YouTube2Text

Inflazione al 5%: perché ti serve un aumento dell’10% — Transcript

by The Bull · 4,860 words · 799 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00Inflation in Italy in October was 5.4%.
  2. 0:05If we earn € 38,000 gross per year and,
  3. 0:08with inflation at 5.4%, we simply want
  4. 0:10to maintain our purchasing power, how
  5. 0:12big of a raise do we need?
  6. 0:155.4%, one would say, right?
  7. 0:18It seems logical. Actually no, we need
  8. 0:21more than 10%.
  9. 0:24And not to be better off, not to buy
  10. 0:26more things, just to stay at the same
  11. 0:28point; and a 10%annual raise, let's be
  12. 0:30honest, almost nobody gets that.
  13. 0:34It sounds crazy, but this is exactly
  14. 0:36what really happens to our pockets in
  15. 0:38real life, not in Excel files.
  16. 0:41The reason is that for every € 100 raise
  17. 0:44in that income bracket, only about 40
  18. 0:46reach our pockets.
  19. 0:48The other 60 are split up. Social
  20. 0:50security contributions, income tax,
  21. 0:51disappearing deductions, and local
  22. 0:53surtaxes. And the most absurd thing is
  23. 0:55that those who earn double get to keep
  24. 0:57more of those € 100, about 50.
  25. 1:01By the end of this episode, we will know
  26. 1:03why a salary alone is not enough and how
  27. 1:06to invest to truly grow our purchasing
  28. 1:08power, especially in this environment
  29. 1:10where inflation seems to be a travel
  30. 1:12companion we won't get rid of anytime
  31. 1:14soon.
  32. 1:15But, above all, we will understand that
  33. 1:18defending ourselves against inflation
  34. 1:20can mean two very different things that
  35. 1:22require two very different portfolios.
  36. 1:25Get comfortable, let’s defuse the tax
  37. 1:28traps and save the value of our savings
  38. 1:30. In this podcast, we talk about money
  39. 1:33and tell it like it is to learn how to
  40. 1:35invest better and build the life we
  41. 1:37desire. If you haven't already, follow
  42. 1:40the channel on YouTube, Spotify, or
  43. 1:42Apple Podcasts. It costs you nothing,
  44. 1:44but for me, it is a vital gesture to
  45. 1:46keep this channel going.
  46. 1:49So, we were saying that in October,
  47. 1:51inflation in Italy rose to 5.4%from 4.2
  48. 1:54%in September.
  49. 1:56Of course, the vast majority of that
  50. 1:58figure depends on energy prices, which
  51. 1:59skyrocketed due to the war in Iran.
  52. 2:02But energy inflation sooner or later
  53. 2:04spreads into the real economy, and once
  54. 2:06the prices of goods and services go up,
  55. 2:08they rarely come back down.
  56. 2:11And in any case, as we have said many
  57. 2:13times before, we find ourselves in an
  58. 2:15economy that is structurally dominated
  59. 2:17by scarcity and supply crises: energy,
  60. 2:19defense spending, geopolitical
  61. 2:21fragmentation, infrastructure investment
  62. 2:23spending, and much more.
  63. 2:25Not to mention the persistent deficits
  64. 2:27of almost all major countries in the
  65. 2:29world.
  66. 2:30If you accumulate budget deficits every
  67. 2:32year and increase the debt stock to
  68. 2:34finance public spending, then inflation
  69. 2:36works in favor of the debtor and to the
  70. 2:38detriment of creditors and consumers.
  71. 2:41The real value of debt decreases, but
  72. 2:43the price is paid by the holders of
  73. 2:44those government bonds and by consumers
  74. 2:46who face higher prices.
  75. 2:48So let's resign ourselves to it.
  76. 2:51The stagnant inflation of the 2010s
  77. 2:53probably won't be on the menu for a
  78. 2:54while, and, by the way, if it does
  79. 2:56return, it might be for reasons that are
  80. 2:58not exactly desirable, like a nasty
  81. 3:00recession.
  82. 3:02But if inflation is to be our unpleasant
  83. 3:04traveling companion, what solutions do
  84. 3:05we have?
  85. 3:08Well, if things are going to cost more,
  86. 3:09perhaps much more and persistently, the
  87. 3:11most intuitive path seems to be
  88. 3:13increasing income, right?
  89. 3:15Earning more.
  90. 3:17Before Debull, I worked as a headhunter
  91. 3:19for 14 years. I met tens of thousands of
  92. 3:22people, and the most frequent scene was
  93. 3:24always the same.
  94. 3:26A candidate changing jobs, with
  95. 3:28everything that entails, for a 10-20%
  96. 3:30salary increase.
  97. 3:33Then the first paycheck would arrive,
  98. 3:35and if we start from € 35,000 gross, for
  99. 3:37example, the average increase is around
  100. 3:39€ 5,000, which becomes about € 1,900 net
  101. 3:42per year, which, divided by 14 months,
  102. 3:44comes to € 136 per month.
  103. 3:47Now, it's not irrelevant, heaven forbid
  104. 3:49, but it very much has the effect of
  105. 3:51spinach in a pan: when you put it in, it
  106. 3:53overflows, and 10 minutes later, it
  107. 3:55would fit on a coffee saucer.
  108. 3:57If you think it's little that € 5,000
  109. 4:00gross becomes € 1,900 net, well, this
  110. 4:02difference is the marginal tax rate, and
  111. 4:05when the raise only serves to keep up
  112. 4:07with rising prices, it's called fiscal
  113. 4:10drag.
  114. 4:11It works like this. In Italy, income tax
  115. 4:13brackets are fixed in nominal euros.
  116. 4:16You pay 23%up to € 28,000 of income, 33
  117. 4:19%up to 50,000—or perhaps 55,000 with the
  118. 4:23new reform—and 43%above that.
  119. 4:26Those thresholds, however, don't move
  120. 4:28with prices, so when our salary rises to
  121. 4:30keep up with inflation, a larger and
  122. 4:32larger part of our income ends up in the
  123. 4:35higher bracket, even if in real terms we
  124. 4:37aren't earning a single euro more.
  125. 4:40Double bad luck: inflation eats away at
  126. 4:42my purchasing power on its own, and on
  127. 4:44top of that, I have to pay more taxes.
  128. 4:46And then there is an aggravating factor
  129. 4:48: deductions.
  130. 4:49Employee tax deductions are the amount
  131. 4:51the state discounts from our taxes,
  132. 4:53which decreases as income rises.
  133. 4:56Between € 28,000 and € 50,000 of taxable
  134. 4:58income, every extra euro we earn makes
  135. 5:00us lose a piece of the deduction, and
  136. 5:02between € 32,000 and € 40,000 another
  137. 5:04one is added—the one introduced with the
  138. 5:06tax wedge cut—which zeroes out in that
  139. 5:08range.
  140. 5:09Now let's put it all together. Once
  141. 5:12contributions are deducted from an extra
  142. 5:14€ 100 of taxable income, we must then
  143. 5:16subtract 33 for the tax rate, nearly 9
  144. 5:18due to lost employee deductions, and 12
  145. 5:20and a half for another vanishing
  146. 5:22deduction, totaling € 54 in income tax
  147. 5:24out of 100. And that is still excluding
  148. 5:26regional and municipal surtaxes.
  149. 5:29For the record, in this little
  150. 5:30calculation we just performed, the
  151. 5:32entire tragedy of the Italian economy is
  152. 5:33captured in a nutshell.
  153. 5:36The exorbitant cost a company must bear
  154. 5:38to increase an employee's income versus
  155. 5:39the pittance that remains, with real
  156. 5:41wages that on average haven't grown
  157. 5:43since I was in elementary school.
  158. 5:45Now, let's take this already tragicomic
  159. 5:48situation and pile 5.4%inflation on top
  160. 5:50of it.
  161. 5:52The question is the one from the
  162. 5:54beginning: by how much must I increase
  163. 5:56my gross salary just to preserve my
  164. 5:58purchasing power?
  165. 5:59Across the entire income curve, you need
  166. 6:02more than inflation, and in the middle
  167. 6:04bracket, almost double.
  168. 6:05And recent experience tells us that is
  169. 6:07not what typically happens.
  170. 6:10The Bank of Italy ran the numbers for
  171. 6:12the 2022-2025 period—the time of the
  172. 6:14great price surge following the start of
  173. 6:16the war in Ukraine—and found that income
  174. 6:18adjustments covered, on average, barely
  175. 6:2062%of inflation.
  176. 6:22To be fair, it must be said that the
  177. 6:24same Bank of Italy study reports that
  178. 6:26the tax cuts decided by governments
  179. 6:27during those years more than compensated
  180. 6:29for those 18 billion in fiscal drag on
  181. 6:31average.
  182. 6:32But I say "on average" because the
  183. 6:34recovery came when and how the
  184. 6:36government decided, not automatically;
  185. 6:38that is, it is a discretionary refund:
  186. 6:40sometimes it arrives, sometimes it
  187. 6:42doesn't, and we never know to whom in
  188. 6:44advance. And if we widen our view, the
  189. 6:46picture is even clearer.
  190. 6:48Compared to 20 years ago, average real
  191. 6:51wages are still worth 5%less.
  192. 6:53It is obvious that salaries and the real
  193. 6:55economy in Italy stopped speaking to
  194. 6:56each other a long time ago.
  195. 6:58Be careful, though, because I don't want
  196. 7:00the wrong message to get across.
  197. 7:02The first asset class against inflation
  198. 7:04is us: our ability to earn, our human
  199. 7:06capital, is our most important asset.
  200. 7:09I confirm this word for word.
  201. 7:13Asking for a raise, changing jobs at the
  202. 7:14right time, investing in skills that the
  203. 7:16market pays for.
  204. 7:18Following The Bull Playbook, which comes
  205. 7:19out every other Friday with guests much
  206. 7:21more extraordinary than me.
  207. 7:23All of this remains fundamental.
  208. 7:26But today's numbers tell us that all of
  209. 7:27this is not enough. Your salary is the
  210. 7:29fuel, but with raises that chase
  211. 7:31inflation and a tax system that takes
  212. 7:33nearly 2/3 of it in the wrong bracket,
  213. 7:35it’s like having a car that gets 10 km
  214. 7:37per liter.
  215. 7:38You need an efficient engine, and
  216. 7:40obviously, the engine is making the
  217. 7:41money we manage to set aside work for us
  218. 7:43.
  219. 7:44Except here comes the second nasty
  220. 7:46surprise, because the same mechanism
  221. 7:48that screws us on our paycheck awaits us
  222. 7:50identically with our investments.
  223. 7:53But before the second screw-up, let's
  224. 7:54say right away how to save ourselves
  225. 7:56from the third screw-up: throwing money
  226. 7:58away on commissions and various costs.
  227. 8:00As John Bogle used to say, you get what
  228. 8:02you don't pay for. And so, what better
  229. 8:05thing to do than set up ETF savings
  230. 8:07plans with zero commissions with
  231. 8:08Scalable Capital? Which, by the way, is
  232. 8:11also the sponsor of this episode.
  233. 8:12Scalable is the German bank that I've
  234. 8:14been using for 3 years to invest part of
  235. 8:16my portfolio and that from today offers
  236. 8:17the administered tax regime to its
  237. 8:19Italian clients. So they'll take care of
  238. 8:21paying your taxes with your money,
  239. 8:22obviously, because after all, it's
  240. 8:24Scalable Capital, not Scalable Charity.
  241. 8:26By the way, its country manager
  242. 8:28Alessandro wasn't even stopped by a bus
  243. 8:30that hit him in a crosswalk a year ago.
  244. 8:33He was almost meeting his maker, then he
  245. 8:34said, "No, no, send me back down because
  246. 8:36I've got the administered regime to
  247. 8:37launch." Now that he's made it, and
  248. 8:39since with Scalable you invest almost
  249. 8:41for free and don't have to worry about
  250. 8:43taxes anymore, why don't we open an
  251. 8:44account using the link in the
  252. 8:46description, so your favorite bull gets
  253. 8:47a little happy too? Oh, and besides the
  254. 8:49zero-commission savings plans, there's
  255. 8:51also cash remuneration at the ECB rate
  256. 8:53with no strings attached, the ability to
  257. 8:55connect it to your favorite cloud or
  258. 8:57ChatGPT, and much more.
  259. 8:59So, link in the description, open an
  260. 9:00account with Scalable and start spending
  261. 9:01less on your investments.
  262. 9:03Now, reducing costs is great, but when
  263. 9:06we invest, sooner or later we pay 26%on
  264. 9:08profits, right?
  265. 9:09We all know this.
  266. 9:12What we ask ourselves less often, though
  267. 9:14, is: 26%of what?
  268. 9:17Of the nominal gain, meaning even the
  269. 9:19part that just serves to keep up with
  270. 9:21prices. Let's take an example. Let's say
  271. 9:24an investment returns 7%in a year and
  272. 9:26inflation is at 3%.
  273. 9:29The real gain will be about 4%.
  274. 9:32But the tax authority doesn't look at
  275. 9:34the 4%, it looks at the 7%and takes 26%
  276. 9:36of that, which is almost two points.
  277. 9:39Two points on a real gain of 4.
  278. 9:42Translated, with a 26%tax rate, the tax
  279. 9:45authority takes 45%of our real gain, and
  280. 9:48if we add the stamp duty paid every year
  281. 9:51on the account value, we get to 51%,
  282. 9:53more than half.
  283. 9:56Vote for me and I'll index capital gains
  284. 9:58taxes to inflation.
  285. 10:00No, I'm kidding, but it would be a nice
  286. 10:02idea. Jokes aside, there is a variable
  287. 10:04we can play with, and that is how much
  288. 10:06we pay in those taxes.
  289. 10:09We have shown many times that delaying
  290. 10:11tax payments by using efficient
  291. 10:13accumulating instruments and limiting
  292. 10:15trading activity as much as possible
  293. 10:17significantly reduces the tax burden.
  294. 10:20It is not just about postponing taxes,
  295. 10:22but actually putting the taxable capital
  296. 10:24to work so that it generates further
  297. 10:26returns.
  298. 10:27For instance, the difference between
  299. 10:29paying taxes on capital gains every year
  300. 10:32or all at the end over 30 years can be
  301. 10:34worth 30%more in final net assets.
  302. 10:37It is a mini tax-based leverage. It is
  303. 10:39as if the government gave us an
  304. 10:41interest-free loan that we put to work
  305. 10:43for 30 years.
  306. 10:44This is an extreme example, but the
  307. 10:46point is clear. Procrastinating taxes as
  308. 10:48much as possible is one of the most
  309. 10:50reliable sources of return.
  310. 10:53That said, the first concrete step we
  311. 10:55can take is choosing where to invest
  312. 10:57wisely; even before looking for a
  313. 10:59miraculous inflation-hedging asset,
  314. 11:01let’s use instruments that allow us to
  315. 11:03keep more of what we earn.
  316. 11:07We have seen the benefit of deferring
  317. 11:08taxes, but in some cases, we can also
  318. 11:10reduce what we pay today, meaning we can
  319. 11:11go where the tax authority gives back
  320. 11:13instead of taking away.
  321. 11:15The first lever is, in fact, the pension
  322. 11:18fund. Contributions we pay into the
  323. 11:20pension fund are tax-deductible from
  324. 11:22income up to € 5,300 per year. Deducting
  325. 11:24means the state returns that money at
  326. 11:26our highest tax bracket rate. And which
  327. 11:28bracket has the highest tax rate on the
  328. 11:30last euro? The one where the "hump" is.
  329. 11:33If we pay contributions directly through
  330. 11:35our paycheck, in the € 35,000 to €
  331. 11:3844,000 gross annual income bracket, for
  332. 11:40every € 100 paid, we save about € 56 in
  333. 11:43taxes. Those same euros taken as a raise
  334. 11:45would leave us with € 40 in our pocket,
  335. 11:47whereas putting them into a pension fund
  336. 11:49costs us only € 44.
  337. 11:52And obviously, if we join our collective
  338. 11:53bargaining agreement's fund and pay our
  339. 11:55minimum share, the employer is obligated
  340. 11:57to pay theirs.
  341. 11:58In the commerce sector contract, for
  342. 12:00example, on a gross annual income of €
  343. 12:0240,000, we would put in about € 220 as a
  344. 12:04minimum mandatory contribution, and the
  345. 12:06company would put in € 620.
  346. 12:10And by the way, when we start
  347. 12:11withdrawing money from our pension fund
  348. 12:13once we retire, the taxation could drop
  349. 12:15to as low as 9%if we have had at least
  350. 12:1735 years of fund membership.
  351. 12:20The second lever is, naturally, a
  352. 12:22portfolio of accumulating equity ETFs.
  353. 12:24What we want, in fact, is to capture the
  354. 12:27average market return by reinvesting
  355. 12:29dividends rather than having them
  356. 12:30distributed, and without getting anxious
  357. 12:33every time the market acts up.
  358. 12:35Dividend reinvestment plus tax deferral
  359. 12:38are the secret sauce—well, not so secret
  360. 12:41, actually—for maximizing our equity
  361. 12:43investment.
  362. 12:45The combination of these two factors, in
  363. 12:47fact, is what has historically made
  364. 12:49stocks one of the best vehicles
  365. 12:50available for beating inflation in the
  366. 12:52long term.
  367. 12:53Over the last 100 years, no other asset
  368. 12:55class has come remotely close, and I’m
  369. 12:57not just talking about the S&P 500.
  370. 13:01Investing in stocks has been a success
  371. 13:03story in basically every developed
  372. 13:05market, to varying degrees, with an
  373. 13:08average global return of 5.3%above
  374. 13:10inflation and 4.5%for countries outside
  375. 13:12the United States.
  376. 13:16So, if we want to aim for a positive,
  377. 13:18real expected return in the long term,
  378. 13:20stocks are certainly a great option,
  379. 13:22albeit with a caveat that we’ll see in a
  380. 13:24minute.
  381. 13:26In the short term, however, stocks have
  382. 13:28never been a good protection against
  383. 13:30inflation.
  384. 13:32If we look at the periods with the
  385. 13:33highest inflation over the last 80 years
  386. 13:35, commodities have certainly performed
  387. 13:36the best, and cash has often limited the
  388. 13:38damage.
  389. 13:41Stocks, on the other hand, almost always
  390. 13:43performed poorly in all these
  391. 13:44sub-periods because persistent inflation
  392. 13:46generally pushes interest rates up,
  393. 13:48which, as a nearly mechanical effect,
  394. 13:49depresses stock valuations.
  395. 13:53That is why the third lever works better
  396. 13:55in the short term: investing in real
  397. 13:57assets or other strategies that react
  398. 13:59well to inflationary shocks.
  399. 14:02The main ones are commodities, which are
  400. 14:04investable through ETFs that replicate
  401. 14:06diversified indices like the Bloomberg
  402. 14:07Commodity Index or similar versions that
  403. 14:09are useful especially when inflation is
  404. 14:11triggered by energy shocks, as happened
  405. 14:13this year.
  406. 14:15Then we have inflation-indexed
  407. 14:17government bonds, understood both as
  408. 14:19individual securities like BTP Italia or
  409. 14:21European equivalents and as ETFs that
  410. 14:23pool indexed bonds. Here, one might
  411. 14:26naturally think, "If they adjust
  412. 14:27payments to inflation, I’ve found the
  413. 14:29solution."
  414. 14:31However, if we look at how they
  415. 14:32performed exactly when they were needed
  416. 14:33, well, that's not quite the case. Over
  417. 14:35the last 5 years, an ETF on Eurozone
  418. 14:37indexed bonds is still down by about 4%
  419. 14:40.
  420. 14:41Certainly, better than nominal bonds,
  421. 14:43which are currently still down 13%, but
  422. 14:45regardless, if the goal was to cancel
  423. 14:47out the effects of inflation on
  424. 14:49government bonds, it didn't work.
  425. 14:52But why should an inflation-indexed
  426. 14:54instrument lose money when inflation
  427. 14:56rises?
  428. 14:57I mean, it sounds like a life jacket
  429. 14:59that works perfectly as long as it
  430. 15:01doesn't get wet.
  431. 15:02The point is that indexation adjusts the
  432. 15:04cash flows to prices, but it doesn't
  433. 15:06prevent the market value from falling.
  434. 15:08If the real returns required by
  435. 15:10investors increase, the price of
  436. 15:12previously issued securities decreases.
  437. 15:14This doesn't make indexed bonds useless
  438. 15:16, but they must be used with the correct
  439. 15:18expectations.
  440. 15:20A single bond can help me protect my
  441. 15:21purchasing power for a future expense on
  442. 15:23a specific date.
  443. 15:25An ETF, on the other hand, maintains
  444. 15:27continuous exposure to those securities
  445. 15:29and serves to capture their risk premium
  446. 15:31consistently.
  447. 15:32But "inflation-indexed" doesn't mean it
  448. 15:35always goes up when your bills increase
  449. 15:37.
  450. 15:38And by the way, there's a cruel irony:
  451. 15:40even the revaluation linked to prices is
  452. 15:42taxed, so the anti-inflation instrument
  453. 15:44ends up paying an inflation tax.
  454. 15:47Finally, other options in this category
  455. 15:49include trend-following strategies,
  456. 15:51which we discussed in this episode, or
  457. 15:53stocks in the energy or mining sectors.
  458. 15:57Over these last 5 years, commodities,
  459. 15:59trend following, and especially energy
  460. 16:01sector stocks have performed
  461. 16:02exceptionally well.
  462. 16:05Commodities have actually yielded as
  463. 16:07much as stocks, albeit on a completely
  464. 16:09different path, due exclusively to the
  465. 16:11two energy shocks of 2022 and this year
  466. 16:13.
  467. 16:15However, in terms of diversification,
  468. 16:17the fact that an asset moves in an
  469. 16:18antithetical way to stocks is certainly
  470. 16:20a desirable thing.
  471. 16:22The fourth lever, finally, strange but
  472. 16:24true, is the bond portion of the
  473. 16:26portfolio in nominal government bonds.
  474. 16:29First of all, because they are taxed at
  475. 16:3112.5%instead of 26%.
  476. 16:33It may seem like a trivial argument, but
  477. 16:36we too often underestimate this glaring
  478. 16:38, uniquely Italian distortion that
  479. 16:39clearly rewards government bonds,
  480. 16:41further legitimizing their place in
  481. 16:43portfolios.
  482. 16:44And even if they take a hit when
  483. 16:46inflation rises, in today's environment
  484. 16:48they have three good reasons to exist.
  485. 16:50The first is that when real rates are
  486. 16:53positive and you have a yield to
  487. 16:54maturity, as we do today around 3-4%on
  488. 16:57medium durations, it is an
  489. 16:58income-generating instrument.
  490. 17:01The second is that they still reduce
  491. 17:03portfolio volatility, even if less than
  492. 17:04they did in the first 20 years of the
  493. 17:062000s, when they often balanced major
  494. 17:08stock market shocks—less, but not zero.
  495. 17:11The third is that inflation can also be
  496. 17:13curbed by a severe recession, and this
  497. 17:15is the base case in which government
  498. 17:17bonds appreciate because, in those
  499. 17:19situations, rates generally fall.
  500. 17:22Now, short-term rates might fall while
  501. 17:24long-term ones might still rise even in
  502. 17:26a severe recession if states are too
  503. 17:27heavily indebted, but that's a
  504. 17:29discussion for another time.
  505. 17:33And gold, well, yes and no.
  506. 17:36The asset that comes to everyone's mind
  507. 17:38first as a hedge against inflation hit
  508. 17:40an all-time high of over $ 5,600 an
  509. 17:42ounce in January, while today, as I
  510. 17:44record this, it is hovering near 4,000.
  511. 17:47The decline began right when the war
  512. 17:49with Iran started—the very factor that
  513. 17:51caused inflation to rise significantly.
  514. 17:54Since the beginning of the year, it has
  515. 17:56lost about 7%, and from its peak, it has
  516. 17:57shed nearly 30%.
  517. 17:59Just in the year when inflation has
  518. 18:01returned, indeed.
  519. 18:03But this is no accident, because gold
  520. 18:05does not provide specific protection
  521. 18:07against inflation, but it protects us
  522. 18:09from other things like fear, crises of
  523. 18:11confidence in currencies, uh,
  524. 18:12geopolitical shocks of another nature,
  525. 18:14and it certainly does a useful job in
  526. 18:16portfolio diversification; however, it
  527. 18:18does not protect against price increases
  528. 18:20from one day to the next.
  529. 18:23From 1971 to today, it has generated a
  530. 18:25significant real return. In this sense,
  531. 18:27yes, it has more than compensated for
  532. 18:29inflation, but protecting against
  533. 18:31inflation in utility bills is a
  534. 18:32different job. Now, having understood
  535. 18:35that inflation is a twofold problem
  536. 18:36because for the middle class, it remains
  537. 18:39difficult to solve solely by relying on
  538. 18:41income increases.
  539. 18:43And having also understood that there
  540. 18:44are tools that can help us counter
  541. 18:46inflation, whether on a fiscal level, or
  542. 18:48for expected return, or for
  543. 18:49diversification characteristics.
  544. 18:52Now we must answer this question.
  545. 18:56What does it mean for me to protect
  546. 18:58myself from inflation? It seems like a
  547. 19:00silly question, but in reality, there
  548. 19:02are at least two versions of the problem
  549. 19:04that lead to completely different
  550. 19:05solutions.
  551. 19:07The first is to beat inflation over the
  552. 19:09long term. Here, history is clear. When
  553. 19:11the dust settles, those with more stocks
  554. 19:13win, as they have the highest expected
  555. 19:15return and, at least in developed
  556. 19:17markets over long horizons, have always
  557. 19:19generated positive real returns.
  558. 19:21If I am a relatively young investor with
  559. 19:24a very long time horizon, high human
  560. 19:26capital, good risk tolerance, and in
  561. 19:28general my goal is to maximize long-term
  562. 19:31expected return, then there is little to
  563. 19:34say: investing heavily in global stocks
  564. 19:36is almost a no-brainer.
  565. 19:39Clearly, there are two conditions: I
  566. 19:41must invest in a broad, diversified
  567. 19:43index and use low-cost, tax-efficient
  568. 19:45tools.
  569. 19:46Because if I instead invest in stocks at
  570. 19:48random, or worse yet, based on my
  571. 19:50superior intuition, I have a small
  572. 19:52probability of doing much better and a
  573. 19:54high probability of doing much worse.
  574. 19:57The second solution, however, is a bit
  575. 19:59less obvious, and it is to have assets
  576. 20:01that remain useful along the way. This
  577. 20:03is one of the themes of debunking that I
  578. 20:05am most fond of, and to understand it,
  579. 20:07three premises are needed.
  580. 20:09One, the average expected return of a
  581. 20:11portfolio will almost certainly not be
  582. 20:13my realized return.
  583. 20:16The one realized by me will be at some
  584. 20:18point within a spectrum of possible
  585. 20:20outcomes that can be clearly better or
  586. 20:21clearly worse than the average in
  587. 20:23proportion to how volatile my portfolio
  588. 20:25is, because the more volatile it is, the
  589. 20:27wider the spectrum of possibilities will
  590. 20:29be.
  591. 20:30Where can I end up?
  592. 20:32Second thing, the compound return of a
  593. 20:35portfolio corresponds roughly to its
  594. 20:37arithmetic mean return minus half the
  595. 20:39variance.
  596. 20:41So, if I invest in something with a high
  597. 20:43average return but also high volatility
  598. 20:45, that volatility eats away at my
  599. 20:47returns along the way. Let's take an
  600. 20:49example.
  601. 20:50If I have a portfolio with an expected
  602. 20:52average return of 8%and 20%volatility,
  603. 20:55and one with an expected average return
  604. 20:57of 6%but 5%volatility, the compound
  605. 20:59return of both portfolios is similar,
  606. 21:01but I achieve the second one with a much
  607. 21:03smoother ride.
  608. 21:06And what I actually take home is the
  609. 21:08compound return, not the arithmetic
  610. 21:10average return. Furthermore, I don't
  611. 21:12just invest a lump sum at the beginning
  612. 21:14and never touch my money again for 30 or
  613. 21:1640 years. Along the way, I tend to add
  614. 21:18capital little by little, and
  615. 21:20occasionally I withdraw some, too.
  616. 21:22Consequently, having a volatile
  617. 21:24portfolio amplifies sequence of returns
  618. 21:26risk; in other words, it's not just the
  619. 21:28average compound return of my portfolio
  620. 21:31that matters, but also the portfolio's
  621. 21:33path and the timing of my cash flows.
  622. 21:37You see, in this simulation, both
  623. 21:38portfolios have the same median compound
  624. 21:40return, but the more volatile one—the
  625. 21:42one in yellow—produces much more
  626. 21:44dispersed results.
  627. 21:46The path that actually happens to me can
  628. 21:48be very far from the central case.
  629. 21:51Thirdly, in life, we never really know
  630. 21:54when we will truly need our money. We
  631. 21:56can plan for the short, medium, and long
  632. 21:58term as much as we want, but then comes
  633. 22:01a layoff, an illness, the right house at
  634. 22:03the wrong time, the love of your life,
  635. 22:05an unexpected child, or an unforeseen
  636. 22:07divorce.
  637. 22:08In short, dividing money between short,
  638. 22:10medium, and long term is certainly
  639. 22:12useful, but thinking that life will
  640. 22:14strictly adhere to those deadlines is a
  641. 22:16beautiful fantasy. Our plan must be
  642. 22:19robust enough to hold up even if we need
  643. 22:21the money sooner than we had anticipated
  644. 22:23. But what does all this have to do with
  645. 22:26inflation? Well, it matters because
  646. 22:28inflation has different impacts
  647. 22:29depending on whether I have an
  648. 22:31all-equity portfolio, or one composed
  649. 22:33only of stocks and bonds, versus a
  650. 22:34portfolio diversified with real assets
  651. 22:36as well.
  652. 22:37During demand-side crises, when stocks
  653. 22:39fall, bonds rise and act as a cushion,
  654. 22:41as happened in the first 20 years of
  655. 22:43this century.
  656. 22:44With rising inflation, however, this
  657. 22:46mechanism breaks down; the benefits of
  658. 22:48diversification are reduced, and
  659. 22:50portfolio volatility increases, which,
  660. 22:52as we just mentioned, is not good for
  661. 22:54compound returns.
  662. 22:57Now, as a real individual and not an
  663. 22:59abstract average entity, the question I
  664. 23:01must ask myself is: am I interested in
  665. 23:03maximizing my wealth growth in the long
  666. 23:05term, or am I instead interested in
  667. 23:07preserving the ability to use my money
  668. 23:09as much as possible, as often as
  669. 23:11possible, and, above all, avoiding the
  670. 23:14most adverse scenarios?
  671. 23:17Let me put it another way: would I
  672. 23:19rather have a high ceiling and a low
  673. 23:21floor, or do I want a high floor and a
  674. 23:23low ceiling?
  675. 23:25Maximizing final capital seems like an
  676. 23:27obvious choice, but we must account for
  677. 23:29the fact that the marginal utility of
  678. 23:31money is diminishing. That is, having a
  679. 23:33lot of money or a massive amount of
  680. 23:35money changes my life very little, but
  681. 23:36having a lot versus very little changes
  682. 23:38it quite a bit, doesn't it?
  683. 23:40So, reducing adverse scenarios even if
  684. 23:42it means giving up more favorable ones
  685. 23:45might be exactly what I need, and
  686. 23:46therefore I must understand what I want
  687. 23:49.
  688. 23:51And here we get to the point. Let's
  689. 23:53assume we want to choose between two
  690. 23:55portfolio models to hold for life.
  691. 23:58Portfolio A: 75%global stocks and 25%
  692. 24:01global bonds.
  693. 24:03Aggressive enough, but with a minimum of
  694. 24:05diversification.
  695. 24:06This is the portfolio that aims to
  696. 24:08maximize the long-term expected return,
  697. 24:10my expected terminal wealth.
  698. 24:12I could do 100%stocks, but that would be
  699. 24:14unrealistic.
  700. 24:16Portfolio B: 50%global stocks, 25%
  701. 24:19global bonds, 15%gold, 10%commodities.
  702. 24:23This is a portfolio that instead aims to
  703. 24:25maximize the expected utility of the
  704. 24:27portfolio over time.
  705. 24:28Now, thanks to the powerful tools of
  706. 24:30Portfolio Charts, look at what happens
  707. 24:32over 15 years using real returns. I'm
  708. 24:35using 15 years because that is the
  709. 24:36maximum that Portfolio Charts allows.
  710. 24:38You see, Portfolio A has a median return
  711. 24:41of 7%, against B which stops at 5.9%,
  712. 24:44just as the best-case scenario is
  713. 24:46significantly higher, 11.8%versus 8.6%.
  714. 24:51If things go very well, Portfolio A
  715. 24:53yields much more.
  716. 24:55But the interesting thing is what
  717. 24:56happens on the floor below.
  718. 24:59The 15th percentile return, which we
  719. 25:01could consider a conservative
  720. 25:02expectation—excluding the most
  721. 25:04disastrous scenarios—is much higher for
  722. 25:06B, 4.2%versus 2.8%.
  723. 25:10And in the worst cases, Portfolio B
  724. 25:12yielded double.
  725. 25:13Get it? Now, the point is not to prove
  726. 25:16that one portfolio is better than
  727. 25:17another. Besides, this is a simulation
  728. 25:19that should be taken as such anyway. The
  729. 25:21point is to understand what we need and
  730. 25:23reason accordingly.
  731. 25:24Let's say we have been investors for a
  732. 25:26few years, are, say, 40 years old, maybe
  733. 25:29with 100,000, 200,000, or 500,000 in
  734. 25:31invested assets. What do I do?
  735. 25:34That is, I must ask myself this question
  736. 25:36: what is the goal of my investment? I
  737. 25:38must ask myself whether my goal is to
  738. 25:40maximize the expected terminal wealth
  739. 25:42from here to the next 15-20 years, or to
  740. 25:45optimize the utility of my capital over
  741. 25:47time.
  742. 25:48We will have the opportunity in the
  743. 25:49future to go into detail on how to
  744. 25:51compose these two types of portfolios,
  745. 25:52but today it was essential to understand
  746. 25:54two things.
  747. 25:55Problem one, inflation makes us pay
  748. 25:57twice: once through prices, and a second
  749. 26:00time through taxes.
  750. 26:01On our salary, where in the middle tax
  751. 26:03bracket you need a raise nearly double
  752. 26:05the inflation rate just to stay put, and
  753. 26:07on savings, where the taxman takes even
  754. 26:08the portion of gains needed just to keep
  755. 26:10up with prices.
  756. 26:12The solution: your salary alone isn't
  757. 26:13enough; you need to put your capital to
  758. 26:15work, and do it where the tax system
  759. 26:16rewards us instead of punishing us.
  760. 26:19So, pension funds, accumulating ETFs,
  761. 26:21and government bonds taxed at 12.5%.
  762. 26:25Problem two: with high inflation, stocks
  763. 26:28and bonds tend to fall together, and a
  764. 26:30poorly diversified portfolio becomes
  765. 26:32more volatile just when we might need
  766. 26:34the money.
  767. 26:36The solution: first, decide what
  768. 26:38protecting yourself from inflation means
  769. 26:40to you—either growing your wealth as
  770. 26:41much as possible or raising the floor—
  771. 26:43and then build your portfolio
  772. 26:44accordingly, which in the second case
  773. 26:46will also require diversification, for
  774. 26:48example with real assets.
  775. 26:50But we must not reason in reverse.
  776. 26:52We started with inflation at 5.4%, which
  777. 26:55on a paycheck requires a 10.2%raise.
  778. 26:59Well, we don't choose inflation. Where
  779. 27:02do we put our money and what do we want
  780. 27:03to protect it from? That, we do choose.
  781. 27:05Alright, my friends, that's the end of
  782. 27:07today's episode.
  783. 27:08I hope you enjoyed it and that it gave
  784. 27:10you a useful perspective to think about
  785. 27:12the very current topic of inflation and
  786. 27:14our Italian fiscal woes with fresh eyes
  787. 27:15.
  788. 27:17And if you want a weekly update on the
  789. 27:19most important market events,
  790. 27:20recommended readings, and much more,
  791. 27:22sign up for my free newsletter at the
  792. 27:24link in the description or by going to
  793. 27:27www.debull.it/newsletter.
  794. 27:30For this episode, that really is all,
  795. 27:33and we'll see each other again in a few
  796. 27:35days for a new appointment together,
  797. 27:37always right here, naturally, with The
  798. 27:39Bull, your personal finance podcast.
  799. 27:43A Corax production, social media.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Inflazione al 5%: perché ti serve un aumento dell’10% by The Bull , generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,860 words across 799 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.