is head cannoning a strong woman trans misogynistic? | #cartoon #indieanimation — Transcript

Full transcript

1. 0:00is head cannon strong women as trans
2. 0:01misogynistic. Let's talk about head
3. 0:02cannoning
4. 0:04strong women as trans is misogynistic
5. 0:06because assigning trans identity to
6. 0:07characters that are exceptionally
7. 0:08strong, have high muscle mass, and or
8. 0:10have dominant features inadvertently
9. 0:11perpetuates the narrative that it's an
10. 0:13inherently masculine feature, the likes
11. 0:14of which theoretically strips these
12. 0:15women of having diverse body types and
13. 0:17physical prowess and fiction. But
14. 0:18opposed to that, a lot of people defend
15. 0:19these head cannons because they argue
16. 0:20that their intentions are simply rooted
17. 0:21in positive representation. For many
18. 0:23fans, finding a beloved, powerful, or
19. 0:24heroic character and then projecting
20. 0:26that trans identity onto them is simply
21. 0:28a way of finding empowerment in media,
22. 0:29likes of which are important because
23. 0:30historically trans women have been
24. 0:31depicted in a negative light. Now, I'd
25. 0:33like to preface this by saying that head
26. 0:34cannon is simply one's personal
27. 0:35imagination. But the reason why people
28. 0:37are critical of others' imagination is
29. 0:38primarily because it could theoretically
30. 0:39perpetuate harmful narratives. This
31. 0:41conflict generally arises when personal
32. 0:42empowerment and the desire for positive
33. 0:44trans representation inadvertently
34. 0:45collides with the societal fight to
35. 0:46allow cisgender women to be powerful
36. 0:48without their womanhood being
37. 0:49questioned. But I feel like something
38. 0:50worth noting is that the conversation
39. 0:51also reduces both cisgender and
40. 0:52transgender identities to shallow
41. 0:54physical markers. It reduces womanhood
42. 0:55to traditional delicate femininity, and
43. 0:57for trans fans, it can come across as
44. 0:58isolating or insulting because it
45. 1:00suggests that trans women can be
46. 1:01physically identified by simply having a
47. 1:02larger frame, ignoring the diversity of
48. 1:04diverse [music] trans body types, the
49. 1:05likes of which further stereotyping
50. 1:07them. Nevertheless, I would consider
51. 1:08these very nuanced and important
52. 1:09conversations to have. But the
53. 1:10villainization of one group just to
54. 1:11perpetuate your own does nothing but
55. 1:13suppress actual constructive
56. 1:14conversation.