YouTube2Text

Is This The Best EDC That Smith & Wesson Has EVER made? | 1 Year Smith & Wesson Shield X Review — Transcript

by Ben Hart Shoots · 4,600 words · 638 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:03Smith & Wesson Shield X. Here we go.
  2. 0:38After about a year ownership and all the
  3. 0:40hype has died down about this gun, do I
  4. 0:42still think this is the best concealed
  5. 0:44carry gun that Smith & Wesson has ever
  6. 0:46made?
  7. 0:47Let's talk about it. For my YouTube
  8. 0:48manual reviewer, there is no ammunition
  9. 0:50anywhere near me. This firearm has been
  10. 0:52made safe and clear. I'm in a controlled
  11. 0:54environment. Nothing in this video is
  12. 0:56for sale. Everything I talk about in
  13. 0:57this video is for entertainment purposes
  14. 0:59only. Question of the day is, do you
  15. 1:01think you should carry a flashlight on
  16. 1:04your EDC? Comment down below and I may
  17. 1:06choose your comment to respond to in the
  18. 1:08next video coming up. So, quickly I'm
  19. 1:10going to tell you guys how this pistol
  20. 1:11is set up. That way you don't have to
  21. 1:13ask me down in the comments. Although,
  22. 1:14please comment down below if you have
  23. 1:16any questions. I am rocking the
  24. 1:17Streamlight TLR-7 sub. This is the
  25. 1:19non-HLX, just the standard sub. And for
  26. 1:22the optic, I'm running the Vector Optics
  27. 1:24Frenzy MRT, fully enclosed RMSC pattern
  28. 1:27multi-reticle micro red dot. Fantastic
  29. 1:31red dot option and I would never tell
  30. 1:32you guys to ever in a million years use
  31. 1:34code VHS10 to save yourself a few coins
  32. 1:38on something like this. First things
  33. 1:40first, the basics on the Shield X. And
  34. 1:42yes, I do have notes down here. It's a 9
  35. 1:44mm striker-fired handgun at 6.87 in
  36. 1:47long, 0.9 in wide, 4.9 in tall, and it's
  37. 1:51got a 3.6 in barrel with a flush fit
  38. 1:54capacity of 13 rounds and an extended
  39. 1:56capacity of 15 rounds. The Shield X is
  40. 1:59going to be the very first firearm I'm
  41. 2:00putting on my new firearms ranking list.
  42. 2:03Each firearm is going to go through five
  43. 2:05different categories. Each category has
  44. 2:07a one out of 10 score. One being the
  45. 2:09worst, 10 being the best, and five being
  46. 2:11neutral. And at the very end, we're
  47. 2:13going to tally up all five categories
  48. 2:15for a total up to 50. So, a perfect
  49. 2:17score for any firearm would be 50. That
  50. 2:18makes sense? Cool. Get it. Got it. Good.
  51. 2:21Let's go. So, category number one is
  52. 2:22features. The Shield X is a fairly
  53. 2:25feature-rich being the the newest
  54. 2:27concealed carry gun from Smith & Wesson.
  55. 2:29You have front and rear slide
  56. 2:31serrations, very nice iron sights with a
  57. 2:33blacked-out rear and a high-vis front.
  58. 2:35You have an accessory rail, which is a
  59. 2:37big deal coming from the Shield Plus,
  60. 2:38which didn't have that at all. Flat face
  61. 2:40trigger, very similar to the one that's
  62. 2:42on the M&P 2.0. Aggressive grip texture
  63. 2:44on the front and back. A textured
  64. 2:46magazine release. Beaver tail. Optics
  65. 2:48ready. You do have a loaded chamber
  66. 2:50viewport here on top of the barrel.
  67. 2:51However, Smith & Wesson has alleviated
  68. 2:54that by doing something they call the
  69. 2:55clear sight cut. There's a small
  70. 2:58angled cut right here on the slide that
  71. 3:01ejects those gases forward, and I can
  72. 3:03happily say that it does work very well.
  73. 3:05And lastly, they are one of the few
  74. 3:07options in this size of firearm that can
  75. 3:10actually be equipped with a safety.
  76. 3:11Whether you want it or not, it is
  77. 3:13available on the Shield X, and for some
  78. 3:14people that's important. Most of the
  79. 3:15features on the Smith & Wesson Shield X
  80. 3:17are fairly ubiquitous in this segment of
  81. 3:19firearm. However, it does have the
  82. 3:21ability to have a safety and that clear
  83. 3:23sight cut, which is going to raise the
  84. 3:25score in the features category to eight
  85. 3:27out of 10. The pros of the ergonomics of
  86. 3:28the Shield X. It's got good grip
  87. 3:30texture. It's abrasive enough to be
  88. 3:32usable, but not so abrasive that it's
  89. 3:34going to rip up your skin really bad
  90. 3:36like the M&P 2.0. It's got a really nice
  91. 3:38length of pull, and what that means is
  92. 3:41the distance from the back of the
  93. 3:42backstrap to the trigger is nice. Now, I
  94. 3:44have a large to XL size hands, and for
  95. 3:47me, it's just a nice place to put my
  96. 3:49trigger. Maybe on just on the small
  97. 3:51side, but for anyone who has average
  98. 3:53size hands, I think this would be
  99. 3:54totally comfortable. And for me who have
  100. 3:56a large hands, it's completely doable
  101. 3:57and and very comfortable. I don't feel
  102. 3:59myself, you know, craning over the
  103. 4:00trigger too much or under riding it back
  104. 4:02here, which those things will affect
  105. 4:04your accuracy under rapid fire. I don't
  106. 4:06feel that at all and really is kind of
  107. 4:08inconsequential. So, good design. The
  108. 4:09cons are going to be similar to the
  109. 4:11shootability. I really don't like the
  110. 4:13magazine design of the Shield X. And
  111. 4:15this is a hot take and I on my last
  112. 4:16video I got a lot of hate for this, but
  113. 4:18I still stand by it after having this
  114. 4:19thing for a year. I think this gun
  115. 4:21should have been a 15 round flush fit
  116. 4:23capacity from the factory. I think
  117. 4:26basically the Shield X should have been
  118. 4:28this long from the factory with a flush
  119. 4:30fit base plate. And then if we wanted
  120. 4:33to, they should have given us a 17 round
  121. 4:35magazine. That way one, it can compete
  122. 4:37with the largest players in the segment,
  123. 4:40which is the X1 rows, the MC9 primes,
  124. 4:43the Glock 43X, which has 15 round
  125. 4:45capacity from the factory. Because check
  126. 4:47this out. So, this is a Glock 19. The
  127. 4:49Shield X and its flush fit magazine is
  128. 4:51almost identical in dimension to a Glock
  129. 4:5419, obviously aside from the width,
  130. 4:56while other competitors like the Canik
  131. 4:59MC9 prime are also almost equal in size,
  132. 5:02but this is a 17 plus one round pistol.
  133. 5:05So, I personally think that Smith &
  134. 5:07Wesson should have nixed the 13 round
  135. 5:09flush fit, given us a longer grip from
  136. 5:11factory, a 15 round flush fit just like
  137. 5:13this. Get rid of this little
  138. 5:16dingus thing here. Give us some square
  139. 5:18magazines like a Glock, you know, to
  140. 5:19where other companies can build
  141. 5:21aftermarket mag wells for this thing
  142. 5:22without having to do some weird jicky
  143. 5:24stuff. And then if we want the higher
  144. 5:25capacity magazine, that could be the 17
  145. 5:27plus one. I think that would make this
  146. 5:29gun compete closer with its competitors.
  147. 5:31I think it would bring more value to the
  148. 5:33customer and I don't think people would
  149. 5:35be upset with a gun that is
  150. 5:3815 round capacity at the same length as
  151. 5:40a Glock 19 just being a thinner more
  152. 5:42carryable package. I know it's a hot
  153. 5:44take, but it's how I feel. And I felt
  154. 5:45that way for a long time about the
  155. 5:47Shield X. All the controls are easily
  156. 5:49accessible, even the safety, although
  157. 5:51it's so small that you really don't ever
  158. 5:52notice it's there. Just get the one with
  159. 5:54the safety on it because you literally
  160. 5:55never know it's there. It doesn't get in
  161. 5:56the way at all. You don't feel it, you
  162. 5:58don't see it. But, if you're traveling
  163. 6:00or maybe you put on your bedside and
  164. 6:01your kids are around or something, who
  165. 6:02knows, and you want to use it, it is
  166. 6:04there. Actually activating the safety is
  167. 6:06a little bit tedious. It's hard to do
  168. 6:08one-handed, but swiping it down is
  169. 6:10actually fairly easy. So, if you you
  170. 6:12know, say you forgot you left it on safe
  171. 6:14and you need to use your firearm,
  172. 6:15swiping it down is pretty simple. Also,
  173. 6:18the the trigger guard on the Shield X is
  174. 6:20very large, which I didn't think I was
  175. 6:22going to like it first. I thought it was
  176. 6:23going to kind of get in the way of my
  177. 6:24finger and kind of give me like a Glock
  178. 6:25knuckle situation. Not at all. It's been
  179. 6:27actually really enjoyable, and I do like
  180. 6:29having this much space. It's a little
  181. 6:31bit less with this light here, but I do
  182. 6:33like having the space here on inside the
  183. 6:35trigger guard for maybe if you had
  184. 6:36gloves or, you know, you have super
  185. 6:38duper large hands, something like that.
  186. 6:40This is something that could be
  187. 6:41beneficial for a few people out there,
  188. 6:43and so I do like that. And the last
  189. 6:44thing I'll critique on ergonomics is I
  190. 6:46wish they brought some of this texture
  191. 6:48onto the sides here. I know why they
  192. 6:49didn't, obviously, to make it more
  193. 6:51comfortable during carry. However, I
  194. 6:53feel like, in my personal opinion, just
  195. 6:55give me all the texture everywhere and
  196. 6:56let me deal with I'll put some goon tape
  197. 6:58on it, I'll file it down, I'll flatten
  198. 7:00it, I'll make it more comfortable. But,
  199. 7:01give me that texture everywhere. Make it
  200. 7:03that Make this a fighting gun. You can
  201. 7:05see how much room they have here on this
  202. 7:07gas pedal area, but for some reason they
  203. 7:09give you this tiny little square texture
  204. 7:10instead of filling out this entire area.
  205. 7:13Especially on this side, it's very
  206. 7:14noticeable. Look how small that little
  207. 7:15guy is versus all the space they had to
  208. 7:18put some texture. So, I like the texture
  209. 7:20itself, I just wish it was in more
  210. 7:22places. So, for ergonomics on the Shield
  211. 7:24X, I'm going to go 7 out of 10.
  212. 7:26So, the next category is going to be
  213. 7:27reliability and build quality. Now, I
  214. 7:29don't think it's any surprise that Smith
  215. 7:32& Wesson has been been making quality
  216. 7:33firearms for a very, very, very long
  217. 7:35time. Just for funsies, I'm pretty sure
  218. 7:37it's going to pass, obviously, but we're
  219. 7:39going to do some limp wrist and just to
  220. 7:40see how this thing cycles cuz it is It
  221. 7:42feels like it's sprung a little bit
  222. 7:43tighter than some of their guns. And so,
  223. 7:45we're going to see how it does if I
  224. 7:46really try and loosey-goosey grip this
  225. 7:47thing, if it cause any kind of short
  226. 7:49stroking or malfunctions. So,
  227. 7:51let's let's give it a shot.
  228. 7:54We're just going to go real
  229. 7:54loosey-goosey with it.
  230. 7:57Good so far.
  231. 7:59Okay, even looser.
  232. 8:03This feels so wrong.
  233. 8:05It feels so wrong to do that. Okay, last
  234. 8:07one real loose.
  235. 8:10And lock back. Not like we expected
  236. 8:12anything different, but seems like Smith
  237. 8:14& Wesson's got the reliability and
  238. 8:16spring pressure down. So, Shield X
  239. 8:18looking good so far. And it's no
  240. 8:20different with the Shield X. The slide
  241. 8:22coatings are fantastic. The polymer
  242. 8:24quality is very good. All the components
  243. 8:26have been working very well, and there's
  244. 8:28really no complaints there. Except for
  245. 8:30two things. In regards to build quality,
  246. 8:32I've noticed that this roll pin right
  247. 8:34there seems to have started to walk out
  248. 8:36just slightly
  249. 8:38compared to the other side. You can see
  250. 8:39it's kind of sunken in there. To be
  251. 8:40honest with you, I can't confirm on
  252. 8:42whether or not that was like that from
  253. 8:43the factory or not. So, it's something
  254. 8:45I'm definitely going to kind of keep an
  255. 8:46eye on to make sure it doesn't get any
  256. 8:47worse, and I'll probably end up pushing
  257. 8:49it back to center and seeing if we can
  258. 8:50kind of replicate this over time. Now,
  259. 8:52for reliability during shooting this
  260. 8:53pistol, it was stellar. I ran everything
  261. 8:55from 115 grain to self-defense rounds.
  262. 8:58It fit everything. It shot everything.
  263. 9:00It was great. However, I did have issues
  264. 9:02with this flush fit base plate magazine.
  265. 9:05And I'm actually going to take the slide
  266. 9:06off to try and convey this to you guys
  267. 9:08on camera. What was happening is I would
  268. 9:10have a fully loaded magazine. I'd go and
  269. 9:12shoot my, you know, 13 rounds. After I'd
  270. 9:14be done with that, the slide would lock
  271. 9:16back, and I would go to take out my
  272. 9:18magazine, and I couldn't for some
  273. 9:19reason. I'd pull on it, and it wouldn't
  274. 9:20come out. It didn't feel like it was
  275. 9:23super duper jammed in there, but there
  276. 9:24was kind of like some springy kind of
  277. 9:26tension to it, to where I could pull it
  278. 9:28a little bit, and it would sort of snap
  279. 9:29back in. After looking at the inside of
  280. 9:32the firearm, what was happening was
  281. 9:33this. Somehow, and only after shooting a
  282. 9:35few rounds,
  283. 9:37the follower of the magazine would end
  284. 9:39up on top of the slide stop slide
  285. 9:41release right here.
  286. 9:48Oh, interesting.
  287. 9:52Not sure what that was. Magazine won't
  288. 9:53drop free.
  289. 9:55It does now.
  290. 9:59Yeah, look at that. I'm not sure. Oh,
  291. 10:01okay, I see. Interesting. Let me see if
  292. 10:04I can try and show this to you guys. And
  293. 10:05so what I would have to do is push this
  294. 10:08down to pop off the top of that slide
  295. 10:10stop slide release, and then I could
  296. 10:12pull the magazine out just fine. And you
  297. 10:13can even tell right here on the corner
  298. 10:15of this magazine that that slide stop
  299. 10:17slide release lever has started to chew
  300. 10:18up the edge of it right there just a
  301. 10:21little bit. So, it wasn't all the time.
  302. 10:24It happened intermittently. I'll
  303. 10:25probably end up reaching out to Smith &
  304. 10:26Wesson, kind of telling them, and I bet
  305. 10:27they'll probably just send me a new
  306. 10:28magazine, and it should be okay from
  307. 10:30there. But nobody gets a free pass here
  308. 10:31on the channel, and so I got to tell you
  309. 10:33how it is, and that is how it was.
  310. 10:36So, for build quality and reliability on
  311. 10:38the Smith & Wesson Shield X, if 10 is a
  312. 10:40great score, we had an issue with the
  313. 10:42roll pin, and I had an issue with one of
  314. 10:44the magazines, but none of the
  315. 10:46malfunctions were related to cycling or
  316. 10:48reliability with different types of
  317. 10:50ammo. So, I'm going to give this a 7 out
  318. 10:52of 10 for reliability. But keep in mind,
  319. 10:54this is a sample size of one. So, not
  320. 10:55every gun is going to have this issue,
  321. 10:57but I think it's worth mentioning
  322. 10:59anyway. All right, so next category for
  323. 11:01the Shield X is going to be
  324. 11:02shootability. And considering that it is
  325. 11:04really slim and kind of a, you know,
  326. 11:06smaller profile gun, I was able to get
  327. 11:08some really nice groups with this
  328. 11:09firearm and consistently over time with
  329. 11:12different types of ammo and different
  330. 11:13types of higher pressure loads, things
  331. 11:15like that, I was not having a hard time
  332. 11:17at all getting nice solid consistent
  333. 11:19groupings with THE SHIELD X.
  334. 11:27ALL RIGHT, LET'S BRING THE TARGET BACK.
  335. 11:29PART OF that is due to this trigger,
  336. 11:31which I actually really enjoyed. It's a
  337. 11:33very reminiscent trigger to the new
  338. 11:34style on the M&P 2.0. Just like you can
  339. 11:37see here on my 2.0 full-size metal here,
  340. 11:40it has that kind of hybrid curve {slash}
  341. 11:42flat trigger shoe here. I would consider
  342. 11:44this to be one of the best triggers in
  343. 11:46this segment. You have your take-up
  344. 11:49right there. You hit your wall, pull,
  345. 11:50pull, pull.
  346. 11:52Nice clean break, no overtravel. It
  347. 11:53stops where it's at.
  348. 11:55The reset
  349. 11:57nice and lightweight, pushes your finger
  350. 11:58forward.
  351. 12:00There's your click, audible and tactile.
  352. 12:02Back to the wall, pull again.
  353. 12:04And it breaks.
  354. 12:05It's a very serviceable trigger. Now, is
  355. 12:07it some competition trigger? No, it's
  356. 12:08not meant to be. It's a everyday carry
  357. 12:11duty style trigger, but it feels good.
  358. 12:13It has those characteristics that allow
  359. 12:14you to be accurate, consistent,
  360. 12:16predictable, and reliable. Another
  361. 12:18feature I really like, and this is a
  362. 12:20maybe a big hand problem kind of thing,
  363. 12:22but it does have a small beaver tail
  364. 12:23here on the back of the handgun, which
  365. 12:25is nice because I do tend to get slide
  366. 12:27bite on very low bore axis handguns like
  367. 12:30Glocks and things like that. And with
  368. 12:31this beaver tail, there's no way I'm
  369. 12:32getting slide bite at all. The width of
  370. 12:35it is very thin, but it kind of has a
  371. 12:37wider section here, so it fills up the
  372. 12:38hand nicely even though I have large
  373. 12:40hands. And with that beaver tail, it
  374. 12:41really feels like you can lock in tight
  375. 12:43on this thing and get a lot of traction
  376. 12:45and control over it. The grip texture
  377. 12:46itself is very nice as well. It's not
  378. 12:48quite as aggressive as your M&P 2.0's,
  379. 12:51but it is more aggressive than say the
  380. 12:53Bodyguard 2.0. You have some really nice
  381. 12:55slide serrations on the front and back
  382. 12:57of the slide, as well as some kind of
  383. 12:59moderate cocking ears. You can see here,
  384. 13:01you can kind of do your pinch pull here
  385. 13:02on the back if you'd like to. I do have
  386. 13:04a couple of buddies who say these aren't
  387. 13:05quite as aggressive as they'd like them
  388. 13:06to be. However, I haven't found them to
  389. 13:09be very difficult to use, but I could
  390. 13:11see if maybe your hands were sweaty or
  391. 13:12bloody or messed up or something that
  392. 13:14you might slide off these serrations cuz
  393. 13:16they're not quite as aggressive as they
  394. 13:18could be. Or maybe they could have
  395. 13:19wrapped those serrations around the top
  396. 13:21like Shadow Systems does. Now, in
  397. 13:22regards to shootability, the cons of the
  398. 13:24Shield X is it is Is bit snappy. I don't
  399. 13:26want to say it has a lot of muzzle flip
  400. 13:28because it doesn't. Uh Um, you have a
  401. 13:30lot of great texture here to hold that
  402. 13:31muzzle down. However, whether it's the
  403. 13:33way that it's sprung or because it has
  404. 13:35kind of a tapered grip profile towards
  405. 13:37the back here, maybe you are just I'm
  406. 13:39feeling more recoil in the hand because
  407. 13:41of the angle of the grip towards the
  408. 13:43back. But it doesn't shoot as flat,
  409. 13:45obviously, as a compensated pistol or a
  410. 13:47ported pistol. And I know they have the
  411. 13:49uh carry comp model, which maybe that
  412. 13:50does alleviate some of that more
  413. 13:52perceived in-hand recoil. But, I would
  414. 13:55put this just as equal to something like
  415. 13:56a Canik MC9 Prime, a Glock 43X, 365XL.
  416. 14:01It feels like a micro-sized 9 mm
  417. 14:04handgun. However, it's a little bit
  418. 14:05skinnier in the back, so maybe that's
  419. 14:07why it has more perceived in-hand
  420. 14:09recoil. Now, lastly, a con in the
  421. 14:11shootability category is the grip length
  422. 14:14is not quite long enough. As you can
  423. 14:16see, my my pinky is kind of halfway on
  424. 14:18the grip there. And so, when you go to
  425. 14:20insert magazines, because Smith & Wesson
  426. 14:22integrates, for whatever reason, they've
  427. 14:23been doing this for years, and it's
  428. 14:25People have been complaining about this
  429. 14:26for like decades, it seems like. The
  430. 14:28base plates integrate with
  431. 14:30the bottom of the gun. You have this
  432. 14:32weird little kind of dongle on the back
  433. 14:34here, and then the the actual base plate
  434. 14:36is part of the grip geometry. And
  435. 14:38especially when you put in the 15-round
  436. 14:40magazine,
  437. 14:41it fits like a puzzle piece. And because
  438. 14:43of that, this is your extended This is
  439. 14:44your grip now. But, if your finger is
  440. 14:47already hanging off the edge here on the
  441. 14:48front, like mine, and you go to reload,
  442. 14:51guess what happens?
  443. 14:53Pinches right here. And it's It did that
  444. 14:55to me quite a few times. Now,
  445. 14:57oh, yeah. I'll I just There's an example
  446. 15:00for you right there. You can see right
  447. 15:01there, it pinched me on my pinky. Not a
  448. 15:04massive issue. However, when this gun is
  449. 15:06comparing to things like the X-MACRO,
  450. 15:08which is a fully fleshed out, I mean,
  451. 15:10it's it's basically a compact gun at
  452. 15:12this point with 17-round capacity, or
  453. 15:14say the Canik MC9 Prime that comes with
  454. 15:16a magwell, that is something you don't
  455. 15:18have to worry about. And I think Smith &
  456. 15:19Wesson needs to start understanding that
  457. 15:21people are shooting these guns a lot.
  458. 15:23They are training with these guns a lot.
  459. 15:24They are doing tactical reloads. They
  460. 15:26are doing manipulations. They're doing
  461. 15:27things that maybe back in the day when
  462. 15:29people were carrying, you know, Walther
  463. 15:30PPS M2s, they weren't doing quite as
  464. 15:32much. And so, this This needs to go
  465. 15:34away. I've been saying this for a long
  466. 15:37time, and it's the killer of this gun,
  467. 15:39in my opinion. It's kind of like it's
  468. 15:40Achilles' heel, which is funny cuz it's
  469. 15:41on the bottom here. So, that is what is
  470. 15:43going to bring the score down just a
  471. 15:44little bit in the shootability category.
  472. 15:46It was good overall, and so,
  473. 15:47shootability for the Shield X is going
  474. 15:49to be an eight out of 10.
  475. 15:51All right, last category is value. Now,
  476. 15:53I can't tell you exactly how much the
  477. 15:55Shield X is going to cost you. However,
  478. 15:58what I can say is I went to go fill up
  479. 16:00my truck with gasoline, and it cost me
  480. 16:03$499,
  481. 16:04dude. Isn't that crazy? Which, I think,
  482. 16:07is great value. That makes this more
  483. 16:09affordable than the SIG 365 XL, or
  484. 16:14especially the 365 X-Macro, which is
  485. 16:17really getting close to 1K, which is
  486. 16:18kind of crazy. It plays in the same area
  487. 16:21as the Canik MC9 Prime and the Glock
  488. 16:2343X. It actually costs the exact same
  489. 16:25amount as its predecessor, the Shield
  490. 16:27Plus, which is kind of funny. I'm not
  491. 16:29really sure
  492. 16:30what Smith & Wesson is doing there with
  493. 16:32their pricing structure, but I think
  494. 16:34this is way more gun for the same price
  495. 16:36than the Shield Plus. So, I'm definitely
  496. 16:37recommending this over the Shield Plus.
  497. 16:39And the only other option I could think
  498. 16:41of in this same category that would be
  499. 16:43less expensive than this is the Taurus
  500. 16:46GX4 XL, but I don't really think that's
  501. 16:49a big player in the market, but I
  502. 16:50thought I would mention it just to kind
  503. 16:53of give you something to scale this
  504. 16:54thing at. So, for the cons in the value
  505. 16:56department, I I'm going to stand by this
  506. 16:58till the day I die, and I stand with
  507. 17:00John from the Gun Collective. This gun
  508. 17:01only comes with two magazines, your 13
  509. 17:03and your 15. I think that's ridiculous.
  510. 17:06It's time that we get three magazines
  511. 17:07with our guns, and any company who knows
  512. 17:09that their their shooters are going to
  513. 17:11shoot their guns seriously would give
  514. 17:13them three magazines. And the reason why
  515. 17:15is cuz you have one in the gun and two
  516. 17:17on your belt when you're training.
  517. 17:18People are shooting smaller guns like
  518. 17:20bigger guns. They're going to the range,
  519. 17:21they're training, they're shooting
  520. 17:22competitions with them. You have a lot
  521. 17:24of competitions with like the Hunter
  522. 17:25Constantine Belt Competition Series
  523. 17:27where people are shooting high-level
  524. 17:29competitions from inside the waistband
  525. 17:31and we demand three magazines. Even if
  526. 17:34you have to I me personally, I would pay
  527. 17:36more than what this gun is priced at if
  528. 17:39I got three magazines. You tack on an
  529. 17:41extra 10 bucks, 20 bucks, whatever to
  530. 17:43the MSRP. Give me a third king magazine,
  531. 17:46dude. What the
  532. 17:48You know what I'm saying? So for value
  533. 17:49on the Shield X, I'm going eight out of
  534. 17:5110. And as a little bonus, I'm going to
  535. 17:52throw in one more category. Now this
  536. 17:54category is not scored, but I think it's
  537. 17:56something that will be important for the
  538. 17:57review for you guys the viewer. And I'm
  539. 17:58going to call it the X-Factor category.
  540. 18:00It's something special about the gun
  541. 18:02that makes it stand out above other
  542. 18:04guns, right? And from my perspective
  543. 18:05after having this thing for a year, it's
  544. 18:08the width. This is a very very thin
  545. 18:11firearm. While it does decrease your
  546. 18:13capacity potential, and it does makes
  547. 18:16the recoil feel a little bit sharper in
  548. 18:17your hand, that makes this a very easy
  549. 18:20gun to carry. It disappears on your
  550. 18:22waistline, guys. Or if you have a we use
  551. 18:24a grab bags, it fits really nice and
  552. 18:26easy in a grab bag. And to me, that is
  553. 18:28very important. The most important thing
  554. 18:30about choosing an EDC gun is figuring
  555. 18:32out which gun you're actually going to
  556. 18:34carry every single day. Now, not
  557. 18:36everybody does carry every single day. I
  558. 18:37know I don't. There are some days where
  559. 18:39I I'm I eat a a big meal, I'm feeling
  560. 18:41extra fluffy. I already have love
  561. 18:43handles and guns with aggressive texture
  562. 18:44can rub me the wrong way, I get it. But
  563. 18:46when you go from carrying a Glock 19,
  564. 18:48which is a fairly wide gun, to a skinny
  565. 18:51gun like this at .9 inches wide, even
  566. 18:54the Glock 43X is wider than this. And so
  567. 18:57that to me is the X-Factor of the Shield
  568. 18:59X. That makes this a very easy gun to
  569. 19:02conceal carry. That's to me my first
  570. 19:04contribution to the X-Factor category.
  571. 19:06All right, so after tallying up all the
  572. 19:08different categories, the Smith & Wesson
  573. 19:10scored on the BHS proprietary scoring
  574. 19:14tier list a 39 out of 60. So, that puts
  575. 19:18the Shield X at quite above average
  576. 19:20scoring and that is basically how I feel
  577. 19:22about the gun. The gun is not the best
  578. 19:24carry gun I've ever shot in my entire
  579. 19:25life and you know, the most interesting,
  580. 19:28the most feature-rich, the most fun.
  581. 19:30However, it is by no means the worst and
  582. 19:32it is a good competitor in the market,
  583. 19:34brings a lot of value and so it is a
  584. 19:36good above average gun. Now, who do I
  585. 19:38think this gun is for? I think it's for
  586. 19:39anybody who's looking for a comfortable,
  587. 19:42higher capacity 9 mm carry gun and
  588. 19:44especially for those guys who are Smith
  589. 19:46& Wesson loyalists. If you shoot M&P in
  590. 19:48competition or that's your duty gun for
  591. 19:51work, if you're a police officer or a
  592. 19:53security guard, something like that and
  593. 19:54you use an M&P for work, the Shield X is
  594. 19:56a great way to translate that across the
  595. 19:57board and I really don't think you're
  596. 19:58going to be upset. I don't think
  597. 20:00necessarily anybody's going to be too
  598. 20:01upset about the Shield X. It's pretty
  599. 20:03unoffending, I guess you could say, but
  600. 20:05I can already tell that this is kind of
  601. 20:06like, you know, good old faithful. Like
  602. 20:08this is going to be in the rotation for
  603. 20:10a while and it's really never going to
  604. 20:11let me down. It's just that typical
  605. 20:14Smith & Wesson quality that we have come
  606. 20:16to know and love. All right, fellas, so
  607. 20:18that is going to be it for the Smith &
  608. 20:19Wesson Shield X. I hope you guys like
  609. 20:22this video. I hope you enjoyed it and
  610. 20:24maybe this helped you kind of make a
  611. 20:25better purchasing decision. That's what
  612. 20:27my channel is all about, making that
  613. 20:28harder and dollar in this economy last
  614. 20:31as long as it can when it comes to your
  615. 20:332A consumeristic habits. Like, share and
  616. 20:36hype this video. If you guys want to
  617. 20:38watch a few more things, I'm going to
  618. 20:39throw some videos up here in a second
  619. 20:40that you can kind of continue to watch.
  620. 20:42If you like this one, you'll probably
  621. 20:43like those. Hey, come say hi at Gun Con
  622. 20:442026 by the way. I'll be there with my
  623. 20:46with my boys and I would love to shake
  624. 20:49your hand, give you a little ball tap,
  625. 20:51you know? But aside from that,
  626. 20:52gentlemen, thank you so much for
  627. 20:53watching. Talk less, shoot more. We'll
  628. 20:55see you in the next one. Peace.
  629. 21:07As I have five categories we're going to
  630. 21:09go through. Each of those categories has
  631. 21:10one out of 10. You throw all those
  632. 21:12points together and we're going to get a
  633. 21:13one out of 100.
  634. 21:15That's not true. One out of 50.
  635. 21:18I'm a freaking idiot.
  636. 21:20Yes, I am.
  637. 21:22But don't say anything otherwise I'll
  638. 21:23blast you.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Is This The Best EDC That Smith & Wesson Has EVER made? | 1 Year Smith & Wesson Shield X Review by Ben Hart Shoots, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,600 words across 638 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.