Historian Explains the ENTIRE ODYSSEY — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00The Odyssey, the ultimate journey. A
- 0:03story thousands of years old about a
- 0:06hero, Odysseus, enduring everything
- 0:09nature, God, and man, and woman can
- 0:13throw at him
- 0:14as he tries to get home. It is the most
- 0:17famous journey in history. [music] It is
- 0:19the first journey, and this is
- 0:21everything you need to know. Friends,
- 0:24>> [music]
- 0:24>> today we are telling that story, the
- 0:26Odyssey, in this episode using my mega
- 0:29pad. We're going to map Odysseus's
- 0:32journey across the Mediterranean. Here
- 0:34is a map of the Mediterranean. We're
- 0:35going to trace his epic voyage as he
- 0:37sails from up here all the way across
- 0:40the Mediterranean, tossed by storms,
- 0:42perhaps even out of the Mediterranean,
- 0:44until he arrives back here
- 0:47in Ithaca. [music]
- 0:48Yes, I hear you shouting. It is fantasy,
- 0:52but like all literature, it's inspired
- 0:54by real places. So, we're going to
- 0:56attempt to make sense of this convoluted
- 0:59journey, and explore some of the many
- 1:02theories about where some of the places
- 1:04he goes could have been
- 1:06in the real world.
- 1:08We're going to tell the story. We're
- 1:09going to talk about the challenges he
- 1:11faces, Cyclopses, Sirens, Lotus-Eaters,
- 1:15and what this mega myth all means,
- 1:18because this is the greatest adventure
- 1:19story ever written.
- 1:21So, let's do it.
- 1:32So, a little backstory before we get
- 1:34into things. This is what you need to
- 1:36know. The Odyssey was a poem. It was
- 1:38spoken. It was sung over generations,
- 1:40and it evolved. Bits were added. Bits
- 1:42were edited until someone, we call them
- 1:45Homer, wrote it down around about the
- 1:488th century BC.
- 1:50The Odyssey is set in a period a few
- 1:53hundred years before that. The
- 1:55technology and the places mentioned
- 1:58suggest the story is set around 1200 BC
- 2:01in what we call the Mycenaean age. This
- 2:05is the late Bronze Age. I've got a map
- 2:07here of the world that shows the big
- 2:10players. The late Bronze Age world,
- 2:12which is roughly speaking 1600 to 1200
- 2:14BC, was dominated by several powerful
- 2:18interconnected civilizations, including
- 2:20famously you've got the Egyptians here
- 2:24in and around the Nile Valley. We've
- 2:28also got
- 2:29these guys up here, the Hittites,
- 2:32roughly speaking dominating much of
- 2:35Anatolia, much of what is today Turkey.
- 2:39Over to the west in Greece, we have got
- 2:43the famous Mycenaean civilization
- 2:47that spreads across Greece and the
- 2:49islands of the Aegean. So, over here,
- 2:53let's put them in green, we've got sort
- 2:55of wealthy cities down this
- 2:58coastal strip of the Levant, what is
- 3:00today Lebanon, Israel, Palestine. Then
- 3:03as we go further west, let's go orange,
- 3:07we have the Kassites down in Babylon,
- 3:10which is just off the map here, but it's
- 3:11towards the Persian Gulf. And then we
- 3:13have the Assyrians in Mesopotamia. So,
- 3:16let's put them around about here.
- 3:20These kingdoms are linked by maritime
- 3:24trading network works right across the
- 3:26Eastern Mediterranean. We know there's
- 3:27lots of exchange, lots of contact
- 3:30between them all. We've got ships
- 3:32carrying copper, very importantly, from
- 3:35Cyprus [snorts] here. That's going in
- 3:36all directions. It's going into the
- 3:38Greek world, it's going down to Egypt
- 3:40here, but we've also got tin from
- 3:43Central Asia flowing in. We've got
- 3:45luxury goods, grain, ivory, gold, wine,
- 3:49olive oil, textiles right across this
- 3:53network.
- 3:54Bronze production, really, really
- 3:56important. That depended on
- 3:58long-distance trade because copper and
- 4:00tin, which you use to make bronze, come
- 4:02from very different regions. A lot of
- 4:05that tin, if you can believe this, is
- 4:06coming either overland or by sea routes
- 4:11from little old England today, a great
- 4:13source of tin.
- 4:15Now, relations between these great
- 4:17powers, they're a mix of diplomacy,
- 4:19trade, and sometimes warfare. You get
- 4:21kingdoms forming, you get alliances, you
- 4:23get marriage ties, but you do
- 4:25occasionally get conflict. We do know
- 4:27about one major battle. Uh it was the
- 4:29Battle of Kadesh. It was between the
- 4:30Egyptians and Hittites. You got the
- 4:32Hittites marching down here just to a
- 4:33spot in modern Syria, and you have the
- 4:36Egyptians under Ramses, let's see, they
- 4:39march in there and they meet at Kadesh.
- 4:43There's also piracy, there's coastal
- 4:45raiding. These things are common. Now,
- 4:48let's look at Greece over here. Look at
- 4:50this. They were seafarers. They were
- 4:53traders. Their pottery has been found
- 4:55across the Mediterranean world.
- 4:57And they probably acted as merchants and
- 5:00raiders, occasionally both at the same
- 5:02time. We know they regularly traveled to
- 5:04Egypt and the Nile. This is the world
- 5:08that later inspired stories like the
- 5:11Odyssey. Okay, that's the context. What
- 5:13about the Odyssey itself? It tells the
- 5:15story of Odysseus, king of Ithaca, an
- 5:18island right on the edge of the Greek
- 5:19world. Today, there's an island called
- 5:21Ithaca, just over here. This one here,
- 5:25in fact. Now, I'll come back to whether
- 5:27that's actually, in fact, Ithaca in a in
- 5:29a second.
- 5:30Odysseus spends 10 years trying to
- 5:33return home after fighting a massive,
- 5:36decade-long war in Troy, which is what
- 5:39we'd now call in Asia Minor. That is up
- 5:43here,
- 5:44at the northwest of modern-day Turkey.
- 5:48He faces storms. He faces monsters. He
- 5:50faces gods. He faces temptation. And he
- 5:53deals with his own flaws along the way.
- 5:56It's split into 24 different books.
- 5:58While he's trying to get home, his wife
- 6:00is being besieged by men trying to marry
- 6:02her cuz they all think her husband's
- 6:03dead. And these suitors are eating all
- 6:06the food in in in the royal storerooms.
- 6:09They're drinking all the wine in his
- 6:10cellars. They're being mean to
- 6:12Odysseus's teenage son, Telemachus.
- 6:14They're generally being a total pain.
- 6:17So, I'm going to be telling the story of
- 6:18the Odyssey, but I'm also going to get
- 6:19into that millennia-old game of trying
- 6:21to work out if there any real-world
- 6:24locations
- 6:25that Odysseus might have actually
- 6:27visited or or certainly that inspired
- 6:29the tale. So, let's zoom back out to our
- 6:31map of the whole of the Mediterranean
- 6:33world. As you can see here, we've got
- 6:35the whole thing laid out and we're going
- 6:36to mark
- 6:38places where scholars and thinkers and
- 6:40fans have speculated that Odysseus would
- 6:44have visited or traveled to across the
- 6:47Mediterranean and beyond on this map
- 6:50here. So, you can see, for example,
- 6:51we've got modern-day countries like
- 6:53Turkey, Greece, we've got places like
- 6:55Sicily, Malta, North Africa. Some
- 6:58theories get a bit rogue. Plutarch, the
- 7:00ancient Greek historian, has him
- 7:03visiting the shores of the UK, but we'll
- 7:05get into that a little later on. But for
- 7:08the moment, we're starting a little old
- 7:10place in northwestern Turkey today
- 7:14called
- 7:16Troy.
- 7:18This episode is brought to you by
- 7:19Klarna. Folks, summer
- 7:22is within touching distance. If I close
- 7:24my eyes, I can almost smell the espresso
- 7:28wafting across the Piazza della Rotonda
- 7:30in Rome, hear the cicadas humming around
- 7:33the Parthenon, see the Aegean glittering
- 7:35in the late afternoon sun, a little
- 7:37sailboat just on the horizon that I'd
- 7:39like to be on. And with Klarna
- 7:40memberships, you can plan your trip with
- 7:42confidence. Packed with perks like
- 7:44cancel for any reason protection, travel
- 7:46and car rental insurance, and access to
- 7:49over 1,800 airport lounges, a Klarna
- 7:52membership makes your money travel well.
- 7:55And right now, when you sign up for a
- 7:56premium or max membership, you get 30%
- 8:00off for 3 months. Sign up now at
- 8:02klarna.com
- 8:04or in the Klarna app.
- 8:12The Greeks have been fighting the
- 8:14Trojans for years, in fact, a decade.
- 8:17And actually, just looking at the
- 8:18geography, you can see why it's such a
- 8:19valuable place.
- 8:21It sits on the banks of the Bosphorus,
- 8:23this narrowed channel that leads from
- 8:26the Mediterranean
- 8:27into the Black Sea. It's always been an
- 8:29important place. Today, the city of
- 8:30Istanbul is there. People have fought
- 8:34over this stretch of water, this
- 8:35landscape, for millennia. It's right on
- 8:38the edge of Asia where it meets Europe.
- 8:41Now, eventually, the Greeks come up with
- 8:44a cunning plan to capture the obstinate
- 8:46city, a gigantic wooden horse. This
- 8:49makes sense when you think about the
- 8:50fact that the Trojans were famous for
- 8:53horsemanship. They absolutely loved
- 8:54horses. The the the horse became it was
- 8:57a powerful symbolic offering. The Greeks
- 9:00appeared to abandon the siege. They
- 9:02packed up their tents. They rode off in
- 9:05their ships over the horizon. But, they
- 9:06left behind in front of the gates of
- 9:08Troy this massive horse made of wood.
- 9:11Now, the Trojans debated what to do with
- 9:12the horse. There was a a princess called
- 9:15Cassandra. She was a a prophet
- 9:16prophetess, and she warned that if you
- 9:18brought the horse inside the city, it
- 9:20would bring on disaster, but everyone
- 9:21ignored her.
- 9:23Instead, the Trojans dragged the horse
- 9:25through the gates into the city. They
- 9:27believed the war was over. They
- 9:29celebrated. They cracked open those last
- 9:31few
- 9:32uh barrels of wine. They had a party.
- 9:34But, as they slept, a hidden hatch
- 9:37opened in the horse's belly. Elite Greek
- 9:40warriors climbed out including Odysseus,
- 9:43sacker of cities, Neoptolemus, son of
- 9:46Achilles, Thrasymedes, son of Nestor.
- 9:49They all got great names. And the Greeks
- 9:51crept through the streets over the
- 9:54drunken revelers, and they overpowered
- 9:56the gate guards. They lifted the great
- 9:59beam that held the gates shut
- 10:02and opened the gates. Those gates closed
- 10:06for a decade when are thrown open from
- 10:08within. The Greek army had crept back
- 10:11overnight under cover of darkness. They
- 10:13were waiting for those gates to open.
- 10:14They entered the city and they ransacked
- 10:17it.
- 10:18The terrible destruction of Troy began.
- 10:20Men were butchered. Blood ran through
- 10:23the streets. Women and children were
- 10:26enslaved. They were marched off to the
- 10:29ships in shackles. Troy was burned. It
- 10:33was destroyed. What's exciting is that
- 10:37we think we know where Troy was. In the
- 10:3919th century, an archaeologist
- 10:41discovered the remains of a wealthy city
- 10:44in northwest Turkey overlooking the
- 10:46Mediterranean, right on the edge of
- 10:48Asia, as I said. Now, it's a very
- 10:50complicated place to get your head
- 10:51around. Here is a a map of of what the
- 10:54surviving archaeology tells us. It is a
- 10:57place that was built and rebuilt several
- 10:59times over the centuries. There was a
- 11:00fortified city, a settlement on this
- 11:03little hilltop as early as 3,000 BC. So,
- 11:06we call that Troy 1. And we can see this
- 11:10outer fortification here is Troy 1.
- 11:15That was then destroyed by fire, and
- 11:17Troy 2 was built. That was also
- 11:20destroyed after a while, and then we get
- 11:22Troy 3.
- 11:24You get the picture. What we're left
- 11:26with is like a a lasagna of Troys, all
- 11:29built on top of each other at different
- 11:31times. And we try we try and work out
- 11:33which ruin, which bit of archaeology
- 11:35relates to which period. Now, I recently
- 11:37went to Troy. Let's take a look at some
- 11:38of these images. It's a beautiful place
- 11:40to go, too. You can see it's slightly
- 11:42raised up on that hill overlooking the
- 11:43surrounding landscape. Great place for a
- 11:46fortified settlement. The Troys that
- 11:48we're interested in are, I'm sorry to do
- 11:51this, six and seven.
- 11:53They're big cities. Uh there is a sort
- 11:56of ceremonial, religious, important
- 11:59citadel in the middle, and then lots of
- 12:00residential and commercial buildings
- 12:02stretching off into that plane in the
- 12:04distance, only a fragment of which have
- 12:06been excavated. Now, Troy six was
- 12:10destroyed in around 1300. Troy seven was
- 12:13destroyed a smidge over 100 years after
- 12:16that. Both of those are roughly in the
- 12:20set of dates that the Odyssey is set in.
- 12:24So, perhaps perhaps the Odyssey reflects
- 12:28a real war, a real siege that took place
- 12:30that ended in the destruction of this
- 12:33city
- 12:34of Troy.
- 12:35Now, let's get back to the story. Let's
- 12:36get back to the Odyssey. What you've got
- 12:37to remember is that there is no unified
- 12:40Greece at the time. Doesn't exist. Let's
- 12:42come back out to our map of the Greek
- 12:45world here. There we go.
- 12:47Instead, you've got
- 12:49rival kingdoms, warlords. Yes, they're
- 12:52linked by language and religion and
- 12:54culture, but they're fiercely proud of
- 12:57their independence. All of these
- 12:59different contingents obviously they all
- 13:00fall out the minute they capture Troy,
- 13:02and they all sail home in their little
- 13:04fleets back to their their particular
- 13:06parts of the Greek world. You've got
- 13:07people like the Spartans who come from
- 13:09down here. You've got the Cretans who
- 13:12come from the big island of Crete. And
- 13:14you've got the Ithacans heading back to
- 13:17their little island of Ithaca over
- 13:19there. And their ships were loaded with
- 13:22plunder and slaves.
- 13:25Odysseus's long
- 13:28and disastrous journey
- 13:30has begun.
- 13:38The gods were angry at the Greeks for
- 13:40their astonishing
- 13:41rapacious violence. So, everything goes
- 13:45wrong pretty quickly cuz they've annoyed
- 13:46the gods. Odysseus is blown from Troy
- 13:49here. Look at this where the where the
- 13:50horse is.
- 13:51Up north
- 13:53to Thrace, this part of the world. Up
- 13:57there, he didn't want to go there, but
- 13:59he since he's there, he takes the
- 14:00opportunity to sack another city. As he
- 14:03put it,
- 14:04"I sacked the town and killed the men.
- 14:07We took their wives and shared their
- 14:10riches equally among us." I should say
- 14:12at this point that a close reading of
- 14:13the Odyssey makes it a little tricky for
- 14:15a modern audience to really
- 14:17root for Odysseus.
- 14:19Uh I It's interesting. There's a
- 14:20classicist Emily Hauser I interviewed
- 14:22for a project on this. She explained to
- 14:24me that a Greek hero is not necessarily
- 14:27someone who we just admire, the hero in
- 14:29the modern sense.
- 14:31To the Greeks, a hero is someone
- 14:32actually who's got main character
- 14:34energy, sure, but someone whose ambition
- 14:36for glory ultimately leads them and
- 14:38everyone around them to ruin. So,
- 14:41they're a character that we just can't
- 14:42look away from.
- 14:44It's true that Odysseus,
- 14:46he often makes mistakes and most of them
- 14:48are born from his ambition.
- 14:51And he makes one now. The Thracians are
- 14:53the people up here. They counterattacked
- 14:55Odysseus and he and his men barely
- 14:58escaped. On they sailed down here
- 15:02into the Aegean.
- 15:04So, I'll put a little helmet up there
- 15:06for Odysseus's first stop on his journey
- 15:08home. But, let's quickly talk about the
- 15:10sort of the geography, really,
- 15:12of of the Greek world. Look at that.
- 15:14Look at that. It's a place of the
- 15:15islands. It's fragmented. This is a a
- 15:18culture of seafarers. It's a maritime
- 15:21culture because you've got to sail from
- 15:23A to B. The mountainous interior of
- 15:26Greece is very hard to travel across, so
- 15:28people are sailing around the coast. And
- 15:31it's a coast of headlands and bays and
- 15:34harbors and caves. These are places to
- 15:37shelter from storms and enemies.
- 15:40And that creates a world of diversity, a
- 15:44world of pirates and kings who are often
- 15:46the same person. And it means that each
- 15:48one of these islands has its own
- 15:50particular customs and rulers and
- 15:52character.
- 15:53And it means that Odysseus never knows
- 15:55quite what kind of society he'll
- 15:57encounter next.
- 15:59That's very different to the large
- 16:01unified
- 16:03river-based civilizations place like
- 16:05Egypt down here or Mesopotamia over in
- 16:09Asia. The Greek world was much more
- 16:11fractured, much more maritime.
- 16:14Odysseus is about to launch himself into
- 16:17that world, but also a world of fantasy
- 16:19and magic because he's about to have his
- 16:22first unreal experience.
- 16:31A violent storm drives him and his men
- 16:34for 10 days until they arrive at a lush
- 16:38island inhabited by the Lotus-Eaters.
- 16:42Now, where was this mysterious island of
- 16:45Lotus-Eaters? We've got all sorts of
- 16:47theories. One takes us to Jerba in
- 16:51Tunisia, just here.
- 16:54That's the most enduring and widely
- 16:57accepted geographical theory. But we've
- 16:59also got, well, the whole of the Libyan
- 17:01coast here. Could have been somewhere
- 17:02along there. That's where the ancient
- 17:04Greek historian Herodotus placed the
- 17:05Lotus-Eaters, somewhere on the coast of
- 17:08Libya.
- 17:09And he described them as a people that
- 17:12ate the fruit of a special tree that
- 17:15tasted like dates. Some people suggest
- 17:18it could be on the Atlantic coast of
- 17:19Morocco way
- 17:21to the west because they argue that
- 17:22Homer intended for this land to be at
- 17:24the extreme edge of the known world. And
- 17:27it's true that the lush coast of Morocco
- 17:30does vaguely fit the mythical
- 17:32description of this place that was at
- 17:34the end of the world. We are going to
- 17:35stick with Jerba in Tunisia. So, let's
- 17:38chart this journey. They're blown down
- 17:41here by this terrible storm
- 17:45until they reach Jerba.
- 17:48Some men, when they arrived at this
- 17:50place, went inland and they discovered
- 17:52these lotus eaters. These were people
- 17:55who
- 17:56were ate an addictive special fruit. And
- 18:00once they ate it, well, they lost all
- 18:02their ambition. In fact, the sailors who
- 18:05discovered these guys tried the fruit
- 18:07and they lost all of their will to
- 18:09return home. Odysseus had to go inland.
- 18:12He had to drag them back to the ships
- 18:15and he tied them beneath the benches.
- 18:17So, this is Odysseus's first brush with
- 18:19the supernatural.
- 18:21It certainly wouldn't be his last. So,
- 18:22I'm putting the little lotus there in
- 18:24Tunisia for the second stop on his
- 18:28mythical journey. Right, next, we have
- 18:31reached the most famous moment of the
- 18:33story, I think.
- 18:35Odysseus pulls up at another island.
- 18:38This one home to the Cyclops, the
- 18:42one-eyed giant.
- 18:49Now, we have obviously no idea where
- 18:50this is. Euripides, the ancient Greek
- 18:53playwright, he locates the land of the
- 18:56Cyclops on the isle of Sicily. So, let's
- 19:00zoom out a bit and come over to Sicily
- 19:02here, the big island off the south coast
- 19:06of Italy. He thinks it's near Mount
- 19:08Etna.
- 19:09Now, Virgil, the Roman epic poet, he has
- 19:13the Cyclops also living on Sicily, also
- 19:16near Mount Etna. Now, who am I to
- 19:18disagree with Euripides and Virgil?
- 19:21Let's say that Odysseus' next voyage is
- 19:24up here
- 19:25to northeast Sicily
- 19:29in the shadow of Etna.
- 19:31We're told that Odysseus lands on a
- 19:33fog-covered island with a with a good
- 19:35natural harbor. He and his men feast on
- 19:38wild goats. They drink strong wine
- 19:40camping on the beach. Then Odysseus and
- 19:4312 chosen companions explore inland, and
- 19:46they discover a giant cave. There's
- 19:48cheeses in there. There are livestock
- 19:51pens full of sheep and lambs.
- 19:54But everything's on a huge scale. It's
- 19:56clearly home to a giant. Now, his men
- 19:59want to steal supplies and get out of
- 20:01there immediately, and I do not blame
- 20:03them. Odysseus, strangely, insists on
- 20:05staying to meet the cave's owner.
- 20:08Well, he would live to regret that,
- 20:10because that night a giant got back. A
- 20:13Cyclops. One big eye in the middle of
- 20:16his ugly forehead. He rolled a massive
- 20:19stone across the cave entrance. He
- 20:21trapped the Greeks inside. After
- 20:23Odysseus says, "Hey, what about a bit of
- 20:25hospitality?" the Cyclops grabs two of
- 20:27his men and gobbles them down. Odysseus
- 20:30wants revenge immediately, but realizes
- 20:33there's no point killing the Cyclops
- 20:34because they cannot move the huge stone
- 20:36blocking the exit. The next morning,
- 20:39Cyclops eats two more men, and Odysseus
- 20:42comes up with a plan. He prepares a big
- 20:45wooden stake. This big piece of big log
- 20:47in there. He sharpens the end and turns
- 20:49it into a spear. So, that night when
- 20:51Cyclops returns, and eats another two
- 20:53men for dinner, by the way, Odysseus
- 20:55offers him strong wine. The Cyclops
- 20:58becomes drunk. He collapses. Odysseus'
- 21:01men heat the sharpened stake in the
- 21:04fire. Then they all heft it onto their
- 21:06shoulders, and drive it into the
- 21:09Cyclops' single eye. Blood pours out.
- 21:13The eye crackles, we're told, like hot
- 21:15metal in water. The Cyclops is blinded.
- 21:18He falls into a kind of fitful sleep,
- 21:21but in the morning he wakes up, and he's
- 21:22forced to roll away the rock that guards
- 21:25the entrance to the cave, cuz he's going
- 21:27to let his going to let his sheep out to
- 21:28go and graze. But Cyclops has got his
- 21:30arm across the entrance, making sure
- 21:32that only his sheep can get through.
- 21:34Odysseus ties his men beneath the
- 21:37sheep's bellies, and the Greeks escape
- 21:40unnoticed
- 21:42hanging from the bottom of the flock.
- 21:44They flee to their ship. By the way,
- 21:46they steal the sheep, and then they
- 21:48start rowing away. But Odysseus cannot
- 21:51resist
- 21:52at this point doing something very, very
- 21:55stupid. He taunts the Cyclops from the
- 21:58sea. His crew beg him to stop provoking
- 22:00the giant. Instead, Odysseus proudly
- 22:03reveals his name. He shouts that he is
- 22:06Odysseus, king of Ithaca. Now, the
- 22:09Cyclops, who was called Polyphemus, he
- 22:12also reveals his identity.
- 22:13Disappointingly, he reveals he is the
- 22:15son of the sea god Poseidon, and he
- 22:18prays for revenge. He says, "May
- 22:20Odysseus never return home, or if he
- 22:23does get home, may he be late, and
- 22:25broken, and alone."
- 22:28That curse terrifies Odysseus's crew.
- 22:32They sail onward, but they're now
- 22:34shaken. They're mourning their dead, and
- 22:36they're very worried that the god of the
- 22:39sea, Poseidon,
- 22:41has condemned them.
- 22:43Now, what's all this mean? I think the
- 22:45Cyclops chapter of the story symbolizes
- 22:48a clash between sort of civilization and
- 22:50savagery. And the Cyclops is seen as a
- 22:53an evil figure because he violates the
- 22:55sacred Greek code of xenia, which means
- 22:58hospitality, uh
- 23:00because he eats his guests.
- 23:02And the story also highlights Odysseus's
- 23:04cunning. He's famous, isn't he, all over
- 23:06the world ever since for being the
- 23:07cleverest of the Greeks. So, he's he's
- 23:09showing cunning. He manages to overcome
- 23:11brute force. He escapes through
- 23:13deception, through trickery and
- 23:14planning, rather than physical prowess.
- 23:18But, let's just say this also exposes
- 23:22Odysseus's greatest flaws, greed and
- 23:26pride.
- 23:27Why on earth was he snooping around this
- 23:29cave in the first place, stealing things
- 23:31and hoping for a gift from the owner?
- 23:33And why, by the thunderbolts of Zeus,
- 23:37did he reveal his true name after
- 23:40escaping?
- 23:41Because he's arrogant. Because he wants
- 23:43the world to know that it was him.
- 23:45But actually, he's now cursed. He turned
- 23:48victory
- 23:50into disaster.
- 23:57So, I've got my Cyclops there now. Let's
- 23:59get on with the next stage of the
- 24:00journey because Odysseus's men are
- 24:01sailing on. They're mourning their
- 24:03mounting casualties. They're getting a
- 24:04bit worried. But they reach the floating
- 24:07island of Aeolus, ruler of the winds. In
- 24:11the ancient and modern worlds, uh this
- 24:14part of the myth is tied to the Aeolian
- 24:16Islands, which are actually very close
- 24:18by. They're located right here in the
- 24:21Tyrrhenian Sea. We've got Lipari.
- 24:24It's the largest and it's the most
- 24:27populous today of all these islands. And
- 24:29ancient
- 24:30writers associated Lipari directly with
- 24:33the home of Aeolus. But Stromboli,
- 24:35you've heard of that, another
- 24:37island in this archipelago, this one
- 24:39over here, famous for its continually
- 24:42active volcano. It's also linked to this
- 24:45myth because inhabitants used to predict
- 24:48the weather based on the shape and
- 24:51direction of the smoke and the clouds
- 24:53rising from the volcano's peak. And that
- 24:56was a skill that was a that was all
- 24:57attributed to the god of the winds.
- 25:00Anyway, this was a place of feasting and
- 25:03ease. And Aeolus gives Odysseus a
- 25:07leather bag tied with silver wire
- 25:10containing all the nasty winds, all the
- 25:12stormy winds, leaving only the perfect
- 25:14wind to get home to Ithaca. So, let's
- 25:17assume it's the Aeolian Islands. I'm
- 25:18going to take Odysseus the long way
- 25:20around for reasons I will explain later
- 25:22on. So, here he goes, he's sailing
- 25:24around there.
- 25:25And he arrives
- 25:26at the Aeolian Islands.
- 25:28Now, he's got his bag of wind.
- 25:31He's feeling good about himself. They've
- 25:32got full bellies. They've had a bit of
- 25:33feasting. And they're going to sail with
- 25:36those wonderful winds
- 25:38all the way
- 25:40from the Aeolian Islands
- 25:42around here
- 25:45back towards Ithaca and the Greek world.
- 25:49For 9 days and nights, they sailed
- 25:51perfectly until Ithaca itself appears on
- 25:54the horizon. But at that exact point,
- 25:56exhausted from steering constantly,
- 25:59Odysseus
- 26:00falls asleep. Now, his crew believe he's
- 26:04hiding treasure from them.
- 26:06And they
- 26:07crawl down and open the leather bag. ALL
- 26:11THE WINDS BURST out of the bag. There's
- 26:13a terrible storm, and his fleet is blown
- 26:16all the way back again
- 26:19to Aeolus. And that second time, Aeolus
- 26:22refuses to help. He's convinced Odysseus
- 26:26is hated by the gods. He doesn't want to
- 26:27be involved. And the crew row their
- 26:30ships miserably onwards. After a week of
- 26:34rowing, which is all that's a lot of
- 26:35rowing, they reach Laestrygonia,
- 26:39which turns out to be a land of giant
- 26:41cannibals. Now, it's funny this bit, cuz
- 26:43it's not one of the most famous moments
- 26:45in the Odyssey, but for me, it's
- 26:46certainly one of the most important.
- 26:47Now, where did all this take place?
- 26:49You'll be surprised to learn we have
- 26:51absolutely no idea. But
- 26:54really, it could be anywhere. People
- 26:55have come up with theories from Sicily
- 26:58here to Sardinia, and indeed all the way
- 27:01out into the Atlantic.
- 27:04However, later writers like Thucydides,
- 27:07the great Greek historian, or Pliny the
- 27:10Elder, the Roman, they argued that
- 27:11Laestrygonia was a fictionalized account
- 27:16of early settlements in central Italy.
- 27:19So, we're going to send Odysseus up to
- 27:21central Italy
- 27:24up
- 27:25here. As they land, they are attacked by
- 27:29the Laestrygonians.
- 27:31Giant men hurling massive rocks from the
- 27:34cliffs, smashing ships to pieces. The
- 27:38men swimming around in the sea were
- 27:40speared like fish. Odysseus manages cut
- 27:43his own ship free and orders his crew to
- 27:45row for their lives.
- 27:48Only Odysseus's ship escapes. The rest
- 27:52of Odysseus's fleet
- 27:54is destroyed.
- 27:55So, we've reached the part of the epic
- 27:57story where now nearly all the survivors
- 28:00of Troy have been wiped out.
- 28:03Odysseus and his crew sail on alone,
- 28:06devastated,
- 28:08feeling increasingly isolated.
- 28:16Odysseus and his crew next reached the
- 28:20island of Aeaea.
- 28:23Now, my most bonkers theory about where
- 28:24this island might have been was put
- 28:25forward by Robert Graves, the wonderful
- 28:27novelist and poet, uh the British
- 28:29novelist and poet. He thinks that it was
- 28:31way up the top of the Adriatic. It was
- 28:33on the coast of Croatia. But the most
- 28:35famous, the most long-standing theory uh
- 28:37that the Greeks and that the ancient
- 28:38Greeks and ancient Romans believed was
- 28:40that it was here in a place called Monte
- 28:45Circeo. And that is important because
- 28:49Aia, this island, was the home of Circe,
- 28:52the beautiful sorceress. And today, that
- 28:54is still known as Monte Circeo. So,
- 28:57there's a bit of a link there. Now, it
- 28:59would have appeared more of an island
- 29:00back then. It's a beautiful promontory
- 29:02on the on the coast of Italy. It would
- 29:03have appeared more of an island back
- 29:04then because it was surrounded by
- 29:07marshes. So, that is where Roman writers
- 29:09like Strabo and Virgil believed it was.
- 29:13And it's very cool it still has that
- 29:14name today. The crew is exhausted.
- 29:16They're traumatized. They're grieving
- 29:17after all their recent losses. They send
- 29:19a scouting party inland. They're very
- 29:21fearful they're going to encounter
- 29:22another monster or hostile tribe of
- 29:24cannibals. But they actually discover a
- 29:26beautiful house deep in the woods. And
- 29:28inside lives Circe. She's described as a
- 29:31beautiful, dreadful goddess. She
- 29:34welcomes in the men. She offers them
- 29:35food and wine.
- 29:37Uh but one crewman remains suspicious
- 29:39and he stays outside.
- 29:41And he witnesses Circe transforming all
- 29:44the other crewman into pigs. They're
- 29:47herded into a pigsty. This surviving
- 29:51crewman runs back to the ship in terror.
- 29:54And he says to Odysseus, "Let's get out
- 29:56of here. Don't try and rescue them.
- 29:57Let's just sail away." But Odysseus
- 29:59refuses to leave his men behind. And he
- 30:01marches inland towards the house. And on
- 30:03the way, he's stopped by Hermes,
- 30:06messenger of the gods. Uh Hermes warns
- 30:09him about Circe and he gives him a
- 30:10magical antidote, a white flower with a
- 30:14black root. Circe welcomes Odysseus into
- 30:17her hall. She seats him in comfort and
- 30:20she secretly laces a drink with her
- 30:22concoction, her magic spells.
- 30:25When Circe tries to transform him,
- 30:27though,
- 30:28the magic fails. Instead, Odysseus draws
- 30:31his sword and Circe begs for mercy and
- 30:34asks Odysseus to become her lover
- 30:37and her ally. And Odysseus says, "Sure,
- 30:40but first you have to restore my men to
- 30:42human form. And Circe does that, and she
- 30:45turns his men back into humans, and
- 30:46they're all quite happy. In fact,
- 30:47Odysseus and his companions remain on a
- 30:51for a year, feasting, drinking wine,
- 30:54enjoying comfort and safety, and
- 30:56Odysseus enjoys Circe's bed as well. But
- 31:00eventually, the crew remind Odysseus
- 31:01they still need to get home. But before
- 31:03they depart, Circe gives them some
- 31:05crucial advice.
- 31:07If they're going to get home, they had
- 31:08to visit the underworld. Now, there he
- 31:12must seek the spirit of the prophet
- 31:14Tiresias, cuz only Tiresias can tell him
- 31:17how to get home safely. This is a
- 31:19fascinating section of the story, and it
- 31:20really explores the temptation, the
- 31:22masculinity, self-control, and the
- 31:25danger of forgetting your purpose. Homer
- 31:28reminds us, if we need to be reminded,
- 31:31that men can easily surrender their
- 31:33reason and discipline to appetite.
- 31:36Thanks, Homer.
- 31:37I'm not sure it took an epic poet to
- 31:39point that one out. The episode
- 31:40deliberately twists, again, this Greek
- 31:42concept of xenia, as I said,
- 31:44hospitality.
- 31:45Remember, there's no money in Bronze Age
- 31:48Greece. There are no hotels. So, when
- 31:50you travel, you have to rely on the
- 31:51kindness of strangers. You get food, you
- 31:53get a bed for the night. And then, when
- 31:56other people travel, they can expect the
- 31:58same thing in return. So, it's a whole
- 32:01culture that depends on trust.
- 32:03Circe appears to be the perfect host.
- 32:06She welcomes the strangers and gives
- 32:07them food. But beneath that hospitality
- 32:10lies danger. And for Homer's audience,
- 32:12this really reflects a real anxiety. Not
- 32:16every welcoming stranger is what they
- 32:18seem. And in this seafaring world, where
- 32:22survival depended on hospitality, well,
- 32:26that was sacred. It could also be
- 32:28dangerous. The crew push on, following
- 32:31Circe's instructions. They head to the
- 32:34underworld.
- 32:41>> Now, as you have spotted, the underworld
- 32:43is obviously a mythical location. It is
- 32:47beyond the edge of the known world, but
- 32:49ancient Greeks
- 32:51did believe that they were able to
- 32:52pinpoint a location.
- 32:54In the 5th century BC, the Greek
- 32:56historian Herodotus mentions a river in
- 33:00northwest Greece, the Acheron,
- 33:03and he said that there there was an
- 33:05oracle associated with the underworld
- 33:08speaking to the dead in that area.
- 33:10Thucydides, another historian, another
- 33:11Greek historian, also refers to that
- 33:14region having mythical associations.
- 33:18A place where the boundary between this
- 33:20world and the afterlife was at its
- 33:21thinnest. Another Greek writer,
- 33:23Pausanias, says that the rivers in that
- 33:27part of Greece were entrances to the
- 33:29underworld. So, let us take Odysseus and
- 33:31his men back up here to northwest
- 33:34Greece. There we go.
- 33:36Boom, in there. Luckily, I've just been
- 33:38following the footsteps of Odysseus and
- 33:40his crew.
- 33:41I happen to see it. Let's check it out.
- 33:43Hey, you look at this. You can just see
- 33:44why the ancient Greeks associated this
- 33:47with the underworld. It was a gloomy,
- 33:49mysterious, quiet, magical place.
- 33:52And water spurts from out of the earth.
- 33:55The rivers appear from underground. You
- 33:58can walk all the way up it, and truly it
- 34:01feels like you're passing from one
- 34:03dimension into another. There is also an
- 34:06archaeological site there which could be
- 34:09a necromanteion. It's a cavern in the
- 34:11earth which some archaeologists think
- 34:13was a place that subsequent generations
- 34:15of ancient Greeks would climb down into
- 34:18and perform rituals which involved
- 34:21talking to people in the afterlife. That
- 34:24could be inspired by the Odyssey.
- 34:27What Odysseus does here is he sacrifices
- 34:31a sheep. He pours fresh blood into a
- 34:34trench and that summons the spirits of
- 34:37the dead. Ghosts swarm around the blood.
- 34:40Odysseus encounters many famous people.
- 34:43You've got the Lord Agamemnon, the
- 34:45overall commander of the Greek
- 34:46coalition. He'd been murdered by his
- 34:49wife and her lover upon returning home.
- 34:51You have Achilles, the greatest of the
- 34:53Greek warriors, who was killed in the in
- 34:55the battle for Troy. You have Patroclus,
- 34:58Achilles' closest companion and best
- 35:01friend. You have Ajax, one of the
- 35:03greatest Greek heroes. But this is also
- 35:05it's like a who's who. He also sees
- 35:07other mythical figures. Minos, Heracles,
- 35:09Sisyphus, Tantalus, you name it. But
- 35:12he's he's also very sad. He meets the
- 35:13spirit of his mother. She had died while
- 35:16he was away at Troy and three times he
- 35:18tries to embrace his mother, but each
- 35:20time she slips away because she's a
- 35:22ghost. And Odysseus finally talks the
- 35:24prophet Tiresias.
- 35:26He tells Odysseus that he must sail to
- 35:29the island of the sun god Helios.
- 35:32There he will find Helios' sacred herd
- 35:35of cattle, but under no circumstances
- 35:38should the cattle be harmed or eaten.
- 35:40If the crew obey,
- 35:42they may still reach Ithaca. If the crew
- 35:44disobey, the ship will be smashed and
- 35:46destroyed.
- 35:47Then Tiresias tells Odysseus that the
- 35:49trouble brewing in Ithaca because all
- 35:50the suitors are trying to marry
- 35:53and he says that in order to lift the
- 35:55curse of Poseidon, he's got to go on
- 35:56another adventure. He's got to carry an
- 35:59oar inland until he meets people who
- 36:01don't know anything about the sea. Then
- 36:04he's got to put the oar in the ground
- 36:05and sacrifice a bull to Poseidon.
- 36:08Only then will Poseidon forgive him. So,
- 36:11that's quite a mission.
- 36:18Odysseus sails onwards, but obviously
- 36:19he's going to face more challenges. The
- 36:21first are the Sirens. They are monsters
- 36:24who lure men to their deaths on the rock
- 36:27by singing a beautiful song. Now,
- 36:29Odysseus has a plan to get past the
- 36:31Sirens. He's going to plug his crew's
- 36:34ears with wax, and he's going to tie
- 36:36himself to the mast cuz he'd like to
- 36:38hear their famous song, but he doesn't
- 36:40want to drive his ship to destruction.
- 36:43As Odysseus sails past the Sirens, he
- 36:45hears that sweet song. They're tempting
- 36:48Odysseus with
- 36:50stories about himself. They sing of his
- 36:53heroic deeds. So, obviously, Odysseus
- 36:55loves that. He begs to be released, but
- 36:57his crew ignore him. They can't hear
- 36:58anything cuz they've got they've got wax
- 36:59in their ears, and they safely row past.
- 37:02So, let's put the Sirens somewhere
- 37:04magically
- 37:06in the middle of the Mediterranean here.
- 37:08Next, Odysseus comes to a terrible
- 37:11place, a narrow strait with not one but
- 37:13two monsters in it.
- 37:14Charybdis, a giant monster who sucks
- 37:17down the sea causing a massive
- 37:18whirlpool, and then eats anything that
- 37:21gets sucked down and spits out the
- 37:22debris into the sea,
- 37:24but also, Scylla, a six-headed monster
- 37:28lurking in a cave above. Most people
- 37:30associate this part of the story with
- 37:32the Straits of Messina right here. These
- 37:36very narrow straits between Sicily and
- 37:39mainland Italy.
- 37:41Odysseus steers the ship away from
- 37:44Charybdis, but this brings the ship to
- 37:46within reach of Scylla, and Scylla
- 37:48snatches six crewmen from the deck,
- 37:51lifts them up off the ship, and devours
- 37:53them. Odysseus later calls it the most
- 37:55heartbreaking sight in all his years at
- 37:59sea.
- 38:00They press on to find the island of
- 38:03Helios. So, I'll put my little whirlpool
- 38:05right in here.
- 38:13Shockingly, the island of Helios has no
- 38:15universally accepted real-world
- 38:17location. We've got a couple of
- 38:19geographical clues. Some have speculated
- 38:22that it's Malta down here.
- 38:25It's It's halfway between Sicily and
- 38:26North Africa. It's an important waypoint
- 38:28if you're trading through the
- 38:30Mediterranean, but like we got no
- 38:31evidence. Most ancient Greeks thought it
- 38:34was Sicily itself.
- 38:37The name given in the Odyssey is
- 38:38Thrinacia, which could be linked to
- 38:41Sicily's roughly triangle three-cornered
- 38:44shape.
- 38:45So,
- 38:46once again, Odysseus is back in Sicily.
- 38:50Let's take him along there
- 38:52and put him at the north coast of
- 38:54Sicily.
- 38:55Both Tiresias and Circe had warned him,
- 38:59"Do not touch Helios' sacred cattle on
- 39:02this island." And Odysseus really had
- 39:04hoped to avoid the island completely,
- 39:05but
- 39:06he has to go there. His men are
- 39:07exhausted. They They They desperately
- 39:09want to rest, pull ship up on the shore,
- 39:11and take a few days off.
- 39:13Before landing, Odysseus makes them
- 39:15swear they won't harm the cattle, but
- 39:17then a violent storm blows up, and
- 39:20they're trapped on this island for a
- 39:21month, and supplies run out. They eat
- 39:23the birds. They eat any fish they can
- 39:25find,
- 39:26but they're really really hungry. And
- 39:27Odysseus goes away. He has a little
- 39:28pray, and he falls asleep.
- 39:30And his second-in-command persuades the
- 39:33crew to break their oath.
- 39:35He says, "Look, we're going to die
- 39:36anyway. Let's die with full bellies."
- 39:38Odysseus wakes up, and he can smell
- 39:41roasting meat, and he knows what's
- 39:42coming. He knows it's going to be a
- 39:44disaster. The men have killed the cattle
- 39:47of Helios, the sun god.
- 39:50It's not good.
- 39:52As soon as the weather clears,
- 39:54>> [sighs]
- 39:54>> they set sail. And as soon as they do
- 39:56so, the sky darkens. There's a terrible
- 40:00storm. Lightning smashes into the ship.
- 40:04The whole boat collapses. The mast comes
- 40:07down. The vessel's shattered, and the
- 40:10entire crew is killed apart from
- 40:13Odysseus. He is left clinging to the
- 40:15wreckage, drifting for days at sea. And
- 40:19eventually, he's washed ashore on, you
- 40:21guessed it, a distant, mysterious
- 40:24island.
- 40:30This island, Ogygia, is another very
- 40:33mysterious location in the Odyssey. It's
- 40:36inhabited by another beautiful goddess,
- 40:40Calypso. Homer describes it as a sort of
- 40:42remote paradise where Odysseus will be
- 40:45held for seven long years. But, he
- 40:48doesn't provide many geographical
- 40:50details. As a result, scholars and
- 40:52travelers have had a great time. There
- 40:54have been local traditions that have
- 40:55popped up all over the place. One of the
- 40:57most persistent is a place on Gozo known
- 41:01as Calypso's Cave. So, let's take
- 41:03Odysseus, for the sake of argument,
- 41:05round to Gozo. Here we go. His ship has
- 41:08been destroyed. He's coming round here.
- 41:11He's floating a long way,
- 41:13and he's reached the island of Gozo
- 41:16right next to Malta.
- 41:18That island has dramatic cliffs. It's
- 41:20got secluded bays. It's got a fertile
- 41:22landscape. So, you know, it could easily
- 41:24match Homer's description. And the
- 41:26locals are thrilled. They tell everyone
- 41:29who will listen that this is definitely
- 41:31Ogygia since, well, for centuries that's
- 41:33been going on.
- 41:35There are some problems with this. There
- 41:36is no ancient evidence linking that. So,
- 41:39the ancient Greeks and the Romans were
- 41:40not super convinced about that. So, the
- 41:42association is much later than the
- 41:44ancient world. I want to just shout out
- 41:45one of the most rogue theories here. So,
- 41:47I'm coming out to this big map here
- 41:48because Plutarch, the ancient Greek
- 41:49historian, says that this is washed,
- 41:52swept out of the Mediterranean
- 41:53altogether into the Atlantic.
- 41:55And Plutarch says that he was five days
- 41:58west of Britain. So, what where does
- 41:59that get us? So, he comes out of the
- 42:01Mediterranean into the Atlantic, five
- 42:04days west of Britain. Potentially
- 42:05Iceland, Greenland,
- 42:08Newfoundland. Now, I I been to those
- 42:10places, and they could not be described
- 42:13as tropical paradises, but who knows?
- 42:15That's how widely the debate around the
- 42:18geography of the Odyssey has ranged. But
- 42:20for our purposes,
- 42:22we're putting him in slightly more
- 42:24temperate Gozo.
- 42:26And on that island, Calypso keeps
- 42:28Odysseus for years. She loves him. She
- 42:32wants him to stay.
- 42:33Homer says that Odysseus is trapped.
- 42:36He's uh he's he's not willing. He longs
- 42:39for Ithaca. He longs for his wife,
- 42:41Penelope. He longs to get home. He
- 42:43spends his days weeping on the shore.
- 42:46Poor Odysseus, forced to share the bed
- 42:49of this beautiful supernatural
- 42:52woman on this tropical paradise. During
- 42:55those seven long years,
- 42:57Penelope, his wife back in Ithaca,
- 43:00well, she understandably believes her
- 43:01husband is probably dead. His son,
- 43:04Telemachus, grows up without knowing his
- 43:05father. The suitors are pushing ever
- 43:09harder. They're abusing the rules of
- 43:11hospitality. They are demanding that she
- 43:13marries one of them.
- 43:15Finally, Odysseus catches a break. The
- 43:18goddess Athena
- 43:20intervenes on his behalf.
- 43:22She persuades her father, Zeus, to help
- 43:25Odysseus. Zeus agrees and orders Calypso
- 43:30to release poor Odysseus. Hermes, the
- 43:34messenger god, goes down and delivers
- 43:36that command to Calypso. So,
- 43:37reluctantly, Calypso helps Odysseus uh
- 43:40build a raft, get some supplies
- 43:42together, and set out
- 43:45on another voyage across the sea. He's
- 43:47now alone. He's carrying a bit of food
- 43:49and wine. He's navigating by the stars.
- 43:52But,
- 43:53Poseidon spots him as he's halfway on
- 43:56this voyage towards Greece
- 43:58and smashes the raft to bits. Odysseus
- 44:01ends up once again swimming in the water
- 44:04and is eventually washed up
- 44:05on the island of Phaeacia.
- 44:12So, Phaeacia is another mythical place.
- 44:15It's full of magic. There's vessels that
- 44:17steer themselves. There's extraordinary
- 44:19wealth. There's a special relationship
- 44:20with the gods in this particular place.
- 44:23Ancient scholars have suggested Corfu.
- 44:25That's this island here. Uh it's one of
- 44:28the most beautiful of the Ionian
- 44:29Islands. It's got lots of nice harbors
- 44:31and beaches and and it could easily fit
- 44:34Homer's description. So, let's take
- 44:36Odysseus from Calypso here on his raft
- 44:41via catastrophic shipwreck
- 44:43up here
- 44:44to Corfu.
- 44:46Odysseus is washed ashore. He's naked.
- 44:49He's exhausted. He's alone. He hides
- 44:50beneath leaves. He's terrified about
- 44:52what awaits him. But, instead of
- 44:53monsters, he meets a princess, Nausicaa,
- 44:57daughter of the king. She's playing on
- 44:58the beach.
- 45:00Odysseus wins her trust and manages to
- 45:02get himself into the royal palace.
- 45:04And then he tells the story of his
- 45:06wanderings. And the Phaeacians are
- 45:08spellbound. The king orders a ship to
- 45:11take him home loaded with treasure and
- 45:14gifts.
- 45:16Odysseus sleeps all the way back. And
- 45:19the Phaeacians take him to Ithaca. They
- 45:22carry him ashore asleep. They lay him to
- 45:24rest on a beach.
- 45:26Finally, on Ithacan soil
- 45:29after 20 years away. And importantly, he
- 45:33might not have any men with him, but
- 45:35he's got booty. He's got lots of wealth
- 45:37and treasure given him to him by the
- 45:38Phaeacians, which means he's actually
- 45:40richer than he was when he left Troy.
- 45:42Side note, as the Phaeacians sail away,
- 45:45Poseidon punishes them for helping
- 45:46Odysseus by turning their ship into
- 45:48stone.
- 45:50So, here's Odysseus
- 45:51on the final part of his journey being
- 45:54taken home to Ithaca right there.
- 45:58Now, I was lucky enough recently to
- 45:59follow in those footsteps in the wake of
- 46:01Odysseus. and I too went ashore on
- 46:03Ithaca for our recent history hit
- 46:05documentary. I say the real island of
- 46:09Ithaca, and this is the island today in
- 46:11Greece that has the name Ithaca,
- 46:14but there is a little bit of a problem
- 46:16because Homer specifically says that
- 46:18Ithaca is the westernmost of these
- 46:21Ionian Islands, and you can see that
- 46:23today Ithaca is not the westernmost of
- 46:26these islands. Look, there's a huge big
- 46:27island here, Cephalonia, just to the
- 46:28west. So, some people say the old Ithaca
- 46:30could be Lefkada up here, or it could be
- 46:33Cephalonia, but a theory that I find
- 46:35quite exciting is that this bit of
- 46:37Cephalonia here, this of peninsula on
- 46:40the western edge, that this was once an
- 46:42island, and that because of seismic
- 46:45activity, let me just rub this out, you
- 46:47get a land bridge forming here. And that
- 46:51today is is low-lying, it's quite
- 46:53marshy,
- 46:54and that means that Cephalonia was
- 46:56joined to the island to the west. So,
- 46:58that could have been
- 47:00the original Ithaca. Awesome. But for
- 47:03the moment, we're going to assume that
- 47:05Ithaca is Ithaca.
- 47:08Now, as I've mentioned earlier,
- 47:10this year I was able to follow in
- 47:11Odysseus's footsteps, I was able to sail
- 47:13in his wake, and I too washed up on a
- 47:17beach in Ithaca for my recent History
- 47:19Hit documentary. It was so exciting to
- 47:21step foot on Ithaca after years of
- 47:23hearing stories of the Odyssey and and
- 47:25reading and studying it.
- 47:26It's one of those places where
- 47:27archaeology and tradition and myth and
- 47:29storytelling all collide. Look,
- 47:32we need to say it may that be that
- 47:34everything in this story is pure
- 47:35fantasy. It may be that looking for
- 47:37Odysseus's palace is like looking for
- 47:39Hogwarts in Scotland, but it may be that
- 47:42there is a kernel of truth, a whisper of
- 47:45history that inspired the epic story.
- 47:47So, perhaps just perhaps someone called
- 47:49Odysseus did once come ashore on this
- 47:52coast. Just imagine that. It gives you
- 47:54goosebumps. In In speaking of
- 47:55goosebumps,
- 47:56there was a a different island near
- 47:58Ithaca that we visited where we were
- 47:59charged by wild boar. They were all
- 48:02quite chill until the kids arrived. And
- 48:05at that stage, the mom started to get a
- 48:07bit nervous that we were getting too
- 48:08close to the children.
- 48:09And we did get charged a few times. And
- 48:12if you'd been there, you'd have heard
- 48:13and seen some grown men running into the
- 48:16sea in absolute terror. And strange that
- 48:19those pigs could swim. There you go. So,
- 48:21even today these islands are still full
- 48:23of strange and wonderful things. On
- 48:26Ithaca, there are sites that are
- 48:27associated with Odysseus. It's really
- 48:29interesting.
- 48:30There are buildings from the right
- 48:32period, so from the Mycenaean period,
- 48:34but which we know the ancient Greeks and
- 48:36the ancient Romans
- 48:38they believed they were connected with
- 48:41Odysseus. So, they would visit these
- 48:43places like like this one here. I've got
- 48:44an image here. We filmed at a place
- 48:46called Odysseus's palace.
- 48:48This is a place that was visited by
- 48:50ancient tourists who came here to
- 48:52connect with the Odysseus myth. So,
- 48:56let's get back to the Odyssey. Our
- 48:57wandering king Odysseus, he is back in
- 48:59Ithaca, but he doesn't immediately
- 49:00reveal himself. Instead, with Athena's
- 49:03help, he well, he first of all he hides
- 49:05the treasure that's been given to him by
- 49:06the Phaeacians, first things first. But
- 49:08then he realizes to proceed cautiously.
- 49:10He's been gone for 20 years. A new
- 49:12generation has grown up with little
- 49:14personal connection to their absent
- 49:15king. So, Odysseus has lost everything
- 49:18that underpinned his power. He hasn't
- 49:20got any ships, he hasn't got any men.
- 49:22His his loyal servants have probably
- 49:24grown old and died. So, instead Athena
- 49:27disguises him as a beggar and he works
- 49:29his way into the palace to sort of beg
- 49:32for food and gather intelligence. And
- 49:33the suitors mock him, they abuse him. He
- 49:36watches the feasting, he watches the
- 49:38music, the partying that's going on. He
- 49:40watches his his household, his wealth
- 49:43being consumed by these terrible
- 49:44suitors. He reveals himself to his son
- 49:48Telemachus. They have a tearful reunion.
- 49:51And then they come up with a plan, how
- 49:53they're going to win back the kingdom.
- 49:55Athena inspires Penelope, Odysseus's
- 49:59wife, to announce a contest.
- 50:01Whoever can string Odysseus's great bow
- 50:06and shoot an arrow through an opening in
- 50:0912 axe heads, that person will win her
- 50:12hand in marriage. The suitors try, they
- 50:15each take their turn. They compete with
- 50:17each other. None of them can even string
- 50:19the bow, they can't bend the bow to fit
- 50:21the bowstring, let alone shoot an arrow.
- 50:23The disguised Odysseus, the old beggar,
- 50:26asks for a turn. He steps up and strings
- 50:29it effortlessly. Odysseus shoots an
- 50:32arrow cleanly through all 12 axes and at
- 50:35that moment he reveals himself.
- 50:38He kills Antinous, leader of the
- 50:41suitors, with an arrow through the
- 50:43throat.
- 50:45Pandemonium results. The suitors beg for
- 50:48mercy, they offer repayment. Odysseus
- 50:51and Telemachus refuse. There is a battle
- 50:54and father and son, side by side,
- 50:57slaughter the suitors.
- 51:00Odysseus then stands victorious, covered
- 51:03in blood, having reclaimed his palace
- 51:07and his kingdom. After the slaughter,
- 51:09Odysseus orders the palace to be cleaned
- 51:12up and Penelope comes down from her
- 51:14bedroom, is brought before Odysseus, but
- 51:17she's pretty skeptical. She's wise.
- 51:19She's nervous this man is truly her
- 51:20husband. Could this be a trick by the
- 51:22gods? So, Penelope tests him. She says,
- 51:25"Bring down our marriage bed from my
- 51:27bedroom so that this gentleman can have
- 51:29a nice rest, he can go to sleep." And
- 51:31Odysseus reacts immediately. The bed
- 51:33cannot be moved because he himself built
- 51:36that bed,
- 51:37carved from a living olive tree. And
- 51:40only then Penelope finally believes him.
- 51:43Only then does she know
- 51:45that this is the real Odysseus,
- 51:48the only man who knows that secret.
- 51:49Husband and wife are reunited.
- 51:52Odysseus
- 51:54is finally home.
- 51:56Well, that's it, folks. That is the end
- 51:57of this particular Odyssey. I really
- 51:59hope you've enjoyed it. It was great fun
- 52:01to make. I actually got a big series
- 52:03coming up on the Megapad this summer on
- 52:07the history of Britain. It will be
- 52:09delivered straight to your devices. Make
- 52:11sure you smash all the buttons on Dan
- 52:13Snow's History Hit and they won't miss a
- 52:15single one. See you next time.
- 52:20>> [music]
- 52:26[music]
- 52:31[music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Historian Explains the ENTIRE ODYSSEY by Dan Snow's History Hit, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 8,181 words across 1,322 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.