How to Establish a Foundation for your Worldbuilding - Cosmology — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00[Music]
- 0:03You can quite simply begin the building
- 0:05of a world from anything anywhere. Odds
- 0:09are you have at least the germ of an
- 0:10idea. It may be a culture, a battle, a
- 0:13city, a species, a hero, or a monster,
- 0:16or any combination thereof. Or maybe you
- 0:19don't have an idea and it is a tableau
- 0:22raza world. That's fine, too. That being
- 0:24said, it may be best to begin with some
- 0:26sort of starting point. Today we're
- 0:28going to look at using that root idea of
- 0:30yours to build out your cosmology. I
- 0:34should add that my examples will be
- 0:35mostly fantasy, but it works for sci-fi
- 0:37as well because both universes can be
- 0:40built using the same methodology. Hi, my
- 0:42name is Jonathan Oldenberg. I am a
- 0:44worldbuilder and a writer, which is to
- 0:46say that the purpose behind my world
- 0:47building is to write stories. As I said
- 0:50in my inaugural video, you can world
- 0:52build for any number of reasons, but as
- 0:54you go through the process, it's always
- 0:56a good idea to keep that core purpose at
- 0:58heart. The name of my world is is
- 1:00Falloness, and the construction of it
- 1:02has been a labor of love for 25 years,
- 1:04culminating so far in one book called
- 1:06Tears from Iron, and I'm working on the
- 1:08sequel, which should be coming out
- 1:10hopefully later this year. This video is
- 1:11a continuation of a series on world
- 1:13building. So, if you'd like to stay up
- 1:14to date with all the topics as I release
- 1:16them in this series, please like and
- 1:18subscribe so you can catch each new
- 1:19video. I'll put a link to the series in
- 1:21the description, and it will also be one
- 1:22of the cards showing at the end of this
- 1:25video. So, with that introduction out of
- 1:27the way, let's dive into the fun
- 1:29definitions. As I said at the beginning
- 1:31of this video, you can start your world
- 1:33building process from pretty much
- 1:35anywhere. That being said, I suggest
- 1:37starting with at least a little bit of
- 1:39cosmology. And as we get into that,
- 1:41let's look at a definition to guide us.
- 1:43Various dictionaries define cosmology as
- 1:46the study of the physical universe
- 1:47considered as a totality of phenomena in
- 1:50time and space or a field of study that
- 1:54brings together the natural sciences,
- 1:56particularly astronomy and physics in a
- 1:59joint effort to understand the physical
- 2:00universe as a whole. In a practical
- 2:03sense, for world building, to create a
- 2:05cosmology is to essentially settle on
- 2:08those foundational building blocks that
- 2:11hold up your world. These are the
- 2:13natural laws within which your universe
- 2:16functions. I think that people also
- 2:17often confuse cosmology and cosmogyny.
- 2:20They're related, so it makes sense and
- 2:22they almost sound identical, but the
- 2:24difference is important. To provide a
- 2:26comparison, cosmology is how a universe
- 2:29functions. Cosmogyny is how a universe
- 2:33came to be. Cosmogyny is frequently
- 2:36important in world building, and we'll
- 2:37take a deeper dive into that in a later
- 2:40video. But sometimes origins are less
- 2:42significant depending upon your intent
- 2:44and your scope. Cosmology, however, is
- 2:47essential to all world building because
- 2:49it defines what your world is. To put it
- 2:52another way, much like the expression,
- 2:54all thumbs are fingers, but not all
- 2:56fingers are thumbs. All cosmogyny is an
- 2:59aspect of cosmology, but not all
- 3:01cosmology is cosmogyny. Okay, with those
- 3:05definitions out of the way, let's get
- 3:06into it. In this video, we're going to
- 3:08take a deeper dive into a couple of
- 3:10foundational concepts to cosmology. And
- 3:12then in the second half, we're going to
- 3:13get into the fun part where we're going
- 3:14to actually look at the various aspects
- 3:16that make up a cosmology and begin to
- 3:18establish those rules that we want to
- 3:21have in our worlds. The first core
- 3:23concept of cosmology is verimilitude,
- 3:26which is to say realism. How consistent
- 3:30and realistic do you want your world to
- 3:32be? I see this as breaking into two
- 3:35basic halves. One of these is what I
- 3:38call external consistency and the other
- 3:41is internal consistency. So let's take a
- 3:43look at these. By external consistency,
- 3:46I mean the degree to which your world
- 3:48follows the natural laws of our world.
- 3:51Does rain fall up or is the moon made of
- 3:53cheese? Okay, so maybe those examples
- 3:55are a little bit absurd, but they help
- 3:57serve this point. Perhaps consider this
- 3:59instead. As a traveler heads poleward,
- 4:02does it get colder? Is your world
- 4:04influenced by plate tectonics? Are
- 4:07volcanoes a result of geological
- 4:10processes or are they actually spirits
- 4:13of fire throwing a party and they want
- 4:15to invite everybody else? I see three
- 4:18basic answers to this general question
- 4:20with a lot of blurring in between.
- 4:22First, some worldbuilders like to toss
- 4:24out as many of the natural laws of our
- 4:25world as possible to see if they can
- 4:27successfully still sculpt a plausible
- 4:31interesting world in which to set their
- 4:34project. And that could be pretty cool.
- 4:36If pushing the bounds of cosmology isn't
- 4:39your greater motivation, you may prefer
- 4:41the second option, which is to strive to
- 4:43achieve a great level of external
- 4:47consistency. Consistency between the
- 4:49world you're making and our world. I
- 4:52fall into this camp. And if you agree,
- 4:53you may find a rule of thumb that I
- 4:55follow helpful. It's basically this. I
- 4:57strive to make my world as realistic
- 4:59following the natural laws of our earth
- 5:02to the greatest degree possible except
- 5:05for those areas where I choose
- 5:07specifically to make it different. And
- 5:10then I like to follow the ramifications
- 5:12of that change to the logical conclusion
- 5:14which can have a lot of fun ripple
- 5:16effects. The third option is you simply
- 5:18don't want to sweat it too much. Yeah,
- 5:21realism and all that stuff is maybe a
- 5:23little bit important to you, but you
- 5:24don't want to get bogged down in the
- 5:26weeds. You aren't so picky about all
- 5:28those concepts and overall precision
- 5:30isn't that important to you. I submit
- 5:32that a perfect example of this in action
- 5:34is the World of Warcraft, which has
- 5:38frozen snowbound wastelands right next
- 5:41to highly volcanic lava zones right next
- 5:44to deep aroreal forests right next to
- 5:47tropical savannah. It's also largely
- 5:49abandoned any desire to have national
- 5:52borders through which different kingdoms
- 5:54and realms are in conflict. Instead,
- 5:57they're largely interspersed with
- 5:58outposts and things like that. While
- 6:00this may drive a precision world builder
- 6:02nuts, it works perfectly for the goals
- 6:05that World of Warcraft is trying to
- 6:07achieve. So, if you want to delve into
- 6:09worldbuing philosophy around this,
- 6:11perhaps the most important thing is to
- 6:13know thyself. What will drive you nuts?
- 6:17and what will allow your creative spirit
- 6:19to blossom? What effort is worth it to
- 6:22you and what effort is not? The answers
- 6:24to these questions will guide you into
- 6:26the kind of world that you want to make.
- 6:28And if somebody doesn't like your world
- 6:30where Death Valley above Siberia and
- 6:32rain falls upward, well, maybe that
- 6:34person isn't your target audience.
- 6:37You're not going to please everyone. So
- 6:39know what your goals are and reach for
- 6:41that audience, not the ones that you're
- 6:43never going to make happy. Okay. Okay,
- 6:45so the second question of ver similitude
- 6:47is to look at internal consistency. This
- 6:50can be very similar to external
- 6:51consistency like we just talked about
- 6:53because frankly we are drawing a lot of
- 6:56our own world building whether we like
- 6:58it or not from our own experiences in
- 7:00this world and so there is going to be
- 7:02some blurring of those lines. But that
- 7:04being said, as you begin to establish
- 7:06those aspects of your world that are
- 7:08unique, whether that is a few things or
- 7:10a lot of things, this internal
- 7:13consistency question will rear its head.
- 7:15And that question is once you have
- 7:18established a rule for how your world
- 7:20functions, how strictly do you want to
- 7:23follow and enforce that rule across the
- 7:25board? I'm going to pick on Star Trek
- 7:27again. I did it in my intent and scope
- 7:30video, and it really is the perfect
- 7:32example for this. Now, like I said in
- 7:34that one, I love classic Star Trek, but
- 7:37one of the things that classic Star Trek
- 7:39fails at terribly is internal
- 7:41consistency. One example of this is with
- 7:44their warp drive and how warp drive
- 7:45correlates and interacts with natural
- 7:48space. Those rules vary episode to
- 7:50episode, movie to movie, and have been
- 7:54utterly inconsistent throughout. Every
- 7:56once in a while, someone will come along
- 7:57and try to justify after the fact, but
- 8:00it's just so scattered in its
- 8:01interpretations that I don't think
- 8:04anyone will ever be wholly successful.
- 8:05And maybe that's okay. With Star Trek,
- 8:07it works because that is not their main
- 8:10focus. And with your world, that may
- 8:12work, too. But if you do strive to have
- 8:14that internal consistency, that's
- 8:15something you're going to have to watch
- 8:16out for. to approach this from another
- 8:18direction along the veins of a little
- 8:20bit of what we've already talked about.
- 8:22Once you do establish something in your
- 8:24world that does not exist in our earth,
- 8:27to what degree do you want to follow the
- 8:29trail of what kind of impacts that has?
- 8:32As an example, let's talk about the
- 8:34interreationship of physics and magic.
- 8:37Let's say you adopt all the basic
- 8:38physical laws of our world. probably
- 8:40most worldbuilders will because it's
- 8:43easier that way including gravity uh the
- 8:46concept of like force equals mass times
- 8:49acceleration conservation of energy and
- 8:52so on. We're going to cover magic in a
- 8:54little more detail further on in our
- 8:56cosmology discussion and it'll have its
- 8:57own video to be sure. But for purposes
- 9:00of this discussion, let's say that you
- 9:02have decided that your magic has
- 9:04physicality to it. what we might often
- 9:07call elemental magic with fireballs and
- 9:10lightning and earthquakes and whirlwinds
- 9:12and things like that which physically
- 9:13affect the world around them. And let's
- 9:15also say that magic is fairly common in
- 9:17your world. In a population of 100,
- 9:19maybe there's a there's at least one
- 9:21magic user. They're all around. They
- 9:23maybe have magic shops and magic schools
- 9:26and all those kinds of things that are
- 9:28so popular in many of the worlds that
- 9:30you know from fantasy. But also, let's
- 9:32say that your world is set in an
- 9:35approximation of our medieval world
- 9:38because who doesn't like castles, right?
- 9:40So, there's castles dotting the
- 9:42landscape. So, you have magic with
- 9:44physicality to it and you have castles.
- 9:47What are the implications of that? The
- 9:49challenge is that castles in our world
- 9:52became obsolete as soon as cannon were
- 9:54introduced on the battlefield. Castles
- 9:57were developed with very high,
- 9:59relatively thin walls to give archers
- 10:01great height to shoot down from and also
- 10:04to require any invader to have a long
- 10:07ways to climb to get into the
- 10:09fortification. But with cannon, only a
- 10:12few shots could blast entire holes
- 10:14through what used to be an impregnable
- 10:16castle, completely changing the face of
- 10:19warfare and also the structure of
- 10:21society that developed around those
- 10:23castles. What happened with the
- 10:24introduction of cannon in our world is
- 10:27that fortifications instead of being
- 10:29tall castles became very short. The
- 10:32reason they were short was it was easier
- 10:33for cannonballs just to fly over. They
- 10:36also had extremely thick walls with lots
- 10:39of earth and other materials in them to
- 10:42cushion any blows from cannon so it
- 10:45wouldn't crumble and fall apart. These
- 10:46were called star forts because they
- 10:48built these projections along the
- 10:51fortifications allowing for inflating
- 10:53fire against anyone who tried to storm
- 10:54them. A perfect example is Fort Mckenry
- 10:57of the Star Spangled Banner fame. A cool
- 10:59fort if you ever have a chance to visit
- 11:00Baltimore. So if you have magic that can
- 11:03blast castle walls down, are you still
- 11:05going to have those castles that you
- 11:07want? Maybe not. If your goal is
- 11:10internal consistency, then you have a
- 11:12few challenging questions you may need
- 11:14to grapple with. You may decide to
- 11:15reduce the power of magic or the number
- 11:18of magic users. Or perhaps there are
- 11:21societal or magically functional rules
- 11:24that limit their ability on the
- 11:26battlefield to to reduce these castles
- 11:28to rubble. Or perhaps in addition to
- 11:30fireballs, magic can also be used to
- 11:33make the castle fortifications more
- 11:35resistant to magical attack, thereby
- 11:38allowing you still to keep those cool
- 11:39medieval structures. The point here is
- 11:41that any cosmological change from our
- 11:44world that you introduce can have
- 11:47trickle down effects that you may not
- 11:48have anticipated which can have huge
- 11:51impacts on how societies develop,
- 11:54interact and so on. It can be both fun
- 11:57and challenging to try to work these
- 11:58things out. If internal consistency is
- 12:01important to you, you'll probably want
- 12:02to have some sort of log where you can
- 12:04keep these rulings in play to keep them
- 12:06consistent. One technique you might try
- 12:08is building a wiki to track all this. As
- 12:10with all world building, there is a give
- 12:12and take for all these choices that you
- 12:14make. There is a third aspect of
- 12:15verilitude that we could get into that
- 12:18involves stepping beyond the
- 12:20natural, physical, even metaphysical
- 12:23aspects of your world and moving on
- 12:25towards those political, economic,
- 12:28sociological parts of the societies that
- 12:31you put into your world. This is
- 12:33especially true if you are mimicking to
- 12:34a certain degree a particular part of
- 12:37our world's history. Whether that be
- 12:39classic antiquity, three kingdoms,
- 12:41China, the Middle Ages, the age of sale,
- 12:44and so on. Do you adopt the beliefs of
- 12:47that period and have the people in your
- 12:50world act like the people in those
- 12:53periods did? Or do you superimpose our
- 12:5521st century values onto those
- 12:58societies? Even though that super
- 13:00imposition never really happened in our
- 13:02world. One is more realistic while the
- 13:05other may be more comfortable because
- 13:07it's familiar. I've waffled back and
- 13:09forth whether to do a deeper dive on
- 13:11this topic in this video and decided
- 13:13against it ultimately because it truly
- 13:16isn't cosmology the looking at the
- 13:18natural physical rules of your world
- 13:22among other reasons. I may go ahead and
- 13:24do a deeper dive on this concept in the
- 13:26future especially if there's interest.
- 13:27We'll see. Uh but for now I want to
- 13:30stick to the cosmological concepts and
- 13:32so I'm just bringing this up as an aside
- 13:34of something else to think about in the
- 13:36realms of realism and verilitude. All
- 13:40right, with that let's move on to the
- 13:41next aspect of
- 13:43cosmology and core foundational world
- 13:47building and that is the measure of
- 13:49familiar versus strange in your world.
- 13:53This has already cropped its head in
- 13:54some of the videos I've already done,
- 13:56namely Poisons of the Secondhand Tolken,
- 13:58where I talk about fantasy races. Uh,
- 14:00and it's sure to crop up in future
- 14:02videos as well, because it is so
- 14:04important when you are figuring out how
- 14:07you want to handle your world. When you
- 14:10consider anything and everything that
- 14:12you're going to include in your world
- 14:14building, you're also looking at things
- 14:17on a spectrum with familiar on one end
- 14:21and strange on the other. Let's say you
- 14:24are planning on introducing a
- 14:26fantastical race of your own design. If
- 14:28they are similar to humans or at least
- 14:31similar to those fantastical races that
- 14:33already exist such as elves, dwarves,
- 14:36goblins, dryads, merolk, then you are
- 14:39introducing something that is on the
- 14:41familiar end of the spectrum. The
- 14:43advantage here is that you don't have to
- 14:45push your audience too far to understand
- 14:47what you're doing.
- 14:49The risk is that because you're dealing
- 14:52with the familiar, it may end up being
- 14:54humdrum, especially if it's just another
- 14:56species of perpetually angry, greedy,
- 14:59drunken, brawling, subterranean dwarf
- 15:03creatures. On the other end of the
- 15:05spectrum, you could introduce something
- 15:07completely strange and explore what that
- 15:10means. Let's say you introduce a species
- 15:13of chitus quadripeds with an armored
- 15:16carropus and clawed hands. The advantage
- 15:19here is that you have introduced
- 15:20something completely foreign to your
- 15:23audience's experience. This is new,
- 15:26fresh, and potentially can be really
- 15:28compelling for them. One example for me
- 15:31here personally is back in the day when
- 15:33I was playing the online game Asheron's
- 15:36Call, and there was a group called the
- 15:38Shadows, and I just found them
- 15:40absolutely compelling. And so in the
- 15:41game, I would go and I would try to find
- 15:43all the lore I could to understand them
- 15:45better because it was really such an
- 15:47interesting race. The risk though is
- 15:50that if you push this too far, your
- 15:51audience will not be able to relate.
- 15:54This is especially true if you are
- 15:55intending to explore aspects of the
- 15:58human condition such as adolescence,
- 16:02growing up, falling in love, dealing
- 16:04with human mortality, so on and so
- 16:07forth. Because how can you relate
- 16:09adolescence of a chititness quadriped to
- 16:12adolescence of a human boy or human
- 16:14girl? To go back to Ashon's Call as an
- 16:17example, I think they also failed when
- 16:20they tried to roll out their second
- 16:21game, which did not do very well and was
- 16:25shut down very quickly. I've heard
- 16:27various reasons, but personally, I've
- 16:28always theorized that one of the reasons
- 16:31for its failure is that two of the
- 16:32playable races were strange and
- 16:35uncompelling and uninteresting to play.
- 16:38That certainly is the reason why I never
- 16:39picked it up and stuck with the
- 16:40original. So, there is risk on both ends
- 16:43of the spectrum, just like there are
- 16:44advantages to be found as well. As I
- 16:46said, I already covered this under
- 16:48poisons of the secondhand token. I'll
- 16:49make sure to link that also at the end
- 16:51of this video if you're interested in
- 16:53that topic. The reason I use the same
- 16:55example here is because fantasy races is
- 16:58such a good clean example of this at
- 17:00play. But really this strangeness and
- 17:02this familiarity can apply to any aspect
- 17:05of your cosmology. So, with veric
- 17:07similitude and familiar versus strange
- 17:10out of the way, let's get on to the fun
- 17:12stuff, which maybe is where you wish I
- 17:13had begun from the start. But I really
- 17:15felt like it was important to discuss
- 17:17those grounding underlying concepts to
- 17:19your cosmology before we actually get
- 17:21into the cosmological aspects of your
- 17:23world. I'm only going to touch on each
- 17:26of these topics in brief because
- 17:28frankly, there is at least a full video,
- 17:30if not multiple videos on each of the
- 17:32topics. And spoiler, we'll be diving
- 17:35into those in the future to a far more
- 17:38comprehensive
- 17:39degree. And as we get started, one of
- 17:42the other reasons to just look at it
- 17:43lightly here is to emphasize the idea
- 17:47that you don't have to have all of the
- 17:49answers as you set out. When I first
- 17:52began building the world of Isfalleness,
- 17:54I had settled upon four races: humans,
- 17:57elves, dwarves, and eagles. Over time, I
- 18:00replaced the eagles with winged folk.
- 18:02And then I ended up axing the dwarves
- 18:03for a completely different race called
- 18:05the burgarist. I ended up axing the wing
- 18:07folk for a completely different race
- 18:09called the ehay. And I changed the elves
- 18:13from being elves to something elflike
- 18:16called the estari. So in the end of
- 18:19those original four, the only survivors
- 18:21really are the humans and then the
- 18:23somewhat elflike theari. The rest of the
- 18:25two were completely changed. And that's
- 18:27the thing with the beginning of your
- 18:29world building. There is time to flesh
- 18:31this stuff out. So as you start out, I
- 18:33would instead encourage you just to come
- 18:35up with some general answers to these
- 18:37questions, realizing that there may be
- 18:39room to alter them a little bit or even
- 18:41profoundly in the future as you really
- 18:44solidify what your world is. And if you
- 18:47don't trust me, trust the master Tolken.
- 18:49He was still struggling to define what
- 18:51orcs are six decades after he first
- 18:55began working on Middle Earth. If you
- 18:57didn't know, Sylmerelion says that orcs
- 19:01are corrupted elves, but Tolken wasn't
- 19:03entirely satisfied with that and was
- 19:04striving to find a better answer um even
- 19:07when he passed away. And so we never did
- 19:09get the final answer uh to that question
- 19:13from him. Okay, so the first on our list
- 19:15is cosmogyny. Wait, you might say we
- 19:18already talked a bit about cosmogyny and
- 19:20that's right. That's because cosmogyny
- 19:22falls under the umbrella of cosmology.
- 19:24It isn't all of it, but it is part of
- 19:26it. So, as we think about cosmogyny,
- 19:28that is the establishment of how your
- 19:32world came to be. There are some
- 19:34questions you need to consider. Was your
- 19:36world created? If so, do the inhabitants
- 19:40know it was created? Do they know how it
- 19:42was created? If they don't, do you even
- 19:45know how it was created? to jump back to
- 19:47Tolken in his cosmogyny. His world began
- 19:50with Illuvatar. I think I pronounced
- 19:52that right. Who created the Valar and
- 19:54the Mayar and that group sang together a
- 19:59great song that became the world and
- 20:02then they watched it all play out. For
- 20:04Robert Jordan and his Wheel of Time, he
- 20:07had a world that went through seven
- 20:09different ages and each age quickly
- 20:11forgot about the one that came before in
- 20:12a perpetual cycle. So there is no real
- 20:15known beginning of that world. It's just
- 20:18a world that continuously repeats. In
- 20:20Norse mythology, the world was shaped
- 20:22out of the body of a dead giant. So
- 20:25there are many possibilities on what
- 20:27kind of a cosmogyny you have and how
- 20:30much of it is known by the people who
- 20:32live in your world. In a similar vein,
- 20:34does your world have religion? And if
- 20:36not, how do they function without it? Is
- 20:38that religion founded upon a pantheon or
- 20:41dualism or deism or monotheism or any
- 20:45number of other possible isms? Fantasy
- 20:48frequently has one kind of overarching
- 20:51religion with different waring factions.
- 20:54Either whether it's dualistic with two
- 20:56factions fighting each other or a whole
- 20:57bunch of different factions with each
- 20:59god having their followers all
- 21:00squabbbling together. Some works of
- 21:02fantasy largely ignore religion
- 21:04altogether. And they can often pull this
- 21:07off if they don't worry about cosmogyny
- 21:10and if they're not talking about
- 21:11worldwide shaping events like you would
- 21:15see in the Wheel of Time or in Lord of
- 21:18the Rings and stories like that.
- 21:20Furthermore, if you have a cosmogyny, as
- 21:23we just talked about, where there is a
- 21:25creation story or multiple
- 21:27interpretations of possible creation
- 21:29stories, odds are you're going to need
- 21:32various religions based upon what those
- 21:34beliefs happen to be. Another option is
- 21:37to have the same religion permeate the
- 21:40world with various sects and groups and
- 21:43dissident and so on and so forth. Okay,
- 21:46so next let's look at the heavens and
- 21:47the earth. And by heavens, I don't mean
- 21:49heaven. I mean the skies, which
- 21:52depending upon your world, may actually
- 21:54be the heavens, too. Is there a sun, a
- 21:58moon, the stars? Or maybe there are many
- 22:00suns or many moons. Is there a solar
- 22:03system like ours wherein the earth
- 22:06revolves around the sun? Or perhaps it's
- 22:08more of the medieval model where it was
- 22:10believed that the world was at the
- 22:11center of the solar system and the
- 22:13universe revolved around it. Or are the
- 22:17celestial spheres not celestial spheres
- 22:19at all, but rather holes in a great dome
- 22:22and heaven shines through? What about
- 22:24the world itself? Is it a globe? Or is
- 22:27it a flat world, perhaps on the back of
- 22:29a turtle with waters from the oceans
- 22:32falling over the sides? Or is it some
- 22:34other shape? Perhaps everyone lives on
- 22:36the inside of a sphere rather than the
- 22:39outside. There are so many possibilities
- 22:41of different kinds of worlds and
- 22:43universes that you can have.
- 22:46geography. Do the lands and the seas
- 22:48behave like our own driven by tectonic
- 22:52forces, the coralolis effect, winds and
- 22:54currents, pressure zones and so on, all
- 22:57driving climate and soil types and
- 22:59vegetation etc. Or are there other
- 23:03worldly, magical, divine or infernal
- 23:05influences at play making your world
- 23:08function very differently from ours?
- 23:11Magic. Is there magic in your world? If
- 23:14so, how does it function? Is it
- 23:17scientific, logical, and mathematically
- 23:20quantifiable? Or is it an inscrable
- 23:22wonder, not wholly understood really by
- 23:25anyone? In other words, is magic
- 23:28worldly, part of the natural order of
- 23:30things, or otherworldly, outside of
- 23:33those laws? How powerful is this magic?
- 23:36Can it destroy huge swaths of the world
- 23:39like a nuclear bomb? Or is it no more
- 23:41dangerous than one guy holding a pointy
- 23:43stick? What powers the magic? I kind of
- 23:45touched on this already, but to dive
- 23:48deeper into this, is it integrated and
- 23:50natural like all other sources of energy
- 23:52in the world? Does the caster draw it
- 23:54from himself? Is the source divine or
- 23:57infernal? Is magic good, neutral, and
- 24:00evil? Is it vivid with fireballs and
- 24:03lightning? Or is it much more subtle and
- 24:06spiritual? Or both? Who can use magic?
- 24:09And how do these magic users develop
- 24:11their skills and abilities and grow
- 24:13their power? Or can they even grow their
- 24:15power? And what price do they pay for
- 24:17that effort? Races. What kinds of
- 24:21sentient races inhabit your world? Are
- 24:24there humans? There don't have to be.
- 24:27Are there other fantastical races? Are
- 24:29these races traditional like elves and
- 24:32dwarves and gnomes? Or are they
- 24:34concoctions of your own design? Are they
- 24:37humanoid or alien? Are some races good
- 24:41and some races evil? Or are good and
- 24:44evil applied based upon individual
- 24:47choice? Do these races live side by side
- 24:49such as in Elder Scrolls? Or do they
- 24:51tend to congregate only in their own
- 24:54domains like in Middle Earth? If they
- 24:57intermix, is it a general mix like Elder
- 25:01Scrolls, or is there one species that is
- 25:03superior like in Steven Bruss Dragar
- 25:06books? Are there non-sapient monsters in
- 25:09addition to your sapient races? If so,
- 25:12is there a vast beastiary of all these
- 25:14fantastical creatures, or do they exist
- 25:16in much smaller variety and numbers? Are
- 25:19they fay and otherworldly? Or are they
- 25:22part of the natural world much like a
- 25:25wolf or a bear or a deer? Or some blend
- 25:28thereof with some being otherworldly and
- 25:31some being
- 25:32worldly. So that's a good start to our
- 25:34cosmology list and we'll stop there for
- 25:36today. Frankly, I think I covered all of
- 25:39those core aspects of cosmology. If I
- 25:41missed one or there's a particular topic
- 25:42you think should be included on this
- 25:44list, let me know in the comments and
- 25:45I'll add it potentially to a future
- 25:47discussion. I've also begun putting on
- 25:49my website jonathan oldenberg.com a log
- 25:53of all the various topics that we are
- 25:55covering in this video series including
- 25:56a I guess you call call it a cheat sheet
- 25:59uh for this particular topic with all
- 26:01the questions I asked about these
- 26:02cosmological concepts. So if you would
- 26:05like that as a tangible copy to work
- 26:06with check it out there I will link that
- 26:09website in the description as well. But
- 26:11before we wrap up this video there is
- 26:13one final concept I would like to cover
- 26:15with you. Is there some sort of quirk
- 26:17that makes your world stand out from all
- 26:20the others? There doesn't have to be. I
- 26:22mean, there are great many worlds that
- 26:24some might decry as humrum, but are
- 26:26nevertheless very popular and very
- 26:28enjoyable to read books in, play games
- 26:32in, so on and so forth. So, you don't
- 26:34have to have a quirk, but you might want
- 26:36one. And that's something to think
- 26:38about. If you want a quirk, but you
- 26:39aren't quite sure where to go with that,
- 26:41then maybe think about your own
- 26:43interests and build upon that as a
- 26:46concept point. For example, Tolken built
- 26:48Middle Earth based upon his love of
- 26:50languages and also his fascination with
- 26:52old English legends going back into the
- 26:55old Norse past. Steven Ericson is an
- 26:59archaeologist and anthropologist by
- 27:01background. Robert Jordan, as we already
- 27:03talked about, decided that he wanted to
- 27:05have his world run through seven ages
- 27:07rather than have a beginning, middle,
- 27:09and an end. Mark Lawrence in his Book of
- 27:11the Ancestors trilogy provides another
- 27:13example wherein he has a fantasy world
- 27:16sort of with an interesting blend of
- 27:18sci-fi where the world is ice covered
- 27:22and the polar caps are being kept at bay
- 27:24by satellites that have begun to fade
- 27:26and so the snows are gradually
- 27:27encroaching more and more towards the
- 27:30equator. For me, my background is
- 27:31history. So, I love to study and see the
- 27:34interreationship of different societies
- 27:36and cultures across both narrow and
- 27:38broad swaths of time that drives a lot
- 27:41of the choices I make and steers my
- 27:43focus. So, what is the passion that's
- 27:46driving you? And if you don't have
- 27:47another quirk in mind, I don't know that
- 27:49Robert Jordan and Mark Lawrence had a
- 27:51quirk in the same way that Tolken or
- 27:53Ericson do. But either way, it can help
- 27:56you develop a world that is distinctly
- 27:59yours.
- 28:00And that's something to think about. All
- 28:02right, so we have come to the end of our
- 28:04initial dive into the cosmology of your
- 28:07world. As I said already, we'll be
- 28:09spending a lot more time with each of
- 28:10these concepts. I plan on devoting at
- 28:12least one video to each concept we've
- 28:14talked about today, perhaps more for
- 28:16those which require it. And in those
- 28:18future videos, we will seek to hone the
- 28:21rough ideas we came up with today into
- 28:23much more concrete, solid conclusions.
- 28:27For the moment though a quick review as
- 28:29I like to do of the concepts in this
- 28:31video. First we looked at verimilitude
- 28:34and the two aspects of that. One which
- 28:36is the external consistency. How
- 28:38consistent is your world to our earth
- 28:41and internal consistency. How consistent
- 28:44is your world within itself? Especially
- 28:47are you following the vein of if you
- 28:50have introduced something unique seeing
- 28:53where that plays out. Next, we looked at
- 28:55the balance of familiar versus strange,
- 28:58where familiar is comfortable but
- 29:00potentially humdrum, while strange may
- 29:02be compelling but also so far beyond our
- 29:06comprehension as to be unrelatable.
- 29:07There is a risk and a reward wherever
- 29:09you decide to fall on that spectrum.
- 29:11Then we went through the laundry list of
- 29:13all those fun core cosmological
- 29:16concepts. cosmogyny, religion, the
- 29:19universe, that is the earth and the
- 29:20heavens, geography, magic, and what
- 29:24races inhabit your world, both sapient
- 29:28and monstrous. Finally, we close with
- 29:30that question of whether you want to
- 29:32find a particular quirk that makes your
- 29:34world unique from all the others or not.
- 29:38Either choice is fine depending upon
- 29:39what your goals are. So, with that, it's
- 29:41time to bring this video to its final
- 29:43conclusion. If you have any thoughts on
- 29:45anything we've talked about today,
- 29:46please put them in the comments. I
- 29:47always love to hear those. If you have
- 29:49any other cosmological concepts that you
- 29:51would like me to cover, please include
- 29:52those as well. And of course, please
- 29:54like and subscribe to continue following
- 29:56this series. And I look forward to
- 29:58seeing you again in the next video.
- 29:59Until then, have a good day.
- 30:04[Music]
- 30:15Is there a solar system like ours where
- 30:18the world in which you are putting your
- 30:21setting rotates around the sun? Is it
- 30:24rotates around the
- 30:29sun? I always get that
- 30:33wrong. Revolves around the sun. I'm glad
- 30:36I checked.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of How to Establish a Foundation for your Worldbuilding - Cosmology by Jonathan Oldenburg, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 5,331 words across 782 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.