Integrity in EBRD Funded Projects Training Video (Armenian Subtitles) — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00foreign
- 0:05course during the next half hour or so
- 0:09we will cover what the ebrd expects of
- 0:11clients and Consultants that work on
- 0:13ebrd funded contracts
- 0:16the course is designed to help you
- 0:18understand the ebrd's approach to
- 0:20integrity and compliance
- 0:23policies and procedures the bank applies
- 0:25and finally how you play an important
- 0:28role in ensuring that the ebrd is able
- 0:30to achieve its mission on the ground by
- 0:33reporting misconduct and other issues
- 0:39foreign
- 0:40first of all the course will provide you
- 0:42with an understanding of what the ebrd
- 0:44means when it talks about integrity
- 0:47not just the concept itself but also how
- 0:50this is anchored in every aspect of the
- 0:52bank's work
- 0:53[Music]
- 0:55we will then talk about what the ebrd
- 0:57does when it finds issues in its
- 0:59projects how it assesses problems and
- 1:02what action it takes to protect its
- 1:04funds and reputation
- 1:06last but not least the course will
- 1:09explain how you can help the ebrd uphold
- 1:11Integrity standards and what you must do
- 1:14if you become aware of issues that you
- 1:16think are not right
- 1:17[Music]
- 1:19we will also explain how you can contact
- 1:21the ebrd if you have any questions or if
- 1:24anything we have covered today has been
- 1:26unclear
- 1:31so what does the ebrd mean when it
- 1:34speaks about integrity
- 1:36Integrity or being Guided by clear and
- 1:40consistent moral principles underpins
- 1:42everything the ebrd does there are
- 1:45several components to this
- 1:47Integrity is most clearly reflected in
- 1:51conduct be it for the ebrd or its
- 1:54counterparties
- 1:55not engaging in bribery and other forms
- 1:58of corruption treating customers and
- 2:01employees properly and making sure that
- 2:04every action you take is rooted in
- 2:06honesty and fairness
- 2:08all of these are signs of a person or
- 2:11organization striving to conduct itself
- 2:14positively
- 2:15the second building block of Integrity
- 2:17is transparency
- 2:19reality can be complex and as we shall
- 2:22see later some challenging situations
- 2:24may be unavoidable
- 2:26the key here is to communicate openly
- 2:28and proactively addressing and
- 2:31disclosing issues head-on
- 2:33positive conduct and transparency in
- 2:36turn are what determines your and our
- 2:38reputation maintaining a reputation as a
- 2:42fair and honest counterparty is
- 2:44extremely important to the evrd and we
- 2:47expect that our counterparties are also
- 2:49focused on maintaining good reputations
- 2:51locally and internationally
- 2:55now that we have defined Integrity why
- 2:58does the ebrd care about it
- 3:00the first thing to always remember is
- 3:02that the ebrd is a public institution it
- 3:06is capitalized with taxpayer funds from
- 3:08over 72 countries including yours and is
- 3:12also a major conduit for donor funds
- 3:16the bank and each of its staff members
- 3:18is therefore not only responsible to the
- 3:21ebrd's management and board but also to
- 3:24every member of the public
- 3:27the ebrd also plays an important role in
- 3:30the International Development
- 3:31architecture and is supported by many
- 3:34national governments and international
- 3:36organizations to administer and channel
- 3:39donor funds to where they are needed
- 3:42the ebrd needs to therefore protect its
- 3:46funds which are owned by the public and
- 3:49its reputation which is key for its
- 3:51ability to do its work
- 3:56Integrity is deeply rooted in the ebrd's
- 3:59work this can be summarized as
- 4:02transition with integrity and reflected
- 4:05in the ebrd's transition qualities
- 4:09creating market economies that are free
- 4:11from corruption is anchored in the
- 4:14well-governed transition quality and
- 4:16therefore one of the guiding principles
- 4:18underlying the ebrd's mission
- 4:20[Music]
- 4:24practical terms this means that the ebrd
- 4:27takes concrete steps to fight corruption
- 4:29through its work
- 4:31this is done by carefully scrutinizing
- 4:33its Partners to avoid those involved in
- 4:35corruption investigating allegations and
- 4:38reports of wrongdoing and also helping
- 4:41Partners who may have been involved in
- 4:43issues and want to reform
- 4:46as outlined at the beginning of this
- 4:48session the ebrd's clients and partners
- 4:51need to show that they engage in
- 4:53appropriate conduct
- 4:54are committed to transparency and
- 4:57therefore Safeguard their reputations
- 5:01finally when and where necessary the
- 5:04ebrd will enforce its Integrity
- 5:06standards to do so it relies on its
- 5:09enforcement policy and procedures and
- 5:11the prohibited practices it contains
- 5:14[Music]
- 5:15we'll cover the enforcement policy and
- 5:17procedures in more detail later but
- 5:19let's run through the prohibited
- 5:21practices here briefly to understand
- 5:23what Behavior the bank does not want to
- 5:25see
- 5:28we will also illustrate the different
- 5:29practices with some case studies drawn
- 5:32from real life problems
- 5:34as you listen to their prohibited
- 5:36practices and case studies keep in mind
- 5:39that the same negative behavior can fall
- 5:42under different prohibited practices
- 5:45they can intersect and often depend on
- 5:48one another
- 5:51what are prohibited practices
- 5:54fraud
- 5:55any act or a mission including a
- 5:58misrepresentation that knowingly or
- 6:01recklessly misleads or attempts to
- 6:03mislead a party to obtain a financial or
- 6:07other benefit or to avoid an obligation
- 6:12collusion
- 6:14an arrangement between two or more
- 6:16parties designed to achieve an improper
- 6:18purpose including to influence
- 6:20improperly the actions of another party
- 6:24corruption offering giving receiving or
- 6:28soliciting directly or indirectly of
- 6:31anything of value to influence
- 6:33improperly the actions of another party
- 6:37scenario sharing the spoils
- 6:41a company has had a 10 000 US dollar
- 6:43Grant agreed by the ebrd after
- 6:46submitting a proposal to enhance its
- 6:48financial management system with the
- 6:50help of a consultant
- 6:52prior to approaching the ebrd the
- 6:55consultant and the company agreed to
- 6:57carry out the work for 5 000 US dollars
- 7:01they share the remaining 5 000 US
- 7:03Dollars between themselves
- 7:06this is a clear-cut case of fraud
- 7:09a company and consultant have
- 7:11misrepresented the true cost of the
- 7:13assignment to the ebrd both sides have
- 7:17also engaged in collusion by agreeing to
- 7:20defraud the ebrd
- 7:22more broadly the conduct of both the
- 7:25company and consultant Falls far short
- 7:27of the ebrd's expectations for the
- 7:29Integrity of its partners the ebrd would
- 7:33take such Behavior into account When
- 7:35selecting Partners even if the conduct
- 7:37occurred in non-ebrd projects
- 7:42what are prohibited practices
- 7:45misuse of Bank resources or Bank assets
- 7:48improper use of the bank's resources or
- 7:51Bank assets committed either knowingly
- 7:53or recklessly
- 7:55theft
- 7:56misappropriation of property belonging
- 7:59to another party
- 8:01coercion impairing or harming or
- 8:05threatening to impair or harm directly
- 8:07or indirectly any party or the property
- 8:11of any party to influence improperly the
- 8:14actions of a party
- 8:17obstruction
- 8:19one
- 8:21destroying falsifying altering or
- 8:24concealing of evidence material to a
- 8:26bank investigation which impedes the
- 8:29bank's investigation
- 8:31too making false statements to
- 8:34investigators in order to materially
- 8:36impede a bank investigation into
- 8:39allegations of a prohibited practice
- 8:42three
- 8:43failing to comply with requests to
- 8:46provide information
- 8:48documents or records in connection with
- 8:51a bank investigation
- 8:534. threatening harassing or intimidating
- 8:56any party to prevent it from disclosing
- 8:59its knowledge of matters relevant to a
- 9:01bank investigation or from pursuing the
- 9:05investigation or five materially
- 9:09impeding the exercise of the bank's
- 9:12contractual rights of audit or
- 9:14inspection or access to information
- 9:20scenario one contract two funders
- 9:25a company receives financial support
- 9:27from the ebrd to enhance its Human
- 9:29Resources function with support from a
- 9:32consultant
- 9:33the consultant approaches a local
- 9:35government entity with the same
- 9:37assignment the disguising that it is
- 9:39already funded by the ebrd and receives
- 9:42additional support
- 9:44when the ebrd learns of this and starts
- 9:47this investigation the consultant
- 9:49attempts to pressure local government
- 9:51representatives to confirm to the ebrd
- 9:54that there is no issue
- 9:57in addition to fraud like in the
- 9:59previous example the consultant has
- 10:02engaged in theft by double funding the
- 10:04assignment
- 10:06finally by attempting to pressure local
- 10:09government Representatives the
- 10:11consultant has engaged in coercion and
- 10:14also in obstruction
- 10:18he was aware of the practice they would
- 10:20be held equally responsible
- 10:24conflicts of interest
- 10:26in addition to activities captured by
- 10:28the ebrd's prohibited practices real and
- 10:31perceived conflicts of interest are key
- 10:33issues that frequently arise in its work
- 10:36conflicts of interest are situations or
- 10:38circumstances in which private interests
- 10:41influence or may influence objective and
- 10:44impartial decision-making
- 10:47private interests include any advantage
- 10:50for yourself your families or personal
- 10:53acquaintances
- 10:55given appropriate circumstances
- 10:57conflicts can be managed more about that
- 11:01later
- 11:02it is important to remember that the
- 11:04ebrd will not only consider your
- 11:06interest when assessing or investigating
- 11:08conflicts the bank will also scrutinize
- 11:11situations in which family members
- 11:13friends or acquaintances have or appear
- 11:16to have benefited unduly
- 11:19however
- 11:20if the context is right and proper
- 11:22actions are taken conflicts can be
- 11:25managed let's look at a case study to
- 11:27illustrate this
- 11:29scenario it's all about transparency a
- 11:33company receives financial support from
- 11:35the ebrd to build a quality management
- 11:37system and have it independently
- 11:39certified
- 11:41the company hires a consultant for this
- 11:43assignment
- 11:44the consultant in turn hires a local
- 11:47certification agency
- 11:50the ebrd later learns that the
- 11:52certification body is owned by a close
- 11:55relative of the consultant
- 11:58the issues here would depend on how
- 12:01transparent the consultant has been
- 12:03if the relationship was disclosed there
- 12:06is a clear rationale for the selection
- 12:08of the certification agency and there
- 12:11are no irregularities in the prize this
- 12:13conflict may be manageable if the
- 12:16relationship was not disclosed and is
- 12:18subsequently discovered it reflects
- 12:21poorly on the consultant's business
- 12:23practices and may lead to a review to
- 12:26assess if any prohibited practices or
- 12:28other adverse conduct have occurred
- 12:32we have now covered what the ebrd
- 12:34considers as integrity and the
- 12:36prohibited practices in the ebrd's
- 12:38projects
- 12:40in this next section we will address
- 12:42what the ebrd does when it encounters
- 12:44prohibited practices in its projects
- 12:48the ebrd policy that addresses
- 12:51prohibited practices is the enforcement
- 12:53policy and procedures or the Epps the
- 12:58Epps set out how the ebrd will address
- 13:01prohibited practices in its projects you
- 13:05can find a copy of the Epps on the ebrd
- 13:08website
- 13:09the department within the ebrd that
- 13:12handles prohibited practices is the
- 13:14office of the chief compliance officer
- 13:17or OKO OKO receives allegations and
- 13:21conducts investigations and if necessary
- 13:24recommends whether to resolve the
- 13:26allegations through no further action or
- 13:29sanction
- 13:30when we speak about occo investigations
- 13:33we should be clear that these are not
- 13:35like investigations by the police or
- 13:37national authorities
- 13:39OKO does not have the power to compel
- 13:42parties to answer questions or provide
- 13:44information
- 13:45instead Orco investigations are
- 13:48conducted through requests of
- 13:50information Audits and interviews with
- 13:53Witnesses
- 13:54a failure to respond and cooperate could
- 13:57result in a finding of an obstructive
- 14:00practice
- 14:02during the investigation OKO will
- 14:05provide an opportunity for the
- 14:06individual or entity being investigated
- 14:09to respond to the allegations and
- 14:11present their side of the story
- 14:14OKO gathers the information through its
- 14:17investigation but it does not decide
- 14:19whether an individual or entity should
- 14:22be sanctioned
- 14:23that role is played by the enforcement
- 14:25commissioner who acts like a judge
- 14:27independent from OKO if occo's
- 14:30investigation determines that the
- 14:32allegations are more likely than not to
- 14:34be true occo will make a submission to
- 14:37the enforcement commissioner requesting
- 14:38that the individual or entity is
- 14:41sanctioned
- 14:42[Music]
- 14:43the enforcement commissioner will notify
- 14:45the individual or entity that OKO has
- 14:47referred the matter to them and the
- 14:50individual or entity will have an
- 14:51opportunity to defend itself before the
- 14:54enforcement commissioner makes their
- 14:55decision
- 14:57if the individual or entity disagrees
- 14:59with the enforcement commissioner's
- 15:00decision the individual or entity can
- 15:03appeal to the ebrd's enforcement
- 15:05committee which is made up of five
- 15:06members three of whom are external
- 15:11what are the sanctions that the ebrd can
- 15:13impose
- 15:15the Epps provide for a range of
- 15:18sanctions to reflect the seriousness of
- 15:20the wrongdoing
- 15:22for minor wrongdoing the ebrd can issue
- 15:25a letter of reprimand
- 15:27however the sanction normally imposed by
- 15:30the ebrd and the most serious sanction
- 15:32is debarment
- 15:34debarment means that a company or
- 15:37individual is prevented from being an
- 15:39ebrd counterparty and cannot be a
- 15:42recipient in any ebrd Finance project
- 15:46a debate entity and individual cannot
- 15:49submit a tender in any ebrd Finance
- 15:52procurement or take any part in any
- 15:55aspect of that project whether as a
- 15:57supplier sub supplier or consultant
- 16:00if you are debarred your name will be
- 16:03published on the list of ineligible
- 16:05entities located on the ebrd's website
- 16:08while this may not seem like a severe
- 16:10sanction this list is used by many
- 16:13institutions including Banks government
- 16:16agencies and the private sector in order
- 16:19to determine the reputation of the
- 16:21business partners
- 16:23D Barman can have a severe impact on a
- 16:26company's business and reputation
- 16:29some companies and individuals will also
- 16:32be subject to cross-devironment
- 16:34Krusty Barman means that the company and
- 16:36individual will also be ineligible for
- 16:39financing from the Asian development
- 16:41Bank African Development Bank
- 16:43inter-american Development Bank and
- 16:45World Bank
- 16:47their names will also be published on
- 16:49the website of each Institution
- 16:53now that we have explained what the ebrd
- 16:55does we are going to explain what the
- 16:57ebrd expects you to do
- 17:01as a party in an ebrd Finance project
- 17:04you have a responsibility to help root
- 17:07out fraud and corruption in ebrd
- 17:10projects
- 17:11when you suspect that wrongdoing may
- 17:13have occurred you must report suspicions
- 17:15of wrongdoing to the ebrd
- 17:18it is important to note that you do not
- 17:19need to be certain that the suspicions
- 17:21are true
- 17:22as long as you genuinely believe the
- 17:25information you are providing to be true
- 17:26you have a good faith basis and you
- 17:29should report your concerns
- 17:32you can make an anonymous report through
- 17:34the ebrd website under the link report
- 17:37fraud and Corruption or you can report
- 17:41your concerns to your local ebrd office
- 17:46you may be asking yourself why you
- 17:48should report wrongdoing
- 17:50this may be especially true if you think
- 17:53that the wrongdoing was not your fault
- 17:55or you do not believe that you have the
- 17:57full story
- 17:59first you should report your suspicions
- 18:02because you may be required to under the
- 18:04financing agreement and other documents
- 18:06with the ebrd for instance the ebrd's
- 18:10Covenant of integrity and contractual
- 18:13Provisions require you to report
- 18:15suspicions of prohibited practices and
- 18:18failure to do so could constitute a
- 18:21breach of your obligations
- 18:23but
- 18:24also consider that reporting wrongdoing
- 18:27can help protect the ebrd and donor
- 18:30financing to your country or region by
- 18:33reporting wrongdoing you are helping to
- 18:35prevent Bad actors in your country from
- 18:38abusing the ebrd's financing and you are
- 18:41helping the ebrd to direct financing to
- 18:44parties that are more deserving of our
- 18:46financial assistance
- 18:49reporting wrongdoing also helps remove
- 18:51Bad actors from ruining the business
- 18:53reputation of your country which can
- 18:55have negative effects on the foreign
- 18:57investment
- 18:58these Bad actors are creating an unfair
- 19:01system and they should not be allowed to
- 19:03freely operate
- 19:05finally if you committed wrongdoing
- 19:08reporting it early to the ebrd could
- 19:11lead to a reduction in sanction for
- 19:13instance if you neglected to report a
- 19:16conflict of interest initially reporting
- 19:18a conflict of interest as early as you
- 19:20realize you have made a mistake could
- 19:22result in a more lenient sanction or
- 19:24perhaps no sanction at all
- 19:27that brings us to the end of this
- 19:29training session thank you very much for
- 19:31your time and attention we hope that
- 19:33this training has provided you with
- 19:35clear guidance and information
- 19:37you can visit the links on this slide or
- 19:39on the ebrd's website if you want to
- 19:41learn more about the bank's approach to
- 19:43integrity and compliance
- 19:46you're free to send any questions that
- 19:48you may have using the link provided we
- 19:50would be happy to help
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Integrity in EBRD Funded Projects Training Video (Armenian Subtitles) by European Bank for Reconstruction and Development, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,566 words across 472 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.