How do we heal medicine? | Atul Gawande — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:15I got my start
- 0:18in writing and research
- 0:20as a surgical trainee,
- 0:23as someone who was a long ways away
- 0:25from becoming any kind of an expert at anything.
- 0:28So the natural question you ask then at that point
- 0:31is, how do I get good at what I'm trying to do?
- 0:33And it became a question of,
- 0:35how do we all get good
- 0:37at what we're trying to do?
- 0:40It's hard enough to learn to get the skills,
- 0:44try to learn all the material you have to absorb
- 0:47at any task you're taking on.
- 0:49I had to think about how I sew and how I cut,
- 0:52but then also how I pick the right person
- 0:54to come to an operating room.
- 0:56And then in the midst of all this
- 0:58came this new context
- 1:00for thinking about what it meant to be good.
- 1:02In the last few years
- 1:04we realized we were in the deepest crisis
- 1:07of medicine's existence
- 1:09due to something you don't normally think about
- 1:11when you're a doctor
- 1:13concerned with how you do good for people,
- 1:16which is the cost
- 1:18of health care.
- 1:20There's not a country in the world
- 1:23that now is not asking
- 1:25whether we can afford what doctors do.
- 1:28The political fight that we've developed
- 1:31has become one around
- 1:33whether it's the government that's the problem
- 1:36or is it insurance companies that are the problem.
- 1:41And the answer is yes and no;
- 1:45it's deeper than all of that.
- 1:47The cause of our troubles
- 1:49is actually the complexity that science has given us.
- 1:52And in order to understand this,
- 1:54I'm going to take you back a couple of generations.
- 1:58I want to take you back
- 2:00to a time when Lewis Thomas was writing in his book, "The Youngest Science."
- 2:03Lewis Thomas was a physician-writer,
- 2:05one of my favorite writers.
- 2:07And he wrote this book to explain, among other things,
- 2:10what it was like to be a medical intern
- 2:13at the Boston City Hospital
- 2:15in the pre-penicillin year
- 2:17of 1937.
- 2:20It was a time when medicine was cheap
- 2:24and very ineffective.
- 2:28If you were in a hospital, he said,
- 2:31it was going to do you good
- 2:34only because it offered you
- 2:36some warmth, some food, shelter,
- 2:40and maybe the caring attention
- 2:42of a nurse.
- 2:44Doctors and medicine
- 2:48made no difference at all.
- 2:50That didn't seem to prevent the doctors
- 2:52from being frantically busy in their days,
- 2:54as he explained.
- 2:56What they were trying to do
- 2:58was figure out whether you might have one of the diagnoses
- 3:01for which they could do something.
- 3:04And there were a few.
- 3:06You might have a lobar pneumonia, for example,
- 3:09and they could give you an antiserum,
- 3:11an injection of rabid antibodies
- 3:15to the bacterium streptococcus,
- 3:18if the intern sub-typed it correctly.
- 3:22If you had an acute congestive heart failure,
- 3:25they could bleed a pint of blood from you
- 3:28by opening up an arm vein,
- 3:31giving you a crude leaf preparation of digitalis
- 3:34and then giving you oxygen by tent.
- 3:39If you had early signs of paralysis
- 3:41and you were really good at asking personal questions,
- 3:44you might figure out
- 3:46that this paralysis someone has is from syphilis,
- 3:49in which case you could give this nice concoction
- 3:52of mercury and arsenic --
- 3:56as long as you didn't overdose them and kill them.
- 4:01Beyond these sorts of things,
- 4:03a medical doctor didn't have a lot that they could do.
- 4:08This was when the core structure of medicine
- 4:10was created --
- 4:12what it meant to be good at what we did
- 4:15and how we wanted to build medicine to be.
- 4:17It was at a time
- 4:19when what was known you could know,
- 4:21you could hold it all in your head, and you could do it all.
- 4:24If you had a prescription pad,
- 4:26if you had a nurse,
- 4:28if you had a hospital
- 4:30that would give you a place to convalesce, maybe some basic tools,
- 4:33you really could do it all.
- 4:35You set the fracture, you drew the blood,
- 4:38you spun the blood,
- 4:40looked at it under the microscope,
- 4:42you plated the culture, you injected the antiserum.
- 4:45This was a life as a craftsman.
- 4:50As a result, we built it around
- 4:53a culture and set of values
- 4:55that said what you were good at
- 4:58was being daring,
- 5:00at being courageous,
- 5:02at being independent and self-sufficient.
- 5:06Autonomy was our highest value.
- 5:12Go a couple generations forward
- 5:14to where we are, though,
- 5:16and it looks like a completely different world.
- 5:18We have now found treatments
- 5:21for nearly all of the tens of thousands of conditions
- 5:25that a human being can have.
- 5:27We can't cure it all.
- 5:29We can't guarantee that everybody will live a long and healthy life.
- 5:32But we can make it possible
- 5:34for most.
- 5:37But what does it take?
- 5:39Well, we've now discovered
- 5:414,000 medical and surgical procedures.
- 5:45We've discovered 6,000 drugs
- 5:48that I'm now licensed to prescribe.
- 5:51And we're trying to deploy this capability,
- 5:53town by town,
- 5:55to every person alive --
- 5:59in our own country,
- 6:01let alone around the world.
- 6:03And we've reached the point where we've realized,
- 6:06as doctors,
- 6:08we can't know it all.
- 6:10We can't do it all
- 6:13by ourselves.
- 6:15There was a study where they looked
- 6:17at how many clinicians it took to take care of you
- 6:19if you came into a hospital,
- 6:21as it changed over time.
- 6:23And in the year 1970,
- 6:25it took just over two full-time equivalents of clinicians.
- 6:28That is to say,
- 6:30it took basically the nursing time
- 6:33and then just a little bit of time for a doctor
- 6:35who more or less checked in on you
- 6:37once a day.
- 6:39By the end of the 20th century,
- 6:42it had become more than 15 clinicians
- 6:45for the same typical hospital patient --
- 6:48specialists, physical therapists,
- 6:51the nurses.
- 6:54We're all specialists now,
- 6:56even the primary care physicians.
- 6:58Everyone just has
- 7:00a piece of the care.
- 7:03But holding onto that structure we built
- 7:05around the daring, independence,
- 7:07self-sufficiency
- 7:09of each of those people
- 7:12has become a disaster.
- 7:14We have trained, hired and rewarded people
- 7:18to be cowboys.
- 7:21But it's pit crews that we need,
- 7:24pit crews for patients.
- 7:26There's evidence all around us:
- 7:2840 percent of our coronary artery disease patients
- 7:31in our communities
- 7:33receive incomplete or inappropriate care.
- 7:3760 percent
- 7:39of our asthma, stroke patients
- 7:42receive incomplete or inappropriate care.
- 7:46Two million people come into hospitals
- 7:49and pick up an infection
- 7:51they didn't have
- 7:53because someone failed to follow
- 7:56the basic practices of hygiene.
- 7:59Our experience
- 8:01as people who get sick,
- 8:03need help from other people,
- 8:05is that we have amazing clinicians
- 8:08that we can turn to --
- 8:10hardworking, incredibly well-trained and very smart --
- 8:13that we have access to incredible technologies
- 8:16that give us great hope,
- 8:18but little sense
- 8:20that it consistently all comes together for you
- 8:24from start to finish
- 8:27in a successful way.
- 8:30There's another sign
- 8:32that we need pit crews,
- 8:34and that's the unmanageable cost
- 8:37of our care.
- 8:40Now we in medicine, I think,
- 8:42are baffled by this question of cost.
- 8:44We want to say, "This is just the way it is.
- 8:48This is just what medicine requires."
- 8:50When you go from a world
- 8:52where you treated arthritis with aspirin,
- 8:55that mostly didn't do the job,
- 8:58to one where, if it gets bad enough,
- 9:00we can do a hip replacement, a knee replacement
- 9:02that gives you years, maybe decades,
- 9:05without disability,
- 9:07a dramatic change,
- 9:09well is it any surprise
- 9:11that that $40,000 hip replacement
- 9:14replacing the 10-cent aspirin
- 9:16is more expensive?
- 9:18It's just the way it is.
- 9:21But I think we're ignoring certain facts
- 9:23that tell us something about what we can do.
- 9:28As we've looked at the data
- 9:30about the results that have come
- 9:33as the complexity has increased,
- 9:35we found
- 9:37that the most expensive care
- 9:39is not necessarily the best care.
- 9:42And vice versa,
- 9:44the best care
- 9:46often turns out to be the least expensive --
- 9:49has fewer complications,
- 9:52the people get more efficient at what they do.
- 9:55And what that means
- 9:57is there's hope.
- 10:00Because [if] to have the best results,
- 10:03you really needed the most expensive care
- 10:06in the country, or in the world,
- 10:08well then we really would be talking about rationing
- 10:11who we're going to cut off from Medicare.
- 10:15That would be really our only choice.
- 10:19But when we look at the positive deviants --
- 10:21the ones who are getting the best results
- 10:24at the lowest costs --
- 10:26we find the ones that look the most like systems
- 10:29are the most successful.
- 10:31That is to say, they found ways
- 10:34to get all of the different pieces,
- 10:36all of the different components,
- 10:38to come together into a whole.
- 10:41Having great components is not enough,
- 10:44and yet we've been obsessed in medicine with components.
- 10:48We want the best drugs, the best technologies,
- 10:51the best specialists,
- 10:54but we don't think too much
- 10:56about how it all comes together.
- 10:59It's a terrible design strategy actually.
- 11:03There's a famous thought experiment
- 11:06that touches exactly on this
- 11:08that said, what if you built a car
- 11:10from the very best car parts?
- 11:13Well it would lead you to put in Porsche brakes,
- 11:16a Ferrari engine,
- 11:18a Volvo body, a BMW chassis.
- 11:21And you put it all together and what do you get?
- 11:24A very expensive pile of junk that does not go anywhere.
- 11:28And that is what medicine can feel like sometimes.
- 11:33It's not a system.
- 11:36Now a system, however,
- 11:38when things start to come together,
- 11:41you realize it has certain skills
- 11:44for acting and looking that way.
- 11:47Skill number one
- 11:49is the ability to recognize success
- 11:51and the ability to recognize failure.
- 11:54When you are a specialist,
- 11:56you can't see the end result very well.
- 11:59You have to become really interested in data,
- 12:02unsexy as that sounds.
- 12:04One of my colleagues is a surgeon in Cedar Rapids, Iowa,
- 12:07and he got interested in the question of,
- 12:11well how many CT scans did they do
- 12:13for their community in Cedar Rapids?
- 12:15He got interested in this
- 12:17because there had been government reports,
- 12:19newspaper reports, journal articles
- 12:21saying that there had been too many CT scans done.
- 12:24He didn't see it in his own patients.
- 12:28And so he asked the question, "How many did we do?"
- 12:30and he wanted to get the data.
- 12:32It took him three months.
- 12:34No one had asked this question in his community before.
- 12:37And what he found was that,
- 12:39for the 300,000 people in their community,
- 12:41in the previous year
- 12:43they had done 52,000 CT scans.
- 12:48They had found a problem.
- 12:51Which brings us to skill number two a system has.
- 12:56Skill one, find where your failures are.
- 12:59Skill two is devise solutions.
- 13:03I got interested in this
- 13:05when the World Health Organization came to my team
- 13:07asking if we could help with a project
- 13:09to reduce deaths in surgery.
- 13:11The volume of surgery had spread
- 13:13around the world,
- 13:15but the safety of surgery
- 13:17had not.
- 13:19Now our usual tactics for tackling problems like these
- 13:22are to do more training,
- 13:24give people more specialization
- 13:27or bring in more technology.
- 13:30Well in surgery, you couldn't have people who are more specialized
- 13:33and you couldn't have people who are better trained.
- 13:36And yet we see unconscionable levels
- 13:39of death, disability
- 13:43that could be avoided.
- 13:45And so we looked at what other high-risk industries do.
- 13:47We looked at skyscraper construction,
- 13:49we looked at the aviation world,
- 13:52and we found
- 13:54that they have technology, they have training,
- 13:56and then they have one other thing:
- 13:59They have checklists.
- 14:02I did not expect
- 14:04to be spending a significant part
- 14:06of my time as a Harvard surgeon
- 14:08worrying about checklists.
- 14:11And yet, what we found
- 14:13were that these were tools
- 14:16to help make experts better.
- 14:19We got the lead safety engineer for Boeing to help us.
- 14:23Could we design a checklist for surgery?
- 14:26Not for the lowest people on the totem pole,
- 14:28but for the folks
- 14:30who were all the way around the chain,
- 14:32the entire team including the surgeons.
- 14:34And what they taught us
- 14:36was that designing a checklist
- 14:38to help people handle complexity
- 14:40actually involves more difficulty than I had understood.
- 14:43You have to think about things
- 14:45like pause points.
- 14:47You need to identify the moments in a process
- 14:50when you can actually catch a problem before it's a danger
- 14:52and do something about it.
- 14:54You have to identify
- 14:56that this is a before-takeoff checklist.
- 14:59And then you need to focus on the killer items.
- 15:02An aviation checklist,
- 15:04like this one for a single-engine plane,
- 15:06isn't a recipe for how to fly a plane,
- 15:08it's a reminder of the key things
- 15:10that get forgotten or missed
- 15:13if they're not checked.
- 15:15So we did this.
- 15:17We created a 19-item two-minute checklist
- 15:20for surgical teams.
- 15:22We had the pause points
- 15:24immediately before anesthesia is given,
- 15:27immediately before the knife hits the skin,
- 15:30immediately before the patient leaves the room.
- 15:33And we had a mix of dumb stuff on there --
- 15:36making sure an antibiotic is given in the right time frame
- 15:39because that cuts the infection rate by half --
- 15:41and then interesting stuff,
- 15:43because you can't make a recipe for something as complicated as surgery.
- 15:46Instead, you can make a recipe
- 15:48for how to have a team that's prepared for the unexpected.
- 15:51And we had items like making sure everyone in the room
- 15:54had introduced themselves by name at the start of the day,
- 15:57because you get half a dozen people or more
- 15:59who are sometimes coming together as a team
- 16:02for the very first time that day that you're coming in.
- 16:05We implemented this checklist
- 16:07in eight hospitals around the world,
- 16:10deliberately in places from rural Tanzania
- 16:12to the University of Washington in Seattle.
- 16:15We found that after they adopted it
- 16:18the complication rates fell
- 16:2035 percent.
- 16:22It fell in every hospital it went into.
- 16:25The death rates fell
- 16:2747 percent.
- 16:30This was bigger than a drug.
- 16:32(Applause)
- 16:38And that brings us
- 16:40to skill number three,
- 16:43the ability to implement this,
- 16:45to get colleagues across the entire chain
- 16:48to actually do these things.
- 16:51And it's been slow to spread.
- 16:53This is not yet our norm in surgery --
- 16:57let alone making checklists
- 16:59to go onto childbirth and other areas.
- 17:02There's a deep resistance
- 17:04because using these tools
- 17:06forces us to confront
- 17:08that we're not a system,
- 17:10forces us to behave with a different set of values.
- 17:13Just using a checklist
- 17:15requires you to embrace different values from the ones we've had,
- 17:18like humility,
- 17:22discipline,
- 17:25teamwork.
- 17:27This is the opposite of what we were built on:
- 17:30independence, self-sufficiency,
- 17:32autonomy.
- 17:35I met an actual cowboy, by the way.
- 17:38I asked him, what was it like
- 17:41to actually herd a thousand cattle
- 17:43across hundreds of miles?
- 17:45How did you do that?
- 17:47And he said, "We have the cowboys stationed at distinct places all around."
- 17:50They communicate electronically constantly,
- 17:53and they have protocols and checklists
- 17:55for how they handle everything --
- 17:57(Laughter)
- 17:59-- from bad weather
- 18:01to emergencies or inoculations for the cattle.
- 18:04Even the cowboys are pit crews now.
- 18:08And it seemed like time
- 18:10that we become that way ourselves.
- 18:12Making systems work
- 18:14is the great task of my generation
- 18:17of physicians and scientists.
- 18:19But I would go further and say
- 18:21that making systems work,
- 18:23whether in health care, education,
- 18:25climate change,
- 18:27making a pathway out of poverty,
- 18:29is the great task of our generation as a whole.
- 18:33In every field, knowledge has exploded,
- 18:36but it has brought complexity,
- 18:38it has brought specialization.
- 18:41And we've come to a place where we have no choice
- 18:43but to recognize,
- 18:45as individualistic as we want to be,
- 18:48complexity requires
- 18:51group success.
- 18:53We all need to be pit crews now.
- 18:57Thank you.
- 18:59(Applause)
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of How do we heal medicine? | Atul Gawande by TED, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,610 words across 431 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.