I Tried Every AI Video Generator - Full Tierlist — Transcript

Full transcript

1. 0:04Do you know anything about these?
2. 0:07>> Yes, I spent over 100k generating
3. 0:09videos.
4. 0:10>> What?
5. 0:13But this only says 10k. Where did you
6. 0:15get the rest?
7. 0:16>> From that nice Italian place across the
8. 0:18street. I said you'd pay them back.
9. 0:20>> You mean
10. 0:22the mafia?
11. 0:23>> Yes.
12. 0:30>> I told you we couldn't trust this robot.
13. 0:33Don't worry.
14. 0:34>> [music]
15. 0:34>> We just need to find Dan.
16. 0:39>> Dan!
17. 0:41>> Dan! Dan, where are you?
18. 0:44>> Hey, hey, hi Bruiser.
19. 0:46>> Hey, hello Tito.
20. 0:52>> You want to run?
21. 0:54>> No.
22. 0:56>> I need to get BACK TO THE OFFICE.
23. 1:08>> Are you being chased BY THE MAFIA OR
24. 1:09WHAT?
25. 1:10>> Don't say that, please.
26. 1:23>> Okay, I think I'm safe. Anyways, I might
27. 1:25as well show you the results.
28. 1:27>> We'll be comparing six of the most
29. 1:29popular AI video generators in an
30. 1:31eight-round head-to-head battle where
31. 1:33all of the videos have been generated
32. 1:34using the same prompt and references.
33. 1:37I'll be the one ranking this using a
34. 1:39tier list and by the end of it, you know
35. 1:41exactly which model is the best and
36. 1:43[music] why. But first, let's go over
37. 1:45contenders. Now, after judging some of
38. 1:47the videos myself on OpenArt Arena and
39. 1:49going through their leaderboard, I found
40. 1:52these following AI video models. We've
41. 1:54got One 3.0, Minimax A Stream Max, Flux
42. 1:58Tree, Gemini Omni, Kling 4.0 Flash, and
43. 2:01SeaDance 2.5. Now, you can use all of
44. 2:04these models inside of OpenArt, and if
45. 2:06you want to look up the leaderboard
46. 2:07yourself, I will leave a link to it in
47. 2:09the description down below. The rules
48. 2:11are that every video has to be 10
49. 2:13seconds long, generated in 16x9 aspect
50. 2:15ratio, and preferably in 1080p
51. 2:17resolution if they can do that. All
52. 2:19videos will be made using the same
53. 2:21prompt and the same references. And if a
54. 2:23video cannot be generated for any type
55. 2:25of reason, it will be automatically put
56. 2:28into D tier. If a feature is
57. 2:29unavailable, it will also be put into D
58. 2:31tier. I will judging based on the prompt
59. 2:33coherence, if the references were
60. 2:35accurate, if the physics makes sense, if
61. 2:37the character or the objects are
62. 2:38consistent, camera movement, image
63. 2:40quality, audio sync, style match the
64. 2:43prompt, like all of those things. Okay,
65. 2:44let's start with round number one. For
66. 2:47this, we're going to test out prompt
67. 2:48adherence with image references. This is
68. 2:51the prompt that we're using. You can
69. 2:53find all of the prompts that I've used
70. 2:54for this in the description down below,
71. 2:56so you can do this test yourself. The
72. 2:58idea is that I'm visiting an antique
73. 3:00shop, and I come out with a sword and a
74. 3:02helmet from that shop. We've got three
75. 3:04different image references. We're
76. 3:06looking for a faint reflection in the
77. 3:07window. We're looking for me wearing the
78. 3:10helmet with the visor raised, and my
79. 3:12mustache must be fully visible. I'm not
80. 3:14growing this for no reason. Then I want
81. 3:16to have consistency across all of these
82. 3:18five different shots, and the helmet and
83. 3:20the sword need to stay identical to the
84. 3:22references. Okay, let's start. We're
85. 3:24starting off with 1 3.0.
86. 3:36I'm surprised, like this is good. This
87. 3:38is really, really good. The consistency
88. 3:39is there. The reflection is good. The
89. 3:41object, like the helmet and the sword,
90. 3:43is there. It is consistent. I found this
91. 3:46shop a bit like too vague. What's
92. 3:50happening here? Like this this looks
93. 3:51weird. This looks strange. But I would
94. 3:53definitely put this in A tier. This is
95. 3:55really good. Then we have MiniMax.
96. 4:05>> [laughter]
97. 4:07>> Uh, it is not great. It's not the best.
98. 4:10It feels a bit plasticky. We have a
99. 4:12weird sword there. All of the sudden we
100. 4:14have an actual sword. Although it looks
101. 4:16cool, but I would say this is meh slash
102. 4:18decent. Maybe I put it in meh. Okay, now
103. 4:21we have a flux.
104. 4:34What was that at the end? Okay, let's go
105. 4:36over this. I love how we even have the
106. 4:38reflection of the cameraman. I think
107. 4:40this looks good. Like this to me looks
108. 4:42good. The movement looks good. Me having
109. 4:44the helmet on like an idiot. I love
110. 4:47that. I mean the mustache is there.
111. 4:48Doesn't quite look like me.
112. 4:51But I would prefer this over Minimax,
113. 4:53definitely. Okay, now we have Gemini
114. 4:55Omni 1.5 Unfortunately, Google doesn't
115. 4:58have any new model so far.
116. 5:07>> [laughter]
117. 5:10>> I'm not happy with this. Like we're two
118. 5:12doors almost the same. Then I walk out
119. 5:15with the helmet and the sword, but then
120. 5:17you still have the helmet and the sword
121. 5:18there. I'm tempted to put this in refund
122. 5:20my credits. Like I'll give it the
123. 5:22benefit of the doubt and putting it in
124. 5:24meh. Then we have Kling 4.0 flash. This
125. 5:27is not the full 4.0 model yet. This is
126. 5:29the flash model. But let's see what it
127. 5:31can do.
128. 5:42I mean the quality is quite good. I like
129. 5:44the quality here of me. Let me see, does
130. 5:45this stay consistent? Just the sword is
131. 5:47gone. It's good, decent. Like I prefer
132. 5:50one. Okay, lastly we got C dance 2.5.
133. 6:03>> I mean, this is good. Let me just watch
134. 6:04one more time. Ah, this is the best.
135. 6:06Like this this there's nothing that's
136. 6:08like that even the door makes sense the
137. 6:10way it opens. Like it's it's these small
138. 6:13things that you notice that makes
139. 6:16something look AI. So, I'm going to put
140. 6:18this in absolute cinema. I will tell you
141. 6:20why and what I mean by that. Like the
142. 6:21small things. Like for example, this
143. 6:23thing from Kling. To me,
144. 6:25>> [sighs and gasps]
145. 6:26>> the way that door opens doesn't make
146. 6:28sense. Like to me, the door handle
147. 6:30should be on the other side. And
148. 6:31SeaDANCE got those physics correct. Like
149. 6:34this this makes more sense. So, there we
150. 6:36have it. Round number one completed. So
151. 6:39far, SeaDANCE 2.5 takes the cake. Okay,
152. 6:42round number two. We're going to do a
153. 6:44UGC type video because so many people
154. 6:46are generating that. The goal is to make
155. 6:48a UGC selfie type of video of a young
156. 6:51woman that has been gifted an oversized
157. 6:53sky blue wool sweater. It is filmed on
158. 6:55an iPhone. It's 10 seconds long. We're
159. 6:57using two image references here. And on
160. 7:00the text of the sweater, it says, "I
161. 7:02love AI." I've added in a bit of
162. 7:04dialogue. So, we have her saying, "Okay,
163. 7:06look what I just got as a gift. I'm
164. 7:08obsessed. It's so soft. Look at the
165. 7:10knit. It's so cozy. And the best part, I
166. 7:12love AI." when she's like sharing how
167. 7:14that looks. Cool. Let's see what our
168. 7:16contenders can do with this prompt. Just
169. 7:18a side note, UGC videos usually are 9 by
170. 7:2016, but because we're on YouTube, I made
171. 7:23this 16 by 9.
172. 7:24>> Okay, look what I just got as a gift.
173. 7:27I'm obsessed. It's so soft. Look at the
174. 7:29knit. It's so cozy. And the best part,
175. 7:33I love AI.
176. 7:34>> Damn, that's good. That that camera
177. 7:36focus there. This one. This is so good.
178. 7:39I'm impressed. The physics are good. The
179. 7:42voice sounds good. The camera movement
180. 7:44is quite good. Maybe at the end this
181. 7:46zoom in could be edited. I might just
182. 7:48have to do it. Absolute cinema. Then we
183. 7:50have Mini Max H3.
184. 7:52>> Okay, look what I just got as a gift.
185. 7:54I'm obsessed. It's so soft. Look at the
186. 7:57knit. It's so cozy. And the best part,
187. 8:01I love AI.
188. 8:02>> Look, I I was about to say give me my
189. 8:04credits back, but like it it did
190. 8:06everything. It's just the look and feel
191. 8:08of it feels so plastic. Like if if you
192. 8:11use this for an ad, it wouldn't be good.
193. 8:13I'm going to put it in meh. Sound like a
194. 8:14sheep. Okay, Flux Tree. Oh, by the way,
195. 8:17if you have your character sheets and
196. 8:18you put them in Flux Tree, it is always
197. 8:20like this that it's going to put this as
198. 8:23one frame of it. It's super annoying.
199. 8:26>> Okay, look what I just got as a gift.
200. 8:28I'm obsessed. It's so soft. Look at the
201. 8:31knit. It's so cozy. And the best part? I
202. 8:34love AI.
203. 8:35>> The beginning felt really strong, felt
204. 8:36really good, but the the longer I look
205. 8:38at it, the weirder it gets. Let me just
206. 8:40watch this one more time with you. Wait,
207. 8:42pause right there. Wait, wait. What in
208. 8:43the Harry Potter thing is going on here?
209. 8:46How the hell is this thing like floating
210. 8:47there? Flux, man, what are you doing?
211. 8:49Who's holding this up? I love the
212. 8:50excitement. I love the different poses,
213. 8:53angles, and and that. Like this camera
214. 8:55focus pulls good. Here it feels weird
215. 8:57with her movement of her neck. Too far.
216. 9:00Nah. Refund me. Let's go Gemini.
217. 9:03>> Okay, look what I just got as a gift.
218. 9:05I'm obsessed. It's so soft. Look at the
219. 9:07knit. It's so cozy. And the best part?
220. 9:11I love AI.
221. 9:13>> I mean, Flux did the same. I I didn't
222. 9:15point it out, but when you put in UGC
223. 9:17filmed on iPhone, then it's putting an
224. 9:19iPhone in the screen. Like that's super
225. 9:21annoying. But what's going on here with
226. 9:22the former thing? We have 9 by 16, then
227. 9:25we have 16 by 9, then we go back to 9 by
228. 9:2716. To be honest, like the video is
229. 9:29good. Where's her head, by the way? I'm
230. 9:31going to put this in Ah, I mean, like
231. 9:33this to me like this is unusable because
232. 9:35I would have to regenerate this. Like I
233. 9:37wouldn't use this. So, I'm going to put
234. 9:38this in refund my credits, please. Next
235. 9:40up, Cling.
236. 9:41>> Okay, look what I just got as a gift.
237. 9:43I'm obsessed. It's so soft. Look at the
238. 9:45knit. It's so cozy. And the best part?
239. 9:50I love AI.
240. 9:51>> It works. It It just feels like a tiny
241. 9:54bit AI. Like it it doesn't feel
242. 9:56completely organic, but I must say the
243. 9:58accuracy on on her is really good. Let
244. 10:01me just watch it one more time. Where's
245. 10:03her head, by the way? This focus pulls
246. 10:04really good. Physics here good. Just
247. 10:07feels like it needs a a bit more grain
248. 10:09to it to make this more believable, but
249. 10:11I I would say this is decent. Okay, next
250. 10:13up we got Seedance.
251. 10:16>> Okay, look what I just got as a gift.
252. 10:17I'm obsessed. It's so soft. Look at the
253. 10:20knit. It's so cozy.
254. 10:23And the best part? I love AI.
255. 10:25>> I'm a bit confused. It It looks good,
256. 10:27but is this our character? It didn't get
257. 10:29the belt right or whatever you might
258. 10:32call this. The jeans look like that that
259. 10:34make the jeans look slightly different,
260. 10:36too. Don't get why it's like the fish
261. 10:37islands. I might put this in in decent,
262. 10:40too. It's not overly excited about this
263. 10:43one. One was definitely the best on this
264. 10:45one. Let's go over to the next round,
265. 10:47which is lip sync. This time I have
266. 10:50these two references of me and my boy
267. 10:53Bruiser. We are having an intense
268. 10:55standoff. I've also added in an audio
269. 10:57file with the dialogue. Most of these
270. 11:00models could have an audio input, except
271. 11:03for Gemini only. But, we're still going
272. 11:05to review it because I still managed to
273. 11:07make the video, but dialogue will be
274. 11:09different here. Okay, let's start with
275. 11:11One 3.0.
276. 11:12>> You know exactly who I am. Say my name.
277. 11:15>> The AI guy who says this changes
278. 11:18everything every week?
279. 11:20>> You're goddamn right.
280. 11:22>> I mean, this is really good. Like, this
281. 11:23is quite good. I I just don't like that
282. 11:25the hand gestures of Bruiser. Like, it
283. 11:28should have been like like this. Also, I
284. 11:30feel like the voice doesn't really feel
285. 11:31baked in there. It feels like put on top
286. 11:33of it. I'm going to put this in really
287. 11:35good because I think that's it. Now,
288. 11:37let's go with Minimax.
289. 11:39>> Do you know who I am?
290. 11:41Say my name.
291. 11:42>> The AI guy who says this changes
292. 11:45everything every week?
293. 11:47>> You're goddamn right.
294. 11:49>> Wait, what what am I saying in the
295. 11:50beginning here? You knew who you I'm I'm
296. 11:52I'm like stumbling. Like, I mean, I know
297. 11:54I'm not natively English, but like I
298. 11:56don't sound like that, I hope. I would
299. 11:58regenerate this. Like, I I put this in
300. 12:00meh. Now, let's go with Flux. For Flux
301. 12:03and Gemini, it didn't work with the
302. 12:05audio reference. So, Flux doesn't have
303. 12:07native audio.
304. 12:08>> You know exactly who I am. Say my name.
305. 12:13>> The AI guy who says, "This changes
306. 12:15everything every week."
307. 12:17>> You're goddamn right.
308. 12:18>> This just bad. Like it also didn't get
309. 12:20my audio. Going to re-ask for a refund
310. 12:22on this. No, Gemini, keep in mind, not
311. 12:24my own audio.
312. 12:26>> You know exactly who I am. Say my name.
313. 12:29>> The AI guy who says, "This changes
314. 12:32everything every week."
315. 12:34>> You're goddamn right.
316. 12:36>> It took the length from the character
317. 12:37sheet and then baked it into the frame.
318. 12:39Sorry, Google. Refund my credits,
319. 12:41please. Then we have Kling.
320. 12:43>> You know exactly who I am.
321. 12:46Say my name.
322. 12:48>> The AI guy who says, "This changes
323. 12:51everything every week."
324. 12:53>> You're god
325. 12:53>> What the hell is happening with Kling
326. 12:544.0 flash? Is this the reason why
327. 12:57they're gatekeeping this model yet? What
328. 12:59the hell is this? Let me ask for a
329. 13:01refund there. Like where where the hell
330. 13:02is the lip sync? It's not just your
331. 13:04audio. Like I'm hearing this like a live
332. 13:06trout speaker. Like it's We cannot use
333. 13:08that. Lastly, we have Seedance.
334. 13:10>> You know exactly who I am. Say my name.
335. 13:13>> The AI guy who says, "This changes
336. 13:16everything every week."
337. 13:18>> You're goddamn right.
338. 13:20>> Okay, that's good. That that is really
339. 13:22really good. Like this is the model that
340. 13:24I use in all my intros. Like I'm not
341. 13:26trying to be biased here, but come on.
342. 13:28Like nothing beats this. The only thing
343. 13:29I would say you might want to regenerate
344. 13:31is the the this one with Bruiser. But
345. 13:34the audio feels insanely well. Like the
346. 13:36audio feels really good. It feels better
347. 13:38than once. So, I'm going to put this in
348. 13:40absolute cinema. Moving on to round
349. 13:42number four. We're going to do text to
350. 13:44video here. No references, just a
351. 13:46prompt. This will be the prompt that we
352. 13:48will be using. What I put in there is
353. 13:51raw found footage. It's a film video,
354. 13:53Jackass energy. Like that's super
355. 13:55important here. The video is about a
356. 13:56tough-looking rapper that's building a
357. 13:58house of cards in a speeding minivan. It
358. 14:00hits a speed bump and the cards collapse
359. 14:03and he's devastated. Before I play it, a
360. 14:05few details that I added in there. He
361. 14:07should have a tattoo on his forehead
362. 14:09that reads exactly, "I love House of
363. 14:11Cards." He should have heavy gold and
364. 14:14diamond chain with a large AI pendant.
365. 14:16The minivan needs to be speeding. We see
366. 14:18trees, fences, and parked cars like
367. 14:20striking past the windows, and then
368. 14:22everything stays upright until we have
369. 14:25the bump. And now we're just going to
370. 14:26look for natural shot. Let's start with
371. 14:29one 3.0.
372. 14:37>> [laughter]
373. 14:40>> Yeah, this ain't it. This is not good.
374. 14:42My love house of cards, that doesn't
375. 14:44make sense. The bump also like it feels
376. 14:46the response is too slow where it gets
377. 14:48to like this like the the the editing is
378. 14:50too slow. This is a meh for me. Then we
379. 14:53have Minimax.
380. 14:59>> [laughter]
381. 15:04>> I mean it looked good like it looked
382. 15:06decent up until the cars actually like
383. 15:09stopping. Like why the hell are we
384. 15:10stopping car? Like what's going on? If I
385. 15:13were to regenerate just that scene, it
386. 15:15would be savable because I do like the
387. 15:17rest of it, but it's still not that
388. 15:19great. I might have to regenerate this
389. 15:21so I want a refund. Then we have flux
390. 15:243.0.
391. 15:32>> [laughter]
392. 15:34>> Why does it sound like the cars are
393. 15:36exploding?
394. 15:38I mean it's good house of cards. The the
395. 15:40physics of the car going over the speed
396. 15:42bump don't make that much sense. I
397. 15:44honestly expected better of flux here.
398. 15:47I'm going to put this in in refunds to
399. 15:49be honest. Then we have Gemini.
400. 15:57>> [laughter]
401. 16:01>> What's going on with like all of the
402. 16:03recording? Like iPhone here, iPhone
403. 16:06here. The physics are are better though.
404. 16:09I love house of cards.
405. 16:11This is still like maybe this test was
406. 16:13too hard like still for this test. Like
407. 16:15I need a refund like I won't be happy
408. 16:17with this. Now, Kling.
409. 16:25>> [laughter]
410. 16:28>> Wow. Technically, it's a stack of cards,
411. 16:30house of cards. That physique looked
412. 16:32good though. I don't like the way it's
413. 16:34printed on his forehead, the aisle of
414. 16:36cards, but I might put this in
415. 16:38Leslie Sidens.
416. 16:49Feels like that's the only one that can
417. 16:51do this. This feels really good. Still
418. 16:54not too happy with this. That's why I
419. 16:56often use like image to video reference
420. 16:58to video because as you see like like
421. 17:00what's going on with these gangsters,
422. 17:02like they don't look great. Let's
423. 17:04continue straight to the next test. For
424. 17:05this test, we're going to do video to
425. 17:07video. What we're going to do is we're
426. 17:09going to take this video that we have
427. 17:11right here, and we're going to change it
428. 17:12to me in pink boxing gear, and Bruiser
429. 17:15as the punching bag. I will also be
430. 17:17changing the gym into a garage, and I
431. 17:20want the punches and the movements to
432. 17:22stay the same because I think the
433. 17:24reference video is quite good. We're
434. 17:26going to start with 1 3.0.
435. 17:35>> [snorts]
436. 17:37>> It's quite good. Feels tiny bit
437. 17:39plasticky, but it's it's decent, I would
438. 17:41say. Then we have MiniMax H3.
439. 17:54I mean, the garage looks better than 1
440. 17:55on was given that, but that the sound,
441. 17:57like I hear the sound, like didn't
442. 17:59match. Like there's one punch after that
443. 18:01that I didn't throw, but you still hear
444. 18:03the sound. It's okay. It's
445. 18:05going to give it to decent as as like at
446. 18:08least that location all right. Still the
447. 18:10style, I it's okay-ish. Then we have
448. 18:13Gemini, and Gemini only flash used to be
449. 18:16the best for this.
450. 18:27>> What the hell is this dude? Like why do
451. 18:28we have the original dude? Sorry Google,
452. 18:30I want a refund. Then Flux couldn't
453. 18:32generate this because it doesn't do
454. 18:34video-to-video, so it's automatically in
455. 18:36D tier. Then we have Kling.
456. 18:48Wait, what the hell is that music? Upon
457. 18:50seeing 1 again, I'm actually going to
458. 18:52put 1 in really good. Kling, going to
459. 18:54put you in decent. SeaDance, let's see.
460. 19:06I mean it did the movement really well.
461. 19:08I just don't know what's going on with
462. 19:10my face. Like it it struggled to keep
463. 19:12the side angle of my face. Might also
464. 19:14have to do with the reference that I
465. 19:15don't have a side reference of what my
466. 19:17face looks like. But the movement I
467. 19:19think it is the best one. Let me see if
468. 19:20I want to make some changes to these
469. 19:22ones. From checking all of them again,
470. 19:24I'm going to keep it like this. I think
471. 19:26both SeaDance and 1 are like our similar
472. 19:28category. Both MiniMax and Kling are
473. 19:30decent and and Gemini and Flux need a
474. 19:33refund. Let's move on to the next round.
475. 19:35Round number six. Here we're going to
476. 19:37test which one is best for making
477. 19:39cinematic or realistic looking videos.
478. 19:41We're going to try and generate a
479. 19:42realistic looking scene with references
480. 19:45in it. We will have a woman that is
481. 19:46smelling a puppy and then she's running
482. 19:49through a sunlit field of flowers in
483. 19:51slow motion. We have close-ups, tracking
484. 19:53shots, and a wide ending. There's no
485. 19:55dialogue, so let's take a look. We're
486. 19:57starting off with 1 3.0.
487. 20:09It's okay, but it's like slow motion.
488. 20:11This part is good, but then here's where
489. 20:13to me it gets strange. Going to put this
490. 20:15in decent. Then we have MiniMax.
491. 20:27>> The slow motion there was really good.
492. 20:29Still has a bit of a plastic feel to it,
493. 20:31but I like this part. I like this. This
494. 20:33shot looks really cool. That one is bad
495. 20:36like that shot after. Would be usable. I
496. 20:38wouldn't put this lower than one. Like
497. 20:40maybe maybe even higher, but let's see
498. 20:42the rest first. Then we have Flux. I
499. 20:44hate how Flux hasn't fixed this yet.
500. 20:56Didn't start off that strong. Wait, let
501. 20:57me watch this again. That's good. That's
502. 20:59good. The running is is interesting way
503. 21:03to run. That's a good shot. It's an
504. 21:05interesting angle. This is a tough one.
505. 21:07This is a really really tough one. Like
506. 21:09I would also say this is decent. Now
507. 21:11let's go over to Gemini.
508. 21:22You know what it is with with Google? I
509. 21:24feel like they have the potential to
510. 21:26make amazing videos. They just don't
511. 21:28want to. They I feel like they might
512. 21:31have really really good stuff. Like like
513. 21:33logic to their video. Like it it all
514. 21:35makes sense that they understand like
515. 21:37what looks good. It's just that they
516. 21:38choose not to cuz it will be used for I
517. 21:41don't know something wrong. In terms of
518. 21:42like the video, like this opening shot
519. 21:45is good. This shot is good I guess. It
520. 21:46feels a tiny bit AI-ish. It's between
521. 21:49meh and decent for me. Then let's go
522. 21:52with Kling.
523. 22:03Where else she going? Kling 4.0 flash is
524. 22:05not the vibe yet. I don't know like I
525. 22:07don't know if I got scammed or what the
526. 22:09hell is going on with Kling 4.0. Like
527. 22:12maybe 3.0 is even better. Like maybe
528. 22:13it's because it's flash. I don't know
529. 22:15what this is. This is refund. We're
530. 22:18going to end it off with C Dance.
531. 22:29>> This would be the strongest in my
532. 22:31opinion. The only thing, if I have to be
533. 22:33like an annoying dude, which I'm a
534. 22:35judge, so I can be that. It's like the
535. 22:37consistency in the field of flowers.
536. 22:40Like when it's going with the hands
537. 22:42through the flowers, we only see this
538. 22:44basic like white flower, but not the
539. 22:45other type of flowers. Like where are
540. 22:47the Where's the rest? Like here we have
541. 22:48all the others. That would like maybe
542. 22:51break it, but in terms of physics,
543. 22:53cinematic style, she has five fingers,
544. 22:55just checking. Yeah, this one is really
545. 22:57good. Still not perfect.
546. 22:58>> We'll be going over test number seven,
547. 23:00which is making an animation. I'm not
548. 23:03using any references here, but within
549. 23:05the prompt, I basically want to have a
550. 23:07black cat with green eyes and a small
551. 23:10yellow duck. And the duck is sitting on
552. 23:12a pink inflatable flamingo in the pool.
553. 23:15It should be one continuous take, so
554. 23:17let's take a look.
555. 23:27>> It is quite good. Just the the just the
556. 23:30physics of of when the cat puts his nail
557. 23:33in the flamingo, like it's looks like
558. 23:35it's stuck in there. Like the the style
559. 23:37looks really good. I really love the
560. 23:39animation style. It's just this physics
561. 23:41here. It's a bit strange. This one is
562. 23:43good. It's between really good and
563. 23:45decent. Like yeah, maybe I'll put it in
564. 23:47these for now. Let's see what the rest
565. 23:48has and then based on that we will
566. 23:50compare it.
567. 24:01It looked really impressive to start
568. 24:03with. Like up until here. Like this is
569. 24:05really really good. Like up until here,
570. 24:07this is really good. And then this, but
571. 24:10then what happened at that splash? Still
572. 24:12quite like it. Undecided between decent
573. 24:14and really good. Next up, Flux.
574. 24:26Physics were quite good there. Like in
575. 24:28terms of how it deflates. Like this is
576. 24:30quite good. The way it falls into the
577. 24:33water is is better than Mini Max and
578. 24:36Mona, I would say. It's just this part
579. 24:38where the duck starts flying and then
580. 24:41puts his hand on the head of the cat. I
581. 24:43might have to do some readjusting. I'm
582. 24:45going to put it in decent for now. Let's
583. 24:47go Gemini.
584. 24:54>> [screaming]
585. 24:58>> Gemini is just taking the piss again.
586. 25:00Like the style is really good. The
587. 25:01physics in the beginning look really
588. 25:03good, but then I said like blowing like
589. 25:05on the duck and then how it's going into
590. 25:08the water. Ah, Gemini, man. Meh. Let's
591. 25:11go with Kling.
592. 25:22Kling this is quite good. This in terms
593. 25:23of physics is quite good. I I might not
594. 25:26like the animation style that much, but
595. 25:28audio is also really strange, but
596. 25:29physics here you guys probably will give
597. 25:31me hate for this, but this is not like I
598. 25:34think this is better than some of the
599. 25:35other ones, like more usable in the
600. 25:37case. See dance.
601. 25:48Quite like this. Feels like all of them
602. 25:50struggle to get the water right. I mean,
603. 25:52this would be usable. Is it absolute
604. 25:54cinema? Not sure. Is it really good?
605. 25:57Yes, yes, it would be, yeah. Okay, put
606. 25:59my second opinion. I'm actually going to
607. 26:00put Gemini in as a refund and Flux in
608. 26:03meh. All right, let's go to the next
609. 26:05one. This will be our last test. For
610. 26:07this one, we're going to do motion
611. 26:09graphics. I will do a text-to-video
612. 26:11typography type animation with bold text
613. 26:15and movement and like five different
614. 26:17layouts. I've described it in a detailed
615. 26:20prompt. You can see my entire prompt.
616. 26:22Basically, I'm going to animate the
617. 26:24following text. We have five short
618. 26:26phrases which will be look closer, think
619. 26:28bigger, make a difference, more ideas,
620. 26:30and create without limits. All text
621. 26:33needs to be large and bold. We have one
622. 26:35continuous virtual camera journey with
623. 26:37no hard cuts. We have one small
624. 26:39illustrated eye, a flat white almond,
625. 26:42and a solid black dot that is appearing
626. 26:44in the middle of the final O. First O
627. 26:46stays an ordinary letter. We won't have
628. 26:49no speech or narration. Let's take a
629. 26:51look how good this is. We'll start off
630. 26:53with one 3.0.
631. 27:05Quite good upon like first impression,
632. 27:07but let's watch it again because I think
633. 27:09I spotted like a small error. Now, for
634. 27:11make a difference, it feels like it
635. 27:14tries and thinks that it needs to make
636. 27:15it bigger, but the idea was that it's
637. 27:17like one hand pulls it into a different
638. 27:19direction. Like each pulls it in a
639. 27:21different direction. Would be useful.
640. 27:23Like it this would be decent. Next, we
641. 27:26go with Minimax.
642. 27:30>> [music]
643. 27:37>> That's sick. This is really, really
644. 27:39good. Like this is There's no errors in
645. 27:41this. This is what I think people don't
646. 27:43know AI's capable of doing. Like you can
647. 27:45make these type of motion graphics.
648. 27:47Absolute cinema. Next, Flux.
649. 27:59This is good. This is really good. It's
650. 28:01not that special, but it's I would put
651. 28:03it in between really good and decent.
652. 28:05Let's go Gemini.
653. 28:11>> [music]
654. 28:15>> It's really good. I'm impressed. Now, we
655. 28:17go with Kling.
656. 28:28What is the audio? Like like my brain
657. 28:30hurts from listening to this. What's
658. 28:32going on here? Like why is this What is
659. 28:35What is What is it writing here? I'm
660. 28:36going to put this straight into meh.
661. 28:38Dance C Dance?
662. 28:49It looks cool, but it is not that great,
663. 28:52I would say. Maybe I'll put this in
664. 28:53decent. Also, I don't think it has done
665. 28:56this right. Think closer, like that was
666. 28:58not the text. Was Think Bigger. Look
667. 29:00Closer, Think Bigger. Make it Oh, now it
668. 29:02goes Think Bigger. Make a Difference,
669. 29:04More Ideas, Create Without Limits, yeah.
670. 29:07Decent, I would say, yeah. All right, so
671. 29:09those were the eight different rounds of
672. 29:12tests that we're doing. Let's go over to
673. 29:14the final standings. Based upon the
674. 29:16ranking system that we applied, we got
675. 29:18on the last place Gemini. Gemini
676. 29:22outdated, we need a new model, man.
677. 29:23Then, place number five, we got Flux
678. 29:26Tree. It's done a little bit better than
679. 29:28Gemini. It has some use cases, I would
680. 29:30say. Better Okay, yeah, it's not great.
681. 29:32Then, place number four, which surprises
682. 29:34me, is Kling 4 Flash. I'm hoping the
683. 29:38real version of Kling is actually better
684. 29:39than this, because the Flash version
685. 29:41This ain't it. Like, I don't know if
686. 29:43this is not optimized for prompting, if
687. 29:45if I'm doing anything wrong, but yeah,
688. 29:47this is This is unfortunate. Then,
689. 29:49number three, we have Minimax. Quite
690. 29:52good. It did quite decent, like overall.
691. 29:54It didn't do the worst, like it did It
692. 29:56was like an average decent type of tool.
693. 29:59Really good at motion graphics, though.
694. 30:01Then, place number two, can I get a drum
695. 30:03roll?
696. 30:041 3 This one really surprised me. Like,
697. 30:071 is actually quite good, especially for
698. 30:10UGC type videos, it was doing really
699. 30:11well. And for some of the other tests,
700. 30:13it also came into like the A and B tier.
701. 30:16Then, number one, which is only by four
702. 30:19points, is C Dance 2.5. I did expect C
703. 30:22Dance 2.5 to win. I did think the the
704. 30:25difference would be bigger, but this
705. 30:27goes to tell that for some type of
706. 30:29generation that you do, you might
707. 30:30actually want to experiment with using
708. 30:32different models. Interestingly, if I
709. 30:34compare this to OpenArt Arena, we also
710. 30:36can see that Cinians 2.5 came out on
711. 30:38top. Then second came one. I didn't
712. 30:40include Cinians 2.0 into this test, but
713. 30:42Cinians 2.0 still a valid tool. I don't
714. 30:45know who rated Google only flash in
715. 30:47here. I I disagree. Like I don't see
716. 30:49only as that great. But the other
717. 30:52interesting thing here is that in terms
718. 30:53of price, like one 3.0 might actually be
719. 30:56one of the best tools you could use for
720. 30:58the value that you get for the price.
721. 31:00Let me know in the comments what your
722. 31:01ranking was, which one you liked the
723. 31:03most. And also, if you want to try out
724. 31:05all of these tools yourself, I will
725. 31:06leave a link in the description down
726. 31:08below. Make sure to click the video
727. 31:09that's on the screen right now if you
728. 31:11want to learn how you can make AI
729. 31:12cartoon type videos.