YouTube2Text

IS THIS $300 ESPRESSO TOOL WORTH IT?: The Porcupress Review — Transcript

by Lance Hedrick · 3,176 words · 462 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00what's up everyone lance hedrick here
  2. 0:02and today we're going to look at
  3. 0:05the porcupress
  4. 0:07[Music]
  5. 0:14now to begin i would ask that you all
  6. 0:16take a second you know like subscribe if
  7. 0:18you haven't yet that'll be awesome um
  8. 0:20yeah and then check out i'm going to put
  9. 0:22down below um who this is works design
  10. 0:25sheldon did send this to me for free so
  11. 0:27i want to be upfront about that but what
  12. 0:28i'm doing in this video is is somewhat
  13. 0:30it's pretty objective so um it's not
  14. 0:32really going to be affecting what i'm
  15. 0:34saying i'm doing a more so of an
  16. 0:36objective analysis of what this does i
  17. 0:37will talk about taste at the end but
  18. 0:39you'll see when we get there okay
  19. 0:42so you're looking at this and you're
  20. 0:43saying what the heck is this i have no
  21. 0:46idea i'm gonna read what sheldon himself
  22. 0:49says about this tool um but anyway the
  23. 0:52porky press is here to help reduce
  24. 0:54channeling specifically on very finely
  25. 0:56ground coffee the tool perforates the
  26. 0:58coffee puck such that after you tamp you
  27. 1:01will leave behind a defined array of
  28. 1:03less compacted regions these regions
  29. 1:06will initially allow water through the
  30. 1:08entire depth of the puck water will then
  31. 1:10saturate outwards from each of these
  32. 1:12holes causing the entire puck of coffee
  33. 1:14to be fully wet as the entire puck
  34. 1:16swells these holes in other naturally
  35. 1:18present channels will seal up so the
  36. 1:20idea according to sheldon is you have
  37. 1:22your untamped bed of coffee
  38. 1:27you have your untamed bed of coffee you
  39. 1:29wdt do whatever do whatever preparation
  40. 1:32preparation you need to do and then
  41. 1:34you're going to take this and as you see
  42. 1:35we have little
  43. 1:37flaps for the flaps on your portafilter
  44. 1:39you're gonna put it on and then watch
  45. 1:41see this you're gonna go down and you're
  46. 1:43gonna perforate the coffee with all
  47. 1:45those needles okay so what's gonna
  48. 1:47happen is you're gonna have holes you're
  49. 1:48gonna have a holy puck so there's gonna
  50. 1:50be holes all over the place all right
  51. 1:52then you're gonna tamp on top of that
  52. 1:53and the speculation what sheldon says is
  53. 1:55that's going to cause a less dense puck
  54. 1:57because you're going to have all these
  55. 1:58different little holes in it though
  56. 1:59they're still going to be there even
  57. 2:01though you won't see them and so when
  58. 2:02the water hits it the water is going to
  59. 2:04find these lesser dense areas that its
  60. 2:06water is going to be able to get to the
  61. 2:07bottom of the puck with less perturbance
  62. 2:09and it's going to be able to give you a
  63. 2:11more even extraction okay and it's going
  64. 2:13to seal up those channels when the
  65. 2:14coffee expands okay so that is kind of
  66. 2:17the philosophy behind it so the
  67. 2:18origination of this idea doesn't
  68. 2:19actually trace back to sheldon it
  69. 2:21predates sheldon it goes back to 2016 or
  70. 2:23so when matt perger uh down at barista
  71. 2:26hustle was playing with this idea with
  72. 2:27his with michael cameron so they had
  73. 2:29this idea they had tools you can
  74. 2:32actually see a video i'll link below
  75. 2:33where they discuss this in 2017 uh this
  76. 2:36idea that they've been having and
  77. 2:37sitting on for the past year when they
  78. 2:38made that video so this is a
  79. 2:40pre-established idea and this is just an
  80. 2:43engineered version of what they were
  81. 2:45talking about and
  82. 2:47very well engineered i might add so is
  83. 2:50that actually what's going on though
  84. 2:51because i know you're watching this and
  85. 2:52you're going
  86. 2:53there's no way right so
  87. 2:56you know what we can test it out i know
  88. 2:58that there have been other videos made
  89. 2:59on this there have been other people who
  90. 3:01have done tests with it and it shows a
  91. 3:03minimal increase in extraction and so i
  92. 3:05was wanting to find someone to
  93. 3:06collaborate with on compiling some data
  94. 3:10and so i found out a friend of mine from
  95. 3:12the espresso aficionado discord had
  96. 3:14already begun doing a study on this and
  97. 3:16was about to publish a blog so i talked
  98. 3:18with him i corroborated some of his
  99. 3:20evidence and i'm going to present to you
  100. 3:21now what shay
  101. 3:23has found about what actually happens
  102. 3:27when you use this and it is not what you
  103. 3:29think it is
  104. 3:32so
  105. 3:33what this actually does according to his
  106. 3:35study i'm just going to give you the
  107. 3:36tldr or too long didn't watch tldw
  108. 3:39what this is actually doing is it is not
  109. 3:42creating those channels in fact what it
  110. 3:43is doing is it is priming your puck to
  111. 3:45be able to be compressed to a higher
  112. 3:47density
  113. 3:49what what does that even mean so i have
  114. 3:52this blog below so you can you can look
  115. 3:53more in depth there but in short what's
  116. 3:56going on is when you create those holes
  117. 3:58hypothetically what's going on is you
  118. 4:00are creating a more
  119. 4:03susceptible bed for a higher compression
  120. 4:05when you tamp it okay so that just means
  121. 4:07whenever you use normal wdt and then you
  122. 4:10tamp you have x density and then
  123. 4:12whenever you use the porky press and
  124. 4:14then you tamp you have x density
  125. 4:17plus a little bit okay that's i'm not
  126. 4:20obviously mathematically correct but
  127. 4:21that the idea i'm trying to get is
  128. 4:23whenever you don't use the porky press
  129. 4:24you have a lesser dense puck than when
  130. 4:26you do use the porky press and this is
  131. 4:28all laid out in his blog the way he
  132. 4:30discovered this is he measured the puck
  133. 4:31density of with wdt and tamp and then
  134. 4:34wdt porky press and tamp the way he
  135. 4:37measured it was using a methodology
  136. 4:39outlined by michael cooper michael
  137. 4:41cameron who is with perger michael
  138. 4:42cooper who has an instagram called uh
  139. 4:45quantitative cafe i'll have a link down
  140. 4:47below go check out the work that
  141. 4:48michael's doing it's fantastic data
  142. 4:50analysis anyway by using the the method
  143. 4:54that michael cooper came up with on how
  144. 4:55to measure putt density shea repeated
  145. 4:57this experiment four times and found a
  146. 4:59direct correlation between using the
  147. 5:01porky press and the uh and not using the
  148. 5:04porcupine as regards the density so what
  149. 5:06does that mean you have higher density
  150. 5:08when using the porcupress this means
  151. 5:09that you have been able to take out dead
  152. 5:11space more dead space than without using
  153. 5:13it which can arguably increase your
  154. 5:16extraction now
  155. 5:18i ran the numbers i did exactly what
  156. 5:20shea did and i found that indeed when
  157. 5:22you're using really finely ground coffee
  158. 5:24you can in fact get higher extractions
  159. 5:27and i'll put my numbers up right here so
  160. 5:29what i found is when i did a a slow
  161. 5:32bloom style shot on the decent i
  162. 5:33replicated shae's parameters almost
  163. 5:35exactly on the decent espresso machine
  164. 5:37so i could have a consistent output
  165. 5:39when i replicated it i found a one to
  166. 5:41one and a half percent variance when i
  167. 5:44wasn't using the perky press versus when
  168. 5:46i was however when i first did the
  169. 5:48experiments i did not want to have to
  170. 5:50use some sort of crazy flow profile i
  171. 5:52used instead my breville dual boiler and
  172. 5:54i used just typical pre-infusion into a
  173. 5:57nine bar shot i did i wanted to see if
  174. 5:59this was
  175. 6:00purposeful for the typical home user who
  176. 6:02doesn't have you know an insane machine
  177. 6:04that allows you to do crazy float
  178. 6:05profiles and what i found was there was
  179. 6:07little to no difference with or without
  180. 6:09the porcupress when i was talking to
  181. 6:11shea about this it turns out that the
  182. 6:13coarser you go in your grind size the
  183. 6:15less of an effect this has and it's
  184. 6:17because the coarser you go the less
  185. 6:20channeling there's going to be in
  186. 6:22general because the coarser it is the
  187. 6:23less clumping the less um
  188. 6:26the less higher dense
  189. 6:28areas in the puck will be occurring for
  190. 6:30there to be a need for this porky press
  191. 6:32which allows for a higher density tamp
  192. 6:34so that actually collaborates well with
  193. 6:37the chris hendon paper that i discuss in
  194. 6:40this video on turbo shots that talks
  195. 6:42about this volcano effect whenever you
  196. 6:44you would expect when you start let's
  197. 6:46say we have an x y axis here so we're
  198. 6:48actually going to draw it with my finger
  199. 6:49and i'm going to do it the opposite
  200. 6:50direction i'm going to do it this so it
  201. 6:51makes more sense for you boom all right
  202. 6:53now down here on the x-axis we have
  203. 6:56fineness to coarseness on the y-axis we
  204. 7:00have extraction yield okay
  205. 7:03fineness to coarseness extraction yield
  206. 7:04now if you're thinking about it the more
  207. 7:06surface area that you expose when
  208. 7:08grinding finer and finer you should be
  209. 7:10able to go higher and higher and higher
  210. 7:12until you can't grind and find any more
  211. 7:14right
  212. 7:15theoretically that's what should happen
  213. 7:17but what was discovered in that hidden
  214. 7:19paper with turbo shots is that you
  215. 7:21actually increase increase increase
  216. 7:22until a certain amount and then you
  217. 7:24start to decrease extraction and that is
  218. 7:26very peculiar the reason is because as
  219. 7:29you get finer and finer it's more and
  220. 7:31more difficult for the water to go
  221. 7:33through the puck evenly a lot of
  222. 7:35channels become created and you start
  223. 7:37decreasing your extraction
  224. 7:39so
  225. 7:40what you can do is use this porky press
  226. 7:42it allows for more even extraction
  227. 7:44allows for the water to go through it
  228. 7:45more evenly by breaking up by by
  229. 7:48disallowing some of those clumps that
  230. 7:49might disallow a higher density and uh
  231. 7:52and forces the water through at a more
  232. 7:55even rate okay so instead of having the
  233. 7:57peak be say here on our graph maybe we
  234. 7:59can move the peak a little higher to
  235. 8:01over here you know so that's kind of
  236. 8:03what the purpose of this tool is is when
  237. 8:04you get into those really fine settings
  238. 8:06where it's difficult to control
  239. 8:07channeling this can help you by
  240. 8:09increasing your puck density and thereby
  241. 8:11increasing your extraction yield now
  242. 8:14let's just ask the question is this
  243. 8:16absolutely necessary even if it does
  244. 8:18increase it
  245. 8:20it depends on what you're looking for in
  246. 8:21a coffee i have found that when i do use
  247. 8:24this side by side with one that i don't
  248. 8:25use a porky press and where it does work
  249. 8:28effectively enough to have one or one
  250. 8:29and a half percent extraction advantage
  251. 8:32over the other i have found sweeter
  252. 8:34shots okay and a little more clarity a
  253. 8:37little less muddle and i suspect it's
  254. 8:38because i'm getting a little less
  255. 8:40channels and a little higher extraction
  256. 8:42with
  257. 8:43without with a more even extraction
  258. 8:45throughout the bed so maybe i'm getting
  259. 8:4723 percent without the porcupress and i
  260. 8:49have a part of the puck that's 25 apart
  261. 8:52that's 20
  262. 8:53perhaps with this i'm getting more
  263. 8:54evenly 24 across the pug so i'm not
  264. 8:56getting some undesired flavors from
  265. 8:58certain parts of the puck that i might
  266. 9:00in one without the porky press of course
  267. 9:01this is all speculation but what i'm
  268. 9:03trying to get at is i have noticed an
  269. 9:05increase in my enjoyment of the espresso
  270. 9:07using the porky press but only in those
  271. 9:10shots where you use a fine enough grind
  272. 9:12where it would make a difference if
  273. 9:13you're doing nine bar style shots or
  274. 9:15even i did a 20 second pre-infusion nine
  275. 9:18bar shot and even there the differences
  276. 9:20were so minimal it didn't really matter
  277. 9:22if i used the porcupress or not so
  278. 9:25does this tool matter
  279. 9:28it depends on what style of espresso
  280. 9:29you're drinking if you're doing darker
  281. 9:31roasted coffees it's not going to do
  282. 9:32anything for you if you're doing medium
  283. 9:34to light to really lightly roasted
  284. 9:35coffees and you're doing crazy flow
  285. 9:37profiles this can really increase your
  286. 9:39extraction and can really help with some
  287. 9:42skewed puck preparation but is it
  288. 9:44necessary that's up for you to decide
  289. 9:47now what i'm going to do now just as
  290. 9:49proof because i know you all like this
  291. 9:50i'm going to pull two shots
  292. 9:52and one of them i'm going to use a porky
  293. 9:54press one i'm not going to use a porky
  294. 9:55press i'm going to quickly measure the
  295. 9:56extraction and then we're going to taste
  296. 9:58it and i'm going to show you the how i
  297. 10:00did it how i did these shots when i was
  298. 10:03collecting data which it mirrors what
  299. 10:05shea was doing when collecting their
  300. 10:06data so here we go i'm going to get
  301. 10:08these shots ready here we go boom all
  302. 10:10right so the way i'm going to be
  303. 10:11preparing this is i've got these chemex
  304. 10:13filters that i cut using a 2.25 inch
  305. 10:16hole cutter
  306. 10:17and i have same basket in both of these
  307. 10:19portafilters they're both 18 grand
  308. 10:21baskets and so i put the filter on the
  309. 10:23bottom i'll grind the coffee up dump it
  310. 10:25in here and then i'm going to take
  311. 10:27just as shae did
  312. 10:29let's see
  313. 10:30i'm going to take my 0.3 millimeter wdt
  314. 10:34tool same exact one that shea used and
  315. 10:36i'm going to be doing deep wdt the way
  316. 10:38that i do it which is i like to call it
  317. 10:40earth around the sun so we're going to
  318. 10:41do small rotations in a big revolution
  319. 10:43and i'm going to do that all the way up
  320. 10:45to the surface then right after that i'm
  321. 10:47gonna give for when i do porky press a
  322. 10:49slight tap
  323. 10:51put it on
  324. 10:52punch
  325. 10:53flip it
  326. 10:54punch and that way i get double the
  327. 10:56amount of holes because the design flips
  328. 10:57at 180. and then the other one i'm going
  329. 10:59to do everything the same with the
  330. 11:00slight tap and all i won't use a porky
  331. 11:02press i'll just tamp and for the tamping
  332. 11:05i'll be using
  333. 11:06my calibrated
  334. 11:08self-leveling decent v3 tamper so this
  335. 11:12is going to allow me to replicate almost
  336. 11:14exactly uh the the puck preparation in
  337. 11:17both and then we'll pull the shots we'll
  338. 11:19see which one uh what what they pulled
  339. 11:21in the extraction level and then taste
  340. 11:23and then we'll be done all right and
  341. 11:24here we go all right so i just pulled
  342. 11:26both shots i again i put the chemex
  343. 11:28filter at the bottom i put in the
  344. 11:29grounds i deep wdt'd coming up and then
  345. 11:32i
  346. 11:33did a slight tamp and with the porky
  347. 11:35press
  348. 11:36pressed it 180 pressed it with this
  349. 11:38design on the bottom okay
  350. 11:40same as what shea used and then i put a
  351. 11:43mesh filter on top i forgot to add that
  352. 11:45and i tamped it once more with the
  353. 11:46calibrated tamper for both of them all
  354. 11:48right so everything was exactly
  355. 11:49identical i pulled both shots now
  356. 11:52interestingly and i've already refracted
  357. 11:54them so the one with the porcupress came
  358. 11:56out in 42 seconds and that's using that
  359. 12:00slow bloom profile obviously it's gonna
  360. 12:02take a long time for that and then with
  361. 12:04the uh with the one without the porky
  362. 12:06press it came out in 43 seconds so it
  363. 12:09took one second longer now the
  364. 12:11differences in the extractions is where
  365. 12:13it's interesting with the one and i'm
  366. 12:15pulling a lot papaya last year's crop
  367. 12:17that i had frozen my freezer from
  368. 12:19lacabra the one with the porky press
  369. 12:21came out just over 24 extraction 24.1
  370. 12:25the one without it came out at
  371. 12:2823.22 percent extraction and it was one
  372. 12:31second longer so we're getting a
  373. 12:33higher extraction and just about just
  374. 12:35about the same amount of time which is
  375. 12:37really interesting and shay yet has
  376. 12:38another uh hypothesis there i've not
  377. 12:40done enough to really be able to
  378. 12:41corroborate that evidence but
  379. 12:43interesting to look at that article none
  380. 12:45the less that i have down the caption
  381. 12:46anyway let's get to tasting and we're
  382. 12:48gonna see if there is a difference
  383. 12:50between this one we use the porky press
  384. 12:53on and the one without all right here we
  385. 12:54go
  386. 12:57actually i should probably do the one
  387. 12:58without porky press first
  388. 13:08okay let me grab a sip of water
  389. 13:15all right
  390. 13:22okay well
  391. 13:25as always my tastings are more so a
  392. 13:26reflection of all the testing that i've
  393. 13:28already done i've pulled
  394. 13:29on this specifically i've pulled at
  395. 13:31least 40 or 50 by sides
  396. 13:34and again this this lines up with it i'm
  397. 13:36getting much more of that ripe fruit
  398. 13:38taste and sweetness coming out of the
  399. 13:40one i use a porky press with then the
  400. 13:41one without though they're both
  401. 13:43incredibly delicious shots that it seems
  402. 13:45that the porky press what it really does
  403. 13:47well is when it's really fine settings
  404. 13:49it can improve the extraction but for
  405. 13:51the most part it helps improve your
  406. 13:53consistency so regardless of what style
  407. 13:55shot you're pulling it's going to be
  408. 13:58it's not going to hurt
  409. 13:59the question is whether or not you
  410. 14:01should invest the amount of money these
  411. 14:02are like 250
  412. 14:03whether you should invest that amount of
  413. 14:05money to improve your espresso if you're
  414. 14:07someone that pulls normal shots no i
  415. 14:09would not recommend it if you're someone
  416. 14:11that every now and then pulls a flow
  417. 14:12profile shot no i would not recommend it
  418. 14:14even if you're someone that pulls
  419. 14:15frequently flow-profiled shots
  420. 14:18it depends on what you're looking for in
  421. 14:19your coffee if you want to squeeze out
  422. 14:20an extra percentage of extraction then
  423. 14:22this is likely for you if you want to
  424. 14:24push your if you're drinking really
  425. 14:26really lightly roasted coffees and you
  426. 14:28need help pushing the extraction then
  427. 14:29this could probably help you out a lot
  428. 14:31if you're someone let's see drinking
  429. 14:33medium roast something that's really
  430. 14:34soluble it's likely not going to do that
  431. 14:36much to your coffee so keep that in mind
  432. 14:39i i like this tool it will definitely be
  433. 14:41a part of my preparation whenever i'm
  434. 14:43dealing with really lightly roasted
  435. 14:44coffees and i'm trying to go with crazy
  436. 14:46high extractions but if you're doing
  437. 14:47anything that's coarse enough for a nine
  438. 14:49bar extraction or a turbo shot or
  439. 14:51anything along those lines it's too
  440. 14:53coarse for this to make a big difference
  441. 14:55at least in my experience as well as in
  442. 14:57shae's experience
  443. 14:59anyway i hope that was helpful if you
  444. 15:01you know if you have one of these around
  445. 15:03you know take take a look there's also a
  446. 15:05more budget-friendly one i didn't do or
  447. 15:07just testing with it but my friend
  448. 15:09dennis sabu out in austria has made a 3d
  449. 15:11printed one
  450. 15:13with a with sewing needles in it so you
  451. 15:15can check this out and see if it does
  452. 15:16something similar i'll be i'll be
  453. 15:18playing around with this soon now that i
  454. 15:19have all the data with the porky press
  455. 15:20but anyway thank you so much for
  456. 15:22watching this video again if you enjoyed
  457. 15:25it please you know drop a like subscribe
  458. 15:26check out my patreon check out the
  459. 15:28caption i have all my resources there i
  460. 15:30just want to thank you so much you all
  461. 15:31rock brew something tasty today and
  462. 15:34cheers

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of IS THIS $300 ESPRESSO TOOL WORTH IT?: The Porcupress Review by Lance Hedrick, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,176 words across 462 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.