Is Keto Bad For Your Heart — Dr. Eric Thorn — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00is Quito bad for your heart and I'm not
- 0:03going to promise to give you a
- 0:04definitive answer but I'm gonna give you
- 0:06my take on it so to really kind of
- 0:11define what we're talking about I want
- 0:13to talk about what is heart disease
- 0:15because we all know it so it's very
- 0:16important heart disease kills one out of
- 0:18four people in the United States about a
- 0:21quarter of a million people every year
- 0:22in the United States has a heart attack
- 0:26and this is the leading cause of death
- 0:28in men and women and most almost all
- 0:31ethnic groups and when it's not it's
- 0:32just behind cancer so it's a pretty
- 0:34important topic
- 0:36not to mention costs our society two
- 0:38hundred billion dollars a year so heart
- 0:42disease can mean a lot of different
- 0:44things but what I'm going to refer to is
- 0:46specifically coronary heart disease so
- 0:50this is the process by which the
- 0:51arteries that carry blood to our heart
- 0:53build up what we refer to as plaque
- 0:56which can cause narrowing of the
- 0:58arteries and ultimately when it becomes
- 1:02unstable can lead to blood clots forming
- 1:05inside these tiny vessels I mean these
- 1:07things are at best four millimeters in
- 1:09diameter and so as you can imagine if a
- 1:10blood clot forms there you're in bad
- 1:12shape and that's what causes a heart
- 1:13attack
- 1:14so the question then becomes what is
- 1:17plaque and why does it get there because
- 1:19if we want to know about whether we're
- 1:20harming ourselves we need to be able to
- 1:22answer that question
- 1:23so plaque is a substance that builds up
- 1:28within the walls of the vessel and it's
- 1:32made up of a number of things so partly
- 1:34it's made up of cholesterol and a very
- 1:38simplistic way of thinking about it is
- 1:40if you have high cholesterol will build
- 1:42up in the arteries and that forms the
- 1:43plaque and that's what causes the
- 1:45problem but over the years for decades
- 1:50now our understanding of plaque or
- 1:52sometimes this is referred to as
- 1:54atherosclerosis has become a lot more
- 1:57nuanced and we know that there's a lot
- 1:59that goes into this in fact cholesterol
- 2:00is not the only things there so there's
- 2:02cells from the immune system there's
- 2:05expansion of smooth muscle cells and
- 2:09fibrous scar tissue in the plaque
- 2:12and this happens for multiple reasons
- 2:16so cholesterol likely does play a role
- 2:19but there's also a process of
- 2:22inflammation where the immune system is
- 2:24over activated or chronically activated
- 2:27there's something called oxidative
- 2:28stress where oxygen causes damage to
- 2:31molecules which then damages the
- 2:33arteries there's excessive blood sugar
- 2:36which then the sugar can attach to
- 2:37proteins and fats in the system and
- 2:42cause problems that way there's calcium
- 2:44deposition the same mineral that's found
- 2:46in bone ends up depositing in the plaque
- 2:49so it's a very complex process some of
- 2:51it's just related to the way the blood
- 2:53flows so the key then is to determine
- 2:58how are these things leading to risk too
- 3:00so that we can then figure out how do
- 3:02you prevent this process and that's the
- 3:04answer the question is if keto is going
- 3:06to harm it so the way that heart disease
- 3:11risk is looked at is there's a number of
- 3:13so-called traditional risk factors so
- 3:16some of these things we can't do
- 3:17anything about so aging is a risk factor
- 3:19when you figure out that one let me know
- 3:21about it
- 3:23genetics we can't change where you know
- 3:26we are you have what you're born with
- 3:28and some and heart disease does run in
- 3:30families and it's not just usually just
- 3:31one gene it's usually kind of the sum
- 3:33total of everything that you come into
- 3:35the world with other factors you're
- 3:39probably very familiar with things like
- 3:40smoking lack of physical activity
- 3:44they're elevated blood sugar and
- 3:50abnormalities in cholesterol in
- 3:53particular elevated LDL cholesterol low
- 3:56HDL cholesterol I'm going to talk more
- 3:58about this in a little bit high
- 4:00triglycerides high blood pressure is a
- 4:03risk factor and and then and then there
- 4:09are the other respect factors that are
- 4:11not necessarily considered the
- 4:12traditional risk factors but things like
- 4:14excessive inflammation if you look at at
- 4:21these different factors so some of them
- 4:23we can't change
- 4:24some of them are we can address by
- 4:28lifestyle changes or medications and
- 4:30then some of them stand out in
- 4:32particular over the past 30 or 40 years
- 4:34because they've been getting worse and
- 4:37specifically these are the epidemics of
- 4:40obesity and weight gain and I mentioned
- 4:42obesity is a risk factor and and also
- 4:46diabetes so presumably if we're going to
- 4:53favorably impact or unfavorable impact
- 4:57heart disease one way to look at it
- 5:00would be to say how does anything we do
- 5:01affect these so called risk factors now
- 5:06notice one of the things I didn't
- 5:08mention as a risk factor was diet or fat
- 5:13in the diet so the the conception of how
- 5:17diet plays into it and the risk diet
- 5:19plays is that fat is the harmful factor
- 5:21this is the so called diet heart
- 5:24hypothesis and so the idea is that if
- 5:27you eat fat in your diet it's going to
- 5:30collect in your bloodstream and it's
- 5:31gonna then raise your cholesterol
- 5:33or just remain and its own form as fat
- 5:37in the blood vessels and then it's going
- 5:39to get in the walls of the blood vessels
- 5:40and that makes plaque very simple right
- 5:42it's just like if you poured fat down
- 5:43your drain it's going to clog the drain
- 5:44same thing happens in the arteries so
- 5:47this idea came about over fifty years
- 5:51ago and as it turns out it's just not
- 5:53true it doesn't happen this way and
- 5:57that's been shown through a number of
- 6:00different studies and and more recently
- 6:04in what are called meta analyses where
- 6:06scientists researchers will take a
- 6:08number of different studies and combine
- 6:10them together using statistics to try to
- 6:12see if there's a signal to show harm or
- 6:15benefit and so when when a lot of this
- 6:19data supposedly showing that fats
- 6:22harmful comes from observational studies
- 6:24where they just follow a big group of
- 6:26people for years and years and years and
- 6:28to see you know and you know that a
- 6:30certain number of people are gonna have
- 6:31heart attacks or strokes or die and so
- 6:34then you look to see you know okay well
- 6:36what what could predict that if we
- 6:38ahead of time and when they've gone back
- 6:41and analyzed these studies and put them
- 6:43together they found that one of the
- 6:44things that doesn't predict heart
- 6:46disease or death is that trait of fat
- 6:52what's stronger than observational
- 6:54studies are randomized control trials so
- 6:59here what we'd like to be able to do is
- 7:01say let's take a group of people and
- 7:02we'll do an intervention for half of
- 7:05them and not for the other half or two
- 7:06different interventions and then compare
- 7:09because then you know that the only
- 7:10thing that was different between the
- 7:11people and the group is what you changed
- 7:14and in fact this has been done in a
- 7:18number of different trials looking at
- 7:20lowering people's fat intake or
- 7:21sometimes replacing the saturated fat
- 7:24with a different type of fat called
- 7:26polyunsaturated fat this is a fat that's
- 7:27in you know nuts and and vegetables so
- 7:32different from animal fats and then
- 7:35let's look in the randomized trial to
- 7:37see who has more events or not now
- 7:40there's been quite a few of these done
- 7:43when you look though at the very largest
- 7:46of these trials so this is one of the
- 7:49largest diets diet studies are very hard
- 7:51to do because you it's hard to change
- 7:53one thing you have to file people for
- 7:55many many years it's tremendously
- 7:56expensive but though there was a study
- 8:00called the Women's Health Initiative
- 8:01that was done in the 90s where they took
- 8:03forty eight thousand forty nine thousand
- 8:06women and they took a certain proportion
- 8:09of them and put them on a low-fat diet
- 8:10and the rest of them they just gave the
- 8:12Dietary Guidelines not ideal I know but
- 8:15that was the control group that gave the
- 8:16dietary guidelines just said try to do
- 8:18this in the group of women on the
- 8:20low-fat diet they did successfully
- 8:22reduce the fat in their diet that they
- 8:25were eating they reduced the saturated
- 8:26fat to less than 10% is recommended and
- 8:29when that study was done what they found
- 8:31was that there was no difference and
- 8:34death and heart disease in cancer rates
- 8:37it didn't make a bit of difference and
- 8:39now the researchers tried to spin it to
- 8:41say well this means you know all of you
- 8:43low-carb people thought that low-fat
- 8:45diets would be horrible and look we did
- 8:46a low-fat diet and didn't hurt anybody
- 8:48that's called changing the goal moving
- 8:50the goalposts right
- 8:52and more recently there been some other
- 8:54meta-analyses that have looked at some
- 8:56of these trials because some people
- 8:57would say well it's not just loading the
- 8:58fat because people are fat and replaced
- 9:00with carbs we know that's bad but if you
- 9:03replace the fat with these
- 9:04polyunsaturated fats healthier fats then
- 9:07good things will happen but even in
- 9:11these trials when they're analyzed and
- 9:13we only include the ones that were
- 9:15actually performed with good research
- 9:18methodology no signal for fat reducing
- 9:21fat causing heart disease so this idea
- 9:24that fat in the diet causes high
- 9:25cholesterol it's out the window it's not
- 9:29just just not true
- 9:30it doesn't mean diets not important as I
- 9:33think we all know but fats not the
- 9:34problem
- 9:35so the question then is in light of all
- 9:40these risk factors you know what what
- 9:42role does keto have so it is how does
- 9:44keto affect these risk factors so in
- 9:48answering this question I think it's
- 9:52helpful to have a conception of this
- 9:55idea called the metabolic syndrome how
- 9:57many of y'all have heard that term
- 9:58before yeah so any time we use the word
- 10:02syndrome in medicine it means that we've
- 10:05made an observation there's some things
- 10:07some symptoms some clinical conditions
- 10:09some things that thank you
- 10:17[Applause]
- 10:20right so that that's just proof that I
- 10:24don't do this alone and nor could I okay
- 10:31so when we use the term syndrome in
- 10:33medicine it means there's something
- 10:35going on here we don't really know what
- 10:38and the implication is that there's some
- 10:41kind of unifying feature so a lot of
- 10:45these risk factors high blood pressure
- 10:47high triglycerides low HDL cholesterol
- 10:50elevations in blood sugar fat deposition
- 10:54the liver and in fact weight gain
- 10:56particularly belly fat the visceral fat
- 10:58are in the middle these things cluster
- 11:01together they seem these are separate
- 11:03things you know what does high blood
- 11:04pressure have to do with fat in the
- 11:06liver and yet they cluster together and
- 11:07so there must be something underlying
- 11:10all this a lot of people would say it's
- 11:11it's the way Cade is the fat but plenty
- 11:13of people have this problem and they're
- 11:15not overweight and so that doesn't
- 11:18really make a whole lot of sense that
- 11:19the fats the the cause so when we look
- 11:24back at what unifies these things it's a
- 11:26hormone and that hormone is insulin and
- 11:28then ultimately there's something called
- 11:31insulin resistance that dr. Westman
- 11:32spoke about where then the liver and the
- 11:34muscles and other parts of body stop
- 11:36responding as well but the root issue
- 11:38here is excessive levels of insulin well
- 11:41then it's okay what causes the insulin
- 11:43and that's carbohydrate so it stands to
- 11:50reason that if you wanted to favorably
- 11:55impact these risk factors causing heart
- 11:57disease you would want an intervention
- 11:58that lowers insulin and ultimately to
- 12:00lower the insulin you probably know
- 12:01lower the carbohydrate so wait a second
- 12:03seems like keto ought to be good for the
- 12:05heart
- 12:06and so let's ask the question of how
- 12:08does keto affect these risk factors is
- 12:10this true
- 12:12what's certainly true the keto lowers
- 12:18carbohydrate and insulin because first
- 12:19we need to make sure that this is a true
- 12:21statement and in fact when this is study
- 12:23this is just a graph and you could see
- 12:25the red line are patients this is from a
- 12:28small study where
- 12:30the patients were divided into three
- 12:31groups half of whom were given a very
- 12:32low carb diet that's the red line and
- 12:34then the other half we were given either
- 12:36given a very low-fat diet or a high
- 12:40unsaturated fat diet and so this is a
- 12:43graph from with where they gave him what
- 12:45they called a meal tolerance test and
- 12:46they gave him an appropriate meal from
- 12:48the type of diet they were eating and
- 12:49they followed what was the sugar and
- 12:50what was the the insulin doing and you
- 12:56can see you don't even need to see the
- 12:58bars of statistical significance here to
- 13:01see that there's a marked difference
- 13:02with the very low carb diet so nothing
- 13:05lowers carbohydrate in the blood and
- 13:07insulin like Aikido or low-carb diet and
- 13:12in fact when we look at the risk factor
- 13:15of obesity consistently almost without
- 13:18fail low carb diets have been shown to
- 13:20be superior to low-fat diets for weight
- 13:23loss so this is a graphic from the
- 13:27public health collaboration this is the
- 13:29same website and I put the website I got
- 13:31it from on the bottom it's the same one
- 13:33that dr. Westman mentioned and actually
- 13:34I have to correct them because now at 62
- 13:36studies not 47 so these studies keep on
- 13:40coming out and it's never a different
- 13:43result you might wonder why people keep
- 13:44doing them because there's always either
- 13:47a statistical improvement on low-carb or
- 13:51even if it's not statistical still
- 13:52numerically low-carb does better there
- 13:55are only two where it's equal you could
- 13:58see there's seven where low-fat did
- 14:01better but those weren't statistically
- 14:02significant so this you know this this
- 14:05is called what we call runaway victory
- 14:13well this I think I not sure how read
- 14:16how often they update this this is at
- 14:17least from 2016 and maybe more recent so
- 14:20so here's some graphs from comparing
- 14:23looking at a couple of different studies
- 14:25and looking at a number of these risk
- 14:27factors and what you could see this so
- 14:30the one on the the left side of the
- 14:32screen is from a study that was
- 14:33published way back at 2003 so definitely
- 14:36the grad students aren't looking at that
- 14:37one and here they looked at a number of
- 14:40different diets and what you could see
- 14:42on the bars is that for way
- 14:43for insulin levels 40 Aegeus
- 14:45triglycerides HDL cholesterol and then
- 14:48diastolic blood pressure you could see
- 14:50that that the the low-carb group which
- 14:53is the light blue and the dark blue is
- 14:54just six and twelve months you know
- 14:56number one its favorably impacting the
- 14:58risk factor so forget about low fat but
- 15:00low carbs doing good things but it's
- 15:02also better than low fat for what it's
- 15:04worth and then on the right side we're
- 15:06just seeing kind of more of the same
- 15:07this is a summary from two different
- 15:10studies where one of which was one of
- 15:12dr. Westman studies and you could see
- 15:16that in the the first study that's the
- 15:19orange and the blue bars this was a
- 15:22cereal diet high grain versus a low
- 15:25glycemic index which is lower carb but
- 15:27not very low carb and then that's
- 15:29compared to the low glycemic index in
- 15:32the purple and then the fuchsia is the
- 15:34low carb group and you could see that
- 15:35number one that the low carb favorably
- 15:38in favorably impacts almost all the risk
- 15:40factors weight a one C which is a
- 15:42measure of blood sugar glucose which is
- 15:45blood sugar the total cholesterol the
- 15:48HDL and the triglycerides so low carb is
- 15:50clearly effective for favorably
- 15:53impacting these risk factors that we've
- 15:55already identified as being causative
- 15:56heart disease
- 15:57we'll get to the LDL in a moment one one
- 16:01thing that people might say it's like
- 16:02all Shore the low-carb helps these
- 16:04things but it's because people are
- 16:05losing weight but this isn't completely
- 16:08true that's probably part of it but this
- 16:10is an example one of many where the
- 16:14low-carb diet was compared to a
- 16:16calorically restricted low-fat diet with
- 16:19a drug called or Lissette that prevents
- 16:21fat absorption and people lost weight
- 16:24essentially to an equivalent degree in
- 16:27both groups so here you help the low-fat
- 16:30out diet out by lowering the calories
- 16:31and giving them a medication and they
- 16:33can have equal weight loss to low carb
- 16:35but the effects on blood pressure were
- 16:37different so the patients in the
- 16:38low-carb group that's the blue line you
- 16:40could see it 48 weeks the blood pressure
- 16:42went down on the other hand on the on
- 16:46the other group where they also lost
- 16:47weight the blood pressure didn't get
- 16:49better and it may have started to for
- 16:51the diastolic and the picture on the
- 16:52right but it's sort of going back up
- 16:54again so this isn't just weight loss
- 16:55that's causing the benefit
- 16:57this is a graph of a study done on fatty
- 17:00liver disease and here's what's what
- 17:01this is sort of similar to the one I
- 17:03just showed you where there wasn't a
- 17:04real difference in weight loss because
- 17:06they set up the study because it's not a
- 17:07weight loss study and on the right hand
- 17:10side you could see that on both a high
- 17:12carbon low-carb diet there is a
- 17:14reduction in IH TG
- 17:16that's that's fat and liver so the fat
- 17:19in the liver goes down if you lose
- 17:20weight but in 48 hours it's gone down
- 17:24much much more with the low-carb so
- 17:26low-carb improves fatty liver and
- 17:28potentially does it quicker and more
- 17:30effectively than low fat how about
- 17:34inflammation so there again there are
- 17:37multiple studies this is just one
- 17:40example of a study done with low carb
- 17:43versus versus a I care I think this was
- 17:47indeed a low-fat high-carb diet and CRP
- 17:51is a it's a it's a test we could do in
- 17:53the blood so when people have chronic
- 17:55inflammation really any inflammation to
- 17:57CRP level will be elevated and so a
- 17:59marker of how it flamed your body is as
- 18:01you do this blood test and in the
- 18:03low-carb group the CRP was reduced
- 18:07significantly versus the low fat group
- 18:09it didn't change a whole lot and so so I
- 18:13think these the comparisons to low-fat
- 18:14are important and useful and I think
- 18:16impressive but even more important than
- 18:18that I think is the idea that if we just
- 18:21want to say how does keto affect our
- 18:23risk factors it's consistently it's
- 18:26favorable so
- 18:29and lastly blood sugar it probably goes
- 18:31without saying that blood sugar improves
- 18:34better on a very low carb diet and and
- 18:37the a1c reduction here at 24 weeks in
- 18:41this particular study was nearly 2
- 18:43percent so let's talk about cholesterol
- 18:46because that's kind of the you know it's
- 18:48the it's the one thing that scares
- 18:49everybody so with this slide this is a
- 18:52bit competent aspect of the cholesterol
- 18:58panel or in the case of the upper left
- 19:00this is the total cholesterol and the
- 19:02authors of this study what they did is
- 19:04they reviewed a number of studies and
- 19:06each dot on the graph is one of these
- 19:09studies and they said let's look at all
- 19:11these
- 19:11different diet studies that compared
- 19:12low-carb and low-fat and see how did
- 19:15this the particular aspect of
- 19:18cholesterol change did it go up which
- 19:20would be above the line or down which
- 19:22was below the line and then you could
- 19:23kind of just look at the graphs to get a
- 19:24general Gestalt of what's happening and
- 19:27what they found is that the total
- 19:29cholesterol for the most part except for
- 19:31one outlier study didn't change a whole
- 19:32lot the HDL cholesterol so this is the
- 19:36so-called good cholesterol you want it
- 19:37to go up it did it went up probably by
- 19:39on average around 10 or 20 percent now
- 19:42that's in the bottom left there and for
- 19:44what it's worth when the total
- 19:45cholesterol went up in study number do
- 19:47you see number 22
- 19:48so the HDL went up a lot in that study
- 19:51so that made that probably explains why
- 19:54the total cholesterol went up in part
- 19:55and then the triglycerides on the upper
- 19:57right they went down a lot so
- 19:59triglycerides on low-carb typically with
- 20:01down about 30% and so so then that
- 20:04leaves us with LDL so if you look at LDL
- 20:08and generally speaking it looks like
- 20:10there's not a whole lot going on there
- 20:11so if somebody has concerns that if you
- 20:15go on a keto diet your LDL is going to
- 20:16go up well you could tell them that the
- 20:18data shows that it probably won't go up
- 20:20or if it does probably not a whole lot
- 20:22that's the broad general answer to the
- 20:25question it's probably a slight increase
- 20:29but this this is this basically what you
- 20:32could expect on average for cholesterol
- 20:34to do so a lot of favor all changes and
- 20:38nothing that's obviously harmful there
- 20:43so but let's talk in a little more
- 20:45detail about the LDL so LDL is reported
- 20:48when you get your cholesterol panel it's
- 20:50a concentration its milligrams of
- 20:52cholesterol per deciliter of blood the
- 20:55concentration doesn't tell you how it
- 20:58consists when it's in the blood so LDL
- 21:01stands for low density lipoprotein that
- 21:03refers to a particle carrying the
- 21:05cholesterol you know it's like a ship in
- 21:07the ocean carrying cargo and so these
- 21:09particles can be small or large they
- 21:14could be numerous or few and the
- 21:17concentration of the cholesterol doesn't
- 21:19tell you whether that's going to be the
- 21:22case or not in terms of the number size
- 21:24of the particles
- 21:25and so you could see from the simplistic
- 21:27diagram my slide you could have the same
- 21:30amount of cholesterol it had would be a
- 21:31whole lot of small little particles or
- 21:33you could have a the same amount of
- 21:34cholesterol and have just a small number
- 21:36of really big particles people refer to
- 21:38this as small dense versus large and
- 21:40buoyant and they've they've described
- 21:43these different patterns because you can
- 21:44basically categorize people to sort of
- 21:46one pattern or the other as pattern be
- 21:48having lots of small dense particles
- 21:51versus pattern a we have a smaller
- 21:53number of large particles same amount of
- 21:55cholesterol but it's packaged completely
- 21:57different and so even if the LDL
- 22:00concentration is not changing on keto
- 22:02maybe this is changing and in fact
- 22:04that's exactly what we see so what this
- 22:09slide demonstrates is a summary of a
- 22:13series of studies that were done with
- 22:14varying levels of carbohydrate versus
- 22:16fat in the diet and what you'll see is
- 22:19that if you go towards the left the fat
- 22:23percent is going down and the card
- 22:24percent is going up and what do you see
- 22:26in terms of the percent of patients who
- 22:28have pattern B it's going up and so what
- 22:33that says if you if you have more
- 22:34carbohydrate in your diet you're more
- 22:36likely to have that pattern B that's
- 22:38that's smoother lots of little particles
- 22:39versus going to the right as our fat
- 22:42percentage goes up but our carbohydrate
- 22:44percentage goes down the percent with
- 22:46pattern B goes going down well what's
- 22:48that mean that means more of those
- 22:49patients have pattern a so they're more
- 22:51likely to have the large particles why
- 22:53is that important so it's important
- 22:55because if you look at the risk for
- 22:58atherosclerosis for plaque buildup from
- 23:00LDL cholesterol when there's lots of
- 23:04little particles the risk is high when
- 23:06there's a small number of large
- 23:07particles the risk is low and so in fact
- 23:11even though the LDL is not changing on
- 23:13keto we are seeing favorable changes too
- 23:16even the bad cholesterol
- 23:22so lastly looking at the way these risk
- 23:25factors are impacted I'm going to show
- 23:29you a slide from a more recent study so
- 23:31this was not a randomized study but what
- 23:32it was was a control trial where
- 23:34patients with diabetes were put on a
- 23:37very low carb diet Keith's ketogenic
- 23:40diet ketone levels were measured so they
- 23:44knew the patients were following the
- 23:45diet there's a problem with a lot of
- 23:47these studies is you don't really know
- 23:48the patients are doing it so they knew
- 23:50these patients were doing it and
- 23:51somewhere around 85% of the patients at
- 23:54the end of the year we're still on the
- 23:55diet and they measured all of these risk
- 23:58factors and they just didn't just
- 23:59measure cholesterol this group measured
- 24:02the particles and the small particles
- 24:05and what you can see is that not only
- 24:08are all those risk factors that we just
- 24:10went through decreasing getting better
- 24:14but if you point out let me see if you
- 24:17can see my mouse pointer there so yeah
- 24:18so we look at the small LDL particles
- 24:21but going down a lot by about 20% and if
- 24:24we look at the total LDL particle never
- 24:27look again and see where that is they
- 24:28think it's here the total particle count
- 24:31on average went down and so even though
- 24:35the LDL cholesterol right here went up
- 24:40the aspects of the LDL cholesterol that
- 24:43are harmful improved what I'll also
- 24:47point out is so you go back here look
- 24:52down at the bottom look at these
- 24:53patients medications so they were able
- 24:56to take patients off of medications
- 24:58because of these improvements because we
- 25:00don't want to hurt people if somebody's
- 25:01blood pressure's going down I don't want
- 25:03to give them the same amount of blood
- 25:04pressure medication if the diabetes is
- 25:05getting better and I keep them on their
- 25:06diabetic medications it's harming them
- 25:10so the science that this at this stage
- 25:16in the game in 2018 is very clear all of
- 25:18the risk factors that we know about
- 25:20including LDL cholesterol on keto
- 25:23improve but there's this question
- 25:28regardless of all of this evidence and
- 25:30partly because people don't know it but
- 25:32there's this question that you get asked
- 25:34is there evidence
- 25:35that a ketogenic diet is safe so okay
- 25:41that's I guess a reasonable thing to ask
- 25:43although I think it's not completely
- 25:45fair because really the question in my
- 25:50mind is is there evidence that a
- 25:51ketogenic diet is harmful and so it's
- 25:55semantic but it's a little bit of a
- 25:56different question the burden of the
- 25:58proof should be on somebody who wants to
- 26:01say what you're doing is bad for you
- 26:03particularly when all the risk factors
- 26:05are getting better if they can't if they
- 26:08can't show you why it's harmful then we
- 26:12should be able to ignore them now they
- 26:14shouldn't have to you know we shouldn't
- 26:15be apt to prove that it's safe so the
- 26:20answer the question is there really
- 26:23isn't any evidence that these diets are
- 26:25harmful now I'm going to get some of the
- 26:28observational data in a few moments and
- 26:30I'll tell you straight off the bat that
- 26:32if you want to talk to me about rats and
- 26:35mice and what they eat I don't care
- 26:38that's that's that's fine and I'm a
- 26:41clinician and once you translate that
- 26:43research into at what actually happens
- 26:45to people then I'm all ears
- 26:47but what a mouse eats does not have
- 26:50relevance to the patients in my office
- 26:52so but there are a few things we can
- 26:56look at that are suggestive that a
- 26:59ketogenic diet is not harmful beyond
- 27:01looking at risk factors now that's a
- 27:04little disingenuous because this first
- 27:05graph that I'm showing you we're looking
- 27:07at risk factors but what I like about
- 27:09this particular study that was published
- 27:11a few years ago is that they did a
- 27:12meta-analysis and they took a number of
- 27:14different studies of low fat versus low
- 27:16carb and they looked at the risk factors
- 27:18and they they amalga today's in a way to
- 27:22say okay on balance is this person
- 27:25better off or not now we do this all the
- 27:27time in medicine and we use what are
- 27:29called risk calculators because you know
- 27:30let's say you quit smoking but then you
- 27:32start eating bad foods and your
- 27:34cholesterol gets worse are you better
- 27:36off or worse off it can be hard to say
- 27:40but what we can do is we can take
- 27:41observational studies that have been
- 27:43done punch your particular numbers into
- 27:46a calculator there's a number of
- 27:47different ones online and
- 27:49we can determine what's your risk of
- 27:50having a cardiovascular event in the
- 27:52next 10 years based on what has been
- 27:54observed in other populations and what
- 27:58these what this group did is that is
- 27:59they ran these calculations from the
- 28:02data and the studies that they looked at
- 28:04and then they said what's the chance
- 28:07that your risk would be better or worse
- 28:10on low-carb versus low-fat now in this
- 28:14graph one thing to point out is changed
- 28:17and predicted risk this is so first of
- 28:19all this is reduction and zero means
- 28:22there's no change up to 1.5 which is a
- 28:251.5 percent reduction in risk over 10
- 28:27years and so they didn't show anything
- 28:29on the other side because frankly
- 28:31there's hardly any data points there
- 28:34because when people adopt low-carb diets
- 28:37and so not adopt when they're assigned
- 28:39to it in a study and you look at the
- 28:40risk factors and you run the calculation
- 28:42if you look all the way over here just
- 28:45next to zero so let's say what's the
- 28:47chance that there's at least the most
- 28:49miniscule reduction in the patient's
- 28:51risk on a calculator if they follow
- 28:53though carb there's a 98.5 percent
- 28:55chance that your risk will be better on
- 28:59low-carb based on the risk calculators
- 29:01that all your doctors and cardiologists
- 29:03are using and in fact particularly for
- 29:08people who are at higher risk to begin
- 29:10with so these are divided by ethnicity
- 29:12but these two lines are the higher risk
- 29:14groups the chance on low-carb for
- 29:18high-risk whites that you get it at
- 29:20least a half a percent reduction there's
- 29:22a 50 / 50 percent chance that you'll get
- 29:25a half percent reduction or more and
- 29:27that's even higher for the
- 29:29african-americans now what about some
- 29:32actual markers of the VAT or si
- 29:35measurements of the vascular system so
- 29:38one way to measure how the vascular
- 29:41systems working is to look at something
- 29:42called flow mediated dilation so
- 29:44basically we're going to block off blood
- 29:47flow and then we're gonna let up the
- 29:48cuff and what should happen is you
- 29:50should see an increase in blood flow if
- 29:51the arteries are working properly and
- 29:54they in this study what was looked at
- 29:57was a comparison on low-carb versus
- 29:59low-fat to say is there a change in the
- 30:01flow mediated dilation
- 30:03Kito was bad this should get worse our
- 30:05blood vessel shouldn't work as well what
- 30:07they found is on average there wasn't a
- 30:08significant change at eight weeks
- 30:13another group looked at plaque in the
- 30:16carotid arteries and thickness of plaque
- 30:17in the even just thickness of the vessel
- 30:20wall in the carotid artery these
- 30:22arteries that carry blood or brain what
- 30:25they found was that comparing a low-fat
- 30:28diet to low-carb that there wasn't any
- 30:32significant difference
- 30:33so a low-carb conject diet did not make
- 30:36plaque thickness worse and in fact
- 30:40anybody who lost weight if the blood
- 30:42pressure went down it got better and
- 30:44they're the one most predictive feature
- 30:46and this in this particular study was
- 30:49how well the blood pressure improved for
- 30:50reducing carotid artery thickness which
- 30:52based on the previous data we know that
- 30:55more likely your blood pressure's going
- 30:56to improve on low-carb so even yep
- 30:58notwithstanding I think we're better off
- 31:02with low-carb so I'm gonna skip ahead a
- 31:06little bit just so we don't go too long
- 31:07on time but suffice it to stay there's
- 31:11not a lot of information in the stuff
- 31:12that I'm showing you our small studies
- 31:14short timeframe and I'm showing you that
- 31:17because there isn't much else out there
- 31:18there's no big long-term studies looking
- 31:22at actual heart disease rates or death
- 31:25and people who follow one diverse
- 31:27another a randomized study because
- 31:29they're hugely expensive and they really
- 31:30just haven't been done and probably
- 31:32never will be if you want to know my
- 31:33opinion because I don't I don't think
- 31:35it's really possible so then what about
- 31:38this question because you're going to
- 31:40get this one over and over again or
- 31:41you're gonna ask me so what about that
- 31:44study that just came out because I just
- 31:45told you there's no studies and yet we
- 31:46seem to hear about one every six weeks
- 31:49in the media so this is the latest so
- 31:53did you guys hear that if you eat a
- 31:55low-carb diet that you're going to die
- 31:56three years earlier yeah so here's the
- 32:00thing almost all these studies are
- 32:03observational studies these are not
- 32:05actual trials and in fact the
- 32:09observational studies usually aren't
- 32:11even truly studying Lokar versus
- 32:15something else there
- 32:17just studying whatever and and they're
- 32:22measuring things and then finding you
- 32:23know what comes out in the wash for the
- 32:25most part and they probably would say
- 32:26that's not a fair way to describe how
- 32:28they do these studies but overall in
- 32:31practice it sure seems that way
- 32:33so this particular study and I'm going
- 32:41to give you some points that were made
- 32:42by Nina title's who's an author and
- 32:45journalist who writes a lot about this
- 32:46so this was from an editorial she wrote
- 32:49in The Wall Street Journal so problems
- 32:51it was based on food question yeah
- 32:53questionnaires
- 32:54the amount of calories they ate in the
- 32:55study were were lower than so low they
- 32:59didn't make sense they said half the
- 33:01people in the study we're eating less
- 33:02than 1500 calories or so a day they only
- 33:06asked what people ate two times and and
- 33:09then didn't for 15 years and following
- 33:11the patients and they didn't include
- 33:14anybody who developed heart disease or
- 33:17diabetes before the second time they
- 33:19asked them they threw those people out
- 33:22any observational study where you're not
- 33:24randomizing there's all kinds of what
- 33:27are called confounding variables things
- 33:29that are interrelated that don't get
- 33:31measured that they try to control for so
- 33:32I'll give you a particular example in
- 33:34this study the best I can tell in
- 33:36reading their statistical method section
- 33:37they didn't control for how much sugar
- 33:39people are eating that's kind of idiotic
- 33:42right and and then the fact that matter
- 33:47is it the if the end result they can't
- 33:50explain it in a way that makes sense so
- 33:52if you supposedly are showing that
- 33:54low-carb kills people you have to
- 33:56explain how and one of their
- 33:59explanations for instance was
- 34:00inflammatory stress but low-carb diet a
- 34:03keto diets reduce markers of
- 34:04inflammation so how does this make sense
- 34:06when all of those other markers are
- 34:08getting better and whenever you hear
- 34:11these studies in the media you never
- 34:12hear anybody really explaining how this
- 34:14happens and that's got to get your
- 34:16antennae for something suspicious going
- 34:18on going up and so I'll just give you a
- 34:21few pointers on why my recommendation is
- 34:23to try to really tune this stuff out so
- 34:26this is data from the National Health
- 34:27and Nutrition survey that the government
- 34:29does and they
- 34:30use what are called food frequency
- 34:32questionnaire so almost all these
- 34:33studies use some kind of memory based
- 34:35tool for determining what people ate and
- 34:38the percentage on the left is the
- 34:41percentage of reports that if the
- 34:43patient was telling the truth or I
- 34:44should say if they were remembering
- 34:46accurately cuz I'm not saying they're
- 34:47not telling the truth but people can't
- 34:49remember what the ADA I'd be trying to
- 34:50remember what you ate two weeks ago it's
- 34:52hard and it's colored by a lot of other
- 34:55things so if these people actually were
- 34:57eating what they reported they eat then
- 35:00over two thirds of them couldn't be
- 35:03alive it's not compatible with basic
- 35:06metabolic rates in life it's craziness
- 35:10and so any study that's based on this
- 35:13particular tool which is flawed you know
- 35:16you've heard the term garbage in garbage
- 35:17out you've heard that saying well there
- 35:20you go I mean how can you make
- 35:22conclusions off of bad data in the first
- 35:24place and there's all these different
- 35:27things I don't know if they it does did
- 35:29my I should have used a different slide
- 35:31there but you could think of any number
- 35:33of things that might be connected to
- 35:34what you eat and let me give you an
- 35:37example of how this potentially works so
- 35:40you know if you imagine that somebody's
- 35:44really focused on health and they've
- 35:47been listening to these Dietary
- 35:48Guidelines and so they're eating what we
- 35:51would consider probably not the best
- 35:52diet well they're probably if they're
- 35:56that focus though on health and
- 35:58following rules they're probably
- 36:00focusing on a lot of other things like
- 36:01they don't smoke they exercise they're
- 36:03probably you know making sure they're
- 36:07getting good sleep there's a lot of
- 36:09other things that they do whereas
- 36:11somebody who has been living you know
- 36:15hasn't I should say hasn't been living
- 36:17under a rock and is has been completely
- 36:22ignoring the flawed advice that's out
- 36:25there well the reason they're ignoring
- 36:28it is probably not because there are a
- 36:29low carb proponent it's probably because
- 36:31they just don't care that much and
- 36:32they're probably not doing all the other
- 36:34healthy or other other health-related
- 36:37behaviors that they ought to be doing
- 36:38and you can't control for all of these
- 36:41things and so what you get is they call
- 36:43it like the healthy
- 36:44user effect and so the people who do
- 36:46better where you find out that they were
- 36:48eating a low-fat diet but maybe that's
- 36:51just because they were doing all these
- 36:52other things so and when it comes down
- 36:56to it you can relate just about any food
- 37:00this is a really interesting one and
- 37:02I'll probably end on this and then save
- 37:04the other stuff of questions but so that
- 37:06this this graph is from a study that was
- 37:10done by a researcher and Stanford who
- 37:15focuses a lot on these methodological
- 37:16issues with studies and what they did is
- 37:20they took a cookbook that's been in
- 37:22print for a long long time and they
- 37:23randomly selected ingredients and they
- 37:27picked out randomly 50 ingredients from
- 37:29the cookbook things including pepper
- 37:30flour
- 37:31common stuff and then they went into the
- 37:34medical literature and they said how
- 37:36many of these things have been
- 37:37associated with some sort of health
- 37:39outcome good or bad and specifically
- 37:41they're looking at different cancers and
- 37:42they found that then I'm probably going
- 37:45to give you the I'm probably gonna get
- 37:47the slightly wrong but I think it was 47
- 37:49out of 50 ingredients
- 37:50we're associated with something and what
- 37:53the graph shows is for most of those
- 37:55ingredients so they listed that's on the
- 37:57bottom part here you could see dots on
- 37:59both sides of the line so they were
- 38:01found to be both helpful and harmful
- 38:04depending on the study and this just
- 38:07goes to show how fraught this this type
- 38:11of data is when you try to prove
- 38:13anything so so you know my conclusion is
- 38:22that low carbohydrate diets are safe and
- 38:24sustainable this bottom picture comes
- 38:27from diet doctor from doctor I'd felled
- 38:29site and I loved it because how could
- 38:32you argue with that this is just a real
- 38:34food stuff people been eating for
- 38:36hundreds of thousands of years and Mary
- 38:38Lou I forgot to give you this pyramid
- 38:40but
- 38:42so so this is this is the keto pyramid
- 38:45and again there's anything on there look
- 38:48particularly unhealthy there is no such
- 38:53thing as an essential carbohydrate so on
- 38:56the left here is something I believe the
- 38:58left is quasi core which is a protein
- 39:00deficiency because there are essential
- 39:03amino acids and proteins on the right as
- 39:05marasmus this is due to missing
- 39:09essential fats and just general
- 39:10malnutrition and let me show you now I'm
- 39:14going to show you a picture of a
- 39:14carbohydrate deficiency are you ready
- 39:17yeah there you go so these are annually
- 39:21people and they consist on a diet that
- 39:24is composed of very little carbohydrate
- 39:27and I think the picture speaks for
- 39:30itself there's plenty of vegetable
- 39:34intake allowed one thing that struck me
- 39:36from Marylou stalk was the food pyramid
- 39:38recommends I think it was two and a half
- 39:40to four point two three servings of
- 39:43vegetables a day we recommend three cups
- 39:46of vegetables a day the vegetable
- 39:50content on a keto diet is not really
- 39:52different from what's recommended by the
- 39:54government for what that's worth
- 39:58processed foods ought to be reduced on a
- 40:00low-carb diet you don't have to be
- 40:02perfect of course but generally speaking
- 40:04a lot of the bad stuff we're getting is
- 40:06it's not it's not the fats and this is
- 40:11sort of a complicated way of saying that
- 40:13in studies of Lokar versus low-fat diets
- 40:16people drop out to the equivalent degree
- 40:18they're not dropping out of the low-carb
- 40:20are faster so people can't stick with
- 40:22these diets and frankly my book we don't
- 40:24even need graphs or studies to tell us
- 40:25this because we have the patients that
- 40:27come back to show it so this isn't a fad
- 40:30diet this is this is evolution and it's
- 40:33the way we should be eating so it does
- 40:35it you know if you come away with
- 40:38nothing else you know the theme of sort
- 40:40of my approach is it's got to make sense
- 40:42and to say that a way of eating that our
- 40:47species of Auld eating that we can
- 40:50measure all kinds of risk factors
- 40:51improving on with no evidence that
- 40:55actually is harmful no evidence that is
- 40:58worth believing why would we be worried
- 41:02so I'll stop there
- 41:13you
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Is Keto Bad For Your Heart — Dr. Eric Thorn by Dr. Eric Westman - Adapt Your Life, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,083 words across 1,015 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.