YouTube2Text

How to Become a Master Storyteller (Richard Powers Interview) — Transcript

by David Perell · 12,754 words · 1,896 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00character is complex and I I would
  2. 0:03always challenge my students I would say
  3. 0:06push them to the wall push them to the
  4. 0:08wall yeah and that's where the drama of
  5. 0:10being alive is can you live with
  6. 0:12yourself if you have to do something
  7. 0:14that you ordinarily would hate to do but
  8. 0:17the circumstance makes it necessary for
  9. 0:19you so you got person against themselves
  10. 0:21person against person is that it no
  11. 0:25there's a third level of drama tell me
  12. 0:27about these relationships with
  13. 0:29characters so if character drives drama
  14. 0:32and voice drives character what drives
  15. 0:35voice H and this might be lesson number
  16. 0:38one of craft so when you're writing what
  17. 0:40are you doing to make it feel alive read
  18. 0:45the first sentence again cuz you'll see
  19. 0:47a little registral trick there okay tell
  20. 0:49me when to stop each child's tree has
  21. 0:51its own Excellence
  22. 0:54stop Richard Powers won the Pulitzer
  23. 0:56Prize for the over story in 2019 and and
  24. 1:00I had some friends who recommended it to
  25. 1:01me they said wow the writing is so alive
  26. 1:03so I walk into a bookstore one day I
  27. 1:05pick it up and I start reading the
  28. 1:07sentences and the paragraphs and I was
  29. 1:10in awe of the descriptiveness The Wonder
  30. 1:13of his writing so that's a major part of
  31. 1:16what we talked about in this interview
  32. 1:17but also we spoke about the three
  33. 1:19different kinds of stories there's
  34. 1:21people against people people against
  35. 1:23themselves and people against the
  36. 1:24environment and he walked us through all
  37. 1:26three and then he said but we also need
  38. 1:28to talk about characters I want to show
  39. 1:30you how drama conflict voice and
  40. 1:33dialogue can bring a character to life
  41. 1:36so if you're somebody who's trying to
  42. 1:37write better stories and write with more
  43. 1:40life in your own work well you're going
  44. 1:42to love this conversation with Richard
  45. 1:45Powers character is complex and we all
  46. 1:50do this in course of Our Lives you know
  47. 1:55we our brains have adapted to try to
  48. 1:59understand understand the hidden
  49. 2:01motivations of other people in fact
  50. 2:03there when when you talk to evolutionary
  51. 2:06biologists there will be some who say we
  52. 2:09needed the big brain because we were
  53. 2:12social you know we had I mean mammals
  54. 2:16have by and large solved a lot of the
  55. 2:19problems of predation avoiding prey you
  56. 2:22know um you know responding flexibly to
  57. 2:26change you know you can get by on a lot
  58. 2:30less Hardware but what you need a lot of
  59. 2:32hardware for is keeping track of who's
  60. 2:35up and who's down who's in and who's out
  61. 2:37who that's right that's right so we're
  62. 2:40all novelists in our own lives we're all
  63. 2:43saying I this guy is
  64. 2:47remembering what happened between us 20
  65. 2:51years ago right and he's holding a
  66. 2:53grudge or I haven't seen her in a long
  67. 2:56time I wonder if she's also a little bit
  68. 2:59in the nostalgic about the road that we
  69. 3:01did not take you know all those kinds of
  70. 3:03things that we do with each other all
  71. 3:05the time those are the underlying skills
  72. 3:08that we use to assemble character when
  73. 3:10we're creating
  74. 3:13stories who's a character in a recent
  75. 3:15novel that you still feel like you have
  76. 3:18a really intimate relationship with well
  77. 3:23I'm very close to the to the people in
  78. 3:26playground still um and
  79. 3:30one of the great joys of being a
  80. 3:33novelist is you get up in the morning
  81. 3:35and you
  82. 3:36say how are they going to surprise me
  83. 3:39today one of the great sadnesses of a
  84. 3:41novelist is you have to come to an end
  85. 3:43and you have to surrender the manuscript
  86. 3:45at some point and it becomes this fixed
  87. 3:48thing and yet your heart is still saying
  88. 3:51did I do right by
  89. 3:53them uh was there something else that
  90. 3:56they wanted or needed that I didn't get
  91. 3:58to you know so you know there's an odd
  92. 4:01way in which the character lives on in
  93. 4:03in your sense of of potential or
  94. 4:06Prospect as you're telling stories but
  95. 4:09you know the the two Central
  96. 4:11protagonists in this book uh Todd
  97. 4:16Keane who is a a Norths side chicagoan
  98. 4:20white privileged
  99. 4:23wealthy and Rafi young black guy from
  100. 4:26the South Side who's coming from a very
  101. 4:28different socioeconomic straum and whose
  102. 4:31personal history is very different than
  103. 4:33Todd's in weird ways I I used them both
  104. 4:38as alter OS you know I used them almost
  105. 4:43psychoanalytically to get to various
  106. 4:46things in my personal past that I wanted
  107. 4:49still to work through here at the age of
  108. 4:5267 I put them I put them in collision
  109. 4:55with each
  110. 4:56other um character leads naturally into
  111. 4:58drama in a way that we can talk about
  112. 5:01but I let them Collide I you know they
  113. 5:03formed a friendship that was
  114. 5:07tight dedicated but also highly
  115. 5:11competitive and with a certain degree of
  116. 5:13weariness and
  117. 5:15distrust a certain degree of
  118. 5:18um ribbing and uh
  119. 5:22Relentless Uh crap shoveling as males do
  120. 5:26to each other um
  121. 5:30and the drama that arose out of that was
  122. 5:34naturally a kind of extension of all the
  123. 5:37unfinished drama of my young life you
  124. 5:40know from the age of 10 to the age of 30
  125. 5:45uh and Beyond character leads into drama
  126. 5:49I think that's true I mean when we think
  127. 5:51of character you I used to teach
  128. 5:54character using something like the
  129. 5:56stanislowski method I don't know if
  130. 5:59you've had writers who have approached
  131. 6:01it that way but he was a great
  132. 6:04theoretician of
  133. 6:06acting and how how to uh an actor
  134. 6:10prepares is one of one of his works and
  135. 6:12you know how how to inhabit a role of
  136. 6:16someone on stage who isn't you and how
  137. 6:19to locate in the
  138. 6:22role something in the core inner values
  139. 6:26of that
  140. 6:27character that you yourself can identify
  141. 6:31with knowing full well that you don't
  142. 6:34you are not that person you do not
  143. 6:36belong to that world but
  144. 6:39somehow abstracting it enough so that
  145. 6:42you can use your own inner experiences
  146. 6:46and core inner values to inhabit and
  147. 6:48participate in that other characters uh
  148. 6:51and and of course what an actor does to
  149. 6:53inhabit a role is not that different
  150. 6:55than what a novelist has to do to create
  151. 6:57a character so
  152. 7:00make this concrete for me I don't know
  153. 7:02why I was thinking of Nemo and Nemo is
  154. 7:05you know this little kidf fish and Nemo
  155. 7:09wants to get out right and go do things
  156. 7:11go explore the ocean and then you have
  157. 7:13what's his name Marlin the dad Marlin I
  158. 7:15think is his name Marlin is this super
  159. 7:17overprotective dad and Marlin says to
  160. 7:20him very early in the movie he's like
  161. 7:21are you sure you want to go to school
  162. 7:23today because it's the first day of
  163. 7:24school he's trying to say stay home stay
  164. 7:26home because he is this just
  165. 7:30gripping on the life of his young son so
  166. 7:33if we take that tell me about what
  167. 7:36you're saying through the Prisma of
  168. 7:37those character so I I used to do this
  169. 7:40uh I and and this also derives from the
  170. 7:42stanowski method but I used to teach
  171. 7:45characterization as an onion so you you
  172. 7:49have on the outside of a person I don't
  173. 7:52necessarily mean the outside in the way
  174. 7:54that they perform themselves in the
  175. 7:55world because that's always a delicate
  176. 7:57and elaborate dance hiding a lot of
  177. 8:00things uh displaying a lot of things you
  178. 8:03know uh negotiating a lot of things but
  179. 8:06in in terms of the the psychic economy
  180. 8:09of that
  181. 8:10character in the outer shell are the
  182. 8:14traits H and he he's he's got a green
  183. 8:18shirt on it's got a little Insignia uh
  184. 8:21nice haircut you know he he holds one
  185. 8:24you know all the things that you can use
  186. 8:26to make a character Visual and visible
  187. 8:29to the reader yeah but those traits come
  188. 8:33from somewhere H right they derive from
  189. 8:37things that are farther on the in the
  190. 8:39interior of the onion and uh the beneath
  191. 8:44that level of surface you know physical
  192. 8:48traits or or behavioral
  193. 8:50traits you might have
  194. 8:52mannerisms like he likes
  195. 8:56to uh unnerve people
  196. 9:00right whenever somebody says something
  197. 9:03instead of saying all right he'll say
  198. 9:06what do you mean by that and and that
  199. 9:08mannerism of of uh uh challenging or
  200. 9:12subverting or undercutting somebody man
  201. 9:14there's a sensitivity of awareness that
  202. 9:19you must really have to have and is that
  203. 9:21something that you're cultivating I
  204. 9:23think it can be cultivated because I
  205. 9:25don't think I ever came by any of this
  206. 9:27naturally you know I if if you're
  207. 9:29talking about you know various uh
  208. 9:33distribution curves of people some of
  209. 9:35whom have very high emotional
  210. 9:36intelligence are immediately aligned
  211. 9:39with uh reading other people and then
  212. 9:42other people you know the cliche is the
  213. 9:44other end of the spectrum are people who
  214. 9:46do better with machines or or
  215. 9:48mathematical Concepts or I'm probably on
  216. 9:51that side of that Spectrum but I I I do
  217. 9:56think we can all we are all conversent
  218. 9:59you know to some degree with finding you
  219. 10:02know equivalence and and analoges across
  220. 10:05the ways of knowing the world so the
  221. 10:08next level inside of mannerisms would be
  222. 10:11what What I Call Core inner values and
  223. 10:15what I I get this again from people who
  224. 10:17have done a lot of thinking uh about the
  225. 10:21creation and inhabiting of characters so
  226. 10:24but by a value has to be something like
  227. 10:30honesty or
  228. 10:32Fidelity or
  229. 10:35perseverance right so so so we're now
  230. 10:39seeing Oh the
  231. 10:41reason he holds his hand like that is he
  232. 10:47he has a manner where he wants to set
  233. 10:51other people at
  234. 10:52ease um and underneath that manner of
  235. 10:57wanting to set people at ease is the
  236. 10:59value
  237. 11:00of complicity or or attentiveness or you
  238. 11:04know whatever it is but you see how
  239. 11:06multiple values can drive the same
  240. 11:08mannerism multiple mannerisms can be can
  241. 11:10lie behind the same trait so you have to
  242. 11:12find you have to find ways of making
  243. 11:14coherence so that the outward behavior
  244. 11:17of the person is both hiding and
  245. 11:21revealing things that they need things
  246. 11:24that they want to preserve in the world
  247. 11:27and and I I would always challenge my
  248. 11:29stud I would say push him to the wall
  249. 11:32push him to the wall yeah so I'd say you
  250. 11:35know this guy is a good guy you know he
  251. 11:38he values honesty but you know he also
  252. 11:42values
  253. 11:43Fidelity
  254. 11:44now put him in a place where he cannot
  255. 11:47have both so now you got to make a
  256. 11:50choice yeah what is what is your core in
  257. 11:53value and what one will fall by the
  258. 11:55wayside when push comes to shove because
  259. 11:58you got to choose and the the scenarios
  260. 12:01are obvious you know your friend has
  261. 12:03just done something
  262. 12:06wrong do you go to him and say look man
  263. 12:11you got to pay for that you have to own
  264. 12:13up to that or do you say I'm a good
  265. 12:15faithful friend I I you know I'm just
  266. 12:17going to support this guy I'll be with
  267. 12:19you no matter what yeah that's a story
  268. 12:22in fact that's 10,000 Stories right so
  269. 12:26what I'm hearing you say is you take
  270. 12:28these two values and you take them to
  271. 12:30the extreme you almost make somebody
  272. 12:32fight those two values internally yeah
  273. 12:34what would it take what situation or
  274. 12:37challenge would it
  275. 12:38take to force that person to have to
  276. 12:41jump ship from one and embrace the other
  277. 12:45now that's drama and that's a very
  278. 12:48specific kind of drama it's interior
  279. 12:51drama um and in the hierarchy of drama
  280. 12:55that I learned way back in grade school
  281. 12:57yeah back in the day very sexist
  282. 13:00language that would be called a man
  283. 13:02versus
  284. 13:03himself okay and that that fundamental
  285. 13:07kind of interior
  286. 13:10instability you know when I when I go
  287. 13:14out into the tum of the world my sense
  288. 13:17of self has to readjust my sense of what
  289. 13:20I think was most important to me has to
  290. 13:23change mhm that's the classic
  291. 13:26psychological novel how do we cope with
  292. 13:28the differences and the dramas inside
  293. 13:30our own head because look you know I
  294. 13:33don't want to have to choose between
  295. 13:35honesty and Fidelity I want to have both
  296. 13:38well life doesn't always let you have
  297. 13:40both right and that's where the drama of
  298. 13:42being alive is can you live with
  299. 13:43yourself if you have to do something
  300. 13:46that you ordinarily would hate to do but
  301. 13:48the circumstance makes it necessary for
  302. 13:51you yes
  303. 13:53now I'm doing that and David's doing
  304. 13:57that too and here we are sitting in the
  305. 14:00same room right and you need something
  306. 14:03from me and I need something from you
  307. 14:06right you have core interv value that's
  308. 14:08very different than my core interv value
  309. 14:11so November's coming up let's say for
  310. 14:15point of argument that my core inner
  311. 14:17value is
  312. 14:19equality and your core inner value is
  313. 14:22freedom and now we have to go to the
  314. 14:24election box and we have to vote for one
  315. 14:27candidate I can't believe who you're
  316. 14:30voting for you see what I'm saying now
  317. 14:32we have interpersonal drama now we have
  318. 14:34the sociological novel or the political
  319. 14:37novel where I can make you completely
  320. 14:40sympathetic to the
  321. 14:42reader and I can make myself completely
  322. 14:46sympathetic to the reader but now the
  323. 14:48reader is watching two people Collide in
  324. 14:51a way
  325. 14:53where they the reader has to say who's
  326. 14:56right the author doesn't necessarily
  327. 14:57have to say who's right but but the
  328. 14:59reader has to
  329. 15:00say if that were me which would I do
  330. 15:03well how would I jump I got to jump got
  331. 15:07to jump got to put a vote in The Ballot
  332. 15:08Box so you got person against themselves
  333. 15:11person against person right is that it
  334. 15:14no there's a third level of drama which
  335. 15:17is that human
  336. 15:20beings want to have a certain story in
  337. 15:23the world they want to have a project
  338. 15:26they want to have they they have a
  339. 15:28conception
  340. 15:30of what a good life
  341. 15:32is and how we can best go about doing
  342. 15:35that on this
  343. 15:37Earth the rest of the
  344. 15:40world and it is a very large rest of the
  345. 15:44world a very
  346. 15:45big comprehensive and interconnected
  347. 15:48living planet might be hostile to that
  348. 15:52idea of what it is that we want most it
  349. 15:54might be at best indifferent to it or it
  350. 15:56might be very sympathetic to it but
  351. 15:58there is
  352. 15:59battle between humans in the Aggregate
  353. 16:04and a world of which humans are only a
  354. 16:06very tiny part
  355. 16:07M and that level you would call man
  356. 16:11against the elements or man
  357. 16:14against life so you have the the the
  358. 16:18psychological component of all
  359. 16:21stories you have the sociological or
  360. 16:24political element of all stories but you
  361. 16:26also have this environmental or
  362. 16:28metaphysical iCal element to all stories
  363. 16:31MH now if I you know when I was reading
  364. 16:38everything I could get my hands on and
  365. 16:40deciding that I was going to give my
  366. 16:42life to this craft and this this
  367. 16:46work and I was reading especially
  368. 16:49contemporary
  369. 16:51novels in the 8S and then the '90s
  370. 16:54and even into the early 2000s there were
  371. 16:58a lot
  372. 16:59a lot of novels that were exceptionally
  373. 17:02good at
  374. 17:04Psychology and very very good at
  375. 17:06sociology and and
  376. 17:09politics but almost never ventured
  377. 17:13beyond the human
  378. 17:14world almost never introduced the idea
  379. 17:19that what we want out of our lives on
  380. 17:22this planet might not be commensurate
  381. 17:24with what the planet
  382. 17:25wants so the whole third kind of drama
  383. 17:29was disappearing from literary
  384. 17:32fiction we were getting
  385. 17:35extremely able and capable in our
  386. 17:39ability to tell stories about humans but
  387. 17:43only as if humans were autonomous and
  388. 17:47Inter independent from everything else
  389. 17:50right and it seemed to me that can't be
  390. 17:54right and and I started to look at the
  391. 17:56history of of liter fiction and then the
  392. 17:59history of world literature even before
  393. 18:01the
  394. 18:02novel and I was looking for that third
  395. 18:05kind of
  396. 18:07story and I saw I mean you can think of
  397. 18:10great examples of it right I mean if I
  398. 18:11said tell me a book about man versus
  399. 18:14nature or Man versus you know the gods
  400. 18:16or Man versus the elements Greek
  401. 18:19mythology a bunch all of it almost all
  402. 18:23mythological Traditions now now bring it
  403. 18:25up to the present what do you think you
  404. 18:27know what's what's the latest kind of
  405. 18:29great book in the American Canon that
  406. 18:31you think really concerned took
  407. 18:33seriously the idea of man versus
  408. 18:36nature I have no idea you got to go back
  409. 18:39away yeah and you got to go back to Mobi
  410. 18:41dick where you got to go back to the
  411. 18:43frontier American frontier no it's been
  412. 18:45that long huh well I mean there are
  413. 18:47always exceptions sure right but it
  414. 18:50there's a dip there's a real dip where
  415. 18:53you know from you know from 1851 when M
  416. 18:57dicks published to you know
  417. 19:011914 at start of the first world war you
  418. 19:05you see a trend for sure where that
  419. 19:08novel starts to seem quaint like the
  420. 19:11battle against
  421. 19:13nature you know it's like Jack London
  422. 19:15you know is well you know why why
  423. 19:18doesn't it seem literary to us because I
  424. 19:21think the practitioners of
  425. 19:24Storytelling were under the mistaken
  426. 19:27impression
  427. 19:29that man had defeated nature that human
  428. 19:31beings had won that
  429. 19:34drama and now we could invoke that drama
  430. 19:37kind of nostalgically but it wasn't a
  431. 19:39real issue in our lives anymore our
  432. 19:41Technologies had gotten so
  433. 19:43powerful that it didn't seem like
  434. 19:47questions that we had to ask
  435. 19:50anymore now what happens in the last
  436. 19:53couple decades is there's a growing
  437. 19:55awareness that we didn't win that in
  438. 19:58fact we're losing in that war and we're
  439. 20:00in bad shape not just on the climate
  440. 20:03front but on the species Extinction
  441. 20:05front and now that drama comes flooding
  442. 20:08back into the literary novel it never
  443. 20:11left the novel of Science Fiction it
  444. 20:15never left fantasy I mean fantasy is man
  445. 20:19against nature right it's telling that
  446. 20:23those things became second class those
  447. 20:25genres became subordinate genres genres
  448. 20:29in the eyes of the people who wanted to
  449. 20:31to be practitioners of literary fiction
  450. 20:34right but now now it where where it
  451. 20:38would have been strange for me in 1980
  452. 20:40to pick pick up a a a new literary
  453. 20:43fiction that had a lot of non-human
  454. 20:46elements in it non-human agents or
  455. 20:47non-human concerns or taking place
  456. 20:50seriously or taking other kinds of
  457. 20:52creatures
  458. 20:53seriously now it's rare to pick one up
  459. 20:55that it isn't addressing this question
  460. 20:57of how are we going to stay here much
  461. 20:59longer as you were thinking about the
  462. 21:02overstory and learning about trees
  463. 21:05and developing a kind of empathy for
  464. 21:08trees right I think of how big is the
  465. 21:10distance between you as the person and
  466. 21:13the dare I say consciousness of a tree
  467. 21:16it almost felt like your mind and the
  468. 21:19consciousness of trees fused together
  469. 21:23and I know that in your research process
  470. 21:25you just spent a lot of time in the
  471. 21:27woods and I would to hear about that
  472. 21:29research but even more fundamentally how
  473. 21:32you developed that kind of empathy for
  474. 21:35trees and turning up the dial of just
  475. 21:39how real they were to
  476. 21:41you I found that in Old
  477. 21:45literature I you mentioned
  478. 21:48mythology um indigenous
  479. 21:51stories and of course I found it also by
  480. 21:56recovering
  481. 21:59my own
  482. 22:00earliest sense of narrative so you know
  483. 22:05I I've often said that young
  484. 22:09children are are animists you know or or
  485. 22:15uh you know they they have they they
  486. 22:18take
  487. 22:19seriously these magical creatures around
  488. 22:22us you know I was just looked at at some
  489. 22:24crows flying past I'm looking at these
  490. 22:26marvelous locusts out of the window you
  491. 22:28you know and a child will could look at
  492. 22:31that and know that that creature is
  493. 22:34alive in really profound ways that
  494. 22:36adults now stop taking seriously no it's
  495. 22:38just wood it's just wood right so to go
  496. 22:42back to my own childhood of pantheism
  497. 22:46and to go back to the stories that
  498. 22:49underwrite world literature that know
  499. 22:52that you can't talk about human beings
  500. 22:55you can't understand human beings except
  501. 22:58in conversation with the neighbors you
  502. 23:00know with understanding them in the full
  503. 23:02context of who we're not you know and
  504. 23:05our our fascination with the non-human
  505. 23:06world is that somehow we can see
  506. 23:08qualities in these other ways of being
  507. 23:11in the world that resonate with our own
  508. 23:13values so to look at the non-human world
  509. 23:15is also to understand interior drama so
  510. 23:18it's not just a question of giving trees
  511. 23:21voice it's a question of remembering
  512. 23:23those voices inside human beings that
  513. 23:26were suppressed by this cultural
  514. 23:29colonialism that said no no no don't you
  515. 23:31know pay no attention to the world
  516. 23:33behind the curtain it's just us so to
  517. 23:37recover to recover that
  518. 23:39amazement wasn't a separate thing than
  519. 23:43you know to than to go deep into
  520. 23:45character for me for the creation of
  521. 23:47that book they they became the same
  522. 23:48Enterprise well what's wild about the
  523. 23:50overstory is how articulate you are
  524. 23:54about trees let me just read
  525. 23:57this we we found that trees could
  526. 23:59communicate over the air and through
  527. 24:01their Roots Common Sense hooted us down
  528. 24:03we found that trees take care of each
  529. 24:05other Collective science dismissed the
  530. 24:07ideas Outsiders discovered how seeds
  531. 24:10remember the seasons of their childhood
  532. 24:11and set buds accordingly Outsiders
  533. 24:14discovered that trees sense the presence
  534. 24:16of other nearby life that a tree learns
  535. 24:18to save water that trees feed their
  536. 24:20young and synchronize their masts and
  537. 24:22Bank resources and warm kin and send out
  538. 24:25signals to wasps to come and save them
  539. 24:27from Attack
  540. 24:29I mean Richard for somebody who didn't
  541. 24:31know a lot about trees before he started
  542. 24:33writing this book to then getting to a
  543. 24:36place where you could see that feel that
  544. 24:39put that into language and then do it
  545. 24:41lyrically and poetically it's just
  546. 24:44astonishing and I just need to
  547. 24:48understand how you did that well my
  548. 24:51whole project from the
  549. 24:53beginning has been driven forward by
  550. 24:57these these ways of knowing the world
  551. 24:59that we think are incompatible or in
  552. 25:03inimical you know opposite uh uh or in
  553. 25:07opposition to each other the the way of
  554. 25:09knowing the world through empiricism and
  555. 25:12Science and the way of knowing the world
  556. 25:15through intuition and the
  557. 25:17spirit I think the greatest science
  558. 25:20writers know that these aren't
  559. 25:24really
  560. 25:26combating programs
  561. 25:28that that that they actually are
  562. 25:30commensal that they actually depend on
  563. 25:32one another so the in the passage that
  564. 25:35you read this character Patricia
  565. 25:36westerford she's an outsider and she's
  566. 25:40not afraid to anthropomorphize which
  567. 25:42drives a lot of scientists nuts even now
  568. 25:44although there are interesting ways in
  569. 25:46which that attitude is changing because
  570. 25:48it has prevented us from seeing certain
  571. 25:51things about the world Beyond us but she
  572. 25:54uses a vocabulary that's very lyrical
  573. 25:57and very poetic
  574. 25:58very spiritual but every claim that she
  575. 26:02makes in that catalog that you read has
  576. 26:05some kind of empirical backing in
  577. 26:07peer-reviewed journal articles that I
  578. 26:10researched when I was reading the book
  579. 26:13so to me that's going to be our
  580. 26:15Salvation we have to know the world the
  581. 26:18way a scientist knows the world and we
  582. 26:21have to know the world the way an
  583. 26:22animist or pantheist child knows the
  584. 26:25world and if we can get those both going
  585. 26:28in our individual selves and in our
  586. 26:30culture as a whole we might have a shot
  587. 26:33of sticking around for a
  588. 26:35while and I think that this is so I I
  589. 26:40didn't grow up liking novels very much
  590. 26:42it was not I didn't read novels it just
  591. 26:45it wasn't super compelling to me and
  592. 26:49reading this now it's something about
  593. 26:50reading out reading it out loud is
  594. 26:53really showing me what the novel can
  595. 26:55uniquely do I'll read a little bit more
  596. 26:58a forest knows things they wire
  597. 27:00themselves up underground there are
  598. 27:01brains down there ones our own brains
  599. 27:04aren't shaped to see root plasticity
  600. 27:06solving problems and making decisions
  601. 27:08fungal synapses what else do you want to
  602. 27:11call it link enough trees together and a
  603. 27:13forest grows
  604. 27:15aware and I mean it almost brings tears
  605. 27:17to my eyes and what it's doing is that
  606. 27:21language
  607. 27:22is giving life to something that I've
  608. 27:25seen 10,000 times and like you were
  609. 27:27saying earlier you just become an adult
  610. 27:29you're like ah it's just a chunk of wood
  611. 27:30and some leaves they fall every every
  612. 27:33Autumn whatever and you're giving them
  613. 27:35life and vitality again through the
  614. 27:37language and that's that's the great
  615. 27:39grace of of the form the novel form you
  616. 27:42could have come across those facts in a
  617. 27:45very well done popularization of the new
  618. 27:47forestry and and uh you know all the
  619. 27:50discoveries about U symbiotic
  620. 27:53relationships in in a forest that have
  621. 27:55come out the last several decades
  622. 27:58and you could have grasped them
  623. 28:00intellectually but I think as
  624. 28:03psychologists
  625. 28:06know the apprehension of
  626. 28:10fact
  627. 28:11and a shift in
  628. 28:15values are not the same thing and that
  629. 28:19we can be
  630. 28:21seduced much
  631. 28:23more by emotion and AFF effect and
  632. 28:26feeling than we can stand by statistics
  633. 28:29and graphs and
  634. 28:31arguments uh in fact the word emotion is
  635. 28:35interesting
  636. 28:36atomically so it means to to to move to
  637. 28:40to to to move someone you know a m a
  638. 28:44right the to to move through something
  639. 28:46or uh and there this has been verified
  640. 28:50again in so many Laboratories using so
  641. 28:53many
  642. 28:55experiments but the smallest appeal
  643. 28:58to affect and to
  644. 29:02identification can make people do
  645. 29:05things you know that argument cannot and
  646. 29:08there's odd experiments that you know
  647. 29:11that make you wonder how how fragile and
  648. 29:14La labile mankind is you know like uh
  649. 29:18they'll have they'll have subjects
  650. 29:21reading two different texts or three
  651. 29:22different texts you know with with
  652. 29:24control text and a text about you know a
  653. 29:27story about someone who does something
  654. 29:29good for someone else and and the
  655. 29:32ostensibly the experiment is about
  656. 29:34comprehension so someone reads some data
  657. 29:37and someone reads a control neutral
  658. 29:41narrative that has no bearing on you
  659. 29:43know the question of emotion and someone
  660. 29:45reads a fictional
  661. 29:47passage that you know has the potential
  662. 29:51to to move you m um to break your heart
  663. 29:54and make you cry a little bit and the
  664. 29:57the a sensible experiment is we want to
  665. 29:59test your reading comprehension please
  666. 30:00answer the following questions so all
  667. 30:02three groups answer the following
  668. 30:04questions and when you're done answering
  669. 30:06the questions you know please take your
  670. 30:08exams down the hall and deposit them at
  671. 30:10this at this
  672. 30:11door and meanwhile a Confederate is
  673. 30:14walking down the hall in the other
  674. 30:15direction and they dump their pencils on
  675. 30:18the ground as if by accident you know
  676. 30:20they've got a a bunch of uh they're
  677. 30:23carrying a bunch of goods and they make
  678. 30:26a mess
  679. 30:28the the group that has read the
  680. 30:32story is far more likely to stop and
  681. 30:35help the person who just dumped their
  682. 30:39goods all over the
  683. 30:40hallway and it doesn't really have that
  684. 30:43much to do with you know with the
  685. 30:46temperaments of the individuals in that
  686. 30:47group they've all been Baseline shifted
  687. 30:50to for a moment anyway to be more
  688. 30:53empathetic to to to identify more with
  689. 30:55this person who's now in a moment of
  690. 30:56suffering right
  691. 30:58um and that's what fiction does it
  692. 31:00invites
  693. 31:02identification it invites you to say who
  694. 31:05would I be if I weren't myself but that
  695. 31:08guy and simply the act of doing
  696. 31:13that increases your
  697. 31:17desire to to to be connected to to to to
  698. 31:20be empathetic to be helpful to another
  699. 31:23person hey I want to tell you about a
  700. 31:25new site that I built called writing
  701. 31:27exam exles we take writers like
  702. 31:30Steinbeck Orwell Seinfeld and break down
  703. 31:33what makes their writing so good if that
  704. 31:36sounds like it's kind of your thing
  705. 31:38we'll go to writing examples.com and if
  706. 31:40you go there you enter email I'll send
  707. 31:43you my three favorite editions right
  708. 31:45away all right back to the
  709. 31:48episode as I was reading that I started
  710. 31:52I really felt how attentive you are to
  711. 31:55Rhythm and pacing and language and the
  712. 31:57different Hues of a paragraph and I'm
  713. 32:01curious how you think about sentences
  714. 32:04and in order to create that effect in
  715. 32:06the reader yeah so so when you think
  716. 32:09about a good book a good
  717. 32:11novel um there are a lot of dogs pulling
  718. 32:15the sled you know there there are a lot
  719. 32:17of horses in harness and and some are
  720. 32:20you some of the concerns of of crafting
  721. 32:22a novel are what I would call lowlevel
  722. 32:25very very granular
  723. 32:28um addiction register syntax uh and then
  724. 32:33you know you work up to the kinds of
  725. 32:35things that you're talking about
  726. 32:36sentence level pace and Cadence and then
  727. 32:39the scene grows out of that and how long
  728. 32:41is should should the scene be and what
  729. 32:43is the flow in the shape of the scene
  730. 32:45what's the tempo of the scene and those
  731. 32:47emerge out of the the layers underneath
  732. 32:52so so you have language as one way of
  733. 32:54you know as one of the the dogs in the
  734. 32:56in in the the the pulling sled and you
  735. 32:59have uh drama and you have character and
  736. 33:03you have form and you have structure and
  737. 33:06and different readers attach themselves
  738. 33:09more happily or more easily to different
  739. 33:10elements of fiction right you know like
  740. 33:13you know people can come right out and
  741. 33:15say I'm a I'm a character guy you know I
  742. 33:18just want to see if these people feel
  743. 33:20robust and vital and threedimensional
  744. 33:22you know
  745. 33:24and the the story yeah I'll read for lot
  746. 33:28but it's
  747. 33:29basically do I know this person you know
  748. 33:31can I recognize myself in this person um
  749. 33:34and there there were other people and
  750. 33:36for a long time I was in this category I
  751. 33:39I didn't care about characterization I
  752. 33:41didn't care about plot I didn't care I
  753. 33:43just wanted beautiful language that's
  754. 33:46how I am isn't that funny you know
  755. 33:49because because identification with
  756. 33:51character is the dominant way of
  757. 33:52consuming a novel now in this culture at
  758. 33:54this
  759. 33:56moment people can look at us and and
  760. 33:58cite that fact as if it's a little
  761. 34:01freakish or a little offbeat I like that
  762. 34:03and descriptiveness yeah because setting
  763. 34:06a scene you know uh even before there
  764. 34:09are human agents or non-human agents in
  765. 34:11that scene for me can be you know some
  766. 34:16of the most glorious kinds of fictional
  767. 34:17experiences you can have whereas if you
  768. 34:19go to an MFA program you're likely to
  769. 34:22hear people say things like show don't
  770. 34:24tell which means don't spend a lot of
  771. 34:27time setting the scene just get people
  772. 34:28in there doing things right yeah so
  773. 34:31something is lost when you privilege one
  774. 34:33aspect of a fictional experience overall
  775. 34:35the others I think the the the the ideal
  776. 34:39strategy is getting all those elements
  777. 34:42pulling in the same direction and
  778. 34:45feeding on one another so the question
  779. 34:48is we talked about how drama grows out
  780. 34:52of character well character grows out of
  781. 34:55voice to to a large extent we come to
  782. 34:59know the people on the
  783. 35:01Page by how they're explaining
  784. 35:03themselves sure and how they're
  785. 35:05performing themselves for other people
  786. 35:07and what they're asking from other
  787. 35:09people
  788. 35:10so the moment you hear somebody you
  789. 35:14start to hear somebody you can also
  790. 35:15start to see that person Forest Gump
  791. 35:17from a movie is a great example yeah of
  792. 35:21just the way he speaks and the
  793. 35:24Simplicity of his of his language is a
  794. 35:26place where voice
  795. 35:28really then leads to character yeah so
  796. 35:31if
  797. 35:32if character drives
  798. 35:35drama and voice drives character what
  799. 35:38drives voice H and the answer is you're
  800. 35:41starting to get down to the nuts and
  801. 35:43bolts of your tool chest which is the
  802. 35:46the words the individual words and the
  803. 35:49way they they are aligned in a sentence
  804. 35:54huh right so I'll do the first one first
  805. 35:58although typically I would I would try
  806. 36:00you know with with the my students I I
  807. 36:02did it different ways in different years
  808. 36:03but I would show the inseparability of
  809. 36:06these things I'd show the the questions
  810. 36:07of register and diction are also the
  811. 36:10questions of syntax and and Cadence and
  812. 36:12pacing but the easy ones the lowest
  813. 36:17level is what is the register of that
  814. 36:21word and you know what does that word
  815. 36:24mean and to answer those questions is
  816. 36:27far from trivial when you say the
  817. 36:29register of a word what do you mean by
  818. 36:31that so linguists will talk about the
  819. 36:35levels of speech that people
  820. 36:38use and sometimes you'll see
  821. 36:41three uh casual in the middle formal
  822. 36:46above it and you know down and dirty you
  823. 36:49know uh slangy at the bot sure yeah and
  824. 36:55uh sometimes you'll see four you know
  825. 36:56you'll see different approaches to
  826. 36:58answering this question of you know how
  827. 37:00register works but when you think of the
  828. 37:03various ways that you can say uh hand me
  829. 37:06that right give me that yeah hey will
  830. 37:09you please pass that yeah completely
  831. 37:11different yeah and there there are a
  832. 37:13dozen more I mean there's no end
  833. 37:15actually to the ways that you can say
  834. 37:16that yeah I mean you can literally just
  835. 37:18say yo and then point out it that's
  836. 37:21that's great and you are you are
  837. 37:23performing a submit you're you're
  838. 37:26requesting something specific that can
  839. 37:27be identified but you're also sending
  840. 37:30signals Beyond signals about who you are
  841. 37:33about who you think the other person is
  842. 37:36about the kinds of values that you want
  843. 37:38to manifest to the other person about
  844. 37:40the kinds of values that you want to
  845. 37:41encourage or suppress in the other
  846. 37:43person all of those come out of voice
  847. 37:46and and voice again is what words what
  848. 37:50what how formal or informal are you uh
  849. 37:53are you going for in terms of your word
  850. 37:56choice it would often be eye openening
  851. 37:58to my students when I would come into
  852. 38:00class and I'd say you know you're
  853. 38:02because you're speakers of
  854. 38:04English you have a kind of
  855. 38:07builtin
  856. 38:09bilingualism they say what do you mean
  857. 38:11by that they
  858. 38:13say for historical
  859. 38:17reasons you have the
  860. 38:20possibility of drawing on two completely
  861. 38:24different
  862. 38:25histories and Origins of words in order
  863. 38:29to create registral and color effects
  864. 38:31are you talking about Latin and
  865. 38:32Anglo-Saxon yeah absolutely
  866. 38:35so if if if you say I live in a mansion
  867. 38:40right or if you say I live in a house
  868. 38:43why does one sound more expensive than
  869. 38:45the other right I mean back all the way
  870. 38:48at the beginning they were the same
  871. 38:49thing Mao and you know our English house
  872. 38:52were the same things but you know be
  873. 38:55because the Normans came came over to
  874. 38:58England and conquered the local English
  875. 39:01people and set themselves up in
  876. 39:04court the the the latinate through
  877. 39:07French uh words got a higher
  878. 39:10socioeconomic
  879. 39:12register right and and so immediately
  880. 39:16the words you use talk about your class
  881. 39:19yeah
  882. 39:21and when my students would make this
  883. 39:24realization it was like wow I've got
  884. 39:26some power that I didn't have before I
  885. 39:28maybe I could hear it in my ear when
  886. 39:31somebody's being snoody or somebody's
  887. 39:33trying to establish their street cred
  888. 39:36but now that I know the actual rules for
  889. 39:40making that work my ear becomes better
  890. 39:44right and uh the difference between
  891. 39:49freedom and
  892. 39:51liberty becomes more audible right right
  893. 39:56um so that's the word level
  894. 39:59considerations for voice the other
  895. 40:01consideration is the sentence level so
  896. 40:07and I I would try to teach this it's a
  897. 40:09very complicated question because
  898. 40:11English grammar is not trivial and but
  899. 40:14it's immensely flexible and you can
  900. 40:16create all kinds of different pallet
  901. 40:18effects and color effects uh by uh by
  902. 40:23using the flexible syntax and grammar of
  903. 40:26English
  904. 40:28but I I would say how can I how can I
  905. 40:30teach to my students where they don't
  906. 40:33have to go back to this subject that
  907. 40:34they hated when they were in sixth grade
  908. 40:37but they could get the meat and potatoes
  909. 40:39of it and and I was thinking can I do
  910. 40:4280% of the work with 80% of the effect
  911. 40:45with 20% of the grammar you know sure
  912. 40:47and so I boiled it down to
  913. 40:50saying think about sentences as
  914. 40:53belonging basically to one of three
  915. 40:55classes
  916. 40:57so the the heart and soul of sentence
  917. 40:59call it a predication is the it's the
  918. 41:01main subject and the main verb every
  919. 41:04sentence has these now you might have an
  920. 41:08implied main subject and maybe an
  921. 41:11imperative verb where you know give me
  922. 41:14that would be an example right give the
  923. 41:17the predication is you give me that so
  924. 41:20the subject drops away and you just have
  925. 41:22the the
  926. 41:23command uh but every sentence is built
  927. 41:27around that
  928. 41:29kernel if you can find on the page or in
  929. 41:32your ear that
  930. 41:34kernel then you can build the sentence
  931. 41:37in the way that allows the sentence to
  932. 41:41recreate
  933. 41:44emotionally
  934. 41:45pratically the mental state that the
  935. 41:48speaker is in or that the narrator wants
  936. 41:51you to be in in that that the sentence
  937. 41:54starts to
  938. 41:55participate in the AFF of the thing that
  939. 41:58it's describing right so if I start with
  940. 42:02my
  941. 42:03predication and I put in a lot of other
  942. 42:06modifiers that creates a certain kind of
  943. 42:09syntax M he pointed the gun at his
  944. 42:13friend right there's a there's a kind of
  945. 42:16front-loaded shock to that right y you
  946. 42:19know or the gun
  947. 42:22exploded and uh a whiff of smoke uh
  948. 42:27exited the barrel you know these are
  949. 42:29clauses that have the action up front
  950. 42:33you know the the main subject main verb
  951. 42:35get delivered like that and then we see
  952. 42:36the consequences of those things now
  953. 42:38that's a very different thing than
  954. 42:40delaying the
  955. 42:42predication after a lot of modifiers so
  956. 42:44if you if if you want to put the reader
  957. 42:46into entirely opposite mental state you
  958. 42:50could
  959. 42:51say way back uh across the yard uh near
  960. 42:57the fence where a tiny Brook ran along a
  961. 43:02a an old hedge
  962. 43:05R she hid right M and of course by
  963. 43:10having these modifiers first the reader
  964. 43:12is in this suspenseful State yeah I was
  965. 43:14like what are you going to say what are
  966. 43:15you going to say what are you going to
  967. 43:15say and the she doesn't appear until the
  968. 43:19very end so she is hidden from the
  969. 43:21reader in the sentence oh wow I did not
  970. 43:24catch that right yeah in the same way
  971. 43:26that she's she's hidden in the physical
  972. 43:28space I did not catch that you have to
  973. 43:31wait for it wait for oh there she is
  974. 43:33right now the Third Way would be to
  975. 43:35split that predication down the middle
  976. 43:37and basically start with your subject
  977. 43:39and put a bunch of stuff in the middle
  978. 43:41and then a verb you
  979. 43:44know and and you can do this for all
  980. 43:46kinds of reasons too you can create
  981. 43:47suspense with that you can create comedy
  982. 43:50with it right uh it's probably the
  983. 43:53rarest form if you count the sentences
  984. 43:56in an average number
  985. 43:57most of them are going to be in the
  986. 43:58first uh species you know where the
  987. 44:01where the subject and verb are pretty
  988. 44:04upfront um a smaller number are going to
  989. 44:06be this delayed predication and maybe
  990. 44:08the smallest I I don't know I'd like to
  991. 44:10do that experiment sometime and actually
  992. 44:12get the data but my my intuition is that
  993. 44:15splitting the predication is the rarest
  994. 44:17but it has a very powerful and you know
  995. 44:20not only it the effect in itself can
  996. 44:23create these different forms of delay or
  997. 44:25suspense or or Intrigue but using it
  998. 44:29inside a paragraph when you've just had
  999. 44:32three
  1000. 44:33sentences of you know a a trailing
  1001. 44:36sentence in a row suddenly stopping and
  1002. 44:39changing that changing it up it's like a
  1003. 44:41a key change in music or going to
  1004. 44:43different cord right tell me about
  1005. 44:45writing descriptively because it's the
  1006. 44:49kind of thing that people try to do and
  1007. 44:51then all of a sudden they sound like
  1008. 44:53they're trying too hard and I want to
  1009. 44:54read this sentence cuz I think it's a
  1010. 44:56good examp example of how you write
  1011. 44:59descriptively and I want to hear how you
  1012. 45:01think about doing this you write each
  1013. 45:04child's tree has its own Excellence the
  1014. 45:07ash diamond shaped bark the walnuts long
  1015. 45:11compound leaves the maples shower of
  1016. 45:14helicopters the vasik spread of elm the
  1017. 45:17ironwoods fluted muscle what's cool
  1018. 45:20about that is I can see it I can see it
  1019. 45:21I can see it I can see it you're
  1020. 45:24almost cutting between different scenes
  1021. 45:27but I find that whenever I try to do
  1022. 45:29that the writing just sounds overdone
  1023. 45:31it's like David why are you trying so
  1024. 45:33hard well it's okay it's okay to try
  1025. 45:36hard because you always have an edit
  1026. 45:38where you can make it look more
  1027. 45:41effortless and you know to to push
  1028. 45:44yourself in composition and say let me
  1029. 45:48make a note to myself about the kinds of
  1030. 45:50effects that
  1031. 45:51I'm going
  1032. 45:53after maybe they're too obvious maybe
  1033. 45:56you know maybe they're too blocked out
  1034. 45:58but at least you know now what effects
  1035. 46:01it is that you after so think about that
  1036. 46:03first draft as a note to yourself about
  1037. 46:06you know about the psychic state that
  1038. 46:08you want your senten your descriptions
  1039. 46:10to participate in now when you go back
  1040. 46:12you can hide your footwork and you can
  1041. 46:14you can make it more elegant you can
  1042. 46:16take out the ones the notes that are a
  1043. 46:18bit too loud or that that announce too
  1044. 46:20clearly what your intentions are but in
  1045. 46:23that passage you know one of the tricks
  1046. 46:25is that the idea in that passage is to
  1047. 46:29make each species of tree Vivid and
  1048. 46:31distinct to give them characteristics
  1049. 46:34that are different from all the other
  1050. 46:36trees but to do it I'm I'm I'm
  1051. 46:40introducing it's almost like going back
  1052. 46:42to to to Patricia westerford and saying
  1053. 46:45there's subtle little elements of
  1054. 46:47anthropomorphism in that sentence or or
  1055. 46:49pantheism or animism in those
  1056. 46:51description the ironwood's fluted muscle
  1057. 46:54yeah and and now now it's like that that
  1058. 46:58trunk that's so visually distinct in
  1059. 47:00that in that tree now becomes like a
  1060. 47:03like a weightlifter you see it flexing
  1061. 47:05and you can see the Senus um so it's a
  1062. 47:08it's a subtle invitation to elicit the
  1063. 47:12animism in the reader oh yeah I've
  1064. 47:15looked at a tree and I've
  1065. 47:17thought that tree is evil or that tree
  1066. 47:21is uh shy or that you know all these
  1067. 47:24projected emotions Majestic right yeah
  1068. 47:27yeah but read the first sentence again
  1069. 47:29cuz you'll see a little registral trick
  1070. 47:31there too okay tell me when to stop each
  1071. 47:34child's tree has its own Excellence
  1072. 47:38stop were you expecting that word as the
  1073. 47:41final word of that Clause no it's it's
  1074. 47:45it's like a a great song where you you
  1075. 47:51hear the phrase and you think you know
  1076. 47:52the way the chords are going and then
  1077. 47:54all of a
  1078. 47:55sudden at the the end of that phrase you
  1079. 47:58hear sudden an interesting change of
  1080. 48:00color or change of instrumentation or
  1081. 48:03change of pitch the the last thing you
  1082. 48:05would think to apply to a tree would be
  1083. 48:08some degree of
  1084. 48:10excellent now I always think you
  1085. 48:14know the the beginning of a sentence and
  1086. 48:16the end of a sentence are very powerful
  1087. 48:19places to set a reader's expectation and
  1088. 48:23then to surprise the reader's
  1089. 48:24expectation that each child's tree has
  1090. 48:27its own degree of
  1091. 48:30Excellence right and the reader
  1092. 48:33unconscious they just reading along for
  1093. 48:35the music of it and and the color of it
  1094. 48:37and the the images being
  1095. 48:39created but the
  1096. 48:42composer is
  1097. 48:45saying that word raises the tension a
  1098. 48:48little bit at the end of that sentence
  1099. 48:52and it's not the one that the as we read
  1100. 48:55along we're constant saying what's
  1101. 48:57coming next what's coming next we're you
  1102. 48:59know we're we're like an AI what's the
  1103. 49:03next most likely word we're like a large
  1104. 49:05language model we have a model of the
  1105. 49:07world and as I add each new word to this
  1106. 49:12sentence you are deciding which way I'm
  1107. 49:16going to go spin
  1108. 49:20right exactly you got it you can play
  1109. 49:23off that expectation you can you can set
  1110. 49:25it in motion and then say NOP this way
  1111. 49:28that way so how is it different say when
  1112. 49:30you're describing a person so that one
  1113. 49:32was about trees but then you right the
  1114. 49:36farm was where Nick first started
  1115. 49:37sketching the pencil dreams of boys
  1116. 49:40Rockets outlandish cars masted armies
  1117. 49:43imaginary cities more Baroque with
  1118. 49:45detail each year then Wilder textures
  1119. 49:49directly observed The Forest of hairs on
  1120. 49:51a caterpillar's back and the stormy
  1121. 49:53weather maps in the grain of floorboards
  1122. 49:56yeah and you know it's interesting to
  1123. 49:59read
  1124. 50:00something that I wrote
  1125. 50:03now seven or 8 years ago I'm I'm in a
  1126. 50:06different place the world is in a
  1127. 50:08different place uh that book exists and
  1128. 50:11you know it's trajectory I could never
  1129. 50:14have foreseen when I was working on it
  1130. 50:16and I'm listening to those phrases on
  1131. 50:18the one hand the way a brand new readers
  1132. 50:20is listening to him because enough time
  1133. 50:22has passed for me to forget what that
  1134. 50:25passage how that passage worked
  1135. 50:27so I hear that pencil the pencil dreams
  1136. 50:29of
  1137. 50:30boys and I don't know it's an odd
  1138. 50:33metaphor for a second and then you get
  1139. 50:35the catalog of things that boys might
  1140. 50:36sketch and oh the pencil dreams of boys
  1141. 50:39well what's so cool about this is I put
  1142. 50:42it put me back to being a kid I used to
  1143. 50:45design airports in my room when I was a
  1144. 50:47kid so this is about rockets and
  1145. 50:49outlandish cars it has nothing to with
  1146. 50:50airplanes but something about the
  1147. 50:52similarity put me back to being an
  1148. 50:548-year-old kid kind of messing around
  1149. 50:56and sketching around and designing
  1150. 50:59baseball this and football that and that
  1151. 51:03is now that I'm rereading it so much of
  1152. 51:05what makes this resonate with me yeah
  1153. 51:07now you can look at the the individual
  1154. 51:09words in the syntax and say what is he
  1155. 51:11doing to put me in that mental state
  1156. 51:13beyond the simple uh literal conveyance
  1157. 51:17of the sentence I have to say in all
  1158. 51:20honesty and this might be lesson number
  1159. 51:23one of
  1160. 51:24craft I'm also listening and saying
  1161. 51:26saying no I would do that differently
  1162. 51:28Now give me a red pen you know because
  1163. 51:31that's writing you are never done with
  1164. 51:34it because you're a moving Target your
  1165. 51:37reader is a moving Target the world is a
  1166. 51:39moving Target you look at that sentence
  1167. 51:41and you
  1168. 51:42say give me another shot at that so you
  1169. 51:47know when you say you look at your first
  1170. 51:49draft and it's frustrating for you I say
  1171. 51:51that's not a bug that's a feature let
  1172. 51:54that frustration be another form of
  1173. 51:56seeing your desire so how many times you
  1174. 51:58rewrite those sentences oh
  1175. 52:01gosh now see now with with word
  1176. 52:03processing it's hard to say 12 right or
  1177. 52:0714 it's just continuous it just keeps
  1178. 52:09happening never ends you know you wake
  1179. 52:12up the next day and you're reworking the
  1180. 52:14previous day's material and then you get
  1181. 52:16to the end of the weekend you've got a
  1182. 52:18chapter and you read the and you rework
  1183. 52:19the chapter again and then the whole
  1184. 52:22book is finished and now you say it's
  1185. 52:23time to go do a second draft well that
  1186. 52:25second draft is actually now you know
  1187. 52:28depending on the various passages could
  1188. 52:30might have been drafted a dozen times or
  1189. 52:32more you know and and then you send it
  1190. 52:35off to your first readers and they say
  1191. 52:39it got a little it got a little slow for
  1192. 52:41me from 140 to 200 you know and now you
  1193. 52:45say well how do I pick the pace up and
  1194. 52:46you go back and you draft it again and
  1195. 52:48but the what all I'm saying is accept
  1196. 52:52that as part of the glory and of of of
  1197. 52:56the process of writing don't fight it as
  1198. 52:59something you you know you wish you
  1199. 53:00could finally make it right because
  1200. 53:03there's no final right you know I I take
  1201. 53:07this book that was published yesterday I
  1202. 53:09go behind the podium tonight I start
  1203. 53:11reading from it I want to change
  1204. 53:15it
  1205. 53:17wow when you get
  1206. 53:19frustrated when you're writing and
  1207. 53:21you're agitated
  1208. 53:23or tense because you're not getting
  1209. 53:26something right what is the nature of
  1210. 53:28the things that aren't quite right for
  1211. 53:30you oh they could be anything it could
  1212. 53:33be deafness you know or deafness yeah
  1213. 53:36like like I I I don't know what this
  1214. 53:39person's trying to say or how they
  1215. 53:41should be trying to say it it could be
  1216. 53:44it could be uh a dramatic problem oh my
  1217. 53:46God I just realized that I've been you
  1218. 53:49know I've been counting on these two
  1219. 53:52characters to be uh disagreeing about
  1220. 53:56this matter but now that I see them both
  1221. 53:58in context I'm not sure they would be so
  1222. 54:02you could you you you you're constantly
  1223. 54:06having to to course correct you're
  1224. 54:09constantly having to to discover the
  1225. 54:11things that you're unconscious knew
  1226. 54:13sometimes you can't Discover it um so
  1227. 54:16the ways of going wrong are infinite uh
  1228. 54:19and the the the ways of going right are
  1229. 54:22not final so ride it you know it's it's
  1230. 54:26so definitely like
  1231. 54:28surfing for me the the the craft tip
  1232. 54:33here is relax forgive
  1233. 54:36yourself you know know because it always
  1234. 54:40comes around to something more
  1235. 54:43satisfying that all you need to do is
  1236. 54:46let it breathe a little bit go out take
  1237. 54:48a hike you know uh stand in front of a
  1238. 54:52tree you know breathe the breathe the
  1239. 54:54air you know drink the drink um relax
  1240. 54:58the perfectionism that says I need to
  1241. 55:01get this in a Perfect final State let it
  1242. 55:05let it be
  1243. 55:06process I want to talk about
  1244. 55:09introductions just how you think about
  1245. 55:11where these books begin for over story
  1246. 55:13you write first there was nothing then
  1247. 55:17there was everything for playground
  1248. 55:20before the Earth before the moon before
  1249. 55:22the Stars before the sun before the sky
  1250. 55:24even before the sea
  1251. 55:27there was only time and taroa why do you
  1252. 55:30choose those how do you think about that
  1253. 55:33you're revealing something that I
  1254. 55:36probably had never consciously
  1255. 55:39articulated about what I like in
  1256. 55:42Beginnings um but I see it clearly in
  1257. 55:45both of these I want to situate my
  1258. 55:49stories in a mythological framework yes
  1259. 55:53you know but I also you know I'm
  1260. 55:55imitating a certain kind of
  1261. 55:56cinematography too like
  1262. 56:01uh great films that start with a really
  1263. 56:05distant wide establishing shot yep know
  1264. 56:09and then you know go to a mid shot and
  1265. 56:12then go to close that in my ear I want
  1266. 56:15to say here is the the size of the
  1267. 56:20canvas now we're going to explore this
  1268. 56:23but don't forget that the canvas is all
  1269. 56:25the way out here so if if that opening
  1270. 56:29can be kind of
  1271. 56:32cosmic then you earn the right to tell a
  1272. 56:35local story and let it let it germinate
  1273. 56:38and and grow
  1274. 56:39into into the the the larger frame that
  1275. 56:42you've set for the story but I'll tell
  1276. 56:45you I I I love opening
  1277. 56:49lines I I love looking at the books that
  1278. 56:51I love and seeing how sometimes the
  1279. 56:54entire book is contained in the
  1280. 56:56microcosm of the first sentence or
  1281. 56:58paragraph all the conflicts all the
  1282. 57:00dramas all the characterization you know
  1283. 57:03are hinted at in a way that the reader
  1284. 57:05can't possibly uh see or anticipate I
  1285. 57:09mean Romeo and Juliet two houses both
  1286. 57:11alike in dignity in fair Verona where we
  1287. 57:14lay our scene you get I mean just right
  1288. 57:16at the beginning of that yeah two people
  1289. 57:19they're very similar but uhoh stuff's
  1290. 57:22about to happen right it was the best of
  1291. 57:24times it was the worst of
  1292. 57:26all these lines that have become so
  1293. 57:28classic because after the fact
  1294. 57:32retrospectively we realize that's the
  1295. 57:34story in a nutshell but you know I
  1296. 57:37search and search and search and I throw
  1297. 57:38them out I start again I start somewhere
  1298. 57:40else and it's all good you know it's all
  1299. 57:43it's all discovery the the over story
  1300. 57:46line first there was nothing then there
  1301. 57:50was
  1302. 57:51everything I mean if if you're not
  1303. 57:53sympathetic you could say
  1304. 57:56it's that's kind of philosophical mumble
  1305. 58:00jumble and you know so the Gospel of
  1306. 58:02John Works a little bit like that it
  1307. 58:04could be a little bit of a mystification
  1308. 58:06you know what in the beginning was the
  1309. 58:08word and the Word was with God and the
  1310. 58:09Word was God yeah and in these sort of
  1311. 58:12you know linguistic play with the the
  1312. 58:16the metaphysics of what's being
  1313. 58:17expressed well that line actually
  1314. 58:20comes from one of the last sentences
  1315. 58:27that a dear friend of mine and a
  1316. 58:28brilliant American poet sat on her
  1317. 58:31deathbed and as she was drifting in and
  1318. 58:34out of
  1319. 58:36Consciousness and you know her loved
  1320. 58:38ones were standing by and she would talk
  1321. 58:40and they would lean in and what is she
  1322. 58:42saying you know she said something she
  1323. 58:45they couldn't hear her and they leaned
  1324. 58:47in she said first there was
  1325. 58:52nothing then there was everything you
  1326. 58:55know and I thought you know what a
  1327. 58:57better way to memorialize the life and
  1328. 58:59work of this friendman to to take that
  1329. 59:02and promote it to the start of this
  1330. 59:04book if I remember correctly you you
  1331. 59:08wanted to be a poet or you were very
  1332. 59:10interested in poet want be a poet you
  1333. 59:12still want to be a poet when I grow up
  1334. 59:14yeah I may end up that way I don't know
  1335. 59:17yeah but
  1336. 59:20that's that's the place where those of
  1337. 59:23us who love language first
  1338. 59:27can focus on that as the primary Pursuit
  1339. 59:30and there's also drama in poetry there's
  1340. 59:32voice and there's characterization
  1341. 59:33there's structure for sure and form we
  1342. 59:35didn't even get to how uh drama
  1343. 59:38generates form and structure but in
  1344. 59:40poetry you
  1345. 59:41see most of your job is to create
  1346. 59:47visceral sensation through the
  1347. 59:50musicality of of your
  1348. 59:52words I mean there's there are a lot of
  1349. 59:54other jobs that poets do and of course
  1350. 59:56of course poetry itself is a moving
  1351. 59:58Target and historically has been
  1352. 59:59interested in different things at
  1353. 1:00:00different times and you know what what
  1354. 1:00:03what's considered the central
  1355. 1:00:04preoccupation of poetry has changed so
  1356. 1:00:06much even in the course of my
  1357. 1:00:08lifetime but how does how does drama
  1358. 1:00:11create form yeah so we we've seen these
  1359. 1:00:15three kinds of
  1360. 1:00:16collisions and in any Collision what
  1361. 1:00:19you're talking about the the primary
  1362. 1:00:21variable is
  1363. 1:00:23tension in a collision you go from a low
  1364. 1:00:26tension state to a high tension state
  1365. 1:00:29right and and
  1366. 1:00:31then you can relax that tension as the
  1367. 1:00:34drama is resolved and then it starts up
  1368. 1:00:36again somewhere else and tension goes so
  1369. 1:00:38you are dialing in and out of something
  1370. 1:00:41that most of us can can read intuitively
  1371. 1:00:45as the stakes right and uh what we call
  1372. 1:00:49tension is the realization on the part
  1373. 1:00:51of the protagonists that the stakes are
  1374. 1:00:54going up
  1375. 1:00:56now when you think of
  1376. 1:00:58form as trying to address the potentials
  1377. 1:01:03and the problems of tension now you're
  1378. 1:01:06thinking what does a a writer want to do
  1379. 1:01:09from page one to page
  1380. 1:01:11400 to manipulate the tension in the
  1381. 1:01:15reader and of course it's going up and
  1382. 1:01:18down all the time depending on the drama
  1383. 1:01:20of individual
  1384. 1:01:22scenes but we have the the ability to
  1385. 1:01:25tell stories you know this weird
  1386. 1:01:28adaptation that the human brain has for
  1387. 1:01:31imagining creating imaginary spaces and
  1388. 1:01:34saying you know what if know what if
  1389. 1:01:37this guy said this to this guy right um
  1390. 1:01:41we know that when we tell even the
  1391. 1:01:43simplest stories there's a kind of
  1392. 1:01:47structure that makes sense with regard
  1393. 1:01:48to tension and there's a kind of
  1394. 1:01:50structure that doesn't make sense if I
  1395. 1:01:54said once upon time there was a prince
  1396. 1:01:59and the prince rode out on his his Steed
  1397. 1:02:03and he killed the most challenging
  1398. 1:02:06dragon in the
  1399. 1:02:09country and then the next year the
  1400. 1:02:12prince rode out on his horse and he
  1401. 1:02:15killed a dragon that was somewhat
  1402. 1:02:18challenging right that wouldn't make any
  1403. 1:02:20sense you know and the you know the the
  1404. 1:02:23the finale being and then he killed the
  1405. 1:02:25easiest dragon in the country it would
  1406. 1:02:27never sense at all so we have an
  1407. 1:02:30intrinsic which would actually it would
  1408. 1:02:33Merit some investigation as to why that
  1409. 1:02:37makes absolute sense to us to stack
  1410. 1:02:40tension as a rising thing you know to
  1411. 1:02:44think about that as a as a physiological
  1412. 1:02:47thing as a as part of uh this you know
  1413. 1:02:51um adaptive power that we have to
  1414. 1:02:54Intrigue other people with story
  1415. 1:02:56but a simple rising action isn't really
  1416. 1:03:02the most satisfying kind of story anyway
  1417. 1:03:05especially for long form right so you
  1418. 1:03:09know you you have to
  1419. 1:03:11sculpt that tension
  1420. 1:03:14graph in a way that does Justice to your
  1421. 1:03:17characters does Justice to your readers
  1422. 1:03:19expectations and keeps your readers
  1423. 1:03:22intrigued because you know there there's
  1424. 1:03:25a certain kind of tension in just
  1425. 1:03:27wanting to know what happens next
  1426. 1:03:30there's a certain kind of tension in
  1427. 1:03:32knowing that there are Mysteries early
  1428. 1:03:33on in a story that you can't explain and
  1429. 1:03:36so there's that reverse anticipation of
  1430. 1:03:40of knowing that eventually you're going
  1431. 1:03:43to get an explanation that of something
  1432. 1:03:45that right now is completely mysterious
  1433. 1:03:47to you right so I would teach the
  1434. 1:03:49tension graph as having four
  1435. 1:03:53parts uh a hook
  1436. 1:03:56where at the beginning tension is just a
  1437. 1:03:58little bit higher artificially higher
  1438. 1:04:01right in order to say here's what's here
  1439. 1:04:05this is going to draw you into this
  1440. 1:04:07world there's some Stakes early on that
  1441. 1:04:09you're going to immediately be
  1442. 1:04:10viscerally interested in y and once you
  1443. 1:04:13get the reader hooked with with that
  1444. 1:04:16higher level of of tension you can relax
  1445. 1:04:20the tension a little bit as you move
  1446. 1:04:21into what's what I would call the
  1447. 1:04:23exposition who's who who are they uh
  1448. 1:04:27where you know what what is the the the
  1449. 1:04:31crisis what is the the stakes you know
  1450. 1:04:33where where are these people coming from
  1451. 1:04:35getting everybody on
  1452. 1:04:37stage you you've earned the ability to
  1453. 1:04:41relax the tension and getting it get
  1454. 1:04:42everybody on stage because you've had
  1455. 1:04:44that little bit of a of a bait and
  1456. 1:04:48switch once the reader is oriented in
  1457. 1:04:52this world once a certain amount of
  1458. 1:04:54things have been exposed
  1459. 1:04:56shown to be then you can start to
  1460. 1:04:59explore the instabilities of those
  1461. 1:05:01people in that situation now we go back
  1462. 1:05:04to drama and and every every value
  1463. 1:05:08creates an unstable counter value and
  1464. 1:05:11every contact with another human being
  1465. 1:05:14creates an instability in what those
  1466. 1:05:16people want and
  1467. 1:05:18need now you go through the great middle
  1468. 1:05:21part of the book which is the rising
  1469. 1:05:23action the stakes get higher
  1470. 1:05:26every time something gets solved it
  1471. 1:05:28produces a larger instability because
  1472. 1:05:31the
  1473. 1:05:32ramifications of solving that first
  1474. 1:05:34little episode are larger than the ep
  1475. 1:05:37the first episode itself so you go up
  1476. 1:05:39this letter and you you eventually reach
  1477. 1:05:43you can't you hit the wall you can't
  1478. 1:05:45raise the stakes any farther you've
  1479. 1:05:47reached the ultimate dramatic
  1480. 1:05:50conflict that's the climax of the book
  1481. 1:05:53now typically we don't save that for the
  1482. 1:05:57last page of the book we have
  1483. 1:05:59this followon that says okay now that
  1484. 1:06:03you've seen the final jumps that
  1485. 1:06:06everybody's made now that you've seen
  1486. 1:06:09what everybody has chosen as their core
  1487. 1:06:11in value and seeing the way that they
  1488. 1:06:13have to now live with the consequences
  1489. 1:06:15of their choices MH you release that
  1490. 1:06:18back into the world we use a French word
  1491. 1:06:20for this in in nitology the
  1492. 1:06:23dumal which we think of as the
  1493. 1:06:25Revelation or the you know the the the
  1494. 1:06:29consequences but it literally means the
  1495. 1:06:32untying so you've been wrenching the
  1496. 1:06:34knot Tighter and Tighter and Tighter you
  1497. 1:06:35get to the climax it blows apart and now
  1498. 1:06:38what happens in the world suggests
  1499. 1:06:40anyway the trajectory of these people
  1500. 1:06:43who have gone through fire and now are
  1501. 1:06:46different than they were before in what
  1502. 1:06:48ways are they different and what ways
  1503. 1:06:49will the world that they live in be
  1504. 1:06:51different we need enough of that to know
  1505. 1:06:53what the final consequences of that
  1506. 1:06:55climax would be have you picked up any
  1507. 1:06:59similar tools for writing dialogue
  1508. 1:07:01because dialogue is a representation of
  1509. 1:07:04how people actually speak but it isn't
  1510. 1:07:06it's far more efficient dare I say than
  1511. 1:07:09actual human conversation it's highly
  1512. 1:07:11stylized I mean if you were to sit on
  1513. 1:07:13the the back of a bus here in the city
  1514. 1:07:15and and just transcribe the way that
  1515. 1:07:17people talk to each other and try to
  1516. 1:07:19pass that off on the page you could make
  1517. 1:07:21the claim this is the most realistic
  1518. 1:07:23dialogue you'll ever hear it'd be
  1519. 1:07:24terrible would be chaotic and incoherent
  1520. 1:07:29and you know uh that we depend on
  1521. 1:07:32certain
  1522. 1:07:33conventions and and by when we say real
  1523. 1:07:37or Vivid we're not actually talking
  1524. 1:07:41about empirically accurate we're talking
  1525. 1:07:45about the recognition of certain
  1526. 1:07:48narrative expectations that we've
  1527. 1:07:50learned from the kinds of fiction that
  1528. 1:07:53are viable in our culture right now
  1529. 1:07:56conventional dialogue realistic dialogue
  1530. 1:07:58is the dialogue that knows how to
  1531. 1:08:01manipulate the expect the conventional
  1532. 1:08:03expectations that have been established
  1533. 1:08:05for dialogue at this moment and you
  1534. 1:08:08don't have to go back very
  1535. 1:08:11far to to to start leaving your comfort
  1536. 1:08:14zone in dialogue you know at if you're
  1537. 1:08:18if you're every day if you're cutting
  1538. 1:08:20your it and you're just living on
  1539. 1:08:22fiction that's been written in the last
  1540. 1:08:2410 years and you're shaping your ear on
  1541. 1:08:27those conventions and you go back 20
  1542. 1:08:29years or 40 years or 100 years you might
  1543. 1:08:33say people don't talk talk like that you
  1544. 1:08:37know but all you're saying is I've I've
  1545. 1:08:39lost my context my my my decoder ring
  1546. 1:08:43for you know for understanding how how
  1547. 1:08:46these dialogues work so when you're
  1548. 1:08:48writing what are you doing to make it
  1549. 1:08:52feel alive without it feeling
  1550. 1:08:56like you said empirically accurate to
  1551. 1:08:58how people speak I think you have to
  1552. 1:08:59hear it out loud because I think that's
  1553. 1:09:01the way that most readers are actually
  1554. 1:09:04going to consume the The Narrative when
  1555. 1:09:08when we read we
  1556. 1:09:09subvocalize you're hearing it
  1557. 1:09:13subvocally and that's why sometimes for
  1558. 1:09:16authors it's tough to listen to their
  1559. 1:09:19own audio
  1560. 1:09:20books because they've just spent a
  1561. 1:09:23couple of years subvocalizing all these
  1562. 1:09:27characters and now they have to hear
  1563. 1:09:29those these characters literalized by
  1564. 1:09:31some other voice actor and they're going
  1565. 1:09:33no no no that's not what I'm hearing in
  1566. 1:09:35my head you know um but to to create
  1567. 1:09:40dialogue that can elicit different kinds
  1568. 1:09:43of emotions from
  1569. 1:09:46people is always furthered I think by
  1570. 1:09:50actually saying it out loud and you know
  1571. 1:09:53it testing it in the in The Crucible of
  1572. 1:09:56your ear right so that when your readers
  1573. 1:10:01do the same thing you at least have a
  1574. 1:10:03little sense of the the register the the
  1575. 1:10:07tone the color the Cadence the the
  1576. 1:10:10realism the the
  1577. 1:10:12socioeconomic accuracy of that dialogue
  1578. 1:10:14I have no sense for this so who is
  1579. 1:10:17someone who you really admire with
  1580. 1:10:20dialogue and what is it that you admire
  1581. 1:10:23about the way that they write it that
  1582. 1:10:26you're trying to chase or cultivate
  1583. 1:10:28yourself there's they're practitioners
  1584. 1:10:30that are amazingly
  1585. 1:10:32varied like you can get a writer like
  1586. 1:10:35Anne patchet who whose characters you
  1587. 1:10:40even forget that their characters you
  1588. 1:10:43know because because she somehow can
  1589. 1:10:46participate in the way that they
  1590. 1:10:48speak
  1591. 1:10:49so uh vividly and so
  1592. 1:10:54virtuosic that the performance
  1593. 1:10:56disappears entirely and you just say oh
  1594. 1:10:59oh yeah that's that's my neighbor that's
  1595. 1:11:02that's you know that the the woman that
  1596. 1:11:04I lived with for 11 years or you know
  1597. 1:11:07you're doing all those things just
  1598. 1:11:08through her ability to to let them speak
  1599. 1:11:11themselves to each other but then you
  1600. 1:11:13can also get a writer who's
  1601. 1:11:15aesthetically completely different like
  1602. 1:11:17Don deil and you could look at a book
  1603. 1:11:20like white noise and you could look at
  1604. 1:11:22the dialogue in that book which is crazy
  1605. 1:11:25you know and and highly artificial in
  1606. 1:11:29one sense of the word
  1607. 1:11:31artifice and yet you can say this man
  1608. 1:11:34has the best ear of any living writer
  1609. 1:11:37because he somehow can get to the
  1610. 1:11:39absurdity of the way that we talk
  1611. 1:11:41through each other you know or uh
  1612. 1:11:45uh away from each other yeah you know
  1613. 1:11:49and it's it's not realism it's in some
  1614. 1:11:54ways it's kind of surreal what he does
  1615. 1:11:56with with dialogic but it's so
  1616. 1:12:00real in in terms of
  1617. 1:12:03recognizing the the the the crazy way
  1618. 1:12:06that we play this language game with one
  1619. 1:12:08another okay so what I want to do is I
  1620. 1:12:10want to pop between some different
  1621. 1:12:12quotes we'll we'll kind of do a fire
  1622. 1:12:13round quote parkour first one the best
  1623. 1:12:16arguments in the world won't change a
  1624. 1:12:18single person's mind the only thing that
  1625. 1:12:21can do that is a good story I mean in
  1626. 1:12:24order to move somebody you have to use
  1627. 1:12:26emotions right um and we we we talked a
  1628. 1:12:33great deal about those two different
  1629. 1:12:35appeals uh the the appeal to logic and
  1630. 1:12:37reason and rationality and the appeal to
  1631. 1:12:39the
  1632. 1:12:40guts
  1633. 1:12:42yeah if you would learn the secrets of
  1634. 1:12:45nature you must practice more
  1635. 1:12:49Humanity the secrets of nature are where
  1636. 1:12:51the secrets of humanity arise
  1637. 1:12:57we can see one another we can understand
  1638. 1:13:01ourselves as
  1639. 1:13:03individuals through the difference that
  1640. 1:13:05we have looking at another person but to
  1641. 1:13:08understand what a human being is we have
  1642. 1:13:12to look at the more than
  1643. 1:13:14human the loneliness of writing is that
  1644. 1:13:17you baffle your friends and change the
  1645. 1:13:20lives of
  1646. 1:13:21strangers I I find this true to the
  1647. 1:13:24present day
  1648. 1:13:26you know I C I can give the
  1649. 1:13:30manuscript to my
  1650. 1:13:32brother and he can return it a couple of
  1651. 1:13:35weeks later and
  1652. 1:13:36say
  1653. 1:13:39interesting and and and yet I can turn
  1654. 1:13:42my phone on this morning and get an
  1655. 1:13:45email saying you don't know
  1656. 1:13:48me but I'm studying forestry now because
  1657. 1:13:52of
  1658. 1:13:53you you know what sense is does that me
  1659. 1:13:55that's just crazy yeah when you're sure
  1660. 1:13:59of what you're looking at look harder
  1661. 1:14:02yeah yeah because when you're sure
  1662. 1:14:06you're not
  1663. 1:14:07moving and reality is always moving
  1664. 1:14:10right if if you've arrived at a
  1665. 1:14:14definitive irrefutable point of view
  1666. 1:14:16it's because your point of view is
  1667. 1:14:19stationary and that's not going to help
  1668. 1:14:21you survive in a world where all points
  1669. 1:14:23of view are constantly moving
  1670. 1:14:25interesting when I read that what I was
  1671. 1:14:27thinking about was I was just thinking
  1672. 1:14:29of the over story and I was thinking
  1673. 1:14:31of
  1674. 1:14:34the infinite number of things that
  1675. 1:14:36nature will reveal to you if you sit and
  1676. 1:14:40you stop and you look and look and look
  1677. 1:14:42yeah attention is the most profound
  1678. 1:14:45source of meaning that we can
  1679. 1:14:47have
  1680. 1:14:49and before I I wrote over
  1681. 1:14:53story I had a a path that I would walk
  1682. 1:14:56from my house to my office and it looked
  1683. 1:14:59something like this tree tree tree tree
  1684. 1:15:04and as I started to write a war
  1685. 1:15:07story that path started to look like
  1686. 1:15:10this red oak
  1687. 1:15:14Maple uh
  1688. 1:15:16hornbeam uh and then as I got deeper
  1689. 1:15:20into into over story it was oh
  1690. 1:15:25this
  1691. 1:15:26guy you know it's not a red oak it's
  1692. 1:15:30this guy and he's doing something that
  1693. 1:15:33I've not seen in the other Red Oaks in
  1694. 1:15:35the neighborhood right so the the
  1695. 1:15:38granularity the particularity the
  1696. 1:15:40pleasure of the world depends on slowing
  1697. 1:15:44down and looking harder
  1698. 1:15:46yeah we have the sense that structure is
  1699. 1:15:49inimical to emotion or that systems are
  1700. 1:15:53inimical to individuals you know that a
  1701. 1:15:55book can either be a heart book or a
  1702. 1:15:57head book and my desire of course is to
  1703. 1:16:00write something that's like us namely an
  1704. 1:16:02Allin one and I like this I this idea
  1705. 1:16:06that you're getting at which is that
  1706. 1:16:08there can be novels of thinking novels
  1707. 1:16:09of feeling novels of character novels of
  1708. 1:16:12ideas and this is one of the major
  1709. 1:16:16themes of this conversation is the
  1710. 1:16:18fusion of maybe even the right side and
  1711. 1:16:21the left side of the brain in the work
  1712. 1:16:22that you're trying to do
  1713. 1:16:25the sled is only going to move when all
  1714. 1:16:27the dogs are in harness and they're all
  1715. 1:16:28pulling in the same direction but that's
  1716. 1:16:31that's the craft of writing to find a
  1717. 1:16:33way in which all those different
  1718. 1:16:36approaches and it's far more than just
  1719. 1:16:38head and heart I mean there are 300
  1720. 1:16:41regions of the brain right
  1721. 1:16:44so what you want to do is get all all
  1722. 1:16:48the the elements in your
  1723. 1:16:51repertoire chosen in such a way that
  1724. 1:16:53they're supporting one another other
  1725. 1:16:55right that the levels are emerging from
  1726. 1:16:57the decisions that you've made at the
  1727. 1:16:59levels lower down and they're all in
  1728. 1:17:02harness and in
  1729. 1:17:04harmony I want to end by hearing about
  1730. 1:17:07some of the time that you've spent
  1731. 1:17:08writing in solitude you know when you
  1732. 1:17:11wrote plowing in the dark you said I
  1733. 1:17:13even wish that I could have gone into a
  1734. 1:17:15sensory deprivation tank and it seems
  1735. 1:17:19that Solitude has been a major asset and
  1736. 1:17:23strategy over your
  1737. 1:17:26career I agree with that but I I
  1738. 1:17:29think I have to expand the formulation
  1739. 1:17:33just a little bit moving in and out of
  1740. 1:17:37solitude has been the strategy huh right
  1741. 1:17:41my composition
  1742. 1:17:43process and certain amount of my
  1743. 1:17:47revision
  1744. 1:17:50needs to remove the overwhelming
  1745. 1:17:55stimulus of the world in order to be
  1746. 1:17:57able to create a richness in my own
  1747. 1:18:01imagination so I write lying in bed I'll
  1748. 1:18:04pull the covers up I'll I'll dictate or
  1749. 1:18:07I'll use a pen you know I'll turn the
  1750. 1:18:09light out and do it in the dark I'll
  1751. 1:18:11I'll look up at the bare
  1752. 1:18:13ceiling as a way
  1753. 1:18:15of
  1754. 1:18:17repurposing all my sensory apparatus
  1755. 1:18:20that would ordinarily be taken up with
  1756. 1:18:23you know the the the
  1757. 1:18:26amazing stimulus of the world and and
  1758. 1:18:30now just going back in tranquility and
  1759. 1:18:34recollecting places that I've been
  1760. 1:18:35things that I've
  1761. 1:18:37known uh crisis that I've survived so
  1762. 1:18:41that requires solitude but if you stay
  1763. 1:18:46solitary you're going to spin out of
  1764. 1:18:48orbit
  1765. 1:18:49eventually both literally and
  1766. 1:18:52artistically because you won't have the
  1767. 1:18:55world to test the products of your
  1768. 1:18:58Solitude
  1769. 1:18:59against so you start to make a character
  1770. 1:19:02you start to create a
  1771. 1:19:03scene and and you you you need that
  1772. 1:19:07sensory deprivation to get going and to
  1773. 1:19:09get traction but now it's it's gained
  1774. 1:19:13enough complexity and momentum on its
  1775. 1:19:15own what you want to know now is is it
  1776. 1:19:18true does it resonate and to do that you
  1777. 1:19:22got to give up your Solitude you got to
  1778. 1:19:24go back down into the melstrom and I
  1779. 1:19:26think so many creators talk about that
  1780. 1:19:31that boundary condition you know where
  1781. 1:19:34you can
  1782. 1:19:36control both the degree to which you can
  1783. 1:19:40isolate and organize the complexities in
  1784. 1:19:43the chaos of the world and the degree to
  1785. 1:19:46which you can plunge back into the
  1786. 1:19:48bracing rejuvenating corrective of a
  1787. 1:19:53story that you didn't tell
  1788. 1:19:55yeah and you have to play the one off
  1789. 1:19:57the other well it seems like you've
  1790. 1:19:59really experimented with different forms
  1791. 1:20:01of composition cuz you were just talking
  1792. 1:20:03about
  1793. 1:20:05speech the typewriter or the keyboard
  1794. 1:20:08there's handwriting right how do you mix
  1795. 1:20:11those and how
  1796. 1:20:13does your language show up differently
  1797. 1:20:15in different input
  1798. 1:20:17formats it's kind of scene
  1799. 1:20:19dependent and book dependent to some
  1800. 1:20:22extent the ratio and and what are go to
  1801. 1:20:26uh at each moment it's also depending on
  1802. 1:20:29my state of mind uh but I mean think of
  1803. 1:20:32it the way that a musician would use
  1804. 1:20:36different instruments you know you know
  1805. 1:20:38if you're writing a song you might reach
  1806. 1:20:40for a guitar for a certain kind of song
  1807. 1:20:42you might sit down at the piano for a
  1808. 1:20:44different kind of song go out in the in
  1809. 1:20:47the woods and sing a capella for in a
  1810. 1:20:49different a new a third kind of song or
  1811. 1:20:52or you might you might rotate you know
  1812. 1:20:56you might try you know different
  1813. 1:20:58combinations in sequence or um in
  1814. 1:21:01parallel I I think the samees for
  1815. 1:21:03writing I think the tools that we use to
  1816. 1:21:07write we reach for them when we need
  1817. 1:21:10them when we
  1818. 1:21:11detect through our intuition or through
  1819. 1:21:14our intellect that we need to slow down
  1820. 1:21:17or be more quiet or or speed up be more
  1821. 1:21:20lively you know and and each each tool
  1822. 1:21:24has its affordances and allows you to
  1823. 1:21:26get to different
  1824. 1:21:27places last question be as concrete as
  1825. 1:21:31possible with how do you actually think
  1826. 1:21:33about your day-to-day structure when
  1827. 1:21:35you're writing in solitude I mean you
  1828. 1:21:37were talking about I have this image of
  1829. 1:21:39you just pulling the covers over your
  1830. 1:21:40head and being there and letting your
  1831. 1:21:42imagination wander and do set deadlines
  1832. 1:21:46for yourself how does that work it's
  1833. 1:21:49changed enormously over my 40 years and
  1834. 1:21:51and 14
  1835. 1:21:52books I have always been a person who's
  1836. 1:21:56most Alert in the
  1837. 1:21:58morning and uh I I always uh for the
  1838. 1:22:04maybe the first 25 30 years of my life
  1839. 1:22:07knew that I was going to get best
  1840. 1:22:10results if I had breakfast if I
  1841. 1:22:12minimized my interaction with the world
  1842. 1:22:14resisted the attempt to you know the the
  1843. 1:22:17the uh uh desire to read yesterday's
  1844. 1:22:20news or you know um to check my feeds
  1845. 1:22:25um and simply get to work while my brain
  1846. 1:22:30was
  1847. 1:22:31freshest and to to stay there until I
  1848. 1:22:35had a thousand words that was the
  1849. 1:22:36discipline that was what shaped the day
  1850. 1:22:40I thought my job was getting a thousand
  1851. 1:22:42words out every
  1852. 1:22:44day it worked well for a long long time
  1853. 1:22:48um something happened I became a
  1854. 1:22:51different kind of
  1855. 1:22:52writer I can point to the moment where
  1856. 1:22:54it started and I can point to the moment
  1857. 1:22:56where it started to accelerate but
  1858. 1:22:59basically I now no longer see my day my
  1859. 1:23:04primary job as get is as getting
  1860. 1:23:07thousand
  1861. 1:23:08words I see my primary job as being in
  1862. 1:23:13the world the Living World so the first
  1863. 1:23:17thing I will do in the morning is check
  1864. 1:23:19the weather
  1865. 1:23:20report and and the calendar
  1866. 1:23:25and ask myself what's going on out there
  1867. 1:23:28at what elevation and where's the show
  1868. 1:23:31and where can I learn
  1869. 1:23:33something and that's my primary
  1870. 1:23:36accountability now uh to see myself
  1871. 1:23:39through the nonhuman world to remember
  1872. 1:23:42all of my experiences of my life through
  1873. 1:23:45having this extended final chapter of
  1874. 1:23:48meditation and
  1875. 1:23:49presence
  1876. 1:23:51and usually it means that if after a
  1877. 1:23:54short time of being quickened and
  1878. 1:23:56revived by uh all these amazements
  1879. 1:24:00happening all around
  1880. 1:24:02me without too much deliberation
  1881. 1:24:04something that might have taken me a lot
  1882. 1:24:06of forced effort earlier in my
  1883. 1:24:08career sentences will start to come and
  1884. 1:24:12and scenes will start to come and a lot
  1885. 1:24:14of times you know I'll be four miles
  1886. 1:24:15down a trail and realize I got to get
  1887. 1:24:17home as quickly as I can because I can't
  1888. 1:24:19hold it all in my memory anymore uh so
  1889. 1:24:23the the the the the writing now is a
  1890. 1:24:28supporting
  1891. 1:24:30process for trying to keep me growing as
  1892. 1:24:35a person in the world that keeps
  1893. 1:24:37growing that was such a fun interview
  1894. 1:24:41thank you so much for doing this
  1895. 1:24:42pleasure it was great to meet you thanks
  1896. 1:24:44daavid do yeah yeah

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of How to Become a Master Storyteller (Richard Powers Interview) by David Perell, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 12,754 words across 1,896 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.