Is Frankrijk nog te redden? | LUBACH — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Now onto something else: France.
- 0:02Because things aren't going well there at all.
- 0:14There we go. All good.
- 0:15Look. Well, well...
- 0:21Yeah, he'd nicked sneakers that were just a bit too big.
- 0:24No, he's just kicking up a fuss.
- 0:27Anyway, massive protests.
- 0:29We've all seen it. It started with the students.
- 0:32Later, the radical left joined in too.
- 0:35The yellow vests, but also the Free Handbags Association,
- 0:38and even the Historical Society Against the...
- 0:40Limoges Town Hall made their voices heard.
- 0:43In total, over half a million people took to the streets,
- 0:46and probably will again this coming weekend.
- 0:49And looting and pyromaniacs aside,
- 0:52a lot of French people are furious with...
- 0:55the government over poor education,
- 0:58high fuel prices, and deteriorating public services.
- 1:02So then you think: just improve education a bit.
- 1:05Do something about public services.
- 1:06Costs some money, but then people are happy again.
- 1:09But I also saw this news.
- 1:11French government debt surges to record high.
- 1:14So there's no money at all.
- 1:16In fact, look here. French crisis threatens to spill over into Europe.
- 1:21Some people fear a new euro crisis.
- 1:24Wow, the French are threatening to drag us down...
- 1:26with them into their financial misery.
- 1:28I don't think that's very chic,
- 1:30because why should their faux pas come...
- 1:32at the expense of our joie de vivre?
- 1:35And can anything still be done about it? Or is it a fait accompli?
- 1:38It's going to be a tour de force, so I'm taking off my blazer.
- 1:40It's time for...
- 1:45Nu.a. Deep into Thursday.
- 1:51Yeah, right into it.
- 1:54Yes! So today: why is France in such bad shape?
- 1:59Are they going to drag us down into their financial crisis?
- 2:02And can anything be done about it?
- 2:04Well, let's first take a look at just how bad things are for France.
- 2:07This economist is pretty gloomy about it.
- 2:10In Brussels, André Sapir,
- 2:11a renowned Belgian economist,
- 2:13watches the French situation with concern.
- 2:17Situation in France.
- 2:20Yeah.
- 2:22Boomers only believe it if it's on their iPad.
- 2:26Alright, but check out these numbers.
- 2:28A national debt of over €3.4 trillion.
- 2:32And it's rising. And this was a year ago.
- 2:36By now we're here: €3.6 trillion and counting.
- 2:42Another €5,000 is added every second, which is over €400 million a day.
- 2:48And you might think: okay,
- 2:49that's a lot of money, but it's a big country too.
- 2:52That's true. Except in Europe,
- 2:54we have a rule that national debt can only be 60% of your GDP.
- 2:58Well, the Netherlands is at 45%.
- 3:00Very well-behaved, but France is at 120%.
- 3:04And that's very expensive too, because when you borrow money,
- 3:07you also have to pay interest.
- 3:09And just the interest on all that borrowed money now costs...
- 3:12France more each year than their entire education budget.
- 3:15French kids aren't learning their ABCs,
- 3:17but rather "broke, busted, bankrupt".
- 3:20So that's the big problem.
- 3:22France is deep in debt,
- 3:24and the cause is the same as for anyone in debt:
- 3:27booze. No, no, no, no.
- 3:30The cause is that they spend way more money than they bring in.
- 3:35This Brit finds it quite amusing.
- 3:37They haven't balanced the books for decades,
- 3:40goes right back into the last century.
- 3:43They've run a deficit. They've spent more than they generated...
- 3:47in tax every single year this century.
- 3:50Extraordinary position to be in. Yeah, a bizarre situation.
- 3:54You only really see this otherwise with Henny van de Mosselaar.
- 3:58Anyway. So where does it go wrong?
- 4:00Well, he keeps launching new ideas, while nobody needs...
- 4:04Oh no, France. It was about France.
- 4:06Sorry, France. Right. How? How did that debt get so high?
- 4:10Why do they spend more than they bring in?
- 4:12Well, first: the economy. That's not doing great.
- 4:15They still build quite a few cars, but also weapons and planes.
- 4:21The Laughing Cow. And of course...
- 4:24They also make some money off Dutch people...
- 4:25with a dream and a knack for languages.
- 4:28Bonjour hotel, oui oui.
- 4:33No, no, no.
- 4:38Moi maison hotel.
- 4:49Yeah, this woman tried to buy a hotel at the butcher's.
- 4:52Didn't quite work out.
- 4:54Anyway, so money is still being made.
- 4:56But France does have a real problem.
- 4:58Namely, the population is aging rapidly.
- 5:00Unemployment is rising, especially among youth,
- 5:03and economic growth has dropped to less than half a percent a year.
- 5:07That's half as much as Belgium,
- 5:09a fourth of the Netherlands,
- 5:10and a hundredth of Rutger van Barneveld.
- 5:15Watching the sun go down in silence...
- 5:18Okay, really sing along.
- 5:20Yeah, okay. And then? On top of that, the countryside is emptying out.
- 5:25You might have noticed it on holiday,
- 5:26but in many French villages there is absolutely nothing left.
- 5:29L'Yonne is particularly affected by this desertification:
- 5:32one out of two municipalities has no businesses at all.
- 5:35We have nothing left. We don't even have the bakery anymore.
- 5:38We have nothing left at all. In Vosvres in Saône-et-Loire.
- 5:41No shops either, but bread is available from this dispenser.
- 5:45Well, lovely. No high street, just a bread vending machine.
- 5:49There goes your chat at the bakery, because no matter what you say,
- 5:52that machine just spits out a baguette.
- 5:54Nice weather, isn't it?
- 6:01Thank you.
- 6:03Nice. In France, things are really...
- 6:07So the economy isn't doing very well.
- 6:09But the problem is that the French government just keeps spending money,
- 6:13on civil servants for instance.
- 6:15Check! About one in five working French people is a civil servant.
- 6:19The rest work as grumpy waiters spitting in your coffee if...
- 6:21you don't immediately understand what they're mumbling.
- 6:24And having so many civil servants is also because railways,
- 6:27postal services, and things like that are still run by the government.
- 6:30Even so, they really have an awful lot of them.
- 6:33For instance, France has 35,000 mayors, and they all get paid too.
- 6:39Every municipality, even if there's only a handful of houses, has one.
- 6:43That's strange. Crazy thought: when you see a square full of rioters,
- 6:47statistically there are always a few mayors among them.
- 6:50And that many civil servants.
- 6:52That already costs a lot of money, of course.
- 6:53But in France, those civil servants also get all kinds of perks.
- 6:56If you work for an electricity or gas company,
- 6:59for examplewhich are state-ownedyou get...
- 7:02a 90 percent discount on your energy bill.
- 7:05Even after retirement. So how much does someone like that actually pay?
- 7:09I pay a bill that's around fifteen euros a month.
- 7:12A bit more in winter, of course, with heating.
- 7:15Wow. An energy bill of €15.
- 7:18I think even Moffel and Piertje pay more because of Piertje's Satisfyer.
- 7:25And this scheme alone costs the French...
- 7:27treasury €700 million every year.
- 7:31And then there's the welfare state.
- 7:32In France, almost a quarter of GDP goes towards healthcare,
- 7:35pensions, and benefits.
- 7:37That is truly extreme. The retirement age in France is 62.
- 7:42That's the lowest retirement age in all of Europe.
- 7:44And on top of that, they have a very clumsy pension system.
- 7:47Because we have the state pension, of course.
- 7:49That's a kind of baseline amount paid by the government,
- 7:52plus the pension employees build up themselves.
- 7:55You pay into that every month.
- 7:56That goes into a big fund, so you build something up.
- 7:59But in France, they don't do that.
- 8:00There, the entire pension comes from the government,
- 8:03even for non-civil servants. So there is no pension nest egg.
- 8:07In France, pension money comes out of the budget,
- 8:10so it's entirely paid by people currently working.
- 8:14And there are fewer and fewer of them,
- 8:15because the population is ageing.
- 8:17They used to have five workers per pensioner,
- 8:19but nowadays that's down to just 2.5.
- 8:22So one grandad's pension is now paid by two workers and one lower torso.
- 8:29And I say grandad, but this isn't some rickety,
- 8:31boules-playing old pensioner.
- 8:32That guy is 62, he's chilling playing Call of Duty.
- 8:37So this system is completely unsustainable.
- 8:40At the French Ministry of Education,
- 8:42for example, a third of the budget goes to retired teachers.
- 8:45A third. Are you surprised those kids complain about...
- 8:48poor maintenance and dilapidated schools?
- 8:50All that money goes into maintaining old teachers.
- 8:54And that age of 62 certainly doesn't apply to everyone.
- 8:56Especially highly educated people often don't retire until much later.
- 8:59But there are also sectors where they retire even earlier,
- 9:02like public transport.
- 9:04Currently, many French train drivers can retire as early as 52.
- 9:09So in France, you get this every single day.
- 9:14Okay, well, the economy is doing poorly.
- 9:16The country is ageing,
- 9:18yet they keep clinging to that luxurious welfare state.
- 9:20And that's simply not possible. Something has to change.
- 9:23The French will have to overhaul their entire system.
- 9:25Everyone agrees on that, except the French.
- 9:29Protests erupted across France in 2023 when the...
- 9:33government raised the retirement age from 62 to 64.
- 9:38Yeah, that's what you get when you try to raise...
- 9:40the retirement age to 64 in France.
- 9:42That's lower than what the SP wants in the Netherlands,
- 9:45but in France they think that's far too high.
- 9:47That's a crazy thought, actually, isn't it?
- 9:49In France, Jimmy Dijk would be some kind of right-wing snob.
- 9:52Oh, look at him flaunting his luxury tomato soup.
- 9:55What a jerk.
- 9:59And sorry, I couldn't help myself.
- 10:01And protesting and striking is the French...
- 10:03reaction to pretty much everything.
- 10:06It's really always been like that.
- 10:08The storming of the Bastille in the late 18th century,
- 10:11the student protests in 1968.
- 10:12That resistance against the state is...
- 10:14practically fed to them with a spoon in France.
- 10:16We are all united.
- 10:18Workers, the unemployed, university students, high school students.
- 10:21Everyone agrees this reform is unfair,
- 10:24unjustified, and that we must oppose it together.
- 10:27But you, you are fifteen.
- 10:32Yeah, you think he's starting early,
- 10:33but of course he's already halfway to retirement.
- 10:35So, and that constant massive protesting.
- 10:38That's what every French government runs up against.
- 10:41Anyone who tries to get the finances in order,
- 10:44to reform the system a bit,
- 10:46immediately faces an angry public.
- 10:48France tried to push through pension reform in 1995.
- 10:52Transportation was shut down for three weeks.
- 10:55Yeah, and that's how it always goes.
- 10:56Every French president tries to reform,
- 10:58but they never succeed, because then the public gets angry.
- 11:01This was President Macron three years ago.
- 11:04Macron standing his ground in an interview with French...
- 11:07journalists saying he won't budge on raising the retirement age.
- 11:11And the longer we wait, the more it will deteriorate.
- 11:13So this reform is necessary.
- 11:15But his TV appearance only fueling frustration and strikes.
- 11:19Oil refineries in the south drying up as thousands...
- 11:22of tons of trash lined the streets of Paris.
- 11:25Yes, and in the end, Macron couldn't pull it off either.
- 11:28Sometimes it feels as if the entire French...
- 11:30population refuses to face reality.
- 11:32They live in a fantasy world. You can all call it a croque-monsieur,
- 11:36but it's just a grilled cheese.
- 11:38And the French government just keeps borrowing billions to pay for it all,
- 11:43so the debt keeps mounting.
- 11:45But the French themselves, young and old alike,
- 11:47don't see that as their problem.
- 11:49Would you be willing to make a small...
- 11:51effort to help pay off the debt today?
- 11:53No. Basically, no. It's not up to us to make efforts, either.
- 11:57But I don't think it's up to me to make an effort.
- 11:59They should first pay attention to their lifestyle,
- 12:04the way they spend our money.
- 12:06Yes, those French people all say: not my problem.
- 12:10Your national debt, your problem.
- 12:12And okay, yeah, they might sound like total slackers this way.
- 12:16But keep in mind that France already...
- 12:17has the highest taxes in all of Europe,
- 12:19so these people are already paying through the nose.
- 12:22But yeah, that national debt keeps rising.
- 12:24Here, just look here. Another two and a half million has been...
- 12:27added since the last time I showed it.
- 12:30And something really needs to change.
- 12:32But that's precisely what they don't want. So yeah, where does this end?
- 12:35Well, first off, a country can't go bankrupt, so that's something.
- 12:39But what can happen is investors saying:
- 12:41I don't want to lend money to France anymore,
- 12:43because I'm afraid I won't get it back.
- 12:45Just like it's getting harder and harder for Henny...
- 12:48van der Most to find investors for his crappy ideas.
- 12:51No, but this is an old sewage treatment plant,
- 12:53and the theme is moist toilet wipes.
- 12:55Sure Henny, sure.
- 12:57And that scenario is already starting to play out a bit.
- 13:00This is the interest rate you get when you lend money to France.
- 13:03Six years ago, it was around zero percent.
- 13:06And now it's all the way up there.
- 13:08And it has risen in other eurozone countries too,
- 13:11of course, but even more so in France.
- 13:13Since yesterday, it's even above five percent.
- 13:15France is now paying a higher interest rate than...
- 13:18traditional debtor nations Greece and Italy.
- 13:21And the more expensive borrowing becomes,
- 13:23the worse off France is, making it even riskier to lend them money.
- 13:27Which pushes interest rates up even further.
- 13:28And in the worst-case scenario,
- 13:30France won't be able to pay its debts anymore.
- 13:32And then a lot of people can kiss a lot of money goodbye.
- 13:36Us included, because Dutch banks and pension funds have lent...
- 13:39more than 80 billion euros to the French state.
- 13:43And if France can't pay all that back, our pensions will take a hit.
- 13:47A real French debt crisis would be a disaster for us too,
- 13:50because the entire EUand definitely the...
- 13:53eurozonehas its economies deeply intertwined.
- 13:56We share the same currency, we lend each other money,
- 13:59we invest in each other. We have one central bank.
- 14:01We are connected. And you have to stay connected.
- 14:04Right? Hallo Deutschland, was gibt?
- 14:09Look.
- 14:11Look, it's just... It's just like in the mountains.
- 14:13It's a good idea to be roped together,
- 14:15because if someone slips, the rest can catch them.
- 14:18That's what happened with Greece.
- 14:19Fifteen years ago, they were on the edge of the abyss.
- 14:22So then you got this.
- 14:24Exactly. The rest managed to rescue Greece, but it was a close call.
- 14:29All eurozone countries had to step in.
- 14:30Huge crisis, the whole continent in panic.
- 14:33Even Matthijs van Nieuwkerk suddenly had...
- 14:34to start introducing all these Greeks.
- 14:36Jorgos Nikolidakis, Spiros Galos, Alexis, Alexandridis, Witmecka.
- 14:41Okay, and one Brit, one Brit.
- 14:43Well,
- 14:43in the end we managed to save Greece by lending them a lot of money.
- 14:47They also had to make massive budget cuts themselves.
- 14:48They even had to sell off all kinds of state assets.
- 14:51They sold ports, and even the state bank.
- 14:54So bailiffs showed up like: "We're here to take the bank/couch."...
- 14:57"You mean the corner sofa, I think."... "No, the state bank."...
- 15:01And in the end, it all just barely worked out.
- 15:04But yeah, Greece was relatively a tiny little figure.
- 15:09France, however, is this motherfucker.
- 15:12That's a gigantic economy.
- 15:15Ah, watch out! If that falls, we really have a problem.
- 15:19And what exactly happens then, we don't know.
- 15:21Maybe something like this.
- 15:23Yeah, great.
- 15:24Or this?
- 15:26Yeah, so this is what we need to prevent.
- 15:28France has to spend less so they can finally tackle their national debt.
- 15:33They have to reform. But yeah, who's going to do that?
- 15:36Because so far, no one has succeeded.
- 15:38Well, luckily there are presidential elections next year.
- 15:41And there really are candidates who...
- 15:42understand that something has to change.
- 15:44The bad news is, the French aren't going to vote for them.
- 15:48According to the polls,
- 15:50there are only two possible outcomes:
- 15:53far-right and far-left.
- 15:55The right is, of course, Marine Le Pen of the National Rally.
- 15:58She has a solid lead in the polls,
- 16:00which is quite surprising, as earlier this year she was convicted of...
- 16:03embezzling four million in European funds.
- 16:06So she is good with money, after all. Kind of.
- 16:09Now, what does she want to do about those catastrophic finances?
- 16:12Because yeah, the French treasury is empty.
- 16:14Well, the coffers are empty, it depends on for what.
- 16:16Look, we pay twenty-six billion to the European Union,
- 16:19including ten billion in net contributions,
- 16:22you see, for instance.
- 16:23So there, that's where we can find money for the coffers.
- 16:27Yeah, she wants France to contribute a lot less to the EU.
- 16:31And, and I understand why she wants that,
- 16:33because if anyone knows that EU money...
- 16:35sometimes ends up in the wrong pockets,
- 16:36it's her.
- 16:38But she also wants to give less money to Ukraine,
- 16:41for example, and cut back on migration.
- 16:43And I find myself thinking:
- 16:45how many migrants do you have to stop to save three and a half trillion?
- 16:49So Le Pen does want to make cuts, but they aren't real structural reforms.
- 16:54For instance, she doesn't want to raise the retirement age,
- 16:56but just keep it nice and easy at 62.
- 16:58All right, well, that was the right.
- 16:59Let's also head all the way over to the left.
- 17:01There you have Jean-Luc Mélenchon.
- 17:02He's from La France Insoumise.
- 17:04That means France Unbowed, basically the rebellious teenager party.
- 17:10Also known as 15+.
- 17:13He's 75 himself, but he still moves with the times.
- 17:16At party rallies, for example, he uses holograms.
- 17:19I am.
- 17:24In Lyon.
- 17:29And now in Paris.
- 17:38Yeah, cool tech,
- 17:39but at the end of the day, there's still just an old gray man on stage.
- 17:44Yeah, but now you can also see him in Paris, right?
- 17:46Yes, he can also be seen in Paris. Yes.
- 17:47Well, Mélenchon is very popular among youth,
- 17:50and he really wants to do something about that retirement age.
- 17:54Namely, he wants to lower it to 60.
- 17:57What the fuck?
- 17:59If we did that, Femke Halsema could already retire right now.
- 18:02Say goodbye, everyone, this woman is off to Benidorm.
- 18:07And how does Mélenchon plan to pay for all of that?
- 18:10The great hope of the left, the counterpart to the feared Le Pen.
- 18:13What does he want to do about that national debt?
- 18:15On the left, for Jean-Luc Mélenchon, it simply has to be canceled.
- 18:19At least in part.
- 18:21The European Central Bank can and must...
- 18:25freeze the debts of the member states.
- 18:30Sure thing, put the national debt in the freezer.
- 18:33Tip: stick a popsicle stick in it.
- 18:34Then you can lick it like a popsicle the next day.
- 18:37It's a nice metaphor, but not what you want to hear when someone...
- 18:40still owes you three and a half trillion.
- 18:42Itit just keeps piling up. Okay,
- 18:45well, the largest country in Western Europe,
- 18:47the second-largest economy in the EU,
- 18:48the only nuclear power where you can still smoke indoors,
- 18:51is on the verge of collapse.
- 18:53Their welfare state has completely gotten out of hand.
- 18:55They're deep in debt, and if anyone tries to do something about it,
- 18:59they tear the country down. What are you supposed to make of this?
- 19:02I think it's insane.
- 19:04Nothing is normal anymore, right? Exactly.
- 19:07Exactly.
- 19:11You took the words right out of my mouth.
- 19:13And look, look, if a person has that much debt,
- 19:17you send a bailiff after them.
- 19:19If a company goes bankrupt, the inventory is sold off.
- 19:22But what do you do with a country? Well, turns out:
- 19:24The European Union is already on top of it.
- 19:26They've long had a plan for if France doesn't make it.
- 19:29Yesterday, with all those internet issues,
- 19:32remember, I managed to access the EU servers and saw this video.
- 19:36Check this out.
- 19:37This is a message from the European Union for the attention of France.
- 19:41Since you are heading straight for bankruptcy and...
- 19:44do not seem willing to take the necessary measures,
- 19:48we are forced to intervene.
- 19:50We therefore present to you the FSFP: Forced Sale of France Project 2027.
- 19:56First of all,
- 19:57the following geographical changes will be implemented.
- 20:01Alsace will become German territory,
- 20:04Normandy will go to Belgium,
- 20:06and the French Riviera to Sweden.
- 20:09French cultural heritage has been auctioned off.
- 20:14All Picassos will go to the Guggenheim in Bilbao,
- 20:16and the Mona Lisa to the Drents Museum in Assen.
- 20:20There, it will certainly be safe.
- 20:23The Eiffel Tower will be melted down to make...
- 20:25lots of tiny Eiffel Towers to sell to tourists.
- 20:28Marie Curie's Nobel Prizes will go to an anonymous bidder in Washington,
- 20:34D.C.
- 20:35The Little Prince was bought by Prince Andrew.
- 20:38We ask no questions.
- 20:40Here is the new route of the Tour de France:
- 20:44Liège, Stuttgart, Liechtenstein, Turin,
- 20:47Bilbao, Dublin, Copenhagen, and the finish line will be in Riga.
- 20:53Charles Aznavour was bought by the Toppers.
- 20:57When we told them he was already dead,
- 20:59they replied: whatever, it's still better than Gerard Joling.
- 21:03Dutch Minister Vincent Karremans bought...
- 21:06Barbapapa to replace the Merwede Bridge,
- 21:09which is out of service.
- 21:11And that is how we divide all of France.
- 21:15All of France. No, you may keep one small village: Disneyland.
- 21:21That way,
- 21:21you can enjoy your retirement age in this fairy-tale world.
- 21:26Because right now, this is not normal.
- 21:30Good thing the EU is on top of it.
- 21:33And this was...
- 21:38News Lab's Deep Dive Thursday.
- 21:44And that was the show.
- 21:45Full episodes can be watched via the link, clips on YouTube.
- 21:48Tomorrow we have a compilation featuring the best of the week.
- 21:50See you Monday.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Is Frankrijk nog te redden? | LUBACH by LUBACH, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,545 words across 446 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.