How to Spot a Psychopath — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Hi everybody.
- 0:01This is the eighth consecutive week of
- 0:05releases from my extensive tour
- 0:07archives. We've been gratified to see
- 0:10that this return to the form that I
- 0:13initially relied on when I started using
- 0:15YouTube is still capable of reaching
- 0:18people.
- 0:19More capable perhaps than it was in the
- 0:21beginning. We're attaining combined
- 0:24views and listens across YouTube and the
- 0:26audio channels of about half a million
- 0:27people a week. So, that's very
- 0:31satisfying and gratifying and thank you
- 0:33to all of you who are listening
- 0:34consistently.
- 0:36I also spent a lot of time this week
- 0:38contemplating
- 0:40Peterson Academy ads. We have a
- 0:43wonderful advertising team and
- 0:45have worked on developing cutlines and
- 0:47assessing graphic images and realized
- 0:50this week that we're really reaching
- 0:52millions of people with these
- 0:53advertisements. Far more in some ways
- 0:56than we reach with the lectures from
- 0:58Peterson Academy and it's an opportunity
- 1:00for us to send a cultural message in
- 1:02imagistic form to
- 1:05a huge audience of people.
- 1:08And so
- 1:09we've been concentrating on developing
- 1:11themes of patriotism and respect for the
- 1:13West and gratitude for our philosophical
- 1:16tradition and a harsher and more
- 1:19dramatic view of Christianity that I
- 1:22think is more accurate than the kind of
- 1:25naive sentimentality that often
- 1:27accompanies Christian messaging. And so
- 1:29it's been extremely interesting to think
- 1:31that through philosophically and to work
- 1:33on the Peterson Academy advertisements.
- 1:36Bye-bye.
- 1:38So, I've been writing the introduction
- 1:39to my this book. Um it's it's 95% done.
- 1:44It actually turned into three books.
- 1:47Um cuz it took longer to go through the
- 1:49material that I thought it might and so
- 1:51that's good.
- 1:52I was writing the intro today, the
- 1:53introduction, which is the hardest thing
- 1:55to do really I would say.
- 1:57And uh
- 1:59I started thinking about how to
- 2:03communicate
- 2:06the relationship between the
- 2:08transcendent and the
- 2:10immediate
- 2:12between our realm, you might say, and
- 2:14the spiritual realm, how to communicate
- 2:16that so that it's entirely
- 2:20entirely comprehensible.
- 2:23And it It seems to me that this is
- 2:25something that's now necessary. I mean
- 2:29I think we're at the point in our
- 2:31technological
- 2:33cultural development where
- 2:37uh we can't believe
- 2:39we can't just believe nothing.
- 2:41That's that doesn't work. You You can't
- 2:45make your way through life
- 2:47believing in nothing.
- 2:48Life is too difficult
- 2:51for you to sustain yourself without
- 2:53bitterness and resentment without
- 2:55hopelessness, without succumbing to
- 2:57anxiety
- 2:59if you believe in nothing.
- 3:04But you can't just believe like someone
- 3:05believes in Santa Claus, either.
- 3:08You have to
- 3:11You have to be deeper than that, and I
- 3:13think we have to be deeper than that now
- 3:14because we're too dangerous to be
- 3:16shallow.
- 3:17And I think everyone can feel that. We
- 3:19have
- 3:21amazing tools at our disposal.
- 3:25But they're very, very dangerous. And
- 3:27so, we have to be as wise as we are
- 3:29technologically proficient.
- 3:32And we're pretty technologically
- 3:33proficient. And we're not very wise. And
- 3:36that's not a good combination.
- 3:41And that's why things are shaking. And
- 3:42they've been shaking for quite a while.
- 3:44They've really been shaking, I would
- 3:45say, since the end of the Second World
- 3:46War, when we developed the
- 3:49atomic technologies that
- 3:52led to the
- 3:54to the nuclear bombs, to the
- 3:57fission bomb and the fusion bomb.
- 3:59World-destroying technologies, and those
- 4:02aren't the only technologies of that
- 4:04sort that we've developed. We've
- 4:07The birth control pill is a world
- 4:08shattering technology. The
- 4:11computer chip is a world shattering
- 4:12technology. The large language models we
- 4:15just developed this year, they have the
- 4:18same nature.
- 4:23So, we're going to
- 4:24we're going to take a look at the
- 4:25background of things tonight and we're
- 4:27going to start
- 4:28by investigating
- 4:31what's going on behind the scenes
- 4:33in a relatively everyday manner.
- 4:36This introductory chapter that I'm
- 4:37writing, I started with that
- 4:39description of someone
- 4:42I imagined a man, so I'm a man, I
- 4:44imagined a man on a first date
- 4:47in a busy
- 4:49restaurant. Typical situation of
- 4:53excitement and anticipation and
- 4:56nervousness.
- 4:59Nothing out of the ordinary.
- 5:02Uh
- 5:04except in so far as everything is out of
- 5:06the ordinary if you
- 5:08if you think about it.
- 5:10If you think about it
- 5:11sufficiently.
- 5:17Imagine that
- 5:20the scene is set in a restaurant that's
- 5:22extremely
- 5:24it's busy and noisy.
- 5:26And uh
- 5:27young man comes in
- 5:31waiting to
- 5:33see the woman that he's invited out for
- 5:35an evening and
- 5:36maybe they've met online
- 5:38and uh they decided to meet at this
- 5:40restaurant.
- 5:41And so
- 5:45he sees her at the table.
- 5:48His initial impression, we'll say, is
- 5:50positive.
- 5:51He sits down
- 5:54and they start to
- 5:56Well, they start to what? They start to
- 5:58talk. They start to
- 6:01dance the way people do when they're
- 6:02you're
- 6:03If you're attending to someone
- 6:06when you're talking to them,
- 6:08you tend to match your movements with
- 6:10them.
- 6:12Depressed mothers don't do that with
- 6:13their babies.
- 6:15If you film, video tape
- 6:18mothers
- 6:19who aren't depressed with their babies
- 6:21and are depressed with their babies and
- 6:23you speed up the films, you can see that
- 6:25the mothers who aren't depressed
- 6:27dance as they're communicating with the
- 6:29babies.
- 6:30The baby moves, the mother moves, like
- 6:31there's a continual
- 6:33back and forth exchange of
- 6:36information, but also bodily maneuvering
- 6:39that characterizes an attentive
- 6:41relationship. And
- 6:42you'll notice,
- 6:44perhaps, if you're sitting with someone
- 6:46and you're
- 6:47talking to them and you're listening,
- 6:49more importantly, you're listening, much
- 6:51more importantly, that you'll
- 6:54unconsciously mimic their posture and
- 6:56you'll
- 6:57adjust their
- 6:59your rate of movement to theirs. You
- 7:01start to dance.
- 7:03When a couple dances together,
- 7:06that's actually one of the things
- 7:07they're checking each other out for.
- 7:09It's like, are you capable of adjusting
- 7:12yourself in real time to the
- 7:15movements and subtle offerings of
- 7:16someone else?
- 7:18That's what's being evaluated. That's
- 7:20what children do when they meet each
- 7:21other in a playground and they decide
- 7:23whether they can play. They send some
- 7:24signals back and forth and they see if
- 7:26they can get into a
- 7:27communicative dance and if they can do
- 7:29that, then they can scaffold off that
- 7:31and begin to play. And we're doing that
- 7:33sort of thing all the time.
- 7:34And
- 7:37the couple
- 7:38who are just encountering each other in
- 7:39the restaurant are
- 7:41undertaking to do that. And they're
- 7:43evaluating each other
- 7:47while that is occurring.
- 7:50Now, while they're doing that, they have
- 7:51to solve another problem. It's a very
- 7:53complicated problem. So, imagine they're
- 7:55in the restaurant. Imagine it's a very
- 7:57busy place, noisy.
- 8:00A lot of background activity, kitchen
- 8:02noises. Maybe there's a DJ. There's 30
- 8:04other couples or families or groups of
- 8:06friends sitting there, and they're all
- 8:08buzzing away, talking and chatting, and
- 8:10so there's like
- 8:1140 conversations going on plus the
- 8:16activity of the waiters and the
- 8:18waitresses and the music.
- 8:21Now, what you have to do in a situation
- 8:23like that is you have to
- 8:26filter all that out and attend
- 8:29to the
- 8:31person that you're sitting with.
- 8:34Now,
- 8:37that's a very complicated thing to do.
- 8:39It's an amazing thing you can do it at
- 8:41all. Now, you can imagine that you're
- 8:42sitting there and
- 8:45well, maybe you're nervous.
- 8:48And then you might ask why.
- 8:50But imagine you're nervous. Your
- 8:52attention is distracted. You're
- 8:54distracted by self-conscious thoughts.
- 8:58That often happens. You're wondering
- 9:01what the person thinks of you. You're
- 9:02wondering
- 9:03if they think you're attractive. They
- 9:05one you're wondering
- 9:07if you're impressing them. You're
- 9:09wondering
- 9:11what you should say next.
- 9:15You're wondering how to make the best
- 9:16display of yourself.
- 9:21And while doing that, you're focusing on
- 9:22yourself and not them.
- 9:25And while you're doing that, if you're
- 9:26focusing on yourself, you're going to be
- 9:29anxious.
- 9:31Because it turns out that there's no
- 9:32difference in a social situation between
- 9:35focusing on yourself and being anxious.
- 9:37There's no difference between
- 9:38self-consciousness
- 9:39and anxiety. That's why when the scales
- 9:43fall from out of Adam and Eve's eyes in
- 9:45the Garden of Paradise, they become
- 9:47aware of their nakedness, and that
- 9:50precipitates That's part of what
- 9:51precipitates the fall. To become
- 9:54self-conscious is to
- 9:56is to be miserable. It's to descend.
- 10:00And that's a very useful thing to know.
- 10:01And so one of the things you
- 10:03could take away from this talk tonight
- 10:05if you tend to be a socially anxious
- 10:07person is that
- 10:08the next time you're anxious,
- 10:10pay more attention to the person you're
- 10:11with.
- 10:12Don't pay less attention to yourself.
- 10:15That doesn't work, cuz as soon as you
- 10:16start thinking that you should pay less
- 10:17attention to yourself,
- 10:19you're just thinking about yourself, and
- 10:20then you get anxious. But, you can
- 10:22really, really increase the amount of
- 10:25attention you're paying to the other
- 10:26person. And if you do that, which is a
- 10:28hospitable thing to do, by the way,
- 10:31then your anxiety will decrease.
- 10:34And then,
- 10:36well, then you might imagine, too, that
- 10:37you could get distracted by the
- 10:39conversations of the people around you,
- 10:42right? And so, your attention might
- 10:44wander, so that you were
- 10:46eavesdropping on the table next to you,
- 10:48or two tables away, or you hear the
- 10:49music, or
- 10:51your your attention is fragmented, and
- 10:52as a consequence of that, you you lose
- 10:55the thread of the conversation, and you
- 10:57step out of sync with the person you're
- 10:59communicating with. And that sets up
- 11:01some awkwardnesses in the conversation.
- 11:03You maybe have to ask
- 11:06the person to repeat what they said, or
- 11:07you misunderstand something, and then
- 11:09you say something foolish, and
- 11:11the melody of the the through line of
- 11:14the conversation starts to get
- 11:16disrupted, and the dance is
- 11:19the dance becomes awkward. You're
- 11:20stepping on each other's toes.
- 11:23And
- 11:25that's a consequence of the
- 11:26fragmentation of your attention.
- 11:28>> What's it called?
- 11:29>> Peterson Academy.
- 11:30>> Peterson Academy. Peterson Academy.
- 11:32>> It's called Peterson Academy.
- 11:33>> Peterson Academy. If you want an actual
- 11:36education,
- 11:37>> with hand-selected professors from top
- 11:39universities around the world.
- 11:42>> Bringing the best professors together,
- 11:43making sure they're not censored in any
- 11:45way, giving them the audience and the
- 11:46remuneration and appreciation they
- 11:47deserve.
- 11:48>> were true to your word. You gave me
- 11:49absolute intellectual autonomy. I have
- 11:51had it through every course.
- 11:52>> We figure we can offer people a
- 11:54high-quality university-level education
- 11:57for under $2,000.
- 11:58>> Well, congratulations, Jordan. It's
- 12:00honestly brilliant. Can't wait to enroll
- 12:01myself. I'll be doing that straight
- 12:02after this.
- 12:04>> Find Joe.
- 12:15>> What does it mean to attend?
- 12:23Well, that's where things get strange.
- 12:26What does it mean to attend?
- 12:29Why are you attending?
- 12:31That's the first question. What the hell
- 12:33are you doing there?
- 12:35Right? Cuz you can be sure that the
- 12:37person you're with wants to know that.
- 12:39And you want to know that, too.
- 12:42And so, let's take apart
- 12:45why you're there.
- 12:47You're there
- 12:51Let's Let's Let's presume this.
- 12:54I'll tell you something about
- 12:57human
- 12:59social and sexual patterns.
- 13:01We'll We'll approach this from the
- 13:02biological perspective.
- 13:05In the
- 13:08Most animals reproduce sexually.
- 13:11There's There's complicated for that.
- 13:13It's not strictly necessary. There are
- 13:15animals that can essentially clone
- 13:17themselves. It's not a good strategy.
- 13:19Sexual reproduction is a much better
- 13:21strategy, which is why virtually all
- 13:23species are sexually dimorphic
- 13:26dimorphic. Two sexes.
- 13:28Right? Two. Right.
- 13:31Right.
- 13:39There are various types of sexual
- 13:41strategies in the animal kingdom.
- 13:43Reproduction strategies. That's a better
- 13:45way of thinking about it.
- 13:49On the one end of the distribution of
- 13:51sexual strategies, are low investment
- 13:55high reproduction rate strategies.
- 13:57Um puffballs have that strategy. I don't
- 14:01know if you know the mushroom that's a
- 14:02puffball. It dries, and if you step on
- 14:04it, it puffs out
- 14:06what looks like smoke, but which is
- 14:07actually like hundreds of millions of
- 14:09spores.
- 14:11An immense number of them. And they just
- 14:13float on the wind, and they land
- 14:15anywhere, and
- 14:17even if there's a hundred million of
- 14:19them, there's actually more produced,
- 14:21they all die
- 14:23except one on average, and so
- 14:26we maintain our number of puffballs,
- 14:30but we don't end up knee-deep in them,
- 14:32which is what would happen if the
- 14:33success rate was higher. That's a
- 14:37high reproduction rate, low investment
- 14:39strategy.
- 14:42On the other end of the distribution
- 14:45are human beings, as it turns out.
- 14:48We're low reproduction rate, high
- 14:51investment strategy
- 14:53reproducers. And so, what does that
- 14:55mean? Well, it means
- 14:57you don't have very many kids.
- 15:00I don't know what the world record for
- 15:01number of children
- 15:04for a woman is. It's something like 70.
- 15:07Right?
- 15:08Right. It's a lot. It's a very rare
- 15:10woman who has 70. Very, very
- 15:14Right. The upper end for men is much
- 15:16higher, but for women, it's 70. But that
- 15:20But that's not the typical number of
- 15:22children, obviously. The
- 15:24typical number of children, well,
- 15:26historically, was
- 15:30two on average, because the human
- 15:32population was very stable for a very
- 15:34long period of time. In the last hundred
- 15:36years, as we've become
- 15:39200, as we've become wealthier,
- 15:44our
- 15:45the rate of survival of our children has
- 15:47increased dramatically, but it was quite
- 15:49dismal for a long time. Even so, we
- 15:52didn't have very many children.
- 15:55It's nine months of pregnancy. It's
- 15:57quite difficult.
- 15:59The human infant is very, very dependent
- 16:05when it's first born. There's a variety
- 16:06of reasons for that.
- 16:09We have very large heads.
- 16:12It's hard for the heads to pass through
- 16:13the uh
- 16:15the pelvic structure. Women's pelvic
- 16:17structure is very carefully balanced.
- 16:19It's
- 16:21hips are wide enough so the baby can
- 16:24pass through, but narrow enough so she
- 16:26can still run. And that's a very
- 16:29tight competition.
- 16:31And one of the ways we finesse that is
- 16:34that our infants are born about a year
- 16:36younger than they might be for a mammal
- 16:38of approximately our size. And our
- 16:41infants' heads are compressible.
- 16:43Often a baby after just after it's born
- 16:46has a like a cone-shaped head cuz the
- 16:48skull's compressible. It's a very
- 16:51narrow passageway into life.
- 16:54And
- 16:57it's a consequence in part of our
- 16:58cortical evolution, the expansion of our
- 17:00brain.
- 17:02And the price we pay for that is not
- 17:04only
- 17:06trouble in childbirth, let's say, and
- 17:08the requirement for our infants to be
- 17:11born in essentially a quasi-fetal state,
- 17:15you know, as a opposed to say the
- 17:17a baby calf that can stand up and walk
- 17:19within minutes after it's born.
- 17:22Human infant is basically immobile for 6
- 17:25months and barely mobile for nine and
- 17:28can't walk at all for till about 12
- 17:31months and then
- 17:32can't take care of itself till it's
- 17:3540 and
- 17:42And so they take a lot of investment.
- 17:45And it's not just a single generation of
- 17:48investment, it's a multi-generational
- 17:50investment. That's part of the reason
- 17:52why we're a longer-lived species because
- 17:54there's some utility from a reproductive
- 17:56I'm speaking purely biologically, you
- 17:58understand.
- 17:59There's some utility in having
- 18:01grandparents around because the problem
- 18:03of raising children is so difficult that
- 18:05it has to be borne by a number of
- 18:08closely related people over a very long
- 18:10period of time.
- 18:12Very long period of time and
- 18:13we are
- 18:15pair-bonding.
- 18:17We're a pair-bonding species for the
- 18:19same reason.
- 18:20Is that
- 18:21the burden of a infant and the
- 18:24opportunity the burden and opportunity
- 18:26of infant is such that
- 18:29if it's born by only the mother the
- 18:33chances of cataclysmic failure are much
- 18:36much much much higher.
- 18:39And so we tilt towards
- 18:42pair bonding. So we're high investment
- 18:44low reproducing species for long
- 18:46lifespan very dependent children.
- 18:50Our children require a lot of
- 18:52investment.
- 18:55However,
- 18:58within
- 19:01the
- 19:02domain of human beings
- 19:05there are
- 19:06low investment there are people who
- 19:09adopt low investment
- 19:11mating strategies and high investment
- 19:13mating strategies.
- 19:15Low investment mating strategy is
- 19:19it's a hedonistic strategy.
- 19:22It's a one-night stand strategy.
- 19:25And
- 19:28you might ask well what's your point?
- 19:32The point of attention let's say.
- 19:34Well, you're sitting in your restaurant.
- 19:37You're having dinner with the person you
- 19:38invited out. What's your strategy?
- 19:43And how do you direct your attention in
- 19:45consequence of that strategy?
- 19:48And now it is the question because you
- 19:49direct your attention in consequence of
- 19:52your aim.
- 19:55Okay, so let's imagine that your aim is
- 20:00short-term mating strategy, right?
- 20:02One-night stand.
- 20:04All right, so
- 20:08you're going to direct your attention
- 20:09and you're going to
- 20:13organize your actions in keeping with
- 20:15that goal.
- 20:19Well, how are you going to do that
- 20:20exactly?
- 20:21We know the goal you're serving now.
- 20:23Well, well, do we? What goal are you
- 20:25serving exactly?
- 20:28Well, you might say you're trying to get
- 20:29what you want. It's like
- 20:31that's one way of thinking about it.
- 20:34Depends on how you define you.
- 20:37You're trying to get what a fraction of
- 20:39you wants. Let's say you're trying to
- 20:41get what a desire of yours wants. So,
- 20:44what you're doing if you're pursuing a
- 20:45short-term mating strategy, you want to
- 20:47get the girl in bed as fast as possible,
- 20:50let's say,
- 20:51is that
- 20:52you're reducing who you are to that
- 20:54immediate demand to that
- 20:57narrow
- 20:59demand for immediate self-gratification.
- 21:02And so, that's the you that's having the
- 21:04conversation.
- 21:06Okay. So,
- 21:08there could be all sorts of other yous
- 21:10that might be there. You might be
- 21:12lonely, so you're looking for a
- 21:13companion. You might be
- 21:15lonely and
- 21:17serious, in which case you're not only
- 21:20looking for a companion, but
- 21:22you're looking
- 21:23We'll step out of the sexual realm for a
- 21:25moment. You're looking for a friend. And
- 21:27a friend, think about a friend from the
- 21:29perspective of a child. A friend is
- 21:30someone you that you can play a game
- 21:32with, but that you want to repeat the
- 21:34game with many times. That's a friend.
- 21:37And so, if you're lonesome and you're
- 21:39adopting a companionate strategy, you're
- 21:42going to be looking to make a friend
- 21:44that you can play with, and that would
- 21:46be the dinner, but that would but with
- 21:49whom the game would go well enough so
- 21:51that, well, she would like to repeat the
- 21:53game. That would be the second date,
- 21:55let's say, and that the what would
- 21:58spiral up out of that would be a
- 21:59sequence of games, let's say, and that
- 22:02sequence of games would be a
- 22:03relationship, and in principle, that
- 22:05might move towards,
- 22:07well, then again, it depends on your
- 22:09aim. Move towards what?
- 22:13Steady dating, uh, living together,
- 22:16marriage. Those are very different aims,
- 22:18and they're going to
- 22:20The consequence of those different aims
- 22:22is going to direct your attention and
- 22:23your action
- 22:25accordingly.
- 22:26Right? Now, all that's sitting there in
- 22:28that
- 22:29dinner right at the beginning.
- 22:31Well, let's say that
- 22:34you're not
- 22:36you don't want the responsibility
- 22:39or opportunity of a
- 22:41long-term relationship, long-term
- 22:43committed relationship, which is the
- 22:44awkward terminology we use to replace
- 22:47the much shorter and to the point term
- 22:49marriage. You know, not looking for
- 22:51marriage.
- 22:52Well, what are you looking for? Well, in
- 22:55the extreme, you're looking for
- 22:56short-term
- 22:57sensual gratification.
- 23:00And that's what's directing your
- 23:01attention. So, the you that's there is
- 23:03the part of you that wants short-term
- 23:06gratification. Okay, well, what is that
- 23:08part like? Well,
- 23:10it's it's hedonistically oriented.
- 23:13Obviously, because the goal is sex and
- 23:15sex is pleasure and
- 23:17and it's it's easily it can easily
- 23:21become pleasure
- 23:22at the cost of the person you're with
- 23:25and it can also easily become pleasure
- 23:28at your cost in so far as you are
- 23:31inadvertently sacrificing the
- 23:33possibility of long-term stable
- 23:36committed marriage to the
- 23:38demands of the immediate moment. And so,
- 23:41by switching to a short-term mating
- 23:44strategy, so to speak, not only are you
- 23:47already utilizing the other person as a
- 23:51tool for the gratification of your
- 23:53immediate desires, but you're also doing
- 23:55the same thing
- 23:57that impulse is also doing the same
- 23:59thing to the broader you.
- 24:03Right?
- 24:05It's not You can understand that more
- 24:06deeply if you think about the difference
- 24:08between a 2-year-old and a mature adult.
- 24:10A 2-year-old wants what he or she wants
- 24:14no matter what, right now.
- 24:17And you can see that when 2-year-olds
- 24:19have temper tantrums, which they do
- 24:20quite or or university students
- 24:23for that matter
- 24:25increasingly
- 24:26and because they haven't matured past
- 24:29that point.
- 24:30Because our culture is pathologized
- 24:32enough now so that that often happens.
- 24:35And so that pattern of immature demand
- 24:38for immediate gratification is
- 24:40maintained far past its due date. Cuz
- 24:43that should really disappear by about
- 24:45the age of four. And if it doesn't
- 24:47disappear by the age of four, it tends
- 24:49not to disappear.
- 24:51And so part of what you're doing when
- 24:54you're a parent, if you have any sense,
- 24:55is that you're
- 24:58enticing
- 24:59and disciplining your child towards the
- 25:03substitution of a
- 25:05medium to long-term orientation in time
- 25:10and a communal orientation, one that
- 25:13takes other people into account for
- 25:16in exchange for what they want for
- 25:18themselves right now.
- 25:21And
- 25:22what you want for yourself right now is
- 25:24a more instinctive way of
- 25:27approaching the world.
- 25:29Um
- 25:30Your drives, so to speak, your desires
- 25:33are
- 25:34part and parcel of what you bring into
- 25:36the world. And
- 25:38if you're ruled by them, you're ruled by
- 25:39whim. And you might think that if you're
- 25:42engaging in short-term mating
- 25:44strategies, you're pursuing what you
- 25:46want what you want, but what you don't
- 25:49understand is that you're actually
- 25:51serving
- 25:53a master who's a hedonistic fragment of
- 25:57your total self.
- 25:59And you're doing that
- 26:01in doing that, you sacrifice the
- 26:03possibility of communal relationship and
- 26:06you sacrifice your own future. Okay, so
- 26:08how do we know this? They go, "Well,
- 26:10that's you can say that all you want.
- 26:11You're just, you know, making what?
- 26:13You're making a value judgment about the
- 26:15manner in which people conduct
- 26:17themselves sexually." It's yeah, yes,
- 26:19I'm definitely doing that. What? Why am
- 26:22I doing that? Like on what grounds am I
- 26:24doing that?
- 26:25Well,
- 26:26we actually know as psychologists
- 26:28something about
- 26:30the people who default to short-term
- 26:32mating strategies.
- 26:34Let me tell you that story.
- 26:37The here's the reason I'm telling you
- 26:38this. It's like
- 26:40with every glance you take, you serve a
- 26:43master.
- 26:45Right? Now, you might not know
- 26:47what that master is. You might not want
- 26:48to know.
- 26:50But, there is no avoiding that.
- 26:54It's built into the structure of
- 26:55perception itself.
- 26:59Your perceptions serve your aims.
- 27:03And that's really something to know.
- 27:04It's the world is unfolding for you as a
- 27:06place of dreadful
- 27:08misery. If the world is unfolding for
- 27:11you as a valueless, hopeless,
- 27:13obstacle-ridden,
- 27:15cluttered, friendless pathway forward,
- 27:19you might want to ask just what the hell
- 27:21is it you're aiming at.
- 27:26Your aim is short-term sexual
- 27:28gratification. Okay, so what do we know
- 27:30about that? Well, here's one thing we
- 27:31know.
- 27:33One of the most reliable markers of
- 27:36criminal proclivity in adolescence is
- 27:41early multiple partner sexual
- 27:43experience.
- 27:45So, that's been known for
- 27:4850, 60 years.
- 27:50Independent of moral judgment,
- 27:53it's a clinical marker for antisocial
- 27:55personality, for childhood conduct
- 27:57disorder.
- 27:59So, that's interesting to know.
- 28:03It's a reflection of a person's
- 28:05proclivity to use themselves and other
- 28:07people as instruments of short-term
- 28:10gratification. Right? So, it's also a
- 28:12sign of a radical kind of maturity
- 28:15immaturity.
- 28:17It's also very stable, as I said. If
- 28:19it's if that's proclivity is
- 28:23evident
- 28:26after the age of four, it tends to be
- 28:27very stable and permanent. It
- 28:29characterizes most
- 28:32toddlers.
- 28:35It's characteristic of immaturity.
- 28:38I want what I want now, and
- 28:42look the hell out if you're in my way.
- 28:45Now, that's not such a problem if the
- 28:46person you're dealing with is two,
- 28:49cuz they're this high,
- 28:51right? And they're not very dangerous.
- 28:53Although two-year-olds are the most
- 28:55violent human beings.
- 28:58They've been grouped together, you can
- 28:59group children together in groups of
- 29:01different ages,
- 29:03and by far the most violent group is
- 29:05two-year-olds.
- 29:06So, but again, they're small, and they
- 29:08can't do each other much damage.
- 29:10So, and most of those Some of the
- 29:13two-year-olds are more violent than
- 29:14others, and but even the violent ones
- 29:16tend to be socialized by the age of
- 29:18four.
- 29:20Not all of them. The ones that aren't,
- 29:21the violent two-year-olds that aren't
- 29:23socialized by the age of four, they tend
- 29:25to
- 29:27towards a lifetime criminal path.
- 29:30So, all right. So, what else do we know
- 29:33about short-term mating strategies?
- 29:41In the 1960s, psychologists started to
- 29:44develop what eventually became
- 29:47the technologies that produced the large
- 29:49language models that have come out in
- 29:51recent months.
- 29:53The What large language models do is
- 29:55analyze the statistical relationship
- 29:57between words or sets of words.
- 30:00And And so, what does that mean?
- 30:02Well, imagine that you read a thousand
- 30:03books, and in those books, the word good
- 30:06appeared
- 30:08and multiple times in most books, and
- 30:10then there was some reasonable
- 30:11probability that with good, other words
- 30:14would appear in close
- 30:16proximity. So, if you were talking about
- 30:18what was good, you might talk about what
- 30:20was beautiful. You might talk about what
- 30:21was evil.
- 30:23If good shows up, some other words are
- 30:25likely to show up.
- 30:28It's like when you're analyzing a word
- 30:30per se, like what makes it a word?
- 30:32Cat, c a t. Um
- 30:36That's a word. C I T isn't a word.
- 30:39C I T is more of a word than C
- 30:42Q T.
- 30:44Why? Well, because the pattern of
- 30:47consonant vowel consonant is much more
- 30:49common among words than the pattern
- 30:52consonant consonant consonant. There are
- 30:54statistical regularities between
- 30:56letters, between words, between groups
- 30:59of words, between sentences, between
- 31:01paragraphs, between concepts that can be
- 31:04mapped at all levels. So, maybe a
- 31:07paragraph about the beautiful is
- 31:09more likely statistically to be followed
- 31:11by a paragraph about
- 31:15the beautiful.
- 31:17>> [snorts]
- 31:18>> These large language models, they map
- 31:20all those relationships. Billions of
- 31:21parameters, they map out the domain of
- 31:26statistical conceptual
- 31:28similarity and difference. They're maps
- 31:31of meaning, really. Psychologists
- 31:33started to use very primitive
- 31:35technologies like that 50 years ago, and
- 31:38they started to map out the domain of
- 31:41personality.
- 31:42Um
- 31:45If you're
- 31:47if you smile,
- 31:48imagine you're happy.
- 31:51If you're happy, it turns out you're
- 31:53statistically more likely to be
- 31:54talkative.
- 31:56If you're anxious, you're statistically
- 31:58more likely to be frustrated. If you're
- 32:01agreeable, if you're nice, you're
- 32:03statistically more likely to be
- 32:05welcoming. If you're
- 32:09um if you're combative and competitive,
- 32:11you're statistically more likely to be
- 32:16to say no.
- 32:18If you're interested in ideas,
- 32:22you're statistically more likely to read
- 32:23fiction. Um if you're dutiful, you're
- 32:27more likely to be patriotic.
- 32:29If you take all of the
- 32:31descriptors that you could use to
- 32:33describe human personality and you
- 32:35analyze the relationships between the
- 32:37descriptors, you can see that they clump
- 32:39into five dimensions.
- 32:42Extraversion is one, neuroticism, that's
- 32:45the proclivity to experience negative
- 32:46emotion, that's another. If you
- 32:48experience one negative emotion, you're
- 32:50statistically more likely to experience
- 32:52all of negative emotions.
- 32:54Agreeableness, that's kind of the
- 32:56maternal dimension. Conscientiousness,
- 32:58that makes you orderly and industrious.
- 33:00Openness, that's the creativity
- 33:01dimension. That was all mapped out.
- 33:04When that mapping was occurring,
- 33:09the evaluative words were thrown out,
- 33:12good and evil. They didn't include those
- 33:13words. And the reason for that was that
- 33:15if they included evaluative words, good,
- 33:17evil,
- 33:18criminal, non-criminal,
- 33:21where there was a clear value judgment,
- 33:22the whole statistical model tended to
- 33:24collapse into
- 33:26something like good versus evil. And
- 33:28that wasn't very helpful, so they threw
- 33:29that out. Now, the problem, sorry, this
- 33:32is
- 33:33a roundabout way of getting to the
- 33:34point, but I have to walk you through
- 33:36it.
- 33:37What The consequence of that was that
- 33:40the models of personality that we
- 33:42derived didn't
- 33:44flesh out our understanding of
- 33:47so-called psychopathology,
- 33:50abnormal behavior, antisocial behavior,
- 33:54troublesome,
- 33:56pathological, narcissistic,
- 33:58self-sabotaging,
- 34:01socially undermining behavior. If you
- 34:03throw out the evaluative words,
- 34:06you can't map that quite as well. So,
- 34:07what happened
- 34:09once we established the map of normative
- 34:11personality is that some psychologists
- 34:13started to study
- 34:16the evaluative dimension.
- 34:25The bad actors.
- 34:29And their analysis of
- 34:32how what was antisocial
- 34:34and self-serving
- 34:37made itself manifest manifest revealed
- 34:40initially three dimensions.
- 34:46Narcissism.
- 34:48So, if you're narcissistic, you want
- 34:50attention,
- 34:52but you don't want to do any of the work
- 34:53that would be necessary to validly
- 34:55obtain it. You know,
- 34:57if you're a good guy,
- 34:59you're going to get attention from your
- 35:00family and your community because you're
- 35:02productive and generous. That's a good
- 35:04start. You're reliable, honest,
- 35:06productive, and generous.
- 35:07You can fake that. You can claim status
- 35:10that you don't deserve. You can draw
- 35:12attention to yourself.
- 35:14You can capitalize on that attention
- 35:16without making any of the relevant
- 35:17sacrifices, and if you do that,
- 35:20then you're narcissistic. So, that's one
- 35:22dimension. Another dimension is
- 35:26Machiavellian.
- 35:28Back to the date.
- 35:30Well, first of all, if you're
- 35:31narcissistic in the date,
- 35:33you're not going to be listening much to
- 35:35your date.
- 35:36You're going to be talking a lot about
- 35:39why you're so great and how much
- 35:40attention you deserve. And you're going
- 35:42to be checking that other person out
- 35:45pretty hard to see if they're
- 35:47granting you the attention you deserve.
- 35:49And if you're a man doing that,
- 35:52you can often pull the wool over
- 35:54your date's eyes, especially if she's
- 35:56young and naive, because
- 35:58narcissists mimic competence.
- 36:01Young women who have some wisdom are
- 36:03looking for competent men, but
- 36:05they assess
- 36:07competence with confidence, and
- 36:09narcissists mimic confidence.
- 36:13Right? Which is why, you know, there's a
- 36:14trope, a romantic Hollywood trope, that
- 36:17the girls like the bad boys. Well, why?
- 36:19Cuz they look
- 36:20confident, and
- 36:23the girls confuse that with competence,
- 36:25and that's the narcissistic game. It's
- 36:27one element of the narcissistic game.
- 36:31If you're a ruled by the spirit of
- 36:33narcissism and you're on a date, then
- 36:36you're going to use the date as a stage
- 36:39where you can display your
- 36:43hypothetical virtues so that you can
- 36:44garner attention.
- 36:49Machiavellianism is another one of these
- 36:51dark
- 36:52traits. What do you do if you're a
- 36:54Machiavellian?
- 36:57That's what a con man does or a used car
- 36:59salesman, you know, like go to a
- 37:02used car lot, maybe you go to a store,
- 37:05not a store you'd go to twice.
- 37:07And the person
- 37:09sees you as
- 37:10a means to an end, and the end would be
- 37:13we'll have your money, thank you very
- 37:15much. Which is fine if there's some
- 37:17service returned for the money because
- 37:19then it's a fair exchange, but the
- 37:21Machiavellian thinks if you're enough of
- 37:23a sucker so that I can talk you into
- 37:26opening your wallet, then I should have
- 37:28your money cuz you're too dumb to use
- 37:29it.
- 37:30And so that's a hell of a way of
- 37:32evaluating a social situation. And so
- 37:35for a for a Machiavellian in a
- 37:37conversation, you're just something to
- 37:40be manipulated with words to deliver the
- 37:42goods.
- 37:43That's Machiavellian manipulation,
- 37:46right?
- 37:47And
- 37:49a good Machiavellian will
- 37:51watch you
- 37:53so they can tell you what you want to
- 37:55hear so they can direct you to go where
- 37:58they want you to go. Now, in the case of
- 38:00the date and you're the unfortunate
- 38:03target of the Machiavellian, if
- 38:06that's going to be
- 38:07into sexual exchanges rapidly as
- 38:10possible. That's the example we're
- 38:12using.
- 38:13Machiavellian.
- 38:15That's not all. There's another
- 38:17dimension
- 38:18that goes along with this.
- 38:20Psychopathy.
- 38:22And what's a psychopath? Well, you know
- 38:24what a psychopath is cuz you go to
- 38:25movies.
- 38:27And the psychopaths you see in movies
- 38:29are usually narcissistic and
- 38:30Machiavellian, too, cuz that's what
- 38:32makes them charming.
- 38:33Right? And they're very cold-blooded.
- 38:36And they want just exactly what they
- 38:38want from you right now regardless of
- 38:40the cost to them or to you. Why to them?
- 38:44Being a psychopath is actually not a
- 38:45very good strategy. Lots of psychopaths
- 38:48end up in prison. If you interact with a
- 38:50psychopath a couple of times and it
- 38:52didn't work out so well for you, which
- 38:54is kind of the point, you tend to
- 38:56remember that. And so, if you have the
- 39:00the option as you move forward, you
- 39:02avoid that person. And so, psychopaths
- 39:04are often wandering itinerants. And the
- 39:07reason for that is because they have to
- 39:09move from community to community because
- 39:11they burn their bridges and everybody
- 39:12knows who the hell they are. And so,
- 39:13they have to move on. And that's the
- 39:15kind of wandering
- 39:16con man. That's the origin of the
- 39:19wandering con man archetype, right? If
- 39:21you're going to screw everybody, so to
- 39:23speak, in your social circle, then you
- 39:26have to make tracks for new territory.
- 39:29So, what's the psychopath technically?
- 39:32Predatory
- 39:35parasite.
- 39:36So, what does that mean? Predatory means
- 39:40who whatever you have
- 39:42that can be mine. Thank you very much.
- 39:45That's the predatory aspect. The
- 39:46parasitical element is more subtle. It's
- 39:48more long-term.
- 39:50Someone with a parasitical lifestyle
- 39:53will manipulate you by whatever means
- 39:55necessary so they can live without
- 39:57effort off the fruits of your labor.
- 40:00Right. So, that's the parasitical
- 40:03element. And the real criminal types, 1%
- 40:06of the criminals are responsible for 65%
- 40:09of the crimes, by the way. The real dark
- 40:12criminal types tend towards the
- 40:14psychopathic. You know, you get the odd
- 40:16person in prison who did something
- 40:17spectacularly stupid once. And
- 40:21you know, that's not okay, but that's
- 40:24way different than the repeating pattern
- 40:26that characterizes
- 40:28the
- 40:29the personality whose traits I'm
- 40:30enumerating now. So, that was called the
- 40:32dark triad. And people studied that. The
- 40:36first person to study this really was a
- 40:38guy named Del Paulhus at the University
- 40:39of British Columbia.
- 40:41And he studied the dark triad for a
- 40:43number of years. Then he started
- 40:44figuring out what it was associated
- 40:46with.
- 40:48Short-term mating strategies.
- 40:52Right. So, that's entertaining.
- 40:58So, then you might think
- 41:01well, let's add another layer just for
- 41:02amusement.
- 41:04Turned out that didn't exhaust the
- 41:06network of meaning
- 41:09on the dark side of the personality
- 41:13in the personality realm. Didn't exhaust
- 41:15the
- 41:16full
- 41:17manifestation of what was dark in the
- 41:19personality realm.
- 41:22As the research into the dark triad
- 41:24progressed
- 41:25and more and more questions were asked
- 41:29about
- 41:30just exactly what this pattern of
- 41:32behavior
- 41:35just exactly how this pattern of
- 41:37behavior could be characterized
- 41:40another term
- 41:42entered the
- 41:44diagnostic lexicon.
- 41:46Sadism.
- 41:48Sadism. The positive delight in the
- 41:51suffering of others.
- 41:52That's the dark tetrad.
- 41:54Right. A lovely
- 41:57tetrad.
- 42:00Striving for undeserved attention with
- 42:02no reciprocity.
- 42:04Using language and action
- 42:07instrumentally to gain
- 42:09a narrow end.
- 42:11Predatory and parasitical orientation.
- 42:14Plus
- 42:15if I can hurt you
- 42:17so much the better.
- 42:22How much of that spirits are in the
- 42:24date?
- 42:27All right. So, these are the things that
- 42:29lurk behind
- 42:31everything we do
- 42:33at every moment of our lives. That's on
- 42:35the dark side of things.
- 42:37All right. So,
- 42:38so, I said
- 42:40your aim determines your pattern of
- 42:42attention.
- 42:44Right.
- 42:45Your aim determines your pattern of
- 42:47attention.
- 42:49So, if you're aiming at
- 42:54short-term hedonic self-gratification,
- 42:57then the spirit that you've invited in
- 43:00to direct your attention and orchestrate
- 43:03your actions
- 43:05is the spirit that's at the core of
- 43:09narcissism, Machiavellianism,
- 43:11psychopathy, and sadism.
- 43:14And you might say, "Well, that's a dark
- 43:16spirit indeed."
- 43:18Right?
- 43:20That's a
- 43:22psychoanalytic and now
- 43:25uh
- 43:27conceptual descent into the underworld
- 43:30under human interactions, right? That's
- 43:33the character behind the scenes.
- 43:36You might ask yourself,
- 43:38"Well, how do you become that
- 43:41spirit?" And the answer to that is
- 43:46you invited in. I'll give an example of
- 43:48that.
- 43:54In the story of Cain and Abel,
- 43:57it's the second biblical story.
- 44:00It occurs after Adam and Eve are
- 44:02expelled from the Garden of Paradise for
- 44:04the sin of pride.
- 44:07God tells Adam and Eve that they're
- 44:09going to have to work now because
- 44:11they've fallen.
- 44:12The way of thinking of Here's a way of
- 44:13thinking about that.
- 44:16You can work in your life or you can
- 44:17play in your life, let's say.
- 44:20When do you play? Well, you play when
- 44:23you play with others when they want to
- 44:24play with you. You play when you're
- 44:27pursuing something
- 44:29good and communal joyfully. You work
- 44:32when
- 44:37you work
- 44:39brutally
- 44:42in the aftermath of an error that has
- 44:45made your life much worse than it might
- 44:47have otherwise been.
- 44:49You could say that's an error of pride.
- 44:50You would bite off more than you can
- 44:52chew. You end up in a situation where
- 44:54you have to toil madly to
- 44:59rescue you- yourself from the hole that
- 45:02you dug. There's a insistence in the
- 45:04Judeo-Christian ethical pantheon that
- 45:07suffering enters the life with enters
- 45:09life with sin.
- 45:11It's a hard idea to swallow given the
- 45:14omnipresence of death, let's say, and
- 45:16the reality of pain, but if you
- 45:18understand that story in the manner that
- 45:20I just described, then you also
- 45:22understand very rapidly that
- 45:24a lot of the very difficult work that
- 45:26you have to do and a lot of the
- 45:27suffering that befalls you is a
- 45:29consequence not so much of the structure
- 45:31of existence itself, but of your
- 45:34proclivity
- 45:36to cause for yourself because of
- 45:39misdirected aim way more trouble than
- 45:42you would actually have to have. And
- 45:44that's what happens to Adam and Eve, and
- 45:46that's why they have to struggle
- 45:47forward.
- 45:50Work is established as the pattern of
- 45:52life in that story, and then Eve gives
- 45:55birth to Cain and Abel. They're the
- 45:57first two human beings, really.
- 45:59Speaking biblically, Adam and Eve are
- 46:01made by God, so they don't count. Cain
- 46:04and Abel are the first two human beings.
- 46:06They're the first two
- 46:08They're the brothers, the first brothers
- 46:10who emerge in the profane world of
- 46:12history.
- 46:13Right? They established two patterns,
- 46:15very deep patterns.
- 46:17Two opposed patterns.
- 46:19Cain,
- 46:21Abel.
- 46:23Abel aims up.
- 46:26And he brings
- 46:28his best to the table. That's a good
- 46:30thing to think about in relationship to
- 46:32the date.
- 46:34The man who's there
- 46:37with the woman that he
- 46:40has an interest in
- 46:42could aim up and bring his best to the
- 46:43table. That's one strategy.
- 46:47Cain, by contrast,
- 46:50offers what's second rate.
- 46:54Well, you can understand that in the
- 46:55confines of your own life, you can
- 46:57imagine that first of all, you could
- 46:59imagine aiming up or not.
- 47:02That's easy to imagine. Sometimes you're
- 47:04aiming up and sometimes you're not. And
- 47:06then even
- 47:07independent of that to some degree is
- 47:09how
- 47:11much
- 47:12sacrificial effort you're willing to put
- 47:14into the attempt.
- 47:16Right? Cuz you could imagine at the best
- 47:18times of your life that you were all in.
- 47:21You put your best on the table.
- 47:24You hit it with everything you had.
- 47:26And perhaps if you were fortunate, the
- 47:28consequence of that was that you had
- 47:30some success commensurate with your
- 47:32effort. Or alternatively, you could take
- 47:35the variant route and you could
- 47:38pull the wool over your eyes and the
- 47:41eyes of your fellow men and God himself
- 47:43and you could bring what was second-rate
- 47:45to the table
- 47:47presuming that the ease that that allows
- 47:54if the effort was successful would
- 47:56justify the deception. And that's what
- 47:58people do who
- 48:00bring what's
- 48:02second-rate to the table.
- 48:05They
- 48:10make the prideful presumption that the
- 48:11offering of what is less than
- 48:13is best will be sufficient.
- 48:16And it's a foolish notion because
- 48:20a moment's reflection
- 48:22informs everyone that life is far too
- 48:24challenging and difficult for anything
- 48:26but everything you have to be enough.
- 48:29And so what happens to Cain is that he
- 48:32fails.
- 48:33And
- 48:34he could fail and learn.
- 48:37Cuz you can fail and learn and then the
- 48:39next time you don't fail quite as much
- 48:40or maybe even you partially succeed and
- 48:42you can keep doing that.
- 48:44You have to do that.
- 48:47You do that if you have some humility.
- 48:50Right? Because you know what your
- 48:51failure you presume that maybe, you
- 48:54know, you've got some sorting out to do.
- 48:57You
- 49:00make the sacrifice necessary to sort
- 49:02yourself out and
- 49:04you start walking however
- 49:06awkwardly and poorly uphill.
- 49:09Cain doesn't do that. He
- 49:13gets resentful
- 49:15instead.
- 49:16And he gets resentful enough to call out
- 49:19God. Now, people do this all the time
- 49:21and it's understandable. You know,
- 49:23there'll be times in your life, for
- 49:24example, where something dreadful
- 49:26happens, someone you love becomes
- 49:28seriously ill, for example, and it seems
- 49:30entirely unfair. Perhaps it
- 49:32I'm not making a suggestion that it
- 49:35isn't in this case.
- 49:37And you're so
- 49:40upset, disheartened by that, that you
- 49:43lose faith. Not only do you lose faith
- 49:45in yourself and in existence, but you
- 49:48see within you emerge a strong
- 49:50proclivity to shake your hand at the sky
- 49:52and curse.
- 49:54And
- 49:56that's what happens to Cain, although
- 49:59with much less provocation. Right? He's
- 50:02bitter because
- 50:04he made second-rate sacrifices and they
- 50:06were rejected.
- 50:07He's not bitter because life itself
- 50:10has an element of arbitrariness and
- 50:13misery associated with it. And so he has
- 50:15a little chat with God because that's
- 50:18the sort of guy Cain is.
- 50:20It's not his fault
- 50:23that he isn't proceeding happily in the
- 50:26world like his undeserving successful
- 50:29brother Abel. It's
- 50:31Well, whose fault is it? Well, obviously
- 50:33the creator of all things.
- 50:35And so he has it out with God and he
- 50:37says
- 50:38essentially, I'm paraphrasing the story,
- 50:41it's a consequence of familiarizing
- 50:42myself with multiple translations. He
- 50:44says something like,
- 50:47"What sort of cosmos did you create
- 50:50here?
- 50:51I'm breaking myself in half, which is a
- 50:53complete lie,
- 50:55trying to get ahead and nothing's
- 50:56working out for me and I've got my
- 50:58brother and and no matter where he goes,
- 51:00the sun shines on him and everything's
- 51:01perfectly bloody delightful.
- 51:04It's like, how do you account for that?
- 51:07That's the spirit of resentment.
- 51:10Orienting his aim and God says, if you
- 51:13did well, you'd be accepted.
- 51:16And that's actually kind of a
- 51:17definition, you know, it's an
- 51:19interesting definition because the
- 51:21the impetus there is that if things
- 51:24aren't working out for you,
- 51:27in the most fundamental sense, that's on
- 51:29you.
- 51:30Now, you might think that's a pretty
- 51:32dreadful judgment. It's like, yeah, it's
- 51:34not as dreadful as the alternative
- 51:35because if you're miserable because the
- 51:37cosmos itself is structured badly and
- 51:40set against you, well,
- 51:43you might as well just throw in the
- 51:44towel now.
- 51:45But if it turns out that there's some
- 51:47stupid thing you're doing, no matter how
- 51:49trivial, that's tilted you in a
- 51:50direction that you shouldn't be going,
- 51:52and you could be on your knees with
- 51:54sufficient humility to discover it,
- 51:56there might be the possibility that you
- 51:58could set it right and start wandering
- 52:00uphill instead of farther down. And
- 52:02that's essentially what
- 52:04God suggests to Cain, but he's already
- 52:08possessed, so to speak, as we'll see,
- 52:11and that's just not going anywhere. And
- 52:14so, and then God says something even
- 52:16worse to him, and that's not so good
- 52:18because what's already been said is not
- 52:20good. He says to him,
- 52:26"If you did well, you'd be accepted and
- 52:29you've brought what's insufficient to
- 52:31the table and that accounts for your
- 52:33misery."
- 52:36And more than that,
- 52:38sin
- 52:40crouches at your door like a predatory,
- 52:42sexually aroused animal,
- 52:45and you've invited it in
- 52:48to have its way with you.
- 52:50It's a brutal metaphor and it's very
- 52:52interesting one.
- 52:53So, sin is an archery term.
- 52:56It has to do with aim.
- 52:58To sin is to miss the target. Three
- 53:00different languages.
- 53:02Greek is hamartia. It means to miss the
- 53:04center of the target. It means you can
- 53:06miss by not aiming or you can miss by
- 53:08not being skillful or can miss by aiming
- 53:10in the wrong direction or not at it not
- 53:12aiming at all. To sin means to miss the
- 53:14target.
- 53:17Sin crouches at your door. The
- 53:19temptation to miss the target and you
- 53:22invited it in. So, what does that mean?
- 53:24It's not like you're possessed exactly
- 53:26by the spirit of resentment. It's not
- 53:27like it visited you by some accident
- 53:30while you were unaware.
- 53:33For something like that to gain control
- 53:35of your aim,
- 53:37you have to open the door and invite it
- 53:39in. And so, that's what God tells Cain.
- 53:42It's your
- 53:43You're miserable in account of your
- 53:45failure, but you're resentful and bitter
- 53:48and unhappy because you invited that
- 53:51spirit to take possession of you. And
- 53:53then it's worse than that even because
- 53:55it's not exactly possession. You know,
- 53:56you might think, well, you're kind of
- 53:58naive and you don't know what you're
- 53:59doing and you open the door and
- 54:00something comes in, so to speak, and now
- 54:02it's in you and that's the, you know,
- 54:05it's got you
- 54:06and in a sense you're
- 54:08innocent in proportion to your naivety.
- 54:10But that isn't what God tells Cain. He
- 54:13says,
- 54:14um,
- 54:16you invited it in to have its way with
- 54:17you. It's a sexual metaphor.
- 54:21And what it means is that he God accuses
- 54:24Cain of inviting in the spirit of
- 54:26resentment and entering into a creative
- 54:29relationship with it, brooding on it.
- 54:32Brooding on it, right? Brooding on
- 54:34resentment. People do this all the time.
- 54:36They're they're angry, they're unhappy,
- 54:39they fantasize, they fantasize about
- 54:42revenge, they fantasize about how the
- 54:43world has treated them brutally, they
- 54:45fantasize about what they could do to
- 54:47all those people who
- 54:49did them wrong if they only had the
- 54:50opportunity.
- 54:52They dwell on that, they revel in it,
- 54:54they brood on it, maybe for thousands of
- 54:56hours. If you ever wonder how someone
- 54:58gets to the point
- 55:00when they're 15 that they can take a
- 55:03high-powered automatic rifle and shoot
- 55:06up an elementary school.
- 55:08That's how.
- 55:09Couple of thousands of hours, couple
- 55:11thousand hours of brooding,
- 55:14and you'll end up in one hell of a dark
- 55:16place.
- 55:18Right. And so, that's the pattern of
- 55:20Cain. And God tells Cain all that, and
- 55:22you can bet that doesn't make him very
- 55:24happy.
- 55:25Because it's exactly the last thing he
- 55:27wants to hear.
- 55:29All right?
- 55:31Your failure is to be laid at your own
- 55:33feet.
- 55:35You've multiplied your failure by
- 55:38the invitation you offered to sin, which
- 55:41you
- 55:42conspired with to magnify your
- 55:45bitterness,
- 55:46and
- 55:48that's all
- 55:49on you.
- 55:51So, what happens to Cain?
- 55:55He kills Abel.
- 55:57Right? He destroys his own ideal, and he
- 56:00does that to shake his fist at God.
- 56:03And
- 56:05Cain says, "My punishment is more than I
- 56:07can bear." which is always the case for
- 56:09someone who destroys his own ideal,
- 56:11because how are you going to live
- 56:12without an ideal? You've got nothing to
- 56:14aim at. You've got no pathway forward.
- 56:16You've severed your tie with everything
- 56:18that could give you hope.
- 56:19You're done. But that isn't where the
- 56:21story ends.
- 56:23Cain's descendants become genocidal.
- 56:27Right. And so, that's a story of how,
- 56:29what would you say?
- 56:30Second-rate sacrifices open the door to
- 56:33a creative union with sin
- 56:36that expands into
- 56:38fratricidal murder and morphs into
- 56:42the genocidal impulse.
- 56:44And the next story is
- 56:48the flood.
- 56:51Right.
- 56:55Back to the restaurant.
- 57:01Well, now we've opened the door, right?
- 57:03We can see
- 57:06the background
- 57:07of
- 57:09the forces
- 57:11that are directing the attention of the
- 57:13participants in the dinner.
- 57:19If I want nothing more than what
- 57:22something low in me demands this second,
- 57:27I'm going to direct my own attention in
- 57:29accordance with that aim,
- 57:31and that aim is a reflection of what
- 57:35I've allowed to possess me.
- 57:37And that's a manifestation of
- 57:41the
- 57:42Machiavellian narcissistic
- 57:45psychopathic sadism
- 57:48that I've brooded over and allowed to
- 57:52take possession of me sufficiently to
- 57:54justify my manipulative aims.
- 57:59That
- 58:03battle with temptation, that's going on
- 58:07inside you every time you move your
- 58:09eyes.
- 58:11You can imagine this. Just imagine this.
- 58:13Imagine this. So,
- 58:15maybe your date is wearing something
- 58:17provocative, somewhat provocative, and
- 58:20your eyes slip down from her face to her
- 58:23to her
- 58:25displayed breasts.
- 58:27And she says something like, "My eyes
- 58:29are up here." Now, you know that
- 58:33So,
- 58:35that can be a game on her part, and she
- 58:36can be provoking that response, and she
- 58:38can be playing the same manipulative
- 58:40game that you're playing. Although in
- 58:42the sexual situation, it's less likely
- 58:45for women to do that because they pay a
- 58:46much higher cost for sex. And so,
- 58:50in that particular domain, they're less
- 58:53likely Women are less likely to engage
- 58:55in short-term mating strategies cuz the
- 58:57cost for them is way, way higher. That
- 59:00doesn't mean that women aren't
- 59:01characterized by their own set of
- 59:03proclivities and temptations, but
- 59:05they vary with sex.
- 59:10Imagine the couple goes dancing, right?
- 59:12Now in the
- 59:13woman is evaluating the man and
- 59:17what's she evaluating him for?
- 59:20Well,
- 59:21let's assume for a moment that her aim
- 59:23is higher
- 59:25and that she'd actually like to find a
- 59:27decent man
- 59:29and who
- 59:31is
- 59:33pursuing a longer term goal, who's
- 59:36communally oriented, who is not willing
- 59:39to sacrifice his future self for his
- 59:42whim predicated hedonic desires in the
- 59:45present.
- 59:46Well, how does she evaluate that? Well,
- 59:48she's going to evaluate in the dance to
- 59:49some degree because one thing she's
- 59:51going to find out is whether
- 59:53her partner has the
- 59:56self-control, discipline, maturity, aim
- 1:00:00to keep his damn hands to himself
- 1:00:03or at least to proceed with
- 1:00:06next stage exploration in a manner
- 1:00:09that's voluntary,
- 1:00:11playful, awake, wise, cautious, and
- 1:00:17not too precipitous.
- 1:00:19And that's all being evaluated in the
- 1:00:21exchange of movements that characterizes
- 1:00:23a dance. And all of that's a reflection
- 1:00:26of It's an attempt to use the
- 1:00:30interaction of the moment to assess the
- 1:00:35nature of the spirit that characterizes
- 1:00:38the people in the dance. That's what
- 1:00:42we're doing when we try to get to know
- 1:00:44each other. Can I trust you? That's
- 1:00:46really what I'm trying to figure out.
- 1:00:48Can I trust you?
- 1:00:50Can we play together reciprocally and
- 1:00:53productively across a long span of time?
- 1:00:56Right? Are you mature enough to
- 1:00:58take your turn at bat and then to give
- 1:01:00me mine, right? To dance in this way
- 1:01:03that's mutually beneficial across time.
- 1:01:05Particularly relevant if you want to
- 1:01:06establish a marriage because it's
- 1:01:10an infinitely repeating game that at
- 1:01:13least has to be stable and with
- 1:01:16God's grace, you might say, can be a
- 1:01:18game that improves as it's played, which
- 1:01:20is the ideal situation. That's the ideal
- 1:01:22friendship, the ideal relationship.
- 1:01:25If that's the sort of relationship you
- 1:01:27want, that aim is going to dominate your
- 1:01:30patterns of attention and action right
- 1:01:31from the beginning.
- 1:01:33And when people are evaluating each
- 1:01:35other
- 1:01:37for first impressions, they're trying to
- 1:01:38get a snapshot of the person's
- 1:01:40character. Your character is your aim
- 1:01:42across time.
- 1:01:45That's a good way of thinking about it.
- 1:01:46We really want to know what someone's
- 1:01:48aim is across time, because that's how
- 1:01:50we understand them.
- 1:01:52That's how we evaluate them. That's also
- 1:01:54how we understand ourselves. When you go
- 1:01:56watch a movie,
- 1:01:59what you're seeing is the revelation of
- 1:02:01the character's aim across time.
- 1:02:04Right? So, you see the person in a
- 1:02:05variety of different situations in a
- 1:02:07variety of different snapshots of aim,
- 1:02:10and you infer from that
- 1:02:12their overarching aim. Is he a good guy
- 1:02:15or a bad guy? That's the evaluation
- 1:02:17you're making, let's say, in the typical
- 1:02:18movie. Is this a hero or a villain?
- 1:02:21And you extract that
- 1:02:23realization by watching how his
- 1:02:25character manifests itself in different
- 1:02:27situations, his patterns of attention,
- 1:02:29his patterns of action. And you do that
- 1:02:36You might say you do that so you could
- 1:02:37figure out who to who to cheer for.
- 1:02:40But that bears examination, too, because
- 1:02:42cheer for means something like admire.
- 1:02:45Right? You admire the hero,
- 1:02:47if your head's screwed on straight, in a
- 1:02:49movie.
- 1:02:52Admire,
- 1:02:54what do you do with someone you admire?
- 1:02:56Admiration is the
- 1:02:59instinct to imitate.
- 1:03:01And so, if you go see a movie and you
- 1:03:03watch the hero and you realize he's a
- 1:03:05hero and he makes himself manifest on
- 1:03:07the screen as a hero, and you admire
- 1:03:09that pattern, that's an impetus to
- 1:03:11imitate. And what you're attempting to
- 1:03:12do, this is why you want to go to the
- 1:03:14movie to begin with, is you want to
- 1:03:15figure out how to embody that spirit.
- 1:03:18That's what fiction does. Fiction
- 1:03:19presents you with a sequence of
- 1:03:21spirits to embody.
- 1:03:23Yeah.
- 1:03:24And
- 1:03:27the dramatist characterizes the aim of
- 1:03:29the hero.
- 1:03:31What's the aim of the hero?
- 1:03:35That's the
- 1:03:37question that the
- 1:03:39stories of the Bible are trying to
- 1:03:42tell.
- 1:03:44What's the characterization of the
- 1:03:46proper aim? I outlined already the
- 1:03:49nature of the improper aim, let's say,
- 1:03:51just in relationship to the date.
- 1:03:55What might be the proper aim?
- 1:04:01We can start with something that's
- 1:04:02essentially indistinguishable from
- 1:04:04maturity.
- 1:04:06Okay, so
- 1:04:07when you're a toddler,
- 1:04:09an infant,
- 1:04:11you
- 1:04:13your motive being in the world is very
- 1:04:14instinctively predicated. You know this
- 1:04:16if you have 2-year-olds cuz 2-year-olds
- 1:04:18are fascinating creatures cuz they're
- 1:04:20they're sort of all in every moment.
- 1:04:22They're exciting to be around although
- 1:04:24it's quite tiring.
- 1:04:25>> [snorts]
- 1:04:26>> They're unbelievably happy when they're
- 1:04:29happy.
- 1:04:30And one of the things that was painful
- 1:04:32about being a parent was I found myself
- 1:04:35stopping my children from being so
- 1:04:38damned happy all the time.
- 1:04:41Why? Cuz they run around and they're
- 1:04:43really noisy and they cause all sorts of
- 1:04:44trouble and they exhaust themselves and
- 1:04:46they get hurt. And so you're always
- 1:04:47calming them down. It's like, "Don't be
- 1:04:48quite that happy." Right? And
- 1:04:51positive emotion is associated with
- 1:04:54impulsivity. And so it's it actually
- 1:04:55does need to be not so much inhibited.
- 1:04:58That's not the right that's not the
- 1:05:00right approach. Regulated. Regulated in
- 1:05:02relationship to what? Well,
- 1:05:05a a child might impulsively grab the
- 1:05:08spoon from like say a 2-year-old a
- 1:05:102-year-old child and a 1-year-old child
- 1:05:12and the 2-year-old impulsively grabs the
- 1:05:13spoon from the 1-year-old.
- 1:05:15And they they do that in a fit of
- 1:05:16enthusiasm, but it's not a good strategy
- 1:05:18because if you grab other people's
- 1:05:20stuff, they don't like you.
- 1:05:23And so it's a bad long-term strategy.
- 1:05:25And so one of the things you're doing
- 1:05:26with your kids is you're telling them
- 1:05:28don't let your momentary enthusiasms
- 1:05:33motivate you to act in a manner that
- 1:05:35other people find
- 1:05:36undesirable.
- 1:05:38Well, why? Is that arbitrary? It's like,
- 1:05:40not if you want them to have friends.
- 1:05:43Right? Because the definition Having a
- 1:05:45friend means that you've entered into a
- 1:05:46reciprocal relationship, right? The
- 1:05:48child Children actually can't really
- 1:05:50have friends till they're about three.
- 1:05:51And the reason for that is they're
- 1:05:53actually not, you know, it varies to
- 1:05:55some degree, but
- 1:05:56the reason for that is they're actually
- 1:05:57not capable of reciprocity until they're
- 1:05:59three. They can't take turns. You can
- 1:06:02put two-year-olds together in a room and
- 1:06:04if you're not paying attention, you'd
- 1:06:05think they're playing together, but
- 1:06:07they're not. They're playing side by
- 1:06:08side. Each child is playing their own
- 1:06:10game. When a child hits the age of
- 1:06:12three,
- 1:06:13they can start what what three-year-olds
- 1:06:15will do like a boy and a girl, let's
- 1:06:17say, they'll get together and they'll
- 1:06:19have a little
- 1:06:20negotiation
- 1:06:22like you have with your wife all the
- 1:06:24time about how to play house. And
- 1:06:27the boy will ask the girl or vice versa,
- 1:06:29"Do you want to play house?" And that's
- 1:06:30the first invitation. And in order for
- 1:06:32the play to occur, the answer has to be
- 1:06:34yes, it has to be voluntary.
- 1:06:37Children who force other children to
- 1:06:39play their games don't have friends.
- 1:06:41They're just bullies and they're not
- 1:06:43popular and it's not a good strategy.
- 1:06:45It's not a good strategy because it
- 1:06:46doesn't work out very well
- 1:06:48for the bullies.
- 1:06:50There's no reciprocity in it. The kid It
- 1:06:52won't sustain itself. The other kids
- 1:06:54will try to get away. And if your kid is
- 1:06:56a bullying
- 1:06:59is an impulsive bully, adults won't have
- 1:07:01anything to do with them either. And
- 1:07:02then he won't learn anything cuz adults,
- 1:07:04you know, they know things. That's what
- 1:07:06makes them adults. And if
- 1:07:08the adults around your child don't like
- 1:07:10your child, it's like your child's in
- 1:07:11for a dismal time. And so
- 1:07:13they have to children have to learn to
- 1:07:15integrate their impulses
- 1:07:19in a
- 1:07:20manner that allows for the expression of
- 1:07:23those instincts
- 1:07:25in accordance with reciprocity with
- 1:07:28other people and in
- 1:07:30relationship to the long term.
- 1:07:32You can't do something that you want
- 1:07:34today that's going to cost you tomorrow.
- 1:07:36You can't do that all the time because
- 1:07:38you end up paying doing nothing but
- 1:07:39paying tomorrow for your for today's
- 1:07:42idiocy. You know, that sort of defines
- 1:07:44teenagehood in some ways, right?
- 1:07:46Teenagehood is the state of paying today
- 1:07:48for yesterday's idiocies. And hopefully
- 1:07:51as you mature, you stop doing that,
- 1:07:53right? And there's a sacrifice in that.
- 1:07:55You sacrifice your immaturity. And
- 1:07:57there's there's no real difference
- 1:07:58between that and cortical maturation,
- 1:08:00psychophysiologically speaking.
- 1:08:02So, as you
- 1:08:04mature,
- 1:08:05the
- 1:08:07newer
- 1:08:08and more
- 1:08:10sophisticated parts of your brain
- 1:08:12mature, the
- 1:08:13parts of your brain that are capable of
- 1:08:16regulating your behavior in relationship
- 1:08:18to other people, your friends, your
- 1:08:20family, the broader community, all of
- 1:08:23those things, and also regulating what
- 1:08:25you do now in relationship to what you
- 1:08:27need to do tomorrow and next week and
- 1:08:29next month and next year and 5 years
- 1:08:31down the road. And you might say in some
- 1:08:33ways the more mature you are, the longer
- 1:08:36a span of time across which you
- 1:08:38calculate the consequences of your
- 1:08:40behavior, and the broader the range of
- 1:08:43people across which you calculate your
- 1:08:45impact.
- 1:08:46And so, you know, if you're starting the
- 1:08:48process of maturation, you know, maybe
- 1:08:50you get yourself to the point where you
- 1:08:52can plan a week ahead and you can take
- 1:08:54care of yourself.
- 1:08:55And maybe if you push it and you mature
- 1:08:57further, then you can plan a year ahead
- 1:08:59and you can you can start to take care
- 1:09:01of your wife. And maybe if you get that
- 1:09:04together to some degree, the two of you
- 1:09:06can plan 5 years ahead and you can take
- 1:09:08care of your kids. Right? And so, you're
- 1:09:10you can see that you're establishing a
- 1:09:12kind of harmony of function across
- 1:09:15multiple levels of community and time.
- 1:09:18And that's a good way of defining the
- 1:09:20target of maturation.
- 1:09:23The
- 1:09:26Okay, now imagine you're back in the
- 1:09:28date and you decide that
- 1:09:32you're tired of being alone. You're
- 1:09:34looking for someone to what? To what?
- 1:09:36Let's Let's say your aim is high. So,
- 1:09:38what are you looking for now? Because
- 1:09:39your aim is high. You're looking for
- 1:09:41someone to love.
- 1:09:42And vice versa. And so, what does it
- 1:09:44mean to love someone? Well, it means to
- 1:09:48It means to care for them. It doesn't
- 1:09:50mean to protect them and make them
- 1:09:51secure precisely cuz that's not good
- 1:09:53enough.
- 1:09:54If you love someone, you care for them.
- 1:09:57You offer them security and
- 1:09:58predictability. You're honest with them,
- 1:10:00but you also encourage them.
- 1:10:02Right? And you can see the love that you
- 1:10:03might have for a child if it's optimized
- 1:10:05is there's a certain amount of
- 1:10:06protection that goes along with that.
- 1:10:08Cuz children need a certain amount of
- 1:10:10shelter, but
- 1:10:11a fair bit of that is
- 1:10:13you know,
- 1:10:14get the hell out there. Get out there in
- 1:10:16the world and push yourself and develop
- 1:10:18yourself and dance on the edge so that
- 1:10:20you become who you can become.
- 1:10:22And it's the balance of those two
- 1:10:24things. That's sort of the balance of
- 1:10:25the maternal and the paternal, by the
- 1:10:27way. That balance between security and
- 1:10:29encouragement. That's like the essence
- 1:10:31of love. That's a good way of thinking
- 1:10:32about it.
- 1:10:35That's one of the characterizations of
- 1:10:37God in the Old and New Testament.
- 1:10:40Right? So, you could think about that as
- 1:10:41a spirit that's like the spirit we
- 1:10:44talked about already except on the other
- 1:10:45side of the universe, so to speak, that
- 1:10:47you could invite in and have possess
- 1:10:49you.
- 1:10:50Right? And that's what you're called
- 1:10:51upon to do.
- 1:10:53That's the essence.
- 1:10:55That's one of the ways that the essence
- 1:10:56of religious practice can be
- 1:10:58conceptualized.
- 1:10:59Um how
- 1:11:02So, you're in your date You're at your
- 1:11:03date and you decide that you want to
- 1:11:05find someone to love.
- 1:11:06And then that directs your actions
- 1:11:09and your attention because now at the
- 1:11:10date the frame of reference that you're
- 1:11:13using to
- 1:11:15elicit the words you speak and the
- 1:11:16glances you take and the pattern of
- 1:11:19dancing, the pattern of attention is
- 1:11:21that
- 1:11:23but this could be someone I could love.
- 1:11:26Well, that's going to be a very
- 1:11:27different date. Now, obviously
- 1:11:33if you're wise
- 1:11:35that initial investigation is tentative
- 1:11:38and you look for a
- 1:11:40dance-like response and
- 1:11:43the possibility of that love
- 1:11:46expands as the relationship develops
- 1:11:49but
- 1:11:53it's important to get the aim right at
- 1:11:54the beginning.
- 1:11:56That's why this is a leap. Maybe it's
- 1:11:58worth making now. There's an insistence
- 1:12:00in the biblical corpus that the
- 1:12:02firstborn is to be sacrificed to God.
- 1:12:05Right, dedicated to God. Why? Well,
- 1:12:08because
- 1:12:09how you establish your aim determines
- 1:12:11how things go.
- 1:12:13Right, and so when you undertake
- 1:12:14something
- 1:12:16if you want to do it properly
- 1:12:17you aim at what's highest right at the
- 1:12:21beginning.
- 1:12:22Right.
- 1:12:23Right, what's highest? Well, one of the
- 1:12:25ways we characterize this
- 1:12:28you know, if love if if the short-term
- 1:12:31mating strategy that's associated with
- 1:12:33the dark tetrad is
- 1:12:35exploitation for self for narrowly
- 1:12:38self-centered hedonic purposes, then
- 1:12:41love would be the opposite of that.
- 1:12:43With something obviously in and of
- 1:12:45itself, it's we talked about that a
- 1:12:47little bit.
- 1:12:48Security, predictability, an honest
- 1:12:51relationship honest words forthright
- 1:12:54actions, no deception, encouragement.
- 1:12:58And you know, if if you were aiming high
- 1:13:01you'd think, if you could stand yourself
- 1:13:04that that's what you'd want for
- 1:13:05yourself. Right? So, it it's funny
- 1:13:07because you might think that
- 1:13:10if you
- 1:13:12aren't doing nothing but manipulating
- 1:13:15someone to get them to crawl in bed with
- 1:13:17you as soon as quick possible, you're
- 1:13:19being selfish, but it's it's a very
- 1:13:21strange use of the word self because
- 1:13:24it's not any better for you than it is
- 1:13:26for them. If you were being properly
- 1:13:28selfish, you'd search with every glance
- 1:13:32for everything that was
- 1:13:34best for you as well as for them. And
- 1:13:37that's a real
- 1:13:38optimization, aiming up and treating the
- 1:13:41other person as if they're you.
- 1:13:44Right. That's the great commandment to
- 1:13:46do both of those. And that's the
- 1:13:48commandment that Christ
- 1:13:50posits as the source of the 10
- 1:13:53Commandments that are handed to Moses
- 1:13:55themselves. Right, upward aim.
- 1:13:58Right, radical reciprocity.
- 1:14:01Right, and that's the opposite of the
- 1:14:03spirit of
- 1:14:04bitter exploitation.
- 1:14:06And that's operating in the background
- 1:14:08while you're at the date, too, as it is
- 1:14:11operating in the background
- 1:14:13with everything you do and every word
- 1:14:15you utter.
- 1:14:16And that's the underlying religious
- 1:14:17landscape. Now, that
- 1:14:20spirit that aims up, I'll characterize
- 1:14:22it some other ways.
- 1:14:27It's the spirit towards which proper
- 1:14:29sacrifice is directed.
- 1:14:32These are definitions. That's how what
- 1:14:33happens in the story of Cain and Abel.
- 1:14:35Abel offers his sacrifices upward.
- 1:14:38Well, if you're going to establish a
- 1:14:40long-term beneficial reciprocal
- 1:14:42relationship with someone you love,
- 1:14:45you
- 1:14:46have to offer what's best in order to
- 1:14:48manage that, and you have to sacrifice
- 1:14:51everything that interferes to pursue
- 1:14:53that goal. That's also why there's such
- 1:14:55emphasis in
- 1:14:57on sacrifice in the biblical corpus is
- 1:14:59because there's no difference between
- 1:15:01sacrifice and work. And
- 1:15:04the work you engage in towards an end is
- 1:15:07the sacrifices that you make in relation
- 1:15:09to that aim.
- 1:15:10And that's the pattern of your life.
- 1:15:12Human life is sacrificial because we
- 1:15:14work.
- 1:15:15There's no difference between work and
- 1:15:17sacrifice.
- 1:15:18Right? Work is the sacrifice of the
- 1:15:20moment to the community and the future.
- 1:15:23Right, right. So, what's the highest
- 1:15:24form of sacrifice? Well, that's the
- 1:15:26other mystery that the biblical stories
- 1:15:28attempt to unfold.
- 1:15:29In the final analysis, the offering is
- 1:15:32child and self.
- 1:15:35Right? That's why Abraham is called upon
- 1:15:36to sacrifice his son. Everything is to
- 1:15:39be given up to what's highest.
- 1:15:41And the pattern of the crucifixion is
- 1:15:43self-sacrifice and the crucifixion
- 1:15:44itself is the combination of the
- 1:15:47sacrifice of son and self. Right? It's
- 1:15:49an exemplification of the highest
- 1:15:51conceivable form of sacrifice. And what
- 1:15:53does it represent?
- 1:15:55It means
- 1:15:57everything is to be offered up in
- 1:15:58service
- 1:16:00to what's properly highest.
- 1:16:02That's the core of community. That's why
- 1:16:06in town
- 1:16:08based on the European model, which is in
- 1:16:10turn based on the Judeo-Christian model
- 1:16:13you have a cathedral at the center of
- 1:16:15the town or church in the shape of a
- 1:16:16cross.
- 1:16:18Right? That's the place of
- 1:16:19self-sacrifice, the cross. There's an
- 1:16:21altar
- 1:16:22in the church and the altar is the place
- 1:16:24of sacrifice. Why? Cuz community is
- 1:16:26founded on sacrifice.
- 1:16:29Right. And then the question is, what's
- 1:16:31the highest form of sacrifice? Well, we
- 1:16:33walked through that already. It's the
- 1:16:36willingness to offer your best. Well,
- 1:16:37what's the core of your best? It's
- 1:16:39everything you are.
- 1:16:41Right.
- 1:16:42Right. And that's the
- 1:16:46What does that mean?
- 1:16:47A society that's proc that's predicated
- 1:16:50on the spirit of voluntary
- 1:16:52self-sacrifice
- 1:16:54does not require a tyrant to govern
- 1:16:56itself.
- 1:16:59Right?
- 1:17:00That's something to know. And so, one of
- 1:17:02the things you might ask yourself
- 1:17:06when the tyrant's looming
- 1:17:08like now
- 1:17:10is
- 1:17:11to what degree do you make manifest the
- 1:17:13sacrifice that no longer
- 1:17:15no longer requires the hand of the
- 1:17:17tyrant?
- 1:17:19And that's literally the sacrifice of
- 1:17:21everything. Right? That's the
- 1:17:22willingness It's very straightforward.
- 1:17:25All the responsibility that you do not
- 1:17:27take upon yourself will be taken from
- 1:17:29you by tyrants and used against you.
- 1:17:33Right? In your country, I'm a Canadian.
- 1:17:35I've watched your country a lot. Your
- 1:17:37country knew this better than any
- 1:17:38country that's ever been, I would say.
- 1:17:41The reason that you have been so
- 1:17:42stunningly free and prosperous for so
- 1:17:45long, even though that's threatened now,
- 1:17:47is because
- 1:17:49your country was predicated on
- 1:17:52that sacrificial responsibility.
- 1:17:55Right? And you weren't
- 1:17:57inhabitants of the land of Cain. Because
- 1:18:00one of the things that's remarkable
- 1:18:01about your country, and I've been in
- 1:18:03many countries, is that
- 1:18:06you people actually admire genuine
- 1:18:08success.
- 1:18:09Now, there's variability in that.
- 1:18:11There's no shortage of resentment even
- 1:18:12in your culture, but all things
- 1:18:14considered, this was the shining city on
- 1:18:17the hill where the spirit of Abel was
- 1:18:20celebrated.
- 1:18:22Right?
- 1:18:23Right. And look what happened.
- 1:18:25Look at the miracles that took place as
- 1:18:27a consequence of that.
- 1:18:29Right? The freest and richest and
- 1:18:31fairest nation that was ever
- 1:18:33established.
- 1:18:34Established not on the basis of the
- 1:18:36rights that
- 1:18:37every fool now clamors to have
- 1:18:41re- What would you say? Respected and
- 1:18:43regarded, but on the responsibilities
- 1:18:45that made the citizens of the United
- 1:18:48States neither slaves nor tyrants.
- 1:18:52Right? And that's a reflection, and
- 1:18:54we'll stop with this. This is another
- 1:18:55characterization of God. In the In the
- 1:18:58opening chapters of Genesis,
- 1:19:01God is presented as the spirit of logos
- 1:19:04that broods upon
- 1:19:06the waters
- 1:19:07prior to the emergence of the order
- 1:19:09that's good.
- 1:19:11These waters, it's a mystery because the
- 1:19:14waters are there before creation occurs,
- 1:19:16and so
- 1:19:17a critical reader will be stumped by the
- 1:19:20order of affairs, but
- 1:19:21water in the biblical context, in the
- 1:19:24initial
- 1:19:26act of creation,
- 1:19:28it isn't water in the sense that we
- 1:19:29understand water now. The word is
- 1:19:32actually tohu va- bohu. And then the
- 1:19:34Hebrew, that word means something like
- 1:19:37confusion and possibility.
- 1:19:40Right? And it's
- 1:19:41it's presented as water because
- 1:19:44possibility is deep like water is deep
- 1:19:46and possibility
- 1:19:48gives rise to form like water bears
- 1:19:52form.
- 1:19:53Right? And water
- 1:19:55out of water
- 1:19:56life emerges and out of possibility
- 1:19:59creation emerges.
- 1:20:01And what do I mean by that? Possibility
- 1:20:03is what you confront when you wake up in
- 1:20:05the morning.
- 1:20:07It's what you can wrestle into the shape
- 1:20:10of the world as a consequence of your
- 1:20:11decisions during the day.
- 1:20:14The logos that inhabits you, which is
- 1:20:16the spirit that's made in the image of
- 1:20:17God, is the consciousness within you
- 1:20:20that
- 1:20:21wrestles like God himself at the
- 1:20:23beginning of time with possibility and
- 1:20:26brings forth order
- 1:20:28in consequence.
- 1:20:29The order that's good if the aim is
- 1:20:31upward, if the aim is towards love and
- 1:20:33the effort is undertaken in the spirit
- 1:20:35of truth, the order created is good or
- 1:20:38very good. That's what you do if you're
- 1:20:40a good father in the confines of your
- 1:20:41home.
- 1:20:42You establish little walled garden.
- 1:20:45That's what paradise is, a walled
- 1:20:46garden. Right? Where everyone
- 1:20:49a walled garden that keeps everyone
- 1:20:52secure and encourages them to the point
- 1:20:54where they can
- 1:20:55play
- 1:20:57forever, so to speak. The same idea as
- 1:21:00walking with God.
- 1:21:03There's an insistence in Genesis 1 that
- 1:21:05human beings are made in the image of
- 1:21:07that creator.
- 1:21:10And there's an insistence that that
- 1:21:12creative spirit is
- 1:21:15the same spirit that
- 1:21:17bears the cross of catastrophe up the
- 1:21:21hill of suffering.
- 1:21:24And what does that mean? It means that
- 1:21:25in so far as you bear the responsibility
- 1:21:28for the world on your shoulders that
- 1:21:29you're participating as an image of God
- 1:21:32in the creation of the order that's
- 1:21:35good.
- 1:21:36That's what that all means. Right? And
- 1:21:38the the that you have intrinsic value,
- 1:21:41which is the idea that your society is
- 1:21:43predicated upon, right? Made in the
- 1:21:45image of God with inviolable rights and
- 1:21:48responsibilities that transcend even the
- 1:21:50state. This isn't a gift from the
- 1:21:52government. It's not a gift from other
- 1:21:54people. It's a reflection of your
- 1:21:56intrinsic nature. Why?
- 1:22:01Because your aim is the
- 1:22:05Because the world depends on your aim.
- 1:22:08That's why.
- 1:22:09That's true.
- 1:22:11And that's a terrible thing to know.
- 1:22:13And now you know it.
- 1:22:16Oh, thank you very much.
- 1:22:31Well,
- 1:22:33thank you for putting up with that.
- 1:22:36All right, Mick.
- 1:22:38Way we go.
- 1:22:48>> Is it working now? It's working now.
- 1:22:52Thanks for the claps. Hit two people.
- 1:22:56>> [laughter]
- 1:22:57>> Oh, thanks.
- 1:23:00That's not
- 1:23:01that I didn't mean to ask for that
- 1:23:03accidentally.
- 1:23:04>> I didn't know if I get from the
- 1:23:06restaurant to heaven and hell and back.
- 1:23:08>> Yeah.
- 1:23:10Well,
- 1:23:11everyday basically.
- 1:23:14Okay.
- 1:23:16I've chosen some questions.
- 1:23:18We have
- 1:23:20I have been told we have 17 minutes, so
- 1:23:22we're going to get through as many
- 1:23:23questions as we can, which knowing dad
- 1:23:26will be one.
- 1:23:28>> [laughter]
- 1:23:37>> Hmm. [clears throat]
- 1:23:38Okay.
- 1:23:40Uh
- 1:23:43So, a bunch of people wanted this
- 1:23:45question. I'm a curious about it, too.
- 1:23:48It was
- 1:23:49Is there something specific that you've
- 1:23:51wrestled with God about?
- 1:23:53Something that comes to mind.
- 1:24:05>> Yeah, well,
- 1:24:06def- yes.
- 1:24:08It's a hard question to answer because
- 1:24:11it's true all the time.
- 1:24:13You know,
- 1:24:14I mean, one thing I do, for example,
- 1:24:16when I'm speaking on stage is
- 1:24:22weigh the words.
- 1:24:25You know, so what's the aim?
- 1:24:29Well, my aim, in part, is to get
- 1:24:30somewhere
- 1:24:32further, right? Further in my
- 1:24:34investigation
- 1:24:35because it's a communal enterprise. My
- 1:24:38aim is also to take everybody along with
- 1:24:40me.
- 1:24:41And that's a challenge, so that's
- 1:24:43ridiculously entertaining. It's It's
- 1:24:46It's It's It's like juggling plates, or
- 1:24:49it's more like juggling fire, really,
- 1:24:51but
- 1:24:53And so, that's a wrestling
- 1:24:55match. You can You can come to learn
- 1:24:57that
- 1:25:01you wrestle with God when you speak.
- 1:25:04Your aim with your words Your words are
- 1:25:07arrows that should be
- 1:25:09striking the center of the target.
- 1:25:12And you can feel that. You can And you
- 1:25:14can really learn to
- 1:25:16You can really learn to feel that.
- 1:25:19The words that are true put the
- 1:25:21foundation that is firm under your feet.
- 1:25:24The words that are false fragment you
- 1:25:26and
- 1:25:28and allow you to be washed away when the
- 1:25:30storms come. And you can feel that with
- 1:25:32every word.
- 1:25:34It's a terrifying thing to learn because
- 1:25:36the first thing you learn is that almost
- 1:25:37everything you say is a lie.
- 1:25:39And that's a terrifying thing to learn.
- 1:25:43When God
- 1:25:46banishes,
- 1:25:49No.
- 1:25:50When God bars the way
- 1:25:52to Adam and Eve,
- 1:25:54bars the way to paradise from Adam and
- 1:25:57Eve.
- 1:25:59It that story is often interpreted as
- 1:26:01God banishing Adam and Eve because of
- 1:26:02their sin, but that's not exactly right,
- 1:26:04you see.
- 1:26:05That's not exactly right.
- 1:26:07Adam and Eve are outside paradise
- 1:26:09because of their pride. They bit off
- 1:26:12more than they could chew.
- 1:26:14And and now they're alienated from God
- 1:26:17because pride alienates people from God.
- 1:26:20Now, there's a pathway back to God, so
- 1:26:22to speak, pathway to back to the
- 1:26:24paradise, back to the kingdom of heaven.
- 1:26:26It's another way of thinking about it.
- 1:26:29But the pathway is barred by a sword
- 1:26:31that by terrible monsters, cherubim,
- 1:26:34and by a sword that is on fire that
- 1:26:37turns every which way.
- 1:26:40Well, why?
- 1:26:41Well, what's a sword that turns every
- 1:26:43which way? Well, it's a blade. And what
- 1:26:45does a blade do? Well, a blade slices
- 1:26:47and cuts. And
- 1:26:49what does something on fire do? It
- 1:26:51burns. And
- 1:26:52and so what does a burning blade do? It
- 1:26:55cuts and burns. And what does a burning
- 1:26:57blade that turns every which way
- 1:26:59do? It cuts and burns no matter It cuts
- 1:27:02and burns everything away.
- 1:27:04What do you mean everything? Everything
- 1:27:06not fit to be in paradise.
- 1:27:10So, you pay attention to your words and
- 1:27:11you learn 95% of what you say is a lie.
- 1:27:15All that has to go.
- 1:27:18And so that's a terrible thing to
- 1:27:19understand.
- 1:27:22The The alternative is worse
- 1:27:24because
- 1:27:26the pathway to hell is paved with lies.
- 1:27:29And hell itself is the dominion of the
- 1:27:32lie.
- 1:27:33And you might say, "Well, I don't
- 1:27:35believe that." It's like Well, first of
- 1:27:37all, that's only cuz you don't have any
- 1:27:38idea what you're talking about.
- 1:27:41And second, you can make the case in a
- 1:27:44manner that's not the least theological.
- 1:27:48A totalitarian state isn't
- 1:27:50freedom-loving innocents striving toward
- 1:27:53the light dominated by the brute Hitler
- 1:27:55or Stalin. One man can't control 20
- 1:27:58million people.
- 1:28:00A totalitarian state is the state that
- 1:28:02exists when every single person in the
- 1:28:04state, bar none, lies about absolutely
- 1:28:09everything
- 1:28:12all the time to themselves and to
- 1:28:14everyone else. And that's hell.
- 1:28:17And if that's not hell enough for you,
- 1:28:19it's like, well,
- 1:28:21you know, have it your way. Have it your
- 1:28:23way.
- 1:28:24You know,
- 1:28:26when God comes to Abraham
- 1:28:29and tells him that he's going to destroy
- 1:28:31Sodom and Gomorrah, he tells
- 1:28:33Abraham that if
- 1:28:35well, Abraham makes a bargain with God.
- 1:28:38And he says, well, I don't think you
- 1:28:40should destroy the
- 1:28:42the cities, regardless of their sin. And
- 1:28:44God says, yeah, I think they think it's
- 1:28:47time to
- 1:28:49lay some waste. And Abraham says, what
- 1:28:51if there's innocent people in the city?
- 1:28:53And God says,
- 1:28:54well, yeah, I don't think there is.
- 1:28:57And Abraham says, well, what if I find
- 1:28:5940? And God says, oh, babe, 40? No
- 1:29:02problem. If you can find 40, I'll spare
- 1:29:05the city. And Abraham, who's kind of
- 1:29:07pushy,
- 1:29:08says, well, how about 30? And God says,
- 1:29:14okay.
- 1:29:15And I think Abraham bargains him down to
- 1:29:1710.
- 1:29:18If there's 10 people who tell the truth
- 1:29:20in the city, then it'll escape
- 1:29:24destruction.
- 1:29:26Well, what does that story mean? You're
- 1:29:27called upon to be one of the 10.
- 1:29:30Right? That's what that story means. It
- 1:29:32means more than that.
- 1:29:34It means if there's 10 people in a city
- 1:29:37who still tell the truth,
- 1:29:40that's enough to save the city from
- 1:29:42destruction.
- 1:29:43All right? That's how important it is to
- 1:29:45say what you have to say.
- 1:29:47You want that hammered home? You look at
- 1:29:49the story of Jonah.
- 1:29:50Jonah is called upon by God to utter the
- 1:29:52words of the of truth that will redeem
- 1:29:55the city of his enemies, Nineveh. And
- 1:29:57Job or Jonah thinks, "Yeah, I don't
- 1:29:59think so. I'm not going to the city of
- 1:30:01my enemies, 150,000 of them,
- 1:30:04to tell them God is outraged and that
- 1:30:06they're in trouble. I just assume
- 1:30:08they're wiped out anyways."
- 1:30:10And there's 150,000 people, 150,000 of
- 1:30:13them, like one of me. So, he does what
- 1:30:16any sensible person would do,
- 1:30:19hypothetically, and makes tracks in the
- 1:30:21opposite direction. Jumps on a boat and
- 1:30:23gets the hell out of there. And
- 1:30:26unfortunately, God is not so easily
- 1:30:28thwarted. And
- 1:30:30the ship is enveloped by a storm. And
- 1:30:33what that means is that if you run away
- 1:30:35when you have something to say, then
- 1:30:37the ship that bears you will be
- 1:30:39threatened.
- 1:30:40That's what that means. And so,
- 1:30:42the sailors
- 1:30:44are concerned about this occurrence, and
- 1:30:47they decide there's probably someone on
- 1:30:48board who isn't right with their God.
- 1:30:51And they cast lots, and they
- 1:30:54choose Jonah as the victim of
- 1:30:56interrogation. And he's asleep, because
- 1:30:57that's what people do when they flee
- 1:30:59from their conscience is they fall into
- 1:31:01unconsciousness,
- 1:31:03so that they don't have to contend with
- 1:31:04the reality of their refusal. And they
- 1:31:06wake him up, and they say,
- 1:31:09"Well, the ship's in peril, and the
- 1:31:11waves are rising, and we think maybe
- 1:31:12you're not exactly right with your God."
- 1:31:14And Jonah says, "As a matter of fact, I
- 1:31:17was told to do something." And that's
- 1:31:19the voice of conscience, by the way. And
- 1:31:22and I didn't. And this the sailors say,
- 1:31:26"Well, who's your God?" Cuz they're
- 1:31:29thinking it's like God of the local
- 1:31:30tavern or something. And
- 1:31:32Jonah says, "Well,
- 1:31:34he created the heavens and earth." And
- 1:31:37the sailors
- 1:31:38think, "Well, you probably shouldn't
- 1:31:40piss him off then."
- 1:31:42And
- 1:31:45he tells them to throw them over throw
- 1:31:46them overboard, because he knows there's
- 1:31:48no hope. And the sailors try mightily to
- 1:31:50reach the shore, but
- 1:31:52they can't, because
- 1:31:54God's not so easily thwarted, so they
- 1:31:56throw Jonah overboard and
- 1:31:58you know, the story could end there
- 1:31:59because
- 1:32:01what that story means is that
- 1:32:03if you flee from the dictates of your
- 1:32:05conscience, if you refuse to bring forth
- 1:32:07the words that you're called upon to
- 1:32:09say, then you put the ship of state in
- 1:32:11peril and you'll end up
- 1:32:14in
- 1:32:15and your own life will end up
- 1:32:17threatened.
- 1:32:19And you might think, well, that's pretty
- 1:32:20damn dismal and it's like that's not
- 1:32:22nearly bad enough.
- 1:32:23That isn't even
- 1:32:25that's just where it starts.
- 1:32:28Because the beast from hell itself comes
- 1:32:30up and takes Jonah in its jaws and pulls
- 1:32:32him down to the bottom of things where
- 1:32:33he's
- 1:32:35where he lies for 3 days, right in hell.
- 1:32:39Because that's the next thing that
- 1:32:40happens if you're quiet when you're told
- 1:32:42when you're called upon to speak.
- 1:32:44Right?
- 1:32:45And so
- 1:32:50No, we'll leave it at that.
- 1:33:02>> Okay, we got two in.
- 1:33:06Uh
- 1:33:09Hm.
- 1:33:14How do you forgive someone that's
- 1:33:16wronged you greatly without becoming a
- 1:33:18martyr and continuing to let them have a
- 1:33:20negative impact on your life?
- 1:33:26>> Well, forgiveness is
- 1:33:31forgiveness is a very complicated
- 1:33:33matter.
- 1:33:35You know, if you're
- 1:33:39pursuing the religious path in the
- 1:33:43traditional Judeo-Christian manner,
- 1:33:46when you ask God for forgiveness, you
- 1:33:48confess,
- 1:33:50repent,
- 1:33:52and atone.
- 1:33:54Right? What does confess mean? Well,
- 1:33:56look, if you if you you and I have had a
- 1:33:58scrap about something and I feel
- 1:33:59betrayed
- 1:34:02and I want to set things right. I want
- 1:34:03to find out like well,
- 1:34:05what's the story here?
- 1:34:07What happened?
- 1:34:08And if I'm have any sense, I'm going to
- 1:34:10confess my part in it, too, right?
- 1:34:12Because if there's something that's
- 1:34:13standing between us, it'd be convenient
- 1:34:15if it was just you,
- 1:34:17but there's a reasonable probability
- 1:34:20Well, there's some probability that it
- 1:34:21was just me, right? And if I don't want
- 1:34:24to replicate the mistake, I want might
- 1:34:26want to find that out. It's a very
- 1:34:27useful thing to know if you're fighting
- 1:34:28with your wife or your husband. It's
- 1:34:30like
- 1:34:31well, it's probably them.
- 1:34:34But it might be you. And so, why bother
- 1:34:37finding out? Well, cuz then you don't
- 1:34:38have to be stupid again.
- 1:34:41Right? So,
- 1:34:43you want to confess, here's what I think
- 1:34:45happened. And you know, if you're if you
- 1:34:47have a real dispute with someone and
- 1:34:48they just tell you exactly what happened
- 1:34:50like honestly,
- 1:34:52you're 80% of the way to
- 1:34:55repairing the relationship right there.
- 1:34:57Like often, what you want to know from
- 1:34:59someone is do they at least understand
- 1:35:01what the hell happened?
- 1:35:03Right? And then And but But then let's
- 1:35:05assume that
- 1:35:07I don't know, we have a scrap and we
- 1:35:09decide it's like 60% you and 40% me. And
- 1:35:12so, then what do we do? It's like well,
- 1:35:13I
- 1:35:14figure out what I have to offer you to
- 1:35:18I have to indicate that I'm sorry.
- 1:35:20That's the repentance. Then I have to
- 1:35:22atone for it. It's like well, what what
- 1:35:23do I need to do to set things right? And
- 1:35:25that's kind of a two-pronged issue. It's
- 1:35:26like what do I have to do so I feel I
- 1:35:29can forgive myself?
- 1:35:31Right? Cuz you you hold yourself
- 1:35:32accountable if you have any sense. And
- 1:35:34then I have to figure out well, what do
- 1:35:35you need so that we can put this behind
- 1:35:37us? And then we have to negotiate that.
- 1:35:39And then you put it behind you and
- 1:35:42then you have a friend instead of an
- 1:35:44enemy. And that's a good deal unless you
- 1:35:45want to collect enemies and that's
- 1:35:47that's not wise. One enemy is a lot of
- 1:35:50enemies, but you know,
- 1:35:52five or six and you're pretty much done.
- 1:35:54And so,
- 1:35:57that's the process of forgiveness. It's
- 1:35:59very, very complicated. Now, you might
- 1:36:00say, "Well, if someone did me wrong long
- 1:36:02ago and I need to let go."
- 1:36:06That's That's different. That's a
- 1:36:07different I mean, that's that's
- 1:36:10You You can't have the repentance or the
- 1:36:12atonement then on the part of that
- 1:36:14person. Maybe they're no longer alive,
- 1:36:15for example. Then usually what you have
- 1:36:17to do is
- 1:36:18Well, you have to figure out what you
- 1:36:20contributed to it the same way that you
- 1:36:22would if you were actually discussing it
- 1:36:23with someone.
- 1:36:25And then you have to understand
- 1:36:29what it was that brings of a state of
- 1:36:31affairs like that about so that
- 1:36:33when you move forward into the future,
- 1:36:35you're not likely to fall prey to the
- 1:36:36same circumstance.
- 1:36:38Cuz otherwise, it'll it'll just haunt
- 1:36:40you. It haunts you partly because you're
- 1:36:43set up so that once you fall into a pit
- 1:36:45once,
- 1:36:47anytime you approach the territory
- 1:36:49defined by that pit, you're going to be
- 1:36:51apprehensive. If you haven't figured out
- 1:36:53a way of navigating around that
- 1:36:55obstacle, the obstacle signals threat to
- 1:36:58you forever. Forever. It'll never go
- 1:37:00away. It'll never go away.
- 1:37:02And so, you can clean all that up, but
- 1:37:05it'll you have to do a very careful
- 1:37:07analysis. I'll give you an example of
- 1:37:09that. So often, soldiers who suffer from
- 1:37:12post-traumatic stress disorder, it's
- 1:37:14always often conceptualized, by the way,
- 1:37:16as a severe moral injury. They often
- 1:37:18develop PTSD because not because of
- 1:37:21something terrible that happened to
- 1:37:22them, but because of something terrible
- 1:37:25they saw themselves do.
- 1:37:28Right? Cuz you can be a naive, you know,
- 1:37:30corn-fed Iowan and end up in a foreign
- 1:37:32land in a very dreadful circumstance and
- 1:37:35watch yourself do something absolutely
- 1:37:37ungodly and really enjoy it. And then
- 1:37:40you'll understand very rapidly that you
- 1:37:42know absolutely nothing about yourself
- 1:37:44or the depth of the soul or the nature
- 1:37:46of human beings. And
- 1:37:49your attempt to live forward in that
- 1:37:52state of ignorance will be
- 1:37:53indistinguishable from trauma.
- 1:37:56And then you might say, "Well, how do
- 1:37:57you recover from that?" And the answer
- 1:37:59is you develop a philosophy of evil
- 1:38:02that's as deep as your sin.
- 1:38:04That's how. Yeah. And then maybe you can
- 1:38:06forgive yourself cuz you can see your
- 1:38:09capacity for the commission of sadistic
- 1:38:12atrocity, you know, in the light of the
- 1:38:15eternal battle between good and evil
- 1:38:18that characterizes the cosmic landscape.
- 1:38:20It's something like that.
- 1:38:22You know, and the atheist types think,
- 1:38:24well, no, it's like
- 1:38:27if you think that, you've never dealt
- 1:38:29with someone who's had a severe moral
- 1:38:31injury because if you ever have, you'll
- 1:38:33find out very soon that the landscape of
- 1:38:35good and evil is a lot more real than
- 1:38:37you might think. And if you don't know
- 1:38:39that, you should be on your knees every
- 1:38:41second of your bloody life thanking God
- 1:38:43that that terrible knowledge has not
- 1:38:45been yet revealed to you.
- 1:38:47And yeah, that's for sure.
- 1:38:58>> One more.
- 1:38:59>> Sure.
- 1:38:59>> Even though I was told not to do that.
- 1:39:01Okay. Okay.
- 1:39:02>> I'll be quick.
- 1:39:03>> Okay.
- 1:39:03>> Find a quick one if you can.
- 1:39:05>> Okay, this is kind of a cute one.
- 1:39:07We'll see if we can keep it cute.
- 1:39:11My My wife and I are having our first
- 1:39:13kid in 4 weeks. Congratulations.
- 1:39:16Neither of us have a relationship with
- 1:39:18God, but want to raise our kids in
- 1:39:19church. Please give your advice.
- 1:39:22>> Oh, you can do a good thing badly.
- 1:39:25>> Yeah.
- 1:39:26>> I mean that. I mean that. Look. Look.
- 1:39:29It It It's very much in keeping with
- 1:39:31what we talked about tonight. It's It be
- 1:39:34regardless of the state of your
- 1:39:36religious belief or lack thereof, you
- 1:39:38can make the decision to
- 1:39:40place your child in a situation where he
- 1:39:43or she can learn the
- 1:39:45fundamental stories of our culture. And
- 1:39:48you can't be
- 1:39:50you can't be a citizen of the West
- 1:39:52without knowing those fundamental
- 1:39:53stories. Those are the same thing. Like
- 1:39:56inhabiting that narrative world and
- 1:39:59being a citizen of the West, those are
- 1:40:01the same thing.
- 1:40:02And so you can provide them with that,
- 1:40:05and every single person, and this will
- 1:40:07include your own children, have to
- 1:40:10wrestle with God
- 1:40:13within the confines of their own soul,
- 1:40:15and you can facilitate that process by
- 1:40:18educating them in the
- 1:40:21traditions of your people, so to speak.
- 1:40:24And
- 1:40:26so, go to church and
- 1:40:31listen, and see if you can learn, and
- 1:40:35participate in the community.
- 1:40:38Uh and if the church isn't everything
- 1:40:39you think it
- 1:40:41could or should be, then you can work to
- 1:40:43rectify that, and
- 1:40:45that's a useful thing to do, too. And
- 1:40:49you know, I didn't bring my kids to
- 1:40:50church when they were kids, and
- 1:40:53that was a mistake.
- 1:40:55>> There was one time we went to church,
- 1:40:56Mom brought us to church.
- 1:40:59And we went to a church in Toronto, and
- 1:41:02they're all woke. They're really woke
- 1:41:04now. But this was like 15 years ago. I
- 1:41:06think I was in grade six, and they
- 1:41:08started the Lord's Prayer with our
- 1:41:10mother-father who art in heaven, and we
- 1:41:12just got up and left. Now, that was our
- 1:41:15That was our experience with church
- 1:41:16growing up.
- 1:41:18>> Right. [clears throat] Right. Well, and
- 1:41:19you know, you could say, too, and and I
- 1:41:22certainly wouldn't be likely to think
- 1:41:24that way at that time, that if you go to
- 1:41:26a church, and it's woke, then you should
- 1:41:28leave. And that might be the case,
- 1:41:30unless they're all like that, in which
- 1:41:32case you're in some trouble. But the
- 1:41:34alternative
- 1:41:35strategy is to
- 1:41:38take back the territory.
- 1:41:40Right? And if you don't, well,
- 1:41:44all of you
- 1:41:45all of you have to think about this in
- 1:41:47relationship to your duty to your
- 1:41:49community, because
- 1:41:50part of the reason that
- 1:41:52the woke mob has prevailed is because
- 1:41:56the responsible people
- 1:41:58abdicated their responsibility.
- 1:42:01And so, why are the school boards full
- 1:42:03of woke
- 1:42:08of confused woke
- 1:42:10activists.
- 1:42:12Well,
- 1:42:13cuz they took the job.
- 1:42:16And so,
- 1:42:17there you have it. And if you want to do
- 1:42:19something about that, think what should
- 1:42:21be done? It's like,
- 1:42:22take the job.
- 1:42:24Right? And so, and that's the only way
- 1:42:26out of this mess.
- 1:42:28So,
- 1:42:29it's the same on the church front.
- 1:42:33You know, you have a responsibility
- 1:42:36to rebuild Well, what are you going to
- 1:42:38do? You're either going to rebuild the
- 1:42:39damaged institutions of your community
- 1:42:41or you're going to abandon them.
- 1:42:43Those are your options. And if you
- 1:42:45abandon them,
- 1:42:48well, then what?
- 1:42:50Then what do you have?
- 1:42:51You're in the desert then. And
- 1:42:55the idol worshipers come calling pretty
- 1:42:57quickly when you're lost in the desert,
- 1:42:59as you can see if you look.
- 1:43:02And on that cheery note,
- 1:43:06thank you, everyone.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of How to Spot a Psychopath by Jordan B Peterson, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 14,707 words across 2,736 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.