YouTube2Text

πŸ’₯ IS THIS THE WORST INTERROGATION EVER? Watch Suitcase Killer Sarah Boone Take Control β€” Transcript

by The Behavior Panel Β· 17,324 words Β· 2,527 segments Β· language en Β· Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00today we're going to talk about the
  2. 0:01interrogation of Sarah Boone Greg we're
  3. 0:04going to tell us about the videos we're
  4. 0:05going to watch we'll keep this pretty
  5. 0:07short she was arrested in 2020 for this
  6. 0:11murder I think she was charged with
  7. 0:12second-degree murder this is the Orange
  8. 0:14County Sheriff's department and there is
  9. 0:16same two investigators are talking to
  10. 0:18her this is a day later than when they
  11. 0:21went to talk to her on site
  12. 0:25to your recollection no videos on Sunday
  13. 0:28not that I'm aware of okay
  14. 0:32maybe I took a picture of them the two
  15. 0:35of Tess and the dogs and George and them
  16. 0:39dancing but I mean or it's just tests
  17. 0:44okay
  18. 0:45um so I have something that I want to
  19. 0:47show you that we found
  20. 0:49um and it was from your phone
  21. 0:56can you see it
  22. 0:59you need to move it around go ahead
  23. 1:10no I don't remember that for everything
  24. 1:12you've done to me
  25. 1:13for everything you've done your
  26. 1:16battery's about to die shutting down oh
  27. 1:18okay
  28. 1:20let me
  29. 1:29the battery doesn't last very long yeah
  30. 1:32it used to last a lot longer than that I
  31. 1:33don't know what happened okay let me
  32. 1:35just grab something all right
  33. 1:42I was just simply asking because
  34. 1:44um you had a look on your face when she
  35. 1:47asked you if you've ever done that
  36. 1:48before you look kind of shocked and no
  37. 1:51okay why did you say it like that like
  38. 1:55I don't think you all understand who I
  39. 1:57am where well tell me I mean I've always
  40. 2:01been a straight A student I am an
  41. 2:03outstanding mother to my son I excel at
  42. 2:06everything
  43. 2:08I
  44. 2:10I would not do that
  45. 2:12you wouldn't lock something is it
  46. 2:14somebody in a suitcase
  47. 2:16well I didn't like completely lock it I
  48. 2:19mean I opened it with one finger I left
  49. 2:21enough in there for him to get out
  50. 2:25and I wasn't planning on going upstairs
  51. 2:27and going to sleep
  52. 2:35all right Greg what do you got yeah so
  53. 2:38what should have become an old moment
  54. 2:40turns into a whale moment when you are
  55. 2:43an interrogator everything is about
  56. 2:44control everything's about me being in
  57. 2:46charge of the entire environment not
  58. 2:49about going in with a dead battery and
  59. 2:51and actually the per looking over and
  60. 2:53going hey your battery's dying this is
  61. 2:55an opportunity to show a video that is
  62. 2:57very compromising and what do they do
  63. 2:58they come in and Bumble that that's not
  64. 3:00a good start to an interrogation she's
  65. 3:02calm I I don't know why she's as calm as
  66. 3:06she is but maybe she was just plowed
  67. 3:07when this thing happened but there's no
  68. 3:09planning in prep here she calmly points
  69. 3:12that out her breathing does increase and
  70. 3:14you can see it because we're looking
  71. 3:15down on top of her you see her breathing
  72. 3:16rate increase and then she loses fluency
  73. 3:20and Chase you'll appreciate this she
  74. 3:22says I mean just like the guy from
  75. 3:24Stephen McDaniel videos
  76. 3:26so she's lost fluency and then she goes
  77. 3:29to us to a resume statement that is one
  78. 3:31of the dumbest I've ever heard I'm a
  79. 3:33straight A student this is a
  80. 3:3440-something-year-old woman who Zips it
  81. 3:36up and suitcase and that's her defense
  82. 3:39that's not a good defense so if I were
  83. 3:42interrogating her I'd anchor her
  84. 3:43admission that she knew it wouldn't be
  85. 3:45good for him to stay in the suitcase
  86. 3:47that long and start from there I would
  87. 3:50say why'd you leave the hole number one
  88. 3:51and she'd say well I left the hole
  89. 3:53because he needed some air well then
  90. 3:55why'd you go upstairs
  91. 3:57because she says I wouldn't have left
  92. 3:59him zipped up and gone upstairs so she's
  93. 4:02got some cognitive dissonance here just
  94. 4:04right by saying look I left a hole
  95. 4:07because I knew it was dangerous I
  96. 4:08wouldn't have gone upstairs if so right
  97. 4:11there you got the beginning of the whole
  98. 4:12problem if if you're already convinced
  99. 4:15of guilt which you are when you use this
  100. 4:17process this is a read style process
  101. 4:19ideally but this is a read style process
  102. 4:21you start off convinced of guilt and
  103. 4:23you're looking for confession this is
  104. 4:25not an intelligence interrogation they
  105. 4:27should anchor what she starts off with
  106. 4:29by saying I left it open enough that he
  107. 4:31could get some air and I didn't plan to
  108. 4:33go upstairs Mark what do you got
  109. 4:36yeah so here's a universal in terms of
  110. 4:40how all of us behave no matter who you
  111. 4:43are or who you think you are is we are
  112. 4:45all trying to defy gravity in some way
  113. 4:48we're all at most points in our life in
  114. 4:51some kind of battle against gravity no
  115. 4:54matter what sex you are where you are
  116. 4:57born who nurtured you we're all trying
  117. 5:00to work with gravity and this particular
  118. 5:02situation the sticks and rubber bands
  119. 5:05that are holding her body together are
  120. 5:08not working at their full capacity and
  121. 5:09so we get this convex
  122. 5:12um abdomen where gravity is taken hold
  123. 5:16of her shoulders and it's pulling her
  124. 5:18down now you could say it's an abdominal
  125. 5:20Retreat and maybe there's some
  126. 5:21nervousness there and I think that would
  127. 5:24be true as well but as the shoulders are
  128. 5:27rolled forward and she's so sunk into
  129. 5:29that chair I think she's really feeling
  130. 5:31the pressure of this whole situation and
  131. 5:34it's dragging her down down uh if you
  132. 5:37want some interesting work on that
  133. 5:39concave abdomen Cuddy who's well known
  134. 5:43in the body language world did some
  135. 5:44interesting papers on that abdominal
  136. 5:47retreat in pubescent females very very
  137. 5:50interesting how um how the uh the
  138. 5:54introduction of estrogen and Body Image
  139. 5:57will cause females to become concave
  140. 5:59there anyway
  141. 6:02um I'm with you Greg Straight A's
  142. 6:04outstanding mother excel at everything
  143. 6:06well that's just grandiose at this point
  144. 6:09and so Greg I think you're right she
  145. 6:11doesn't show a lot of nervousness in the
  146. 6:14way that we'd expect it she seems quite
  147. 6:16calm she's got them kind of messing up
  148. 6:19clearly right from the get-go I don't
  149. 6:22think it's a tactic of theirs to have a
  150. 6:24dodgy battery at all I think is an
  151. 6:26absolute mistake but yet she is concave
  152. 6:30and she's going for these grandiose
  153. 6:32images as well to prove herself not
  154. 6:36looking good from the get-go even with
  155. 6:38some terrible mistakes going on from the
  156. 6:41interviewers uh Scott what do you got on
  157. 6:44this one all right I'm not going to
  158. 6:45focus as much on her as I am on the
  159. 6:47interrogation this is the worst
  160. 6:49interrogation I've ever seen in my life
  161. 6:51it's not just it's not bungled and
  162. 6:54nothing went wrong the whole thing is
  163. 6:56this is not an interrogation it's just
  164. 6:58some people fussing in a room that's all
  165. 7:00this ends up being
  166. 7:01after after she brings up the part about
  167. 7:03her boyfriend being in a suitcase in
  168. 7:06walks that detective with a new cord
  169. 7:08went for the computer after this guy's
  170. 7:10been taught the other detective has been
  171. 7:12asking her questions and while she's
  172. 7:13answering this question he gets up and
  173. 7:16walks over and starts dick around with
  174. 7:18the wall plug while she's talking all
  175. 7:20she's telling him the answer to the to
  176. 7:22the question he asked
  177. 7:23and then when she finishes her answer he
  178. 7:25says okay he gets up doesn't look at her
  179. 7:28and shuts the door
  180. 7:30I I it was I was dumbfounded by that and
  181. 7:33you could say this is a technique this
  182. 7:35this is some kind of it's not there's no
  183. 7:37never seen this before never heard this
  184. 7:39and you'll see it's not a technique
  185. 7:40because it doesn't get any better than
  186. 7:42this
  187. 7:43the body language of this interest and
  188. 7:45disrespect is incredible here that they
  189. 7:48have for for there's no Rapport building
  190. 7:50there's nothing they they they I I don't
  191. 7:54think they know what they're doing and
  192. 7:55we're going to see that as we go as we
  193. 7:57go through this maybe maybe they're
  194. 7:58burned out but they're disinterested it
  195. 8:00it just floored me Chase what do you got
  196. 8:04absolutely agree while this isn't a
  197. 8:08great interrogation the setup of this
  198. 8:11interrogation room is I don't know great
  199. 8:15there's no table between them
  200. 8:19there's no one blocking sitting between
  201. 8:21the suspect and the door this is the
  202. 8:23setup uh that we should have seen you
  203. 8:26know in lots of other videos those two
  204. 8:28rules of thumb should be in every
  205. 8:30interrogation room we see it in this one
  206. 8:33I just wish the interrogators were there
  207. 8:35too I too am a long time victim of
  208. 8:39Panasonic Toughbook battery life
  209. 8:43I can attest uh they are awful
  210. 8:46but there's a lot of stuff there you
  211. 8:49also notice that the door is not blocked
  212. 8:52you know there's a clear line to the
  213. 8:53door that's a good important point that
  214. 8:56I've always heard in training and I've
  215. 8:57seen it I've seen the results in real
  216. 8:59life if the interrogators have the
  217. 9:02ability to spot Behavior they would know
  218. 9:05that one of her biggest objections to
  219. 9:07confession would be feeling like she
  220. 9:09isn't known or appreciated
  221. 9:12and what do they do she's not known they
  222. 9:15don't even look at her they don't build
  223. 9:17rapport with her they don't do anything
  224. 9:18to make exactly what she needs and not
  225. 9:21everyone needs to feel known and
  226. 9:23appreciated some people need different
  227. 9:25things and we'll get into that uh in the
  228. 9:27next couple that's all I got yeah let me
  229. 9:30add one thing I I taught interrogation
  230. 9:32and I've seen few that were this bad
  231. 9:34because at least my students listen to
  232. 9:37what the person is saying and didn't say
  233. 9:39well hold on don't tell me that I want
  234. 9:40to ask you something else that's the
  235. 9:43first step in interrogation listen
  236. 9:46so
  237. 9:48to your recollection
  238. 9:49no videos on Sunday not that I'm aware
  239. 9:53of okay I mean I like maybe it's like a
  240. 9:56picture of them the two of Tess and the
  241. 10:00dogs and George and them dancing but I
  242. 10:03mean or it's just tests
  243. 10:06okay
  244. 10:08um so I have something that I want to
  245. 10:10show you that we found
  246. 10:12um and
  247. 10:14it was from your phone
  248. 10:17foreign
  249. 10:50foreign
  250. 10:52doesn't last very long yeah it used to
  251. 10:55last a lot longer than that I don't know
  252. 10:56what happened okay okay let me just grab
  253. 10:58something all right
  254. 11:04I was just simply asking because
  255. 11:07um you had a look on your face when she
  256. 11:10asked you if you've ever done that
  257. 11:11before you look kind of shocked and no
  258. 11:14okay why did you say it like that like
  259. 11:17I don't think you all understand who I
  260. 11:20am where well tell me I mean I've always
  261. 11:23been a straight A student I am an
  262. 11:26outstanding mother to my son I excel at
  263. 11:28everything
  264. 11:31I
  265. 11:33I would not do that
  266. 11:35you wouldn't lock something is it
  267. 11:36somebody in a suitcase
  268. 11:39well I didn't like completely block it I
  269. 11:42mean I opened it with one finger I left
  270. 11:44enough in there for him to get out
  271. 11:48and I wasn't planning on going upstairs
  272. 11:50and going to sleep
  273. 12:01no it's just the way you said it you
  274. 12:03guys are scaring me sorry
  275. 12:06we just want you to watch this this came
  276. 12:07from your phone don't you want to know
  277. 12:09what's on it yes
  278. 12:26is it long because I don't know how much
  279. 12:28I can take
  280. 12:33I don't know how much I can pay
  281. 12:36I don't know how to find
  282. 12:45this do I have to watch this
  283. 12:48I continuously throw up I don't sleep I
  284. 12:51don't want to see it if that's okay
  285. 12:54well it's on your phone
  286. 12:57and you can either explain it or we take
  287. 13:00it for what it is yeah we're just trying
  288. 13:02to give you these opportunities tell us
  289. 13:03what's going on that's it
  290. 13:08foreign
  291. 13:13[Applause]
  292. 13:40yeah that's when you do when you showed
  293. 13:42me so
  294. 13:48I don't want to watch it please
  295. 13:51I'll go first on this one
  296. 13:54uh Chase I'm gonna have to I'm gonna
  297. 13:56have to
  298. 13:57to go against on the setup of the room
  299. 14:00I I think that I think the person you're
  300. 14:02talking to needs something they need
  301. 14:04something to lean on just a little
  302. 14:05something just that corner I put that
  303. 14:07thing I'd get him so they're in the
  304. 14:09corner right there I wouldn't sit right
  305. 14:11next to him the thing that scared me
  306. 14:13half to death when he stood up and put
  307. 14:15his gun in her face I put his side over
  308. 14:18there all she had to do was reach up
  309. 14:19there grab that and pop both of them and
  310. 14:21she's out and then go down the hall if
  311. 14:23she knew how to work her way out of that
  312. 14:25that that completely freaked me out when
  313. 14:27he when he did that
  314. 14:29his gun's right there in her face it'll
  315. 14:31just be really easy to get a hold of it
  316. 14:32and I I really think people need a a
  317. 14:35thing to to protect themselves just a
  318. 14:37little bit so they can at least get some
  319. 14:38comfort in there as for themselves so
  320. 14:41you can help them relax because if not
  321. 14:43they're going to be all they don't know
  322. 14:43where to put their hands and look the
  323. 14:45way she's sitting she's sitting all you
  324. 14:47know bunched up and uncomfortable and
  325. 14:50with their personalities they're not
  326. 14:51going to be able to get her to loosen up
  327. 14:53a little bit
  328. 14:55just but
  329. 14:56it's just I think it's just a mess
  330. 14:58before they can get the video ready she
  331. 15:00starts telling them that she doesn't
  332. 15:01want to watch it she gets sick she has
  333. 15:03she hadn't been sleeping they missed
  334. 15:05their window here for shock value for
  335. 15:08this thing
  336. 15:09completely there's no way to say really
  337. 15:11what's this you said you didn't have a
  338. 15:13thing and let's watch this
  339. 15:15they don't shut up the whole time
  340. 15:17there's not a spot in this entire
  341. 15:18interrogation where they're they're
  342. 15:20quiet more than 20 seconds 15 20 seconds
  343. 15:22tops you know she says I don't know how
  344. 15:25much I can take
  345. 15:26there's the there's the door to go in
  346. 15:29take what what you know what do you know
  347. 15:31about these what do you think about
  348. 15:32these this video what tell me how you
  349. 15:34just break it up and and give it to them
  350. 15:36so they can start talking and then she's
  351. 15:39pretty still while she's watching the
  352. 15:40video no emotion no oh my God no nothing
  353. 15:43especially if she hasn't seen it before
  354. 15:44and she's not aware of it there's no
  355. 15:46surprise there there's no shock there
  356. 15:48there's no horror there she just
  357. 15:50comments back in her chair and he says I
  358. 15:52don't want to watch it please and they
  359. 15:53turn it off for her at that point and
  360. 15:57then so far we've seen no structure to
  361. 16:00an interrogation there was no there's
  362. 16:02there's there doesn't seem to be a go
  363. 16:05the the woman detective talks and then
  364. 16:07the the guy detective talks and they're
  365. 16:09asking two different questions and just
  366. 16:11as he finishes the question and and
  367. 16:13Sarah starts to answer that woman start
  368. 16:16the the woman starts asking another
  369. 16:18question nobody's in control no but no
  370. 16:21nobody is leading there's no teamwork
  371. 16:24here there's no structure to what's
  372. 16:26going on
  373. 16:27this thing is is headed right for the
  374. 16:29squatter I mean it's in the squatter
  375. 16:31there's no and I don't think there's a
  376. 16:32way to get it out Mark what do you got
  377. 16:35yeah so uh Scott I think you missed out
  378. 16:37on the shock value of the shirt that's
  379. 16:40where they're going for the shock value
  380. 16:41okay
  381. 16:43that's where it is that's where he
  382. 16:45clearly you know this might be your
  383. 16:47first rodeo on this spot so clearly you
  384. 16:49haven't seen this technique okay not yet
  385. 16:52he's he's leaving with that shirt
  386. 16:55straight down to Bojangles nightclub
  387. 16:57that is that is
  388. 16:59exactly where that shirt fits in what is
  389. 17:04he wearing what is he wearing number one
  390. 17:06but then he's got the badge there which
  391. 17:08you know automatically just you know
  392. 17:11he's got the weapon he's got the badge
  393. 17:13he's got this audacious shirt I mean
  394. 17:17there's nothing comfortable about this
  395. 17:19situation and look we're not saying you
  396. 17:22have to make criminals comfortable you
  397. 17:25know but if if you want them to open up
  398. 17:27to you you have to give them some basic
  399. 17:30fundamental uh Comfort levels this isn't
  400. 17:33doing it
  401. 17:34she goes straight into it she's she
  402. 17:36takes that victim stance you guys are
  403. 17:38scaring me I don't know how much I can
  404. 17:41take uh I continuously throw up I don't
  405. 17:45sleep so she's she's taking this
  406. 17:48opportunity of the stress of this
  407. 17:49situation to cast herself in the victim
  408. 17:52she goes more concave they're not
  409. 17:55picking up on any of this because
  410. 17:56they're dealing with their Tech right
  411. 17:58now and they haven't I mean you know
  412. 18:00that that release of the video should be
  413. 18:03built up to it seems I don't know how
  414. 18:05long they've been there but in this tape
  415. 18:07it seems almost immediately there you go
  416. 18:09there's our Ace card let's just throw it
  417. 18:11oh we just screwed it up oh no never
  418. 18:13mind I mean it's terrible from the
  419. 18:16soundtrack in in the um in the actual
  420. 18:20tape that they're showing and uh you can
  421. 18:23probably find that on the internet
  422. 18:24somewhere it's pretty Grim so I don't
  423. 18:27suggest you should go and look at it but
  424. 18:30if you want to get a closer uh listen to
  425. 18:33that soundtrack track
  426. 18:35is she glib in that or is she drunk what
  427. 18:39is it about her demeanor there that
  428. 18:41means she can be so kind of light around
  429. 18:44around what she's saying
  430. 18:47is it slurred is she is she had more
  431. 18:49than
  432. 18:51um half a bottle or a bottle uh not sure
  433. 18:54or is there a glibness to it again this
  434. 18:57is a question on my part I don't have an
  435. 18:59answer to that but but so far man that
  436. 19:02the fashion is is has done it for me uh
  437. 19:06Chase what do you got on this one
  438. 19:09I I don't want to hit too hard on the
  439. 19:12investigators because many many times
  440. 19:14I'm sitting I'm standing in front of a
  441. 19:16room with one of those little
  442. 19:17microphones with 55 detectives homicide
  443. 19:21detectives and I do a show of hands at
  444. 19:23day one who's had interrogation training
  445. 19:26maybe or maybe four hands go up maybe
  446. 19:31so a lot of times it would astonish most
  447. 19:35people how little interrogation training
  448. 19:37police departments invest in
  449. 19:40so here is some interrogation training
  450. 19:42for you based on this one clip
  451. 19:44when you hear somebody's objections and
  452. 19:47initial requests in an interrogation
  453. 19:49room objections and initial requests or
  454. 19:52in almost any high stress situation they
  455. 19:55are using behavioral patterns that work
  456. 19:57for them in the past Greg says this all
  457. 20:00the time the organism does what makes it
  458. 20:02successful we carry a lot more from
  459. 20:04childhood into adulthood than we really
  460. 20:06realize these patterns here are
  461. 20:09extremely revealing about her psychology
  462. 20:11and her behavioral patterns here's the
  463. 20:13question you should be asking yourself
  464. 20:14when you see anything even remotely
  465. 20:17similar to what you're seeing here what
  466. 20:20is being used to escape a stressful
  467. 20:22situation
  468. 20:24in Sarah's case she's using fear
  469. 20:27not injecting it but talking about being
  470. 20:30scared you guys are scaring me and she's
  471. 20:32using being overwhelmed I don't know how
  472. 20:34much I can take these two things alone
  473. 20:37got her out of trouble before I
  474. 20:40guarantee it and if you're the
  475. 20:41interrogator you will now know that will
  476. 20:44be the way that you know she used to be
  477. 20:47to get out of stuff in the extreme and
  478. 20:50she's going to do it later if you don't
  479. 20:53jump on them and use some training to
  480. 20:55stop those from the beginning from the
  481. 20:57beginning of the interrogation or to
  482. 20:59preempt some of those objections because
  483. 21:01that's going to be the barrier to a
  484. 21:03confession Greg what do you got yeah
  485. 21:05let's talk about interrogation for a
  486. 21:06minute when we talk about interrogation
  487. 21:08there are really two real schools of
  488. 21:09thought in today's world one is read the
  489. 21:11read technique goes from the supposition
  490. 21:13you've done all the work and you know
  491. 21:15the person's guilty and you're going
  492. 21:16after information and use things that we
  493. 21:19refer to as themes they're ways of
  494. 21:20letting a person out and feel okay about
  495. 21:22telling you that in the sharpian version
  496. 21:25on sharf the brilliant luftwaffe
  497. 21:28interrogator who used non-coercion on
  498. 21:29Americans what he did was work your
  499. 21:32psyche work your psyche make you feel
  500. 21:34better about talking gain trust get you
  501. 21:37to do whatever it took either one of
  502. 21:39these has a certain set of approaches if
  503. 21:41you're going from read you would give
  504. 21:43them rational outlets for why this
  505. 21:45happened at this point that's the way
  506. 21:46you go if you're going from Shark when
  507. 21:48she brought up those accomplishments in
  508. 21:50the last video you'd say tell me more
  509. 21:51about that you must be pretty smart you
  510. 21:53start working your ego you're working
  511. 21:55her right back into the same place so
  512. 21:57that when you go to say look be rational
  513. 21:59and she's told you how brilliant
  514. 22:01brilliant she is you put her at odds
  515. 22:03with herself none of that's happening
  516. 22:04here and Chase I agree with you few
  517. 22:07people get good interrogation training
  518. 22:09it's a reason we all have jobs if you
  519. 22:12watch her when this whole thing starts
  520. 22:13she's got a lip compression and internal
  521. 22:15dialogue
  522. 22:16she does this she's withholding
  523. 22:18something we don't know what that is
  524. 22:19could be emotion could be other
  525. 22:22information but she's withholding
  526. 22:23something as this female detective sets
  527. 22:26that laptop up and she goes to internal
  528. 22:28dialogue she's thinking to herself
  529. 22:29something about what's going on it could
  530. 22:31be hey what the hell are they doing and
  531. 22:34she does this when she says you're
  532. 22:36scaring me well we associate this with
  533. 22:39real stress relief because you're
  534. 22:41massaging those muscles right in that
  535. 22:43forehead to show concern and grief and
  536. 22:45all those things and they get knotted
  537. 22:46over time I would say when she starts
  538. 22:49working through there and working
  539. 22:50through this thing the why question is
  540. 22:52the most powerful one you can ask it
  541. 22:54always works children ask it for a
  542. 22:56reason when she says you're scaring me
  543. 22:58I'd say why are we scaring you why
  544. 22:59simple question you get her started in
  545. 23:02the process of answering and then she
  546. 23:05asked the question is it long and Scott
  547. 23:07when she says is it long and I don't
  548. 23:09know how much I can take hold on I
  549. 23:11thought you didn't know this video
  550. 23:13you tell me how long it is and you tell
  551. 23:15me why you can't take it that's what I
  552. 23:16want to know that's all I'd stop right
  553. 23:18there
  554. 23:19she that's a source lead I always tell
  555. 23:22you guys when a person brings something
  556. 23:23up they're willing to talk about it if
  557. 23:25you bring it up they may not be but that
  558. 23:27is a missed opportunity they don't pay
  559. 23:29attention to her they're not listening
  560. 23:31to her and they're looking to each other
  561. 23:32they came in with a plan and this is a
  562. 23:35number one problem with interrogators if
  563. 23:37I go in a room full of people who think
  564. 23:39they're good interrogators most of them
  565. 23:40will say I've always won arguments
  566. 23:42that's not an interrogator that's an
  567. 23:44arguer that's our knucklehead from the
  568. 23:46Waukesha parade who is always won by
  569. 23:48barraging people with BS or some other
  570. 23:50way good interrogation is not that I may
  571. 23:53look stupid just to win in a good
  572. 23:55interrogation it's all about getting
  573. 23:57what I needed or confessional
  574. 23:58information and going after it so the
  575. 24:00source leads are powerful okay then this
  576. 24:04prop thing know when to say when turn
  577. 24:06that damn thing off and turn and listen
  578. 24:08to what the source is saying what the
  579. 24:09perpetrators saying she's moved from
  580. 24:11internal voice to emotional eye
  581. 24:13accessing at this point her torso Mark
  582. 24:15to your point is caving in she's
  583. 24:18shrinking into that chair if you you
  584. 24:20turn right now and talk to her and you
  585. 24:22use the right approaches the right
  586. 24:23themes you're going to get this person
  587. 24:25to start bleeding information because
  588. 24:27she's on the verge of going emotional
  589. 24:28and going into a shell that's what
  590. 24:31you're looking for and that's the
  591. 24:32beginning of it you don't have to watch
  592. 24:34this if you tell us what happened was is
  593. 24:36the answer you should say I agree just
  594. 24:38tell us what happened we're just trying
  595. 24:39to get the bottom of it and this is what
  596. 24:41we can see and she's almost moving into
  597. 24:44that what we call a I'd call a clamshell
  598. 24:46exoskeleton where her feet are crossed
  599. 24:49under a chair and her voice is dropping
  600. 24:51and her body is caving in guys that's
  601. 24:54the and that chin is covering her throat
  602. 24:56that's the beginning of pre-confession
  603. 24:58body language and we know exactly how to
  604. 25:00get it to happen what you don't do is go
  605. 25:02headlong at her and attack her what you
  606. 25:04do is go
  607. 25:05okay tell us exactly what happened
  608. 25:08soften it get there and regardless of
  609. 25:11what space you have I mean you're both
  610. 25:12have we all have opinions about space it
  611. 25:15all has to be built around Mission what
  612. 25:18usually is a doctrinal change from this
  613. 25:22is you carry no weapon whatsoever in any
  614. 25:26interrogation room I'll go back to my
  615. 25:28sear days we had a guy named Rocky
  616. 25:30Gonzalez who struck a guy and he came
  617. 25:33out flying out of the room we went and
  618. 25:34found out what happened he said I hit
  619. 25:36the guy and he turned into Bruce Lee you
  620. 25:38never know who's in the room with you
  621. 25:39you never know who's in the room with
  622. 25:41you so we don't wear any kind of gear
  623. 25:42that they can get their hands on or any
  624. 25:44kind of weapons bad Doctrine and this is
  625. 25:46a bad start to an interrogation
  626. 25:48regardless of what cost it just my
  627. 25:50opinion yeah now if you don't know who
  628. 25:52we are with the behavior panel and I'm
  629. 25:54Scott Rouse I create
  630. 25:56I created the only online True Crime uh
  631. 26:00course with Greg Hartley Mark what less
  632. 26:03do we do that again
  633. 26:05don't don't do that from Star Wars you
  634. 26:08can write that stuff but you can't say
  635. 26:09it all right all right uh if you don't
  636. 26:12know who we are we're the behavior panel
  637. 26:14I'm Scott Rouse I'm a body language
  638. 26:15expert and analyst I created the uh God
  639. 26:18now my Brave I'm trying to I'm trying to
  640. 26:23ah let's go to the next one
  641. 26:29foreign
  642. 26:37don't you want to know what's on it yes
  643. 26:56is it long because I don't know how much
  644. 26:58I can take
  645. 27:03I don't know how much I can take
  646. 27:15honestly do I have to watch this
  647. 27:18I continuously throw up I don't sleep I
  648. 27:21don't want to see it if that's okay
  649. 27:24well it's on your phone
  650. 27:27and you can either explain it or retake
  651. 27:30it for what it is yeah we're just trying
  652. 27:32to give you the opportunities tell us
  653. 27:33what's going on
  654. 27:34that's a
  655. 27:39it's that long two minutes
  656. 27:43[Applause]
  657. 27:44for everything
  658. 27:58Sarah
  659. 28:00this is my name and wear it up
  660. 28:08foreign
  661. 28:26[Music]
  662. 28:33[Music]
  663. 28:45[Music]
  664. 28:54like as if you're packing something so
  665. 28:57this is upside down guys this is killing
  666. 28:59me right now so this image is upside
  667. 29:01down and then this small video that
  668. 29:06occurred 11 minutes later it slipped
  669. 29:09over the other way
  670. 29:12closer to your dining room table okay
  671. 29:14now he's obviously still in there so he
  672. 29:17didn't how did that how did it go from
  673. 29:19the back to the front I flipped it okay
  674. 29:23my plan was not to go upstairs and go to
  675. 29:26sleep
  676. 29:28well that's what you did yeah but not
  677. 29:30intentional though
  678. 29:31no you told me you went upstairs because
  679. 29:34what you were getting ready for bed
  680. 29:36stopped here okay but first here show me
  681. 29:39where you can see any fingers coming out
  682. 29:42because there's the end
  683. 29:44it's in his head's right here so going
  684. 29:47like this
  685. 29:48rather than going all the way up it's
  686. 29:50like this
  687. 29:53but why is he saying I can't breathe and
  688. 29:55why is he pushing on it as if he can't
  689. 29:58get out
  690. 29:59and it doesn't show a hole there's no
  691. 30:01hole there's no fingers I don't see his
  692. 30:03fingers there's no hole I don't know
  693. 30:05what you want me to tell you like I
  694. 30:07don't know like what you want me to tell
  695. 30:08you I'm just showing you I'm just
  696. 30:10telling you what we see and what we've
  697. 30:12heard from that I understand I
  698. 30:14understand he's begging to let for you
  699. 30:17to let him out
  700. 30:18you sound you're laughing in the
  701. 30:21beginning and then in the end it sounds
  702. 30:22kind of like a no it's not malicious
  703. 30:26well same it's not malicious then what
  704. 30:30is that what does you mean to you
  705. 30:33well like if you're just if I were to
  706. 30:36tell myself yes like I get called
  707. 30:39Everything by a white woman so okay I my
  708. 30:43intention was not to leave him in there
  709. 30:46please understand that my intention was
  710. 30:49not to leave him in there but you went
  711. 30:52upstairs thinking that he could get
  712. 30:54himself out but the video shows at this
  713. 30:58point and I seen his fingers
  714. 31:01and then 30 minutes later he didn't show
  715. 31:04and he's telling him
  716. 31:07do you think you told me he was laughing
  717. 31:10and I we were
  718. 31:13there
  719. 31:15wow that's yeah wow all right Greg what
  720. 31:20do you got yeah let me give you three
  721. 31:22poor choices of words number one you're
  722. 31:24killing me
  723. 31:26look you're in there for murder you're
  724. 31:28killing me is a bad choice of words
  725. 31:29because it's a tether I can quickly say
  726. 31:31well let's talk about you and this so
  727. 31:34there's an opportunity my plan okay you
  728. 31:37just said look this happened by accident
  729. 31:39you didn't say accident but if you're
  730. 31:41trying to get away with something and
  731. 31:43say it was an accident my plan or bad
  732. 31:45choice of words now whether she's
  733. 31:46conscious enough to realize that or not
  734. 31:48that's why I say I don't think she's
  735. 31:49conscious of this I think she doesn't
  736. 31:51realize what kind of trouble she's in
  737. 31:52and she's just feeding into this she
  738. 31:55also finishes a thought when the woman
  739. 31:57brings up I think it was not malicious
  740. 32:01hmm that sure puts you in a bad place
  741. 32:04poor choice of words from the beginning
  742. 32:06and they don't use elicitation there
  743. 32:08well what do you think killing is they
  744. 32:09have a flawed plan because they're not
  745. 32:11listening they're there to argue and not
  746. 32:12interrogate if you're listening it would
  747. 32:14change your path look I I hate beating
  748. 32:17these guys up because you're right they
  749. 32:18don't get enough training I will Mark
  750. 32:20have to add your comedy for just a
  751. 32:22minute and say if you're Chris Noth you
  752. 32:24have to wear Chris Noth clothes
  753. 32:26and if you don't know who Chris knoweth
  754. 32:27is go look at all the cop shows and he
  755. 32:30dresses all kinds of wild ways this guy
  756. 32:32looks a lot like him and maybe that's
  757. 32:33why he's dressing the part they're here
  758. 32:36to argue not interrogate she leans into
  759. 32:37the evidence I love it she leans over to
  760. 32:39look at the evidence and they don't lean
  761. 32:41on her then she uses that my plan that's
  762. 32:44a push-pull word anytime you use
  763. 32:46something like my plan I thought there
  764. 32:47was no plan thence when I go why did you
  765. 32:49leave a hole why'd you leave a hole
  766. 32:51because you needed air then why'd you go
  767. 32:53upstairs
  768. 32:55you can't have both of those they're not
  769. 32:57congruent so you put her at odds with
  770. 32:58self and then you go back after it it's
  771. 33:00not intentional not intentional sounds
  772. 33:02like a guilty person saying it was on
  773. 33:04accident she's prayerful when she says
  774. 33:06what do you want me to do she does that
  775. 33:07little chipmunk thing again a hamster
  776. 33:09thing and then she finishes the person's
  777. 33:11thoughts about malice that doesn't sound
  778. 33:14good
  779. 33:15these guys could have leaned in there
  780. 33:17and said hold on Sarah I wasn't going to
  781. 33:18say malicious let's talk about that word
  782. 33:19what does that mean to you
  783. 33:21that's the way you get a person to start
  784. 33:23telling you something about what's going
  785. 33:25on
  786. 33:26and then he does get it he almost gets
  787. 33:28it he goes in and he says something to
  788. 33:31her that causes her to say like he does
  789. 33:32me when he says what does FU mean like
  790. 33:35he does me but they miss it again they
  791. 33:37push and disparage her instead of going
  792. 33:39after it if this is Reed where's the
  793. 33:41narrative if this is sharp where's the
  794. 33:43approach so we gotta have somewhere in
  795. 33:45there we start to figure this out if you
  796. 33:47pay attention when this there's a really
  797. 33:50great indicator that I think Reed would
  798. 33:52be powerful when this female detective
  799. 33:55starts to rationalize what happened
  800. 33:56watch the body language ever open up
  801. 33:58it's powerful it tells you that she's
  802. 34:00susceptible but then she goes right back
  803. 34:03to the argument and says but the video
  804. 34:04shows and you see the body language
  805. 34:06shift really hard for me to watch Scott
  806. 34:08what do you got I I think even with
  807. 34:10training I think these two are burnt out
  808. 34:12or just don't want to be there they're
  809. 34:15and we're going to see some examples
  810. 34:16later on that that would prove my theory
  811. 34:20there
  812. 34:21I I don't think I don't think any kind
  813. 34:23of structure would help them I think
  814. 34:24they need to get rid of them and start
  815. 34:25all over again he's sitting back in his
  816. 34:28chair running his own game he's doing
  817. 34:29something else they're asking two
  818. 34:30different questions almost at the same
  819. 34:32time and when she says I don't know what
  820. 34:34you want me to tell you
  821. 34:36he should have said one of them should
  822. 34:37have said look
  823. 34:39I want to tell me why you did this and
  824. 34:41just everybody hush and then go on to
  825. 34:44well tell me why it's there's no
  826. 34:46questioning there's no there's nobody in
  827. 34:49charge there's no nobody's leading it's
  828. 34:51just bouncing around the room and then I
  829. 34:55think this the guy detective is the most
  830. 34:57uncomfortable interrogator I've ever
  831. 34:59seen in my life he can't sit still can't
  832. 35:01keep his fingers out of his nose he
  833. 35:03can't he can't stop
  834. 35:05scooching around squishing around he it
  835. 35:07just looks like something's wrong it
  836. 35:09looks like he's the guilty one that when
  837. 35:11we're looking at it from from this point
  838. 35:13of view I mean she says my plan was not
  839. 35:15to go upstairs and go to sleep they say
  840. 35:17but that's what you did
  841. 35:20come on man
  842. 35:22there's you know a lot even on TV shows
  843. 35:25they know where to go after that I think
  844. 35:27every you know but they don't they're
  845. 35:29not even following their their TV show
  846. 35:31and movie structure there's no structure
  847. 35:33here whatsoever her body language is
  848. 35:36pretty much the same as it has been like
  849. 35:38you're saying Greg she's doing the same
  850. 35:39thing she's got her her Baseline her
  851. 35:41basic setups that she does and uses to
  852. 35:43get rid of her her stress and built up
  853. 35:45tension and the protective things
  854. 35:48everything everything seems the same but
  855. 35:51but this interrogation is not an
  856. 35:52interrogation it's just a fuss
  857. 35:55Chase what do you got
  858. 35:56yeah this uh I agree with you guys this
  859. 36:00would have been a great opportunity
  860. 36:01because in this audio or in this video
  861. 36:03there's a thing like it it she says you
  862. 36:06choked me
  863. 36:07I would be on that and I would say well
  864. 36:11I know you don't want to listen to it
  865. 36:12I'm sorry we don't have to do that right
  866. 36:14now we're going to have to but I wanted
  867. 36:17to ask you about one thing in there when
  868. 36:19it said he was choking you and that
  869. 36:22happened to my sister
  870. 36:24and it's disgusting and I wanted to ask
  871. 36:27you if that is a true statement or you
  872. 36:30made that up
  873. 36:31so now we can get clarity there and now
  874. 36:34we're starting to project
  875. 36:36and and which right after this
  876. 36:38rationalization we've shown that it's
  877. 36:40she's susceptible to that boom project
  878. 36:42I'm gonna leave the rest of it alone
  879. 36:45this video if you watch this video again
  880. 36:48which you're going to right after uh I
  881. 36:50finished talking here this is as if you
  882. 36:53interviewed Dwight Schrute from Dunder
  883. 36:55Mifflin that's the character we're
  884. 36:58seeing across the table there
  885. 37:01so I got
  886. 37:03all right
  887. 37:04I want to go yeah yeah Mark Cuban uh you
  888. 37:09can have a turn this time yeah let me
  889. 37:10jump let me jump in uh look uh look here
  890. 37:14would be my structure okay watch and
  891. 37:17listen watch and listen watch and listen
  892. 37:20and ask questions out of curiosity and
  893. 37:24there's this moment right up the front
  894. 37:26where she Retreats right back it's a big
  895. 37:29movement from her her Baseline of being
  896. 37:32subdued by gravity she goes right back
  897. 37:34and she says I don't want to watch it
  898. 37:36please I don't want to watch it please
  899. 37:38well my question having seen that and
  900. 37:42heard what she said my question out of
  901. 37:44curiosity would be what what most causes
  902. 37:48you want to not want to watch this
  903. 37:50I mean it's just a curious question
  904. 37:52maybe it'll get me somewhere maybe it'll
  905. 37:54get me nowhere but it isn't arguing with
  906. 37:57her and just as everybody else has said
  907. 38:00they are just arguing with her they're
  908. 38:02literally putting forward what they have
  909. 38:04as evidence good evidence yeah and then
  910. 38:08she's responding and then they're
  911. 38:10arguing with her response and so
  912. 38:13everyone's getting frustrated as far as
  913. 38:16I can see everybody's getting frustrated
  914. 38:20um they talk over each other they all
  915. 38:22talk over each other she ends up
  916. 38:25standing up and helping out at that
  917. 38:28point I would go she's in control now
  918. 38:31it's like I'm almost on her side going
  919. 38:34take it take this one why not why not
  920. 38:38take this one like you got this one now
  921. 38:40he's there he's
  922. 38:42exhaling it's clear indicators of his
  923. 38:46his frustration or boredom or I think
  924. 38:49both upset effect with it the the the
  925. 38:52the female interviewer is mirroring and
  926. 38:57escalating her tone so not only is it
  927. 38:59argumentative but she's taking the same
  928. 39:02tone as the subject and then they're
  929. 39:04escalating each other uh and the male
  930. 39:07just continues to get kind of irritated
  931. 39:10and restless and and just as you were
  932. 39:13saying right up the front Scott right
  933. 39:15here is my last note I've got who is in
  934. 39:17control here who's in control here like
  935. 39:21nobody's in control apart from the
  936. 39:23subject I think who is in the most
  937. 39:25control there but but then kind of gives
  938. 39:28it up because I don't think she quite
  939. 39:29knows how to take control of this moment
  940. 39:32I would I I think God has said well I'll
  941. 39:36be going now and um you know give me a
  942. 39:38call when you've sorted out your Tech
  943. 39:40and stuff and you got you've got you
  944. 39:42together I'd have been out of there wow
  945. 39:45Mark uses Mark cusses wow
  946. 39:48wow that's a that's a first not bad it's
  947. 39:51that two and a half years and there it
  948. 39:53is wow unbelievable unbelievable all
  949. 39:57right if you don't know who we are we're
  950. 39:58the behavior panel and I'm Scott Rouse
  951. 40:00I'm a body language expert and analyst
  952. 40:01and I trained law enforcement in the
  953. 40:03military and interrogation and Body
  954. 40:04Language I created the number one online
  955. 40:06body language course body language
  956. 40:08tactics with Greg Hartley mark
  957. 40:10I'm Mark Bowden I've been expert in
  958. 40:12human behavior and Body Language help
  959. 40:13people all over the world to stand out
  960. 40:15Wind Trust and gain credibility every
  961. 40:17time they communicate including some of
  962. 40:19the leaders of the G7 Chase
  963. 40:21bam Chase used it in 20 years in the U.S
  964. 40:23military roughly number one best-selling
  965. 40:25book on Behavior profiling persuasion
  966. 40:27and influence can I change people's
  967. 40:29lives teaching those things today Greg
  968. 40:32Greg Hartley I'm a former Army
  969. 40:34interrogator interrogation instructor
  970. 40:35resistance to interrogation instructor
  971. 40:37I've written 10 books on body language
  972. 40:38and behavior and put together that
  973. 40:40number one body language course at body
  974. 40:42language tactics.com with Scott Rouse
  975. 40:46Mark said [Β __Β ]
  976. 40:49yeah this is some of the worst I've ever
  977. 40:51seen you know what I wonder what I
  978. 40:53wonder do they think this video is
  979. 40:54enough they don't need her to say
  980. 40:56anything
  981. 40:56I thought about that too I thought about
  982. 40:59that too and I thought maybe exactly
  983. 41:01what maybe they're trying to go for the
  984. 41:03I did it on purpose thing but they can't
  985. 41:06because they're they're they they have a
  986. 41:08goal but they don't know how to get
  987. 41:10there no it's just a picture they're not
  988. 41:13there's not enough conspiracy between
  989. 41:15them there's not enough they're not
  990. 41:16reading nothing they're not a
  991. 41:18partnership they're all over the shop I
  992. 41:20mean if you and I when if any of us went
  993. 41:22hey let's go in but let's really mess
  994. 41:25this one up we'd be doing it together
  995. 41:27we'd be like exactly a great performance
  996. 41:30of life
  997. 41:32you know failure of a computer you know
  998. 41:35that would cause a reaction like this is
  999. 41:38just uh it's a show yeah they just don't
  1000. 41:42know what look I can tell they don't
  1001. 41:43know what they're doing it's that part's
  1002. 41:45very clear because they don't know
  1003. 41:46anything about the psychology part of it
  1004. 41:48any approaches no structure to the
  1005. 41:50interrogation of questioning
  1006. 41:53okay
  1007. 41:55last last time we talked to you you had
  1008. 41:57said that you put him in the suitcase he
  1009. 42:00had two fingers hanging out right
  1010. 42:04I flipped him over and that's where it
  1011. 42:06was
  1012. 42:07right there's two different videos and a
  1013. 42:10still picture where yeah it shows you
  1014. 42:12flipping them in different positions and
  1015. 42:14him saying that he can't breathe and
  1016. 42:16you're saying put it upside down so in
  1017. 42:19order for him to have gotten into it it
  1018. 42:22was flipped up right it just looked
  1019. 42:24abnormal yeah like is if you're packing
  1020. 42:27something so this is upside down guys
  1021. 42:29this is killing me right now so this
  1022. 42:31image is upside down and then this small
  1023. 42:34video that occurred 11 minutes later it
  1024. 42:39slipped over the other way
  1025. 42:42closer to your dining room table okay
  1026. 42:45now he's obviously still in there so he
  1027. 42:48didn't how did that how did it go from
  1028. 42:49the back to the front I flipped it okay
  1029. 42:54my plan was not to go upstairs and go to
  1030. 42:56sleep
  1031. 42:58well that's what you did yeah but not
  1032. 43:01intentional though no you told me you
  1033. 43:03went upstairs because what you were out
  1034. 43:06of here for bed stopped here okay but
  1035. 43:08first here show me where you can see any
  1036. 43:11fingers coming out because there's the
  1037. 43:13end
  1038. 43:14it's in his head's right here so going
  1039. 43:18like this
  1040. 43:19rather than going all the way up it's
  1041. 43:21like this
  1042. 43:23but why is he saying I can't breathe and
  1043. 43:26why is he pushing on it as if he can't
  1044. 43:28get out
  1045. 43:29and it doesn't show a hole there's no
  1046. 43:31hole there's no fingers I don't see his
  1047. 43:33fingers there's no hole I don't know
  1048. 43:36what you want me to tell you like I
  1049. 43:37don't know like what you want me to tell
  1050. 43:39you I'm just showing you I'm just
  1051. 43:41telling you what we see and what we've
  1052. 43:42heard from that I understand I
  1053. 43:44understand he's begging to let for you
  1054. 43:47to let him out
  1055. 43:48you sound you're laughing in the
  1056. 43:51beginning and then in the end it sounds
  1057. 43:53kind of like a no it's not malicious
  1058. 43:56well same
  1059. 43:58it's not malicious then what is that
  1060. 44:01what does you mean to you
  1061. 44:04well like if you're just if I were to
  1062. 44:06tell me I like cheetahs like I get
  1063. 44:09called Everything by a white woman so
  1064. 44:11okay I my intention was not to leave him
  1065. 44:15in there
  1066. 44:17please understand that my intention was
  1067. 44:20not to leave him in there but you went
  1068. 44:23upstairs thinking that he could get
  1069. 44:24himself out but the video shows
  1070. 44:28and I seen his fingers
  1071. 44:32and then 30 minutes later he didn't show
  1072. 44:34and he's telling him
  1073. 44:37do you think you told me he was laughing
  1074. 44:40and I we were
  1075. 44:43here
  1076. 44:46both of us were so how long was he in
  1077. 44:47there for like this video is at 11 12
  1078. 44:50when it starts so was he in there for
  1079. 44:52like a long time prior did you know
  1080. 44:54recording this no
  1081. 44:55no
  1082. 44:57so it goes from funny to no longer funny
  1083. 44:59but you're the only one laughing but I
  1084. 45:02didn't think that he
  1085. 45:04was wait panicky like I didn't I so
  1086. 45:08pushing Up On A Suitcase saying Sarah
  1087. 45:11Sarah
  1088. 45:12I can't breathe
  1089. 45:15George has done that in the past before
  1090. 45:17too where it's just like he thinks that
  1091. 45:19he's well with me kind of thing where
  1092. 45:21it's like he's never been lost in a
  1093. 45:23suitcase but no he couldn't get out so
  1094. 45:24it's kind of I thought it was you know
  1095. 45:26the oxygen crawling walls crying wolf
  1096. 45:28kind of thing okay and again but nowhere
  1097. 45:32in there is he laughing is he joking he
  1098. 45:35is begging
  1099. 45:36and you're the only one laughing okay
  1100. 45:39and you're the only one saying
  1101. 45:41derogatory comments like you're mad no
  1102. 45:46please don't I don't mean to sound
  1103. 45:49negative and I don't know if I can say
  1104. 45:51this but like it's like you guys are
  1105. 45:53kind of trying to like feed me like no
  1106. 45:55I'm just trying to show you a video that
  1107. 45:56you no longer want to watch because you
  1108. 45:58probably don't want to know the outcome
  1109. 45:59of how and what you said well I know
  1110. 46:02what
  1111. 46:03what you know you know what's on that
  1112. 46:05video now no you remember making that
  1113. 46:06video oh why don't you remember making
  1114. 46:09the video probably because we had been
  1115. 46:11drinking but you weren't drunk
  1116. 46:13no just because I went upstairs and just
  1117. 46:17because you're wrong
  1118. 46:18but you were not drunk you said that you
  1119. 46:21had your way about you you said he had
  1120. 46:23his lips about you you said that you
  1121. 46:27don't like not having your whips in my
  1122. 46:29experience if somebody cannot remember
  1123. 46:31doing something to the extent of making
  1124. 46:34two videos and a video and taking a
  1125. 46:36photo
  1126. 46:38they are intoxicated okay I understand
  1127. 46:41where you all are coming from well I
  1128. 46:43can't try to make sense of it we're
  1129. 46:44trying to figure out we're trying to
  1130. 46:45figure out
  1131. 46:46Chase what he got
  1132. 46:48this precisely right here is where
  1133. 46:51knowing Behavior comes in handy the
  1134. 46:54interviewers are
  1135. 46:56trying to do their best I think but I
  1136. 46:59think they're making what I call the
  1137. 47:01academic Folly they're treating everyone
  1138. 47:03as if they all respond to the exact same
  1139. 47:06thing
  1140. 47:07and the reason this is so different from
  1141. 47:09other interrogations you've seen is that
  1142. 47:11in many of the other videos the
  1143. 47:12interrogators needed confessions and
  1144. 47:15admissions to both place the suspect at
  1145. 47:18the scene to begin with and then to get
  1146. 47:21them to admit some form of involvement
  1147. 47:23we have those two things known so maybe
  1148. 47:26they had some level of training and they
  1149. 47:29thought that they could kind of skip
  1150. 47:30forward in the process I'm not sure what
  1151. 47:33was going on
  1152. 47:34but every point of resistance you are
  1153. 47:36seeing here every single point could
  1154. 47:38have been prevented by knowing just a
  1155. 47:40tiny bit about Behavior Uh profile I put
  1156. 47:43together in the previous video based on
  1157. 47:45a 29 second clip of of her talking to a
  1158. 47:48police officer all of that could have
  1159. 47:50been prevented by just knowing that one
  1160. 47:5229 seconds of time Greg
  1161. 47:55yeah let me tell you this I don't think
  1162. 47:57you even need to be that smart to get
  1163. 47:58this one Chase I think what has to
  1164. 48:00happen is you just need to listen to
  1165. 48:01what she's saying and she's feeding you
  1166. 48:04exactly the story she's spoon feeding
  1167. 48:07them the elements of getting her to talk
  1168. 48:08because what she says out loud was they
  1169. 48:11just don't use it he's abusive he's all
  1170. 48:13the time up for fun things he fakes
  1171. 48:16neediness
  1172. 48:17it sounds like he got in there
  1173. 48:18voluntarily then he he panicked or fakes
  1174. 48:21panic and easily I would say did you
  1175. 48:23feel powerful because he'd always been
  1176. 48:25rough with you yeah I did and then you
  1177. 48:28thought he would be able to escape
  1178. 48:29because you left him a little Gap yep
  1179. 48:31and I would give her the point where she
  1180. 48:32said I went upstairs I and then I went
  1181. 48:35to bed and I didn't think about it and I
  1182. 48:37would then close the loop and come back
  1183. 48:38and say if that's the case why were you
  1184. 48:41so concerned about going upstairs in the
  1185. 48:42beginning you said it wasn't part of
  1186. 48:44your plan you can't have it both ways
  1187. 48:45you didn't leave him an air gap and then
  1188. 48:47go upstairs and that not be part of your
  1189. 48:49plan you've got an issue here now I
  1190. 48:51could force her into a corner where she
  1191. 48:52has to come out swinging and give me
  1192. 48:55something I don't think she is smart
  1193. 48:56enough to do that and I think you could
  1194. 48:59put her at odds with herself when she's
  1195. 49:00assaulted with that you're the only one
  1196. 49:03piece I thought she's going to go back
  1197. 49:04and say I need a lawyer because she
  1198. 49:06started to back off pretty hard right
  1199. 49:07there she threw up both hands and said
  1200. 49:10that's not how it went I think you guys
  1201. 49:12are trying to feed me
  1202. 49:14my God if you've ever been in a place
  1203. 49:17where a person's giving you the
  1204. 49:19information you need to break her
  1205. 49:21but they don't
  1206. 49:23the guy steps on her and says no he's
  1207. 49:26got a plan and he's going to stick to
  1208. 49:28that plan in the Army we have goes and
  1209. 49:30no-go's at stations meaning you pass
  1210. 49:32this station you guys are a no-go this
  1211. 49:35is a no-go all day every day Mark what
  1212. 49:38do you got yeah so look everybody's
  1213. 49:40confounded everybody's irritated
  1214. 49:42everybody's confused until the subject
  1215. 49:45uh says
  1216. 49:47um I see where you're coming from she's
  1217. 49:50a better interviewer than they are she's
  1218. 49:52like I see where you're coming from I
  1219. 49:54get it I get it so she started to build
  1220. 49:57the bridge towards them but what do they
  1221. 50:00do well he says well we're just trying
  1222. 50:03to and then continues and they both pile
  1223. 50:06on top of that she accepts she agrees I
  1224. 50:10see where you're coming from I get it I
  1225. 50:12get it well we're just trying to and
  1226. 50:13then they pile on instead of what they
  1227. 50:15could do at this point to become maybe a
  1228. 50:17go which would be to say thank you
  1229. 50:20thanks for that I'm sorry we've had to
  1230. 50:22argue about this let's start again start
  1231. 50:25afresh Clean Slate take us through it
  1232. 50:28what happened from the start it'd be a
  1233. 50:31great time to just reset now she's in
  1234. 50:34now she's trying to make agreement I
  1235. 50:37think she's trying to make agreement
  1236. 50:38because it's chaos there and she's under
  1237. 50:41stress and she needs to know somebody's
  1238. 50:44in control somebody's calling this one
  1239. 50:46so she's going to start calling it and
  1240. 50:48creating the the Concord and the
  1241. 50:51agreement uh Scott what do you got on
  1242. 50:53this one
  1243. 50:54the fact that this detective has has his
  1244. 50:57phone out and is texting and returning
  1245. 50:59emails is bananas I've never seen that
  1246. 51:02before never heard of that before it's
  1247. 51:05CR and the further this interrogation
  1248. 51:06goes the more it becomes like that Meme
  1249. 51:08where that those two women are sitting
  1250. 51:10at a table and there's a cat on the
  1251. 51:12other side and they're yelling at the
  1252. 51:13cat that's what that reminds that's what
  1253. 51:15this is starting to remind me of it's
  1254. 51:17just there's there's no reason for this
  1255. 51:19this is I keep saying the same thing but
  1256. 51:21nobody's in charge nobody's in control
  1257. 51:22here she's answering the questions
  1258. 51:25they're asking her she's answering them
  1259. 51:27she's told them about 40 times this
  1260. 51:30wasn't an accident she's saying yeah I
  1261. 51:32did it but it wasn't an accident
  1262. 51:34and they're not doing anything about it
  1263. 51:36they're they're they it's okay yeah and
  1264. 51:39it gets back to texting unbelievable
  1265. 51:41unbelievable I'll leave it there
  1266. 51:45both of us were so how long was he in
  1267. 51:46there for like this video is at 11 12
  1268. 51:49when it starts so was he in there for
  1269. 51:51like a long time prior to that recording
  1270. 51:53this no
  1271. 51:54no
  1272. 51:56so it goes from funny to no longer funny
  1273. 51:58but you're the only one laughing but I
  1274. 52:01didn't think that he
  1275. 52:03was like panicky like I didn't I so
  1276. 52:07pushing Up On A Suitcase saying Sarah
  1277. 52:10Sarah Sarah
  1278. 52:11I can't breathe
  1279. 52:14George has done that in the past before
  1280. 52:16too where it's just like he thinks that
  1281. 52:18he's well with me kind of thing where
  1282. 52:20it's like he's never been lost in a
  1283. 52:22suitcase that no he couldn't get out so
  1284. 52:23it's kind of I thought it was you know
  1285. 52:26crying wolf kind of thing okay and again
  1286. 52:29but nowhere in there is he laughing is
  1287. 52:33he joking he is begging
  1288. 52:35and you're the only one laughing okay
  1289. 52:38and you're the only one saying
  1290. 52:40derogatory comments like you're mad no
  1291. 52:45please don't I don't mean to sound
  1292. 52:48negative and I don't know if I can say
  1293. 52:50this but like it's like you guys are
  1294. 52:52kind of trying to like feed me like no
  1295. 52:54I'm just trying to show you a video that
  1296. 52:55you no longer want to watch because you
  1297. 52:57probably don't want to know the outcome
  1298. 52:58of how and what you said well I know
  1299. 53:01what
  1300. 53:02you know you know what's on that video
  1301. 53:04now no you remember making that video oh
  1302. 53:06why don't you remember making the video
  1303. 53:08probably because we had been drinking
  1304. 53:10but you weren't drunk
  1305. 53:12no just because I went upstairs and just
  1306. 53:16because you're wrong doesn't mean that
  1307. 53:17you sometimes that you were not drunk
  1308. 53:19you said that you had your way about you
  1309. 53:21you said he had his lips about you you
  1310. 53:24said that you don't like not having your
  1311. 53:27whips in my experience if somebody
  1312. 53:29cannot remember doing something to the
  1313. 53:32extent of making two videos and a video
  1314. 53:35and taking a photo
  1315. 53:37they are intoxicated okay I understand
  1316. 53:40where you all are coming from well I
  1317. 53:42can't try to make sense of it we're
  1318. 53:43trying to figure out we're trying to
  1319. 53:44figure out
  1320. 53:46the camera
  1321. 53:48it makes sense of it we're trying to
  1322. 53:50figure out we're trying to figure out
  1323. 53:51this videos we're listening
  1324. 53:54I just did like we were playing and then
  1325. 53:58like I thought it was
  1326. 54:02my plan was not to go upstairs and go to
  1327. 54:06sleep my plan was not to he'll be up
  1328. 54:08here any minute
  1329. 54:09but you willingly went upstairs and went
  1330. 54:12to sleep no one forced you to go
  1331. 54:13upstairs and my pain wasn't also to
  1332. 54:15leave him in the suitcase
  1333. 54:17so why didn't you take him out because I
  1334. 54:20went upstairs and then I fell asleep but
  1335. 54:22why didn't you consciously think
  1336. 54:25he's asking to come out I didn't do it
  1337. 54:27intentionally
  1338. 54:28what do you think is going to happen if
  1339. 54:30you
  1340. 54:31leave a confined space like
  1341. 54:33that well I thought by not tipping it up
  1342. 54:36all the way it would be okay my plan was
  1343. 54:39not to leave him in what was your plan
  1344. 54:44waiting for him to come upstairs
  1345. 54:46and then when he did it
  1346. 54:48I fell asleep you said you were up there
  1347. 54:5130 minutes after 30 minutes somebody not
  1348. 54:53coming up
  1349. 54:55knowing that you that the last time you
  1350. 54:57saw him was in the suitcase 30 minutes
  1351. 54:58later you're like
  1352. 55:00um maybe I should go check on him maybe
  1353. 55:02I shouldn't no
  1354. 55:04that didn't cross your mind because like
  1355. 55:07that's like an assumption like that's
  1356. 55:08what you all are thinking just we're
  1357. 55:11asking it's the whole show
  1358. 55:14it's the drinking
  1359. 55:18that's what it is
  1360. 55:21it's the drinking
  1361. 55:23I thought it was like
  1362. 55:25I thought he was okay like I didn't that
  1363. 55:28you are telling you he's not he's
  1364. 55:30telling you Sarah I can't breathe he's
  1365. 55:32saying your name and you're like that's
  1366. 55:34my name don't wear it out
  1367. 55:35guys
  1368. 55:36that's how we are with each other like
  1369. 55:40he has
  1370. 55:42nobody understands our relationship this
  1371. 55:45this whole suitcase thing
  1372. 55:48never happened before would you leave
  1373. 55:50someone else in a suitcase all right
  1374. 55:52Mark what do you got yeah so look her
  1375. 55:56strategy I think is that to put forward
  1376. 55:58that it isn't premeditated in any way
  1377. 56:01and either that's because she
  1378. 56:02understands something of the law and
  1379. 56:04something of of of
  1380. 56:07um of what she could get convicted on
  1381. 56:10and what the sentence would be or she
  1382. 56:13just knows that that's a a better idea
  1383. 56:16uh to say that she's involved obviously
  1384. 56:19but but but it's an accident and there
  1385. 56:22is no forethought around it premeditated
  1386. 56:25murder is is obviously as as pretty much
  1387. 56:27as strong as you can get
  1388. 56:29um so but the the male is always showing
  1389. 56:32disagreement pursed lips clear pursed
  1390. 56:36lips as well to show disagreement closed
  1391. 56:40and protective
  1392. 56:41this is not great body language I mean
  1393. 56:44it could be a tactic but I think by this
  1394. 56:46point we know it's not it's his demeanor
  1395. 56:49it's his demeanor within this he's he's
  1396. 56:51closed now what's
  1397. 56:54what's this turning into well they're
  1398. 56:57not they're never entering into her idea
  1399. 57:01you don't have to agree with the world
  1400. 57:03that she's in but you've got to accept
  1401. 57:05that that's her world and except and if
  1402. 57:08you know she's lying just accept that
  1403. 57:11world for a bit to get in there with her
  1404. 57:13uh they're trying to undo that world
  1405. 57:16from outside they're trying to show
  1406. 57:18evidence and go well whatever you're set
  1407. 57:20you're saying doesn't fit with this
  1408. 57:22outside idea what I would suggest they
  1409. 57:25should be doing is getting inside the
  1410. 57:27world and dismantling it from within
  1411. 57:30from a sense of agreement from a sense
  1412. 57:32of accord and just unpicking it from
  1413. 57:35inside rather than outside so they're
  1414. 57:37being judgmental they make judgment
  1415. 57:39calls they're being moral whether
  1416. 57:42they're kind of going well you know why
  1417. 57:44why would you do that you know well
  1418. 57:46that's not the right thing to do well
  1419. 57:47that's just judgment and morals and and
  1420. 57:50also they're attacking the Norms of
  1421. 57:53relationship she puts a norm forward
  1422. 57:54that says hey you know it's kind of a
  1423. 57:57thing you do is to stick somebody in a
  1424. 57:58suitcase and kind of play around with
  1425. 58:01that well look it may not be a norm for
  1426. 58:03me or a norm for you but you've got to
  1427. 58:05get an acceptance of that Norm to be
  1428. 58:08able to unpick it from the outside
  1429. 58:09they're arguing the idea let's go it's
  1430. 58:12going nowhere good uh Scott what do you
  1431. 58:14got on this one all right he says you
  1432. 58:17explain it to us we're listening and
  1433. 58:19then he looks down at his phone and
  1434. 58:20doesn't pay attention to her anymore
  1435. 58:22then she's still in protective mode like
  1436. 58:24you're saying she's got her arms really
  1437. 58:26close to her body all that it's it's
  1438. 58:28staying with her Baseline of the of the
  1439. 58:30behaviors we've seen at this point and
  1440. 58:33again the guy detective looks like he's
  1441. 58:35the one being questioned he's sitting
  1442. 58:37back in his chair he's got his arms
  1443. 58:38crossed he's moving around he looks
  1444. 58:40nervous he's touching his face
  1445. 58:41everything else he's adapting with his
  1446. 58:43hands everything he looks like he's the
  1447. 58:45one in trouble then out of nowhere she
  1448. 58:48says because when I went upstairs then I
  1449. 58:50fell asleep
  1450. 58:51his open-handed gesture comes out when
  1451. 58:53hers does out of nowhere and he says
  1452. 58:55nothing and he's just distracting at
  1453. 58:57this point he's just I don't know what
  1454. 58:59this guy's doing at this point and she
  1455. 59:00says I didn't do it intentionally boom
  1456. 59:03there it is again we're done all you got
  1457. 59:05to do is move move forward from that
  1458. 59:07point say okay well shoot let's talk
  1459. 59:09about that nobody does that nobody does
  1460. 59:12that but he says so what do you think is
  1461. 59:15going to happen if you leave someone who
  1462. 59:16can spot a confined space like that he's
  1463. 59:18not even listed at that point he's not
  1464. 59:19listening he's not even looking at her
  1465. 59:21and I don't think he has I don't think
  1466. 59:23he knows what's going on and I agree
  1467. 59:24with you chase a lot of detectives
  1468. 59:27haven't had training but
  1469. 59:30this is this isn't good because somebody
  1470. 59:32may go to prison that doesn't need to go
  1471. 59:34to prison because these people will get
  1472. 59:36it wrong they'll push them into it and
  1473. 59:37won't realize they're seeing a false
  1474. 59:39confession
  1475. 59:40and that this this worries me this
  1476. 59:42worries me they need to call somebody
  1477. 59:43and get some help down there in Florida
  1478. 59:46quick
  1479. 59:47Greg what do you got
  1480. 59:52[Music]
  1481. 1:00:00foreign
  1482. 1:00:10hey it's Dr Phil here please subscribe
  1483. 1:00:13to the behavior panel
  1484. 1:00:14[Music]
  1485. 1:00:22next
  1486. 1:00:26you you wouldn't have gotten me but I
  1487. 1:00:28covered it up when I was reading all
  1488. 1:00:29this from the statute
  1489. 1:00:33okay here you go let's see if I can go
  1490. 1:00:36find it take me again again a second now
  1491. 1:00:40all right man this time yeah so there
  1492. 1:00:44really are just told them now you gotta
  1493. 1:00:47wait for me sorry go get it good all the
  1494. 1:00:49time in the world all right go ahead uh
  1495. 1:00:53okay so state courts have ruled that
  1496. 1:00:55this is murder too a killing that was
  1497. 1:00:58the result of ill will hatred spider
  1498. 1:01:00evil intent an act of a person that a
  1499. 1:01:03person of ordinary judgment would know
  1500. 1:01:05is reasonably certain to kill or cause
  1501. 1:01:07seriously body injury bodily injury or
  1502. 1:01:09an act showing the difference to human
  1503. 1:01:11life what sure feels like they're trying
  1504. 1:01:12to force her to say I knew it would kill
  1505. 1:01:14him and I made a mistake or whatever
  1506. 1:01:17because intent is there then that's all
  1507. 1:01:19they have to do maybe that's what
  1508. 1:01:21they're after is an element they're
  1509. 1:01:22trying to close the loop on but look the
  1510. 1:01:26one thing I firmly disagree is when he
  1511. 1:01:28says we're listening no you're not
  1512. 1:01:29listening he gets right one thing he
  1513. 1:01:32does one thing he mirrors her and it
  1514. 1:01:34actually makes sense she goes what am I
  1515. 1:01:37to do and he's like you know that kind
  1516. 1:01:39of thing he throws his hands out again
  1517. 1:01:40they miss a great lead there's the word
  1518. 1:01:43plan I would lean in and say Sarah what
  1519. 1:01:45was your plan was this a way to show him
  1520. 1:01:47how powerless you feel when he's in that
  1521. 1:01:49suitcase and something went wrong give
  1522. 1:01:51her the opportunity give her the out
  1523. 1:01:52give her a rationalization instead it
  1524. 1:01:55goes back to one more of this argument
  1525. 1:01:57in circular logic she now says her plan
  1526. 1:02:00was to go upstairs and wait for him
  1527. 1:02:03wait a minute if we go all the way back
  1528. 1:02:05to what I told you in the very beginning
  1529. 1:02:06and we say I didn't go upstairs
  1530. 1:02:09intentionally I left an air gap because
  1531. 1:02:12I knew he would it was not safe now
  1532. 1:02:15you're telling me you went upstairs and
  1533. 1:02:16that was in your plan you're going to
  1534. 1:02:17wait for him now you just admitted to me
  1535. 1:02:19that you know you put him in bodily harm
  1536. 1:02:21and you caused element three of that law
  1537. 1:02:24now you got him but there's here's the
  1538. 1:02:28now they allow her to have a chance she
  1539. 1:02:30set up the alcohol day one that's a
  1540. 1:02:32rescuer she's been saying I only had one
  1541. 1:02:35bottle of alcohol between the two of us
  1542. 1:02:37and now she's changing that she does
  1543. 1:02:39helplessness and she looks at each of
  1544. 1:02:41them with good intent she signals with
  1545. 1:02:44regulators and she says I thought he was
  1546. 1:02:46okay there's a lot of control there and
  1547. 1:02:49they go back at her instead of eliciting
  1548. 1:02:51and Challenger again
  1549. 1:02:53if you just would pay a little bit of
  1550. 1:02:55attention you you would get somewhere
  1551. 1:02:57Instead This detective instead of saying
  1552. 1:02:59what do you think would happen forgets
  1553. 1:03:01everything the woman's saying and jumps
  1554. 1:03:03right on and says would you leave
  1555. 1:03:04someone else in the suitcase altercation
  1556. 1:03:06again I think what she's they're trying
  1557. 1:03:07to do is push him to that third element
  1558. 1:03:09but if you look at every one of these
  1559. 1:03:11videos we've shown each of those is a
  1560. 1:03:13standalone there's no sequitur between
  1561. 1:03:15these pieces if you look at this one
  1562. 1:03:18it's an argument the first one's an
  1563. 1:03:19argument the second one's an argument
  1564. 1:03:20it's just there's no power to it that's
  1565. 1:03:22all I got uh who don't forget
  1566. 1:03:25Chase Chase what do you got yeah I'll be
  1567. 1:03:28quick here this assault on her character
  1568. 1:03:31is what's causing this resistance and
  1569. 1:03:34you already know that because of the
  1570. 1:03:36behavior profile
  1571. 1:03:37so how would you have used that behavior
  1572. 1:03:40profile I'm curious to know what you
  1573. 1:03:42would have done at home let us know in
  1574. 1:03:44the comments we'll take a look
  1575. 1:03:46so what could have been done here is to
  1576. 1:03:49demonize or shift the blame to the
  1577. 1:03:51victim this sounds horrible it sounds
  1578. 1:03:54atrocious but it's extremely effective
  1579. 1:03:57in getting guilty people to confess in
  1580. 1:03:59many cases just like this one thousands
  1581. 1:04:02of confessions were obtained guilt by
  1582. 1:04:04guilty people by blaming the victim for
  1583. 1:04:07the crime initially and this is called
  1584. 1:04:08projection in many many cases and this
  1585. 1:04:11is a common tactic that has proven to be
  1586. 1:04:13extremely effective if they built a
  1587. 1:04:15narrative focused on how she tried hard
  1588. 1:04:18to take care of him he's been abusive
  1589. 1:04:20and mean and violent Etc then the
  1590. 1:04:23interrogator shifts to socializing
  1591. 1:04:25wherein they would start making it these
  1592. 1:04:27are two or two things right so then
  1593. 1:04:30they're going to start making it normal
  1594. 1:04:31they'd say something like anybody would
  1595. 1:04:33have done that it's totally
  1596. 1:04:34understandable people are going to
  1597. 1:04:36understand this and that's why I came in
  1598. 1:04:38here to help you this would be
  1599. 1:04:40especially effective just based on her
  1600. 1:04:42profile that we developed in 29 seconds
  1601. 1:04:44so this is a formula for this behavioral
  1602. 1:04:48type where projection leads the way in
  1603. 1:04:51the interrogation so in some
  1604. 1:04:53interrogations you want to minimize then
  1605. 1:04:55socialize and then rationalize this one
  1606. 1:04:58you want to project the brain socialize
  1607. 1:05:01the actions that the person took
  1608. 1:05:02minimize the seriousness rationalize the
  1609. 1:05:05motive for taking action and that would
  1610. 1:05:07have probably cleaned the table even
  1611. 1:05:10Scott was saying that she's
  1612. 1:05:11pre-confession she's kind of just ready
  1613. 1:05:12the whole time get that out there it
  1614. 1:05:15looked like that would have been a short
  1615. 1:05:17discussion like an un sub 45-minute
  1616. 1:05:21interrogation that's all what did I say
  1617. 1:05:23Greg we were talking about the same
  1618. 1:05:25thing cops a new city yeah yeah so yeah
  1619. 1:05:29yeah you said you said 45 minute stops
  1620. 1:05:31and I just said look this is a falling
  1621. 1:05:32off a log easy went five minutes into it
  1622. 1:05:34she's already starting to believe
  1623. 1:05:36done but if it's altered I agree with
  1624. 1:05:39you chase that's not in her personality
  1625. 1:05:40you can't go ahead Long Island
  1626. 1:05:42yeah I understand where you all are
  1627. 1:05:45coming from well I can't try to make
  1628. 1:05:47sense of it we're trying to figure out
  1629. 1:05:48we're trying to figure out
  1630. 1:05:50we're listening
  1631. 1:05:52I just did like we were playing and then
  1632. 1:05:56like I thought it was
  1633. 1:06:00my plan was not to go upstairs and go to
  1634. 1:06:03sleep my plan was not he'll be up here
  1635. 1:06:06any minute
  1636. 1:06:07but you willingly went upstairs and went
  1637. 1:06:10to sleep no one forced you to go
  1638. 1:06:11upstairs and my pain wasn't also to
  1639. 1:06:13leave him in the suitcase
  1640. 1:06:15so why didn't you take him out because I
  1641. 1:06:18went upstairs and then I fell asleep but
  1642. 1:06:21why didn't you consciously think
  1643. 1:06:23he's asking to come out I didn't do it
  1644. 1:06:25intentionally
  1645. 1:06:26what do you think is going to happen if
  1646. 1:06:28you leave some
  1647. 1:06:34leave something by the way it would be
  1648. 1:06:36okay my plan was not to leave him in the
  1649. 1:06:40world
  1650. 1:06:42waiting for him to come upstairs
  1651. 1:06:44and then when he did it
  1652. 1:06:46I fell asleep you said you were up there
  1653. 1:06:4930 minutes after 30 minutes somebody not
  1654. 1:06:51coming up
  1655. 1:06:53knowing that you that the last time you
  1656. 1:06:55saw him was in the suitcase 30 minutes
  1657. 1:06:56later you're like
  1658. 1:06:58um maybe I should go check on him maybe
  1659. 1:07:01I shouldn't no
  1660. 1:07:03well that didn't cross your mind because
  1661. 1:07:04like that's like an assumption like
  1662. 1:07:06that's what you all are thinking just
  1663. 1:07:08we're asking it's the whole house
  1664. 1:07:12it's the drinking
  1665. 1:07:17that's what it is
  1666. 1:07:19it's the drinking
  1667. 1:07:21I thought it was like I thought he was
  1668. 1:07:24okay like I didn't that you were telling
  1669. 1:07:27you he's not he's telling you Sarah I
  1670. 1:07:29can't breathe he saved her name and
  1671. 1:07:31you're like that's my name don't wear it
  1672. 1:07:33out
  1673. 1:07:33subscribe that's how we are with each
  1674. 1:07:37other like he has
  1675. 1:07:40nobody understands our relationship this
  1676. 1:07:43this whole suitcase thing
  1677. 1:07:46never happened before would you leave
  1678. 1:07:48someone else in a suitcase I think
  1679. 1:07:50someone that knows nothing about this or
  1680. 1:07:53hears just a little bit like oh they
  1681. 1:07:55were playing around in a suitcase
  1682. 1:07:57[Music]
  1683. 1:07:59that's what happened
  1684. 1:08:01but you let him out before I mean you
  1685. 1:08:02put them in so why don't you take them
  1686. 1:08:04out because I was upstairs when I fell
  1687. 1:08:06asleep
  1688. 1:08:07no before you go upstairs you like
  1689. 1:08:09consciously had to walk upstairs do you
  1690. 1:08:11I mean you obviously remember going to
  1691. 1:08:13bed because you remember giving me a
  1692. 1:08:14time frame on that and you specifically
  1693. 1:08:16told me that like upstairs
  1694. 1:08:19my intention is not for this to happen
  1695. 1:08:23I am sick about it
  1696. 1:08:27I've never done anything like this
  1697. 1:08:30before in the past I am sick
  1698. 1:08:34especially with that I thought I
  1699. 1:08:36couldn't sleep last night
  1700. 1:08:39I don't know here's the thing
  1701. 1:08:41you tell us the last night you you
  1702. 1:08:43vividly remember this when you told us
  1703. 1:08:45last night that he was laughing you were
  1704. 1:08:48laughing you put him in the suitcase he
  1705. 1:08:50has two fingers sticking out and you go
  1706. 1:08:51to bed now we see something totally
  1707. 1:08:53different and it actually shows you
  1708. 1:08:56upset and again using uh derogatory
  1709. 1:09:01terms to him when he's begging for his
  1710. 1:09:03life to get out of that suitcase so so
  1711. 1:09:06we're assuming we're not assuming
  1712. 1:09:08so it just happened to be that whenever
  1713. 1:09:11I was videotaping or doing whatever else
  1714. 1:09:13it was had just happened to not have
  1715. 1:09:15that in it okay
  1716. 1:09:17and you also in the video you can't see
  1717. 1:09:19any holes there's nowhere in that where
  1718. 1:09:22the zipper separates and you can see a
  1719. 1:09:24hole if there's a hole he's pushing on
  1720. 1:09:25it begging you to get out
  1721. 1:09:27we should probably see that
  1722. 1:09:30that hole this eventually would have
  1723. 1:09:32been able to get out alcohol based off
  1724. 1:09:34what you're telling us he should have
  1725. 1:09:35been able to get out but the video
  1726. 1:09:38shows him attempting to get out begging
  1727. 1:09:40to get out and he can't so that's that's
  1728. 1:09:42just what we're trying to figure out I
  1729. 1:09:44don't know if maybe you had too much to
  1730. 1:09:46drink you zipped it up all the way and
  1731. 1:09:47then you know I did not tip it up all
  1732. 1:09:49the way
  1733. 1:09:50okay well
  1734. 1:09:52I did not zip it up all the way
  1735. 1:09:57this is horrific okay
  1736. 1:09:59horrific
  1737. 1:10:00it is terrible
  1738. 1:10:03I don't think I'll ever be right because
  1739. 1:10:06of this ever be right
  1740. 1:10:08dealing with everything else that I have
  1741. 1:10:10in my life personally and then this okay
  1742. 1:10:13whom I loved
  1743. 1:10:17it was not intentional
  1744. 1:10:20I will put my hand on the Bible it was
  1745. 1:10:23not intentional
  1746. 1:10:25I would not do that to him nor anyone
  1747. 1:10:28else
  1748. 1:10:28but she did
  1749. 1:10:31not intentional you intentionally went
  1750. 1:10:34up to bed
  1751. 1:10:36because I'm thinking okay
  1752. 1:10:40how did you not intentionally go to bed
  1753. 1:10:42you said you went up to upstairs and got
  1754. 1:10:44into bed that's intentionally going to
  1755. 1:10:45bed waiting for him
  1756. 1:10:48if he doesn't come but you don't go down
  1757. 1:10:49to check on him so I happened to go to
  1758. 1:10:52sleep when I say go to sleep
  1759. 1:10:55what do you normally do when you go to
  1760. 1:10:57bed what do you mean what is a bed for
  1761. 1:11:00going to sleep right so you go
  1762. 1:11:03some people can tell you that like okay
  1763. 1:11:08all right Mark what do you got yep so uh
  1764. 1:11:11the female interviewer lint picking I'm
  1765. 1:11:14not not up here I'm just demonstrating
  1766. 1:11:16it up here so you can see it she's doing
  1767. 1:11:18it on a on a trousers or pants
  1768. 1:11:20um a a clear show of disinterest which
  1769. 1:11:25is very similar Scott I think to the the
  1770. 1:11:28guy's previous show of disinterest by
  1771. 1:11:31being into his phone again no good
  1772. 1:11:33reason for that no good reason for lint
  1773. 1:11:36picking even if you had stuff all over
  1774. 1:11:39your pants
  1775. 1:11:40don't touch it it's not important so
  1776. 1:11:43you know I've even got like tactic
  1777. 1:11:45question mark because I was bemused by
  1778. 1:11:48that I was bemused as to whether they
  1779. 1:11:50you know had a conversation outside
  1780. 1:11:52should we do the lint picking router
  1781. 1:11:54yeah I'll do the lit you do the phone
  1782. 1:11:55thing I'll do the limp picking and
  1783. 1:11:58she'll Pro she'll she'll be done she'll
  1784. 1:12:00be done in in in 15 minutes if we do
  1785. 1:12:03that I just can't work out why they're
  1786. 1:12:07doing it she goes to uh victim
  1787. 1:12:11um you know what with everything that
  1788. 1:12:12I've had in my life you know pick up on
  1789. 1:12:15that I don't pick up on that you know be
  1790. 1:12:18again listen watch listen watch be
  1791. 1:12:21curious what do you mean by that would
  1792. 1:12:24be a great question yeah simple question
  1793. 1:12:26what do you mean what do you mean by
  1794. 1:12:28that what exactly what have you had in
  1795. 1:12:30your life that's had the most impact
  1796. 1:12:32what are you talking about you know
  1797. 1:12:33because then we as Chase was saying we
  1798. 1:12:35could get into that stuff well you know
  1799. 1:12:37he was beating me up and okay we could
  1800. 1:12:40socialize that and accept that and have
  1801. 1:12:43have a agreement with that no none of
  1802. 1:12:45that going on she goes for hand on the
  1803. 1:12:47Bible which is always a great indicator
  1804. 1:12:49that that that no good is is coming of
  1805. 1:12:52it and I loved him in uh in in past
  1806. 1:12:56again it's a day afterwards you know I
  1807. 1:12:59would expect I love I love him
  1808. 1:13:02you know even of the deceased I love him
  1809. 1:13:04yeah anyway not good at all uh Greg what
  1810. 1:13:08do you think yeah she's congruent in her
  1811. 1:13:11messaging when she says she'd been
  1812. 1:13:12drinking and went to sleep she goes back
  1813. 1:13:14look if you were paying attention if you
  1814. 1:13:16had a plan and you were setting a trap
  1815. 1:13:18you'd go all the way back to that
  1816. 1:13:20beginning argument well it wasn't your
  1817. 1:13:22plan to go upstairs and why did that
  1818. 1:13:24happen well I went upstairs and I was
  1819. 1:13:26waiting for him we've seen a lot of
  1820. 1:13:27anomalies but we don't see any tie back
  1821. 1:13:29to those interrogation steps we see a
  1822. 1:13:32lot of arguing right now and for that
  1823. 1:13:34reason I think this woman sees it as an
  1824. 1:13:36argument I don't think she has any idea
  1825. 1:13:37what kind of trouble she's in here
  1826. 1:13:39because she's arguing openly like you
  1827. 1:13:41would in school like you would argue
  1828. 1:13:43with your friends and try to win you
  1829. 1:13:45don't win with an interrogator who knows
  1830. 1:13:46what they're doing because anything they
  1831. 1:13:48do that lets you win is about the next
  1832. 1:13:50step in setting it up it isn't happening
  1833. 1:13:52here she doesn't think she's in that
  1834. 1:13:54much trouble her open posture will tell
  1835. 1:13:56you that she's doing this people close
  1836. 1:13:58up when they think that they're in
  1837. 1:13:59trouble
  1838. 1:14:00they let her talk a minute and she
  1839. 1:14:02starts to say alcohol and and then they
  1840. 1:14:05step on her again and when that happens
  1841. 1:14:06her body language goes to oppositional
  1842. 1:14:08she pushes back in the chair her hands
  1843. 1:14:12and feet are folded and then she does
  1844. 1:14:14that thing about me and her face
  1845. 1:14:16actually shows some disdain for the
  1846. 1:14:18interviewer here it's just powerful when
  1847. 1:14:20you see that that powerful look in her
  1848. 1:14:22face and then she starts to try to tell
  1849. 1:14:25you about her life she's like please
  1850. 1:14:29feel sorry for me and help me to confess
  1851. 1:14:32and tell you how this goes but we don't
  1852. 1:14:34do that we just go right back at it
  1853. 1:14:36again and there we go we just at the end
  1854. 1:14:38she's telling you what she believes and
  1855. 1:14:40you're attacking your logic Listen to If
  1856. 1:14:42you want to believe that go and listen
  1857. 1:14:44to what she does she's in a downward
  1858. 1:14:46telling tone and the the detective is an
  1859. 1:14:50upward lilting voice that she's asking
  1860. 1:14:53for approval really not a good place to
  1861. 1:14:55be this late in an interrogation Chase
  1862. 1:14:57what do you got yeah just kind of copy
  1863. 1:14:59paste whatever I said on the last video
  1864. 1:15:00he had a suspect that's desperate for
  1865. 1:15:03acceptance approval and pity and you're
  1866. 1:15:06giving them the exact opposite of what
  1867. 1:15:08they desire it's a recipe for absolute
  1868. 1:15:11uh and Rapid failure Mark uh I'm done
  1869. 1:15:15I've been oh yeah Scott sorry all right
  1870. 1:15:17all right yeah I agree with you chase
  1871. 1:15:19it's the same stuff we've seen before
  1872. 1:15:21there's there's no reason to keep doing
  1873. 1:15:23this whatsoever and what should have
  1874. 1:15:26happened if somebody's monitoring this
  1875. 1:15:27they should have stepped in and said
  1876. 1:15:29come here a minute man let me talk to
  1877. 1:15:30you a minute well either one of those
  1878. 1:15:31and said come here let's shut this down
  1879. 1:15:33this isn't this isn't what you I don't
  1880. 1:15:35know what you're doing we're gonna get
  1881. 1:15:35in trouble for this you know this this
  1882. 1:15:37isn't where you're just it's just three
  1883. 1:15:39people in a room fussing that's all it
  1884. 1:15:41is I'll end mine there
  1885. 1:15:43um
  1886. 1:15:45I think someone that knows nothing about
  1887. 1:15:47this or hears just a little bit like oh
  1888. 1:15:50they were playing around in a suitcase
  1889. 1:15:52[Music]
  1890. 1:15:54that's what happened
  1891. 1:15:56but you let him out before I mean you
  1892. 1:15:57put them in so why don't you take them
  1893. 1:15:59out because I was upstairs when I fell
  1894. 1:16:01asleep
  1895. 1:16:02no before you go upstairs you like
  1896. 1:16:04consciously had to walk upstairs do you
  1897. 1:16:06I mean you obviously remember going to
  1898. 1:16:08bed because you remember giving me a
  1899. 1:16:09time frame on that and you specifically
  1900. 1:16:11told me that that you went upstairs
  1901. 1:16:14my intention is not for this to happen
  1902. 1:16:18I am sick about it
  1903. 1:16:22I've never done anything like this
  1904. 1:16:25before in the past I am sick
  1905. 1:16:29especially with that I thought I
  1906. 1:16:31couldn't sleep last night
  1907. 1:16:34I don't know here's the thing
  1908. 1:16:36you tell us the last night you you
  1909. 1:16:38vividly remember this when you told us
  1910. 1:16:40last night that he was laughing you were
  1911. 1:16:43laughing you put him in the suitcase he
  1912. 1:16:45has two fingers sticking out and you go
  1913. 1:16:46to bed now we see something totally
  1914. 1:16:48different and it actually shows you
  1915. 1:16:51upset and again using uh derogatory
  1916. 1:16:56terms to him when he's begging for his
  1917. 1:16:58life to get out of that suitcase so so
  1918. 1:17:01we're assuming we're not assuming so it
  1919. 1:17:04just happened to be that whenever I was
  1920. 1:17:07videotaping or doing whatever else it
  1921. 1:17:08was had just happened to not have that
  1922. 1:17:10in it okay
  1923. 1:17:12and you also in the video you can't see
  1924. 1:17:14any holes there's nowhere in that where
  1925. 1:17:17the zipper separates and you can see a
  1926. 1:17:19hole if there's a hole he's pushing on
  1927. 1:17:20it begging you to get out
  1928. 1:17:22we should probably see that
  1929. 1:17:25that hole eventually would have been
  1930. 1:17:27able to get out alcohol based off what
  1931. 1:17:29you're telling us he should have been
  1932. 1:17:30able to get out but the video
  1933. 1:17:33shows him attempting to get out begging
  1934. 1:17:35to get out and he can't so that's that's
  1935. 1:17:37just what we're trying to figure out I
  1936. 1:17:39don't know if maybe you had too much to
  1937. 1:17:41drink you zipped it up all the way and
  1938. 1:17:42then you know I did not tip it up all
  1939. 1:17:44the way
  1940. 1:17:45incredible
  1941. 1:17:47I did not zip it up all the way
  1942. 1:17:52this is horrific okay
  1943. 1:17:54horrific
  1944. 1:17:55it is terrible
  1945. 1:17:58I don't think I'll ever be right because
  1946. 1:18:01of this ever be right dealing with
  1947. 1:18:04everything else that I have in my life
  1948. 1:18:05personally and then this okay whom I
  1949. 1:18:10loved
  1950. 1:18:13it was not intentional
  1951. 1:18:15I will put my hand on the Bible it was
  1952. 1:18:18not intentional
  1953. 1:18:20I would not do that to him nor anyone
  1954. 1:18:23else
  1955. 1:18:23but she did
  1956. 1:18:26not intentional
  1957. 1:18:28you intentionally went up to bed
  1958. 1:18:31because I'm thinking okay
  1959. 1:18:35how did you not intentionally go to bed
  1960. 1:18:37you said you went up to upstairs and got
  1961. 1:18:39into bed that's intentionally going to
  1962. 1:18:40bed waiting for him
  1963. 1:18:43and he doesn't come but you don't go
  1964. 1:18:44down to check on him so I happen to go
  1965. 1:18:47to sleep I say go to sleep
  1966. 1:18:50what do you normally do when you go to
  1967. 1:18:52bed what do you mean what is a bed for
  1968. 1:18:55going to sleep right so you go to
  1969. 1:18:57college and tells you that like
  1970. 1:19:00what okay
  1971. 1:19:04is that what you all are trying to do to
  1972. 1:19:07portray you don't need to do anything
  1973. 1:19:09I'm simply asking you to explain to me
  1974. 1:19:12what happened
  1975. 1:19:14everything was fine and dandy
  1976. 1:19:23okay for for me to tell you this again
  1977. 1:19:27mind you I've been without him for a day
  1978. 1:19:29now
  1979. 1:19:34I don't
  1980. 1:19:36know
  1981. 1:19:39I I mean I don't know what you all want
  1982. 1:19:42me to tell you because this was not in
  1983. 1:19:45any way shape or form hand on the Bible
  1984. 1:19:47intentional okay
  1985. 1:19:54I didn't mean to leave him there that's
  1986. 1:19:57what I'm trying to tell you you got up
  1987. 1:19:59and walked away how is that not
  1988. 1:20:00intentionally leaving him because I'm
  1989. 1:20:02looking at the whole knowing that it's
  1990. 1:20:04so it's there
  1991. 1:20:06he'll get out in Ohio
  1992. 1:20:11you say you're up for 30 minutes and he
  1993. 1:20:14doesn't come up you don't go down and
  1994. 1:20:15check on him
  1995. 1:20:22like over so you roll it out like it's
  1996. 1:20:26not like I said it wouldn't have been me
  1997. 1:20:28like that
  1998. 1:20:30don't what you didn't want him to be
  1999. 1:20:32upside down how do you even get upside
  2000. 1:20:33down right
  2001. 1:20:38you guys are killing me right now
  2002. 1:20:41I just want you to hear
  2003. 1:20:43that's how he talks to me most of the
  2004. 1:20:45time
  2005. 1:20:53I don't know how I don't know how
  2006. 1:20:56you want me to say it
  2007. 1:20:58I'm just trying to figure out what you
  2008. 1:21:00would expect to happen to somebody when
  2009. 1:21:02you leave them in a suitcase I didn't
  2010. 1:21:04mean to leave him in there
  2011. 1:21:06okay
  2012. 1:21:07seriously what when was that 12. 13.
  2013. 1:21:11okay
  2014. 1:21:13okay Chase what do you got
  2015. 1:21:16in this video you can see every single
  2016. 1:21:19stress marker that we spent all this
  2017. 1:21:20time identifying and showing you here
  2018. 1:21:22appearing at the precise moments of
  2019. 1:21:25having her character attack at the
  2020. 1:21:27precise moments and just 10 minutes of
  2021. 1:21:30training uh in any even a even a crappy
  2022. 1:21:34body language course would have showed
  2023. 1:21:36them these little stress markers so
  2024. 1:21:38these interviewers are doing the best
  2025. 1:21:40they can probably with the training that
  2026. 1:21:42they have maybe and most departments do
  2027. 1:21:46not invest in interrogation training
  2028. 1:21:48very well Sarah is driven by how she's
  2029. 1:21:51perceived by other people and that's
  2030. 1:21:53what's being attacked I'm not suggesting
  2031. 1:21:56the detectives here should have known
  2032. 1:21:57that but it's definitely visible to you
  2033. 1:22:00now and there's this what I teach
  2034. 1:22:03there's six essential ways people are
  2035. 1:22:04driven who have significance acceptance
  2036. 1:22:07approval intelligence pity and Power
  2037. 1:22:10and those are the six things that that
  2038. 1:22:12person desires from other human beings
  2039. 1:22:14this is how they need to feel and what
  2040. 1:22:16they need to get confirmation of in
  2041. 1:22:18other people from other people
  2042. 1:22:20so Sarah is acceptance and pity right
  2043. 1:22:23now but keep in mind they don't know
  2044. 1:22:25this so this is such a crystal clear
  2045. 1:22:28warning to everyone watching this to pay
  2046. 1:22:31attention to behavior and communicate
  2047. 1:22:33with some precision and not treat people
  2048. 1:22:36as if they're all the same little
  2049. 1:22:39molecules like a science experiment like
  2050. 1:22:41an academic study would treat human
  2051. 1:22:43beings uh Greg
  2052. 1:22:46yeah if we go back and look at what she
  2053. 1:22:48said way back when I was a straight A
  2054. 1:22:50student now we're talking 30 years later
  2055. 1:22:5225 years later that tells you a lot
  2056. 1:22:54about something about this person she
  2057. 1:22:56said look I used to be somebody I've
  2058. 1:22:59always excelled at everything I've done
  2059. 1:23:00I'm a great mother to your point Chase
  2060. 1:23:02she's screaming out look I'm this
  2061. 1:23:05respectable person who did something
  2062. 1:23:06stupid if you can hear that and you can
  2063. 1:23:09say hey everybody makes mistakes now
  2064. 1:23:12you've got a different approach here's
  2065. 1:23:13what's really interesting look at these
  2066. 1:23:14big illustrators she's wiping things
  2067. 1:23:16away everything was this and everything
  2068. 1:23:19was that they don't even notice that
  2069. 1:23:20they don't appear when she says finding
  2070. 1:23:22Dandy they attack the fine and dandy
  2071. 1:23:23she's giving them I if if we skip
  2072. 1:23:27everything else in this video and she
  2073. 1:23:28goes everything was fine and dandy I
  2074. 1:23:31didn't mean to
  2075. 1:23:34the rest of the interrogation that
  2076. 1:23:35you've made just shut up and go and say
  2077. 1:23:38what do you mean you didn't mean to
  2078. 1:23:42that's the interrogation right there
  2079. 1:23:44because that's what you're after is her
  2080. 1:23:46saying I did something stupid that a
  2081. 1:23:48normal human being should know will kill
  2082. 1:23:50or injure somebody that's the element of
  2083. 1:23:52law you're trying to get and she just
  2084. 1:23:54told you I did something stupid I didn't
  2085. 1:23:57mean to kill the guy Scott what do you
  2086. 1:23:59got yeah he says I'm simply trying I'm
  2087. 1:24:03simply asking you to explain what
  2088. 1:24:05happened
  2089. 1:24:06explain to me what happened and she's
  2090. 1:24:08done that about 40 times she keeps
  2091. 1:24:11saying she's not going to say anything
  2092. 1:24:12other than that because that's what
  2093. 1:24:13happened she keeps telling what happened
  2094. 1:24:15over and over and over but he was on his
  2095. 1:24:17phone
  2096. 1:24:18when she was saying all that now he's
  2097. 1:24:20just bad drainer so and like you're
  2098. 1:24:23saying you've got those spread out arms
  2099. 1:24:24and then the the the the woman detective
  2100. 1:24:27her phone dings
  2101. 1:24:29she's getting texts in there and
  2102. 1:24:30returned him during this I I've never
  2103. 1:24:33seen anything like this for my life I
  2104. 1:24:34hope I never get in trouble in Orlando
  2105. 1:24:36or wherever this is because that's it
  2106. 1:24:39that they'll be like that's one of those
  2107. 1:24:40guys from that and behavior panel thing
  2108. 1:24:44and you'll never see me again if I ever
  2109. 1:24:45go to Florida and you all never hear
  2110. 1:24:47from me again
  2111. 1:24:49I love you guys I'll be searching the
  2112. 1:24:51Everglades for you yeah it won't be sure
  2113. 1:24:53to be doing that
  2114. 1:24:56is that what you all are trying to do to
  2115. 1:24:58prepare to do anything I'm simply asking
  2116. 1:25:02you to explain to me what happened
  2117. 1:25:06everything was fine and dandy
  2118. 1:25:14okay for for me to tell you this again
  2119. 1:25:19mind you I've been without him for a day
  2120. 1:25:21now
  2121. 1:25:25I don't
  2122. 1:25:27know
  2123. 1:25:30I I mean I don't know what you all want
  2124. 1:25:34me to tell you because this was not in
  2125. 1:25:36any way shape or form hand on the Bible
  2126. 1:25:39intentional okay
  2127. 1:25:45I didn't mean to leave him there that's
  2128. 1:25:48what I'm trying to tell you you got up
  2129. 1:25:50and walked away how is that not
  2130. 1:25:52intentionally leaving him because I'm
  2131. 1:25:53looking at the whole knowing that it's a
  2132. 1:25:55it's there
  2133. 1:25:57he'll get out in Oklahoma
  2134. 1:26:03you say you're up for 30 minutes and he
  2135. 1:26:05doesn't come up you don't go down and
  2136. 1:26:07check on him
  2137. 1:26:08I'm in the bed you even move I mean you
  2138. 1:26:12moved you admit to moving the suitcase
  2139. 1:26:14like over so you roll it up like it's
  2140. 1:26:18not like I said it wouldn't have been me
  2141. 1:26:19like that
  2142. 1:26:21right
  2143. 1:26:30you guys are killing me right now
  2144. 1:26:32I just want you to hear
  2145. 1:26:34that's how he talks to me most of the
  2146. 1:26:36time
  2147. 1:26:44I don't know how I don't know how
  2148. 1:26:47you want me to say it
  2149. 1:26:50I'm just trying to figure out what you
  2150. 1:26:52would expect to happen to somebody when
  2151. 1:26:53you leave them in a suitcase I didn't
  2152. 1:26:55mean to leave him in there
  2153. 1:26:57okay okay what's your reasoning for um
  2154. 1:27:01not calling 911 sooner because I didn't
  2155. 1:27:04know what to do and how horrific it was
  2156. 1:27:08I called Ryan in like what five minutes
  2157. 1:27:10later I called you guys
  2158. 1:27:12not even five minutes nonetheless that I
  2159. 1:27:14had to like try to I was trying to do
  2160. 1:27:16CPR
  2161. 1:27:18I was trying to do CPR I had to get him
  2162. 1:27:20out
  2163. 1:27:22and try to do CPR
  2164. 1:27:24and then called you guys
  2165. 1:27:26and it was continually doing CPR with
  2166. 1:27:30the dispatch on the phone
  2167. 1:27:32where he had me count out loud to help
  2168. 1:27:36me focus on what I was doing
  2169. 1:27:43it just
  2170. 1:27:46I don't know how
  2171. 1:27:49I mean you you can sit here all day long
  2172. 1:27:51and say I thought he was gonna get
  2173. 1:27:53himself out but that
  2174. 1:27:55he didn't and you went upstairs
  2175. 1:27:59and you stayed there for 30 minutes
  2176. 1:28:01before you fell asleep but can I say two
  2177. 1:28:04like I chose not to ever at any point
  2178. 1:28:07during that 30 minutes walk back down
  2179. 1:28:09and check on him no wait one second
  2180. 1:28:11because I know like with you all and
  2181. 1:28:13then like if you continually ask me like
  2182. 1:28:16time frames time frames time frames
  2183. 1:28:18where I told you like I don't bother
  2184. 1:28:19even looking at the clock most of the
  2185. 1:28:21time so it's like a guesstimate so I for
  2186. 1:28:24all I know I was maybe it was 10 minutes
  2187. 1:28:26okay
  2188. 1:28:28but the point is you left the living
  2189. 1:28:30room where he was begging for help and
  2190. 1:28:33went upstairs regardless how long you
  2191. 1:28:36were there you left you said
  2192. 1:28:40calling again okay
  2193. 1:28:42so when he asked to be let out like
  2194. 1:28:45what's your reasoning for not letting
  2195. 1:28:47him out when I was upstairs no when he's
  2196. 1:28:49asking on the video he asked multiple
  2197. 1:28:51times he has to be let out I can't
  2198. 1:28:53breathe what like why didn't you let him
  2199. 1:28:55out
  2200. 1:28:57well number one number one I had no idea
  2201. 1:29:00it was going to end like that okay
  2202. 1:29:01number one okay
  2203. 1:29:04uh number two just
  2204. 1:29:06you know what
  2205. 1:29:08I'll give you five minutes or so in
  2206. 1:29:09there that's don't give me five minutes
  2207. 1:29:11or so five minutes for what
  2208. 1:29:15well based off the video One video is at
  2209. 1:29:1811 12 and the next one's 11 23 so you
  2210. 1:29:21actually gave him at least 11 minutes
  2211. 1:29:23per video recording
  2212. 1:29:24so my my thing is when it stopped he
  2213. 1:29:28asked multiple times I mean why why did
  2214. 1:29:30you not let him out it's just a simple
  2215. 1:29:31question to be honest with you I mean
  2216. 1:29:36yeah are you punishing them
  2217. 1:29:38no just well that's what you're saying
  2218. 1:29:41in the video
  2219. 1:29:42this is what you got this is what you
  2220. 1:29:45make me feel like see and then it's all
  2221. 1:29:48backfired on me I get to all backfired
  2222. 1:29:50on me and I understand the severity of
  2223. 1:29:52this I just I just do it it's awful I
  2224. 1:29:55know okay
  2225. 1:29:57it's awful
  2226. 1:30:01and I will tell you both this right now
  2227. 1:30:03too I will never drink alcohol again
  2228. 1:30:05okay like I will never drink alcohol
  2229. 1:30:07again I don't care what it is in any way
  2230. 1:30:09shape or form
  2231. 1:30:11all right Chase what do you got
  2232. 1:30:14I'm just going to talk about one thing
  2233. 1:30:15in here that I don't think y'all will
  2234. 1:30:17cover uh or I hope
  2235. 1:30:20one thing that I've seen many times with
  2236. 1:30:23guilty people who think they're about to
  2237. 1:30:25get off the hook or think there's a
  2238. 1:30:26chance it's something that I call
  2239. 1:30:28self-administered punishment
  2240. 1:30:31and innocent people don't feel that they
  2241. 1:30:34need to tell you that they will
  2242. 1:30:36self-administer some kind of punishment
  2243. 1:30:37and that they've learned a lesson
  2244. 1:30:40and you see that here I'm never gonna do
  2245. 1:30:42I'm never going to drink alcohol again
  2246. 1:30:44for the rest of my life and then the
  2247. 1:30:46detective you know in the back of her
  2248. 1:30:48mind this is not a conscious process in
  2249. 1:30:49the back of her mind she's going well if
  2250. 1:30:52she knows that I've kind of learned a
  2251. 1:30:53lesson from this
  2252. 1:30:54oh I'll just head home after this it is
  2253. 1:30:57over with and another brilliant
  2254. 1:31:00brilliant interrogation technique to get
  2255. 1:31:02a confession is to walk in there with a
  2256. 1:31:04paper
  2257. 1:31:05and say all I need you to do is hand
  2258. 1:31:07write a statement that says you
  2259. 1:31:09understand that this was bad and you
  2260. 1:31:11promised that you won't do it again
  2261. 1:31:13and the person believes that that might
  2262. 1:31:16get me out of there but all it does is
  2263. 1:31:17get you a step closer to the confession
  2264. 1:31:19in many cases and that's a case-by-case
  2265. 1:31:21basis that's all I got uh for that one
  2266. 1:31:23Mark pretty good yeah you got there
  2267. 1:31:25first again I'm afraid Chase uh I will
  2268. 1:31:28never drink again and then it says there
  2269. 1:31:32sorry punishment
  2270. 1:31:34so uh yeah I I totally agree I totally
  2271. 1:31:38agree it's it is she's she's punishing
  2272. 1:31:40she's displaying that she's already
  2273. 1:31:42punished herself I'm never going to
  2274. 1:31:43drink again we can all go home now you
  2275. 1:31:46know done and dusted
  2276. 1:31:48um and she does that after it's all
  2277. 1:31:51backfired on me now again like watch and
  2278. 1:31:54listen watch and listen and just get
  2279. 1:31:55curious It's all backfired on me how did
  2280. 1:31:58it how did that start how did it start
  2281. 1:32:01backfiring take us through that if if
  2282. 1:32:04that's your idea that it's backfired on
  2283. 1:32:06you take us through that little element
  2284. 1:32:08of it because there's that that's a
  2285. 1:32:11great metaphor it's a great idea that
  2286. 1:32:14she's put forward there they're just not
  2287. 1:32:16listening to the ideas and investigating
  2288. 1:32:18them
  2289. 1:32:19um now body language rise she's now
  2290. 1:32:22really locked herself down in part of
  2291. 1:32:24this hands on knees she's she's locked
  2292. 1:32:27down so I think she she believes
  2293. 1:32:30something is coming I think she believes
  2294. 1:32:33the end is near but they're not gonna
  2295. 1:32:35take her there but she's
  2296. 1:32:37she thinks uh she's a little less
  2297. 1:32:40optimistic than I think we are around
  2298. 1:32:42how good this interrogation is Greg what
  2299. 1:32:45do you got on there yeah I'm gonna skip
  2300. 1:32:47all the body language except for one
  2301. 1:32:49little piece but she confesses right
  2302. 1:32:51here to what they need and they just
  2303. 1:32:53miss it they just miss it and she gets
  2304. 1:32:57it by saying why didn't you let him out
  2305. 1:33:00the single best question I've heard the
  2306. 1:33:02entire day and then you get that I'll
  2307. 1:33:05give you five minutes or so ding ding
  2308. 1:33:08ding we have a winner that right there
  2309. 1:33:10shows that she is punishing him that
  2310. 1:33:13something is going on that she had some
  2311. 1:33:14intent now you go back to that law look
  2312. 1:33:18when she's on trial and that's going on
  2313. 1:33:19right about now they're going to bring
  2314. 1:33:21all that up they're going to say look I
  2315. 1:33:22told him I'd give him five minutes or so
  2316. 1:33:24and she did kind of a really with her
  2317. 1:33:25face if you notice that's the only piece
  2318. 1:33:27of body language I would say that's the
  2319. 1:33:29beginning of a confession with a good
  2320. 1:33:31interrogator all I do is I go in there
  2321. 1:33:33and I start asking questions and I'll
  2322. 1:33:35say was that retribution did he choke
  2323. 1:33:38you you said he choked you did you
  2324. 1:33:40intend to keep him in there five minutes
  2325. 1:33:42and then you thought well
  2326. 1:33:44I think I'm just going to go upstairs
  2327. 1:33:46and let him suffer a little bit longer
  2328. 1:33:47and then you passed out
  2329. 1:33:49you knew he was suffering you knew he
  2330. 1:33:51couldn't get out but they don't they
  2331. 1:33:54just keep pushing instead of listening
  2332. 1:33:57and instead of going back to her first
  2333. 1:33:59thing where it wasn't in my plan I went
  2334. 1:34:01upstairs and then I passed out and
  2335. 1:34:03looping that back after she says I was
  2336. 1:34:06going to give him five minutes in there
  2337. 1:34:07we miss all that we miss a confession
  2338. 1:34:09and she's giving you the elements that
  2339. 1:34:11are right here Scott what do you got all
  2340. 1:34:14right
  2341. 1:34:15um
  2342. 1:34:15so you got everything whatever
  2343. 1:34:17everything I was good I thought I had a
  2344. 1:34:18big old uh thing there and she nailed
  2345. 1:34:21everything but let's focus on the guy
  2346. 1:34:23again just for a second let me talk
  2347. 1:34:24about that guy watch his body language
  2348. 1:34:26and think about the people you've seen
  2349. 1:34:27on TV and cartoons when they're in a
  2350. 1:34:29poker game or something and they're and
  2351. 1:34:31they won and they're pushing all the
  2352. 1:34:32chips over to him he's sitting there
  2353. 1:34:34with his all scrunched up doing his
  2354. 1:34:36hands looking like that like you just
  2355. 1:34:37want a bunch of money or you just won
  2356. 1:34:38the lottery or something
  2357. 1:34:40again no teamwork in this nobody's
  2358. 1:34:43listening to anybody everybody's on
  2359. 1:34:44their phones texting back and forth the
  2360. 1:34:46phones are dinging they're looking at
  2361. 1:34:48their phones and when the the woman is
  2362. 1:34:50is talking to the to uh Sarah she asked
  2363. 1:34:54when she asked her a question she looks
  2364. 1:34:55down because her phone dings and then
  2365. 1:34:57she just sits there and flicks on her
  2366. 1:34:59phone for a while even while she's
  2367. 1:35:02I don't think she's even listening to
  2368. 1:35:03her they can't be listening because this
  2369. 1:35:06woman did everything she could do just
  2370. 1:35:08to give them all the information she
  2371. 1:35:10could possibly give him and they haven't
  2372. 1:35:12heard a bit of it and you'll notice it's
  2373. 1:35:14the same thing over and over and over
  2374. 1:35:15like I've been doing because that's
  2375. 1:35:16what's going on in here I feel sorry for
  2376. 1:35:19that I feel sorry for her I feel sorry
  2377. 1:35:20for these two detectives because it's
  2378. 1:35:22this is embarrassing this is bad
  2379. 1:35:26what's your reasoning for um not calling
  2380. 1:35:309-1-1 sooner because I didn't know what
  2381. 1:35:33to do and how horrific it was
  2382. 1:35:36I called Ryan and like what five minutes
  2383. 1:35:38later I called you guys
  2384. 1:35:40not even five minutes nonetheless that I
  2385. 1:35:42had to like try to I was trying to do
  2386. 1:35:44CPR
  2387. 1:35:46I was trying to do CPR I had to get him
  2388. 1:35:48out
  2389. 1:35:50and try to do CPR
  2390. 1:35:52and then called you guys
  2391. 1:35:54and it was continually doing CPR with
  2392. 1:35:58the dispatch on the phone
  2393. 1:36:00where he had me count out loud to help
  2394. 1:36:03me focus on what I was doing
  2395. 1:36:10foreign
  2396. 1:36:16I mean you
  2397. 1:36:18you can sit here all day long and say I
  2398. 1:36:20thought he was going to get himself out
  2399. 1:36:21but that
  2400. 1:36:23he didn't and you went upstairs
  2401. 1:36:27and you stayed there for 30 minutes
  2402. 1:36:29before you fell asleep but can I face
  2403. 1:36:32you like chose not to ever at any point
  2404. 1:36:34during that 30 minutes walk back down
  2405. 1:36:36and check on him no wait one second
  2406. 1:36:38because I know like with you all and
  2407. 1:36:41then like if you can continually ask me
  2408. 1:36:43like time frames time frames time frames
  2409. 1:36:46where I told you like I don't bother
  2410. 1:36:47even looking at the clock most of the
  2411. 1:36:49time so it's like a guesstimate so I for
  2412. 1:36:52all I know I was maybe it was 10 minutes
  2413. 1:36:54okay
  2414. 1:36:56but the point is you left the living
  2415. 1:36:58room where he was begging for help and
  2416. 1:37:01went upstairs
  2417. 1:37:02regardless of how long you were there
  2418. 1:37:04you left you said about the
  2419. 1:37:08again okay
  2420. 1:37:10so when he asked to be let out like
  2421. 1:37:13what's your reasoning for not letting
  2422. 1:37:14him out when I was upstairs no when he's
  2423. 1:37:17asking on the video he asked multiple
  2424. 1:37:19times he has to be let out I can't
  2425. 1:37:21breathe what like why didn't you let him
  2426. 1:37:23out
  2427. 1:37:25well number one number one I had no idea
  2428. 1:37:28it was going to end like that okay
  2429. 1:37:29number one okay
  2430. 1:37:31uh number two just
  2431. 1:37:34you know what
  2432. 1:37:35I'll give you five minutes or so in
  2433. 1:37:37there that's don't give me five minutes
  2434. 1:37:39or so five minutes for what
  2435. 1:37:43well based off the video One video is at
  2436. 1:37:4611 12 and the next one's 11 23 so you
  2437. 1:37:49actually gave him at least 11 minutes
  2438. 1:37:50per video recording so my my thing is
  2439. 1:37:54when it stopped he asked multiple times
  2440. 1:37:56I mean why why did you not let him out
  2441. 1:37:58it's just a simple question to be honest
  2442. 1:38:01with you I mean
  2443. 1:38:03definitely punishing them
  2444. 1:38:06no just well that's what you're saying
  2445. 1:38:08in the video
  2446. 1:38:10this is what you got this is what you
  2447. 1:38:13make me feel like see and then it's all
  2448. 1:38:15backfired on me I get to all backfired
  2449. 1:38:18on me and I understand the severity of
  2450. 1:38:20this I just I just did it it's awful
  2451. 1:38:25awful it's awful
  2452. 1:38:28awful and I will tell you both this
  2453. 1:38:30right now too I will never drink alcohol
  2454. 1:38:32again okay like I will never drink
  2455. 1:38:35alcohol again I don't care what it is in
  2456. 1:38:37any way shape or form
  2457. 1:38:39foreign
  2458. 1:38:40let's throw around the room one time and
  2459. 1:38:42talk about what we think we've seen Mark
  2460. 1:38:44why don't you go first
  2461. 1:38:45yeah look just you don't need to argue
  2462. 1:38:47don't argue watch listen be curious
  2463. 1:38:50don't argue Chase what do you think yep
  2464. 1:38:54with the zero training and interrogance
  2465. 1:38:57interrogation zero and just three
  2466. 1:39:00minutes of training in understanding
  2467. 1:39:02behavior and who you're speaking to who
  2468. 1:39:04that person is this would have been a
  2469. 1:39:06dramatically different interrogation and
  2470. 1:39:08I think they would have been successful
  2471. 1:39:10without any interrogation training just
  2472. 1:39:12a tiny tiny bit of behavior training
  2473. 1:39:15different outcome Greg
  2474. 1:39:17I'll take it a step further if you take
  2475. 1:39:19the words of Don Landrum one of my
  2476. 1:39:21mentors you got one mouth and two ears
  2477. 1:39:23shut up and listen you would get a lot
  2478. 1:39:25more the word patterns that this person
  2479. 1:39:27used along the way would tell you that
  2480. 1:39:29they're trying to give you information I
  2481. 1:39:31think that she has no idea how much
  2482. 1:39:32trouble she sent she ends up getting
  2483. 1:39:34arrested and is on trial I think she has
  2484. 1:39:36no idea how much trouble she's in and
  2485. 1:39:37she is bleeding information I don't know
  2486. 1:39:40that I would think that this was
  2487. 1:39:43intentional it looks like something gone
  2488. 1:39:45wrong not going to weigh in on that not
  2489. 1:39:46my my job but she bleeds so much
  2490. 1:39:49information that the Right Touch point
  2491. 1:39:51the right listen the right process
  2492. 1:39:54interrogation approaches or narrative
  2493. 1:39:57would have gotten her to give you the
  2494. 1:39:58right words Scott
  2495. 1:40:00I think I could take my mother and the
  2496. 1:40:02woman that cuts her hair and set them
  2497. 1:40:04down for about four minutes and say do
  2498. 1:40:06this this this this and this and they
  2499. 1:40:08would have done so much better than
  2500. 1:40:10these two I think they would have walked
  2501. 1:40:11together with confession first what they
  2502. 1:40:14needed right out of the gate I think it
  2503. 1:40:16would have been over in about 15-20
  2504. 1:40:18minutes
  2505. 1:40:18and that had been it all right I think
  2506. 1:40:21this is another good one that has been a
  2507. 1:40:22good haircut as well that's true too
  2508. 1:40:24that's true that's true too all right I
  2509. 1:40:27think this is another good one and I'll
  2510. 1:40:28see you next time
  2511. 1:40:30hey
  2512. 1:40:32[Music]
  2513. 1:40:36all right I hate how bad we had to abuse
  2514. 1:40:38these guys but damn man me too me too
  2515. 1:40:41you know what maybe I'll get back to him
  2516. 1:40:43and maybe they'll do something about
  2517. 1:40:44that because they're going to put
  2518. 1:40:45somebody in prison who doesn't need to
  2519. 1:40:47be in prison yeah they're going to pull
  2520. 1:40:48me over when I'm driving down I-4 buddy
  2521. 1:40:51yeah besides this is my trip to Disney
  2522. 1:40:54I'm serious they're not gonna get false
  2523. 1:40:56confession
  2524. 1:40:57no they can't well they're going to talk
  2525. 1:41:00and not listen that's the problem yeah
  2526. 1:41:02yeah
  2527. 1:41:08hello

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of πŸ’₯ IS THIS THE WORST INTERROGATION EVER? Watch Suitcase Killer Sarah Boone Take Control by The Behavior Panel, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 17,324 words across 2,527 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator β€” no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.