See, this is the thing, right? I think
- 45:12that ends up making so many of us so
- 45:15unhappy. Because because we know,
- 45:19I think, that doomscrolling, that being
- 45:22in these online communities, when you're
- 45:24in them, it feels like it's scratching
- 45:26the itch that you need to scratch,
- 45:28right? It's sort of it's doing the thing
- 45:30that our species adapted for. It's that
- 45:32we're a cognitive social species. It's
- 45:34like it's thinking and socializing in
- 45:37this way. But because it's only the mind
- 45:40part, because you are tapping into sort
- 45:43of an alternate, what did you call it? A
- 45:45a different version of reality.
- 45:48>> A heterotopia.
- 45:50>> An other place.
- 45:51>> Because you're tapping into this
- 45:52heterotopia,
- 45:54I think that your body,
- 45:57you know, then ends up realizing that
- 45:59it's missing something. You know, all
- 46:01these tech bros are talking now about
- 46:03like, oh, touching grass, right? And
- 46:05they sort of say it in a very flippant
- 46:07way, but you know what? I think touching
- 46:09the earth, right?
- 46:11Physically touching the earth. I
- 46:13actually think there's something in it,
- 46:14and I think that that's something that
- 46:16um you can't replicate in the digital
- 46:19world.
- 46:20>> I I completely agree, and so I'm going
- 46:22to make a prediction. I think that we
- 46:24will see a lot more
- 46:27in-person
- 46:29association in the future within our
- 46:31lifetimes. It's mainly going to be
- 46:33accomplished by some huge technological
- 46:36innovation in travel. It'll probably be
- 46:38something like, oh yeah, we found a way
- 46:40to not just take an airplane, but
- 46:42literally go suborbital
- 46:44and and be able to go from, you know,
- 46:46New Zealand to London in like half an
- 46:48hour.
- 46:50Then people will be able to say, hey,
- 46:51I'm really into this one really specific
- 46:53thing, or I like this one kind of
- 46:55specific book. I can that that community
- 46:57that loves that can all get physically
- 46:59together, and we can interrupt each
- 47:02other and hear each other's voices, and
- 47:05be embodied together. I think that's
- 47:07going to happen in our lifetime. I also
- 47:09think that linear
- 47:12entertainment is going to come back. And
- 47:15this is this is
- 47:16It's not going to come back and replace
- 47:19um streaming, you know, video on demand,
- 47:22but I think it'll come back. And this is
- 47:24based purely on the fact that um I was
- 47:26in LA recently in a house where I wasn't
- 47:29logged into any of my streaming
- 47:30services, and I had to watch Tubi, and I
- 47:33had to watch logged out YouTube where I
- 47:35where I didn't have my premium account,
- 47:37so ads were appearing. And I actually
- 47:40came to love
- 47:42the commercial breaks, and I even made a
- 47:45rule that I can't pause, because that
- 47:47wasn't the way things were when I was a
- 47:49kid. I'm like, I'm going to have
- 47:50commercial breaks, and I'm not going to
- 47:51be able to pause it, and the connection
- 47:55it made between me and the program was
- 47:57really strange. I had never been so
- 47:59committed to something. I couldn't pause
- 48:01it and look at my phone. Um if I needed
- 48:04to go to the bathroom or get a snack, I
- 48:06had to wait for
- 48:08the commercial break. It felt like me
- 48:11and the and the story were together as
- 48:13opposed to I'm in control of you.
- 48:16To not have control made me so much more
- 48:20vulnerable and present for the show. I
- 48:23don't know. I I loved it in a way that I
- 48:25think we're going to all
- 48:27embrace.
- 48:29>> You, Michael, are an optimist.
- 48:31>> [snorts]
- 48:32[laughter]
- 48:33>> I love that idea. My concern is that
- 48:36that the the exact opposite might
- 48:37happen, that rather than people changing
- 48:40their geography to get with the other
- 48:42people they like,
- 48:45>> [laughter]
- 48:45>> I I I rather fear that that people may
- 48:48decide that the people they don't like
- 48:50can't share their geography.
- 48:52>> [laughter]
- 48:53>> I'm talking civil war. Anyway, there's
- 48:55um one of those two. One of those two.
- 48:57>> One of those two, exactly. It's going to
- 48:59be one of those two. And I have an
- 49:01unfortunate piece of evidence that kind
- 49:02of supports what you just said. And it's
- 49:04the fact that
- 49:05we we are doing this. We are
- 49:07geographically sort of relocating
- 49:09ourselves because that has become easier
- 49:11to do along ideological lines. And
- 49:15in 2012, 50% of Americans, and ever
- 49:19since then it's gone up, 50% of
- 49:21Americans found themselves living in a
- 49:23county
- 49:24that voted for one presidential
- 49:26candidate over the other by 20 points or
- 49:28more. They're called landslide counties.
- 49:31So, we stopped living
- 49:33surrounded by a diversity of people that
- 49:35we kind of had to learn to live with and
- 49:37also like kind of made our own beliefs
- 49:39stronger because we were having to
- 49:40coexist with people who disagreed with
- 49:42them.
- 49:43That is eroding away. And I don't know
- 49:46how we solve that because yeah, if if I
- 49:47can get together with people that I
- 49:49agree with,
- 49:50who's going to force me to to get a
- 49:52little bit of diversity now and then and
- 49:54get around people who really just don't
- 49:56understand the movies that I like, do
- 49:57not have the same values as me?
- 50:00>> Yeah.
- 50:00>> I'll say the thing that really made my
- 50:02whole 2012 project fall apart was that I
- 50:04really hoped that political polarization
- 50:08somehow like really took off in 2012.
- 50:13But it just didn't. 2012 has there's
- 50:16nothing special about polarization in
- 50:172012. I'll tell you though it really
- 50:21really took over American society in
- 50:252003.
- 50:26>> Okay.
- 50:27>> So for for for a long time Pew Research
- 50:29has been doing this American Values
- 50:31Survey. It's 48 questions about what you
- 50:34value, uh what's the role of family, the
- 50:37role of government, all these things.
- 50:39And they would track how different
- 50:41people's values were
- 50:43based on their education, their income,
- 50:47their race, their religiosity. When they
- 50:50started doing this in the '80s, all the
- 50:52way from then until 2003, the number one
- 50:55predictor of a value difference in
- 50:57America was race.
- 50:59>> Right.
- 50:59>> But in 2003 that changed. And suddenly
- 51:02the biggest predictor that you were
- 51:04going to have different values than
- 51:05someone was what political party you
- 51:07preferred.
- 51:08>> Haha. Hmm, it's definitely the case now,
- 51:10right?
- 51:10>> big.
- 51:11And then when they surveyed again in
- 51:132012, the difference was astronomical.
- 51:17It used to be that they were all still
- 51:19pretty clumped, but political party
- 51:20preference was the top. Now
- 51:23every race, income, education, gender,
- 51:26they're all different by maybe two,
- 51:27three percentage points. Political
- 51:29party, 30 percentage percentage point
- 51:31difference. I mean, it's it's huge. And
- 51:34so yeah, something
- 51:37is is still going on and I don't know
- 51:39how that's going to work with the way we
- 51:42consume information together or apart,
- 51:46if it's going to get better or worse.
- 51:47>> The one thing I've seen recently that
- 51:49actually does make me feel quite
- 51:50positive about that is um some evidence
- 51:53around the way polarization is changing
- 51:57large language models.
- 51:58So, you've had this era, the 2012 being
- 52:01the tipping point, of people on social
- 52:03media, of people finding their own
- 52:05individual communities, of of these
- 52:07bubbles happening, of people spiraling
- 52:09down into more and more and more extreme
- 52:11content. And people were really
- 52:13concerned that if you were talking to
- 52:14large language models, you end up
- 52:16getting the exact same effect. But
- 52:18actually,
- 52:19and there's like the evidence is really
- 52:22emerging on this, but it's it it's
- 52:24looking pretty robust, that actually you
- 52:26get the exact opposite effect. That
- 52:29people, when they are talking to a large
- 52:30language model, not only do they not
- 52:32feel judged or or sort of insulted or
- 52:35looked down on because of their
- 52:36political views, but actually, they end
- 52:39up uh asking the questions that they
- 52:42want to ask, and it appears that it's
- 52:45nudging people from both extremes, by
- 52:47the way, not from one extreme, but from
- 52:50both extremes slightly more together
- 52:52than we were before. And it's an effect
- 52:54also, actually, sorry, forgive me
- 52:56because I can't remember the name of the
- 52:57author, but there was one study really
- 52:59looked amazing, which is where they sat
- 53:00people with quite extreme views down,
- 53:03and then they had a conversation with a
- 53:04large language model, and they they
- 53:05changed their opinion, but not only
- 53:07that, they went back and spoke to them
- 53:09again a few weeks later, and their
- 53:11opinions had remained softened from from
- 53:13earlier.
- 53:14>> We'll We'll We'll do a whole episode on
- 53:16this, because I know exactly what you're
- 53:18talking about. I've had this experience,
- 53:20and I've seen it from other people,
- 53:22where if they talk to someone, a a human
- 53:25they disagree with,
- 53:27they're easy they're able to just
- 53:28psychologically say, "There's something
- 53:30wrong with you."
- 53:31>> Yeah.
- 53:31>> But if if a language model is is I mean,
- 53:34it can be tuned to do the opposite. It
- 53:35can just say, "You're right, and let's
- 53:37let's exacerbate your current feelings."
- 53:39If it provides that necessary friction
- 53:42for us to really shape out what it is we
- 53:45really believe. We do get pushed into a
- 53:48more reasonable perspective that that
- 53:51that is aware of his own subjectivity
- 53:53and that we're you know that not
- 53:55everyone agrees with us. So gosh,
- 53:58there'll definitely be a role played
- 53:59there. I think in a in a way people look
- 54:02at AI as being just like so smart these
- 54:05LLM's. They they think they think think
- 54:07that they are like omniscient basically
- 54:11almost to a fault I agree. Where someone
- 54:13will say, "Oh, well, I asked chat GPT
- 54:16and it didn't say that that's true." And
- 54:17it's like, "Oh my gosh, but it's wrong."
- 54:20However, they just trust it. They don't
- 54:22think it has a personality or ulterior
- 54:24motives. They just think that it's like
- 54:27either right or wrong.
- 54:28I don't know that's going to be a
- 54:30significant influence on this whole
- 54:32topic in the future. Let's let's
- 54:34definitely do an episode on that one.
- 54:35But I think you know what I I end up
- 54:37being persuaded. I am persuaded by your
- 54:39argument here. I think 2012 was a
- 54:41turning point. I think that the world as
- 54:43we knew it did end in 2012. I agree with
- 54:46you.
- 54:47>> And a whole new world began. I mean look
- 54:50I'll end with this. I'll say in 2012
- 54:52Facebook went public, all right? So
- 54:54social media became this like very
- 54:57mainstream not private thing. Also, what
- 55:00else started in 2012? Tinder. Okay? I
- 55:04think I think it's it's certainly true
- 55:07that 2012 stands out as an important
- 55:10year for this migration to digital
- 55:13heterotopias. But the process has been
- 55:17a slow one that's happened over time and
- 55:18we still don't really know where it's
- 55:20taking us. I think it's taking us
- 55:22together.
- 55:23But whether it does that or takes us
- 55:26apart
- 55:28in bad ways is completely up to us.
- 55:32>> Amazing.
- 55:33>> Like this is this isn't a great like
- 55:35bumper sticker slogan, but we kind of
- 55:37need both. We need to be apart, but also
- 55:42a part.
- 55:43We need the freedom to escape, but we
- 55:46also need to be forced into friction and
- 55:49disagreements. So, if we keep that in
- 55:52mind, I think it'll guide us well.
- 55:55>> Okay, well, I'm just writing down your
- 55:57predictions here for for the future and
- 55:59we will see if they see if they come
- 56:01true in the next back to
- 56:03>> That's a lot of time.
- 56:04>> There's a lot of
- 56:05>> time. We got to work
- 56:05>> Sometime in the next 394 years, we'll
- 56:07see what happens.
- 56:08>> what happens. All right. Well, thank you
- 56:10very much for
- 56:11>> [laughter]
- 56:11>> for as ever for joining us. Send us your
- 56:13thoughts, your your ideas to the rest of
- 56:15science at goldhanger.com and we'll see
- 56:17you next time.
- 56:18>> See you then.
- 56:18>> Bye.
- 56:20>> [music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of It Wasn't A Hoax After All by The Rest Is Science, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 9,787 words across 1,579 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.