I decreti disciplinari del Concilio di Trento — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:01Good morning everyone, here we are
- 0:03again. Today we will talk about the
- 0:07Council of Trent, the 19th council in
- 0:09the history of the Church, a very
- 0:11important council not only for the
- 0:13history of the Church, but for history
- 0:15in general. It was a council that
- 0:18marked an era, the so-called
- 0:19Counter-Reformation era. Let’s start
- 0:22briefly with Luther, shall we? We
- 0:24remember that in 1517 Luther started
- 0:29the so-called Lutheran Reformation. The
- 0:35Catholic Church's response was, from a
- 0:37certain point of view, unfortunately
- 0:39for a series of reasons that we will
- 0:41quickly look at now, late; it could
- 0:43have perhaps addressed the Lutheran
- 0:45problem sooner and maybe resolved it at
- 0:47the outset. Instead, for one reason or
- 0:53another, the Council of Trent, which
- 0:55was the great council that responded to
- 0:58and addressed the Lutheran Reformation
- 1:00and all the other reformations, the
- 1:02Calvinist one and so on, was only
- 1:04convened in 1545. So, a lot of water
- 1:06had passed under the bridge in the
- 1:08meantime, and the Lutheran and
- 1:10Calvinist reformations had by then
- 1:12spread throughout Europe—in some
- 1:14areas more extensively than others—
- 1:16but they were beginning to consolidate.
- 1:22Uh, let's take a quick look to
- 1:27understand what happened leading up to
- 1:28the convening of the Council of Trent.
- 1:31You see, Luther posts his famous theses
- 1:34in 1517. There are a series of popes
- 1:39who cross paths with the Lutheran
- 1:40Reformation. The first is Leo X. Leo X
- 1:44is the Pope who excommunicates Luther.
- 1:48Then we have Adrian VI. Adrian VI, who
- 1:54was also the tutor of Charles V,
- 1:56remained on the papal throne for a very
- 1:58short time, so he did not have the
- 2:00physical time to organize a council
- 2:02that could stem the Lutheran
- 2:04reformation. We had already met Clement
- 2:12VII, because he is the Pope who has to
- 2:14deal with the crisis with Henry VIII,
- 2:16the King of England. And Clement VII
- 2:21was a rather energetic pope, also a
- 2:23political protagonist of his time. We
- 2:26are in the first decades of the 1500s,
- 2:30and this period is characterized, as we
- 2:33had already seen, by continuous
- 2:34struggles between France and Spain.
- 2:39Especially for the possession of the
- 2:41Duchy of Milan, and therefore Francis I
- 2:43, King of France, against Charles V,
- 2:46Emperor and at the same time King of
- 2:48Spain. So much so that some said at the
- 2:53time, "France or Spain, as long as we
- 2:55eat," because the French and Spaniards
- 2:57kept coming and going, back and forth
- 2:59in Northern Italy and the Duchy of
- 3:01Milan in order to take possession of
- 3:03that region. Well, Clement VII decides
- 3:09to let himself be involved—which,
- 3:11after all, he perhaps could not have
- 3:13done otherwise—in these struggles,
- 3:15and at a certain point he sides with
- 3:18France in the League of Cognac because
- 3:20Charles V seemed too strong to everyone
- 3:22. Emperor, King of Spain; that Habsburg
- 3:28grip seemed like a vice that would soon
- 3:30suffocate both France and the papacy.
- 3:37Clement VII sided politically with
- 3:39France, but he was burned by it because
- 3:41, at a certain point during one of the
- 3:43various battles, the famous German
- 3:45Landsknechts—that is, the German
- 3:47mercenaries in the pay of Charles V—
- 3:50penetrated Italy and even managed to
- 3:52reach Rome. 1527, a disastrous year for
- 4:03many reasons, because Rome was sacked
- 4:05for about a year; the Landsknechts
- 4:07managed to penetrate Rome, take
- 4:09possession of it, pillage it, brutalize
- 4:11the people, and carry off artistic
- 4:14treasures. Some of Raphael's frescoes
- 4:21were ruined with graffiti that, well,
- 4:23insulted the Pope as the antichrist
- 4:25because the Landsknechts were Lutheran.
- 4:29In short, for about a year, Rome fell
- 4:32prey to the fury of the Landsknechts.
- 4:37Then the Landsknechts withdrew, and
- 4:39Clement VII realized that things were
- 4:41not looking good and decided to
- 4:43compromise with Charles V and therefore
- 4:45to appear much more docile. Charles V
- 4:53was pressuring the Pope to finally
- 4:55convene a council capable of curbing
- 4:58the theological controversies. Clement
- 5:05VII, defeated on the field following
- 5:07the Sack of Rome, decided to convene
- 5:09this Council, but on one condition:
- 5:12that all Christian states be at peace.
- 5:20The situation of international peace
- 5:22was an almost necessary condition so
- 5:24that the Council could deliberate and
- 5:26address the Lutheran problems with all
- 5:28the necessary psychological and
- 5:30material serenity, so to speak. What
- 5:35was the problem? That in those years in
- 5:38Europe there was anything but peace,
- 5:40because France and Spain, Francis I and
- 5:43Charles V, were always at war, and so
- 5:45that condition sine qua non, in fact,
- 5:48never materialized. And to this, we add
- 5:53, toward the end of the pontificate of
- 5:55Clement VII, the tension with Henry
- 5:58VIII, which would later lead to the
- 6:00Anglican schism. In short, an extremely
- 6:03chaotic and violent international
- 6:05context. See the Sack of Rome. In the
- 6:08end, it prevented, even under the
- 6:10pontificate of Clement VII, the
- 6:12convening of this council, which from
- 6:17many sides, from many sides was invoked
- 6:22, was hoped for. Keep in mind that the
- 6:30Ecumenical Council was hoped for above
- 6:32all by Charles V because the Lutheran
- 6:34problem existed primarily in German
- 6:36territory, the Holy Roman Empire, and
- 6:39therefore concerned Charles V. But
- 6:41Charles V, however powerful, was
- 6:43basically the only sovereign pressuring
- 6:45the Pope to convene this council. A
- 6:51council that would have solved the
- 6:53internal problems of the empire and
- 6:55therefore would have solved a lot of
- 6:57headaches for Charles V. But many other
- 6:59European powers, I repeat, were opposed
- 7:01. Henry VIII in 1534 was already
- 7:05carrying out the schism, and so he was
- 7:08absolutely not on good terms with the
- 7:10papacy. The King of France, Francis I,
- 7:18had even allied himself with the German
- 7:20Protestants in order to confront
- 7:22Charles V. The German Lutherans were
- 7:24certainly not willing to submit to the
- 7:27Pope; they did indeed hope for a
- 7:29council to be convened, but their
- 7:31formula was this: a free council on
- 7:33German soil. A free council meant a
- 7:42council that excluded the Pope, and
- 7:44evidently, they could not accept the
- 7:46Pope himself being the one to convene
- 7:48it. So, Charles V was the only one
- 7:52pressuring the Pope, while everyone
- 7:54else was working against it. In reality
- 8:00, we know that even when the Council
- 8:02was finally convened, it led to
- 8:04outcomes opposite to those Charles V
- 8:06had imagined. Charles V hoped the
- 8:15Council would smooth over doctrinal
- 8:17disputes, but in the end, the Council
- 8:20of Trent drew a very solid, rigid line
- 8:22between orthodoxy—Catholicism—and
- 8:25heresy—Protestantism. And so the
- 8:32Council of Trent ended up sharpening
- 8:34the differences, not resolving them.
- 8:39And it could not have been otherwise,
- 8:41because the Lutherans had pushed things
- 8:42too far from a doctrinal point of view.
- 8:48Therefore, by 1545, when the Council of
- 8:51Trent was convened, the doctrinal
- 8:53differences were such—especially due
- 8:55to the Lutherans, who had introduced a
- 8:58series of innovations, so to speak,
- 9:00into their articles of faith—that a
- 9:02theological synthesis became impossible
- 9:05. The Council of Trent could do nothing
- 9:10but essentially acknowledge a fracture
- 9:12that had already occurred and reaffirm
- 9:14the eternal Catholic truths. So, in the
- 9:18end, Charles V did manage to get the
- 9:21Council of Trent convened, but the
- 9:23results of the Tridentine Council were
- 9:28opposite to what he had hoped for.
- 9:36Finally, with Paul III the Council was
- 9:43convened. As soon as he ascended to the
- 9:47papal throne, Paul III immediately made
- 9:52it known that it was his intention to
- 9:54convene the Council, and it was
- 9:58convened for the first time in 1537 in
- 10:03Mantua. However, it was an initial
- 10:08failed attempt because, in theory, all
- 10:10the bishops of the world—in practice,
- 10:12all the bishops of Europe—should have
- 10:15been summoned and participated in the
- 10:17proceedings. And what happened? That in
- 10:221537 France and Spain were still at war
- 10:27, so the King of France, Francis I, did
- 10:29not look favorably upon a council and
- 10:40implied a political convergence and
- 10:42interests between Pope Paul III and
- 10:44Emperor Charles V. Therefore, when Rome
- 10:46sent letters of convocation for the
- 10:48Council of Mantua to France to summon
- 10:50the French episcopate, the King of
- 10:52France, Francis I, gave orders that
- 10:54those letters sent from Rome should not
- 10:56be delivered to the various bishops;
- 10:59consequently, the French bishops did
- 11:01not receive the summons and could not
- 11:03participate in the Council of Mantua,
- 11:05so the Council of Mantua never even
- 11:07began. That is, it failed before
- 11:14starting precisely because of the
- 11:16political opposition of Francis I, who
- 11:18wanted to prevent his own bishops from
- 11:21participating in that council. It then
- 11:25became very clear that the Council and
- 11:31as much as it was a strictly religious,
- 11:33doctrinal meeting, it could not take
- 11:35place without the political consent of
- 11:37the great European powers. Because once
- 11:43again, religion and politics are linked
- 11:46together; it is right to distinguish
- 11:48them conceptually, but then in fact
- 11:50there are always reciprocal
- 11:51implications of religion on politics or
- 11:53of politics on religion. Therefore, a
- 11:58first attempt in Mantua fails. Consider
- 12:01that at a certain point, the following
- 12:03year, Paul III thought, hoped to be
- 12:06able to convene it again, this time in
- 12:08the Veneto, in Vicenza. But even this
- 12:17attempt failed, imagine that, due to
- 12:19the opposition of the Venetian
- 12:21authorities, of the Serenissima, not
- 12:23because they were absolutely against
- 12:25the Council, but because they feared
- 12:27that convening it in Vicenza, and
- 12:28therefore in the state of the
- 12:30Serenissima, could make a bad
- 12:32impression on the Sultan of the Turks.
- 12:40Think about how things are connected—
- 12:42it was Suleiman the Magnificent,
- 12:44because Suleiman the Magnificent knew
- 12:46little or nothing about councils, he is
- 12:48Islamic. Agreed? But what could
- 12:51Suleiman the Magnificent suspect? That
- 12:55that Council convened in Vicenza in the
- 12:57territory of the Serenissima could
- 12:59unite all the Christian European rulers
- 13:01against him? And this could have had
- 13:06negative repercussions on the very
- 13:08delicate, very fragile, precarious
- 13:10relations between the Ottoman Empire
- 13:12and Venice. You know that between the
- 13:17Ottomans and the Venetians there was a
- 13:19very, very fragile relationship, made
- 13:22of commercial relations, but also often
- 13:24and willingly of war. So the
- 13:29Serenissima finally rejected the
- 13:31hypothesis of Vicenza as the seat of
- 13:33the Ecumenical Council. 1542 there was
- 13:41another attempt and the Council was
- 13:43convened in Trent. So, Trent was an
- 13:52important and significant city because,
- 13:54as I was telling you, the Lutherans
- 13:56were demanding a free council on German
- 13:58soil. Initially, the Pope thought of
- 14:07extending the invitation also to the
- 14:09Lutheran bishops or pastors so that—
- 14:11the hope was this—to be able to
- 14:13reabsorb them into the Catholic Church,
- 14:15right? Heal the schism. Um, and Trent
- 14:22was a significant city because it was a
- 14:24good compromise. See on the map where
- 14:27Trent was located. Trent, you see, was
- 14:34located within the borders of the Holy
- 14:37Roman Empire, so it was, let's say,
- 14:39fundamentally Italian in culture, but
- 14:41politically and formally imperial,
- 14:43making it a good meeting point between
- 14:46the German world, which was largely
- 14:48Protestantized, and the Catholic
- 14:50ecumene. Um, but this time too, but
- 15:01this time too, in 1542, the convocation
- 15:04failed because once again Francis I
- 15:07found himself at war with Charles V and
- 15:09the plans fell through. A council could
- 15:15not be called while the two great
- 15:16European superpowers of the time were
- 15:18slaughtering each other on the
- 15:20battlefield. Finally, the right time
- 15:23arrives: 1545. Second convocation in
- 15:29Trent. Here it effectively begins, the
- 15:35Council gets underway, and the European
- 15:38political-military situation is
- 15:40favorable because Francis I loses an
- 15:43important battle against Charles V, and
- 15:45in the subsequent peace treaty, Charles
- 15:48V forces Francis I to consent to the
- 15:54convocation of the Council of Trent;
- 15:57therefore, defeated on the battlefield
- 15:59and politically weakened, Francis I
- 16:02yields, and finally, in 1545, the
- 16:06various Catholic bishops, and to some
- 16:09extent Lutherans as well, travel to
- 16:11Trent and. The Lutherans would only
- 16:15attend the first sessions, then they
- 16:17would abandon the proceedings. So, all
- 16:21things considered, the Council of Trent
- 16:24would be an exclusively Catholic
- 16:25council that, as I repeat, would mark a
- 16:28clear division or acknowledge a clear
- 16:30division between Catholic doctrine and
- 16:32the Lutheran world. It is the 19th
- 16:38Council in the history of the Church.
- 16:41Currently, we have reached 21. There
- 16:44will be the First Vatican Council, the
- 16:4820th, and the Second Vatican Council.
- 16:53Here in the slide, you can see the
- 16:55Cathedral of Trent in the background,
- 16:57the Cathedral of San Vigilio, which was
- 16:59the place where the Tridentine dogmas
- 17:01were proclaimed after being discussed
- 17:03in other areas of the city. Here in the
- 17:08foreground, you see the Fountain of
- 17:10Neptune. A fountain chosen probably on
- 17:14purpose in the 1700s because Neptune
- 17:16holds a trident, as per tradition. The
- 17:20trident recalls the ancient name of
- 17:22Trent, which was Tridentum, hence the
- 17:24Council of Trent or the Tridentine
- 17:26Council. Tridentine ultimately means
- 17:30from Trent. It is a synonym. The
- 17:35council was finally convened, as I was
- 17:38telling you, in 1545, but it had to
- 17:43endure a series of mishaps that caused
- 17:45its interruption three times. In fact,
- 17:51you see that the council was convened
- 17:53in Trent, then there was a plague, and
- 17:55the bishops had to move to Bologna,
- 17:58also thanks to the supervision of the
- 18:00most important doctor of the time,
- 18:02Girolamo Fracastoro, of Veronese origin
- 18:04. Then it could be convened in Trent
- 18:07again a second time, then there was an
- 18:10interruption of the work for 10 years,
- 18:12just think about it, and finally the
- 18:14end of the work between '62 and '63; in
- 18:17short, the Council of Trent followed a
- 18:21rather bumpy path. Overall, the council
- 18:27was held from 1545 to 1563. What did
- 18:37the bishops discuss at the Council of
- 18:39Trent? There were two major issues, and
- 18:44we can find traces of this in the
- 18:46documents of the Council of Trent
- 18:48itself. "This holy and general Council
- 18:58of Trent," states a document from the
- 19:00Council, "considering the importance of
- 19:02the subjects to be addressed,
- 19:04especially those included under two
- 19:06headings, namely the eradication of
- 19:08heresies and the reform of morals, for
- 19:10which it has been primarily convened,"
- 19:12and so on. What does this opening of
- 19:19the Council of Trent tell us? It tells
- 19:25us that the main goals for which the
- 19:27council was convened were two: to
- 19:29eradicate heresy, meaning to try to
- 19:31confront Lutheranism on its own
- 19:33doctrinal ground to win back to
- 19:35Catholicism all those regions that had
- 19:37followed Luther. And the second goal,
- 19:45no less important, was the reform of
- 19:47morals, that is, the internal reform of
- 19:49the Catholic Church. So, the Council of
- 19:54Trent produced various documents, and
- 19:57after all, the work lasted for several
- 19:59years, right? From '45 to '63, these
- 20:04can be divided into two main categories
- 20:06. Disciplinary decrees, which aim at
- 20:13reforming the internal discipline of
- 20:16the Catholic clergy, and doctrinal
- 20:18decrees, which aim to reaffirm Catholic
- 20:20truths in opposition to all the
- 20:22heretical changes introduced in those
- 20:24years by Luther, Calvin, Melanchthon,
- 20:26and all their followers. So, today we
- 20:36will address the first group of these
- 20:38decrees, namely the disciplinary
- 20:40decrees. We will talk about the
- 20:43doctrinal decrees on another occasion.
- 20:51With the disciplinary decrees, the
- 20:53Catholic Church accepts many of the
- 20:55Protestants 'criticisms. Protestants
- 21:00had made some legitimate criticisms, as
- 21:03we saw, regarding certain bad customs
- 21:05or abuses of ecclesiastical authority
- 21:07that existed. The Church had already
- 21:11noticed them, but had never had the
- 21:13strength to intervene effectively. With
- 21:17these disciplinary decrees, Catholics
- 21:19accept the criticisms raised by
- 21:21Protestants and try to remedy them.
- 21:28Basically, the goal is to increase
- 21:30hierarchical discipline within the
- 21:32Church, meaning the control of bishops
- 21:34over parish priests and, in turn, of
- 21:36parish priests over the faithful,
- 21:38because abuses were occurring at all
- 21:40levels: at the highest levels with
- 21:42bishops and sometimes cardinals, but
- 21:44also at lower levels, so to speak, at
- 21:47the level of the common people. They
- 21:58realized something that history very
- 22:00often teaches: that the excessive
- 22:02freedom many had enjoyed within the
- 22:04Church up to that point, if not limited
- 22:07by either external constraints (the law
- 22:09) or internal constraints (ethics
- 22:11emanating from within), can lead not
- 22:13only to anarchy but also to serious
- 22:15disorder, abuse, and injustice. And so
- 22:23it was understood that hierarchical
- 22:25control needed to be increased and,
- 22:27therefore, from a certain point of view
- 22:30, limit freedom to obtain a greater
- 22:32good. What is this greater good? To
- 22:35reduce, if not abolish, the abuses,
- 22:37injustices, and inconsistencies that
- 22:39burdened the Catholic Church. So,
- 22:43greater control to obtain a higher good
- 22:45, something desired by almost everyone,
- 22:48even the Lutherans. Well, these
- 22:52disciplinary decrees then concretely
- 22:55identify some specific cases for which
- 22:57they wanted to find a solution once and
- 22:59for all. For example, regarding bishops
- 23:07, it was decided in Trent that bishops
- 23:09could no longer receive multiple
- 23:11benefices, meaning they could not be
- 23:13ordained as bishops—and thus be
- 23:15ordinaries—of multiple dioceses. One
- 23:22diocese for each bishop. A diocese is
- 23:25that territorial jurisdiction over
- 23:27which the bishop, precisely, has
- 23:29authority. Until the Council of Trent,
- 23:31bishops could obtain multiple benefices
- 23:33, meaning they could be appointed
- 23:35ordinaries of several dioceses. Clearly
- 23:38, a bishop who had to govern multiple
- 23:40dioceses ended up governing all of them
- 23:42poorly. So, what is said at Trent? One
- 23:47bishop can correspond to only one
- 23:49diocese. The bishop is required to
- 23:53govern the diocese in the best possible
- 23:55way and therefore also to monitor what
- 23:57happens within the borders of their own
- 24:00diocese, for which so-called pastoral
- 24:02visits are ordered. Every bishop was
- 24:07required to periodically make pastoral
- 24:09visits within their own diocese,
- 24:11meaning to travel around the parishes,
- 24:13speak with the parish priests, speak
- 24:15with the faithful, and see if
- 24:17everything was working and if there
- 24:18were any abuses or not. Pastoral visits
- 24:24that, moreover, had already been
- 24:26provided for centuries earlier in other
- 24:29ecclesiastical councils, but which then
- 24:31unfortunately fell into disuse.
- 24:39Indulgences, remember that the Lutheran
- 24:42Reformation was triggered by the
- 24:43problem of indulgences. There were a
- 24:50series of problems, but the straw that
- 24:52broke the camel's back was that famous
- 24:54indulgence collection proclaimed by
- 24:57Albert of Hohenzollern in Brandenburg
- 24:59in 1517, which infuriated Luther and
- 25:01started the whole thing. What does the
- 25:06Council of Trent say regarding these
- 25:08indulgences? We could resolve the
- 25:11matter with a Latin adage. Abusus non
- 25:15tollit usum. That is, the abuse does
- 25:21not take away the use; if there is an
- 25:23abuse, one must eliminate the abuse,
- 25:31not the correct practice from which the
- 25:34abuse derived. In other words, if I
- 25:39were to eat, I don't know, 18 pandori a
- 25:42day, what would be the wrong thing? The
- 25:46wrong thing is the exaggeration of
- 25:48eating 18 pandori, not eating the
- 25:50pandoro itself. The Council of Trent,
- 25:54excuse the slightly profane analogy,
- 25:56essentially adopts this logic by saying
- 25:59what? That indulgences in themselves
- 26:01are a good thing. It is true that the
- 26:06Church, in certain circumstances, has
- 26:08the power to grant indulgences to the
- 26:10faithful, that is, to remit the
- 26:12temporal punishment of sin, or
- 26:14translated, to remit the penance linked
- 26:16to sins already confessed in the
- 26:18confessional. It is true that the
- 26:25Church has this power, but all the
- 26:27abuses that piled up around this issue
- 26:29of indulgences had to be drastically
- 26:31eliminated. Let us read the document.
- 26:38The power to confer indulgences has
- 26:40been granted by Christ to the Church,
- 26:42which from the earliest times has used
- 26:44this faculty divinely granted to her.
- 26:49It is the famous power of the keys, by
- 26:52which the Pope or the Church, as
- 26:54Christ's vicar, has the power, in
- 26:56certain circumstances, to either remit
- 26:58sins in the confessional, a sacrament,
- 27:01or to remit the satisfaction, that is,
- 27:03the penance linked to sins. For this
- 27:06reason, the Holy Synod, that is, the
- 27:08Council of Trent, teaches and commands
- 27:10that this use be maintained in the
- 27:12Church, therefore that indulgences be
- 27:14maintained, as they are very salutary
- 27:16for the Christian people. And yet, in
- 27:20granting these indulgences, moderation
- 27:22should be used to avoid having the
- 27:24excessive ease in granting them weaken
- 27:26ecclesiastical discipline. Therefore,
- 27:30indulgences yes, but exaggeration or
- 27:33abuses of indulgences no. Wishing then
- 27:39to amend and correct the abuses that
- 27:41nest within the practice of indulgences
- 27:44, with this present decree the Council
- 27:46establishes in general the complete
- 27:48abolition of all unworthy traffic of
- 27:50money made to obtain indulgences. So
- 27:58the words of the council are very clear
- 28:00and follow this logic, right, of*abusus
- 28:02tollit usum*. Moving on. Parish priests
- 28:11, they too are made more accountable.
- 28:15Parish priests are monitored by bishops
- 28:17, but they in turn must exercise
- 28:19greater control over the faithful and
- 28:21therefore, for example, registers of
- 28:23the sacraments are introduced. It was
- 28:26necessary to register everyone who got
- 28:29married, and this was to avoid chaos,
- 28:31because sometimes it happened that
- 28:33someone would marry someone else, but
- 28:35no trace remained, so they managed to
- 28:37obtain a second marriage; in short, a
- 28:39mess. Parish priests had to maintain
- 28:45the register of the sacraments, in
- 28:47particular of baptisms, marriages, and
- 28:49then also of deaths and funerals.
- 29:01Weddings were then linked to the
- 29:03practice of banns, that is: when two
- 29:05people wanted to marry, they had to
- 29:07publish their intention to marry;
- 29:09therefore, to post a notice in the
- 29:11parish stating that so-and-so were
- 29:13going to get married, to allow anyone
- 29:15who had anything to object to that
- 29:17marriage to express their criticism
- 29:19before the wedding. This too was a form
- 29:29of social protection to avoid strange
- 29:31dealings in the shadow of the sacrament
- 29:33of marriage. Keep in mind that this
- 29:36practice of publishing marriage
- 29:38intentions is still in effect today.
- 29:42Those who wish to marry know that
- 29:44before the wedding, for several days,
- 29:46the notice of marriage intention must
- 29:48remain posted, precisely to allow
- 29:50anyone who wishes to object to do so in
- 29:52time. Furthermore, seminaries were
- 29:58established. This is very important
- 30:03because in the 16th century, in various
- 30:05European regions, there was
- 30:07unfortunately not always, but in more
- 30:13than a few cases, yes, a serious lack
- 30:16of preparation among the clergy and
- 30:18priests. Just think, I'll cite one of
- 30:22the most extreme cases—it wasn't
- 30:24always this way, but extreme cases make
- 30:26you reflect—that some historians have
- 30:29found that around 1530, let's say
- 30:35shortly before the Council of Trent, in
- 30:37England, many priests did not know,
- 30:39they didn't even know, just imagine,
- 30:41they didn't know how to recite the
- 30:43Lord's Prayer or know who the author of
- 30:46the Lord's Prayer was. (Opening and
- 30:50closing parentheses, because I can
- 30:52imagine that even today many do not
- 30:54know who the author of the Lord's
- 30:56Prayer is; it is Jesus Christ.) The
- 30:58Lord's Prayer, a prayer found in the
- 31:00New Testament taught by Christ to the
- 31:02apostles (end parenthesis); they did
- 31:04not know the Lord's Prayer, or many
- 31:06English priests did not know the Ten
- 31:08Commandments. Many did not even know
- 31:13Latin, the very language of the
- 31:15official liturgy, so they often mumbled
- 31:17nonsensical words, because the faithful
- 31:19didn't know Latin either. Now, this is
- 31:23an extreme case—it wasn't always like
- 31:26this, let's be clear—but in several
- 31:28parts of Europe, the lack of
- 31:30preparation among the clergy was
- 31:32serious. Sometimes there were even
- 31:34cases of concubinage with children to
- 31:37follow and so on. So, quite rightly,
- 31:41the Council of Trent decided to tackle
- 31:43this problem by raising the doctrinal
- 31:46and intellectual preparation of its
- 31:48priests, thus establishing the
- 31:49seminaries that still exist today.
- 31:55Seminaries are schools where future
- 31:57priests are trained according to proper
- 31:59doctrine. A priest must also be capable
- 32:06of being a priest; there must be a
- 32:08vocation, but he must also be
- 32:09intellectually capable, knowing a
- 32:11series of things that allow him to best
- 32:14exercise his ministry. The
- 32:19establishment of these seminaries was
- 32:22so important that, just to say, the
- 32:24very first seminary established in the
- 32:26world was founded about fifty days
- 32:28after the end of the Council of Trent's
- 32:30proceedings. Yes, already in January
- 32:351564, practically two months after the
- 32:41end of the proceedings in Trent, the
- 32:43seminary of Larino in the province of
- 32:45Campobasso was established. The first
- 32:48seminary in the world. What am I trying
- 32:50to say? That the establishment of
- 32:52seminaries was felt as an urgent
- 32:53necessity. So much so that immediately
- 32:57after the work ended, the first
- 32:59seminary began to emerge and sprout,
- 33:01and from there, they gradually spread
- 33:03throughout Europe. Now, a particularly
- 33:11important figure to remember in
- 33:12connection with the establishment of
- 33:15seminaries is Saint Charles Borromeo,
- 33:17cardinal and archbishop of Milan, who
- 33:19poured a great deal of effort, time,
- 33:21and energy into building seminaries in
- 33:24his own diocese and into, shall we say,
- 33:26defining them more clearly from an
- 33:28institutional standpoint. In fact, the
- 33:35seminary you see at the bottom left set
- 33:38the standard in Milan. It is the
- 33:41so-called Helvetic College, now the
- 33:43Palazzo del Senato, but that is not
- 33:45relevant to us. It was commissioned by
- 33:52Saint Charles Borromeo’s cousin, and
- 33:54it was called the Helvetic College
- 33:56because it mainly housed students
- 33:58coming from Swiss regions, and thus
- 34:00those students most exposed to
- 34:02Calvinist doctrine, whom the Catholics
- 34:04wanted to bring back into the fold of
- 34:06the Catholic Church; and here you see
- 34:08another seminary, also important for
- 34:10other reasons, in Valencia. I am
- 34:18showing you these two out of hundreds
- 34:20and hundreds of possibilities to
- 34:22demonstrate how, for example, there was
- 34:24a certain homogeneity even from an
- 34:26architectural point of view. You can
- 34:32see that generally, the seminaries of
- 34:34this period were built with a typically
- 34:37Renaissance architecture and a large
- 34:39cloister inside, often formed by
- 34:41two-tiered loggias. Do you see? You can
- 34:46see it here in Valencia and you can
- 34:47also see it here in Milan. This was an
- 34:51architectural model that set a trend
- 34:53and can be found more or less the same
- 34:55in many European states. Furthermore,
- 35:02one last thing, the drafting of the
- 35:04catechism. Not only did priests need to
- 35:09be better prepared in Christian matters
- 35:11, but the faithful did as well. Well,
- 35:16you can imagine that if many priests
- 35:18already ignored Christian doctrine, you
- 35:20can imagine the ripple effect of what
- 35:22the situation might have been like
- 35:24among the faithful. Many were ignorant
- 35:28of the fundamentals of the Christian
- 35:30religion. Others were confused, no
- 35:34longer understanding what was Catholic,
- 35:36what was Lutheran, what was Calvinist.
- 35:38It was an extremely fluid, complex, and
- 35:41also rather chaotic situation. Even
- 35:45among the faithful, we can find extreme
- 35:47cases. Some of the faithful did not
- 35:50know the Ten Commandments; then again,
- 35:52often the priests did not know them
- 35:54either. Some did not know the prayers,
- 35:59some did not know the seven deadly sins
- 36:01, and so, in short, the Christian
- 36:03people also needed to be better
- 36:05educated, and therefore the catechism
- 36:07was drafted. What is the catechism? We
- 36:12have heard this term before, haven't we
- 36:14? When I was little, I went to
- 36:17catechism; that is, in common parlance,
- 36:20catechism is an activity. In itself,
- 36:24the catechism is a book, not an
- 36:26activity. That is, whoever goes to
- 36:28catechism should, in theory, be
- 36:30instructed based on a text, namely the
- 36:33catechism. A catechism is a text, a
- 36:37small book that condenses, that is,
- 36:39summarizes Catholic doctrine—it
- 36:41explains what Catholic doctrine is,
- 36:43what the Church thinks on certain
- 36:45topics, what are the articles of faith
- 36:48specific to Catholics, and what
- 36:49Catholics believe from a theoretical
- 36:52and existential point of view. Think,
- 36:57and I'll open and close a parenthesis
- 36:59here, that the first catechism, the
- 37:01so-called "Small Catechism," was
- 37:03published by Luther for the Lutherans,
- 37:05obviously, not for the Catholics. The
- 37:08year was 1529. Well, Catholics did the
- 37:13same in 1550 that is, they drafted
- 37:17their own catechism. Eh, who was
- 37:23commissioned? Naturally, it was a
- 37:27rather delicate task to draft the
- 37:29catechism. It was a matter of defining
- 37:33what Catholic doctrine was. Naturally,
- 37:38a Jesuit could not help but be involved
- 37:40in this project. I remind you that the
- 37:44Jesuits at that time were perhaps the
- 37:46most educated order in the Catholic
- 37:48Church, along with the Franciscans and
- 37:50Dominicans. However, the Jesuits were a
- 37:53newly founded order that embodied,
- 37:55better than other orders at the time,
- 37:57the spirit of the Counter-Reformation.
- 38:02Therefore, a Dutch Jesuit named
- 38:04Canisius was commissioned; he was very
- 38:06active in Germany and managed to bring
- 38:09many German regions back to Catholicism
- 38:11, so the first catechism was the
- 38:13Canisius catechism. I repeat, that
- 38:18catechism listed a whole series of
- 38:20points that made explicit the identity
- 38:23of Catholic doctrine and, consequently,
- 38:25also the difference between Catholic
- 38:27doctrine and Lutheran doctrine. This
- 38:34type of catechism was extremely
- 38:36effective; it was a godsend for the
- 38:38Christian people, for the baptized
- 38:40faithful, because it somehow curbed—
- 38:42it didn't completely solve, but it
- 38:44curbed—the profound doctrinal
- 38:46ignorance that was rampant everywhere.
- 38:50Agreed? Which, opening and closing a
- 38:53parenthesis, is an ignorance that is
- 38:55often and gladly encountered even today
- 38:57. Even today, if we were to stop 100
- 39:01people on the street and ask them about
- 39:03the fundamentals of Catholic doctrine,
- 39:05well, we would get some rather
- 39:07surprising answers. The situation was
- 39:12not much different back then, and they
- 39:14tried to curb it by providing a
- 39:16catechetical tool that could solve this
- 39:18problem. After all, in the absence of
- 39:23this tool, there weren't many others
- 39:25for self-instruction. Sure, one might
- 39:29say attending the liturgy of the Mass.
- 39:33Yes, it is true that one could attend
- 39:35Mass, but it is also true that Masses
- 39:38were not very well attended, especially
- 39:40in the countryside, because there were
- 39:42few churches in the countryside, and
- 39:44those that existed were often private
- 39:47chapels; therefore, statistically, not
- 39:49many people attended Mass, at least on
- 39:51a regular basis. And here, too, we have
- 39:55some extreme cases—that is, sometimes
- 39:58historical records remain of those who
- 40:00attended Mass, but even then, it was
- 40:03not the rule; they were extreme cases.
- 40:07They would attend, but either by
- 40:09chatting, playing cards, or showing up
- 40:11drunk—just imagine—or some would
- 40:13even fall asleep, or some would enter
- 40:15with their dog. Now, this was not the
- 40:19rule, I repeat, but these were extreme
- 40:21cases that tell us there was something
- 40:23that needed improvement. Nowadays,
- 40:25extreme cases of this type no longer
- 40:28exist. Therefore, the Council of Trent
- 40:31also managed to buffer these these
- 40:36shortcomings, right, that were nesting
- 40:38in some local settings. And, on the
- 40:43other hand, if the faithful did not
- 40:45regularly attend Mass, especially in
- 40:47the countryside, not only were they not
- 40:49instructed in Catholic doctrine, but
- 40:51they also rarely attended the
- 40:53sacraments, rarely confessed, rarely
- 40:55received the Eucharist, and so on. And
- 41:03with the establishment of seminaries,
- 41:06the catechism, and the erection of a
- 41:08series of new churches, even in the
- 41:10countryside, it was possible to, how
- 41:12shall I say, to effectively stem this
- 41:14problem as well. I will finish with a
- 41:24curiosity. Let’s build a bridge to
- 41:27the contemporary world. The catechism
- 41:30that was established conceptually and
- 41:32materially at Trent still exists today.
- 41:38It is a catechism that has been updated
- 41:40with all the doctrinal pronouncements
- 41:42that have occurred from Trent to today,
- 41:44naturally; but it is a book that
- 41:46conceptually performs the same function
- 41:48as Canisius's catechism, just as it was
- 41:50conceived—that is, it is a rather
- 41:52voluminous book that contains the
- 41:54thinking of the Catholic Church from a
- 41:56doctrinal point of view. What does the
- 42:01Catholic Church think about the
- 42:03creation of the universe? What will
- 42:05there be after death? What is the Last
- 42:07Judgment? What are the seven deadly
- 42:10sins? What does the Catholic Church
- 42:13think about purgatory? What does it
- 42:15think of Satan and hell? What does it
- 42:18think about demonic possession? I cite
- 42:21these last examples on purpose because
- 42:23I know they pique curiosity. So, what
- 42:26the Catholic Church thinks is contained
- 42:29in the catechism, so just to be clear,
- 42:31if I, if a priest, if anyone were to
- 42:34say "the Catholic Church thinks X," but
- 42:36the catechism says Y, what is
- 42:38authoritative is the catechism. That is
- 42:42, it is the priests, the ministers, who
- 42:44must conform to the catechism, which is
- 42:47the eternal teaching of the Catholic
- 42:49Church, and not vice versa. In fact,
- 42:53you see, this is a 1993 catechism that
- 42:56was promulgated by the then-pontiff
- 42:58John Paul II, who said what about this
- 43:01tool? That the CCC, the Catechism of
- 43:06the Catholic Church, is an exposition
- 43:08of the Church's faith and Catholic
- 43:10doctrine. I recognize it as a valid and
- 43:21legitimate tool at the service of
- 43:23ecclesial communion and a secure
- 43:25standard for teaching the faith, and
- 43:26thus as a tool capable of bringing
- 43:28unity to the Catholic Church because it
- 43:30can channel Catholic teachings into a
- 43:32single instrument. Well, these were, in
- 43:46essence, the disciplinary decrees of
- 43:48the Council of Trent, which managed to
- 43:50breathe new life into the Church and
- 43:52also resolve several problems that had
- 43:55accumulated up to that point, giving
- 43:57new impetus to pastoral work,
- 43:59especially the work of apostolic
- 44:00missions. of the Franciscans, the
- 44:07Dominicans, and the Jesuits around the
- 44:09world. Next time, however, we will see
- 44:14what the doctrinal decrees consist of.
- 44:21While the disciplinary decrees accepted
- 44:23many of the Protestants' criticisms,
- 44:25considered them legitimate, and sought
- 44:27to patch those problems, the doctrinal
- 44:29decrees instead marked, I repeat, a
- 44:31clear opposition between the eternal
- 44:33Catholic truths and the new doctrines
- 44:35introduced by the Lutherans, so the
- 44:37great confrontation will ultimately
- 44:39remain on the doctrinal aspect. We will
- 44:46pick this up next time. Goodbye.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of I decreti disciplinari del Concilio di Trento by Alberto Zago, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 5,562 words across 896 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.