Is Black Culture a Manufactured Identity? | The Construct EP8 with Chad O. Jackson — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the construct, a show about
- 0:02how civilizations are built and how they
- 0:04fall apart. I'm your host Liam the board
- 0:06and today we're asking a highly
- 0:08controversial question. Is there such
- 0:11thing as black culture? My guest is Chad
- 0:14O. Jackson, documentary filmmaker
- 0:16featured in Uncle Tom and known called
- 0:18Tom too and now making the myth of
- 0:20blackness. Chad's answer is that black
- 0:23culture is a manufactured political
- 0:25identity. We get into why the right
- 0:27surrendered the arts, why you can't
- 0:30reason with a crowd, why people get
- 0:32angry when mass graves turn up empty, as
- 0:35well as the battle for the soul of the
- 0:36West between socialism, tribalism, and
- 0:39Christendom. Before we get started, if
- 0:42you'd be so generous as to leave a kind
- 0:44review on whichever platform you're
- 0:45listening to the show on, that would be
- 0:47greatly appreciated. So, let's get into
- 0:49it.
- 0:55So, Chad, is there such thing as black
- 0:59culture?
- 1:02>> Um, that's a very
- 1:04loaded question.
- 1:06Um, it it it's funny because I
- 1:09participated in a debate not too long
- 1:11ago in Las Vegas
- 1:13on the digital social hour podcast and I
- 1:16was actually thinking about this that
- 1:18this morning when I woke up because one
- 1:19of the
- 1:20opponents who sat across from me,
- 1:23um,
- 1:24she she referred to blacks as we and
- 1:28this is she stopped herself and said,
- 1:30"Wait, are you black?"
- 1:32And I said, "No." And she's like, "Oh,
- 1:35okay. Well, that makes sense." And we
- 1:36continued the conversation. I was
- 1:38thinking about that this morning and I
- 1:39was thinking, you know, what what should
- 1:41I have said instead?
- 1:43Um,
- 1:44I think the answer is that I should have
- 1:46asked her to qualify what she means by
- 1:48black.
- 1:50I think that would have made for a
- 1:52better moment and hopefully would have
- 1:55caused people to actually think about
- 1:57these words that we just throw around
- 1:59loosely, like black and black culture
- 2:01and and and things of this nature.
- 2:04The context, or not the context, but but
- 2:06basically what I meant when I said no
- 2:09was
- 2:11typically when people think of black
- 2:13they think of, whether consciously or
- 2:16subconsciously,
- 2:17a kind of
- 2:20slew of
- 2:22of principles or perceptions that go
- 2:26along with this identity we call black.
- 2:30Uh which is in large part political,
- 2:34philosophical, there's an ethos, there's
- 2:36a pathology, there's so many different
- 2:39things working with that word black.
- 2:43And so
- 2:44because I don't identify with political
- 2:47blackness
- 2:49because I don't identify with the
- 2:52struggle that the word suggests uh the
- 2:56historical mythology
- 2:58um that one is taught to believe when
- 3:01they come up in this culture
- 3:04um because I reject a lot of it, I just
- 3:07simply choose not to identify with it.
- 3:09Not necessarily the aesthetic of
- 3:12blackness, but the the political kind of
- 3:16characteristic of blackness is the thing
- 3:18that I'm rejecting. So, to ask the
- 3:20question, what is black culture?
- 3:22Um black culture is a deliberately
- 3:25manufactured
- 3:27identity for the sake of serving
- 3:30political purposes.
- 3:32That's the best way I can describe it.
- 3:34>> And it's very odd to me because the
- 3:37people that manufactured that often
- 3:41subscribe to the notion that race is a
- 3:44social construct. So, it it it's it's
- 3:47very strange. I don't know how to square
- 3:50that circle essentially, where you're
- 3:52telling me on one hand that race is a
- 3:54social construct, but then on the other
- 3:58that this thing defines you and your
- 4:01ability to
- 4:03uh
- 4:04actualize yourself in the world. And now
- 4:07it's So, now it's the primary thing. I
- 4:09don't I don't get Do you understand that
- 4:11part of their ideology and how they
- 4:12connect those two dots, or is that just
- 4:15complete cognitive dissonance?
- 4:16>> actually going to throw throw the
- 4:18question at you and say and ask you like
- 4:20what do you think that they realize that
- 4:21they are being contradicting?
- 4:24Um
- 4:25>> Well,
- 4:26>> I don't cuz I don't I don't think they
- 4:27realize that they're being
- 4:28contradicting, but I'm interested in
- 4:29hearing your thoughts.
- 4:30>> Yeah, well, I wonder whether maybe
- 4:33that's part of the ideology's goal in
- 4:37terms of the contradiction because that
- 4:39was Orwell's whole concept with
- 4:41doublethink, right? The The concept of
- 4:44holding two contradictory beliefs as
- 4:47true simultaneously,
- 4:49and it's not so much about getting
- 4:53that person to believe that single
- 4:56thing, whether it's black culture or
- 4:58whether it's race as a social construct.
- 5:01It's about creating contradictions in
- 5:03order to break down people's
- 5:07rational ability and their uh and in
- 5:10logic in their mind. And because as soon
- 5:12as you do that, now they can't form any
- 5:14opinions about anything.
- 5:16That's kind of where I would go to with
- 5:18it, but also part of it is just I think
- 5:21maybe there's like a that concept of
- 5:24Schrödinger's feminist as well where
- 5:26it's like they're simultaneously
- 5:28uh empowered and independent and also
- 5:32victimized, and it's like just depending
- 5:34on the scenario which narrative is
- 5:36beneficial for me to be able to get
- 5:38power and assert myself in this
- 5:40discussion, then I'll take that stance.
- 5:43Yeah, I don't I don't I don't It's It's
- 5:45It's pretty wild to me that people just
- 5:46accept these things openly.
- 5:48>> Well, it's also very characteristic of
- 5:51what we call black culture, and you see
- 5:53it time and again. In fact, uh
- 5:55you know, I was doing some research just
- 5:57the other day.
- 5:58I wanted to see
- 6:00how many times uh the pastor from
- 6:03Atlanta named Jamal Bryant
- 6:06um
- 6:07used the pulpit to talk about abortion.
- 6:11And so I did a transcript a transcript
- 6:13search on his YouTube channel.
- 6:15And what was interesting is, you know,
- 6:17he rightly said from the pulpit at least
- 6:20half a dozen times that God
- 6:23can forgive you even of your abortion.
- 6:26And if you believe in God's forgiveness,
- 6:28you don't have to be ashamed of it.
- 6:30And so he's talking about abortion in
- 6:32that context. However, I found other
- 6:35videos that he
- 6:37did from his from his podcast where he's
- 6:40at the same time
- 6:42um and and what I mean by that is in the
- 6:44same year, same month, sometimes even
- 6:46the same day uh went on his podcast and
- 6:49he's talking about
- 6:51um how those, you know, darned
- 6:54Republicans and those right-wingers are
- 6:57trying to
- 6:59take away women's reproductive rights
- 7:01and it's a woman's right to choose, it's
- 7:03her body, it's her choice. So, this
- 7:06pastor on the one hand is saying it is
- 7:09talking about abortion as though it's
- 7:11this is this, you know, evil and wicked
- 7:14thing, but God can forgive you for it.
- 7:16Like God will, you know,
- 7:18heal you and mend you. But then at the
- 7:20same time he's advocating for access to
- 7:23abortion. How does that make sense in
- 7:25the mind of this pastor? And there's a
- 7:27history there that we don't have time to
- 7:29get into specifically about how um the
- 7:33black church was specifically targeted
- 7:36um for, you know, with this birth
- 7:38control
- 7:40propaganda, which was encouraged by W.
- 7:43E. B. Du Bois, the great black
- 7:45intellectual who who was an atheist, but
- 7:47specifically said that we need to send
- 7:51this propaganda into the Negro church.
- 7:53Um so that's a history. Um but then too,
- 7:56you look at the fact that the use of the
- 7:58N-word
- 8:00is something that, you know,
- 8:03many so-called black people uh, get
- 8:05offended when white people use it, but
- 8:08then they use it amongst each other. A
- 8:11contradiction.
- 8:12There's so many kind of working
- 8:14contradictions that we see show up in
- 8:17the so-called culture.
- 8:19And it's become this kind of routine
- 8:21thing where they don't realize that it's
- 8:23that it's
- 8:25uh,
- 8:25that it's a contradiction, which tells
- 8:27me
- 8:28that they are operating from a very
- 8:31post-modern kind of predisposition.
- 8:34Where,
- 8:36you know,
- 8:37for for you or for me to say, "Hey,
- 8:40that's a contradiction. Do you realize
- 8:41how fallacious that is?" That doesn't do
- 8:44anything in the minds of somebody who
- 8:46who is operating from a
- 8:49this kind of cognitive dissonance, who's
- 8:50operating from this kind of post-modern
- 8:53worldview. Logic doesn't mean anything
- 8:55at that point. Um, how do you reason
- 8:58with someone somebody like that? And so,
- 9:01that's not to say that all people we see
- 9:04as black uh,
- 9:07are operating from cognitive dissonance.
- 9:08I know many who aren't. Um, but it has
- 9:11become characteristic of what we call
- 9:13black culture, for sure.
- 9:16>> Well,
- 9:17that brings up an interesting
- 9:19conversation when it comes to the very
- 9:23concept of logic and whether people are
- 9:26operating on it rationally.
- 9:28I I really like
- 9:30Nietzsche's concept where he said,
- 9:33"Every drive, so every internal
- 9:36instinct, seeks to be master and
- 9:39attempts to philosophize in that
- 9:41spirit." So, for instance, if you allow
- 9:44anger to overtake you, you're going to
- 9:46now create philosophical worldviews that
- 9:49justify your emotional position. Same
- 9:51thing with You can imagine that somebody
- 9:53who's very hedonistic is going to create
- 9:56a utilitarian type of argument. Okay,
- 9:59well, you know, the greatest good in the
- 10:00world is just to maximize pleasure for
- 10:02everybody. And so, they create the
- 10:04philosophical to justify the emotional.
- 10:08And then so, this leads me to where I
- 10:10see the world getting to nowadays, and
- 10:12it's why I originally started this was,
- 10:15"Okay, I want to try and model what a
- 10:20reasonable conversation is, engage in
- 10:23dialogue as I think the opposite is
- 10:26violence, and I'm very much getting to
- 10:30this point now where I wonder how
- 10:35I I I
- 10:35like are we past the point of dialogue
- 10:38socially? Because as you're pointing to,
- 10:41people aren't at all thinking about
- 10:44things logically. And this this happens
- 10:46all sides, all different types of
- 10:48people. It's just the the emotional
- 10:50state of society has reached such a
- 10:53degree that people's rational faculties
- 10:56have just disappeared.
- 10:58>> Yeah.
- 10:59That's a fantastic question.
- 11:02Um I'm going to say something
- 11:03interesting here, and I'm interested in
- 11:04hearing your thoughts on it.
- 11:06But,
- 11:07um
- 11:10for all of his wickedness,
- 11:15I don't believe that Herbert Marcuse was
- 11:18all the way wrong
- 11:20in his assessment of how to
- 11:24push public opinion, or at least public
- 11:27sensibilities.
- 11:29Um
- 11:30in what he would have perceived as the
- 11:33appropriate direction. And of course, he
- 11:35believed that socialism was natural. It
- 11:39it it it was most compatible with man's,
- 11:43you know, wiring. And so, he wanted to
- 11:47to basically detach man, the Western
- 11:51man, from the Odyssean sirens of
- 11:54capitalism. Because he acknowledged that
- 11:56capitalism
- 11:58um was successful. He acknowledges in I
- 12:02believe it was
- 12:04uh
- 12:06I'm actually not going to quote the book
- 12:08because I'm I'm going to share with you
- 12:09after this because I have it in my
- 12:11archives.
- 12:13Um
- 12:14but I I don't want to mislead people in
- 12:16in terms of where they can find it. But
- 12:17he did
- 12:20talk about how I'm just going to look at
- 12:22it later. I'll send it to you after
- 12:23this. But he he
- 12:25he talked about how
- 12:28um you know, capitalism is successful in
- 12:32terms of creating creature comforts, in
- 12:34terms of of promoting and advancing
- 12:36creature comforts. Uh but he said that
- 12:40that man still needs to be liberated
- 12:41from it.
- 12:43Um and
- 12:45that socialism was natural and organic.
- 12:50And this is where we need to push man
- 12:52to, right? So that was his objective.
- 12:55Now,
- 12:56the reason I say that I think he was
- 12:58right
- 13:00in a sense was not on the basis of
- 13:03socialism being natural and organic, but
- 13:06on how to get man to to kind of cozy up
- 13:11to this particular idea,
- 13:13which was through the arts. Because he
- 13:16said that the arts can do
- 13:18what the orator can't do.
- 13:20The arts can do what the activists can't
- 13:23do. The arts can do what social
- 13:25movements marching in the streets can't
- 13:28do. Namely, it can basically give the
- 13:32audience or give the masses a kind of
- 13:34picturesque
- 13:36um idea of what it is they're fighting
- 13:39for. It can deal with you know, human
- 13:41love and human tension and and all the
- 13:43different things that
- 13:46are successful in kind of like loosening
- 13:48people's minds, so to speak, and getting
- 13:51them to a certain point, getting them to
- 13:53think a certain ways. You're you're in a
- 13:55sense using the arts to rewire man. And
- 13:57so this is what Marcuse was was was
- 14:00understanding as one of the vehicles or
- 14:02the catalyst to get society to shift in
- 14:06the sense.
- 14:07And so what I think um
- 14:10is that, you know, when it comes to
- 14:13exactly what it is you're talking about
- 14:14with regard to
- 14:16uh the fact that there are a lot of
- 14:18people who just aren't willing to have
- 14:20the conversation. There are There are a
- 14:21lot of people who aren't willing to
- 14:22engage or to to have their their
- 14:26thinking um scrutinized for the better,
- 14:30you know?
- 14:31Um
- 14:33we do still have the arts to uh
- 14:37um
- 14:39to
- 14:41basically
- 14:42uh
- 14:44give a picturesque picturesque version
- 14:46of what it is we're talking about.
- 14:48If that makes sense.
- 14:50Um
- 14:50We we we can through the arts take a
- 14:54very high-shelf
- 14:56you know, philosophy, good philosophy
- 14:59and theology and bring that down to the
- 15:03shelf
- 15:05uh or or to the counter rather in a way
- 15:08that resonates with people. And we can
- 15:10do that through the arts. And so I know
- 15:13I butchered that explanation, but um I
- 15:16do think that we still have other
- 15:18mediums to get our points across. Um and
- 15:23I think that you know, what we've seen
- 15:25is that conservatives, Christians,
- 15:28whatever you want to call them, even
- 15:29though you know, throughout Western
- 15:31civilization have mastered the arts,
- 15:33have mastered literature, have mastered
- 15:35the classics
- 15:36at some point we let our foot off the
- 15:39gas, so to speak, and we've we've punted
- 15:43this gift to these postmodernists, to
- 15:47these leftists, to these so-called
- 15:48progressive types. And they've made a
- 15:50mockery of it.
- 15:52And they do it well, you know, they make
- 15:54decent films that are watchable, you
- 15:56know, they um and part of that may be
- 15:59that they are appealing to
- 16:01like the
- 16:03the
- 16:04uh wicked passions of man, the vices of
- 16:08man, um they they are appealing to
- 16:11uh the temptation of man, much the same
- 16:15as, you know, Satan appealed to Adam and
- 16:18Eve in the garden.
- 16:20Um even though they had paradise, they
- 16:23had the they had the garden, they had
- 16:25God,
- 16:26um
- 16:26they were lured into
- 16:29uh the desire to have knowledge that
- 16:32made them equal to God.
- 16:34And so,
- 16:36if since it's a prince if if Satan is
- 16:38the prince of the power of the air,
- 16:41and you know, Jesus said that, you know,
- 16:43those who don't obey
- 16:45obey God are children of their father
- 16:48the devil. Uh it it then makes sense why
- 16:51you know, these Hollywood executives,
- 16:53many of these satanic artists and things
- 16:55of this nature,
- 16:56uh they use the talents and the gifts
- 16:58they have to sing, to make films, to do
- 17:01write, to do whatever,
- 17:03um to to be the kind of temptus, if you
- 17:06will,
- 17:07um
- 17:08uh encouraging and aiding and abetting
- 17:11the public to
- 17:13to embrace vice, to embrace degeneracy,
- 17:16to embrace, you know,
- 17:18uh
- 17:19discombobble thinking, you know what I
- 17:21mean?
- 17:21And so, how do you counteract that with
- 17:24with positive messaging through the
- 17:26arts?
- 17:27Uh so so I'm rambling, but but but this
- 17:30opens up so many different questions,
- 17:32but it also opens up so many
- 17:34possibilities
- 17:35uh when it comes to how can we, yes,
- 17:39take to college campuses like Charlie
- 17:41was doing,
- 17:42write uh on our substacks and our books,
- 17:45um
- 17:46um do lectures and all the things. Yes,
- 17:49continue that, but how can we take that
- 17:53to the arts in a way that's not uh
- 17:57you know, third rate, you know, in a way
- 17:59that's not
- 18:00crap, you know, to put it in to a word.
- 18:03Uh because we've proven for centuries
- 18:07throughout Western tradition and Western
- 18:09civilization that we're capable, but how
- 18:11do we get back to using the arts
- 18:13to push this messaging?
- 18:15>> Construct is a brand new show, and the
- 18:17best way to help it grow is to subscribe
- 18:20or follow wherever you're watching or
- 18:21listening. Your support is greatly
- 18:23appreciated and now let's get back to
- 18:25the conversation.
- 18:27>> So.
- 18:27>> Yeah, no I I I completely agree and I
- 18:30think even even Stalin would agree as
- 18:32well. He famously said that
- 18:35writers are the engineers of human souls
- 18:38and so he was meaning that more in terms
- 18:40of like poets and novelists than
- 18:42journalists, but
- 18:45I think he was entirely correct and
- 18:46that's why
- 18:48those communist regimes have always
- 18:50clamped down on that very early, the
- 18:52cultural aspect. Whether you look at
- 18:54Mao's cultural revolution, but even as
- 18:57soon as he took power in '53,
- 19:00they immediately started clamping down
- 19:02on on arts and science in general, any
- 19:06way that man could express himself.
- 19:09Um and so I think that goes to another
- 19:11one of Orwell's observations that all
- 19:14art is propaganda, but not all
- 19:16propaganda is art.
- 19:18>> Mhm.
- 19:18>> So all art is telling you one way or
- 19:21another what the proper way to live is
- 19:23or what it means to live, um but then
- 19:26the propaganda aspect is when we kind of
- 19:29butt up against reality and go, "No,
- 19:31this seems this seems manufactured." And
- 19:34so that would have been the the latter
- 19:36side of that quote.
- 19:37But
- 19:39I think that is very much I I completely
- 19:42agree with you where
- 19:45the right has lost a lot of cultural
- 19:49influence is by
- 19:53seeding the grounds of the arts because
- 19:57it makes complete sense to in in a way
- 20:00because
- 20:02leftists are always going to be more
- 20:05creative. They It's actually It's It's
- 20:08It's one of the defining features. If
- 20:10you're creative, you don't like being
- 20:12put in a box. You don't like being
- 20:14orderly. Um and so you are naturally
- 20:17going to kind of take a stance against
- 20:19that and if you're a creative type,
- 20:21you're very artistic. Uh luckily I got
- 20:23balanced with the conscientiousness
- 20:25aspect, so I think that's where the more
- 20:27more right right-leaning side of it
- 20:29comes, but I am very very creative on
- 20:31that front, too.
- 20:32>> Yeah.
- 20:33>> Um
- 20:34but yeah, there's there's three
- 20:35different ways that you can make an
- 20:37argument. I think this was Aristotle,
- 20:40where he pointed to logos, ethos, and
- 20:43pathos. So, logos being logic and
- 20:46rationale, then ethos being authority.
- 20:51So, you know, I'm an expert in this
- 20:53subject matter or whatever that you can
- 20:54build your opinion on that. And then
- 20:56there's pathos, which would be your
- 20:59emotional. Now, when I first got into
- 21:01this, yeah, I was
- 21:03I purposefully said, "I'm going to put
- 21:05all of my energy and effort into logos,
- 21:08into logical uh I'm not going to try to
- 21:11tell people how to feel, even if, you
- 21:14know, it's funny when people ask me
- 21:16uh certain things about my content, and
- 21:19I go back and I I I ask them I go, "Go
- 21:21listen to all of it, and I can promise
- 21:23you that 95% plus of everything I say is
- 21:27descriptive claims. So, I'm not telling
- 21:29you how things should be. I'm not
- 21:31telling you how you should feel about
- 21:34something. I am simply trying to make a
- 21:36diagnosis, um which is quite different,
- 21:39but
- 21:40yeah, I don't think that speaks to the
- 21:42masses quite like art or and kind of
- 21:46more of that pathos element does.
- 21:48>> Mhm.
- 21:49>> And you look at guys like, for instance,
- 21:51whether it be
- 21:53C. S. Lewis or whether it be Tolkien,
- 21:56it's like did
- 21:57what had a greater impact? Was it their
- 22:00essay writing, which I personally enjoy
- 22:03more, because I'm like, let's let's pull
- 22:05away all the symbolism and like I want
- 22:07to get down to the base of how you
- 22:08think.
- 22:09>> Right.
- 22:09>> But that's not what the average person
- 22:11is looking for, and so they go to Narnia
- 22:15or The Lord of the Rings, which are
- 22:17explicitly
- 22:19um explicitly based on their
- 22:21philosophical principles.
- 22:23And then I think that's where you can go
- 22:26and show somebody. It is It is kind of
- 22:28funny. It's like
- 22:30I've I've seen videos of people online
- 22:33like breaking down crying after watching
- 22:35The Lord of the Rings for the first time
- 22:37and how amazing of a story it is and
- 22:38you're like, "This is an implicitly
- 22:40right-wing story." Like it's all It's
- 22:43all about establishing the proper order.
- 22:46>> Yeah.
- 22:47>> And
- 22:48And yeah, so I like I think definitely
- 22:51you're onto something there in terms of
- 22:53the the art side of things and it does
- 22:55make me think more and more about my
- 22:58strategy on the way that I approach
- 23:00these and whether I should be putting
- 23:01more time into making music like which
- 23:04was my original creative passion and I
- 23:06never I've never done any of that
- 23:08publicly since doing this. And so it's
- 23:11like, "Yeah, is that is that the Is that
- 23:13the play?"
- 23:14>> Yeah. I texted you by the way the the
- 23:17quote from Marcuse. It was actually from
- 23:19a lecture and not from a book, but just
- 23:21just so you have it.
- 23:23But no, like I mean it's cuz I'm the
- 23:25same way. That's the way my brain works.
- 23:27But thankfully, you know, um
- 23:30I am able to delve into
- 23:34the conversation and and I'm a
- 23:36conversationalist. I enjoy having
- 23:37conversations with people um from
- 23:40different spectrums, from different
- 23:41walks of life,
- 23:43um you know, prying in areas that need
- 23:45to be pried,
- 23:46um and having my own
- 23:49um having my own logic pried because I
- 23:52mean, you know, I'm I'm a
- 23:54finite human being. I don't know all
- 23:57things, but I do know
- 23:59I do know who the author of truth is.
- 24:02You know, I do um
- 24:04I I do read the scripture and I believe
- 24:07the scripture. um But, you know, at the
- 24:10same time as a human being I have my
- 24:12blind spots and so it's necessary to
- 24:14like to to kind of duke it out as it
- 24:17were rhetorically with with folks. And
- 24:21you know, I try to be approachable in
- 24:23that way, but also am sure of what I
- 24:26believe and am going to you know, jab
- 24:30like the like the like the best of them
- 24:32in in in debate and conversation and
- 24:34discourse.
- 24:36Um
- 24:38and at the same time, I I do see the
- 24:41necessity of the creative. I do see the
- 24:43necessity of and this is why I'm a
- 24:45filmmaker, you know, I do see the
- 24:46necessity of like actually um
- 24:50putting into pictorial form
- 24:53um the points that I'm that I'm trying
- 24:56to make the points that I'm trying to
- 24:57get across.
- 24:58Um
- 24:59you know, when you look at, for example,
- 25:01I mean, you brought up
- 25:03you know, Lord of the Rings and
- 25:05Chronicles of Narnia, which are great
- 25:06examples. Um but, you know, you look at
- 25:09somebody like Ayn Rand
- 25:11who had some unique and interesting
- 25:15beliefs, you know,
- 25:17and she saw that the
- 25:19necessary way of getting these points
- 25:21across was through novels. She wrote
- 25:24Atlas Shrugged, The Fountainhead.
- 25:27Um her her
- 25:29views would become increasingly weirder
- 25:32as she got older.
- 25:34Um but, she was successful in basically,
- 25:39cuz everybody has an opinion, but she
- 25:40was successful in
- 25:42in pushing her opinion over and beyond
- 25:45her contemporaries in so far that she
- 25:48was able to disseminate them through a
- 25:51novel.
- 25:52Which I think is very interesting.
- 25:54Um
- 25:55and so
- 25:57not not to belabor this point, but I do
- 25:59think uh
- 26:01that
- 26:02that's one of the ways that we should
- 26:04pick back up in terms of trying to
- 26:07figure out how do we wrestle
- 26:09back
- 26:11society and civilization to some some
- 26:14sense of sanity.
- 26:15Um if it is true that, you know,
- 26:19uh we're getting to a point where not
- 26:22even conversation is working. Um where
- 26:25people are not open to logic. People are
- 26:28open to reason. People are open to to
- 26:32dissent, quite frankly.
- 26:34So.
- 26:34>> And I'm starting to very much feel that
- 26:37way in when you look at something like
- 26:40what's unfolding in France right now. I
- 26:42go
- 26:43>> Yeah.
- 26:43>> Like you can't have a debate about this.
- 26:45Hundreds of thousands of people in the
- 26:48streets. Like obviously this has nothing
- 26:51to do with school conditions. All of
- 26:54that is simply just an excuse in order
- 26:57to be violent and radical. Um
- 27:00but it's like you look at that and you
- 27:02go, there's no talking to these people
- 27:04anymore. And this is one of the
- 27:06characteristics of mass movements where
- 27:10by their very nature, they have to
- 27:13operate at the lowest common
- 27:15denominator.
- 27:16>> Uh-huh.
- 27:17>> And you at that point, actually Gustave
- 27:20Le Bon, a social psychologist from the
- 27:221800s in France, he wrote a fantastic
- 27:25book that I've referenced a lot called
- 27:27The Psychology of Crowds. And he said,
- 27:29crowds themselves, they have the
- 27:31temperament of child, women, and
- 27:33savages.
- 27:35And you look at it and you go, yeah,
- 27:37that's pretty pretty spot on.
- 27:40>> Yeah.
- 27:41Um and so like, yeah, you can't reason
- 27:43with that and that's why I do kind of
- 27:45worry that in the next
- 27:47I'd say 5 to 10 years, you are going to
- 27:50see mass civil unrest. And you've
- 27:54already started to see in certain areas
- 27:57of France, there was
- 27:59uh like patriotic types getting together
- 28:01with uh like large crowds to fight these
- 28:03other crowds. And I go
- 28:05I think this is this is where we're
- 28:08headed. That's the new form of
- 28:10conversation for the
- 28:13you know, 2030 era is is just people are
- 28:16going to speak through through violence.
- 28:17And that's not how I
- 28:20want to you know, I much more I'm I
- 28:23would much more take the position of
- 28:25going, I've got my property and stay the
- 28:27hell off of it. Leave me the hell alone.
- 28:29Uh if you want to come onto my property,
- 28:31all right, we can we can do battle, but
- 28:33uh I'm not going to go out and look for
- 28:35look for it. Um but then I do like I I
- 28:38look at
- 28:39people that are concerned about this
- 28:41kind of stuff
- 28:42rightfully so
- 28:44and I think like how are you not
- 28:46preparing for that?
- 28:48Like how are you not preparing for that
- 28:49that future? And so I guess a good a
- 28:52good cuz you've you've done a lot more
- 28:54of the
- 28:56cross aisle talk than I have in debates.
- 28:59Um
- 29:00but you're really good at keeping a
- 29:03level head during those. Like your
- 29:06passion level essentially is the same in
- 29:08this conversation as it would be on the
- 29:11opposite end. Like how do you how do you
- 29:13maintain that that emotional state
- 29:16throughout all of this?
- 29:18>> Um
- 29:19I guess
- 29:21this is going to sound cheesy and very
- 29:22Sunday school,
- 29:24but
- 29:26it's really the fact that I'm at peace,
- 29:28quite frankly.
- 29:29Um
- 29:31given everything that you just said
- 29:33about like what the state of America or
- 29:37the world might look like in 10 years,
- 29:39the things that we see going on in
- 29:41France and other parts of the world, um
- 29:45I can see why it would be easy to to be
- 29:48anxious. I mean, I have four children.
- 29:50You know, they're going to have to live
- 29:51in this future world.
- 29:54>> [sighs]
- 29:54>> And then their children are after them
- 29:56and so it's it's it's necessary as a as
- 30:00a father as a man as a son of God
- 30:03to um
- 30:04do what is is necessary with
- 30:06faithfulness
- 30:08to try to prevent this kind of ensuing
- 30:11doom
- 30:12that is self-inflicted,
- 30:14uh which means it's necessary to try to
- 30:16to to to to train your children up in
- 30:18the way that they should go. It's
- 30:19necessary you know, to the extent that
- 30:20you have a voice your in in in a
- 30:23platform to to try to
- 30:25to speak sense into this dark and dying
- 30:28generation, and to speak reason and and
- 30:31logic into the the crowds that herds of
- 30:35people who are otherwise confused is
- 30:36necessary to do those things. And I and
- 30:39I do those things. I try to do those
- 30:41things at least.
- 30:42Uh but I'm at peace with how all this is
- 30:44going to end. Yes, we're going to have
- 30:46to go through the suffering. Yes, we're
- 30:47going to have to have the you know, the
- 30:50labor pains as it were as the Bible puts
- 30:52it.
- 30:53Um but you know, in the end we will be
- 30:56comforted by our Lord. And so I'm at
- 30:58peace with that. And you know, watching
- 31:01people like Yuri Bezmenov talk about
- 31:03like, "Hey, this is inevitable. You can
- 31:05show them this. You can show them that.
- 31:07You can take them to the gulags and you
- 31:09know, they still won't get it. They
- 31:10still won't know."
- 31:11When I'm in a crowd or not a crowd, when
- 31:13I'm in a debate and somebody sitting
- 31:16across from me being smug or yelling or
- 31:18whatever the case may be, I'm not even
- 31:19really thinking about them so much. I
- 31:21understand that, you know, this video is
- 31:23going to go out. Thousands of people are
- 31:24going to see it. I'm really talking to
- 31:26them. I'm really talking to that person
- 31:27who
- 31:28in the the the quietness of their home
- 31:32or their car or their cubicle
- 31:35is watching this video without
- 31:37distractions, without the outside buzz,
- 31:39and are and are listening to reason
- 31:42versus lunacy.
- 31:44Hopefully they side with reason.
- 31:46Hopefully they saw they they they
- 31:49uh
- 31:50side with peaceful resolve, you know, as
- 31:52opposed to
- 31:54um
- 31:55further exacerbation, chaos, calamity,
- 31:58so on and so forth.
- 32:00And so
- 32:02I think that, you know, to the extent
- 32:04that you show that you're outraged and
- 32:08um
- 32:09angry and all the things, like I think
- 32:11there's obviously such a thing as
- 32:12righteous indignation.
- 32:14Um there's plenty of things in this
- 32:16world that we should be angry about. Um
- 32:19but we as men have to
- 32:23exemplify
- 32:24control. We have to exemplify
- 32:27um
- 32:29this kind of even-handed
- 32:32resolve even in the midst of the storm.
- 32:36You know, i- i- if
- 32:39if, you know, we are driving if I'm
- 32:42driving my family. We just took a road
- 32:44trip to Idaho.
- 32:46And the
- 32:48let's say that we we we decided to leave
- 32:50during the winter and there was a patch
- 32:52of of black ice that I didn't see. I'm
- 32:54driving.
- 32:56Um
- 32:57if the van began to wobble and and shake
- 33:03and my family started screaming
- 33:05frantically and I started screaming
- 33:07along with them.
- 33:09I'm not going to be able to save the
- 33:12family by taking control of the wheel
- 33:15and getting us back all right that we
- 33:17might continue on our path.
- 33:20Um and you know, if I were screaming
- 33:23frantically
- 33:24and we still somehow managed to survive
- 33:27it. How would my children look at me?
- 33:30You know, how how much confidence will
- 33:31my children have in me moving forward.
- 33:35How much how much confidence will my
- 33:36wife have in me?
- 33:38Uh I think that in such times as this
- 33:42it's up to us uh men in particular to
- 33:46address what needs to be addressed
- 33:49to do the work that needs to be done
- 33:51with faithfulness, but do it with
- 33:53resolve, do it with uh
- 33:57a degree of stoicism
- 33:59quite frankly
- 34:00um and do it with with certainty, but
- 34:03most importantly do it with peace and
- 34:04peace and none other than Christ.
- 34:08>> Do you think that this is a Noah's Ark
- 34:11kind of situation where it's
- 34:13>> It kind of is. It kind of is.
- 34:16>> you know,
- 34:17and I don't mean to like I'm not a black
- 34:20pillar by any means. Um I I'm very
- 34:23similar to you where
- 34:25as an individual I find myself very much
- 34:28at peace with my day-to-day. I've got a
- 34:30good uh family circle around me. I've
- 34:33got good great friends. Um I've got
- 34:36passions and interests that I very much
- 34:39enjoy.
- 34:41And then
- 34:43but a lot of people definitely don't
- 34:45have that. And so I wonder more so,
- 34:48yeah, whether this is just okay,
- 34:51essentially
- 34:53button down the hatches, take what you
- 34:56need for recreation, and just try to
- 35:00weather the storm that is inevitably
- 35:02going to come.
- 35:03>> In a way it is,
- 35:04because the fact is
- 35:07um you know, I too am not a black pill
- 35:10guy. I'm very much a white pill guy.
- 35:12Uh at the same time
- 35:15you're dealing with people. You're
- 35:16dealing with what Walter Lippmann called
- 35:19the bewildered herd
- 35:20in a sense.
- 35:22And the question is, you know, how many
- 35:24people are
- 35:26um
- 35:28willing to
- 35:30rise above it
- 35:32and to take ownership and take
- 35:35responsibility
- 35:37and to
- 35:38uh resist the propaganda, resist
- 35:42the ensuing doom that is in many ways
- 35:45self-conflict, you know, self-inflicted,
- 35:47which then brings me to the other side.
- 35:49You know, how many of us are are
- 35:52uh gullible enough to go along with the
- 35:56uh
- 35:57the the messaging
- 35:59the
- 36:01uh doom and gloom kind of like, you
- 36:03know, the world will end unless we get
- 36:06you know, climate change legislation,
- 36:08unless we get socialist legislation,
- 36:11unless we get X, Y, and Z.
- 36:13Uh the world will end. And so they take
- 36:16to protesting, they take to all all all
- 36:19the all the things that we see on on
- 36:21news. And not just even that, and also
- 36:24the way that
- 36:26um it shows up in the institutions,
- 36:28whether it be education, academia
- 36:30entertainment, uh which are all, I
- 36:33guess, complicit in in pushing this
- 36:35narrative, pushing this
- 36:37this uh
- 36:38you know, helping to shape public
- 36:39opinion in that way.
- 36:41And as a result of taking that ideology
- 36:46to its logical conclusion, you're you're
- 36:48left without a civilization. I hate to
- 36:51be so um
- 36:53I I hate to be so uh
- 36:55apocalyptic about it, but it but but
- 36:58that
- 36:59what what else can we expect from
- 37:02institutions, academia, entertainment,
- 37:05uh the the activist class
- 37:08all singing to the same tune, all
- 37:11singing you know, in a chorus in this
- 37:14diabolical
- 37:16symphony, as it were.
- 37:18Um
- 37:19What else do we expect in terms of where
- 37:22something like this will end up? And so,
- 37:25um I'm not saying that we lay down or
- 37:28you know, fall asleep at the gate. Um I
- 37:31do think now is the time to fight, uh
- 37:33but it does become a kind of Noah's Ark
- 37:36situation in so far that you know, the
- 37:39people who
- 37:41are going to hear it are the ones
- 37:43willing to hear it and not everybody
- 37:44else. And and and and and you know,
- 37:46there are too many unfortunately who are
- 37:49unwilling to hear it. And so, at at some
- 37:51point,
- 37:53you know, when some major catastrophe
- 37:55happens as a result of
- 37:58the bewildered masses insisting on their
- 38:01own way,
- 38:03um
- 38:05you know, what what do you do? You know,
- 38:08be
- 38:09I'm not saying that we go out and we
- 38:10build compounds and underground bunkers
- 38:12and things of this nature. Um but what I
- 38:15am saying is that like uh we we can't
- 38:18the very least uh equip our minds
- 38:21um in a way that uh
- 38:26allows allows us to sustain any kind of
- 38:29uh
- 38:30of uh
- 38:31harsh conditions that are brought about
- 38:34by a bewildered herd who insists on
- 38:38carrying these bad ideas to their
- 38:41logical conclusion.
- 38:43>> Yeah, well, and this is where I've got
- 38:45to in terms of you know, when people
- 38:48say, "Oh, we we want the same things,
- 38:51but we just differ on how to get there,
- 38:53right?" And I even saw this in in regard
- 38:56to what we were watching unfold in
- 38:58France. And it's just like I I genuinely
- 39:01don't get how you can be that daft. I
- 39:04think maybe the only thing is that you
- 39:07don't want to reach a point where you
- 39:09lose faith in humanity and you want to
- 39:11be able to believe that all of those
- 39:13people are capable of salvation
- 39:15essentially. Um and hey, you know, maybe
- 39:19maybe they are, but at the same time
- 39:22you look at what you're talking about in
- 39:24terms of anti-civilization,
- 39:27the
- 39:28doctrines and the ideologies,
- 39:31especially, you know, the ones that run
- 39:33through universities and higher academia
- 39:36today, they explicitly call for this.
- 39:39And so, even for instance, uh John Paul
- 39:43Sartre,
- 39:44famous French intellectual,
- 39:47and he said, "Our soil must be occupied
- 39:51by a formally colonized people and we
- 39:54must starve of hunger."
- 39:57Like they're calling for this. They're
- 39:59And it's it's funny cuz it's kind of
- 40:01that religious impulse in a sense for
- 40:04wanting to atone for your sins. And so,
- 40:07they look at the sins of say Western
- 40:09civilization in the past, although I
- 40:11don't think they were unique. I think
- 40:13that was [snorts] very much the time and
- 40:17that was I mean, to this day, there are
- 40:20still many nations that operate the way
- 40:23that we
- 40:25self-flagellate for operating
- 40:28uh
- 40:29centuries ago.
- 40:31And it does seem like this this drive to
- 40:36get rid of guilt, get rid of to deal
- 40:39with shame, and their idea for doing
- 40:42that is to destroy
- 40:46what
- 40:47has been built. It's It's like It's
- 40:50almost a little bit of like a survivor's
- 40:52guilt type of thing where it's like, you
- 40:54know, you got home okay from the war and
- 40:57you feel bad about the fact that other
- 40:59people didn't and so you start becoming
- 41:02self-destructive because you think that
- 41:04is kind of like almost balancing the
- 41:06scales of some sort. But I think that is
- 41:08very important for if there is one
- 41:11narrative to correct that is uh so
- 41:15pervasive socially is the idea that, you
- 41:18know, these leftist types, especially in
- 41:20their modern form, simply want, you
- 41:23know, better health care and better
- 41:24education. It's like, no, they want to
- 41:27smash the foundations of civilization
- 41:29because they believe that civilization
- 41:31itself, you know, going back to
- 41:34Rousseau, French French intellectual who
- 41:36kind of started this entire idea of
- 41:38thinking, you know, man is born free but
- 41:40everywhere in chains. And so the way to
- 41:44get to liberation, which they all talk
- 41:46about so much, is to break down social
- 41:50structures. And so it's like, no, this
- 41:52is this it's it's not that we just
- 41:55disagree on how to get to the same
- 41:57place, it's that we want fundamentally
- 41:59different things.
- 42:01>> Absolutely. It's interesting because I
- 42:03mean France
- 42:06I don't know when France will learn its
- 42:07lesson. Um
- 42:10I mean this goes all the way back as you
- 42:12all know.
- 42:13It's interesting because
- 42:15there was a student in the midst of the
- 42:17protests
- 42:19who was asked about, well, what about
- 42:22the violence? I don't know if you saw
- 42:24this. You know, what about the violence
- 42:26that uh
- 42:28that the students are engaged in,
- 42:29they're beating up teachers, they're
- 42:31doing all kinds of things.
- 42:33And you could tell that her answer was
- 42:35prepared uh for her
- 42:38uh cuz she said something to the extent
- 42:40of, well, what about the violence of the
- 42:42state?
- 42:43And so far and so far that they are, you
- 42:46know, they're not paying well enough or
- 42:49they they're denying health care or are
- 42:51they're denying this or they're denying
- 42:53that?
- 42:54So,
- 42:55these people have
- 42:57come to acknowledge
- 42:59the fact that the government isn't
- 43:01benevolent enough, is not as great of a
- 43:04nanny as it ought to be. It's not as
- 43:07great as of a big brother as it ought to
- 43:09be. And as a result of this,
- 43:11it's committing violence against against
- 43:13me.
- 43:14And so, it's like whether she this this
- 43:17young woman had an a handler who who
- 43:20coached her with that answer or whether
- 43:21she's learning that in her schools,
- 43:23that's problematic and that's what I
- 43:24mean when I said earlier, when you look
- 43:27at academia, education, entertainment,
- 43:29those three in particular,
- 43:31uh the demonic trinity, as it were.
- 43:34Um th- this is the the way that they're
- 43:38indoctrinating and shaping
- 43:40our youth around the world.
- 43:43Um certainly in the Western world. And
- 43:45and it's a problem.
- 43:47Um instilling the virtues of
- 43:50multiculturalism and
- 43:53you know, all the things. And and that
- 43:54it will be the end of us. And and again,
- 43:56I'm not I'm not a black-pilled person,
- 43:58but I'm saying like so long as these
- 44:00people remain
- 44:02um authoritative in these institutions
- 44:06and they're churning out hundreds of
- 44:09thousands, millions of of young people,
- 44:12it's like what do you do to to to change
- 44:15that mindset if you're not leading the
- 44:18institutions?
- 44:19You know? Um and so, we we do have to
- 44:22find other ways to do it, but it's like
- 44:25um
- 44:26you know, to to to believe that because
- 44:29the government is not giving me
- 44:31something that I should be giving
- 44:34myself, that I should be doing for
- 44:35myself, is tantamount to violence.
- 44:39Like
- 44:40how do you turn that around, you know?
- 44:42So.
- 44:43>> Yeah, well, silence is violence, right?
- 44:46You know. [laughter]
- 44:47It's not It's not It's not merely that
- 44:50you don't uh that you have to or that
- 44:53you can't say certain things that are
- 44:55hate speech or whatever. It's that you
- 44:57must affirm the ideology. And I mean,
- 45:00that's that goes back to both, you know,
- 45:02Mao's China and stuff as well, and
- 45:04that's very much part a part of that
- 45:06entire ideology. There's no freedom of
- 45:08conscience, no freedom of thought. In
- 45:10fact, they believe that you are in false
- 45:12consciousness, and it's their job to
- 45:14break you out of that and so that you
- 45:16can become a proper proper radical if
- 45:19you only knew how how oppressive things
- 45:21were.
- 45:22But like even to that point, it's like
- 45:24what are you comparing this against?
- 45:26Because you look at France, for
- 45:29instance. Yeah, oh well, it's it's this
- 45:30is about health care and education.
- 45:32France's public social spending
- 45:35as a share of GDP, now these were 2022
- 45:37numbers, although I'm sure the trends
- 45:39are more or less the same,
- 45:41is [snorts] that 31.4%
- 45:44of their GDP was being spent on public
- 45:47social services, and the highest in the
- 45:50world. And so, if you look at in
- 45:53especially the social state is far
- 45:56larger than any other in human history.
- 45:59And so, you could make the case that
- 46:02France has the best social programs, or
- 46:05at least not maybe best, but puts the
- 46:08most amount of effort and resources
- 46:10towards social programs than any other
- 46:13nation in human history. And yet you're
- 46:16using that for a justification to burn
- 46:18it down.
- 46:19And that's why I think I think that
- 46:21yeah, there's got to be something much
- 46:23deeper and darker here because
- 46:25if you create an incentive structure
- 46:28where
- 46:29your moral virtue and your opportunities
- 46:33are tied to your victimization,
- 46:37then you are going to fight tooth and
- 46:41nail against any narrative that pulls
- 46:44that moral authority, which is
- 46:45essentially power, away from them. And
- 46:48you can see this
- 46:50I This is when it first clicked for me
- 46:52was after the mass graves hoax in Canada
- 46:56where they were saying there's thousands
- 46:58of bodies across across Canada, but then
- 47:01you looked into it
- 47:02under residential schools. This was a
- 47:04genocide of indigenous children. And
- 47:07then you looked at it and what they were
- 47:09doing was using ground penetrating radar
- 47:12and then saying any soil anomalies that
- 47:15they could find were dead children.
- 47:17They've not They spent millions of
- 47:19dollars on excavation at one site in
- 47:22particular and they found nothing. Um
- 47:25and but this was then used in order to
- 47:30attack the system, so to say. And I
- 47:32remember I was having a conversation
- 47:33with a comedian in a green room.
- 47:36And he was talking about
- 47:39that that issue in particular. And so I
- 47:42mentioned the whole ground penetrating
- 47:43radar stuff and how the excavations
- 47:45didn't actually turn up anything. And
- 47:47hey, maybe certain things did happen,
- 47:49but we don't have anything evidence-wise
- 47:52to make that claim yet.
- 47:54And he got upset. And I And I asked him,
- 47:56and you could tell this is actually when
- 47:58it flipped. So maybe this is a good
- 47:59question for any audience members to put
- 48:01on these people is being like, "Why do
- 48:04you want this to be true? Like if you
- 48:06care so much about indigenous children,
- 48:09shouldn't you be glad to hear that there
- 48:12wasn't actually thousands of them buried
- 48:15in unmarked graves essentially in a
- 48:17ditch somewhere? Like
- 48:18>> Mhm.
- 48:19>> You should be relieved, but you're not.
- 48:22You're actually angry because that thing
- 48:24would give you power today. And so
- 48:26that's what That's where I think it all
- 48:28comes from.
- 48:29>> Oh, 100% and I said
- 48:32>> [laughter]
- 48:32>> I mean, we you see something similar
- 48:34with the
- 48:35the the Tulsa race riot of 1921.
- 48:39Um the original numbers I think showed
- 48:42like
- 48:43Uh
- 48:44well, the original story covered it as a
- 48:46riot. It said it was a riot and that 10
- 48:50Negroes and three whites died in this in
- 48:54the midst of this kerfuffle.
- 48:56Um but the numbers keep getting larger
- 48:58and larger and larger over the years.
- 49:01And not only does that happen, it's now
- 49:03called a race massacre
- 49:06as opposed to a race riot, which is what
- 49:09it actually was. There's this claim that
- 49:11there's this mass grave of Negroes
- 49:15buried near in the Greenwood district of
- 49:17Tulsa, Oklahoma.
- 49:19Haven't been able to find the grave.
- 49:21Uh they're raising all kinds of money to
- 49:23try to to locate it and it's like it's
- 49:26not there. It just simply isn't there.
- 49:28And it's interesting because, you know,
- 49:30the the the Greenwood district, which
- 49:32was burnt down, like many of the
- 49:34buildings were burnt down during this
- 49:35race riot in 1921, but by 1925, all of
- 49:39it was built back. All of it was built
- 49:41back and it wasn't just Negroes building
- 49:44back up their own community, it was
- 49:45white people helping them in many
- 49:47instances
- 49:49uh build back their community. So, by
- 49:511925, it was completely built back.
- 49:53There's archival video of this having of
- 49:56this happening and it wouldn't it
- 49:58wouldn't decline again until the 1960s
- 50:01during the height of the Civil Rights
- 50:02era.
- 50:03Um and all the rhetoric that was
- 50:06poisoning the well, as it were,
- 50:08uh would begin to take shape.
- 50:10Now, it's interesting because when I
- 50:12tell people, uh particularly black
- 50:13people, that story, like, "Hey, you
- 50:15know, you realize it was built back,
- 50:17right? And that there is no mass grave,
- 50:19that the original numbers were
- 50:20significantly lower than what's being
- 50:22reported right now by the likes of the
- 50:24Library of Congress and other such
- 50:25things." And they get upset and similar
- 50:28to what you're talking about, and they
- 50:30want so badly for the numbers to be in
- 50:33the thousands. They want so badly for
- 50:36there to be a mass grave. They want so
- 50:38badly to for it to not be true that
- 50:42Tulsa
- 50:43the Greenwood district was built back.
- 50:46They they they want that and it's like,
- 50:48"What is that?" Like the
- 50:50What it is, Liam, I believe, is that
- 50:53they're they're constantly looking for
- 50:56fodder to justify the revolution.
- 51:01That's what they're interested in.
- 51:02They're They're They're interested in
- 51:03fodder and using that weaponizing that
- 51:08as a as a tool
- 51:10for the revolution. And that's
- 51:12That's That's what they're interested
- 51:13in. They're not interested in And And it
- 51:15And it kind of show It reveals the mask
- 51:18kind of slips to the extent that they
- 51:20get upset
- 51:21because it reveals that you're not so
- 51:22much interested in the the people who
- 51:27were massacred
- 51:30uh in the Tulsa
- 51:32uh situation or in the situation that
- 51:34you're talking about. You don't give a
- 51:36damn about them. You You What you care
- 51:38about is the revolution and using them
- 51:41to push the revolution. That's really
- 51:43what this is about. And to the extent
- 51:46that you expose that, I think that
- 51:48you're you're you're doing the right
- 51:50thing. You're on to something. Uh I
- 51:52think I used this analogy before on your
- 51:54show, but it's like you're like the boy
- 51:57in the fable The Emperor's New Clothes.
- 52:00To the extent that you say the quiet
- 52:02part out loud, you say the thing that
- 52:03needs to be said,
- 52:05um
- 52:06and encourage other people around you to
- 52:09acknowledge the same thing. Like, "Hey,
- 52:11these people don't care about the
- 52:12situation. They don't care about the
- 52:13facts, which which actually uh betrays
- 52:17everything that they're saying. The
- 52:18facts complicate the issue at the very
- 52:21least, but but but at worst, it
- 52:23completely dismantles their whole
- 52:26logic."
- 52:27Um
- 52:29but they're not interested in having
- 52:31those questions answered. They're not
- 52:32interested in looking into those
- 52:33details, into those facts, because they
- 52:35just are using it to to further the
- 52:36revolution at the end of the day.
- 52:38>> If you'd like to get my work delivered
- 52:40directly to your inbox and receive
- 52:42newsletters, essays, and exclusive
- 52:44content, please head over to Liam Out
- 52:46Loud.substack.com.
- 52:49The link is in the description as well.
- 52:51And now, let's get back to the show.
- 52:53Yeah, and I think too, even on a more
- 52:55spiritual level outside of the
- 52:57political, and I think what we're seeing
- 52:59is this spirit being amplified through
- 53:04the political. And so, it ends up taking
- 53:06hold, but
- 53:07essentially two passages I just wanted
- 53:09to throw out there that I think touch on
- 53:12this kind of human condition aspect so
- 53:14deeply is uh from Dostoevsky's
- 53:18The Brothers Karamazov, and then also
- 53:21Kierkegaard's The Sickness unto Death,
- 53:24where Dostoevsky said, "A man who lies
- 53:27to himself is often the first to take
- 53:30offense. He sometimes feels very good to
- 53:33take offense, doesn't it? And surely he
- 53:35knows that no one has offended him and
- 53:37that he has invited the offense and told
- 53:39lies just for the beauty of it, that he
- 53:42has exaggerated for the sake of effect,
- 53:44that he has picked up on a word and made
- 53:46a mountain out of a pea. He knows all of
- 53:48that, and still he is the first to take
- 53:51offense. He likes feeling offended. It
- 53:53gives him great pleasure, and thus he
- 53:56reaches the point of real hostility."
- 53:59And I noticed that Kierkegaard ended up
- 54:01touching on pretty much the exact same
- 54:03thing, and what he said was that the the
- 54:06sufferer fastens onto one pain point,
- 54:10gives it all of his energy, and then
- 54:12turns that into his identity of sorts,
- 54:15and would even turn down relief from God
- 54:19and the angels. And so he wrote, uh "He
- 54:22prefers to rage against everything and
- 54:25be the one whom the whole world, all
- 54:27existence, has wronged, the one for whom
- 54:30it is especially important to ensure
- 54:32that he has his agony on hand, so that
- 54:35no one will take it from him. For then
- 54:38he would not be able to convince others
- 54:40and himself that he is right. This
- 54:43finally fixes itself so firmly in his
- 54:46head that he becomes frightened of
- 54:48eternity for a rather strange reason. He
- 54:51is afraid in case it should take away
- 54:54from him what from a demonic viewpoint
- 54:57gives him infinite superiority over
- 55:00others."
- 55:01And that's another great paradox of this
- 55:03kind of
- 55:04I I I do view it more spiritual than I
- 55:08kind of went at first I was like oh it's
- 55:10a political party that's doing all of
- 55:11this and then I was like okay it's a
- 55:12political ideology and then I kind of
- 55:15went okay now it's actually I think it's
- 55:17much more like a spiritual where that
- 55:19type of person is is essentially who
- 55:23falls into these these mass mass
- 55:25movements
- 55:27but he
- 55:28Kierkegaard I think put it as like a
- 55:31form of demonic despair.
- 55:33>> Yeah.
- 55:34>> I guess like how do you how do you as a
- 55:36Christian kind of
- 55:38get to these two because now that I've
- 55:40viewed it more spiritual
- 55:42I've started to very much see people as
- 55:45possessed by these things like you can
- 55:47see it in their eyes sometimes too I've
- 55:49seen it in person I've seen it online a
- 55:51bunch where like you just look at
- 55:53somebody and you go like that demonic
- 55:54despair that he's talking about it's
- 55:56like I can see that there's just nothing
- 55:58behind your eyes and I'm essentially
- 56:01dealing with this demonic presence
- 56:03like how I don't know like how do I
- 56:05guess
- 56:06I'm very similar to you where I like to
- 56:08try to remain calm and all of that but I
- 56:10guess I'm looking at it going like at a
- 56:12certain point you do start to feel
- 56:14threatened by those types.
- 56:15>> Yeah.
- 56:17No I mean the best again I'm going to
- 56:19give you another Sunday school answer
- 56:21but the best you can do is just pray for
- 56:23them and pray for the world quite
- 56:24frankly
- 56:26because you know
- 56:29unfortunately people who who are in that
- 56:31space like they're captured but there's
- 56:34but there's still hope for them yet you
- 56:36know so long as they have breath in
- 56:37their lungs
- 56:38um
- 56:39but you know for
- 56:41I know that faith comes by hearing and
- 56:43hearing by the word of God and so for me
- 56:46it's like to the extent that I engage in
- 56:48these conversations
- 56:50whether it be in person or even when I
- 56:52do stuff on YouTube or what have you
- 56:55I
- 56:56incorporate scripture I incorporate
- 56:59biblical knowledge and wisdom and the
- 57:01things that I say and thankfully there's
- 57:04been people who have
- 57:08boldly come to me
- 57:10uh or emailed me or DM'd me or or even
- 57:13wrote in the comment section for all to
- 57:15see uh that they were in that place that
- 57:18you're talking about. And after having
- 57:20watched some of my stuff and some other
- 57:22people's stuff, uh they they were able
- 57:25to thankfully overcome it.
- 57:28Um and so it's it's really nothing that
- 57:30I can do other than being faithful. Um
- 57:33because that's what God calls us to do
- 57:35is to be faithful.
- 57:36Um
- 57:37Some of us want to be like Peter, the
- 57:39Apostle Peter,
- 57:41where we just uh are over the top and
- 57:44what and what it is that we want to do.
- 57:46I mean, during the Transfiguration,
- 57:48uh you know, um Peter wanted to like
- 57:51immediately start building this
- 57:53tabernacle. And he had to God actually
- 57:55had to tell him like, "Hey, calm down.
- 57:58This is my son with whom I'm well
- 58:00pleased, you know?" Uh speaking of of of
- 58:03Christ. Um Peter was willing to cut off
- 58:07the ear of the soldier uh whenever they
- 58:09came to seize Jesus, a Roman soldier.
- 58:12So, Peter was that guy who was always
- 58:14willing to go to the max, you know? Um
- 58:17and then you had other apostles who were
- 58:19who were less so, but they were more
- 58:21obedient in things of this nature. And
- 58:22so, it's like I think that um
- 58:25that we have to leave room obviously for
- 58:28the Holy Spirit. We have a role to play
- 58:30as uh children of God who are in his
- 58:35royal family. And we all have different
- 58:37skills, we all have different talents,
- 58:39we all have different um um abilities.
- 58:42And and and that's beautiful, quite
- 58:44frankly. Um because the way that you
- 58:46communicate, Liam, is always going to be
- 58:48the same way that I communicate and vice
- 58:49versa. But that's beautiful. Um because
- 58:51the fact is like we're all reaching
- 58:53people in in various ways, uh but for
- 58:57the same purpose. And so, as a result of
- 58:59this,
- 59:00um
- 59:01you know, the Bible says one uh plants,
- 59:04one waters.
- 59:06And and so, we have different roles. And
- 59:10so, for me it's like I can't be the
- 59:11planter and the waterer and the one that
- 59:14causes it to grow.
- 59:15Um I have the role as the planter and
- 59:18and maybe the waterer, but but only God
- 59:21can make that seed grow. And so
- 59:24what what is what is tantamount
- 59:26biblically to planting and watering?
- 59:29Well, it's it's the uttering of the
- 59:31word. It's the the the telling of the
- 59:34truth.
- 59:35Um and beyond that I can't be too much
- 59:39like Peter where I'm just doing too much
- 59:42and and actually maybe even
- 59:43self-sabotaging, you know? So, I'm
- 59:46hoping that answer makes sense.
- 59:48>> Yeah, and
- 59:49I think
- 59:51where I come to with a lot of the the
- 59:54Christian side of things in cuz I'm I'm
- 59:57definitely I I grew up I was very
- 1:00:00atheistic, you know, I think my
- 1:00:02introduction to the more intellectual
- 1:00:04sphere was like a lot of people at that
- 1:00:06age and it was the Christopher Hitchens
- 1:00:09and, you know, the
- 1:00:10>> Dawkins
- 1:00:11>> Yeah, Dawkins and Sam Harris and all of
- 1:00:13these and, you know, dunking on dunking
- 1:00:16on
- 1:00:16>> of Peter Atkins?
- 1:00:18>> Uh not familiar, actually.
- 1:00:20>> Uh I think Oxford.
- 1:00:22>> Okay.
- 1:00:22>> an interesting debate with uh
- 1:00:25uh
- 1:00:27um
- 1:00:29Professor Lennox.
- 1:00:30>> Okay.
- 1:00:31>> Back in I think 2008
- 1:00:34or 9. But anyway, I cut you off. Go
- 1:00:35ahead.
- 1:00:36>> No, it's okay. Um
- 1:00:38yeah, I didn't uh I I I was very much
- 1:00:40that's kind of what I was brought into.
- 1:00:43Now that I've
- 1:00:44dove into these more philosophical and
- 1:00:47theological
- 1:00:49frameworks more deeply, I start to
- 1:00:51understand how shallow a lot of their
- 1:00:54arguments were.
- 1:00:55Um but they're they're highly appealing
- 1:00:57if if you don't kind of know cuz a lot
- 1:01:01of it is is straw man type of arguments
- 1:01:03and so you kind of take their caricature
- 1:01:05of what Christianity or religion is and
- 1:01:08then you assume that that is the the
- 1:01:11idea. But where I was going to with this
- 1:01:13is that it's very interesting because
- 1:01:17I've had a lot of controversial
- 1:01:20opinions. I've had a a lot of Well, and
- 1:01:23it's funny cuz actually it's only I
- 1:01:25don't think they're controversial to the
- 1:01:27majority. I think they're controversial
- 1:01:29to a small sum that is very loud.
- 1:01:32>> Right.
- 1:01:32>> And because because the number one thing
- 1:01:34that I get all the time is like thank
- 1:01:36you so much for saying the things I'm
- 1:01:37thinking and I'm scared to say.
- 1:01:40>> Yeah.
- 1:01:40>> Um but
- 1:01:42one thing that I've just noticed from my
- 1:01:44own personal thing is like the religious
- 1:01:47side of things is and I I I I wouldn't
- 1:01:50classify myself as a Christian because I
- 1:01:54don't know it well enough yet and I've
- 1:01:56been trying to explore this and actually
- 1:01:59take it seriously, not uh not engage on
- 1:02:02it on this uh this caricature level and
- 1:02:04also just from understanding how
- 1:02:07important it was to the history of the
- 1:02:10West.
- 1:02:10>> Mhm.
- 1:02:11>> But
- 1:02:12I have not experienced as much
- 1:02:17pushback or
- 1:02:22whether it's even if it's not anger,
- 1:02:23just like discomfort from people when
- 1:02:26you talk about that. Like even if I just
- 1:02:29say for instance that I I'm exploring
- 1:02:32these ideas and starting to try to uh
- 1:02:35try to live by them a little bit better
- 1:02:36and and actually apply them to my life
- 1:02:39and yeah, take them seriously.
- 1:02:42Why is that do you think
- 1:02:44that that side of things
- 1:02:46has so much
- 1:02:48hesitation towards people? Like they can
- 1:02:51a lot of people can obviously there's
- 1:02:53types that can't entertain anything
- 1:02:55outside of their worldview, but even
- 1:02:57I've noticed the types of people that
- 1:02:59are typically more
- 1:03:01intellectually curious and not
- 1:03:04extremely dogmatic
- 1:03:06they all of a sudden become that way
- 1:03:08when religion is the topic. Why do you
- 1:03:10think?
- 1:03:12>> Um I think that part of it has to do
- 1:03:15with uh
- 1:03:16what they think
- 1:03:19um religion is responsible for
- 1:03:21historically.
- 1:03:23Um they think of
- 1:03:28religion and Christianity in particular
- 1:03:30what I think of communism.
- 1:03:33In other words, when I look at the
- 1:03:36millions of bodies
- 1:03:38uh that have been
- 1:03:41piled up as a result of communism in the
- 1:03:4420th century alone,
- 1:03:46um a lot of
- 1:03:49Americans, I mean, I know you're in
- 1:03:50Canada. I imagine it's the same there.
- 1:03:53Um have a similar
- 1:03:55uh belief when it comes to
- 1:03:59the Crusades or
- 1:04:01uh this idea that
- 1:04:04Christianity is so dogmatically
- 1:04:07inhibiting
- 1:04:08that it doesn't allow you to be your
- 1:04:10true self.
- 1:04:12Um
- 1:04:14and that's that in itself is genocidal.
- 1:04:18Um because what if a person wants to be
- 1:04:21gay?
- 1:04:22What if a person wants to be trans? What
- 1:04:24if, you know,
- 1:04:27um a person doesn't want to abide by
- 1:04:30this rule book called the Bible that
- 1:04:34prevents me from having fun and and just
- 1:04:37finding myself and being myself?
- 1:04:39Um
- 1:04:41and so
- 1:04:42I think it's it's mainly on those two
- 1:04:44fronts. So, one,
- 1:04:46uh what they believe Christianity has
- 1:04:48been responsible for historically,
- 1:04:50and two, what they believe Christianity
- 1:04:53prevents people from from doing, from
- 1:04:55experiencing true liberation.
- 1:04:58They can't define what true liberation
- 1:04:59is, but they know that
- 1:05:02or at least they think they know that
- 1:05:03the scriptures prevent them from
- 1:05:05experiencing it.
- 1:05:07>> Yeah, and that kind of just
- 1:05:09jogged something in my head a little
- 1:05:10bit, which is even I think why, you
- 1:05:13know, I'm speaking more from personal
- 1:05:14experience here, having been on the
- 1:05:15other before where
- 1:05:18I think
- 1:05:20an aspect is how demanding it is as
- 1:05:23well. It's not like say for instance if
- 1:05:26I have a certain opinion on
- 1:05:30how a certain like a specific
- 1:05:32institution like university should
- 1:05:34operate or something. Trying to convince
- 1:05:36somebody of that, it's like okay, here's
- 1:05:38this one belief that applies to this
- 1:05:40very small aspect of society. And so if
- 1:05:44you are to accept that belief it doesn't
- 1:05:47require all that much from you. But if
- 1:05:51you make that leap from an atheist to a
- 1:05:54believer
- 1:05:56it
- 1:05:57makes you change everything. It's not oh
- 1:06:01it's not oh I now have to cut out sweets
- 1:06:03at 9:00 p.m. Like that's the one change
- 1:06:05I have to do in my life. It's no, I have
- 1:06:07to I have to change how I behave. I have
- 1:06:10to change how I interact with people. I
- 1:06:11have to change how I think how I think.
- 1:06:14I have to change how I how I approach
- 1:06:17relationships. I have to change how I
- 1:06:21view the world top to bottom.
- 1:06:24And so I think that's probably part of
- 1:06:26it as well where it's just the the the
- 1:06:29demanding aspect of of essentially the
- 1:06:31the ask is so large. And I think that's
- 1:06:34why even subconsciously I I resisted it
- 1:06:37a little bit because I was extremely
- 1:06:43I wouldn't say extremely but even just
- 1:06:45little things like okay, partying. Oh, I
- 1:06:47like partying with my friends on on
- 1:06:48weekends but then can I really if I
- 1:06:50accept this faith like can I now engage
- 1:06:53in what would be considered moral
- 1:06:55degeneracy? And so it's like you have to
- 1:06:58essentially
- 1:07:01to put it in harsh terms it's like you
- 1:07:02have to kill your prior self.
- 1:07:04>> Mhm.
- 1:07:04>> So maybe in your sense they have a
- 1:07:06point.
- 1:07:08>> Yeah, I mean and that is that is the the
- 1:07:12the ask.
- 1:07:13That is the demand.
- 1:07:16Um to die. That's what the cross
- 1:07:19represents is dying.
- 1:07:22Um you're born in a natural world to
- 1:07:25natural parents who taught you natural
- 1:07:27things. [snorts]
- 1:07:29Um, and you have to die to that natural
- 1:07:31self
- 1:07:33and supernaturally
- 1:07:36be born again
- 1:07:38with a new set of values
- 1:07:40um, that are God's values.
- 1:07:43Um,
- 1:07:45the Bible calls this Christian walk
- 1:07:48sanctification.
- 1:07:50It's It's a you're a daily work in
- 1:07:52progress and you're following the Holy
- 1:07:55Spirit, which means that you are denying
- 1:07:58yourself. You're denying the flesh. Um,
- 1:08:02and you're choosing to to uh,
- 1:08:05to walk with with God, quite frankly.
- 1:08:08Um,
- 1:08:09and a lot of us don't want to do that.
- 1:08:11We don't want to die to ourselves.
- 1:08:13Uh, we
- 1:08:15and and it's really tantamount to
- 1:08:17believing you are a God, quite frankly.
- 1:08:20Again, it goes back to the Garden of
- 1:08:21Eden and I and I know Jordan Peterson
- 1:08:22talked about this as well. Uh,
- 1:08:25the the the the what what Satan was
- 1:08:28offering
- 1:08:29uh, Eve and the reason why she was
- 1:08:32interested was she can become like a God
- 1:08:35herself.
- 1:08:36Um, knowing good from evil or choosing
- 1:08:39for herself what is good
- 1:08:41and evil and rejecting what God has to
- 1:08:43say about it.
- 1:08:45Um, that that intrigued her and so she
- 1:08:48ate from the fruit and gave some to Adam
- 1:08:50and he
- 1:08:51who was was with her
- 1:08:53ate from it too and we are descendants
- 1:08:55of Adam and Eve. The Bible calls Adam
- 1:08:57the first Adam.
- 1:08:58It calls Christ the second Adam. In
- 1:09:01other words, what Adam broke
- 1:09:03Christ repairs.
- 1:09:05And so,
- 1:09:07what is it that he's repairing? Well,
- 1:09:09he's repairing the fact that we have
- 1:09:12fallen from God.
- 1:09:14Uh, in the desire to be gods ourselves.
- 1:09:17But what Christ does on the cross is he
- 1:09:19reconciles us back to God.
- 1:09:22Um,
- 1:09:23and it's a it's a better life
- 1:09:26when you're reconciled back to God.
- 1:09:28You're still going to
- 1:09:29endure suffering. You're still going to
- 1:09:33slip up, mess up, and um these are
- 1:09:36things that are still going to happen.
- 1:09:37You still live in the world. You're
- 1:09:38still a
- 1:09:39a fleshly human being in the world on
- 1:09:41this side of heaven.
- 1:09:43Um
- 1:09:44however, you're perpetually being
- 1:09:46sanctified. Uh you now have an
- 1:09:49intercessor
- 1:09:50um on your behalf that is Christ
- 1:09:53interceding on your behalf to God.
- 1:09:56Um
- 1:09:58and
- 1:09:59like what I've experienced as a
- 1:10:01Christian is
- 1:10:03that
- 1:10:05because of my faith
- 1:10:08I am a better father than I would
- 1:10:10otherwise be, a better friend than I
- 1:10:12would otherwise be, a better dad than I
- 1:10:14would otherwise be.
- 1:10:16Um because you're constantly taming that
- 1:10:19natural passion
- 1:10:21um to be a bad father, to be a bad
- 1:10:25husband, to be That's not to say that,
- 1:10:27you know, there aren't atheists who, you
- 1:10:29know,
- 1:10:30uh
- 1:10:32don't treat their wives well and take
- 1:10:34them on dates and are pleasant to their
- 1:10:36children. I'm not saying that at all.
- 1:10:38But to love with a with with with God's
- 1:10:41love, it's it just hits different, quite
- 1:10:43frankly. Um
- 1:10:45and so
- 1:10:47a lot of us insist on our own way.
- 1:10:50And it's to that extent that we don't
- 1:10:52want to give our lives unto God. Uh we
- 1:10:57we we believe with our finite minds that
- 1:11:00we can just figure this thing out on our
- 1:11:02own
- 1:11:02um and still enjoy the pleasures that we
- 1:11:05seek. We we can still, you know, satisfy
- 1:11:09uh our desires uh in a way that God
- 1:11:13can't quite fulfill.
- 1:11:15Um and so for this reason we're not
- 1:11:17interested in in
- 1:11:19and uh
- 1:11:21submitting to him.
- 1:11:22So.
- 1:11:24>> Tying this into the larger conversation
- 1:11:28that we are kind of having socially.
- 1:11:32I was I picked up The Camp of the Saints
- 1:11:35recently, which is a uh controversial
- 1:11:37book, but uh all about essentially a
- 1:11:40dystopian vision of mass migration and
- 1:11:42what it would look like.
- 1:11:44And actually that Sartre quote that I
- 1:11:46referenced earlier, that, you know, our
- 1:11:48soil has to be filled with the colonized
- 1:11:52and we have to starve, that I found that
- 1:11:55in the forward because actually he wrote
- 1:11:58that book as a
- 1:12:01response to that worldview. He went,
- 1:12:03"Let me Let me allow this worldview to
- 1:12:05play out." And so it starts off as,
- 1:12:08"Okay, you've got this large migrant
- 1:12:11population that first tries to go to
- 1:12:13South Africa and gets shot at." Like the
- 1:12:16boats get shot at. So they turn away and
- 1:12:18head towards Europe. And then they get
- 1:12:21to Europe and they
- 1:12:24the leaders of France,
- 1:12:27cuz he was a Frenchman, you know, it's
- 1:12:28very very timely. Um that they didn't
- 1:12:31have the will to shoot down the boats
- 1:12:34because of this universality of the
- 1:12:36Christian ethic that is so deeply
- 1:12:39intertwined with our civilization that
- 1:12:42they see no difference between us and
- 1:12:45them. You know, there's just one
- 1:12:47universal. And
- 1:12:49but it's like, "Okay, now
- 1:12:52how do we balance those two?" Because I
- 1:12:55would like to live in a world where yes,
- 1:12:57we can have a universal ethic that, you
- 1:13:01know, whether it's
- 1:13:03whether it's my skin color, whether it's
- 1:13:04my gender, or anything of this nature,
- 1:13:06like a law doesn't apply to me
- 1:13:08differently
- 1:13:10or benefit me. I don't want an
- 1:13:12undeserved benefit. I also don't want
- 1:13:14somebody to or I and I don't want to be
- 1:13:16undeserved persecution.
- 1:13:19But
- 1:13:20then how do we balance that with like
- 1:13:22this particular, so we've got the
- 1:13:24universal being the Christian ethic that
- 1:13:27our society's function on, and then the
- 1:13:29particular, which all of these other
- 1:13:32societies function on, which is very
- 1:13:34much a more tribalistic us versus them,
- 1:13:37they do not see us as one whole. And
- 1:13:40it's kind of like, how do I how do we
- 1:13:43bridge those two?
- 1:13:46>> That's a interesting question.
- 1:13:49Um because you're absolutely right. Uh
- 1:13:52when you when you look at
- 1:13:55um the communist ploy
- 1:13:58over the course of the 20th century
- 1:14:01to spread their ideology in the West,
- 1:14:05and particularly in America,
- 1:14:07um this is something that they came up
- 1:14:09against because
- 1:14:11you know,
- 1:14:12when you look at American institutions
- 1:14:14and Americans in general,
- 1:14:16uh who had a Christian disposition,
- 1:14:20um
- 1:14:23the communists kind of found a way
- 1:14:27to use that against them in order to
- 1:14:31neutralize them and thus infiltrate.
- 1:14:36Uh much like what you're talking about
- 1:14:37with regard to migrants coming into
- 1:14:40France.
- 1:14:41Um
- 1:14:44and so
- 1:14:46mhm
- 1:14:47And so, for me, the word that comes to
- 1:14:48mind is discernment.
- 1:14:51And
- 1:14:53you know, it it in studying to show
- 1:14:55yourself approved, it
- 1:14:58not letting your foot off the gas, so to
- 1:15:00speak. And so, what that means is like,
- 1:15:02how is it how do you, on the one hand,
- 1:15:06maintain the posterity,
- 1:15:10the the foundation of your civilization,
- 1:15:14um
- 1:15:15and at the same time,
- 1:15:18uh honor the scriptures when it talks
- 1:15:21about, you know, thou shalt not kill,
- 1:15:24uh to to to welcome the stranger, and
- 1:15:27and things of that nature. How how how
- 1:15:29can both of those things fit into the
- 1:15:31same
- 1:15:32box or fit into the same civilization
- 1:15:35because, you know, there are those who
- 1:15:37say, "Well, you have to do what South
- 1:15:40Africa did um in order to prevent uh the
- 1:15:44collapse of your own society."
- 1:15:47Um and I think there is a way to do
- 1:15:49that. I think I think it comes down to
- 1:15:51once again studying to show yourself
- 1:15:53approved, understanding what's going on,
- 1:15:57having the discernment enough to um
- 1:16:01to say, "Okay, we are going to show
- 1:16:04brotherly love by welcoming the
- 1:16:06stranger, but we insist on
- 1:16:10our civilization, our foundations,
- 1:16:13uh our faith, and we're not going to
- 1:16:16allow a kind of poisoning of the well,
- 1:16:19we're not going to allow
- 1:16:20multiculturalism because we are Canada,
- 1:16:23we are America. Um and we have a set of
- 1:16:27values. Um and so
- 1:16:30um and so there's this balancing act
- 1:16:33that one has to do uh legally um and
- 1:16:37socially uh to to to on the one hand
- 1:16:41say, "Look, we welcomed you in. Um
- 1:16:45y- y- you you fled uh a disastrous
- 1:16:49situation from where, you know, that
- 1:16:52that was going on wherever you're from,
- 1:16:54and obviously there's something about us
- 1:16:57that caused you to come here
- 1:16:59um that wasn't true of where you came
- 1:17:02from. So, we're not going to allow
- 1:17:05where we are to become where you came
- 1:17:07from by bringing those same
- 1:17:10twisted values here, right? That's
- 1:17:14essentially what multiculturalism is in
- 1:17:16a large metropolitan area or wherever
- 1:17:18the case may be.
- 1:17:20And so
- 1:17:22you know, how do you strike that balance
- 1:17:24of welcoming the stranger
- 1:17:27but un- but but making the stranger know
- 1:17:30that you're coming to us, like you're
- 1:17:32you're coming to where we are. Here's
- 1:17:34how we do things.
- 1:17:36Um we're not going to allow uh
- 1:17:39this kind of melting pot as it were
- 1:17:42um of this amalgamation of confusion uh
- 1:17:45that would ultimately mean our collapse,
- 1:17:48you know? And so I think that
- 1:17:50unfortunately over the course of the
- 1:17:5120th century
- 1:17:53uh because of the fact that we didn't
- 1:17:55know what hit us and we were all too
- 1:17:57willing to um
- 1:18:00to uh
- 1:18:01acquiesce to the exaggerated grievances
- 1:18:05of
- 1:18:07of
- 1:18:09groups who played victim
- 1:18:12in order to uh usher in a foreign
- 1:18:15ideology.
- 1:18:17We've lost our way.
- 1:18:20We we we've been neutralized.
- 1:18:23And as a result uh we live in a nation
- 1:18:25that's unrecognizable at this point.
- 1:18:28And so it's this kind of slow bleeding,
- 1:18:30this kind of slow death from within
- 1:18:32that's taken place.
- 1:18:34Multiculturalism is a sickness.
- 1:18:36Um
- 1:18:38and and you know
- 1:18:41when you when you read the scriptures
- 1:18:43Old and New Testament
- 1:18:45but specifically the New Testament
- 1:18:48and it and you see this language of you
- 1:18:50know God's people are made up of every
- 1:18:53tongue, tribe, and nation. That in
- 1:18:56Christ there's no longer slave nor free,
- 1:18:58Jew nor Gentile, male nor female, for we
- 1:19:00are all one in Christ Jesus.
- 1:19:02That's an interesting verse
- 1:19:04because you know it it's the subject is
- 1:19:08in Christ.
- 1:19:11Right?
- 1:19:12And so you have this kind of diverse
- 1:19:16group of people from different walks of
- 1:19:20life, different backgrounds, different
- 1:19:22ethnicities, so on and so forth so on
- 1:19:24and so forth so so on and so forth, but
- 1:19:26they are in Christ, which means Christ
- 1:19:29is the authority.
- 1:19:31I don't get to bring my blackness
- 1:19:34to the equation or my maleness or
- 1:19:37whatever to the equation, I'm subject to
- 1:19:41Christ. Christ is considered Lord, which
- 1:19:43necessarily means that I'm
- 1:19:45subject to the Lord. I'm I'm the
- 1:19:47subject, he's the Lord. I'm subordinate,
- 1:19:50he is the authority.
- 1:19:53And so, what he says goes. But, the
- 1:19:55beauty in that is,
- 1:19:57you know, he whom the Christ you know,
- 1:20:00he whom uh the Lord sets free is free
- 1:20:02indeed, right? Is this Is this beautiful
- 1:20:05dichotomy because we're all slaves.
- 1:20:08We're all slaves to our passions, we're
- 1:20:09all slaves to something. The old Bob
- 1:20:11Dylan says, yeah, show the old Bob Dylan
- 1:20:13song, you know, goes, you know, uh it
- 1:20:16might be the devil or it might be the
- 1:20:18Lord, but you're going to have to serve
- 1:20:19somebody. We all serve something,
- 1:20:21whether it's ourselves, whether it's
- 1:20:23whatever. Whatever your passions are,
- 1:20:25you you become in a sense a slave to
- 1:20:27that passion, a slave to that
- 1:20:30desire.
- 1:20:32And so, you know, Paul the Apostle Paul
- 1:20:34calls himself a slave to Christ. He
- 1:20:36says, I'm a bondservant to Christ.
- 1:20:38Uh but but the beautiful dichotomy of
- 1:20:40that is
- 1:20:42those whom the son sets free are free
- 1:20:44indeed. We're we're slaves to Christ,
- 1:20:47yet we're free in Christ.
- 1:20:49We're free indeed in Christ. And so,
- 1:20:53um and so, in other words, Christ is the
- 1:20:56only master
- 1:20:58who can grant you true liberation.
- 1:21:01If you're a slave to money,
- 1:21:03right?
- 1:21:04Money's not a good master.
- 1:21:07It It's okay to have money. I'm not
- 1:21:09pooh-poohing the the whole aspect of
- 1:21:11having money. Money is necessary, money
- 1:21:13is a tool.
- 1:21:14But, to the extent that you become a
- 1:21:15slave to money,
- 1:21:17um it's just not a good master to have.
- 1:21:20Your wife is not a good master to have
- 1:21:23to the extent you become a slave to her.
- 1:21:25Um mankind in general are not good
- 1:21:29masters to have. Uh
- 1:21:31they can they can, you know, rain down
- 1:21:35uh
- 1:21:36you know, love and confidence on you,
- 1:21:38and they can also abuse you. Uh
- 1:21:41physically, um
- 1:21:43mentally, emotionally, whatever the case
- 1:21:46may be.
- 1:21:47It's up and down because we're finite
- 1:21:49individuals who
- 1:21:51are sinners.
- 1:21:54Objects, you know, to the extent that
- 1:21:56you become a slave to an inanimate
- 1:21:57object, a video game.
- 1:22:00You know, it robs you of your time, robs
- 1:22:01you of brain cells.
- 1:22:04Christ is the only entity
- 1:22:07who is a good and faithful master.
- 1:22:11And so,
- 1:22:12all that to say that whenever we model
- 1:22:16civilization
- 1:22:17after the standards of biblical
- 1:22:21Christianity,
- 1:22:24understanding that God is a god of
- 1:22:25common grace,
- 1:22:27who allows the sun to to rise on the
- 1:22:29just as well as the unjust and the rain
- 1:22:31to fall on the righteous as well as the
- 1:22:33unrighteous.
- 1:22:35In other words, and that's what English
- 1:22:37common law is fashioned after, you know,
- 1:22:39equal justice, you know. The Supreme
- 1:22:43Court, it says above the door,
- 1:22:47equal justice under the law.
- 1:22:49And so, in other words, we don't believe
- 1:22:53or
- 1:22:54in in theory, and
- 1:22:56wait and
- 1:23:00you know,
- 1:23:02unequal scales,
- 1:23:04um,
- 1:23:05we're not going to show favoritism
- 1:23:08in a court of law to
- 1:23:11someone because they're wealthy or we're
- 1:23:13not going to we're not going to virtue
- 1:23:15signal
- 1:23:16by
- 1:23:18throwing a case in the favor of someone
- 1:23:21who's poor just because of their
- 1:23:23condition.
- 1:23:24Obviously, we've gotten to a point where
- 1:23:26we are doing that, both of those things,
- 1:23:29but on paper, we're not supposed to be
- 1:23:32that. But to the extent that we depart
- 1:23:34from those values, from those biblical
- 1:23:37virtues,
- 1:23:39in pursuit of multiculturalism or trying
- 1:23:41to tilt the scales in favor of some
- 1:23:45fulfilling some political or or
- 1:23:47ideological
- 1:23:49um
- 1:23:50endeavor or agenda, um
- 1:23:53you know, your your civilization is not
- 1:23:55long for this world. So, I know I'm I'm
- 1:23:57kind of off on that rant at this point,
- 1:23:59but my to bring it back to your question
- 1:24:01with regard to migration and
- 1:24:05um and and this kind of
- 1:24:08shifting of the scene as it were
- 1:24:10in order to appeal to the sensibilities
- 1:24:15or what one thinks are the sensibilities
- 1:24:17of these newly emerged people um
- 1:24:22instead of recognizing, "Hey, there's a
- 1:24:24reason why they are a refugee. They're
- 1:24:27seeking refuge. Um it's because we're
- 1:24:30doing something right, whereas where
- 1:24:32they came from is is doing something
- 1:24:35wrong. Let's maintain those things that
- 1:24:39made us a highly sought-after nation as
- 1:24:42opposed to and embracing
- 1:24:44multiculturalism
- 1:24:45um and and thus losing this nation. I'm
- 1:24:49hoping that makes sense.
- 1:24:51>> No, it made a made a lot of sense, and I
- 1:24:52think that's a a perfect cap off to the
- 1:24:55discussion and the perfect place to
- 1:24:57leave it because yeah, I very much see
- 1:24:59that similarly to you where
- 1:25:03there's only a few options, which is
- 1:25:05either we end up in a socialist state, a
- 1:25:09socialist civilization, we end up in a
- 1:25:12tribal pagan civilization where it's
- 1:25:15just multicultural all against all
- 1:25:18or we restore Christendom, and I think
- 1:25:22those are the options. I I don't see
- 1:25:25I don't see any other ones on the plate.
- 1:25:27I know a lot of people still believe in
- 1:25:30kind of a more classical liberalism
- 1:25:33approach
- 1:25:35of the civic institutions and
- 1:25:37participation in society is what's going
- 1:25:39to hold us together. I don't think
- 1:25:40bureaucracy can tell a people how to
- 1:25:42operate.
- 1:25:44You know, I think two people are always
- 1:25:46going to have more influence on the
- 1:25:49institutions than institutions have an
- 1:25:51influence on people.
- 1:25:52>> Right.
- 1:25:53>> And so, we're going to see that flip if
- 1:25:55we don't restore the ideals that created
- 1:25:59those institutions in the first place in
- 1:26:01the people.
- 1:26:02Um and so, if that essentially type of
- 1:26:04person doesn't find themselves back into
- 1:26:08the institutions, then I think yeah,
- 1:26:11you're going to see them see them vastly
- 1:26:13overhauled in the next 5 to 10 years.
- 1:26:16Actually, that's a great point about the
- 1:26:17camp of the saints, too, is because
- 1:26:19people talk about it as if it's this
- 1:26:22racist book against the or you know,
- 1:26:25against the third world and calling them
- 1:26:27all savages, but actually his his entire
- 1:26:29point was that the
- 1:26:33battle was lost long before a boat ever
- 1:26:35landed on the shore, which was that
- 1:26:37those people no longer
- 1:26:40uh no longer viewed their civilization
- 1:26:42as something worth upholding. And so,
- 1:26:44it's like, yeah, at that at that point,
- 1:26:47you've just
- 1:26:48Can you really blame the wind for
- 1:26:50knocking down your house if you've first
- 1:26:53gone and broken the foundations? And so,
- 1:26:56it's like, yeah, I think I think that's
- 1:26:58very much very much where we're at, but
- 1:27:00uh
- 1:27:01>> That's a great point.
- 1:27:03>> But I think I think you touched on the
- 1:27:05the return vision quite uh quite quite
- 1:27:08well there. So, yeah, thank you very
- 1:27:09much for joining me today, Chad. Is
- 1:27:11there anything you're working on that
- 1:27:13you want the uh audience to know of or
- 1:27:15where they can find you?
- 1:27:16>> Yeah, uh you can find me at
- 1:27:18chadojackson.com,
- 1:27:21as well as @chadojackson on IG,
- 1:27:25Facebook, YouTube, and X. I am working
- 1:27:29on a film called The Myth of Blackness.
- 1:27:32It is an independent film, which means
- 1:27:34that we are relying on uh
- 1:27:38the people, quite frankly, to to help us
- 1:27:41get this film to the finish line. So, if
- 1:27:43people want to contribute to what we're
- 1:27:45trying to accomplish with this film, uh
- 1:27:48you can learn more about it at
- 1:27:49chadojackson.com.
- 1:27:52>> Well, thank you very much for joining me
- 1:27:53and I always appreciate our
- 1:27:55conversations very much and look forward
- 1:27:57to doing so again in the near future.
- 1:27:58So, all right. Thank you all for
- 1:28:00watching and we'll catch you next time.
- 1:28:02If you enjoyed this discussion, please
- 1:28:04consider supporting my work. I am
- 1:28:06entirely independent and have exclusive
- 1:28:08content available for paid subscribers
- 1:28:10on YouTube, Substack, and Instagram.
- 1:28:13Thanks for watching and we'll catch you
- 1:28:14on the next one.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Is Black Culture a Manufactured Identity? | The Construct EP8 with Chad O. Jackson by Liam Out Loud, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 13,531 words across 2,262 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.