InduTwin Discussion Group 4 — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Welcome to today's discussion on the
- 0:02topic tourism degrowth versus economic
- 0:05efficiency talking about the question
- 0:08whether global destinations should
- 0:10impose hard quotas in order to decrease
- 0:12the negative impacts of tourism.
- 0:15We are here today with an environmental
- 0:17expert, a small business owner in the
- 0:19tourism industry, and me as a travel
- 0:22industry
- 0:23representative.
- 0:25To start off, maybe you could introduce
- 0:27yourself and give a quick statement
- 0:29about your opinion on the topic.
- 0:33>> Well, hello. My name is Patricio Saucedo
- 0:36and I'm the environmental expert.
- 0:39As an environmental expert, I believe
- 0:41that mass tourism can't continue growing
- 0:43without considering its environmental
- 0:46and social consequences.
- 0:48But I'll get further in it during the
- 0:51discussion.
- 0:54>> Thank you.
- 0:58>> Uh my turn?
- 1:00I
- 1:01>> Yes.
- 1:03>> Okay. So, my name is Segye. I'm a small
- 1:06business owner
- 1:08uh in the tourism industry. I understand
- 1:11why people support tourist quotas.
- 1:13Overcrowding is a serious problem.
- 1:16Uh and having fewer tourists could make
- 1:18a destination more comfortable.
- 1:21Um
- 1:23So, probably the solution improve
- 1:25working conditions and attract tourists
- 1:28who spend more money and see and stay
- 1:30longer.
- 1:33>> Okay, thank you. So, my name is Yula and
- 1:36I work in the travel industry as well.
- 1:39And I think we all share the idea that
- 1:42our goal is to protect the destinations,
- 1:45but in my opinion, quotas are tool that
- 1:48price out ordinary travelers and do not
- 1:50fix the real problem. Instead, we should
- 1:53manage tourism smartly and sustainably
- 1:56while keeping it open to everybody. So,
- 1:58for me, quotas are not the solution.
- 2:01Um
- 2:02does maybe someone want to start with
- 2:05the first argument?
- 2:10Okay.
- 2:10>> it will be great to hear your opinion.
- 2:12>> Okay.
- 2:13>> And then we can start to discuss.
- 2:15>> Okay. So, in my opinion, quotas would
- 2:19make travel a luxury good because travel
- 2:22would become more expensive and the
- 2:24prices prices are pushed up when there
- 2:27are less travelers. So, I think the
- 2:30problem would be that only the wealthier
- 2:32or rich people would be afford to travel
- 2:35to the remaining places or the popular
- 2:37destinations and travel would become
- 2:41less accessible for ordinary travelers.
- 2:46What do you think about that?
- 2:50>> Well, I think that first,
- 2:52more tourists to a destination do not
- 2:55automatically mean that there's more
- 2:57prosperity because
- 2:59however, more money will come into the
- 3:01economy because of the tourism.
- 3:04Also, the people that live already
- 3:06there,
- 3:07everything will be like more expensive,
- 3:10even the rent, and it will force them to
- 3:13like need to get out of their
- 3:15neighborhood and travel to other parts.
- 3:18So, this is
- 3:19why this type of tourism could affect
- 3:22like the living people in there.
- 3:24Also,
- 3:26mass tourism increases the environmental
- 3:29pressure.
- 3:31Uh flights, cruise ships, hotels, and
- 3:34tourist transport generate greenhouse
- 3:37gas emissions
- 3:38and consume energy and water. Even when
- 3:41individual businesses become more
- 3:42efficient, growing visitor numbers can
- 3:45increase like the whole total
- 3:47environmental impact.
- 3:49And also,
- 3:50uh sometimes,
- 3:53destinations are being sailed,
- 3:56but
- 3:57uh this type of
- 3:59like organizations just make the profit
- 4:02but
- 4:03then do not
- 4:05um
- 4:06generate locally and a part of the
- 4:09society in helping to the damage.
- 4:13Like what about the beaches, forests,
- 4:16coral reefs, and historic neighborhoods
- 4:19that are like that get overcrowded and a
- 4:23lot of waste and habitat disturbance
- 4:26like it's
- 4:27in the way of all of that.
- 4:31>> Okay.
- 4:33Um do you maybe want to say something to
- 4:35that?
- 4:36Saki?
- 4:38>> Um
- 4:40I can say my
- 4:41my perspective.
- 4:43So for in my opinion, three quarters
- 4:46could create
- 4:48uh another problem.
- 4:51Uh
- 4:51smaller businesses
- 4:53depend on the busy season to earn enough
- 4:56money to survive the rest of the year.
- 4:58So we see a we still have to pay rent,
- 5:01salaries,
- 5:03um and other expenses even there
- 5:07uh even there are fewer tourists.
- 5:10>> Mhm.
- 5:12Um I would like to say something to both
- 5:15of your points. So
- 5:17um to what Patricio said, so first um
- 5:21you talked about um the people that live
- 5:24there and that the tourism affects them
- 5:26negatively, for example, because of the
- 5:28renting prices.
- 5:30Um but I think um that's a problem that
- 5:34mostly is caused by concepts like
- 5:37Airbnb, for example, because Airbnb
- 5:40places um
- 5:42like take up the apartments of um
- 5:46travelers
- 5:48uh of the local residents. But for
- 5:50example, if we are talking about hotel
- 5:53guests or people who live in apartments
- 5:56and hotels,
- 5:57um
- 5:58you are not like stealing the living
- 6:00places of the people there. So I think
- 6:02only concepts like Airbnb um would
- 6:06directly affect that.
- 6:08And
- 6:11also about the environmental aspects, I
- 6:14think
- 6:15it's important to remember that many,
- 6:17for example, conservation projects
- 6:21are only surviving because of tourism,
- 6:25because of people who are, for example,
- 6:27visiting those conservation products
- 6:31or
- 6:34yeah, supported
- 6:36by giving them money.
- 6:38So, I think it would be really hard for
- 6:40them to survive without the tourism.
- 6:45>> Okay, I see.
- 6:47And now I would like to introduce a new
- 6:49concept based in my experience in
- 6:51Mexico.
- 6:52Well,
- 6:53here
- 6:54explaining what I said about rents,
- 6:57prices, and that people needs to leave
- 6:58their houses to go to maybe a poor area,
- 7:02well, poorer areas.
- 7:04And here's a concept that is called
- 7:06gentri- gentrification.
- 7:09And this basically means, for example,
- 7:12there's a neighborhood.
- 7:14And then many tourists come to this
- 7:16neighborhood. Maybe the tourists are not
- 7:18staying like an Airbnbs, but at hotels.
- 7:22But these tourists being around the
- 7:24neighborhood
- 7:26and
- 7:27and consuming, for example, in dollars
- 7:30when they travel to Mexico, mostly the
- 7:32Americans,
- 7:34consuming in dollars, then these, like
- 7:37all the local businesses,
- 7:39start raising their prices.
- 7:41And with this, also rent gets like
- 7:43higher, and everything in the area
- 7:46starts like getting more expensive. This
- 7:48happened in like a very known area in
- 7:51Mexico City called El Larosa or La
- 7:55Condesa,
- 7:56where many people had to leave these
- 7:58type of places to like go and live like
- 8:02to other places. So, that's why there
- 8:05are some like, I don't know, uh parades
- 8:09about people complaining about tourism
- 8:11and all of these type of things because
- 8:14sometimes
- 8:16this tourism affects not the rich
- 8:17people, but like the people who live
- 8:20locally and earn a lot earn
- 8:23uh
- 8:24like a base salary.
- 8:26>> Mhm.
- 8:28Yeah, thank you for this perspective. I
- 8:29think that's really worth um thinking
- 8:32about. Um but I think maybe another
- 8:36point we should keep in mind is that for
- 8:38some countries tourism is a major
- 8:41economic lifeline. So, I think for a lot
- 8:44of countries it would be really hard to
- 8:47have like a stable economy without the
- 8:50tourism. So, for example, I looked up
- 8:52some facts. So, um
- 8:55that tourism is accounted for one in
- 8:57three jobs that are created new
- 8:59worldwide and
- 9:01that um
- 9:02worldwide tourism supports more than 366
- 9:06million job and generated 9.8%
- 9:10of the global economies worldwide.
- 9:14Um so, I think that's also um
- 9:17something we should keep in mind because
- 9:19if we just um
- 9:21like introduce quotas, that could really
- 9:25affect those countries negatively.
- 9:31>> Okay.
- 9:32I would like to hear now the opinion of
- 9:35a business
- 9:37uh
- 9:38that a local business, so it will be
- 9:41good.
- 9:42Can you help us?
- 9:45>> Uh
- 9:46so, okay. I have some arguments uh
- 9:50for the quotas and also against the
- 9:53quotas. Uh in my perspective as a
- 9:55business owner uh owner, I'll
- 10:00give you the first against the quotas.
- 10:04Uh so,
- 10:05um
- 10:06as um
- 10:08Julie said before,
- 10:10uh it affects the whole local economy.
- 10:13This isn't only about the business
- 10:15owners, however, the drivers, guides, or
- 10:19some restaurant workers, local shops all
- 10:23depend on tourist spending. Uh so the
- 10:27whole economies of the country go down.
- 10:31Also
- 10:32um
- 10:33in general uh small businesses suffer
- 10:36more than large companies.
- 10:39Uh large hotel chains and international
- 10:41companies may be able to survive lower
- 10:44tourist numbers
- 10:45uh even in the
- 10:49um in other seasons, not only in the
- 10:52favorable and business season for the
- 10:55country, it still can survive.
- 10:58Uh however, the small businesses usually
- 11:01uh don't have the same the financial
- 11:03resources.
- 11:05Uh so this would affect them very
- 11:08negatively.
- 11:10So and also my opinion the strict quotas
- 11:15are
- 11:16too simple solution.
- 11:18So um
- 11:21instead of just um strict uh strict
- 11:24quotas uh I propose alternative.
- 11:29Flexible quotas instead um
- 11:32we could limit tourists only in the
- 11:33overcrowded places or during extremely
- 11:36busy uh busy periods
- 11:39and encourage more tourism during the
- 11:41low seasons.
- 11:43So
- 11:45yes.
- 11:47Um that's my opinion.
- 11:50>> Thank you.
- 11:51>> Okay.
- 11:54Okay, going back uh to the quotas, yeah,
- 11:57I think that's like a better solution
- 12:00because uh
- 12:01tourism only
- 12:04like being enabled to the rich people.
- 12:08I don't think it's a great solution
- 12:09because I think it's a right for
- 12:12everyone to travel
- 12:13and there should be like cheap options
- 12:16also for everyone to have this
- 12:18experience and like travel to all the
- 12:21world.
- 12:22Uh don't get me wrong.
- 12:24I'm not against tourism.
- 12:26I'm just stating like the causes
- 12:29and like the environmental harms like
- 12:32mostly like to the residents
- 12:35because
- 12:36we also need to
- 12:38think about like the base like the base
- 12:41of our population
- 12:43who gets like
- 12:45yeah suffer by all these type of
- 12:48by all these type of things of tourism.
- 12:52But yeah that
- 12:54that could be good.
- 12:58>> Um yes and I think um maybe um another
- 13:03point that is more in favor of your um
- 13:06opinion or a concept that would be like
- 13:09a compromise is that we also should
- 13:12think about the fact that if we like
- 13:15manage the number of visitors in some
- 13:17way it doesn't mean that we like need to
- 13:19completely cap them or reduce them.
- 13:22Maybe it would also be possible to
- 13:24distribute the visitors more over the
- 13:27whole year so that we
- 13:29don't have like peak seasons where the
- 13:31places are very busy but it could also
- 13:34help us to reduce the crowds in the
- 13:37tourism places and that could also
- 13:39improve the experience for our tourism
- 13:42tourists um because overcrowding somehow
- 13:47like damages the touristic places and
- 13:50maybe the places also lose some kind of
- 13:53character
- 13:55or um
- 13:58like
- 13:59um
- 14:01it could like improve the experience for
- 14:03our visitors.
- 14:07>> Yeah I think that's a good point. Maybe
- 14:09for like the top or most crowded
- 14:11destinations
- 14:13a limit a certain number of tourists. I
- 14:17don't know if it can be per year, per
- 14:20season, but do an environmental study
- 14:23depending on the place and determining
- 14:26which could be like the a good amount of
- 14:29people so that they can enjoy, but not
- 14:32affect the people and also not the
- 14:34environment.
- 14:35And that everything not gets harmed.
- 14:38>> Mhm.
- 14:39I think that's really good point. And I
- 14:42think um
- 14:44it's also important um that we still
- 14:48generate some kind of income so that we
- 14:51are maybe from an environmental
- 14:54perspective able to invest in
- 14:56sustainable technologies or something
- 14:59like electric transport or an
- 15:01eco-friendly infrastructure. So, I think
- 15:04it's important that we keep the tourism
- 15:07at some level so that it is uh that we
- 15:11are able to invest in such
- 15:13environmentally friendly concepts and
- 15:15introduce them.
- 15:19>> Yeah, because a clear example, going to
- 15:22the far extreme, we have Japan now.
- 15:26Everyone wants wants to be in Japan
- 15:28right now. And what is happening there?
- 15:31That there's a lot of people and like no
- 15:34one can fit there anymore.
- 15:36So, all of the people are getting
- 15:38affected by the tourists and some of
- 15:41them are not respecting their culture
- 15:44or even imposing their religion on them
- 15:48and disrespecting them. So, this is why
- 15:51a lot of riots have started in Japan
- 15:53that they want to stop like the mass
- 15:55tourism and this is a like a clear
- 15:57example why we need to control
- 16:00uh tourism and maybe limit it to a
- 16:03certain type to avoid ended up like
- 16:07Japan. Because also recent studies have
- 16:10showed that a lot of
- 16:13yeah, environmental damage has been
- 16:15caused and also garbage consumption.
- 16:19All of these type of things damaging the
- 16:21environment, even their temples and
- 16:24their culture because tourists
- 16:27sometimes don't know how to act when you
- 16:30present them to a new religion.
- 16:33Like in Japan, the Buddhism.
- 16:36Uh for example, the the Toji doors that
- 16:40they will cling from them and all those
- 16:42type stuff. So, I think yeah, we should
- 16:45encourage like limiting the tourism and
- 16:48also maybe
- 16:50encourage people to before going to a
- 16:52place
- 16:54get to know it a little better, do some
- 16:56research like to avoid all these type.
- 17:00>> Yeah.
- 17:02I think that would be a really good
- 17:04compromise.
- 17:05Um
- 17:06does anyone has anything to add like any
- 17:10arguments?
- 17:24>> What do you think about the situation in
- 17:26Japan from a business owner perspective?
- 17:30What can you tell us?
- 17:34>> Uh I'm not sure I understood your point
- 17:38correctly.
- 17:40So, uh can you summarize about the
- 17:42Japan?
- 17:44Uh so, I understood this idea of the
- 17:48religion.
- 17:49Right?
- 17:51Uh
- 17:51>> You know, mostly summarizing my point.
- 17:55Uh right now, everyone wants to travel
- 17:57to Japan. So, there's an excess in
- 17:59tourism
- 18:01where everything is getting damaged
- 18:03including like disrespecting their
- 18:06culture and there's a lot of waste
- 18:09consumption and all of that.
- 18:13>> Uh okay. So, your point is uh
- 18:15disrespecting from tourists.
- 18:18Yes?
- 18:19Uh so, the tourism tourist and tourism
- 18:23the whole
- 18:25um
- 18:26negatively affect the and disrespecting
- 18:28the culture of the country, right?
- 18:31And okay.
- 18:33Uh, but
- 18:36um my opinion is um
- 18:39uh, tourism uh, promoting the country's
- 18:43cultures to foreigners.
- 18:46So,
- 18:47um
- 18:48from this
- 18:50um my perspective uh, I think that uh,
- 18:55business owners can sell the
- 18:58um
- 19:00national products and every tourist can
- 19:03try it. For example, the food um or the
- 19:06clothes
- 19:08and I think it's more about the
- 19:10promoting the culture.
- 19:14>> Mhm.
- 19:15>> Okay.
- 19:16>> Okay. And
- 19:17Yeah, sorry. Didn't want to interrupt.
- 19:20>> Okay, so yes, so um it is positive from
- 19:24the both sides from the ethical and
- 19:27culture
- 19:28because others countries other countries
- 19:32and foreigners would get would
- 19:35um know more about the country's owns
- 19:39culture and also it it would make a
- 19:42profit.
- 19:44>> Mhm.
- 19:45>> Okay.
- 19:46>> Thank you for this perspective. Um I
- 19:49think we are kind of running out of
- 19:51time, but I think we already came to a
- 19:54good compromise I would advise. So,
- 19:56maybe in conclusion we could say that we
- 19:59all agree that it is very important that
- 20:02we limit the tourism in some in some way
- 20:05or like distribute it more over the
- 20:08seasons so that we stop the overcrowding
- 20:11in touristic places so that we um
- 20:14protect environment, but still we also
- 20:18need to see from our perspective that we
- 20:21still support the tourism industry
- 20:24because it is really important for some
- 20:28countries and their economy really
- 20:30depends on it and maybe the tourism can
- 20:33also be seen as an opportunity to
- 20:36introduce or to invest the money from it
- 20:40into more sustainable concept. So
- 20:43maybe if we all if you all agree that's
- 20:46something we could find a compromise
- 20:49with.
- 20:52>> Yeah, I think that's a great example.
- 20:55Of how countries can work and keeping
- 20:58also environmental safe.
- 21:01>> Okay, perfect.
- 21:03Thank you.
- 21:04>> Thank you.
- 21:07>> Okay, thank you.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of InduTwin Discussion Group 4 by Jule , generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,543 words across 492 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.