If I was retiring in 2027 with an RRSP or LIRA, this is what I'd do (Ep 063) — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Okay, welcome to episode 63 of
- 0:01Retirement Unpacked. Myself, Adam
- 0:03Bourne, and I have Stephen Arnett from
- 0:04our team. Uh, Steve joined us not too
- 0:06long ago, but uh many many years in the
- 0:09industry and a lot of people in industry
- 0:11know who Steve is. So, welcome Steve
- 0:12back to uh to another video here. So,
- 0:15>> thanks Adam.
- 0:16>> Let's jump Yeah, let's jump into the
- 0:18first question. So, here I'm retiring
- 0:20partway through next year, which is
- 0:21obviously common. People don't always
- 0:23retire on December 31st. So, um should I
- 0:26establish my lift my life income fund?
- 0:29uh in January or wait until retirement
- 0:31and how could that affect my withdrawal
- 0:33limits? So um I think this is not just
- 0:36lift. So a life income fund comes from a
- 0:37LRA locked and registered account
- 0:39typically a a work pension type plan. Um
- 0:42it could be your RSP to a RIFF or
- 0:43retirement income fund that could also
- 0:45be part of this question as well. Um, so
- 0:48if you're retiring halfway through the
- 0:50year, you really have to determine, do I
- 0:52need some of that money for the second
- 0:54half of the year or have I earned, which
- 0:55often happens where, you know, okay,
- 0:57I've earned enough in the first half of
- 0:58the year, I need to use some of that
- 0:59money, or maybe some of my TF say I
- 1:01don't want to drive up any additional
- 1:03taxable income for the rest of the year.
- 1:05So, that really comes down to your plan.
- 1:07Figure out, am I drawing taxable income
- 1:09for the second half of the year or non-t
- 1:10taxable income or any income for that
- 1:12matter? If you're drawing down um
- 1:15taxable income, then the benefit of
- 1:18converting to a lifer actually not in
- 1:21January, but in December the previous
- 1:23year, that will give you that minimum
- 1:25amount for the following year. So, if if
- 1:28you're if let's say let's assume you're
- 1:30retiring, you know, July 1st of 2027 and
- 1:33we're late in 2026 right now and you
- 1:36know that once you retire, you need to
- 1:38pull out $15,000 from your RIFF or uh
- 1:41any registered account for the second
- 1:43half of 2027, you may want to convert or
- 1:46at least set up a lift or RIFF now and
- 1:48preund some of that in there. What that
- 1:50will do is give you that minimum amount
- 1:52for your lift, a minimum and a maximum
- 1:54amount. That will help with the
- 1:56withholding tax at tax time. Now, again,
- 1:59do you need to do this? I would say for
- 2:01most people, no. Um, I think where it
- 2:03makes a difference would be if you're
- 2:05retiring in the first quarter of the
- 2:07year. So, February, March, April, and
- 2:10you're going to be pulling out a
- 2:11substantial amount of money out of your
- 2:13LIFF or RIFF next year, 2027.
- 2:17open up and fund your lifer now in 2026
- 2:20so you have that you know a larger
- 2:22minimum amount less withholding tax
- 2:24it'll put you in a better tax situation.
- 2:26So that's really the only time. So if
- 2:28you want kind of a cheat sheet if you're
- 2:30retiring in the first you know 3, four,
- 2:32five months of the year uh set up the
- 2:34income accounts and fund them in the
- 2:36year before to give you that minimum
- 2:38amount. Hopefully that all made sense.
- 2:40>> Completely agree. [laughter]
- 2:43>> Yeah. Thanks Adam. And and another note
- 2:45on the lifts, um, one thing is that
- 2:48maximum withdrawals for some
- 2:49jurisdictions are prrated for the year.
- 2:52So if you wait until midway through the
- 2:54year for a lift, for instance, you may
- 2:56not be able to get as much out of that
- 2:57account on a maximum basis as if you had
- 3:00converted either January or to Adam's
- 3:02point in 2026. So there there can be
- 3:05advantages to to getting things moving
- 3:07early. The only caveat that that we
- 3:09would add is just making sure that you
- 3:11do need that income and that you're
- 3:13going to want those those riff minimums
- 3:15and lift minimums in place going forward
- 3:17because sometimes we'll see situations
- 3:19where a client might want to or a
- 3:21listener might want to take out for one
- 3:23or two years but then because of their
- 3:24tax situation maybe they want to wait
- 3:27for a couple years. So yeah, when you do
- 3:29go to convert your your accounts into
- 3:32lifts and riffs, just make sure that you
- 3:33need that income going forward uh and
- 3:35that you're kind of comfortable with all
- 3:37of the the admin work.
- 3:38>> Well, that's a good point because if you
- 3:39plan to retire early in the year, so
- 3:41you've converted a large riff and you
- 3:42have that minimum amount and it's like
- 3:44actually, you know, work's giving me a
- 3:45good offer. I'm going to work the rest
- 3:47of the year. It's like, well, now you
- 3:48have this minimum you have to take out,
- 3:50right? So there's a downside to it, too.
- 3:52So, you know, really make sure you know
- 3:54your plans going forward. That's a
- 3:55really good point.
- 3:57All right, next question. What changes
- 3:59to RSP to RIFF rules are actually being
- 4:02proposed and would they change the
- 4:04reasons for drawing down an RSP earlier
- 4:06in retirement? So, this is in regards to
- 4:08the the budget 2026 that proposes to
- 4:11have an RRSP for life. So this idea that
- 4:13you'll no longer need to open a riff,
- 4:16transfer your account, think about the
- 4:18timing of when to do that and all of the
- 4:20the administrative and and logistical u
- 4:23you know nightmare for both people and
- 4:27institutions. So I think it's a great
- 4:29effort to simplify you know retirement
- 4:31accounts and the retirement process. Uh
- 4:34unfortunately there's not a ton of
- 4:36information just yet about how it's all
- 4:38going to work. there is a an open uh
- 4:40forum for for submitting uh feedback on
- 4:43the proposed changes open until January
- 4:458th next year. So hopefully once that's
- 4:48been digested and and reviewed, we'll
- 4:51have a better sense of the the finalized
- 4:53rules of how this will all work. You
- 4:56know, generally speaking, there's not
- 4:57major changes yet proposed. It's really
- 5:00mostly on the administrative side. So,
- 5:02not having to open a new account, you
- 5:04can now designate a uh a successor
- 5:08holder for the RRSP. So, there's a
- 5:10couple admin benefits, but no major
- 5:12changes to taxes, right? It's it's still
- 5:14going to have minimums starting at age
- 5:1672. Uh there's going to be no
- 5:18contributions at that point. You're
- 5:20going to have contributions be
- 5:22taxdeductible, withdrawals be taxable.
- 5:24So, like the the structure of combining
- 5:26an RRSP and RIFF is still going to
- 5:27behave very similarly. It's really the
- 5:30the middle ground that we're not yet
- 5:32sure about. And that's, you know, if if
- 5:34you think about RSPs and RIFFs today,
- 5:37they behave very differently between age
- 5:3965 and 71, right? If you withdraw from
- 5:42an RRSP any time between those ages,
- 5:45today there's likely a fee for
- 5:47withdrawing that money. There's, you
- 5:50know, u no pension splitting, no pension
- 5:52credit. Uh there's withholding taxes on
- 5:55the full amount. So, if you withdraw
- 5:58that same money from a RIFF, now you're
- 6:00getting uh no fee uh from my
- 6:03understanding everywhere. Um there's
- 6:05there's pension credit, there's pension
- 6:07splitting, there's no withholding tax on
- 6:09the minimum. So, kind of fundamentally
- 6:11different accounts and really the the
- 6:13what we want to learn next is what of
- 6:15those differences is going to be
- 6:17maintained with this new change. Um so,
- 6:21lots still unclear. Um, the last note
- 6:23that I'll I'll just mention is, you
- 6:25know, based off of the most likely
- 6:27scenario where they keep everything as
- 6:29is. It's not going to have a change to
- 6:31plans. Like what you've modeled so far
- 6:32in in your retirement plan is likely
- 6:35going to be the same case. U, but you
- 6:37might just have a much simpler time with
- 6:39it, right? You're not going to have to
- 6:40open a RIFF and transfer money from a
- 6:42RSP into a RIFF so that you can withdraw
- 6:44it from there and get the pension credit
- 6:46eligibility. It'll just be hopefully a
- 6:48lot simpler for everyone involved. Um
- 6:51that's kind of our our hopes. U yeah
- 6:54there's yeah there's there's certainly
- 6:56things that could change. It's possible
- 6:58that they take this this opportunity to
- 6:59also look at some of the um other
- 7:02discussions around pension uh income
- 7:05eligibility. Right. It would be nice if
- 7:07if we get an early earlier eligibility
- 7:09age from the RIFF or from the RSP for
- 7:12life. Now uh it's going to take a while
- 7:14to adjust to that.
- 7:14>> Yeah. To to align with the pension.
- 7:16Right. If you have a pension it's it's
- 7:18income split. Why not RSP? So
- 7:21>> yeah.
- 7:21>> Yeah.
- 7:22>> Yeah. That'd be big. Another thing a lot
- 7:24of our viewers have mentioned on, we'll
- 7:25cover this in a in a future podcast or
- 7:27video, but you know, streamlining the
- 7:29pension legislation. You know, in BC,
- 7:32you can't unlock any lera whereas other
- 7:34provinces 50 to 100%. So it's like, can
- 7:37we just make this the same across the
- 7:38board? Like why is it different in BC
- 7:40versus Ontario versus, you know, New
- 7:42Brunswick, etc. So um I think that's
- 7:44something else that they should be
- 7:46looking at over the next few budgets. So
- 7:49hopefully that's something down the
- 7:49pipeline as well. So I know often
- 7:51discussed amongst our peers but also uh
- 7:54clients have been commenting that a lot
- 7:56uh in the videos as well. All right,
- 7:58next question here. My income wedge has
- 8:00missed substantial market gains. Again,
- 8:03something we hear all the time. Uh how
- 8:05do I judge whether the protection i.e.
- 8:07having an income wedge is worth the loss
- 8:09growth and whether I'm holding too much?
- 8:12So we'll touch on this briefly. We're
- 8:15going to do a deep dive, Stephen and I,
- 8:16in on this question in our community.
- 8:19So, if you haven't joined our community
- 8:20yet, now is a great time to do that. Uh
- 8:23there's a link below. It's absolutely
- 8:24free. We've built a community. It's in a
- 8:26bit of a soft launch right now. And it's
- 8:29really a place to come talk about
- 8:30retirement and anything. It's it's
- 8:32people that are in retirement, you're
- 8:33close to retirement that just want to
- 8:34have a place to discuss and look at
- 8:36options. Our team jumps in there on a
- 8:38daily basis. We're putting some private
- 8:40content in there as well. Again, it's
- 8:41free to join today. So click that link
- 8:43below and we're going to have a deeper
- 8:45dive into this. But um from a high
- 8:48level, so my income wedge has missed
- 8:50substantial market gains. Yeah, you
- 8:52know, you're safe money in your
- 8:53investments earn less, right? And if you
- 8:56actually look at your investment
- 8:57philosophy going back, most of you are
- 9:008020, 7030, 6040. So if you're a 6040 uh
- 9:05portfolio, that means 40% of your money
- 9:06has been safe always, right? We're just
- 9:08saying allocate that now to your income
- 9:10wedge. just make sure it's in the right
- 9:12buckets so that when you need money and
- 9:14the markets are down, you're not selling
- 9:16things at a loss. So, you know, the the
- 9:18second part, how do I judge whether the
- 9:20protection is worth the loss growth? I
- 9:23would say, do you have loss growth here?
- 9:24Like, have you actually reduced your
- 9:26risk tolerance? Now, for some people,
- 9:27yeah, there were 100% equity going to
- 9:29retirement and they've had to scale
- 9:31back. But did you scale back just to
- 9:33build your income wedge or did you scale
- 9:35back because I have enough I don't need
- 9:36to get, you know, 15% return anymore and
- 9:39100% equity. I can actually take a
- 9:41little bit less risk. So I think you
- 9:42have to ask yourself like what were you
- 9:44doing before? What are you doing now?
- 9:45And has there been an actual shift?
- 9:47Because I think for 99% of people that's
- 9:50not the case. Um you know and are you
- 9:52holding too much? I would say most
- 9:55people uh if you look at the average
- 9:56plans that we do Stephen as a team you
- 9:59know the the draws 8 to 10%. Right? So
- 10:03let's say on average so if you're have a
- 10:05million bucks well if you want three
- 10:07years that's about 30%. So you're you
- 10:09could have a 7030 asset mix in
- 10:11retirement, have a proper income wedge,
- 10:14and probably carry on the same risk
- 10:16tolerance that you had pre-retirement.
- 10:17So I'll leave it at that. Let you jump
- 10:19in briefly, and then again, we'll cover
- 10:20more of this uh in the community.
- 10:23>> Yeah. So I agree. I I think it's
- 10:25important to to consider the the income
- 10:27wedge as part of your overall asset
- 10:29allocation. So for some people they
- 10:31might actually be earning a higher gross
- 10:33total return with the income wedge than
- 10:36they would have been without that that
- 10:38mindset in place. Right? If if you were
- 10:40planning to go into retirement with a
- 10:4160/40 portfolio because that's what you
- 10:43read online, then you know once you
- 10:46understand the income wedge and why you
- 10:48need a a fixed income portion of your
- 10:50portfolio and how to best structure that
- 10:53you might be comfortable at at your
- 10:55point 7030. And so you might actually be
- 10:57earning more total because of the income
- 10:59wedge than without it. And so you know
- 11:01there there's lots to consider. We'll
- 11:03dive in in much more detail in the
- 11:05community version. Uh and look forward
- 11:07to seeing you over there. All right. So
- 11:09in terms of our our next question we
- 11:11have uh can my TFSA serve as my entire
- 11:14retirement income wedge or should I hold
- 11:17protected investments in each account
- 11:19I'll withdraw from? So this is another
- 11:21very common question that we get related
- 11:23to the income wedge. You know, people
- 11:24will say, "I've got a bunch of GIC's and
- 11:26a high interest savings in my
- 11:27non-registered or in my TFSA, so I'm all
- 11:30set for my income wedge." And really,
- 11:32what we want to emphasize is those
- 11:35wedges should be within each individual
- 11:37account. So, if you're planning to
- 11:39withdraw from your registered account
- 11:42$50,000 for the next three years, you
- 11:44should have 150,000. If your target is 3
- 11:47years of a wedge, you should have
- 11:49150,000 in that RSP available for
- 11:51withdrawals. And the primary reason is
- 11:54so that your overall tax plan is not
- 11:57impacted by market circumstances. So
- 12:00going back to the idea of having
- 12:01everything in a TFSA, you have two
- 12:04choices in a year where the market is
- 12:07down. You can either take everything
- 12:08from your TFSA because that's where your
- 12:10income wedge is. That means that you're
- 12:12no longer melting down your registered
- 12:15account, right? So we've completely
- 12:16taken a year off of your your income tax
- 12:18plan. And that might mean instead of
- 12:20getting money out at 20% this year,
- 12:23you're waiting and taking that out at
- 12:2430% in future years. So we're we're
- 12:26losing 10% to taxes right there because
- 12:29we're taking the year off of our
- 12:30meltdown. And then the other option that
- 12:33you have is okay, I'm going to continue
- 12:35with my withdrawal strategy, but I'm
- 12:37going to sell in my registered account
- 12:38to do that. And so if you do that, now
- 12:42your registered account balance is is
- 12:45thrown off from what was projected,
- 12:46right? We're taking out in a down
- 12:47market. were eating up more of that that
- 12:50uh wealth than we had expected and now
- 12:53all the subsequent years are off. So you
- 12:55know there are ways that you can tinker
- 12:57but really the the best way to ensure
- 12:59that you stay as close to the projected
- 13:01plan as possible is if you keep those
- 13:03income wedge in each respective account
- 13:05where the withdrawals are being made.
- 13:07>> Yeah, exactly. And I think that goes,
- 13:09you know, off the last question too, a
- 13:11little bit of like you may not be taking
- 13:13less risk or or you might not be
- 13:15increasing your fixed income or quote
- 13:17unquote safer money in in your overall
- 13:19portfolio, but where it lies might look
- 13:21a little bit different, right? Like if
- 13:23you have a plan where you're not
- 13:25touching your TFSA for a decade, and
- 13:27that's that's often the case, but you
- 13:29want some flexibility in there just in
- 13:31case you have an emergency, etc. So you
- 13:32might say, "Well, I only need, you know,
- 13:34I have a $100,000 TFSA. I don't need any
- 13:37money, but I want some flexibility.
- 13:39Maybe5 or $10,000. Okay. Well, let's say
- 13:4110,000. So, you need 10%. So, you're 90%
- 13:44equity, 10% fixed income in there. So,
- 13:47it might be moving some fixed income,
- 13:48higher fixed income into the registered
- 13:50accounts at that point. So, again, not
- 13:52taking uh less or more risk necessarily.
- 13:55It's just reallocating that risk to a
- 13:57different uh bucket. But yeah, we we get
- 13:59this question a lot, right? It's like,
- 14:00oh, I got Yeah, I got my cash wedge
- 14:02under my mattress. It's like that's not
- 14:04the way it works. Like yes, from a cash
- 14:06flow perspective you're good, but from a
- 14:08tax planning perspective you're you're
- 14:11not. And I said all the time, retirement
- 14:14for most Canadians is the first time
- 14:15they actually can do proper tax
- 14:17planning. Like most Canadian other than
- 14:19an RRSP and a donation, most Canadians
- 14:22don't have a lot of tax flexibility. Uh
- 14:25when you hit retirement, there's a ton
- 14:26of it. And so having that income wedge
- 14:28is part of taking advantage of it and
- 14:31utilizing it and building it into your
- 14:33uh kind of your retirement plan
- 14:35financial plan there. So my RIF keeps
- 14:37growing despite my withdrawals. Should I
- 14:39withdraw more and accept some OAS
- 14:41clawback or leave the money invested and
- 14:44face a potentially larger tax bill
- 14:46later? And this is something we hear
- 14:48quite a bit especially the last maybe
- 14:50five years or so where markets have
- 14:52taken you know quite a run and maybe
- 14:53your plan was built at four, five, six%
- 14:56and you've been getting 8 n 10%. And
- 14:58yeah, the the accounts are actually
- 15:00growing more than you're drawing out of
- 15:02it. great problem to have. But yeah, it
- 15:04does become after a period of time and I
- 15:06talked about this last week on the
- 15:07podcast too of there there becomes a
- 15:09point where typically after three years
- 15:11like don't don't make huge adjustments
- 15:13based on one year like market went up
- 15:15one year I'm going to totally change my
- 15:16withdrawal strategy. Uh but when there's
- 15:19a trend like a three-year trend which
- 15:21maybe you bumped into now it's like hey
- 15:22the account's actually grown. it's
- 15:24becoming a bit of a tax issue then yeah
- 15:26it's really uh sitting down with your
- 15:29financial planner again get your plan
- 15:30updated to see does it make sense like
- 15:32one will point in the right direction
- 15:34right and this is where planning
- 15:35software and your planner can really
- 15:37help you through this does it make sense
- 15:39to pull more yeah I'm going to pay a bit
- 15:41more tax maybe lose a bit old day
- 15:42security but I'm in a better position
- 15:45plus you have more money potentially
- 15:46right like if you want to go spend a
- 15:47little bit more maybe you can spend a
- 15:49little bit more because markets have
- 15:51been good so I always say in situations
- 15:53ations like this, which a lot of people
- 15:54are in, sit down with your financial
- 15:56planner, get your plan updated, see
- 15:58where things are at, and see like you're
- 16:00kind of at this crossroads, right? You
- 16:01got to figure out there is a better path
- 16:03to go. Um, and the data in the plan will
- 16:06show you that. What are your thoughts,
- 16:07Stephen?
- 16:08>> Yeah, I agree entirely. I think the plan
- 16:10will ultimately be the judge of the best
- 16:12path in terms of general you know
- 16:14guidelines or or numbers that that you
- 16:16know our listeners can can consider is
- 16:19we typically do accelerated registered
- 16:21withdrawals in order to try and manage
- 16:24taxes paid later. Right? If if we leave
- 16:26them too long, it's going to create
- 16:28potentially OAS recovery or there might
- 16:30be a large estate bill or if one spouse
- 16:32passes and transfers it to the surviving
- 16:34spouse. Now with two combined registered
- 16:37accounts, it could create a bit of a tax
- 16:39mess. So we always want to look at can
- 16:41we get that money out earlier
- 16:43efficiently? And so if if you're already
- 16:45at a 40% marginal tax rate and then you
- 16:47add on top of that OAS recovery now on a
- 16:50on a net basis each additional dollar is
- 16:53coming out at you know 50% total cost.
- 16:56And so that's not necessarily better
- 16:57than than waiting until later, right?
- 16:59That's almost the same that you would
- 17:00pay in in an estate case. So it will
- 17:03come down to where's you know where are
- 17:05you at right now in terms of taxable
- 17:07money. uh what are you going to do with
- 17:08that money? To Adam's point, if you're
- 17:10going to spend it, then you know, that's
- 17:12great. Enjoy it. Take advantage of the
- 17:14higher market uh returns and go out and
- 17:16and enjoy your your retirement. If it's
- 17:19just going to come out and sit in a
- 17:20non-registered account, now that money's
- 17:22be going to be getting taxed every year,
- 17:24and the return isn't going to be as high
- 17:26as if it stays in the the registered
- 17:28account. So there are some key numbers
- 17:30that will determine what the best
- 17:32approach is, but ultimately will come
- 17:33down to updating the plan. And at the
- 17:35same time, not just looking at the the
- 17:37taxation on the registered account, but
- 17:39your broader goals, like to Adam's
- 17:41point, the the accounts are probably
- 17:42well above what they were originally
- 17:44projected to be. So do you want to do
- 17:45some more gifting? Do you want to
- 17:47increase your spending or or make other
- 17:49adjustments to the plan given your new
- 17:51circumstances?
- 17:52>> Yeah. No, great points.
- 17:55>> All right. uh my employer won't offer a
- 17:57lump sum payout of my defined benefit
- 18:00pension. What determines whether I can
- 18:02take the commuted value and can that
- 18:04option expire? So, this is in response
- 18:07to one of our recent videos where we
- 18:08talked about comparing commuted and uh
- 18:11defined benefit pension plans and you
- 18:13know some people might have been
- 18:14interested in the commuted option and
- 18:16and gone to look into it. That option
- 18:19almost always expires at age 55. So what
- 18:22happens with the pension uh legislation
- 18:24in Canada is that there's kind of two
- 18:26categories of of individuals. There's
- 18:29people that are pre-age 55. And so in
- 18:32that case, if you either go to retire or
- 18:35you leave your employer, you are
- 18:37typically offered the option of either
- 18:39waiting until you take your full pension
- 18:41or getting the commuted value, which is
- 18:43just a lump sum payout equivalent to
- 18:47what the pension would take to to
- 18:49provide that income in the future. So,
- 18:51if you're going to get 50,000 a year in
- 18:53retirement from your pension, you might
- 18:55be offered an $800,000
- 18:57uh commuted value today to provide that
- 19:00income. Again, that that goes off the
- 19:02table once you're 55 because then you
- 19:04fall into a new category within the
- 19:07legislation. And that is you're
- 19:08essentially a a retired individual. So,
- 19:11it's not necessarily that you're you're
- 19:13retiring. you might still be switching
- 19:15employers, but just from a legislation
- 19:17standpoint, um you're you're kind of
- 19:19falling under an a category where the
- 19:22money is meant to provide lifetime
- 19:24income. And so, at that point, the
- 19:25commuted value is off the table. So,
- 19:27it's not necessarily your employer
- 19:29that's, you know, just not not being
- 19:31flexible. It's that they they're not
- 19:33allowed to do it after a certain point.
- 19:36>> Yeah. And we've seen that with So, 55 is
- 19:38most common. We had a client not too
- 19:39long ago, a couple weeks ago now, um age
- 19:4250. So, she was coming up to age 50,
- 19:44wasn't sure if she should take her
- 19:45community value or not. Um but yeah,
- 19:47it's not really, you know, you may have
- 19:49a pension where you can't take the
- 19:51community value. Like, it's just that it
- 19:52is what it is. Um now, if you have the
- 19:54option to take community value, sit down
- 19:57with an independent financial planner,
- 19:59someone that's not going to manage the
- 20:00money for you because often times it's
- 20:02like, yeah, take your community value so
- 20:04I can manage a million dollars for you.
- 20:05you know, like there's a there
- 20:07potentially is a conflict of interest
- 20:09there. So, talk to someone, you know,
- 20:11independent that can run an apples to
- 20:13apples. Look, if you take your pension,
- 20:14here's what things look like, and you
- 20:16have to incorporate everything else in
- 20:18your plan. Like, that's a big piece of
- 20:19it, too. Um, we've done pension uh, you
- 20:23know, reviews of here's your pension,
- 20:24here's your cumulative value. One will
- 20:27look a lot better, but then when we
- 20:28incorporate the rest of their assets and
- 20:30you know, financial world into it, the
- 20:32game totally changes. So don't look at
- 20:34it like an apples to apples isn't
- 20:36commutive value versus pension what's
- 20:38going to give me more. It's actually
- 20:39layering everything else into it because
- 20:40there's again tax planning and structure
- 20:42and um you know you take your commutive
- 20:44value oftent times a lot of that is cash
- 20:47so it's a taxable position how much RSP
- 20:49room you have to add in everything else.
- 20:52So, um, just when you do a comparison,
- 20:54just be very aware of a who you're
- 20:56working with, but b make sure that it's
- 20:58everything else is built into each side
- 21:00of the plan as well to get a truly
- 21:02reflective should I take community value
- 21:04because obviously there's benefits and
- 21:06risks to both. So, you want to and it's,
- 21:08you know, for most people it's one of
- 21:10their biggest financial decisions you're
- 21:11going to make in their lifetime. Um, so
- 21:13make sure you you do it right because
- 21:14once you make that decision it's done.
- 21:17So, uh, big decision there. Uh, next
- 21:20question here. Uh, we're already retired
- 21:22and considering selling a rental
- 21:23property. Could using our remaining RRSP
- 21:26contribution room reduce the tax or
- 21:29simply create a bigger problem later?
- 21:31Um, yes and yes. So, yeah, if you have a
- 21:34rental property, um, you know, as long
- 21:36as you're uh not 72 or older, you're
- 21:39still in that window where you can
- 21:40contribute to an RRSP, then yeah, you
- 21:42could utilize your RSP. And, and often
- 21:44times that's part of our planning that
- 21:46we do. It's like, hey, you have this
- 21:47rental, you're going to sell it down the
- 21:48road. we actually want to keep a little
- 21:51bit of your RRSP room for down the road
- 21:53to kind of again it's all about leveling
- 21:55out how do we pay less tax. Leveling it
- 21:56out will help with that. Um so
- 21:58definitely you can use your RRSP room.
- 22:01Again if you're putting a bunch of money
- 22:02in RSP you have to pull it out at some
- 22:04point. But again if you're going to have
- 22:06if you're already retired likely a sale
- 22:08of a rental property is going to kind of
- 22:11blip your taxable income. So your
- 22:13taxable income is going to have this big
- 22:15blip. We want to get rid of that. So an
- 22:16RRSP and then leveling it out. you can
- 22:18then you get the tax break in one year
- 22:20and then level it out over many years
- 22:22going forward. Again, putting this into
- 22:24software, sitting down with your
- 22:25financial planner, very easy way to get
- 22:26the the pure answer on this, but
- 22:28definitely something to consider. Um,
- 22:31delaying old age security. I know we've
- 22:33touched on that a little bit through
- 22:34this podcast. We've had clients where
- 22:37they're coming up 65 and they know
- 22:39they're going to sell a rental property
- 22:40or have a taxable event in their life
- 22:43over the next few years. Delay your old
- 22:45age security. There's no point starting
- 22:46at 65, selling a rental property and
- 22:49ballooning your income and not get
- 22:50collecting OAS for a year and then
- 22:52getting it back again. So again, those
- 22:54are reasons why you might want to delay
- 22:55OAS. So there's there's these other
- 22:57factors here um that you're going to
- 22:59want to look at. Uh could it create a
- 23:00bigger problem later? Yeah, I mean if
- 23:02you have a very large RSP and then you
- 23:04make it bigger. Um it could create a
- 23:06problem, but Steve, I would say rarely.
- 23:08Like if you have this blip from a a
- 23:10rental property or or any type of event,
- 23:13it's going to make sense to put money in
- 23:14an RRSP because at least you're bringing
- 23:16that down and then smoothing it out over
- 23:18time. Plus, that money is growing tax
- 23:20deferred. So, if you're already maxed on
- 23:21TFSA, like where is that money going to
- 23:23sit in the meantime? A taxable account
- 23:25likely. So, there's a few layers to
- 23:26that.
- 23:27>> Yeah, absolutely. I think it would
- 23:29ultimately come down to how large the
- 23:31capital gain is, right? If it's 20,000,
- 23:33$30,000, there may not be a benefit to
- 23:36contributing to the RRSP because you
- 23:37might even be in the same marginal tax
- 23:39rate you wanted to be anyways. But if
- 23:41you're talking about a couple
- 23:42hundred,000, you know, we've seen some
- 23:45large real estate growth in Canada over
- 23:46the last decade. If if you're sitting on
- 23:48a $500,000 gain, that's certainly going
- 23:51to put you up into close to the top
- 23:53brackets in in most provinces and
- 23:54territories. So, at that point, you're
- 23:56getting say a 50% refund on the
- 23:59contribution. you know, you're going to
- 24:00be able to take that out at some point
- 24:02in the plan at a lower rate in most
- 24:05circumstances. So, it tends to make
- 24:07sense. One thing that I would note uh
- 24:09just around planning for a real estate
- 24:12sale is, you know, market conditions can
- 24:15impact your your desire and ability to
- 24:17sell. So, planning too firmly on a
- 24:20specific year to sell and and working
- 24:22around that. you know, if if the market
- 24:24is down, you may want to wait on that
- 24:25sale a couple years or, you know, you
- 24:27might get a great opportunity and do it
- 24:29a couple years earlier. So, it can be
- 24:30something difficult to plan explicitly
- 24:32around, but as long as you're not giving
- 24:35up too much by preparing for it. Uh, one
- 24:37example would be, you know, some people
- 24:39will wait in their final years of of
- 24:41retirement, hold on to RRSP contribution
- 24:44room with a plan of of using that when
- 24:46they when they sell the property, and
- 24:48there the difference might be a couple
- 24:50percent in taxes, right? if if you can
- 24:51get 35% refund while you're working
- 24:54versus 40% when you sell the property,
- 24:56taking that guaranteed refund now, might
- 24:59still be worth it. Um whereas if it's a
- 25:01large difference, again, 30,000 or 30%
- 25:04marginal tax versus 50, it might be
- 25:06worth waiting and and even taking the
- 25:08risk that you you delay the the sale
- 25:10because the thing to remember is that we
- 25:13can't contribute after you turn 72,
- 25:15after the year you turn 72. So if you're
- 25:17planning to sell it early retirement, um
- 25:20you may only have a couple years window
- 25:21where the market needs to agree with
- 25:23you.
- 25:24>> Yeah. Which is often around like people
- 25:26ask and we have rental properties is
- 25:28there a better worse time to sell it?
- 25:30Sometimes there is like you know you
- 25:32talk about market conditions can't
- 25:33control that but it's like if you're
- 25:34going to sell it yeah maybe before 7071
- 25:38actually makes sense and before you
- 25:40start your old age security and if you
- 25:41have RSP room like there's that's why
- 25:43you know people say well there can't be
- 25:45a better time than other actually can be
- 25:48right from a tax planning perspective
- 25:50obviously markets typically throw that
- 25:51out the window a little bit you know as
- 25:53we're in right now where does it make
- 25:54sense to sell a rental property now
- 25:57probably not in Canada um you know you
- 25:59might want to give it a or two to come
- 26:00back. Hopefully it does. But um from a
- 26:03timing wise, there can be better windows
- 26:05uh based on tax planning from, you know,
- 26:07fin from a financial planning mindset.
- 26:10>> Yeah, absolutely.
- 26:12Why would someone start OAS at 65 but
- 26:16delay CPP? When would delaying both make
- 26:19more sense? So, you know, this is a
- 26:21fairly common question that we get. You
- 26:23know, why not either start both early or
- 26:25delay both? And there are situations
- 26:27where it can make sense to start OAS at
- 26:2965 and delay CPP later. The the key
- 26:33consideration is that CPP has the higher
- 26:35deferral benefit. So if you're going to
- 26:37delay one or the other, typically it
- 26:39makes sense to delay CPP. And so if
- 26:42someone's on the fence about their cash
- 26:44flow situation, maybe they they
- 26:46understand the benefits of deferring
- 26:48their OAS and CPP, but they they have
- 26:50high go- go spending goals. And so if
- 26:53they delay all of their government
- 26:54benefits till 70, they're they're not
- 26:57going to have enough cash flow to to
- 26:58meet their needs. So that could be one
- 27:00reason to start OAS at 65 while still
- 27:03deferring CPP. You're just getting the
- 27:04highest bang for your buck on any
- 27:06deferrals that you are making. The the
- 27:08other situation could be if you know the
- 27:11there's a health consideration where
- 27:14they they understand the deferral
- 27:16benefit, but they want to kind of hedge
- 27:18a bit and so they're going to start one
- 27:19early. Again, you would typically look
- 27:21at at OAS. So, um, it can be certainly
- 27:25reasonable if you're going to start one,
- 27:27we we always say start your OAS and in
- 27:30terms of, you know, peace of mind that
- 27:32you're starting to get some cash flow
- 27:33into the projection, you're not delaying
- 27:35everything. That's when it can make
- 27:36sense to do one or the other. Otherwise,
- 27:38you know, a lot of the case, it it uh
- 27:40yeah, it tends to make sense to delay
- 27:41both. But curious on your thoughts,
- 27:43Adam.
- 27:44>> Yeah, financially makes sense for most
- 27:46people to delay both. Uh, oftentimes
- 27:48we'll put OAS starting at 65. more of a
- 27:51psychological thing, right? Especially
- 27:52people that are retiring earlier. Let's
- 27:54say you retire at 60 years old. Uh,
- 27:57financially, yeah, you could delay both
- 27:58till 70. Financially, makes the most
- 28:00sense. But what happens is like, okay,
- 28:02it's been 5 years. I'm I'm burning down
- 28:04my own money here, and I I could get
- 28:06this like, you know, air quote free
- 28:08government money that's sitting out
- 28:10there that I'm not collecting. And so,
- 28:12people get that itch, right? and and and
- 28:13this is just like experience and
- 28:15watching people live retirement where
- 28:16we're like yeah no delay CPP delay old
- 28:18age security and then they come back to
- 28:20us in 5 years they're like okay so I
- 28:22started CPP and I started old age
- 28:23security and I just I felt I needed that
- 28:25money it's like okay showing them like
- 28:27okay if you're going to start one old
- 28:29age security makes the most sense and
- 28:30again you can run with your planner like
- 28:32okay if I delay CPP till 70 o 65 or vice
- 28:36versa what is the difference so at least
- 28:38it's like if you get that psychological
- 28:40itch of like okay I just need to get
- 28:42money from the government um you know
- 28:44and you want to kind of throw the
- 28:45financial side out of the window then
- 28:48really understand understand the benefit
- 28:50and again uh OAS 65 uh is the smarter
- 28:54decision if you're going to start one
- 28:55earlier so you know that's why we run it
- 28:57a lot of the times in our plans and you
- 28:59know a lot of the scenarios I show on
- 29:02our YouTube videos uh educational videos
- 29:04is that right it's like okay o starts at
- 29:0665 CPP at 70 it's that psychological
- 29:09piece if I delay old age security as
- 29:11long as the client has enough other
- 29:12assets to draw down. It will give them
- 29:14more money, but that means five more
- 29:17years that they're not collecting that
- 29:18government benefit. And you know, we're
- 29:21humans at the end of the day and we get
- 29:23that itch. And you know, you don't want
- 29:24that itch to be costly. So
- 29:27>> yeah.
- 29:27>> Yeah.
- 29:28>> Absolutely.
- 29:29>> Beautiful. Well, let's jump into what we
- 29:30learned this week with John from our
- 29:32team. Welcome, John. Thanks for joining
- 29:34us today. Uh talking about withholding
- 29:36taxes. So maybe jump into that for
- 29:37retirees here.
- 29:39>> Yeah, thanks Adam. So yeah, today I
- 29:40wanted to just talk a little bit about
- 29:42accumulation plans and tax management on
- 29:44that. Um it's one thing to save and
- 29:47invest. Uh but when you're investing in
- 29:50your RRSP, you don't have withholding
- 29:51tax. So you don't often see this until
- 29:54you come into retirement. So um came
- 29:57across some situations where didn't see
- 29:58any withholding tax at source on
- 30:00government benefits or riff minimum
- 30:02payments. So I thought this was a a good
- 30:04topic to talk about here. There's a
- 30:06couple schools of thought when it comes
- 30:07to withholding tax and paying your taxes
- 30:09throughout the year. Um, some people
- 30:11like to get a large tax refund. Some
- 30:13people would prefer to have some tax
- 30:15owing. Um, and I remember back when I
- 30:17was in school, uh, the professor
- 30:19teaching this tax management course
- 30:20talked about just pay so that you have
- 30:23exactly zero owing at the end of the
- 30:25day. Um, you know, see, yeah, good luck
- 30:27with that, right? You can't get it
- 30:29exactly accurate, but CRA is not paying
- 30:31you interest on your on your deposits.
- 30:34uh nor are they investing on your
- 30:36behalf. So, the money is really better
- 30:37in your hands at the end of the day. Um
- 30:39but really when it comes down to
- 30:40withholding tax, uh you just look at
- 30:42your all of your taxable sources of
- 30:45income and the best way to do this is to
- 30:47run a plan. Uh we always talk about
- 30:50plans and the best things start with a
- 30:52good plan. So yeah, run a projection.
- 30:54Then you can see your taxable sources of
- 30:56income and the effective tax rate that
- 30:58you're going to be paying which is your
- 31:00average tax rate uh throughout the
- 31:02timeline. And I talk about timelines
- 31:04because we often look at RSP meltdown
- 31:06strategies. So, you know, there's a
- 31:08timeline on that on that uh that
- 31:10strategy. So, your your t your common
- 31:14sources of income that are going to be
- 31:15taxable are government benefits. So,
- 31:18you've got your Canada pension plan, old
- 31:20age security, you might have a private
- 31:21pension in a defined benefit pension
- 31:24plan, and then your standard kind of
- 31:26withdrawals from your investments on
- 31:28your registered accounts, which would be
- 31:29your RIFF and Lyft accounts. And so just
- 31:33kind of dialing that in on the
- 31:35withholding tax at source, getting it as
- 31:38close to that effective tax rate. So
- 31:40let's say for example, you've got about
- 31:4115% effective tax rate. I would suggest
- 31:45looking at all those taxable sources of
- 31:47income. So 15% at source on your
- 31:50government uh benefits like your CPP and
- 31:52OAS, 15% at source on your private
- 31:55pension, and 15% at source on those riff
- 31:58and lift uh payments. That way you know
- 32:01that you're kind of prepaying some tax
- 32:02throughout the years and and you you
- 32:05probably have a better uh like situation
- 32:08at the end when it comes to actually
- 32:10paying your tax. You're not getting hit
- 32:12with like oh now I owe like 10 grand at
- 32:14the end of the year. Uh cuz you didn't
- 32:16have
- 32:17>> Yeah. Yeah. if you don't have any
- 32:19withholding tax on those those RIFF
- 32:21minimums, those annual minimums, they
- 32:23can kind of uh it can just kind of hit
- 32:25you blindly where you just didn't
- 32:27realize that uh you should be paying
- 32:28some tax throughout the year.
- 32:30>> Yeah. Now, on non-registered accounts,
- 32:33it's a little different. You can't have
- 32:34tax withheld at source. So, what I'd
- 32:37recommend in that situation is you can
- 32:38actually lots of firms will allow you to
- 32:41run a report and see, you know, what's
- 32:43your projected income for the year and
- 32:45you can kind of see what's happening
- 32:47there from an interest income or the
- 32:48dividends or even a capital gain report
- 32:51to uh see what your realized income is.
- 32:54Um, various types of investments will
- 32:56have uh capital gains distributions. For
- 32:58example, if you hold like a mutual fund
- 33:01or or like a poolled fund, a ETF for
- 33:03example, some of these will do capital
- 33:05gain distribution. So, keep an eye on
- 33:07that and just, you know, when you're in
- 33:09the flow and have similar investments
- 33:11year-over-year that are producing
- 33:13income, you can kind of get a sense of
- 33:14what what's going to be going on there
- 33:16and then you can uh kind of plan your
- 33:19withholding tax at source uh
- 33:20accordingly.
- 33:22>> Yeah. Yeah. you may have a big capital
- 33:24gain, sold a stock or investment during
- 33:26the year, um, which you haven't paid tax
- 33:28on, which you may want to do before the
- 33:31end of the year so you don't fall into
- 33:32installments. There's also with
- 33:34withholding tax too, sometimes uh you
- 33:36might have, let's say a large uh portion
- 33:39of your income is coming from a riff and
- 33:41so yeah, you're not taxed or withholding
- 33:43taxes on the minimum, still taxable. Uh,
- 33:45and then you have more tax withheld on
- 33:47the rest than you actually owe for the
- 33:49year. um then you might want to take a
- 33:51look at your other you know your pension
- 33:53CPP old age security um to have no
- 33:56withholding tax right so there's I like
- 33:58the 15% like you said John but for a
- 34:00handful of people it's like well I'd
- 34:02love to do 15 but they're actually
- 34:03taking off more and I can't control that
- 34:06um then then adjust the ones that you
- 34:08can adjust again CPPOAS you can move
- 34:11from zero up to 100% essentially uh
- 34:14withheld at source so there is some
- 34:16flexibility there but yeah definitely
- 34:17for those with non-registered accounts
- 34:19It's a bit more year-end adjustment to
- 34:21make sure. One good piece of news is the
- 34:24budget 2026. We'll see if it actually
- 34:26goes through, but they're talking about
- 34:27making the threshold for installments
- 34:30from 3,000 up to 7500. And so, a lot of
- 34:34retirees, especially in the first couple
- 34:36years, they fall into installments
- 34:37because they owe more than 3,000 because
- 34:40they didn't have enough withholding tax.
- 34:41And this is why John brought it up
- 34:43today. It's really important. Like, we
- 34:44see this with every single client we
- 34:46have. This is one thing we do in
- 34:47January, February with every single
- 34:49client in our retirement income program
- 34:50is go through their withholding taxes to
- 34:53make sure that come tax time next year,
- 34:55we're as close to zero as possible. Um,
- 34:58but that 7,500 threshold will help a lot
- 35:00of especially retirees not fall into the
- 35:03uh the payment schedule.
- 35:05>> Yeah, there's a bit of a feeling out
- 35:07period when you get into retirement as
- 35:09well. Like your first year is a bit of a
- 35:11a wild card where you're just kind of
- 35:13figuring out your budget, withholding
- 35:14tax. you might have retired halfway
- 35:16through the year. So, you don't get a
- 35:17full year's experience of what this
- 35:19actual tax circumstance is going to be.
- 35:22So, probably by year three of
- 35:24retirement, you're going to have it
- 35:25pretty dialed in. And you can just kind
- 35:27of change things like it's not at the
- 35:28end of the day if you owe a little bit
- 35:29of tax or if you get a refund. But over
- 35:32the years, you can certainly refine the
- 35:34process and and really dial it in.
- 35:36>> Exactly. Yeah. Beautiful. Great points
- 35:39today, John. Thanks for joining us.
- 35:40>> Absolutely. Thanks, Adam. Take care. So,
- 35:43thanks for joining us in episode 63.
- 35:45Now, Steve and I are jumping into the
- 35:47third question, which is, "My income
- 35:48wedge has missed substantial market
- 35:50gains. How do I judge whether the
- 35:51protection is worth the loss growth and
- 35:53whether I'm holding too much?" We're
- 35:55going to jump into that in a longer
- 35:57answered video in our community. Link is
- 35:59below. It's absolutely free to join. So,
- 36:01go check that out. We'll see you in the
- 36:02next podcast. Thanks for joining us on
- 36:05this week's episode of Retirement
- 36:06Unpacked. If you found today's
- 36:08conversation helpful, don't forget to
- 36:10subscribe so you don't miss next week's
- 36:12episode. And remember, the ideas we talk
- 36:14about are general in nature. They may
- 36:17not fit your personal situation. Always
- 36:19consult a qualified financial planner
- 36:21before making decisions about your
- 36:23retirement. Take care and we'll see you
- 36:25next
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of If I was retiring in 2027 with an RRSP or LIRA, this is what I'd do (Ep 063) by Parallel Wealth, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,571 words across 1,065 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.