How a 50-Year Veteran Thinks About Risk Management · Peter Brandt — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00I do not use indicators, Kevin. I don't
- 0:02believe in indicators. Indicators are
- 0:04just simply a derivative of price. Why
- 0:06study an indicator when I can study
- 0:08price directly, but I do use ADX because
- 0:11it shows me compression. My assumption
- 0:13on every trade I do, Kevin, is it's
- 0:15going to be a loser. I do not assume
- 0:17that my next trade is going to win
- 0:18money. I assume it's going to lose money
- 0:20because that puts me in a frame of
- 0:21reference where I want to be a risk
- 0:23manager and not a braggger. What I tell
- 0:25people, Kevin, that say I I want to be a
- 0:28full-time trader, I I would say to them,
- 0:30you got to make sure you have a day job.
- 0:32Don't just quit what you're doing and
- 0:34assume you're going to do 3x on on
- 0:36whatever money you have the first year
- 0:38in the rest of your life. You better
- 0:39have a day job. And if you're going to
- 0:42quit your day job and trade, there are
- 0:44few things that I think people should
- 0:46have. I think first thing they should
- 0:48have is a trading account, which
- 0:49represents profits they've already made.
- 0:51Why would somebody quit their day job
- 0:53and become a trader when they haven't
- 0:55proven in themselves they're profitable?
- 0:57And the only way you prove that is you
- 0:59open an account of at least $100,000
- 1:02with profits you've already made. And
- 1:03then I would say you need another
- 1:05$100,000 to pay your family's expense in
- 1:08the bank. That money is not for trading.
- 1:11It's set aside to meet expenses. I have
- 1:13a bullish scenario and a bearish
- 1:14scenario for any market at any given
- 1:16time. And what pushes me to one or the
- 1:19other is price action. it will direct me
- 1:22into a narrative, but I don't want to
- 1:23hold on to that narrative. I want to let
- 1:25that narrative go very quickly if price
- 1:28turns. And so that's strong opinions.
- 1:31When I'm in a trade, I want to have a
- 1:32strong opinions because with strong
- 1:34opinions, that allows me to have a big
- 1:36enough position that it matters. But I
- 1:39also want to have that opinion weekly
- 1:41hell. And the thing that the old guys,
- 1:43keep in mind, when I joined the board of
- 1:45trade, there were guys in the pit that
- 1:46were World War II veterans. They fought
- 1:48on Omaha Beach. These guys knew what it
- 1:51was like to be in in battle conditions
- 1:54and they would just drill into us young
- 1:56guys. Cut your losses short but have
- 1:59some way where you can allow a winning
- 2:02trade to grow. And the only way you can
- 2:04do it statistically, the only way
- 2:06probability theory works is if losses
- 2:09get cut quick and you have some
- 2:11provision to not to avoid the temptation
- 2:14of taking the first profit that comes
- 2:16along. And most novice traders think
- 2:18that trade identification is where it's
- 2:20all about. I contribute of my niche. I
- 2:24think trade identification represents
- 2:26about 5%.
- 2:27>> You really want to know who you are as a
- 2:29person deep down inside. Be honest with
- 2:32yourself and become a trader because a
- 2:34person will find out the good, bad, and
- 2:36the really ugly. And the really ugly
- 2:39attempts to sabotage us from success. I
- 2:42just make a really important point here
- 2:44again to repeat Kevin. There is no real
- 2:47distinct edge to a chart themselves.
- 2:49Charts do not predict where markets are
- 2:51going to go. I cannot look at a chart
- 2:53and do a price forecast based on a
- 2:55chart. All a chart does is show me where
- 2:58I can enter a trade with a defined risk
- 3:01and a likelihood some likelihood that a
- 3:03market will follow through. That's all a
- 3:05chart is for me. It's just a tool. The
- 3:07chart is not the answer. The chart is
- 3:09just a tool I use. It's a tool to which
- 3:12I apply risk management. My edge comes
- 3:14from risk management and emotional
- 3:16management and process.
- 3:18>> What would your trading look like if
- 3:19capital wasn't the constraint? That's
- 3:21the reality for most traders. It's not
- 3:23skill holding them back. It's size.
- 3:25Trade the pool changes that. Step into
- 3:28the US equity markets with up to
- 3:30$200,000 in buying power without
- 3:32committing your own capital. Full access
- 3:34to stocks and ETFs. Long or short.
- 3:37Executed with the precision and freedom
- 3:38serious traders expect. Your performance
- 3:41is measured by one standard. disciplined
- 3:43risk management and consistent
- 3:44execution. Meet that standard and you
- 3:47operate at scale. No subscriptions, no
- 3:49ongoing obligations, just a clear path
- 3:52forward. For those ready to trade beyond
- 3:54limitations, this is the next level.
- 3:58>> Markets, speculation, and risk. [music]
- 4:01This is the Chat with Traders podcast.
- 4:07Traders, welcome back [music] to another
- 4:09episode of Chat with Traders. Today's
- 4:11guest is Peter Brandt. Now, he first
- 4:12joined Chat with Traders back on episode
- 4:1436 with Aaron Field. Since then, he's
- 4:17become one of the most recognizable
- 4:19traders in the world. He was featured in
- 4:21Jack Schwagger's Unknown Market Wizards.
- 4:24He has authored multiple books on
- 4:26speculation, classical charting. He
- 4:28built the factor trading company and
- 4:30today his market commentary and chart
- 4:32work are followed by millions of people.
- 4:34He has amassed over a million people on
- 4:36X. He's read by traders around the
- 4:38globe. Peter's journey is very
- 4:40fascinating because it's one of
- 4:42longevity. He's been in this space for
- 4:44over 50 years. He entered the commodity
- 4:46business in the 1970s, traded through
- 4:49everything, inflationary booms, crashes,
- 4:52wars, technological revolutions, you
- 4:54know, the transition from open outcry
- 4:56pits to electronic markets. And he's
- 4:59remained a student, a student of
- 5:01speculation through it all. So, I'm
- 5:02excited really to dive into his past,
- 5:04his journey, and where it's led him to
- 5:06today. Peter, thank you so much for
- 5:08joining Chat with Traders.
- 5:09>> I enjoy it. Thanks for inviting me,
- 5:11Kevin. I've been on Chat with Traders
- 5:13twice before with Aaron, I believe. And
- 5:16you know, you've you've got a great
- 5:17audience. You've got a great brand, and
- 5:19congratulations for now being the voice
- 5:21of Chat with Traders. I think you're you
- 5:23you serve a very important role within
- 5:26the market speculation community.
- 5:28>> Hey, thank you so much. You I watched
- 5:29that episode that 10 years ago. So,
- 5:31what's transpired 10 years ago, 50 years
- 5:34ago? Tell us a little bit about your
- 5:35your journey. I mean, you started in the
- 5:371970s, right? This is 50 years and still
- 5:40just as passionate as ever.
- 5:42>> You know, it's crazy. I was a trader.
- 5:46Gold was not a tradable commodity in the
- 5:48United States until 1972, 1973. So, you
- 5:51know, I started trading right at the
- 5:53beginning of trading gold. I started
- 5:55trading when we started trading currency
- 5:58futures back at the international
- 5:59monetary market, which was part of the
- 6:01CME. You know, I have been through every
- 6:04bull market in soybeans and corn since
- 6:091970. And sometimes I have to pinch
- 6:11myself and kind of go, really? I I've
- 6:15made a living. I've built a net worth as
- 6:17a as a commodity trader. I mean, how
- 6:20crazy is that?
- 6:21>> Unbelievable. And you know, part of, you
- 6:23know, in reading your work, especially
- 6:25the diary of a professional commodity
- 6:27trader, you mentioned that you wanted a
- 6:29career out of this. You were not
- 6:30necessarily looking just to get rich
- 6:32quick. I mean, you've made a career out
- 6:34of it. Do you pinch yourself looking
- 6:35back at that?
- 6:36>> Yeah. You know, that's right. And I
- 6:38guess that's why I have a hard time, I
- 6:40think, connecting with a lot of newbie
- 6:42aspiring traders who just look at it as
- 6:45a way to, you know, turn 10 grand into a
- 6:47million in a year, which is highly
- 6:48unlikely. We'll probably get into that.
- 6:50But, you know, I was in the advertising
- 6:52business back in 1974.
- 6:56Um, my brother was involved in silver
- 6:59coins because this was prior to the time
- 7:02that silver futures became actively
- 7:04trading. and uh he asked me if I wanted
- 7:07to get involved with him in buying these
- 7:09bags of pre-1970
- 7:11silver quarters and and and I said yes
- 7:14because back then the the content of
- 7:16silver quarter prior to the Brentton
- 7:18Woods uh deal with Nixon well pretty
- 7:22much pure silver and that's the way
- 7:24people speculated with silver back then
- 7:26as they buy these coins and bags and I
- 7:28did so and I made some money and it it
- 7:31sparked my interest but I was in a
- 7:33career in advertising I was a a kind of
- 7:35a young fast starter in a big
- 7:37advertising agency in Chicago. That was
- 7:40my major in college. And we moved from
- 7:42Minnesota to bigtown Chicago to work for
- 7:45a what today is the largest advertising
- 7:47agency in the world. And my little son
- 7:50played hockey, which was my sport in
- 7:52high school and college and growing up.
- 7:54And and he had another kid who played
- 7:57with him whose father was a soybean
- 7:59trader at board of trade. And so I'd
- 8:01stand next to him or sit in the stands
- 8:03and we'd chat watching our kids playing
- 8:05hockey, little kids playing Kiwi hockey.
- 8:08And he told me what he did and it it
- 8:10fascinated me and he said, "Peter, come
- 8:12on down and I I'll buy you lunch on the
- 8:14fifth floor, Chicago Board of Trade,
- 8:16members dining room overlooking the
- 8:18floor." And I went down there and I was
- 8:22like, "Seriously, people make their
- 8:24money doing this. They don't have to go
- 8:26to meetings. They don't write memos.
- 8:28they anywhere from 9:15 in the 9:30 in
- 8:32the morning to 1:15 and their day is
- 8:34done. Then they go golfing. This is kind
- 8:36of a cool gig. And uh so I you know went
- 8:41home and I I started hustling and found
- 8:44out how in the world do I get in this
- 8:46business and I landed really a
- 8:48beginner's job uh entrylevel job because
- 8:51in as speculators that's the only thing
- 8:54you have is everybody even today you
- 8:56have entrylevel jobs. Nobody starts with
- 8:59an NBA fast track. And I I I gained a
- 9:02position with at the time was one of the
- 9:04world's largest uh commodity merchants,
- 9:08Continental Grain Company. And I I got
- 9:11my start in 1975 with Continental Grain.
- 9:14And my job was to bring in customers at
- 9:16first is, you know, you want to be in
- 9:17this business, you have to bring in
- 9:19customers. and I'd get paid something
- 9:21like a tenth of a cent per bushel of of
- 9:24grain that I'd bring in for futures
- 9:27trading. And I brought in some massive
- 9:29customers. But even back then, Kevin, my
- 9:31goal was to really have a career. I was
- 9:34thinking in terms of career that this is
- 9:37something I could do. If I could learn
- 9:38how to trade, this would be a fun thing
- 9:40to do for the rest of my life. And so
- 9:43that was really my initial goal was to
- 9:46learn enough about trading so that it
- 9:49could be a job. I could create a job out
- 9:51of it. Now obviously making the money
- 9:54was part of it. And I knew that guys
- 9:56that were on the board of trades of
- 9:58making massive amounts of money, but
- 10:00that was not my thinking at the time. My
- 10:02thinking was I could be a trader for for
- 10:04a living. That could be my career. How
- 10:06cool would that be?
- 10:08>> And you've sustained it. Do you think
- 10:10that is again a problem with some of the
- 10:12newer traders? They want to dive in just
- 10:15head first and maybe allocate nearly
- 10:17their entire portfolio to one two trades
- 10:20and just get rich quick.
- 10:21>> Oh yeah. I mean there's no question
- 10:22about it. If I think through let's say a
- 10:25list of the top reasons why people who
- 10:28decide they're going to trade and it
- 10:29could be futures, it could be forex, it
- 10:31could be crypto, could be equities. I
- 10:34mean you name the asset class. But but
- 10:36they're thinking in terms of the
- 10:38get-rich stories, and there are plenty
- 10:40of those out there. I mean, most of them
- 10:42are phony, by the way. Most of the
- 10:43get-rich stories that you see on Axe or
- 10:46YouTube are are bogus, but the ones that
- 10:48Jack writes about in Market Wizards,
- 10:51they're for real stories. They're
- 10:52documented. Jack asked for a lot of
- 10:55proof. But yeah, I mean, they go in and
- 10:57they, you know, I it took me five years
- 11:00to become profitable. You know, I would
- 11:03make money as as customers, man. I had
- 11:06some massive customers that were doing
- 11:08million bushels of corn at corn and
- 11:11grain at a time. And so, you know, I was
- 11:14actually doing pretty well as a
- 11:16customers guy. You know, this is back
- 11:181977
- 11:201978, you know, where I was making
- 11:23$150,000 a year handling brokerage
- 11:26business, which was not a bad living
- 11:28back then. That was a lot of money back
- 11:30then. But my idea was I need to learn to
- 11:33trade first. And that takes a while. I I
- 11:36mean, people come in and they hop in and
- 11:38they think they're going to be brilliant
- 11:39traders, right? Ray, if you go through
- 11:41Jack, by the way, has interviewed and
- 11:44included, I don't know, somewhere under
- 11:46a hundred traders in his Market Wizard
- 11:48series, Kevin. And I think you just
- 11:51assume that they basically represent, I
- 11:53don't know, maybe half of the best
- 11:55traders in the world. Uh, I mean, his
- 11:58under 100 traders are among the best
- 12:00traders in the world. And you read
- 12:02through those stories and and I asked
- 12:04Jack once, how many people for market
- 12:06wizards hit the ground running, made big
- 12:10buku bucks first year, second year, and
- 12:12were off and flying. And I think Jack
- 12:15said maybe there were two or three of
- 12:17the whole group that made a lot of money
- 12:20their first year and never looked back.
- 12:22But the common story was it took people
- 12:25a lot of time of solving problems,
- 12:28working through the process, figuring
- 12:30out how they trade, what they trade,
- 12:32when they trade, what size they trade,
- 12:35what orders they use that you typically
- 12:38it's three to five years, and that's
- 12:40just to get a scent. That's to pick up
- 12:42the smell and follow the trail. and you
- 12:45know but at least in 3 to 5 years maybe
- 12:47you you break even start making a little
- 12:50bit of money and not lose it
- 12:51automatically.
- 12:52>> So it's that discovery period. I I like
- 12:55what Dr. Brett Steamberger says. He he
- 12:57says to survive your learning curve and
- 13:00that sounds like you know what you did
- 13:02in the majority of even the wizards do
- 13:04is they have to survive that learning
- 13:07curve which took you I mean you started
- 13:10you said early to mid 1970s and then you
- 13:13had profitability was it 1980 and then a
- 13:16monster year 1981 is that accurate
- 13:18>> I would say you know my first trade 74 I
- 13:21you know I entered the business
- 13:22full-time in 75 I get a ticket I get a
- 13:26badge to the floor in 76. Keep trying
- 13:29different ways. I mean, I tried trading
- 13:32with point and figure charts, with
- 13:33cycles, with spreads, with, you know,
- 13:36with a number of different ways, but I I
- 13:39started following charts in 78, 1978, a
- 13:43friend bought me the Edwards and Biggie
- 13:45fifth edition. I still have it. It's
- 13:47just it's thread worn and pages are
- 13:49brown. It's it's all beat up. But uh you
- 13:54know it was that point at which I
- 13:56discovered classical charting was 78. So
- 13:5978 I start looking at charts. I start
- 14:02following charts. Now these are futures
- 14:04markets. Back then there were only 20
- 14:05markets maybe that that we could trade.
- 14:08That was it. and and and so I would
- 14:11chart these 20 commodity markets and you
- 14:14know um I started getting the sense that
- 14:17I can I can do it with charting and
- 14:20charting made sense to me. You know I'd
- 14:22look at a chart it would tell me where
- 14:25price has been. It would tell me path of
- 14:28least resistance. It would point out
- 14:31levels price levels at which thrust
- 14:33could take place. It would give me an
- 14:35idea where market could go. would give
- 14:37me a risk point. Th those were all key
- 14:40key met key things for me. Those were
- 14:42components a combination components I
- 14:44had not had in any other way to trade.
- 14:47And so I would say by mid78
- 14:51I started gaining a little traction. My
- 14:53first profitable year year or half year
- 14:56I would say was the last half of 79
- 14:58where I felt like I I I've got it. I
- 15:02think I it still needs work but I think
- 15:05I have found a way that I want to trade.
- 15:08So that was five years after I placed my
- 15:10first trade and then you know my first
- 15:13full profitable year was 80 and then you
- 15:17know I I guess it you went from there
- 15:20and so you you have to learn a lot of
- 15:22lessons and you know you have to eat a
- 15:24lot of humble pie and you you learn by
- 15:26mistakes. What what allowed you to stay
- 15:29in the game for those five years where
- 15:32you where you were learning through
- 15:34those losses?
- 15:35>> You know, I was really lucky. I I look
- 15:37at these guys today, Kevin, they they
- 15:39inherit, let's say, $50,000 from their
- 15:43mom or they take a loan and they say,
- 15:45"Okay, I'm I'm going to do 200% a year
- 15:49for the rest of my life and trading on a
- 15:52laptop in their mom's basement." And I
- 15:55go, "Really?
- 15:58Is is is that true? Now, I had a big
- 16:00advantage in that I had massive
- 16:02customers that were trading massive
- 16:05amounts of commodities. So, I was
- 16:07collecting brokerage commission uh on
- 16:10these customers. And so, that allowed me
- 16:13to lose money in an account and refund
- 16:15it. And it allowed me to support my
- 16:17family. It allowed me to buy a home in
- 16:201979.
- 16:22Uh was my first home. uh you know back
- 16:26then you know I'm still I'm still a kid
- 16:29I'm still a kid in in my 20s and uh and
- 16:33so I had that advantage but and so I
- 16:36think it's it's really important for
- 16:38somebody who says I want to be a
- 16:39full-time trader what I tell people
- 16:42Kevin that say I I want to be a
- 16:44full-time trader
- 16:46I I would say to him you got to make
- 16:48sure you have a day job
- 16:50just quit what you're doing and assume
- 16:52you're going to do 3x on on whatever
- 16:54money you have the first year in the
- 16:57rest of your life. You better have a day
- 16:59job. And if you're going to quit your
- 17:02day job and trade, there are a few
- 17:04things that I think people should have.
- 17:07I think the first thing they should have
- 17:08is a trading account, which represents
- 17:10profits they've already made. Why would
- 17:12somebody quit their day job and become a
- 17:14trader when they haven't proven in
- 17:16themselves they're profitable? And the
- 17:18only way you prove that is you you open
- 17:21an account of at least $100,000 with
- 17:24profits you've already made. And then I
- 17:26would say you need another $100,000 to
- 17:29pay your family's expense. In the bank,
- 17:32that money is not for trading. It's set
- 17:34aside to meet expenses. I mean, people
- 17:36that think they're going to open an
- 17:38account for $10,000 and make $100,000 a
- 17:40year the rest of their life. That that's
- 17:42foolhardy. Uh I mean, good luck. Good
- 17:44luck. I just hope you trade my markets
- 17:46cuz you know we need fresh meat in the
- 17:48game always. But uh the idea I think a
- 17:51trader should have at least $100,000 in
- 17:55an account that represents previous
- 17:57profits and another $100,000 that's set
- 18:00aside to meet family expenses. That's
- 18:02not part of the trading account. It's in
- 18:04a bank account. It's designated for for
- 18:07food and rent and life insurance and
- 18:10child care and the rest of it. So, uh,
- 18:13hey people out there, your audience can
- 18:15believe me or not believe me. It's it's
- 18:17up to them. I'm just expressing my
- 18:19opinion, but I think my opinion would be
- 18:21backed up by the vast majority of of
- 18:23people who are currently members of the
- 18:27Market Wizards Club. Well, you certainly
- 18:29back it up as well because if I remember
- 18:32correctly when you were starting out in
- 18:34the 70s, you actually what gave you
- 18:37additional conviction to take that leap
- 18:39is you had kind of a backup job that you
- 18:42could fall back on in marketing and
- 18:44advertising if all went wrong.
- 18:46>> Yeah, that's a funny Kevin. When I quit
- 18:49advertising to go to the board of trade,
- 18:52uh I worked at the time the agency was
- 18:54needs. It's now Omnicom,
- 18:58massive public company. Uh, I went in
- 19:02the office of Dick Nem and I said, "I'm
- 19:03going to quit. I'm going to go to member
- 19:05of the board of trade. If I if if I blow
- 19:07out, will you hire me back in a year for
- 19:09a 30% raise?" And Dick Nem said, "Yeah,
- 19:12of course we will." And that gave me the
- 19:15freedom to fly, right? And uh then I was
- 19:19able to, you know, bring in customers.
- 19:21So I I didn't have that thread of having
- 19:24to make money in the that's a dangerous
- 19:26thing to have to make money in your
- 19:28trading so that you can live on. That is
- 19:30not something I recommend to people.
- 19:32>> You know when I was reading the your
- 19:34chapter in the unknown market wizards
- 19:36which is great by the way. uh uh you had
- 19:38referenced the job you had which in the
- 19:41largest advertising agency in the
- 19:42country I believe today and you did a
- 19:44piece for McDonald's that I researched
- 19:46and that song's been stuck in my head
- 19:48the last few days to grab a bucket and
- 19:50mop. It was incredible by the way. So
- 19:52you would have had a great successful
- 19:53career there I imagine as well.
- 19:55>> Yeah, a little side story on Grab Your
- 19:57Bucket and Mop. was written by an
- 20:00advertising copywriter by the name of
- 20:02John Yuz who went on to be a movie
- 20:04writer for such movies as Left Behind uh
- 20:08and and became a very famous
- 20:12movie producer and uh since his
- 20:15deceased. So that's an interesting
- 20:17sidlight on on that.
- 20:18>> Yeah. So in that chapter by the way on
- 20:21known market wizards um Jack titles it
- 20:25strong opinions weakly held. Why did he
- 20:28title it that? You know, what's the
- 20:29significance of that?
- 20:30>> You know, again, if if I were to kind of
- 20:33list top 10, top 12, top 20 things
- 20:36retail wannabe aspiring traders
- 20:40do wrong. One of them is they embrace
- 20:43narratives. They get hung up on
- 20:45narratives. Uh whatever that narrative
- 20:47may be, it's the AI narrative. It's
- 20:50interest rate narrative. It's, you know,
- 20:52it's so interest rates go up. What does
- 20:54that [clears throat] mean to crude oil?
- 20:56They they adopt these macro narratives
- 20:58that gives them bias. And I don't want
- 21:00narratives. I I am a basian. For those
- 21:04people who might be interested, they
- 21:05might want to Google what it means to be
- 21:07to be into basian probability. At any
- 21:10given time, Kevin, uh I have for
- 21:13instance, in the case of corn, I have
- 21:15played out in my mind a bullish scenario
- 21:18and a bearish scenario. I have a bullish
- 21:20scenario and a bearish bearish scenario
- 21:22for any market at any given time. And
- 21:25what pushes me to one or the other is
- 21:28price action. Uh will will direct me
- 21:31into a narrative, but I don't want to
- 21:33hold on to that narrative. I want to let
- 21:36that narrative go very quickly if price
- 21:38turns. And so uh that's strong opinions.
- 21:42When I'm in a trade, I want to have a
- 21:44strong opinions because with strong
- 21:45opinions, that allows me to have a big
- 21:47enough position that it matters. Uh but
- 21:51I also want to have that opinion weekly
- 21:54hell so that I could be and and that's
- 21:57where I get grief on Twitter is I may be
- 22:01uh constructive on Bitcoin
- 22:04last month and now I'm not constructive
- 22:07this month. And you know people don't
- 22:09understand that. People on Twitter
- 22:11cannot comprehend that a trader could
- 22:14hold binary opinions of a market in any
- 22:18given time. that just escapes their
- 22:20ability to comprehend. But I I want to
- 22:23be basically agnostic about markets. I
- 22:26will have opinions, but I can drop them
- 22:28in a day.
- 22:30>> I love that. And you know, also kind of
- 22:34[clears throat] you you say that, but
- 22:36really your data points to that as well
- 22:38because looking at the last 12 years of
- 22:41for instance, your win rate, you're at a
- 22:4454%. Is that correct? Over the last 12
- 22:46years. Yeah, I'm I'm under 50 this year.
- 22:49This year's been, you know, been a
- 22:51gruesome year. Markets have been choppy,
- 22:52but I I would, you know, Kevin, the
- 22:55people that they're chasing after 80%
- 22:57win rates are they're in dream world.
- 23:00That's goddamn world. Uh, you know, most
- 23:03professional traders who do this for a
- 23:06career would say they're somewhere 50%
- 23:08plus or minus 6 or 7%. I mean, they're
- 23:12somewhere in the 40s or somewhere in the
- 23:1450s. Very few would be much higher than
- 23:16that. Maybe some of the options guys
- 23:18might be. But yeah, I I mean the key to
- 23:20this thing and the thing that that the
- 23:22old guys, keep in mind when I b joined
- 23:24the board of trade, there were guys in
- 23:26the pit that were World War II veterans.
- 23:28They fought on Omaha Beach. These guys
- 23:31knew what it was like to be in in in
- 23:33battle conditions. And they would just
- 23:36drill into us young guys, cut your
- 23:39losses short, but have some way where
- 23:42you can allow a winning trade to grow.
- 23:44And the only way you can do it
- 23:46statistically, the only way probability
- 23:49theory works is if losses get cut quick
- 23:53and you have some provision to not to
- 23:56avoid the temptation of taking the first
- 23:58profit that comes along. You don't want
- 24:00to date the first good-looking girl that
- 24:02you see. Uh, you know, you you want you
- 24:05want to get a good one and hang on to it
- 24:07for a while.
- 24:08Well, I'm sure we could explore that
- 24:10topic with you as well, but uh you know,
- 24:13it reminds me of the three principles
- 24:15that George Coyle brought up amongst
- 24:17studying hundreds of years of the best
- 24:19traders, that is respect the trend, the
- 24:21price action, let your winners run, and
- 24:23cut the losses early. I was watching an
- 24:26interview with you and Jason Shapiro and
- 24:28he was he had a I believe in that one he
- 24:30said he had a 38% uh win rate but he
- 24:34said I mean just again what going off of
- 24:36what you said as well he would take four
- 24:39steps forward two steps back four steps
- 24:41forward two steps back so so it's just
- 24:43the winners you just got to maximize
- 24:45like you were saying Peter just don't
- 24:47get so eager to take those off almost
- 24:50like once you take the trade we're
- 24:51almost getting in the way of those
- 24:52trades right like right there after so
- 24:54maybe step away, shut the computer down
- 24:56as some would re recommend. Uh but why
- 24:59has that myth persisted do you think
- 25:01over all these years that okay we need
- 25:03to 70 80 90% win rate why has that myth
- 25:06persisted?
- 25:07>> Uh here I think there's some psychology
- 25:09behind it. Uh I think that people that
- 25:12start trading taking their trades
- 25:14personally. I mean if if they have a
- 25:16losing trade somehow there's self-
- 25:18condemnation. Um I I did something
- 25:21wrong.
- 25:23uh I I didn't study enough. I this is my
- 25:26fault. That they reflect it back on
- 25:28their character. Look, the marketplace,
- 25:31the computer that by which people put in
- 25:34orders in the S&P, they don't know who
- 25:36some trader. They care less. Uh the
- 25:39price action disregards any individual
- 25:42for who or what he he or she is. and you
- 25:45you know and so there's this thing like
- 25:48I need a high win rate in order to
- 25:50believe in myself as as opposed to
- 25:53understanding probability theory. Uh and
- 25:57so I think that it's it's the desire not
- 26:00to lose that that somehow they feel that
- 26:03a losing trade is a negative as opposed
- 26:06to just the next trade for me is the is
- 26:09the net it's the next datam point in a
- 26:12series of data points subject to random
- 26:15probability theory. It it means nothing.
- 26:17The next trade's insignificant. you to
- 26:19take the name of the commodity or stock
- 26:21off the chart in the upper leftand
- 26:23corner and I'm just trading price. I'm
- 26:26not trading IBM or Cisco or Apple
- 26:30computer or or grains. I'm trading price
- 26:33level and and that's the way it is. You
- 26:36just don't wrap yourself up in in
- 26:39somehow reflect what you're doing as as
- 26:42a reflection of character trade.
- 26:44>> So traders take it kind of personally.
- 26:46Okay.
- 26:47>> Yeah.
- 26:48>> Wise words. Yeah,
- 26:49>> there's one other point on it. You
- 26:50mentioned something is watching the
- 26:52markets during the day, Kevin. My
- 26:55recommendation to people is you would be
- 26:58far better off if you shut your computer
- 27:00up during the day, especially if you
- 27:04know here's here's the real there's a
- 27:06lot of research that's been done on
- 27:08trader success, Kevin. There's a lot of
- 27:10good research done by exchanges, by
- 27:12academic communities, by government
- 27:14regulators, not only in the US, but in
- 27:17the UK, in Asia. And the reality is if
- 27:21you take somebody that is trying to
- 27:24trade and let's say they have three
- 27:25years of experience so far, they they
- 27:28they've been in this thing and they want
- 27:29to trade, they have three years of
- 27:31experience. Now what is the probability
- 27:33then that they will go on and average
- 27:3630% a year for this for the next five
- 27:38years with only one losing year? If you
- 27:42if you really research the data, hard
- 27:46statistical data, it will tell you that
- 27:49there's only five and 1,000 people that
- 27:52will achieve that. That to be a market
- 27:54wizard, that is one in a 100,000 people.
- 27:58uh that people can do 100% a year for a
- 28:01three-year period. That's one in 10,000
- 28:04people. The probability of success, but
- 28:07people don't want to believe that, you
- 28:09know, anyone. And hey, good for them.
- 28:11You know, if anyone in your audience is
- 28:13hearing this, I I would encourage him to
- 28:16pursue trading. It's a wonderful thing
- 28:18to do. But I would just tell them, you
- 28:21need to understand the risks because
- 28:24only if you understand the risks and the
- 28:27probability
- 28:28will you approach trading as a common
- 28:31sense business as opposed to just some
- 28:34wild gambling venture.
- 28:36>> You know, that's a common theme amongst
- 28:39the wizards as well. I noticed that and
- 28:41Jack pointed out too in our interview
- 28:43that they manage risk above all else. In
- 28:47fact, you wrote this, Peter. Um, a
- 28:51strong stomach for losers and a
- 28:54miniature pride in the need for winners
- 28:56are necessary for consistently
- 28:59profitable trading. I was wondering if
- 29:01you could explain that a little bit.
- 29:03Having that strong stomach for losers.
- 29:05Yeah,
- 29:06>> you've got to take a loser and just go
- 29:08on. You know, loser again, it's a datim
- 29:10point. It's I have losers. I have
- 29:14losers. I move on. Two years ago, I had
- 29:16a string, Kevin, where in a 21 trade
- 29:20sequence that I did, entry, right? Entry
- 29:23trades that I put on 21 trades, 19 were
- 29:25losers. You know, that didn't phase me.
- 29:28That didn't make me want to say, I need
- 29:30to change something. Um, my system
- 29:33doesn't work. I need to figure out
- 29:35something. I need to quit trading. It
- 29:37didn't phase me because I understand
- 29:38that that can occur. That's more than a
- 29:41one standard deviation event for me, but
- 29:43it but it can occur. And so when I look
- 29:46and break down what trading is, I I
- 29:49really kind of break it down into
- 29:50components, one of those components is
- 29:53your trade selection. And that's what
- 29:55most noviceses uh focus on, right? Is
- 29:59where is a signal? What's my setup? Is
- 30:01my where is my setup? Can I find a
- 30:03setup? And so that's one component.
- 30:05There's trade management is a component.
- 30:08What do you do with the trade once it's
- 30:09on? Risk management, money management.
- 30:12How much do you risk on a trade? How do
- 30:14you cut losses? Then there's just your
- 30:16whole process. I know what I'm going to
- 30:18be doing. If I'm alive three years from
- 30:20now, I know what I'm going to be doing
- 30:22at 10:00 in the morning on Friday
- 30:24because I my my trade is is is is very
- 30:28well defined. What I do every day of the
- 30:30week is very well defined. I have a
- 30:31process. I have a process. And then what
- 30:34what you need is be properly capitalized
- 30:37and and have an ability to analyze what
- 30:40you're doing and make corrections that
- 30:41you can. And so you all of those define
- 30:44what your niche is. And most novice
- 30:46traders think that trade identification
- 30:48is what it's all about. I contribute of
- 30:52my niche. I think trade identification
- 30:55represents about 5%. 5% of my n my
- 30:58advantage comes from trade
- 31:00identification. It's insignificant.
- 31:02Trade identification doesn't matter at
- 31:04the end of the day. It's how you manage
- 31:05risk. Yeah, that was one of the most
- 31:07fascinating topics when I was reading
- 31:10your book that you had said, you know,
- 31:12it's just most traders spend nearly all
- 31:15of their time trying to search for
- 31:18entries and you were saying this is a
- 31:20mistake. I mean, I I liked what you
- 31:22related it to. You related it to poker
- 31:24and how it's less important what hand
- 31:27you have, but maybe it's more important
- 31:29how you play that hand. Uh, do you think
- 31:32that's one of the largest mistakes
- 31:34traders make? Oh, it absolutely is. I
- 31:37want to talk about introduce something,
- 31:39Kevin, that I think it's really
- 31:40important that those traders uh among
- 31:43your audience that have really made it
- 31:45and have have been successful trading
- 31:47will be able to relate to. There was an
- 31:4818th century Italian, Swiss, French
- 31:53economist by the name of Vilfredo
- 31:55Pareto. And everybody knows about the
- 31:58Pareto principle that 20%
- 32:01of of events represent 80% of of
- 32:06outcome, right? That if you do something
- 32:08anything, 100% of the people in church,
- 32:1120% of the people in church do 80% of
- 32:14the volunteer work. you know, 20% of
- 32:16what you do produces 80% of the results.
- 32:18And I have never found a trader who does
- 32:22not tell me that 20% of their trading
- 32:25events produces at least 80% of their
- 32:28net profits. That's a datam point that I
- 32:30keep every year. I look at that every
- 32:32year. I look through every trade I've
- 32:34done every year. And I have every trade
- 32:36going back decades that I have done. And
- 32:38year in and year out, I find that about
- 32:4115% of my trades produce about 85% of my
- 32:44profits. And I think that's true for all
- 32:47traders. I think anybody who is out
- 32:49there that's an aspiring trader, I would
- 32:51encourage him to keep track of that
- 32:53number because I think what they will
- 32:54find is that will be true to them. So
- 32:57the challenge then becomes what do you
- 32:58do with the 85% because the 85% has got
- 33:02to break even for the 15% to give you
- 33:04your money.
- 33:05>> Man, that is so good. You know, since I
- 33:07started doing the podcast, that's really
- 33:09something I noticed too, Peter, and and
- 33:11talking to the best traders out there.
- 33:14They're looking for these asymmetric
- 33:16opportunities. That was another big
- 33:18theme amongst the wizards, right?
- 33:19Looking for asymmetric trades, as Jack
- 33:22points out. But you did a survey once
- 33:24yourself where you asked, uh, would you
- 33:26rather trade a system that's right 30%
- 33:29of the time or trade a system that's
- 33:31right 70% of the time? You asked
- 33:33professional traders and they
- 33:35overwhelmingly preferred the 30% system.
- 33:38Why is that?
- 33:39>> Well, and that was among floor traders.
- 33:41Okay. And so that was a little informal
- 33:43poll that I did at board of trade in the
- 33:46pits is I handed out a deal to a bunch
- 33:49of I don't know there might have been
- 33:50hundred traders that were trading in the
- 33:52pits. I said would you please give me
- 33:54your answer to this and hand me back at
- 33:56the end of the day. And the reason is at
- 33:5880% you're probably your air rate. All
- 34:02of a sudden something goes kooky on you
- 34:04and you go into a 60% period and you're
- 34:08cooked. Where a professional trader
- 34:10understands that if you can make money
- 34:12at 30% right, you have got a better
- 34:17system in terms of probability because
- 34:19it represents that your risk management
- 34:22is better. that if you have to be right
- 34:2470 or 80% of the time that you have very
- 34:27little margin for error. Because the
- 34:30reality is that if you're right seven
- 34:32out of 10 times, that's seven out of 10
- 34:35times over a thousand trades. And any
- 34:38subgrouping of 10 or 20 trades within
- 34:41that thousand trades, you you get into
- 34:44random probability where you can be
- 34:46wrong 10 straight trades. Uh and and you
- 34:49know if you're not prepared for that is
- 34:52it's you're cooked.
- 34:53>> Yeah. And you even mentioned that some
- 34:56of the trades that you'll take uh this
- 34:58is on the emotional side of things where
- 35:00it will be the ones you're you're least
- 35:02expecting to be among the 10 or 15% that
- 35:06ultimately result in the net 80% more of
- 35:09uh profit on the year.
- 35:10>> You there's something that I call
- 35:12conventional wisdom. Conventional wisdom
- 35:14is the story that they're telling about
- 35:16the stock market. basically on CNBC or
- 35:18Bloomberg. It it's it's the it's the
- 35:20narrative that most people accept. It's
- 35:23gold goes up because of money supply.
- 35:25It's it's some of those narratives.
- 35:27Silver goes up because Hong Kong silver
- 35:29is trading at a premium. And so you have
- 35:31these narratives that come into play.
- 35:33And the reality is is you've got to be
- 35:37prepared for for the surprise in in in
- 35:40what you're doing. And I am not unaware
- 35:44of what conventional wisdom is because,
- 35:46you know, I'm on Twitter so I see what
- 35:48most people think. And what I found is
- 35:51if it's easy for me to do a trade, and
- 35:53it's easy for me to do a trade if I look
- 35:55on social media and everybody agrees
- 35:57with. I'm going to do a trade that
- 35:58everybody agrees with. That gives me a
- 36:01little comfort in the stomach.
- 36:03>> But by and large, those trades are the
- 36:05losers. and it is the trade that to me
- 36:08becomes clear that's let's say a short
- 36:11side trade and social media is basically
- 36:14bending the other way that's a little
- 36:16bit harder to do because I'm going
- 36:17against the grain of what people think
- 36:19and so I'm not unaware of of of
- 36:22sentiment and it's those trades that I
- 36:26think are less likely to be assumed to
- 36:29be correct by the masses those are the
- 36:31trades for me that generally will become
- 36:33the big winners Can you give us an
- 36:36example of one of those home run trades
- 36:38and maybe how they look different uh
- 36:41relative to a loser and also do you do
- 36:44you kind of pyramid into those positions
- 36:47sizing in
- 36:48>> no you know sizing is really important
- 36:52and sizing is the reason that a lot of
- 36:55noviceses blow up Kevin you know my rule
- 36:58is I only risk a a basis point 100 basis
- 37:02points is 1% of capital right So, let's
- 37:05just use a round number that I've got a
- 37:07million dollar account. 1% of a million
- 37:09dollars is $10,000. I will not risk
- 37:12$10,000 on a trade if it's a million
- 37:14dollar capitalized account. I will only
- 37:17risk $6,000, which is basically 60 basis
- 37:21points. I'll risk 610 of 1% of my
- 37:24capital on a trade. And there are
- 37:26noviceses out there that are risking
- 37:28five 10% of their capital on a given
- 37:31trade. That's the risk. That is a
- 37:33guaranteed tap out. They will not make
- 37:36it. They They may get lucky. They may
- 37:39They may hit some big home runs at
- 37:41first, but if they continue to do that
- 37:43kind of sizing, sooner or later the
- 37:46market's going to take them out on a
- 37:47stretcher. Uh it's just a matter of of
- 37:51keeping risk down so that you keep
- 37:54drawowns down. I hate draw downs, Kevin,
- 37:58because it means that I have to make the
- 38:00same money all over again. And if you
- 38:03have a trader that's putting on too much
- 38:06size, you know, they're going to make
- 38:0820% on one trade, they're going to lose
- 38:11the 20%, they'll be up 40%, then they go
- 38:14down 40%. You know, you lose 30% of your
- 38:17capital, you have to make it all over
- 38:18again. And and there was a point in my
- 38:20trading where I decided, I don't want to
- 38:22have to make the same money all over
- 38:24again. I need to make changes in the way
- 38:26I trade so that I can control my draw
- 38:29down. That I don't want to have to make
- 38:32the same dollar over and over and over
- 38:35again. It's harder to keep money than it
- 38:37is to make money. It's easy to make
- 38:39money in the markets. All you have to do
- 38:41is last long enough and have enough
- 38:42money, you're going to make money in the
- 38:44markets. Keeping it the hard part. It's
- 38:47hard keeping profits. And that's where
- 38:49my focus is. Is winners will come. All I
- 38:53have to do is stay alive and protect my
- 38:55capital. I will have winners, but then I
- 38:58have to protect the capital.
- 39:00>> So, would you say you s I mean the one%
- 39:02you're risking, is that consistent
- 39:04across different uh maybe strategies or
- 39:07patterns that you're trading? We can of
- 39:09course dive into some of those patterns
- 39:10as well, but you keep it consistent.
- 39:12>> Well, it's actually less than 1%. 60 to
- 39:1570 basis points. So, it's 610 to 7/10%.
- 39:18That's a standard risk. I don't I don't
- 39:20care whether I go short gold or long
- 39:22corn or long sugar in London or short
- 39:25the Nikkai. Uh I I am risking the same
- 39:29dollar amount on every trade that I do.
- 39:32I enter my trades all at once. I do not
- 39:34pyramid. I do not layer in. I wait for a
- 39:37signal and I and I basically blow I I
- 39:41basically enter the entire amount 100%
- 39:44of the trades at the same approximate
- 39:46price. Now I use stop orders to get in.
- 39:48So, I may get split fills, but you know,
- 39:52that's the way I get into trades. It's
- 39:53all at once. Uh, at that point, I do.
- 39:56Pyramiding is dangerous. I I mean,
- 39:58pyramiding is a real skill. Some people
- 40:00have the skill of pyramiding. I don't
- 40:03like pyramiding because if you're
- 40:04pyramiding, you're either adding to a
- 40:06loser, which is foolish, or if you're
- 40:09adding to a winner, you're raising your
- 40:12average price of entry, which puts you
- 40:16more vulnerable to corrections.
- 40:18And so that for that reason I enter all
- 40:21at once and I'll take partial profits
- 40:25not real quickly but within a week or
- 40:28two if I have some money up and I'm up
- 40:30on a trade I'll get out of it and that
- 40:33gives me more staying power in the other
- 40:35half. There's nothing wrong with taking
- 40:37money off the table.
- 40:38>> The topic fascinates me so much. I've
- 40:41heard different opinions like adding to
- 40:43winners and then of course not p pouring
- 40:46fuel on a fire with the losers and then
- 40:49of course the single entries that you're
- 40:51uh suggesting as well. So traders that
- 40:53are listening let us know in the
- 40:54comments what you do that that topic
- 40:58really fascinates me. But um but really
- 41:01what it sounds like, Peter, is you're
- 41:03trying to remain emotionally neutral
- 41:05across the board, and you don't know
- 41:07necessarily which trade is going to be
- 41:09the best trade of the year, the loser,
- 41:11and so you're sizing them pretty uh
- 41:15consistently. Uh and and you just
- 41:18embrace the risk, shut the computer
- 41:19down, embrace whatever that result's
- 41:21going to be. Is that a fair assessment?
- 41:23>> Yeah. Uh I mean, so I trade futures, I
- 41:26trade spot forex sometimes. I mean, I
- 41:28prefer to trade currencies at the at the
- 41:31CME. I prefer to be in currency markets.
- 41:33I I I'll trade crypto and I do trade
- 41:35stocks in the company account. Not very
- 41:37often, but I trade stocks. Within the
- 41:39last month, I had the best trade I've
- 41:41had in four years. And it was on a stock
- 41:43that I didn't know anything about. I
- 41:45like the chart. It's set up in an in an
- 41:48unbelievably asymmetric way that allowed
- 41:51me to put on a huge position with the
- 41:54same amount of risk with that 70 basis
- 41:56point risk. Uh and it was the best trade
- 42:00I've had as far as I you know I think in
- 42:03four years. I had no expectations for
- 42:05the trade uh other than I put the trade
- 42:08on and I looked at my statement the next
- 42:10day and all of a sudden I have a huge
- 42:12profit in this trade. And so I pull back
- 42:15up the chart and I go, "Holy cow." Um
- 42:19because I don't like looking at prices
- 42:21during the day, Kevin. I I want to enter
- 42:23my orders. And my my routine is this. I
- 42:27scroll my entire list on a Friday
- 42:30afternoon. On a Friday afternoon, I
- 42:32scroll every conceivable market that I
- 42:34might trade. On that list, I will pick
- 42:36out maybe 10 charts that I really like.
- 42:40I will review those 10 charts. Ever
- 42:43watch a stock rip and think, "I could
- 42:45have nailed that if I had real capital."
- 42:47The truth is, many capable traders never
- 42:49reach their potential. Not due to lack
- 42:51of skill, but lack of scale. Trade the
- 42:54Pool was built to solve exactly that. A
- 42:56firm designed for serious individuals
- 42:58who want access to the US equity markets
- 43:01with meaningful buying power up to
- 43:03$200,000 without committing their own
- 43:05capital. Get access to virtually every
- 43:07stock and ETF. Go long or short freely
- 43:10with the flexibility professional
- 43:11traders expect. You're evaluated on one
- 43:14thing, your ability to manage risk and
- 43:16execute with consistency. Meet the
- 43:19standard and you trade at scale. No
- 43:21subscriptions, no ongoing commitments.
- 43:23Whether you're still refining your
- 43:25strategy, a trader with experience who
- 43:27hasn't yet broken through, or a seasoned
- 43:30professional simply looking for more
- 43:31capital, Trade the Pool is built to meet
- 43:34you where you are and take you that next
- 43:36step further. The markets have evolved.
- 43:38Access has evolved. Now, so has the way
- 43:41traders operate within them. Trade the
- 43:44pool.
- 43:44>> So, by Sunday, I have a really good idea
- 43:46of what markets uh I need to be involved
- 43:49in. I have, you know, six, seven, eight
- 43:51charts that I'm looking at. And I put in
- 43:53all open orders. There'll be open order
- 43:55stops on the trades for which I have a
- 43:57position. It'll be open order entry
- 43:59stops on the trades I want to uh enter
- 44:02if certain chart patterns break out.
- 44:04That and that's my script for the week.
- 44:06I might add one other market during the
- 44:09course of the week. I normally do not
- 44:11like to because I really like to turn
- 44:13off my computer. I I'll I'll review my
- 44:17orders early Monday morning. I wake up 3
- 44:194 in the morning, review my orders to
- 44:21see where markets were overnight and and
- 44:24really try to remove myself from the
- 44:26day's action. I just found Kevin that my
- 44:30challenge as a trader is to remove
- 44:32myself from the equation is to really
- 44:35become an order placer that I'm not a
- 44:37trader that I'm a I I'm a person who can
- 44:40enter orders that make sense turn off my
- 44:43computer at the end of the day I find
- 44:44out what orders might have been filled
- 44:47what markets I've been stopped out of
- 44:49what markets I've entered uh and uh then
- 44:53start again the next day so I try to
- 44:57remove my emotions from the equation. Uh
- 44:59I you know I have just found and I found
- 45:01this true for a lot of traders that
- 45:04their own worst enemy becoming a
- 45:06successful trader to a large degree is
- 45:09overcoming self. You know, if you really
- 45:11want to know who you are as a person,
- 45:13deep down inside, be honest with
- 45:15yourself and become a trader because a
- 45:18person will find out the good, bad, and
- 45:19the really ugly. And the really ugly
- 45:22attempts to sabotage us from success.
- 45:25And and so that's really been my
- 45:28challenge as a trader through the years
- 45:30is to become very process driven.
- 45:33[snorts] Do the same things over and
- 45:35over and over again. Try to remove my
- 45:37own judgment from the market. Try to
- 45:40follow rules. I'm a rules-based trader.
- 45:43And I have rules about just about
- 45:45everything. And when I get into trouble,
- 45:48Kevin, it's usually because I
- 45:49secondguess my rules. I don't follow my
- 45:52rules. I stray from the path and I pay
- 45:56the price. And and that happens from
- 45:58time to time. It'll happen to everybody
- 46:00from time to time unless you're a
- 46:02completely systematic trader all the way
- 46:05from sizing to order entry. U but there
- 46:08are not a lot of traders who trade like
- 46:10Renaissance technology. shot.
- 46:12>> Yeah. I I find that there's a lot of
- 46:15wisdom in hearing from Peter Brandt
- 46:17who's had over 50 years in this industry
- 46:20that emotions can still exist and we can
- 46:24still get in our own way. What What do
- 46:27those emotions look like for you 50
- 46:29years later? Because I Peter I think
- 46:31there's this other myth out there that
- 46:33exists that when traders they uh when
- 46:37they start this journey they think that
- 46:38at some point that emotions will just go
- 46:42away. Do they ever?
- 46:44>> I think maybe for some uh I I mean
- 46:46everybody's putting together different I
- 46:48think and that's a real challenge in the
- 46:50market is finding out who you are. Uh I
- 46:53mean I think that leads to you know
- 46:55somewhere just under a hundred market
- 46:57wizards who have found completely
- 46:59different solutions. There's not a
- 47:00market wizard that really trades the
- 47:03same way. The interesting thing is that
- 47:06there are from time to time market
- 47:07wizards get together. We have little
- 47:10retreats and there might be 20 or 25
- 47:12market wizards that get together. The
- 47:14things they don't talk about are do you
- 47:16use RSI and what moving average do you
- 47:19use and what's your chart scale? Those
- 47:23are not things
- 47:25professional traders really talk about.
- 47:26It's more like when you get home after a
- 47:28bad day, does your dog know that you had
- 47:30a bad day? You know, how do you tell
- 47:32your wife she can't be on a budget? Th
- 47:34those are the kind of things traders
- 47:36talk about. But yeah, I mean, I'm like
- 47:40anyone else. I'm a human being. And if I
- 47:43watch myself, if I start paying
- 47:45attention to to to markets during the
- 47:47day, if I would to start all of a sudden
- 47:50looking at hourly charts, you know, that
- 47:53the temptation is to find a reason to
- 47:55get out of a profitable trade, it it
- 47:58it's self-sabotaging. And so for me, uh
- 48:01I I want to become objective and
- 48:04detached as possible from a chart. I
- 48:06don't want my emotions to become
- 48:08involved in a chart. I don't want to
- 48:10become a have a narrative start playing
- 48:12in my head. And the way that I can do
- 48:14that is to try to reduce myself to
- 48:17reduce the equation between a chart and
- 48:20the rules that I've set in place for
- 48:23trading that chart for entering a trade
- 48:25for sizing trade for studying an initial
- 48:28stop. What rules do I use for advancing
- 48:30a stop? What rules do I use for taking
- 48:32profits? uh what rules do I have for you
- 48:37similar trades that really represent
- 48:39highly correlated risk? Those are the
- 48:42things that I've put together over the
- 48:44years to really become finely tuned. Um
- 48:48and and it's not necessarily perfect.
- 48:51You know, I use a moving average to uh
- 48:54as a proxy for trend. And people will
- 48:56say, well, why that moving average?
- 48:58Haven't you done back testing? I do not
- 49:01believe in optimization. And I I will
- 49:03tell your audience that optimization is
- 49:05a myth where you optimize rules. You
- 49:08have a set of rules and you you you you
- 49:12do those set of rules over and over and
- 49:15over again. Are there more perfect rules
- 49:17that I've created? Uh could I could I be
- 49:21optimizing the kind of breakouts? I do
- 49:24not believe in optimization. I believe
- 49:26that my rules are imperfect. There is no
- 49:29single trade that I I can remember this
- 49:32year for instance where when I look back
- 49:35at the trade I I I might not have said
- 49:38to myself well if I would have done this
- 49:40a little differently there would have
- 49:41been a a little bit bit better results
- 49:44if I would have done this a little bit
- 49:46different it wouldn't have been a loss
- 49:48it might have been break even and and we
- 49:50can't allow ourselves to do that to
- 49:52second guessess every decision we make
- 49:55we need to have a set of rules and those
- 49:57set of rules Rules that are imperfect
- 49:59are better than trying to trade a market
- 50:01without a set of rules and letting
- 50:03emotions dictate our buy and sell
- 50:05orders. FOMO enters in, flooders
- 50:09enters in. Those are the things I want
- 50:11to remove from the equation.
- 50:14[sighs and gasps]
- 50:14Yeah. Several points I want to touch on
- 50:17there. And do do you say you that you
- 50:20don't optimize anymore because you've
- 50:22seen just that traders they adjust for
- 50:25example maybe their risk parameters mid
- 50:27trade and it's a very amateur thing to
- 50:30do and Peter's more processoriented
- 50:33versus resultsoriented.
- 50:37>> Yeah I mean rate of return is not a
- 50:40result that I care about actually. Uh
- 50:42you know I don't sharp ratio is a joke.
- 50:45I'm very metrics oriented by the way
- 50:47Kevin I am very attuned to what the
- 50:49metrics of my trading are uh over any
- 50:52given period of 50 trades 200 trades
- 50:56thousand trades I'm very metric oriented
- 50:58I know my metrics inside and out you
- 51:01know so you know I'll ask somebody who
- 51:03is an aspiring trader so what's your
- 51:05expected value what's your profit factor
- 51:07what's your calmar and they look at me
- 51:09like deers in the headlights you know
- 51:11trading is a business you don't operate
- 51:14a McDonald's franchise and and not know
- 51:17what your profit margins are on
- 51:18chocolate shakes. You you don't know how
- 51:21many GL
- 51:23paper [clears throat] cups you need to
- 51:24have an inventory. Those are things you
- 51:26need to know. You need to know the
- 51:27metrics of a business. And you know,
- 51:30people start trading and all they care
- 51:32about is rates of return. How many X are
- 51:35you getting? They don't really keep
- 51:37track of metrics that you need to keep
- 51:39track of uh in the process of running a
- 51:42trading business. and and and so those
- 51:45are the things that I am attuned to.
- 51:47Rate of return I let take care of
- 51:49itself. I don't really care. It's not a
- 51:51metric that I keep track of. Um you know
- 51:54I want to keep track of what's my
- 51:56expected value. What's my profit factor?
- 51:58If you can generate an expected value
- 52:01that's 20 30 basis points a trade over
- 52:05100 trades. If you can if you can do a
- 52:09profit factor of
- 52:123.0 0 over 100 trades without a draw
- 52:15down greater than 15% peak to valley and
- 52:18you can do that over 100 trades and you
- 52:20know that you can do the exact 100
- 52:23trades next year that the trade you did
- 52:26in live cattle futures will be the exact
- 52:29trade that you'll do two years from now
- 52:31in London sugar in terms of a setup you
- 52:34repeat the setup wash rinse repeat over
- 52:38and over again and I don't really care
- 52:41whether my my that I optimize. I don't
- 52:44believe in optimizing. I don't believe
- 52:46that rules can be optimized because next
- 52:49year's markets are going to be different
- 52:51than this year's markets. The markets
- 52:54two years ago are going to be different
- 52:55than the markets two years from now. And
- 52:58markets change personality. And the best
- 53:01we can do is just implement a set of
- 53:04rules that we know will give us give us
- 53:07expected value with a no worst case draw
- 53:11down over a certain amount over a period
- 53:14in. So what I challenge somebody to do
- 53:16is come up with rules that you can
- 53:18follow. They've got to be simple, but
- 53:20you've got to be able to follow them.
- 53:22You have to be true to them and do those
- 53:25rules in whatever asset class that you
- 53:28trade. Execute those rules over a 100
- 53:32trades. See where you are. Make small
- 53:35adjustments. Try them over another 100
- 53:38trades. See where you are. Because you
- 53:41don't really know whether you have an
- 53:43edge unless you follow the exact same
- 53:46trading rules over at least two to 300
- 53:48trades and run the metrics and run them
- 53:51through Monte Carlo simulators and see
- 53:54what your equity curve is. And that's
- 53:56the only way as a trader that you
- 53:58actually find out do you have an edge to
- 54:01exploit or not.
- 54:03>> Absolutely. You know, there's there's
- 54:05something I certainly want to explore
- 54:07there as well. And and with these rules
- 54:09and we know you're a chartist. I want to
- 54:12get into that as well. But let's take
- 54:14for example one of your favorite charts
- 54:17that you like to trade. and give us some
- 54:19give us some rules uh just some inherent
- 54:21rules in your strategy for the listeners
- 54:23that you apply even prior to ever
- 54:26entering the trade if let's say if
- 54:27you're taking uh the rectangle or
- 54:29descending triangle give us some of
- 54:31those rules
- 54:32>> I I don't like diagonal lines on charts
- 54:36uh trend lines are diagonal line lines
- 54:39to a symmetrical triangle are diagonal
- 54:41lines channel lines are are diagonal
- 54:43lines I don't like diagonal lines I like
- 54:46horizontal patterns And that would be a
- 54:49right angle triangle. It would be a
- 54:52rectangle in head and shoulders. I like
- 54:55continuation patterns. I do not like uh
- 54:58I I do not like reversal patterns. An
- 55:03example of a of a
- 55:07of a a
- 55:09of a of a um
- 55:12of a pattern that's not diagonal. might
- 55:14have been a cup and handle that we had
- 55:16in the Dow Jones recently. Uh it
- 55:18definitely Euro stocks futures have had
- 55:22uh rectangles or right angle triangles.
- 55:25So I like a diagonal pattern or I'm
- 55:28sorry I like a horizontal pattern such
- 55:30as a rectangle that lasts somewhere
- 55:32between 8 to 12 weeks. That's my sweet
- 55:34spot. Maybe 8 to 14 weeks. And
- 55:37>> so I look at at a chart and I can draw a
- 55:39rectangle or I think some people might
- 55:42also uh refer to them, you know, as a
- 55:47box pattern or something like that. And
- 55:50so I'd like to have it be contained
- 55:52within a price range of about 15% of the
- 55:55price. And so let's say it's a commodity
- 55:58that's trading at 100, whatever. I'd
- 56:01like to see a rectangle that is 8 to 14
- 56:03weeks uh in duration. I'd like to see it
- 56:06within a 15% range. So between 85 and
- 56:10100 in the case of just trying to use
- 56:12examples. Uh I like to see the only uh
- 56:16uh indicator I use. I do not use
- 56:18indicators Kevin. I don't believe in
- 56:20indicators. Indicators are just simply a
- 56:23derivative of price. Why study an
- 56:25indicator when I can study price
- 56:26directly? And but I do use ADX because
- 56:29it shows me compression. And I like to
- 56:32see an ADX reading. And that's a 14-day
- 56:35ADX somewhere under 12, maybe close to
- 56:3910. And so we have this pattern uh
- 56:42that's like a Darvis box. It's a
- 56:45rectangle. It's right angle triangle.
- 56:47It's 14 weeks long. Uh ADX comes market
- 56:51drifts higher. Um I use moving averages
- 56:55as a proxy for trend. I use an 18 and 18
- 56:58and 18 day moving average. And so the
- 57:01market moves up and we break out. And we
- 57:03break out by a certain amount. And what
- 57:06I use for a breakout is 50 50% of a
- 57:0930-day ATR. And so I use an ATR. It's
- 57:12the only time I use an ATR. Do not trail
- 57:14stops based on an ATR, but I do enter a
- 57:18market based on an ATR breakout. It's
- 57:20the only time I use ATR. But it just
- 57:22gives me a standardization for what a
- 57:25breakout is. I've just found again
- 57:27removing my emotions from a market. I
- 57:30want to adapt rules that I can follow
- 57:33that are simple for me to follow. And so
- 57:35that is where I put a a buy stop order
- 57:38to consider a breakout. And then I have
- 57:41set rules for sizing uh where if I enter
- 57:45a market at a certain price, I will know
- 57:48today for instance if I'm looking let's
- 57:50say at Euro stocks utility index futures
- 57:55which is a market I'm looking at and I
- 57:58I'll look at it today and it hasn't
- 58:00broken out. Well, I'll know where the
- 58:02breakout is and I know where I will
- 58:04probably set my protective stop if I am
- 58:07filled on a breakout and I just use
- 58:10those two numbers to work out what my
- 58:12sizing is. And uh you know I'll put in a
- 58:16stop order and when I put in a buy stop
- 58:18order to Ander Kevin, I attach to it a
- 58:21const a contingency sell order. So when
- 58:25my buy order is executed, my sell order
- 58:27automatically becomes active. I do not
- 58:30need to always be chasing the market to
- 58:32make sure that I have orders in. I want
- 58:34to make sure I have orders in to cover
- 58:36my risk at all times. Uh sure, I'm
- 58:39stopped out sometimes and I see a market
- 58:42stops me out and then goes. That
- 58:43happens. That's life. Uh I mean, that's
- 58:45why they call it speculation and not
- 58:47shity,
- 58:48>> but you don't optimize in those moments.
- 58:51>> I I don't you can't optimize those
- 58:52moments. It happens. Those things
- 58:54happen. I'm not going to beat myself up.
- 58:56Self forgiveness is an important trait
- 58:59for a trader to have because we're we're
- 59:02we're going to have those situations of
- 59:04could a would a should of could a would
- 59:05a should happen the reality of trading
- 59:09and and so I I want to try to have my
- 59:12trading model be auto drive as as much
- 59:17as possible. I want to I want my trading
- 59:19model to be like a Tesla. you know, I
- 59:22want to put in where it goes and put in
- 59:24the orders and let let the model really
- 59:26run itself during a week. And so I do
- 59:29that with open orders and at any given
- 59:32time I might have a position on in three
- 59:35and four or four futures markets and I
- 59:38may have orders in to enter maybe
- 59:40another two or three markets. And so
- 59:42that's it. You know, if I do, if I enter
- 59:44two markets, two trades in a week,
- 59:47that's about average for me is two to
- 59:49three new trades per week is about what
- 59:53I trade. You know, maybe uh maybe I'll
- 59:56do 150 trades in a year. Somewhere
- 59:59between 125 and 150 trades a year.
- 1:00:02That's that's my life.
- 1:00:04>> That's your life, man. Peter, thank you
- 1:00:06so much for sharing. I know the
- 1:00:07listeners are going to find tremendous
- 1:00:09value in all the detail you shared there
- 1:00:12and it's clear to me that when you
- 1:00:15discovered technical analysis uh that
- 1:00:17book by Edwards and McGee that you had
- 1:00:19read I mean that you fell in love even
- 1:00:22to this day technical analysis runs
- 1:00:25through your blood. What do you think it
- 1:00:27was? I mean again you had you were on a
- 1:00:29journey of un you were unprofitable
- 1:00:31until pretty much you read this book
- 1:00:33that gave you direction timing risk all
- 1:00:36these parameters and and rules what do
- 1:00:40you think it was and and all by the way
- 1:00:42also in the 70s charting wasn't
- 1:00:45necessarily the most popular thing was
- 1:00:47it I imagine fundamentals were more
- 1:00:49popular at that point
- 1:00:50>> back in the 1970s there were no day
- 1:00:52traders except for those people in the
- 1:00:54pit if you were a retail trader you did
- 1:00:56not day trade. They were rare because
- 1:00:59commission rates were high. You know,
- 1:01:01you'd pay you do a contract of coin. It
- 1:01:03was a $30 commission. Um, you know, that
- 1:01:06was the going rate for a retailer. You'd
- 1:01:08pay $50 commission per contract of
- 1:01:11futures you traded. Now, I was a member
- 1:01:13of the Board of Trade, so I had I had
- 1:01:15cheaper rates than that. Hey, very low
- 1:01:17rates. But but but nevertheless,
- 1:01:21uh for me, you know, I I I'm a visual
- 1:01:25person, you know, as a kid, I I could
- 1:01:28spend
- 1:01:31giving, you know, we used to have maps
- 1:01:32printed. We used to have printed maps.
- 1:01:34We didn't, you know, nowadays you use
- 1:01:36your you know, you use your phone to get
- 1:01:38from point A to point B. You didn't back
- 1:01:40then. You had road maps. and and when
- 1:01:42you'd have an entire book of road maps
- 1:01:45for all 50 states. I could as a kid I
- 1:01:48could spend hours looking through the
- 1:01:49road maps. When I became a pilot, I was
- 1:01:53instrumentated as a pilot, but I still
- 1:01:55like flying VFR, visual flight rules,
- 1:01:58because I like flying with a map. I like
- 1:02:01knowing there's a grain elevator up
- 1:02:02ahead. I'm going to cross railroad
- 1:02:04tracks in in five nautical miles. Uh,
- 1:02:08you know, for me, I'm just highly
- 1:02:10visual. And so charts for me really
- 1:02:13resonate with who I am as trying to fit
- 1:02:16lines. I'd like to know where lines are
- 1:02:18and boundaries and you know where's the
- 1:02:20boundary. How you know how do you draw a
- 1:02:23boundary of a state? The Mississippi
- 1:02:25River is the boundary between Minne
- 1:02:27Minnesota and Wisconsin. You know it's
- 1:02:29it's either a it's you know that that's
- 1:02:32the way things are done. So I'm just
- 1:02:34always visual. So being a chartist for
- 1:02:36me is very very consistent with kind of
- 1:02:40my mind's uh attempt to always create
- 1:02:43some sort of order out of chaos. And for
- 1:02:47me that's what charting is. It's a
- 1:02:49systematic way to to sort order from
- 1:02:52what might be chaos.
- 1:02:54>> Now a lot of those same patterns that
- 1:02:55you were trading 50 years ago, are you
- 1:02:57trading much of the same today? You
- 1:03:00know, in in 19, this is funny, uh, uh,
- 1:03:03Kevin, funny story. In 1991, I was
- 1:03:06invited to do a feature speak speech at
- 1:03:10at what the time was the MTA, market
- 1:03:12technicians association. Today, it's
- 1:03:13called a certified market technicians.
- 1:03:16And it's what it's what technicians
- 1:03:18attempt to pass their test and become
- 1:03:20CMT certified. So, I I flew down to
- 1:03:23Florida to give a speech to uh, MTA in
- 1:03:271991. And a few years ago, uh, somebody
- 1:03:31sent me a copy of my speech and I
- 1:03:34because I have not kept a copy. And I
- 1:03:36looked at it and I go,
- 1:03:38>> not much has changed.
- 1:03:41>> I I pretty much trade there's a few
- 1:03:43patterns I don't trade anymore. I've
- 1:03:44eliminated diagonal patterns. I don't
- 1:03:47trade trend lines. I don't trade
- 1:03:49channels. I don't trade symmetrical
- 1:03:52triangles anymore. I don't trade wedges
- 1:03:54anymore. And so I've eliminated uh
- 1:03:57diagonal patterns and gone pretty much
- 1:03:59with horizontal patterns. But other than
- 1:04:01that, I could give the same speech
- 1:04:03today, you know, and so my trading has
- 1:04:06basically be unchanged now really since
- 1:04:09about 1981.
- 1:04:11I look back at the charts and I have
- 1:04:14kept charts over the years. I still have
- 1:04:16copies of charts of trades that I've did
- 1:04:1950 years ago. Uh uh yeah, I have a copy
- 1:04:22of a chart in copper that I did in in
- 1:04:251977
- 1:04:26and and so I look back and I'm looking
- 1:04:29for the same things in charts now that I
- 1:04:31look for then. I think I've become much
- 1:04:33more nuanced. I've become much more
- 1:04:36sophisticated in try in in timing, in
- 1:04:39sizing,
- 1:04:41uh in profit taking
- 1:04:44and some of those things. But in terms
- 1:04:47of just the basic patterns themselves, I
- 1:04:50pretty much trade the same things now
- 1:04:51that I traded in bonds in 1982.
- 1:04:55>> Now you you're trading similar patterns.
- 1:04:58Are you trading with a similar time
- 1:05:00frame? Because back then you were
- 1:05:01trading over periods ranging from like
- 1:05:03four weeks to months. Is it consistent?
- 1:05:06>> It's similar. I mean, I use weekly
- 1:05:08charts when I do my scroll on a Friday
- 1:05:11of every futures market in the in the
- 1:05:13world, you know, from and there are some
- 1:05:15great futures markets in Singapore to
- 1:05:18Tokyo,
- 1:05:20London, um, Winnipeg, Paris, and so I
- 1:05:26scroll through those markets and I
- 1:05:27scroll through weekly charts and I want
- 1:05:29to see something pop out at me. You
- 1:05:31know, people tell me they're going to go
- 1:05:32home and study their charts and I kind
- 1:05:34of go, "What does that mean?" Uh because
- 1:05:37I'll spend about a half a second on a
- 1:05:40chart when I do my scroll and something
- 1:05:42either pops out to me or it doesn't. And
- 1:05:45I guess that's because I've traded so
- 1:05:46many patterns, you know, thousands of
- 1:05:49patterns over the years that I kind of
- 1:05:51know instinctively this is something
- 1:05:53that interests me or not. And so I'll
- 1:05:55scroll through, you know, hundreds of
- 1:05:58charts in about a 15 20 minute period of
- 1:06:00time and and and the ones that pop out
- 1:06:03at me are the ones that I that I really
- 1:06:05pay attention to.
- 1:06:08>> Is there anything you can identify
- 1:06:09looking back though in 1980 that maybe
- 1:06:13worked then but doesn't work now for for
- 1:06:15example the introduction of high
- 1:06:17frequency trading like what did that
- 1:06:19have an impact you know today? Oh, that
- 1:06:21had a big impact. You know, I took uh in
- 1:06:231995, I actually took a hiatus for
- 1:06:26trading. I you know, I I felt like,
- 1:06:28okay, I' I've made money. I' I'm I'm
- 1:06:31fine. I don't need to work anymore if I
- 1:06:33don't want to. Uh and I had been
- 1:06:36trading, you know, at that point 20
- 1:06:38years. And 20 years, you know, you when
- 1:06:40you trade in your own account, you you
- 1:06:42know, it wears on you. Now, I think I've
- 1:06:44found different ways to have be able to
- 1:06:47s sustain myself without feeling uh as
- 1:06:50much pressure, but we used to keep our
- 1:06:51charts by hand back then. We'd start
- 1:06:53with a with a piece of paper and we'd
- 1:06:56create charts with with with with
- 1:06:59template paper. And so, there was a lot
- 1:07:01more work back then, but I think back in
- 1:07:03the 80s, chart patterns were actually
- 1:07:05more reliable. And I think they were
- 1:07:07more reliable because markets were less
- 1:07:09efficient back then, just as is now. I
- 1:07:13think some of the better patterns come
- 1:07:14out of the exchanges that don't have the
- 1:07:16liquidity that there might be better
- 1:07:19patterns that might come out of European
- 1:07:21wheat for instance than out of corn at
- 1:07:24the board of trade or out of a stock
- 1:07:26index in the Netherlands as opposed to
- 1:07:29the the S&P sometimes. So I think chart
- 1:07:33patterns were a little bit more reliable
- 1:07:35back in the in the 80s than they are
- 1:07:37now. And highfrequency trading really
- 1:07:40didn't start until we had computer
- 1:07:43trading with the GlobeEx became active.
- 1:07:45That was in the 2000s. You know, 2004,
- 1:07:482005, 2005 six or so, we had high
- 1:07:52frequency trading. And I think that
- 1:07:54affects day traders more than position
- 1:07:57traders. You know, I hold positions and
- 1:07:59so I think that I do not have the
- 1:08:01competition of high frequency traders
- 1:08:03that a day trader would have.
- 1:08:06>> Yeah. Yeah. So now it's it's taken you
- 1:08:08back in the 70s it took you that period
- 1:08:10of time we discussed where you you got
- 1:08:13to learn through these losses to really
- 1:08:15discover your edge uh maybe where you
- 1:08:20find success what you can identify with
- 1:08:22for example you be being the chartist.
- 1:08:24So
- 1:08:26I mean looking back at that time period
- 1:08:28you know how
- 1:08:30you you had given an example in your
- 1:08:33book about how during that those seven
- 1:08:35years when you when Peter was trying to
- 1:08:37discover you know who you were as a
- 1:08:39trader. There was a trader on the floor
- 1:08:41who you were he was trading soybeans and
- 1:08:45I think he was bullish on them and then
- 1:08:46so he he recommended a buy there and
- 1:08:49then you bought them. But you were
- 1:08:50operating it wasn't it wasn't Peter
- 1:08:53strategy you know you were operating on
- 1:08:54two different time frames. So how
- 1:08:56important is tell us about that story
- 1:08:57and how important is it to identify like
- 1:09:00your way of trading because as you know
- 1:09:03Jack said there's no singular approach
- 1:09:05looking at all the wizzers uh a little
- 1:09:08bit about that.
- 1:09:09>> Well you know I need to see a pattern on
- 1:09:11a weekly chart to begin with and and so
- 1:09:13that's just my standard. Uh I don't care
- 1:09:15about hourly charts or minute charts or
- 1:09:18you know daily charts. I use for timing,
- 1:09:20but I use weekly charts for trade
- 1:09:22identification. But you have to know
- 1:09:24your time frame. Uh I mean I know my
- 1:09:26time frame. I know my patterns. I know
- 1:09:29my trade. I mean I own my trade. Um and
- 1:09:34so back when I first started and was
- 1:09:36just trying to learn how to trade, there
- 1:09:38was a soybean trader who told and this
- 1:09:41probably was 76 75 76. I mean Peter, I
- 1:09:45am really bullish on on soybeans. I'm
- 1:09:47really, but man, I like the soybean
- 1:09:50market. And so I went in and bought a
- 1:09:52contract of soybeans. And uh, you know,
- 1:09:56[clears throat]
- 1:09:57about a week later, I'm down 10 15 cents
- 1:10:00in a contract of, you know, 750 bucks
- 1:10:03per contract. And and I saw John again
- 1:10:06and I said, "Hey, John, uh, you know,
- 1:10:08I'm in soybeans. I'm losing money. You
- 1:10:10still bullish?" And he said, "Wasn't
- 1:10:12that a magnificent trade?" He had a one
- 1:10:14day he had a one day time frame, you
- 1:10:17know, he he was bullish on beans for for
- 1:10:19him that meant beans were gonna have a
- 1:10:21five- cent move, you know, because he
- 1:10:24was a local trader on the floor that was
- 1:10:25trading for a quarter of a cent and half
- 1:10:27cent. And all of a sudden, he felt like
- 1:10:29he was convicted for a 5-cent move in
- 1:10:32beans. And for him, it was a glorious
- 1:10:34trade. So, you know, I I should have
- 1:10:37asked him, "What's your time frame? What
- 1:10:38point are you wrong?" If someone tells
- 1:10:40you I'm bullish on something, you ask
- 1:10:42them, "What's the price at which you're
- 1:10:43wrong?" That's what you want to know.
- 1:10:46Where do you think the market's going to
- 1:10:47go? And what's going to tell you you're
- 1:10:49wrong on the trade? That's what you
- 1:10:50always have to ask yourself. What tells
- 1:10:52me I'm wrong on the trade,
- 1:10:54[sighs and gasps]
- 1:10:55man. But in, you know, in those initial
- 1:10:57years, we don't you think it's important
- 1:11:00to have apprenticeship though? I mean,
- 1:11:02you had a mentor, I believe, uh, Dan
- 1:11:05Marky. Is that right? And that Yeah.
- 1:11:07>> It's significant, isn't it? But you have
- 1:11:08you can't copy anybody. So how do you
- 1:11:11distinguish the difference?
- 1:11:13>> Um you mentioned Brent Stanbarger.
- 1:11:16Great. He's a great teacher. He's a
- 1:11:19great mentor. He doesn't mentor he
- 1:11:21mentors big hedge funds one-on-one. He
- 1:11:23doesn't mentor in individual retail
- 1:11:25traders one-on-one, but he produces
- 1:11:27materials that are good. Um I had a
- 1:11:30couple really good mentors. I mean, when
- 1:11:32you when you're trading at an exchange
- 1:11:34like the board of trader, the merc,
- 1:11:36you're in a building with hundreds of
- 1:11:38professional traders and professional
- 1:11:40traders by and large, some of them are
- 1:11:42very secret about what they they do.
- 1:11:44They don't really let much out. They're
- 1:11:46pretty tight lipped, but some of them
- 1:11:48they want to share what they've learned.
- 1:11:51You know, they love they love teaching
- 1:11:53other traders. They like helping new
- 1:11:55traders to to achieve. They've been
- 1:11:57successful and they want to pay back.
- 1:11:59And I had a couple of those. And one in
- 1:12:01particular who had been one of the
- 1:12:03all-star traders for Cargill, which is,
- 1:12:05you know, they're the largest grain
- 1:12:07traders in the world, uh, cattle trader,
- 1:12:10livestock trader, they're in everything,
- 1:12:11Cargill, but, uh, he had been one of
- 1:12:14their all-star traders. And he really
- 1:12:16took me under his wing. And he never
- 1:12:19shared with me how he traded. I never
- 1:12:21really knew how he traded. He didn't
- 1:12:23say, "Well, I'm use charts or I do this
- 1:12:25or do that." He would share other things
- 1:12:28that that dealt with with risk
- 1:12:30management. You know, he would drill
- 1:12:32into me, get out of your losses really
- 1:12:35quickly. You know, one of the things he
- 1:12:36shared with me is never carry a loser
- 1:12:38home on a weekend. Always take a losing
- 1:12:40trade off on a Friday. No matter what
- 1:12:43you think about a market, have money
- 1:12:45management more important than your
- 1:12:46market opinion. Have protection of your
- 1:12:49capital more important than what you
- 1:12:50think about a chart. Always protect your
- 1:12:53capital because you lose your capital,
- 1:12:55you're out of the game. So, you protect
- 1:12:57your your nest egg. You know, consider
- 1:12:59taking losses at the end of each day. If
- 1:13:01you have a losing trade at the end of of
- 1:13:03a day, take it off. If you have a
- 1:13:05winning trade at the end of the day,
- 1:13:06leave it on. U you look at that every
- 1:13:10time you do a trade. Uh at what point
- 1:13:12can you move a stop to a break even? And
- 1:13:15so, those were the kind of things that
- 1:13:17he would share with me. How do you how
- 1:13:19do you stay neutral in your mentality?
- 1:13:21How do you avoid news? Don't listen to
- 1:13:23other people's opinions. You have to
- 1:13:26develop yourself. You have to be your
- 1:13:27own trader. You have to own every trade
- 1:13:29you do. Uh don't pay attention to
- 1:13:32anybody who starts bragging about a
- 1:13:34profits in the pits, Peter. That's the
- 1:13:36last person you want to listen to. You
- 1:13:38if somebody's not talking about about
- 1:13:41how they trade, but you know they're
- 1:13:43making money, that's the guy that you
- 1:13:44want to invite out for lunch. Because if
- 1:13:46you invite him for lunch and you develop
- 1:13:48a personal relationship, he may share
- 1:13:50money management tricks with you. I
- 1:13:52could care less how somebody else
- 1:13:54identifies a trade. Whether they use a
- 1:13:56moving average, whether they use an
- 1:13:58indicator, whether they use a chart,
- 1:14:00whether they use global macro, it
- 1:14:02doesn't matter to me. I care more about
- 1:14:04how people protect their capital. What
- 1:14:06are their money management rules? How do
- 1:14:08they really protect the profits they
- 1:14:11make rather than make money and give it
- 1:14:13back? you know, how do they uh control
- 1:14:15their mentality? What do they do at the
- 1:14:17end of the day to release their tension?
- 1:14:20You know, do they uh do they do yoga? Do
- 1:14:23they do meditation? What does that
- 1:14:25meditation look like? Uh how do they
- 1:14:28release themselves so the markets don't
- 1:14:30control their lives, you know, because
- 1:14:32like like I told you, I want to trade
- 1:14:34for a living. I don't want to live to
- 1:14:36trade. I want to be trader is what I do.
- 1:14:39It's not who I am. Uh, but I think with
- 1:14:41some of these young people, trading owns
- 1:14:43them. Their their their current position
- 1:14:46owns them. Their current position
- 1:14:48defines who they are. Their setup
- 1:14:50defines who they are as a person. That's
- 1:14:52never been what I want to be as a
- 1:14:54trader. You know, I want I want to be a
- 1:14:57trader who looks for certain things in
- 1:14:59the markets, does same things over and
- 1:15:01over and over again. You know, wash,
- 1:15:04rinse, repeat with the same setup, with
- 1:15:07the same risk management rules. I just
- 1:15:09make a really important point here again
- 1:15:11to repeat Kevin chart. There is no real
- 1:15:15distinct edge to a chart themselves.
- 1:15:17Charts do not predict where markets are
- 1:15:19going to go. I cannot look at a chart
- 1:15:21and and do a a price forecast based on a
- 1:15:24chart. All a chart does is is show me
- 1:15:27where I can enter a trade with a defined
- 1:15:30risk and a likelihood some likelihood
- 1:15:33that a market will follow through.
- 1:15:35That's all a chart is for me. It's just
- 1:15:37a tool. The chart is not the answer. The
- 1:15:39chart is just a tool I use. It's a tool
- 1:15:42to which I apply risk management. My
- 1:15:45edge comes from risk management in
- 1:15:47emotional management and process. That
- 1:15:50is where I get my edge. The my edge does
- 1:15:52not come from a chart. Does not come
- 1:15:54from a chart pattern. Does not come from
- 1:15:56a stop order. It comes from emotion
- 1:15:59management. It comes from process
- 1:16:01management. It it comes from repeating
- 1:16:05the same rules over and over and over
- 1:16:07again. You know, that's where I get my
- 1:16:09edge. There is no edge in a in a head
- 1:16:11and shoulders. There's no edge in a
- 1:16:13rectangle or an ascending triangle.
- 1:16:16That's just a tool to which you apply
- 1:16:18risk and emotional management.
- 1:16:21>> So much wisdom here, Peter. Thank you
- 1:16:23again for sharing all this. I mean, when
- 1:16:25you look back over the course of your
- 1:16:27career, I mean, what what aren't you
- 1:16:29most proud of?
- 1:16:31Um, I I'm I'm re I'm really proud that I
- 1:16:36could support my family doing what I'm
- 1:16:38doing. Uh, I I mean that that's really
- 1:16:41been something that that's made me
- 1:16:43really happy. I've been able to pay for
- 1:16:45my kids college educations. I've been
- 1:16:47able to help grandkids
- 1:16:49do different things, you know, take a
- 1:16:53intensive Spanish learning trip to Spain
- 1:16:56for a summer, that sort of thing. I that
- 1:16:59makes me really happy. Makes me happy
- 1:17:01that I can give money to to really
- 1:17:03really really worthy causes because
- 1:17:06there's no actually there's no social
- 1:17:09there's no social redemptive quality to
- 1:17:11being a trader. I mean it's not like
- 1:17:12being a doctor or being a teacher. I
- 1:17:15mean being a trader adds nothing to the
- 1:17:17society. Uh, but what you do with your
- 1:17:20money can uh and I'm pr I I really am
- 1:17:24very proud that Jack chose me uh to be
- 1:17:27in Market Wizards book. That's an
- 1:17:29achievement I'm I'm really proud of. Uh
- 1:17:32I'm really proud that I've been able to
- 1:17:34share things about risk management with
- 1:17:36other people uh through forums such as
- 1:17:40this, Kevin, where I can talk about
- 1:17:42things that I really think are important
- 1:17:43for young traders to know. I'm really
- 1:17:46really proud that I was asked to do the
- 1:17:48forward for the hardcover copy of
- 1:17:51Richard W. Shawacher's book. You know,
- 1:17:53Edwards and McGee did not create the
- 1:17:55rules. The rules were created by Richard
- 1:17:57W. Shawacher in 1933
- 1:18:01in in not a book. It was a manuscript
- 1:18:03called technical analysis and stock
- 1:18:05market profits. All of these things like
- 1:18:07head and shoulders and trend lines and
- 1:18:09fan lines and and horns and megaphones
- 1:18:13and that sort of thing, they trace back
- 1:18:14to Richard W. Shawacher. Uh, and the
- 1:18:18Richard Wag Shawacher's uh uh writings
- 1:18:21were put into a hardcover book form a
- 1:18:23few years ago and I was asked by London
- 1:18:26Publisher to write the forward to
- 1:18:29Shawacher's book. That is the Bible. I
- 1:18:31was asked to do the Bible [snorts] for
- 1:18:33the real, you know, the forward for the
- 1:18:35real Bible of chart analysis. You know,
- 1:18:37I that is really something I'm I'm super
- 1:18:40super proud of that I was asked to do
- 1:18:42that that I was recognized to do that.
- 1:18:45Um, so those are the things that that
- 1:18:48it's not it's not what you do, it's not
- 1:18:50what money you make, it's what do you do
- 1:18:52with the money you make, you know? I
- 1:18:54live simply. I buy used cars. I don't
- 1:18:56buy I I don't buy Lamborghinis, you
- 1:18:59know. I I don't drink expensive wine. I
- 1:19:02don't fly a private jet. Um, you know,
- 1:19:06I'd rather do other things with money
- 1:19:08that really help people. I' I'd rather
- 1:19:10feed the hungry. You know, I'd rather do
- 1:19:12things like that. I'd rather give to uh
- 1:19:15a causes that might go into a a country
- 1:19:19that has serious hurricanes and try to
- 1:19:22recover uh recover food supplies and and
- 1:19:25that sort of thing. So, you know, it's
- 1:19:28it's
- 1:19:30I haven't been greedy.
- 1:19:33That's something that I guess that I'm I
- 1:19:36for me
- 1:19:39my achievement in has been to be
- 1:19:42excellent in what I do. Uh I want I want
- 1:19:46to achieve excellence in in in the
- 1:19:48things I do and how I trade. Uh if that
- 1:19:51produces more profits, that's good.
- 1:19:54[clears throat]
- 1:19:54But if it doesn't, I want to achieve
- 1:19:56excellent. I want to be excellent at how
- 1:19:58I enter orders. I want to be excellent
- 1:20:00in how I examine uh my trading metrics.
- 1:20:03I want to be excellent in h in how I
- 1:20:05review markets. You know, I want to be
- 1:20:08excellent in all aspects of my trading
- 1:20:10and seek excellence in the things that
- 1:20:12really matter. And you know, then you
- 1:20:14let trading results speak for
- 1:20:16themselves. You know, you don't you
- 1:20:18don't go after big performance. these
- 1:20:21ideas of guys talking about they're
- 1:20:24doing 10x. I see that I see that on on
- 1:20:27Twitter all the time, Kevin, is
- 1:20:29somebody's advertising they bought a
- 1:20:31stock and they made a,09% in in four
- 1:20:34weeks in the first place. That's bogus
- 1:20:37because what they're doing is they're
- 1:20:38reporting the results against maybe the
- 1:20:40op the cost of an options. So, how did
- 1:20:43they do on their other trades? What was
- 1:20:45the result of that trade against their
- 1:20:48total trading capital? That's the
- 1:20:50important thing. How have they done for
- 1:20:52the year? What's their worst draw down?
- 1:20:54And so I see a level of dishonesty
- 1:20:57especially among people that do U-turn
- 1:21:00YouTube YouTube channels. So I I think
- 1:21:02my advice for novice traders is stay
- 1:21:05away from YouTube. Stay away from the
- 1:21:08experts, the self-proclaimed experts.
- 1:21:11You know, all they're doing is they're
- 1:21:13using a chart to try to sell a service.
- 1:21:16uh you know and and you really need to
- 1:21:20develop your own skills. That doesn't
- 1:21:22mean you do not read books that you find
- 1:21:24books, you find things that work for you
- 1:21:26and you you cobble together your own
- 1:21:29approach, but you got to own your
- 1:21:31approach. Don't don't try to trade like
- 1:21:33someone else's trading. You develop your
- 1:21:35own approach, but risk small. You've got
- 1:21:39to know that the odds of a new trader
- 1:21:41making money in his first three, five
- 1:21:44years is very, very, very small. And so
- 1:21:48assume that you're going to lose money.
- 1:21:51My assumption on every trade I do,
- 1:21:53Kevin, is it's going to be a loser. I do
- 1:21:55not assume that my next trade is going
- 1:21:56to win money. I assume it's going to
- 1:21:57lose money because that puts me in a
- 1:22:00frame of reference where I want to be a
- 1:22:01risk manager and not a braggger. And and
- 1:22:04so you you try to hold your money
- 1:22:07together for the three to five years
- 1:22:10while you figure out who you are as a
- 1:22:12trader because it takes three years to
- 1:22:14just pick up the clues just to figure
- 1:22:16out what it is you want to be, what
- 1:22:18markets you want to trade, what time
- 1:22:20frame you want to trade, what kind of
- 1:22:23orders do you want to use, what's your
- 1:22:24setup. And then it takes a few years to
- 1:22:27kind of really work that through the
- 1:22:29system and and and work out the bugs in
- 1:22:32it. and then see where you are. But you
- 1:22:35got to have your capital at the end of
- 1:22:36the day, at the end of that three to
- 1:22:38five years to even be in the game.
- 1:22:41>> Yeah. It reminded me of this quote that
- 1:22:43says amateurs, they focus on money.
- 1:22:47Professionals focus on risk. And I know
- 1:22:49that's how you've identified yourself as
- 1:22:51a money manager. You know, you you
- 1:22:53embrace this risk versus a trader. And
- 1:22:56you know, you gave perhaps the greatest
- 1:22:59answer to that question. Thank you so
- 1:23:01much for it. Uh, you know, looking back
- 1:23:04though, I mean, if you could the the
- 1:23:06young Peter, the 25-year-old Peter, if
- 1:23:08you could if you were looking back could
- 1:23:10say something to him, you know, what
- 1:23:11would you tell young Peter?
- 1:23:15>> Uh, you you the chances of running
- 1:23:1810,000 into a million. And I know there
- 1:23:20are those people who have actually done
- 1:23:21it. There are those people that Jack has
- 1:23:23written about. They're they're they're
- 1:23:24few and far between. You know, we're
- 1:23:26we're really talking one in a 100,000.
- 1:23:30uh when you talk about the odds of
- 1:23:31running 10,000 into a million in three
- 1:23:33years and you know that's fine if
- 1:23:36somebody wants to assume they're they're
- 1:23:38one of those people but the reality is
- 1:23:40that you know there there may be one
- 1:23:42person in your entire audience that is
- 1:23:45going to achieve that. Of course
- 1:23:46everybody thinks they're the one but you
- 1:23:49assume you're not.
- 1:23:51Look at trading as a marathon not a
- 1:23:54sprint.
- 1:23:55uh figure out how to keep your money
- 1:23:58together. You know, let me give you some
- 1:24:01figures that are interesting, Kevin. Be
- 1:24:04you know, really speaking to those
- 1:24:06people who think that they can do 100% a
- 1:24:08year and do it every year.
- 1:24:10you know, Renaissance Technologies
- 1:24:13uh is really
- 1:24:16the most known the most successful
- 1:24:18trader of of of speculative markets that
- 1:24:22they that's Jim Jim Simon's group.
- 1:24:25There's a book on it, excellent book on
- 1:24:27it. They've got probably 100 PhDs
- 1:24:29working for him and and they trade their
- 1:24:32their average rate of returns 45%.
- 1:24:35That's the best best in the world. Um,
- 1:24:38Stan Ducken Miller, probably the best
- 1:24:41equities trader in the world. He
- 1:24:43averages 40%.
- 1:24:45Uh, Paul Tudtor Jones, everyone talks
- 1:24:48about Paul Tudtor Jones. He's he's he's
- 1:24:51infamous. Paul Tudtor Jones hedge fund
- 1:24:54has made 46% in the last three years.
- 1:24:58Three years, 46%. But yet, a novice
- 1:25:01thinks they're going to do 10x every
- 1:25:03year for the next 10 years. You look at
- 1:25:05the turtles. Everyone talks about the
- 1:25:08turtles. Take a look at what those
- 1:25:10turtles did that left the turtle program
- 1:25:13and became commodity trading advisors
- 1:25:15and r and ran hedge funds uh for years.
- 1:25:18Some of them were very successful. But
- 1:25:20as it grew, they averaged about 30% a
- 1:25:24year. 30% a year is outstanding.
- 1:25:28[snorts] 30 35% a year is world class.
- 1:25:32The idea of expecting 100% a year is
- 1:25:35only going to put somebody in trouble.
- 1:25:38It's only going to cost you your
- 1:25:40account. You may be, listener, a one
- 1:25:43inund,000. That may be you, but it's not
- 1:25:47you. If you cannot figure out how to
- 1:25:49keep your money together for the next
- 1:25:50three years, it'll never be you. Uh and
- 1:25:53and so that's what you focus on in the
- 1:25:56early years is is is how do you work out
- 1:25:58how do you solve all of the problems
- 1:26:00that you're going to face to try to
- 1:26:02become the trader? How do you learn who
- 1:26:03you are as a trader? In the meanwhile,
- 1:26:05you need to protect your capital.
- 1:26:07There's only one way to protect your
- 1:26:09capital, and that is bet small, get out
- 1:26:12quick. Uh and and you just use that as a
- 1:26:15rule. It doesn't matter how else you
- 1:26:17trade is you need to cut losses short
- 1:26:20because if you don't cut losses short,
- 1:26:22you're going to take big losses. You
- 1:26:24know, my my average loss last year was
- 1:26:2817 basis points. Uh that was my average
- 1:26:31loss. That that's that's 210 of 1% was
- 1:26:36my average loss last year. And that's
- 1:26:4045% that were losses. And and so that's
- 1:26:44what you have to look at. You got to
- 1:26:45keep losses at least under 1%. People
- 1:26:49that take losses of 10% 5% of their
- 1:26:53capital, they they will b they will blow
- 1:26:56out. It's just a question of when uh but
- 1:26:59it will happen. You just assume that
- 1:27:02there's a graveyard stone waiting for
- 1:27:04you that said thought you could beat the
- 1:27:07game. Um so that's my advice. Think long
- 1:27:11term. Think what does this look like for
- 1:27:13you in 10 years? not how much you going
- 1:27:15to make this year. Don't think in terms
- 1:27:18of you you got to trade because you love
- 1:27:20to trade. If [snorts] your reason to
- 1:27:22trade is you want to make a lot of
- 1:27:24money, that's the wrong reason to trade.
- 1:27:28And it's a reason to trade that may
- 1:27:31cause you to not be successful.
- 1:27:35Trade to become good at it. Trade to to
- 1:27:39achieve excellence. The money will come
- 1:27:43but the motive for trading has to be
- 1:27:45that you like it to begin with. It's a
- 1:27:47challenge you to begin with and you want
- 1:27:50to become good at it. You want to become
- 1:27:52a craftsman. It's like the old furniture
- 1:27:55makers of Europe 200 years ago. They
- 1:27:57were craftsman. It's like artists.
- 1:28:00They're craftsman. They become skilled
- 1:28:02at their craft. and and view trade
- 1:28:06trading not not as a science, not as an
- 1:28:09art,
- 1:28:10but as a craft. You want to become
- 1:28:13excellent craftsman at what you do. And
- 1:28:16you do that by knowing there's an
- 1:28:18apprentice time that lasts three to five
- 1:28:20years to learn how to do it right.
- 1:28:24>> When you look around you as some of the
- 1:28:26most successful traders, I mean, money
- 1:28:29certainly is a byproduct of that
- 1:28:31passion, right? I mean, have you even
- 1:28:33met any traders who were just their
- 1:28:35focus was the money and they became
- 1:28:37successful or overwhelmingly it's those
- 1:28:40who are passionate about trading and
- 1:28:42turning that into a craft like you just
- 1:28:44mentioned. Money ultimately is the
- 1:28:45byproduct of that.
- 1:28:47>> Yeah. I mean, I think there's a lot of
- 1:28:48people come in for the money and learn
- 1:28:49quickly that it's more about the money
- 1:28:51that it's not about the money. I mean, I
- 1:28:53think that's common. I I think a lot of
- 1:28:56people who become very good at trading.
- 1:28:58Their initial thing is, hey, I I know a
- 1:29:00couple traders, they all drive
- 1:29:01Lamborghinis and they live in the
- 1:29:03wealthy suburbs and they they play golf
- 1:29:05at the expense of golf clubs and that's
- 1:29:07a cool thing to do. And so there's that
- 1:29:09motive that pulls you. You hear stories
- 1:29:11of successful traders and you can't
- 1:29:13avoid hearing stories of successful
- 1:29:15traders and there's no way that doesn't
- 1:29:17affect somebody somehow. Um and and and
- 1:29:21so I knew full well when I went into the
- 1:29:24board of trade that I was going to join
- 1:29:25a group of people that were pretty
- 1:29:27financially successful. There was
- 1:29:29ability to make a lot of money and and
- 1:29:31certainly that's the case for for a lot
- 1:29:33of people who might become you know one
- 1:29:35of the underund traders that that that
- 1:29:38are now market wizards is is there was
- 1:29:40an attraction to make money to begin
- 1:29:42with. But I think at some point in time
- 1:29:44even in their lives they learn this is
- 1:29:46about becoming really good at something
- 1:29:49because ultimately that's the way you
- 1:29:50learn to make money and hold on to that
- 1:29:52money and let that money accumulate and
- 1:29:54grow and compound over time is is you
- 1:29:58have to become good at something. And so
- 1:30:00the focus becomes how do you improve in
- 1:30:03different areas of your trading and how
- 1:30:05do you focus on those improvements and
- 1:30:08it becomes processoriented
- 1:30:10uh and out of the process comes
- 1:30:13consistent profitability with minimum
- 1:30:16asset volatility which for me is is the
- 1:30:19key is I I try to limit my draw downs
- 1:30:22every year to less than 1%. 1% draw down
- 1:30:25for me is a is a big draw down. Uh you
- 1:30:28know I certainly have them. Um you know
- 1:30:30I may have two or 3% draw down.
- 1:30:33>> Have you become more risk averse uh over
- 1:30:36the 50 years would you say?
- 1:30:38>> Uh no I think I've not necessarily risk
- 1:30:41adverse. Uh I I think originally it was
- 1:30:45how do I take the asset volatility out
- 1:30:48of out of play you you know where where
- 1:30:51I think in the early years had 35% draw
- 1:30:54downs 38% draw downs I think in the
- 1:30:56early years I probably had some 50% draw
- 1:30:58downs marked to the market at least and
- 1:31:01and those are no fun and and but but you
- 1:31:04live through them and then you swear
- 1:31:06you're never going to have them again
- 1:31:07and I always like to tell people their
- 1:31:09worst draw down is the one yet to happen
- 1:31:11And if you take that attitude, you
- 1:31:13you'll be a good risk manager. And and
- 1:31:16so it was initially just this feeling
- 1:31:18like I'm sick and tired of having to
- 1:31:20make the same money all over again. How
- 1:31:23do I how do I take asset volatility out
- 1:31:26of play? Now, we certainly have market
- 1:31:28volatility we deal with, but as a
- 1:31:30trader, you have asset volatility. And
- 1:31:33how do I reduce that asset volatility to
- 1:31:35the point I can sleep at night? you know
- 1:31:38how how is that done through how I
- 1:31:40process markets how sizes I put on is
- 1:31:44for me at first I think it became I I
- 1:31:46need to limit my worst draw down to 20%
- 1:31:49and then there was a point in which I
- 1:31:51felt like okay I I I can live with 10%
- 1:31:54draw downs and I think as you get older
- 1:31:56you know I'm approaching 80 years old
- 1:31:58Kevin at 80 years old next year you know
- 1:32:01at 80 years old you don't want to be
- 1:32:02swinging for the fences you know I'm I'm
- 1:32:05too old to lose a million dollars and
- 1:32:07take it back. And and and so I think I'm
- 1:32:11not necessarily risk adverse, I'm
- 1:32:13volatility adverse. I'm asset volatility
- 1:32:17adverse. And so I've developed the rules
- 1:32:20that I that I believe have taken asset
- 1:32:23volatility out of play. H
- 1:32:27>> you know when I look over the books that
- 1:32:29you've written or been in the interviews
- 1:32:32as well that you've been into you know
- 1:32:33the I come away with the impression that
- 1:32:36and like you mentioned earlier like your
- 1:32:38success nec that wasn't necessarily
- 1:32:40built on Peter like forecasting into the
- 1:32:42future. It wasn't you trying to predict
- 1:32:45you know the next big move. It was like
- 1:32:47we had just discussed where 80% of the
- 1:32:50profits have come from 20% of the
- 1:32:53trades. So, it's not about identifying,
- 1:32:56like you say, identifying that perfect
- 1:32:57trade, but more controlling the losses,
- 1:33:01surviving the adversity, and staying in
- 1:33:04the game long enough for perhaps that
- 1:33:07opportunity to emerge over time. Would
- 1:33:10you say that's a fair assessment?
- 1:33:12>> Yeah, I mean, I think, you know, last
- 1:33:15year I had big gains through January of
- 1:33:17this year, actually, in silver and gold.
- 1:33:20They were my big markets last year, you
- 1:33:23know, and that changes year to year, you
- 1:33:25know, the year before that I think it
- 1:33:27might have been interest rates. You
- 1:33:29know, I never know I never know from
- 1:33:30year to year where the profits are going
- 1:33:32to come. Um, but in the case of silver,
- 1:33:36uh, you know, one of the things I do to
- 1:33:38manage a position I have on is I just
- 1:33:40use a a simple 8day moving average. You
- 1:33:43know, as long as market stays above the
- 1:33:458day moving average, I stay with the
- 1:33:46trade. Um, and if someone wants to look
- 1:33:50at a silver chart, you know, it
- 1:33:52basically went from 40 bucks to 120
- 1:33:55bucks without breaking an 8 day moving
- 1:33:57average, you know, and so I wouldn't
- 1:34:01have expected that. I there there's no
- 1:34:04way I would have been able to predict
- 1:34:06that I could use an 8day moving average
- 1:34:08and stay with silver for a $60 move.
- 1:34:12But those will happen. They're oneoffs.
- 1:34:15They're, you know, they're two standard
- 1:34:17deviation events, but they do happen.
- 1:34:20And but without rules, it would have
- 1:34:23never happened. I I wasn't a I didn't
- 1:34:26make money in silver because I was a
- 1:34:27silver bull. I made money in silver
- 1:34:30because I followed my rules and silver
- 1:34:33happened to make, you know, a $60 run uh
- 1:34:36when it broke out through through
- 1:34:38actually it was 70 cent move when it
- 1:34:40broke out through 55 bucks. uh you know
- 1:34:44and it it's the it's the same thing with
- 1:34:47the stock market. You look at the NASDAQ
- 1:34:50uh look at the NASDAQ going back to the
- 1:34:52March lows. You know there was one big
- 1:34:54correction but other than that one
- 1:34:56correction the as NASDAQ index has
- 1:34:58stayed above the 8day moving average
- 1:35:00except for that one correction that uh
- 1:35:02that occurred in March. We had the March
- 1:35:04break, but then, you know, we've started
- 1:35:06back up and so that both legs, the one
- 1:35:08we're in and the one we were in earlier
- 1:35:11in the year in the NASDAQ, all stayed
- 1:35:13above the 8day moving average. Well, you
- 1:35:16know, those things happen. You don't
- 1:35:18expect them to happen, but they happen,
- 1:35:21but if you don't follow rules, they
- 1:35:23never happen. Um, you know, if you're
- 1:35:26out to grab quick profits, they never
- 1:35:28happen. Uh, you know, people say you
- 1:35:31can't you can't go broke taking small
- 1:35:34profits. The reality is you can go broke
- 1:35:36taking small profits.
- 1:35:38You you you you
- 1:35:41will go broke taking large losses. You
- 1:35:44will make money taking small losses and
- 1:35:47periodic large gains. But you can't get
- 1:35:51the periodic large gains if you want to
- 1:35:54take quick profits. And so just the way
- 1:35:57that the statistics, the way that the
- 1:35:59number there is beauty to the math of
- 1:36:01trading. The math of trading is is is
- 1:36:04it's just beautiful when once you
- 1:36:06understand the math of trading, but the
- 1:36:08math of trading requires small losses
- 1:36:11and periodic large gains. That's the
- 1:36:14only way the math works. And and so the
- 1:36:18temptation to take a profit every time
- 1:36:20you take profits and believe me Kevin
- 1:36:22when I was wrong 19 out of 21 trades my
- 1:36:24temptation on that 22nd trade that was a
- 1:36:28profit was to take it and run but it's
- 1:36:31only because that 22nd and 23rd trade I
- 1:36:35avoided the temptation to take profits
- 1:36:38the only reason the numbers work
- 1:36:40>> and perhaps those 19 trades that were
- 1:36:42losers maybe you had an opportunity to
- 1:36:44take a small win But but you had the
- 1:36:47discipline not to.
- 1:36:48>> Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:36:49>> Yeah. I I've heard it put this way,
- 1:36:51Peter. You know, you you got small wins,
- 1:36:53large wins, small losses, but you got to
- 1:36:55avoid that big number four, which is the
- 1:36:57large losses that you pointed out. Uh
- 1:36:59so, look, Peter, you've been so gracious
- 1:37:01and spending so much time instilling
- 1:37:03wisdom into us. Uh this may be the
- 1:37:06largest the longest episode that we ran.
- 1:37:10So, hey traders, if you're still in here
- 1:37:12and you're listening, comment below. 50
- 1:37:15years uh for us. So, we still know
- 1:37:17you're you're here and you're in it for
- 1:37:19the long run, not for the quick win, but
- 1:37:21for the long run. So, Peter, we'll end
- 1:37:23with this. You know, the single most
- 1:37:24important takeaway you'd leave the next
- 1:37:26generation of traders, what would that
- 1:37:28be?
- 1:37:29>> Uh be patient. View trading as a
- 1:37:34marathon.
- 1:37:35Take small losses. Learn from your
- 1:37:38mistakes.
- 1:37:40Avoid taking small profits and see what
- 1:37:43happens.
- 1:37:44Don't watch the screens during the day.
- 1:37:46Don't be a day trader. Uh learn to hold
- 1:37:49positions and I think you start stacking
- 1:37:52things in your favor.
- 1:37:55>> Excellent. Well, Peter, where can the
- 1:37:57traders find you if they want to follow
- 1:37:59your work?
- 1:38:00>> Uh, you know, I'm on Twitter. You know,
- 1:38:02Peter O'Berrant
- 1:38:04on on Twitter they can find me. Um, it's
- 1:38:07the Factor Report. I mean, that's the
- 1:38:09the factor is my company. Um and uh it's
- 1:38:13the trading I do is for the company
- 1:38:15account. Uh so they can find me on
- 1:38:17Twitter. Uh they they can join. I you
- 1:38:20know I look at Twitter and one of the
- 1:38:21things I say who are these million
- 1:38:23people? I mean I I'm see I don't see
- 1:38:27that what I have to say to people is
- 1:38:29actually worth having a million people
- 1:38:30want to hear it. So I I'm just you know
- 1:38:34my grandkids they they called me and
- 1:38:37said you know papa you've got a million
- 1:38:39followers. I kind of go, "Huh?" I I
- 1:38:42mean, who are these people? So,
- 1:38:45[laughter]
- 1:38:45you know, any anyway, I I think for
- 1:38:49people who want to hear about risk
- 1:38:51management and dealing with their
- 1:38:53emotions, I I have things worthy to say.
- 1:38:57If people want to hear about my next
- 1:38:58trade, I I really they don't need to
- 1:39:00follow me. I do post charts from time to
- 1:39:02time that I think are interesting. You
- 1:39:05know, I post charts that that I think
- 1:39:08are the type of charts that are patterns
- 1:39:10that I base my trading upon. I don't
- 1:39:13make recommendations. I, you know, I do
- 1:39:16not make recommendations to people. Um,
- 1:39:18but I do comment on the process of
- 1:39:21trading and on the agonies and on the on
- 1:39:24the wins, on the losses, on the, you
- 1:39:28know, going through hard times. How do
- 1:39:29you withdraw? How do you how do you go
- 1:39:31through a draw down? you know, what's it
- 1:39:33like to have 20 straight losing trades?
- 1:39:35What does that feel like? You know, how
- 1:39:36do you deal with that? You know, those
- 1:39:38are the things that I really want to
- 1:39:40teach people. Uh, you know, they they
- 1:39:44can find their big brilliant trade from
- 1:39:46someone else. I I don't want to have to
- 1:39:48be the person that brings it to them.
- 1:39:50>> Excellent, Peter. Well, traders, we'll
- 1:39:52we'll put those socials down, your
- 1:39:53website and ex account below in the
- 1:39:56description, so traders, you can follow
- 1:39:57Peter's work. And thank you to the
- 1:39:59listeners that made it uh to the end of
- 1:40:01this episode. Thank you, Peter. Of
- 1:40:03course, u incredibly kind and gracious
- 1:40:05of you to share so much of your wisdom
- 1:40:07with us. U traders, that wraps up
- 1:40:09another episode of Chat with Traders.
- 1:40:11Thank you again, Peter. Until next time,
- 1:40:12maybe in 10 more years, we'll get you
- 1:40:14going here.
- 1:40:15>> I got this to work. It's good that we
- 1:40:17got this to work. I'm I'm glad that we
- 1:40:19that that we finally did and, you know,
- 1:40:22we're able to connect and that's that's
- 1:40:24that's awesome.
- 1:40:25>> Amazing. All right, traders.
- 1:40:26>> Thanks, Kevin. Take care.
- 1:40:28>> Y Byebye. You've reached the end of this
- 1:40:30episode of Chat with Traders, but rest
- 1:40:33assured, there are more episodes loaded
- 1:40:35with real market insight and zero hype
- 1:40:38on [music] the way soon. So, to stay
- 1:40:40updated with each great new release,
- 1:40:42subscribe to the podcast, and we'd love
- 1:40:44it if you'd leave a rating and review.
- 1:40:46We'll catch you next [music] time on
- 1:40:48Chat with Traders.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of How a 50-Year Veteran Thinks About Risk Management · Peter Brandt by Chat With Traders, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 18,180 words across 2,491 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.