How Top Prop Traders Find and Scale Their Edge · Jeff Holden — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00And so even in these these simple
- 0:01reading the tape lessons that we're
- 0:03doing, we're talking about where to put
- 0:05your attention and your focus, which is
- 0:07the biggest challenge for I think
- 0:09traders in general. Where is your focus?
- 0:11Where is your attention? You know, all
- 0:12of us are governed by a couple basic
- 0:15principles of every single trader has a
- 0:17timeline. Whether or not you're going to
- 0:18make more money where to the point where
- 0:20you can, you know, never have to trade
- 0:22again or you're going to, you know,
- 0:24completely lose all the money you have.
- 0:26Like there's still a timeline. There's a
- 0:28finite amount of time that all of us
- 0:30will get the opportunity to trade. So,
- 0:32we're reviewing it time and time again.
- 0:33So, when we say A plus B equals C, your
- 0:37career, right? A plus plus B, you know,
- 0:40of your baseline equals a trading
- 0:42career. We're talking about you have to
- 0:44develop a baseline of strategies. And
- 0:46that's the thing that that a lot of
- 0:48independent traders need to do first is
- 0:51you need to get to the point where you
- 0:53have a baseline set of strategies where
- 0:55you're going to build out your runway.
- 0:58>> So Jeff question here. I mean this is
- 1:00this is fascinating to me because let's
- 1:02take let's take a trader that's trading
- 1:04maybe the baseline trade or a C trade
- 1:07where I saw with you know you have
- 1:09different dynamic risk allocation. I
- 1:11believe A was 80% of the daily stop
- 1:13>> uh A+. Yeah. So yeah. So, if you're
- 1:16talking about like like our risk
- 1:17allocation, so that this is we're we're
- 1:19getting deep really fast. So, I hope
- 1:20we're not losing people and and that's
- 1:22okay. You know, like everything we
- 1:24always say that the first couple weeks
- 1:25is like drinking from the fire hose
- 1:27here, right? So, like there's a lot
- 1:28thrown at you really quickly and we're
- 1:30going very deep much faster than I I
- 1:32think I've ever done it in any
- 1:33conversation. If I put risk on for every
- 1:37time my gut talked to me, I would not be
- 1:39a profitable trader [laughter]
- 1:41because my gut talks to me all the time
- 1:44and every trader I know, their gut talks
- 1:46to them all the time about this is maybe
- 1:49this is a good idea. Maybe this is a
- 1:50good idea. And so we need that extra
- 1:52check. And so that's why we created that
- 1:54asset protocol because if you can't
- 1:56actually articulate it and turn it into
- 1:57a trade, then you're just kind of
- 2:00trading off of a feel that is, you know,
- 2:03not really there. But if you turn it
- 2:05into a trade idea, then you've actually
- 2:07got a plan to move forward. And if that
- 2:09plan doesn't happen, you just can't
- 2:11execute, right? At the end of the day,
- 2:13trading is this thing that we get to do.
- 2:15And so that equinimity kind of gets
- 2:17built into you when you think about how
- 2:19this fits. We're all so lucky to be
- 2:22traders in the time that we're that
- 2:24we're traders. You know, 30 years ago,
- 2:2625 years ago, you basically had to be on
- 2:29a floor at an exchange. So, that meant
- 2:31you had to live in New York, Chicago,
- 2:33London, you know, and maybe a couple
- 2:35other places in the world, plus have a
- 2:38seat on the exchange to be able to trade
- 2:40the way we get to trade. I think at the
- 2:41end of the day, if there's one thing
- 2:44that that traders have to get right at
- 2:46every level, I think you have to always
- 2:49be what would your trading look like if
- 2:51capital wasn't the constraint. That's
- 2:53the reality for most traders. It's not
- 2:55skill holding them back. It's size.
- 2:58Trade the pool changes that. Step into
- 3:00the US equity markets with up to
- 3:02$200,000 in buying power without
- 3:04committing your own capital. Full access
- 3:06to stocks and ETFs, long or short,
- 3:09executed with the precision and freedom
- 3:11serious traders expect. Your performance
- 3:13is measured by one standard. Disciplined
- 3:15risk management and consistent
- 3:16execution. Meet that standard and you
- 3:19operate at scale. No subscriptions, no
- 3:21ongoing obligations, just a clear path
- 3:24forward. For those ready to trade beyond
- 3:26limitations, this is the next level.
- 3:30Markets, speculation, [music] and risk.
- 3:33This is the Chat with Traders podcast.
- 3:36>> [music]
- 3:38>> Traders, welcome to an exciting episode
- 3:41of Chat with Traders. Now, I don't know
- 3:43how he has not been on Chat with Traders
- 3:45before. Jeff Holden, the head of trader
- 3:48development over at SMB Capital. He has
- 3:50helped identify, recruit, and really
- 3:52take traders to the next level. He's
- 3:55helped develop traders into seven and
- 3:56eight figure traders. So yesterday we
- 3:58actually were on the phone and he we
- 4:00were talking and talking about the
- 4:01direction we're going to take this
- 4:02episode and he said he wants to
- 4:04emphasize adding value to you and that's
- 4:07really the theme of the show adding
- 4:09value to you. So that's what we're going
- 4:10to do today traders. There's a few
- 4:11topics that we're going to explore.
- 4:13That's how how are great traders
- 4:15developed. Finding an edge building a
- 4:17process allocating risk and recognizing
- 4:19those rare moments when we got to swing
- 4:22the bat hard. That's something that Jeff
- 4:24is a principle really that he's guided
- 4:26by. So, I'm excited to really just dive
- 4:28into that topic. Jeeoff, thank you so
- 4:30much for joining Chat with Traders. How
- 4:32are you?
- 4:33>> Good, good. Thanks, Kevin. I'm excited
- 4:35about the opportunity to chat and uh
- 4:38like you said, I mean, a lot of what we
- 4:39do is just trying to add value. I
- 4:41started out as a as a trader just trying
- 4:43to find my own way. A lot of the traders
- 4:45on our desk started in very similar ways
- 4:47to I did to the way I did. And what we
- 4:50really like doing is at the end of the
- 4:52day, we're a bunch of nerds that are
- 4:54really excited about trading. really
- 4:56excited about breaking it down and we
- 4:57love talking about it. So, this is this
- 4:59is a great forum for us to do that.
- 5:01>> Well, breaking it down indeed because
- 5:03you told me that you just came out of a
- 5:05reading the tape session where you were
- 5:07breaking it down. So, talk to us in the
- 5:09traders. You know, what are you guys
- 5:10looking at when you're doing these
- 5:12sessions on reading the tape?
- 5:13>> Yeah, reading the tape's a little bit of
- 5:15this it gets a bad rap. People say, "Oh,
- 5:17you can't read the tape anymore." or
- 5:19especially somebody that was trading,
- 5:20you know, way, you know, let's call it
- 5:231015 years ago where there were actually
- 5:25you could see Goldman Sachs on the bid
- 5:27or you you could see Bank of America,
- 5:28you could see these real players because
- 5:31there weren't as many different players
- 5:33as there are now. And so, a lot of
- 5:35people moved away from reading the tape.
- 5:36We've actually gone deeper and deeper
- 5:38into reading the tape throughout the the
- 5:40time that I've been leading the trader
- 5:42development at S&B Capital. And one of
- 5:44the reasons why is because we're
- 5:46thinking about each of these
- 5:47opportunities, whether it's a stock or
- 5:49or an ETF or even if we're looking to
- 5:51trade options or or if it's a futures
- 5:53product that we're looking to trade.
- 5:55We're watching the tape because it's
- 5:57helping us understand the story of not
- 5:59just what game is being played, but how
- 6:02are the players playing that game at any
- 6:04time? And we were kind of chatting about
- 6:06it offline because you mentioned, hey,
- 6:08how was that that meeting? And I was
- 6:09like I was like it was actually
- 6:10fascinating because we're sitting there
- 6:12with 12 traders and you know hundred
- 6:14some people in our community who get to
- 6:16listen in to all of our meetings. We
- 6:18broadcast all of our meetings because
- 6:19transparency is huge to us. Um so
- 6:22there's a there's an avenue that you can
- 6:23do it and I'm sure there'll be a link
- 6:24somewhere or whatever. And and we're not
- 6:26here to promote anything but just want
- 6:27to give people access. We don't do
- 6:29anything behind closed doors in the way
- 6:30a lot of other people, you know, have
- 6:32chosen to to to do it. We like
- 6:33transparency as much as we can can give
- 6:35it. But we're sitting there with like,
- 6:37you know, call it 120 people and and
- 6:40we're asking our traders to read the
- 6:41tape. Tell me what you're seeing on the
- 6:43tape. And we took two charts from today
- 6:45that looked almost identical. You know,
- 6:47when you're looking at it before the
- 6:48entry, they looked almost identical. And
- 6:51the context was different. SpaceX was
- 6:53one of them. People were wa looking for
- 6:55a bounce at SpaceX. So that's the one
- 6:57that that we really liked. But then when
- 6:59you're actually watching the tape, even
- 7:00though the charts in the five minute or
- 7:02the one minute or the two-minute look
- 7:04very similar, when you're reading the
- 7:06tape, you're really hearing the story as
- 7:08it's being told of what's happening when
- 7:11the interplay between the buyers and the
- 7:13sellers. And even people who are
- 7:15relatively new to reading the tape, when
- 7:17we pointed out just a couple things,
- 7:19we're like, "Oh, I see that. That's so
- 7:21clear of how aggressive the buyers are
- 7:24in this SpaceX trade and how they're
- 7:27just the biders are stepping up and then
- 7:29holding and then they'd give a little
- 7:30bit and they'd step up and they'd hold
- 7:32more and it's like as soon as you see
- 7:34that you recognize that that's what most
- 7:36people are like a buy program's
- 7:38happening. It's like yes, this is
- 7:39visually represented in the tape in the
- 7:42time and sales in the level two of
- 7:44exactly what a buy program looks like
- 7:46and it sort of demystifies that how do I
- 7:49walk into those situations where I have
- 7:51a tremendous amount of edge and trading
- 7:53opportunity. And the other example that
- 7:55we were looking at was uh was something
- 7:57that looked similar on the chart but
- 8:00that interplay wasn't there. The buyers
- 8:02weren't aggressive enough. So every time
- 8:04you'd see this flash higher on the bid,
- 8:07you know, the buyers would step up up up
- 8:08up [laughter] up and then you'd see this
- 8:10like almost rug pull happen. And it's
- 8:12like if you're managing those true
- 8:14trades the exact same way, one of them
- 8:16is just a recipe for frustration because
- 8:18every time it goes up, you're excited.
- 8:20You're thinking this trade's going to
- 8:21work out really well. That comes
- 8:22crashing against you and so you have to
- 8:24go into risk management mode and then
- 8:26that buyer stuff, you know, and it's
- 8:28like one of them is worth paying a lot
- 8:29of attention to and one of them's not.
- 8:31And so even in these these simple
- 8:33reading the tape lessons that we're
- 8:34doing, we're talking about where to put
- 8:37your attention and your focus, which is
- 8:39the biggest challenge for I think
- 8:40traders in general. Where is your focus?
- 8:42Where is your attention? You know, all
- 8:44of us are governed by a couple basic
- 8:46principles of every single trader has a
- 8:49timeline. Whether or not you're going to
- 8:50make more money where to the point where
- 8:52you can, you know, never have to trade
- 8:54again or you're going to, you know,
- 8:56completely lose all the money you have.
- 8:57Like there's still a timeline. There's a
- 8:59finite amount of time that all of us
- 9:01will get the opportunity to trade. And a
- 9:03lot of what we have to do is spend our
- 9:05time focusing on the most important
- 9:08opportunities for us and sidest stepping
- 9:10some of those things that really just
- 9:12get us caught up in the emotional side
- 9:14of trading and and and get a little more
- 9:17frustrating for us when we're exposed to
- 9:19the randomness that can occur every day.
- 9:21>> Yeah. You know, focusing Jeff on the
- 9:23opportunity when it presents itself. I I
- 9:26believe you would call this the A+
- 9:28setup, right? You've discussed this
- 9:30before where you have the baseline plus
- 9:32A+ equals your trading career. Can you
- 9:36explain what that means to the traders
- 9:37listening?
- 9:38>> Yeah, so you know the opportunity that
- 9:40we were drilling into and we had covered
- 9:42it, I think probably four times. We had
- 9:45talked about it by the time we got into
- 9:47the reading the tape today. So we talked
- 9:48about it in pre-market as this is what
- 9:50we might look for. Then we talked about
- 9:53it when it was happening live, right?
- 9:55were in our calls and and and on the
- 9:57desk and we're talking about that
- 9:58opportunity and then we reviewed it in
- 10:00the 11:00 a.m. meeting, you know, one of
- 10:01our trader development meetings. And so
- 10:03we had talked about it three maybe four
- 10:05times before we even got into the
- 10:06reading the tape session. Well, this is
- 10:08for a baseline trade. This wasn't an A+
- 10:11opportunity even. So we're reviewing it
- 10:13time and time again. So when we say A
- 10:15plus B equals C, your career, right? A+
- 10:19plus B, you know, of your baseline
- 10:22equals a trading career. We're talking
- 10:23about you have to develop a baseline of
- 10:26strategies. And that's the thing that
- 10:28that a lot of independent traders need
- 10:30to do first is you need to get to the
- 10:33point where you have a baseline set of
- 10:34strategies where you're going to build
- 10:37out your runway. So, it might be that
- 10:40you can make $5,000 a year in your or
- 10:43$5,000 a month in your baseline
- 10:45strategies, right? So, your baseline
- 10:47strategies are I understand a a
- 10:50hitchhiker scalp or I understand a
- 10:52fashionably late and I I know if I just
- 10:54have a just a couple of those a month I
- 10:57you know a couple of those a week I can
- 10:58make about $5,000 a month. Right? So,
- 11:01for some people $5,000 a month is a
- 11:04sustainable amount. Right? If I do
- 11:07$5,000 a month in those and I can grow
- 11:10that over time, um, all of a sudden I
- 11:12have room to take those A+ opportunities
- 11:15in a bigger and better way. A+
- 11:18opportunities are, you know, they're
- 11:19really well known because of the work
- 11:20we've done with Lance and and Lance
- 11:22talks about them all the time and is
- 11:24always putting them up and everything
- 11:25like that, but they're they're really
- 11:27big telegraphed opportunities that a ton
- 11:30of traders are looking at. Those are the
- 11:32ones that you want to risk up. That's
- 11:33what we get excited about. We don't shy
- 11:36away from those opportunities when they
- 11:38come in and we don't want to shy away
- 11:39from putting risk on in those
- 11:41opportunities. But if you don't have a
- 11:43baseline
- 11:45>> Yeah. Go ahead. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Go
- 11:46ahead.
- 11:46>> I want to dive into those A+ setups too
- 11:48and risk allocation as part of that. But
- 11:51when you're developing traders, Jeff, I
- 11:54mean, how many edges in their playbook
- 11:57do you normally suggest they start with?
- 11:59cuz you were just discussing, you know,
- 12:00find maybe find the one, but how how
- 12:03many in your baseline should a trader
- 12:05have that's just starting out?
- 12:06>> Yeah. So, it's interesting, right?
- 12:09Because what we see is similar to if
- 12:13you've ever read Atomic Habits or any,
- 12:15you know, any of the books about growth
- 12:16and personal development, Atomic Habits
- 12:19is a great one. You have to start with
- 12:21one win first. And that doesn't mean
- 12:25that you get a little win and then you
- 12:27move on to the next one. It actually
- 12:28means that you develop one strategy, you
- 12:32know, and we call it a setup and a trade
- 12:34combination, right? So maybe you're
- 12:36really good at at range breaks, a higher
- 12:39time frame range break, and then you're
- 12:41good at an opening range break coming
- 12:44from that range break, right? That would
- 12:46be one trading strategy. The setup plus
- 12:49the trade equals one trading strategy,
- 12:52right? Once you develop one of those
- 12:56takes a little bit of time, but you
- 12:57study it and you understand it, and then
- 12:59you look for it, and you start to
- 13:01execute it, and then the fun thing
- 13:03happens is all of a sudden you realize
- 13:05that you build the trust in yourself
- 13:07that you can start to scale it a little
- 13:09bit. And I don't mean a ton, but just a
- 13:11little bit. You know, maybe you go from
- 13:13risking $50 to risking $70, or you risk
- 13:17$100 in in a baseline trade to risking
- 13:20$200 in a baseline trade, right? Once
- 13:23you can do that, then all of a sudden
- 13:26you built a a machine, right? You've
- 13:28built a factory of how you can you
- 13:32personally can understand a strategy,
- 13:34understand the components of it, and
- 13:36then start to put that into practice,
- 13:38and then scale that strategy. So, each
- 13:41one's sort of a little bit of a business
- 13:42that you're building on its own. And
- 13:45once you've built one, then the goal is
- 13:47to get to three and then to five. And if
- 13:49you're at five, that's where we really
- 13:52see traders have that sustainability. So
- 13:54it's you have to start with one, which
- 13:56is the hardest thing early on because
- 13:58you really feel like you need to get to
- 14:00five, but you kind of need to win at one
- 14:03first and then you very quickly can get
- 14:05to five once you've been able to scale.
- 14:08So Jeff, question here. I mean this is
- 14:11this is fascinating to me because let's
- 14:13take let's take a trader that's trading
- 14:15maybe the baseline trade or a C trade
- 14:18where I saw with you know you have
- 14:19different dynamic risk allocation I
- 14:21believe A was 80% of the daily stop
- 14:24>> uh A+ yeah so yeah so if you're talking
- 14:26about like like our risk allocation so
- 14:28that this is we're we're getting deep
- 14:30really fast so I hope we're not losing
- 14:31people and and that's okay you know like
- 14:34everything we always say that the first
- 14:35couple weeks is like drinking from the
- 14:37fire hose here right so like there's a
- 14:39lot thrown at you really quickly and
- 14:40we're going very deep much faster than I
- 14:42I think I've ever done it in any
- 14:44conversation. We'll probably talk about
- 14:46why in just a second just just you know
- 14:48why I think it's important to get this
- 14:49deep this quickly. But um when we're
- 14:52talking about our risk allocation, so
- 14:54what we see on the desk is traders break
- 14:56up their risk into different
- 14:59allocations, right? It's like walking
- 15:00into the casino and saying, "I know I'm
- 15:03really good at blackjack, so here's how
- 15:04much I'll spend on blackjack, but I
- 15:07really like playing craps, but I don't
- 15:08tend to win that much there, so I'll
- 15:11have this budget for craps." And then,
- 15:13you know, sometimes I just like to sit
- 15:14there and do slots, and so I'll have
- 15:16this budget for slots, right? But you're
- 15:18not walking in and saying, "I have all
- 15:20this money that I can spend every day,
- 15:21and I have no plan on how I'm going to
- 15:23do it. I'll just do whatever feels
- 15:25right." That's not how we approach
- 15:28trading as much. We're pretty dynamic
- 15:30with our allocation. When you know you
- 15:33have a positive expectancy, you likely
- 15:35want to increase your bet sizing. When
- 15:37you don't really understand it as much,
- 15:39you massively want to decrease the
- 15:42amount that you're willing to put at
- 15:43risk, right? It has nothing to do with
- 15:46with with your P&L. It has everything to
- 15:48do with you being in control and
- 15:49treating it like a business.
- 15:51>> Have you heard this before though,
- 15:52Jeeoff, that 90% of the profits come
- 15:54from 10% of the trades? But I'm
- 15:57wondering with your traders that are
- 16:00taking the C setups or the baseline
- 16:02trades, can those B or C setups evolve
- 16:06into an A trade during the trades? Maybe
- 16:08taking that quote into
- 16:09>> Yeah, I think you're looking at it the
- 16:11wrong way. I mean, [clears throat] yeah.
- 16:13Yeah, it can. And there are times that
- 16:15it does. And and and that's great. That
- 16:18tends to happen on a little higher time
- 16:20frame, like on an intraday basis.
- 16:22Sometimes if that if that is
- 16:24transitioning from a C to a B to an A,
- 16:26that's happening really really fast and
- 16:28a lot of times it's hard to keep up with
- 16:30them. What I think that 90% uh or 10% of
- 16:34your trades makes 90% of your profits or
- 16:36something like that, what I find about
- 16:40all this is that's a very accurate
- 16:43statement over your trading career for
- 16:46most people, but it's a somewhat
- 16:48misleading statement as a developing
- 16:51trader. You know, we have I've pushed
- 16:56and we push each of our traders to not
- 16:59worry about their size. We actually had
- 17:00a trader today email me. He's been with
- 17:02us for like a couple weeks and he's up,
- 17:05you know, two stops, two daily stops in
- 17:08in in I think 5 days, right? So, you
- 17:10think about it and he's not risking very
- 17:12much, but he's he's making really good
- 17:14returns. And he goes, you know,
- 17:16shouldn't I ask for a risk bump? And I'm
- 17:18like, you're like, you're less than a
- 17:20month in. Don't even worry about a risk
- 17:22bump for three months. Don't don't even
- 17:25think about it for three months because
- 17:28if you're starting to worry about your
- 17:30allocation and and how much you have to
- 17:33risk right away, you're probably going
- 17:36to add a dynamic variable that really is
- 17:40coming a little bit too early. So, I
- 17:42think for most traders, the goal should
- 17:44be consistency
- 17:46first. And we say it on our desk. The
- 17:48first goal of the desk is be consistent.
- 17:51The second goal of the desk, be
- 17:53consistent. The third goal of the desk,
- 17:56be consistent. Only after that three
- 17:59months of consistency should you even
- 18:02think about, do I need to change my risk
- 18:05sizing? Do I need to be betting bigger
- 18:07in certain things? Do I need, you know,
- 18:08like that's that's not as important over
- 18:11the course of your career as people
- 18:13think early on.
- 18:15Certainly, when you've shown Excellent.
- 18:18>> What do you think it is? Yeah, that's
- 18:20exactly it. Yeah. And we did it. We
- 18:22pulled all this data around it, too. It
- 18:24was interesting like we have these
- 18:26monthly reviews with with our traders.
- 18:28And so we pulled all this data around
- 18:30traders that were coming up the curve.
- 18:32Not our not our experienced traders, not
- 18:34traders who had been, you know, at the
- 18:36firm for a long time like me, but
- 18:38traders coming up the firm, right? And
- 18:41what was interesting was traders that
- 18:44would show consistency for one month and
- 18:46then lose that consistency. It was
- 18:48almost like they got set back in time
- 18:51until they started to get that
- 18:53consistency back. They would sort of
- 18:55level off in their P&L. And if anybody
- 18:57out there is like noticing, I can be
- 18:59consistent for a month, but then things
- 19:01get really wonky, you have to ask
- 19:03yourself this really honest question of
- 19:06am I really focused on being consistent
- 19:08or is that voice in my head saying, oh,
- 19:11I can start to make more money by
- 19:14increasing my risk. and then you're sort
- 19:16of starting to change your trading
- 19:18because you're increasing your risk a
- 19:19little bit and you're not really focused
- 19:22on just being consistent first, right?
- 19:25So, the goal for our traders is just be
- 19:28consistent and be consistent. And what
- 19:31we found was there was a tipping point
- 19:34at month four. We actually all assumed
- 19:38it was month two and so we were like,
- 19:40"This guy's been consistent for two
- 19:42months. let's start to think about how
- 19:44should we increase their their risk.
- 19:46What we found was for all of the really
- 19:49successful traders, it was about four
- 19:51months of just being consistent that
- 19:54then if we started to push their risk,
- 19:55then if we started to to challenge them
- 19:57a little bit more by increasing their
- 19:59daily stop, they had built up that
- 20:02muscle memory of they knew how to be
- 20:04consistent and it became this really
- 20:06exponential growth curve.
- 20:08>> You know, the puzzle's coming together
- 20:09for me, Jeff. four months of repetition
- 20:12and repetition doing what? When you
- 20:15start with S&B Capital and you're
- 20:16developing these traders, they start
- 20:19with scalping. And this is such an
- 20:21interesting um thing I want to discuss
- 20:24with you. Well, you know, why is that?
- 20:26Is it because you get you just build in
- 20:28this repetition and learn that
- 20:29consistency over time?
- 20:31>> So, I think to really answer that
- 20:33question, I want to take a step back and
- 20:35talk about why I started trading, right?
- 20:38because we don't we didn't just randomly
- 20:40choose to develop our traders that way.
- 20:42But, you know, so I had this this
- 20:44unfortunate experience when I was uh
- 20:47like sixth or seventh grade. Um you
- 20:49know, my dad, who I respect a ton, uh
- 20:51you know, is is certainly one of my
- 20:53heroes, if not my my primary hero in
- 20:56life. Uh he was let go. His you know, he
- 20:58ran a department, his entire department
- 21:00got cut, right? I'm in I think it was
- 21:02seventh grade, you know, and so like one
- 21:04of those things that you're just like I
- 21:06didn't really realize what was
- 21:08happening, you know, I was a kid in
- 21:10middle school like you know, I knew my
- 21:12dad the department got cut, whatever,
- 21:14like you know, fine. Wasn't that
- 21:16traumatic or anything like that, but
- 21:18what what hit me, what made it personal
- 21:21for me was I was at my buddy's house and
- 21:23we had this little community pool right
- 21:26down the down the street. It wasn't
- 21:27anything special or anything, but we
- 21:28would all go hang out there. We had been
- 21:30going there for a long time and it was
- 21:33the beginning of the summer and we were
- 21:34all going to, you know, go hang out at
- 21:35this community pool. I think probably
- 21:37ride our bikes there and like one of my
- 21:40friends mom said, "Well, Jeff, you you
- 21:42can't go." And I was like, like I
- 21:44remember this so vividly of like her
- 21:47saying, "What? You can't go. Your parent
- 21:49your family's not a member anymore."
- 21:51Right? And like that was the first time
- 21:53I really understood like how impactful
- 21:56like losing a job could be. And and that
- 22:00was the the only time I know it made it
- 22:01personal for me, but that was like the
- 22:04time that I was like, "Holy shit." Oh,
- 22:06so this is what it means down the line,
- 22:08right? And a little bit later through
- 22:11talking with my dad and stuff, I
- 22:12realized he didn't have any control,
- 22:14right? The market shifted and that
- 22:16department that he was running just got
- 22:18completely moved away. That was a really
- 22:22important moment for me looking back
- 22:26because that taught me that first of
- 22:28all, I don't want to ever be in a
- 22:30position where I'm completely exposed,
- 22:33right? If I lose, I want it to be
- 22:34because of me. And also, if I win, I
- 22:37want it to because be because of me,
- 22:39right? I want to have a little more
- 22:40control over that. And I'm sure if we
- 22:43worked with our our colleague Dr.
- 22:45Christine Berger, he and I could have
- 22:47very long conversations about what that
- 22:49ultimately means. But to me, that meant
- 22:51that, okay, I love trading. I want to
- 22:55pursue trading. I I feel like trading
- 22:57like picked me just as much as I picked
- 22:59trading, right?
- 23:01I need to make sure that I'm always in
- 23:04control enough where I'm always making
- 23:07money and I have reliable strategies so
- 23:09I can stay in the game so that
- 23:11opportunity doesn't get taken from me.
- 23:14And so we studied all the different
- 23:17strategies and we looked at what are the
- 23:19ways to be the most consistent so that
- 23:21you can just constantly have something
- 23:23to fall back on where if your big trade
- 23:25ideas aren't working, right? If if if
- 23:28the big opportunities you're looking for
- 23:30aren't there, how do you still show up
- 23:32and put together a good month where
- 23:35you're taking money home? Right? We say
- 23:37this expression all the time on our
- 23:39desk, right? You eat what you kill as a
- 23:42trader.
- 23:44So, you better learn how to kill a lot,
- 23:46right? Like, like you absolutely need to
- 23:49know that. And what we found was that
- 23:52scalping offered us a structural way to
- 23:55teach and allow our traders to learn
- 23:59consistently.
- 24:01They were able to get a lot of reps in
- 24:03so they could learn very quickly. And
- 24:05then they were able to build that
- 24:06baseline because they had lots of
- 24:08different trades that they could
- 24:09execute. And so all of a sudden this
- 24:12becomes a really tremendous opportunity
- 24:15instead of it being this big threat of
- 24:17of you know people worrying about what
- 24:19if I don't get an A+ setup this month.
- 24:22Okay, fine. If you don't that's fine.
- 24:24You still have your scalping baseline to
- 24:26come back to. You can still put up P&L
- 24:28that way. you can still take advantage
- 24:29of it and it gives people a little more
- 24:32control of their destiny of their
- 24:34opportunity to be a part a market
- 24:36participant for a long time when you can
- 24:39just whenever I need to just come back
- 24:41to the scalping strategies that I know
- 24:43so well look for those and don't get me
- 24:46wrong when the market's really hot and
- 24:47there's a tremendous amount of
- 24:48volatility and we've had pockets of it
- 24:51this year um those are times to kind of
- 24:53go away from those scalping strategies
- 24:56and take those those um bigger trades.
- 24:59But for most of the time, it's really
- 25:01comforting to come in and go, "Listen, I
- 25:03know I can put up whatever P&L I need to
- 25:06just by showing up and trading these
- 25:08scalping strategies day in and day out."
- 25:10>> Jeff, you start these traders with
- 25:11scalping and you know, I I did when I
- 25:13was watching one of your prior videos, I
- 25:15consumed a lot of your material and it's
- 25:17it's gold traders. You guys got to go
- 25:19out there and watch Jeff's videos. Uh
- 25:21and I I heard you say that based on the
- 25:23report cards now you would take these in
- 25:25year after year and just echoing what
- 25:28you just said Jeff year after year these
- 25:30report cards would say what sustained
- 25:33the traders were those baseline trades
- 25:36and C trades not necessarily the A+
- 25:38trades. It's right it's what sustains
- 25:40their trading career and their journey
- 25:41were those baseline trades. So it makes
- 25:43sense why you start them there. Uh now a
- 25:46couple
- 25:48things based off of the scalping that I
- 25:50want to discuss with you is you know
- 25:53maybe take one of these strategies.
- 25:54There's a couple routes I want to take
- 25:56with with the with the scalping. One of
- 25:58them is I was watching it's called the
- 26:00Bella Scalp Mike Bell Fury scalp. And
- 26:04now he tell us what that is and what
- 26:06he's looking for and a couple of the
- 26:08ideas like them the reasonable expected
- 26:11move and the shot clock. Break that down
- 26:13for the traders listening. Okay, cool.
- 26:15We I love talking about this scalp
- 26:17because it just reminds me so much of,
- 26:19you know, when I started at the desk, I
- 26:20I didn't know this trade at all. And um
- 26:24it took a while for somebody to explain
- 26:26it to me, but I my first big boy seat,
- 26:29you know, we we have a section where the
- 26:31interns, the new developing traders sit
- 26:32and then then you kind of as you grow,
- 26:34you get to sit in a big boy seat, right?
- 26:36Or big girl seat, right? So you're
- 26:37you're kind of on the main desk and and
- 26:40it so happened that my first seat was
- 26:42right next to Bella. And so I would
- 26:44watch Bella take this trade over and
- 26:48over and over every single day. And the
- 26:50whole story behind it is, you know,
- 26:53Bella is a master at reading the tape
- 26:55and and he's a master at understanding,
- 26:57you know, when something's gone a little
- 26:58too far. I think that's probably the way
- 27:01that he was taught and and the tra types
- 27:04of trading that he did early on in his
- 27:06career. And so it's sort of that like
- 27:08that's his version of one of those
- 27:10strategies that he can just show up and
- 27:12he knows it so well that when he sees
- 27:15that opportunity it's like all right
- 27:16it's go time right and so I'd be sitting
- 27:19next to him and we used we used to joke
- 27:22and I hope I'm not embarrassing him by
- 27:24telling this story but we used to joke
- 27:26that he would have a huffy meter where
- 27:28he would get really huffy when the price
- 27:30would go too far against him and not
- 27:33because it like went against him but
- 27:34because he knew that that was just not
- 27:36right. And he would say things like kind
- 27:38of muttering under his breath like why
- 27:40the hell are you still selling it here?
- 27:42You could you could you could literally
- 27:44lift and sell it like 30 cents higher,
- 27:46right? So he would like be talking to
- 27:48the stock non-stop of like of like
- 27:50talking to these these imaginary
- 27:53participants giving them trading advice,
- 27:55right? He'd be like, "Don't sell it
- 27:56here." Like, you know, when somebody
- 27:58would be pushing the stock all the way
- 27:59down and selling, he you can sell it a
- 28:01dollar higher. Like why are you doing
- 28:03this? And so he would get like like
- 28:05huffy, right? He would get frustrated
- 28:07about it. And it was like when that
- 28:09huffy meter started, that's when all of
- 28:11us knew to start to pay attention to the
- 28:13stock because he'd be like, you know,
- 28:15really, really like, what the hell are
- 28:18you guys doing? This is just bad
- 28:19trading. And I remember him vividly
- 28:21saying that this is just a bad decision.
- 28:24And it's like, oh, I got to watch that
- 28:25stock now, right? Like, so as that would
- 28:28be happening, what it is is essentially
- 28:30off the open, it's a sell program. If
- 28:32we're looking for a long, right, it's a
- 28:34sell program that hits ideally in a
- 28:36stock that's gapped up more than 3% on
- 28:39good news, right? Elevated pre-market
- 28:43volume. You know, the stock pulls in
- 28:45hard off the open, but it's got a good
- 28:47news catalyst. And typically what's
- 28:50happening is it's some and he would he
- 28:52would use this term all the time. He
- 28:53would be like, "That's just lazy. That's
- 28:55lazy." And what it is is it's a lazy
- 28:57cell program that just is selling
- 29:00selling selling. Not even trying to
- 29:02fight for price at all. Just selling
- 29:04selling and then then it starts to sell
- 29:06a little more and a little bit faster
- 29:08and a little bit faster. And the best
- 29:10versions of the bell fade are ones that
- 29:12you can watch the tape and you can
- 29:14actually see the seller stepping down,
- 29:15stepping down, stepping down, stepping
- 29:17down. But essentially, you know, they're
- 29:19walking into what should be a tremendous
- 29:22amount of buying pressure, right? There
- 29:24should be institutions wanting to buy
- 29:26the stock. There should be family
- 29:27offices wanting to buy it. There should
- 29:29be market makers willing to step in and
- 29:31support it because they're trying to
- 29:33take it back up. You know, there should
- 29:34be all of this support for the stock
- 29:37going higher, but there's there's this
- 29:38one lazy seller that's just, you know,
- 29:41taking it lower and lower and lower. And
- 29:43so what would happen would be we would
- 29:44be sitting there and Bella would get all
- 29:46huffy and we would know to start
- 29:47watching the stock and then we would
- 29:49look for this seller seller seller all
- 29:51the way down. And as soon as that seller
- 29:53lifted, it was almost like it was like
- 29:56the end of that sell program would
- 29:58happen.
- 29:59And then the natural inflow from the
- 30:01buyers would take the stock up and it
- 30:03would take it a little bit higher and
- 30:05then there'd be this pause and then it
- 30:07would take it higher and then there'd be
- 30:08this pause and then it would take this
- 30:10last capitulatory move usually higher as
- 30:13as people were kind of chasing it and
- 30:15that was kind of the trade, right? And
- 30:17so we started breaking it down and and
- 30:18and we just took these observations we
- 30:21had from sitting there watching it and
- 30:23then watching tape on it, talking about
- 30:25it and we formalized a structure around
- 30:27it. So for the bell fade, the structure
- 30:30is pretty simple. You know, you have a
- 30:31stock gapping up ideally more than 3%
- 30:34positive news. Hopefully, it's gapping
- 30:36out of a range, you know, away from some
- 30:39resistance area and then off the open
- 30:42you have a seller that steps in. Well,
- 30:44we're not trying to predict where that
- 30:46seller is going to stop. We're going to
- 30:47let that seller do its thing. And then
- 30:50as soon as that seller lifts on the
- 30:51tape, we're going to enter long. Our
- 30:53stop's going to go right below the low
- 30:55of the day because that seller should be
- 30:57done, right? The stock shouldn't go
- 30:59lower anymore. The natural buyer should
- 31:01come in. I think you were asking about
- 31:04measured moves and how we calculate
- 31:07targets essentially.
- 31:09>> Right.
- 31:09>> That's kind of where you wanted this
- 31:10conversation to go, I think. Right.
- 31:12Yeah.
- 31:12>> Yeah. Yeah. I'd like it to get into the
- 31:14measured moves for the traders listening
- 31:16because some like with scalping, Jeeoff,
- 31:18some traders may be, you know, eager to
- 31:21get in and then eager to get out. So,
- 31:24how can they slow that tempo down a
- 31:26little bit with the measured moves?
- 31:27>> And I think it comes back to kind of how
- 31:29we started the conversation. It's about
- 31:32expectations, right? If my expectation
- 31:35is that I'm going to tape scalp this
- 31:37this fade, right? My expectation is I'm
- 31:40going to buy as soon as that seller
- 31:41lifts because I see something on the
- 31:43tape and I'm going to sell all my
- 31:45position as soon as that momentum
- 31:47stalls. That's a tape scout. You're
- 31:50literally just using the tape for your
- 31:52entry and the tape for your exit. And
- 31:55those happen all the time in markets,
- 31:58right? And there are traders that trade
- 32:00that way. Even on our desk, they'll
- 32:02they'll trade the tape in and out.
- 32:05That's a really hard thing to do,
- 32:07especially for a developing trader. And
- 32:09I think you can fall victim
- 32:12unfortunately to feeling like you
- 32:14understand the stock, but when the
- 32:18situation changes in that stock or in
- 32:20that product, you know, when there's new
- 32:22news, when there's a fresh catalyst,
- 32:24when there are different participants
- 32:26involved, the whole playing field
- 32:28changes a little bit. So your ability to
- 32:30read the tape is not as clear as it was
- 32:34before.
- 32:35So we don't teach people to tape scalp
- 32:38right away. What we do is teach people
- 32:41to read the tape in what we call
- 32:44priceaction scalps. And that priceaction
- 32:48element is essentially a descriptor of
- 32:52what is happening between the interplay
- 32:54of buyers and sellers. Right? So, we
- 32:57talked about that lazy seller coming
- 32:59down and then those natural buyers
- 33:02coming back in, right? If I described
- 33:04that to you, you could probably almost
- 33:06envision a little bit of what a chart
- 33:08should look like, right? It should be
- 33:11somebody pushing, pushing, pushing down,
- 33:13pushing down, not fighting for price at
- 33:15all, not letting it lift, just trying to
- 33:17get their order done, right? They're
- 33:19just trying to dump the shares as much
- 33:20as they possibly can. and then those
- 33:23natural buyers where they're just going
- 33:24to lift it and lift it and and lift it,
- 33:27you know, as it goes through.
- 33:30So price action scalping is different
- 33:32than tape scalping. Price action
- 33:35scalping has structure to it and it has
- 33:38usually very repeatable historical
- 33:41patterns that you can observe.
- 33:43So, when we're teaching traders this
- 33:46idea, we're not just teaching them what
- 33:48a good entry looks like because of the
- 33:51the structure of the price action scalp.
- 33:53We're actually helping them and forcing
- 33:56them and teaching them what to expect
- 33:59all the way through the move. You know,
- 34:01when we go and recruit for our
- 34:03internship program, right, we're almost
- 34:05at the end of our internship for the
- 34:07summer. Um, I get to be on the
- 34:09recruiting team for that. I get to help
- 34:11out a little bit with the internship and
- 34:13and it's really fun because we get to
- 34:15watch these interns come in and most of
- 34:19them have been trading on their own.
- 34:21Most of them assume they know how to
- 34:23trade. Most of them come in with some
- 34:26knowledge of of of something which is
- 34:28great. But then when we kind of put that
- 34:31structure around it, almost all of them
- 34:35leave the internship or leave this
- 34:37experience by going, "Oh, now what I'm
- 34:41doing makes more sense to me."
- 34:44And a lot of that like selling too early
- 34:48typically occurs because the entirety of
- 34:50the move doesn't really make sense to
- 34:53you.
- 34:56We were using this example the other day
- 34:58and and I I'll share it here. Um I think
- 35:01we used it in trader development, right?
- 35:03So, we were talking about a seller a
- 35:06trader had sold way too early. And I
- 35:08said, "Well, let's imagine, you know, um
- 35:12they were talking about what's the new
- 35:13there's there's a new big movie that
- 35:15came out on IMAX, um the Odyssey, I
- 35:18think, right? So, like you probably can
- 35:20figure out when this video was show this
- 35:21this interview was shot based on that,
- 35:22but it just came out, right? And I was
- 35:25like, imagine you bought a ticket to the
- 35:27Odyssey, right? and you like went with
- 35:29all your friends and and you're excited
- 35:31to go see this this movie, this
- 35:33blockbuster movie on IMAX and shot on
- 35:36IMAX film, first one ever to do that.
- 35:39And you go into the movie and you watch
- 35:42the you know it's like a two-hour movie.
- 35:43I have no idea what the run time is, but
- 35:45let's assume it's two hours. You know
- 35:47it's a two-hour movie. Are you going in
- 35:49with the expectation that you'll be
- 35:51sitting there for two hours or are you
- 35:53going in with the expectation that maybe
- 35:54you'll be there for five or 10 minutes?
- 35:57like you know you're going in for two
- 35:59hours, right? You have a clear
- 36:00expectation of what you're there to do
- 36:04with trading and the the price action
- 36:07scalping. You have a clear expectation
- 36:09of what should happen. Does that mean if
- 36:11something wrong happens, you say, "No,
- 36:14I'm staying in the trade." Absolutely
- 36:16not. But at least you have a guide for
- 36:19this is what should happen and then this
- 36:20is what should happen and then this is
- 36:22what should happen and if it happens,
- 36:24I'm prepared for it. Unfortunately,
- 36:28without that structure, you're going in
- 36:30watching the first five minutes of the
- 36:32movie, making a decision if you want to
- 36:33watch the rest of it, and you're
- 36:34leaving, and you're not really sure, and
- 36:36you're going to miss out on a lot of it.
- 36:38And I think that's what happens with
- 36:40trading. And I know that was a long way
- 36:42of saying you kind of have to understand
- 36:44what your expectation is for the trade,
- 36:46but I think it's important because I
- 36:47don't think enough people realize once
- 36:49you have an entry, that's really a small
- 36:52portion of everything that you have to
- 36:55do because you really have to understand
- 36:56what you expect to happen and what you
- 36:59absolutely don't want to have happen.
- 37:00>> Yeah, there's a lot to unpack there. I I
- 37:03wonder how you go about teaching your
- 37:05traders when they get involved in let's
- 37:08say this scalp. Do you say to disengage
- 37:11from that trade, set the stop and step
- 37:14away? Because what if, okay, let's say
- 37:17there's any invalidation period within
- 37:19the trade. Maybe you were expecting that
- 37:21break, but then the buyers don't really
- 37:24step in, but but Jeeoff, it also doesn't
- 37:26come back to the lows. Is there a point
- 37:28in time which you can the trade can be
- 37:31adjusted in which okay, it's invalidated
- 37:33based on my reasonable expectation in
- 37:36which I'm going to reduce risk or take
- 37:38it off. Yeah, absolutely. That's that
- 37:40shot clock concept that I think you hit
- 37:42on earlier, right? So, with every trade
- 37:45there and you're you're hitting on a lot
- 37:47of these cool concepts that we've taught
- 37:49over time and and hopefully they're
- 37:50they're adding value to people, but we
- 37:52have a shot clock for every trade,
- 37:54right? And it's it's not a finite shot
- 37:57clock of this is exactly what it has to
- 37:59be. It's not 30 seconds. It's not, you
- 38:01know, but it we we stole the idea from
- 38:03basketball, right? you get that you get
- 38:05the you get the ball. You have a certain
- 38:07amount of time to make something happen.
- 38:09If you don't make anything happen, the
- 38:10other team gets the ball back. Right?
- 38:12When you have an entry in trading,
- 38:14there's a certain amount of time that
- 38:16something should help you understand
- 38:18that your entry other people are
- 38:20thinking the same thing as what you were
- 38:22thinking. Right? Just because I enter a
- 38:25trade doesn't mean the market's going to
- 38:26move in my favor. I'm my job in fact is
- 38:29to understand when the market is going
- 38:31to move in my favor and then enter the
- 38:34trade. Not enter the trade and then hope
- 38:36it moves in my favor. It's it's it's
- 38:38this inverse relationship that we often
- 38:40get sucked into of like I think I see it
- 38:43>> now. I want to now I want the market to
- 38:45move for me and it's like no no no you
- 38:47should see the market getting ready to
- 38:49move for you and then you can enter the
- 38:51trade. And so this shot clock idea is
- 38:54for each trade, there's a reasonable
- 38:56amount of time in which you expect
- 38:58something to happen that your el your um
- 39:02your expected value in the trade will
- 39:04start to increase or your expected value
- 39:06in the trade will at least start to play
- 39:08out. And the inverse of that is there's
- 39:10a period of time where the stock's doing
- 39:12nothing and your expected value is
- 39:15actually diminishing, right? And so only
- 39:18when you have something like that happen
- 39:20do you need to adjust your position. We
- 39:22actually don't teach traders when
- 39:24they're starting out to do that at all
- 39:26because it adds too many variables. When
- 39:28traders are starting out we teach
- 39:30traders to put the trade on. As soon as
- 39:34you have your signal put the trade on
- 39:36right
- 39:38>> start very small
- 39:40but put the trade on when you have your
- 39:43signal. You have to make sure it's hard
- 39:46enough as a trader to make sure that you
- 39:49actually have your signal and you're not
- 39:51just guessing that you sort of have your
- 39:54entry signal,
- 39:55>> right? So, don't worry about what you're
- 39:57going to do right after that. Just make
- 39:59sure you actually have the rules for
- 40:02your trade present. And if you have
- 40:04them, put the trade on and manage your
- 40:07risk. Don't worry about managing your
- 40:10reward quite yet, right? just manage
- 40:13your risk the way it's supposed to be
- 40:15managed because that's a really hard
- 40:17thing to do. And if you can do that, the
- 40:21pathway to really pushing and growing
- 40:24and becoming a great trader is a lot
- 40:26more accessible to you than if you can
- 40:28never just put the trade on and manage
- 40:30your risk.
- 40:31>> I've heard this great quote from the
- 40:32infamous Mark Douglas, be rigid with the
- 40:34rules and then flexible with the profit
- 40:37expectations. And I know with the
- 40:38measured moves, you kind of are taking
- 40:41pieces off along the way. So now we have
- 40:43the traders listening. You got the
- 40:45playbook, you have the one trade. Now I
- 40:47think one thing too, Jeeoff, that would
- 40:49be helpful for them is understanding the
- 40:50framework, which is this acronym you've
- 40:53discussed before, asset as
- 40:56can you tell us a little bit about that?
- 40:57>> Yeah. Um, so asset, this is actually a
- 41:00funny story behind asset. So, I was
- 41:03getting really frustrated with one of
- 41:05the traders that's that's now a very
- 41:07successful trader on our desk because
- 41:09you can sort of start to see it when
- 41:11somebody's doing the right work and
- 41:13they're doing a lot of things well and
- 41:15you know, you can't really see it early
- 41:17on, but you can start to see it over
- 41:18time where this person has a lot of
- 41:20potential, but there's almost always
- 41:25um
- 41:27some sort of, you know, downturn that
- 41:30happens to them, right? like like
- 41:32they're looking really good or or or
- 41:34they're just not not accelerating to the
- 41:36upside and then something happens and
- 41:38it's really traumatic at the time,
- 41:39right? And I I feel like this happens
- 41:41almost to every trader that I've
- 41:44interacted with that truly has gone on
- 41:46to something something great is there's
- 41:48always this like gut check moment,
- 41:50right? where you're doing all the work,
- 41:51you're doing everything right, and and
- 41:53you have this gut check moment of
- 41:55something, whether it's within your
- 41:56control or out of your control, it just
- 41:58happens. And it's almost like the
- 42:00market's testing you and teasing you and
- 42:02almost saying you're really close, but
- 42:04you know, um and and and I don't know
- 42:06why it happens, but it it seems to have
- 42:08happened with a lot of people,
- 42:10especially on our desk, and and
- 42:11hopefully it doesn't happen with
- 42:12everybody, but I've seen it a lot. Um,
- 42:15there was this trader that we were
- 42:17working with and I was working with very
- 42:19closely and he had done all the work. He
- 42:22was starting to see some growth and then
- 42:23he had this gut check moment, right? And
- 42:26we were sitting there and trying to not
- 42:28just say, "Oh, that's too bad. I hope
- 42:31you get out of it." But actually come up
- 42:32with a process, right? As soon as that
- 42:35happened, it was like, "Okay, let's cut
- 42:36your risk down so you can get some
- 42:39consistency back." Again, we went back
- 42:41to that consistency, that groundwork,
- 42:43right?
- 42:44and he pushed back and he said, "But I
- 42:46need to maintain my ability to push in
- 42:49my A+ setups." And we said, "Okay, that
- 42:53makes sense. That's a good thing."
- 42:55Right? He recognized that was one of his
- 42:57strengths. And so we wanted to help him
- 42:59with that. So he was like, "So how do I
- 43:02do this?" And one of the the really
- 43:05distinct problems he had was he would
- 43:08enter a trade and then set a stop based
- 43:13on kind of where he thought that would
- 43:16where the where the appropriate stop
- 43:17was. And it was the appropriate stop.
- 43:19But the fact that he was entering first
- 43:22meant that his risk profile was always a
- 43:25little bit off. It was always a little
- 43:27more inconsistent than he needed it to
- 43:30be.
- 43:30>> See where you're going with this? And it
- 43:32didn't really
- 43:34make that much of a difference when you
- 43:36look at it because it didn't change his
- 43:37win rate really that much. But what it
- 43:40changed was how much he was making in
- 43:42trades versus losing in trades. You
- 43:44know, when you extrapolate these
- 43:45numbers, if we're talking about up or
- 43:49down $20 differential in a trade, that
- 43:52doesn't sound like a lot. But if you're
- 43:54then multiplying that out and you're
- 43:56talking up and down $20,000, that's all
- 43:59of a sudden a significant amount of
- 44:01money. And so we needed precision
- 44:05in his process so that he could then
- 44:08grow from there. So we came up with and
- 44:10it wasn't the asset protocol initially.
- 44:13There were about four or five versions
- 44:15of them that were all acronyms with
- 44:17different steps that we worked through.
- 44:20But over time,
- 44:22one of what we settled on was this asset
- 44:25protocol, which is you start with your
- 44:27allocation, right? So that's what we
- 44:29talked I think we started a lot of this
- 44:31conversation with what's your allocation
- 44:33and your dynamic risk allocation.
- 44:37We don't expect allocation to be
- 44:39perfect, but you're constantly getting
- 44:40better at it. And that what we mean by
- 44:43that is your A+ which is 80% of a daily
- 44:46stop,
- 44:48A which is 30% of a daily stop, B which
- 44:51is 15% of a daily stop or C which is 5%
- 44:55of a daily stop. And these are standard
- 44:57numbers and as you get better you you
- 44:59tend to manipulate those numbers a
- 45:01little bit but we teach a basic protocol
- 45:03that anybody can follow and at least
- 45:05start with right and and so that's the
- 45:09allocation
- 45:11component to to this asset formula and
- 45:15the allocation component is important
- 45:17because you need to understand when this
- 45:20is a better opportunity or a less
- 45:23quality opportunity and you want to
- 45:26start to basket that into, okay, this
- 45:29has everything lined up. This is where I
- 45:33need to bet the the most. You know, we
- 45:35take this from playing cards and and
- 45:37poker and it's like I have pocket aces,
- 45:39right? I have to bet big. I have to do
- 45:42everything right there. Yep. Exactly. I
- 45:44have to push it on this one. Otherwise,
- 45:46I'm just middling and and it doesn't
- 45:48help me at all. There also has to be
- 45:50times when you have to kind of pull it
- 45:52back and bet really small, but you need
- 45:55to have that experience, right? So
- 45:57that's why we start with that allocation
- 45:59component. So every trade you take has
- 46:02to have an allocation score. So if you
- 46:04hear traders on our desk, they're like,
- 46:06I really like this. I think it's worth
- 46:08like B- risk, right? And that's what
- 46:10they're starting with. They're saying, I
- 46:12really like this. I think it's worth B-
- 46:14risk. Now, here's the fun thing. Okay?
- 46:17If you're tra if you and I are trading
- 46:18together and I'm like, "Yeah, I just see
- 46:20a couple C opportunities and then all of
- 46:22a sudden I go I'm looking at this A+."
- 46:25How much are the hairs in the back of
- 46:26your neck going to stand up when I say
- 46:28that? And you're going to be like, I got
- 46:30to look at that. Right? Like so it
- 46:32becomes like almost this signal of like
- 46:35I've got conviction here. This is really
- 46:37good, right? And so that allocation is
- 46:41the first element of this protocol that
- 46:44we use.
- 46:45The very very next element of it is what
- 46:48we learned from that trader. You have to
- 46:52set your stop. You have to understand
- 46:54where your stop is next. And the reason
- 46:57is is because you cannot be in a
- 46:59position of playing offense first. You
- 47:02kind of have to be in a position or a
- 47:04mindset of where am I wrong in this
- 47:07trade. You have to know where you're
- 47:09wrong in that trade first. What
- 47:12invalidates the trade? What price action
- 47:14tells me I'm wrong and where would that
- 47:17be? So you have to have your stop first.
- 47:21So that's why we say, you know, asset a
- 47:24allocation stop, right?
- 47:26>> Yeah. There's a significance to the
- 47:28order of it.
- 47:28>> Correct. Exactly. Exactly. Yeah. And
- 47:30like I said, this is like the third or
- 47:32fourth version of it, maybe even the
- 47:33fifth version of it. And we didn't
- 47:34always have that stop that that second
- 47:37thing. It used to be kind of one of the
- 47:39last things which was like we realized
- 47:41the error of our ways and started to
- 47:43readjust, right? That stop takes away a
- 47:48lot of the psychological pressures
- 47:49because if you've already accepted the
- 47:51risk and knowing where you're wrong and
- 47:53you've done that as a logical exercise,
- 47:55it's really hard to let the emotions win
- 47:58at that point. But if you haven't
- 48:00accepted that risk and those emotions
- 48:02come into play, it's really really hard
- 48:05for you to override that and get back to
- 48:07that logical thinking. It's just the way
- 48:08our brains are wired, right? This is why
- 48:10I think some people say AI is going to
- 48:12take over trading. I I don't see that
- 48:15actually happening. I see, you know, a
- 48:16lot of AI slop coming into the market
- 48:19and like kind of mucking things up for
- 48:20all of us, but that's going to tend to,
- 48:22you know, create opportunity for us more
- 48:24than anything else. But the fact that we
- 48:27can start with our stop, we've
- 48:29emotionally taken some some of that
- 48:31risk, that emotional component off the
- 48:33table, right? We've said this is where
- 48:36I'm wrong. You've said it out loud or
- 48:38you've said it to yourself or you've
- 48:39admitted this is where I'm wrong in that
- 48:41trade. In that bell fade example we
- 48:43talked about, right below the low of the
- 48:46day, right? If that seller isn't done
- 48:48selling, I'm wrong. That's it. And just
- 48:51by saying that, Dr. Steamberger taught
- 48:54us this and working with Lance, we've
- 48:55learned this. You're committing yourself
- 48:57to saying, "Yeah, I know I'm wrong here
- 48:59and I know there's a probability I could
- 49:01be wrong here and that's okay, right?"
- 49:05So, you kind of desensitize yourself to
- 49:07that moment. And then only then do you
- 49:11even go to consider what your where your
- 49:14entry actually is going to be. So you
- 49:17have to mention the allocation and the
- 49:19stop first and then you can look at what
- 49:21your entry criteria actually is, you
- 49:24know, and because of that you've
- 49:27automatically calculated your share
- 49:29size. If you know where your stop is and
- 49:31you know where your entry is, you know
- 49:33exactly what size to put on, what share
- 49:36size to put on, right? You're not
- 49:38guessing. You're not just doing a,000
- 49:40shares because you want to do a,000 or
- 49:42500 because you want to do a 500. you're
- 49:44actually saying, I know what my
- 49:45allocation is, okay? I know what my stop
- 49:49is, and I know what my entry is, right?
- 49:52And then you can kind of get into this
- 49:54really important mindset, which is T for
- 49:58target. And I think most people mess up
- 50:00on target because they over complicate
- 50:02it. When you're developing as a trader,
- 50:07T for target is usually pretty static.
- 50:11It's usually like, okay, a measured move
- 50:14is a very straightforward target, right?
- 50:18It should move one measured move for a
- 50:20range break. We often talk about a
- 50:22measured move or two measured moves of
- 50:24the range, right? They just become these
- 50:27self-fulfilling prophecies. That's all
- 50:29it is, right? That's all we do. So, that
- 50:32is a base level concept that you can use
- 50:35in almost every trade of saying measured
- 50:38move. That's the straightup target.
- 50:43If you cannot hold to that base target,
- 50:46don't mess around with this with the
- 50:48with the exit. But if you can execute
- 50:50the strategy, like we said, you have the
- 50:53opportunity. You just put the trade on
- 50:55and you manage your risk, right? And you
- 50:58try and see if I can hold it just to
- 51:00that target.
- 51:01Think about all the positive things
- 51:03you've done just by working this asset
- 51:06protocol even a single time. You know,
- 51:10you mentioned Mark Douglas and all the
- 51:11trading psychology books and you can go
- 51:13back to Ari Kee and you can talk about
- 51:14Dr. Steamberg and you can talk about
- 51:16Jared Ten. All of them have written
- 51:18about all these things that you need to
- 51:20be doing. But what we found on the desk
- 51:23is just by practicing this asset
- 51:25protocol, it's actually incorporating
- 51:27all the things they're teaching us in
- 51:30actionable things that we do every
- 51:32single day.
- 51:33>> Man, traders, uh, if you're finding
- 51:36value, let us know. I mean, Jeeoff,
- 51:38there's so many directions I want to go
- 51:40with this. I'm excited about it. Um, so,
- 51:43okay, traders, you got the playbook now.
- 51:45Now you have the asset protocol
- 51:49and there's many edges in that trade
- 51:52though, right Jeff? It's not just one
- 51:54edge. Now I had a conversation with
- 51:55Peter Brandt recently and he told me
- 51:56trade identification while it's
- 51:58important is not necessarily the most
- 52:00important thing and identifying what the
- 52:03trade is but then thereafter what are
- 52:05you doing in the trade? Are you letting
- 52:07it get to that measured move traders
- 52:09that Jeff is teaching us about? Are you
- 52:12taking you know you taking the profits
- 52:14too early on them? So there was a recent
- 52:18example of for me it was a A+ setup
- 52:21maybe you see for somebody else Jeff but
- 52:24take there was it was Avis group it was
- 52:26car it went from like 50 100 to 800 I
- 52:29hit it short day one but mistakenly you
- 52:32know I'm not leaning in now this man now
- 52:35this reminds me of something you said
- 52:37Jeeoff you said
- 52:39you'll have traders come in that are
- 52:40developing and you've noticed that 80%
- 52:43of them need to be pushed to put risk
- 52:47And that was speaking home to me. It
- 52:49really was because here I am with an A+
- 52:51setup in my mind. The thing goes from
- 52:52$800 to $200 that day, you know, and I
- 52:55don't take advantage of it at all
- 52:57because this disposition effect that you
- 52:59talk about that is when I'm when I'm
- 53:01right, I'm fearful and when I'm wrong,
- 53:03I'm hopeful.
- 53:04>> So for the traders listening that may be
- 53:06in a similar position, you know, how can
- 53:08you take advantage and swing that bat
- 53:11like you discussed when that edge A+
- 53:13presents it presents itself to us? Well,
- 53:16if you don't mind me putting you on the
- 53:17spot. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. No, if you don't
- 53:19mind me putting you on the spot, right?
- 53:21Like, like you brought it up, so I'm
- 53:23gonna open it up and I'm okay. I'm okay
- 53:25with a little friction here. So, I'm
- 53:27okay with push back and I'm perfectly
- 53:29okay and I'm sure the viewers would be
- 53:30fine with you saying, "No, I don't want
- 53:32to talk about my own trading." But this
- 53:34is what we do with our traders. This is
- 53:36why I'm in the role that I'm in uh of
- 53:39trader development because you know I I
- 53:41found that conversations just like this
- 53:44can be hugely impactful or they can be
- 53:47just nice conversations to have. So I if
- 53:49you're comfortable with it, I'd like to
- 53:51ask you some questions about your trade
- 53:53and your thinking in this trade and I'm
- 53:56okay if you want to keep the episode
- 53:57about something else. I'm okay with it.
- 53:59But it would be I think kind of fun to
- 54:01push in. Yeah. Okay.
- 54:04>> Traders want to hear Yeah. We can we can
- 54:06>> Okay, let's push into it. All right. All
- 54:07right. So, let's push into it. Had you
- 54:09been short car previously?
- 54:11>> No, but can I can I ask you something
- 54:14about that? Because this is on my mind
- 54:15as well. When when we discuss these A+
- 54:18this was on my mind, the car trade where
- 54:20I'm like, what if because there's a lot
- 54:22of great traders that focus on this
- 54:24first red day over a ticker that's
- 54:26overextended. So what if they're seeing
- 54:30Jeff an A+ setup on car on when it was
- 54:33at 300 and then no wrong and now it's at
- 54:36400 wrong 500 all the way to eight like
- 54:39at what point do you blacklist the
- 54:41ticker and it's like okay I keep trying
- 54:43the A+ setup and it keeps failing. So at
- 54:46what point do you say you shut the
- 54:47computer down say no more?
- 54:49>> Yeah. Yeah. And we had a couple traders
- 54:52that were relatively close to shutting
- 54:54it down. I was relatively close to
- 54:57saying, you know, if you remember at the
- 55:00top at that, the stories about it were
- 55:02insane, right? These the like I think
- 55:05when it got to 400, people started
- 55:07circulating those stories about the
- 55:08floats being locked and 140% short float
- 55:11or 127% short float and like like all
- 55:14these stories that everybody's like this
- 55:15could go to a,000, this could go to
- 55:175,000. Like nobody knows. And if you
- 55:20remember, it wasn't trading very well
- 55:22for a lot of that up move. It really
- 55:25wasn't. You know, it was going up, but
- 55:27it wasn't trading like there was a ton
- 55:29of participation. It wasn't trading with
- 55:32a lot of liquidity. You know, a lot of
- 55:34people actually got pretty afraid of it
- 55:35because of that, right? And we had we
- 55:38had a lot of discussions with our
- 55:39traders about it and is this getting
- 55:41good, is this getting better or is it
- 55:43actually getting worse? And and that was
- 55:46one of the things, you know, we've had
- 55:47examples of this before. Uh HKD was an
- 55:50awful example of it before where as it
- 55:52went higher it actually got worse and
- 55:54worse and worse. Yeah. Yeah. It got
- 55:56worse and worse and worse and that was
- 55:57dangerous for for some of us. Um but
- 56:01this one was one that was really
- 56:02interesting because it got worse and
- 56:04worse and worse and then better and
- 56:05better and better really really fast.
- 56:07And so you're asking kind of two
- 56:09questions and this is why I like having
- 56:11these discussions because I think I'm
- 56:13big on finding the bottleneck, right?
- 56:15And if you find the real bottleneck,
- 56:18then you can actually start to use this
- 56:19model that we use the five W's, right?
- 56:22But if you're if you're not really using
- 56:24that bottleneck, then you're kind of
- 56:26trying to solve a problem with the wrong
- 56:28tool, right? And so you're asking a
- 56:31question that's different than what
- 56:32we're probably ultimately going to talk
- 56:33about here. But let's entertain the
- 56:36thought. I tried it once. It was exactly
- 56:38what I wanted to see. I got stopped out
- 56:40on big size.
- 56:43That sucks.
- 56:45But didn't you sign up for this as a
- 56:47trader,
- 56:49right? Like at the end of the day, like
- 56:51isn't that a part of being a trader?
- 56:54Now, let's assume you stayed within your
- 56:56risk controls even if you lost a decent
- 56:59amount, right, of your daily stop or
- 57:01whatever.
- 57:03Isn't that within the scope of of
- 57:05normality?
- 57:07Yeah. I mean, that is going to happen.
- 57:10And it does emotionally hurt a little
- 57:12bit, but we have some rules on our desk
- 57:15that we've learned from other traders.
- 57:17You can only mourn a loss for 24 hours.
- 57:21Bad loss, you have 24 hours to be pissed
- 57:23about it, work through it emotionally,
- 57:25whatever you need to do. 24 hours, at
- 57:27the end of 24 hours, you have to go back
- 57:29to being a trader.
- 57:32That comes with another rule. You can
- 57:33only celebrate a win for 12 hours.
- 57:36you can only really sit there and like
- 57:38be really excited about a win for 12
- 57:40hours because at the end of the day then
- 57:42you kind of have to go back to being a
- 57:43trader, right? Like and and and we found
- 57:46this to be something that is is a
- 57:48worthwhile thing to to try and do. Okay.
- 57:52So you can
- 57:54>> although you may be driving and you're
- 57:56celebration for many days thereafter.
- 57:58Well, I mean it I'm not saying you can't
- 58:00feel the emotions, but really genuinely
- 58:02you can only allow yourself that that
- 58:04moment for for 12 hours, right? Because
- 58:06at the end of the day, we're we're back
- 58:08into being a trader.
- 58:09>> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. You come back to being
- 58:10a trader.
- 58:11>> So, let's assume you tried it once and
- 58:1524 you gave yourself 24 hours to mourn
- 58:17that loss.
- 58:18>> You know that trade didn't set up again
- 58:20for another few days, right? and let's
- 58:22say you tried it again and another there
- 58:24is a point where you're just like this
- 58:26stock is not what I expect but that's
- 58:29really where you have to ask yourself
- 58:31did I identify this A+ opportunity
- 58:34correctly because I think a lot of times
- 58:37we get really slippery with our
- 58:39identification of what an A+ is. You're
- 58:42right to point out that it was the first
- 58:44red day at the top, but it was also, I
- 58:45think, three consecutive gap ups. And it
- 58:48was the first time we had had two or
- 58:49three consecutive gap ups with
- 58:51acceleration away from a moving average,
- 58:53with acceleration away from a Ballinger
- 58:55band or outside of a Ballinger band,
- 58:56with accelerating volume. There were all
- 58:58these characteristics that were there
- 59:00for the first time that most of us would
- 59:02identify as pivotal for an A+
- 59:05opportunity that really didn't show up
- 59:07until later in the trade. And so, you
- 59:12know, there's there's a couple different
- 59:13dynamics. The first one is, are you
- 59:15accurately identifying your A+es or are
- 59:18you just assuming they're A+ because of
- 59:20something you read? Sounds like you
- 59:22accurately identified your A+es, which
- 59:25is a huge starting point, right? So,
- 59:28let's, you know, if everybody can just
- 59:30applaud for that because if you didn't
- 59:31short it two days before and the day
- 59:33before and all that stuff and you waited
- 59:35till you actually had a signal, that's
- 59:37huge. And you never want to discount how
- 59:39important that is.
- 59:40>> Well, you've talked about this before
- 59:42where you you almost over time develop
- 59:46this aha moment where your traders see
- 59:49something that's like, hey, you guys
- 59:51seeing this on the desk and nobody else
- 59:54nobody else is seeing it. Ever watch a
- 59:56stock rip and think, I could have nailed
- 59:58that if I had real capital. The truth is
- 1:00:01many capable traders never reach their
- 1:00:03potential. Not due to lack of skill, but
- 1:00:06lack of scale. Trade the Pool was built
- 1:00:08to solve exactly that. A firm designed
- 1:00:10for serious individuals who want access
- 1:00:13to the US equity markets with meaningful
- 1:00:15buying power up to $200,000 without
- 1:00:18committing their own capital. Get access
- 1:00:20to virtually every stock and ETF. Go
- 1:00:22long or short freely with the
- 1:00:23flexibility professional traders expect.
- 1:00:26You're evaluated on one thing, your
- 1:00:28ability to manage risk and execute with
- 1:00:30consistency. Meet the standard and you
- 1:00:33trade at scale. No subscriptions, no
- 1:00:35ongoing commitments. Whether you're
- 1:00:37still refining your strategy, a trader
- 1:00:39with experience who hasn't yet broken
- 1:00:41through, or a seasoned professional
- 1:00:43simply looking for more capital, trade
- 1:00:46the pool is built to meet you where you
- 1:00:48are and take you that next step further.
- 1:00:50The markets have evolved. Access has
- 1:00:52evolved. Now, so has the way traders
- 1:00:55operate within them. Trade the pool.
- 1:00:58>> Yeah. I mean, it's not I don't know that
- 1:01:01it's nobody else is seeing it. I think
- 1:01:03what it is is you kind of just do the
- 1:01:07work and and for the love of trading
- 1:01:10analyze what's happening in the market
- 1:01:13and then you're like I've seen this
- 1:01:14situation before. I I've seen the stock
- 1:01:17trade this way. I know and you know very
- 1:01:19few of us have seen something go from
- 1:01:21200 to 800 in the way that it did. But
- 1:01:23we've seen shades of of of this stuff
- 1:01:26before. You know we've seen shades of
- 1:01:28these opportunities before. And we
- 1:01:30always say the market doesn't um
- 1:01:33it doesn't what it oh shoot I'm gonna
- 1:01:36have to I'll I'll remember this the
- 1:01:37statement later but it's essentially
- 1:01:39like it rhymes. It doesn't mirror
- 1:01:41exactly what it was before but it tends
- 1:01:43to rhyme. Right. So it doesn't repeat it
- 1:01:45rhymes. Right. So I think that's the
- 1:01:47that's the the sentiment. Yeah. The
- 1:01:49market doesn't repeat but it rhymes. So
- 1:01:51you you can see these things again and
- 1:01:54again and it's almost like this we call
- 1:01:56it hits you between the eyes of when
- 1:01:58you've done the work when you've
- 1:01:59identified a setup when you've done the
- 1:02:01work for it when you've practiced it
- 1:02:03when you've talked about it when you've
- 1:02:04studied it you start to see it again and
- 1:02:07you're like oh yeah I kind of see the
- 1:02:09game that's being played here
- 1:02:11>> and then that's that's what
- 1:02:13>> yes and that's where you start to go
- 1:02:15into an asset protocol because that that
- 1:02:18gut starting to talk is just an idea If
- 1:02:20I put risk on for every time my gut
- 1:02:23talked to me, I would not be a
- 1:02:25profitable trader [laughter]
- 1:02:27because my gut talks to me all the time
- 1:02:30and every trader I know, their gut talks
- 1:02:32to them all the time about this is maybe
- 1:02:35this is a good idea. Maybe this is a
- 1:02:36good idea. And so we need that extra
- 1:02:38check. And so that's why we created that
- 1:02:39asset protocol because if you can't
- 1:02:42actually articulate it and turn it into
- 1:02:43a trade, then you're just kind of
- 1:02:45trading off of a feel that is, you know,
- 1:02:49not really there. But if you turn it
- 1:02:51into a trade idea, then you've actually
- 1:02:53got a plan to move forward. And if that
- 1:02:55plan doesn't happen, you just can't
- 1:02:56execute, right? So let's talk about
- 1:03:00your trade. So you're you're waiting for
- 1:03:03that first red bar. Is that that what
- 1:03:05you were waiting for? that first day
- 1:03:07with that first red candle. Is that
- 1:03:09right?
- 1:03:11>> Yeah. First red day.
- 1:03:12>> First red day. Okay. First red day.
- 1:03:14>> The overextended move.
- 1:03:15>> Okay. The overextended move. And if I
- 1:03:17remember correctly and and I don't have
- 1:03:18the chart in front of me, but if I
- 1:03:20remember correctly, it sort of started
- 1:03:21out with um like a little bit of it
- 1:03:24selloff and then it kind of like looked
- 1:03:26like it was going to pop and I think a
- 1:03:28lot of people expected it to kind of
- 1:03:29catch VWOP and go higher and that was
- 1:03:32it. and then it just kind of went
- 1:03:33sideways and then
- 1:03:34>> you know it's based right off the
- 1:03:36expectations like you mentioned earlier
- 1:03:38and these can traders having
- 1:03:40expectations that are these visual
- 1:03:42representation of what you think is
- 1:03:43going to happen. You mentioned it a lot
- 1:03:45of traders were thinking okay basically
- 1:03:47the whole float is locked and it was
- 1:03:50approaching a thousand. So the
- 1:03:51expectation was this thing's going to
- 1:03:53hit a thousand. It did did exactly what
- 1:03:55you said. It it kind of did a little red
- 1:03:57to green move and then down she goes.
- 1:04:01Yep. And and it went down and it went
- 1:04:03sideways though. And I think that
- 1:04:04sideways part was the trickiest because
- 1:04:06people had been rewarded before and I
- 1:04:08certainly was in this boat of you were
- 1:04:10up a lot of money on the short side, but
- 1:04:13then it all got taken away really really
- 1:04:14quickly by these vicious up moves that
- 1:04:17were happening.
- 1:04:18>> Yes.
- 1:04:18>> And it looked like maybe we might walk
- 1:04:20into one of those vicious up moves that
- 1:04:22was happening. So were you involved in
- 1:04:25the trade before that moment or later?
- 1:04:28>> Before the moment.
- 1:04:29>> Before the moment. Okay.
- 1:04:31>> So,
- 1:04:32>> so you're in the trade, right? And you
- 1:04:34have a clear stop high of day, I'm
- 1:04:36assuming. Right. [snorts]
- 1:04:38>> Is that okay? Cool. Generally, let's
- 1:04:40let's assume that's correct.
- 1:04:42>> And then you're thinking this can unwind
- 1:04:45maybe. Now, this is where I think they
- 1:04:48get this this gets really interesting.
- 1:04:52>> You're likely to
- 1:04:55>> It's great. It's great.
- 1:04:57Yeah. Where did you Where in your
- 1:04:59wildest dreams did you think it could
- 1:05:00possibly go?
- 1:05:04If you tell me 200, I know I know you're
- 1:05:06full of it because I don't think I don't
- 1:05:08think any of us that day thought it was
- 1:05:10going to 200 the next day.
- 1:05:13But maybe four or maybe five. Yeah, I
- 1:05:16certainly thought it I mean this thing
- 1:05:19could start the descent back into
- 1:05:23back into normaly land, but I the
- 1:05:27problem really is
- 1:05:29the P&L, you know, you see it and then
- 1:05:32you take it and need there's been a lot
- 1:05:34of trades, Jeeoff, maybe the traders
- 1:05:36listening can learn from this, too,
- 1:05:37where it's almost like if and I know
- 1:05:39you've mentioned turning the P&L off,
- 1:05:41but there's so many often times where if
- 1:05:43I just shut the computer down, took took
- 1:05:45a nap or something like that where it
- 1:05:47would hugely benefit me to just to set
- 1:05:50the levels like you said set the set the
- 1:05:52stop
- 1:05:53>> but be kind of flexible with the with
- 1:05:55the target. I mean maybe with the
- 1:05:57measured moves having having some orders
- 1:05:59out there to take partials but with a
- 1:06:01certain piece of it definitely just let
- 1:06:04it rip chip.
- 1:06:05>> Yeah. Yeah. And maybe that's a part of
- 1:06:07your strategy moving forward is you have
- 1:06:10to you that's a rule that you have to
- 1:06:12put in place of I need to hold but you
- 1:06:15have to solve that before you put the
- 1:06:17trade on because here's an interesting
- 1:06:19thing that starts to happen. Right? So
- 1:06:23we've studied this with with traders and
- 1:06:24and the way our brains work, right? So
- 1:06:27as soon as you put a position on, right?
- 1:06:30So you put a position on and and it's
- 1:06:32it's it's like a risk
- 1:06:35>> element. It becomes an emotional
- 1:06:36exercise. Before it's totally a logical
- 1:06:38exercise, but the trade's on and it
- 1:06:40becomes an emotional exercise, right?
- 1:06:42We'd all like it to remain logical, but
- 1:06:44that's not the case for for most of us,
- 1:06:46right? Most of us, it it becomes an
- 1:06:48emotional exercise. So,
- 1:06:51it's interesting because as you're
- 1:06:53holding your core, there tends to be a
- 1:06:55lot of for some traders, there tends to
- 1:06:57be a lot of fear or overconfidence or
- 1:07:00something along those lines, you know,
- 1:07:01almost like a disbelief that this is
- 1:07:03going to work out. And those traders
- 1:07:05tend to suffer from sort of that like,
- 1:07:08oh, I've got something in my past that
- 1:07:10really, you know, like I don't I'm not
- 1:07:12here to talk about trading psychology as
- 1:07:13much. I just call them like I see them.
- 1:07:15And that's what I've seen before is
- 1:07:17people are like, oh, you know, I'm I'm
- 1:07:19self-sabotaging, I think, is the term
- 1:07:20I've heard a lot, right? I'm really good
- 1:07:22at self-sabotaging. And that's why
- 1:07:24people are like, I take off too early
- 1:07:25because I have a pattern of
- 1:07:27self-sabotage. Maybe that's you, maybe
- 1:07:29it's not, but I've heard that many times
- 1:07:31before. I don't I I look at things a
- 1:07:35little more logically and a little more
- 1:07:36like, well, self-sabotage is this big
- 1:07:38giant thing. How do we get it to the
- 1:07:40bottleneck where we can actually solve a
- 1:07:42problem? Right? And so here are some
- 1:07:44things that are interesting
- 1:07:46with regard to when we're in a trade. We
- 1:07:50have a couple decisions. We can hold,
- 1:07:53we can add, or or we can start to take
- 1:07:56off.
- 1:07:57>> Just let the trade take you out is what
- 1:07:59you said. I heard you.
- 1:08:00>> Well, that that is true. That is true.
- 1:08:02And and certainly in a situation like
- 1:08:05this, um that probably is a solution.
- 1:08:09But I think that there's a component
- 1:08:10that we have to uncover first. And this
- 1:08:13is what we do with traders all the time
- 1:08:15on our desk is we actually get to that
- 1:08:17bottleneck and then we move forward.
- 1:08:18This is why I think we're successful at
- 1:08:20what we do at developing traders
- 1:08:23because we don't assume everything and
- 1:08:24we don't assume everybody's the same. So
- 1:08:27I'm going to ask you one important
- 1:08:28question. Did you take partials in that
- 1:08:31first down move?
- 1:08:35>> Meaning taking taking a position off,
- 1:08:37right? Okay. So, you took a position
- 1:08:39off. Yep. Quarters off. Okay. So, what
- 1:08:41do you think happens to your brain as
- 1:08:44you're taking quarters off? Do you go
- 1:08:46into more of a retreat mode or do you
- 1:08:48stay the aggressor in the position?
- 1:08:50>> Yeah, it's a good point. You stay go
- 1:08:52into the retreat mode, which
- 1:08:54you know, then the Einstein of Wall
- 1:08:56Street said this too. You know, he it's
- 1:08:58an it's an emotional thing. It's not a
- 1:09:00logical thing. It's an emotional where
- 1:09:02you're adjusting your stop. Now, I no
- 1:09:05longer can be read on the trade. And you
- 1:09:07said this too, which it it hit it hit
- 1:09:09hard with me. The there's a pain
- 1:09:11threshold and with it's double it's
- 1:09:16double that. How does it go? You know,
- 1:09:18you you feel the pain twice as much
- 1:09:22of a winner turning into a loser than
- 1:09:24you do
- 1:09:24>> a loser. And that's why we get so
- 1:09:26hopeful in those. And that makes sense.
- 1:09:28I feel certainly feel that.
- 1:09:30>> Yeah. It's interesting because as soon
- 1:09:32as you go into that retreat mode, right,
- 1:09:35as soon as your mind goes into profit
- 1:09:37taking, it really is hard and you have
- 1:09:40to be very conscious of no, no, no, this
- 1:09:43is an opportunity to stay the aggressor,
- 1:09:48right? And and so what I what I hear is
- 1:09:51is and I'm not trying to put words in
- 1:09:53your mouth, but what I'm hearing is this
- 1:09:55pattern that we've seen over and over.
- 1:09:56You probably size the trade perfectly
- 1:09:58fine.
- 1:09:59You probably sized the trade relatively
- 1:10:01close to what you wanted to size it. Is
- 1:10:03that correct?
- 1:10:07>> Correct.
- 1:10:07>> Okay. But you made one maybe
- 1:10:12fifth of what you thought you could have
- 1:10:14made in the trade had you done kind of
- 1:10:16what your ideal plan
- 1:10:18>> you know that's what it is.
- 1:10:19>> But you know and then I had a
- 1:10:20conversation with Alex Tiz. He he he
- 1:10:24spoke on how you know he sizes his
- 1:10:26winners. He doesn't care what his
- 1:10:28average is. hits hits into those
- 1:10:30winners. So it's not retreat mode, it's
- 1:10:32aggressor mode, which is what you just
- 1:10:34pointed out.
- 1:10:35>> Yes. Which
- 1:10:37>> which maybe you don't have the highest
- 1:10:39win rate doing that, but that becomes
- 1:10:41almost superfluous, right? And
- 1:10:43>> it's but it's but it it's understanding
- 1:10:45your psychology because if you're the
- 1:10:47type of person that is going to be the
- 1:10:50aggressor all the time and then you're
- 1:10:53going to get your face ripped off a
- 1:10:55bunch of times being the aggressor and
- 1:10:56that's going to set you back
- 1:10:58psychologically where you're going to
- 1:11:00feel uncomfortable with that then do not
- 1:11:02try and do that.
- 1:11:04Right? We talk about playing to our
- 1:11:07strengths as much as you possibly can
- 1:11:09and each of us have individual
- 1:11:10strengths. So it might be as a
- 1:11:12developing trader you try that you try
- 1:11:14to add add add but that might not fit
- 1:11:17your psychology it might not fit your
- 1:11:19personality and you have to admit that
- 1:11:22that's not for me I feel uncomfortable
- 1:11:25when I add add right me personally I
- 1:11:29feel much better when I'm in the trade
- 1:11:31but I have you know I I kind of find
- 1:11:33that pivotal we call it pivotal moment
- 1:11:35in the trade that moment where I can
- 1:11:38have my asset protocol I know where the
- 1:11:40entry is I know exactly where this trade
- 1:11:43should start to work in my favor
- 1:11:46and that's the moment for me to put the
- 1:11:48risk on. I don't need to stay the
- 1:11:51aggressor by adding but I do need to
- 1:11:53make sure that I am not going into
- 1:11:56retreat mode by taking off or if I do
- 1:11:59take off I have to remind myself to stay
- 1:12:03the aggressor with the rest of my
- 1:12:05position. I watched a live trade with
- 1:12:07you and this demonstrates it perfectly
- 1:12:09how you were working the 9 EMA. And for
- 1:12:12traders listening, this may help you as
- 1:12:14well if you're getting rid of your
- 1:12:15winners too early. What Jeff was doing
- 1:12:18is he attached essentially his uh his
- 1:12:21take profit to a break crack of that
- 1:12:23nine and until then not touching it.
- 1:12:25>> Yeah. And and it's not me adding into
- 1:12:27the position. I don't I personally I
- 1:12:30can't be more aggressive because it
- 1:12:32logically doesn't make sense to me.
- 1:12:33Typically, as the position's moving in
- 1:12:35my favor, if I find pretty close to the
- 1:12:38ideal expected value point, any ads
- 1:12:40after that are are diminishing returns,
- 1:12:43right? So, like my expected value in the
- 1:12:45trade is lower at that ad than it was
- 1:12:48when I entered the trade. So, why would
- 1:12:50I, you know, bet in a worse position
- 1:12:53after I put a bet on that's working,
- 1:12:55right? So, that's just my personality.
- 1:12:57It's the way it works. And some traders
- 1:12:59are that way. Others can be stay that
- 1:13:01aggressor. Um you know we have lot of
- 1:13:04different archetypes of traders. There
- 1:13:06are really three different archetypes
- 1:13:08whole different discussion but there
- 1:13:09really three archetypes of traders that
- 1:13:11we've identified and some of them are
- 1:13:14able to just add add and they don't mind
- 1:13:17if they get blown up or not blown up but
- 1:13:19like blown out. They were up a lot in
- 1:13:21the trade and then it comes back to a
- 1:13:23break even. They're comfortable with
- 1:13:25that. That's great if you're that type
- 1:13:27of person. Others need to maintain that
- 1:13:30sense of control through the entire
- 1:13:31trade, right? And it sounds like you
- 1:13:33were trying to do that, but you're also
- 1:13:35trying to be this third archetype, which
- 1:13:37is you let that trade work for you as
- 1:13:40well.
- 1:13:42>> And all the Yeah. The difference in
- 1:13:44those three, which is interesting to me,
- 1:13:47is
- 1:13:49the self-t talk that they use,
- 1:13:52>> right? the selft talk of somebody who's
- 1:13:55adding that entire time. Every time it
- 1:13:57gets there, they're adding more and
- 1:13:58they're ideally hopefully lowering their
- 1:14:00stop. Lowering their stop, lowering
- 1:14:02their stop or you know in the case of a
- 1:14:04long raising their stop, raising their
- 1:14:05stop. Their selft talk needs to be this
- 1:14:08is okay. This is okay to be doing. If I
- 1:14:11lose everything, that's okay because
- 1:14:14they have to kind of have that selft
- 1:14:16talk. If I lose it, that's okay because
- 1:14:18if I win big, I'm going to really really
- 1:14:21win. And that has to be their selft talk
- 1:14:23when they're in the trade, right?
- 1:14:25>> For the group that's that's kind of in
- 1:14:27the middle, right? The ones that are
- 1:14:29kind of overmanaging the trade and
- 1:14:31overmanaging is the wrong word, but they
- 1:14:33need that control. Their selft talk
- 1:14:35needs to be I'm going to catch the meat
- 1:14:38of the move. I'm going to catch the easy
- 1:14:40meat of the move, right?
- 1:14:43I'm going to catch that that core part
- 1:14:45of the move and I don't care what
- 1:14:47happens after that because I know I'm in
- 1:14:49this game and I'm going to catch that
- 1:14:51core part of the move, right? And that's
- 1:14:53what I'm here to do
- 1:14:56and that has to be their self-t talk for
- 1:14:59them to be effective. A lot of times
- 1:15:01it's the type of traders who are really
- 1:15:03actually very good at capturing that
- 1:15:05core part of the move,
- 1:15:09but they have to remind themselves that
- 1:15:10I can't worry about how far it goes
- 1:15:12after I'm out because I did the right
- 1:15:14thing, right?
- 1:15:16>> And then that other group did the right
- 1:15:17thing.
- 1:15:17>> Yeah. You did the right thing. Yeah. For
- 1:15:19for you. And maybe over time that
- 1:15:21evolves. But then this third archetype,
- 1:15:23this third group, and I know we're we're
- 1:15:25kind of throwing a lot at everybody, but
- 1:15:27this third group, their selft talk,
- 1:15:30maybe it's something where you take
- 1:15:31profits into extensions, but you want to
- 1:15:34hold for the bigger move.
- 1:15:37Your selft talk has to be I'm staying
- 1:15:41the aggressor.
- 1:15:43I'm not adding, but until they rip these
- 1:15:47shares out of my hands,
- 1:15:50they have to show me that they're taking
- 1:15:53these out of my hands. And it's really
- 1:15:55interesting because you would think the
- 1:15:56voice of the aggressor, that first
- 1:15:59group, is the most aggressive voice.
- 1:16:03Actually, typically that's the most
- 1:16:04passive voice because they're kind of
- 1:16:07saying, "Whatever happens happens. I'm
- 1:16:09just going to keep adding and let's see
- 1:16:10what happens, right?
- 1:16:12That middle voice is usually a moderate
- 1:16:14voice of like, "It's okay if I miss at
- 1:16:17the end." That last voice typically is
- 1:16:20the most aggressive voice, right? The
- 1:16:23one that they need to take these shares
- 1:16:26out of my hand. I'm going to make them
- 1:16:29beat me. And it sounds like to me, if we
- 1:16:32were talking through this, we were in a
- 1:16:34trade development meeting, I would say,
- 1:16:36your mindset was of that middle group,
- 1:16:39right? that core archetype if I want to
- 1:16:42catch the meat of the move. But you're
- 1:16:44trying to ask why couldn't I be that
- 1:16:48that that that third group, the one that
- 1:16:50like really forces it to take it out of
- 1:16:53my hands. you know, you're 100% accurate
- 1:16:56and obviously doing these interviews,
- 1:16:58you know, I'm hearing that how different
- 1:17:00traders operate and I wonder if your
- 1:17:05interns ask these questions too when
- 1:17:07they see some of your top performing uh
- 1:17:11traders at the firm trading a certain
- 1:17:13way and they too are asking, you know, h
- 1:17:16I want to trade that way, but
- 1:17:19>> do you think it's important that we
- 1:17:21trade? I mean you touched on this with
- 1:17:24trading our psychology that we need to
- 1:17:26find a strategy that is congruent with
- 1:17:29our personality because the first uh
- 1:17:32market wizard actually Michael Marcus
- 1:17:34said if you take two of the best traders
- 1:17:36and combine them you'll get the worst
- 1:17:38from both of them which is so
- 1:17:40fascinating but have you seen that? I
- 1:17:43mean, so we get asked probably a couple
- 1:17:46times a year, right? We'll have some
- 1:17:49somebody from a very esteemed university
- 1:17:51or somebody from a, you know, PE funded
- 1:17:54uh company that that comes to us and
- 1:17:57says, "Hey, I've got this brilliant
- 1:17:58idea." All right, why don't we uh study
- 1:18:03the personality types of all of your top
- 1:18:05traders to identify commonalities,
- 1:18:08right? And so let's say we have 15 20
- 1:18:11top traders that they would want to
- 1:18:12study, right? And their their pitch to
- 1:18:15us is we're going to tell you the
- 1:18:18personalities, the commonalities of all
- 1:18:21of your traders, right? So we're going
- 1:18:23to tell you what what all those traders
- 1:18:24have in common.
- 1:18:26And it's interesting because we we take
- 1:18:29it seriously. We look at the science
- 1:18:30behind it and all that stuff, but behind
- 1:18:32closed doors, our discussions are always
- 1:18:35like, well, these guys are all these
- 1:18:38these guys and girls are all so
- 1:18:40different and that's what makes them
- 1:18:42special. If we tried to say these are
- 1:18:45all the commonalities,
- 1:18:47it probably would be sort of what you
- 1:18:49talk about of this mismash of like,
- 1:18:52yeah, that's sort of that way. But the
- 1:18:54reason why I think every person that
- 1:18:56I've ever met that's been successful in
- 1:18:57markets, the reason for their success is
- 1:19:00because they're bringing themselves into
- 1:19:01the market. They're allowing themselves
- 1:19:03to be the guide. Now, they're copying,
- 1:19:05they're learning from from the masters
- 1:19:07in front of them first, right? So, on
- 1:19:10our desk, mentoring is not a one-person
- 1:19:13thing. You don't have one mentor. You
- 1:19:15have a series of mentors.
- 1:19:18And the reason for that is because
- 1:19:20you're going to pick up a little bit
- 1:19:21here and a little bit here and a little
- 1:19:22bit here. And then all of a sudden, if
- 1:19:24you're a developing trader, if you're a
- 1:19:26college kid coming in for an internship,
- 1:19:28or are you're a new developing trader
- 1:19:30wanting to join our firm, or even if
- 1:19:32you're an experienced trader who's
- 1:19:34looking to work in the team environments
- 1:19:35that we create, you're going to have
- 1:19:38different voices helping you grow.
- 1:19:43And the thing that's interesting about
- 1:19:45that is if you take all of those voices
- 1:19:48and then ultimately put that, you know,
- 1:19:50internally process that information, but
- 1:19:53then take what makes the most sense to
- 1:19:55you out of all that. That's really where
- 1:19:58the success comes in. You know, we just
- 1:20:00launched a a video where we highlighted
- 1:20:02one of our top teams and you even hear
- 1:20:05them talking about their different
- 1:20:07strengths, right? That's the coolest
- 1:20:09part is they all have different
- 1:20:11strengths. They don't have one
- 1:20:13personality type that makes them great.
- 1:20:15What makes them great is all of these
- 1:20:17different personality types.
- 1:20:19>> You know, Stanley Ducken Miller, he
- 1:20:21emphasized there's certain traits like
- 1:20:23passion, competitiveness,
- 1:20:24open-mindedness, humility, but he said
- 1:20:27something. He suggested that IQ, you
- 1:20:31know, you don't have to have the highest
- 1:20:32level of IQ, which I'm thankful for to
- 1:20:35be a successful trader. I mean, it's
- 1:20:39largely not a part. I mean, what are
- 1:20:41some of those traits? Are there certain
- 1:20:42traits like these guys are highly
- 1:20:44competitive, they're passionate? Passion
- 1:20:46runs deep in a lot of the interviews I
- 1:20:48discuss uh with traders this passion.
- 1:20:50What are are there any of those specific
- 1:20:52traits?
- 1:20:53>> Yeah, there are. Um, you know, we screen
- 1:20:56for them during the interview process.
- 1:20:58Uh, I would say that competitiveness is
- 1:21:01one of them. Diligence is one of them. I
- 1:21:04think being diligent really, really
- 1:21:06important as a trader. I think that gets
- 1:21:07underrated unfortunately a lot of time
- 1:21:10but being diligent is very important. Um
- 1:21:14that competitiveness goes along with it.
- 1:21:16Uh equinimity we think is very important
- 1:21:19like as a trader you know I had a we sh
- 1:21:22I shared a little bit about my my my
- 1:21:24family history but you know and and a
- 1:21:26little bit about me growing up but you
- 1:21:28know just like everybody else in life
- 1:21:30I've gone through my family's gone
- 1:21:31through some really traumatic
- 1:21:33experiences. You know, we've had we've
- 1:21:35had family members get very very sick
- 1:21:37and we've struggled with that and and
- 1:21:40you know, all those experiences are so
- 1:21:43painful in the moment. They really are.
- 1:21:47But they also are a great reminder that
- 1:21:50trading is just trading, right? like
- 1:21:53like when you're sitting there with a
- 1:21:54family member who's going through
- 1:21:55something awful and you're going through
- 1:21:57something awful as a family, you know,
- 1:22:00then you come in to trade the next day,
- 1:22:02you know, you obviously have to be
- 1:22:03careful with your sizing and everything
- 1:22:04like that, but like at the end of the
- 1:22:06day, trading is this thing that we get
- 1:22:09to do. And so that equinimity kind of
- 1:22:11gets built into you when you think about
- 1:22:13how this fits. We're all so lucky to be
- 1:22:16traders in the time that we're that
- 1:22:18we're traders. you know, 30 years ago,
- 1:22:2025 years ago, you basically had to be on
- 1:22:23a floor at an exchange. So that meant
- 1:22:26you had to live in New York, Chicago,
- 1:22:27London, you know, and maybe a couple
- 1:22:30other places in the world, plus have a
- 1:22:32seat on the exchange to be able to trade
- 1:22:34the way we get to trade, right? Like
- 1:22:37>> incredible.
- 1:22:38>> Like we have technology, we have
- 1:22:39artificial intelligence now. We have we
- 1:22:41we have Claude to help us with all of
- 1:22:43these things that we can do research
- 1:22:46that used to take teams of people hours
- 1:22:49and hours and hours of doing. I can do
- 1:22:51by myself in 10 minutes. You can do by
- 1:22:54yourself in 25 minutes. You can just
- 1:22:55like knock it all out. You could
- 1:22:57probably do it in five minutes or you
- 1:22:58could even create an agent that does it
- 1:23:00for you while you're sleeping. So you
- 1:23:02wake up and all the research is done for
- 1:23:03you. Like it's it's astounding the
- 1:23:05resources we have. And so I always view
- 1:23:08it as we just get this opportunity. And
- 1:23:10so we need to never allow ourselves to
- 1:23:12get too high or too low because the
- 1:23:15reality is this is an opportunity for us
- 1:23:17to take advantage of and we're really
- 1:23:19fortunate to be able to trade in the way
- 1:23:21that we trade um on our desk with the
- 1:23:23people that we trade with.
- 1:23:25>> Um you know that that's that's the
- 1:23:27beauty of it. So I think that equinimity
- 1:23:29is really important. I mean you hit on a
- 1:23:31couple of the other things that I think
- 1:23:32the characteristics that are really
- 1:23:34important. I think passion's overrated.
- 1:23:37And I've said this before and I know
- 1:23:39it's controversial. Some people say
- 1:23:41they're very passionate about the
- 1:23:42markets. Um I don't think it's a
- 1:23:45predictive signal. That's why I think
- 1:23:46it's overrated. I've seen intensely
- 1:23:49passionate people about the markets that
- 1:23:52never really explore edge. They're just
- 1:23:54really big fans of of trading, right?
- 1:23:58And you know, the Knicks won the won the
- 1:24:00championship this year. the streets were
- 1:24:03filled with passionate people about the
- 1:24:05the Knicks. None of them were playing
- 1:24:07basketball for the Knicks, but they were
- 1:24:10really passionate about that, right? And
- 1:24:12so I think you really if you're going to
- 1:24:13be a trader, you have to ask yourself
- 1:24:15that question. You have to come to terms
- 1:24:16with that. Am I here to be passionate
- 1:24:18about it or am I here to trade with
- 1:24:20edge? Because those are two different
- 1:24:22things. And I can be fascinated by
- 1:24:25markets. I am. I love talking about
- 1:24:27them. We all love talking about them.
- 1:24:29You know, when we recruit, we look for
- 1:24:31that interest in markets and
- 1:24:34specifically in the type of trading that
- 1:24:36we look to do. You know, when we teach,
- 1:24:39when we have have inside access, which
- 1:24:41is our our product that we just
- 1:24:43broadcast all our meetings that people
- 1:24:45can kind of come and listen, you know,
- 1:24:47so we can provide something to the
- 1:24:48community. Um, you know, when we're
- 1:24:51talking about it, we're talking about
- 1:24:53the type of trading that we do. And
- 1:24:56there's a lot of energy and emotion
- 1:24:58about it. But we always are careful that
- 1:25:00that passion
- 1:25:02has some edge to it, has a little grit
- 1:25:04to it because it needs that. There needs
- 1:25:07to be a positive expectancy out of it.
- 1:25:10Not just I'm doing this because it's
- 1:25:11fun, but I'm doing this because I expect
- 1:25:13there to be a positive outcome from
- 1:25:15this.
- 1:25:15>> You know, I can tell so clearly how
- 1:25:17passionate you are. I mean, as head of
- 1:25:20trader development and recruiting,
- 1:25:21you're [laughter] so passionate and hey,
- 1:25:24thank you, you know, for taking the
- 1:25:25time. I have a few more questions if you
- 1:25:27are available for them. But, you know,
- 1:25:29as far as what you were saying about
- 1:25:31just being so lucky to be able to trade
- 1:25:34alongside your peers, your colleagues at
- 1:25:37SMB. I mean, how important do you think
- 1:25:40that is? Is that almost an edge itself?
- 1:25:42Because I had a conversation with Jason
- 1:25:44Barry, Mr. consistency from the next
- 1:25:46generation. And that was one of the
- 1:25:48largest takeaways from the conversation
- 1:25:50with him. He was discussing how if you
- 1:25:52can pair yourself with some other
- 1:25:55traders, it sharpens you significantly.
- 1:25:58What are your thoughts on that?
- 1:25:59>> Yeah, I mean, let's see, it would have
- 1:26:02been 2020,
- 1:26:04probably 20 2019, we started the concept
- 1:26:07of team trading. [snorts] And I think
- 1:26:09this is a big big thing that we've done
- 1:26:11and I think other people are starting to
- 1:26:12do it as well. But we've really
- 1:26:15just like anything else we do, just like
- 1:26:17anything else I do, we have really
- 1:26:19worked hard to put clear ground rules
- 1:26:22around what these actually are. When we
- 1:26:25say team trading, we don't mean a group
- 1:26:28of people that are sharing ideas and
- 1:26:31talking about their trades, but then all
- 1:26:33executing independently.
- 1:26:35That's not team trading to us. That is
- 1:26:38community trading which is really good
- 1:26:41right and that's a big step beyond
- 1:26:45what trading as an independent trader
- 1:26:47without any support actually is you know
- 1:26:49community trading is a big leap forward
- 1:26:53and it will help everybody. You'll get
- 1:26:56to share your ideas. You'll have a
- 1:26:57little more accountability. You'll get
- 1:26:59to talk with people. They'll get to talk
- 1:27:01with you. You'll hear things. Maybe over
- 1:27:03the course of a month, you'll pick up
- 1:27:04two ideas that you weren't really
- 1:27:06thinking of that could turn into the
- 1:27:08opportunity of the month or even just a
- 1:27:10good baseline trade, right? And
- 1:27:12hopefully you're adding that value back
- 1:27:14to the people in your community. I think
- 1:27:16community trading is a really nice first
- 1:27:18step.
- 1:27:20There's a difference between community
- 1:27:21trading and team trading, though.
- 1:27:24The biggest difference is something
- 1:27:26that, you know, and I'll just share this
- 1:27:29as a team. If you had a team that wasn't
- 1:27:31on the same playbook,
- 1:27:33would they be a very good team in any
- 1:27:35sport anywhere?
- 1:27:38They probably wouldn't, right? They'd
- 1:27:40probably struggle with consistency. They
- 1:27:43would struggle with direction. They
- 1:27:44might have some ups, they might have
- 1:27:46some downs, but they they would really
- 1:27:47struggle with what are we all here to
- 1:27:49do? And that tends to be one of the
- 1:27:52things that we use to structurally
- 1:27:54define a team. Do are you on the same
- 1:27:56playbook or not? because if you're not,
- 1:27:58you're more like a community of traders
- 1:28:00than you are a team of traders. And so
- 1:28:04we developed this team trading concept
- 1:28:07and we've allowed and and really our
- 1:28:09traders have allowed us to participate
- 1:28:12in them building teams.
- 1:28:15And that's one of the most interesting
- 1:28:17things is seeing how these teams evolve
- 1:28:20and and seeing how everybody starts as
- 1:28:22an independent trader and then you get
- 1:28:24into a community of traders and then as
- 1:28:26a community you ultimately move into,
- 1:28:28you know, you pair up with a couple
- 1:28:29other people. You start to share a
- 1:28:31playbook and then you start to do
- 1:28:33something that we call pack hunting,
- 1:28:34right? When there are your best
- 1:28:36opportunities, you know, when it's a big
- 1:28:38game for for a for a sports team, when
- 1:28:40if it's a football team, when there's a
- 1:28:42big game coming up, like I love college
- 1:28:44football. I grew up, you know, around
- 1:28:46college football. So, so when there's a
- 1:28:48big game coming up, I bet you that
- 1:28:50team's preparation is a little bit, you
- 1:28:51know, tighter. Everybody's ready. Even
- 1:28:54the guy running around guy and girl
- 1:28:55running around squirting water in
- 1:28:56people's mouths are a little bit
- 1:28:57snappier than like, you know, when it's
- 1:28:59just like a normal summer practice,
- 1:29:01right? Like like that intensity is is is
- 1:29:03is there. And so the same thing I think
- 1:29:05holds true when you get into team
- 1:29:07trading. Um is is it really allows
- 1:29:10people to bond together and and our our
- 1:29:12traders are terrific. I mean, the people
- 1:29:14that I look at on our desk are
- 1:29:16spectacular. Um, they're inspirational
- 1:29:18to me all the time and and I feel so
- 1:29:21lucky to be a part of it. Um, but at the
- 1:29:24same point, you know, we've got this
- 1:29:25amazing opportunity and and really we
- 1:29:29have a responsibility to see how far we
- 1:29:32can push it, right? Everybody that I
- 1:29:34work with, everybody that we work with,
- 1:29:36we have a responsibility to see how good
- 1:29:38we can get. And I don't think we're
- 1:29:41nearly there quite yet. I think we're
- 1:29:43showing that we have that room to grow,
- 1:29:46but I don't think we're nearly there
- 1:29:47yet. And we're always looking for great
- 1:29:49people to help us push that even
- 1:29:51further. I think that's an important
- 1:29:53thing for us, whether it's in the
- 1:29:54trading community or people that are
- 1:29:56experienced traders or even interns in
- 1:29:59college who are thinking about trading.
- 1:30:00You know, we're always looking for those
- 1:30:02people who are really going to help us
- 1:30:05achieve what we're capable of achieving
- 1:30:07as as teams and as individuals and as a
- 1:30:09firm.
- 1:30:10>> Yeah. Talking to some amazing traders on
- 1:30:13here, they're they're doing exactly what
- 1:30:14you're saying. They're they're always
- 1:30:16hungry for more. Even if they've gone to
- 1:30:18the seven figure level, they still want
- 1:30:20to consume podcasts. They still want to
- 1:30:22learn from other traders. It's quite
- 1:30:24amazing, you know, hearing that. Uh, but
- 1:30:28Jeeoff, as we're wrapping up, you know,
- 1:30:30one of the final questions I I have
- 1:30:32here, [snorts] and I could we could be
- 1:30:34talking for another two hours, maybe
- 1:30:35we'll do a part two one of these days,
- 1:30:38but you know, you've spent years
- 1:30:40developing traders, so I want to ask you
- 1:30:43the single most important thing for
- 1:30:45developing traders you want that you
- 1:30:47want them to get right. Oh,
- 1:30:50the single most important thing for
- 1:30:52developing traders that I want them to
- 1:30:54get right. Um, I'm gonna have to think
- 1:30:57on that for a minute because that is an
- 1:30:59interesting
- 1:31:01question
- 1:31:03because I don't think that there's one
- 1:31:05thing that they need to get right. I
- 1:31:08think there are a lot of things that
- 1:31:09they need to get right, but I guess if I
- 1:31:12had to answer it as one question and and
- 1:31:15by the way, most of those things are the
- 1:31:18things that in my mind that I'm thinking
- 1:31:20they need to get right. Right. And maybe
- 1:31:22maybe this will be part two or whatever,
- 1:31:24but the things that I'm thinking of are
- 1:31:26all
- 1:31:28I classify things in two ways. Are they
- 1:31:30easy to do or hard to do? Right? And if
- 1:31:34they're easy to do, and I think all
- 1:31:35these things that I'm thinking of are
- 1:31:37easy to do, but all of them are easier
- 1:31:39not to do.
- 1:31:42So like all the things that I'm asking
- 1:31:43that that we want our traders to do are
- 1:31:45actually relatively easy to do. They're
- 1:31:47just easier to not not to do, right? So
- 1:31:50it's easy to do a daily report card
- 1:31:52every day, right? It's a lot easier to
- 1:31:54not do a daily report card every day,
- 1:31:56right? So like that's that slippery
- 1:31:58slope of of a lot of the things that I'm
- 1:32:00thinking about, right? I think at the
- 1:32:02end of the day, if there's one thing
- 1:32:04that that traders have to get right at
- 1:32:07every level, I think you have to always
- 1:32:10be in a position
- 1:32:13where you are allocating appropriately
- 1:32:17to the trade. I think you have to get
- 1:32:20the risk management right in this
- 1:32:24because without it, you don't have a
- 1:32:25very long runway. you just don't have
- 1:32:29you don't you won't have the staying
- 1:32:31power and even if you do have an
- 1:32:33insanely high win rate, it's really
- 1:32:36really hard to grow as a trader if you
- 1:32:38can't manage your risk. And so you don't
- 1:32:41have that scalability on the other side
- 1:32:43of it, right? So you might not even stay
- 1:32:45in the game very long, but even if you
- 1:32:47do, it's impossible to continue to scale
- 1:32:50your trading.
- 1:32:52And it's important for us to to be
- 1:32:55surrounded by it's important for us to
- 1:32:56hold a standard of traders on our desk
- 1:32:59being on a path to be seven and eight
- 1:33:00figure traders. The only way to do that
- 1:33:02is by being scalable. For me, it's
- 1:33:04important to work with teams that are
- 1:33:06infinitely scalable over a period of
- 1:33:09time. That's what I'm passionate about
- 1:33:12now more than ever is not just the
- 1:33:14individuals, but the teams I get to work
- 1:33:16with and seeing the incredible results
- 1:33:19our teams are generating much faster
- 1:33:22than we expected them to generate. You
- 1:33:24know, that's a lot of fun for me.
- 1:33:27>> Well, Jeeoff, you know, we've talked I
- 1:33:29mean there's so much value here.
- 1:33:31Building the baseline, the edge,
- 1:33:33creating systems, protecting capital,
- 1:33:35having really the courage, too, like you
- 1:33:36mentioned to swing when you need to
- 1:33:39swing. It was an incredible
- 1:33:41conversation. There's so much value
- 1:33:42here. Traders, let us know what you
- 1:33:43think in the comments below. But Jeeoff,
- 1:33:46the last word's going to go over to you
- 1:33:48and of course, let the traders know
- 1:33:50where they can keep up with you and
- 1:33:51follow along.
- 1:33:52>> Yeah, I'm sure there will be a bunch of
- 1:33:53links in there and and people can take a
- 1:33:55look at them if they want. You know, we
- 1:33:57just try and provide as much value as
- 1:33:59possible. I mean, I started out as an
- 1:34:00independent trader. Um, I have an
- 1:34:02interesting backstory in trading, but uh
- 1:34:04we'll save that for another day. But,
- 1:34:06you know, when I started out, I was I
- 1:34:07was, you know, kind of learning from
- 1:34:09YouTube and and and and trying to learn
- 1:34:11from anywhere I could. And so, I
- 1:34:13understand how hard it is when you're
- 1:34:15starting out to trust information. And
- 1:34:16so, we really hold ourselves to a high
- 1:34:18standard that anything goes out goes out
- 1:34:20that goes out is quality. Um, you know,
- 1:34:23we try and put content out on YouTube.
- 1:34:25Uh, you know, a lot of times it's just
- 1:34:28it's stuff where funny story about it
- 1:34:31actually. So, I didn't start wanting to
- 1:34:33do videos at all. I didn't want to do
- 1:34:35any of that stuff. Bella asked me and I
- 1:34:36was like, "No, no, no." But I was
- 1:34:38writing emails to all of our traders.
- 1:34:41Not all of our traders, but like each
- 1:34:42week I would write an email to a trader
- 1:34:45and I would always CC Bella and it was
- 1:34:47always something like, "Hey, I saw you
- 1:34:49doing this really, really well.
- 1:34:51Appreciate you." Like it was just like a
- 1:34:53gratitude exercise, right? Something
- 1:34:55simple. And he was like, "These are
- 1:34:56really good." like he was like, "You
- 1:34:58should just turn them into videos so
- 1:35:00they can go up on YouTube and then
- 1:35:03they're there forever versus you just
- 1:35:05having them lost in your email." And I
- 1:35:07was like, "I'll try it once." And so I I
- 1:35:10tried it, but every video that I ever do
- 1:35:14is actually just that same concept. It's
- 1:35:16a letter to one specific person that,
- 1:35:20you know, then goes into this video. So,
- 1:35:22every time we're sitting down to produce
- 1:35:24a video, at least from the work that I
- 1:35:25do, it's always to one person. There's a
- 1:35:28lesson that I want one person to learn
- 1:35:30or something that they've done really
- 1:35:32well that I want to highlight for them.
- 1:35:34And I don't really ever tell the person
- 1:35:35who it is. But, but you know, Kevin, if
- 1:35:38you see a video and you're like, "He was
- 1:35:39talking about me." There's a chance that
- 1:35:41I was talking about you. So, you know,
- 1:35:44like that's it's one of the things
- 1:35:45that's that's so much fun about what we
- 1:35:47get to do. But, you know, as far as
- 1:35:48closing words,
- 1:35:49>> group coming soon. [laughter]
- 1:35:51I mean, if if you see us saying don't
- 1:35:54sell here and here's exactly, you know,
- 1:35:55like all that stuff, but like like like
- 1:35:57no, we probably won't do that. But, um,
- 1:36:00it's always we're so lucky to be able to
- 1:36:03participate in markets at the time that
- 1:36:05we do. We're so lucky to be able to do
- 1:36:08what we do and and be traders. You know,
- 1:36:10we could have been born anywhere in the
- 1:36:11world. We could have been born at any
- 1:36:13point in the history of humanity. And
- 1:36:15and we all are living right now. Let's
- 1:36:18take advantage of the opportunity
- 1:36:19presented. And all of us, like I said, I
- 1:36:22believe this firmly. Everything that
- 1:36:24makes a successful trader successful is
- 1:36:26easy to do, but it's just easier not to
- 1:36:30do. So, you just have to hold yourself
- 1:36:31to that standard all the time.
- 1:36:33>> Hold yourself to the standard. Well,
- 1:36:35traders, baseline plus A+ equals the
- 1:36:38trading career. If you made it this far,
- 1:36:40comment that below. Jeeoff, I appreciate
- 1:36:42you. Thank you so much for coming on,
- 1:36:44adding value to the traders. And until
- 1:36:46next time, I'm sure we'll see you soon.
- 1:36:48>> Thanks.
- 1:36:48>> Take care.
- 1:36:49>> You've reached the end of this episode
- 1:36:51of Chat with Traders, but rest assured,
- 1:36:54there are more episodes loaded [music]
- 1:36:55with real market insight and zero hype
- 1:36:58on the way soon. So, to stay updated
- 1:37:01with each [music] great new release,
- 1:37:03subscribe to the podcast. And we'd love
- 1:37:04it if you'd leave a rating and review.
- 1:37:07We'll catch you next time on Chat with
- 1:37:09Traders.
- 1:37:14>> [music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of How Top Prop Traders Find and Scale Their Edge · Jeff Holden by Chat With Traders, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 18,853 words across 2,646 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.