How GTO Ruins Your Game — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00GTO is silly. In this video, I'm going
- 0:03to show you what GTO is and what it's
- 0:04not. And I'm going to differentiate it
- 0:06from two things that are massively
- 0:08important to your success in poker.
- 0:10The first is poker theory
- 0:13and knowing it.
- 0:14GTO is not poker theory. We're going to
- 0:18see why GTO doesn't matter and poker
- 0:21theory really matters. I'll explain the
- 0:24difference in a second. The other thing
- 0:26that really matters is exploitative
- 0:29play.
- 0:30But exploitative play is not the
- 0:31opposite of GTO.
- 0:35I'm going to explain
- 0:36how this misconception comes about and
- 0:39where this false dichotomy between do I
- 0:41play GTO or do I play exploit comes in,
- 0:44which is one of the most nonsensical
- 0:46false dichotomies I've ever heard of.
- 0:48This is a button versus big blind spot.
- 0:52Button opens, big blind calls, the flop
- 0:53is ace queen four, it goes check check,
- 0:55the turn is the four of spades, it goes
- 0:57check check, the river is the seven of
- 0:59hearts. And big blind has this GTO
- 1:03strategy in a solver. A GTO strategy is
- 1:07an output that a solver puts on your
- 1:10screen. It assigns an action and a
- 1:13frequency to every hand within the
- 1:15landing range, the range that gets to
- 1:17that spot.
- 1:19And that is calculated by an algorithm
- 1:22that seeks a Nash equilibrium. So it
- 1:23tries to drive the EVs of both
- 1:26strategies up as much as possible to a
- 1:28point where neither can gain by
- 1:30improving further.
- 1:32But more than that, it cares about the
- 1:34EV of every hand within each strategy
- 1:36and it plays it based on its own
- 1:38properties and how it fits into that
- 1:40range versus range picture.
- 1:43So it's a complete fallacy that GTO is
- 1:46about balance.
- 1:48Balance is a byproduct of a Nash
- 1:50equilibrium seeking algorithm. Without
- 1:53balance, you wouldn't be able to be in a
- 1:55Nash equilibrium because you'd be
- 1:58and your opponent could do something to
- 1:59wreck the EV of your strategy.
- 2:01So, yes, balance is a feature of GTO,
- 2:04but it is not the mechanism by which the
- 2:07strategy is formed. EV is the mechanism
- 2:09by which the strategy is formed. And the
- 2:11reason that looking at GTO, if you know
- 2:13what you're doing, can be really, really
- 2:15useful
- 2:16is that the variables that govern EV,
- 2:20which is the central thing behind a GTO
- 2:22strategy,
- 2:23are the same variables that govern EV in
- 2:26real life as well. And GTO is this
- 2:28useful realm, right? Where you can look
- 2:30under a microscope and you can study
- 2:32ranges and strategies and hands and
- 2:33blockers and EVs and equities, and you
- 2:36can see how they interact, and you can
- 2:38parse that general knowledge about the
- 2:41game. That's what we call poker theory,
- 2:43right? And you can take that to the
- 2:45tables, and then you can play
- 2:46exploitatively. So, we're going to get
- 2:48into this sim in just a minute, and I'll
- 2:49show you how it works in this spot.
- 2:52But, effectively, you have these three
- 2:55completely distinct things.
- 2:58GTO
- 3:00is the output on your screen. It's the
- 3:01instantiation
- 3:03of poker theory in the realm of a Nash
- 3:06equilibrium.
- 3:07That's what it is.
- 3:09Then, you have poker theory, which is
- 3:10this interconnected
- 3:14web of correlated concepts
- 3:17that govern EV, which is the currency of
- 3:19success in poker.
- 3:21And these concepts
- 3:23apply not just here, where we can
- 3:25examine them very closely and clearly,
- 3:27in this sort of synthetic realm that
- 3:29doesn't represent real life that much,
- 3:31but they apply in real life against a
- 3:33fish, against a nit, against a
- 3:37a maniac.
- 3:38Poker theory concepts apply against the
- 3:41maniac because, for example, implied
- 3:43odds, right? Which is a poker
- 3:45theoretical concept, is the idea that
- 3:47when you have a favorable ratio of
- 3:49investment to potential earnings, you
- 3:51want to invest money to see if you hit
- 3:53your hand and then win a big pot, right?
- 3:55Just to give you a lazy definition of of
- 3:57implied odds. And if your opponent's a
- 4:00maniacal fish that's going to bluff off
- 4:01a stack every time they don't have it
- 4:03and donate to you by stationing when
- 4:04they do,
- 4:06your implied odds for seeing if you can
- 4:07hit that suited connector or make trips
- 4:09or set mine or whatever it may be or
- 4:12chase that gutter are going to be
- 4:14phenomenal and you're going to want to
- 4:15chase that gutter. So, there we have an
- 4:16example where a theoretical concept
- 4:19implied odds is massively functional
- 4:22against a complete [ __ ] whale.
- 4:25So, he let's debunk our first fallacy
- 4:27fallacy of the day, which is that theory
- 4:30doesn't work against bad players. GTO
- 4:34is somewhat irrelevant when you're
- 4:37playing against a fish. I'll explain why
- 4:38this is the case here, right? Like how a
- 4:40fish would play this spot and why it
- 4:42would be silly to copy this strategy and
- 4:44why GTO is a silly concept
- 4:46against the fish, but poker theory is
- 4:48not. So, GTO is the example from which
- 4:52we extract the theoretical concepts,
- 4:54learn how they work, and then take them
- 4:56to the real world, right? So, you've got
- 4:57these three things that are not at odds
- 4:59with one one another. They're
- 5:00functioning independently.
- 5:02GTO, the output. Theory, the concepts
- 5:04that govern it, but also govern real
- 5:06life then exploitative play, what you
- 5:07should do in real life, and they all
- 5:09work harmoniously if you can see GTO as
- 5:12a microscope, a magnifying glass,
- 5:15a place where you can deconstruct [ __ ]
- 5:17and learn how it works. If you see GTO
- 5:19as that, you have no problem. If you get
- 5:22sucked into this absolute [ __ ] of do
- 5:24I play GTO? This question is just a
- 5:28absolute non-starter. Like it's so bad
- 5:31in so many levels, right? So, let's take
- 5:34that question to this spot.
- 5:36Big blind arrives on the seven of hearts
- 5:38river. Should I play GTO here? Well, for
- 5:41one, you have absolutely no ability to
- 5:43do that unless you're using real-time
- 5:45assistance. Don't use real time
- 5:47assistance.
- 5:49If you think for one second
- 5:52that you're capable of playing anything
- 5:54like this strategy here
- 5:57where every bluff is basically a give up
- 6:00unless it has exactly the right blockers
- 6:02to break even because it's a shitty spot
- 6:04for your range and you're doing terribly
- 6:06and you need to have exactly the right
- 6:08cards just to not hemorrhage money by
- 6:09bluffing and you need to control the
- 6:11bluff frequency that you remain in the
- 6:13Nash equilibrium and don't give your
- 6:14opponent a way of exploiting you by over
- 6:16calling the river and blah blah blah
- 6:17blah blah. If you think you can do that
- 6:19for a second, you can't. I can't do
- 6:21that. I can't get anywhere near GTO in
- 6:23this spot. I have an idea of roughly
- 6:24what it looks like. I can't get anywhere
- 6:26close to it. It's like flying into the
- 6:28sun. You can get sort of close and then
- 6:30you just burn up and can't do it
- 6:32anymore. So,
- 6:34you can't play GTO in this spot and you
- 6:36don't want to
- 6:38anyway because even if your opponent's
- 6:41not a maniacal whale or a knit that's
- 6:44really bad at cards. Even if they're
- 6:46just like some reg that's playing your
- 6:47stake. Your stake's probably 10 NL,
- 6:49right? I'm accusing you of playing 10
- 6:51NL. There we go. Right, let's say your
- 6:52stake's 10 NL.
- 6:54And your opponent's some ABC reg that's
- 6:56just like blue lining and trying to make
- 6:57money like most regs at 10 NL. Very few
- 6:59red lining regs at 10 NL, right?
- 7:02Thankfully.
- 7:03So, let's say you get to the spot and
- 7:05your hand is
- 7:08let's pick a terrible hand that solver's
- 7:09giving up with. 98 offsuit, right?
- 7:11Solver's like, okay, zero EV as a check,
- 7:14even worse as a bet. So, this hand
- 7:15effectively has a slight blocker effect
- 7:17on the on the folding range in GTO in
- 7:19this snapshot output.
- 7:22And it's a negative blocker effect. It's
- 7:24blocking folds like king eight offsuit
- 7:25or whatever it may be.
- 7:27And because of that,
- 7:29it gives up in a spot that's just not
- 7:32going to be giving you excess fold
- 7:33equity. You're not going to be causing a
- 7:35stronger range than yours, i.e. the
- 7:37button range, to over fold in this spot.
- 7:39The button's going to hit a defense
- 7:41frequency that makes it indifferent for
- 7:42you to bluff hands with
- 7:44okay blockers and negative for you to
- 7:46bluff hands with these blockers, which
- 7:48are which are bad negative blockers,
- 7:50right? So, let me show you how we take
- 7:52theoretical concepts out of this that we
- 7:54can then deploy in the real world.
- 7:56Concept number one we should extract
- 7:57from this verdict that 98 offsuit is a
- 7:59give up in GTO
- 8:01is
- 8:03people meeting defense frequencies,
- 8:05right? MDF. So, in spots where someone's
- 8:08not at a range disadvantage
- 8:10like button is not out here
- 8:12button will meet the right defense
- 8:13frequency against all sizes. So, there
- 8:16we have a useful concept. GTO shows us
- 8:18this here. We can't bluff this hand cuz
- 8:20button's defending often enough. So,
- 8:22here's a theory concept. Even though
- 8:24you've got no showdown value, you still
- 8:26can't bluff bad blockers in spots that
- 8:28aren't over folded. There's an amazing
- 8:31golden nugget of an EV concept something
- 8:34that really relates to EV that shows you
- 8:36how poker theory works. You know what
- 8:37else shows you how poker theory works
- 8:39and exploits it deeply and makes you a
- 8:41really good poker player, the Golden
- 8:43Carrot. Our full access curriculum and
- 8:46it is $404 less for another few hours
- 8:50depending on when you're watching this.
- 8:51You may have already missed this
- 8:53promotion. I'm sorry, it's gone. It's
- 8:55done. If you've missed it, you've missed
- 8:56it, but maybe you're you're quick to
- 8:59watch this video and it's still live. Go
- 9:00to Carrot Corner. If you know you want
- 9:02to go all in with us, it's just lock in
- 9:03the price. You don't have to be ready to
- 9:05do the more advanced concepts, the more
- 9:07advanced tuition right now.
- 9:10So, we extract that theoretical concept
- 9:13from the GTO thing on our screen and
- 9:15then we forget about the GTO thing on
- 9:17our screen cuz we don't need to remember
- 9:19this is we're not going to remember
- 9:20this. It's just one precise spot anyway.
- 9:23And we take that concept and we think
- 9:25about how it works against the ABC net
- 9:27reg at 10 and L. Well, okay. How is he
- 9:29arriving here
- 9:31on the river and how's it different to
- 9:32how the button arrives here? Well, he's
- 9:34going to arrive with a way weaker range
- 9:35to start with, right?
- 9:37In this situation, he's not going to
- 9:39arrive with anywhere near this much A 6.
- 9:42He's going to arrive with way more air.
- 9:44You'll note here that the solver has bet
- 9:47some of its air already, but certainly
- 9:48not all of it's getting through over
- 9:50with like some some jack x and stuff
- 9:51like that, some queen x second pair that
- 9:54going to arrive with that. But what
- 9:56you'll note here
- 9:58is that the solver is actually folding
- 10:00some of its queens
- 10:02to just a B 75 on the river and it's
- 10:04folding a bunch of its under pairs like
- 10:06pretty much all the time. So what's
- 10:08going to happen with the ABC reg is that
- 10:10when he actually has an under pair or a
- 10:12queen, he's going to grossly over defend
- 10:14here. Grossly.
- 10:16Right? And we're taking this concept of
- 10:18like I am not supposed to be able to
- 10:20bluff 98 because it doesn't have good
- 10:23blockers and because it's not a good
- 10:25spot for my range. We're taking this
- 10:26concept of giving up zero showdown value
- 10:29and we're now testing it against an ABC
- 10:31reg.
- 10:32The ABC reg has less A 6 here,
- 10:35but they have more
- 10:37queen x and they well, the same amount
- 10:39of queen x and they're going to over
- 10:40defend with it and they're probably
- 10:41going to over defend with jacks and tens
- 10:43and nines and eights and sixes and fives
- 10:45by far
- 10:46against the B 75.
- 10:48But they're probably going to over fold
- 10:49with king eight and king nine and things
- 10:51like that because these hands are meant
- 10:53to call sometimes. So it's a mixed bag
- 10:54of stuff trying to understand what
- 10:55actually happens in the real world here.
- 10:58But here's what happens. Small bets
- 11:02in this situation
- 11:04against an ABC reg
- 11:07are going
- 11:08to do
- 11:10quite badly. The B 75 bluff is going to
- 11:13do badly because you're going to get
- 11:15looked up by all of these showdown value
- 11:17hands.
- 11:18It's not going to go that well for you.
- 11:20In order for the B 75 bluff to be good,
- 11:23you need an opponent who's like folding
- 11:26nines all the time here and sometimes
- 11:27folding a queen. That's not going to
- 11:28happen. Or you need an opponent that's
- 11:30showing up with loads of air. So, who's
- 11:32it going to be good against? A passive
- 11:34fish.
- 11:35Right? Because a passive fish is going
- 11:37to take loads of air to the river
- 11:40and then fold. But, guess what? To get
- 11:41someone to fold air, you can actually go
- 11:43smaller. So, the best play in real life
- 11:45against a passive fish is just to bet
- 11:46small and make them fold air when you've
- 11:49got nine high.
- 11:50But, there's another option against the
- 11:52netty guy. You could go 4x pot. And if
- 11:55he never has an ace, you might get a
- 11:57range fold.
- 11:58Do you know to risk 4x pot, how much
- 12:01fold equity you need to break even?
- 12:0380%. You might be getting 100% fold
- 12:06equity against ABC reg. So, I'm just
- 12:08rambling here and I'm showing you how we
- 12:10can derive correct exploitative play
- 12:14from a theory concept
- 12:17and from getting the context from GTO.
- 12:19So, GTO is not something you have the
- 12:22option of playing or copying. You cannot
- 12:26play
- 12:28GTO in this spot. You can't even get
- 12:30that close to it. It's too difficult.
- 12:32You don't want to anyway. GTO is there
- 12:35for you to study, to derive the concepts
- 12:37that are true objectively and they're
- 12:40evergreen and eternal, and you take them
- 12:42to the real world and ask how to play
- 12:44against different player types. Going to
- 12:46run through a few player types now
- 12:47really quickly and summarize what you
- 12:49should actually do here exploitatively
- 12:50and show you how to connect the dots by
- 12:53using what we've just learned about the
- 12:55GTO sim.
- 12:56So,
- 12:58what I would do against the fish
- 12:59is I would always bluff.
- 13:0298s and 108s like this for smaller
- 13:04sizing and just make the fish fold jack
- 13:06high and king high and pocket deuces
- 13:08sometimes and not worry too much about
- 13:10anything else. That's just going to be
- 13:11better than checking. Checking's
- 13:13balanced on a knife edge. The solver
- 13:15never checks. It hates checking. No, it
- 13:17doesn't. It doesn't hate checking. It's
- 13:20just restrained by Nash equilibrium.
- 13:22It's not allowed to
- 13:25Did I say checking? I meant bluffing.
- 13:26The solver never bluffs, right? With
- 13:28these hands, it's restrained by the Nash
- 13:30equilibrium. It's not allowed to start
- 13:32bluffing all the time, or it departs
- 13:34from that Nash equilibrium. That's why
- 13:35it doesn't bet with the jack eight here.
- 13:37It's not a big EV loss to bet with jack
- 13:40eight. It's a small one. The blockers
- 13:42aren't right. The hand has a trace of
- 13:44showdown, whatever. It's not allowed to
- 13:46bet, but it's not that it hemorrhages.
- 13:48It's not that a 0% frequency equals
- 13:50hemorrhaging money. It just makes it not
- 13:52viable in a Nash equilibrium energy to
- 13:54your output.
- 13:56So, with this jack eight, right? Let's
- 13:58use this as our case study hand now.
- 14:00Against certain players, what happens?
- 14:02Okay, so villain is a fish. We just want
- 14:04to bet really small with these hands, or
- 14:06maybe even check like king high or good
- 14:08jack high for showdown, cuz they're
- 14:09going to let us get to showdown too
- 14:10often. They're too passive. They don't
- 14:12realize that they need to bluff the
- 14:13river with their weak jack high as the
- 14:16player with the range advantage, right?
- 14:18We won't go too far into that. That's
- 14:19all in Carrot Poker School, grade two
- 14:21especially, and grade one to an extent
- 14:23as well.
- 14:24So,
- 14:26against passive fish, that's what you
- 14:27do. Against a good protected reg at say
- 14:3025 NL, 10 NL, they'll be over protected
- 14:33here. They'll be betting their good
- 14:34hands earlier, and they'll be arriving
- 14:37with loads of pocket pairs and queen X,
- 14:39right? That's what they'll usually have.
- 14:41And you will not be able to make them
- 14:42fold it unless you go absolutely
- 14:45massive, and even then, if they know
- 14:47that you're like a thinking player and a
- 14:48reg, they might figure out that you're
- 14:49just over bluffing. So, the idea of
- 14:51bluffing against a good reg here for any
- 14:54sizing low stakes is just a non-starter.
- 14:56Like, they're going to over defend
- 14:58because they're not rocking up to the
- 14:59spot to over fold. They're going to over
- 15:01defend. So, you just need to not bluff
- 15:02this spot. If they're a bad ABC weak
- 15:05reg, you can use a gigantic sizing and
- 15:08just pulverize them out of the pot with
- 15:09most of their range. Give yourself a
- 15:11high needs to work target, and it's
- 15:13going to exceed that. It's going to work
- 15:14even more. Something that needs to work
- 15:1680% of the time, i.e. 4x pot, might work
- 15:1995 against a nitty reg. and finally
- 15:22against some maniac fish.
- 15:25You probably can't bluff cuz they're
- 15:26going to like raise you, and they're not
- 15:27going to take any air to the spot.
- 15:29Maniac fish is like just going to bluff
- 15:31you by now if they have nothing. So,
- 15:33think about the player type, right? And
- 15:35how can you use the concepts that you
- 15:37can glean from looking at this GTO
- 15:39output,
- 15:40harvest those theoretical concepts, take
- 15:43that knowledge into the exploitative
- 15:44realm, and figure out what to do against
- 15:46your opponent. That is what you need to
- 15:48do. But, when I look at our starter and
- 15:50bronze Discord servers, by the way, get
- 15:52the starter kit for free at Carrot
- 15:54Corner, or if you do get bronze carrot,
- 15:55you'll get in the bronze section of
- 15:56this. But, we have a We have a free
- 15:58Discord now. And I let people discuss
- 16:00hands with each other. And sometimes I
- 16:02come in and say, "Okay, guys, you've
- 16:03completely and utterly made a complete
- 16:05[ __ ] show out of this. This is why."
- 16:07I'll come in and I'll say,
- 16:09"What an absolute riot this is." Cuz it
- 16:11is. It's an absolute mess. It's a
- 16:13carnival of chaos.
- 16:15And the reason for that is that you just
- 16:16have loads of poker players that don't
- 16:18have a good protocol, that don't know
- 16:20many theoretical concepts, trying to
- 16:22guess what their opponents have, and
- 16:23just pick a line. And it's a complete
- 16:26dumpster fire.
- 16:27It really is.
- 16:28But, it's good to see it. It's good to
- 16:30see the carnage, right? And when you
- 16:32when you have this going on,
- 16:35the thought processes
- 16:37will vary between
- 16:40stuff about how solvers are completely
- 16:44terrible for you. Like, guy was going on
- 16:45the other day about how a solver is
- 16:48useless because all it cares about is
- 16:50balance, and your opponents are
- 16:52unbalanced, so you can't use a solver.
- 16:53What a load of [ __ ]
- 16:55A solver doesn't just care about
- 16:56balance. It cares about all of the same
- 16:58concepts that you should care about. It
- 17:00just reaches different conclusions than
- 17:02you do, cuz its opponent is a solver,
- 17:03not a human.
- 17:05Right? But, the concepts are the same,
- 17:06and it's really useful to study with
- 17:08solvers once you reach a certain level.
- 17:10Courses first, then solvers once you
- 17:12know what's going on. That's just how it
- 17:14has to be. It's the only sane way of
- 17:16doing things. No solvers before 50 NL is
- 17:18a bit extreme, but I I have some
- 17:20sympathy for that position, honestly. No
- 17:23solvers at 5 NL is probably just a very
- 17:24good rule, honestly, it really is.
- 17:27The other thing you'll hear people doing
- 17:28in that Discord is they'll just guess.
- 17:30Like, people will oscillate between
- 17:33posting a solver output and telling the
- 17:34other guy to copy it, telling people
- 17:36that solvers are a complete waste of
- 17:38time and it's [ __ ] and just making
- 17:39up an exploitative line and claiming
- 17:41that it's right, or trying to be psychic
- 17:43and hand-read an unknown individual. I
- 17:45just say like, "Here's a hand I played
- 17:47against a reg." And then they'll be
- 17:48like, "Well, the reg is never taking a
- 17:50queen to this node. They're always
- 17:52betting a queen on the turn." Okay, they
- 17:53don't say node, right? But you get the
- 17:54point. They're all They're going to bet
- 17:56a queen on the turn, so they don't have
- 17:57a queen.
- 17:58And it's just so wrong, and it's just so
- 18:00like made up. And guys, like, let's just
- 18:03summarize this by saying
- 18:06you're allowed
- 18:07to look at what happens in a solver, and
- 18:10then you're allowed to look at a big
- 18:11population of humans
- 18:13and ask how things differ on average.
- 18:16You need to be empirical. You need to be
- 18:17a data scientist. You need to be like
- 18:19understanding the right level of
- 18:21specificity here, which is there's a
- 18:23population of humans on average play a
- 18:25certain way, and you need to counter
- 18:26that by using theoretical knowledge. I
- 18:28hope this video has helped you
- 18:30understand what a GTO solution is and
- 18:33what it's not. There's no dichotomy
- 18:34between playing theory and playing GTO
- 18:37and and playing exploitatively.
- 18:38Exploitatively is what drives EV. It's
- 18:40what you should do, but to reach it you
- 18:42need to know what concepts affect EV.
- 18:45And the best way, ultimately when you
- 18:47become skilled at doing that outside of
- 18:50like really good courses and stuff and
- 18:51coaching, is to look at solver with
- 18:54knowledge of why the algorithm is
- 18:57producing the output it's producing, cuz
- 18:58it cares about the stuff that matters.
- 19:00It just reaches a dicey conclusion for
- 19:03humans. I'll leave you with that
- 19:04thought. If this video's been helpful,
- 19:06like it, tell me, subscribe to the
- 19:08channel, let me know if you want more of
- 19:10these like explanatory videos that try
- 19:12and debunk the garbage that floats
- 19:14around the poker sphere and I'll see you
- 19:17next time. Click the link in the
- 19:18description, go to Carrot Corner, and
- 19:20start learning for free with the starter
- 19:21kit if you want more stuff like this.
- 19:23All right, catch you later.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of How GTO Ruins Your Game by Carrot Corner - Poker Education, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,782 words across 572 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.