Ilaria Salis, cosa dice davvero la sentenza? — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone. In this video, I’d
- 0:02like to return to the Ilaria Salis case
- 0:04because, as I anticipated, I wanted to
- 0:07get the full judgment, which I managed
- 0:09to obtain. I’d like to read the
- 0:12judgment with you in this video and
- 0:14analyze it, because when I actually
- 0:16read it, I didn't find the things I
- 0:18expected to find; so, I would also like
- 0:20to have a discussion about this. And
- 0:23then, in the last few days, things have
- 0:25come out that I actually find quite
- 0:27unfair. Unfair in what sense? Well, in
- 0:30the sense that I don't find a reference
- 0:32to what was actually said within this
- 0:34judgment. So, I would like to talk
- 0:37about all these things, and then I’d
- 0:39also like to analyze the crisis
- 0:41communication management of Ilaria
- 0:43Salis, which in my opinion is further
- 0:45aggravating her situation—not because
- 0:47I want to make fun of her, but because
- 0:49communication is my field. I care about
- 0:53this particularly on the left; we’ve
- 0:55been arguing and clashing for years on
- 0:57one specific point. It’s true that
- 1:00many on the left think communication
- 1:02isn’t all that fundamental, whereas,
- 1:05in fact, communication is fundamental
- 1:07because it’s almost more important
- 1:10than the message you are conveying. For
- 1:12what reason? Because if you convey even
- 1:15the best message in the world, but you
- 1:17get it wrong—you completely mess up
- 1:19the communication—then your message
- 1:21will never reach your intended audience
- 1:23, or it could be distorted simply
- 1:25because you are communicating poorly.
- 1:27So, I’m keen to do this analysis as
- 1:30well, to throw some more topics into
- 1:32the mix. I think this video will be
- 1:34long, so I might split it into two
- 1:35parts, so that those who only want to
- 1:37hear the analysis of the judgment can
- 1:39watch just that part. Those who also
- 1:41want to hear the communication analysis
- 1:43will know at what point in the video to
- 1:45find it. But before we dive into
- 1:47today’s video, I’ll take the usual
- 1:48two seconds of your time. Hi, I’m
- 1:50Charlotte Matteini, and I’m a
- 1:51journalist specializing in domestic
- 1:53politics and investigations into labor
- 1:55exploitation. If you like the content I
- 1:57provide, the only thing I ask is for
- 1:59you to click the "Subscribe" button, as
- 2:00that helps me grow this channel. And if
- 2:04you want to comment, like, or engage in
- 2:06other ways, all those things help
- 2:08support my work, so I thank you. So,
- 2:11let’s start with the reconstruction
- 2:13of the events and what the judgment
- 2:15actually says. The ruling, as we have
- 2:18learned in recent days, found Ilaria
- 2:21Salis in default, because Ilaria Salis
- 2:23did not appear in the proceedings, and
- 2:26she explained that she did not appear
- 2:28because, in fact, she never received
- 2:30notification of the filing of the
- 2:33appeal from the opposing counsel. But
- 2:36we will talk about this matter later
- 2:38anyway. So, in the ruling, the judge
- 2:41writes: "With a filed and duly served
- 2:44appeal, the plaintiff party summoned
- 2:46the defendant party mentioned above,
- 2:49asking the court, primarily, to
- 2:51ascertain and declare the
- 2:52discriminatory nature of the dismissal
- 2:55communicated to the appellants by
- 2:57letter dated February 17, 2025, and, as
- 3:00a result, to issue any appropriate
- 3:03measures to fully remove the effects of
- 3:06the reported discriminatory conduct."
- 3:09and consequently to order the defendant
- 3:11to pay the appellants, also by way of
- 3:14damages, all compensation lost from the
- 3:16date of dismissal to the expiration
- 3:19date provided by their respective
- 3:21contracts at the monthly rate of 2,900
- 3:23euros and 3,000 euros for the other
- 3:26former parliamentary assistant, or in a
- 3:28different amount deemed just.
- 3:31Alternatively, to ascertain and declare
- 3:34the nullity and/or illegality of the
- 3:36dismissal, communicated to the
- 3:38appellants by letters also dated
- 3:40February 17, 2025; and as a result, to
- 3:42sentence the Honorable Ilaria Salis to
- 3:45compensate the damages suffered by the
- 3:47appellants as a consequence of the
- 3:49dismissal, to be determined in relation
- 3:52to the salary due until the
- 3:53contractually agreed expiration, at the
- 3:57monthly rate mentioned before or in a
- 3:59different amount deemed just. As a
- 4:03further alternative, finally, to
- 4:05ascertain and declare the right of Mr.
- 4:07So-and-so to receive the sum of EUR
- 4:093,000 as compensation in lieu of notice
- 4:11and to sentence the defendant to pay
- 4:13this amount to the appellant. The
- 4:17defendant party did not appear in court
- 4:19, remaining in default. From this first
- 4:22part, we understand three things: that
- 4:25the appellants first asked to ascertain
- 4:27and declare the discriminatory nature
- 4:29of the dismissal communicated to them;
- 4:32then to ascertain and declare the
- 4:34nullity and/or illegality of the
- 4:36dismissal, to sentence Ilaria Salis to
- 4:39damages for this second reason; and
- 4:41furthermore, also to ascertain and
- 4:44declare the right of Mr. So-and-so to
- 4:47receive € 3,000 as compensation in
- 4:50lieu of notice and to sentence the
- 4:52defendant to pay this amount. However,
- 4:56the issue of ascertaining the
- 4:57discriminatory nature of the dismissal
- 4:59actually disappears because the two
- 5:01parties eventually waived the desire to
- 5:04pursue this matter further. Then the
- 5:07ruling continues with this: the
- 5:09defendant party did not appear in court
- 5:11, remaining in default. At the hearing,
- 5:14the plaintiff parties waived the claims
- 5:16brought as a primary matter relating to
- 5:18the discriminatory nature of the
- 5:20dismissal. Furthermore, they specified
- 5:24that the compensation sums to be
- 5:26recognized, calculated on monthly
- 5:29salary brackets, amount to 147,900
- 5:31euros for Mr. X and 153,000 euros for
- 5:34Ms. Y, taking into account that the
- 5:36expiration date was in June 202-, the
- 5:39end of the contract term. So, these
- 5:42were the requests made by the two
- 5:43opposing parties. The thing that
- 5:46strikes me immediately is that, in
- 5:48reality, the two parties never
- 5:50requested the reclassification of the
- 5:52employment relationship as subordinate.
- 5:56This was the doubt I had raised because
- 5:58when Ilaria Salis released her press
- 6:00statement saying she had hired these
- 6:02two people as VAT-registered
- 6:03contractors and with a COC, which are
- 6:05precarious contracts by excellence,
- 6:07this could have been a huge problem
- 6:09from a reputational standpoint. Why is
- 6:12that? Because of Ilaria Salis's
- 6:15positioning, an extremely clear stance
- 6:17on certain topics and values; therefore
- 6:19, if you really want to release those
- 6:21details that the press hadn't reported
- 6:24until that moment, you then have to
- 6:26explain them. So, if I read the
- 6:29sentence, these two opposing parties
- 6:31never asked for the reclassification of
- 6:33the employment relationship as
- 6:35subordinate, so I imagine either there
- 6:37were no grounds for it, because in this
- 6:39case, it is the party seeking
- 6:41recognition of a subordinate
- 6:43relationship that must prove
- 6:44subordination. Or it could simply be
- 6:47that the relationships were genuinely a
- 6:50real COC and a real VAT-registered
- 6:52contract. Since these are not illegal
- 6:55contracts, as we have said many times,
- 6:57but are problematic contracts from the
- 6:59point of view of Salis's positioning—
- 7:01which is a different matter—this
- 7:03should have been explained. However,
- 7:06Ilaria Salis did not explain this,
- 7:07neither in the stories she released via
- 7:09her Instagram profile, nor the day
- 7:11before yesterday, nor in the interview
- 7:13with Repubblica, where she basically
- 7:15reiterated the same content we had
- 7:17already heard in the stories. And this,
- 7:19in my opinion, complicates the
- 7:21situation. Why is that? Because you are
- 7:24not communicating one of the central
- 7:26points that could actually turn the
- 7:27narrative in your favor, or at the very
- 7:30least, extinguish a source of
- 7:31controversy. Now, as we read from the
- 7:34sentence, the requests from the
- 7:35opposing parties were specific, and the
- 7:38judge ruled against Ilaria Salis based
- 7:40on the mechanism I already mentioned.
- 7:42Why? By default, therefore condemned
- 7:45automatically, simply because as the
- 7:47employer, she did not appear in the
- 7:49proceedings; thus, she could not prove
- 7:51her side, and the judge consequently
- 7:53condemned Ilaria Salis automatically.
- 7:56But there was one request the opposing
- 7:58parties had made that they later
- 8:00abandoned, namely that of
- 8:01discriminatory dismissal. The opposing
- 8:05parties did not follow up on this
- 8:07request, so the only remaining claim is
- 8:09exclusively the challenge against the
- 8:12dismissal for just cause. The appeal,
- 8:14with regard to the remaining
- 8:16subordinate claims, must be upheld for
- 8:18the reasons set forth below. It is on
- 8:21record that on July 30, 2024, a
- 8:23contract for coordinated and continuous
- 8:26collaboration was signed between Ilaria
- 8:28Salis and Ms. Y, in accordance with the
- 8:31law. Okay. The subject of the contract
- 8:34was determined as follows: development
- 8:36of projects aimed at enhancing the
- 8:38European parliamentary role within the
- 8:40European Parliament, and the management
- 8:42of campaigns and events in Italian and
- 8:44European territory. Ex-post analysis
- 8:47and collection of feedback aimed at the
- 8:50client's parliamentary work with
- 8:51reference to the local economy, labor
- 8:53economic policies, information analysis
- 8:56regarding the deputy's activity, and
- 8:58assistance with contacts for national,
- 9:00regional, and local authorities. The
- 9:04contract was stipulated until July 16,
- 9:062029, without prejudice to the
- 9:08possibility of early termination should
- 9:10the client’s parliamentary tenure end
- 9:13. As for the claimant X, the defendant
- 9:16entered into a service provision
- 9:18contract, the object of which was
- 9:20determined as follows. Development of
- 9:23projects aimed at enhancing the role of
- 9:25the European parliamentarian within the
- 9:27European Parliament and the activities
- 9:29carried out by them; development,
- 9:31design, and management of campaigns and
- 9:33events in Italian and European
- 9:34territory aimed at communicating these
- 9:36issues, in short, very similar to that
- 9:38of party Y; political consulting and
- 9:40assistance in strategic and tactical
- 9:42areas; designing and managing dialogue,
- 9:44discussion, and exchange activities on
- 9:46European issues of interest to the
- 9:47deputy regarding the significance of
- 9:49the parliamentary role, the work
- 9:52carried out by the European
- 9:54parliamentarian in the legislature, and
- 9:56its meaning in the context of future
- 9:58European development. Then: creation,
- 10:00development, and administration, on
- 10:02Italian and European territory, of a
- 10:04regional network of partners and
- 10:05contacts who aim, through their
- 10:07specific expertise or the role they
- 10:09hold, to assist and/or collaborate with
- 10:11the parliamentarian on the issues they
- 10:12manage and develop within the European
- 10:14Parliament; consulting and production
- 10:16of content useful to the
- 10:17parliamentarian for carrying out their
- 10:19political representation activity and
- 10:21so on. This contract, exactly like the
- 10:24previous one, was for a fixed term with
- 10:26the final date coinciding with the end
- 10:28of the parliamentary mandate. On
- 10:32February 17, 2025, the defendant
- 10:34communicated the early termination of
- 10:36the contract with Party X, stating that
- 10:38this withdrawal was motivated by the
- 10:40breakdown of the fiduciary relationship
- 10:43, which was particularly intense
- 10:45regarding the collaboration on
- 10:46enhancing the European parliamentary
- 10:49role, as objective grounds for
- 10:50professional unfitness had
- 10:52progressively emerged—eventually
- 10:54becoming absolute impediments—as
- 10:56evidenced by the requested report, the
- 11:00contents of which were largely
- 11:02unacceptable, linked to the failure to
- 11:05carry out assigned tasks, such as,
- 11:07merely by way of example: inadequate
- 11:09support for parliamentary work; failure
- 11:11to establish a national contact center
- 11:14for the electorate to launch projects
- 11:16and campaigns in Milan (despite
- 11:18repeated requests); and highly
- 11:20inefficient management of the email
- 11:22inbox with a lack of timely responses
- 11:24to received mail, as well as the
- 11:27situation of environmental
- 11:29incompatibility. And personal issues
- 11:31that had developed, along with a clear
- 11:33lack of understanding of the role as a
- 11:36mere collaborator. In fact, an
- 11:38autonomous management of unagreed-upon
- 11:40activities emerged, which was not in
- 11:42line with the assigned role and the
- 11:44client's needs. The same measure was
- 11:47also adopted against the other party,
- 11:49whose appointment was revoked with
- 11:51immediate effect with the following
- 11:53communication. Hereby, taking into
- 11:56account the manifest dissatisfaction
- 11:58already expressed regarding the
- 12:00contents of your collaboration, as well
- 12:02as the inadequate and unacceptable
- 12:03contents of the report requested for
- 12:05the justification and verification of
- 12:07activities deemed unsatisfactory, I
- 12:09inform you of the termination with
- 12:10immediate effect, determined by the
- 12:12breakdown of the fiduciary relationship
- 12:14. So these are the two communications
- 12:18that Salis sent to these two
- 12:19collaborators to rescind the contracts
- 12:21she had signed until the end of the
- 12:23term. On March 26, 2025, the plaintiffs
- 12:27challenged the termination out-of-court
- 12:30, simultaneously offering their work
- 12:33services. With this appeal, following
- 12:36the waiver of the primary claims, the
- 12:38plaintiffs denounced the illegitimacy
- 12:40of the challenged terminations because
- 12:42they were not supported by just cause.
- 12:46Well then, regarding the qualification,
- 12:48the judge writes, it appears evident
- 12:50that both employment relationships fall
- 12:52within the scope of Article 409 of the
- 12:54Code of Civil Procedure, being
- 12:56characterized by the requirements of
- 12:58personality, continuity, and
- 13:00coordination. As for the contract of
- 13:03Party X, the reference to
- 13:04quasi-subordinate work, in the sense
- 13:06provided for by civil procedural law,
- 13:09is made explicit in the contract text.
- 13:12As for the contract of Party Y, in
- 13:14light of the factual statements, the
- 13:15existence of the elements indicated by
- 13:17Article 409 can be considered
- 13:19established, also by virtue of the
- 13:21inclusion of the employment
- 13:22relationship within the scope of
- 13:24non-entrepreneurial self-employment as
- 13:26per Law 81/2017. It is also indubitable
- 13:30that the defendant intended to avail
- 13:32herself for both relationships of a
- 13:34termination with immediate effect for
- 13:36just cause. So, the judge then writes,
- 13:39this emerges from the withdrawal letter
- 13:41sent to Party X, which makes explicit
- 13:44reference to Article 5, point number 3,
- 13:46of the contract, which provided that
- 13:48the client may withdraw before the
- 13:50contractual term if, during the
- 13:52relationship, objective profiles of the
- 13:54collaborator's professional
- 13:55unsuitability emerged, such as, by way
- 13:57of example: failure to carry out the
- 14:00activities entrusted to the
- 14:01collaborator, absence repeated more
- 14:04than twice from coordination meetings
- 14:06and/or periodic joint review meetings,
- 14:09clear lack of technical-professional
- 14:11and/or environmental suitability of the
- 14:13collaborator. In any case, the same
- 14:15article, at point 2, recognizes the
- 14:18right of withdrawal before the
- 14:19expiration of the term for just cause.
- 14:22So, this was written in the contract.
- 14:24Regarding the withdrawal letter sent to
- 14:27Party Y, in which the withdrawal is
- 14:29communicated with immediate effect,
- 14:31considering that the contract provided
- 14:34alternatively for unilateral withdrawal
- 14:36with 30 days 'written notice or
- 14:38withdrawal with immediate effect if the
- 14:41provider commits a serious violation of
- 14:43the provisions of this contract or is
- 14:46unable to provide their services, it is
- 14:48therefore easy to conclude that the
- 14:50defendant, Salis, availed herself of
- 14:53the second withdrawal option, having
- 14:55not provided any notice. So, in Party
- 14:58Y's contract, there was the possibility
- 15:00of rescinding the contract by giving a
- 15:0330-day notice to this counterparty, but
- 15:05in this case, Salis decided to avail
- 15:08herself of immediate withdrawal, which
- 15:10was, in any case, always stipulated in
- 15:12the contract. Given the above, since we
- 15:15are dealing with withdrawal for just
- 15:17cause, the burden of proof for the just
- 15:20cause certainly lies with the employer.
- 15:22However, the defendant, by remaining in
- 15:25default, evidently did not fulfill her
- 15:27burden. I have already explained this
- 15:29in the previous video. Salis was, in
- 15:32fact, automatically condemned because,
- 15:34as the employer was called upon to
- 15:37justify the just cause with which she
- 15:39carried out these dismissals, and
- 15:41having not appeared at the proceedings
- 15:43—because it was explained that this
- 15:45appeal had been notified to the
- 15:47residence address, but she had not been
- 15:50made aware of it—she did not appear
- 15:52because, basically, she did not know
- 15:54about the existence of these
- 15:56proceedings. The judge effectively
- 16:00condemned Ilaria Salis automatically
- 16:02because, as the employer has the burden
- 16:04of proof to demonstrate that the just
- 16:06cause was indeed just, she could not do
- 16:08so because she was not present at the
- 16:10proceedings, and therefore she was
- 16:12condemned. It must therefore be
- 16:15affirmed that there was no just cause
- 16:17for the challenged withdrawals, as the
- 16:19judge writes. Having ascertained, for
- 16:21the reasons set out, the illegitimacy
- 16:23of the withdrawals, it is necessary to
- 16:25proceed to examine the consequences. In
- 16:28this regard, we can maintain the
- 16:30precedent according to which, in the
- 16:32event of an employer's dismissal
- 16:33without just cause, a fixed-term
- 16:35employee is entitled to damages that
- 16:37may be legitimately quantified on an
- 16:39equitable basis, equal to the wages
- 16:41they would have received until the
- 16:43expiration of the term. Regarding the
- 16:46amount, the calculation most recently
- 16:48offered by the plaintiff's defense can
- 16:50be accepted, as it is based on the
- 16:52salary the workers would have earned by
- 16:54the expiration of their contracts.
- 16:56Hence the staggering figure of €
- 16:58300,000, which is to be divided by two
- 17:00and which, in any case, covered a
- 17:02period of years. Legal costs follow the
- 17:05losing party, and the judge finds and
- 17:06declares the unlawfulness of the
- 17:08dismissal communicated to the
- 17:10plaintiffs. The court orders the
- 17:13defendant to pay damages, € 147,900
- 17:15to one party and € 153,000 to the
- 17:17other, and orders the defendant to pay
- 17:20the legal fees in favor of the
- 17:21plaintiffs. Now, the effectiveness of
- 17:26this ruling has been suspended, in the
- 17:28sense that since Salis has filed an
- 17:30appeal, she will not only try to prove
- 17:33a defect in notification—meaning that
- 17:35she did not appear at the proceedings
- 17:38because something went wrong—but she
- 17:40will also try to justify and prove, as
- 17:43the employer, that those dismissals
- 17:45were actually carried out for just
- 17:47cause. Now, yesterday, I'll show you,
- 17:50the newspaper came out with this
- 17:52article where in one passage—I won't
- 17:55read it all to you because it doesn't
- 17:57interest us—in this passage that I am
- 17:59highlighting for you now, it says this
- 18:02thing that I cannot find anywhere in
- 18:04the ruling. In his conclusions, Judge
- 18:07Franco Caroleo is clear. The two were
- 18:10not freelancers as Salis had disguised
- 18:12them, but fixed-term employees. In
- 18:16reality, Judge Franco Caroleo does not
- 18:18say this anywhere; on the contrary,
- 18:20this ruling states that the
- 18:22relationships were quasi-subordinate,
- 18:24no one addressed the merits of the
- 18:26relationship, and the two opposing
- 18:28parties never requested the
- 18:29reclassification of the relationship as
- 18:31subordinate. So, saying something like
- 18:34that, I cannot understand where it
- 18:36could come from because it is simply
- 18:38not written in the ruling. And that is
- 18:41exactly the part that struck me,
- 18:43because from a positioning standpoint,
- 18:45I would have highlighted the use of
- 18:47these two contracts, which are
- 18:49precarious by definition, but if you
- 18:51explain that they were used correctly,
- 18:54the controversy naturally deflates; the
- 18:56controversy stems from the fact that
- 18:59these two contract types have
- 19:00unfortunately been used improperly in
- 19:03the Italian Parliament for years,
- 19:06masking what were actually subordinate
- 19:08employment relationships, but these
- 19:10forms are flexible, lack protections,
- 19:12cost less, and so on. They preferred to
- 19:15use these at the expense of workers'
- 19:17rights. Well, after all, if it really
- 19:20had been on that scale, it would have
- 19:22been even more serious than the
- 19:23conviction itself. But there is
- 19:26absolutely no trace of this in the
- 19:27court ruling. Now I would move on to
- 19:29the analysis of Ilaria Salis's crisis
- 19:31communication, or whoever is handling
- 19:33it. For her. I don't know who manages
- 19:35it for her, I don't know if she handles
- 19:37it herself, I have no idea, but the
- 19:39fact is that I want to analyze the
- 19:41communication. The communication errors
- 19:43on the part of Ilaria Salis start
- 19:45basically right away. For what reason?
- 19:47Because the first big mistake was how
- 19:49the press release was constructed. Why
- 19:51was that press release the first big
- 19:54mistake? Because, precisely, in that
- 19:56press release she reveals the existence
- 19:58of these two precarious contract types
- 20:01that clash with her positioning,
- 20:02without explaining, however, or giving
- 20:04details on why she had chosen those
- 20:06contracts. And then, in the closing,
- 20:09she uses the "without my knowledge"
- 20:11phrase, reminiscent of Scajola, which,
- 20:14when you have to manage crisis
- 20:15communication, honestly, borrowing
- 20:17language from the opposing side, or the
- 20:20right, is not really a great idea,
- 20:22because it immediately puts you in a
- 20:24position where you could become a meme
- 20:26or an object of mockery. So, using that
- 20:29"without my knowledge"...Honestly, when
- 20:31I saw it, I was just completely
- 20:32disheartened. Beyond the fact that the
- 20:36press release included a legalist
- 20:38stance—and for heaven's sake,
- 20:40legalism is absolutely a value that
- 20:42must be respected—but in that passage
- 20:44, this legalism regarding the fact that
- 20:46it was a first-instance ruling and she
- 20:48had filed an appeal confident that she
- 20:50could overturn it, all of that is also
- 20:53a construction borrowed from right-wing
- 20:55language and is not a construction that
- 20:57tends to belong to Ilaria Salis's
- 20:59linguistic register. So, reading that
- 21:03stuff from the perspective of the
- 21:05public, or anyone facing this press
- 21:06release, one is left stunned, thinking:
- 21:09"Am I reading a statement from Ilaria
- 21:11Salis or Daniela Santanché?" Regarding
- 21:14the language and the linguistic
- 21:15register, I am not comparing the two
- 21:18people. So, this is the primary mistake
- 21:20that was made. The other main mistake
- 21:23is this series of stories that I would
- 21:25like to show you now, because beyond
- 21:27the visual impact—honestly, the first
- 21:29comment I had when I saw these stories
- 21:32was that it reminds me of Chiara
- 21:34Ferragni’s sweater. Chiara Ferragni's
- 21:37sweater caused quite a stir because,
- 21:39well, gray represents the color of
- 21:41compromise, of someone who doesn't want
- 21:44to question themselves or take a step
- 21:46back. There is that big line about
- 21:49communication errors that was
- 21:50essentially an admission of "I don't
- 21:53want to take any responsibility for the
- 21:55mess I created." But here too, Ilaria
- 21:58Salis is wearing a neutral-colored
- 22:00shirt, which might be fine, but you
- 22:02have this white background, you’re
- 22:04against the wall—it really looks like
- 22:07an image of Aldo Moro when he was
- 22:08kidnapped. In terms of visual impact,
- 22:12communication isn't just what you say;
- 22:14it's the whole context, it’s the
- 22:16paraverbal, there are many things to
- 22:18evaluate. I mean, the visual impact is
- 22:21exactly what I wouldn't want to see.
- 22:23Unfortunately, when she speaks, I also
- 22:25see a huge mistake here. I don't
- 22:27understand who could have given the
- 22:29green light to publish stories recorded
- 22:31in this manner, because we’re about
- 22:34to hear it. She has a very monotonous,
- 22:37single-note tone; you can see she is
- 22:39scared, and when you are at the center
- 22:41of a reputation crisis, you cannot let
- 22:43yourself be seen as scared because you
- 22:45are giving people more ammunition.
- 22:48Would you ever bleed in front of a
- 22:50shark voluntarily? Absolutely not. For
- 22:52the same reason, because you would be
- 22:54giving the shark a way to attack you
- 22:56more easily. So, there are a whole
- 22:59series of things that aren't working,
- 23:01and I’d like to analyze them simply
- 23:03because this is my field, it’s my
- 23:05passion, and I like doing these
- 23:06analyses, but I’ll show you right now
- 23:08why all these things aren't working.
- 23:11The rights of workers are a very
- 23:13serious matter. For this reason, faced
- 23:16with the often partial or incomplete
- 23:18news circulating at this time, I want
- 23:20to clarify things. With great
- 23:23transparency, I want to tell you how
- 23:25things really went and answer the
- 23:27questions that many people are
- 23:29understandably and rightly asking me.
- 23:32To the slanderers, however, I want to
- 23:34remind you that there will be zero
- 23:36tolerance for any exploitation or
- 23:38distortion of this affair. Now, she
- 23:41starts off with a very strong stance
- 23:43here, recalling her battles in favor of
- 23:45workers 'rights, and that is perfectly
- 23:47fine. Then she shifts the focus to the
- 23:51slanderers, those people who are
- 23:53spreading half-truths. The point is,
- 23:57it's not that you can't do this; when
- 23:59you have to manage a reputation crisis,
- 24:02it's not necessarily the case that
- 24:04everyone hit by one has actually caused
- 24:07damage on the scale that is being
- 24:09claimed. There may be people who want
- 24:12to stand their ground because they are
- 24:14absolutely convinced of the decision
- 24:16they have made. But what changes things
- 24:19, what truly shifts everything, is how
- 24:22you communicate your decision and your
- 24:24reasons. Here we have a video recorded
- 24:26with her back against the wall. She is
- 24:29clearly reading a text and is not fluid
- 24:31; there are pauses that are not
- 24:33well-timed. Her eyes, at times—and
- 24:36you will see this later on—are wide
- 24:39open, which really makes you understand
- 24:41that she is under stress and afraid,
- 24:43and so, all of this contributes to
- 24:45distancing and shifting the focus of
- 24:47the person watching these stories. But
- 24:51let's move on to the other story she
- 24:53posted.
- 24:54During the trial, I was not present in
- 24:55the courtroom, but certainly not by my
- 24:57own choice. I wasn't there because I
- 24:59had never been informed of the hearing.
- 25:01I didn't even know that proceedings had
- 25:03been initiated against me. In this type
- 25:06of trial, it is the opposing party that
- 25:08must take action to serve the documents
- 25:10, which essentially did not happen. In
- 25:13fact, they chose to have the document
- 25:15served by a bailiff at my residence in
- 25:18Italy, and the notification never
- 25:20reached me. This first attempt at
- 25:23notification failed, so instead of
- 25:24sending me a certified email or
- 25:26contacting me at my official addresses,
- 25:28which they had used many times to
- 25:30communicate with me, they decided to
- 25:32use the procedure for untraceable
- 25:34persons. Doesn't it seem absurd to you
- 25:37that a member of the European
- 25:38Parliament, a public figure, would be
- 25:40considered as if they were untraceable?
- 25:42So, here Salis explains why she was
- 25:45convicted and returns to this issue
- 25:47that is causing much debate: the fact
- 25:49that they failed to notify her of this
- 25:52appeal, which ultimately led to the
- 25:54conviction in absentia. Now everything
- 25:58hinges on this, because the opposing
- 26:01counsel served this appeal to Salis's
- 26:03residential address, and Salis wonders
- 26:06why they didn't try other avenues.
- 26:09I’m not in Italy very often, but
- 26:11since I’m a well-known member of
- 26:14parliament, my workplace is public
- 26:16knowledge, so they could have easily
- 26:18sent me an official email. Now, lawyers
- 26:22are claiming that no, the email
- 26:24couldn’t be sent because Salis isn't
- 26:28registered as a private citizen with
- 26:31her certified email address in the
- 26:33digital domicile registry. So this is
- 26:38something to be verified on appeal,
- 26:41because as I said, Salis could argue a
- 26:43lack of proper notification, meaning
- 26:46the appeal wasn't served to her
- 26:48correctly by the opposing lawyers. This
- 26:52is a crucial point in the case. It's
- 26:55exactly what Salis will try to use to
- 26:57challenge the ruling that ordered her
- 27:00to pay 300,000 euros in damages, though
- 27:02as I mentioned, the execution of this
- 27:04sentence is currently suspended. Now,
- 27:08in an interview with the newspaper
- 27:11Repubblica, where she repeats the
- 27:13content of her stories from last night,
- 27:16Salis says the ruling was served on May
- 27:194th, two months after the judge's
- 27:21decision, and sent to her home address;
- 27:24the bailiff left a notice, and she went
- 27:27to collect it. After that, she
- 27:30authorized the preparation of this 100-
- 27:32page appeal to fully reconstruct
- 27:34everything she couldn't state in the
- 27:36first instance. She also tells us that
- 27:38there will be a second hearing after
- 27:40the summer, so we should have more
- 27:42information on this case then.
- 27:45Honestly, I believe that ending the
- 27:46relationship with the two collaborators
- 27:48was the right decision. It was not a
- 27:51choice made lightly. I had known them
- 27:53for a long time, and they had followed
- 27:55my situation while I was in prison in
- 27:57Hungary. At the time, I believed they
- 27:59were doing it with no ulterior motives.
- 28:00Over time, however, I realized that the
- 28:03reality was more complex. As the
- 28:05collaboration began and months passed,
- 28:07I had the feeling that the relationship
- 28:09was increasingly being used as leverage
- 28:12to try and influence my decisions. To
- 28:14this, a problem of serious work-related
- 28:16negligence was added. I'll give you
- 28:18just one example. For weeks and weeks,
- 28:20they wouldn't answer emails from the
- 28:22local office, even though that was one
- 28:24of their main duties. And it wasn't an
- 28:28isolated incident; it was constant. I
- 28:31pointed out these issues several times,
- 28:33trying to resolve them. Unfortunately,
- 28:35instead of the situation improving, the
- 28:37atmosphere became increasingly
- 28:38conflictual.
- 28:40Now, the issue is that she is trying to
- 28:42explain how things went, obviously
- 28:45without going too much into detail, but
- 28:47the point is we always return to how
- 28:50these stories were recorded. You can
- 28:54see the fearful look in her wide eyes;
- 28:56it's clear she is in a high-stress
- 28:58situation that is perhaps difficult to
- 29:00manage right now. The point is that by
- 29:04managing the reputation crisis this way
- 29:06, the stress only worsens because,
- 29:08obviously, this type of management is
- 29:11not yielding results precisely because
- 29:13the communication is completely wrong.
- 29:17Here she tries to explain her reasons,
- 29:19and so far I have never questioned that
- 29:21she might be right on the merits, also
- 29:23because the judge himself did not go
- 29:25into the merits of the case, issuing an
- 29:27automatic conviction because she was in
- 29:29default. The big issue that has already
- 29:33been raised was that of the
- 29:35notification, as it is unclear how
- 29:37exactly it was served. From what we
- 29:40gather from the ruling, the
- 29:42notification was considered properly
- 29:44executed based on the statements made
- 29:46by the opposing party's lawyer. And so
- 29:51this matter could effectively be
- 29:53re-argued on appeal, just as the merits
- 29:55of the case could be discussed to
- 29:57understand if Salis actually acted with
- 30:00justification; so, does that just cause
- 30:02really exist, and can she prove it or
- 30:05not? The point is that, in the
- 30:08communication she crafts for this story
- 30:09, she seems to almost discredit the
- 30:11other party. Which is something that,
- 30:14given her current personal standing (
- 30:16i.e., fearful), I would avoid doing,
- 30:18especially if one cannot go into the
- 30:20merits; because it seems like an
- 30:22allusive discrediting that, however,
- 30:24lacks a foundation. Now, the
- 30:26foundations might exist, but
- 30:28communicated this way, in my opinion,
- 30:30they are counterproductive.
- 30:31At a certain point, I realized that the
- 30:34relationship of trust, essential for
- 30:36working together in a context like
- 30:37politics, had been broken. For this
- 30:40reason, I proposed an agreed-upon
- 30:42solution to them, but I was told that
- 30:44there were two alternatives: either
- 30:47continue or end up in court. They also
- 30:49told me.
- 30:50Now, I am pointing out a narrative
- 30:52inconsistency here because, precisely,
- 30:54she says an alternative, a solution,
- 30:56had been proposed to them. I don't know
- 31:00if it was an out-of-court settlement
- 31:02because an article in Open says that
- 31:04there was actually an attempt at an
- 31:06amicable settlement, but it is unclear
- 31:08where Open gets this information. It is
- 31:11not in the ruling. Open traces it back
- 31:13to the newspaper as a source, but this
- 31:15information is not in the newspaper's
- 31:17articles. So, anyway, I don't know,
- 31:19maybe an amicable out-of-court
- 31:21settlement was attempted, we don't know
- 31:24when, we don't know in what way, okay?
- 31:27But here you say that, well, this
- 31:29conciliation was attempted, it didn't
- 31:31succeed, so they had told her that,
- 31:32well, the matter would be resolved in
- 31:34court. Now, did you never have an
- 31:37inkling that something like this could
- 31:39happen? I don't mean going to court so
- 31:43much, but the fact that, anyway, the
- 31:45moment you have a ruling in hand—
- 31:47because, as Salis herself later said,
- 31:50the ruling, the conviction is from
- 31:52March, the ruling was served to her
- 31:54residential address on May 4th and then
- 31:57indeed she started doing everything to
- 31:59challenge it and so on—but in these
- 32:02months, because this is the basis of
- 32:04crisis communication, didn't it occur
- 32:07to you that this story could actually
- 32:09reach the press and cause you
- 32:11reputational damage, that they would
- 32:13turn to the newspapers to ruin my
- 32:15public image? At that point, after
- 32:19ensuring that the termination of the
- 32:21relationship would not leave them
- 32:22without means of support—and believe
- 32:25me, that's not the case at all, given
- 32:27their current work activity—I decided
- 32:29to end the collaboration. Despite
- 32:32everything that happened afterward, I
- 32:34would make that choice again. it had
- 32:36become necessary to protect the proper.
- 32:38Now, in this story which, if I remember
- 32:40correctly, was the last one in this set
- 32:42, there is a fundamental piece of
- 32:44information that obviously, precisely
- 32:46because these stories were not well
- 32:48thought out from a communication
- 32:50standpoint, has been lost. And it was
- 32:52also lost in the interview that Salis
- 32:54gave to*Repubblica*the following
- 32:56morning.
- 32:57Why was I convicted for ending the
- 32:59professional relationship with two
- 33:01assistants? The answer is found in the
- 33:04first-instance ruling for a very simple
- 33:06reason. I was not present in the
- 33:08courtroom, and certainly not by my own
- 33:10choice. In trials of this type, in fact
- 33:12, it is always up to the employer to
- 33:14demonstrate just cause. However, I
- 33:17could not do so because I was
- 33:19blamelessly absent. This is not a final
- 33:23ruling, and when I was informed of it
- 33:25months later, I submitted an appeal of
- 33:27over 100 pages to the Court of Appeal
- 33:29containing the entire reconstruction of
- 33:31what happened and the documentation I
- 33:33could not present at the first-instance
- 33:36trial. In the meantime, the Court of
- 33:39Appeal has suspended the executive
- 33:41effectiveness of the ruling, and now I
- 33:43trust that the appeal process can do—
- 33:44what is the fundamental element? She
- 33:47says here, and reiterates it in the
- 33:49interview as well, that the Court of
- 33:51Appeal has suspended the effectiveness
- 33:53of the first-instance ruling. What does
- 33:55that mean, in plain terms? In labor law
- 33:58, these types of rulings are
- 34:00immediately enforceable. So, the moment
- 34:03you accrue a claim, you can start
- 34:05taking steps to initiate seizures and
- 34:08perhaps take possession of the money
- 34:10you are owed, as established by a judge
- 34:12. In this case, we have the Court of
- 34:15Appeal, which granted Salis a stay of
- 34:17execution. So, what does this tell us?
- 34:20That while Salis was initially
- 34:22sentenced through that automatic
- 34:24process, she has presented all the
- 34:26documents on appeal that should support
- 34:28her position on the merits. The appeal
- 34:31will certainly also challenge any
- 34:34potential defect in the notice, if this
- 34:36defect is indeed proven. But what the
- 34:39stay of execution is telling us is that
- 34:42the enforcement of the first-instance
- 34:44judgment had been triggered, and the
- 34:46Court has granted time, perhaps because
- 34:48it thinks the situation is not quite as
- 34:50clear at the moment. I have read you
- 34:53the judgment, along with the letters
- 34:55Salis sent to the two collaborators and
- 34:58the reasoning, which doesn't address
- 35:00the merits but still gives us a picture
- 35:02of what was in the contract. But this
- 35:05matter of the notice, which apparently
- 35:07was never received, is a mystery: this
- 35:09will actually have to be clarified. And
- 35:12the fact that she was convicted in
- 35:14absentia, and therefore unable to prove
- 35:17her side because she claims she never
- 35:19properly received this notice—well,
- 35:21perhaps that led to the decision to
- 35:23grant this stay; it is actually a
- 35:26central element that no newspaper is
- 35:28covering. For what reason? On one hand,
- 35:32I think it's because it's not actually
- 35:34clear what the effect of the stay is,
- 35:37nor its importance in such a moment and
- 35:39such a case. On the other hand, because
- 35:44these stories are poorly packaged, and
- 35:46because those handling the
- 35:48communication, in my opinion, aren't
- 35:51giving the right advice, one of the
- 35:53main pieces of information was diluted
- 35:56among a thousand other things and,
- 35:58above all, drowned out by the fact that
- 36:01people are drawn to these stories to
- 36:03judge how poorly structured they are in
- 36:06terms of communication and visual
- 36:08impact on the public. The public, and
- 36:12this is an aggravating factor, because
- 36:14when you are in a reputation crisis,
- 36:17what you must try to do, obviously, is
- 36:20to make your reasons understood by the
- 36:22public. Not to those who are already
- 36:25convinced by you, because you don't
- 36:26need to communicate to them; you need
- 36:28to communicate to those—the opposing
- 36:30side isn't much help because it’s
- 36:32obvious, we are in politics and
- 36:33unfortunately team spirit is inevitable
- 36:35—but to those who don't know what
- 36:37position to take because they haven't
- 36:38really understood the issue. And this
- 36:42is the worst way to communicate,
- 36:44because you end up drawing attention to
- 36:46details that shouldn't be the primary
- 36:48focus, and yet, you lose fundamental
- 36:50points because you water them down in a
- 36:52communication format that didn't go
- 36:54very well. And this text, recited in a
- 36:57monotone way with all the errors we
- 36:59mentioned, loses focus on one of the
- 37:02key points. The thing that is totally
- 37:04missing from this response, and also
- 37:06missing from the interview granted to
- 37:08Repubblica, is what we were saying
- 37:09earlier. about why those two
- 37:11contractual forms were chosen. When
- 37:15this is part of the controversy,
- 37:17precisely because it clashes with your
- 37:19positioning, that is one of the first
- 37:21things you must explain, saying: "Look,
- 37:23they didn't even request
- 37:25reclassification as employees, and in
- 37:27any case, the work was carried out
- 37:29according to the guidelines of the
- 37:31contracts I proposed." But by saying
- 37:34nothing, it almost seems like you don't
- 37:36want to provide answers on that point,
- 37:37and therefore you actually validate the
- 37:39controversy. This is the huge mistake.
- 37:43She thought she had to make that
- 37:45decision at that moment, so she felt it
- 37:47was correct to act this way, but the
- 37:49point is that she is managing her
- 37:52reputation crisis in a completely wrong
- 37:54manner. Some details, well, I have
- 37:58already told you, but what I find
- 38:00absolutely crazy, beyond all the
- 38:02aspects we have already analyzed, is
- 38:04that in this text she recites, she
- 38:06evades one of the major controversies
- 38:08that erupted after her press release
- 38:10was released. Since you have built a
- 38:14position where you fight against job
- 38:16insecurity, find these contractual
- 38:18forms wrong, and have waged battles
- 38:20against these types of contracts for
- 38:22workers' rights and so on, when you
- 38:24yourself write this in your press
- 38:26release, it is clear and evident that
- 38:29you will trigger a controversy. So,
- 38:31either you wrote that press release
- 38:34yourself without realizing it could be
- 38:36an additional fuse, or whoever advised
- 38:39you was unable to advise you on how to
- 38:41write a proper press release. If you
- 38:44want to post stories to manage your
- 38:46crisis because a controversy is
- 38:48exploding that you can no longer
- 38:50contain, and you forget a piece of the
- 38:52controversy, what people immediately
- 38:55perceive is that you don't want to
- 38:57address that detail. So this is also
- 39:00how you do not manage a reputation
- 39:02crisis. Now, I also made a video on
- 39:04TikTok yesterday where I got a few
- 39:06things off my chest because, since I
- 39:08started analyzing this controversy, I
- 39:11have received a barrage of insults from
- 39:13people who defend Salis. I always limit
- 39:16myself to analyzing the facts, and I
- 39:18don't think I've ever made it personal;
- 39:20I've always criticized things that
- 39:22people do which I find senseless—the
- 39:24things, not the people. Because even in
- 39:28cases of reputational crises, people
- 39:29undergo crises—and they’re right to
- 39:31—but everything shifts, everything
- 39:33changes based on how you manage it. It
- 39:36is never the event itself that creates
- 39:39or worsens a reputational crisis. The
- 39:42biggest reputational crises, and the
- 39:44Ferragni case teaches us this, explode
- 39:46uncontrollably precisely because they
- 39:48are managed wrongly from the start. I
- 39:51mean, there are events that, if handled
- 39:53well, could actually be resolved in a
- 39:55very short time. If you start relying
- 39:58on people who give you the wrong advice
- 40:00and you start setting up a
- 40:01communication strategy that is
- 40:02absolutely wrong, the crisis blows up
- 40:04and you can’t get it back under
- 40:05control. And I would also like to speak
- 40:09up for the many professionals who work
- 40:11in this sector—which has been my
- 40:13sector, and every now and then is still
- 40:16my sector—that: reputational crises
- 40:18cannot be managed by just any
- 40:20communication graduate who deals with
- 40:22certain branches of communication,
- 40:24because reputation management is a very
- 40:27difficult thing to handle that many in
- 40:29Italy underestimate. In Anglo-Saxon
- 40:32culture, however, reputation management
- 40:34—or at least investing in plans to
- 40:36manage potential crises that we know
- 40:38could explode...and here I’ll add a
- 40:40side note: the ruling was in March, we
- 40:43are in July, the controversy erupted in
- 40:45July; there was plenty of time to plan
- 40:47for potential crisis management, but
- 40:49that was not done. This is typically
- 40:52Italian because, in Italy, companies—
- 40:54even those at a certain level that know
- 40:56crises could erupt—don’t invest in
- 40:59this because, culturally, we just
- 41:00reject this notion. But when these
- 41:03things happen, a random communication
- 41:05graduate isn't enough to handle these
- 41:07dynamics, because they are extremely
- 41:09complex dynamics that require
- 41:11interdisciplinary teams working on a
- 41:13great many aspects. Therefore, in the
- 41:16event that you find yourself having to
- 41:18manage a reputational crisis, my advice
- 41:20is to go on Google and look for a
- 41:21Crisis Manager, because you will
- 41:23absolutely need one. Then there are
- 41:25many things that even a first-year
- 41:27communication student would have
- 41:28avoided in that video we saw, in those
- 41:30stories we saw. But that is another
- 41:32discussion. When it comes to strategy,
- 41:35content, and all these things, well,
- 41:37let's just say that a Crisis Manager is
- 41:39the right person to handle this,
- 41:41because others who try to step into
- 41:43this role without having the necessary
- 41:45skills will end up causing you damage.
- 41:49Over the years, we've seen cases that
- 41:51were managed very poorly, causing even
- 41:53more damage to the person at the center
- 41:56of a reputational crisis, precisely
- 41:58because of mistakes made by both
- 42:00consultants and the person themselves,
- 42:02who didn't realize that the first thing
- 42:04you should do—when you're obviously
- 42:06in the wrong—is apologize, rather
- 42:08than saying others misunderstood or
- 42:11refusing to question yourself. These
- 42:13are the three basic steps, and then you
- 42:15make a promise to fix, well, the damage
- 42:17that you might have caused. If you
- 42:20don't follow this, and if the person at
- 42:21the center of the reputational crisis
- 42:23doesn't question themselves, doesn't
- 42:25intend to take a step back, and accepts
- 42:27advice that shouldn't be given (because
- 42:29it paradoxically complicates the
- 42:31situation, if not blows it out of
- 42:32proportion), then the crisis is bound
- 42:34to explode, and you will suffer even
- 42:36more damage than you would have from
- 42:38the incident itself. So, I'll end this
- 42:41video here. I hope it was an
- 42:42interesting video for you anyway. Let
- 42:44me know what you think, and we'll see
- 42:46each other again in the next few days
- 42:48with who knows what news to comment on.
- 42:50I still have a video I need to edit
- 42:52about employers who respond rudely to
- 42:55me. I hope to have time this weekend
- 42:57since the weather is supposed to be bad
- 42:58, so I should actually have the time to
- 43:00edit and publish it for you. And so I
- 43:02hope that the next video this weekend
- 43:04will be the one about the employers who
- 43:05respond rudely to me. In any case,
- 43:08we'll find something to talk about;
- 43:10maybe on Sunday night we could even do
- 43:11a live stream if there are topics to
- 43:13discuss. Otherwise, I thank you for
- 43:16watching this video until the end. I
- 43:17hope again that it was interesting for
- 43:19you. I’ll say goodbye, wish you a
- 43:21good day or a good evening, and ciao.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Ilaria Salis, cosa dice davvero la sentenza? by Charlotte Matteini - A.C.D.C. , generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,084 words across 1,150 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.