YouTube2Text

"Il Principe" di Machiavelli - Audiolibro spiegato parte 6 — Transcript

by scrip · 12,928 words · 1,889 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00We've been reading The Prince by
  2. 0:02Niccolò Machiavelli, a masterpiece of
  3. 0:04Italian philosophy and literature,
  4. 0:06together for some time now. We've read
  5. 0:09the first 19 chapters. Today, if all
  6. 0:12goes well, we'll try and finish it
  7. 0:14because there are 67 chapters left.
  8. 0:16I've done the math. 20, 21, 22, 23, 24,
  9. 0:2025, 26 chapters, but they're not long,
  10. 0:22so if I can stand it, we'll finish it,
  11. 0:25read it, comment on it, and do
  12. 0:26everything after the intro. Let's get
  13. 0:30started. A cup of coffee in the usual
  14. 0:54cup with the words. Let's get started
  15. 0:57because I'm recording. It's 11:31 p.m.,
  16. 1:01so we need to stay awake. The Comei are
  17. 1:04my fellow adventurers, keeping me
  18. 1:06company as usual: Mickey Mouse Tol Stoy
  19. 1:08here, Batman De Andrè, and the hairy
  20. 1:10monster over there. My name is Ermanno
  21. 1:12Ferretti, I'm a history and philosophy
  22. 1:14teacher. I teach at the Paleocapa
  23. 1:16scientific high school in Lovigo and,
  24. 1:18for 2 years now, which have been well
  25. 1:20past, I have been making video
  26. 1:21explanations of history, philosophy,
  27. 1:23and civic education on this channel
  28. 1:25that more or less follow the curriculum
  29. 1:26that is taught in high school. But
  30. 1:29every now and then I also delve into
  31. 1:31some in-depth studies, some full
  32. 1:33readings of passages, books, texts,
  33. 1:35like today's case. As I said in the
  34. 1:39introduction, we have been reading
  35. 1:40Machiavelli's The Prince for a while
  36. 1:41now and we are continuing. In fact, if
  37. 1:44all goes well, we will finish it today.
  38. 1:45How do we proceed? How do we work? We
  39. 1:48usually do this: I read Machavelli's
  40. 1:50original text verbatim and then, after
  41. 1:52finishing a chapter, I comment on it
  42. 1:54and explain it, trying to give you a
  43. 1:56key to reading it, trying to explain
  44. 1:58this language, which, mind you, is
  45. 2:00written in Italian, but it is written
  46. 2:02in an Italian from the early 1500s. The
  47. 2:05Prince is dated as composed in 1513, so
  48. 2:07it is clear that it is a slightly
  49. 2:09outdated Italian, a bit outdated, it
  50. 2:11needs a bit of explanation, but I think
  51. 2:13it is also understandable. In this way,
  52. 2:17also looking at the description, but
  53. 2:19also looking at the little titles that
  54. 2:21appear here while I speak, you can
  55. 2:23reconstruct and decide: review or
  56. 2:24listen to only the reading part if you
  57. 2:26want, like making a sort of audiobook,
  58. 2:28or only the commentary part, to do a
  59. 2:30reasoned and commented reading, or both
  60. 2:33together and you can endure the whole
  61. 2:35thing. This is to give the initial
  62. 2:38premises. Let's continue. As I was
  63. 2:40telling you, this is not the first
  64. 2:42episode, in fact, it is already episode
  65. 2:43, I'll tell you right away, number 6
  66. 2:47and perhaps the last. Previously we
  67. 2:50recorded five episodes to make up
  68. 2:51chapters up to 19. You can find them
  69. 2:53linked in the description if you missed
  70. 2:55them. Today we start again from chapter
  71. 2:58number 20. Chapter 20. Whether
  72. 3:00fortresses and many other things that
  73. 3:03princes often do are useful or harmful.
  74. 3:06Some princes, in order to hold the
  75. 3:08state securely, have disarmed their
  76. 3:10subjects. Some others have kept the
  77. 3:13subject lands divided into parts. Some
  78. 3:16others have nurtured enmities against
  79. 3:18themselves. Some others have set about
  80. 3:21winning over those who were suspicious
  81. 3:22to them at the beginning of their rule.
  82. 3:25Some have built fortresses, some have
  83. 3:28ruined and destroyed them. And although
  84. 3:31it is not possible to give a definite
  85. 3:33verdict on all these things, unless we
  86. 3:35come to the details of these states
  87. 3:37where one would have to take some
  88. 3:39similar decision, nevertheless I will
  89. 3:40speak in the broadest possible way that
  90. 3:42the subject matter itself permits. It
  91. 3:45was never, therefore, that a new prince
  92. 3:48disarmed his subjects; indeed, when he
  93. 3:50found them disarmed, he always armed
  94. 3:52them, because by arming those arms
  95. 3:54become yours. Those who are suspicious
  96. 3:58of you become loyal, and those who were
  97. 4:00loyal remain loyal, and your subjects
  98. 4:02become your partisans. And why cannot
  99. 4:05all your subjects arm themselves? When
  100. 4:07those whom you arm benefit, you can
  101. 4:09become more secure with the others. And
  102. 4:12the difference in their conduct, which
  103. 4:14they know, makes them obligated to you.
  104. 4:17The others excuse you, judging it
  105. 4:18necessary for those who have more merit
  106. 4:20than they have, more danger, and more
  107. 4:22obligation. But when you disarm them,
  108. 4:25you begin to offend them and show that
  109. 4:27you distrust them, either through
  110. 4:29cowardice or lack of faith. And both of
  111. 4:32these opinions lead to hatred against
  112. 4:35you. And since you cannot remain
  113. 4:37unarmed, it is necessary that you turn
  114. 4:39to mercenary military forces, of which
  115. 4:41we have already described what kind.
  116. 4:43And even if it were good, it cannot be
  117. 4:45sufficient to defend you from powerful
  118. 4:47enemies and suspicious subjects.
  119. 4:50However, as I have said, a new prince
  120. 4:52in a new principality has always
  121. 4:54organized arms. Histories are full of
  122. 4:58such examples, but when a prince
  123. 5:00acquires a new state that is added to
  124. 5:02his old one like a member, then it is
  125. 5:04necessary to disarm that state, except
  126. 5:06for those who have exposed themselves
  127. 5:08to you in acquiring it. And these too,
  128. 5:11with time and opportunity, it is
  129. 5:13necessary to make them soft and
  130. 5:15effeminate and to organize yourself in
  131. 5:18such a way that all the arms of your
  132. 5:20state are in those soldiers of your own
  133. 5:22who in your old state live near you.
  134. 5:26Our ancestors and those who were
  135. 5:28considered wise used to say how
  136. 5:30necessary it was to fear Pistoia with
  137. 5:32its factions and Pisa with its
  138. 5:33fortresses, and for this reason they
  139. 5:35fostered differences in some of their
  140. 5:37subject towns in order to possess them
  141. 5:39more easily. This must have been a good
  142. 5:42thing to do in those times when Italy
  143. 5:45was somewhat balanced, but I do not
  144. 5:47think it can be taken as a precept
  145. 5:49today, because I do not believe that
  146. 5:51divisions ever do any good. On the
  147. 5:54contrary, it is necessary that when the
  148. 5:56enemy approaches, divided cities are
  149. 5:58immediately lost, because the weaker
  150. 6:00party will always approach external
  151. 6:02forces and the other will not be able
  152. 6:05to resist. The Venetians, moved, as I
  153. 6:08believe by the reasons given above,
  154. 6:10fostered the Guelph and Ghibelline
  155. 6:12sects in their subject cities and
  156. 6:14although they never allowed them to
  157. 6:16come to bloodshed, they nevertheless
  158. 6:18fostered these disagreements among
  159. 6:19themselves, so that those citizens,
  160. 6:21occupied with their differences, would
  161. 6:23not move against them. Which, as was
  162. 6:28seen, did not serve them well, because
  163. 6:30when they were defeated at Vattara, one
  164. 6:32part of those cities immediately seized
  165. 6:34them and took away their entire state.
  166. 6:38Such methods, therefore, are inferred
  167. 6:40from the weakness of the prince,
  168. 6:41because in a strong principality such
  169. 6:44divisions will never be permitted,
  170. 6:46because they are only useful in times
  171. 6:48of peace, when by means of them one can
  172. 6:50more easily manage one's subjects. But
  173. 6:53when war breaks out, such an
  174. 6:55arrangement shows its flaw. Without a
  175. 6:59doubt, princes become great when they
  176. 7:01overcome the difficulties and
  177. 7:02oppositions that are made to them. And
  178. 7:06therefore fortune, especially when she
  179. 7:09wishes to make a new prince great, who
  180. 7:11has greater need to acquire reputation
  181. 7:13than an hereditary one, makes enemies
  182. 7:15for him and causes him to undertake
  183. 7:17enterprises against him, so that he may
  184. 7:19have an opportunity to overcome them
  185. 7:21and to overcome that ladder which his
  186. 7:23enemies have carried him up to climb
  187. 7:25higher. And therefore many judge that a
  188. 7:29wise prince, when he has the
  189. 7:31opportunity, should cultivate some
  190. 7:33enmity with cunning, so that, once he
  191. 7:36has overcome it, his greatness may
  192. 7:38increase. Princes, and especially those
  193. 7:42who are new, have found more trust and
  194. 7:44more utility in those men who at the
  195. 7:46beginning of their rule were held in
  196. 7:48suspicion than in those who at the
  197. 7:50beginning were trusted. Pandolfo
  198. 7:53Petrucci, Prince of Siena, governed his
  199. 7:55state more with those who were
  200. 7:57suspected than with others. But this
  201. 8:00matter cannot be discussed at length
  202. 8:02because it varies according to the
  203. 8:03subject. I will only say this, that
  204. 8:06those men who at the beginning of a
  205. 8:08principality were enemies, who are of a
  206. 8:10quality that requires support in order
  207. 8:12to maintain themselves, the prince will
  208. 8:14always be able to win over with the
  209. 8:16greatest ease. And they are all the
  210. 8:19more forced to serve him faithfully
  211. 8:21when they realize that it is more
  212. 8:23necessary for them to erase by their
  213. 8:24actions that bad opinion that was held
  214. 8:26of them. And so the prince always
  215. 8:29derives more utility from them than
  216. 8:31from those who, by serving him with too
  217. 8:33much security, neglect his own affairs.
  218. 8:37And since the subject requires it, I do
  219. 8:39not wish to omit reminding a prince who
  220. 8:41has taken a new state through the
  221. 8:43intrinsic favors of that state to
  222. 8:45consider carefully what motives moved
  223. 8:47those who favored him to favor him; and
  224. 8:50if it is not a natural affection toward
  225. 8:52that state, but only because they were
  226. 8:54not content with that state, it will be
  227. 8:56with great difficulty and effort if he
  228. 8:59can keep friends, because it is
  229. 9:00impossible for him to satisfy them. And
  230. 9:05if he goes over well those examples
  231. 9:06which are drawn from ancient and modern
  232. 9:08events as an opportunity for this, he
  233. 9:10will see that it is much easier to win
  234. 9:12friends from those men who were content
  235. 9:14with the previous state. And therefore
  236. 9:17they were his enemies than those who,
  237. 9:19because they were not content with it,
  238. 9:21became his friends and helped him to
  239. 9:23occupy it. In order to hold their state
  240. 9:28more securely, it has been the custom
  241. 9:30of princes to build fortresses which
  242. 9:31act as a bridle and check on those who
  243. 9:33might design to attack them, and to
  244. 9:35have a secure refuge from a first
  245. 9:37attack. I praise this method because it
  246. 9:41was used in ancient times. Nevertheless
  247. 9:44, in our times Messer Nicolò Vitelli
  248. 9:46saw two fortresses in the city of
  249. 9:48Castello destroyed in order to hold
  250. 9:50that state. Guidobaldo, Duke of Urbino,
  251. 9:53having returned to his state from which
  252. 9:55he had been driven out by Cesare Borgia
  253. 9:57, destroyed all the fortresses in that
  254. 9:59province to their foundations and
  255. 10:01judged it more difficult to lose that
  256. 10:03state without them. The Bentivogli who
  257. 10:06had returned to Bologna used a similar
  258. 10:09term: "Fortresses are useful or not
  259. 10:11according to the times, and if they do
  260. 10:14you good in one area, they harm you in
  261. 10:16another, and this part is discussed in
  262. 10:19this way. The prince who is more afraid
  263. 10:21of the people than of foreigners must
  264. 10:23build fortresses, but he who is more
  265. 10:25afraid of foreigners than of the people
  266. 10:27must leave them behind. The castle of
  267. 10:30Milan, which Francesco Sforza
  268. 10:31experienced, has made and will make
  269. 10:33more war on the house of Sforza than
  270. 10:35any other disorder in that state.
  271. 10:37However, the best fortress that there
  272. 10:40is is not to be hated by the people,
  273. 10:42because even if you have fortresses and
  274. 10:44the people hate you, they do not save
  275. 10:46you. Because a people never lacks
  276. 10:50foreign arms to help them. In our times
  277. 10:54it is not seen that they have actually
  278. 10:56been of any use to any prince except
  279. 10:58the Countess of Forlì, when her
  280. 11:00husband Count Girolamo died, because by
  281. 11:02means of them she was able to escape
  282. 11:04the popular uproar and await the aid of
  283. 11:06Milan and recover her power." State.
  284. 11:10And the times were such that foreigners
  285. 11:12could not help the people, but later
  286. 11:14they were of little use to her when
  287. 11:16Cesare Borgia bypassed her and the
  288. 11:19people, her enemies, allied themselves
  289. 11:21with foreigners. Therefore, both then
  290. 11:24and before, she would have been safer
  291. 11:25not to be hated by the people than to
  292. 11:27have fortresses. So consider these
  293. 11:30things, I will praise those who build
  294. 11:32fortresses and those who do not, and I
  295. 11:34will exempt you from anyone who,
  296. 11:36trusting in fortresses, will not value
  297. 11:38being oiled by the people. This chapter
  298. 11:4120 speaks of fortresses, at least
  299. 11:43according to the title, but in reality
  300. 11:45it speaks of how to maintain the people
  301. 11:48, whether armed or not, and clearly
  302. 11:50ventures into a whole series of cases.
  303. 11:53You have heard that Machiavelli himself
  304. 11:54already at the beginning makes a whole
  305. 11:56series of discussions. Some princes
  306. 11:58have disarmed their subjects, some
  307. 12:00princes have armed them, some princes
  308. 12:02have made enemies because this
  309. 12:04guaranteed them to maintain power.
  310. 12:07Others have tried to make all of them
  311. 12:09friends because they thought this would
  312. 12:10guarantee them power. Some have built
  313. 12:13fortresses, some have demolished
  314. 12:14fortresses. Every prince has followed a
  315. 12:17different strategy since the toronè,
  316. 12:18Machiavelli himself admits. In some
  317. 12:21cases it is difficult to give a general
  318. 12:22case history because situations can
  319. 12:24vary greatly from case to case.
  320. 12:26Therefore, it would be necessary to
  321. 12:27analyze individual cases. However, he
  322. 12:30gives some advice to our friend
  323. 12:32Machiavelli, for example, he says that
  324. 12:34regarding new principalities, the new
  325. 12:36prince who conquers a state, should not
  326. 12:38be afraid to disarm his subjects, that
  327. 12:41is, he should not start disarming his
  328. 12:43subjects because if he does he gives
  329. 12:45the impression that he does not trust
  330. 12:47them. Rather, it is better to keep them
  331. 12:50armed because in this way these people
  332. 12:52will see that the prince trusts them,
  333. 12:54they will more easily remain loyal to
  334. 12:56the prince, they will become supporters
  335. 12:58of this prince. However, if you are not
  336. 13:02a new prince in a new state, but you
  337. 13:03have acquired this state from a
  338. 13:05principality that you already had,
  339. 13:06therefore you have conquered a new
  340. 13:08territory, then in that case it is
  341. 13:09better to disarm the people because you
  342. 13:11cannot trust them too much. Then
  343. 13:14Machiavelli also says, "Be careful, we
  344. 13:15are used to thinking that it is good to
  345. 13:17leave weapons to those who are loyal to
  346. 13:19you and good to take them away from
  347. 13:21those who are unfaithful to you. Sure,
  348. 13:22in principle this is also fine, but in
  349. 13:24many cases when a prince arrives in new
  350. 13:26territory it can be more advantageous
  351. 13:28to do the opposite, that is, not to
  352. 13:30trust those who claim to be loyal to
  353. 13:31you and instead to trust those who
  354. 13:33claim to be against you." Machiavelli
  355. 13:37says exactly this: it is much more, uh,
  356. 13:39logical to give space to those who may
  357. 13:41have opposed you a bit, because, in
  358. 13:42fact, after you have won, if you take
  359. 13:44them with you, if you give them space,
  360. 13:46if you allow them, for example, to have
  361. 13:48weapons, they will be grateful to you,
  362. 13:50because in this way they will have a
  363. 13:52way of erasing a bad reputation that
  364. 13:54they have brought upon themselves and
  365. 13:56therefore they will not want to betray
  366. 13:58you. And on the other hand, those who
  367. 14:01supported you, you should not trust
  368. 14:02them too much, because those who
  369. 14:04supported you may have actually done so
  370. 14:06to obtain some advantage and if this
  371. 14:07advantage does not arrive in the
  372. 14:09desired terms, this friend of yours, so
  373. 14:11to speak, could lead you astray. In
  374. 14:13short, all this to say what? That in
  375. 14:14the end there is no general rule about
  376. 14:16giving weapons or not giving weapons,
  377. 14:18building fortresses or not. What
  378. 14:20matters is understanding the people you
  379. 14:22have in front of you, it seems to
  380. 14:24Riccivelli, understanding what their
  381. 14:26interests are, what are the reasons why
  382. 14:28they side with you or against you and
  383. 14:30understanding how to manage them. So it
  384. 14:32is, I would say, an almost
  385. 14:34psychological task. that the prince
  386. 14:36must put into practice in order to
  387. 14:37understand how to manage his people.
  388. 14:39And in fact, Machiavelli concludes with
  389. 14:42this discussion on fortresses. He says,
  390. 14:45as I said at the beginning, there are
  391. 14:46princes who, as soon as they take over
  392. 14:48a state, have even built new fortresses
  393. 14:49, others who have destroyed the ones
  394. 14:50that were there. And even in this case
  395. 14:53it cannot be said that he is right or
  396. 14:54wrong because it depends on the case.
  397. 14:56In some cases it is advantageous to
  398. 14:58tear down fortresses so as not to give
  399. 15:00space to rebels or to not give space to
  400. 15:02those who arrive and occupy. In other
  401. 15:05cases, however, it is better to build
  402. 15:06them, depending on the case. It is not
  403. 15:08possible to make a general case study,
  404. 15:11but Machiavelli also says that what
  405. 15:13really matters is to make yourself
  406. 15:15loved or not loved by the people. The
  407. 15:17true fortress, metaphorically speaking,
  408. 15:20is to be liked by the people. If you
  409. 15:22have a thousand fortresses, but the
  410. 15:24people hate you. Sooner or later the
  411. 15:25people will find a way to undermine you
  412. 15:27. Sooner or later they will find a way
  413. 15:29to throw you out. An enemy will arrive
  414. 15:31from outside who will ally himself with
  415. 15:33the people, a foreigner, says
  416. 15:34Machiavelli. Someone else will arrive,
  417. 15:36but he is It is certain that no matter
  418. 15:38how many fortresses you build, sooner
  419. 15:39or later the people will chase you away
  420. 15:40if they want to. On the other hand, if
  421. 15:44you are well-liked by the people, if
  422. 15:45you have managed to win the people over
  423. 15:47and conquer them, you may not even have
  424. 15:49a fortress. The people will defend you,
  425. 15:51the people will be on your side.
  426. 15:53Therefore, the advice to princes is
  427. 15:56this: if you want to build fortresses,
  428. 15:58do them. If you don't want to build
  429. 16:00them, don't. But this, yes, absolutely.
  430. 16:03Keep the people happy. Chapter 21. How
  431. 16:06a prince should govern himself in order
  432. 16:09to gain reputation. Nothing makes a
  433. 16:12prince so esteemed as great deeds and
  434. 16:14setting rare examples. In our time we
  435. 16:18have Ferdinand, King of Aragon, the
  436. 16:20present King of Spain. He can be called
  437. 16:23almost a new prince, because from a
  438. 16:25weak king he has become, through fame
  439. 16:26and glory, the first king of the
  440. 16:28Christians. And if you consider his
  441. 16:31actions, you will find them all very
  442. 16:33great and some extraordinary. At the
  443. 16:36beginning of his reign he attacked the
  444. 16:38grenade and that enterprise was the
  445. 16:39foundation of his state. At first, he
  446. 16:42did it lazily and without suspicion. to
  447. 16:44be hindered. He kept the minds of the
  448. 16:48barons of Castile occupied in this, who
  449. 16:49, thinking of that war, did not think
  450. 16:51of innovation, and in the meantime he
  451. 16:53acquired a reputation for power over
  452. 16:55them who were unaware of it. He was
  453. 16:59able to feed the armies, condemning the
  454. 17:01Church and the people, and to lay a
  455. 17:02foundation with that long war for the
  456. 17:04military service which later honored
  457. 17:05him. In addition to this, in order to
  458. 17:09undertake greater enterprises, always
  459. 17:11making use of religion, he turned to a
  460. 17:13merciful cruelty, driving out and
  461. 17:15despoiling his kingdom of the Marranos.
  462. 17:18Nor could this example be more
  463. 17:20admirable or rarer. Under this same
  464. 17:22cloak he attacked Africa, undertook the
  465. 17:24enterprise of Italy, and has most
  466. 17:26recently attacked France. And in this
  467. 17:28way he always plotted great things,
  468. 17:30which have always kept the minds of his
  469. 17:32subjects in suspense and admiration and
  470. 17:34occupied with the outcome of them. And
  471. 17:36these actions of his have arisen one
  472. 17:39from the other in such a way that they
  473. 17:41have never given men time to calm down
  474. 17:43and act against him. It is useful Again
  475. 17:47, you know, it is a prince to make
  476. 17:48empirical statements about internal
  477. 17:50government, similar to those that are
  478. 17:52told of Messer Bernabò of Milan, when
  479. 17:54he has the opportunity of seeing
  480. 17:55someone who does something
  481. 17:57extraordinary, either for good or for
  482. 17:58evil, in civil life, and to find a way
  483. 18:00of rewarding or punishing him that is
  484. 18:02widely talked about. And above all, a
  485. 18:06prince must strive to give himself a
  486. 18:08reputation for greatness and excellence
  487. 18:10in every action he takes. A prince is
  488. 18:12also esteemed when he is a true friend
  489. 18:14or a true enemy, that is, when he
  490. 18:16reveals himself without any respect in
  491. 18:18favor of one against another. This
  492. 18:20course is always more useful than
  493. 18:22remaining neutral. For if your powerful
  494. 18:24neighbors come to blows, or if they are
  495. 18:26of such a character that if one of them
  496. 18:28is victorious, you will have to fear
  497. 18:29the victor or not. In any of these
  498. 18:32cases, it will always be more useful
  499. 18:34for you to expose yourself and wage a
  500. 18:36good war; because, in the first case,
  501. 18:38if you do not expose yourself, you will
  502. 18:40always be the prey of the victor, to
  503. 18:42the pleasure and satisfaction of the
  504. 18:44one who has been vanquished, and you
  505. 18:46will have no reason to defend yourself
  506. 18:47or to receive you; For the victor does
  507. 18:49not want suspicious friends who will
  508. 18:51not help him in adversity. The loser
  509. 18:54will not receive you because you have
  510. 18:55not chosen to take up arms to try his
  511. 18:57fortune. Antiochus had passed into
  512. 18:59Greece, sent by the Aetolians to drive
  513. 19:01out the Romans. Antiochus sent envoys
  514. 19:04to the Achaeans, who were friends of
  515. 19:06the Romans, to encourage them to remain
  516. 19:08in the middle, while the Romans, on the
  517. 19:10other hand, persuaded them to take up
  518. 19:11arms for them. This matter came to
  519. 19:14light in the council of the Achaeans,
  520. 19:16where the legate of Antiochus persuaded
  521. 19:18them to remain neutral. To which the
  522. 19:21Roman legate replied: "As far as the
  523. 19:23part that is said to be the best and
  524. 19:25most useful to your state is not to
  525. 19:27interfere in our war, nothing is more
  526. 19:29contrary to it. For if you do not
  527. 19:32interfere, without any favor or
  528. 19:34reputation, you will remain the prize
  529. 19:36of the victor, and it will always
  530. 19:38happen that those who are not your
  531. 19:39friends will demand neutrality from you
  532. 19:41, and those who are your friends will
  533. 19:43demand that you expose yourself with
  534. 19:45arms." And ill-decided princes, in
  535. 19:49order to escape present dangers, most
  536. 19:51often follow that neutral path and most
  537. 19:53often they are ruined. But when the
  538. 19:56prince boldly shows himself in favor of
  539. 19:58one party, if the one with whom you are
  540. 20:00allied wins, even though he is powerful
  541. 20:02enough to allow you to remain at his
  542. 20:04discretion, he is under obligation to
  543. 20:05you and a love is contracted. And men
  544. 20:08are never so dishonest as to oppress
  545. 20:11you afterwards with such an example of
  546. 20:13ingratitude. Victories are never so
  547. 20:16prosperous that the victor does not
  548. 20:17have some regard, especially for
  549. 20:19justice. But if the one with whom you
  550. 20:22are allied loses, you are received by
  551. 20:24him and while he can he helps you and
  552. 20:26becomes a companion in a fortune that
  553. 20:28can rise again. In the second case,
  554. 20:31when those who fight together are of
  555. 20:33such quality that you have nothing to
  556. 20:35fear from the one who wins, it is all
  557. 20:36the more prudent to advise him; because
  558. 20:38you ruin one with the help of one who
  559. 20:40should save him if he were wise, and if
  560. 20:42he wins he remains at your discretion,
  561. 20:43and this is impossible with Your help
  562. 20:45shall not prevail. And here it is to be
  563. 20:49noted that a prince must be careful
  564. 20:51never to associate with one more
  565. 20:53powerful than himself in order to
  566. 20:54offend others, except when necessity
  567. 20:56compels him, as was said above, because
  568. 20:58if he is defeated you remain at his
  569. 21:00discretion, and princes must avoid
  570. 21:01being at the discretion of others as
  571. 21:03much as possible. The Venetians allied
  572. 21:07themselves with France against Luca of
  573. 21:09Milan and could have avoided forming
  574. 21:11that alliance, which resulted in their
  575. 21:14ruin. But when it cannot be avoided, as
  576. 21:17happened to the Florentines when the
  577. 21:19Pope and Spain went with armies to
  578. 21:20attack Lombardy, then the prince must
  579. 21:22adhere to it for the reasons mentioned
  580. 21:24above. Nor should anyone ever believe
  581. 21:28that any state can take safe measures.
  582. 21:31On the contrary, he should consider
  583. 21:33having to deal with all doubts, because
  584. 21:35it is in the order of things that one
  585. 21:37never tries to avoid one inconvenience
  586. 21:38without running into another. But
  587. 21:41prudence consists in knowing how to
  588. 21:43recognize the nature of inconveniences
  589. 21:45and taking the least bad for granted. A
  590. 21:49prince must also show himself to be A
  591. 21:50lover of virtue and honoring those who
  592. 21:52excel in each art. He must encourage
  593. 21:56his citizens to be able to quietly
  594. 21:58pursue their professions, whether in
  595. 22:00trade, agriculture, or any other human
  596. 22:02activity, so that one does not refrain
  597. 22:05from decorating his possessions for
  598. 22:07fear of being taken from him, and
  599. 22:09another from opening up trade for fear
  600. 22:12of taxes. But he must prepare rewards
  601. 22:15for those who want to do these things
  602. 22:17and for anyone who thinks, in any way,
  603. 22:19of expanding his city or his state. In
  604. 22:22addition to this, he must keep the
  605. 22:24people busy at suitable times of the
  606. 22:25year with festivals and shows. And
  607. 22:28since every city is divided either into
  608. 22:31guilds or into tribes, he must take
  609. 22:33account of these universities, meet
  610. 22:35with them sometimes, and give an
  611. 22:37example of humanity and magnificence,
  612. 22:39while always maintaining the majesty of
  613. 22:41his dignity, because this is never to
  614. 22:43be lacking in anything. Oh, this
  615. 22:46twenty-first chapter is very topical,
  616. 22:49if you have noticed, you have heard
  617. 22:51what Machiavelli writes. The theme is:
  618. 22:54What must a prince do to be esteemed?
  619. 22:56So, Machiavelli says: "Well, there are
  620. 22:58many ways." Let's look at some examples
  621. 23:00, and he cites Ferdinand II of Aragon,
  622. 23:03King of Spain, who was able to gain
  623. 23:05appreciation in many ways through his
  624. 23:07wars. He fought wars here and there,
  625. 23:09the ones he won against the French, and
  626. 23:12so on; he drove the Marranos, that is,
  627. 23:14the Jews, out of the territory, and he
  628. 23:17stood up for the faith. In short, he
  629. 23:19accomplished 1,000 feats and with these
  630. 23:211,000 feats he made himself look great.
  631. 23:23So, the first way to gain appreciation
  632. 23:26is to show yourself to be capable,
  633. 23:28resolute, brave, strong, and so on. And
  634. 23:32Fer Nord Aragona is certainly an
  635. 23:34example in this sense, but this is not
  636. 23:36the only way, says Machiavelli, because
  637. 23:39you also have to be able to, well,
  638. 23:41obviously, make the right alliances,
  639. 23:43but above all decide which side to take
  640. 23:46when wars break out. This makes the
  641. 23:48chapter relevant because Machiavelli
  642. 23:50analyzes a case, or rather various
  643. 23:52cases related to the fact that a war
  644. 23:54breaks out between your neighbors. And
  645. 23:56at that point, what do you have to do
  646. 23:58to be esteemed, to attract advantages?
  647. 24:02When I was reading just a few minutes
  648. 24:03ago, the war in Ukraine came to mind,
  649. 24:05which is a similar case, right? What
  650. 24:07would Machiavelli say to Italy or any
  651. 24:09other country in this war today? Remain
  652. 24:11neutral or take sides? So, Machiavelli
  653. 24:13says: "Be careful, neutrals, remaining
  654. 24:15neutral is never good for the strength
  655. 24:17of the state." Machiavelli is obviously
  656. 24:20a realist, he reasons in terms of
  657. 24:22advantages, that is, in terms of what I
  658. 24:24, as a prince, can do to maintain power
  659. 24:26, to make myself stronger, to
  660. 24:27strengthen my power. So, neutrality is
  661. 24:31never good, never. He only says that at
  662. 24:34a certain point, unwise princes remain
  663. 24:37neutral. It is much more advantageous
  664. 24:39to take sides, much more advantageous
  665. 24:41to take sides because first of all you
  666. 24:43have to side with the one you are most
  667. 24:44friendly with, the one you feel closest
  668. 24:46to. And when you take sides, two things
  669. 24:49can happen, your friend can win or your
  670. 24:51friend can lose. Obviously, if you take
  671. 24:54sides in this war and your friend wins,
  672. 24:56well, then your friend will be grateful
  673. 24:59to you. After all, even the worst of
  674. 25:01men do not forget gratitude. No one can
  675. 25:04be so dishonest as to forget gratitude,
  676. 25:07says Machiavelli. So if your friend
  677. 25:09wins, then he will owe you something,
  678. 25:11he will be obliged to you. And this is
  679. 25:14a good thing for a prince, having
  680. 25:15someone who owes you something is
  681. 25:17essential. So if you take sides and you
  682. 25:19win, good, if you You take sides and
  683. 25:21lose, your ally loses, what can happen?
  684. 25:24Well, he loses out anyway, especially
  685. 25:26since you are still an external ally,
  686. 25:28but above all, says Machiavelli, this
  687. 25:30person will remember that you tried to
  688. 25:32help him, you tried to rescue him and
  689. 25:34if in the future he rises again and can
  690. 25:37reorganize and try again, he will take
  691. 25:39your loyalty into account. So, siding
  692. 25:41with one of the two sides is always
  693. 25:43advantageous, essentially, whether you
  694. 25:45win or lose. But it is even more
  695. 25:47advantageous if the two sides are
  696. 25:49weaker than you, says Machiavelli,
  697. 25:51because in that case your entry into
  698. 25:53the war can be truly decisive; and then
  699. 25:55you can force everyone to do so:
  700. 25:57everyone can owe you something
  701. 25:58afterwards. So it is worth trying again
  702. 26:01, in my opinion, Chevelli, it is worth
  703. 26:03taking sides, not remaining neutral and
  704. 26:05outside the vicissitudes. Of course,
  705. 26:07Machiavelli does not contemplate
  706. 26:09pacifism. We are not in the 20th
  707. 26:11century, we are in the 16th century.
  708. 26:13When wars are fought, wars are fairly
  709. 26:16normal and sovereign princes They have
  710. 26:18to decide how to side with wars, beyond
  711. 26:21moral precepts for the advantages that
  712. 26:23those wars entail. And then in the end
  713. 26:27he concludes by saying "Well, okay, you
  714. 26:29also have to be careful who you ally
  715. 26:30yourself with, but ally yourself with
  716. 26:32someone more powerful than you, because
  717. 26:34you could become obligated to them,
  718. 26:35it's better to ally yourself with
  719. 26:37someone who owes you something." And
  720. 26:40then, of course, the prince must also
  721. 26:41show himself to be a lover of the arts,
  722. 26:43he must honor artists, he must organize
  723. 26:45parties and shows for the people, he
  724. 26:47must go to the various districts, the
  725. 26:48various guilds, and show that he is
  726. 26:50interested in one or another section of
  727. 26:52the people. In short, if he wants to be
  728. 26:55esteemed, of course great deeds, of
  729. 26:57course military victories, perhaps by
  730. 26:59allying himself with the right people,
  731. 27:01but then also more, let's say, concrete
  732. 27:04things, parties, balls, siding with a
  733. 27:06faction or showing that he is keeping a
  734. 27:08faction and so on. Chapter 22. Of the
  735. 27:12secretaries of the princes. The
  736. 27:15election of ministers is of no small
  737. 27:17importance to a prince, who is good or
  738. 27:18not according to the prudence of the
  739. 27:20prince. And the first conjecture that
  740. 27:23is made of a master of the brain is to
  741. 27:25see the men that he has around him and
  742. 27:26when they are sufficient and faithful,
  743. 27:28one can always consider him wise
  744. 27:30because he has known how to recognize
  745. 27:32them as sufficient and keep them
  746. 27:33faithful. But when they are otherwise,
  747. 27:36one can always form a bad opinion of
  748. 27:39him because the first mistake he makes
  749. 27:41is in this election. There was no one
  750. 27:44who knew Messer Antonio da Venafro as
  751. 27:46the minister of Pandolfo Petrucci,
  752. 27:48Prince of Siena, who did not judge
  753. 27:50Pandolfo to be a very prudent man,
  754. 27:52having him as his minister. And because
  755. 27:55brains are of three generations. One
  756. 27:58understands for himself, another
  757. 27:59understands what is shown to him by
  758. 28:01others, is a monster to him, the third
  759. 28:03understands neither himself nor by the
  760. 28:05demonstration of others. The first is
  761. 28:08most excellent, the second excellent,
  762. 28:10the third useless. It was therefore
  763. 28:14necessary that if Pandolfo was not in
  764. 28:16the first degree he would be in the
  765. 28:18second. For every time one has the
  766. 28:20judgment to recognize the good and evil
  767. 28:22that another does and says, even if he
  768. 28:25has no invention of his own, he
  769. 28:26recognizes the bad and the good deeds
  770. 28:28of the minister and exalts the former
  771. 28:30and corrects the latter, and the
  772. 28:32minister cannot hope to deceive him and
  773. 28:34remain good. But how a prince can
  774. 28:37recognize his minister, there is this
  775. 28:38method that never fails. When you see
  776. 28:41the minister thinking more of himself
  777. 28:43than of you and that in all his actions
  778. 28:44he seeks his own advantage, this is the
  779. 28:46way. Such a person will never be a good
  780. 28:48minister, nor can you ever trust him,
  781. 28:51because he who has someone's state in
  782. 28:53his hands should never think of himself
  783. 28:55, but of the prince, and never remind
  784. 28:57him of anything that does not belong to
  785. 28:59him. And on the other hand, in order to
  786. 29:02keep him good, the prince must think of
  787. 29:05the minister, honoring him, making him
  788. 29:07rich, obliging him, sharing with him
  789. 29:10honors and positions so that the many
  790. 29:12honors and riches granted to him will
  791. 29:14cause him not to desire other honors
  792. 29:17and riches. And the many positions will
  793. 29:19make him fear changes, knowing that he
  794. 29:21will not be able to hold his own
  795. 29:23without him. When, therefore, the
  796. 29:26eliminating princes are made in this
  797. 29:28way, they can trust each other, when
  798. 29:30otherwise the end will always be
  799. 29:32harmful to one or the other. Chapter 22
  800. 29:36speaks of secretaries, but note, this
  801. 29:37word secretaries is the word that was
  802. 29:39used in the 16th century to indicate
  803. 29:40those who today we would call ministers
  804. 29:42, the members of the government. So how
  805. 29:45does a prince choose good ones?
  806. 29:47Ministers? And this is a very important
  807. 29:50thing, says Machiavelli, because if you
  808. 29:52want to understand if there is a good
  809. 29:53prince, if you want to judge the work
  810. 29:55of a prince, you must first of all look
  811. 29:57at the ministers he surrounds himself
  812. 29:58with. Because if he is a good prince he
  813. 30:01will choose his ministers well, if he
  814. 30:02is a bad prince he will choose his
  815. 30:04ministers badly. So the first way, the
  816. 30:06first litmus test to understand if he
  817. 30:08is a prince or a great prince is to
  818. 30:09look at the people he has chosen. And
  819. 30:12there are three types of people that
  820. 30:14can be chosen. Even the prince can
  821. 30:15belong to one of these three categories
  822. 30:17, says Machiavelli. The first category
  823. 30:19is that of the most excellent, those he
  824. 30:21says who understand for themselves,
  825. 30:22those who understand everything on
  826. 30:24their own immediately. The second
  827. 30:27category, those of the excellent, that
  828. 30:29is, those who understand what others
  829. 30:31also understand, that is, they are not
  830. 30:32particularly brilliant people who
  831. 30:34understand for themselves things that
  832. 30:36others do not understand, they are
  833. 30:37people who understand things that
  834. 30:39others also understand, but they are
  835. 30:41excellent nonetheless. The second type,
  836. 30:43the third type, the useless ones, that
  837. 30:45is, those who do not understand either
  838. 30:46for themselves or from others, that is,
  839. 30:47who do not understand They don't
  840. 30:49understand. They don't even understand
  841. 30:50if they are explained to them. So, a
  842. 30:52prince must belong to the first two
  843. 30:53categories if he wants to stand on his
  844. 30:54own two feet. Either he must be very
  845. 30:56excellent himself or he must be
  846. 30:57excellent enough to understand when
  847. 30:59things are explained to him. If he
  848. 31:01doesn't understand, it's over. But for
  849. 31:03example, a prince, say Machiavelli, can
  850. 31:04also be in the second category, one of
  851. 31:06those who understands and if things are
  852. 31:08explained to him, and he can govern
  853. 31:09very well as long as he looks for a
  854. 31:11minister belonging to the first
  855. 31:12category, that is, the most excellent.
  856. 31:14This was the case, for example, in
  857. 31:16Siena when Machiavelli says Pandolfo
  858. 31:18Petruzi surrounded himself with
  859. 31:19excellent ministers. So what really
  860. 31:22matters is knowing how to choose. You
  861. 31:24don't necessarily have to be an
  862. 31:26extraordinary prince, you just have to
  863. 31:28be able to judge a good advisor, a good
  864. 31:29minister. That's what's important. And
  865. 31:33how can you tell when someone is a good
  866. 31:34minister? Well, there's a very simple
  867. 31:36way. Just see if this minister thinks
  868. 31:39more about himself or about the State.
  869. 31:41When this minister acts, does he always
  870. 31:43have his own advantage, his own benefit
  871. 31:45, etc. in mind or does he have the good
  872. 31:47of the State in mind? If he has If he
  873. 31:49thinks more of himself than of the
  874. 31:51state, he is not a good minister. If,
  875. 31:52on the other hand, he thinks more of
  876. 31:53the state than of himself, he is a
  877. 31:55trustworthy minister. And so, at that
  878. 31:56point, Machevelli says: the prince must
  879. 31:58keep him happy if he is trustworthy,
  880. 32:00that is, for example, it is he, the
  881. 32:02prince, who must honor the minister,
  882. 32:04make him rich, and make him happy,
  883. 32:06because if he is a good minister who
  884. 32:07works for the state and does not look
  885. 32:09after himself, he must nevertheless be
  886. 32:11rewarded in such a way that he will not
  887. 32:13later get strange ideas. Chapter 23.
  888. 32:17How to avoid flatterers. I do not want
  889. 32:20to leave out an important point and an
  890. 32:22error from which princes have
  891. 32:24difficulty defending themselves unless
  892. 32:25they are very prudent or if they do not
  893. 32:27have good judgment. And this is that of
  894. 32:30flatterers, of whom courts are full
  895. 32:32because men take such pleasure in their
  896. 32:34own affairs and are so deceived in them
  897. 32:36that they have difficulty defending
  898. 32:38themselves from this plague. And by
  899. 32:41wanting to defend oneself from it one
  900. 32:43runs the risk of becoming despised.
  901. 32:45Because there is no other way to guard
  902. 32:47against flatterers except to Let men
  903. 32:49understand that they do not offend you
  904. 32:50by telling you the truth. But when
  905. 32:53everyone can tell you the truth, you
  906. 32:54lose respect. Therefore, a prudent
  907. 32:57prince must adopt a third method,
  908. 32:59reading wise men in his state; and to
  909. 33:01them alone he must give the free will
  910. 33:03to speak the truth to him, and only
  911. 33:05about those things that he asks and
  912. 33:07nothing else. But he must ask them
  913. 33:09about everything and listen to their
  914. 33:11opinions, and then decide for himself
  915. 33:13in his own way; and with this advice,
  916. 33:15and with each of them, he must behave
  917. 33:17in such a way that everyone will know
  918. 33:19that the more freely he speaks, the
  919. 33:21more he will be accepted. Apart from
  920. 33:24these, he must not want to listen to
  921. 33:26anyone, follow the matter decided upon,
  922. 33:27and be obstinate in his decisions.
  923. 33:30Whoever does otherwise either falls
  924. 33:32prey to flatterers or is often changed
  925. 33:34by the change of opinions from which
  926. 33:36his low esteem arises. I wish to cite a
  927. 33:39modern example in this regard. Preluka,
  928. 33:43a man of Maximilian, the present
  929. 33:44emperor, speaking of his majesty, said
  930. 33:47that he did not take advice from anyone
  931. 33:49and never gave in to anything. his own
  932. 33:51way. This arose from keeping the
  933. 33:53opposite approach to the one mentioned
  934. 33:54above. Because the emperor is a
  935. 33:57secretive man, he does not communicate
  936. 33:59his secrets to anyone, he does not take
  937. 34:01any advice on them, but as soon as they
  938. 34:02are known and discovered in putting
  939. 34:04them into effect, they begin to be
  940. 34:06contradicted by those around him, and
  941. 34:08he, being easy, turns away from them.
  942. 34:11From this it follows that the things he
  943. 34:13does one day he destroys the next, and
  944. 34:15that it is never understood what he
  945. 34:17wants or intends to do, and that no one
  946. 34:19can base his decisions on them. A
  947. 34:22prince, therefore, must always take
  948. 34:23advice, but when he wants to, not when
  949. 34:25others want to; indeed, he must
  950. 34:27discourage anyone from advising him on
  951. 34:29anything unless he is asked to do so.
  952. 34:32But he must be a generous questioner,
  953. 34:33and then, regarding the things asked,
  954. 34:35patient, a listener of the truth, and
  955. 34:37indeed, if he understands that someone
  956. 34:39does not tell him anything for some
  957. 34:41reason, he is disturbed. And because
  958. 34:44many think that a prince who gives the
  959. 34:46impression of being prudent is
  960. 34:47considered so not because of his nature
  961. 34:49, but because of the good advice he has
  962. 34:52around, they are undoubtedly mistaken;
  963. 34:54for this never fails, and it is a
  964. 34:55general rule that a prince who is not
  965. 34:57wise in his own right cannot be well
  966. 34:59advised. Unless he were to choose one
  967. 35:03man who would govern him completely,
  968. 35:05and who was a very prudent man. In this
  969. 35:08case he might well be well governed,
  970. 35:10but he would not last long, because
  971. 35:12that governor would soon take away his
  972. 35:15state. But by taking advice from more
  973. 35:17than one, a prince who is not wise will
  974. 35:19never have united his counsel, nor will
  975. 35:21he know how to unite it by himself.
  976. 35:23Each of his counselors will think of
  977. 35:25his own interests, and he will not know
  978. 35:28how to correct or recognize them, and
  979. 35:30they cannot be found otherwise, because
  980. 35:32men will always turn out badly if they
  981. 35:34are not made good by necessity.
  982. 35:37Therefore it follows that good advice,
  983. 35:39no matter where it comes from, must
  984. 35:41arise from the prudence of the prince,
  985. 35:42and not the prudence of the prince from
  986. 35:44good advice. This chapter 23 is also
  987. 35:47interesting and topical; it speaks of
  988. 35:50flatterers, flatterers of power. In
  989. 35:52this case, flatterers of the prince, as
  990. 35:55How do you deal with these flatterers?
  991. 35:57Because he says: "How wonderful, the
  992. 35:59courts are full of flatterers", that is
  993. 36:01, people who compliment you a thousand
  994. 36:03times, who say how good you are, who
  995. 36:05say how strong you are and who, in
  996. 36:07doing so, also lead you to ruin.
  997. 36:09Because a prince must also understand
  998. 36:11whether his state is truly strong,
  999. 36:12whether his army is truly strong,
  1000. 36:14whether he can wage war or not.
  1001. 36:16Speaking of current events, I note that
  1002. 36:18in the meantime, the war in Ukraine
  1003. 36:19between Russia and Ukraine has been
  1004. 36:21going on for months now. It was
  1005. 36:23probably said at the beginning that
  1006. 36:25Putin was also badly advised, because
  1007. 36:27he is perhaps surrounded by a series of
  1008. 36:29flatterers who told him that the war in
  1009. 36:31Ukraine would be very easy, because the
  1010. 36:33Russian army was tremendously stronger.
  1011. 36:35Then it was not very easy. So, you see,
  1012. 36:38if this hypothesis is true, which is
  1013. 36:39only a hypothesis, then in that case
  1014. 36:41Machiavelli would be right, because
  1015. 36:42flatterers push you to ruin if you do
  1016. 36:44not know how to guard against them. So
  1017. 36:47Machiavelli gives his advice, he says
  1018. 36:49the only clear way to avoid flatterers
  1019. 36:51flatterers is to allow total freedom of
  1020. 36:53speech. That is, that one can truly say
  1021. 36:57what one thinks without suffering harm,
  1022. 36:59without risking one's life. However, it
  1023. 37:02is clear that you, prince, cannot grant
  1024. 37:04this freedom to everyone because at
  1025. 37:06that point all respect would be lost.
  1026. 37:08So Machelle says, you, prince, must
  1027. 37:10choose a nucleus, a group of a few wise
  1028. 37:12people to whom you can give this
  1029. 37:14opportunity, that is, to speak frankly,
  1030. 37:16to tell you what they think. She was
  1031. 37:18clear. If you are governing badly, they
  1032. 37:20must be able to tell you, if your army
  1033. 37:22is weak, they must be able to tell you.
  1034. 37:24Of course, this freedom of speech must
  1035. 37:26also be kept under control, Machevelli
  1036. 37:28says, so it is better for your prince
  1037. 37:30to choose who will be your advisor and
  1038. 37:33then it is you who ask the questions,
  1039. 37:35not them who speak whenever they want.
  1040. 37:37In fact, if they start talking, you
  1041. 37:39must stop them and silence them. So you
  1042. 37:41, prince, must be a listener, you must
  1043. 37:43ask everything, but when you want and
  1044. 37:45in the way and at the time you want.
  1045. 37:47And then you must also listen to
  1046. 37:49criticism, obviously from these people,
  1047. 37:51from these few people, because that
  1048. 37:53criticism They must guide you in making
  1049. 37:55changes, reforms, and so on. If you do
  1050. 37:57this, you can be sure that you can
  1051. 37:59govern well. But be careful, says
  1052. 38:01Machiavelli, only wise princes truly
  1053. 38:02know how to do this. Only wise princes
  1054. 38:05know how to choose a few equal people,
  1055. 38:07give them this freedom, and accept it.
  1056. 38:10Very often princes prefer to be
  1057. 38:12flattered or to let everyone talk, thus
  1058. 38:15ruining themselves. And so you have to
  1059. 38:19be careful, you have to choose well. At
  1060. 38:21the limit, sometimes you can even
  1061. 38:23choose just one person as an advisor,
  1062. 38:24but it is a bit risky. Machiavelli also
  1063. 38:26says, if this person is very capable,
  1064. 38:28he can advise you very well, but then
  1065. 38:29at a certain point he could also get
  1066. 38:31fed up with you and say, "Well, at this
  1067. 38:32point I might as well govern alone and
  1068. 38:34get rid of you." So a group of people
  1069. 38:37is better than a single person, but you
  1070. 38:40have to act with caution. In the end, I
  1071. 38:43will conclude on these notes
  1072. 38:44Machiavelli because he says, in fact,
  1073. 38:46good advice must come from the prudence
  1074. 38:48of the prince, not the prudence of the
  1075. 38:50prince of good advice, that is, the
  1076. 38:52prince must anticipate, already know
  1077. 38:53what it means to be wise, already know
  1078. 38:55who Listening, as in listening to him
  1079. 38:57and then listening to him. Chapter 24.
  1080. 39:01Why the Princes of Italy Lost Their
  1081. 39:03States. The above-mentioned things,
  1082. 39:06when prudently observed, make a new
  1083. 39:07prince appear old and immediately make
  1084. 39:09him more secure and more steadfast in
  1085. 39:11the state than if he had been old in it
  1086. 39:13. For a new prince is much more
  1087. 39:16observed in his actions than an
  1088. 39:18hereditary one. And when his actions
  1089. 39:21are recognized as virtuous, they win
  1090. 39:22over men much more and bind them much
  1091. 39:24more than old blood, because men are
  1092. 39:26much more interested in present things
  1093. 39:28than in past ones, and when they find
  1094. 39:30good in the present they enjoy it and
  1095. 39:32do not seek anything else. Indeed, they
  1096. 39:35take every precaution against him if
  1097. 39:37the prince does not fail himself in
  1098. 39:39other things. And so the glory of
  1099. 39:41having founded a new principality and
  1100. 39:43adorned and strengthened it with good
  1101. 39:46laws, good arms, good friends and good
  1102. 39:48examples is doubled. Just as the shame
  1103. 39:51of having been born a prince and lost
  1104. 39:53it through his own lack of prudence is
  1105. 39:54doubled. And if we consider those lords
  1106. 39:57in Italy who have lost their states in
  1107. 39:59our times, such as the King of Naples,
  1108. 40:01Tucca of Milan and others, one will
  1109. 40:02find in them first a common defect,
  1110. 40:04namely, alarms for the cones that have
  1111. 40:06been discussed at length above. Later
  1112. 40:09it will be seen that some of them
  1113. 40:11either had the people as enemies or, if
  1114. 40:13they had the people as friends, did not
  1115. 40:15know how to secure themselves against
  1116. 40:16the great, because without these
  1117. 40:18defects, states that have enough nerve
  1118. 40:20to hold an army in the field are not
  1119. 40:22lost. Philip of Macedon, not the father
  1120. 40:25of Alexander the Great, but he who was
  1121. 40:27defeated by Titus Quinctius, had a
  1122. 40:29small state compared to the greatness
  1123. 40:30of the Romans and of Greece who
  1124. 40:32attacked him. Nevertheless, because he
  1125. 40:34was a military man and knew how to
  1126. 40:36entertain the people and secure
  1127. 40:38themselves against the great, he fought
  1128. 40:40against them for many years, and if in
  1129. 40:42the end he lost the dominion of some
  1130. 40:44city, he nevertheless retained the
  1131. 40:45kingdom. Therefore, these princes of
  1132. 40:49ours, who had been in their
  1133. 40:51principality for many years and then
  1134. 40:52lost it, should not accuse Fortune of
  1135. 40:54casting malice upon them, because,
  1136. 40:56having never considered that in quiet
  1137. 40:58times there might be changes (which is
  1138. 41:00a common fault of men, not to reckon
  1139. 41:02with the storm in calm), when then When
  1140. 41:04adverse times came, they thought of
  1141. 41:06fleeing, not of defending themselves,
  1142. 41:08and they hoped that the people,
  1143. 41:09irritated by the insolence of the
  1144. 41:11victors, would recall them. Which
  1145. 41:15course, when others are lacking, is
  1146. 41:17good; but it is very bad to have
  1147. 41:18abandoned other remedies for this one,
  1148. 41:20because one would never want to fall
  1149. 41:22and then think of finding someone to
  1150. 41:24pick you up: which either does not
  1151. 41:25happen, or, if it does happen, it is
  1152. 41:27not to your safety, because that
  1153. 41:29defense is vile and does not depend on
  1154. 41:31you. And those defenses alone are good,
  1155. 41:34certain and lasting that depend on you
  1156. 41:36and your own virtue. Therefore,
  1157. 41:39Macchiarelli says in this 24th chapter:
  1158. 41:41a prince can generally govern well if
  1159. 41:43he follows this advice, especially if
  1160. 41:46he is a new prince. Because it is true
  1161. 41:49that a hereditary prince already has
  1162. 41:51power in his hands, so the game is a
  1163. 41:53little easier for him, but a new prince
  1164. 41:55is kept under observation; but, if he
  1165. 41:57governs well, he also gains a certain
  1166. 41:59loyalty, because men had more of the
  1167. 42:01present than the past. So it is true
  1168. 42:05that as a new prince you are pilloried,
  1169. 42:08you are pilloried, you are They watch
  1170. 42:10and control you, but if you act well
  1171. 42:12you will certainly guarantee great love
  1172. 42:14and support from the people. However,
  1173. 42:17when you do not govern well, it is your
  1174. 42:19downfall. And here Machiavelli brings
  1175. 42:21up the examples of many Italian princes
  1176. 42:23. Italy is full, says Machiavelli, of
  1177. 42:26princes who governed very badly and
  1178. 42:28quickly lost their dominion. Why did
  1179. 42:31they govern so badly? Above all,
  1180. 42:33because they did not take precautions,
  1181. 42:35that is, they thought, since things are
  1182. 42:37going well, there is no need for me to
  1183. 42:38do anything to prepare for the worst
  1184. 42:40eventualities. Then, when the worst
  1185. 42:43eventualities occurred, these princes
  1186. 42:45lost everything. Then, of course, they
  1187. 42:48hoped to be recalled, says Machiavelli,
  1188. 42:50at a certain point they hoped that the
  1189. 42:52people, fed up with the new occupier,
  1190. 42:54would recall them to power. But
  1191. 42:56Machiavelli also says, of course, it
  1192. 42:58can happen, but in short one remains a
  1193. 43:00bit of a victim, a bit weak, because it
  1194. 43:02is much better to be the master of a
  1195. 43:04state for one's own virtues than to be
  1196. 43:06the second choice, the third choice,
  1197. 43:08the fourth choice. In short, The
  1198. 43:11important thing is to prevent, to
  1199. 43:13forestall adverse events. The true
  1200. 43:15virtue of a prince is to think ahead of
  1201. 43:18time about what can go wrong and to
  1202. 43:20take steps to contain these risks. And
  1203. 43:23there is this phrase, in parenthesis,
  1204. 43:25which is very beautiful: the common
  1205. 43:27fault of men is not to count on the
  1206. 43:29calm of the storm. When things are
  1207. 43:32going well, no man thinks about the
  1208. 43:33fact that they could also go badly at a
  1209. 43:35certain point and therefore no man
  1210. 43:37prepares for the worst, and instead we
  1211. 43:39must be prepared for the worst. Chapter
  1212. 43:4225. How much fortune can do in human
  1213. 43:44affairs and in what ways it can hinder
  1214. 43:46it. It is not unknown to me, as many
  1215. 43:50have had and have the opinion, that the
  1216. 43:52affairs of the world are so governed by
  1217. 43:54fortune and by God that men, with their
  1218. 43:56prudence, cannot correct them, indeed
  1219. 43:58that they have no remedy at all. And
  1220. 44:01for this reason they might judge that
  1221. 44:03it was not necessary to sweat too much
  1222. 44:05in things, but to let fate govern them.
  1223. 44:08This opinion is more believed in our
  1224. 44:10times because of the change in the
  1225. 44:12great events that have been seen and I
  1226. 44:15am so far removed from all human
  1227. 44:17conjecture that when I think about it I
  1228. 44:19am sometimes inclined to their opinion.
  1229. 44:23Not least because our free will is not
  1230. 44:25extinguished. I judge it to be true
  1231. 44:27that fortune is the arbiter of half of
  1232. 44:30our actions, but that she also leaves
  1233. 44:32the other half, or a little less, to us
  1234. 44:34to govern. I compare her to a raging
  1235. 44:38river that, when it bursts forth in
  1236. 44:40anger upon the plains, ruins trees and
  1237. 44:42buildings, and lifts up soil from one
  1238. 44:44side and places it on the other.
  1239. 44:47Everyone flashes before it, everyone
  1240. 44:48ignites its fury without being able to
  1241. 44:50stop it. And although this is the case,
  1242. 44:54it is still not the case that men, when
  1243. 44:56times are calm, cannot take measures
  1244. 44:58against it, with barriers and
  1245. 44:59embankments, so that when it grows
  1246. 45:01either it would flow through a channel
  1247. 45:03or its empire would not be so wanton or
  1248. 45:05so harmful. In a similar way, fortune
  1249. 45:10shows its power where there is no
  1250. 45:12strength to resist, and turns its
  1251. 45:14forces there, where there is no
  1252. 45:15resistance. He knows that there are no
  1253. 45:18barriers or barriers to hold it back.
  1254. 45:22And if you consider Italy, which is the
  1255. 45:24series of these changes and the one
  1256. 45:26that has set them in motion, you will
  1257. 45:27see that it is a country without
  1258. 45:29barriers, without any barriers; and if
  1259. 45:31it had been protected by suitable
  1260. 45:33virtue, as is the case in Germany,
  1261. 45:34Spain, and France, this flood would not
  1262. 45:36have caused the great changes that it
  1263. 45:38has, or would not have come to pass.
  1264. 45:42For this reason I want to suffice to
  1265. 45:44have said as to opposing fortune in
  1266. 45:46general; but limiting myself more to
  1267. 45:48the particular, I say how one sees a
  1268. 45:50prince prospering today and ruined
  1269. 45:51tomorrow, without seeing him have
  1270. 45:53changed his mind or character. I
  1271. 45:55believe, moreover, that it arises first
  1272. 45:58from the causes that have long been
  1273. 46:00discussed, namely, that a prince who
  1274. 46:02relies entirely on fortune is ruined as
  1275. 46:05it changes. I also believe that he is
  1276. 46:08happy whose method of proceeding is in
  1277. 46:10line with the quality of the times, and
  1278. 46:12similarly if he is happy whose method
  1279. 46:14of proceeding is inconsistent with the
  1280. 46:16times. For it is seen that men proceed
  1281. 46:19in various ways in the things that lead
  1282. 46:22them to the end that each has before
  1283. 46:24him, namely, glory and riches, one with
  1284. 46:26caution, another with impetuosity, one
  1285. 46:28by violence, another by art, one with
  1286. 46:30patience, another by its opposite. And
  1287. 46:33each one can arrive at it by these
  1288. 46:34different methods. And it is also seen
  1289. 46:37that two men are equally successful,
  1290. 46:38one by achieving his design, the other
  1291. 46:40not. And similarly two men are equally
  1292. 46:42successful by two different efforts,
  1293. 46:44one being prudent, the other impetuous,
  1294. 46:46which arises from nothing else than the
  1295. 46:48quality of the times that conform to
  1296. 46:50them or from their procedure. From this
  1297. 46:53arises what I have said, that two men
  1298. 46:56acting differently produce the same
  1299. 46:58effect, and two acting equally, one is
  1300. 47:00led to his end, the other is not. From
  1301. 47:04this also depends the variation of good
  1302. 47:06, because if for someone who governs
  1303. 47:08himself with caution and patience the
  1304. 47:09times and things turn in such a way
  1305. 47:11that his government is good, he becomes
  1306. 47:13successful. But if times and
  1307. 47:15circumstances change, he is ruined,
  1308. 47:17because he does not change his method
  1309. 47:18of proceeding. Nor is there a man so
  1310. 47:21prudent as to know how to adapt himself
  1311. 47:23to this. Both because he cannot deviate
  1312. 47:25from that to which his nature inclines
  1313. 47:27him, and also because, having always
  1314. 47:29prospered by following one path, he
  1315. 47:31cannot persuade himself that it is good
  1316. 47:32to depart from it. And therefore a
  1317. 47:35prudent man, when it is time for him to
  1318. 47:37rush into an impetus, does not know how
  1319. 47:38to do so. Hence he is ruined, for if
  1320. 47:40his nature were to change with the
  1321. 47:42times and circumstances, his fortune
  1322. 47:44would not change. Pope Julius II
  1323. 47:47proceeded with great care and found the
  1324. 47:49times and circumstances so in keeping
  1325. 47:51with his method of proceeding that he
  1326. 47:54always had a happy ending. Consider the
  1327. 47:57first enterprise he undertook in
  1328. 47:58Bologna, while Messer Giovanni
  1329. 48:00Bentivogli was still alive. The
  1330. 48:02Vicentini were not satisfied with it.
  1331. 48:04The King of Spain, likewise with France
  1332. 48:06, had discussions about such an
  1333. 48:08enterprise; and he, nevertheless, with
  1334. 48:10his ferocity and impetuosity,
  1335. 48:11personally set out on that expedition,
  1336. 48:13which move made both Spain and the
  1337. 48:15Venetians pause and hesitate: the
  1338. 48:16former out of fear, the latter out of a
  1339. 48:19desire to recover the entire kingdom of
  1340. 48:21Naples. On the other hand, he drew the
  1341. 48:24King of France along with him, because,
  1342. 48:26having seen that king move and wishing
  1343. 48:27to make him his friend in order to
  1344. 48:29subdue the Venetians, he judged that he
  1345. 48:30could not refuse him his troops without
  1346. 48:32openly offending him. Therefore Julius,
  1347. 48:35with his impetuous move, accomplished
  1348. 48:37what the other pontiff, with all human
  1349. 48:39prudence, had never achieved. For if he
  1350. 48:43had waited to leave Rome with firm
  1351. 48:45conclusions and everything in order, as
  1352. 48:47any other pontiff would have done, he
  1353. 48:49would never have succeeded. Because the
  1354. 48:52King of France would have found a
  1355. 48:54thousand excuses and the others would
  1356. 48:55have filled him with a thousand fears.
  1357. 48:57I will leave aside his other actions,
  1358. 48:59which were all similar and all went
  1359. 49:02well for him, and the brevity of his
  1360. 49:04life did not allow you to hear the
  1361. 49:06contrary. Because if times had come
  1362. 49:09when it was necessary to proceed with
  1363. 49:10caution, his ruin would have followed,
  1364. 49:12because he would never have deviated
  1365. 49:14from those ways to which nature
  1366. 49:16inclined him. I conclude, therefore,
  1367. 49:19that when fortune changes and men
  1368. 49:21remain obstinate in their ways, they
  1369. 49:23are happy while they agree together,
  1370. 49:25and when they disagree they are unhappy
  1371. 49:27. I judge this well, that it is better
  1372. 49:29to be impetuous than cautious, because
  1373. 49:31fortune is a woman and it is necessary,
  1374. 49:33if one wishes to keep her under control
  1375. 49:35, to beat her and provoke her. And it
  1376. 49:38is seen that she is more easily
  1377. 49:39overcome by the latter than by those
  1378. 49:40who proceed coldly. And therefore, as a
  1379. 49:43woman, she is always a friend to the
  1380. 49:45young, because they are less cautious,
  1381. 49:46more ferocious, and command her with
  1382. 49:47more audacity. This penultimate chapter
  1383. 49:50is again one of the most famous of
  1384. 49:52Machiavelli's The Prince. It speaks of
  1385. 49:54fortune, that is, fate. How much does
  1386. 49:56fortune count in human affairs and
  1387. 49:58especially in the affairs of the prince
  1388. 50:00? Machelli begins by saying that some
  1389. 50:03people think that everything depends on
  1390. 50:05luck, on God, or at most on providence,
  1391. 50:07on those who act for him, and that
  1392. 50:09therefore man can do nothing to change
  1393. 50:10his fate. Machelli says: "Yes, it is
  1394. 50:14true that luck has a great influence, I
  1395. 50:16agree", he says, but he also says that
  1396. 50:18in my opinion, let's make it 50-50,
  1397. 50:20that is, about half or a little more
  1398. 50:22depends on luck, the rest depends on us
  1399. 50:24, on our free will. So it is true that
  1400. 50:28luck has a great influence, but man can
  1401. 50:29do a lot, he can at least do something.
  1402. 50:32And here there is a famous comparison
  1403. 50:33with floods. After all, even the
  1404. 50:36shelter of a river depends on luck, on
  1405. 50:38fate, it depends on man. Usually there
  1406. 50:41is a lot of rain. The river overflows
  1407. 50:43and floods the land. But what can man
  1408. 50:45do? Man can create embankments, he can
  1409. 50:49divert the river, he can ensure that in
  1410. 50:52the event of adverse fortune, in the
  1411. 50:56event of a flood, this flood is more or
  1412. 50:59less managed. This is political virtue.
  1413. 51:03In the end, as we said in the previous
  1414. 51:06chapter, it is predicting disasters and
  1415. 51:08doing something to contain them. The
  1416. 51:11problem with Italy, he also said, is
  1417. 51:12that it has none of these embankments.
  1418. 51:15France, Spain and Germany build these
  1419. 51:17arsenals, that is, they create a
  1420. 51:19framework to ensure that fortune does
  1421. 51:21not devastate too much. Italians are
  1422. 51:25generally not capable of this, so they
  1423. 51:27lead themselves to ruin, also because
  1424. 51:29Italians or princes in general are
  1425. 51:31rather stubborn, says Machiavelli, in
  1426. 51:33the sense that they have their own
  1427. 51:35style and then persevere in this style
  1428. 51:37of government, not adapting to
  1429. 51:39circumstances, which is completely
  1430. 51:41wrong. Why does he say this? Well, he
  1431. 51:44also makes a reasoning where he says
  1432. 51:46that at the end of the day, it will be
  1433. 51:47seen that sometimes an impetuous prince
  1434. 51:49is lucky, sometimes not, sometimes very
  1435. 51:51successful, sometimes not. A prudent
  1436. 51:52prince is sometimes very successful,
  1437. 51:54sometimes not. So what is the criterion
  1438. 51:56? And the fact is that there is no
  1439. 51:58criterion, it depends on luck, but
  1440. 52:00there are times when being impetuous is
  1441. 52:02a good thing and there are times when
  1442. 52:04being prudent is a good thing. So a
  1443. 52:06good prince should foresee both times
  1444. 52:09and find tricks, ways, and methods to
  1445. 52:13overcome the arrows of fortune, the
  1446. 52:16adverse blows of fate. And he gives an
  1447. 52:21example in this regard which is that of
  1448. 52:23Pope Julius II who had a very impetuous
  1449. 52:25character and who, precisely because of
  1450. 52:26this impetuous character, attacked many
  1451. 52:28peoples and he speaks of Bologna, in
  1452. 52:30particular the case of the capture of
  1453. 52:32Bologna, but he did the same on other
  1454. 52:33occasions as well. Machavelli says that
  1455. 52:36Julius II was always lucky, things
  1456. 52:37always went well for him. His impetuous
  1457. 52:40character led him not to seek alliances
  1458. 52:42, not to clarify diplomacy, but he
  1459. 52:44attacked, attacked, attacked and was
  1460. 52:46lucky because things went well for him.
  1461. 52:49But we can say that he was a victorious
  1462. 52:51pope, also because he died early. If he
  1463. 52:55had lived longer, says Machiavelli,
  1464. 52:56probably at a certain point fortune
  1465. 52:58would have changed and he, with his
  1466. 53:00always impetuous, always aggressive
  1467. 53:02ways, sooner or later would have hit a
  1468. 53:03wall and lost. He would have lost badly
  1469. 53:07, because he was not, did not seem to
  1470. 53:08be someone capable of adapting to
  1471. 53:10circumstances, to fortune: he was
  1472. 53:11someone who kept going straight, as
  1473. 53:13sometimes happens. So Machiavelli's
  1474. 53:15advice seems to be to look at the
  1475. 53:18moments, understand the moment and
  1476. 53:20above all use a virtue that can help
  1477. 53:23you protect yourself and your state
  1478. 53:28from adverse events. And he concludes
  1479. 53:31with a famous quote from Machiavelli
  1480. 53:33and says, let's see if I can find it
  1481. 53:34again. Um, I think it is better to be
  1482. 53:38impetuous than respectful because
  1483. 53:40fortune is a woman and it is necessary,
  1484. 53:42if you want to keep her under control,
  1485. 53:44to beat her and hurt her. Machiavelli
  1486. 53:47is not very feminist here, is he? He
  1487. 53:51says fortune is a woman and then, like
  1488. 53:53women, he seems to say, she loves those
  1489. 53:56who mistreat her, beat her and hurt her
  1490. 53:59, that is, those who appear impetuous,
  1491. 54:01not those who proceed coldly. In other
  1492. 54:05words, we must not be too cautious. If
  1493. 54:06we have to choose. It is true that we
  1494. 54:09have just said that depending on the
  1495. 54:11circumstances, we must know when to be
  1496. 54:13cautious and when to be impetuous, but
  1497. 54:15not knowing which way to turn, it is
  1498. 54:16better to be more impetuous because
  1499. 54:18fortune loves impetuous people, those
  1500. 54:20who go against fortune, who beat her,
  1501. 54:22who beat her, who hurt her. Fortune is
  1502. 54:26a woman and therefore she is a friend
  1503. 54:28of the impetuous, but she is also a
  1504. 54:29friend of the young, says Machiavelli,
  1505. 54:32because she does not like the more
  1506. 54:33cautious old people, after all. It is
  1507. 54:36Italy in the 16th century. Well,
  1508. 54:39obviously fortune is personified in a
  1509. 54:42woman, but the idea is that of being
  1510. 54:44princes capable of judging the moment
  1511. 54:47and if we are not capable, at least
  1512. 54:49impetuous. Chapter 26. Exhortation to
  1513. 54:53free Italy from barbarians. Considering
  1514. 54:58all the above, and thinking to myself
  1515. 54:59that at present in Italy there were
  1516. 55:01times when a new prince could be
  1517. 55:03honored, and if there was material that
  1518. 55:05would give an opportunity to a prudent
  1519. 55:07and virtuous man to introduce a new
  1520. 55:08form that would do honor to him and
  1521. 55:10good to the community of men there, it
  1522. 55:12seems to me that so many things concur
  1523. 55:14in the benefit of a new prince that I
  1524. 55:16do not know that the time was ever more
  1525. 55:18suited to it. And if, as I said, it was
  1526. 55:22necessary, in order to see the virtue
  1527. 55:24of Moses, that the people of Israel
  1528. 55:26should be slaves in Egypt, and to know
  1529. 55:28the greatness of the soul of Cyrus,
  1530. 55:30that the Persians should be oppressed
  1531. 55:32by the Medes, and to illustrate the
  1532. 55:33excellence of Theseus, that the
  1533. 55:35Athenians should be dispersed; Thus at
  1534. 55:37present, if we wish to know the virtue
  1535. 55:39of an Italian spirit, it was necessary
  1536. 55:41that Italy should conduct herself in
  1537. 55:42the present conditions and that she
  1538. 55:44should be more enslaved than the
  1539. 55:46Hebrews, more subservient than the
  1540. 55:48Persians, more scattered than the
  1541. 55:51Athenians, without a leader, without
  1542. 55:53order, beaten, plundered, torn, overrun
  1543. 55:55, and having endured every kind of ruin
  1544. 55:57. And although up to this point there
  1545. 56:02has been some evidence of someone who
  1546. 56:04could be judged to have been ordained
  1547. 56:06by God for her redemption, it has
  1548. 56:08nevertheless been seen how later, in
  1549. 56:11the highest course of her actions, she
  1550. 56:13was rejected by fortune, so that, left
  1551. 56:15as if lifeless, she awaits someone who
  1552. 56:18can heal her wounds and put an end to
  1553. 56:20her governments and sackings of
  1554. 56:22Lombardy, to the plundering and
  1555. 56:24ransacking of the kingdom and of
  1556. 56:26Tuscany, and to heal her of those
  1557. 56:29wounds which have festered for a long
  1558. 56:31time. We see how she prays to God to
  1559. 56:34send him someone who will redeem her
  1560. 56:36from these barbarous cruelties and
  1561. 56:38debaucheries. You see, too, all ready
  1562. 56:41and disposed to follow a banner,
  1563. 56:42provided there is someone who will take
  1564. 56:44it up; nor is it seen at present in
  1565. 56:46whom it can hope more than in your
  1566. 56:48illustrious house, which, with its
  1567. 56:50virtue and fortune, favored by God and
  1568. 56:52by the Church, of which it is now the
  1569. 56:54prince, can make itself the head of
  1570. 56:55this redemption. And this will not be
  1571. 56:59very difficult for you if you will
  1572. 57:00bring before you the deeds and lives of
  1573. 57:02the aforementioned. And although those
  1574. 57:04men are rare and wonderful, they were
  1575. 57:06nonetheless men. And each of them had a
  1576. 57:09better opportunity than the present.
  1577. 57:11For their enterprise was not more just
  1578. 57:13than this one, nor was God more
  1579. 57:15friendly to them than to you. Here
  1580. 57:17there is great justice, because that
  1581. 57:19war is just, that it is necessary for
  1582. 57:21them, and those weapons are merciful
  1583. 57:23where nothing else is hoped for but God
  1584. 57:25. Here there is very great disposition,
  1585. 57:28nor can there be great disposition and
  1586. 57:30great difficulty, provided that it
  1587. 57:32takes the orders of those whom I have
  1588. 57:34proposed to you as its aim. In addition
  1589. 57:37to this, extraordinary and unparalleled
  1590. 57:39figures are being led here by God. The
  1591. 57:41sea has opened up, a cloud has shown
  1592. 57:43you the way, the rock has poured out
  1593. 57:45water. Manna has rained down here.
  1594. 57:48Everything has contributed to your
  1595. 57:49greatness. The rest is up to you to do.
  1596. 57:53God does not want to do everything. He
  1597. 57:55takes away our free will for us. He
  1598. 57:57does not take away our free will. It is
  1599. 57:59part of that glory that belongs to us.
  1600. 58:01And it is no wonder that none of the
  1601. 58:03aforementioned Italians has been able
  1602. 58:05to do what your illustrious house can
  1603. 58:07hope to do for us. And if in so many
  1604. 58:09revolutions in Italy and in so many
  1605. 58:12warlike maneuvers, it always seems that
  1606. 58:14military virtue is extinguished,
  1607. 58:16because this is because the old laws of
  1608. 58:18that country were not good and no one
  1609. 58:21has been able to find new ones. Nothing
  1610. 58:24gives so much honor to a man who rises
  1611. 58:27up anew as do new laws and new orders
  1612. 58:29invented by him. When these things are
  1613. 58:32well founded and have greatness in them
  1614. 58:34, they make him revered and admirable.
  1615. 58:36And in Italy there is no lack of
  1616. 58:37material to introduce you to every form
  1617. 58:39. Here there is great virtue in the
  1618. 58:41members when it is not lacking in the
  1619. 58:43leaders. Reflect in the duels and in
  1620. 58:46the conferences of the few how superior
  1621. 58:47the Italians are in strength, in skill,
  1622. 58:49in intelligence. But when it comes to
  1623. 58:52armies they do not appear and
  1624. 58:54everything proceeds from the weakness
  1625. 58:56of the leaders because those who know
  1626. 58:58are not obeyed and everyone seems to
  1627. 59:00know, not having yet acquired it, any
  1628. 59:02one who has revealed himself so much
  1629. 59:04either by virtue or by fortune that the
  1630. 59:06others yield. From this it comes that
  1631. 59:09in so long a time, in so many wars
  1632. 59:11fought in the past 20 years, when there
  1633. 59:13was an all-Italian army, it has always
  1634. 59:15made a bad impression. As witness first
  1635. 59:18Taro, then Alessandria, Capua, Genoa,
  1636. 59:20Va là, Bologna Mestri. Since your
  1637. 59:25illustrious house wishes to follow
  1638. 59:27those excellent men who restored their
  1639. 59:28provinces, it is necessary, before all
  1640. 59:30else, as the true foundation of every
  1641. 59:32enterprise, to provide itself with its
  1642. 59:34own arms, because it is impossible to
  1643. 59:36have better soldiers, more faithful or
  1644. 59:37more reliable. And although each of
  1645. 59:41them is good, all together they will
  1646. 59:43become better when they see themselves
  1647. 59:45commanded by their prince and honored
  1648. 59:47and entertained by him. It is therefore
  1649. 59:50necessary to prepare for these arms in
  1650. 59:52order to be able to defend oneself with
  1651. 59:54Italian valor from outsiders. And
  1652. 59:57although the Swiss and Spanish infantry
  1653. 59:59are considered terrible, nevertheless
  1654. 1:00:01there is a defect in both, by which a
  1655. 1:00:03third rank could not only oppose them,
  1656. 1:00:05but be confident of overcoming them;
  1657. 1:00:07for the Spaniards cannot withstand
  1658. 1:00:09cavalry and the Swiss are truly afraid
  1659. 1:00:11of infantry, when they find them as
  1660. 1:00:13obstinate in fighting as they are. We
  1661. 1:00:17have seen and will see the Spaniards
  1662. 1:00:20unable to withstand a French cavalry
  1663. 1:00:22and the Swiss ruined by a Spanish
  1664. 1:00:24infantry. And although there has not
  1665. 1:00:28been a complete experience of this
  1666. 1:00:30latter, nevertheless a sample of it
  1667. 1:00:32came about on the day of Ravenna, when
  1668. 1:00:34the Spanish infantry faced the German
  1669. 1:00:36troops, who served in the same order as
  1670. 1:00:39the Swiss; where the Spaniards, with
  1671. 1:00:41the skill of their bodies and the help
  1672. 1:00:43of their armor-bearers, had entered
  1673. 1:00:45between their pikes and were secure in
  1674. 1:00:47attacking them, without the Germans
  1675. 1:00:49having any remedy. And if it had not
  1676. 1:00:52been for the cavalry that attacked them
  1677. 1:00:54, they would have consumed them all. It
  1678. 1:00:56is therefore possible, recognizing the
  1679. 1:00:58defects of both of these infantry, to
  1680. 1:01:00organize a new one, which can withstand
  1681. 1:01:02cavalry and has no fear of infantry,
  1682. 1:01:04which will be accomplished not by the
  1683. 1:01:06generation of arms, but by the change
  1684. 1:01:08of the orders. And these are those
  1685. 1:01:11things which, when newly organized,
  1686. 1:01:13give reputation and greatness to a new
  1687. 1:01:15prince. Therefore, this opportunity
  1688. 1:01:18must not be allowed to pass so that
  1689. 1:01:20Italy may see the appearance of her
  1690. 1:01:22redeemer, not so long after all this
  1691. 1:01:23time. Nor can I express with what love
  1692. 1:01:26he was received in all those provinces
  1693. 1:01:28that suffered from these external
  1694. 1:01:30floods. With what vengeance, with what
  1695. 1:01:33obstinate faith, with what pity, with
  1696. 1:01:36what tears, what doors would be closed
  1697. 1:01:38to him? What people would refuse him
  1698. 1:01:41obedience? What envy would oppose him?
  1699. 1:01:45What Italian would refuse him homage?
  1700. 1:01:48This barbaric dominion stinks to
  1701. 1:01:49everyone. Therefore, your illustrious
  1702. 1:01:51home, undertake this undertaking with
  1703. 1:01:53the same spirit and with the same hopes
  1704. 1:01:55that are undertaken in just
  1705. 1:01:56undertakings. So that under his banner
  1706. 1:01:59this country may be ennobled and under
  1707. 1:02:02his auspices what Petrarch said may
  1708. 1:02:04come true: virtue against fury, to take
  1709. 1:02:07alarm and to fight short, for the
  1710. 1:02:09ancient valor in the Italians is not
  1711. 1:02:11yet dead. Here is the 26th and last
  1712. 1:02:15chapter. We have finished the book, and
  1713. 1:02:17what does he say in this last chapter?
  1714. 1:02:19How does he take leave of his audience?
  1715. 1:02:21Machelli launches an exhortation
  1716. 1:02:23addressed to the Medici family because,
  1717. 1:02:25as you will recall, we said in the very
  1718. 1:02:28first episode that the book is
  1719. 1:02:29dedicated to Lorenzo De Piero de '
  1720. 1:02:31Medici. Di Piero de' Medici, a member,
  1721. 1:02:34at least at that time, the last of the
  1722. 1:02:36Medici family, but in general it is an
  1723. 1:02:39exhortation to the entire family
  1724. 1:02:41because they take the fate of Italy to
  1725. 1:02:43heart. Machevelli says, Italy has never
  1726. 1:02:47been so ready to be unified, to be led
  1727. 1:02:49by a strong prince, a prince who can
  1728. 1:02:51gather under the same banner, under the
  1729. 1:02:54same flag, a people, says Machevelli,
  1730. 1:02:56who is waiting for nothing else. Cesare
  1731. 1:03:01Borgia had recently tried, but he
  1732. 1:03:03failed because fortune turned against
  1733. 1:03:05him. Now it is the turn of the Medici
  1734. 1:03:08family, who are the best placed family
  1735. 1:03:09from this point of view: because they
  1736. 1:03:11have the support of God, because they
  1737. 1:03:13are popes of the Medici family and so
  1738. 1:03:15on, because they have the strength and
  1739. 1:03:17prestige of this family, which has been
  1740. 1:03:19one of the most important and still is
  1741. 1:03:21one of the most important. Italy is
  1742. 1:03:23ready because the conditions are
  1743. 1:03:25excellent, says Machiavelli. Never has
  1744. 1:03:27there been such a good opportunity in
  1745. 1:03:28Italy as at this moment. Of course, if
  1746. 1:03:31you want to undertake such an
  1747. 1:03:32undertaking, you need to organize a
  1748. 1:03:34good army. This is Italy's weak point.
  1749. 1:03:36This has always been the case, he says,
  1750. 1:03:37"But how beautiful is a weak point?"
  1751. 1:03:39Because Italy has been full of
  1752. 1:03:40ingenuity and science, but when it came
  1753. 1:03:42time to fight, it fought very badly,
  1754. 1:03:44and there are many examples of this.
  1755. 1:03:47Why did it fight badly? Because of its
  1756. 1:03:48leaders, says Machiavelli, who are weak
  1757. 1:03:51leaders, dull leaders. You need to be
  1758. 1:03:54more resolute leaders and prepare for
  1759. 1:03:56war, obviously also studying enemy
  1760. 1:03:58armies. Here Machiavelli also makes a
  1761. 1:04:01quick analysis of the Spanish and Swiss
  1762. 1:04:04armies, showing their defects. So he
  1763. 1:04:07says: "It is true that the Spanish and
  1764. 1:04:09Swiss armies seem unbeatable, very
  1765. 1:04:11strong, but by knowing their defects,
  1766. 1:04:12one can create an army that knows how
  1767. 1:04:14to defeat them, that knows how to
  1768. 1:04:16inflict strong blows on them; all that
  1769. 1:04:23is needed is to field good cavalry or
  1770. 1:04:24infantry that knows how to fight on par
  1771. 1:04:26with enemy infantry", and he gives his
  1772. 1:04:28advice. Once all this is achieved,
  1773. 1:04:33Italy can be freed from the barbarians,
  1774. 1:04:35freed from the invaders; and that
  1775. 1:04:37exhortation that Petrarch himself had
  1776. 1:04:39written in that famous song of his with
  1777. 1:04:41which the chapter and the entire work
  1778. 1:04:44concludes can be fulfilled. The four
  1779. 1:04:48verses are taken from Petrarch's song
  1780. 1:04:51about Italy, the song entitled "My
  1781. 1:04:54Italy". They are the verses, to be
  1782. 1:04:57precise, between 93 and 96. Virtue
  1783. 1:04:59against fury will cause alarms and the
  1784. 1:05:01fight will be short, for the ancient
  1785. 1:05:04valor in the Italian heart is not a
  1786. 1:05:06dead heart. I would like to point out
  1787. 1:05:08the use of the word Italy, Italians,
  1788. 1:05:10Italics. Macvell was one of the first
  1789. 1:05:13to use this word, which would be a word
  1790. 1:05:16for a long time, Italy, Italians, etc.,
  1791. 1:05:18used mainly in cultured circles, in
  1792. 1:05:20literary circles, in these exhortations
  1793. 1:05:23of Petrarch and Machiavelli, not yet at
  1794. 1:05:25a popular level. However, it was
  1795. 1:05:28already a strong signal of a desire, at
  1796. 1:05:30least among intellectuals, for an Italy
  1797. 1:05:32that could compete on equal terms with
  1798. 1:05:34other countries, with France, Spain,
  1799. 1:05:36Switzerland, in these countries that at
  1800. 1:05:38the time seemed the strongest, the most
  1801. 1:05:40combative, when Italy, despite being
  1802. 1:05:41rich, despite being a land of rebirth,
  1803. 1:05:43remained somewhat behind. Machiavelli's
  1804. 1:05:47hopes were obviously disappointed. No
  1805. 1:05:49Italian lord would succeed in becoming
  1806. 1:05:51prince of anything for very long. Italy
  1807. 1:05:54would remain a land of foreign conquest
  1808. 1:05:57for all of the 500s and even for the
  1809. 1:05:59600s. Things will start to change much
  1810. 1:06:02later, to tell the truth, much later
  1811. 1:06:04between the end of the 18th and 19th
  1812. 1:06:07centuries, especially when, after the
  1813. 1:06:09aftermath of the French Revolution and
  1814. 1:06:12the Napoleonic era, some patriots in
  1815. 1:06:14Italy will start to take action. They
  1816. 1:06:16will no longer be the princes, because
  1817. 1:06:19the princes certainly will start on
  1818. 1:06:21some occasions, but, uh, they will not
  1819. 1:06:23be too trustworthy. They will put off
  1820. 1:06:26the project for a long time, it will
  1821. 1:06:28initially be the patriots, the
  1822. 1:06:29followers of Mazzini and the Carbonari
  1823. 1:06:31who will put forward proposals of this
  1824. 1:06:33type. Then the princes will also arrive
  1825. 1:06:36, but very late, the princes of Savoy,
  1826. 1:06:38in short, not certain doctors who, uh,
  1827. 1:06:40have passed, three centuries will have
  1828. 1:06:42passed, they will no longer be so
  1829. 1:06:44important. This is how The Prince by
  1830. 1:06:47Niccolò Machiavelli ends. There, we
  1831. 1:06:49have read everything as I promised. We
  1832. 1:06:51made it, we finished the book and the
  1833. 1:06:53final chapters were quite short,
  1834. 1:06:54relatively short, at least compared to
  1835. 1:06:56other chapters that we have read; so
  1836. 1:06:58there was no point in making two
  1837. 1:06:59separate videos, even if this video
  1838. 1:07:01ended up being slightly long, but
  1839. 1:07:02anyway we made it. And I remind you
  1840. 1:07:05that, as usual, in the description you
  1841. 1:07:07will find the titles so as to separate,
  1842. 1:07:09as you have seen, the reading parts
  1843. 1:07:10from the commentary parts. You will
  1844. 1:07:13also find the link to the playlist with
  1845. 1:07:15all the previous episodes, in case you
  1846. 1:07:17missed them, and also the link to buy
  1847. 1:07:18The Prince by Machiavelli, because it
  1848. 1:07:20is one thing to hear it read like this
  1849. 1:07:22by me, by the way with some difficulty,
  1850. 1:07:24because you see that Machiavelli's
  1851. 1:07:26sentences are sometimes very long, full
  1852. 1:07:28of incidentals, subordinate clauses: it
  1853. 1:07:30is not easy to read Machiavelli, you
  1854. 1:07:31will have noticed that? At least
  1855. 1:07:34reading it out loud, reading it in
  1856. 1:07:35writing is already a bit easier. So if
  1857. 1:07:38you have the chance, if you feel like
  1858. 1:07:39it, buy The Prince, it is an enjoyable
  1859. 1:07:41read. I read it in high school, then I
  1860. 1:07:44read it again in university and I have
  1861. 1:07:46always found it funny because
  1862. 1:07:48Machiavelli is also this sarcasm that
  1863. 1:07:50hits the mark every now and then and
  1864. 1:07:52then if you need to understand
  1865. 1:07:54somewhere, come back here and listen
  1866. 1:07:56again to the relative commentary on the
  1867. 1:07:58chapter. And I always remind you that
  1868. 1:08:01in the description you can also find
  1869. 1:08:03ways to stay in touch, social networks,
  1870. 1:08:04the free weekly newsletter and then you
  1871. 1:08:06can find ways to support the channel if
  1872. 1:08:08you like what we do. And in any case,
  1873. 1:08:10my children always tell me, I always
  1874. 1:08:12forget: remember to also subscribe, if
  1875. 1:08:14you haven't subscribed to the channel,
  1876. 1:08:16with the bell. Subscribe, there are
  1877. 1:08:18some buttons of this type below, all
  1878. 1:08:20free of course; and instead, to support
  1879. 1:08:22us, you can also pay a few euros, but
  1880. 1:08:24there it's your choice. Thanks to
  1881. 1:08:26everyone who gives us a hand, thanks
  1882. 1:08:28for staying here until the end of the
  1883. 1:08:30complete reading of Machiavelli's The
  1884. 1:08:32Prince and soon we will be back with
  1885. 1:08:34other works because the world is full
  1886. 1:08:35of classics of history and philosophy
  1887. 1:08:37and we will get to them. In the
  1888. 1:08:39meantime, good night, bye everyone and
  1889. 1:08:41see you next time.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of "Il Principe" di Machiavelli - Audiolibro spiegato parte 6 by scrip, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 12,928 words across 1,889 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.