I Tested Dollar Cost Averaging vs Buying the Dip for 30 Years — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00You probably heard it hundreds of times.
- 0:03>> Buy the dip.
- 0:04>> Buy the dip. We are in buy the dip
- 0:05country.
- 0:06>> Buy the dip. It's probably the most
- 0:09repeated advice in investing, at least
- 0:12on the internet. So, I tested it against
- 0:16the most boring strategy there is,
- 0:19dollar cost [music] averaging. But,
- 0:22since I don't want this video to be
- 0:24boring, let me introduce you to my
- 0:27friends.
- 0:28>> Hi, my name is Warren.
- 0:30>> And my name is Charlie.
- 0:33>> It's January 1996, and we decided to
- 0:37invest $6,000 every year for the next 30
- 0:42years.
- 0:43>> We will invest in the S&P 500 index
- 0:47only.
- 0:48>> But, the strategies are going to be
- 0:52different.
- 0:53>> I will buy $500
- 0:56of that ETF every single month, no
- 1:00matter what.
- 1:01>> And I will wait and buy only when the
- 1:05market drops at least 10%. That is,
- 1:10buying the dip.
- 1:11>> And after 30 years, you will see my
- 1:15strategy
- 1:17crush
- 1:19>> [music]
- 1:20>> Warren and Charlie are my old friends.
- 1:22Any similarity to two famous investors
- 1:26from Omaha is
- 1:27>> [music]
- 1:27>> pure coincidence. The race starts on the
- 1:31first trading day of 1996.
- 1:35Charlie buys $500 of shares at $62,
- 1:41then in February at $64,
- 1:45March at $65.
- 1:48Warren
- 1:49waits. And he keeps waiting, because in
- 1:521996,
- 1:54there is no 10% dip, not one. The market
- 1:59climbs almost 19% that year and Warren's
- 2:03$6,000
- 2:04sits in cash the whole time. By the end
- 2:08of the year, Charlie has $6,721.
- 2:13Warren has exactly 6,000.
- 2:17Charlie is 12% ahead and Warren hasn't
- 2:21made a single move. In January 1997,
- 2:26Warren gets another $6,000
- 2:29and he's holding 12,000.
- 2:32And the market keeps going up. Then
- 2:36finally, April 11th, 1997.
- 2:40The market closes 10.4%
- 2:43below its high. Warren puts in all
- 2:48$73.
- 2:52He waited 15 months for a discount and
- 2:57the discount price is 18% higher
- 3:01than the price on the day he started.
- 3:05So, after round one, it looks like the
- 3:08race is over before it began.
- 3:12It isn't.
- 3:14>> [music]
- 3:15>> Here is what Warren's rule does well.
- 3:18Charlie spends 1997 buying a little
- 3:23every month while prices climb.
- 3:26His average price that year is almost
- 3:29$86.
- 3:31Warren got all of his money in at $73.
- 3:3610 weeks later in June 1997,
- 3:40Warren takes the lead.
- 3:43And he keeps it. In 1998, the market
- 3:47drops in August and Warren buys at $106.
- 3:53Charlie's average for the year, $107.
- 3:57In 1999,
- 3:59Warren buys at 127.
- 4:02Charlie pays $131.
- 4:05In 2000, 3 weeks after the dot-com peak,
- 4:09Warren buys at $136.
- 4:13Charlie pays $144.
- 4:17Four years, four dips, four times Warren
- 4:22gets the better price. By early 2001,
- 4:26his lead is almost $1,300.
- 4:30That's 2.6%.
- 4:34Not huge, but he has been in front for
- 4:37more than 3 and 1/2 years, and his
- 4:39strategy is working exactly as
- 4:42advertised.
- 4:44If we were Charlie right now, we would
- 4:47be asking ourselves some questions.
- 4:50>> I don't have time for such nonsense. I
- 4:53got 16 books to finish before my bridge
- 4:56game this evening.
- 4:58>> Yeah, just give up already.
- 5:03>> [music]
- 5:05>> Then the dot-com crash really gets
- 5:08going, and we find the first crack in
- 5:12Warren's rule.
- 5:14On the first trading day of 2001,
- 5:18the market is already 16% below its
- 5:21high. So, the rule says, "Buy."
- 5:25Warren invests his $6,000
- 5:28on January 2nd at $129.
- 5:34And the market keeps falling. January
- 5:382002,
- 5:40already 16% below the high again. Warren
- 5:44buys on day one at $116.
- 5:49And the market keeps falling. Meanwhile,
- 5:52Charlie does what he always does. $500
- 5:57a month all the way down. His average
- 6:01price in 2002 is $100.
- 6:05Warren paid 116
- 6:08for the same years money.
- 6:12In June 2002, after 5 years behind,
- 6:17Charlie takes the lead back.
- 6:20But nobody is celebrating. On October
- 6:249th, 2002, the market hits bottom at
- 6:28$78.
- 6:30Each of them has put aside $42,000
- 6:35over 7 years.
- 6:37Charlie has 34,000 left. Warren 33,500.
- 6:457 years of discipline.
- 6:48Both of them are down about 20%.
- 6:53Then January 2003,
- 6:55the market is 23% below its high. Warren
- 7:00buys at $91.
- 7:03And this time, it works. The market
- 7:06turns and by the end of 2003,
- 7:09the two friends are separated by about
- 7:13$100.
- 7:17In August 2004, Warren gets back in
- 7:20front
- 7:21for 13 [music]
- 7:23days by less than $100.
- 7:27And now comes the one thing his strategy
- 7:31can't handle.
- 7:33A market that just goes up.
- 7:36There is no 10% dip. 2005,
- 7:40no dip. 2006, no dip. 2007,
- 7:45no dip.
- 7:47Four years, more than a thousand trading
- 7:51days. Every January, another $6,000
- 7:56arrive, and Warren adds it to the pile,
- 7:59which by now is $24,000.
- 8:05And while he waits, the market goes up
- 8:0940%.
- 8:11By October 2007, Charlie's lead is
- 8:14almost $7,000,
- 8:17the biggest gap of the race so far. But,
- 8:20let's look at where Warren is standing.
- 8:24He has $24,000
- 8:26in cash. In January, it becomes
- 8:30$30,000,
- 8:31and he's about to get what every dip
- 8:35buyer dreams of,
- 8:37the worst crash since the Great
- 8:41Depression.
- 8:42If buying the dip is ever going to win,
- 8:46it's now.
- 8:49January 8th,
- 8:51>> [music]
- 8:51>> 2008,
- 8:52the market closes 11% below its high.
- 8:57That is the signal. Warren has waited
- 9:02four years for it. He invests all
- 9:05$30,000
- 9:07at $139.
- 9:11And the market
- 9:13falls another 51%
- 9:17on March 9th, at the bottom,
- 9:20at the best buying opportunity of a
- 9:24generation,
- 9:26the dip buyer has no cash.
- 9:30And who is buying near the bottom?
- 9:33Charlie. March 2nd, 2009,
- 9:38$500 invested at $71.
- 9:43Not because he's brave, not because he
- 9:45saw it coming.
- 9:47Because it was the first trading day of
- 9:51the month.
- 9:52Now, let's look at the scoreboard. 14
- 9:56years
- 9:57$84,000
- 9:59put aside by each of them.
- 10:02Charlie has $61,000.
- 10:05Warren has 57,000.
- 10:08Charlie leads by 6%
- 10:12and both of them have lost more than a
- 10:15quarter of everything they ever saved.
- 10:21To be fair to Warren, his rule now
- 10:23starts working again.
- 10:26He buys the 2010 dip at $108.
- 10:30Charlie's average is 113.
- 10:34He buys the 2011 dip at $120.
- 10:39Charlie's average is $127.
- 10:44The gap shrinks to under 3%. [snorts]
- 10:48And then the same movie plays again.
- 10:522012,
- 10:54no dip. 2013,
- 10:56no dip. 2014,
- 10:59no dip.
- 11:00The pile grows to $24,000.
- 11:05And the market goes from $128
- 11:08to 213.
- 11:11August 24th, 2015.
- 11:15The Dow opens down 1,000 points. It's
- 11:19the scariest morning in years. The
- 11:22signal fires and Warren puts in $24,000
- 11:27at $190.
- 11:31Charlie's average price for the same 4
- 11:33years of saving
- 11:36$170.
- 11:39Warren waited more than 3 and 1/2 years
- 11:43for a discount, and he paid 11% more
- 11:46than the friend who didn't wait.
- 11:51The last 10 years are the best case for
- 11:55a dip buyer.
- 11:56The dips come fast, and Warren buys
- 12:00every one of them. February 27th, 2020,
- 12:05in the first week of the COVID panic.
- 12:07February 22nd, 2022,
- 12:112 days before Russia invades Ukraine.
- 12:13[clears throat]
- 12:14March 2025, in the middle of the tariff
- 12:18scare.
- 12:20Some of these are great purchases, but
- 12:23look at what happens after he buys.
- 12:27COVID, another 25% down. 2022, another
- 12:3217% down. 2025, almost another 10% down.
- 12:39On November 29th, 2024,
- 12:43Charlie becomes a millionaire. Warren
- 12:47gets there 7 months later.
- 12:52December 31st, 2025. [music]
- 12:5630 years. $180,000
- 13:00invested by each of them.
- 13:02>> I have $1,122,804.
- 13:10>> Sorry, old friend. I have $1,157,127.
- 13:20>> Charlie wins by $34,323.
- 13:27And that only 3.1%.
- 13:31And here's the number that surprised me
- 13:33the most. Warren made 19 purchases. On
- 13:3913 of them, he got a better price than
- 13:42Charlie got for the same money.
- 13:45He won 13 rounds out of 19.
- 13:50And he still lost the race because the
- 13:53rounds he lost were the big ones.
- 13:57So, that's it. Buying every month wins?
- 14:01Well, not so fast.
- 14:063% after 30 years is not a knockout. So,
- 14:11I changed the rules one at a time to see
- 14:15how solid this result really is. First,
- 14:19the cash. Remember Warren's waiting
- 14:22money earned nothing.
- 14:25If we let it earn the Treasury bill rate
- 14:29while it waits,
- 14:31Charlie's lead drops from 34,000
- 14:35to
- 14:36$4,600.
- 14:39That is a tie.
- 14:40Then, the size of the dip. What if
- 14:44Warren is more patient and waits for a
- 14:4815% drop?
- 14:50He loses by $88,000.
- 14:55A 20% drop?
- 14:57He loses by $160,000.
- 15:01He only gets to buy nine times in 30
- 15:06years, and he finishes the race with
- 15:09cash he never invested.
- 15:12But if he's less patient and buys every
- 15:175% a dip,
- 15:19Warren wins by $40,000.
- 15:23The less Warren waits, the more he ends
- 15:27up with. Which raises a question,
- 15:30what if somebody didn't wait at all?
- 15:34>> [music]
- 15:36>> So, let's add a third friend,
- 15:40Ben. Ben has no real strategy. He gets
- 15:44his $6,000 in January and he invests it
- 15:49the same day. He doesn't wait for the
- 15:51dip. He doesn't spread it over 12
- 15:54months.
- 15:55One purchase a year. And he ends up with
- 16:00$1,195,345.
- 16:06That is $38,000
- 16:09more than Charlie, more than $72,000
- 16:13ahead of Warren. And this is what the
- 16:17race was really about. We thought we
- 16:20were testing buying the dip against
- 16:24buying every month.
- 16:26We weren't. We were testing how long the
- 16:30money waits. Warren's money waited the
- 16:33longest. He came last. Charlie's money
- 16:37waited a few months on average. He came
- 16:40second. Ben's money
- 16:42didn't wait at all.
- 16:45And this changes how we should see
- 16:48Charlie. He didn't win because buying
- 16:51every month is clever.
- 16:53In this race, he had the full $6,000 in
- 16:58January and feeding it slowly actually
- 17:02cost him $38,000.
- 17:07But most of us are not paid once a year.
- 17:11We're paid once a month. And for
- 17:14somebody who invests each month's money
- 17:17as soon as it arrives,
- 17:20Charlie's schedule and Ben's rule are
- 17:24basically
- 17:25the same thing.
- 17:27>> Okay. Okay. So, we are all millionaires
- 17:30now. Great.
- 17:31Let's play some bridge.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of I Tested Dollar Cost Averaging vs Buying the Dip for 30 Years by Bald Investor, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 1,647 words across 313 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.