YT YouTube2Text

YouTube2Text → Transcripts → HOA Fined Me Over Acorns From My Oak — I Cut It Down and the Next Flood Took Her Fence

HOA Fined Me Over Acorns From My Oak — I Cut It Down and the Next Flood Took Her Fence — Transcript

by Hoa Tales · 7,429 words · 1,085 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Open in transcriber Summarize with AI Download SRT/VTT

Full transcript

0:00Your acorns are trashing my lawn every
0:02morning. Whole yard looks like nobody
0:04gives a damn.
0:05I'm finding you every Monday until that
0:07tree is gone.
0:08>> Ma'am, that tree keeps the water off
0:10this hill.
0:11>> I don't care what it keeps. I'll lean
0:13this dump. You won't sell, won't borrow,
0:16won't do a thing. Choke on your acorns.
0:19>> She walked off my porch without looking
0:20back. I went inside and made one call.
0:24Crew came Saturday. I walked out when
0:26the chainsaw started. Couldn't watch.
0:28Trunk down by eight, stump flat by noon.
0:30She walked over that afternoon.
0:32>> She walked over that afternoon, stood
0:34right on the bare dirt where the roots
0:35used to be. Took a photo, posted it that
0:38night. One word, clean. 22 days later,
0:42the flood came through. What county
0:44flood control found where her fence used
0:45to be, I'll get to that. What would you
0:48do if your HOA fined you over something
0:50that falls from your own tree? Where are
0:52you watching from? Drop your state. Have
0:54you ever watched a white fence wash off
0:57someone's yard because they forced their
0:58neighbor to cut down their own tree?
1:01Because you are about to. Hit subscribe.
1:04You do not want to miss what happens to
1:05her. My name's Floyd Adams, and for 19
1:08years I lived at the end of a quiet
1:10cul-de-sac in Ridgemont, a small
1:12subdivision tucked into the foothills
1:14about 40 minutes south of Atlanta. 52
1:16homes spread across rolling Georgia
1:18clay. Most of them built in the early
1:202000s. Mine was one of the originals.
1:24The day I moved in, I planted a white
1:26oak in my backyard. Bare root sapling, 4
1:29ft tall, cost me $11 at the county
1:32nursery. 19 years later, that tree stood
1:3560 ft high with a trunk you couldn't
1:37wrap your arms around. Its canopy
1:39covered half my yard. Its roots ran deep
1:42into the slope behind my house, a hill
1:44that dropped maybe 15 ft from my lot
1:46line down to the property below. Every
1:48October, that oak would drop thousands
1:50of acorns. They'd hit the tin roof of my
1:53tool shed like a drum line.
1:56Tap, tap, tap. Starting at dawn. I used
1:59to sit under that tree after work. Old
2:01wooden chair, can of Bud Light, a radio
2:04tuned to WSB playing classic country.
2:07The air smelled like wet oak leaves and
2:09red Georgia clay. That tree was my
2:11favorite thing about my house. Now,
2:14Ridgemont didn't have an HOA when I
2:15bought in. That came 6 years ago when a
2:18developer added 40 new homes on the east
2:20side and folded the whole neighborhood
2:22under a homeowners association. Nobody
2:25in the original 12 lots voted on it. We
2:27just got a letter one day that said,
2:29"Welcome to the Ridgemont Community
2:30Association. Dues are 280 a year, and
2:34here's your handbook." I paid the dues,
2:36kept my head down, mowed my lawn, didn't
2:39bother anyone. Then Nadine Prescott
2:41moved in. She bought the house directly
2:43below mine on the slope. Brand new
2:45construction, three bedrooms, vinyl
2:47fence around the entire backyard. White,
2:506-ft tall, looked like a row of teeth.
2:53She kept her lawn cut so short you could
2:55see the dirt between the blades. Her
2:57driveway was pressure washed every other
2:59weekend. You could hear that pressure
3:01washer screaming through the
3:02neighborhood at 7:00 on Saturday
3:04mornings like clockwork. Nadine ran for
3:06HOA president 8 months after she moved
3:09in. Nobody else wanted the job, so she
3:11won unopposed. First month in office,
3:14she sent out 14 violation notices across
3:17the neighborhood. Trash cans visible
3:19from the street, wrong color mulch,
3:22basketball hoop too close to the
3:24sidewalk. Most people pushed back and
3:26she dropped it. Now, with me, my first
3:28letter showed up on a Tuesday in
3:30October. Official HOA letterhead,
3:33certified mail.
3:34I opened it standing at the mailbox, and
3:37I remember the acorns tapping on my shed
3:39roof behind me while I read it. The
3:41violation said, and I'm quoting the
3:43letter here, "Homeowners tree deposits
3:45organic debris, specifically acorns,
3:48onto adjacent property creating an
3:50aesthetic nuisance and potential slip
3:52hazard." Fine, $75
3:55due in 30 days. $75
3:58for acorns. From a tree that had been
4:01standing on my property since before
4:03Nadine Prescott knew this zip code
4:05existed, I called the HOA office. The
4:08woman who answered said I could file a
4:09written appeal within 14 days, so I did,
4:12wrote it out by hand, mailed it
4:14certified. Three weeks later, I got the
4:16response. One paragraph, appeal denied,
4:20fine stands, $75 due within 30 days. I
4:24stood at my kitchen window that evening
4:26looking at the oak. 60 ft of wood and
4:29leaf and root that I'd watched grow from
4:31a stick in the ground, and somewhere on
4:33the other side of that slope behind a
4:35white vinyl fence she'd owned for less
4:37than 2 years, Nadine Prescott was
4:40charging me for gravity. That was the
4:42first $75. It wasn't the last. I decided
4:45to handle it the simple way. Every
4:47morning at 6:00 I'd go out with a rake
4:49and a 5-gallon bucket, sweep every acorn
4:52off my lawn, then reach over the fence
4:54and sweep Nadine's side, too. 40 minutes
4:56a day, 7 days a week. My knees hated me.
4:59My back hated me more, but I figured if
5:02there were no acorns on her property,
5:04there was no violation. 2 weeks of that
5:06earned me a second letter. Same
5:08language, same certified mail.
5:11This time the fine was $150.
5:14The violation read, "Homeowner's tree
5:17continues to deposit organic material on
5:19adjacent property." I remember reading
5:21that line out loud to myself in my
5:23driveway and laughing. I was sweeping
5:25her lawn for free every morning and she
5:27was still writing me up. The tree was
5:29the crime, not the acorns. The tree. I
5:32went to the next board meeting. First
5:34Tuesday of the month, 7:00 p.m.,
5:37community center conference room that
5:38smelled like old carpet and burnt
5:40coffee. Nadine sat at the head of a
5:42folding table. Two board members on
5:44either side, Lorraine Whitfield and
5:46Clyde Osborne, both staring at their
5:48phones. Three homeowners in the
5:50audience, including me. I brought
5:53photos. Time-stamped every morning for 2
5:55weeks. My lawn, clean. Nadine side of
5:59the fence, clean. I spread them on the
6:01table and said, "This is my appeal."
6:03Nadine didn't look at the photos. She
6:06opened a binder, flipped to a tab, and
6:08pointed at section 4.12 of the CC&Rs.
6:12Read it out loud. No homeowner shall
6:14permit any condition that creates a
6:16nuisance to adjacent property. Acorns
6:19are a nuisance, she said. The tree
6:21produces the acorns. The violation is
6:23the tree. Ruling stands. I looked at
6:26Lorraine. She looked at her phone. I
6:28looked at Clyde. He shrugged. That was
6:31the meeting. On the drive home, I passed
6:33Garrett Coleman's place on lot 14.
6:36Garrett had a pecan tree in his front
6:38yard bigger than my oak, older, too.
6:41Pecan shells all over the sidewalk, all
6:43over the gutter, scattered into the
6:45street. I'd been walking past that tree
6:47for years without thinking about it.
6:49That night, I pulled over and took six
6:51photos. Shells on the concrete, shells
6:54in the grass, shells in the storm drain.
6:56Not a single violation notice on
6:58Garrett's door. Not one. I want you to
7:01understand something because this is
7:03important. What Nadine was doing has a
7:06legal name. It's called selective
7:08enforcement. The idea is simple. If your
7:11HOA enforces a rule against you, but
7:13ignores the exact same violation for
7:15your neighbor, the fine can be thrown
7:17out in court. Judges have voided
7:19thousands of HOA fines on that basis
7:21alone. I didn't know that word yet, but
7:24I was starting to feel it. I filed my
7:26photos with the appeal, certified mail,
7:29return receipt, wrote one line at the
7:31bottom. Please explain why lot 14 has
7:34not received a violation for pecan
7:36shells. Three weeks, no response to the
7:38question. Just another fine. $150.
7:42That put me at 375 in 8 weeks. I sat at
7:45my kitchen table that night doing math I
7:47didn't want to do. 375 in 2 months. If
7:51she kept going at 150 a week, that was
7:53almost 8 grand in a year. I'd read
7:55somewhere once, I think it was a Nolo
7:57legal guide, that in Georgia, an HOA can
8:00put a lien on your house if you don't
8:02pay fines. A lien, meaning she could
8:05cloud my title over acorns. I looked out
8:08the window at the oak. I could hear the
8:10acorns on the shed roof, morning drum
8:12roll. Except now it sounded like a
8:14clock. The next letter didn't come by
8:16mail, it came taped to my front door. I
8:19got home from work on a Thursday and
8:21there it was, white envelope, HOA seal,
8:23stuck to the wood with blue painter's
8:25tape like a parking ticket. I opened it
8:27on the porch, same violation, same
8:30language. But this time there was a new
8:32paragraph at the bottom. Failure to pay
8:34outstanding fines within 60 days may
8:37result in a lien filed against the
8:39property. The homeowner will be
8:41responsible for all legal and
8:43administrative costs associated with
8:45lien enforcement. I read it twice, then
8:48I went inside and searched HOA lien
8:50Georgia on my phone for an hour. Here's
8:53what I found out and this is something
8:54every homeowner should know. In Georgia,
8:57your HOA doesn't just have the right to
8:59fine you, they have the right to put a
9:01lien on your house and in some states
9:03that lien can rank above your mortgage.
9:05They call it a super lien, meaning if
9:07things go far enough, your HOA can
9:09technically force a sale of your home to
9:11collect unpaid fines. Over acorns, over
9:15pecan shells, over a trash can left out
9:1711 minutes too long. I needed to
9:20refinance my mortgage that spring. Rates
9:22were coming down and I was looking at
9:24saving close to 200 a month if I could
9:26lock in. But a lien on my title would
9:28kill that. No lender touches a clouded
9:30title. Nadine wasn't just finding me
9:33anymore. She was standing between me and
9:35my own house. That Saturday I was out
9:38front fixing a loose board on my fence,
9:40my fence, nothing to do with Nadine's
9:42when she walked by with two other
9:44neighbors. She didn't slow down, didn't
9:46stop, just said it loud enough for all
9:48of us to hear. If he spent half the
9:50energy on that tree he spends on this
9:52fence, the whole street wouldn't smell
9:54like a forest floor every October. The
9:57two neighbors looked at me. I didn't say
9:59anything, just held my hammer and
10:01watched her walk away. The screws on the
10:03board were hot from the sun and I could
10:05smell the pressure treated wood baking
10:07in the Georgia heat. That smell stuck
10:09with me the rest of the day, pine tar
10:12and something chemical. Garrett Coleman
10:14was washing his truck across the street.
10:16He waited until Nadine was out of
10:18earshot, then walked over. "She fined me
10:21once, too," he said, "over my mailbox
10:23post. Said it was leaning 2°. I just
10:26paid it." "How much?" "50 bucks. I
10:29figured it wasn't worth the fight."
10:31"Mine's up to 525," I said. Garrett just
10:35whistled through his teeth. The next
10:37Monday, I came home and found something
10:39I wasn't expecting.
10:40Three low branches on my oak, the ones
10:42that hung closest to Nadine's fence
10:44line, had been cut.
10:46Clean cuts, pruning saw, not wind
10:48damage. Nobody asked me. Nobody left a
10:51note. I walked next door and knocked.
10:53Nadine answered in workout clothes,
10:55towel over her shoulder, like she'd just
10:57come off a treadmill. "Did you cut
10:59branches off my tree?" "I had my
11:01landscaper trim what was hanging over my
11:03property line. I'm within my rights."
11:06"That's my tree, on my lot." "Anything
11:09over my fence line is my problem, and I
11:11dealt with it. You're welcome." She
11:13closed the door.
11:14I stood there on her porch, smelling her
11:16dryer vent pumping lavender fabric
11:18softener into the afternoon air, and I
11:21realized something. She wasn't just
11:23finding me. She was touching my
11:24property, cutting pieces off my tree
11:26without permission. I drove to the
11:28library that afternoon and spent 2 hours
11:31on their computer. Found out what I
11:33needed. In Georgia, if your neighbor
11:35cuts branches off your tree without
11:37permission, even branches that hang over
11:39their property line, they can be liable
11:41for damages. The overhang rule lets them
11:43trim to the property line at their own
11:45expense, but they have to notify you
11:47first. No notification, no permission,
11:51potential trespass. I didn't file a
11:53report. I didn't call a lawyer. I took
11:56photos of the cuts, wrote down the date,
11:58and put it in a folder. But the clock
12:00was running. 60 days until lean. My
12:03refinance application was sitting in a
12:05drawer, and every morning the acorns
12:07kept falling on that shed roof, fewer
12:09now since she'd taken three branches.
12:12morning drum roll with missing beats,
12:15total fines $525,
12:18days until lien filing 41. I called a
12:21lawyer, Mitchell Prior, small office off
12:24Route 20, specialized in HOA disputes.
12:2740-minute consultation, 180 bucks. Prior
12:31listened, read my file, looked at the
12:33photos of Garrett's pecan tree, read the
12:36CC&R section on nuisance. Then he put
12:39the folder down and gave it to me
12:41straight. You've got a selective
12:42enforcement case, solid one, but taking
12:45this to superior court costs you 10 to
12:4712 grand minimum, 6 months to a year in
12:50litigation, and the lien is real, she
12:53can file it next month, and once it's on
12:55your title, your refinance is dead until
12:57it's resolved. So what do I do? You've
12:59got two choices, pay the fines, cut the
13:02tree, make it go away, or fight it and
13:05spend a year in court while your
13:06refinance window closes and the fines
13:09keep stacking. I drove home with the
13:11windows down, warm Georgia air, late
13:14February, the smell of pine straw and
13:16red dust. My road dead ended at a
13:19cul-de-sac, and as I came around the
13:21curve, I could see the oak's canopy
13:22above my roofline, biggest tree on the
13:24street, 60 ft tall, 19 years old, and a
13:28woman who'd lived here 22 months was
13:30about to take it from me. That same
13:32week, Nadine played her next card. I
13:35went to use the community pool, first
13:37warm weekend of the year, wanted to
13:39rinse off after yard work, gate was
13:41locked. New sign, pool access suspended
13:44for homeowners with outstanding HOA
13:46violations, see board office for
13:49details. I was the only homeowner in
13:51Ridgemont with outstanding violations,
13:53that sign was for me, built for one
13:56person. I stood there in my work boots
13:58with a towel over my shoulder staring at
14:00that padlock while two kids from the
14:02next street over splashed on the other
14:04side of the fence. Their mom looked at
14:06me through the chain link like I was
14:07trespassing. That night I tried one more
14:10thing. Mitchell Prior had told me that
14:12any fine over $500 required a full
14:14homeowner vote, not just a board
14:16decision. My total was 525. I filed a
14:20written request for a special homeowner
14:22meeting. Nadine approved it, but
14:23scheduled it for a Wednesday at 7:00
14:25p.m. midweek dinner time.
14:28Most families in Ridgemont had kids,
14:30jobs, commitments. Quorum required 25%
14:33of homeowners. That meant 13 people had
14:35to show up. 11 came. Me, Garrett, and
14:39nine others.
14:41Not enough. Nadine stood at the front of
14:43the room. No quorum, no vote. Existing
14:47fine stand. The board will proceed with
14:49lien filing if payment is not received
14:51within 30 days. She tapped the table
14:53once and walked out. The whole meeting
14:55lasted 4 minutes. I caught her in the
14:57parking lot, asked one question. Can I
15:00at least see the full fine log? Every
15:02violation you've issued since you took
15:04over? HOA records are available with a
15:07written request and a $35 processing
15:09fee. $35 to read her homework.
15:12>> I paid out my black suit and tie.
15:14>> an envelope showed up. 94 violations
15:17issued in 18 months. 31 of them sent to
15:20my address. The second highest homeowner
15:22had eight. I had almost four times as
15:25many violations as anyone else in the
15:27neighborhood. I sat with Garrett on his
15:29tailgate that night, passing a beer back
15:31and forth. 31 out of 94, I said. 1/3 of
15:35every fine she's ever written went to my
15:37house. Garrett shook his head. She put a
15:39target on your lot the day she moved in.
15:41The math was sitting right in front of
15:43me. Fines, $1,050 and climbing. Lien
15:47deadline, 14 days. Refinance locked in a
15:50drawer. Attorney said 12 grand to fight.
15:53My savings were good, but not fight the
15:55HOA in court for a year good. And every
15:58week, another 150 on the pile. Prior
16:01called the next morning. Clock's
16:03ticking, Floyd. What do you want to do?
16:05I sat in my kitchen, looked out the
16:07window. The oak was starting to bud late
16:09February in Georgia. You get those first
16:12green tips right before spring rain
16:13season hits. I'd watched that tree bud
16:1619 times. It was the most alive thing in
16:19my yard. I closed my eyes, said two
16:22words, "Book the crew." The crew came on
16:24a Saturday in early March. Three guys, a
16:27flatbed, and a chainsaw that sounded
16:30like it was angry about something. I
16:32walked out when they started the first
16:33cut, stood in my kitchen doorway for
16:36maybe 10 seconds, heard the blade bite
16:38into wood, and went inside. I couldn't
16:41watch. 19 years of growth coming down in
16:4340 minutes. I sat at the table and
16:46listened to it through the walls. The
16:47saw screaming, then silence, then the
16:50deepest crack I've ever heard, then the
16:52ground shaking through the foundation
16:54when 60 ft of white oak hit Georgia
16:56clay. Trunk sectioned and loaded by
16:59eight. Stump ground flat by noon. Cost
17:01me $1,400 to kill something I'd raised
17:04from a stick. Nadine came over that
17:06afternoon. I watched her from the
17:08kitchen window. She walked right up to
17:10the bare dirt where the root ball used
17:12to be, stood there in clean white
17:14sneakers, and took a photo with her
17:16phone. I found out later she posted it
17:18to the neighborhood Facebook group that
17:19night. One word in the caption, clean.
17:23Four days later, it rained. Not hard,
17:25just a steady Tuesday afternoon shower,
17:28maybe half an inch. Normal for early
17:30March in Georgia. But when I looked out
17:32my back window, something was wrong.
17:35Water was sheeting across the bare slope
17:37behind my house. Not soaking in, not
17:39slowing down, running straight down the
17:41hill like a creek, picking up red clay
17:43as it went, pooling at the bottom
17:45against Nadine's white vinyl fence. A
17:48brown puddle 3 ft wide sitting at the
17:50base of her fence posts. That had never
17:52happened before. 19 years of rain, and
17:55I'd never seen water pool against that
17:57fence line. The oak's roots used to
17:59drink it. The canopy used to break the
18:01rain before it hit the ground. Now there
18:03was nothing, just bare clay on a 15-ft
18:05slope with a vinyl fence at the bottom
18:07acting like a dam. I got curious, went
18:10to the county assessor's website that
18:12night, and pulled up the plat map for
18:13Ridgemont subdivision. Took me 20
18:16minutes to find it free, public record,
18:18anyone can access it. And there it was,
18:21a 15-ft wide strip marked drainage
18:23easement running from the top of the
18:25ridge through my lot, down the slope,
18:27and across the back edge of Nadine's
18:29property. A county drainage easement,
18:32meaning the county controlled that strip
18:33of land specifically to keep water
18:35flowing downhill without obstruction.
18:38Two things hit me at once. First,
18:40Nadine's fence, all 6 ft of white vinyl,
18:43was sitting directly on top of that
18:45easement. No county permit, no approval.
18:48She'd built a wall across a drainage
18:50path that the county had designated for
18:52water flow. That fence wasn't just ugly,
18:55it was illegal. Second, my oak tree had
18:58been standing right on that easement for
19:0019 years. Its roots held the slope
19:03together. Its canopy slowed the rain.
19:05The county's own planting guidelines
19:07recommend keeping mature trees on
19:09drainage easements for exactly that
19:10reason. And I'd just cut it down because
19:13a woman with a binder full of violations
19:15told me to. I sat at my kitchen table
19:17with the plat map printed on regular
19:19paper, creased where I'd folded it, and
19:21I looked at that dotted line running
19:23through both our properties. She'd built
19:25her fence on county land. She'd forced
19:27me to remove the only thing protecting
19:29that county land from erosion. And the
19:31first real rain of spring was 3 weeks
19:34away. I didn't call Nadine. I didn't
19:37call the county. Not yet. I put the plat
19:39map in the folder with everything else
19:41and poured myself a drink. The next
19:43morning I drove to Garrett Coleman's
19:45place before work and spread the plat
19:46map across his kitchen counter. He put
19:49on his reading glasses, traced the
19:51easement line with his finger, and said
19:53one sentence. "Her fence is sitting on
19:55county land, every inch of it along the
19:57back line." Garrett had spent 20 years
20:00in the insurance industry before he
20:01retired property and casualty claims,
20:04the kind of work where you learn exactly
20:06which mistakes cost people money. He
20:08looked at the map for a long time, then
20:10looked at me. "Floyd, if that fence is
20:13on a drainage easement without a permit,
20:15her homeowner's insurance won't cover
20:17it. Unpermitted structures on easement
20:19land are excluded from standard
20:21policies. If anything happens to that
20:23fence, wind, water, a falling branch,
20:26she's paying out of pocket. How do you
20:28know? Because I denied those claims for
20:3020 years. That conversation changed
20:33everything. I wasn't just sitting on
20:35information about an illegal fence. I
20:37was sitting on information about an
20:39uninsured illegal fence on a drainage
20:42path with no tree left to slow the
20:44water. But I had to be careful. Prior
20:46told me once off the record, end of our
20:48consultation, that the worst thing you
20:50can do in an HOA fight is act emotional.
20:53Document everything. Move slow. Let them
20:56make the mistakes. So, that's what I
20:58did. Step one was the survey. I called a
21:01licensed surveyor out of Canton, cost me
21:04$450,
21:05and had him mark the property line, the
21:08easement boundary, and the exact
21:10position of Nadine's fence. His report
21:12came back clean. The fence encroached 4
21:14and 1/2 ft into the drainage easement
21:16along its entire length. 46 linear ft of
21:19unpermitted structure on
21:21county-controlled land. Step two was
21:23photos. Every time it rained, and in
21:25Georgia in March, that's every three or
21:28four days, I went out and photographed
21:30the slope. The bare clay was already
21:32cracking. Small channels were forming
21:34where water carved paths through the
21:36exposed dirt. Each rain pushed a little
21:38more mud down the hill. A little more
21:40red sediment pooling at the base of
21:42Nadine's fence. I time-stamped every
21:45photo, saved them to a folder, and
21:47backed them up to a thumb drive. Step
21:49three. I called the county drainage
21:52office. Didn't file a complaint. Didn't
21:54mention Nadine by name. Just asked a
21:56general question. If a homeowner builds
21:58a structure on a drainage easement
22:00without a county permit, what happens?
22:02The clerk was polite and bored. Property
22:05owner is responsible for removal at
22:07their own cost. If the structure
22:09contributes to flood damage on adjacent
22:11properties, the property owner may be
22:13liable for damages as well. I asked her
22:15to put that in an email. She did. I
22:18printed it and added it to the folder.
22:20Step four was people. Garrett was
22:22already in. He agreed to testify if it
22:25ever came to a hearing. Then I started
22:27knocking on doors, quiet, low-key, just
22:29neighbors who'd been fined by Nadine and
22:31never pushed back. Dina Hollis on Birch
22:34Lane fined $50 because her mailbox was
22:37the wrong shade of white. Her mailbox
22:39was eggshell. The approved color was
22:41ivory. She'd paid the fine and repainted
22:44the mailbox, and she was still mad about
22:46it. Roy Braddock on the corner lot fined
22:49$75 for leaving his trash can visible
22:52from the street 12 minutes after the
22:54truck came.
22:55He had a ring camera that proved the
22:57timeline. He'd paid anyway because, in
23:00his words, it wasn't worth the headache.
23:03Both of them signed a petition
23:04requesting a special homeowner meeting
23:06for a vote of no confidence in the
23:08current HOA board. So did 15 others. 22
23:12signatures total. Quorum needed 13. I
23:15had almost double. While I gathered
23:17signatures, I read something that stuck
23:19with me. A USDA Forest Service study
23:22that said a mature oak tree adds between
23:2515 and 25,000 dollars to a property's
23:27value. Not just your property,
23:29neighboring properties, too. Shade,
23:32drainage, curb appeal, all of it. I'd
23:34cut down a tree worth more than every
23:36fine Nadine had ever written, combined.
23:38And her own home value had dropped right
23:40along with mine the day that stump went
23:42flat. I put the petition in the folder
23:45with everything else. The folder was 2
23:47inches thick now. Garrett saw it on my
23:49counter and shook his head. That's
23:51thicker than my divorce file. And it's
23:54about to cost her more, I said. 14 days
23:57since the tree came down. Eight days
23:59until the spring rains were supposed to
24:01get serious.
24:02I wasn't in a hurry. The weather was
24:04going to do the talking for me. Nadine
24:07found out I was asking questions. I
24:09don't know who told her, could have been
24:10anyone. Small neighborhood, but she came
24:12out swinging. First thing she did was
24:14send a special HOA newsletter. Printed
24:1752 copies, hand delivered to every
24:19mailbox in Ridgmont. I found mine rolled
24:22up in my box on a Monday morning. No
24:24name mentioned, but the second paragraph
24:26made it clear. One lot in our community
24:28has been a recurring source of organic
24:30debris, drainage concerns, and multiple
24:33unresolved violations. The board remains
24:36committed to maintaining Ridgemont's
24:37standards for all residents. Drainage
24:40concerns. That was new language. She'd
24:42never mentioned drainage before, only
24:44acorns, which meant someone had told her
24:47I was asking about the easement. She was
24:49getting nervous, and she didn't even
24:50know exactly what I had. Three days
24:53later, the lien hit. Nadine filed it
24:55with the county recorder's office. Total
24:57amount, $1,315.
25:01My fines plus 180 in administrative
25:04fees, plus 85 for the filing. I got the
25:07notice in a brown envelope with the
25:08county seal. The lien was now a public
25:11record, attached to my deed, visible to
25:13any lender who pulled my title. My
25:15refinance was dead.
25:17I'd known it was coming, but seeing it
25:19in print, the county stamp, the docket
25:22number, my address in bold type that was
25:25different. That it was real. Then Nadine
25:27made the move I didn't expect. The
25:29Saturday after the lien, I heard a
25:31diesel engine on the slope behind my
25:33house. Went out to look. Nadine had
25:36hired a contractor with a skid steer, a
25:38small one, bright yellow, the kind
25:40landscapers use for grading. He was on
25:42the bare slope where my oak used to
25:44stand, scraping the topsoil flat,
25:46smoothing it out. When I walked over to
25:48the property line, Nadine was standing
25:51in her backyard on the other side of the
25:53vinyl fence, watching him work. "What's
25:55going on?" I asked. "I'm grading the
25:57slope behind my fence, preparing for a
25:59retaining wall. That slope is on my lot.
26:02The upper section is. The lower section
26:05is mine, and I'm improving it." I looked
26:08at the skid steer churning through red
26:09clay that was already cracked and loose
26:12from 2 weeks without tree roots. The
26:14operator was scraping off what little
26:16grass had started to grow back, exposing
26:19raw earth to whatever rain came next.
26:21Every pass of that blade was making the
26:23erosion worse. I wanted to say
26:25something. I wanted to tell her she was
26:27digging her own grave, or at least her
26:29own fence's grave, But, Mitchell Pryor's
26:32voice was in my head. "Let them make the
26:34mistakes. Your property," I said, and
26:37walked back inside. That evening, I went
26:39out and photographed the freshly graded
26:41slope. The topsoil was gone. What was
26:44left was smooth red clay with skid steer
26:47tracks pressed into it like fingerprints
26:49hard packed on top, loose underneath.
26:52The kind of surface that looks solid
26:53until water hits it, then it turns into
26:56a slip and slide. I checked the weather
26:58that night. A front was building over
27:00the gulf. The National Weather Service
27:02had issued a watch for heavy rain across
27:04North Georgia starting Thursday. 3 to 5
27:07in expected over 24 hours. The first
27:10major spring storm of the year. I looked
27:13at the slope through my kitchen window.
27:15Bare, scraped. No roots, no grass, no
27:19canopy to break the rain. 15 ft of red
27:22Georgia clay pointing straight at a 6-ft
27:25vinyl fence that was sitting on a county
27:27drainage easement without a permit,
27:29owned by a woman who just paid someone
27:31to make the surface smoother. Garrett
27:33called that night. "You see the
27:35forecast?" I saw it. "You going to warn
27:38her?" I thought about that for a second.
27:4019 years of that tree, 31 violations, a
27:43$1,000 lien on my house, cut branches
27:46without permission, a newsletter calling
27:48my home a problem lot. A pool I paid
27:51dues for but couldn't use. "She didn't
27:53warn me before she filed that lien," I
27:55said. Fair enough. I hung up and looked
27:57at the weather map one more time.
27:59Thursday, 6 days out. The rain was
28:02coming, and there was nothing between it
28:05and Nadine's fence but gravity and clay.
28:07Thursday came in dark. I woke up at 5:30
28:10to the sound of rain on my roof. Not the
28:13light patter of a spring shower, but the
28:15hard steady hammering that means the sky
28:17has opened up and isn't planning to
28:19close. The weather service had upgraded
28:21the watch to a warning overnight. 4 to 5
28:24in expected by midnight.
28:26Flash flood advisory for all of North
28:28Georgia. I made coffee and stood at my
28:30kitchen window. The slope behind my
28:32house was already running. Water came
28:35off the ridge in sheets, hit the bare
28:36clay, and turned into a river. No roots
28:39to hold it. No canopy to slow it. No
28:42topsoil to absorb it. Nadine's
28:44contractor had scraped that off 6 days
28:46ago. Just smooth, hard-packed red clay
28:49funneling water downhill like a chute.
28:51By noon, the drainage channel at the
28:53base of the slope, the one that the
28:54county easement was supposed to protect,
28:56was overwhelmed. Water wasn't flowing
28:59through it anymore. It was pooling
29:01against Nadine's vinyl fence, which was
29:03sitting right across the flow path like
29:05a dam. Brown water, red mud, pieces of
29:08clay and gravel pressing against those
29:10white panels. I could hear it from
29:12inside my house. Not the rain, the
29:14water. A low, steady rushing sound, like
29:17someone left a bathtub running in the
29:19next room. And underneath that, a
29:21creaking. Vinyl under pressure.
29:24Fence posts shifting in saturated
29:26ground. I didn't go outside. There was
29:28nothing to do. The math was already
29:30done. 4 inches of rain on a stripped
29:32slope with no drainage and a fence
29:34blocking the outflow. This wasn't
29:36revenge. This was physics. At 2:15 in
29:39the afternoon, I heard the first crack.
29:42Sharp, loud, like someone snapping a 2x4
29:45over their knee. I looked out the
29:47window. One panel of Nadine's fence had
29:49buckled inward. Brown water was pushing
29:52through the gap, spraying mud across her
29:54patio. 20 minutes later, a second panel
29:57went.
29:58This one didn't just buckle, it snapped
30:00off at the post and folded flat into her
30:02yard like a door blown open. Water and
30:05mud poured through, spreading across her
30:07lawn in a thick red tongue. By 4:00,
30:10four of her 12 fence panels were down.
30:12Two were lying flat in her yard. Two had
30:15washed down the slope into the drainage
30:17ditch at the back of the subdivision.
30:19Her patio furniture, a glass table, four
30:22chairs, an umbrella stand was sitting in
30:243 inches of mud. The white vinyl panels
30:27that were still standing were stained
30:29red halfway up, like they'd been dipped
30:31in paint. And I have to tell you about
30:33this one detail, because it's the part I
30:35still think about. when the second panel
30:37went down. The force of the water pushed
30:39a section of fence into Nadine's
30:41backyard so hard that it knocked over
30:43her real estate sign. She'd put her
30:45house on the market 2 days earlier. The
30:47sign was face down in the mud. I didn't
30:50find that out until later. At the time,
30:52all I saw was the water. The rain
30:54stopped around 8:00 that evening. I
30:56walked my property line with a
30:57flashlight. My yard was muddy but
30:59intact. The slope drained away from my
31:01house, not toward it. But Nadine's
31:04backyard looked like a construction
31:05site. Mud everywhere. Fence panels
31:08scattered. That pressure washed driveway
31:11she was so proud of had a river of red
31:13silt running down the center of it. The
31:15next morning, Nadine was in her backyard
31:18on the phone. I could hear her through
31:19what used to be her fence. She was loud.
31:22She was angry. And she said one sentence
31:24that told me everything I needed to
31:26know. What do you mean it's not covered?
31:28Insurance. She was on the phone with her
31:30insurance company. And they were telling
31:32her exactly what Garrett told me. They
31:34would unpermitted structure on a county
31:36drainage easement, no coverage. The
31:38fence, the cleanup, the mud damage to
31:41her patio, all of it out of pocket. 22
31:44days. That's how long it took from the
31:46day my oak hit the ground to the day her
31:48fence washed off the hill. 22 days from
31:51the chainsaw to the flood. She spent 19
31:54months finding me for acorns from a tree
31:56that was holding her entire backyard
31:58together. And it took 22 days without it
32:01for the hill to prove her wrong. I went
32:03inside, made coffee, opened my folder,
32:06and started writing a letter to the
32:08county code enforcement office. The
32:10Monday after the flood, I filed three
32:12things before lunch. First, a formal
32:14complaint to county code enforcement.
32:17Nadine Prescott's vinyl fence, 46 linear
32:20feet of it, was built on a county
32:22drainage easement without a permit. I
32:24attached the surveyor's report, the plat
32:26map, 14 timestamped photos of the
32:29easement flooding, and the email from
32:31the county drainage clerk confirming
32:33that unpermitted structures on easement
32:35land must be removed at the owner's
32:37expense. Sent it certified mail with a
32:39return receipt. Second, a petition
32:42signed by 22 Ridgemont homeowners
32:44requesting a special meeting for a vote
32:46of no confidence in the current HOA
32:48president. Quorum required 13. I had 22.
32:53There would be no 4-minute meeting this
32:54time. Third, a selective enforcement
32:57complaint filed with the Georgia
32:59Attorney General's Consumer Protection
33:01Division. 31 out of 94 violation notices
33:04issued to a single address in 18 months.
33:07I included the full fine log, the one
33:09Nadine charged me $35 to read. County
33:13Code Enforcement moved faster than I
33:14expected. An inspector showed up 5 days
33:17later, a guy in khaki pants and a county
33:19polo, clipboard in hand, mud still on
33:22Nadine's slope. He spent 40 minutes
33:24measuring, photographing, and writing. 2
33:27days after that, Nadine received a
33:29notice of violation from the county. Not
33:31the HOA, the actual county. 30 days to
33:35remove the fence. All costs on her. She
33:38called her insurance company. They said
33:40the same thing they'd said about the
33:41flood damage, unpermitted structure on
33:43easement land, not covered. Estimated
33:46cost to remove what was left of the
33:48fence and restore the drainage path,
33:50$4,200
33:52out of pocket. The special homeowner
33:54meeting was scheduled for a Thursday
33:55evening, 7:00 at the Ridgemont Community
33:58Center. Same room where Nadine had shut
34:00down my quorum meeting in 4 minutes.
34:03Same folding tables. Same burnt coffee
34:05smell from the machine in the corner
34:07that nobody ever cleaned. But the crowd
34:09was different. 34 homeowners showed up.
34:12Standing room only, people leaning
34:14against the back wall, sitting on window
34:16sills. Someone brought folding chairs
34:18from home. I'd never seen that many
34:20people from Ridgemont in one room,
34:22including the 4th of July cookout. A
34:24reporter from the county weekly, The
34:26Dawson Ledger, was sitting in the second
34:28row with a notebook. I hadn't called
34:30her. Dina Hollis had. Dina's exact words
34:33to me in the parking lot, "If I had to
34:35repaint my mailbox over the word ivory,
34:38the newspaper should know about it." I
34:40stood at the front of the room, no
34:42podium, no microphone, just me and a
34:44stack of papers and a plat map I'd had
34:47enlarged at the FedEx store for $6. I
34:49kept it simple. I went through the fine
34:52log first, 94 violations in 18 months,
34:5431 sent to my address. I held up the
34:57spreadsheet so people could see the
34:58highlight. A third of every fine Nadine
35:01had written went to one house, mine.
35:03Then I showed the surveyor's report.
35:05Nadine's fence, 4 and 1/2 ft into the
35:07county drainage easement. No permit, no
35:10approval, built across a designated
35:12water flow path. Then I unfolded the
35:15plat map and held it up, pointed to the
35:17easement line running through both our
35:19lots, pointed to where the oak used to
35:21stand, pointed to where Nadine's fence
35:23used to stand, half of it still lying in
35:25her backyard under dried mud. And then I
35:27said what I'd been thinking for 22 days,
35:30her fence was sitting right here on
35:32county drainage line for 2 years
35:35while she was finding me $75 at a time
35:38over acorns falling from a tree that was
35:40holding this hill together. That tree
35:42wasn't the problem, her fence was. The
35:45room was quiet for about 3 seconds. Then
35:47someone in the back row started
35:49clapping. Nadine stood up, her face was
35:52tight. This is a personal attack. I've
35:55given 2 years of my life to this
35:57community. She didn't finish. Garrett
35:59Coleman stood up in the third row,
36:01turned his laptop around so the room
36:03could see the screen, and said five
36:05words. This is her Facebook post. It was
36:08the photo the one Nadine took standing
36:11on the bare dirt where my oak used to be
36:13the afternoon I cut it down. White
36:15sneakers on red clay. One word caption,
36:19clean. Below it, her own comments
36:21bragging about how she'd finally gotten
36:23the tree removed. 43 likes, eight
36:26comments, all from her. The room didn't
36:29gasp. Nobody shouted. They just looked
36:32at Nadine. 34 sets of eyes on a woman
36:35who had bragged about destroying the
36:36thing that was protecting her own
36:38property. Dina Hollis broke the silence.
36:41You fined me $50 because my mailbox was
36:44the wrong shade of white. Laughter.
36:47Not mean tired. The kind of laughter
36:49that comes from people who've been
36:50putting up with something for too long
36:52and just realized they don't have to
36:54anymore. The vote was quick. 28 in favor
36:57of removal. Four against. Two
37:00abstentions. Nadine Prescott was no
37:03longer HOA president. She picked up her
37:05purse, walked to the door, didn't say a
37:08word. The door closed behind her with a
37:10soft click, not a slam. That was somehow
37:12worse. The reporter from the Dawson
37:14Ledger was still writing. Here's what
37:16happened after. The new board, Garrett
37:18Coleman as interim president, Dina
37:20Hollis as secretary, Roy Braddock as
37:23treasurer, held their first official
37:25meeting the following Tuesday. Seven
37:27people in the room, but this time, the
37:29right seven. They passed three changes
37:31to the CC&Rs in under an hour. One. Any
37:35fine over $100 now requires a full
37:38homeowner vote. No more board-only
37:40decisions on someone's wallet. Two. The
37:43complete fine log is public record. Any
37:46homeowner can request it for free. No
37:48$35 processing fee. No waiting period.
37:51You want to see who's being fined and
37:53how often, you walk in and ask. Three.
37:56And this one matters. No violation can
37:58be issued for natural vegetation growing
38:00on a homeowner's own lot. Acorns,
38:03leaves, pecans, pine needles, magnolia
38:06pods. If it grows on your land and falls
38:08where gravity takes it, that's not a
38:10violation. That's a tree doing what
38:12trees do. Mitchell Prior filed a motion
38:15to void every fine Nadine had issued
38:17against my property under the selective
38:20enforcement doctrine. The new board
38:22didn't fight it. They voted unanimously
38:24to release the lien and refund every
38:26dollar I'd paid. $375
38:29back in my account within 2 weeks. The
38:32lien came off my title 8 days later. I
38:34called my lender that afternoon and
38:36restarted my refinance application.
38:38Nadine had the remains of her fence
38:40removed in late March. County gave her
38:4230 days. She did it in 19. Cost her
38:45$4,200 for removal and drainage
38:48restoration. Her insurance company sent
38:50a letter confirming the denial, I know,
38:52because Garrett saw a copy during the
38:54board file transfer.
38:56Unpermitted structure on easement land,
38:58not $1 covered. She put her house on the
39:01market the same week the fence came
39:03down. Sold it in 41 days at 14,000 under
39:07asking. The buyer's agent told Garrett's
39:09wife at closing that the drainage issues
39:11and the newspaper article were both
39:13factors. The Dawson Ledger had run a
39:15half-page story with the headline,
39:17"Ridgemont HOA President ousted after
39:20fine dispute, fence violation."
39:22Nadine's name was in the second
39:24paragraph. She moved to a condo complex
39:27in Marietta.
39:28No yard, no fence, no HOA president
39:32title. I heard she joined the condo
39:34board 6 months later, but I can't
39:36confirm that. Some people just need a
39:38clipboard. Now, my yard. I hired a
39:42landscaper that April and planted two
39:44white oak saplings on the slope where
39:46the old tree stood. Same species, same
39:49nursery. They were $13 each now, up from
39:5211 19 years ago. Inflation even hits the
39:55tree lot. They're small, 6 ft tall,
39:58skinny trunks you could wrap one hand
40:00around. It'll take 15, maybe 20 years
40:03before they look anything like the tree
40:05I lost. I won't hear acorns on the shed
40:07roof for a while. That morning drum roll
40:09is gone. But, I put my old wooden chair
40:12between those two saplings. Same chair
40:14I've had for 19 years, weathered gray,
40:16one armrest loose, a ring stain on the
40:18left side from 10,000 cans of beer. I
40:21sat down the evening I planted them.
40:23Radio on the porch playing WSB. Late
40:26April in Georgia, the air warm and soft,
40:29smelling like fresh mulch and red clay
40:31after a light rain. The new leaves were
40:33so small and thin that the sunlight came
40:36straight through them, bright green
40:38against the sky. No shade yet. No
40:40acorns. No drum roll. Just two little
40:43trees and a quiet slope and the sound of
40:45the neighborhood settling into something
40:46that felt, for the first time in 2
40:48years, fair. Garrett and I started a
40:51thing after that. We called it the
40:53Ridgemont Community Tree Fund. Every
40:55homeowner chips in $10 a year voluntary,
40:58not mandatory, because we learned the
41:00hard way what mandatory fees turn into.
41:02First year, 28 households contributed.
41:05County Drainage Office co-sponsored and
41:07donated the saplings for free. We
41:09planted eight trees along the drainage
41:11easements behind the subdivision. Oak,
41:13hickory, sweet gum, trees that hold
41:16soil. Trees that drink water. Trees that
41:19belong there. One last thing, if your
41:22HOA has ever fined you for something
41:24that grows on your own property, a tree,
41:26a bush, a vine, a flower that bloomed
41:29the wrong color, I want to hear about
41:31it. Drop your story in the comments. I
41:34read every single one. And if you stuck
41:36around this long, hit subscribe.
41:38Because the next story, a new homeowner
41:41on Maple Court just sent five violation
41:43letters in her first week. It's already
41:46worse.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of HOA Fined Me Over Acorns From My Oak — I Cut It Down and the Next Flood Took Her Fence by Hoa Tales, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,429 words across 1,085 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.