How The US Stole The Philippines — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:02There was a cluster of 7,000 islands
- 0:05that looks like one of the most
- 0:06beautiful places on Earth.
- 0:09People have been living here for over
- 0:1130,000 years, traveling between these
- 0:13islands, trading with each other and
- 0:15with the region, and developing
- 0:17religion, identity, and culture. It
- 0:20eventually became a country called
- 0:21Ma'ohi. And while all of these
- 0:23advancements were happening here on
- 0:24these islands, another group of humans
- 0:26had been evolving in another part of the
- 0:28world, over here in Europe.
- 0:33But this other group had a different
- 0:34culture, a different religion.
- 0:38Many of their advancements were achieved
- 0:40through expansion, not collaboration.
- 0:46And their religion thrived when they
- 0:48stomped out others.
- 0:53They wanted to conquer.
- 0:56These island, these people, this culture
- 0:58would soon be swallowed, stripped of
- 1:01what made them them. And soon their name
- 1:04would be changed after the name of the
- 1:06king of their conquerors.
- 1:09This isn't a story just about a big,
- 1:11powerful military taking over new lands.
- 1:14We know that story pretty well. The
- 1:16story of these people offers a new
- 1:18perspective to anyone who will listen.
- 1:21It's a perspective that has been wiped
- 1:22from our history books because of the
- 1:24inherent discomfort and tension with
- 1:27this fact that the United States once a
- 1:30colony that heroically threw off an
- 1:32empire to become independent soon became
- 1:36an empire itself. It contradicts our
- 1:39founding belief that it is, quote,
- 1:41self-evident that all men are created
- 1:44equal. And this story isn't just
- 1:45history. That empire still exists today
- 1:49with colonial possessions and subjects.
- 1:51It's all wrapped up in the story of
- 1:53these 7,000 islands and their people.
- 1:56So, I want to tell you the story of how
- 1:59the US stole the Philippines.
- 2:01There are still American citizens today
- 2:03who do not have equal voting rights.
- 2:05These are citizens of American island
- 2:07territories.
- 2:13The US Constitution grants a citizenship
- 2:15to everyone born on US soil except in
- 2:19one jurisdiction.
- 2:29Quick pause, um because I want to tell
- 2:31you about something that is important to
- 2:33me and happens to also be the sponsor of
- 2:35today's video, which is BetterHelp. I'm
- 2:37a big believer in therapy. I've been in
- 2:39therapy for almost 2 years now and it
- 2:42has changed my life. For many years I
- 2:44didn't think therapy was for me. I
- 2:46thought it was for everyone else and so
- 2:48I sort of avoided it. But when I finally
- 2:50started going last year, I really
- 2:52started to realize that there was so
- 2:53much that I could be working on day in
- 2:56and day out that could dramatically
- 2:59reshape how I think about the world and
- 3:01ultimately make make me more happy.
- 3:02BetterHelp is a platform that is trying
- 3:05to make therapy more accessible to
- 3:07people. It's a virtual platform, so you
- 3:09have access not just to the therapists
- 3:10that are in like your town, but to a
- 3:12huge network of like 15,000 therapists.
- 3:15So, you can find the right fit for you.
- 3:17Finding the right therapist is sometimes
- 3:19difficult and with BetterHelp, you can
- 3:21for free switch to a new therapist as
- 3:24many times as you need to until you find
- 3:25the right fit. Your therapist is in
- 3:27touch with you. You can message them
- 3:29right in the app throughout the week if
- 3:31needed and it is an affordable and
- 3:33approachable way to get in on therapy
- 3:36whenever you want. And BetterHelp is
- 3:38available worldwide. Anywhere in the
- 3:40world that you are that has an internet
- 3:42connection, you can get in on
- 3:45counseling. This isn't a crisis line.
- 3:47This is a a professional counseling and
- 3:50therapy by like certified professional
- 3:53therapist. Therapy can be expensive and
- 3:56with better help it is more affordable
- 3:58than traditional therapy and they even
- 4:00offer financial aid when needed. So,
- 4:03they really are trying to make this more
- 4:04accessible which is something I deeply
- 4:05believe in. I think that in our culture
- 4:08we don't value therapy enough and we
- 4:11really should because I think all of us
- 4:12have stuff we can work on. Thank you
- 4:14BetterHelp for supporting this channel,
- 4:16for sponsoring this video. There's a
- 4:17link in my description. It is
- 4:19betterhelp.com/johnnyharris.
- 4:21Going to that link will get you 10% off
- 4:24your first month of BetterHelp if you
- 4:25want to get started today. So, let's get
- 4:28back to the video.
- 4:31This video could be called how Spain
- 4:33stole the Philippines since Spain was
- 4:35the first nation to conquer and control
- 4:37these islands like 500 years ago.
- 4:39Actually, exactly 500 years ago. And
- 4:42indeed, Spain left a very deep influence
- 4:45on these islands not least of the name
- 4:48itself which is named after King Philip.
- 4:50Spain brought their religion, their
- 4:51language, their culture which is why the
- 4:53most common last names in the
- 4:54Philippines are like Reyes or Del
- 4:57Rosario, Dela Cruz, Del Del Los Santos.
- 5:00But the heyday of the Spanish Empire
- 5:02came and went and by the 1800s it was
- 5:05kind of crumbling. But it was the
- 5:07arrival of a new superpower that I
- 5:09believe had a bigger imprint not just on
- 5:12the Philippines but on the US itself. It
- 5:15established rules and behaviors that we
- 5:17still grapple with today and that's why
- 5:20this is the story of how the US stole
- 5:21the Philippines. So, let's go.
- 5:23To this day we can see the traces of the
- 5:26almost 400 years of Spanish rule over
- 5:28the Philippines.
- 5:30But even more striking is the more
- 5:32recent influence of the United States.
- 5:34Okay, so it's the end of the 1800s. Up
- 5:36until now US expansion sort of looks
- 5:38like this.
- 5:40It's all happening on this mainland and
- 5:42at this point there sort of became a big
- 5:44debate of like do we keep going? Some
- 5:46people wanted keep expanding the US
- 5:48outside of this mainland. The president
- 5:51at the time wasn't a big expansion guy,
- 5:53but he was surrounded by people who
- 5:55loved war, specifically this guy. And
- 5:58these people who surrounded the
- 5:59president had their eye on this Spanish
- 6:02colony right off the American coast
- 6:04called Cuba, where the locals were
- 6:06rising up against Spain.
- 6:11Wait a minute, isn't this a video about
- 6:12the Philippines? Why are we talking
- 6:13about Cuba? We're getting there in just
- 6:15a second, okay? So, anyway, Cuba.
- 6:17Americans didn't want to go to war with
- 6:19Cuba. They're like, we don't need more
- 6:20war. But, thanks to the explosion of an
- 6:23American submarine in Cuba, which is
- 6:25probably an accident, and thanks to some
- 6:27highly unethical journalism that blamed
- 6:29the explosion on Spain, and a big thanks
- 6:32to, again, this guy, Teddy Roosevelt,
- 6:34who at this point was just a peon. He
- 6:35was literally the assistant secretary of
- 6:37the Navy, but he somehow cajoled his
- 6:40bosses' boss, the president of the
- 6:41United States, to go to war in Cuba to
- 6:44like liberate the Cubans from Spain. So,
- 6:47the US declared war on Spain in 1898.
- 6:50But, this begins a new era of war in the
- 6:53United States. No longer can you just go
- 6:55into war and just like take over land.
- 6:57You need an angle. You need to sell the
- 7:00war to the American people. So, the
- 7:02angle on this war was liberation. We're
- 7:05liberating the people.
- 7:06The people you liberate will witness the
- 7:08honorable and decent spirit of the
- 7:11American military.
- 7:12No, no, no, no, no, that's that's later.
- 7:13We're talking about 1898. But, yes, the
- 7:16whole idea of selling war to the
- 7:18American public didn't really go away
- 7:20after this.
- 7:20Why did the US go to war in Iraq?
- 7:23In the early stages of military
- 7:24operations
- 7:26So, anyway, the US is now at war with
- 7:27Spain, which is an empire that is deeply
- 7:30in decline, as I mentioned. It's not
- 7:31going to be hard to win. But, soon, it's
- 7:33not just Cuba. The US, really meaning
- 7:36Teddy Roosevelt, who again is just an
- 7:38assistant secretary of the Navy. He's
- 7:40like not a big decision maker. He's
- 7:42somehow maneuvers the situation to say
- 7:44like let's liberate next door Puerto
- 7:47Rico. And while we're at it, let's go
- 7:49into the Pacific and liberate Guam and
- 7:51the Philippines from Spain as well.
- 7:53Teddy didn't even ask his boss to do
- 7:55this. He literally sent off a cable to
- 7:58the Navy commander in Asia that was like
- 7:59George Dewey, go attack the Philippines
- 8:02where Spain is. That is what your
- 8:03mandate is. And George Dewey's like,
- 8:05okay. I'm being told to go to war with
- 8:08Spain in the Philippines. Teddy was sort
- 8:10of of the mind like better to ask
- 8:11forgiveness than permission. I mean, I
- 8:13get that, but
- 8:15kind of nuts that he pulled it off.
- 8:17Anyway, and now because of Teddy
- 8:19Roosevelt, who we literally named the
- 8:21teddy bear after, side note, we are at
- 8:23war not in the Caribbean only, but also
- 8:26in the Pacific. The US arrives to the
- 8:28Philippines and sees that the locals had
- 8:30already been fighting against the
- 8:32Spanish for like years. The Spanish were
- 8:35weak and were totally declining.
- 8:38So, it's like the top of the ninth
- 8:39inning or like the fourth quarter of the
- 8:41Spanish in the Philippines. And the US
- 8:43shows up and is like, let us liberate
- 8:45you. And the Philippines were like,
- 8:47well, we've sort of already been
- 8:48fighting this bloody war for years
- 8:50against the Spanish. So, yeah, I guess
- 8:52United States, if you want to come help
- 8:53us deal the final blow to Spain, like
- 8:55sweet. So, George Dewey, this Navy
- 8:58commander, and his fleet show up to
- 8:59Manila. Meanwhile back in the US, people
- 9:01are like, wait, weren't we just supposed
- 9:04to invade Cuba? What are we doing in the
- 9:05Philippines now? And the US government's
- 9:07like, because the Philippines is a
- 9:08perfect hub for commercial opportunities
- 9:11in Asia, and we think that if we don't
- 9:12take it, Japan or Germany might take it,
- 9:14which would clearly diminish our
- 9:16geo-strategic advantage in the Pacific.
- 9:18No.
- 9:19They didn't say that. They said, we want
- 9:21to liberate the people of the
- 9:24Philippines.
- 9:25Liberate.
- 9:26The people you liberate will witness the
- 9:28honorable and decent spirit of the
- 9:30American military.
- 9:32So, the Spanish see the US arrive to the
- 9:34Philippines and they're like, great,
- 9:35we're done. So, the Spanish military
- 9:37commanders asked to meet with the US
- 9:40military commanders. They meet in
- 9:42secret, and Spain's like, "Listen, I
- 9:44know we're losing, but we really want to
- 9:47save some face here. We don't want it to
- 9:48look like we lost to the Filipino
- 9:50revolutionaries." And I'm not kidding,
- 9:52the Spanish commander literally said
- 9:54that he would, quote, "be willing to
- 9:56surrender to white people, but not to
- 9:58the Filipinos." So, the US commander's
- 10:00like, "Okay, there's an opportunity
- 10:02here. We said we were here to liberate
- 10:04the Filipinos, but we haven't promised
- 10:06anything yet. So, we would much rather
- 10:08it look like the US defeated Spain
- 10:11instead of helped the Filipinos defeat
- 10:14Spain. Much better for our brand," said
- 10:16the United States. So, together, the
- 10:18United States and Spanish militaries
- 10:20organize a fake battle. A fake battle in
- 10:23which the US would fight the Spanish in
- 10:26Manila, and the Spanish would
- 10:28intentionally lose. And the climax of
- 10:30this whole theatrical battle, according
- 10:33to the plan, was that at the end, the US
- 10:36would storm towards the inner walled
- 10:38city of Manila, the last stronghold of
- 10:41where the Spanish are. Oh, and the key
- 10:43detail in this whole plan, they would
- 10:45not let the Filipino fighters, the ones
- 10:47that had been doing all the actual
- 10:48fighting against the Spanish, join them
- 10:50as they stormed towards the walled city
- 10:53to deal the final blows to the Spanish
- 10:55empire. And this would mean that the
- 10:57Filipinos technically didn't gain their
- 10:59independence. It was actually the US who
- 11:01conquered the Spanish, and then the
- 11:03Spanish are like, "Oh, can you give us
- 11:04$20 million for our troubles?" And the
- 11:07US was like, "Yeah, sure." So, now the
- 11:08US wins the war, and they claim
- 11:11sovereignty over the Philippines.
- 11:14So, yeah, this happened. They did the
- 11:16fake battle, they won the war, instead
- 11:18of liberating the Filipinos, they just
- 11:20say, "Hey, we're your new colonizers."
- 11:22Psych. Meanwhile, back in the United
- 11:24States, they got to keep up this white
- 11:26savior liberation narrative that they
- 11:29created to justify going to war with
- 11:31Spain. So, you see a lot more theatrical
- 11:34PR by the government. They staged this
- 11:36giant military parade in New York City
- 11:39where this military commander who did
- 11:41the fake war, George Dewey, marches down
- 11:44They called it Dewey Day. It was like a
- 11:45two-day parade in New York City. They
- 11:47created a big like military arch for
- 11:49him. He became like a military hero for
- 11:52having like liberated all these people
- 11:54from the Spanish. And then you start to
- 11:56see these like crazy advertisements.
- 11:58Like this soap advertisement that has
- 12:00George Dewey, the commander, washing his
- 12:02hands with the caption, quote, "The
- 12:04first step towards lightening the white
- 12:06man's burden is through teaching the
- 12:08virtues of cleanliness."
- 12:12And on the side you have soap being
- 12:14offloaded in the Philippines and being
- 12:16given to the locals. The US had to frame
- 12:19this not as conquest, but as the
- 12:21honorable duty of the US to civilize
- 12:24these people. Or, in the words of the
- 12:26soap ad, quote, "To brighten the dark
- 12:29corners of the earth."
- 12:32Jeez. This is insane and was not that
- 12:35long ago. Okay, so this is where things
- 12:38really heat up. It's 1900 now. Spain
- 12:41loses the war, obviously, and the US now
- 12:44owns Puerto Rico, Guam, and they claim
- 12:47the Philippines. But the local Filipinos
- 12:50who have been fighting for their freedom
- 12:52for years are like, "No, no, no, no, no.
- 12:54You just waltzed in here on our
- 12:56rebellion and conspired with the Spanish
- 12:58to make it look like you were liberating
- 13:00us." No, this is our country. We don't
- 13:03need another colonizer. And this is
- 13:04where things really heat up.
- 13:15The Filipinos start fighting again for
- 13:18their independence and this time against
- 13:19the United States. It is a pretty
- 13:21horrible, bloody war, one that I never
- 13:24learned about in school. It include
- 13:25massacres of men, women, and children by
- 13:28the United States and hundreds of
- 13:30thousands of civilian deaths. But, the
- 13:33US eventually won.
- 13:34And they established a government in the
- 13:36Philippines. Back in the US, the
- 13:38appetite for expansion continued to go
- 13:41down and people sort of just forgot
- 13:43about the Philippines. They forgot that
- 13:44there was a war there. One newspaper
- 13:46summed it up by saying, "Americans
- 13:48didn't know if the Philippines were
- 13:50islands or canned fruit." But, the fact
- 13:52remained that the US went to war and now
- 13:55owned the Philippines in addition to
- 13:57Puerto Rico and Guam. So, this begged a
- 13:59very important question, one that hadn't
- 14:01been asked before, which is, "Is all of
- 14:03this land America? Are these people
- 14:06Americans?" This was a huge question and
- 14:09the answer to that question affects how
- 14:12we see these territories still today.
- 14:15Okay, so a few years after these wars,
- 14:17there's a guy in New York City who's
- 14:19importing oranges from one of these
- 14:21territories, Puerto Rico. And he's
- 14:22paying tariffs on these imports because,
- 14:25you know, that's what you do when you're
- 14:26importing oranges from another country.
- 14:29Wait a minute. Another country?
- 14:31This guy was like, "Didn't we conquer
- 14:34Puerto Rico and Guam and the
- 14:35Philippines? Isn't that America? The The
- 14:37Constitution says that you can't put
- 14:39tariffs on stuff coming from other parts
- 14:41of the US. Like New Jersey can't put
- 14:43tariffs on like avocados from
- 14:45California." So, he sued and his case
- 14:48and a bunch of others like it made it to
- 14:50the Supreme Court. So, now the Supreme
- 14:51Court must decide, "Is this land where
- 14:54we just won a war? Is this America? Are
- 14:57these Americans? If they are, do they
- 14:59get all the same rights as other
- 15:01Americans? Do they get to vote? Do they
- 15:03get to participate in the US economy
- 15:04without tariffs like any other state
- 15:06does?" And honestly, this isn't a
- 15:08question about oranges and tariffs. The
- 15:11real question at stake here is, "Is
- 15:13America the land of the free where all
- 15:16are created equal? Or are we an empire,
- 15:19no different than any other empire that
- 15:21scoops up colonial possessions in war
- 15:24and rules the people who are usually
- 15:26black and brown as subjects, not fully a
- 15:29part of the country. That was the
- 15:31question that was at stake. And in this
- 15:33series of cases in the early 1900s, the
- 15:36Supreme Court decided that America was
- 15:39the latter.
- 15:41Is the latter. They created a new
- 15:43category of land called unincorporated
- 15:46territories, where the people don't have
- 15:48any representation in the democracy, but
- 15:50where Congress could create laws on
- 15:52their own, particularly laws dealing
- 15:54with revenue, which would not be allowed
- 15:56by the Constitution for states within
- 15:58the union.
- 16:00We can create revenue laws, stuff that's
- 16:02totally unconstitutional for other parts
- 16:03of our country. In other words,
- 16:05unincorporated territories are land we
- 16:07control and exploit for revenue, but
- 16:10whose people don't get to vote and don't
- 16:13get the right to trial by jury. So,
- 16:15yeah, the Philippines, in addition to
- 16:17Puerto Rico and Guam, remained
- 16:19unincorporated territories, a place that
- 16:21the US could kind of just ignore without
- 16:23a lot of consequence. They weren't
- 16:24important enough or strategic enough to
- 16:27be considered to become states like
- 16:29Hawaii or Alaska. So, they sort of faded
- 16:31from American consciousness. Like, this
- 16:34is why we never heard about this in
- 16:36school. Like, it didn't make it into the
- 16:37history books in any salient way. And
- 16:39how far the Philippines had faded from
- 16:41people's mind became very clear in
- 16:43December of 1941 during World War II.
- 16:46The US had owned the Philippines for
- 16:48like 40 years when a fleet of Japanese
- 16:51bombers flew across the Pacific and
- 16:53bombed an American naval base in Hawaii.
- 17:02But, what we don't really remember is on
- 17:04that day Japan bombed Guam and the
- 17:07Philippines, two American territories,
- 17:09as well as several other American and
- 17:11British territories.
- 17:13Yesterday,
- 17:15December 7th,
- 17:181941,
- 17:21a date which will live
- 17:24in infamy.
- 17:25Here's the draft of this speech.
- 17:28This is the original draft that FDR
- 17:30spent the day marking up before he gave
- 17:32it. Zoom in a little bit and you'll see
- 17:34on this draft that it mentioned the
- 17:36Philippines originally.
- 17:38But FDR crossed it out. He crossed out
- 17:41the mention of Manila.
- 17:43Yes, the Philippines was on some map
- 17:45somewhere. Yes, we technically owned it.
- 17:48But the people really didn't want to
- 17:49hear about it because these people
- 17:51weren't Americans.
- 17:52The Supreme Court had decided that. They
- 17:54weren't going to become states anytime
- 17:56soon. So, why mention them? After that
- 17:58day, Japan actually full on invaded the
- 18:02Philippines. They didn't do that to
- 18:03Hawaii, but they did to the Philippines
- 18:05until the end of the war, at which point
- 18:07the Philippines were finally granted
- 18:09independence in 1946. Fast forward to
- 18:12today
- 18:13and this we own you, but you're not
- 18:15really Americans precedent established
- 18:18by the Supreme Court still applies to 4
- 18:21million people who live in
- 18:22unincorporated territories. Or let's
- 18:24just call it a spade a spade. Let's call
- 18:26them what they are. These are colonial
- 18:27possessions. The people who live here
- 18:29don't experience the full rule of law.
- 18:32They don't get trial by jury. They don't
- 18:34have full representation in our
- 18:36democracy and they don't get to vote for
- 18:38the president. This is why when a
- 18:40hurricane hits Puerto Rico, the
- 18:42government response is not nearly what
- 18:44it should be. The way Trump talked about
- 18:46Puerto Rico as almost another country,
- 18:49as not a part of us, mirrors exactly how
- 18:52the Supreme Court talked about these
- 18:53unincorporated territories. They're for
- 18:55revenue, not to compete with American
- 18:57farmers. We conquered these places,
- 19:00but we didn't want to bring the people
- 19:02fully into the American project. We left
- 19:05them out.
- 19:06And there they remain today.
- 19:15Mhm.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of How The US Stole The Philippines by Johnny Harris, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,319 words across 512 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.