Is ADHD Real? What a 600-Page Review Found About the Diagnosis — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:03[music]
- 0:07>> Hello and welcome to another episode of
- 0:10the Dr. Leaf Show. I am Dr. Caroline
- 0:12Leaf. I'm a clinical and research
- 0:14neuroscientist and I'm thrilled to have
- 0:16you join us today to explore another
- 0:19interesting episode around ADHD. It's
- 0:22exploding around the world this
- 0:24discussion. So we felt it was really
- 0:26good to do a part two. And for those of
- 0:29you that have just tuned in, go over and
- 0:31search out for part one and listen to
- 0:33that first or it doesn't really matter
- 0:34which order, but definitely make sure
- 0:36you listen to both because we really
- 0:37dive in quite a lot of depth into the
- 0:39discussion and I think it's very
- 0:41helpful. We've had tremendous feedback
- 0:43from this this part one, which is also
- 0:45why we're doing part two. And joining me
- 0:47in the studio as normal is my beautiful,
- 0:50brilliant daughter. She really is
- 0:51brilliant. She really does so much in
- 0:53our company and does so much to help me
- 0:56shape what I do. So welcome back Dom
- 0:58from all the way from Tel Aviv.
- 1:00>> Thank you. It's good to be back and do
- 1:02part two. I know we've had so much
- 1:04interest from the last one, so many good
- 1:06questions and I know some exciting new
- 1:08research has come out on the topic. But
- 1:10before we get into that, Caroline, did
- 1:12you want to talk about the community?
- 1:15>> Absolutely. So we in response to a lot
- 1:18of people over the years asking us for a
- 1:21way to connect on a more intimate basis,
- 1:23we have started the community. So I'm
- 1:25very excited that we launched this just
- 1:27a few days about a week ago. So and that
- 1:30is an insider community that you can
- 1:32join where for a minimal amount every
- 1:35month Dominic will put put the
- 1:36information in the show notes. But
- 1:38essentially every Friday you connect
- 1:40with me. We do a live Zoom session and
- 1:44that's where you can ask me questions,
- 1:46where we can connect, where we can
- 1:47discuss things. The big thing though
- 1:49that this community focuses around is my
- 1:51neurocycle, which is that formula for
- 1:53how you manage your mind. We apply this
- 1:55in different scenarios and I have
- 1:57created a concept called the neurocycle
- 1:59prescription, which where I show you how
- 2:01to use the Neurocycle for specific
- 2:03things. So every time we do a podcast, I
- 2:06create a Neurocycle Prescription which
- 2:08is put into the app. So if you if you
- 2:10have the app, you'll find the
- 2:11prescription there, but if you want to
- 2:13go deeper, the community is where you go
- 2:15deeper because I will be discussing that
- 2:17and working through elements of that
- 2:19prescription during in the Friday
- 2:21sessions. It's this on done on the
- 2:23Circle community. Dominic will tell you
- 2:25more about that. I also give we download
- 2:27a PDF of the prescription. You get a
- 2:30worksheet, you get a lot of other little
- 2:32tips and things from me during the week,
- 2:34and you get a chance to walk this
- 2:35healing journey with other people. So
- 2:37sharing how you are managing and moving
- 2:39forward and your healing journey.
- 2:41Dominic, do you want to add any more to
- 2:42that?
- 2:43>> I think you've covered all the main
- 2:45highlights. Everything will be linked in
- 2:46the show notes and all other resources,
- 2:50the one-on-one, people can work
- 2:51one-on-one with you, the Neurocycle app,
- 2:54the books, blogs, everything, working
- 2:57with our strategists if you're
- 2:58interested in our strategist training,
- 3:00but we have a great discount going on
- 3:02now if you sign up. And if you're a
- 3:03coach or therapist or
- 3:06educator, a parent, a small business
- 3:09owner, whoever, it's for everyone. If
- 3:10you wanted to just dive deep into the
- 3:13methodology, if you love what Dr. Leaf
- 3:15talks about and you really want to dive
- 3:17deeper into it and learn how to apply it
- 3:18in your clinic or your practice or your
- 3:21church or whatever, your school, we have
- 3:24the certification. As I mentioned, it's
- 3:26January 8th through 9th, and we'll put
- 3:28all the details in the show notes as
- 3:30well as everything can be find found at
- 3:32drleaf.com.
- 3:34>> Yeah, I'm very excited about the
- 3:35strategist training as well. So that's
- 3:37separate from the community. The
- 3:38community is not you becoming certified.
- 3:40That's you connecting with me and a
- 3:42whole group of people and weekly and
- 3:44it's a whole walking that healing
- 3:45journey together, whereas the strategist
- 3:47is if you want to, as Dominic said,
- 3:49actually become certified in the
- 3:51Neurocycle methodology, you can learn
- 3:53more about that in the links that Dom
- 3:55provides. Okay, so let's dive in. Dom,
- 3:58do you want to give a little background
- 4:00or dive into the questions?
- 4:03>> Yeah, so I think we gave a really great
- 4:05background in part one. So if you
- 4:07haven't listened to that yet, highly
- 4:08recommend pausing on this and going to
- 4:11listen to that. I give a quite a bit of
- 4:13a extensive background, some stats, all
- 4:15that. So really I wanted to start this
- 4:17one with as it's part two, but a lot has
- 4:20happened since we released part one,
- 4:22which is really last week. The UK
- 4:26government just published a huge review
- 4:27on ADHD and autism.
- 4:30Can you talk a bit about this review as
- 4:33well as what jumped out to you?
- 4:35>> Absolutely. So it was just so
- 4:37interesting because it's literally the
- 4:38day that we recorded that other podcast.
- 4:40This it's called the Fenagi report
- 4:42popped out and it's exploding all over
- 4:44the place. You may have even read it
- 4:45yourself, but essentially it's a 600
- 4:47page report, so it's very long. And
- 4:50basically what stood out to me was that
- 4:53we're going to talk a lot about this
- 4:54report in a simple way, but the biggest
- 4:56thing in these 600 pages that really
- 4:58jumped out and we briefly referenced
- 4:59this also this concept in the previous
- 5:02podcast is that there's no biological
- 5:04test. There's no blood test. There's no
- 5:07scan and there's no what we call a
- 5:09biological marker for ADHD. This is a
- 5:13big huge part of what that report
- 5:15stressed. And that's interesting
- 5:18because at the same time as them saying
- 5:20that they really emphasize that in the
- 5:22report, but then there's another part of
- 5:23the report if you read through it and
- 5:25it's a long report, is it basically says
- 5:28that ADHD is a strongly genetic
- 5:30condition of the developing brain. So
- 5:32that's two contradicting claims in one
- 5:35document and that was very interesting.
- 5:37>> Can you repeat those two contradicting
- 5:39claims because I think it's a big
- 5:41fact and I want to make sure people got
- 5:42that.
- 5:43>> Okay. So there's a general claim that
- 5:46most people have heard is that ADHD is
- 5:48strongly genetic and it's a condition of
- 5:50the developing brain.
- 5:52Okay, so genetic and it's a brain thing.
- 5:54That's what people mostly know about and
- 5:57when it comes to ADHD. But this 600 page
- 6:00report actually say in the report that
- 6:03it 's not.
- 6:04And they say that it's not because there
- 6:06isn't a biological test, a blood test,
- 6:08or a scan, or a marker that has been
- 6:10identified to actually make that
- 6:12statement that it's a brain that it's
- 6:13something wrong with your brain and that
- 6:15it is a genetic fault.
- 6:17So it's two contradictory statements. So
- 6:19they explain it's not and then they go
- 6:20on to
- 6:21they have this little statement put
- 6:23halfway through. And now a lot of
- 6:25scientists in this field for and against
- 6:28the diagnosis labeling model have picked
- 6:30that up and have commented on these
- 6:32contradicting claims. So in other words,
- 6:34the label being handed to people
- 6:36describes a struggle
- 6:38and then it gets treated as the cause of
- 6:40the struggle.
- 6:42And that's what I want to talk about
- 6:43today because that's what we would call
- 6:45circular reasoning.
- 6:47Does that make sense?
- 6:49>> Yes. So before we go further, people are
- 6:52going to ask us, are you saying
- 6:54ADHD, ADD are not real?
- 6:57>> Absolutely not. They're so real.
- 7:00The struggle is real. If you can't get
- 7:02through that lesson, if you can't focus,
- 7:03you can't get through the day, your mind
- 7:04feels scattered, you can't pay
- 7:06attention, you can't focus, that is a
- 7:07very real set of signals that we can
- 7:11describe about ourselves and that is
- 7:13existing in that people are battling
- 7:15with across the globe. So definitely I'm
- 7:16not saying that the struggle isn't real.
- 7:18Absolutely. But what I am questioning
- 7:21alongside many researchers, PhDs,
- 7:24psychiatrists, psychologists is the
- 7:27explanation. So the idea that the label
- 7:29points to an identified fault in the
- 7:31brain.
- 7:32Okay, that's explanation that if you
- 7:34have this battle, there's something
- 7:37wrong with your brain. But that report
- 7:39along with many other studies say that
- 7:40we don't actually have definitive proof
- 7:42that it is. We don't actually have a
- 7:44test or anything to say that it's
- 7:45something wrong with the brain.
- 7:47So therefore it's contradictory. We
- 7:49can't actually say that. There isn't
- 7:50science to prove that. So the struggle
- 7:52is real, but you've got to stop saying
- 7:55that it's the fault of the brain.
- 7:56Whatever we do with our life or whatever
- 7:58experiences that we have will
- 8:01basically our mind experiences and then
- 8:03it affects the brain. So the brain can
- 8:05be affected by how we direct our
- 8:07attention and that kind of thing. Now,
- 8:09having said that, I want to put a a
- 8:10proviso in here because we also
- 8:12discussed this in part one, is that
- 8:13there definitely are cases where these
- 8:16symptoms that are that fall into the
- 8:17category of ADD and ADHD exist, but it's
- 8:21the the referral rate is not as high as
- 8:24what we are getting. In other words,
- 8:26where people have actually experienced
- 8:28like maybe brain tumors or birth issues
- 8:30or something like that, something's
- 8:31happened
- 8:33physically in the brain during the
- 8:34course of their life, traumatic brain
- 8:36injuries, that sort of thing that can
- 8:38definitely produce these symptoms. So,
- 8:40yes, you can have something happen to
- 8:43you that affects how your brain
- 8:44functions and it can produce these types
- 8:46of symptoms, but that's in a much
- 8:48smaller percentage than what we've been
- 8:49told because all of it's being lumped
- 8:51together as one big percentage that
- 8:54anyone who's battling with these kind of
- 8:56struggles has something wrong with their
- 8:58brain. And that's the problem that
- 9:00myself and a lot of people in the field
- 9:03are having.
- 9:04>> Okay, interesting. That raises a lot of
- 9:06questions about the nature versus
- 9:08nurture side of ADD and ADHD. So, would
- 9:13you place ADD and ADHD in the nature
- 9:16versus nurture conversation?
- 9:19>> ADD, ADHD
- 9:21is a great word to use to describe a set
- 9:24of symptoms that people are battling
- 9:25with that are affecting their ability to
- 9:27function of all ages.
- 9:29We're seeing an explosion in women,
- 9:31which we discussed in the last episode,
- 9:33and the reason why is related to another
- 9:35bigger issue, and that's that women
- 9:37haven't been used enough in research.
- 9:39So, this is popping up all over the
- 9:40place as well when it comes to
- 9:41cardiovascular issues, when it comes to
- 9:43our hormonal cycles. That has not been
- 9:46taken enough into consideration in many
- 9:48areas. And that's being changed, thank
- 9:50goodness, not enough, not quick enough,
- 9:52but it is being changed. And so, this
- 9:54generally ADHD was seen as a male thing
- 9:56often starting with young boys, which is
- 9:59not fair because males and females
- 10:01battle with this.
- 10:03So, that's one part of the question. The
- 10:05other part is that if you battle to
- 10:07struggle that there's something wrong
- 10:08with your brain, there's a lot of
- 10:09implications about
- 10:11It's nice to have a label, but it
- 10:12doesn't necessarily fix the problem. So
- 10:14there is, as I said, in terms of nature,
- 10:16which is your genetics and your biology
- 10:18and so on, there can be things that go
- 10:21wrong, absolutely. There can be things
- 10:23like fetal alcohol syndrome, there can
- 10:25be things like birth trauma, there can
- 10:26be things like illnesses that we
- 10:28experience, tumors, all that kind of
- 10:30thing that can produce very similar
- 10:32symptoms. So there is that for sure.
- 10:35And so we can't rule that out. So that's
- 10:37the nature component, but it's not as
- 10:39big as what we are
- 10:42actually seeing in the media.
- 10:44Nurture is how we are brought up, how we
- 10:47experience life, what we're exposed to
- 10:49all the way through from birth through
- 10:51to whatever age you are at now. So the
- 10:52world that you live in. And that's
- 10:54nurture. And nurture is processed by our
- 10:57mind, all our experiences are processed
- 10:59by our mind, and we live in a world that
- 11:01is literally almost like an ADHD
- 11:03society. And so we getting bombarded
- 11:06with so much. So I think this is
- 11:07possibly it's a combination, but that
- 11:10nurture factor is the bigger factor that
- 11:12we need to consider. So in addressing
- 11:14this very real struggle, we can't just
- 11:17keep going back to the biology because
- 11:20there's very little evidence that that's
- 11:21neurodevelopmental, only in certain
- 11:23cases. And we're going to look at a lot
- 11:24of that research today. I'm going to
- 11:25actually give you research studies that
- 11:27to back up what I'm saying. What we're
- 11:28not addressing sufficiently is people's
- 11:31stories, the context, what has happened,
- 11:33what life are they living, all that kind
- 11:35of thing. And that's the nurture aspect.
- 11:37That needs a lot more attention because
- 11:39it also needs it means how you address
- 11:41the situation is very different. And
- 11:43that actually goes to that whole concept
- 11:45of the demand because related to the
- 11:47Finnegan report, the UK also
- 11:50atomized some of the the level of
- 11:52demand. Should we talk a little bit
- 11:53about that, Dominique?
- 11:55>> Yeah, I would like to get on that. But
- 11:57before you dive into that, because I do
- 11:58have that written down as one of the the
- 12:00questions I wanted to understand a lot
- 12:01more, dive more into the study, how
- 12:03does, in your opinion, AI play a part in
- 12:08the and the conversation around ADHD and
- 12:12ADHD?
- 12:13>> Well, people
- 12:14>> can put their symptoms in and ask AI and
- 12:16they'll get a whole description back of
- 12:18what's wrong with them. And we must
- 12:19remember AI doesn't think. And we're
- 12:21going to be doing a whole podcast on AI,
- 12:22so watch out for that one. AI doesn't
- 12:24think. AI simply mirrors what is out
- 12:27there in the world, in the tech world,
- 12:29in the internet world. And it basically
- 12:32will pull from that data and feedback.
- 12:34It's also very biased towards the
- 12:35question and the way that we prompt AI.
- 12:38So that's the one aspect is that you can
- 12:40literally get whatever onto you want.
- 12:42You can by the way that you ask AI, you
- 12:44can find the data and that data is going
- 12:45to reflect a general trend. It's not
- 12:47necessarily going to be you
- 12:49specifically. So that isn't in itself a
- 12:52danger because and we're going to give
- 12:54and I'm going to give you some
- 12:55techniques towards the end of this
- 12:56podcast on what you can do just to help
- 12:59you distinguish is this a a struggle
- 13:01that's something maybe biological, maybe
- 13:05a nurture thing? And what should you do?
- 13:07So I'm going to give you a simple thing
- 13:08that can just get you going in making
- 13:10that decision.
- 13:11So but that's where everything is AI and
- 13:13technology. We've got access to so much
- 13:15information. And one of the things that
- 13:17the brain
- 13:18because of the nature of the physical
- 13:20structure of the brain, one of the
- 13:21things that the brain needs is
- 13:23organization. And organization because
- 13:26it's been coded. So if you throw too
- 13:28much with your conscious mind, whatever
- 13:29you pay attention to with your conscious
- 13:31mind is going to be coded into the
- 13:33brain. And if we are paying a lot of
- 13:35attention in a disorganized way, that
- 13:38gets coded into the brain in a
- 13:39disorganized way. So we can wire in
- 13:42networks in our brain that can make us
- 13:45feel all of those symptoms of ADHD, ADD,
- 13:48ADHD. And so that's part of that nurture
- 13:50aspect that then makes a change in
- 13:52biology and that can produce the
- 13:53symptoms and it's real. So we do have to
- 13:55address that, but we need to find the
- 13:57source.
- 13:58>> So
- 13:59then what would you say to now I've seen
- 14:01this quite a lot on Instagram
- 14:03and different social media platforms,
- 14:05people giving hacks for using AI to help
- 14:09with ADD or ADHD?
- 14:12I'm trying to recall one when I was
- 14:14doing some for this podcast like how to
- 14:17have Claude create a schedule for you
- 14:21that is optimized for if you have ADD
- 14:24and ADHD to get tasks done. I understand
- 14:28so there's that component. Have you
- 14:30heard anything about this, seen anything
- 14:32and what do you think about that first
- 14:33of all? And second of all,
- 14:35I can see how AI may contribute to
- 14:39feeling like scattered or things like
- 14:41that because there's also something
- 14:43going around now people making jokes and
- 14:45about oh while I'm waiting for my Claude
- 14:48prompt to load I'm scrolling TikTok
- 14:52and now instead of
- 14:56before when we were consuming content
- 14:59like TikTok and Instagram for example
- 15:02Instagram Reels we were consuming these
- 15:04content and it was oftentimes would just
- 15:06come to us. You could do some searching
- 15:07and stuff but there was still like a
- 15:09level of like having to
- 15:13gather a lot of information and then
- 15:14maybe come up with something now with AI
- 15:16some people might also say
- 15:19we're shortening even our ability to
- 15:21write sentences and do research and
- 15:24things like that. So I guess what I'm
- 15:26saying is there's pros and cons I've
- 15:27seen on about the debate with AI
- 15:30especially as it relates to ADD. But
- 15:31going back to my original question, have
- 15:33you seen people using this as to help
- 15:36them with ADD or ADHD and what do you
- 15:39think of that?
- 15:40>> Okay, so it's called cognitive
- 15:41offloading, this thing of not letting
- 15:45trying to get AI to think for you and
- 15:47it's definitely these studies are
- 15:48already showing how it's changing our
- 15:50biological structure. So whatever you do
- 15:52with your mind
- 15:53is going to change your brain and not
- 15:55necessarily in the best direction. It's
- 15:56called the plastic paradox. So whatever
- 15:58you're doing from the moment you open
- 15:59your eyes in the morning till when you
- 16:02go to sleep whatever you do is changing
- 16:04the structure of your brain and if you
- 16:05are not managing what that is you could
- 16:08be wiring in networks that add to and
- 16:10create the symptoms that we see that we
- 16:13classify as ADD and ADHD by not
- 16:16processing things properly. We are
- 16:17designed for deep intellectual thought.
- 16:19Humans are brilliant. You are brilliant.
- 16:22You need the thinking, deep thinking
- 16:25exercise to function well as a human.
- 16:28It's a process of learning and learning
- 16:30how to connect with the deep,
- 16:31insightful, wise, instinctive part of
- 16:33you. And it's a process that develops
- 16:35over the years from a baby all the way
- 16:38through your adult working life. We're
- 16:40supposed to think through things deeply.
- 16:43But if we are so bombarded with
- 16:44information, and I'm not anti the
- 16:46information, thank goodness we have it,
- 16:48but if we don't know how to deal with
- 16:50it, and now with the whole AI component
- 16:52added on top of that, we are just
- 16:54consuming bits and pieces without
- 16:56thinking deeply. And that in itself
- 16:58creates tremendous chaos in our
- 17:00nurturing of ourselves and in the
- 17:02nurturing of our brain and our body
- 17:04because our brain and our body simply do
- 17:06what the mind tells it to do. So
- 17:08therefore, deep thinking, the deep
- 17:11thinking that goes into, oh, I've got
- 17:12this great idea, let me think this idea
- 17:15through,
- 17:16and then maybe create a Claude prompt
- 17:19that helps me to organize my thinking,
- 17:21but the Claude prompt's quite long
- 17:22because I actually put my whole thing in
- 17:23a Word doc first or whatever the case
- 17:25may be. I've actually done that deep
- 17:27thinking first. Or I read a great
- 17:29article that just is so interesting and
- 17:32you can see it's been written by AI, but
- 17:34it's talking about the dangers of AI or
- 17:35something like that. But instead of just
- 17:37throwing that in Claude and saying, what
- 17:38does this mean, it's to actually work it
- 17:41out, read it through, use a technique
- 17:42that I call the metacog, which is a way
- 17:44of organizing information. Point being
- 17:46is that think it through first and then
- 17:49maybe get Claude to tidy it up for you.
- 17:51To the I answered your second part of
- 17:52your question first. First part, have I
- 17:54seen this? Absolutely. I've had private
- 17:55clients that have come to me and said,
- 17:56oh, I put a Claude a ChatGPT or Claude
- 17:59prompt in and I got this little routine
- 18:01to help me with this. What do you think?
- 18:03And I said, what do you think? Is this
- 18:05you? Does this work for you? Is this
- 18:08something coming from you? It looks
- 18:09really nice. It's all pretty and
- 18:11organized and beautiful, but walk me
- 18:13through it. Tell me. And as soon as I
- 18:15get them to actually think it through,
- 18:17they'll say, this doesn't work, that
- 18:19doesn't work, that's not realistic,
- 18:21that's really who I am. So it's to be
- 18:22curious. In other words,,
- 18:24yes, throw it into Claude, but then
- 18:26go out of Claude mode, out of tech mode,
- 18:29and go back into your brilliant mind and
- 18:31ask yourself deep intellectual
- 18:33questions, think deeply about that
- 18:35content. Then you're going to find
- 18:36something that's more realistic for you.
- 18:38>> Yes, I think there is definitely
- 18:41obviously pros and cons to everything. I
- 18:43think
- 18:45it can be a great tool to help people
- 18:47organize their day.
- 18:50As long as there is always the critical
- 18:51reasoning aspect, but everybody will say
- 18:53this about AI now. Or I'm hoping this is
- 18:56what people are saying. AI can
- 18:58can give you information, it can be
- 18:59super helpful, but there's always the
- 19:01need for critical reasoning and human
- 19:04review with AI.
- 19:06And I know we're going to get into we
- 19:08have already released one podcast about
- 19:09AI and we're going to do another one,
- 19:11the fear of being replaced by AI and how
- 19:13to manage that. Just to let everyone
- 19:15know who's listening that we're going to
- 19:17dive more into
- 19:18the mental health side of AI.
- 19:21But before we continue with the
- 19:23questions regarding the study, because I
- 19:24want to dive more into this because it's
- 19:25a fascinating study, we need to take a
- 19:27quick break.
- 19:28>> Do you actually know what's in the
- 19:30creatine you take every day? Mometus is
- 19:34the most trusted and tested supplement
- 19:36company on the market, built on the
- 19:38Mometus standard, the highest standard
- 19:41in supplements. Every production lot is
- 19:44verified by an independent third party,
- 19:46and Mometus publishes the results.
- 19:49If a run fails, it never reaches a
- 19:51customer.
- 19:53They also hold the highest certification
- 19:55in the industry,
- 19:56NSF certified for sport.
- 19:59Mometus makes many single ingredient
- 20:01supplements, so you take exactly what
- 20:03you need and nothing you don't.
- 20:06In our house, that's signature spec
- 20:08creatine. Mac takes it for his workout
- 20:11recovery. It's made in a pharmaceutical
- 20:13facility with 10 times fewer impurities,
- 20:16and the ultra fine powder mixes with no
- 20:18grit or clumping.
- 20:20If you want to try Mometus signature
- 20:21spec creatine, head to lovemomentous.com
- 20:25and use the code Dr. Leaf for up to 35%
- 20:29of your entire first order. That's
- 20:31lovemomentous.com
- 20:33promo code Dr. Leaf for up to 35% off.
- 20:36lovemomentous.com
- 20:38promo code Dr. Leaf. If you're in
- 20:41back-to-back meetings all day, you know
- 20:43the struggle, nodding along, trying to
- 20:45stay present while part of you is
- 20:47scrambling to remember what was just
- 20:49said or who's following up on what. And
- 20:51that's why I started using granola.
- 20:54It's an AI powered notepad built for the
- 20:57way people actually meet. You take rough
- 20:59notes like normal and in the background
- 21:01granola turns everything into clean
- 21:03structured notes the second the meeting
- 21:06ends. It runs through your device's
- 21:08audio so it works right inside the tools
- 21:10you already use. No setup, no awkward
- 21:13bots on the call. I've tried other tools
- 21:15for this and granola is the one that
- 21:17actually stuck. My meetings run smoother
- 21:20and I walk away knowing exactly what was
- 21:22decided and what's next. If meetings are
- 21:25eating up your day, granola is a no
- 21:28brainer. You can try today totally free.
- 21:31Just head to granola.ai/drleaf.
- 21:34That's granola.ai/drleaf
- 21:37to get your time back. Try it for free
- 21:39at granola.ai/drleaf.
- 21:43>> And we're back. So I want to get back to
- 21:46the study now and I have a few questions
- 21:49on this. So first of all, can you tell
- 21:50us who led it, all the scientific stuff
- 21:53like background and then kind you
- 21:55mentioned some of the highlight key
- 21:57findings that they found. So if we can
- 21:58go over some of those and dive deep into
- 22:00those and then the conclusions or the
- 22:02recommendations they give.
- 22:05>> Absolutely. So just if we can step back
- 22:07to a little interesting thing in England
- 22:09for example, at the end of 2025
- 22:12open referrals for ADHD assessments
- 22:14passed 560,000.
- 22:16That's more than 17 times the number in
- 22:182019. 17 times more in six years and
- 22:23that is quite representative of a global
- 22:27trend. So, basically the Finnegan
- 22:30review, it was Professor Peter Finnegan,
- 22:32who's a psychologist. That's why it's
- 22:33called the Finnegan review. And the
- 22:35review gets to be fair, it gets a lot
- 22:37right and like
- 22:39that where it says that there are no
- 22:40biological tests, even though they had a
- 22:42contradictory statement, at least they
- 22:43identify that. There's a lot of stuff I
- 22:45really like about this report and a lot
- 22:46of contradictory statements that are
- 22:48quite fascinating.
- 22:50So, just as a little background, they're
- 22:52really looking are people actually
- 22:54developing are there more people
- 22:56actually developing ADHD? Now, if you
- 22:58ask that question, developing ADHD, that
- 23:01means it's something that's in progress,
- 23:02which means that society's changed and
- 23:05there's a consequence of change. So,
- 23:06that's a huge sort of social phenomenon
- 23:08that we also have to consider and
- 23:09obviously we can't cover every aspect,
- 23:11but there is a little bit about that
- 23:12concept, a little bit in the report.
- 23:15The review actually says a no to that.
- 23:18They said that their best estimate is
- 23:19that the actual rate of ADHD in children
- 23:21has stayed broadly stable or only risen
- 23:23a little over decades. What has exploded
- 23:26is how many people get the label
- 23:27recorded.
- 23:29Among 12 to 17 year olds, so 12 to 17
- 23:32year olds recorded diagnosis where
- 23:33people are actually recording, it's been
- 23:35documented, went up more than 15-fold
- 23:38since 2000. So, more people are
- 23:40recording it. So, the Finnegan report
- 23:42doesn't think that there's been an
- 23:43increase, but that there's more
- 23:44awareness and there's more actual
- 23:45documentation of it. So, it may not have
- 23:47been as documented before.
- 23:50And then the review says that traits
- 23:51like
- 23:52this was very good point that they
- 23:53bring. Inattention can show up in
- 23:56various degrees across the whole
- 23:58population
- 24:00really depending on what's going on in
- 24:03in a person's life. So, most people at
- 24:04certain times are inattentive because of
- 24:07something going on in our life. We're
- 24:08just retired or we got distracted by
- 24:10something or something whatever. So, the
- 24:12diagnosis comes down to clinical judging
- 24:14because there isn't any test. There's a
- 24:15lot of clinical judgment. And clinical
- 24:18judgment's based on what the client or
- 24:20patient comes to the professional with.
- 24:23And if they are coming with TikTok in
- 24:25the back of their mind, self-diagnosis,
- 24:28the trends, the articles they've read,
- 24:31and they've identified and thought
- 24:33searches or whatever AI tool they're
- 24:35using.
- 24:36They're coming in with a pre-packaged
- 24:38expectation.
- 24:40And that expectation is verbalized. And
- 24:43this is what the report also briefly
- 24:45mentioned. So clinical judging
- 24:48is almost a little bit biased based on
- 24:50what the client is bringing to the
- 24:52table. So what you've got to do is just
- 24:54as an aside note, someone who's a
- 24:55clinician, a professional who's dealing
- 24:57with this, they are well trained, but
- 25:00it's very important that one is able to
- 25:02and I think people are doing this, I
- 25:03hope to a certain extent,
- 25:05what is the person telling me that they
- 25:07have listened to on TikTok? So we should
- 25:08be asking,
- 25:10where did you get all of this
- 25:11information? It's very insightful. And
- 25:12then they said, well, TikTok Claude.
- 25:14Well, that's great, but now let's look
- 25:16at you. Tell me your story. So if you
- 25:18can distinguish
- 25:20the information that they've taken in
- 25:22and then get the person to talk about
- 25:23their story, then the clinician's going
- 25:25to get a much more accurate judgment. So
- 25:27Dr. Peter and his team looked at all the
- 25:30rising demand for people wanting
- 25:32assessments. Why? What was this going
- 25:34on? Assessments for ADD and ADHD and
- 25:36autism, which is sometimes referred to
- 25:37as neurodiversity, and then to also help
- 25:40people get the right support. So they
- 25:41wanted to see what was going on. Why?
- 25:43What was the demand? So it was a report,
- 25:45not an actual study.
- 25:47To be fair, the review, as I mentioned
- 25:49before, gets a lot right. For example,
- 25:51it says the services provided lean too
- 25:53heavily on a diagnosis as the only route
- 25:56to help.
- 25:57And people are waiting for months,
- 25:59sometimes years, to get an appointment.
- 26:01And this is why this report was
- 26:03commissioned. There's such a demand and
- 26:04people aren't getting the treatment and
- 26:06what can we do and why? And what they
- 26:07also said is that support should follow
- 26:09a person's need with or without a label.
- 26:11When they get an assessment, it's very
- 26:13much around a label and a diagnosis. And
- 26:16then the support that's needed for them
- 26:18to actually then, now what do I do? Is
- 26:20not provided. That's missing.
- 26:23So I've been reading a lot of what the
- 26:24critics have been saying and it's quite
- 26:26interesting. For example, Joanna
- 26:28Moncrieff, I've mentioned her before.
- 26:30She's a professor of psychiatry at
- 26:31University College London.
- 26:33And she still works for the NHS, so
- 26:35she's very familiar with this scenario.
- 26:37She wrote a response that every person
- 26:39should hear. It's great. I'm actually
- 26:40going to just read it verbatim because
- 26:42it's just short. She uses a cough as an
- 26:44example. So an easy way to understand
- 26:46the issue. So you go to the doctor with
- 26:48a cough.
- 26:50If they find lung cancer, the cancer
- 26:51explains the cough.
- 26:53It's a cause. So you're coughing, it's
- 26:55lung cancer is the cause of the cough.
- 26:56That
- 26:57we can all understand that logic. But if
- 26:59the doctor says you have coughing
- 27:01disorder,
- 27:02that doesn't tell you anything. You'd
- 27:04laugh because that's just a cough with a
- 27:05new name. So her point is that ADHD
- 27:08works the same way. We give a cluster of
- 27:11difficulties,
- 27:12can't pay attention, unfocus, etc. a
- 27:15name.
- 27:17If you have difficulties, we say you
- 27:19have that name.
- 27:21So you have this thing. And then we use
- 27:23the name to explain the difficulties. So
- 27:25that's circular reasoning. So basically
- 27:27this is an example.
- 27:29Why can't she finish her homework?
- 27:31Because she has ADHD. How do you know
- 27:33she has ADHD? Because she can't finish
- 27:35her homework.
- 27:36That's what that's basically saying. You
- 27:37can have a cardiovascular issue, but you
- 27:40can't have ADHD because it doesn't have
- 27:42this biological genetic component that
- 27:44you can test for. That's what he's
- 27:45basically trying to say in terms of this
- 27:48report.
- 27:49So this having thing is what they saying
- 27:51is the problem because then it goes to,
- 27:53okay, you have those symptoms, you have
- 27:55ADHD. Why do you have ADHD? Because you
- 27:57have those symptoms. Whereas versus if
- 27:59you have a cough and it's related to
- 28:00lung cancer or if you have cardio cardio
- 28:03cardiomyopathy cardi cardiomyopathy,
- 28:06you've got a disease of your heart.
- 28:07There's a cause. This is what they
- 28:08saying is hugely lacking, but it's been
- 28:10clumped in the same way. The diagnosis
- 28:13is not
- 28:14doing what it says it does, so it's
- 28:16misleading.
- 28:18It's misleading because people then
- 28:19think there's something wrong with my
- 28:20brain and that in itself has a whole lot
- 28:21of implications. That's the one thing.
- 28:23The second thing is that so what do you
- 28:25do about it?
- 28:26The thing that they've been told to do
- 28:27about is you need a medication.
- 28:29And I know we're going to talk about
- 28:30that and we have briefly. And that's not
- 28:32the only thing you can do. one of the
- 28:34things that you can do. And so that's my
- 28:36concern and people like Gotsche,
- 28:38Moncrieff, and Timimi, a lot of these
- 28:40other scientists in this field,
- 28:43is that what do you do?
- 28:45>> Do you find that it's putting a strain
- 28:47on
- 28:48perhaps the healthcare systems and
- 28:50insurance as well? Is that something
- 28:52that's also reported one and then might
- 28:54say that the medication's helping them?
- 28:56And I know we talked about this too in
- 28:57another podcast in part one.
- 29:00So if the medication's helping them,
- 29:03is that really a problem?
- 29:06Yeah.
- 29:07>> I'd like to address that. The the big
- 29:08thing is that a medication given in the
- 29:11way it attached to a diagnosis creates
- 29:13an expectation that's unrealistic. And
- 29:16so yes, it does help some people, but if
- 29:18you look at the research on the
- 29:19medication, it helps whether you've been
- 29:22labeled or not that kind of stimulant
- 29:24medication
- 29:25kind of operates a bit like coffee. It's
- 29:27psychoactive. So if you dozy and you
- 29:30have your cup of coffee and you feel
- 29:31focused, does it mean you have a lack of
- 29:34caffeine in your brain or you have a
- 29:35caffeine disorder in your brain? That's
- 29:36the reasoning that's being used here. So
- 29:39if the coffee helps you have it, if the
- 29:40medication helps you have it, but know
- 29:42the side effects and I've actually got
- 29:44some information on that on studies that
- 29:46have shown the short and long-term side
- 29:49effects of the medication. So I'm not
- 29:50saying go off it at all. I'm saying
- 29:52right over here, if it works for you,
- 29:54make sure that you understand exactly
- 29:56why you're taking it and that you're
- 29:58doing other things as well and that you
- 30:00also understand the side effects and
- 30:03that you've asked your physician and if
- 30:04you do decide to go off, never stop
- 30:06anything
- 30:07quickly, any kind of medication because
- 30:10your brain has adapted, your body has
- 30:12adapted. Whatever you put into your
- 30:13brain, food, medication, thoughts
- 30:15changes the structure of your brain. So
- 30:17if you suddenly just stop something,
- 30:19your brain is now got to adjust and it
- 30:21takes time and that in itself creates a
- 30:22bunch of symptoms that can be quite
- 30:24scary. So I cannot stress enough.
- 30:26Don't just stop. If you decide that's a
- 30:28big decision, get the information, work
- 30:30within a professional who understands
- 30:32that and then do it properly if that's
- 30:34your choice. If you're on it and you
- 30:35decide to stay on it, there's no
- 30:36judgment at all. If it's helping you,
- 30:37fantastic. But make sure you understand
- 30:40the implications of taking a medication
- 30:42long-term. That's what I'm saying here
- 30:44in terms of the meds. So one of the
- 30:46things that I think is something that we
- 30:47can do so that with that circular
- 30:50reasoning
- 30:51is there's like a little exercise you
- 30:52can do just to double check that you ask
- 30:54the right questions when you go to the
- 30:55medical professional
- 30:57or the whatever professional you go to.
- 30:59Okay, so it takes about 10 seconds. It's
- 31:01so simple. Maybe you can just do it
- 31:03along with me whoever is listening. So
- 31:05finish this sentence, okay?
- 31:07Finish the sentence you say most often.
- 31:09I can't
- 31:11do fill in the blanks
- 31:13because I have ADHD. So I can't pay
- 31:16attention. I can't focus. I lose my
- 31:18attention. I do whatever. Fill fill that
- 31:21in because I have ADHD and take the
- 31:22label out and just put in a plain
- 31:24description.
- 31:26I can't finish reports because I have
- 31:27trouble finishing reports because I find
- 31:29them difficult and because I constantly
- 31:30get distracted in the office because
- 31:31people keep pinging me on my phone and
- 31:33sending me emails and wanting See what
- 31:35I'm saying the different there? There's
- 31:36a description.
- 31:37So okay, so then that would tell me that
- 31:40you're saying you have ADHD. I'm giving
- 31:41a very simple example
- 31:43that you're battling with reports
- 31:44because of ADHD. When you put the
- 31:46description and you're telling me that
- 31:47reports first of all you find quite
- 31:49difficult to do, so maybe you need some
- 31:51help in how to do a report for your
- 31:54particular line of work. So you can ask
- 31:56someone who is good at it or whatever
- 31:58Claude to help you.
- 32:00So in other words, you need a skill
- 32:01developed. Then the other side of things
- 32:03is if you're sitting in an office and we
- 32:05all know that experience because of
- 32:06texts and emails you get can you do this
- 32:08now? Can you do this now? Knock on the
- 32:10door if you're working in a physical
- 32:11office. Is it that's distracting you? Is
- 32:13it just because of the way life works
- 32:15now and you actually need
- 32:17when you're concentrating deeply because
- 32:19I know when I'm concentrating deeply and
- 32:20working on something and if I constantly
- 32:22get
- 32:23interrupted, I lose my train of thought.
- 32:25It doesn't mean I have ADHD. It means
- 32:27that I know when I do a certain type of
- 32:29work, I need to create this kind of
- 32:32environment. So it's to ask yourself
- 32:34that I can't do this
- 32:36simply because I have ADHD, which is a
- 32:38sweeping statement that doesn't really
- 32:39take you anywhere, versus I can't finish
- 32:42the report because I have trouble
- 32:43finishing reports because of so they're
- 32:45getting the full description.
- 32:47>> So we're going to take a quick break and
- 32:49when we come back, we'll continue this
- 32:50discussion.
- 32:51>> Today's episode is sponsored by Jevity.
- 32:55In 40 years of this work, I have watched
- 32:58so many people put their health off
- 33:00until someday when life slows down,
- 33:03but it really does. We all know that.
- 33:05Nobody ever handed them a plan and a
- 33:08team to help them act on that.
- 33:11I use Jevity now. A phlebotomist came to
- 33:13me. The draw took a few minutes and then
- 33:17my Jevity care team walked me through my
- 33:19results on video.
- 33:20My vitamin D was low. My team adjusted
- 33:22my supplements and I'll see on my next
- 33:25draw whether it moved.
- 33:27Anyone can hand you a lab report.
- 33:29Jevity is the team that tells you what
- 33:32to do next with quarterly check-ins and
- 33:36new blood work twice a year, so your
- 33:38plan adjusts as you change. And 88% of
- 33:42Jevity members see health mark
- 33:44improvements between their first and
- 33:47second round of blood work.
- 33:48More life starts here. Get started at
- 33:52gojevity.com/leaf
- 33:54and use the code leaf for 20% off your
- 33:57membership. That's g o g e v i t i
- 34:02.com/leaf
- 34:04for 20% off today. What makes it so hard
- 34:07to turn an idea into a real business? In
- 34:1040 years of this work, I found that it's
- 34:12really the idea. It's the not yet
- 34:15pattern, not ready yet, not the right
- 34:17time yet. Rehearse that thought long
- 34:19enough and it starts to feel like a
- 34:20fact.
- 34:21For a lot of people, the setup is what
- 34:23feels too big.
- 34:25We run drleaf.com on Shopify and
- 34:28everything we needed to start selling
- 34:31was already there.
- 34:32They pre-built themes and AI site
- 34:34builder that you launch a
- 34:35professional-looking store without
- 34:37touching a line of code.
- 34:39And checkout with Shop Pay converts up
- 34:42to 36% higher than the competition. So
- 34:45more people who find you actually buy.
- 34:49Launch before Black Friday, a time of
- 34:51year when more people are already
- 34:52shopping and ready to buy.
- 34:55And if you ready to launch your business
- 34:56before Black Friday, go to
- 34:58shopify.com/leaf
- 35:01to start your free trial. That's
- 35:03shopify.com/leaf.
- 35:05Go to shopify.com/leaf
- 35:07today to hear your first
- 35:10Okay, welcome back.
- 35:12I know there was something you wanted to
- 35:15say regarding this exercise to test the
- 35:18one you were talking about with the
- 35:19circular reasoning.
- 35:21So do you want to pick up from there?
- 35:24>> Absolutely. So that was just a little
- 35:25test to just help people check that
- 35:27they're not doing circular reasoning,
- 35:28which is I can't do this because I've
- 35:29got ADHD versus describing it. So it's
- 35:32those two little sentences. And when I
- 35:34do this with people, initially they can
- 35:36feel they feel two emotions. And you can
- 35:38always have two emotions at once. It's
- 35:40never either or it's and. The one thing
- 35:41is they can maybe feel a little bit
- 35:43deflated because the label made them
- 35:45feel comfortable. So if you understand
- 35:48that, but as long as you see the label
- 35:49is not as the end point,
- 35:51then it can also be for what they also
- 35:53say to me is it can be very freeing.
- 35:55Very freeing in that because the
- 35:57description can change. So if I am
- 35:59backing like I get that whole
- 36:00long-winded example of I can't write
- 36:02reports because I've got ADHD versus I
- 36:04can't write reports because of
- 36:05interruptions. And that means that the
- 36:07description's given me power. I'm back
- 36:10in the power seat. I can see okay, I
- 36:12need those kinds of conditions. I can
- 36:14change something. I can do something
- 36:16about it. Versus a label, what can I do?
- 36:18Oh, I've got ADHD, but you can't have
- 36:20ADHD.
- 36:22But I've got the symptoms and they're
- 36:23real and they're affecting me. So by
- 36:25describing, you don't get stuck in that
- 36:27circular reasoning. You don't get stuck
- 36:29in that now what? And that's what the
- 36:30Fenogi report was really emphasizing is
- 36:33that people are feeling like okay, I've
- 36:35got to wait for the assessment. I get
- 36:36the assessment and now what? So I'm
- 36:38trying to just ease that in for people.
- 36:40Does that make sense?
- 36:41>> Yes, yeah, thank you. So now what about
- 36:44the the brain scans? People say they've
- 36:46seen brain scans showing ADHD brains are
- 36:49different.
- 36:51>> I'm very glad you brought that up
- 36:52because that's a big thing. So in 2017
- 36:55there was a big international group
- 36:56called ENIGMA. And what they did is they
- 36:59pulled all these MRI scans and they
- 37:01analyzed them. They did like a meta
- 37:03analysis.
- 37:04And it was for more than 3,000 people.
- 37:06And what they found is that there were
- 37:08slightly
- 37:10smaller volumes, which is size, have got
- 37:13a brain, okay? They reported
- 37:15slightly smaller volumes in a few
- 37:18different brain regions in people with
- 37:21the ADD ADHD diagnosis.
- 37:24But that isn't what the headlines
- 37:26reported. This thing was huge. I
- 37:27remember when this came out. I actually
- 37:28did a podcast years ago on this ENIGMA
- 37:30report quite a few years ago when it
- 37:32came out in 2017.
- 37:34And basically the headline said ADHD is
- 37:36a disorder of the brain and things like
- 37:38that. It is has been now proven that
- 37:40ADHD brains are different. But that
- 37:42isn't actually what the study did
- 37:44because people went back in and they re
- 37:45looked at the scans and there's lots of
- 37:47statistical ways that you can analyze
- 37:49results. And interestingly enough is and
- 37:52when they did that they challenged that.
- 37:53The results were not actually saying
- 37:56that people with ADHD have smaller
- 37:58brains. It didn't actually say that when
- 38:01you analyze the results statistically.
- 38:03Mad in America also did a very full
- 38:05report. That's the website Mad in
- 38:07America. If you literally Google ENIGMA
- 38:112017 Mad in America report, they
- 38:13actually explain that whole meta
- 38:15analysis saying that they've got a great
- 38:17summary there. But what's interesting is
- 38:19years later that the scientist who
- 38:20actually led this work, her name's
- 38:22Martine Hoogman, told a journalist
- 38:24called Paul Tough
- 38:26that you could just as fairly Now, she
- 38:29led this this ENIGMA study. She said you
- 38:32could just as fairly say that the brain
- 38:34volumes of people with and without ADHD
- 38:37are almost identical. So the lead
- 38:39researcher said literally when you
- 38:41account for all the statistical
- 38:43differences and all the different things
- 38:44that they didn't account for and the
- 38:46potential
- 38:47and the things that you do with good
- 38:48statistics on meta-analyses. There
- 38:51wasn't really any difference between
- 38:53people who have been diagnosed with ADHD
- 38:55and people who haven't. So that's very
- 38:57significant. That's how small those
- 39:00differences were. For something to be
- 39:02reported like I I do research, I have to
- 39:04report if for me to report that there's
- 39:06a significant difference, there's rules.
- 39:08They have to reach a certain level
- 39:10before you can say something is
- 39:11significant and then you have to say
- 39:12what level of significance and then you
- 39:14have to talk and I'm stressing it
- 39:15because
- 39:16one thing I've seen as a clinician and
- 39:18as someone who works one-on-one with
- 39:19clients, I don't practice clinically
- 39:21anymore but I did for 25 years, is
- 39:23people would come and say, oh my gosh,
- 39:24there's something wrong with me. I've
- 39:25got a smaller brain. I've got an
- 39:26abnormal brain. Now that sets a whole
- 39:29mindset
- 39:31in the conscious mind that wires that
- 39:33into the brain and a network between the
- 39:35conscious mind and brain is built up
- 39:37that gets you stuck in a loop that
- 39:39there's something wrong with me. I'm not
- 39:40as good or as smart or as intelligent or
- 39:43I'm broken in some way. And that in
- 39:45itself makes you look at your identity
- 39:46in a different way.
- 39:48And that's something I would work a lot
- 39:50against I do to help people to say,
- 39:52let's look at this differently. Let's
- 39:53look at your etc etc. So J. N. von
- 39:56Krieff also points out that these
- 39:58studies didn't properly account for
- 39:59things like IQ, birth complications,
- 40:02family income,
- 40:04and a whole lot of other stuff which
- 40:05have all been shown scientifically to
- 40:07affect how people function.
- 40:09>> Okay, and now what about genetics?
- 40:12>> Good question. I'm glad you asked me
- 40:13that because there's so much around
- 40:15genetics. I'm going to give the simplest
- 40:16answer I can.
- 40:18You get gene genes, genetics or genes
- 40:21and you get variants which means that
- 40:23there's different types of genes. Now
- 40:24what they have found is that there's
- 40:26some gene variants that have been linked
- 40:28to ADHD
- 40:29but they overlap with the same genes
- 40:32that link that in other words you
- 40:34overlap means that they found those same
- 40:36genes with other things like depression,
- 40:38insomnia, obesity, even smoking.
- 40:41And almost every behavior that we have
- 40:44as humans, if you study it you'll find a
- 40:46genetic link. And that's because
- 40:49genes are switched on with every
- 40:51experience we have and they are coding
- 40:53the experience. So obviously genes are
- 40:55involved in everything. So there's so
- 40:57much overlap
- 40:59that the more we study about and I'm not
- 41:01a geneticist, but I do follow this
- 41:02research, but the more that these
- 41:04geneticists follow the research, the
- 41:06less inclined they are to link a gene
- 41:09with a particular disorder, especially
- 41:12because things like ADHD, bipolar, etc.
- 41:14All these disorders that are real, but
- 41:16they are descriptions of things that
- 41:18we've gone through, responses in we've
- 41:20gone through in life. There's just not
- 41:21clear distinctions between them. There's
- 41:23so much overlap, so much grey area, and
- 41:26no proven biological foundation. A
- 41:29biological effect, but not cause, except
- 41:33in the cases where there's been things
- 41:34as I mentioned like TBI, brain tumours,
- 41:37etc. etc.
- 41:38>> Okay, interesting. And now we talked
- 41:39about
- 41:40medication. Is it
- 41:42>> Sorry, can I interrupt you to tell you
- 41:43something funny that your animal she's
- 41:44got quite a sense of humor. She said
- 41:46there's even been genes associated with
- 41:48going to the pub.
- 41:50So people that go to a pub lot. So
- 41:52really we've got to be careful what we
- 41:53tell people. Anyway, I just thought that
- 41:55was funny. She always throws in a little
- 41:56bit of humor.
- 41:58>> I like that. I think it's important to
- 42:00have humor when talking about such
- 42:02serious subjects.
- 42:03So yes, I just wanted to go back to the
- 42:05medication question. Is there anything
- 42:06else you wanted to say that was
- 42:08mentioned in this review? Do they talk a
- 42:11lot about medication? Is anything else
- 42:13you'd like to add?
- 42:14>> They did mention it too. What I get a
- 42:16lot, people will often challenge me in
- 42:18conferences or on social media or
- 42:21whatever. They say I tried the
- 42:22medication. It works, so I must have
- 42:24ADHD. So now when people say things like
- 42:26that, that's come from what they've been
- 42:27told. So the social media, the the media
- 42:30in general that has made these big
- 42:33statements like ADHD brains are
- 42:35different. Now you read that, you may
- 42:36not be a scientist, so you don't know
- 42:37how to analyze the studies, so you read
- 42:39the report and you read what the media
- 42:41says. So people have that mindset wired
- 42:44into their brain. So that's the one
- 42:46thing. So
- 42:48I tried it, it worked, I must have ADHD.
- 42:49I'd rather people say things and this is
- 42:51what I would advise my clients, patients
- 42:53and so on.
- 42:54People that just asked me randomly, I'll
- 42:56say, okay, you tried the medication, it
- 42:58worked, but you don't have to have I
- 42:59must have ADHD because that implies that
- 43:03stimulant is what's missing in your
- 43:05brain and that's has not been proven.
- 43:07It's like the caffeine. Wow, caffeine
- 43:09works for me. Caffeine must be missing
- 43:10in my brain. If it works for you and it
- 43:12helps you, great, but don't say it works
- 43:14therefore I must have ADHD because we
- 43:18haven't the science to prove that you
- 43:19have ADHD. You have a symptoms that are
- 43:22very real in your life, but those
- 43:24symptoms are a cluster related to
- 43:26something.
- 43:27So there's also a study that I tend to
- 43:29point people towards and it's a 1978 an
- 43:31old study from the US National Institute
- 43:33of Mental Health
- 43:34and it was led by Judith Rapoport. They
- 43:37gave one dose of a stimulant to boys
- 43:40with no diagnosis and those with the
- 43:41diagnosis and their attention sharpened,
- 43:44they moved around less
- 43:46and they did better on the learning
- 43:47task. So based on that, the researchers
- 43:49concluded that stimulants act similarly
- 43:51on children with and without diagnosis
- 43:53and on adults too. In other words, what
- 43:54they basically said is that
- 43:56it's going to work for anyone because
- 43:58it's a stimulant. Stimulants help people
- 44:00focus.
- 44:01>> And now when we've talked about this
- 44:03topic of ADD, ADHD, you get really fired
- 44:06up about the private clinics. Can you
- 44:08talk about this why and share more about
- 44:11what that is?
- 44:12>> The numbers in the review
- 44:14were
- 44:15kind of scary because basically in the
- 44:17UK for example and it's I don't have the
- 44:19American stats in front of me, but this
- 44:21what they do references it seems to be
- 44:23representative of a global trend that
- 44:25basically private providers
- 44:28now do more than half of all NHS funded
- 44:30ADHD assessments. In other words,
- 44:31there's such a long waiting
- 44:33list to get into the NHS, the health
- 44:35system that private providers are
- 44:38basically do more than half
- 44:40and the spending on people going for
- 44:42assessment rose around 250% in three
- 44:46years.
- 44:47So that in other words, people a lot of
- 44:49people are going to get assessments from
- 44:52private providers and they project based
- 44:55on that that there's going to be a huge
- 44:56spend. In the UK, they're talking about
- 44:58164 million pounds in the areas that
- 45:01they looked at. That's just in the UK.
- 45:03But that, as I said, it does tend to
- 45:05reflect a global trend. Some providers
- 45:07now sell neurodiversity assessments
- 45:10and the review points out that
- 45:12neurodiversity is a social term. And
- 45:14this is very interesting. It's not a
- 45:15clinical term. It's a social term,
- 45:17neurodiversity.
- 45:18It's very trendy. It's very popular.
- 45:19It's all over social media as most of us
- 45:21know.
- 45:22And it's being turned into a diagnosis.
- 45:24Now, I love the word neurodiversity when
- 45:26we talk about it as a description. I
- 45:28don't love it when it's being turned
- 45:30into a diagnosis and there's no research
- 45:31to back it up. It's not a clinical
- 45:33diagnosis. There's no science behind it.
- 45:35But to use it as a description and to
- 45:37qualify that description, not just take
- 45:40a word
- 45:41and say that's it, but to say that's one
- 45:43of the adjectives to describe something
- 45:45and then expand on that is that's what
- 45:47we should be doing.
- 45:49>> Fascinating. Okay. And you've talked a
- 45:51lot about the August birthday study of
- 45:54fair and you've mentioned it once or
- 45:56twice here. Can you Can you tell us
- 45:58about this?
- 45:59>> Yeah, this is super interesting. I used
- 46:01to see this a lot when I was practicing
- 46:02clinically because I worked with a lot
- 46:03of children that were referred for with
- 46:06learning disabilities.
- 46:08And ADHD would be one of the symptoms,
- 46:11past symptoms. So basically the August
- 46:13study is in 2018 a Harvard team
- 46:16published in the New England Journal of
- 46:18Medicine. What they did was they looked
- 46:19at more than 400,000 American children
- 46:22and in states where the school cutoff is
- 46:24September 1st.
- 46:26So that means that a child born on
- 46:28August 31st sits in the same class as a
- 46:32child almost a year older.
- 46:34Now we know from brain development and
- 46:37mind brain development that a child who
- 46:40is a year older it's very different
- 46:43focus wise, concentration wise, etc.
- 46:45than a child who's a year younger.
- 46:47And so many of those kids I can tell you
- 46:49in my practice alone that were referred
- 46:51to me with ADHD
- 46:53as a diagnosis
- 46:55they were just younger
- 46:56than their classmates. and this is been
- 46:59a global thing that's been found as
- 47:00well. So August born children were 30%
- 47:02more likely to be diagnosed with ADHD.
- 47:03That's what they found. So it's about
- 47:05being the youngest in the room.
- 47:07>> And how did you approach this back when
- 47:08you were working with kids?
- 47:10>> Basically what I would do is that would
- 47:11be one of the first things that I would
- 47:13look at is the age, especially if they
- 47:15were
- 47:16it's still obviously at school because a
- 47:18younger child's going to look more
- 47:20restless next to an older child. And the
- 47:21second thing that I would do is we we'd
- 47:24never just diagnose in a 15 minute time
- 47:26slot. Just tick tick and this is it. I
- 47:29mean there are a lot of practitioners
- 47:31that we give credit to those
- 47:32practitioners that take a lot of time to
- 47:34diagnose because
- 47:36if you're going to get someone to
- 47:37describe
- 47:39I can't do a report because I've got
- 47:40ADHD. It takes few seconds, but I can't
- 47:43do a report and you start exploring why
- 47:45and you start describing you start
- 47:46talking about that takes time to get
- 47:47that person's story. So we so we never
- 47:50would diagnose in a short time slot. We
- 47:52would spend weeks and sometimes months.
- 47:54So there was always you were always in a
- 47:56state of looking. It was never just boom
- 47:58whack on a diagnosis. It was always
- 47:59let's explore, let's work together. And
- 48:02I found so many cases and I know my
- 48:04colleagues so I had a big practice with
- 48:06colleagues working with me and I've been
- 48:08in this field for a long time and
- 48:09research has also shown this and I did a
- 48:11lot of work in my masters and PhD
- 48:13especially on working with children with
- 48:15learning disabilities and so on and
- 48:18from all the way through from very young
- 48:20through 18 plus.
- 48:22And what we would find is that often no
- 48:25one had just shown them how to manage a
- 48:27school day, how to learn, how to know
- 48:30how to
- 48:31deal with like a child who's had a bad
- 48:34day at home and they don't pay attention
- 48:35in class and they get bullied in the
- 48:37playground or they knew in the there's
- 48:38so many other parts to a person's story
- 48:41that you need to look at, but also how
- 48:42to learn.
- 48:44Showing a child how to learn honestly in
- 48:46the majority of cases when I taught them
- 48:48how to learn, how to listen in class,
- 48:50how to be able to take that information
- 48:53and prepare for a test, organize the
- 48:55information, that changed the diagnosis.
- 48:57We would have neurologist saying what
- 48:59did you do? What is different? How come
- 49:01the we pediatricians or teachers,
- 49:03because very often they get frightened.
- 49:05They don't know what to do. The new
- 49:06class, new year, often at the beginning
- 49:08of a new year, whether it is at school
- 49:10or university, sometimes when people are
- 49:12going into at work and they're studying
- 49:14further, not knowing how to learn and
- 49:17you're trying to run a life as well, if
- 49:18you're a busy adult, mom, dad, whatever,
- 49:21and you're running a business or your
- 49:23child and you're going into a new school
- 49:24year and there's so many more demands
- 49:25and there's new friends, that's often
- 49:27when we would get the referrals. And
- 49:29often it was just helping them deal with
- 49:30that emotional side and then also
- 49:32teaching them how to learn. It's amazing
- 49:34how many kids in this day and age do not
- 49:37know how to learn.
- 49:39And that's a huge thing that helped a
- 49:41lot. So we'd spend a lot of time working
- 49:42on that.
- 49:43>> And so since we're coming to the end of
- 49:45this podcast, before we get into more of
- 49:48the practical, what we can do, is there
- 49:50anything else you would like to talk
- 49:53about in relation to medication or the
- 49:55report or anything like that before we
- 49:57get into the how to navigate this in the
- 50:00healthiest way possible?
- 50:01>> Just a couple of things like it's
- 50:03important that we always hear both
- 50:04sides. So the Royal College of
- 50:06Psychiatrists, the Charity ADHD UK and
- 50:09International Consensus Statements
- 50:11signed by many researchers all tend to
- 50:13say ADHD is a well-established
- 50:15neurodevelopmental condition, strongly
- 50:18heritable, and the biggest problem is
- 50:20underdiagnosis, especially in girls and
- 50:21women.
- 50:23So that's what most people are hearing.
- 50:25Now what the Fenergi report is looking
- 50:27at that and not just the Fenergi report
- 50:29but all these other studies and I've
- 50:30mentioned quite a few and my work and so
- 50:32on and Moncrieff and all these people is
- 50:35saying that there isn't actually proof
- 50:37that it's heritable, that it's an
- 50:39established neurodevelopmental, that
- 50:41whole brain scan thing I spoke about
- 50:43earlier on. So the message that's coming
- 50:45through is it's no wonder people are
- 50:48saying I've got ADHD,
- 50:50because if the professionals are telling
- 50:51them that. So I think here is a huge
- 50:53responsibility for professionals
- 50:55to
- 50:57dive deep and look at both sides, which
- 51:00I've tried to as well and that why I
- 51:01don't say
- 51:03throw the term out. I just say don't say
- 51:05it as a diagnosis, use it as a
- 51:06description. I'm not saying throw the
- 51:08medication away, but question, get
- 51:10details, look at your whole story,
- 51:12examine deeper. So that's just what I
- 51:14wanted to stress there. In the absence
- 51:16of a definitive diagnostic test, any
- 51:18diagnosis remains inherently bound to
- 51:20surrounding context. So it's not telling
- 51:22us enough nor way forward. In other
- 51:24words, if you just say you have ADHD
- 51:25because of those symptoms, the circular
- 51:27reasoning, it's not a way forward. And
- 51:28that's a huge thing that the Fenugi
- 51:30report stressed that it's not enough. We
- 51:32have to do more.
- 51:34Okay, so then just in terms of
- 51:35medication quickly, because we briefly
- 51:37mentioned medication earlier on, there
- 51:40there are some studies that aren't
- 51:42always mentioned. The one is the MTA
- 51:44study funded by the US National
- 51:45Institute of Mental Health. It started
- 51:47in 1990s with 579 children ages 7
- 51:50through 10. And in the first 14 months,
- 51:53carefully managed medication looked the
- 51:55best on symptom rating. So in the first
- 51:57year more or less, it seemed to be
- 51:59helping a lot. And that's the result
- 52:01that hit the headlines. This is working.
- 52:04But they kept following the children
- 52:05into adulthood. So it was 1990s. Then in
- 52:082017, when a lot of these kids were now
- 52:11in their 20s,
- 52:13the young people who kept taking the
- 52:14stimulants long-term didn't end up with
- 52:16fewer symptoms than those who mostly
- 52:18stopped. It's obviously it's
- 52:19statistical, so there's a whole group of
- 52:20people that didn't. There's some other
- 52:22things very quickly as well that we need
- 52:23in terms of this is long-term use of
- 52:25stimulants of any kind. The other thing
- 52:27is a study done by researchers at
- 52:29Karolinska Institute in Sweden. They
- 52:31followed ADHD medication for up to 14
- 52:34years to people age 6 to 64. So it's a
- 52:37good broad expansive study.
- 52:39Every extra year on medication was
- 52:42linked to about a 4% higher risk of
- 52:44heart disease. So it's an observational
- 52:46study, but it's something that we need
- 52:48to be aware of. So it's all this
- 52:49awareness that this could be something
- 52:51to watch for. So in checkups and things
- 52:54it's always if you're on something like
- 52:56a stimulant, it's always to
- 52:57when you do your annual checkups or
- 52:59biannual checkups just to always check
- 53:00for that. And then on mental health
- 53:02there's been some very interesting
- 53:03studies, lots of them. This tends to
- 53:05surprise people. There was a 2024 study
- 53:08from a clean hospital
- 53:09part of Harvard's teaching network
- 53:12and they looked at young people 16 to 35
- 53:14who were hospitalized with first episode
- 53:16of psychosis or mania.
- 53:18And a recent prescription for
- 53:20amphetamines like Adderall or Vyvanse
- 53:22more than doubled the odds. On high
- 53:24doses was even more than five times
- 53:26higher. Methylphenidate like Ritalin or
- 53:28Concerta wasn't linked to a higher risk.
- 53:31So certain types of stimulants can more
- 53:33than double the odds of someone having a
- 53:35psychotic break in their 20s.
- 53:37And then to keep it in proportion, it is
- 53:38rare, around about one in 1,000. That's
- 53:41what it breaks down to statistically,
- 53:42but it does matter. It's like the
- 53:43cardiovascular You can't overlook if
- 53:45it's happening and it's happening in
- 53:47certain populations, we need to be
- 53:48aware.
- 53:49And then just everyday side effects, a
- 53:51Cochrane review in 23, they pooled
- 53:54randomized trials of using
- 53:56methylphenidate in children and they
- 53:58said children on the drug had a greater
- 54:00risk of sleep problems and more than
- 54:01three and a half times the risk of
- 54:03decreased appetite. I remember that was
- 54:04a big complaint that parents would come
- 54:06to me with that their children suddenly
- 54:09didn't eat as much and they battled with
- 54:11sleep.
- 54:12So most of these trials in fairness
- 54:14lasted six months or less and the
- 54:16authors rate the certainty of the
- 54:17evidence as low. Okay, so the pattern
- 54:19across These are pattern.
- 54:21The longer the use, the higher the dose,
- 54:23the more all of these risks show up. So
- 54:25it's awareness. The big thing here, it's
- 54:27a lot for people to take in. So I just
- 54:29want to be careful.
- 54:30Some other studies haven't found a
- 54:32lasting effect a lasting heart effect
- 54:34and later years of the MTA weren't
- 54:36randomized. So that big study that
- 54:38looked at the other effects, it wasn't
- 54:40randomized. So that does also question
- 54:42the results. But it's what we have to
- 54:44do. Take all of the And I've just given
- 54:45a few. There's so many studies out there
- 54:47and I know this is already a lot of
- 54:48information for people to process, but
- 54:50in general, there's enough evidence for
- 54:53us to be aware
- 54:54and to not just overlook the signals and
- 54:56to get as much information as possible
- 54:58and to watch all your health,
- 55:00sleep, heart, all these kinds of things
- 55:02to watch for those. So I believe in
- 55:04medications.
- 55:06Finishing something for the first time
- 55:07in years is a very real experience for
- 55:09people to have,
- 55:11but it's I keep stressing, be aware,
- 55:13check all these other things. Don't just
- 55:15go into this blindly and be careful of
- 55:16getting stuck in that label.
- 55:18that that's a lot.
- 55:20>> we'll also make sure to link all the
- 55:23studies in the show notes and if people
- 55:26are wanting something specific that we
- 55:28forgot to include or did not include,
- 55:29just reach out to us an email and we'll
- 55:31make sure that we can share all the
- 55:33resources and studies. Now just for the
- 55:36practical side, do you want to walk
- 55:37through the steps you put together for
- 55:40people when asking, I've listened to all
- 55:42this, it's a lot to take in, I hear what
- 55:44you're saying, what can I do?
- 55:46>> So something practical that you can do
- 55:48immediately today, something I would do
- 55:49with my clients and my patients, get a
- 55:51piece of paper, two columns, on the one
- 55:53side put where my attention held and on
- 55:56the other side
- 55:57where my attention slipped. Simple. And
- 56:00then for seven days, every time you
- 56:02notice either one,
- 56:04just note it down. You can also do this,
- 56:05doesn't have to be paper, you can do it
- 56:07on your computer or your phone, however
- 56:09you want, okay? For seven days, notice
- 56:11either one and write just write a single
- 56:13line. So watch it for seven days. So as
- 56:15you're going through the day that you're
- 56:16working and then your attention slipped
- 56:18and you found yourself your mind
- 56:19wandering, then you stop and say my mind
- 56:21wandered, I was doing this and then you
- 56:23what happened that your mind oh this
- 56:25person phoned me, this person walked in
- 56:27my office, the dog barked, whatever. So
- 56:30you that you can see where you lost your
- 56:32attention, where it slipped and then you
- 56:34got your reason why and you do that over
- 56:35seven days to observe the pattern.
- 56:37You've heard me say the seven-day rule
- 56:38before. Seven days is a nice number for
- 56:40you to start establishing a pattern. So
- 56:43basically for seven days, each time you
- 56:45notice either one, write a single line,
- 56:47then next to each line write what's
- 56:48happening in the 20 minutes before.
- 56:50That's really important. What's
- 56:51happening in the 20 minutes before?
- 56:54Did you sleep? Had you eaten? Did you
- 56:56have a hard conversation? Maybe you just
- 56:57had a whole argument with someone and
- 56:59then you had to go and do something and
- 57:00you came into that task with all those
- 57:03emotions like firing. It's really hard
- 57:06to pay attention to something hard when
- 57:09you've just gone through a hard
- 57:09conversation. Maybe you didn't sleep
- 57:11last night. Maybe you haven't eaten for
- 57:13a few hours.
- 57:14Were you doing something you chose or
- 57:16something somebody chose for you which
- 57:19is significant and we can't always
- 57:21choose our tasks. If you're working for
- 57:22someone, you've got certain things you
- 57:23just have to get done. Not everything's
- 57:25fun, but that's significant in terms of
- 57:27concentration. It's so much easier to
- 57:29concentrate on something that you're
- 57:31interested in as we know versus
- 57:32something that someone chose for you to
- 57:33do with your phone in your hand.
- 57:36And then on day eight, you read it back
- 57:38like a little scientist, okay? Most
- 57:40people find their attention isn't
- 57:41randomly missing.
- 57:42Most people. It holds under certain
- 57:44conditions and it slips under others.
- 57:46And that's a pattern maps. You work out
- 57:48a pattern map.
- 57:49And so you're not just putting the
- 57:51remember it's two columns. So you're
- 57:52going to identify where your attention
- 57:55slipped and also where it held. So maybe
- 57:57you think you looked down and started
- 57:59working on something and you looked up
- 58:01and it was 2 hours later and you've done
- 58:03the most amazing work. Did you credit
- 58:05yourself that or you you read a really
- 58:07interesting
- 58:08article and you spent 20 minutes and
- 58:11your mind didn't wander once. Put the
- 58:12positive down where you did focus on
- 58:15something. And if you're observing your
- 58:16children, you can do this with your kids
- 58:18too. You can observe where the attention
- 58:20went. So you In other words, we're
- 58:21creating a pattern map
- 58:23of where it held, where it slipped, and
- 58:25the circumstances around that. That's a
- 58:28really great exercise to start from
- 58:29there and instead of just like
- 58:31immediately labeling. So it's really the
- 58:33whole way through this podcast, I'm
- 58:34pushing you towards a description
- 58:37versus just getting stuck just in the
- 58:40label. And that's the biggest thing that
- 58:41came out the
- 58:42report is that we can't just have the
- 58:44label and the diagnosis as the end
- 58:47point.
- 58:48>> Thank you. I think that'll be really
- 58:49helpful. And if people want to get this
- 58:51handout that we're going to put
- 58:52together, be sure to join our Neurocycle
- 58:55Insiders community because we'll put it
- 58:57there as well as Dr. Leaf will host a
- 59:00live Q&A on that platform answering
- 59:03questions, concerns, comments. So in the
- 59:05show notes, we'll include the link to
- 59:07the community. And I know you also put
- 59:10together a Neurocycle prescription and
- 59:12that neurocycle prescription will be in
- 59:14the neurocycle app, which again, you can
- 59:17find on the app store, Google Play, or
- 59:19at drleaf.com. And that's also something
- 59:21we'll walk through in the neurocycle
- 59:24Insiders community. Before we wrap up
- 59:27here, Mom, is there any last parting
- 59:30words you want to say? I know we have,
- 59:32you know, given people a lot of
- 59:33information and there's a lot more
- 59:35questions and concerns, we can always do
- 59:38a part three.
- 59:40>> I think so. I think what listen to these
- 59:42two podcasts as a set. I think it'll
- 59:43help a lot and then try out the
- 59:45exercises, look at the research studies
- 59:47as far as you need to go. Use this
- 59:48content to go to your professional if
- 59:50you feel like this is who you are. I'm
- 59:52trying to help you have knowledge so
- 59:54that you don't
- 59:56I don't want you to short yourself. I
- 59:57don't want you to think there's
- 59:58something wrong with you and that you
- 1:00:01have lose your identity. I want you to
- 1:00:03be empowered to be able to manage your
- 1:00:04own life because your mind is your
- 1:00:06superpower. So that's really important.
- 1:00:08And just a couple of things to wrap up.
- 1:00:10People who change their attention
- 1:00:12patterns, if we change, like let's say
- 1:00:13that we understand, we do this whole
- 1:00:15description, this is not a willpower
- 1:00:17thing. That's what I'm trying to say.
- 1:00:18This is not a willpower. So I don't want
- 1:00:20you thinking, oh, I just don't have the
- 1:00:21willpower. There's something wrong with
- 1:00:22me. I don't have enough willpower so
- 1:00:24there's something wrong with you. This
- 1:00:25is not about willpower. This is about
- 1:00:27understanding you, your patterns, your
- 1:00:29life, and describing those and then
- 1:00:31working around those situations and it
- 1:00:34most likely will be a combination of
- 1:00:36maybe meds and some therapy and some how
- 1:00:38to learn and some changes in boundaries
- 1:00:41at work or something like that. But
- 1:00:43getting to know yourself is important
- 1:00:44and without crushing your identity. So
- 1:00:47the more curious you are about you and
- 1:00:50how you are functioning in your
- 1:00:52day-to-day life, the more power you give
- 1:00:54yourself back over something like
- 1:00:55attention wandering all over the place.
- 1:00:57I think that's really the key thing in
- 1:01:00final closing statements, your mind was
- 1:01:02directing your attention long before
- 1:01:04anyone gave your struggle a name. It
- 1:01:07still is starting. Your mind runs the
- 1:01:10show. Thank you for joining us today. As
- 1:01:12I said, listen to this as a set and we
- 1:01:14look forward to your feedback and
- 1:01:15and we look forward to connecting next
- 1:01:17time.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Is ADHD Real? What a 600-Page Review Found About the Diagnosis by Dr. Leaf Show: Neuroscience & Mental Health, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 11,955 words across 1,832 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.