YouTube2Text

In Conversation with European Central Bank President Christine Lagarde at BWC's 2026 Spring Summit — Transcript

by Bretton Woods Committee · 5,070 words · 834 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:01So, welcome.
  2. 0:02Thank you, Bill. Lovely to be here.
  3. 0:04>> so And lovely to see so many friends
  4. 0:06here. Yeah, it's like it's like you're
  5. 0:08coming home, right? Here.
  6. 0:09>> [laughter]
  7. 0:11[applause]
  8. 0:12>> So, I'm going to jump right in. World
  9. 0:14Economic Outlook came out today and as
  10. 0:16you might expect, growth down, inflation
  11. 0:19up. Uh reflecting obviously what's going
  12. 0:21on in terms of the war and the impact on
  13. 0:24energy prices.
  14. 0:25So, when you look at it from the
  15. 0:27European Union perspective, ECB
  16. 0:29perspective, what what what's your view
  17. 0:31in terms of how this going to affect the
  18. 0:33the European outlook? Base case,
  19. 0:36you know, adverse case, severe case.
  20. 0:39Where where where are you in terms of
  21. 0:41your forecast? How's that evolving? Are
  22. 0:43you are you are you sort of moving from
  23. 0:45one case to the other?
  24. 0:50Well, it's you know, it's what the the
  25. 0:53head of the
  26. 0:54International Energy Agency has called
  27. 0:56the worst shock on a global basis that
  28. 1:00we could have. So, if you start from
  29. 1:02that basis, um wherever you're located
  30. 1:05in your region and as a central banker,
  31. 1:09uh you look at the impact it can have on
  32. 1:11your economy. You look at the impact it
  33. 1:13has on inflation, which is clearly, you
  34. 1:15know, mission critical for us as central
  35. 1:18bankers. You look at the impact it has
  36. 1:19on growth and you try to navigate to see
  37. 1:23on the basis of the best possible
  38. 1:25information and I can come back to that
  39. 1:27in a second if you if you want, uh what
  40. 1:29is the likely baseline and given the
  41. 1:32level of uncertainty that we are facing,
  42. 1:35uh we work with uh scenarios. We um have
  43. 1:38a variety of them. We select the ones
  44. 1:41that are most relevant for the purpose
  45. 1:43of publication and communication uh with
  46. 1:46markets and with whoever is interested
  47. 1:47in the work that we are doing and we
  48. 1:49also uh pay great attention to risks
  49. 1:52around the baseline. And you know, it's
  50. 1:55all of that is terribly unfortunate,
  51. 1:57okay? And when I look at the the death,
  52. 1:59the casualties, the destruction, it's
  53. 2:01highly unfortunate.
  54. 2:03Where we are fortunate
  55. 2:05uh in in Europe and particularly at the
  56. 2:08ECB
  57. 2:09is that we had developed a strategy
  58. 2:12uh back in
  59. 2:152021 because it took a little bit of
  60. 2:17time because of COVID to complete the
  61. 2:19exercise, but as soon as I took the job,
  62. 2:21I decided that we should conduct this
  63. 2:23strategy review and we have just
  64. 2:24recently updated the strategy. So,
  65. 2:28two findings from that strategy review.
  66. 2:30One is
  67. 2:32we need to incorporate risk analysis
  68. 2:35into our thinking much more so and
  69. 2:37second, we need to use scenario
  70. 2:39analysis. Surprise, surprise, it's
  71. 2:41extremely helpful now and I'm delighted
  72. 2:44>> the outcomes are very wide, right?
  73. 2:46>> Yeah. Yeah, when you have a a very high
  74. 2:48level of uncertainty and you are
  75. 2:51uncertain about some of the numbers and
  76. 2:53the facts that we are observing, it's
  77. 2:56really good to be able to do that. The
  78. 2:58second aspect
  79. 2:59that makes us a little bit more
  80. 3:00fortunate in this unfortunate situation
  81. 3:03is that we were nicely positioned.
  82. 3:06>> You were on your inflation target.
  83. 3:08>> We were
  84. 3:09I mean, we had
  85. 3:10>> Un- unlike some other unnamed
  86. 3:12>> no, no. I I won't go there. Won't go
  87. 3:13there. But no, but look at it, we were
  88. 3:16um I mean, growth was on on its way up.
  89. 3:20We were in a recovery process. We were
  90. 3:22just about to uh upgrade our
  91. 3:24projections. Inflation was at our target
  92. 3:28and had been for almost a year. So, we
  93. 3:30were really confident that we had tamed
  94. 3:33inflation as it was and the unemployment
  95. 3:35level was at rock bottom bottom. We
  96. 3:38never had an unemployment level so low.
  97. 3:40So,
  98. 3:41that
  99. 3:42That gives you credibility, right? That
  100. 3:43gives you credibility in terms of going
  101. 3:45forward.
  102. 3:46>> I hope so. I I hope so.
  103. 3:47>> I I think it does. And uh but it it put
  104. 3:49it, you know, we are in a good position
  105. 3:51to now respond to the situation and and
  106. 3:54be able to demonstrate the level of uh
  107. 3:57agility
  108. 3:58uh to calibrate the response depending
  109. 4:01on the facts and on the data that we are
  110. 4:04trying to collect, ascertain, correlate,
  111. 4:07verify because that's an area where we
  112. 4:10need to constantly do some work. So, you
  113. 4:12asked me about whether we are constantly
  114. 4:15um updating
  115. 4:16>> updating and yes, we are. So, we are
  116. 4:18not, you know, publishing on a weekly
  117. 4:20basis.
  118. 4:21>> But but yes, we are constantly updating
  119. 4:23and as I was saying earlier today, it
  120. 4:26it it makes our job particularly
  121. 4:28difficult at the moment and it gives us
  122. 4:30that level of schizophrenia as I
  123. 4:32mentioned because we need to be focused
  124. 4:35on
  125. 4:36you know, our time horizon, which is the
  126. 4:38medium term. That's where we want to be.
  127. 4:40>> Because monetary policy takes time to
  128. 4:41work.
  129. 4:42>> policy is medium term target uh
  130. 4:45But at the same time, we have to be
  131. 4:47constantly aware of almost a daily
  132. 4:49evolution uh of of
  133. 4:53the overall situation
  134. 4:55and the market situation as well. So,
  135. 4:57where are you today in terms of thinking
  136. 4:58about the outlook for
  137. 5:01uh ECB monetary policy? Is it are we
  138. 5:03still are we in a
  139. 5:04wait to see which of these scenarios
  140. 5:07sort of materializes or you how far how
  141. 5:09long can you wait?
  142. 5:11We have three. We have
  143. 5:13you know, we have one baseline, which is
  144. 5:15the the the the one that
  145. 5:17we believe is is reasonable and sensible
  146. 5:20to anticipate, which has helped us give
  147. 5:22our revised production projection with,
  148. 5:24you know, growth down, inflation up. Um
  149. 5:27and and that over the course of 26, 27,
  150. 5:3128 because we conducted a three-year
  151. 5:32exercise. And in addition to that, we
  152. 5:34have constructed and published with all
  153. 5:37the hypotheticals and with all the
  154. 5:38assumptions and you know, with zero
  155. 5:40monetary or fiscal reaction incorporated
  156. 5:42in the in the in the scenarios, we have
  157. 5:45what we call an adverse scenario and a
  158. 5:49severe scenario. And the the two factors
  159. 5:52that change between the adverse and the
  160. 5:55severe is the peak at which oil and gas
  161. 5:59go
  162. 6:00and the length of time that it takes for
  163. 6:03both oil and gas and every derivative
  164. 6:06products to go back to normal. So,
  165. 6:08presumably right now we're sort of in
  166. 6:09the baseline or a little bit beyond the
  167. 6:10baseline. We're sort of marching towards
  168. 6:12the adverse. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. No
  169. 6:14no question. And and you know, we don't
  170. 6:17update on a daily basis, but uh it
  171. 6:20it changes on a daily basis. So, we have
  172. 6:22to update regularly and and um be
  173. 6:25mindful of potential changes. How do you
  174. 6:28think about the shock of, you know, in
  175. 6:29terms of inflation, you know,
  176. 6:31a lot central bankers like to talk about
  177. 6:32transitory shock. We can look through
  178. 6:34transitory price changes. Yeah, I've
  179. 6:36heard that story.
  180. 6:36>> How how yes.
  181. 6:38>> [laughter]
  182. 6:38>> How do you how do you think about how
  183. 6:39how long how how how strongly can you
  184. 6:42hold to that belief and at what point
  185. 6:45does inflation become high enough for
  186. 6:46long enough that it's no longer uh
  187. 6:48tenable to look through that transitory
  188. 6:50shock? You know, when obviously
  189. 6:53the teams look at it very carefully and
  190. 6:57historically, energy shocks in Europe
  191. 7:00have been rather transitory and in in
  192. 7:03the past,
  193. 7:05monetary policies in those days could
  194. 7:07just look through it, wait until it
  195. 7:09comes back because we cannot as a
  196. 7:11central banker, as you know very well,
  197. 7:13we cannot, you know, reduce the energy
  198. 7:15prices. This is something that is
  199. 7:17external. It has
  200. 7:19predominantly a supply dimension until
  201. 7:21it, you know, something happens, but
  202. 7:23this is not something that we can
  203. 7:25affect.
  204. 7:26I think what we need to do on the basis
  205. 7:29of current circumstances is
  206. 7:33assess the data,
  207. 7:35determine the actual nature of the
  208. 7:37shock,
  209. 7:38the possible variation of that nature,
  210. 7:41the magnitude, the potential duration,
  211. 7:45and then
  212. 7:47we have to be open
  213. 7:49and we cannot I think it it would be a a
  214. 7:51serious mistake today to say this is a
  215. 7:55case of look through.
  216. 7:58We simply don't know.
  217. 7:59>> Too soon to tell. Too soon to tell. So,
  218. 8:02where we will move and demonstrate our
  219. 8:05agility is once we have enough data,
  220. 8:08enough information and once that is the
  221. 8:11case, then we will not be hesitant.
  222. 8:13But if you I mean, for those of of you
  223. 8:16who are
  224. 8:17really look at the ECB position, we have
  225. 8:20laid it out very clearly in a speech
  226. 8:22that I gave recently to the ECB watchers
  227. 8:25um which, you know, divides
  228. 8:28our approaches and our potential stance
  229. 8:31into three categories. One where it's
  230. 8:34transitory, we look through it and it's
  231. 8:37relatively short-lived and it comes back
  232. 8:40to previous or more or less previous
  233. 8:42situation.
  234. 8:43We don't do anything.
  235. 8:44>> Right.
  236. 8:45And we we we, you know, we see how the
  237. 8:48situation evolves.
  238. 8:49The second at the other opposite is it's
  239. 8:52a long um
  240. 8:55long-lived um
  241. 8:57quite
  242. 8:59And then you worry about getting into
  243. 9:00getting into wages and getting into
  244. 9:02expectations.
  245. 9:03>> then yeah, it's I mean, it's a it's a
  246. 9:05it's a long-lived sustainable um energy
  247. 9:08shock, which has the direct effect,
  248. 9:10which has the indirect effect, which has
  249. 9:12eventually the risk of second round um
  250. 9:14effect and then we have to be so
  251. 9:16attentive to
  252. 9:18inflation expectations that it requires
  253. 9:21for us to take
  254. 9:23decisive measure
  255. 9:25um and then you have anything in between
  256. 9:28these two, which may or may not require
  257. 9:31that we act upon uh the situation. But
  258. 9:35the key certainty that I have is that
  259. 9:36number one, we will not let inflation
  260. 9:38expectations be de-anchored and we will
  261. 9:41deliver and continue to deliver on our
  262. 9:42mission to keep prices stable, which
  263. 9:45means 2% medium term. That is
  264. 9:47>> Absolutely. Absolutely.
  265. 9:47>> what I'm certain of.
  266. 9:49Let me switch gears and you've talked
  267. 9:50talked about the erosion of trust in
  268. 9:52multilateral institutions. Um how how
  269. 9:56serious do you think the damage is? Uh,
  270. 9:58and
  271. 9:59what should be done to sort of bolster
  272. 10:02uh, their their their their
  273. 10:04reputation and effectiveness?
  274. 10:07I don't think that their their
  275. 10:09reputation is at stake. I think that
  276. 10:11institutions of the Bretton Woods system
  277. 10:14have proven their worth. I think they
  278. 10:17are being challenged uh, because of the
  279. 10:20fragmentation of the world as we see it
  280. 10:22at the moment. And um,
  281. 10:26you know, it's it's almost conventional
  282. 10:28wisdom now to argue that the the system
  283. 10:30is broken and that it needs to be
  284. 10:32rebuilt.
  285. 10:33I don't share that view.
  286. 10:35And I think that there has been so much
  287. 10:38um,
  288. 10:39accumulation of knowledge, of expertise,
  289. 10:41of talent, of goodwill with a mission
  290. 10:45associated with that that a lot of it is
  291. 10:47actually solid and valid and should be
  292. 10:49kept.
  293. 10:51Which doesn't mean that it shouldn't be
  294. 10:53changed. And there are lots of things
  295. 10:56that can be improved. Uh, and I think
  296. 10:59the institutions themselves together
  297. 11:01with the help of the membership that is
  298. 11:04willing to move it forward has to find
  299. 11:06ways to reform it in depth so that it
  300. 11:09becomes effective, efficient, and fit
  301. 11:11for the challenges that we have. But I
  302. 11:14I'm not one of those who believe that
  303. 11:16international institutions such as the
  304. 11:18IMF, such as the World Bank, such as uh,
  305. 11:21WTO, WHO, and and you name it, uh, are
  306. 11:24irrelevant. I think that the challenges
  307. 11:26that we are facing is not what you're
  308. 11:27saying. I know that. I think they're I
  309. 11:28think they're essential myself.
  310. 11:29Absolutely. And I think that, you know,
  311. 11:31they're even more so essential because
  312. 11:33we are facing
  313. 11:34uh, issues and challenges of a global
  314. 11:37nature. And you might decide as much as
  315. 11:39you want that you will be fragmented,
  316. 11:40that you will go alone. That doesn't
  317. 11:42work. Doesn't work when you have
  318. 11:44pandemic. Doesn't work when you have
  319. 11:45major security challenges. It doesn't
  320. 11:48work when you need to have an
  321. 11:49international payment system that works.
  322. 11:51So we have all these global public goods
  323. 11:53and this is why we need these
  324. 11:54institutions. One of the models of the
  325. 11:56Bretton Woods Committee is international
  326. 11:58policy cooperation coordination leads to
  327. 12:00better outcomes than countries going on
  328. 12:02their own.
  329. 12:03Uh, so how do we get people to
  330. 12:06understand that and lean in as opposed
  331. 12:09to pull back?
  332. 12:11I think these institutions have to
  333. 12:12deliver. Mhm. And you know, you you you
  334. 12:16pick and choose the the hill that you
  335. 12:17want to die on. I think you have to pick
  336. 12:19and choose the deliverables that you are
  337. 12:21confident you will offer to demonstrate
  338. 12:23uh, the the the the value and the
  339. 12:25worthiness of of the institutions. So
  340. 12:27presumably you have to make sure you
  341. 12:28have
  342. 12:29>> or a good moment to talk about well
  343. 12:31define the mission, you know, clearly
  344. 12:33and and not not too expansively. I think
  345. 12:35the mandates are pretty clear for these
  346. 12:38institutions. And I'm not talking about
  347. 12:39the the UN uh, because I think that's
  348. 12:42that's a a you know, a whole kettle of
  349. 12:44fish.
  350. 12:46There's there's some there's some
  351. 12:48serious structural issues, right? Yeah.
  352. 12:50We're not going to fix the UN today.
  353. 12:51>> But the ones that
  354. 12:53But the ones we know well and the ones
  355. 12:55that are hosting us at the moment, I
  356. 12:57think that uh,
  357. 12:59they they know where the deliverables
  358. 13:00can be can be identified and can be can
  359. 13:03be offered. Mhm.
  360. 13:05Central bank independence has certainly
  361. 13:07come back into focus. I think people in
  362. 13:09the US are probably quite jealous of the
  363. 13:11ECB setup where your independence is
  364. 13:13established by uh, treaty.
  365. 13:16Uh, you've been a strong proponent of
  366. 13:17the importance of independence. What do
  367. 13:18you think's at risk if independence is
  368. 13:20compromised?
  369. 13:22Well, the decision-making process and
  370. 13:24and ultimately
  371. 13:25the the the the quality, validity, and
  372. 13:27credibility of the decisions that are
  373. 13:29made.
  374. 13:30If if investors or markets are under the
  375. 13:33impression that decisions are made
  376. 13:35because of uh, political pressure to go
  377. 13:38in that direction or the other, I think
  378. 13:40that undermines clearly the credibility
  379. 13:42of the institutions. I think that you
  380. 13:44know, the independence is not a given.
  381. 13:46It it might be in the treaty, it can
  382. 13:48also be in in in a law, um, but it has
  383. 13:51to be earned. Yep.
  384. 13:53And it has to be earned through um,
  385. 13:56transparency. You know, how do you how
  386. 13:58do you how do you decide? How do you
  387. 14:01communicate the decisions that you have
  388. 14:03made? And I think it it it is also
  389. 14:05earned as a result of the accountability
  390. 14:07that you have when you go to parliament.
  391. 14:09I go to parliament on a regular basis. I
  392. 14:11take the questions. I answer all the
  393. 14:13members of parliament and and and you
  394. 14:16know, we are fairly transparent in how
  395. 14:19we do it and and why we do it. So you
  396. 14:21you would argue that the central bank
  397. 14:22has a role to play in in sort of
  398. 14:24securing their independence by
  399. 14:26accountability, credibility, trust.
  400. 14:28>> you can never take it for granted. You
  401. 14:30have you you really have to earn it all
  402. 14:31the time because it it's it's a give and
  403. 14:33take. You are independent, but to earn
  404. 14:36that independence, you have to deliver
  405. 14:37on your mandate, but you also have to be
  406. 14:39transparent in how you do it and you are
  407. 14:41accountable to those who ultimately have
  408. 14:44the all own the sovereignty of the
  409. 14:46territory within which you operate.
  410. 14:47Where where do you think the ECB is
  411. 14:49today in terms of its acceptance? You
  412. 14:50know, when the ECB was established,
  413. 14:52there there was a lot of anxiety about
  414. 14:54the Bundesbank
  415. 14:55>> was going to give up its, you know,
  416. 14:56inflation The Financial Times had all
  417. 14:59these things up for all.
  418. 15:01So what where do you think it is today?
  419. 15:02>> I'm sorry. [clears throat]
  420. 15:03We've celebrated our 25th anniversary
  421. 15:05not long ago.
  422. 15:06>> credible at this point.
  423. 15:08Well, when I look at the the the
  424. 15:09popularity, if you will, of the euro,
  425. 15:1382% of the European citizens value and
  426. 15:16trust the euro.
  427. 15:18Um,
  428. 15:19the numbers are lower for the ECB itself
  429. 15:22because quite a few a few people
  430. 15:23actually don't know what the ECB
  431. 15:25[laughter] is. Um, Everybody in this
  432. 15:27room does though.
  433. 15:29But I you know, to the extent that the
  434. 15:31euro is is the currency that we are the
  435. 15:34custodian of, I think that to have that
  436. 15:3682% is quite a quite a tribute to the
  437. 15:39work that has been done by my
  438. 15:40predecessors, by the staff, and that I
  439. 15:42try to continue to emulate. And then
  440. 15:44maybe even expand. I mean, people are
  441. 15:45talking about Hungary potentially
  442. 15:47eventually.
  443. 15:47>> Yes. Yes, that's
  444. 15:49that's that's a
  445. 15:51yeah, that's a piece of good news
  446. 15:52because I
  447. 15:53I heard the uh,
  448. 15:55just newly elected prime minister of
  449. 15:56Hungary actually indicate that he will
  450. 15:58be looking forward to to joining uh, the
  451. 16:01euro area and and having the euro
  452. 16:03instead of the foreign. So this is the
  453. 16:05beginning of a journey. Yeah. There will
  454. 16:07be work. There will be uh, hard reforms,
  455. 16:10I'm sure, but to have this indication,
  456. 16:12which is not it's not a you know, a
  457. 16:14political major decision. It's it's
  458. 16:17joining the family as was predicated at
  459. 16:19the time when the euro was set up. Every
  460. 16:22member of Europe except Denmark. Denmark
  461. 16:25took a step out and carved out their
  462. 16:27right to stay out with their crown, but
  463. 16:29everybody else is expected to join. So
  464. 16:32we are 21. If we are 22,
  465. 16:35We're we're making progress. Yes.
  466. 16:37[laughter]
  467. 16:38We have four more to go.
  468. 16:41I'm going to ask switch switch gears
  469. 16:42again and ask you about uh,
  470. 16:45crypto and
  471. 16:47decentralized finance. So the genius act
  472. 16:49was passed in the United States last
  473. 16:51year. Now you are the expert. I'm not.
  474. 16:52And as but established a framework for a
  475. 16:54dollar payment stable coins. Um, and you
  476. 16:58know,
  477. 16:59dollar denominated stable coins are
  478. 17:00represented about 98% of all stable
  479. 17:02coins outstanding.
  480. 17:04Uh,
  481. 17:05do do you think of dollar stable coins
  482. 17:07as a threat to Europe in the sense of if
  483. 17:09if people decide that they want to use
  484. 17:11dollar stable coins for cross-border
  485. 17:12payments, then
  486. 17:14that'll make the euro less attractive.
  487. 17:16The European economy could be
  488. 17:18potentially dollarized. Is this
  489. 17:19something that you worry about? And and
  490. 17:21two, uh, how should the euro your your
  491. 17:23Europe respond? How is the ECB thinking
  492. 17:25about what the appropriate response is?
  493. 17:28You know, point number one, uh,
  494. 17:30we at the ECB and within the euro
  495. 17:32system, we are
  496. 17:34300% in favor of innovation,
  497. 17:37breakthrough, use of new technologies.
  498. 17:39And and DLT, by the way, is not a new
  499. 17:41technology, but it's one that that can
  500. 17:43certainly be
  501. 17:44exploited for the purpose of all sorts
  502. 17:46of payment representation of assets.
  503. 17:50But honestly,
  504. 17:52I don't understand the business case for
  505. 17:54a stable coins.
  506. 17:56Honestly. Yes.
  507. 17:57That's true. Yes. I don't.
  508. 18:01So
  509. 18:02you know, you you can do uh, tokenized
  510. 18:05deposit
  511. 18:07for for much better and more efficient
  512. 18:10uh, purpose than these stable coins.
  513. 18:13But you know, having said that, if
  514. 18:15people really want to uh, use these
  515. 18:18these, you know, non-business case
  516. 18:20devices and and talk about it as if it
  517. 18:22was of huge value,
  518. 18:25let's let's see.
  519. 18:27But having said that,
  520. 18:30I think that it should be number if it
  521. 18:31is done, it should be in compliance with
  522. 18:33the rules. So you are the expert on the
  523. 18:35genius act, I'm the expert on me car. So
  524. 18:37between the two of us, we can probably
  525. 18:39cover the regulatory environment except
  526. 18:43that they're not exactly the same. No,
  527. 18:44they're not. Right? So and and and
  528. 18:48you're not yet done and I'm not yet done
  529. 18:50because you will have clarity act as
  530. 18:52well in the background. You'll have to
  531. 18:53make up to your mind as to whether or
  532. 18:55not cusps uh,
  533. 18:57will be entitled to pay some interest to
  534. 19:01the stable coins.
  535. 19:03>> controversial.
  536. 19:03>> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Big battle
  537. 19:05between the banks and Yeah. And I have
  538. 19:07my bet on that, but I'm not going to
  539. 19:09we'll share it later.
  540. 19:10>> [laughter]
  541. 19:11>> So we're we're not completely done on
  542. 19:13the regulatory environment because me
  543. 19:15car is going to be under review as well.
  544. 19:17But if these instruments, the US stable
  545. 19:20coins, euro stable coins eventually,
  546. 19:23uh, are, you know, to be considered as
  547. 19:25fungible
  548. 19:26and therefore eligible to redemption in
  549. 19:29one place or the other, especially if
  550. 19:30they are multi-currencies,
  551. 19:32then it has to be exactly some you know,
  552. 19:35subject to the same kind of regulations.
  553. 19:38And I don't think that we can tolerate
  554. 19:39that for instance, redemption of these
  555. 19:42multi-currency stable coins
  556. 19:44uh, be had in Europe um,
  557. 19:49which could be siphoned very nicely uh,
  558. 19:53because the outcome for the holder of
  559. 19:55the stablecoin is going to be more
  560. 19:58beneficial. Now, you need a level
  561. 20:00playing field.
  562. 20:00>> level playing field and you need to have
  563. 20:02a definition of fungibility between the
  564. 20:04two that is commonly accepted and that
  565. 20:07is as you said a level playing field.
  566. 20:09Cuz otherwise it's it's just
  567. 20:11as a matter of principle just not
  568. 20:12acceptable. You cannot transfer the
  569. 20:14risks to a redemption fund that is
  570. 20:17not operating under the same principle
  571. 20:18and with less supervision. So, Europe
  572. 20:20has laid down set of regulations in MiCA
  573. 20:23you know in terms of how this should go.
  574. 20:26Do you think that
  575. 20:27we're we're going to be able to get
  576. 20:28convergence between the European vision
  577. 20:30and the the regulations that have yet to
  578. 20:32be written elsewhere? Cuz obviously if
  579. 20:34you don't have convergence here, it's
  580. 20:36going to be very hard to get to that
  581. 20:37sort of harmonized world. Well, I think
  582. 20:39the business case has to be demonstrated
  583. 20:40first of all. As you said for the
  584. 20:41moment, 90% of the stablecoins are US
  585. 20:44dollar denominated. You have essentially
  586. 20:46two key players on the scene. One very
  587. 20:49largely dominant and the other one a
  588. 20:50little bit
  589. 20:51less so. And one is definitely trying to
  590. 20:55comply with the rules. The other one
  591. 20:57couldn't care less about the rules.
  592. 20:58Okay? [laughter]
  593. 20:59And you know
  594. 21:03that's an issue. No, I think I think I
  595. 21:04think that is a legitimate issue.
  596. 21:06>> mention any name by the way, huh?
  597. 21:09I I think I think most of the people can
  598. 21:11draw the inference.
  599. 21:12>> [laughter]
  600. 21:14>> Um so so
  601. 21:16how do we get to that sort of harmonized
  602. 21:18you know regime?
  603. 21:20I mean who's who's going to who's that
  604. 21:21who's going to lead that? Is that a
  605. 21:22Financial Stability Board? Is it the
  606. 21:24Committee on Payments and
  607. 21:25>> the FSB has issued quite a lot of
  608. 21:27recommendations and guidelines in
  609. 21:29relation to stablecoins.
  610. 21:30>> of the countries to Yes, absolutely. You
  611. 21:32know, you need to have
  612. 21:34you know, I can speak for Europe. You
  613. 21:36you need to have the sponsorship of the
  614. 21:37Commission and the sponsorship on the
  615. 21:39other side of whoever is going to come
  616. 21:40up. I guess it's Congress for from your
  617. 21:43perspective, wouldn't it? It's Congress
  618. 21:45and whoever is
  619. 21:47implementing and enforcing and that
  620. 21:48matters as well because you are in the
  621. 21:50sort of second layer of regulation.
  622. 21:52Yeah, and the central bank plays a role.
  623. 21:53I mean especially the Federal Reserve
  624. 21:54they've always been very very important
  625. 21:55in this in the payment space.
  626. 21:57>> Yeah.
  627. 21:57Um Yeah, but you have the Fed, you have
  628. 21:58the FDIC, you have the SEC.
  629. 22:01>> it's more complicated here than it
  630. 22:02probably should be.
  631. 22:03Okay, well you keep saying that we are
  632. 22:04complicated. So, I can tell you that you
  633. 22:06are this complicated. [laughter]
  634. 22:07>> No, absolutely.
  635. 22:09Absolutely. Let me switch gears once
  636. 22:11again. So, financial stability risk
  637. 22:12non-bank private credit we've been
  638. 22:14reading more and more about non-bank
  639. 22:16private credit.
  640. 22:17Uh how worried are you about the
  641. 22:19financial stability risks there?
  642. 22:21And what should we do about it? What how
  643. 22:22should how can we mitigate those risks?
  644. 22:25I think we should have more
  645. 22:26transparency, more data, more
  646. 22:28information
  647. 22:30than than we have at the moment. So, you
  648. 22:32you you hear one thing on the contrary.
  649. 22:33You have some who argue that you know,
  650. 22:35it's it's the canary in the coal mine
  651. 22:38and we are heading towards disaster.
  652. 22:40Others who seem to be well informed are
  653. 22:42saying well, this is not systemically
  654. 22:43important and it's only 2. something
  655. 22:45trillion. So, it's okay. 2. something
  656. 22:47trillion not not trillion.
  657. 22:49>> [laughter]
  658. 22:50>> Maybe a little less.
  659. 22:51Well, you have but that's the point.
  660. 22:53That's exactly what I'm saying. Some
  661. 22:55will tell you that it's 1.8 and other
  662. 22:56will tell you that it's 2.5. Well, the
  663. 23:00you know, the gap between the two is not
  664. 23:01totally insignificant but relative to
  665. 23:03the entire lending that is
  666. 23:05being given around the world, it is not
  667. 23:07that
  668. 23:09big a number. So, first thing you first
  669. 23:11thing you before is a lot more
  670. 23:12transparency. So, we need more
  671. 23:13information like who who who owes what
  672. 23:15to whom. Exactly. And what what is the
  673. 23:17what are the points of
  674. 23:18interconnectedness with the banking
  675. 23:20system as well? Mhm.
  676. 23:22And what is the level of information
  677. 23:23that is given to the retail investors in
  678. 23:25particular because I hear that you know,
  679. 23:27there is a tendency to attract retail
  680. 23:30investment into those those particular
  681. 23:33risk because they can be more reward.
  682. 23:35You know, I think if people know exactly
  683. 23:37what risk they're buying into that's
  684. 23:38fine. But retail investors are not
  685. 23:39necessarily the most informed investors
  686. 23:42to actually get into those businesses
  687. 23:43where liquidity is not necessarily as
  688. 23:45abundant as it would otherwise be in the
  689. 23:47banking system. No, absolutely. I mean
  690. 23:49there
  691. 23:49there should be some sort of suitability
  692. 23:51for sure for sure. I'm going to talk
  693. 23:53about probably the most popular subject
  694. 23:55of the last 6 months
  695. 23:57artificial intelligence.
  696. 23:59So
  697. 24:00central banks around the world are
  698. 24:02wrestling with what's what's the impact
  699. 24:04going to be on productivity
  700. 24:07employment inflation both in the short
  701. 24:10term and the medium term. How how are
  702. 24:11you thinking about it? Uh in ECB.
  703. 24:15Are are you thinking of it like this is
  704. 24:17really a benign it's going to raise
  705. 24:18productivity, hold down inflation you
  706. 24:20know, thousands flowers are going to
  707. 24:21bloom or are you more concerned about
  708. 24:24this disruptive impact?
  709. 24:26Well, I think
  710. 24:27I think along
  711. 24:29two lines. First line of thinking which
  712. 24:32is
  713. 24:33recent development really is
  714. 24:36what risks are we opening ourselves to
  715. 24:39with the artificial intelligence that is
  716. 24:42currently being developed and which is
  717. 24:44at the forefront of
  718. 24:47innovation, invention, creativity and
  719. 24:50and and potential risk. What what
  720. 24:52exactly
  721. 24:55are we opening ourselves to? And you
  722. 24:57know, I know it's I shouldn't be doing
  723. 24:59that but there is clearly
  724. 25:01an artificial intelligence company that
  725. 25:03has currently alerted
  726. 25:05all of us about the software. about the
  727. 25:07latest software development and the the
  728. 25:10the the
  729. 25:11the risk that can be identified for good
  730. 25:15are the risk that can be identified for
  731. 25:16bad.
  732. 25:17And I certainly think that all of us in
  733. 25:19the financial sector should be cognizant
  734. 25:22of that, be able to test it without risk
  735. 25:26and and certainly
  736. 25:28take the remedies and the precaution
  737. 25:30in order to mitigate those risks. So,
  738. 25:33that's one line of thinking which is
  739. 25:35which is recent development really
  740. 25:36because that company has had the courage
  741. 25:39to say whoops. We may have a problem
  742. 25:41here.
  743. 25:41>> We may have a problem. Yes.
  744. 25:44I think the other line of thinking has
  745. 25:45been fed by you know, much better
  746. 25:46thinkers than me. I'm thinking of
  747. 25:48Acemoglu, Simon Johnson,
  748. 25:51Krugman and and many others who are
  749. 25:53thinking about the consequences of
  750. 25:57artificial intelligence in terms of both
  751. 25:59productivity improvement, alternative
  752. 26:03between job
  753. 26:05displacement and job enhancement.
  754. 26:08Segregation of tasks and how it is going
  755. 26:11to affect the jobs.
  756. 26:14Um
  757. 26:16and how we going to deal with that.
  758. 26:19And I'm not sure that the jury is
  759. 26:20actually out as you know, I said
  760. 26:22recently I think you have a group of
  761. 26:25economists who are working hard on this
  762. 26:26concept and you you find
  763. 26:29There's a pretty wide range of views
  764. 26:30here.
  765. 26:30>> Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. In both in terms of
  766. 26:32productivity but in terms of
  767. 26:34consequences on on on the fabrics of our
  768. 26:36society. And you know, the employment
  769. 26:39versus unemployment, the skilling, the
  770. 26:41reskilling. Who is going to finance all
  771. 26:42that?
  772. 26:44And on the other hand you have
  773. 26:46the large tech the the the the big
  774. 26:48hyperscalers and and and the the you
  775. 26:50know, new developers um
  776. 26:53who rely on them or or are partnering
  777. 26:55with them who are saying that it's going
  778. 26:57to be nirvana.
  779. 27:00So, of course they have an incentive to
  780. 27:01say that.
  781. 27:02Absolutely. Absolutely. But I would say
  782. 27:04one thing.
  783. 27:05I would say that
  784. 27:07those developments are predicated on a
  785. 27:09world that is not too fragmented. Mhm.
  786. 27:12Because if it if there is too much
  787. 27:14fragmentation, if data has have to stay
  788. 27:17in particular corners behind certain
  789. 27:19walls
  790. 27:20if money doesn't move too much
  791. 27:24because of
  792. 27:25you know, further segregation,
  793. 27:28fragmentation
  794. 27:29then this movement of artificial
  795. 27:31intelligence will find its limit.
  796. 27:33How how do you think think about AI in
  797. 27:36terms of Europe's position? So, it's
  798. 27:38really a US story and a
  799. 27:40China story competing with each other
  800. 27:43and Europe is sort of not that
  801. 27:45competitive in this space.
  802. 27:46>> Sometimes there is value in being a
  803. 27:48second. So, you so
  804. 27:50being being a fast follower is that sort
  805. 27:51of the model?
  806. 27:52>> [laughter]
  807. 27:53>> Yeah, well you may you may save a lot of
  808. 27:55money on the long run.
  809. 27:56>> in time if the first line of thinking
  810. 27:57that I was referring to
  811. 28:00materializes and if we face those risks
  812. 28:02of suddenly some of our you know, health
  813. 28:05data management system or our
  814. 28:07international payment system or you
  815. 28:10know, everything that is actually
  816. 28:12managed by
  817. 28:14by by software system that have been
  818. 28:17thought through in the last 20 years if
  819. 28:19that is at risk.
  820. 28:21We are going to ask ourselves and we
  821. 28:23will have to answer the question of the
  822. 28:25governance.
  823. 28:27Who who is going to determine the use,
  824. 28:29the non-use, the barriers, the
  825. 28:31liabilities? Yeah. You know, I was
  826. 28:33reading recently that Illinois is
  827. 28:35thinking of exempting all AI companies
  828. 28:38of any liability.
  829. 28:40I am sorry.
  830. 28:42I'm a lawyer by background. This is not
  831. 28:44possible.
  832. 28:45You know? So.
  833. 28:47Well, thank you very much. It's been a
  834. 28:48great conversation.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of In Conversation with European Central Bank President Christine Lagarde at BWC's 2026 Spring Summit by Bretton Woods Committee, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 5,070 words across 834 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.