Introduction to Recruitment — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00[Music]
- 0:19you
- 0:23recruiting is the process of creating a
- 0:25reasonable pool of qualified candidates
- 0:27for a job opening
- 0:31notice that this definition identifies
- 0:34the fact that we need qualified
- 0:36applicants in a recent study 84% of HR
- 0:40professionals reported candidates having
- 0:42applied skill deficits such as problem
- 0:44solving skills and 68% were having
- 0:47difficulty in filling jobs recruiting
- 0:51does us no good if the candidates whom
- 0:52we attract are not qualified for the
- 0:54work in recruiting we want to use a
- 0:58series of tools to show the candidates
- 1:00why they might want to become part of
- 1:02the organization but it's critically
- 1:05important that the candidates that we
- 1:06show are in fact qualified for the job
- 1:09we need to fill when should we go
- 1:13through the recruiting process and what
- 1:15alternatives do we have to recruiting
- 1:17and who should we recruit or where
- 1:19should we recruit our applicants from in
- 1:21terms of sources and methods we have to
- 1:24set policies on these topics in order to
- 1:27maintain consistency and we need
- 1:29consistency in order to be fair and
- 1:31equitable so that we can defend our
- 1:33processes if it becomes necessary so
- 1:36what do we have to think about and in
- 1:38what level of detail we have to think
- 1:42about a lot of things as we work to Ally
- 1:44a shortage of people within a company we
- 1:46need to determine how we're going to go
- 1:49through the recruiting process before we
- 1:51start trying to recruit new members into
- 1:52our workforce among other things we have
- 1:57to answer the following questions under
- 2:00what conditions will we recruit new
- 2:01people into the company
- 2:03where should we recruit what primary
- 2:05recruiting sources will provide us our
- 2:07best recruits we have to make these
- 2:12determinations based on our particular
- 2:14company characteristics taking into
- 2:16account all of the information from our
- 2:18forecasting processes we might be able
- 2:22to solve our problem with temporary
- 2:23employees instead of new full-time
- 2:25workers we have to weigh all of the
- 2:29available options is an example and we
- 2:32should generally have a policy that
- 2:33tells us when we should use each option
- 2:36we need to analyze each of the options
- 2:39for mitigating the labor shortage other
- 2:41than making new hires and we need to
- 2:43create a policy concerning when of each
- 2:46of these options is useful to our
- 2:48organization we also need to identify
- 2:51our effective labor market do we plan to
- 2:54recruit only from local sources as an
- 2:56example the first factor is simple can
- 3:01we find the right number and types of
- 3:03employees if we recruit locally if so
- 3:06then we may be able to work only in our
- 3:09local labor market we have to create
- 3:13policies concerning when and how we
- 3:15recruit from our current employee pool
- 3:17and when we go outside the organization
- 3:19why probably the biggest reason is that
- 3:22our employees perceive fairness in our
- 3:24recruiting process they might begin to
- 3:29show less loyalty to the organization
- 3:31because they feel the organization
- 3:33failed to show them loyalty through the
- 3:35recruiting decision if our policies say
- 3:38that we go outside for recruits then
- 3:41it's unlikely that anyone in the
- 3:42organization would have the skillset
- 3:44necessary to do the job identified in
- 3:46our job specification we bring new
- 3:50people with new ideas in the
- 3:52organization with different skills we
- 3:54may also identify specific occupations
- 3:57in our organization that we typically
- 3:59recruit from the outside usually due to
- 4:02the need for this specialized skill set
- 4:05these are just a few of the things that
- 4:07we need to consider as we create our
- 4:09recruiting policies specific to internal
- 4:12or external methods of recruitment
- 4:14internal recruiting involves filling job
- 4:17openings with current employees or
- 4:19people employees know here we'll discuss
- 4:23internal recruiting sources promote
- 4:26ability ratings and managerial
- 4:28sponsorship and the advantages and
- 4:30disadvantages of internal recruiting
- 4:34there are two common types of internal
- 4:37recruiting promotions from within an
- 4:39employee referrals when it comes to
- 4:43promotion from within as an internal
- 4:45recruiting method the organization has
- 4:47several options
- 4:48we can use open targeted or closed
- 4:50recruiting methods open recruiting
- 4:53consists of advertising the job openly
- 4:55within the organization and anyone who
- 4:58meets the qualifications can apply for
- 4:59the job opening targeted recruiting is
- 5:04pretty much what it sounds like we do
- 5:06not openly advertise the position
- 5:07internally instead we ask managers to
- 5:10privately nominate workers who they feel
- 5:12would be able to do the job that needs
- 5:14to be filled
- 5:15HR then evaluates the candidates put
- 5:18forward by the managers and then
- 5:19forwards the list of the best candidates
- 5:21to the hiring manager finally closed
- 5:26recruiting occurs when hiring managers
- 5:28have a need to fill a position and they
- 5:30communicate that need to HR HR
- 5:33recruiters then search the
- 5:34organization's files for people who have
- 5:37the requisite skills and qualifications
- 5:39and send a list of such individuals to
- 5:41the hiring manager one of the difficult
- 5:45issues the organization may run into if
- 5:47it chooses an internal recruiting option
- 5:49is the presence of a bona fide seniority
- 5:51system meaning a system that gives
- 5:53preference to individuals with longer
- 5:56tenure in the organization we can do
- 6:00some things within the organization to
- 6:02make internal recruiting processes go a
- 6:04bit smoother in most cases we may use
- 6:08some other tools to assess promote
- 6:10ability in our efforts to find the best
- 6:12qualified individuals within an
- 6:14organization we can have each of our
- 6:16employees complete a self-assessment and
- 6:18we can also ask peers to assess their
- 6:20co-workers for promote ability we can
- 6:24also request managerial sponsorship for
- 6:27a person to be considered for job
- 6:28opportunities through internal
- 6:30recruiting in this case we would ask
- 6:32managers to provide their sponsorship
- 6:34for an individual before that person
- 6:36would be considered for a promotion
- 6:38through the internal recruiting process
- 6:41possible advantages of internal
- 6:43recruiting include increases in
- 6:45organizational commitment the internal
- 6:48recruit will be more able to learn about
- 6:49the big picture of the company and the
- 6:51individual also has shown at least some
- 6:54interest in the organization further the
- 6:57organization has existing knowledge of
- 6:59the applicant and a record of previous
- 7:00work the
- 7:02organization can save money by
- 7:03recruiting internally because of lower
- 7:05costs and internal recruiting is usually
- 7:08faster disadvantages include the pool of
- 7:12applicants being significantly smaller
- 7:14in internal recruiting and there'll
- 7:16still be a job to fill when all is said
- 7:18and done further success in one job
- 7:21doesn't necessarily mean success in
- 7:23another an external candidate may have
- 7:25better qualifications and current
- 7:27employees may feel entitled we may
- 7:31create or perpetuate a strong resistance
- 7:34to change or stifle creativity and
- 7:36innovation because everyone in the
- 7:38organization even new hires are part of
- 7:41the old organizational culture
- 7:44understanding internal recruiting
- 7:46enables managers to make the best
- 7:48possible hiring decisions external
- 7:53recruiting is the process of engaging
- 7:54individuals from the labor market
- 7:56outside the firm to apply for a job
- 7:59external recruiting can also be
- 8:01accomplished in either an open or
- 8:03targeted manner in much the same way as
- 8:06internal recruiting Ken if we have an
- 8:10open recruiting effort will provide the
- 8:12job information for anyone who wishes to
- 8:14apply if however we used targeted
- 8:17recruiting for example through a
- 8:19headhunter we would seek out specific
- 8:21individuals with necessary skills and
- 8:23invite them to apply for the job opening
- 8:26when we decide to recruit from external
- 8:29sources what options do we have where
- 8:31would you recruit we have to look at the
- 8:34type of person that we're trying to find
- 8:36and then go to the source or sources
- 8:38that will most likely provide that type
- 8:40of person without actually being
- 8:43recruited good candidates may come to an
- 8:46organization cold and ask for a job
- 8:49recruiting takes place at high schools
- 8:51vocational or technical schools and
- 8:53colleges and universities temporary
- 8:57agencies provide part-time or full-time
- 8:59help for a limited periods of time
- 9:02public agencies are state employment
- 9:04services they generally provide job
- 9:07candidates to employers at a very low or
- 9:10no-cost private employment agencies are
- 9:14privately owned
- 9:15in charge a fee for their services
- 9:18general employment agencies operate on a
- 9:21for-profit basis some of them charge job
- 9:24seekers for their services and others
- 9:25charge the employer contingency agencies
- 9:30offer employees to the employer and are
- 9:32paid when a job candidate is hired by
- 9:35the employer retained search firms or
- 9:39executive recruiters are paid to search
- 9:41for a specific type of recruit for the
- 9:43organization and will be paid regardless
- 9:45of success in their recruiting efforts
- 9:48it is important to use the appropriate
- 9:51source to reach qualified candidates as
- 9:55you can see now there are a number of
- 9:58options when recruiting externally
- 10:00regardless of the method however
- 10:01external recruiting has gone mobile and
- 10:04agile to a great extent as a result we
- 10:09want to pay attention to the
- 10:10effectiveness of our recruiting methods
- 10:13some methods can give us too many new
- 10:16recruits to review costing us valuable
- 10:18time and money other options will not
- 10:20give us enough pool so that there's not
- 10:22flexibility in whom to choose while
- 10:24still other options will cost too much
- 10:27for the results that we get so the
- 10:30process of recruiting new employees has
- 10:32to be targeted a bit better than we
- 10:34might think
- 10:34all management functions are subject to
- 10:38constraints and challenges and the
- 10:40recruiting function is no different
- 10:42probably the most obvious constraint is
- 10:45money we have to live within our budgets
- 10:47in all cases and recruiting is no
- 10:49exception there are many organizational
- 10:53policies that can affect our recruiting
- 10:55efforts we have to be familiar with such
- 10:57policies in detail to take them into
- 10:59account as we go through the recruiting
- 11:01process below are some of the policies
- 11:04that may affect recruiting whether we
- 11:08have a promote from within policy or not
- 11:10affects how we recruit our policies on
- 11:13temporary to permanent employees would
- 11:15also affect how we recruit in most cases
- 11:19we're also affected in our recruiting
- 11:21efforts by organizational image in
- 11:24markets from which we source our
- 11:25recruits organizational image
- 11:29play a significant part in determining
- 11:31our ability to source the people we need
- 11:33from the communities around us the
- 11:39recruiter is in fact one of the primary
- 11:41factors responsible for an applicant
- 11:43showing interest in our organization and
- 11:45in our jobs how does the recruiter
- 11:49affect the job seeker and how can we
- 11:51make sure that the effect is both
- 11:53positive and realistic the recruiter is
- 11:57a critical piece in the recruiting
- 11:59process in addition to their desire to
- 12:03perform though we have to ensure that
- 12:05our recruiters have certain skill sets
- 12:07to perform their jobs well this means
- 12:11that recruiters have to want to listen
- 12:13and must have developed their own active
- 12:15listening skills so that they not only
- 12:17hear the words that recruits are saying
- 12:19but also understand the context of the
- 12:22conversations so that they can empathize
- 12:26if recruiters can do this they can
- 12:29respond accordingly and usually
- 12:31successfully besides active listening
- 12:34skills recruiters have to have a strong
- 12:36set of communication skills the
- 12:40recruiters job also includes
- 12:42successfully communicating with the
- 12:43hiring managers in the organization we
- 12:47also have to Train recruiters in the
- 12:49process of realistic job preview known
- 12:52as rjp so our selection and training of
- 12:57the recruiter is a major factor in our
- 12:59overall recruiting success most
- 13:04companies have come to the conclusion
- 13:06that realistic job previews are now a
- 13:09necessary part of the recruiting process
- 13:11a realistic job preview or rjp is a
- 13:16review of all of the tasks and
- 13:18requirements of the job both good and
- 13:20bad a good job analysis with a clear job
- 13:25description should provide a good rjp
- 13:29satisfaction and organizational
- 13:30commitment would almost certainly go
- 13:32down and this would happen literally
- 13:34right after taking the job if a
- 13:36realistic job preview is not provided
- 13:41is this what we want to do in a
- 13:43recruiting situation how likely is it
- 13:46that a person would quit very early on
- 13:48if they felt like they were lied to in
- 13:50order to get them to accept a job and if
- 13:52they do quit we incur all of the
- 13:54recruiting costs again almost
- 13:56immediately the recruiting process is
- 14:02expensive and unless we identify and
- 14:04control those costs the beneficial
- 14:06results may end up being outweighed by
- 14:08the costs recruiting costs for one
- 14:13management position can run as much as
- 14:15thirty percent of the individuals yearly
- 14:17salary or more and this doesn't include
- 14:20later costs for things like selection
- 14:22and internal training the recruiting
- 14:26yield ratio is a calculation of how many
- 14:29people make it through the recruiting
- 14:30step to the next step in the hiring
- 14:32process
- 14:34another measure that you probably want
- 14:36to use is how much it costs to get each
- 14:38person hired or the cost per hire you
- 14:42may also want to analyze how long it
- 14:44takes to get someone hired this is
- 14:46called time to hire employee retention
- 14:50remains a critical issue for
- 14:51organizations and HR managers you may
- 14:55also want to know how well your newly
- 14:57recruited employees perform on the job
- 15:01accurate measurement of the performance
- 15:03of recruitment makes organizations
- 15:05better selection is the process of
- 15:10choosing the best qualified applicant
- 15:12who's recruited for a given job
- 15:15selection is a critical management task
- 15:17but why is it so critical to the
- 15:20organization the reasons have to do with
- 15:22the negative consequences of bad hiring
- 15:24decisions which are essentially the
- 15:26results of myth smashes between jobs and
- 15:29employees first and probably most
- 15:32notably well it's often important to
- 15:35fill jobs quickly hurrying can result in
- 15:37a mismatch or as the old saying goes
- 15:39haste makes waste think about your
- 15:43experiences in the past have you ever
- 15:45seen or been part of an organization
- 15:47with employees who did the minimum
- 15:49amount of work possible who didn't ever
- 15:51go out of their way to help customers in
- 15:54any situation
- 15:55and who didn't cooperate with others in
- 15:57the organization do you think that
- 15:59organization started out that way or did
- 16:02people start out working hard and paying
- 16:04attention in such an organization what
- 16:06kinds of overall productivity are you
- 16:09trying to have it's easier than you
- 16:13think to get into this type of situation
- 16:15just a few new hires who show this lack
- 16:18of concern for both the organization and
- 16:20its customers can be highly contagious
- 16:24another issue that makes selection
- 16:26critical is the potential for negligent
- 16:28hires almost every state in the United
- 16:30States recognizes this concept so HR
- 16:33management must understand it well a
- 16:36negligent hire is a legal concept that
- 16:39says if the organization hire someone
- 16:41who may pose a danger to co-workers
- 16:43customers suppliers or others and if
- 16:47that person then harms someone else in
- 16:49the course of working for the company
- 16:51then the organization can be held liable
- 16:53to the individuals actions so we have to
- 16:58make sure and take every legitimate
- 16:59attempt to find out if candidates have
- 17:02the potential to be a danger to others
- 17:04and weed them out during our selection
- 17:07process there are many tools at our
- 17:10disposal during selection there are
- 17:14interviews written tests physical tests
- 17:17personality tests honesty tests drug
- 17:20testing background checks of various
- 17:22types and much more which tools should
- 17:25we use in which circumstances almost all
- 17:28of our selection devices are
- 17:29discretionary or optional we don't have
- 17:32any written or physical ability tests we
- 17:35don't have to administer any cognitive
- 17:37ability tests and we don't have to
- 17:39provide tests for stamina honesty or
- 17:42judgment the steps do however make
- 17:45logical sense people apply for jobs and
- 17:48the firm screens job candidates to
- 17:50narrow down the selection process the
- 17:53screening can include tests of some type
- 17:55and an initial interview for top
- 17:57candidates for lower-level jobs it's not
- 17:59uncommon for the HR department to do the
- 18:02screening conduct any testing and
- 18:04background checks and send the best
- 18:06applicants to the manager the candidate
- 18:08would actually
- 18:08for the manager commonly conducts
- 18:11interviews and makes conditional job
- 18:13offers that may include drug screening
- 18:15and other physical exams the final step
- 18:18occurs when the applicant is hired but
- 18:22what do we need to look for in the
- 18:23selection process in order to put the
- 18:25right person in the right job
- 18:28we need to attempt to assess three
- 18:31things personality job fit ability job
- 18:34fit and person organization fit our
- 18:39personality defines to a great extent
- 18:41who we are and how we act and react in
- 18:44certain situations some of us are
- 18:46strongly extroverted and enjoy working
- 18:48the crowd in a social setting while
- 18:50others may be fairly introverted and
- 18:52feel extremely uncomfortable in such an
- 18:55environment some of us desire to try new
- 18:57things constantly while others are more
- 18:59comfortable with things that they know
- 19:01well there are many traits that help
- 19:03define our personalities but the fact
- 19:05remains that each of us is different you
- 19:10have to make an attempt to identify
- 19:12personality types and put them in
- 19:14positions that will be enhanced by their
- 19:16particular personality traits this is
- 19:19called personality job fit so if we need
- 19:24to hire an employee who will have to
- 19:26work the crowd in a sales job for our
- 19:28organization would you want to hire
- 19:30someone who's very uncomfortable talking
- 19:32and relating to strangers if we did hire
- 19:35that person is it likely that the
- 19:37employee would succeed or fail in the
- 19:39position obviously it's more likely that
- 19:41such a person would fail in that type of
- 19:44environment so one of the things we try
- 19:46to determine in the selection process is
- 19:48personality job fit in addition to
- 19:53personality job fit we want to determine
- 19:55ability job fit every individual has a
- 19:58certain set of physical and intellectual
- 20:00skills and no two people are exactly
- 20:02alike some people are very capable at
- 20:05working with computers while others are
- 20:07more capable at a physical type
- 20:09environment still others may be able to
- 20:11successfully perform both physical and
- 20:13computer-based tasks but they may have
- 20:16differences in how they analyze
- 20:18quantitative information as an example
- 20:20each of us is more
- 20:22skilled at some things than others
- 20:26managers have to analyze the skillset
- 20:28and abilities of each subordinate or new
- 20:31hire to understand that person's
- 20:33individual limitations and their
- 20:35abilities finally we have to be aware of
- 20:38person organization fit when deciding on
- 20:41which candidate to hire there are plenty
- 20:43of potential employees out there that
- 20:45have the required skills to do the jobs
- 20:47that we need them to do and they may
- 20:50even have the right types of personality
- 20:52to be comfortable in that job however
- 20:54they might not fit well with the
- 20:56organization itself person organization
- 20:59fit deals with the cultural and
- 21:01structural characteristics of the
- 21:03organization and how well the candidate
- 21:05will fit within that structure and
- 21:06culture if a candidate works best in a
- 21:10decentralized organization with strong
- 21:12individual reward systems and if we're
- 21:14hiring people to work in a tightly
- 21:16controlled and centralized team-based
- 21:18division then it's unlikely that the
- 21:20candidate will be able or willing to
- 21:22conform to the requirements of the
- 21:24organization structure and culture most
- 21:28managers will rank cultural fit is the
- 21:30most important item in a job interview
- 21:31even above analytical thinking there's
- 21:35one caveat to the concept of fit we're
- 21:37not looking to hire people who are just
- 21:39like us
- 21:40research consistently shows the value of
- 21:42diversity in a business setting so we
- 21:45don't want to hire all of the same types
- 21:47of person the uniform guidelines on
- 21:50employee selection procedures known as
- 21:53the ug ESP provide information that can
- 21:57be used to avoid discriminatory hiring
- 21:59practices as well as discrimination in
- 22:01other employment decisions most often
- 22:06simply called the uniform guidelines
- 22:08they were created to guide employers in
- 22:11their efforts to comply with the federal
- 22:13laws concerning all employment decisions
- 22:15especially the selection process let's
- 22:18discuss some of the most important
- 22:19sections of the ug ESP the ug ESP
- 22:26formalizes and standardizes the way in
- 22:28which the federal government identifies
- 22:30and deals with discriminatory employment
- 22:33practices they define the concept
- 22:35of tests for employment that are used in
- 22:38either the selection process or in other
- 22:40employment decisions but what is a test
- 22:43for employment it's a pretty broad term
- 22:47the guidelines themselves specifically
- 22:50say that they apply only to the
- 22:52selection procedures which are used as a
- 22:54basis for making employment decisions we
- 22:59need to select for fit and follow the
- 23:01guidelines in every step of the
- 23:03selection process
- 23:04in simple language validity is the
- 23:08extent to which a test measures what it
- 23:10claims to measure the uniform guidelines
- 23:12require validity in our selection
- 23:14procedures it notes that users may rely
- 23:17upon criterion-related validity studies
- 23:19content validity studies or construct
- 23:22validity studies to validate a
- 23:24particular selection measure but what
- 23:26are these validity measures
- 23:30criterion-related validity is an
- 23:32assessment of the ability of a test to
- 23:34measure some other factor related to the
- 23:36test content validity is an assessment
- 23:41of whether a test measures knowledge or
- 23:43understanding of the items it's supposed
- 23:45to measure so in measuring content
- 23:47validity for selection we have to show
- 23:50that the content of a selection
- 23:51procedure is representative of important
- 23:54aspects of performance of the job a
- 23:56selection procedure can be supported by
- 23:59content validity strategy to the extent
- 24:02that it's representative as a sample of
- 24:04the content of the job in other words if
- 24:06we have good work sample tests or other
- 24:09tests of knowledge skills or abilities
- 24:12that are directly applicable to the job
- 24:14then we can probably use content
- 24:16validity to validate our selection
- 24:18procedure construct validity measures a
- 24:22theoretical concept or trait that's not
- 24:24directly observable for construct
- 24:27validity to be applicable we must
- 24:29demonstrate that a selection procedure
- 24:30measures a construct something believed
- 24:33to be an underlying human trait or
- 24:35characteristic such as honesty and the
- 24:38construct is important for successful
- 24:40job performance
- 24:41for example intelligence is a construct
- 24:44that's measured by an IQ test and
- 24:47research has supported the IQ test
- 24:49validity intelligence is a major
- 24:52predictor of job performance however the
- 24:54uniform guidelines say that this method
- 24:57of validation is far more difficult to
- 24:59demonstrate than the other two options
- 25:01so it would be best if you could show
- 25:03that a measure has criterion related or
- 25:06content validity reliability is the
- 25:10consistency of a test measurement in
- 25:13addition to being valid for a measure to
- 25:15be useful in any type of testing
- 25:17including employment testing it needs to
- 25:19be reliable we want our measures when
- 25:23we're working with people to be reliable
- 25:26measures meaning they should be
- 25:27consistent over time and between people
- 25:32let's put validity and reliability
- 25:34together by stating the obvious if a
- 25:37test is not reliable
- 25:38it can't be valid then we do preliminary
- 25:44screening that may include a background
- 25:46check testing an initial interviewing to
- 25:48narrow down the applicants to the best
- 25:51matches or fit for the job because these
- 25:54preliminary steps may not be done until
- 25:56later in the selection process or may
- 25:59not be done at all and because the
- 26:01process is essentially the same no
- 26:03matter when they're done we'll discuss
- 26:05testing interviewing and background
- 26:07checks in three separate sections but
- 26:10here we'll discuss the application and
- 26:12resume and what you generally can and
- 26:15can't do with those pre-employment
- 26:17enquiries as part of the selection
- 26:20process the recruited candidates are
- 26:22typically asked to complete an
- 26:24application to provide biographical data
- 26:27we need data to aid in selecting the
- 26:29best person for the job
- 26:31organizations may use different
- 26:32application forms for different jobs why
- 26:39does the company need candidates to fill
- 26:41out an application if it already has a
- 26:42resume with the same information there
- 26:44are a couple of reasons first the
- 26:46application gives the company
- 26:48information on the applicant in a
- 26:50standard form this makes it easier to
- 26:52quickly scan and evaluate different
- 26:54applicants second applications almost
- 26:58always have some legal language or
- 27:00disclosures that must be agreed to by
- 27:01the applicant
- 27:03this information will generally include
- 27:04language to inform the applicant of an
- 27:07employment at-will clause allow the
- 27:09company to conduct background and
- 27:10reference checks with the applicants
- 27:12permission tell the applicant that the
- 27:14company will conduct some mandatory
- 27:16tests prior to final employment and
- 27:18inform the applicant that any false
- 27:21information provided will be grounds for
- 27:23immediate termination of any
- 27:24relationship between the company and the
- 27:26applicant in reality we use applications
- 27:32and resumes for much of the same reasons
- 27:34we're trying to figure out your basic
- 27:36skill set background work history
- 27:38education and other core information one
- 27:43area we absolutely want to check is
- 27:46educational level because as you can see
- 27:48from the previous sections of this
- 27:50course it's one of the most commonly
- 27:52exaggerated items on a resume or
- 27:55application form as such the EEOC will
- 27:59use these guidelines anytime it's faced
- 28:01with a discrimination in hiring
- 28:03complaint so every HR manager needs to
- 28:06be familiar with the uniform guidelines
- 28:07and its requirements one of the most
- 28:11common issues in larger organizations
- 28:13and even in some midsize firms is the
- 28:15case where a manager has found a test on
- 28:18the internet and they decide to use it
- 28:20as a candidate screening device in many
- 28:26if not most cases the test has no
- 28:28evidence of validation in any form and
- 28:30should therefore not be used in a
- 28:32selection process if the EEOC
- 28:34investigates a complaint about
- 28:36employment testing being discriminatory
- 28:38the company will have to show that the
- 28:40selection procedure that's being used is
- 28:43valid as a measure for filling the job
- 28:45if the company can't show that the
- 28:49measure is valid it's likely that the
- 28:51EEOC will consider the test a
- 28:53discriminatory hiring practice in 1988
- 28:58the employee polygraph Protection Act or
- 29:01EPP a was passed this Act made it
- 29:04illegal to use a polygraph to test
- 29:06employees honesty in most circumstances
- 29:10however there are two exceptions for
- 29:13organizations and other businesses there
- 29:15are other exceptions
- 29:16for government and national security the
- 29:20use of polygraph tests on prospective
- 29:22employees by any private employer whose
- 29:24primary business for the purpose
- 29:26consists of providing armored-car
- 29:28personnel personnel engaged in the
- 29:30design installation or maintenance of
- 29:32security or alarm systems and uniformed
- 29:35or plainclothes security personnel also
- 29:41the use of polygraph tests by any
- 29:43employer authorized to manufacture
- 29:45distribute or dispense a controlled
- 29:47substance listed on Schedule one two
- 29:50three or four of section 202 of the
- 29:53Controlled Substances Act if you own a
- 29:57store and things are being stolen can
- 29:59you give a polygraph test to all of your
- 30:01employees no the Act says you can there
- 30:04is one other case however where an
- 30:06employer might be allowed to request
- 30:08that an employee submit to testing using
- 30:10a polygraph but the use is severely
- 30:12restricted this only can occur when all
- 30:17of the following apply there is an
- 30:20active investigation involving economic
- 30:22loss or injury to the employers business
- 30:24the employee had access to the property
- 30:27the employer has reasonable suspicion
- 30:29that the employee was involved in the
- 30:31incident or activity under investigation
- 30:33the employer executes and maintains a
- 30:36statement of the facts that will be
- 30:37retained for a period of three years and
- 30:39provides a copy of the statement to the
- 30:42employee however due to the nature of
- 30:46this exemption for ongoing
- 30:47investigations and the ability of the
- 30:49employee to deny the request a polygraph
- 30:52test is probably not generally of
- 30:54significant value to the average
- 30:56employer as such the company would be
- 31:00advised to avoid the use of polygraph in
- 31:02these situations unless there is a clear
- 31:04and convincing evidence of the employees
- 31:07involvement the basis for this testing
- 31:11was an attempt to make sure that a
- 31:12potential employee didn't have a genetic
- 31:15predisposition to certain known
- 31:17illnesses or diseases that might
- 31:19adversely affect the person's ability to
- 31:21work however many individuals felt that
- 31:25this was a significant invasion of their
- 31:27privacy and as a result should
- 31:29be used by a potential employer as a
- 31:33result of these concerns Congress began
- 31:36looking at the issue of genetic testing
- 31:38and in 2008 it passed the genetic
- 31:40information non-discrimination Act known
- 31:43as Gina which protects people from
- 31:45discrimination by health insurers and
- 31:47employers on the basis of their DNA
- 31:49information illegal tests can result in
- 31:54lawsuits some of the major types of
- 31:58written tests include skill tests
- 32:00personality tests interest tests
- 32:03cognitive ability tests which are tests
- 32:06of general intelligence or some type of
- 32:08job-related aptitude and honesty tests
- 32:12today written tests are a common part of
- 32:15the selection process in fact 80% of
- 32:18midsize and large companies use
- 32:20personality and ability assessments for
- 32:23entry and mid-level management positions
- 32:25to help ensure that the right fit
- 32:27between the job candidate and the job
- 32:31companies are seriously concerned that
- 32:33job candidates don't have the skills to
- 32:36match up with their education and
- 32:37degrees and with good reason one recent
- 32:40study noted that Millennials are on
- 32:42track to be the best educated generation
- 32:45in US history but their educational
- 32:47level isn't translating into the job
- 32:49skills that most employers seek and a
- 32:52number of other developed countries are
- 32:54having similar problems so testing is
- 32:57becoming more common to figure out who
- 32:59can perform and who can't
- 33:02skills tests can be either written or
- 33:04done in physical form for now let's
- 33:07discuss written skills testing a skills
- 33:10test is simply an assessment instrument
- 33:12designed to determine if you have the
- 33:14ability to apply a particular knowledge
- 33:16set personality tests measure the
- 33:19psychological traits or characteristics
- 33:21of applicants to determine suitability
- 33:23for performance in a specific type of
- 33:25job the myers-briggs Type Indicator and
- 33:28the Berkman method are two common
- 33:30personality tests interest tests are
- 33:34similar but they measure a person's
- 33:36intellectual curiosity and motivation in
- 33:39a particular field
- 33:42cognitive ability tests are assessments
- 33:44of general intelligence or some type of
- 33:46aptitude for a particular job here again
- 33:49we need to ensure that the tests that
- 33:51may be used are professionally developed
- 33:53reliable and valid indicators of a
- 33:56particular ability or knowledge set
- 33:58otherwise we shouldn't use them as an HR
- 34:02manager you will have to make decisions
- 34:05about whether or not written testing has
- 34:07value in your particular industry
- 34:10physical tests are designed to ensure
- 34:13that applicants are capable of
- 34:15performing on the job and ways defined
- 34:17by the job specification and description
- 34:20physical testing will generally be
- 34:23valuable where there are significant
- 34:25physical skills required to perform a
- 34:27job skills tests determine whether or
- 34:31not you have the ability to apply or use
- 34:33a particular knowledge set physical
- 34:36skills tests are designed to determine
- 34:38whether you have the skills and
- 34:40abilities to perform a particular set of
- 34:42physical tasks these tests can also be
- 34:47conducted in several different forms
- 34:49including by administering work sample
- 34:51tests and assessment centers and by
- 34:54using simulations one option is to have
- 34:58candidates perform a small sample of
- 35:00actual work for the company for free as
- 35:02part of the selection process work
- 35:07sample tests are basically what they
- 35:09sound like we provide a sample of the
- 35:11work that the candidate would perform on
- 35:12the job and ask that candidate to
- 35:14perform the tasks under some type of
- 35:17controlled condition a simple example of
- 35:19a work sample test might be asking the
- 35:22candidate to type a particular letter
- 35:24and then judging the speed and accuracy
- 35:26of the individuals results another might
- 35:29be asking the candidate to lift a
- 35:30package of a similar size and weight to
- 35:32what they'd be lifting on the job an
- 35:36Assessment Center is a more detailed
- 35:38physical testing environment internal
- 35:41and external candidates for positions
- 35:43are often tested through assessment
- 35:45centers assessment centers are places
- 35:47where job applicants undergo a series of
- 35:49tests interviews and simulated
- 35:51experiences to determine their potential
- 35:53for a particular job
- 35:56for physical testing we can also use
- 35:58simulations tests where a candidate are
- 36:01put into a high-pressure situation but
- 36:03in a controlled environment so that the
- 36:05danger and cost are limited simulations
- 36:08are very valuable in cases where a real
- 36:10event could be dangerous emotionally
- 36:12taxing or cost a lot of money
- 36:22you
- 36:28if the job will require heavy physical
- 36:31exertion there may be a legitimate need
- 36:33to have individuals submit to a physical
- 36:35exam to ensure that they are healthy
- 36:37enough for the stress in other cases we
- 36:41may be required by the state or federal
- 36:43government to have individuals who work
- 36:45in specific fields take a physical exam
- 36:47before they're allowed to work in
- 36:49certain jobs such as driving heavy
- 36:51trucks d-o-t physicals or flying a plane
- 36:54an FAA physical or we may just have our
- 36:58candidates take a physical exam before
- 37:00they start work so that we have a
- 37:02baseline knowledge of their health at
- 37:04the time of hire we can then use this
- 37:06baseline later to determine whether they
- 37:08are subjected to conditions that harm
- 37:10them physically for instance if we have
- 37:14a candidate take a physical and the
- 37:16physician finds out that the candidate
- 37:18has significant carpal tunnel syndrome
- 37:20in the wrists it makes it harder for the
- 37:22candidate to claim after being hired the
- 37:24job caused the injury however we may
- 37:28have to be very aware of the potential
- 37:30for discrimination based on disability
- 37:32if we require a physical exam as a
- 37:34prerequisite to work in our organization
- 37:37if the exam is not directly related to
- 37:41the essential functions of the job
- 37:42it may not be advisable for an employer
- 37:45to require it as part of the selection
- 37:47process because of the potential for
- 37:50legal liability and illegal
- 37:51discrimination on the basis of
- 37:53disability a fitness for duty test
- 37:56simply identifies whether or not an
- 37:58employee is physically capable at a
- 38:01particular point of time for performing
- 38:03a specific type of work under what
- 38:06conditions can we generally utilize
- 38:08fitness for duty testing federal law
- 38:10notes that we can use a medical
- 38:12examination if it is job-related and
- 38:14consistent with business necessity of
- 38:16fitness for duty exam is just one type
- 38:19of medical exam in fact this type of
- 38:23testing can be superior to drug testing
- 38:25for certain business purposes for
- 38:27instance if you manage a courier who
- 38:29drives a company vehicle and the driver
- 38:31is not abusing drugs but has gotten any
- 38:33sleep in the past couple of days a
- 38:35fitness for duty test would be quite
- 38:37likely to identify that the courier is
- 38:40unable to make quick correct
- 38:42Asians will a drug test would show that
- 38:44the courier is not impaired due to drug
- 38:46use a common form of this type of test
- 38:48is based on individual reaction time
- 38:51which slows significantly when someone
- 38:53is fatigued in such a case the courier
- 38:58would be required to retest or rest for
- 39:00a certain period of time before being
- 39:02allowed to drive the vehicle another
- 39:04plus of this type of testing is that
- 39:06it's much less invasive and much more
- 39:08acceptable to employees than drug
- 39:10testing if you develop your own test you
- 39:15still have to provide support for its
- 39:16reliability and validity two critically
- 39:19important concepts in the world of
- 39:21selection testing so you have to use
- 39:23experts to develop the test which takes
- 39:25time and significant amounts of money
- 39:28the other option is to use tests that
- 39:30have already been developed and tested
- 39:32for reliability and validity the problem
- 39:34here is that you usually have to pay a
- 39:36fee for every single time you give the
- 39:38test not to mention the time and effort
- 39:40to give and assess the tests themselves
- 39:43so testing can be time-consuming and
- 39:46expensive for employers therefore
- 39:48testing has to pay for itself through
- 39:50its ability to help you hire applicants
- 39:52who are in fact a good fit for the job
- 39:54in the organization it may save you time
- 39:57and money by preventing you from hiring
- 39:59them and immediately losing employees
- 40:01who are a bad fit preventing negligent
- 40:04hires and improving worker productivity
- 40:06by maximizing the chance of hiring good
- 40:08fit employees this justifies the
- 40:13significant investment in the selection
- 40:15test itself in a structured interview
- 40:19all candidates are asked the same list
- 40:22of prepared questions in an unstructured
- 40:25interview there are no pre-planned
- 40:27questions or sequence of topics in a
- 40:31semi structured interview the
- 40:33interviewer has a list of questions but
- 40:35also asks unplanned questions the
- 40:37interviewer departs from the structure
- 40:39when and where appropriate at the same
- 40:42time using a standard set of questions
- 40:44makes it easier to compare candidates
- 40:47the amount of structure you should use
- 40:50depends on your experience as an
- 40:51interviewer the less experience you have
- 40:53the more structure you need
- 40:55one thing to keep in mind is the need to
- 40:58develop a set of consistent questions to
- 41:00ask all candidates so that you can
- 41:02objectively compare the candidates and
- 41:04select the most qualified the questions
- 41:07you ask give you control over the
- 41:09interview they allow you to get to the
- 41:11information you need to make a decision
- 41:14today HR interviewers prefer behavior
- 41:18based questions that ask candidates to
- 41:20describe how they handled specific
- 41:22situations there are two basic types of
- 41:26behavior based questions situational
- 41:28questions and behavior descriptive
- 41:30questions a situational question puts
- 41:34you in a hypothetical situation that you
- 41:36would likely face in the job you're
- 41:38applying for on the other hand a
- 41:41behavioural descriptive question asks
- 41:43you in an open-ended format about
- 41:45something specific that you have done in
- 41:47the past these questions help us find
- 41:51out what you've done in the past and
- 41:52what you're likely to do in the future
- 41:56completing the interview preparation
- 41:58steps will help you improve your
- 41:59interviewing skills step 1
- 42:03review the job description and
- 42:05specifications you cannot effectively
- 42:08match a candidate to a job if you're not
- 42:10thoroughly understanding that job read
- 42:12and become familiar with the job
- 42:14description and job specifications step
- 42:182 prepare a realistic job preview
- 42:21candidates should understand what the
- 42:23job is and what they're expected to do
- 42:25they should know the good and the bad
- 42:27points of the job plan how you'll
- 42:30present a realistic job preview for your
- 42:32next selection process step 3
- 42:36plan the type of interview what level of
- 42:39structure will you use the interview
- 42:42should take place in a private quiet
- 42:43place without interruptions it would be
- 42:46appropriate to begin the interview in an
- 42:48office and then tour facilities while
- 42:50asking questions decide when the tour
- 42:53will take place and what questions will
- 42:54be asked take a list of the questions
- 42:57that you want to ask during that
- 42:58interview step 4 develop questions for
- 43:04all candidates your questions should be
- 43:06job-related non-discriminatory and in
- 43:09the
- 43:09of a structured interview asked of all
- 43:11candidates use the job description and
- 43:14specifications to develop questions that
- 43:16relate to each job tasks and
- 43:18responsibilities use a mixture of
- 43:20closed-ended open-ended and hypothetical
- 43:22questions don't be concerned about the
- 43:24order of questions just write them out
- 43:26at this point
- 43:28step 5 develop a form once you've
- 43:31created a list of questions determine
- 43:33the sequence start with the easy
- 43:35questions one approach starts with
- 43:37closed-ended questions moves on to more
- 43:40open-ended questions and then to
- 43:42hypothetical questions and uses probing
- 43:44questions as needed
- 43:45another approach structures the
- 43:47interview around the job description and
- 43:49specifications each responsibility is
- 43:51explained and then questions are asked
- 43:53related to each step 6
- 43:56develop questions for each candidate
- 43:58review each candidates application and
- 44:00resume you'll most likely want to add
- 44:02specific questions to a copy of the form
- 44:05to verify or clarify some of the
- 44:07information provided the job interview
- 44:12is commonly given the most weight in the
- 44:14selection process following these steps
- 44:18you'll do a better job of interviewing
- 44:20candidates step 1 open the interview
- 44:24develop rapport put the candidate at
- 44:27ease by talking about some topic not
- 44:29necessarily related just to the job
- 44:31maintain eye contact in a way that's
- 44:33comfortable for you in the candidate
- 44:35step to present the realistic job
- 44:38preview be sure the candidate
- 44:40understands the job and its requirements
- 44:42answer any questions the candidate has
- 44:44about the job and the organization step
- 44:483 ask your questions to get the most out
- 44:51of a job interview you must take notes
- 44:52on responses to those questions tell the
- 44:55candidate that you've prepared a list of
- 44:57questions that you plan on taking notes
- 44:59as you ask those questions and
- 45:00dialoguing with them about the job step
- 45:044 introduce top candidates to coworkers
- 45:06introduce top candidates to people with
- 45:09whom they'll be working to get a sense
- 45:11of the candidates interpersonal skills
- 45:12and overall attitude step 5
- 45:15close the interview be honest and don't
- 45:18lead candidates on think candidates for
- 45:21their time and tell them what the next
- 45:22step in the
- 45:23selection process is tell candidates
- 45:25when you'll contact them in the future
- 45:28be sure to get coworkers impressions of
- 45:31each candidate because they'll have to
- 45:33work with the candidate if they're hired
- 45:36background checks are needed to help
- 45:38prevent negligent hiring during the
- 45:42selection process in addition to
- 45:44verification of the information on a
- 45:46candidate's application and their resume
- 45:48several other types of background checks
- 45:50may or may not be appropriate it's not
- 45:54unusual for the background check to be a
- 45:56simple pass or fail background checks
- 45:59can become rather expensive depending on
- 46:01which checks we do and how often we have
- 46:03to do them so they're usually left until
- 46:06we have at least narrowed down the list
- 46:08of candidates to a final few or in most
- 46:10cases even a final candidate we may
- 46:15offer employment to the candidate
- 46:17conditioned on passing various
- 46:18background checks remember though that
- 46:20you cannot use a background check to
- 46:22discriminate in violation of federal or
- 46:24state law although several states have
- 46:28recently put limits on its use one of
- 46:30the most commonly used background check
- 46:32is the credit check credit checks are
- 46:38subject to the Fair Credit Reporting Act
- 46:40known as FIR Kragh which requires
- 46:42employers to disclose to the applicant
- 46:44that they will use credit reports for
- 46:46employment decisions the acts also says
- 46:49that if the information on the credit
- 46:50report results in adverse employment
- 46:52action the employer has to give a copy
- 46:55of the report to the person and inform
- 46:57the applicant of their rights under
- 46:59FERPA including the right to dispute the
- 47:01report when can employers complete
- 47:06credit checks on applicants and why
- 47:08would they do it at all credit checks
- 47:10will most likely be done if applicants
- 47:12will have access to any money or if they
- 47:14will work with the company's financial
- 47:15information credit checks may also be
- 47:18done with other employees who evaluate
- 47:20their personal responsibility to see if
- 47:23they have a habit of being dishonest in
- 47:25credit transactions a history of not
- 47:29paying bills tells the organization that
- 47:31the person is likely to be dishonest in
- 47:33other ways as well does something like a
- 47:35bankruptcy on your credit
- 47:37or automatically knock you out of
- 47:38contention for a job
- 47:40no in fact by law the company can't
- 47:42refuse to hire you solely because of a
- 47:45negative issue like a bankruptcy on a
- 47:47credit check
- 47:47however again if your credit report
- 47:50shows a pattern of failure to live up to
- 47:52your credit obligations the company can
- 47:54and probably will use that information
- 47:56to remove you from the applicant pool as
- 47:59long as the company's home state allows
- 48:01it credit reports also give the employer
- 48:05other reference information that can be
- 48:07used in background checks all states
- 48:11allow criminal background checks at
- 48:12least in some cases however laws vary so
- 48:16significantly across jurisdictions that
- 48:18it's difficult to enumerate the
- 48:20circumstances in which criminal
- 48:21background checks are allowed can or
- 48:26should a criminal record keep someone
- 48:28from being hired it depends on a few
- 48:30things the nature and seriousness of the
- 48:32offense how long ago it occurred and
- 48:34what type of job the individual is being
- 48:36considered for reference checks include
- 48:41not only calls to references that are
- 48:42provided by the applicant but also
- 48:44reference letters from employers
- 48:46personal letters of recommendation and
- 48:48possibly cold calls from previous
- 48:50employers finally with the ability to
- 48:54access very large amounts of information
- 48:56via the Internet virtually all
- 48:58organizations are using the Internet to
- 49:00do research on job candidates whenever
- 49:02they're allowed to do so by applicable
- 49:04federal state and local laws googling a
- 49:07candidates name is becoming a standard
- 49:08practice should social media be used as
- 49:13a selection device HR departments are
- 49:15going to use the tools that they have
- 49:17available to get the best possible
- 49:18people so social media will most likely
- 49:21continue to be a tool that's used in the
- 49:23recruiting and selection process however
- 49:26we need to be very careful to avoid
- 49:28using information that would be illegal
- 49:30in consideration for employment
- 49:34employers will most likely do a web
- 49:36search on you as a candidate in today's
- 49:38business world and this goes for
- 49:40part-time jobs summer jobs and
- 49:42internships as well as full-time
- 49:44positions also make sure your email
- 49:46addresses and telephone messages are
- 49:48professional for job searching
- 49:51there are two basic methods that we use
- 49:54to make final selection decisions for an
- 49:56organization the multiple hurdle
- 50:00selection model requires that each
- 50:02applicant must pass a particular
- 50:04selection test in order to go on to the
- 50:06next test if an applicant fails to pass
- 50:09any of the selection tests in the
- 50:10process the person is immediately
- 50:12removed from the running on the other
- 50:15hand the compensatory selection model
- 50:17allows an individual to do poorly on a
- 50:20test but make up for that poor grade by
- 50:22doing exceptionally well on other tests
- 50:26again each step of the selection process
- 50:28like interviews and background checks is
- 50:31a test using the compensatory model
- 50:35allows the employer to rank each of the
- 50:37candidates based on their overall score
- 50:39from all of the testing the employer can
- 50:41also group candidates based on this
- 50:43information so after all selection
- 50:47activities are completed compare each
- 50:49candidates qualifications to job
- 50:51specifications identify whether or not
- 50:54this person really wants to do the job
- 50:56and analyze whether or not the
- 50:57individual has been basically honest
- 50:59during the selection process do all of
- 51:04this to determine who would be the best
- 51:06possible fit for the job be sure to get
- 51:08coworkers impressions of each candidate
- 51:10when appropriate because they'll have to
- 51:13work and get along with one another
- 51:14depending on who you hire diversity
- 51:17should also be considered during the
- 51:19selection process so to bring this
- 51:23selection process to an end contract the
- 51:26best possible candidate and offer that
- 51:28person the job if the candidate does not
- 51:31accept the job offer or accepts but
- 51:33leaves after a short period of time you
- 51:35can frequently offer the next best
- 51:37candidate the job
- 51:40[Music]
- 51:45you
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Introduction to Recruitment by GreggU, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,759 words across 1,241 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.