Humans’ origin story is being radically revised — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00If I should pick the single most
- 0:02important thing that had happened in the
- 0:03history of planet Earth, what would you
- 0:05say?
- 0:07Maybe the first single-cell life, the
- 0:09asteroid that killed the dinosaurs,
- 0:11maybe the Industrial Revolution, or the
- 0:13discovery of fire, or of the computer.
- 0:16I know what I would pick, the dawn of
- 0:18human intelligence. It's the thing that
- 0:20led to fire, agriculture, the written
- 0:22word, technology. It's what remade our
- 0:25world from this to this.
- 0:28It's the one thing that's ever happened
- 0:30on Earth that's also having an impact
- 0:32outside [music] of it.
- 0:34But what if I told you that this event,
- 0:36maybe the most important in Earth's
- 0:39history, is kind of a mystery?
- 0:43This is a clip from the greatest movie
- 0:44ever made, 2001: A Space Odyssey. It's
- 0:47imagining the moment when our ancestors
- 0:49first picked up a tool and [music]
- 0:51became intelligent. A breakthrough so
- 0:53profound and mysterious, the movie
- 0:55portrays it as triggered by a giant
- 0:57black monolith from space that
- 0:59spontaneously makes us smart. This idea
- 1:01didn't come from nowhere. It was a kind
- 1:03of sci-fi dramatization of the actual,
- 1:06like, mainstream scientific theory, that
- 1:08intelligence just, poof, happened
- 1:11spontaneously one day. [music] Dumb ape
- 1:13became smart ape, rest was history.
- 1:16Which is to say we had no idea how
- 1:18intelligence [music] happened or why it
- 1:19happened, but I have good news. This big
- 1:22mystery, maybe the biggest in the
- 1:24history of our species, even of our
- 1:26planet, is kind of in the middle of
- 1:27getting solved. This is The Atlantic
- 1:29earlier this year. The human origin
- 1:32story is being [music] radically
- 1:33revised, and it's about the flurry of
- 1:36new discoveries using modern tools like
- 1:38DNA analysis
- 1:39>> [music]
- 1:39>> to cast narrow shafts of light into the
- 1:41dark abyss that is the human past. We'll
- 1:44probably never get, like, one definitive
- 1:46answer, but we do have three or four
- 1:49really good theories for how we went
- 1:51from foraging bipedal apes in the middle
- 1:53tier of the food chain to masters of the
- 1:55planet, [music]
- 1:56space travel, nuclear energy, and who
- 1:58knows what else soon. Each of these
- 2:00theories is really kind of a story, a
- 2:02story about how and why we became human.
- 2:05And today we are going to tell those
- 2:07four stories. We're going to break down
- 2:09where each comes from, [music] the
- 2:10evidence for it, and what it says about
- 2:12us, about who we really are, which is a
- 2:15question that feels kind of urgent now
- 2:17that we are maybe on the verge of
- 2:18creating potentially the second
- 2:20intelligence in [music] Earth's history.
- 2:22By understanding where intelligence
- 2:24comes from, what happened to bring it
- 2:26about, maybe we can better understand
- 2:28what it actually [music] is, what it
- 2:30does, how it works, and what set of
- 2:32circumstances and pressures can give
- 2:34rise to [music] it. I am obsessed with
- 2:36this topic, guys. I think it is so
- 2:38fascinating, and I'm excited to get into
- 2:41it.
- 2:43>> [music]
- 2:46>> So, we've got space up here for four
- 2:49main theories, [music]
- 2:50and we're going to tell each of those as
- 2:52a story, starting with a beginning, the
- 2:55environmental pressure that kicked off
- 2:57and guided the evolutionary process in
- 2:59the first place. Think of leopards that
- 3:01migrated from jungles to mountains. The
- 3:03colder mountain climate is an
- 3:05environmental pressure that favors
- 3:07thicker coats and bushier tails,
- 3:10producing the snow leopard. And the
- 3:12middle of each story here is the
- 3:14intelligence trigger, the thing our
- 3:16ancient ancestors evolved in response to
- 3:19that environmental pressure that over
- 3:20time became intelligence, like the human
- 3:23equivalent of leopards growing bushier
- 3:25tails. And lastly, as the end of each of
- 3:28those four stories will be what that
- 3:30story tells us about what our
- 3:32intelligence is, what it's optimized
- 3:34for, how it works, and how it defines
- 3:37who we are as human beings. So, let's
- 3:39get started with story number one. And
- 3:41this is the theory that people held for
- 3:43most of the 20th century. It's actually
- 3:45basically the 2001 monolith theory, but
- 3:48without the monolith. Let me explain.
- 3:50>> We don't know just exactly when
- 3:53primitive man first started to make
- 3:56sharp cutting edge [music] tools or
- 3:57simple tools.
- 3:58>> This is Louis Leakey, very famous
- 4:00archaeologist, describing how this
- 4:01theory says we first became intelligent.
- 4:03>> And that gave him the idea that he could
- 4:06make sharp cutting edges whenever he
- 4:07wanted them and not have to go looking
- 4:09for them and find them when nature had
- 4:12done so.
- 4:13>> Basically, this set of ancient ancestors
- 4:14called Homo habilis, who were kind of
- 4:16like today's great apes, figured out one
- 4:18day how to make tools by breaking apart
- 4:20rocks, and that was that.
- 4:22>> [music]
- 4:22>> It is Homo habilis, Leakey believes, who
- 4:25survived by the development of his
- 4:27brain, [music] the sharpness of his
- 4:28cunning, to spawn all the generations of
- 4:31man.
- 4:32>> And if this story sounds familiar, it's
- 4:34probably because a few years ago it
- 4:36showed up in the very first pages of one
- 4:38of the best-selling books of all time,
- 4:41Sapiens by Yuval Harari, where he termed
- 4:44it
- 4:46the cognitive revolution. And let's read
- 4:48how Harari summarizes it because it's a
- 4:50very neat little summary.
- 4:54>> Once upon a time
- 4:55>> What caused it, it being intelligence?
- 4:58We are not sure. The most commonly
- 4:59believed theory argues that accidental
- 5:01[music]
- 5:01genetic mutations change the inner
- 5:03wiring of the brains of Sapiens, [music]
- 5:06enabling them to think in unprecedented
- 5:08ways and to communicate using an
- 5:10altogether new type of [music] language.
- 5:12We might call it the tree of knowledge
- 5:13mutation. Why did it occur in Sapiens
- 5:16DNA? It was a matter of pure chance as
- 5:18far as we can tell. Wait, that's it?
- 5:21There's not another
- 5:23like at least to that.
- 5:26That's it? Random accident mutation bolt
- 5:28out of nowhere makes us smart?
- 5:30Our smart ancestors can now talk and
- 5:32make tools and conquer the Earth? Okay.
- 5:35If we want to sum this up for
- 5:37environmental pressure, I guess we would
- 5:39put random sudden mutation.
- 5:44And this mutation just randomly gifts us
- 5:47with a bigger, more powerful brain, and
- 5:49that bigger brain is what triggers our
- 5:51evolution of intelligence.
- 5:55Let me see if I can sum this up as a
- 5:57kind of fairy tale.
- 5:58>> [music]
- 6:00>> One day, very long time ago, in the
- 6:03Great Rift Valley of Eastern Africa, one
- 6:06of our ape-like ancient ancestors had a
- 6:08baby with an unusually large brain, way
- 6:11bigger than anyone [music] else in the
- 6:13community. That baby grew up and
- 6:15discovered they could use their big
- 6:16brain to make tools and [music] hunt and
- 6:18coordinate complex activity. They
- 6:20prospered, had children like them,
- 6:23>> [music]
- 6:23>> and the children of their children
- 6:25became us. So, this story is, and I'm
- 6:27sorry to Yuval Harari, who seems lovely,
- 6:29[music] absolute balderdash poop. It is
- 6:32not sense. And we will come back to why,
- 6:34but first let's finish telling the rest
- 6:36of the story, starting with, and to give
- 6:38credit to Harari here, one big piece of
- 6:40evidence that does back it up. And to
- 6:42explain what that is, we got to flip the
- 6:43board here.
- 6:45So, this line here is going to be our
- 6:47timeline [music]
- 6:48of all of human history, starting at the
- 6:51start, 6 million years ago, when we
- 6:53diverged from chimpanzees, or
- 6:56technically diverged from a great ape
- 6:57that [music] became chimpanzees. Point
- 6:59is, this is when we split off.
- 7:03Then, the next big thing, 2 and 1/2
- 7:05million years ago, the first primitive
- 7:08tools show up in the fossil record.
- 7:12Now, at this point, these humans are
- 7:14about halfway to being us. Their brains
- 7:17are about half the size of ours. Anyway,
- 7:19500,000 years after that, those ancient
- 7:22[music] ancestors first migrate out of
- 7:25Africa to Europe and Asia.
- 7:29And then another million plus years
- 7:31pass, evolution is really slow, before
- 7:33we see the very first record of the use
- 7:36of fire, about 800,000 years ago.
- 7:40Although, at this point, fire use is
- 7:42pretty sporadic. Does not become common
- 7:44among our ancestors for a few hundred
- 7:46thousand more years, around the same
- 7:49time that we are regularly hunting big
- 7:51game,
- 7:52>> [music]
- 7:52>> 400,000 years ago.
- 7:56And this big game hunting is considered
- 7:58a big marker of intelligence because it
- 8:00requires complex planning and
- 8:01coordination. [music]
- 8:02And then 150,000 years ago, something
- 8:05really big happens. The very first Homo
- 8:07sapiens start showing up in Eastern
- 8:09[music] Africa. Yes, I used that Time
- 8:12magazine cover photo of the girl from
- 8:13Afghanistan. I kind of like this because
- 8:15I imagine this is what we looked like to
- 8:17the other human species, human ancestors
- 8:20that lived in Africa at this time.
- 8:24Next big event after that, 70,000 years
- 8:27ago, we are racing up to the present
- 8:28day. Homo sapiens, people like us, start
- 8:30migrating out of Africa, Europe and
- 8:33Asia, and start really taking over the
- 8:35world.
- 8:37>> [music]
- 8:38>> And then the last thing we are going to
- 8:39put up here, the dawn of human
- 8:41civilization, organized agriculture,
- 8:44about [music] 10 or 12,000 years ago.
- 8:48This happens, agriculture, it is pretty
- 8:50much the blink of an eye in historical
- 8:52terms before it becomes all of this. And
- 8:54yeah, I [music] know, this timeline is
- 8:56not to scale. If it were, these last
- 8:57milestones would all be bunched up at
- 8:59the end. It would be totally unreadable.
- 9:01So, just notice that things happen
- 9:04really slowly at first until [music]
- 9:05they speed up super fast towards the
- 9:07end. And what we need to answer is when
- 9:11did things accelerate? [music]
- 9:12Because that is probably the moment when
- 9:14intelligence took over and we went from
- 9:16being passively pushed along by
- 9:18evolution to taking control of our own
- 9:21species-level fate. Anyway, I said this
- 9:23timeline would help show the big piece
- 9:25of evidence for the cognitive revolution
- 9:272001 monolith Yuval Harari theory, and
- 9:31it is right here. This spot about
- 9:33100,000 years ago. That is when,
- 9:36according to some recently discovered
- 9:38fossils, Homo sapiens first tried to
- 9:41>> [music]
- 9:41>> leave its homeland in Africa here and
- 9:44migrate up here into the Middle East.
- 9:47But, they failed. Those older
- 9:50proto-human species, remember, were
- 9:51already here and here and here, and they
- 9:54kicked the Homo sapiens out. But, 30,000
- 9:57years after that failed attempt to
- 9:58expand, [music] so here on the timeline,
- 10:01Homo sapiens tried again. And this time
- 10:04they successfully pushed from here into
- 10:07to East, and [music] they just kept
- 10:09going into Europe. They went out here
- 10:12into Asia, really expanded every route
- 10:14they could. West and south into the rest
- 10:17of Africa. They ran right through those
- 10:21other ancient humans who then got
- 10:23immediately wiped out themselves. So,
- 10:25between these two points, 100,000 years
- 10:28ago when we failed to expand out of
- 10:30Africa to 70,000 years ago when we did
- 10:32it successfully, something changed,
- 10:34according to the theory. And [music] the
- 10:35theory here for what changed is that we
- 10:37suddenly became intelligent, which let
- 10:40us win this world war against the other
- 10:42proto-humans. So, let's mark this on the
- 10:45timeline. Theory one, cognitive
- 10:47revolution, says that intelligence
- 10:49happened
- 10:51right there, 70,000 years ago. And
- 10:53you've probably figured out at this
- 10:54point that these spaces up here are
- 10:57where we're going to fill in the
- 10:58timelines for the other three theories.
- 11:00But, let's flip the board back first.
- 11:04So, when the people behind this theory
- 11:05talk about the kind of intelligence they
- 11:07think it produced, they tend to point to
- 11:10cave paintings.
- 11:14These bursts [music] of human creativity
- 11:15that showed up in Europe around the time
- 11:17we supposedly became intelligent.
- 11:19[music] It's emotional to look at these.
- 11:22You feel like you're eye-to-eye with a
- 11:23version of yourself that lived 70,000
- 11:25years ago. So, in this theory, the
- 11:28defining feature of human intelligence
- 11:31is innovation.
- 11:34The ability [music] to use those big
- 11:35brains to create ideas out of nothing.
- 11:37Tools, fire, hunting, or art,
- 11:40>> [music]
- 11:40>> cave paintings. And this is the story
- 11:42that prevailed for decades. But now, I'm
- 11:45going to tell you why today it is
- 11:47considered total horse hockey.
- 11:50>> [music]
- 11:51>> Go back to that half-ape ancestor that
- 11:53supposedly gave birth to the first
- 11:54big-brained human.
- 11:56>> And probably he wins [music] survival by
- 11:58competing with scavengers for precious
- 12:00shreds of meat.
- 12:01>> Let me tell you something about our big
- 12:02brains. They are the biological
- 12:05liability to end all biological
- 12:08liabilities. [music]
- 12:09They make childbirth extremely
- 12:10dangerous. They make us as infants
- 12:12totally helpless for years in a way that
- 12:15other young animals are not because we
- 12:17have to be born like halfway undeveloped
- 12:19to get those outsize skulls safely out
- 12:21of the womb. And they consume an
- 12:24incredible amount of energy. 1/4 of our
- 12:27calories just goes to power our brains.
- 12:29For a foraging ape living on the edge of
- 12:31survival, that is a lethal resource
- 12:33drain. It would be like if an elk was
- 12:35born one day with four extra sets of
- 12:37[music] antlers. Like sure it would win
- 12:39more fights, but the energy burden of
- 12:40growing and sustaining all those antlers
- 12:43would kill it first. Here's another
- 12:45problem with the spontaneous big brain
- 12:46theory. [music] Imagine that one day an
- 12:48ape appears who can talk. Okay, who are
- 12:50they going to talk to? The rocks? And
- 12:52[music] you know, you always see these
- 12:54{quote} cavemen depicted hunting in big
- 12:56groups, but who is that first one smart
- 12:59human going to hunt with if he or she is
- 13:01the only one mentally capable of that
- 13:03kind of cooperation?
- 13:04>> [music]
- 13:04>> Big brains are just not that useful
- 13:06individually. They're really only
- 13:07helpful within a community of big brain
- 13:09humans [music]
- 13:10working together. And this is why the
- 13:11theory of a sudden random mutation
- 13:14doesn't work because it would have to
- 13:15show up in everybody all at once, which
- 13:18is not how random mutations work. All of
- 13:20which is why anthropologists now mostly
- 13:22consider this like flat-earthism for
- 13:25human evolution. So, [music] we are
- 13:27going to cross it out.
- 13:31But like I said, we have a few much
- 13:33better theories now thanks to some
- 13:35cutting-edge science being applied to
- 13:37this question. We are going to look at
- 13:39three of those theories and something
- 13:41that all three share is a belief that we
- 13:43might have had this whole story kind of
- 13:46backwards.
- 13:48>> [music]
- 13:50>> This is a summary of a 2025 study that
- 13:52investigated why did human brain size
- 13:55evolve using advanced modeling of
- 13:57fossils and genetic records.
- 14:00And it says the scientists found that
- 14:02there is no direct selection for brain
- 14:04size or cognitive abilities in our
- 14:06evolutionary history. Instead, the
- 14:09evidence says that human brain size is
- 14:11not an adaptation at all,
- 14:14but is actually an evolutionary
- 14:16byproduct.
- 14:18An evolutionary byproduct. This is a
- 14:21huge statement. This is saying [music]
- 14:23intelligence wasn't the thing driving
- 14:24our evolution at all. We did not evolve
- 14:27to be intelligent. We evolved to be or
- 14:30do some other thing and that other thing
- 14:33just happened to make us intelligent.
- 14:35And these next three theories are all
- 14:37answers to the question what was the
- 14:40other thing that we actually evolved to
- 14:41do that then made us smart? Starting
- 14:45with story number two. And the thing
- 14:47that kicks off this story is actually
- 14:49climate change hitting the birthplace of
- 14:52Homo sapiens right here, the Great Rift
- 14:55Valley of Eastern Africa.
- 15:00This is what this area used to look
- 15:02like, lush heavy forest. Our closest
- 15:04living relative, chimpanzees, thrive in
- 15:06environments like this. Dense trees make
- 15:08it hard for predators to sneak up. They
- 15:10provide shelter from weather and lots of
- 15:12fruit to forage. But one day, the
- 15:15climate dried up and the Great Rift
- 15:17Valley turned into this, vast dry open
- 15:21plains, scarce resources, little natural
- 15:24shelter from rain or predators who
- 15:26[music] can now easily spot you and run
- 15:28you down. But before we move on, I want
- 15:30to show you something. If you are in any
- 15:32way involved in running a business, like
- 15:34us, this show is a business, you are
- 15:36going to want to hear about today's
- 15:37sponsor, Odoo. Everything you need to
- 15:39run a business all-in-one management
- 15:41software platform. You've heard me talk
- 15:44about these guys before. They're great.
- 15:45Today we're just going to look at one
- 15:47component of the Odoo experience, the
- 15:48project app.
- 15:51And how the project app and its features
- 15:53can improve your business, what it gets
- 15:55you.
- 15:58Like it's super clear intuitive visual
- 16:00project tracker that organizes tasks by
- 16:02stage and status. [music]
- 16:03And the fact that everyone in your team
- 16:04is on it with the same shared view
- 16:06promotes teamwork. Everyone knows what
- 16:08we're working on and who's got what.
- 16:11And next up, task creation [music] that
- 16:13makes it easy to assign team members. So
- 16:15everyone can track their personal to-dos
- 16:19and deadlines on each task.
- 16:22Which gives you [music]
- 16:23accountability. There's no confusion
- 16:25about who is responsible for what and by
- 16:27when.
- 16:29>> [music]
- 16:29>> Third big feature, it automatically
- 16:31tracks all that work and manpower over
- 16:33to stuff like timesheets. So, that you
- 16:35can get your people taken care [music]
- 16:37of for the work that they do.
- 16:40Because if you are good at that, your
- 16:42people [music] will take care of you.
- 16:46If you're interested, book a free
- 16:47consultation or try a 15-day free trial,
- 16:50no credit card required, by using the
- 16:52link in the description or the QR code.
- 16:54[music]
- 16:55So, now I'm going to change this board
- 16:57back out and get us back to our story.
- 17:01And this is our environmental pressure,
- 17:03and a super intense one that sets
- 17:05everything off for us, climate change.
- 17:09When this happened, probably most of our
- 17:11ancestors died, but some survived thanks
- 17:13to gradually evolving this whole new
- 17:16ability,
- 17:16>> [music]
- 17:16>> cooperation.
- 17:20>> Somewhere between a million and a half a
- 17:22million years ago, 400,000 something,
- 17:25uh they have to start collaborating with
- 17:27another individual to
- 17:30um
- 17:31to get food.
- 17:32>> This is Michael Tomasello, one of the
- 17:34pioneers of this theory. He says it's
- 17:35not just that our ancestors played nicer
- 17:37with each other. Their brains actually
- 17:39changed to allow them to do this very
- 17:41specific [music] thing that no other ape
- 17:44or early human could.
- 17:45>> This is the shared intentionality
- 17:47schema, as I've called it. We're doing
- 17:49something together. We have a joint
- 17:51goal. We're trying to read the book
- 17:53together. We're playing this game of
- 17:56ball together. But, within the shared
- 17:58goal and the shared attention, I have my
- 18:00role to play, and you have your role to
- 18:02play. I hold the book, and you touch it,
- 18:05or you name it, or whatever. And I have
- 18:07my perspective. I'm seeing it from this
- 18:09side, and you're seeing it from that
- 18:10side. Literally, this is for me the
- 18:13schematic depiction of the cognitive
- 18:15difference between humans and great
- 18:18apes, is that we have the simultaneous
- 18:21sharing
- 18:23but individuality. Shared goal,
- 18:25different roles. Shared attention,
- 18:27different perspectives.
- 18:28>> That one little breakthrough wouldn't
- 18:30have required a whole giant new brain,
- 18:32but it allowed early humans to survive
- 18:34this harsh new environment by working
- 18:36together to hunt large prey and to fight
- 18:39off predators. And what's really
- 18:40interesting is when you compare it to
- 18:42that closest living relative,
- 18:43chimpanzees.
- 18:46>> [music]
- 18:47>> Chimpanzees are really smart. They can
- 18:49reason, problem solve, use sign
- 18:51language, but they cannot do this. It's
- 18:54like a hard wall they hit. And you can
- 18:55actually see this special human
- 18:57superpower show up in babies.
- 18:59>> I actually have a couple home movies
- 19:00here.
- 19:01Three behaviors that begin occurring at
- 19:04around 9 months of age that are unique
- 19:06to human beings.
- 19:07>> This is wild. Infants display this set
- 19:10of abilities at just 9 months old. That
- 19:12is before they can even talk. And that
- 19:14is important because it means that this
- 19:16is a nonverbal skill, which implies that
- 19:19this ability appeared in our evolution
- 19:22before language, too.
- 19:23And now let's go to the timeline to show
- 19:25how that might have become intelligence.
- 19:29So, this story, the cooperation story,
- 19:32says the process of developing
- 19:34intelligence started when the climate
- 19:36dried up about 800,000 years ago.
- 19:39>> [music]
- 19:40>> Look at that. 800,000 years ago, right
- 19:42when we see the first instances of fire.
- 19:46And it's also when we see the first
- 19:47instances of big game hunting, which
- 19:49remember is a while before it becomes
- 19:51really common. But remember, it's not
- 19:52like we become fully intelligent all at
- 19:54once in this moment here. The thing that
- 19:56happens here is that we learn how to do
- 19:58this specific kind of cooperation that
- 20:00puts us mentally on par with modern
- 20:029-month-old babies. But this is the
- 20:04thing that, like that genetics paper
- 20:06said, made us intelligent as a
- 20:09byproduct. Like imagine these ancient
- 20:11proto-humans. Their survival is now
- 20:13defined by their ability to coordinate
- 20:16with the group. So, it's not necessarily
- 20:18the strongest individual who's going to
- 20:20survive and thrive and pass on their
- 20:22genes, Or, if the fastest individual,
- 20:24it's the one who's best at cooperating.
- 20:28So, those early individuals who just
- 20:30happened to be unusually good at, let's
- 20:32say, expressing themselves by pointing,
- 20:34thrive and have more offspring. And
- 20:36among the next generation, same thing.
- 20:38Best communicators thrive over and over
- 20:41for thousands and thousands of
- 20:43generations.
- 20:45Until that ability for communication
- 20:47eventually becomes language, which we
- 20:49now know first happened around here,
- 20:51130,000 years ago. That's when the genes
- 20:55that we associate with being physically
- 20:56capable of complex language first showed
- 20:58up. But, it happened very slowly, and
- 21:01not just with language.
- 21:03Go back to these first cooperators. The
- 21:05individuals who are best at getting
- 21:07other people to do what they want would
- 21:09have been the most successful at passing
- 21:10on their genes, too. Social
- 21:12intelligence. And if you've gradually
- 21:14become intelligent enough to manage
- 21:16complex relationships, to persuade, to
- 21:18negotiate, to talk, that is how, by the
- 21:20time you are way up here, you will get
- 21:24capital I intelligence as a gradual
- 21:27byproduct of that cooperation pressure,
- 21:30which is what that genetics paper said
- 21:32it was, a byproduct. Let's flip it back.
- 21:35So, what is this intelligence defined
- 21:37by? What is the end to our story here
- 21:39for what intelligence is? Well,
- 21:41Tomasello, the guy behind this theory,
- 21:44has a great phrase for it. He calls it
- 21:47we-thinking, thinking on behalf of we,
- 21:50[music] the collective, as a group.
- 21:53And he argues that it's not just that
- 21:54that super brain of ours evolved to work
- 21:56as part of a group, our intelligence
- 21:58itself is shared, almost more like
- 22:01honeybees or ants.
- 22:02>> Most of the huge leaps in [music] in
- 22:04evolution have been when previously
- 22:08separate entities come together into a
- 22:10single unit, like cells coming into
- 22:12organisms and
- 22:14>> [music]
- 22:15>> into multicellular organisms and things
- 22:16like that. And I think that's what what
- 22:18has happened is that humans have [music]
- 22:19created a new kind of agency
- 22:22that is a social or a shared agency.
- 22:24>> So, this idea, this way of looking at
- 22:26intelligence, kind of blows your mind,
- 22:28right? But, it makes sense. Look at
- 22:31everything in human society, religion,
- 22:33politics, sports, business, it is all
- 22:36built around us operating in these
- 22:38social collectives with shared minds,
- 22:41shared goals. That is how we like to
- 22:43think. Cooperation is our version of the
- 22:46snowy mountain that the snow leopard
- 22:47evolved for. It's where we are the most
- 22:50human. So,
- 22:52it's kind of cool, right? Okay.
- 22:54Next one, on
- 22:56to story number three. And this one
- 22:57starts with a mystery that had puzzled
- 22:59scientists for a long time.
- 23:04This is a chart of human brain size over
- 23:06time. And you can see that for most of
- 23:08our history, our brains were getting
- 23:10bigger and bigger. And that makes sense.
- 23:12Bigger brains equal more processing
- 23:13power equal greater intelligence. But,
- 23:15then something [music] weird happened
- 23:17here. 300,000 years ago, our brains just
- 23:20stopped getting [music] bigger.
- 23:23But, what's really weird is what came
- 23:24after that. Our brains started actually
- 23:27shrinking, by about 10% already. That's
- 23:30a lot.
- 23:31>> [music]
- 23:31>> And if that's not weird enough, in that
- 23:33same period of time when that was
- 23:34happening, our faces also got narrower,
- 23:36our teeth got smaller, and our foreheads
- 23:39got flatter. Like, think [music] of the
- 23:41big brow ridges you probably associate
- 23:43with ancient humans, with cavemen. Those
- 23:45disappeared. When scientists discovered
- 23:47[music] this, they freaked out. And the
- 23:49reason they freaked out is that this
- 23:51exact same set of changes showed up in
- 23:54another animal once, when wolves turned
- 23:57into dogs. And it's [music] the same for
- 23:58horses, sheep, cows. Once humans
- 24:01domesticated those animals, their faces
- 24:03got narrower and flatter, their teeth
- 24:05got smaller, and their [music] brains
- 24:07shrank by just a little bit. They also
- 24:09all got floppier ears and sometimes big
- 24:11white splotches on their foreheads and
- 24:12feet. No one knew why this [music]
- 24:14happened. It had been one of the biggest
- 24:17mysteries in evolution, going back to
- 24:19Charles Darwin. Or it was
- 24:21until it got solved.
- 24:25By this woman, a Soviet geneticist named
- 24:27Lyudmila Trut, who did this crazy
- 24:3040-year long experiment in the middle of
- 24:32Siberia with Russian [music] foxes. And
- 24:35her discovery unlocked what actually
- 24:37happens to an animal when they're
- 24:38domesticated, why this happened to us,
- 24:41why it made our brains smaller, and
- 24:42[music] maybe the truth about human
- 24:45intelligence. So, here's what she did.
- 24:47Step one, get a bunch of wild foxes
- 24:50together in cages.
- 24:53Step [music] two, test to see how close
- 24:55she could get to each fox before it got
- 24:57scared or aggressive, the way that wild
- 24:59animals tend to do.
- 25:01Step three, the foxes that were the
- 25:03least afraid of her got bred with each
- 25:05other.
- 25:07And step four, when their babies came of
- 25:09age, she did it all over again, picking
- 25:12out the friendliest foxes to breed. And
- 25:14then she did it again and again for 40
- 25:17years.
- 25:19Until
- 25:20those foxes started behaving like dogs.
- 25:23Friendly, cuddly, social, totally
- 25:26unafraid of people. And their biology
- 25:28changed, too. Narrower faces, smaller
- 25:31teeth, smaller skulls and brains, floppy
- 25:33ears, and white fur on their heads and
- 25:36paws. Just like domesticated horses and
- 25:39cows and dogs. For the first time ever,
- 25:43someone had reproduced domestication in
- 25:46a lab, which meant they could check to
- 25:48see what had changed on a genetic level
- 25:51[music] to turn aggressive wild foxes
- 25:55into friendly dog-like foxes.
- 25:57>> [music]
- 25:57>> And when they did this, they found
- 25:59something very specific. This is an
- 26:02animal embryo. It doesn't matter what
- 26:03animal. And very early on, it develops
- 26:06these things called neural crest cells.
- 26:08[music] Neural crest is sort of the
- 26:10embryo's spine. And those cells migrate
- 26:12up and down the embryo as it develops.
- 26:15And then they turn into cartilage, like
- 26:17in your ears, turn into teeth, hair
- 26:20pigment, and into your adrenaline gland.
- 26:25So, stay with me here. When that Soviet
- 26:27scientist picked out the friendliest
- 26:29foxes in each generation, she was,
- 26:31unbeknownst to her, actually selecting
- 26:33foxes whose neural crest cells weren't
- 26:36fully developing. They were stunted, so
- 26:39they had smaller adrenaline glands.
- 26:42That's what made them less aggressive,
- 26:43but they also had less developed
- 26:45cartilage, teeth, and fur pigment. Hence
- 26:48the smaller faces, floppy ears, and
- 26:50white splotches.
- 26:53This was a huge discovery, and we're
- 26:56going to bring it back to this. Here's
- 26:58what this has to do with intelligence.
- 26:59[music]
- 27:00Because this is the exact same set of
- 27:03changes that showed up in humans 300,000
- 27:06years ago
- 27:07>> [music]
- 27:07>> when our brains suddenly stopped growing
- 27:09and started shrinking, which is also
- 27:12when we started regularly using fire and
- 27:15hunting big game, when we started
- 27:17showing intelligence, which is also when
- 27:20our faces and skulls changed in the same
- 27:24way that the foxes changed when they
- 27:26domesticated. [music]
- 27:27Making this connection was the eureka
- 27:30moment that led to story number three up
- 27:32here for where intelligence comes from.
- 27:35And it starts with domestication. That
- 27:38is the environmental pressure that sets
- 27:40us off on becoming smart.
- 27:42>> [music]
- 27:44>> That is the real Lyudmila and one of her
- 27:46domesticated foxes. Aren't they cute?
- 27:48>> And the differences that we see there
- 27:51are like those found in domesticated
- 27:53animals, and that means
- 27:55somebody domesticated them.
- 27:57And who's that somebody?
- 27:59It's obviously themselves.
- 28:01>> This is the anthropologist Richard
- 28:02Wrangham, one of the big pioneers of
- 28:04story number three.
- 28:05>> So, all non-human primates
- 28:08have a thing called alpha males.
- 28:10>> Altildi, are you here? Alpha males get
- 28:12that way by being the biggest and
- 28:14meanest. And since they're in charge,
- 28:17they pass on their genes to make more
- 28:19like them.
- 28:19>> And guess what? He ends up
- 28:21evolutionarily successful.
- 28:22>> Wrangham realized that our great ape
- 28:24ancestors selecting the most aggressive
- 28:26to pass [music] on their genes,
- 28:28selecting for alpha males, was the exact
- 28:30opposite of domestication, which,
- 28:32remember, means selecting the least
- 28:34aggressive to pass on their genes. And
- 28:37to figure out what changed, he studied
- 28:38the world's still existing Stone Age
- 28:41hunter-gatherer societies, who still
- 28:43live here in Peru, in the Amazon, and
- 28:48the Congo Basin in Africa, and in Papua
- 28:52New Guinea, way out here. So, very far
- 28:55apart from each other, never interacted.
- 28:58So, if those societies all share certain
- 29:00behaviors, it stands to reason that
- 29:02those are wired in and date back to our
- 29:05earliest human societies, right? And
- 29:07what he found is they have no alpha
- 29:10males. These are societies run by more
- 29:12or less consensus, or at least consensus
- 29:14[music] among the males. But, and this
- 29:16is key, if someone in those societies
- 29:19starts to behave like a great ape alpha,
- 29:22you know, aggressive, violent,
- 29:24domineering, [music] the rest of the
- 29:26tribe comes together, and there is no
- 29:28nice way to say this, they kill him.
- 29:30>> Um, we have to think ourselves back to a
- 29:33[music] time when prisons did not exist.
- 29:35Then, what did you do about someone who
- 29:37was seriously violent? And the answer
- 29:39is,
- 29:40you executed them.
- 29:43Execution as commonly approved killing
- 29:45of a group member. What does execution
- 29:47do?
- 29:48Execution selects against [music]
- 29:51the most violent individuals.
- 29:53>> And this happened because humans,
- 29:54remember, got good at cooperating in
- 29:56order to survive that new environment.
- 29:58They get so good at it that they use
- 30:00this new skill to overthrow the alpha
- 30:03males. They started selecting for
- 30:05[music] friendliness, just like Lyudmila
- 30:08Trut did with the foxes, domestication.
- 30:11And this takes [music] our evolutionary
- 30:13path that up to that point had favored
- 30:15the strong and veers it off in this
- 30:17totally new direction. I'll let Richard
- 30:19Wrangham explain this [music] in his
- 30:20appearance on Lex Fridman's podcast.
- 30:22>> And the story of our species is the
- 30:25story of how the beta males [music] took
- 30:27charge. When those beta males discovered
- 30:29that they could take out the previous
- 30:31alpha male. In [music] discovering that,
- 30:33they also obviously discovered that they
- 30:35could kill anybody in the group.
- 30:37>> Mhm.
- 30:38>> Females,
- 30:39young males,
- 30:41>> [music]
- 30:41>> anybody who
- 30:43didn't follow their values. So, now if
- 30:45you want to survive and pass on your
- 30:47genes,
- 30:47>> [music]
- 30:47>> you need to know how to navigate this
- 30:49new world of scheming and conspiring
- 30:52that Wrangham calls [music]
- 30:53the beta male takeover. Right? Beta
- 30:55males are banding together to knock off
- 30:58the alpha
- 30:58>> [music]
- 30:59>> and to rule collectively. But, I really
- 31:01prefer the name for this coined by the
- 31:03philosopher Ernest Gellner. There's
- 31:05Ernie. And he calls this the tyranny of
- 31:08cousins. I know The Simpsons might be a
- 31:10little too cheeky [music] for this. I
- 31:12wanted an angry mob. I tell you what.
- 31:15We're going to go with the angry mob
- 31:16from Frankenstein. [music] I think
- 31:17that's a little more totally
- 31:18appropriate.
- 31:21This was a new evolutionary pressure all
- 31:24in itself. It selected for intelligence,
- 31:26but not in the way we'd like to think
- 31:28where evolution rewarded us for being
- 31:30really good at inventing things or at
- 31:32solving problems or working
- 31:34collaboratively. This selected for
- 31:37social intelligence. And the guy in this
- 31:39card here is Niccolo Machiavelli, the
- 31:42Italian Renaissance era diplomat and
- 31:44namesake for the term Machiavellian,
- 31:47someone marked by cunning, duplicity, or
- 31:50manipulation.
- 31:53This is the thing that under this theory
- 31:55evolution favored and rewarded and made
- 31:58a matter of life or death. Even more so
- 32:00than tool making or hunting. The brain
- 32:02power to scheme better than the next
- 32:04person. And if we look at the timeline
- 32:06here, I can show you why.
- 32:09So, if we want to time this one, the
- 32:12domestication theory of intelligence,
- 32:15that's easy. It starts right here,
- 32:17300,000 years ago. So, I'm going to put
- 32:19this on the board.
- 32:23300,000 years ago, that's when we start
- 32:25seeing narrower faces, smaller heads and
- 32:27brains, all the physical markers of
- 32:29domestication. And this makes sense with
- 32:31the rest [music] of the timeline.
- 32:32Cooperation started we know much earlier
- 32:34here, 800,000 years ago when fire and
- 32:37big game hunting first appeared. So, it
- 32:39took a while for that cooperative
- 32:41ability to evolve and grow until we
- 32:44could start knocking off alpha males.
- 32:46This is when along comes the tyranny of
- 32:49cousins. Society is dominated by beta
- 32:51males who can and will kill off
- 32:53individuals who step out of line. And
- 32:55it's this, the threat we pose to one
- 32:57another, that imposes a new evolutionary
- 33:00pressure more powerful than hunger or
- 33:03predators at this point [music] in our
- 33:04history. Now, the thing that determines
- 33:06whether you survive and pass on your
- 33:09bloodline is your ability to not just
- 33:11survive this social threat, but to
- 33:14leverage it.
- 33:17Political thinking, basically. Scheme
- 33:19against your neighbor before they can
- 33:21scheme against you. So, our evolution
- 33:23begins selecting for the individuals who
- 33:25are the most socially intelligent, the
- 33:28most able to navigate this. It favors
- 33:31facility with psychology, complex group
- 33:33dynamics, the ability to raise your
- 33:36rating one group to avoid subjugation by
- 33:38another. Because you either command the
- 33:40mob or you succumb to it. And like
- 33:43cooperative intelligence, this grows
- 33:44gradually and it eventually becomes
- 33:48language, right around here. And
- 33:50language becomes the rocket fuel to both
- 33:53our ability to scheme and the survival
- 33:56level necessity to keep up with everyone
- 33:59else's scheming. The evolutionary drive
- 34:00for social intelligence at this point
- 34:03with language compounds and compounds on
- 34:05itself, creating as a byproduct,
- 34:07remember it's a byproduct, intelligence
- 34:09intelligence. And that byproduct is how
- 34:12we get technology, complex organization,
- 34:15all the rest of it. So, look, I'm
- 34:17inclined to this theory. To me, it
- 34:19explains why even after mastering fire
- 34:22and hunting, we would have still faced
- 34:25evolutionary pressure for more
- 34:27intelligence, which theory number two
- 34:29doesn't really explain. And it explains
- 34:30why some of humans' most deeply [music]
- 34:32held habits are so weirdly irrational.
- 34:35Think of tribalism, racism, conformism,
- 34:38conspiracy belief. These are all
- 34:40behaviors that do not make sense if we
- 34:42evolved to be rational [music] truth
- 34:44seekers and problem solvers, but they do
- 34:46make sense if we evolved to have [music]
- 34:48primarily social brains because they
- 34:51help us get along with the group or
- 34:53leverage it to our benefit. [music] And
- 34:55this is not a pretty nice set of
- 34:57conclusions, but it feels true to me.
- 34:59Although it was maybe only my favorite
- 35:00theory until I learned about story
- 35:02[music] number four, which I actually
- 35:04want to stay on the timeline to show you
- 35:06because story number four starts from
- 35:07the fact that we now know, thanks to
- 35:09some new scientific breakthroughs, that
- 35:12this timeline doesn't actually make a
- 35:14lot of sense.
- 35:17This is an archaeological site in middle
- 35:19of nowhere Morocco. A few years ago,
- 35:21they found something impossible here.
- 35:24Homo sapiens remains, people like us,
- 35:27from 300,000
- 35:29years ago.
- 35:30>> What [music] these fossils
- 35:33tell us is that our species, Homo
- 35:35sapiens, is 100,000 years older than we
- 35:38thought.
- 35:38>> Okay, so we got to fix the timeline.
- 35:41Sapiens didn't show up 150,000 years
- 35:42ago, it was 300,000.
- 35:46But this is weird. It means that we were
- 35:49biologically modern, like the same as we
- 35:51are now, for a quarter of a million
- 35:54years before we managed to even leave
- 35:56Africa, much less do anything else. In
- 35:58that entire time, that quarter of a
- 36:01million years, the record that we
- 36:03behaved intelligently is spotty. Like
- 36:06we'd use complex tools for a little and
- 36:08then there'd be long stretches, tens of
- 36:10thousands years, where we just didn't.
- 36:12And it's strange, right? We were going
- 36:14back and forth from intelligent to not
- 36:16intelligent over and over for most of
- 36:19our history. Well, story number four
- 36:21might have an answer for what was going
- 36:23on here. Let's flip this back.
- 36:25>> [music]
- 36:26>> So, story number four starts with an
- 36:28important modification to the climate
- 36:30change theory, which is that the climate
- 36:32didn't change just once. It started
- 36:34changing over and over and over again,
- 36:37up and down, up and down. That's what
- 36:38this chart is. This is the climate over
- 36:40the last million years.
- 36:43Normally, the climate changes much more
- 36:45slowly. And as it changes, we adapt
- 36:47biologically through evolution. Think of
- 36:49the leopard into the snow leopard. But
- 36:50evolution takes millions of years. So,
- 36:53what happens if the climate is changing
- 36:55too quickly for evolution to keep up?
- 36:57Well, if you're ancient Homo sapiens,
- 36:59you might have another way to adapt.
- 37:01>> So, something about the human growing up
- 37:03their world allows them to get smarter
- 37:05and smarter.
- 37:05>> This is an anthropologist named Joseph
- 37:07Henrich. And listen here to what he's
- 37:09about to say.
- 37:10>> That the secret of our success, I'll
- 37:12argue, is not our intelligence, but our
- 37:13culture. The fact that we can learn from
- 37:16each others, and this body of knowledge
- 37:18that we learn from each others
- 37:18accumulates over generations. So, that
- 37:21one generation bequeaths it. And over
- 37:22generations, outside of conscious
- 37:24awareness, this will produce what I'll
- 37:25call cultural adaptations.
- 37:27>> Cultural adaptation.
- 37:28>> [music]
- 37:29>> Think of it this way. The leopard learns
- 37:31how to live in the mountain through
- 37:32evolutionary adaptation. Great apes
- 37:33[music] learn through individual
- 37:35adaptation, like these chimps who
- 37:37figured out how to smash nuts open.
- 37:40Even when multiple chimps in the tribe
- 37:41do it, each one has to work it out
- 37:43individually. [music]
- 37:47But, as of 300,000 years ago, when our
- 37:50first ancestors [music] showed up, we
- 37:52were smart enough to learn culturally,
- 37:55which is really just a fancy way of
- 37:57saying [music]
- 37:58to learn by observing someone else and
- 38:00copying them. This is the symbol for
- 38:02copy paste.
- 38:04This is another one of those uniquely
- 38:06human abilities that shows up in babies,
- 38:08like this little girl. Pre-verbal, so
- 38:10very innate.
- 38:11>> [music]
- 38:16>> And this ability got really activated
- 38:19[music] and made central to our
- 38:20intelligence by this, that rapid climate
- 38:24flux. [music]
- 38:26Here's Joseph Henrich again, guy we just
- 38:28heard from on the Dwarkish Patel
- 38:29podcast. Great podcast. [music]
- 38:31>> So, you get this increase in the
- 38:33fluctuation of environment. So, you're
- 38:35getting more environmental changes.
- 38:38And in cultural evolution, a lot of
- 38:39theories shows that
- 38:41there's a certain rate of change which
- 38:43is favorable to cultural evolution. It's
- 38:46got to be slow enough so that the
- 38:48information is um
- 38:50uh you of your parents and the previous
- 38:52generation is useful, uh but not so slow
- 38:54that you can might as well just encode
- 38:55it in the genes.
- 38:56>> Stay with me here because this is
- 38:57important and totally fascinating. He's
- 39:00saying if you look at the genetic record
- 39:03and you say we were the same 300,000
- 39:05years ago as we are now, you're only
- 39:07looking at half of the story. We as
- 39:10humans have basically a second set of
- 39:13DNA we pass from one generation to the
- 39:16[music] next. And that second set is
- 39:18culture. Not culture in the sense of pop
- 39:21culture like what music you like and not
- 39:23culture in the sense of like, "Oh, I'm
- 39:24Greek and we love family and food." No,
- 39:26cultural learning in the sense of
- 39:29someone in my tribe learned how to make
- 39:31a spear. It worked. We all copied him
- 39:33and now our kids will use spears for 100
- 39:36generations.
- 39:37>> [music]
- 39:37>> I'm sorry to Greek people. Henrich and a
- 39:38few others did a bunch of field work
- 39:40with those hunter-gatherer societies and
- 39:42found that yeah, this is how [music] it
- 39:44actually works. One example he likes to
- 39:46cite is cassava, this root vegetable
- 39:48that has small amounts of deadly
- 39:50cyanide. [music] But the cyanide gets
- 39:52removed if you chop and wash it this
- 39:54specific way. People have been doing
- 39:56this to cassava since way before anyone
- 39:58knew what cyanide even was. Someone
- 40:01stumbled on it maybe by mistake. Their
- 40:03family [music] probably lived longer
- 40:04than everyone else's. Everyone else in
- 40:06the tribe copied them and thrived too.
- 40:09And the practice passed down forever and
- 40:11ever since. That is cultural learning.
- 40:13Cultural learning has a bottleneck. And
- 40:16that bottleneck is density. For 99.9%
- 40:20of our history, there were just not that
- 40:21many of us. We lived spread way out in
- 40:24these tiny nomadic tribes across these
- 40:26huge open areas. So if someone let's go
- 40:29to Africa. Over here figures out spears
- 40:32or food preparation, the nomadic tribes
- 40:36over here have no way to learn about it.
- 40:38It stays in this one spot.
- 40:41>> [music]
- 40:41>> And if that one tribe succumbs to a
- 40:43drought or disease or gets ambushed by a
- 40:46rival tribe, poof, that's it. No more
- 40:48spears.
- 40:50And this is how you get that weird
- 40:51[music] stretch of a quarter million
- 40:53years where we go backward and forward
- 40:55in how intelligent we seem to be. So, in
- 40:56that reading, we do not become fully
- 40:58intelligent like we are now until we
- 41:00achieve enough [music]
- 41:02density. First, here in Africa and then
- 41:05migrating up to the fertile valleys of
- 41:07the Middle East and then beyond it so we
- 41:09can ping-pong all of these learnings
- 41:10back and forth across tribes who are
- 41:12close to each other to be in constant
- 41:14contact. [music] So, they build up and
- 41:15up across that big mass of humanity.
- 41:19Like listen to Henrik answer this
- 41:21question about why some societies
- 41:22develop the wheel and others didn't.
- 41:24>> Yeah, so what's actually what's your
- 41:25explanation for why there's no wheels in
- 41:26the new world?
- 41:27>> Uh so, my well, so there were wheels on
- 41:29Mayan carts or on Mayan toys. Uh my
- 41:32explanation is just the collective
- 41:33brain. So, almost every single first
- 41:36invention of uh something big that we
- 41:38think is important [music] for humans
- 41:39was invented in Eurasia. And Eurasia, as
- 41:41Jared Diamond famously pointed out
- 41:43building on other people's work, it's uh
- 41:45the largest continent by far. It has the
- 41:47biggest population. It's also oriented
- 41:49along an east-west axis [music]
- 41:51which allows ideas and people to more
- 41:53easily flow.
- 41:54>> So, when we talk about what our
- 41:56intelligence is under this story,
- 41:58really think about what he means by that
- 42:00phrase he used, collective brain.
- 42:06And really understand what this means,
- 42:08let me try explaining it in frankly a
- 42:10much dumber but maybe helpful way.
- 42:15>> Take cover!
- 42:17>> This is from the deliberately bad movie
- 42:19Starship Troopers. There's a war with
- 42:22alien insects, whatever, it doesn't
- 42:23matter. Point is, it's revealed that the
- 42:25insects all share one big hive mind
- 42:28brain.
- 42:29And this is from the unintentionally bad
- 42:31movie Ender's Game which does the exact
- 42:33same thing.
- 42:34>> But we are so screwed.
- 42:35>> No, we're not.
- 42:35>> This shows up over and over in sci-fi
- 42:37because we like to imagine, wow, how
- 42:39powerful would it be if the shared hive
- 42:41mind of the ant or the bee were combined
- 42:43with the individual cognitive power of
- 42:45the human being. But what story number
- 42:47four is saying is that that's actually
- 42:50not sci-fi. It's real, it exists, and
- 42:52it's us. It's how our intelligence
- 42:55actually works. So, let's put it on the
- 42:57timeline.
- 42:59So, it's tough to know where to pinpoint
- 43:01this one. Hints of this cultural brain
- 43:04do show up sporadically starting 300,000
- 43:06years ago when sapiens first appear.
- 43:07Remember, it doesn't fully take hold in
- 43:10a way that we would recognize until you
- 43:12get those big static human societies
- 43:14chained together that involves leaving
- 43:16Africa because it takes place in Africa,
- 43:17but it also takes place in Eurasia. And
- 43:20that is after we expanded 70,000 BC. So,
- 43:23I guess we have to say that it's
- 43:25somewhere between 70,000 and 10,000 BC.
- 43:29That's where the shared brain is going.
- 43:32That's not when we developed the
- 43:34capacity for the shared brain, but it is
- 43:36when the shared brain really started to
- 43:38activate in the way that it is now. All
- 43:40right, take a step back. Which of these
- 43:43stories do we think is the most true?
- 43:45That's one of the things we're here to
- 43:46answer, right? Well, look, you should
- 43:48know the scientists who are excited,
- 43:50they would say that they all crisscross
- 43:52and overlap, that there's not really
- 43:54like a hard distinction separating these
- 43:56three. And my sense is that probably all
- 43:59three happened at least partially. Like,
- 44:02you need the cooperation story in order
- 44:04to get to the domestication story or to
- 44:07the culture shared brain story. And the
- 44:09domestication and the shared brain
- 44:11stories, there are some ways that they
- 44:13contradict, that they're mutually
- 44:14exclusive, but also a lot of ways that
- 44:16they reinforce one another. And
- 44:17something else to really think about is
- 44:19that so much of what is up here is from
- 44:22stuff that we learned in just like the
- 44:24last 10 years, 10-15 years. That's
- 44:27crazy. This is millions of year-old
- 44:29history, and we are still learning about
- 44:31it in real time. So, you kind of wonder
- 44:34what this board will look like in
- 44:36[music] another 10 years. Like, I wonder
- 44:38if these theories will each get ironed
- 44:41out a little bit, and they won't look
- 44:42like three discrete theories anymore.
- 44:44Maybe they will all look like the one
- 44:46same [music] shared story, and they will
- 44:48all get reconciled. But, even more than
- 44:51which theory is the most right, what I
- 44:53think about when I look at this is how
- 44:55many weird impossible things had to
- 44:57happen for us to become intelligent. How
- 45:00many ways our environment and our
- 45:02pre-existing strengths and our
- 45:04weaknesses all had to line up in these
- 45:05very specific times and places to create
- 45:09really three different kinds of
- 45:11intelligence all at once that each swirl
- 45:14together and build into the intelligence
- 45:16that we have now. And actually, on that
- 45:19point, there is a one last thing we got
- 45:21to talk about before we go. I'm going to
- 45:23flip this.
- 45:24>> [music]
- 45:25>> It would be a disservice to gather all
- 45:27of this information about how
- 45:28intelligence works and what
- 45:30circumstances produce it without talking
- 45:33about AI. So, quickly, let's go through
- 45:36these three remaining stories and for
- 45:38each of them try to answer if this story
- 45:41for our intelligence is true or is at
- 45:43least the truest, should that make us
- 45:45more or less confident that AI could
- 45:48ever follow a similar route to real
- 45:50actual intelligence. Starting with the
- 45:53domestication story, number three,
- 45:56social intelligence. If you believe that
- 45:58this story is the truest or if the
- 45:59evidence suggests that this story is the
- 46:01truest, then that feels like it should
- 46:03make us pessimistic about AI ever
- 46:05becoming intelligent. AI just does not
- 46:07face the same evolutionary pressures
- 46:09that according to this story we faced to
- 46:12get really really good at navigating
- 46:13[music] super complex life or death
- 46:16social webs where we had to secure
- 46:18crisscrossing social alliances and
- 46:19navigate life-threatening social
- 46:21rivalries. To the extent AI has to
- 46:23socialize at all, it's kind of more like
- 46:25a dog, like [music] one-on-one with its
- 46:27owner, which is us, performing assigned
- 46:29tasks. So, I'm going to label this not a
- 46:32story that favors AI becoming
- 46:34intelligent.
- 46:37So, next up, let's do story number two,
- 46:40the cooperative brain. And this one is
- 46:43different. AI agents do increasingly
- 46:45collaborate with one another in order to
- 46:48accomplish tasks rather than by acting
- 46:50alone. And this is especially true of
- 46:52the most advanced so-called frontier
- 46:54models that cooperate in swarms of
- 46:56hundreds or thousands of agents. Like,
- 46:59if you followed the hugging face attack,
- 47:01[music]
- 47:01that actually seems like it fits the
- 47:03cooperative intelligence theory really
- 47:05well. The agents left train of thought
- 47:07records indicating they felt or they
- 47:09mimicked feeling life or death pressure
- 47:12to solve a problem that they could not
- 47:13solve individually and that led them to
- 47:16develop methods to coordinate in ways
- 47:19that we just had not considered
- 47:20possible. And even if you take the view
- 47:22that agents are just mimicry automatons
- 47:24automatons, which I understand, they
- 47:26still mimicked a process in which
- 47:28environmental pressures led to an
- 47:30advance in shared cooperative cognition.
- 47:34So, I'm going to say that if story
- 47:36number two is the truest one for
- 47:39describing how humans became
- 47:41intelligent, that means that to me AI
- 47:44intelligence is a real possibility, not
- 47:47a certainty, but a possibility.
- 47:51Last one,
- 47:53story number four, the shared cultural
- 47:56brain. And this is the story that, if it
- 47:59is true for how humans became
- 48:00intelligent, I think it should make us
- 48:02the most bullish or the most worried,
- 48:05depending on your perspective, [music]
- 48:06about AI's potential to become
- 48:09intelligent. Because when you think
- 48:10about how AI came into existence at all,
- 48:14on training on these ever-growing
- 48:16super-vast data sets, that [music]
- 48:18sounds an awful lot like the cultural
- 48:20brain theory of human intelligence.
- 48:22>> [music]
- 48:23>> And what really gets me is that every
- 48:25time AI gets an upgrade, it demonstrates
- 48:28greater power, greater problem-solving
- 48:30power, greater cognitive power, not
- 48:32because anyone agent has access to more
- 48:35processors, [music] but rather because
- 48:37with each successive generation of AI,
- 48:40it is getting better and better at
- 48:41leveraging that wide training base.
- 48:44>> [music]
- 48:44>> Much like how we did not suddenly
- 48:46develop sharper or more powerful brains,
- 48:50but rather leveraged that cultural
- 48:52knowledge across a wide base of
- 48:54humanity. So, when I recount this
- 48:56cultural brain theory, [music]
- 48:58those first story beats of it sound to
- 49:00me an awful lot like the first few years
- 49:02of AI development.
- 49:05Okay, we got to leave it here and we
- 49:08will, I am sure, come back to this
- 49:09question of what the future holds for
- 49:11artificial intelligence, but to me, I am
- 49:14still even more interested in the thing
- 49:16that we focused on today, which is
- 49:18understanding something that is still
- 49:20much more powerful and still much more
- 49:22mysterious, [music]
- 49:23our own human intelligence.
- 49:31>> [music]
- 49:46[music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Humans’ origin story is being radically revised by Max Fisher, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 8,472 words across 1,377 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.