YouTube2Text

Israele e i sionismi - storia del pensiero geopolitico - parte VI — Transcript

by Fiore · 7,663 words · 1,239 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00Hi! In this sixth episode of the
  2. 0:02history of geopolitical thought, I
  3. 0:04would like to tell you what I have
  4. 0:06understood about one of the most
  5. 0:07convoluted topics I have ever dreamed
  6. 0:09of tackling: Zionism, or rather,
  7. 0:11Zionisms. What they are, where they
  8. 0:14come from, how they relate to one
  9. 0:15another, and how they contributed to
  10. 0:17the creation of the nation-state of
  11. 0:18Israel. All this in the most concise
  12. 0:22and linear way I possibly can. First of
  13. 0:25all, Zionism is not a unified political
  14. 0:27movement. That is why you go crazy
  15. 0:29trying to make sense of it. It is
  16. 0:32rather a platform of ideologies into
  17. 0:34which very different projects converge,
  18. 0:37not only in terms of roots and deep
  19. 0:39inspirations, but also in terms of
  20. 0:41concrete objectives—political and
  21. 0:43even spatial, territorial goals. Now,
  22. 0:47to understand how and why Zionism was
  23. 0:49born, we must take a long step back. I
  24. 0:52told you that over the centuries,
  25. 0:54various Jews attempted to make aliyah,
  26. 0:57that is, to ascend, to return to the
  27. 0:59promised land. These were individual
  28. 1:02migrations or small groups attempting
  29. 1:04to move to the Holy Land, even if only
  30. 1:06to be buried on the Mount of Olives in
  31. 1:07Jerusalem, which is the place from
  32. 1:09which, according to Jewish tradition,
  33. 1:11the resurrection of the dead will begin
  34. 1:13. Well, Jewish tradition is the first
  35. 1:16element we must consider, and let us
  36. 1:18start with the obvious. According to
  37. 1:21tradition, Jewish identity is founded
  38. 1:23on three pillars: the Torah, the Jewish
  39. 1:25people, and the land promised to
  40. 1:27Abraham and his descendants. And it is
  41. 1:31precisely this triangular relationship
  42. 1:33that managed to keep the bond with the
  43. 1:34Holy Land alive during the long
  44. 1:36centuries of the diaspora. There is a
  45. 1:38Hebrew expression: "L'shanah haba'ah
  46. 1:41b'Yerushalayim"—next year in
  47. 1:43Jerusalem. An expression that speaks of
  48. 1:45the hope to return. Return, yes, but
  49. 1:48when? That is the question. And the
  50. 1:50answer the Torah gives is: when the
  51. 1:52Messiah arrives. But since centuries
  52. 1:55pass and the Messiah does not arrive,
  53. 1:57some rabbis decide to roll up their
  54. 1:58sleeves. They say the time has come to
  55. 2:02prove to God that the Jews have not
  56. 2:04forgotten the promise and that they
  57. 2:06truly want that land, because the
  58. 2:07redemption of the Jewish people is tied
  59. 2:09to that land. Mind you, though:
  60. 2:13redemption of the Jewish people as a
  61. 2:15religious community, not as a nation.
  62. 2:19One cannot read the Bible through the
  63. 2:20eyes of nationalism. Nationalism is a
  64. 2:22political phenomenon a couple of
  65. 2:24centuries old. The Torah is just a few
  66. 2:26more years old than that. Therefore, we
  67. 2:28cannot apply the political categories
  68. 2:30produced by the modern age to the Torah
  69. 2:32because the perspective was completely
  70. 2:34different. Nation-states did not exist.
  71. 2:36Moreover, the Jews of that era were
  72. 2:38semi-nomadic, and the land is indeed
  73. 2:40promised to the Jews, but it belongs to
  74. 2:42God. But let's get back to our topic.
  75. 2:44We were saying that over the last three
  76. 2:46centuries, several rabbis tried to make
  77. 2:49Aliyah along with their followers, with
  78. 2:51the goal of reaching Jerusalem and
  79. 2:53Hebron in particular. During those
  80. 2:55years, migration waves occurred,
  81. 2:57especially around the year 1840, which
  82. 3:02for the Jewish calendar was 5600. And
  83. 3:06what was so special about the year 5600
  84. 3:07? The fact that it was the 6th year of
  85. 3:11the sixth millennium, the year that the
  86. 3:13Zohar, the main text of Jewish Kabbalah
  87. 3:16, identified as the year of redemption,
  88. 3:18the year of the Messiah's arrival. Thus
  89. 3:22, the approach of the year 1840
  90. 3:24increased messianic expectations and,
  91. 3:26consequently, the number of Jewish
  92. 3:28immigrants to Israel. At the beginning
  93. 3:31of the 19th century, for example, there
  94. 3:33were the Perushim, followers of the
  95. 3:35Vilna Gaon, a Lithuanian rabbi who
  96. 3:37immigrated to the Holy Land and became
  97. 3:39the core of the Ashkenazi communities
  98. 3:41in Jerusalem, Tiberias, and Safed. Then
  99. 3:44there was Yehuda Alkalai, a Sephardic
  100. 3:46rabbi this time, who developed a rather
  101. 3:48unique, slightly different project,
  102. 3:50because he was also influenced by
  103. 3:52European national liberation movements.
  104. 3:56Alkalai also argued that one could no
  105. 3:58longer passively wait for the arrival
  106. 4:00of the Messiah. Jews had to take their
  107. 4:02destiny into their own hands and
  108. 4:04immigrate to Israel. But this
  109. 4:06immigration could not be improvised; it
  110. 4:09required organization, the creation of
  111. 4:11an international Jewish body, and
  112. 4:13obtaining the consent of the Ottoman
  113. 4:15Sultan. This was a hypothesis that had
  114. 4:19become conceivable also because,
  115. 4:21starting in 1832, Palestine was
  116. 4:22dominated by Muhammad Ali's Egypt,
  117. 4:24which had made that territory much
  118. 4:26safer and more prosperous than in the
  119. 4:28past, Jerusalem included. And already
  120. 4:31with this small example, we see
  121. 4:33something different in its infancy. No
  122. 4:36longer just a simple hope of "next year
  123. 4:39in Jerusalem," but a first attempt,
  124. 4:41even if founded on religious grounds,
  125. 4:44to politically organize the immigration
  126. 4:47of Jews to Israel—of all Jews, but
  127. 4:49for now, of those who felt ready. A
  128. 4:53fundamental role in supporting these
  129. 4:55small Jewish communities in the Holy
  130. 4:57Land was played by philanthropists, by
  131. 4:59European Jewish philanthropy. In 1860,
  132. 5:02the Alliance Israélite Universelle was
  133. 5:04born in Paris, which concerned itself
  134. 5:06with Jews in difficulty in North Africa
  135. 5:08and the Middle East. And in 1870, this
  136. 5:11Alliance created the agricultural
  137. 5:13school of Mikveh Israel, the hope of
  138. 5:16Israel. Another example of Jewish
  139. 5:19philanthropy in support of these small
  140. 5:21communities is that of a London banker
  141. 5:23whom we had actually already mentioned
  142. 5:25in the previous video, Sir Moses
  143. 5:26Montefiore, born in Livorno to a
  144. 5:28Sephardic family. He financed the
  145. 5:31construction of the first Jewish
  146. 5:33neighborhood outside the Old City walls
  147. 5:35in Jerusalem, a neighborhood that was
  148. 5:36completed in 1894 and named in his
  149. 5:38honor Yemin Moshe, the Memorial of
  150. 5:40Moses, where he also had a windmill and
  151. 5:42a textile factory built with the idea
  152. 5:44of allowing the Jews to be
  153. 5:45self-sustaining. But let's talk about
  154. 5:48figures. In 1850, the total population
  155. 5:52of the Holy Land was approximately
  156. 5:55340,000 people, 96%of whom were Arab.
  157. 5:59And a few years earlier, in 1839,
  158. 6:03according to the census by Moses
  159. 6:06Montefiore, Eretz Israel was home to
  160. 6:086,547 Jews, 60%of whom had immigrated
  161. 6:11in the previous decade, just before
  162. 6:13what the Zohar claimed would be the
  163. 6:16year of the Messiah's arrival. And we
  164. 6:20continue to notice one thing, that all
  165. 6:22these immigration initiatives were
  166. 6:24still tied to the traditional
  167. 6:26perspective, that is, those three
  168. 6:27pillars we spoke of earlier: Torah, the
  169. 6:29Jewish people, and the Promised Land.
  170. 6:32But we also notice that, little by
  171. 6:34little, a new element begins to
  172. 6:36intervene. These migrations are no
  173. 6:39longer just the fruit of religious
  174. 6:41inspiration; they are also the first
  175. 6:43step of a political project. The idea
  176. 6:47is to create a Jewish state as a point
  177. 6:50of reference for the Jewish nation. The
  178. 6:54question is, how and why does all this
  179. 6:56happen? And there are at least three
  180. 6:59reasons that trigger this change. The
  181. 7:01first of which is, in my opinion, the
  182. 7:03most interesting and at the same time
  183. 7:04the most paradoxical: Jewish
  184. 7:06emancipation. The fact is that in many
  185. 7:09European cities, during the 1800s, the
  186. 7:11walls of the ghettos fall. Jews become
  187. 7:14full citizens alongside all other
  188. 7:16minorities, which is an excellent thing
  189. 7:19—undoubtedly an excellent thing—but
  190. 7:22at the same time, it poses a huge
  191. 7:25question: once you leave the ghetto,
  192. 7:27are you still a Jew? That is, from an
  193. 7:31identity standpoint, who are the Jews
  194. 7:33now? Do you see what I mean? After
  195. 7:36centuries and centuries of civil and
  196. 7:38political discrimination, starting from
  197. 7:40the end of the 1700s, Jews in many
  198. 7:42European countries, beginning with
  199. 7:44France, change status; their legal
  200. 7:46inferiority ends, and they finally
  201. 7:49become holders of civil and political
  202. 7:51rights. But what does this mean in
  203. 7:54terms of identity? Does it mean that
  204. 7:56from now on they will stop being Jews
  205. 7:58of France and will simply be French?
  206. 8:01Well, in that case, being Jewish
  207. 8:02becomes a private, personal matter, a
  208. 8:04question of religious faith that has
  209. 8:06nothing to do with nationality. And
  210. 8:09this is no small matter, because Jews
  211. 8:11have always been perceived as a people
  212. 8:13apart, very atypical because they have
  213. 8:15no motherland, having been in the
  214. 8:17diaspora for centuries. And yet, now
  215. 8:20that they have the possibility to fully
  216. 8:22integrate into the national fabric, to
  217. 8:25fully enjoy civil and political rights,
  218. 8:28what happens to Jewish identity?
  219. 8:31Because the paradox is that the ghetto
  220. 8:33was certainly an instrument of
  221. 8:34exclusion and discrimination. It had
  222. 8:37been conceived to do exactly that, but
  223. 8:40as a side effect, it had helped to
  224. 8:42preserve Jewish identity. It was
  225. 8:46precisely the separation of the ghetto
  226. 8:48from the rest of society that had
  227. 8:50fueled that social and cultural
  228. 8:51cohesion, that sense of solidarity
  229. 8:53among discriminated Jews. Now, the
  230. 8:56question of Jewish identity was one of
  231. 8:58the great concerns of the Haskalah, an
  232. 9:01intellectual movement that roughly
  233. 9:02translates to Jewish Enlightenment,
  234. 9:04which I wouldn't dream of summarizing
  235. 9:06in a single video. Yes, well, actually,
  236. 9:10provided you remember, as always, that
  237. 9:12history is much richer and far more
  238. 9:13complex than what I will be able to
  239. 9:15tell you here. Jewish emancipation was
  240. 9:19both a great opportunity and a great
  241. 9:20challenge because it forced a
  242. 9:22rethinking of Jewish identity, and
  243. 9:24because the paths to doing so were
  244. 9:25diverse, just as the positions among
  245. 9:27the different intellectuals were. To
  246. 9:31simplify as much as possible, some
  247. 9:34intellectuals pushed for complete
  248. 9:36assimilation, while others foresaw the
  249. 9:38danger of secularization and the
  250. 9:40hollowing out of Jewish identity,
  251. 9:42proposing to revitalize Jewish studies
  252. 9:45to counter it. And this was the current
  253. 9:49that paved the way for Jewish
  254. 9:51nationalism, yet there was one point in
  255. 9:52common among all the different visions.
  256. 9:56Everyone agreed on the need to
  257. 9:58integrate into the national fabric,
  258. 10:00which does not mean abandoning one's
  259. 10:02culture and identity; on the contrary,
  260. 10:05regarding the linguistic issue, for
  261. 10:07example, many intellectuals pushed for
  262. 10:09Hebrew not to remain just a liturgical
  263. 10:12language, but to be rediscovered and
  264. 10:14spread as a common tongue. At least one
  265. 10:18of these intellectuals, however, I must
  266. 10:20mention, and I would like to talk to
  267. 10:21you about Leo Pinsker, who was a doctor
  268. 10:23from Odessa. Pinsker had been among the
  269. 10:26founders of the Society for the
  270. 10:28Promotion of Enlightenment among the
  271. 10:30Jews and was convinced that Jews should
  272. 10:32assimilate while still preserving their
  273. 10:34religion. Except that within a few
  274. 10:37years he changed his mind radically,
  275. 10:39and he was not the only one. Many like
  276. 10:43Pinsker changed their minds radically
  277. 10:45in the face of the facts, because while
  278. 10:47Enlightenment ideals had certainly made
  279. 10:49headway in Western Europe, in Eastern
  280. 10:51Europe, where about three-quarters of
  281. 10:53the 9 million Jews worldwide lived, the
  282. 10:56atmosphere was very different. In the
  283. 11:00Tsarist Empire, living conditions for
  284. 11:02Jews had improved under Alexander II
  285. 11:04after the repressive reign of Nicholas
  286. 11:06I, and even in Russia, the ideals of
  287. 11:08the Haskalah and proposals for the
  288. 11:09integration of Jews into Russian
  289. 11:11society had begun to spread. But then
  290. 11:14in 1881, following the assassination of
  291. 11:19Alexander II, an unprecedented wave of
  292. 11:21pogroms occurred, and those Jewish
  293. 11:24intellectuals who had until then
  294. 11:26promoted integration had to reconsider
  295. 11:28their positions. Pinsker included, who
  296. 11:32wrote: "Jews in the nations where they
  297. 11:34live effectively form a heterogeneous
  298. 11:36element that cannot be assimilated." In
  299. 11:411882, he published "Auto-Emancipation:
  300. 11:43An Appeal to His People by a Russian
  301. 11:45Jew," in which he proposed creating a
  302. 11:48homeland where Jews could live without
  303. 11:50the danger of pogroms or persecution.
  304. 11:54It must be said that this was not an
  305. 11:55entirely new idea. There were
  306. 11:56precursors, but we don't have all day,
  307. 11:58so let's get back to Pinsker. He was of
  308. 12:00the opinion that Jews should convene a
  309. 12:03national congress and create a national
  310. 12:05institution to represent their unity.
  311. 12:09Pinsker was among the founders of an
  312. 12:11organization called Hibbat Zion, whose
  313. 12:13main goal was the creation of a safe
  314. 12:16and inviolable refuge for those Jews
  315. 12:18living a proletarian life. Note that
  316. 12:22Pinsker contemplated the possibility
  317. 12:24that this homeland might not be Eretz
  318. 12:27Israel. He wrote: "We need nothing more
  319. 12:30than a large tract of land for our
  320. 12:32brothers." But in any case, the vast
  321. 12:35majority of Russian Jews fleeing
  322. 12:37pogroms. Did not emigrate to the Holy
  323. 12:40Land; they decided to move to the West.
  324. 12:43Between 1881 and 1914, about 2.5
  325. 12:45million Jews left the Russian Empire,
  326. 12:48heading mainly toward the Americas,
  327. 12:51Great Britain, and Western Europe. And
  328. 12:55only a small minority chose a different
  329. 12:58path: immigration to Eretz Israel, with
  330. 13:00the goal of colonizing that land to
  331. 13:03settle there permanently. However, they
  332. 13:07were no longer pilgrims, because these
  333. 13:09Jewish refugees in the Holy Land
  334. 13:10considered themselves pioneers, moved
  335. 13:12by religious ideals, yes, but above all
  336. 13:14by national ones. This phenomenon,
  337. 13:19known as the First Aliyah, brought
  338. 13:21about 20,000 Jews to Palestine and
  339. 13:23marked the beginning of a new chapter
  340. 13:26in Jewish history, the first concrete
  341. 13:28action to build a Jewish nation-state.
  342. 13:32Here we are talking about Zionism. It
  343. 13:35only took me five pages. First, Zionism
  344. 13:38as an organized political movement was
  345. 13:40born in Europe at the end of the 19th
  346. 13:43century, and late 19 th-century Europe
  347. 13:45was the cradle of nationalism. Just
  348. 13:49think of the unification of Italy in
  349. 13:511861, Germany in 1871, Bulgaria, Serbia
  350. 13:54, Poland; all examples of political
  351. 13:57communities gathering under one flag as
  352. 14:00a nation. Except that in the case of
  353. 14:05these nationalisms, the dirty work, so
  354. 14:07to speak, of creating a nation—
  355. 14:08creating a relationship between people
  356. 14:10and territory—had already been done
  357. 14:12by history. Centuries and centuries of
  358. 14:16history, of tears and blood, of
  359. 14:18separation between those inside and
  360. 14:20those outside the political project
  361. 14:22called a state. And so it was that the
  362. 14:25Jews, despite not having a motherland,
  363. 14:27despite being scattered all over the
  364. 14:30world, began to think of themselves as
  365. 14:32a nation. But then, is Zionism simply a
  366. 14:36strange name for Jewish nationalism?
  367. 14:40Yes, and because as we were saying
  368. 14:42earlier, Zionism is a platform of
  369. 14:44ideologies, often in contradiction with
  370. 14:47one another. But let's take things in
  371. 14:49order. The term Zionism was coined in
  372. 14:521890 by Nathan Birnbaum, a Jewish
  373. 14:54student at the University of Vienna and
  374. 14:57founder of the magazine
  375. 14:58Selbst-Emancipation, in which Birnbaum
  376. 15:01spoke of Zionism as a phenomenon linked
  377. 15:03to Jewish cultural identity, well aware
  378. 15:06of its biblical roots. It is
  379. 15:10interesting to note that Birnbaum later
  380. 15:12became almost anti-Zionist when the
  381. 15:13movement took on the forms of political
  382. 15:15nationalism due to Theodor Herzl. And
  383. 15:19who was Herzl? Theodor Herzl was the
  384. 15:22one who transformed these ideas into an
  385. 15:25organized political movement. Born in
  386. 15:28Budapest, Herzl moved to Vienna to
  387. 15:30study law and was another one of those
  388. 15:32initially convinced that Jews should
  389. 15:34fully integrate into the national
  390. 15:36fabric, but who changed his opinion
  391. 15:38radically in the 1880s, just like
  392. 15:40Pinsker. He reached the conclusion that
  393. 15:43anti-Semitism would never die in Europe
  394. 15:45and that the only solution would be the
  395. 15:47immigration of Jews to a territory
  396. 15:49where they could create an independent
  397. 15:51state. In February 1896, Herzl
  398. 15:54published The Jewish State, which had
  399. 15:56notable circulation, with 17 editions
  400. 15:58published while he was still alive. The
  401. 16:02starting point of his reflection was
  402. 16:04the state of severe distress in which
  403. 16:06Jews find themselves, being persecuted
  404. 16:09in every country where they live in
  405. 16:11significant numbers, and his project
  406. 16:13consisted of assigning Jews a piece of
  407. 16:15land on which to establish a state. To
  408. 16:19achieve this goal, Herzl proposed two
  409. 16:21instruments. On one side, the Society
  410. 16:24of Jews, which would obtain sovereignty
  411. 16:27over a territory by negotiating with
  412. 16:28European powers, and on the other, the
  413. 16:30Jewish Company, which would raise funds
  414. 16:33to be able to purchase that territory.
  415. 16:36It should be noted that at this point,
  416. 16:39in 1896, it was not yet clear in
  417. 16:40Herzl's mind whether this territory
  418. 16:43should be in Israel or elsewhere. The
  419. 16:46first Zionist Congress was held in
  420. 16:49Basel in August 1897. Herzl declared at
  421. 16:53the opening of the congress that the
  422. 16:55foundation stone was being laid for the
  423. 16:57building that would one day house the
  424. 16:59Jewish nation. 197 delegates from 17
  425. 17:02countries participated in the congress.
  426. 17:06It should be noted that initially most
  427. 17:08Jews in Central and Western Europe did
  428. 17:10not show interest in Zionism, but in
  429. 17:12any case, the concrete result was the
  430. 17:15birth of the Zionist Organization, with
  431. 17:17a congress as the legislative body and
  432. 17:19an executive as the governing body. The
  433. 17:23anthem Hatikvah was chosen, based on an
  434. 17:261878 poem that referred to the 2,000-
  435. 17:29year hope of being a free nation in our
  436. 17:33land, the land of Zion and Jerusalem.
  437. 17:37And in 1898, the flag was also adopted,
  438. 17:39two blue stripes on a white background,
  439. 17:41which is a reference to the Tallit, the
  440. 17:43prayer shawl, with the Star of David in
  441. 17:45the center. In fact, the program
  442. 17:49adopted at the Basel congress was a
  443. 17:50compromise between Herzl's vision and
  444. 17:52the vision of the Hibbat Zion groups,
  445. 17:54those of Pinsker, to be clear. And it
  446. 17:58was established that Zionism strives to
  447. 18:01obtain for the Jewish people in
  448. 18:03Palestine a publicly recognized and
  449. 18:05legally secured home through: the
  450. 18:07encouragement of the colonization of
  451. 18:10Palestine; the unification and
  452. 18:12organization of all Jewish communities;
  453. 18:14the strengthening of Jewish national
  454. 18:17consciousness; and preparatory measures
  455. 18:19to obtain the necessary consent from
  456. 18:22various governments, thus combining
  457. 18:24political Zionism, for which government
  458. 18:29consent was a priority, with that form
  459. 18:31of practical Zionism, which had already
  460. 18:33emerged with the first Aliyah, for
  461. 18:35which colonization was fundamental.
  462. 18:39Herzl dedicated the following years of
  463. 18:41his life to seeking the support of a
  464. 18:43European power. He first tried Germany,
  465. 18:46having several meetings with Kaiser
  466. 18:48Wilhelm II in 1898, then the Ottoman
  467. 18:51Empire. He made visits to Istanbul
  468. 18:54between 1896 and 1902. And finally with
  469. 18:57Great Britain. In 1903, the British
  470. 19:00government proposed to the Zionists a
  471. 19:02settlement in East Africa, in
  472. 19:04present-day Kenya, which went down in
  473. 19:06history as the Uganda Proposal. Herzl
  474. 19:10presented this proposal at the Sixth
  475. 19:12Congress in Basel, framing it as a
  476. 19:14colonial fallback, but the majority of
  477. 19:16delegates, particularly the Russians,
  478. 19:18opposed it. In 1904, at only 44, Herzl
  479. 19:22died, and the following year at the
  480. 19:25Seventh Zionist Congress, the British
  481. 19:27offer was formally rejected and it was
  482. 19:29decided that the Zionist project would
  483. 19:32only be realized in Israel. But how
  484. 19:36would it be realized? This is the crux
  485. 19:38to be unraveled, understanding how.
  486. 19:41Because political Zionism doesn't
  487. 19:43simply mean that Jews go to live in the
  488. 19:46Holy Land; it means designing a
  489. 19:47nation-state in a land that was
  490. 19:49unfamiliar with such political forms.
  491. 19:52It means bringing Vienna to Palestine.
  492. 19:55This is a metaphor I didn't invent; it
  493. 19:57belongs to Matteo Marconi and is
  494. 19:59particularly effective because it
  495. 20:01allows us to understand the link
  496. 20:03between the political project and the
  497. 20:05territory it involves. In this sense,
  498. 20:07it is geopolitical. This is the knot
  499. 20:11that to this day has not yet been
  500. 20:12untied and that characterizes all forms
  501. 20:14of Zionism: socialist, revisionist,
  502. 20:16religious. But let's take things in
  503. 20:18order; let's start with socialist
  504. 20:20Zionism. Socialist Zionism, which was
  505. 20:22initially the dominant current, was the
  506. 20:24one that materially built the State of
  507. 20:27Israel, led by figures like David
  508. 20:29Ben-Gurion, to be clear. And its
  509. 20:31geopolitics was that of the "hityashvut
  510. 20:33," the settlement, with the idea that
  511. 20:36the land would be redeemed through
  512. 20:38Jewish labor. Therefore, the goal was
  513. 20:41to create a Jewish nation-state. Okay?
  514. 20:43How do we get there? What is the
  515. 20:45relationship one wants to create
  516. 20:47between people and territory? According
  517. 20:50to socialist Zionism, the way to create
  518. 20:52this relationship was to have Jews do
  519. 20:54what they had never been able to do in
  520. 20:56Europe: work the land according to a
  521. 20:58socialist-inspired project, yes, but
  522. 21:00one that fundamentally served as a tool
  523. 21:03to create a nation in a short time,
  524. 21:05that is, without waiting for the
  525. 21:06centuries it had taken European
  526. 21:08nation-states to build a bond between
  527. 21:10the population and the territory in
  528. 21:12which they lived. Therefore, founding
  529. 21:16collective agricultural communities,
  530. 21:19the famous Kibbutzim and Moshavim, was
  531. 21:21not just a way to achieve the socialist
  532. 21:24ideal; it was first and foremost a
  533. 21:26geopolitical strategy to create a
  534. 21:28Jewish nation, to establish a Jewish
  535. 21:31presence on the territory farm by farm,
  536. 21:33defining the borders of the future
  537. 21:36nation-state from the ground up,
  538. 21:38through practical action on the spot.
  539. 21:42But then is Zionism a form of
  540. 21:44colonialism, of settlement? Yes. Yes,
  541. 21:49undeniably yes, although with a
  542. 21:51fundamental contradiction that ends up
  543. 21:53driving anyone who tries to make sense
  544. 21:55of it crazy: normally, a colonial
  545. 21:57project starts from a mother country;
  546. 21:59only here there is no mother country,
  547. 22:01and the territory to be colonized is
  548. 22:04the one that, according to tradition,
  549. 22:06is the territory of origin. Only the
  550. 22:09origin is not, again, a mother country;
  551. 22:12it is a divine promise. We cannot ask
  552. 22:16the Bible to speak the language of
  553. 22:18Western political modernity, to speak
  554. 22:21of nation-states, to speak of the
  555. 22:23political forms we know; just as we
  556. 22:25cannot ask ourselves, in Western
  557. 22:27political modernity, to accept not so
  558. 22:29much colonialism—which we stopped
  559. 22:31liking only a few decades ago, frankly,
  560. 22:34and which still survives largely under
  561. 22:36the radar—but rather the fact that,
  562. 22:38at the time of the early Zionists, it
  563. 22:40was considered in Europe an entirely
  564. 22:43acceptable, if not even appropriate,
  565. 22:46practice. But what we find even harder
  566. 22:49to accept is that a nation-state can be
  567. 22:52established in the span of a few
  568. 22:53decades, merging and skipping phases
  569. 22:55that in reality all the nation-states
  570. 22:57we know have experienced, and which are
  571. 23:00made of wars, discrimination, and
  572. 23:01mechanisms of inclusion and exclusion
  573. 23:04between those who are inside and those
  574. 23:06who are outside the political project.
  575. 23:09In the DNA of the Nation-State. This
  576. 23:12stuff is there, please, let’s not
  577. 23:14forget it. And not to justify one
  578. 23:17faction or the other, but simply to rid
  579. 23:19ourselves of the self-deception that
  580. 23:21leads us to think that the states in
  581. 23:23the late-democratic phase we know were
  582. 23:26born this way. Our history is a little
  583. 23:30bit uglier than that. I'll stop
  584. 23:31rambling, let's get back to the point.
  585. 23:33We were talking about socialist Zionism
  586. 23:34. For what reason does socialist
  587. 23:37Zionism, which was born as a
  588. 23:39fundamentally secular project, decide
  589. 23:42to create its own refuge? in the Holy
  590. 23:45Land. Socialist Zionism wasn't driven
  591. 23:49by any particular religious tension;
  592. 23:51however, the Zionists explicitly stated
  593. 23:54they wanted to leverage the pull that
  594. 23:56land had on all Jews worldwide, as it
  595. 23:59was part of their identity. Every Jew
  596. 24:03in the world had heard the phrase, "
  597. 24:05Next year in Jerusalem"—everyone,
  598. 24:07even the non-believers. And so, with
  599. 24:11the Second Aliyah between 1904 and 1914
  600. 24:13, young Jewish pioneers arrived in
  601. 24:16Palestine, imbued with socialist ideals
  602. 24:18and the goal of working the land with
  603. 24:21their own hands. But they faced a
  604. 24:25problem because the Arab laborers were
  605. 24:27more skilled, knew the arid and
  606. 24:29malarial lands better, and were also
  607. 24:31less expensive. So much so that the
  608. 24:34agricultural colonies founded during
  609. 24:37the First Aliyah, supported by figures
  610. 24:40like Montefiore and Baron Rothschild,
  611. 24:43had mainly hired Arab labor; but by
  612. 24:45doing so, the entire project risked
  613. 24:48collapsing: that is, building a Jewish
  614. 24:51nation on territory that would become
  615. 24:54part of a Jewish state precisely
  616. 24:56because that land was worked by Jewish
  617. 24:59hands. That is why the Kibbutz was
  618. 25:02formed: a colony of exclusively Jewish
  619. 25:05farmers who produced and defended
  620. 25:07themselves independently. Arabs were
  621. 25:10excluded from it, and they had to be
  622. 25:12excluded. And after all, the Jews had
  623. 25:14purchased those lands. Why should they
  624. 25:17have felt obligated to let Arabs work
  625. 25:19on them? Here is another element that
  626. 25:21makes anyone trying to wrap their head
  627. 25:23around Zionism lose their mind: the
  628. 25:25purchasing of land. If I have purchased
  629. 25:28, paid for, and signed a contract to
  630. 25:31acquire a plot of land peacefully, why
  631. 25:33should I accept the label of "colonizer
  632. 25:36"? Furthermore, most of that land had
  633. 25:40been bought by Jews from large
  634. 25:42landowners in Beirut or Damascus who
  635. 25:44perhaps had never even set foot in
  636. 25:46those places, didn't live there, and
  637. 25:48exploited them poorly. So, what is the
  638. 25:52problem? In my opinion, the problem
  639. 25:55once again is that we cannot mix
  640. 25:57political categories. I, Fiorellino,
  641. 26:00buy a large plot of land in the state
  642. 26:03where I live. Let's make it even
  643. 26:05simpler—not in the region my
  644. 26:07ancestors came from, no, no, no—in
  645. 26:10the state where I live, and let’s
  646. 26:12pretend my blood is perfectly pure and
  647. 26:15Italian. In the state where my family
  648. 26:17and I have lived for generations. Okay?
  649. 26:21I buy a large plot of land in this
  650. 26:23state; I bought it, so I move my family
  651. 26:25in, I build productive businesses there
  652. 26:27, I do whatever I want, right? I
  653. 26:30purchased this land, I don't see why I
  654. 26:33wouldn't have the right to use it as I
  655. 26:35see fit, right? Yet, within a few
  656. 26:39months, I find myself in a sea of
  657. 26:41trouble: because I hadn't requested or
  658. 26:43obtained a building permit from the
  659. 26:45municipality, which they never would
  660. 26:47have granted anyway because, according
  661. 26:49to the zoning plan, that land wasn't
  662. 26:51buildable; because I didn't register my
  663. 26:53business; because I have to pay taxes;
  664. 26:55because I must comply with workplace
  665. 26:57safety regulations and because I cannot
  666. 26:59adopt blatantly discriminatory policies
  667. 27:02toward my employees. But why did I buy
  668. 27:05that land? Is it possible that I can't
  669. 27:07do whatever I want with it? Well, the
  670. 27:09reason I can't do what I want is that
  671. 27:12buying land, living on it, and managing
  672. 27:15it doesn't mean founding "Flowerland,"
  673. 27:19because that piece of land continues to
  674. 27:22be part of the nation-state of the
  675. 27:24Italian Republic. It is, once again, a
  676. 27:29question of sovereignty, and this is
  677. 27:31another reason why we struggle to
  678. 27:33understand Zionism: the early Zionists
  679. 27:36bought the lands, but founding a
  680. 27:38nation-state is not a matter of
  681. 27:40purchase; it is a matter of sovereignty
  682. 27:43exercised and recognized over a certain
  683. 27:46space. And as we were saying: the Jews
  684. 27:51didn't buy land that was within the
  685. 27:53borders of a nation-state; they bought
  686. 27:55it from landlords of an empire, the
  687. 27:57Ottoman Empire, which was on the verge
  688. 28:00of collapse, later obtaining the
  689. 28:02blessing of the British Crown, which
  690. 28:04held the mandate over Palestine but
  691. 28:06also made sure to curb Jewish
  692. 28:08immigration when it became a bit
  693. 28:10inconvenient, even during those times
  694. 28:13when European Jews needed more than
  695. 28:15ever to flee, being persecuted by
  696. 28:18fascist and Nazi regimes. But let's
  697. 28:22return to the Kibbutz, because even as
  698. 28:24a socialist project, it had unusual
  699. 28:26features, at least to those of us
  700. 28:28trying to make sense of it while bound
  701. 28:30by the political categories we grew up
  702. 28:32with. We view the world through those
  703. 28:35lenses. The Kibbutz seems to us a
  704. 28:38political experiment that has one foot
  705. 28:40on the gas and the other on the
  706. 28:42handbrake; on one hand, it represents a
  707. 28:45symbol of equality, gender parity, and
  708. 28:47fair distribution of labor and
  709. 28:49resources—all things we associate
  710. 28:51with the progressive socialist
  711. 28:53political sphere. But on the other hand
  712. 28:56, the kibbutz is strictly Jewish. Arabs
  713. 28:59are programmatically excluded and
  714. 29:01separated from it, and this is an
  715. 29:03attitude we associate with an entirely
  716. 29:06different political area. In any case,
  717. 29:09socialist Zionism represented the
  718. 29:11majority current, the one that led to
  719. 29:13the birth of the State of Israel in
  720. 29:161948 and governed it for the first 30
  721. 29:18years until 1977. It wasn't very
  722. 29:23homogeneous, it was animated by
  723. 29:24different currents, but from the
  724. 29:26beginning it acted according to the
  725. 29:28criteria of this strange settler
  726. 29:30colonialism, made of land purchases and
  727. 29:32at the same time systematic
  728. 29:33discrimination against Arab workers to
  729. 29:36develop an exclusively Jewish society.
  730. 29:39And why was it important that the
  731. 29:41society be exclusively Jewish? Because
  732. 29:45from their point of view, Israel was
  733. 29:47first and foremost a place of refuge,
  734. 29:49the only corner of the world where, for
  735. 29:52the first time in almost 2000 years,
  736. 29:54Jews have an army to defend them so
  737. 29:56they cannot be persecuted. And this is
  738. 30:00an argument that, especially in the
  739. 30:02years immediately following the Shoah,
  740. 30:04caused the line of figures like
  741. 30:05Ben-Gurion to prevail over that of
  742. 30:07others who proposed more universalistic
  743. 30:09ideals and adopted more open positions.
  744. 30:13In concrete terms, that is, in
  745. 30:14geopolitical practice, in the attitude
  746. 30:16that the political community adopts
  747. 30:18toward the territory. Ben-Gurion's line
  748. 30:22translated into what the Arabs call the
  749. 30:24Nakba, which means catastrophe, of 1948
  750. 30:26. About 750,000 Palestinian Arabs were
  751. 30:31expelled from Israel to ensure a Jewish
  752. 30:34majority. But in the following decades,
  753. 30:37something changed. 1967 in particular
  754. 30:40introduced elements of crisis into
  755. 30:42socialist Zionism because, within 6
  756. 30:45days, Israel conquered the West Bank,
  757. 30:48Gaza, the Golan Heights, and the Sinai,
  758. 30:51and found itself facing a dilemma. What
  759. 30:55to do with these territories and, above
  760. 30:56all, the Palestinian population living
  761. 30:58there? As then-Israeli Prime Minister
  762. 31:02Levi Eshkol said, we have obtained a
  763. 31:04dowry. The problem is that a bride came
  764. 31:06with the dowry, and we do not want her.
  765. 31:09The dowry was the land, in particular
  766. 31:11East Jerusalem and Etzion, therefore
  767. 31:14the biblical sites, while the bride was
  768. 31:16the Palestinian population living there
  769. 31:18who could not be integrated because it
  770. 31:20would have undermined the Jewish
  771. 31:22majority. In response to this crisis,
  772. 31:26the Allon Plan emerged, proposed by a
  773. 31:28leading figure of socialist Zionism.
  774. 31:31The plan called for annexing a security
  775. 31:34belt along the Jordan Valley and the
  776. 31:36Judean Desert, as well as the Etzion
  777. 31:38bloc, and, in return, returning the
  778. 31:40densely populated areas of the West
  779. 31:42Bank to Jordanian or Palestinian
  780. 31:44control. The clear objective was to
  781. 31:48create defensible borders without
  782. 31:50incorporating a large Arab population.
  783. 31:54This type of territorial pragmatism of
  784. 31:56socialist Zionism is what lies at the
  785. 31:58basis of the so-called two-state
  786. 32:00solution, which you have surely heard
  787. 32:03of: it comes from this type of
  788. 32:04geopolitical paradigm. And, as we were
  789. 32:07saying, socialist Zionism remained in
  790. 32:09power until 1977, controlling the
  791. 32:13occupied territories, pretending not to
  792. 32:15see, or endorsing limited settlements.
  793. 32:18In 1977, however, the Likud came to
  794. 32:21power, and here we witness a decisive
  795. 32:23turning point. Except that I cannot
  796. 32:26tell you about Likud without having
  797. 32:28told you a little bit about revisionist
  798. 32:30Zionism. Revisionist Zionism is the
  799. 32:33branch of the movement that holds the
  800. 32:34most explicit and harshest geopolitical
  801. 32:36line. Its founder, Ze'ev Jabotinsky,
  802. 32:41was born in Odessa and lived in Italy
  803. 32:43between 1899 and 1903, where he was
  804. 32:46influenced by idealistic philosophy and
  805. 32:48, above all, fascinated by the Italian
  806. 32:51Risorgimento, going so far as to call
  807. 32:54Italy his spiritual homeland. For
  808. 32:58Jabotinsky, the vision of socialist
  809. 33:00Zionism was too soft, too vague, and
  810. 33:02covered in good intentions that
  811. 33:04ultimately ended up harming everyone.
  812. 33:07His geopolitical project was developed
  813. 33:10along two main axes. On one hand, the
  814. 33:13desire to build a Jewish nation-state
  815. 33:15that included both banks of the Jordan
  816. 33:18River—therefore including Transjordan
  817. 33:20—and on the other, opposition to the
  818. 33:22socialist ideas dominant in the Zionist
  819. 33:25movement. In particular, Jabotinsky
  820. 33:28opposed the ruralist vision of the
  821. 33:30Kibbutz. He imagined a state where the
  822. 33:33social core would be the Jewish middle
  823. 33:35class. Not farmers, but a productive
  824. 33:39structure based on capital and small
  825. 33:41industry rather than agriculture, and
  826. 33:43he believed in the necessity of
  827. 33:45building a military culture among the
  828. 33:47Jews. During World War I, he was among
  829. 33:52the founders of the Jewish Legion, a
  830. 33:54unit of the British Army composed of
  831. 33:56Jewish volunteers intent on fighting
  832. 33:59against the Ottoman Empire to
  833. 34:00legitimize claims to remain in
  834. 34:02Palestine to found a state there. And
  835. 34:06we know that with the Balfour
  836. 34:07Declaration of November 2, 1917, the
  837. 34:10United Kingdom became the natural
  838. 34:12partner for the creation of Israel,
  839. 34:14committing to recognize a Jewish
  840. 34:16national home in Palestine. But
  841. 34:19Jabotinsky's most famous theory is that
  842. 34:22of the iron wall, which he outlined in
  843. 34:24two of his 1923 articles. His thesis
  844. 34:27was as simple as it was brutal. It is a
  845. 34:29fairy tale to think that the Arabs will
  846. 34:32voluntarily accept a Jewish state in
  847. 34:34Palestine. They will never do it. The
  848. 34:37only way to realize the Zionist project
  849. 34:40is to build an iron wall of Jewish
  850. 34:42military force that is simply
  851. 34:44unassailable. Only when the Arab
  852. 34:48population has lost all hope of being
  853. 34:50able to destroy this entity, only then
  854. 34:53perhaps will it agree to negotiate. Let
  855. 34:57it be clear, however, that Jabotinsky
  856. 34:59did not necessarily have an idea of
  857. 35:01perpetual war. He argued that an
  858. 35:03agreement might even be possible in the
  859. 35:07future, but not before demonstrating an
  860. 35:10unchallengeable force. He wrote: "The
  861. 35:13only way to obtain an agreement
  862. 35:15tomorrow is to abandon all hope of
  863. 35:17reaching an agreement today." And what
  864. 35:21is even stranger to note when reading
  865. 35:23Jabotinsky is that this vision of his
  866. 35:26actually paradoxically started from a
  867. 35:28form of respect toward the Arabs, whom
  868. 35:30he considered culturally backward but
  869. 35:32not at all naive. Jabotinsky recognized
  870. 35:37that from their point of view, the
  871. 35:39Arabs were perfectly right to reject
  872. 35:41Zionism, and believing that they could
  873. 35:43stoop to a logic of land exchange was,
  874. 35:45in his view, a sign of contempt toward
  875. 35:47them. We were saying that on a
  876. 35:51territorial level, Revisionist Zionism
  877. 35:53insisted on the Jewish right to obtain
  878. 35:56the entire Land of Israel, which had to
  879. 35:58extend from the sea to the desert,
  880. 36:00including both banks of the Jordan. In
  881. 36:03fact, the Jordan River was meant to
  882. 36:06become the backbone of the Land of
  883. 36:08Israel. A vision that was also
  884. 36:10illustrated in the logo of the Irgun,
  885. 36:12the paramilitary organization linked to
  886. 36:14the movement. It depicted the Land of
  887. 36:16Israel with the Jordan flowing from
  888. 36:18north to south and an arm wielding a
  889. 36:20rifle. A perfect synthesis of
  890. 36:22Jabotinsky's Zionist line: military
  891. 36:24culture and territorial fundamentalism.
  892. 36:28It must be said, however, that this
  893. 36:30territorial vision was based on the
  894. 36:32borders of the British Mandate, not the
  895. 36:34biblical borders of the Promised Land,
  896. 36:37which in its most extensive version
  897. 36:39reached from the Nile to the Euphrates.
  898. 36:42Did anyone support that? Yes, there
  899. 36:44were Revisionist Zionists who referred
  900. 36:46to the biblical concept and insisted on
  901. 36:48a Jewish state extending to the
  902. 36:50Euphrates, but they were a minority. In
  903. 36:53any case, between the 1920s and 30s,
  904. 36:56Jabotinsky’s clashes with the Zionist
  905. 36:59leadership led him to found the World
  906. 37:02Union of Zionist Revisionists in Paris
  907. 37:05in April 1925, and the New Zionist
  908. 37:08Organization in Vienna in 1935. There
  909. 37:12is still an open debate among scholars
  910. 37:14on how to classify Jabotinsky and his
  911. 37:16leanings: whether to simply call them
  912. 37:18racist and para-fascist, or to
  913. 37:20recognize his idea of the nation as
  914. 37:22primarily romantic, liberal, and 19
  915. 37:24th-century. But the fact remains that
  916. 37:27many Zionists, both socialist and
  917. 37:29moderate, nicknamed him "Vladimir
  918. 37:31Hitler" due to his cult of force and
  919. 37:33his well-known sympathies for Mussolini
  920. 37:35. Jabotinsky died in 1940, just before
  921. 37:37the Holocaust and without seeing the
  922. 37:40birth of the State of Israel in 1948.
  923. 37:43In the declaration of Israel's
  924. 37:46independence on May 14, 1948, the line
  925. 37:48of Ben-Gurion and the center-left
  926. 37:51Zionists prevailed, willing to accept
  927. 37:53the partition plan and a state limited
  928. 37:56to western Palestine. Transjordan then
  929. 38:00became the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan,
  930. 38:02and over time, the Jordan River ceased
  931. 38:05to be seen as a backbone and became
  932. 38:07Israel's extreme eastern border. But
  933. 38:11let's return once again to the Six-Day
  934. 38:12War. The victory of 1967 was seen by
  935. 38:16the Revisionists as a historic
  936. 38:18opportunity to realize the vision of a
  937. 38:20complete Land of Israel. And in this
  938. 38:24light, Menachem Begin, a student of
  939. 38:27Jabotinsky and the first Likud Prime
  940. 38:29Minister in 1977, was the key figure in
  941. 38:31promoting new settlements in Gaza and
  942. 38:33the West Bank, strongly supporting a
  943. 38:36Jewish presence among Arab-Palestinian
  944. 38:38towns and villages. Although with
  945. 38:42limitations, Begin also showed a
  946. 38:44certain pragmatism when he signed the
  947. 38:46peace accords with Egypt in 1979,
  948. 38:48agreeing to withdraw from the Sinai in
  949. 38:50exchange for peace, a move that cost
  950. 38:52him dearly in terms of breaking with
  951. 38:54the more radical fringes of the
  952. 38:56settlers. The Likud is the direct heir
  953. 39:01to Revisionist Zionism and, ultimately,
  954. 39:03the strategy of the current Israeli
  955. 39:05right perfectly embodies that of the
  956. 39:07Iron Wall, according to which peace is
  957. 39:10not achieved by making concessions to
  958. 39:12the Palestinians, but by building such
  959. 39:14military and economic strength that the
  960. 39:17Arab world is forced to accept Israel's
  961. 39:19existence. Only in this way, according
  962. 39:24to the Revisionists, can one truly work
  963. 39:26toward a lasting peace rather than yet
  964. 39:28another very short truce that is
  965. 39:29punctually violated. However, the 2020
  966. 39:33Abraham Accords, which normalized
  967. 39:35relations between Israel and various
  968. 39:37Arab states, represent a geopolitical
  969. 39:39maneuver that flips the traditional
  970. 39:41paradigm, because for decades the
  971. 39:43paradigm had been peace with the
  972. 39:45Palestinians first, and then peace with
  973. 39:47the rest of the Arab world. But the
  974. 39:51Abraham Accords invert this pattern
  975. 39:52with a strategy that goes from the
  976. 39:54outside in. It somehow bypasses the
  977. 39:58Palestinian issue to make peace
  978. 40:00directly with the Gulf states that were
  979. 40:02never at war with Israel, based on the
  980. 40:05common threat of Iran. The goal of the
  981. 40:09Abraham Accords was to create a new
  982. 40:11regional bloc, Israel plus the Gulf
  983. 40:14states, based on shared security and
  984. 40:16economic development needs, isolating
  985. 40:18the Palestinians and forcing them to
  986. 40:21accept a territorial reality much
  987. 40:23smaller than they had hoped. And today
  988. 40:28it seems that the territorial
  989. 40:29projection of Revisionist Zionism has
  990. 40:32settled on the space between the river
  991. 40:34and the sea, including the entirety of
  992. 40:36Jerusalem, the West Bank, and possibly
  993. 40:38Gaza and the Golan, while effectively
  994. 40:41abandoning claims on the eastern bank
  995. 40:43of the Jordan. If Revisionist Zionism
  996. 40:47is, in my view, the easiest to explain
  997. 40:50—because it is drastic and brutal,
  998. 40:52yet at the same time speaks clearly—
  999. 40:54the same cannot be said for Religious
  1000. 40:57Zionism, because the relationship
  1001. 40:59between Zionism and religion is the
  1002. 41:01most complex and, at the same time, the
  1003. 41:03most significant in the entire history
  1004. 41:06of the State of Israel. Initially, the
  1005. 41:09relationship between Zionism and
  1006. 41:11religion was very conflictual. Early
  1007. 41:14Zionism was secular and in rupture with
  1008. 41:17religious tradition. The creation of
  1009. 41:20Israel had to happen independently of
  1010. 41:22the Messiah, through human action and
  1011. 41:24not through the passive waiting for
  1012. 41:26divine redemption. I was telling you
  1013. 41:30that for this reason many Orthodox
  1014. 41:32groups strongly opposed Zionism,
  1015. 41:33arguing that it was bordering on heresy
  1016. 41:36, because the Tanakh says to wait for
  1017. 41:38the Messiah, not to do it on one's own,
  1018. 41:40and much less to act on the basis of a
  1019. 41:42secular and nationalist ideology. The
  1020. 41:46traditional Orthodox position was that
  1021. 41:48one cannot force the hand of the
  1022. 41:50Messiah. However, figures like Rabbi
  1023. 41:54Abraham Isaac Kook and his son Zvi
  1024. 41:57Yehuda Kook reinterpreted Zionism in
  1025. 42:00messianic terms because, in their
  1026. 42:02theological vision, the Zionist
  1027. 42:05pioneers, however secular and socialist
  1028. 42:08, were unwitting instruments of a
  1029. 42:10divine plan for redemption. The land of
  1030. 42:15Israel was not just a territory or a
  1031. 42:18piece of land to be worked; it was holy
  1032. 42:20land. And the Zionists, despite being
  1033. 42:24secular and socialist, were unknowingly
  1034. 42:27fulfilling the will of God. It may
  1035. 42:31sound strange to you, but in the 50s
  1036. 42:33and 60s, religious Zionism was
  1037. 42:35represented by a very moderate party
  1038. 42:37that sought to promote dialogue with
  1039. 42:39Arab states and was positioned rather
  1040. 42:42to the left within Parliament. But this
  1041. 42:45situation changed radically in 1967. We
  1042. 42:49always come back to that. The Six-Day
  1043. 42:51War. The Six-Day War represented a
  1044. 42:54fundamental watershed for religious
  1045. 42:57Zionism as well, because the conquest
  1046. 42:59of East Jerusalem with the Old City and
  1047. 43:02the Western Wall, Hebron, Bethel—the
  1048. 43:04most sacred places in Judaism—was
  1049. 43:07interpreted by religious Zionists as an
  1050. 43:09unequivocal divine sign. Rabbi Zvi
  1051. 43:14Yehuda wrote: "The six days in which
  1052. 43:17Israel won the war are the six days in
  1053. 43:19which God created the world." And he
  1054. 43:23later declared: "We inform the people
  1055. 43:26of Israel and the whole world that
  1056. 43:28under divine command we have just
  1057. 43:30returned home to the holiness of our
  1058. 43:32city and we will never leave here again
  1059. 43:34." Here we are witnessing a
  1060. 43:37transformation of messianism. From
  1061. 43:40passive waiting to a project that not
  1062. 43:42only prepares for it, but actively
  1063. 43:45anticipates it. Jerusalem was
  1064. 43:48internalized into the Zionist system by
  1065. 43:51the Israeli army, which was
  1066. 43:53fundamentally secular, yet defended the
  1067. 43:55city's connection to original Jewish
  1068. 43:58culture, sealing the secular experience
  1069. 44:00with the religious one. Consider that
  1070. 44:04Moshe Dayan, who at the time was
  1071. 44:06Minister of Defense and was not only
  1072. 44:08secular but also an archaeologist,
  1073. 44:10asked himself the night before the
  1074. 44:12conquest of the Old City: "But what
  1075. 44:13will we do with Old Jerusalem anyway?""
  1076. 44:16Why should we take on a Vatican in our
  1077. 44:17own house?" Yet, after the conquest, he
  1078. 44:21appeared at the Wailing Wall and
  1079. 44:23declared: "Here, 3,000 years of our
  1080. 44:26hopes and desires are fulfilled.""Let
  1081. 44:29no one dare take from us what we have
  1082. 44:31regained with such effort." From 1967
  1083. 44:34onwards, religious Zionism maintained
  1084. 44:37that the conquered territories should
  1085. 44:40not be abandoned for any reason. Thus,
  1086. 44:44in the early 70s, Gush Emunim, the Bloc
  1087. 44:46of the Faithful, was born—a movement
  1088. 44:49that considered settlement in the
  1089. 44:51liberated territories a religious
  1090. 44:52commandment, a mitzvah. So it is that
  1091. 44:56for them, settling in Hebron, Nablus,
  1092. 44:58Judea, or Samaria—which are the
  1093. 45:00biblical names for the West Bank—
  1094. 45:02becomes a sort of divine imperative.
  1095. 45:06Progressively, religious Zionism has
  1096. 45:08shifted further and further to the
  1097. 45:10right, as revisionist Zionism also
  1098. 45:11gained power. And the two movements,
  1099. 45:15despite starting from very different
  1100. 45:17premises, found themselves allied in
  1101. 45:19trying to make the conquest of the
  1102. 45:21territories irreversible. The break
  1103. 45:24between the two movements, as we said,
  1104. 45:26occurred in 1979, when Begin signed the
  1105. 45:29peace agreements with Egypt which
  1106. 45:30involved the withdrawal from the Sinai,
  1107. 45:33which meant the dismantling of the
  1108. 45:35settlements in the Sinai, which was
  1109. 45:37unacceptable for religious Zionists.
  1110. 45:40This led to the radicalization of part
  1111. 45:43of the settlers with attacks against
  1112. 45:45both Palestinians and the Israeli
  1113. 45:47pacifist left. In 1992, two positions
  1114. 45:51emerged that, if we think about it,
  1115. 45:53effectively synthesize the debate. On
  1116. 45:56one side, Yitzhak Rabin proposed the
  1117. 45:58preeminence of Medinat Yisrael, the
  1118. 46:00State of Israel, and compromise with
  1119. 46:02the Palestinians. On the other, Yitzhak
  1120. 46:06Shamir declared the preeminence of
  1121. 46:08Eretz Yisrael, the Land of Israel, and
  1122. 46:10the impossibility of an agreement with
  1123. 46:12the Palestinians. Medinat, Eretz, State
  1124. 46:17of Israel, Land of Israel. These are
  1125. 46:21two dramatically different ways of
  1126. 46:23understanding a political project and
  1127. 46:26its relationship with the territory.
  1128. 46:30Starting in 2000, with the victory of
  1129. 46:32the Zionist right, we witnessed a
  1130. 46:34progressive national, ethno-religious
  1131. 46:35shift with the emergence of a
  1132. 46:37neo-revisionist Zionism. Remember that
  1133. 46:41the revisionism of the 1920s did indeed
  1134. 46:43want a greater Israel, but for national
  1135. 46:45, not religious reasons, so much so
  1136. 46:47that it referred to the borders of the
  1137. 46:49British Mandate. The attachment of
  1138. 46:52revisionist Zionism to sacred places is
  1139. 46:55a recent matter and is precisely the
  1140. 46:57fruit of this synergy with religious
  1141. 47:00Zionism. The settlers in the occupied
  1142. 47:02territories have become hundreds of
  1143. 47:04thousands. They live outside the
  1144. 47:06borders of Israel, but are considered
  1145. 47:09full citizens. Many are recent
  1146. 47:11immigrants from the United States, have
  1147. 47:13organized themselves into a
  1148. 47:14paramilitary structure, and do not
  1149. 47:16hesitate to claim outright punitive
  1150. 47:18expeditions against their Arab
  1151. 47:19neighbors. The practice of
  1152. 47:22expropriating Palestinian-owned land,
  1153. 47:24the construction of roads reserved for
  1154. 47:26Jews, and reprisals have acted as an
  1155. 47:28incentive for colonization without any
  1156. 47:31longer hiding the goal of annexation.
  1157. 47:34Not to mention the fact that
  1158. 47:36demographic pressure in cities like Tel
  1159. 47:38Aviv makes life practically
  1160. 47:40unsustainable, especially for young
  1161. 47:42people. Sometimes young people born and
  1162. 47:45raised in Israel emigrate silently,
  1163. 47:48going abroad in search of a space that
  1164. 47:51is less stifling, less expensive, less
  1165. 47:53anxiety-inducing, and less pressured by
  1166. 47:56the threat of war. Other young people,
  1167. 47:59on the other hand, become radicalized
  1168. 48:01after the second Intifada. Thousands of
  1169. 48:04young people have been trained in
  1170. 48:05pre-military Yeshivot with a mix of
  1171. 48:07religious education and ideological
  1172. 48:09training and have begun to climb the
  1173. 48:10hierarchies of the Israeli army. Here
  1174. 48:14too, however, it is important to note
  1175. 48:16one thing: not all religious Zionists
  1176. 48:18are messianic and colonialist. There
  1177. 48:20have always been more moderate voices
  1178. 48:22that, while believing in the sanctity
  1179. 48:24of the land of Israel, prioritize the
  1180. 48:26pursuit of peace. Organizations like Oz
  1181. 48:29VeShalom and Netivot Shalom have long
  1182. 48:31advocated for the need to accept a
  1183. 48:34territorial compromise, based on the
  1184. 48:36premise that the sanctity of life and
  1185. 48:38the pursuit of peace are supreme values
  1186. 48:41. Then there is the 2018 Nation-State
  1187. 48:44Law, which marked the definitive crisis
  1188. 48:46of classical Zionism—the kind that
  1189. 48:48sought a balance between universal
  1190. 48:50values and Jewish identity, even
  1191. 48:52enshrining it in the Declaration of
  1192. 48:54Independence. The law was passed by the
  1193. 48:58Knesset with 62 votes in favor and 55
  1194. 49:00against, and it marked an institutional
  1195. 49:03turning point because, for the first
  1196. 49:05time, Israel is formally defined as the
  1197. 49:08national home of the Jewish people,
  1198. 49:10with the goal of developing Jewish
  1199. 49:12settlements as a national value,
  1200. 49:14without territorial limits regarding
  1201. 49:17future borders, and downgrading Arabic
  1202. 49:19from an official language to one with a
  1203. 49:22special status. Then the sixth
  1204. 49:26Netanyahu government, formed after a
  1205. 49:29period of great political instability,
  1206. 49:31built an alliance with the Religious
  1207. 49:33Zionist party, Shas, United Torah
  1208. 49:35Judaism, Noam, and Otzma Yehudit—
  1209. 49:37parties that include Jewish supremacist
  1210. 49:40components with the stated goal of
  1211. 49:42building a Greater Israel from the
  1212. 49:44Mediterranean to the Jordan. The rest
  1213. 49:47is current events; you can find the
  1214. 49:49rest in the newspapers. What I have
  1215. 49:50tried to do here is tell you what you
  1216. 49:52would hardly find in the newspapers,
  1217. 49:54because they are two different jobs.
  1218. 49:57What I hope you will take away from
  1219. 49:58this video is, first and foremost, the
  1220. 50:00impossibility of speaking of Zionism in
  1221. 50:03the singular, because Zionisms and
  1222. 50:04their history contain a complexity that
  1223. 50:07I could not reduce any further without
  1224. 50:09falling into error. And I also hope
  1225. 50:12that this account has helped you
  1226. 50:14understand a little more about the
  1227. 50:16historical roots of the Nation-State of
  1228. 50:18Israel that we know today. I take this
  1229. 50:21opportunity to thank all the people who
  1230. 50:24support this project very much, which,
  1231. 50:26as you may know by now, is not
  1232. 50:28supported through advertising or
  1233. 50:30traditional YouTube monetization,
  1234. 50:33because I am not against it. Um, it is
  1235. 50:36sustained solely and exclusively
  1236. 50:38through voluntary donations, and anyone
  1237. 50:41who decides to help me continue has my
  1238. 50:43full gratitude. Sending you a big hug.
  1239. 50:46See you soon. Yes.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Israele e i sionismi - storia del pensiero geopolitico - parte VI by Fiore, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,663 words across 1,239 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.