HOA Tore Down My Dam Over $9,600 in Fake Fees—Then Their Neighborhood Ran Dry — Transcript

Full transcript

1. 0:00You demolish my dam?
2. 0:02I shouted, staring at what was left of
3. 0:04it. Excavators were tearing it apart.
4. 0:07Water was pouring through gap, and the
5. 0:09HOA president stood there in her purple
6. 0:11blazer like she had done something
7. 0:13brilliant. This is how I found out what
8. 0:15unpaid fees really meant. My name is
9. 0:18Nathan Cross, and I live in a restored
10. 0:20stone mill house on Mill Creek. The old
11. 0:23dam beside it was built in the 1920s. It
12. 0:26creates a quiet mill pond, a small
13. 0:29waterfall, and a peaceful valley that
14. 0:31locals love to visit. I'm 45 and civil
15. 0:34engineer by trade. I spent 3 years
16. 0:37restoring that dam with state approval
17. 0:39and professional inspections. Every
18. 0:42stone, every gate, and every document
19. 0:44was done by the book. It was my pride
20. 0:47and joy. I even gave tours to school
21. 0:49kids on weekends.
22. 0:51Just downstream sits Willow Creek
23. 0:53Estates, an HOA community with a pretty
24. 0:56pond and fountain. Since 1998,
25. 0:59that pond has been filled by a small
26. 1:01pipe from my mill pond under a written
27. 1:04agreement. The agreement also says
28. 1:06nobody may alter the dam without a
29. 1:08permit. Karen Ashford, the HOA
30. 1:11president, loved that pond more than
31. 1:13anything. She wore bright purple
32. 1:15blazers, carried a binder everywhere,
33. 1:18and believed every problem could be
34. 1:19solved with new fee. She also believed
35. 1:22she knew more than any engineer. Most
36. 1:25neighbors simply avoided arguing with
37. 1:27her.
38. 1:28One morning, a bill arrived addressed to
39. 1:31me. It said I owed the HOA $9,600
40. 1:35for a pond and dam maintenance
41. 1:37assessment. I read it twice. I had never
42. 1:40joined that HOA in my life.
43. 1:43I pulled out my deed and my copy of the
44. 1:451998 agreement. My property was clearly
45. 1:48outside the HOA, and the agreement said
46. 1:50the HOA couldn't touch the dam. I mailed
47. 1:53copies to Karen with a polite note
48. 1:55explaining everything. I figured that
49. 1:57would end it.
50. 1:59Karen never replied. Instead, 3 weeks
51. 2:02later, I received a notice titled final
52. 2:04warning. It claimed my dam was a
53. 2:06nuisance structure and that unpaid fees
54. 2:09gave the HOA the right to remove it. I
55. 2:11almost laughed. Then I started to worry.
56. 2:14At the next HOA meeting, Karen announced
57. 2:17that she had a legal opinion backing her
58. 2:19plan. The treasurer, Mr. Palmer, asked
59. 2:22to see it. She said it was confidential.
60. 2:24Despite his doubts, the board voted
61. 2:26narrowly to hire a demolition crew. A
62. 2:29friend told me everything afterward.
63. 2:32I had to travel for work that week, a
64. 2:34bridge inspection three states away.
65. 2:37Before I left, I locked the gate and
66. 2:39asked a neighbor to call me if anything
67. 2:41looked strange. I thought I had every
68. 2:43base covered.
69. 2:45On Wednesday afternoon, my phone rang.
70. 2:47"Nathan, there excavators at your dam."
71. 2:50My neighbor said, nearly shouting. I
72. 2:53dropped my coffee, grabbed my bag, and
73. 2:56drove home faster than I should have.
74. 2:58Every mile felt endless.
75. 3:00When I arrived, my heart sank. Two
76. 3:03yellow excavators were smashing the top
77. 3:05of the dam with hydraulic hammers.
78. 3:07Chunks of stone fell into the creek, and
79. 3:09water was surging through a growing gap.
80. 3:12Workers in orange vests were everywhere.
81. 3:14I ran to the foreman, a man named Rick.
82. 3:18"Who ordered this?" I asked. He handed
83. 3:20me a work order signed by the HOA.
84. 3:23"It said the owner owes unpaid fees." He
85. 3:26said.
86. 3:27"They told us it was perfectly legal."
87. 3:29I told him calmly,
88. 3:31"This is a state-regulated dam and you
89. 3:33don't have a permit."
90. 3:35His face went pale. He raised his hand
91. 3:38and the machines slowly stopped. That's
92. 3:40when a white SUV pulled in and Karen
93. 3:42stepped out. Her purple blazer stood out
94. 3:45against the dusty site.
95. 3:47"We have every right." Karen shouted,
96. 3:50waving her binder. "You didn't pay your
97. 3:52fees."
98. 3:53I held up my rolled blueprints and said,
99. 3:56"You demolished my dam?" My voice shook.
100. 3:59"You have no idea with just done."
101. 4:02I called the police and the state water
102. 4:04office. While we waited, I looked at the
103. 4:06damaged dam and the [clears throat]
104. 4:08dropping water. I couldn't just stand
105. 4:10there. Whatever Karen had done, I had to
106. 4:13protect the creek and the people
107. 4:14downstream. I am an engineer and this is
108. 4:17what we do.
109. 4:19Officer Banks arrived within minutes. He
110. 4:21listened to both sides and then he asked
111. 4:24for documents. I handed in my deed, the
112. 4:271998 agreement, and the state permit for
113. 4:30my restoration. He read each carefully
114. 4:32one at a time. The silence around us
115. 4:35grew heavy.
116. 4:36He turned to Karen.
117. 4:38Ma'am, do you have a court order or a
118. 4:40permit for this demolition?
119. 4:42She said, "We have a legal opinion."
120. 4:45"May I see it?" he asked. Her silence
121. 4:48told the whole story. He wrote something
122. 4:50on his notepad and shook his head.
123. 4:53Ms. Torres, an officer from the state
124. 4:55water office, arrived next. She
125. 4:58inspected the broken dam, measured the
126. 5:01water level, and took photos.
127. 5:03"This is an unpermitted demolition of a
128. 5:05regulated dam." she said. She issued a
129. 5:08stop work order on the spot.
130. 5:10Then Ms. Torres and I worked together.
131. 5:13The creek below was a protected park
132. 5:15with no homes at risk, but we still had
133. 5:17to stabilize the flow. I guided Rick's
134. 5:20crew as they placed a temporary barrier
135. 5:22of stone and sandbags in the gap. By
136. 5:24sunset, the water was steady again. I
137. 5:27was exhausted, but I felt proud of that
138. 5:29crew.
139. 5:30But the damage was done. Within days, my
140. 5:33mill pond dropped so low that the pipe
141. 5:35to Willow Creek's pond ran completely
142. 5:38dry. Their fountain sputtered and the
143. 5:40water turned cloudy. The once pretty
144. 5:43pond slowly became a field of mud. It
145. 5:45was painful to watch, even after what
146. 5:47had happened.
147. 5:49Residents gathered along the shore,
148. 5:51staring at the empty pond. Ducks
149. 5:53wandered across the mud, looking
150. 5:55confused. People whispered, "What
151. 5:57happened?"
152. 5:59Some of them were angry and some were
153. 6:00just sad. Everyone was worried about
154. 6:03their property values.
155. 6:05The HOA called an emergency meeting. Mr.
156. 6:08Palmer stood and read the cost estimate
157. 6:10to repair the damage.
158. 6:11$380,000.
159. 6:14And there was never legal opinion. He
160. 6:16added quietly, "I checked with the
161. 6:18attorney's office myself." A shocked
162. 6:21murmur ran through the room.
163. 6:23The room erupted. Residents demanded
164. 6:25answers, and Karen sat frozen. She
165. 6:28finally resigned as president, and the
166. 6:30board turned to me. "Mr. Cross, we owe
167. 6:34you an apology." Mr. Palmer said. I
168. 6:37nodded, and told him I wanted to make
169. 6:39this right. Fixing it mattered more to
170. 6:41me than winning.
171. 6:43I hired an attorney named Ms. Reyes. She
172. 6:46sent a formal claim requiring the HOA to
173. 6:48restore the dam to engineering standards
174. 6:50at its own expense,
175. 6:52plus damages. But I didn't want to
176. 6:54bankrupt my neighbors. I wanted a fair
177. 6:56solution. Fair solutions last longer
178. 6:59than revenge.
179. 7:00At the settlement meeting, we agreed on
180. 7:02a plan. The HOA would pay for rebuilding
181. 7:05the dam under my engineering design and
182. 7:08state inspection. We would sign a new
183. 7:10water sharing agreement, and the feed
184. 7:12the man would be canceled forever.
185. 7:14Everyone around the table seemed
186. 7:16relieved.
187. 7:17Construction began the following week,
188. 7:19this time with permits and inspections.
189. 7:22Rick's crew worked carefully under my
190. 7:23plans, and a state inspector checked
191. 7:25every stone. Rick even shook my hand and
192. 7:28said, "This is a job we should have done
193. 7:30from the start."
194. 7:32Two months later, the new dam was
195. 7:34finished. Water slowly climbed up the
196. 7:36mill pond and flowed to the pipe again.
197. 7:39At Willow Creek, the fountain bubbled to
198. 7:41life, and the residents cheered. Kids
199. 7:44splashed their feet at the edge, and the
200. 7:46ducks came back. It looked just like a
201. 7:48postcard.
202. 7:49One evening, Karen walked up the road to
203. 7:52my gate. She wore a plain jacket instead
204. 7:55of her purple blazer. "I was wrong,
205. 7:57Nathan." She said, "I let pride decide
206. 8:00for me." I shook her hand, and told her
207. 8:03she was welcome to visit the waterfall
208. 8:04anytime. That evening, the waterfall
209. 8:08sounded sweeter than ever. Thank you for
210. 8:10listening to my story. If you enjoyed
211. 8:12it,
212. 8:13please like the video and subscribe to
213. 8:15HWAYboundaries for more stories like
214. 8:17this. And before you go, tell me in the
215. 8:20comments where you're watching from.