HIST 213 L5 The Age of Napoleon 1 of 2 — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:05Hello everybody. This is Dr. Pearson.
- 0:06I've had some trouble getting this
- 0:08recorded for y'all. I've tried various
- 0:10methods. Hopefully this works. This is
- 0:12the last of our lectures we have for you
- 0:15to take notes on. I'll try to post the
- 0:17PDFs for you. I think for the most part,
- 0:20those of you that have stuck with it and
- 0:21been taking care of the readings and the
- 0:23doc um
- 0:25the discussions and things like that
- 0:26have done a really good job. I think
- 0:28most of you, again, that have stayed
- 0:29engaged are doing a great job with um
- 0:34improving.
- 0:35Um evidence-based direct engagement,
- 0:38quoting things, not just kind of
- 0:40paraphrasing, engaging as historians
- 0:42would with the materials. And I
- 0:44appreciate that. So we've got like
- 0:47basically a little over a week left. Um
- 0:49I'll have this posted hopefully here
- 0:51within the hour.
- 0:52Um so today we come to Napoleon, right?
- 0:57Um
- 0:59The one thing to remember about the
- 1:01Terror is that it only makes sense if
- 1:03you see it as part of a larger movement,
- 1:05as I say here on the slide,
- 1:07um
- 1:08to emergency politics. And throughout
- 1:10the Western world in the last 300 years,
- 1:13anytime a government
- 1:15moves to emergency power, um it sets
- 1:18aside all the rules, right?
- 1:20You have constitutional kind of order
- 1:22which um streamlines things along the
- 1:24lines of rules, and then you have
- 1:26emergency power which allows anything
- 1:29pretty much to go so long as um the
- 1:32pursuit of order, trying to reassure
- 1:34people that things are going to be okay.
- 1:37Remember the Tennis Court Oath began
- 1:39um with the claim of the right of the
- 1:41mass of people to create a constitution.
- 1:44It was powerful. It was hopeful. It was
- 1:45something everybody could believe in.
- 1:47Um but at the same time, France faces
- 1:50war,
- 1:51insurrection at home, in the streets of
- 1:53Paris, and specifically in the west, um
- 1:56economic crises. Like they're still
- 1:58broke all reason this thing started and
- 2:01who represents the nation making
- 2:03everything when you upend the total
- 2:05order right more and more dangerous and
- 2:07bloody.
- 2:09Revolutionary leaders believed right the
- 2:12nation could only be saved by destroying
- 2:14its enemies that gets that's a dangerous
- 2:17road to go down.
- 2:18This idea of course is going to turn the
- 2:20revolution from its ideals of liberty
- 2:23and equality into a kind of politics
- 2:26enforced by fear of suspicion coercion
- 2:29and eventually death.
- 2:31Right after the terror many French
- 2:33people were exhausted by the instability
- 2:35and so they're going to look for
- 2:36something strong where does that come
- 2:38from from the army so order and
- 2:40stability and authority.
- 2:42We can see the revolution moving through
- 2:44a clear arc financial crises have
- 2:46exposed the weakness of the old regime
- 2:49the Estates-General became a debate over
- 2:51sovereignty who has ultimate power
- 2:53right?
- 2:54I mean the National Assembly of the
- 2:56Tennis Court over launching the
- 2:57constitutional revolution something to
- 2:58ground France on the rule of law.
- 3:02Popular pressure and radicalism right
- 3:04and war radicalized the revolution to
- 3:06killing field the terror is going to
- 3:08institutionalize that of violence and
- 3:10the failure again of the cast of
- 3:12directory will give way to an autocrat.
- 3:17Napoleon.
- 3:19Makes sense?
- 3:20I hope so.
- 3:25Okay.
- 3:26Napoleon Bonaparte.
- 3:28He is as it says there on the slide
- 3:32presented either as a guy who saved the
- 3:35revolution or betrayed it right?
- 3:38Both
- 3:40of these interpretations are true
- 3:42and both are false excuse me.
- 3:44I'll water here.
- 3:49Um.
- 3:51So.
- 3:52He ends the revolution's most unstable
- 3:55phase. And remember, this is what most
- 3:56bourgeois, any kind of people, really,
- 3:58but especially middle class people want
- 4:00is order, stability. They don't want to
- 4:02feel like things are always crazy.
- 4:04Um
- 4:06he preserves many of the revolution's
- 4:08social and legal reforms. In fact, he
- 4:09himself says he's loyal to it. He's not
- 4:11looking to bring back the monarchy. Um
- 4:14he'll make peace with the church, and
- 4:15I'll show you that here in a second, but
- 4:16he's not looking to bring back that old
- 4:18that late medieval world.
- 4:20Um he spread these reforms across
- 4:23Europe.
- 4:24However, he also eliminated
- 4:26representative government. It's it's
- 4:28him, right? Censored political life.
- 4:30He's not interested in necessarily
- 4:32raising critiques. He restored slavery
- 4:35in the French colonies, right? So,
- 4:37Napoleon's going to send ships
- 4:39to Saint-Domingue, which eventually
- 4:40became Haiti.
- 4:41And created a new hereditary
- 4:43aristocracy, replacing the old Bourbon
- 4:45regime with a Bonaparte one.
- 4:48Um
- 4:49and through his brilliance, his will,
- 4:52sometimes his luck, sometimes all of it,
- 4:54he'll um
- 4:56create a massive French empire.
- 4:59So, the central question we're looking
- 5:01at today is not whether Napoleon simply
- 5:03betrayed the revolution or not. That's
- 5:05that's not helpful.
- 5:06It's which parts of the revolution he
- 5:07preserved, which parts he suppressed,
- 5:10and how empire, his empire, transformed
- 5:12France, Europe, and the Atlantic world,
- 5:15right? So, that's that big world, right?
- 5:17If you're looking at the landmass
- 5:19um encircling the
- 5:21Atlantic Ocean, Napoleon matters a lot.
- 5:25By 1815, right, Napoleon had been
- 5:26defeated, but Europe couldn't go back to
- 5:28the way it was.
- 5:30Um the old monarchies, some many
- 5:32survived, but the political and social
- 5:34assumptions upon which they were based
- 5:36could not, and would not, and did not.
- 5:40Okay.
- 5:41The Directory.
- 5:44Now, remember the French re This is
- 5:46where all these names get weird. Why is
- 5:47it year three? They start history over,
- 5:50right, with um the destruction of the
- 5:52monarchy. So, the Constitution of year
- 5:54three creates the Directory in 1795,
- 5:57right? So, year three back from 1792.
- 6:01Um those that authored it wanted to
- 6:04avoid both royalism. They didn't want
- 6:06the hard right, right, nor the Jacobin
- 6:09left that had authored the terror.
- 6:14In this model,
- 6:15legislative authority would be divided
- 6:17between two chambers, right, and
- 6:19executive power would be divided among
- 6:21five directors, thus the name Directory.
- 6:24The new regime was deliberately designed
- 6:26to prevent, right, any one faction from
- 6:28dominating France or French politics or
- 6:31French power.
- 6:32In practice, you have to think about it,
- 6:34it suffered from internal weakness,
- 6:36right?
- 6:37So, why? Because the Directory depends
- 6:39on a narrow electorate of property
- 6:41owners. It's associated I don't think I
- 6:44put this on the slide. That's where we
- 6:45go.
- 6:46Um with economic hardship, political
- 6:47instability, social inequality. Now,
- 6:50think about the pressures here. On the
- 6:52right, the royalists want to reverse the
- 6:54revolution, restore the monarchy, and
- 6:56the king's brother's on the throne.
- 6:58Radical Republicans, on the other hand,
- 7:00believe the revolution had not gone far
- 7:02enough.
- 7:03Rather than accepting defeat, right, the
- 7:05government repeatedly used force to
- 7:07remove its enemies. When you do that,
- 7:09you rob yourself of legitimacy,
- 7:10especially when you don't prove yourself
- 7:12capable.
- 7:14The people might tolerate a benevolent
- 7:16dictator so long as,
- 7:19you know, prices are low and you prove
- 7:20yourself competent.
- 7:22Now, more important than you know that,
- 7:23the Directory became increasingly
- 7:25dependent on the army. Over and over and
- 7:27over they got to call the army. Military
- 7:29victories brought money into France.
- 7:31People like money.
- 7:32Enhanced the prestige of successful
- 7:34generals, one above all, right, and
- 7:36protected the government from its
- 7:38domestic enemies. They used the army to
- 7:40quell dissent.
- 7:42But, this dependence creates a danger
- 7:44which I hope by now you can all see.
- 7:46A regime that relies completely on its
- 7:48generals
- 7:49can be overthrown by one.
- 7:51That happens over and over. Napoleon's
- 7:53not the first, not even the last.
- 7:56Uh look at Rome.
- 7:59Julius Caesar brought order, then he
- 8:00became dictator. And all we got, right?
- 8:03So, in France, however, that general was
- 8:06Napoleon Bonaparte.
- 8:08Now, Bonaparte was born in Corsica in
- 8:101769.
- 8:14Um the island had just become French. It
- 8:16was no longer Italian.
- 8:18His family belonged to the minor
- 8:19nobility, kind of those people that
- 8:21bought their way in late or won it um
- 8:23through um prestige from a local
- 8:25monarch. Not especially important, but
- 8:28he specialized in artillery training
- 8:33and the technical aspects of what would
- 8:34become modern war.
- 8:36Um
- 8:37his entry into the minor nobility, his
- 8:39his grandfather's allowed him to enter
- 8:41the French military schools. And again,
- 8:42he was a technical genius. Napoleon
- 8:45understood all details. He was precise.
- 8:48He left nothing to chance.
- 8:50Um
- 8:51>> [clears throat]
- 8:52>> the new schools of artillery, of course,
- 8:53rewarded education, diligence in that
- 8:55way, mathematical skill and precision
- 8:57precision of thinking and thought.
- 8:59Um
- 9:00and he's I'm comfortable saying one of
- 9:02the great military minds the world's
- 9:04known.
- 9:06>> [clears throat]
- 9:07>> During his career, um
- 9:09the revolution had helped him advance
- 9:11quickly.
- 9:12Under the old regime, the highest
- 9:13commands are usually reserved to men of
- 9:14high aristocratic birth, regardless of
- 9:16merit. Now, of course, it creates
- 9:17problems with the French military.
- 9:19Revolutionary warfare, on the other
- 9:21hand,
- 9:22um privileges skill and ability.
- 9:26Just because you're noble, if you're
- 9:27stupid and you lose, revolution's going
- 9:29to make the conditions possible for you
- 9:31to either leave France or get replaced.
- 9:34Right? That's certainly what happened.
- 9:35Now, Napoleon the first gained national
- 9:37attention at Toulon, which is Is it on
- 9:41Our map's a little blurry. I'm sorry,
- 9:42y'all.
- 9:43Um that's in 1793. Why? Well, his um
- 9:46artillery helped Republican forces there
- 9:48recover the city from Royalists and
- 9:49their British allies, right? The Brits
- 9:51are going
- 9:52kind of undermine the French cuz they
- 9:53hate them. In 1795, he also helped
- 9:56suppress a Royalist uprising in Paris.
- 10:00Then he received command of the Army of
- 10:01Italy.
- 10:02Now,
- 10:03the Italian um campaigns, those were
- 10:051796
- 10:09to '97, right? These transform both him
- 10:13um and the French army into France's
- 10:15most celebrated general. Why? He defeats
- 10:18the Austrians. He defeats the Italians.
- 10:20He uh reorganizes conquered territory.
- 10:23He seizes wealth for France. He issues
- 10:26proclamations presenting himself as a
- 10:27liberator, as a great man, right?
- 10:29So, he's already learning, right? By
- 10:311796,
- 10:35in '95,
- 10:36um to present himself, you're going to
- 10:38combine military victory, you need the
- 10:40victory, political propaganda, right?
- 10:42And um administrative reorganization.
- 10:44All that salted with
- 10:47ambition.
- 10:50His ambition is almost limitless.
- 10:53By 1798,
- 10:55Napoleon had led expeditions to Egypt.
- 10:57Now, the campaign there uh was intended
- 11:00to threaten British connections with um
- 11:02India and establish French influence on
- 11:04the Eastern Mediterranean. The idea is
- 11:06trade, money. Empires thrive on trade
- 11:08and power.
- 11:09Um
- 11:11the expedition would combine
- 11:12Enlightenment scholarship and military
- 11:13conquest. So, what does Napoleon bring
- 11:15with him? Scientists, artists,
- 11:18engineers, scholars, all to kind of
- 11:20study the Egyptian knowledge
- 11:22um he wants to expand the European
- 11:25knowledge of Egypt and to deepen and
- 11:27decipher hieroglyphs.
- 11:29He literally goes to the pyramids,
- 11:31right?
- 11:32The campaign was also
- 11:34um violent and arrogant. French forces
- 11:37encountered intense local resistance in
- 11:39Egypt and they didn't care.
- 11:40Uh Napoleon presents France as a friend
- 11:42of Islam and an enemy of tyranny, but um
- 11:46under his rule
- 11:47the Egyptians are going to experience
- 11:49invasion, taxation, occupation, and
- 11:52repression, all those things empires do.
- 11:54Um the fresh destruction of the the
- 11:56British destruction of the French fleet
- 11:58in that is about the Nile
- 12:01left the army isolated
- 12:03and Napoleon eventually demanded his
- 12:04forces and returned to France where the
- 12:06directory was facing another challenge.
- 12:08The thing is the French people don't
- 12:10want to hear about that defeat at the
- 12:11Nile until later. They're hearing about
- 12:13all the success Napoleon's having.
- 12:20So, um November 9th and 10th, 1799,
- 12:25um that's the 18th and 19th Brumaire in
- 12:29the new French calendar.
- 12:32Napoleon will participate in a coup
- 12:34against the directory. Now, what do the
- 12:36conspirators want? They are saying the
- 12:39republic has moved um
- 12:41they don't want to go back into disorder
- 12:42and extremism. They want to save the
- 12:44republic from the left and the right.
- 12:45Now, in this instance,
- 12:47um those seizing power are always going
- 12:49to blame the left.
- 12:51Directly rising from the right. Um
- 12:54the legislature was moved outside of
- 12:56Paris at the time. Uh soldiers would uh
- 12:58surround all the deputies and the
- 13:01existing constitution was of course
- 13:03suspended.
- 13:05Um
- 13:07It did not proceed as smoothly. In fact,
- 13:10it did almost didn't work. Now, Napoleon
- 13:12will make sure to
- 13:14edit this later in propaganda, but um
- 13:17Napoleon will face resistance
- 13:20um
- 13:22and turned it out speaking rather poorly
- 13:23and hotly among the uh the arrog- um
- 13:26among the deputies gathered there.
- 13:30Right. Let me see.
- 13:32Sorry. My camera's being strange. That's
- 13:35fine.
- 13:37>> [clears throat]
- 13:39>> His brother, Lucien Bonaparte, right,
- 13:41serving as president of the Council of
- 13:43500, that's the legislature, right,
- 13:46helped turn the situation around and
- 13:48eventually greased the wheels for in
- 13:50Napoleon's favor.
- 13:52Troops would eventually clear the
- 13:53chamber and a provisional government was
- 13:55established.
- 13:57With the France remaining officially a
- 13:59republic, but all meaningful power
- 14:01transferred to the hands of the first
- 14:03consul.
- 14:04There'd be three. The other two won't
- 14:05matter.
- 14:06The first consul is Napoleon Bonaparte.
- 14:09Now, the coup coup de main is often
- 14:10treated as the end of the French
- 14:11Revolution, and that's kind of a debate
- 14:13you can have.
- 14:15It's useful
- 14:16as if if you were defining the
- 14:17revolution as a period of open political
- 14:20experimentation and competition.
- 14:23But many of these revolutionary changes
- 14:24would continue after 1799.
- 14:27So, what Brumaire does is end the
- 14:28revolutionary republic. But it does not
- 14:31end the effort to transform French
- 14:33society.
- 14:36Now,
- 14:39Napoleon's going to offer French
- 14:42the French people a bargain.
- 14:43He would preserve many of the
- 14:45revolution's conquered achievements,
- 14:47right? So, those things that the French
- 14:49had achieved, ending the monarchy, a
- 14:52more legitimate kind of law, he's also
- 14:54going to end disorder.
- 14:56For peasants and property owners, he's
- 14:58going to guarantee the sale of the
- 14:59church and immigrant lands. So, if you
- 15:00left France, you get to keep those
- 15:02lands. Those
- 15:03uh petite bourgeois, the small middle
- 15:05class, if you bought church lands or the
- 15:06lands of nobles, you get to keep them.
- 15:09There'd be no restoration of feudal
- 15:11dues, no restoration of the kind of
- 15:13estates, no restoration of any kind of
- 15:16old medieval um
- 15:18obligations to the church.
- 15:21For the wealthy and the educated, right?
- 15:23And Napoleon promised careers based
- 15:25partly on talent and service. Now, there
- 15:27would still be some bribes, but mostly
- 15:30he's trying to find an an educated
- 15:31bureau- bureaucracy that's effective.
- 15:38For conservatives and Catholics,
- 15:40he restored public worship. He also
- 15:42offered protection for church property
- 15:44and for the rights of the masses or
- 15:46things like that.
- 15:47For former revolutionaries, he offered
- 15:49protection from royalist um revenge.
- 15:52For returning immigrants, right, he
- 15:54provided opportunities for
- 15:55reconciliation if they accepted the new
- 15:57order.
- 15:59And what do they have to accept?
- 16:01Absolute power to the first consul.
- 16:04So, his government is resting therefore
- 16:06on reconciliation, property, the rights
- 16:09of property, administrative competence.
- 16:11Remember, you don't get to stay in
- 16:13charge if you're stupid and bad and
- 16:15people are broke.
- 16:17Um he's going to give them military
- 16:18glory, victory. Napoleon usually wins.
- 16:22And political obedience. That's the
- 16:24price.
- 16:25You will you will obey Napoleon.
- 16:28Uh and most people thought that was a
- 16:30price worth it after over a decade of
- 16:33instability,
- 16:34they're willing to take a shot.
- 16:37So, what do we see?
- 16:39The terror, right, is the excesses of
- 16:41the left. All right, before that we'd
- 16:43seen the excesses of the right, the
- 16:44royalist regime. Both are incompetent.
- 16:45They erode in the middle because they
- 16:47can't hold sway because of competence.
- 16:50So, I'm going
- 16:51kind of a comic book fan as you see.
- 16:53Um
- 16:54So, whenever you see the Riddler there
- 16:55in any class I'm teaching, that means
- 16:57we're going to ask questions or
- 16:58summarize.
- 16:59If you have questions, write them down.
- 17:02Good thing about a video, right, you can
- 17:03stop me talking and make sure you have
- 17:05what you need and send them to me. So,
- 17:07if you're confused at all, let me know.
- 17:10We will continue. Let me
- 17:13move this up in here. So, everybody
- 17:14understand how Napoleon comes to power
- 17:17using the platform of the military
- 17:18competence and success outrunning his
- 17:21embarrassments and making sure he gets
- 17:23credit for all the wins.
- 17:28So, what does Napoleon do? Um, he
- 17:30strengthens, um,
- 17:31the state. So, the power from the
- 17:33periphery comes to the state and
- 17:35specifically to him.
- 17:36In 1800, he's going to introduce a
- 17:39prefect system where each department or
- 17:41state, so it's kind of like these
- 17:43departments, they're almost like states
- 17:45in France, will be supervised by a
- 17:47prefect appointed by the central
- 17:49government.
- 17:50All right, what do prefects do? They
- 17:52implement national policy, they collect
- 17:54information, yes, they're spying on you.
- 17:56They monitor local opinions, so again,
- 17:58they're spying on you. Supervise
- 17:59officials and maintain order. They also
- 18:01make sure laws are obeyed, which people
- 18:03like.
- 18:04They're kind of good with this.
- 18:06Um, local elections, while continuing,
- 18:09become pretty much meaningless.
- 18:11Mayors and other officials were
- 18:13appointed, they're not elected.
- 18:15Um, the state reached far more deeply
- 18:17and more consistently
- 18:19into provincial life
- 18:22um, the Bourbon monarchy had ever
- 18:23managed to do.
- 18:25Right, the king ruled absolutely in
- 18:27theory, but mostly he just stayed in
- 18:29Paris.
- 18:30So, if you were a peasant, you were more
- 18:31or less left alone as long as you worked
- 18:32your land.
- 18:33Not anymore.
- 18:35The revolution cares what you think.
- 18:36Now,
- 18:37nobody's meant to be ahead, right? Rule
- 18:38of law, property and all that.
- 18:41>> [clears throat]
- 18:42>> But, there is quite a lot, uh, quite a
- 18:43large loss of autonomy.
- 18:46This system, I think, became one of
- 18:47Napoleon's most durable and lasting and
- 18:49important legacies, right? A
- 18:51revolutionary France had abolished the
- 18:53old patchwork of provinces and
- 18:55privileges.
- 18:56Um, Napoleon now turned to departments.
- 19:00These new departments are going to be
- 19:01led by appointed administrators
- 19:03reporting to him.
- 19:06Now,
- 19:07what is this all about, ladies and
- 19:10gentlemen
- 19:12of [clears throat] summer 2 2026.
- 19:15Financial reform.
- 19:16Remember, the revolution had been
- 19:17haunted by money crisis. The French
- 19:19government was broke. That is why
- 19:23Louis called the Estates-General in the
- 19:24first place in his inability to manage
- 19:26that effectively is why he lost his
- 19:27head.
- 19:29Right? The French had been haunted by
- 19:30fiscal crisis, inflation,
- 19:34um unstable political or paper currency.
- 19:37All that undermines the political
- 19:38legitimacy of the regime.
- 19:40So, what is Napoleon going to do? You
- 19:42don't get to stay emperor. You don't get
- 19:44to stay anything if you're not
- 19:45competent.
- 19:47He's going to be competent. He wants to
- 19:48restore confidence in the system. So,
- 19:52um Napoleon establishes the Bank of
- 19:54France
- 19:56right?
- 19:58in 1800.
- 19:59Um tax collection will become more
- 20:01efficient. Government accounting will
- 20:03improve, which depending on your
- 20:05perspective, is good or bad, but at
- 20:06least the government's books are better.
- 20:08And um
- 20:09national currency of the franc was
- 20:11established, right?
- 20:13And stabilized, sorry. The money is
- 20:15going to be worth something now. It's
- 20:16not all over the place in terms of, you
- 20:18know, or deflation.
- 20:20>> [clears throat]
- 20:20>> Napoleon's regime is also better able to
- 20:23mobilize French wealth
- 20:25than the old monarchy had ever been able
- 20:26to do.
- 20:28Now, this is a huge change, right? The
- 20:30Bourbons had helped cause the revolution
- 20:32because they couldn't reform national
- 20:34finances without provoking resistance
- 20:36from all those privileged institutions.
- 20:38The church and the aristocrats and many
- 20:40of the rich
- 20:41um middle class didn't want to have to
- 20:43give up all their exceptions.
- 20:46Napoleon governed a society in which
- 20:47many of those institutions had been
- 20:49abolished,
- 20:50placed under the boot of the state.
- 20:52So,
- 20:53in practice, his state was more
- 20:55centralized, more uniform, and far more
- 20:57capable of taxation and conscription
- 21:01than any of his predecessors had been.
- 21:03And think about it, who's he backed by?
- 21:05The army.
- 21:07Firmly behind their general.
- 21:09So, you're not really going to be able
- 21:10to say too much there.
- 21:15>> [clears throat]
- 21:15>> Napoleon also establishes
- 21:17state-controlled secondary schools,
- 21:19which are called lycee or lycees if
- 21:22you're from Kentucky.
- 21:23Now, their purpose is not really the
- 21:26universalize democratic education.
- 21:28That'll come kind of later.
- 21:30No, they're designed to primarily train
- 21:32military officers, civil servants,
- 21:34professionals, and loyal administrators.
- 21:36A well-trained, very loyal bureaucratic
- 21:39cadre.
- 21:43This system emphasized discipline,
- 21:45hierarchy, mathematics, classical
- 21:47learning, especially languages in Greek
- 21:49and philosophy. So, grammar, rhetoric,
- 21:51logic logic, rhetoric.
- 21:53And of course service to the state cuz
- 21:55that's how you got your job.
- 22:00Scholarships did allow some talented
- 22:02people of modest origins. So, you could
- 22:04be kind of broke and if you could caught
- 22:06the eye of the right people, get a shot.
- 22:08Um but access was highly any.
- 22:12Now, the police had a famous principle,
- 22:14right? Careers open to talent contained
- 22:17a kind of I think a really legitimate
- 22:19revolutionary element to it.
- 22:21Um birth certainly mattered less than it
- 22:23had in the ancien regime. But what still
- 22:26matters?
- 22:28Money.
- 22:29Money.
- 22:30Um education, personal connections, and
- 22:33loyalty to to the regime. Matters a lot.
- 22:36So, this Napoleonic meritocracy
- 22:39was not really equality. I mean, I think
- 22:41it was a breadth a broadening though of
- 22:43access.
- 22:45Um but it was a system in which the
- 22:47selected men could rise by serving in
- 22:49the state. So,
- 22:51they create new elites.
- 22:57Two.
- 22:58There's the famous Concordat of 1801.
- 23:00Now, remember,
- 23:02France is known even now as the oldest
- 23:03daughter of the church. The first
- 23:06Western state after the fall of Rome to
- 23:08accept Christianity. Right?
- 23:11Historically a staunchly Catholic
- 23:12country. Um
- 23:15The Pope and the the Catholic and even
- 23:18the Protestant churches weren't excited
- 23:20about the kind of rampant atheism and
- 23:22anti-church um
- 23:24um not only policies but you know,
- 23:27repression.
- 23:28Um
- 23:29of the terror and other kinds of things.
- 23:30Many many religious died, right?
- 23:33Faithful lay Catholics and then
- 23:35you know, famously there's the Carmelite
- 23:37nuns that went singing to the
- 23:38guillotine.
- 23:40Um
- 23:41So, what Napoleon's going to do in 1801
- 23:45is um try to resolve that. So, relations
- 23:48between revolutionary France and the
- 23:49Roman Catholic Church had been deeply
- 23:51divisive.
- 23:52Um
- 23:53The revolutionary government had seized
- 23:55church lands. The civil constitution of
- 23:56the clergy had
- 23:58peeled off um clerical loyalty to Rome
- 24:01and to the church and to Jesus more
- 24:03broadly, right? And placed it on the
- 24:05state.
- 24:06Um
- 24:07At its height of sort of left-wing maybe
- 24:11radicalism
- 24:12the French state had even pursued a
- 24:14policy of de-Christianization.
- 24:16Re-christening Notre Dame, all right, as
- 24:18a temple of reason.
- 24:20The revolutionary calendar had alienated
- 24:22pretty much the entire countryside. It
- 24:24was weird and crazy and people didn't
- 24:25really like it. Um so, what does
- 24:27Napoleon do?
- 24:29He negotiates directly with Pius the
- 24:30VII,
- 24:31the Bishop of Rome, the Pope, right, in
- 24:331801.
- 24:34Um
- 24:36Catholicism is recognized as the
- 24:38religion of the vast majority of French
- 24:40citizens, but it was not restored to its
- 24:43its place as exclusive state religion.
- 24:45There would be religious toleration,
- 24:47which is a nice nod to the Protestants
- 24:49and especially among the middle class.
- 24:52Right? Most of your Catholics are fairly
- 24:53poor or they're really rich.
- 24:55Public [clears throat] worship would
- 24:56resume. Churches could resume their
- 24:58bishop, bishops were reorganized, and
- 25:00the clergy would now be paid by the
- 25:02state, which of course if you're kind of
- 25:04like
- 25:05less burden on the people.
- 25:07Um the Pope in his turn accepted the
- 25:09loss of the church lands. And this is
- 25:12crucial, right, because it reassured new
- 25:13land owners competence that property
- 25:16would be supported.
- 25:18Um that the church would not come to
- 25:20threaten their property, right?
- 25:21Um I think this really demonstrates
- 25:24Napoleon's uh political method. He's not
- 25:27going to restore pre-revolutionary
- 25:29privilege to the church. He's not going
- 25:31to do it. Instead, he's going to
- 25:33incorporate religion and religious
- 25:34toleration into the new centralized
- 25:36order he's building.
- 25:38Catholicism would help produce that
- 25:40social order.
- 25:41The church would remain subordinate
- 25:43to the state. And actually, this is kind
- 25:46of a consequence, right? Not So, you got
- 25:48the Reformation, the Napoleonic Wars,
- 25:51right? Before that, the Thirty Years'
- 25:52War,
- 25:54the World Wars.
- 25:56Even now, the most supreme authority in
- 25:58anybody's life, mine, yours, everybody,
- 26:00but the place beyond which you cannot
- 26:01appeal is not the church, regardless of
- 26:04which church you may belong to or don't.
- 26:07The supreme authority in your life is
- 26:08political.
- 26:09That's
- 26:11kind of a consequence of this, right?
- 26:14You cannot seek sanctuary
- 26:16on church property in a monastery
- 26:17anymore.
- 26:19You couldn't go to your pastor
- 26:21as a legitimate um
- 26:23bulk or bullwark against which the state
- 26:24must respect.
- 26:25If there's a criminal in a like a local
- 26:27Baptist church here in Knox County,
- 26:29the sheriff can and will go into that
- 26:31church
- 26:32and seize that person. That would be a
- 26:34gross violation in the medieval world.
- 26:37Wouldn't happen.
- 26:38You could seek sanctuary anymore.
- 26:40The state right now is supreme.
- 26:43All right, so that's the Napoleonic That
- 26:45was the Concordat showed us. He's not
- 26:46going to restore the pre-revolutionary
- 26:49order, right? But he is going to offer
- 26:51more broad toleration um for disaffected
- 26:54groups so long as they are subordinate
- 26:56to the state.
- 27:00So, what else does he do?
- 27:02Napoleon sharply restricts freedom of
- 27:05expression.
- 27:07Pretty much all autocrats do this.
- 27:09Newspapers are closed or placed under
- 27:11government supervision. Publishers and
- 27:13booksellers are monitored. The police
- 27:15collected information and political
- 27:17opinions, what people were saying,
- 27:19writing, thinking, whatever. Former
- 27:22Jacobins, royalists, Jesuits especially
- 27:25they're going to be suppressed
- 27:26eventually. Staunch loyal
- 27:28church people, anything not loyal to the
- 27:31state is going to be a problem.
- 27:32Public debate is going to be replaced by
- 27:35a managed political culture.
- 27:38So, there're going to be official art,
- 27:39official newspapers, official
- 27:40ceremonies, official bulletins, medals,
- 27:43monuments, paintings, all glorifying
- 27:46First Consul.
- 27:48Now,
- 27:50Napoleonic propaganda would blend
- 27:52several different traditions invoking
- 27:53right to height of the Roman Empire, the
- 27:56French kind of deep strength of
- 27:58Charlemagne,
- 28:00and the kind of
- 28:01trappings of the French monarchy.
- 28:04It'll also be balanced with
- 28:05enlightenment rationality, revolutionary
- 28:08citizenship at least in theory, and
- 28:10military heroism which
- 28:12everyone can understand in theory to be
- 28:14able to everybody.
- 28:15So, the result then is a modern military
- 28:18dictatorship using both coercion,
- 28:20persuasion,
- 28:22and mass communication.
- 28:24Makes sense?
- 28:28So, I just want you all to see, right,
- 28:30how Napoleon is doing this.
- 28:32He's offering success and stability,
- 28:35right, in exchange for obedience.
- 28:38He's kind of getting to side from the
- 28:40old petty disputes between right and
- 28:42left. Everybody's now under the heel of
- 28:44Bonaparte.
- 28:45While making the system more or less
- 28:47work in delivering victories for the
- 28:49French.
- 28:50Because Bonaparte was brilliant, and the
- 28:52French had one of the largest, most
- 28:54effective, most modern armies
- 28:56um in the world.
- 29:05>> [clears throat]
- 29:07>> Um a few other things you should know
- 29:11about Napoleon before we set off for war
- 29:13is um these twin themes of legal unity
- 29:17and through the limits of equality.
- 29:19Honestly, one of Napoleon's most
- 29:21enduring achievements is the Civil Code
- 29:23of 1804.
- 29:25Most textbooks just call it the
- 29:27Napoleonic Code.
- 29:29It's up there with the Justinian Codex,
- 29:32right? From the Byzantine era, which
- 29:33codified Roman law. Um it's it's yeah,
- 29:37it's
- 29:38really, really important.
- 29:39Um now, before the Revolution, France,
- 29:42as I've told y'all and you've read,
- 29:43hopefully, uh had multiple legal
- 29:45traditions all stacked, sometimes in
- 29:47confusing and contradictory and
- 29:48paradoxical ways.
- 29:50Laws varied by province, they varied by
- 29:53status, they varied by So, if you're
- 29:54rich or poor, by corporation, by custom,
- 29:58by tradition, uh are you talking
- 30:00dynastic, are you talking urban, are you
- 30:02talking rural, are you talking lord,
- 30:04king, mayor, whatever.
- 30:07Um
- 30:09it was confusing and terrible. It didn't
- 30:10really work well.
- 30:11Um the Revolution had proclaimed, right,
- 30:14in theory, legal equality, but it had
- 30:16not completed a unified civil code. This
- 30:18is what the Napoleonic Code does. It
- 30:20establishes a more uniform legal
- 30:22framework. Doing what?
- 30:24Protecting private property, affirming
- 30:26the end of feudal privilege, supporting
- 30:29freedom of contract, and treating at
- 30:30least male citizens as formally equal
- 30:32under the law.
- 30:34All these principles reflect the social
- 30:36revolution that began in 1789.
- 30:39Noble birth would no longer
- 30:41automatically place someone in a
- 30:42separate legal category.
- 30:45Offices and rights are no longer
- 30:46supposed to depend on hereditary
- 30:48privileges, although
- 30:50money would matter.
- 30:52But, hey, there you go.
- 30:54So, what are the limits of this?
- 30:56Um you see a conservative social vision
- 30:58kind of leaking through. On the one
- 30:59hand, it is it's a massive improvement
- 31:02and elements of it will be carried all
- 31:03over the world as the basis fundamental
- 31:06order of, you know,
- 31:08all legal systems, really.
- 31:10They're kind of a mashup of the American
- 31:12idea and a
- 31:13Napoleonic kind of balance. Property,
- 31:17no privilege, equality before the law,
- 31:20justice should be blind. So,
- 31:23>> [clears throat]
- 31:24>> in most history classes,
- 31:27um if you're looking for um
- 31:29where are the exceptions, there's like
- 31:31the old triad, right? Race, class,
- 31:33gender. So,
- 31:35people of color, right, carved out there
- 31:38in Napoleon, despite all this rhetoric
- 31:40of supporting
- 31:42the free rights of man, if you're a
- 31:43brown or black person,
- 31:46not necessarily included. This is
- 31:48absolutely hypocritical to the
- 31:50revolution's idea of equality for all.
- 31:53Um the the French will launch in
- 31:55Napoleon's two or three attempts to
- 31:57reconquer Saint-Domingue, Haiti.
- 32:00They won't succeed.
- 32:01Um
- 32:04um class. Workers face many
- 32:06restrictions, right? Labor organizations
- 32:08are prohibited. The legal system is
- 32:10going to employ favor employers and
- 32:12those that hold contracts, those that
- 32:13are not bound by them.
- 32:15So, it's going to combine civil equality
- 32:18among these white men, right, within
- 32:20hierarchy of households and workplaces
- 32:23and
- 32:24we've got some more Saint-Domingue here
- 32:25in a sec.
- 32:26Um and of course there's women.
- 32:29Uh women's legal independence was deeply
- 32:31restricted. Married women were placed
- 32:33under the authority of husbands, fathers
- 32:35exercised extensive, if not complete
- 32:38control over their children.
- 32:39Divorce did remain legal, which was
- 32:42something new,
- 32:44but it became very difficult to obtain.
- 32:47Um
- 32:49So, the revolution is going to destroy
- 32:51legal privileges based on the estate,
- 32:53but it did not produce universal
- 32:54equality.
- 32:56Okay.
- 32:57Napoleon also will stabilize the social
- 33:00society of a legal
- 33:02um legally equal males, property owning
- 33:04men.
- 33:05While reinforcing
- 33:07race, class, colonial, and imperial
- 33:09hierarchy.
- 33:12Limits, right? Limits.
- 33:17Couple more things that I want to
- 33:19probably pause here and I'll just post a
- 33:21part two.
- 33:22>> [snorts]
- 33:22>> Um
- 33:24Napoleon's authority became
- 33:25progressively more personal and more
- 33:27hereditary, right? He's not necessarily
- 33:30looking to hand this thing off to
- 33:31somebody he doesn't know or trust, and
- 33:33even ugly men want their kids to look
- 33:34like them.
- 33:36Um in 1802, he becomes first consul for
- 33:38life.
- 33:39In 1804, he declared himself emperor of
- 33:42the French.
- 33:45Um
- 33:47A broad national consensus, defined
- 33:51however you might want to think about
- 33:52it, more or less approved this.
- 33:55Um
- 33:56Emperor of the French, right?
- 34:00Implied rule over a people rather than
- 34:02ownership of a territory.
- 34:04It's a new empire increasingly resembles
- 34:06a hereditary monarchy.
- 34:08So, what does Napoleon create? A court
- 34:11with titles, ceremonies, and a new
- 34:12nobility, nobility of his loyal
- 34:15followers.
- 34:17So, the revolution had abolished, right,
- 34:19hereditary aristocratic privilege, and
- 34:21Napoleon established a new elite based
- 34:23on money,
- 34:24state service and loyalty to him, and
- 34:26military distinction.
- 34:29Titles returned, but feudal rights did
- 34:30not.
- 34:31So, the new order is not exactly like
- 34:33the old one.
- 34:38Um
- 34:40Napoleon's coronation took place. I
- 34:43believe that's in December
- 34:451804 with the Pope present.
- 34:51Painting's fairly important here. You
- 34:53can kind of see on the slide there's the
- 34:55Pope sitting down. All the cardinals are
- 34:57there.
- 34:59Um
- 35:00It's Jacques-Louis David or David's a
- 35:03It's huge painting, right? Which is on
- 35:05purpose.
- 35:06This is the emperor.
- 35:08It shows uh Napoleon uh crowning his
- 35:11wife Josephine.
- 35:13And [clears throat] what are we seeing
- 35:14here? There's imperial authority
- 35:17um
- 35:17presented as majestic, religiously
- 35:20sanctioned, orderly, and um
- 35:24politically unified.
- 35:26Napoleon will famously crown himself.
- 35:29It's let you know from where he believes
- 35:31his power derives. Himself.
- 35:34So, the Napoleonic empire, right, is
- 35:36going to combine multiple sources of
- 35:38legitimacy.
- 35:39Any successful one's going to have to
- 35:41do.
- 35:42Roman imperial imagery,
- 35:44the empire,
- 35:45Catholic ceremony,
- 35:47French monarchical grandeur, right,
- 35:49revolutionary nationalism,
- 35:52popular ratification and support
- 35:55based on what?
- 35:57Military victory.
- 36:01So, he's not going backward to kingship.
- 36:03What he's doing is constructing a new
- 36:05form of post-revolutionary monarchy
- 36:08based on his own cult of personality and
- 36:10wins.
- 36:11All filtered through a revised legal
- 36:13system um
- 36:15theoretically where uh rewarding merit.
- 36:23So,
- 36:25why keep fighting?
- 36:27The French have been at war with various
- 36:29European powers pretty much constantly
- 36:31since 1792.
- 36:34Um Napoleon will inherit many of these
- 36:36conflicts. In fact, service in those
- 36:37wars had propelled him to power.
- 36:40Um
- 36:41but for his part, he's going to expand
- 36:43them.
- 36:44European monarchs feared French power
- 36:47and revolutionary influence.
- 36:49These ideas undermined their own rule
- 36:52based as it was on late medieval
- 36:54understandings of monarchy, princes,
- 36:57kings. The revolution's whole language
- 36:59is hostile to that.
- 37:01Also, the French are one of the biggest
- 37:03and when they're working right, richest,
- 37:07most powerful mon- armies in the world.
- 37:12It's huge.
- 37:13All right.
- 37:17English will oppose French control of
- 37:19the low countries. That's up there by
- 37:21Denmark, right? North Sea.
- 37:23And the European coast. Austria,
- 37:26Prussia, and Russia will compete with
- 37:27the French and one another over
- 37:29territory and influence in Central and
- 37:31Eastern Europe.
- 37:32Um but what did I tell you?
- 37:35Napoleon needs victories and wars for
- 37:38political legitimacy. Why?
- 37:40Victories bring prestige. They bring
- 37:42money. They bring territory and
- 37:44bargaining power with your defeated
- 37:46enemies.
- 37:47Defeated states will pay
- 37:49um stipends and indemnities, which will
- 37:52then support French armies. Conquest
- 37:55will allow Napoleon to place relatives
- 37:57and allies on European thrones, and he
- 37:59will do this.
- 38:00So, war's not an accident.
- 38:03It's one of its foundations.
- 38:06Now,
- 38:08the other side of this is Napoleon
- 38:10practices a new kind of war.
- 38:13The revolutionary wars and the
- 38:14Napoleonic ones that followed them,
- 38:16right? Differ in, first of all, scale
- 38:20from most 18th century conflicts.
- 38:22We talk about the levee en masse and
- 38:24said that's the um
- 38:26draft of 1793.
- 38:29This said established the principle the
- 38:30nation can mobilize its citizens for
- 38:32war. Now, it said for protection, but
- 38:36protection moves to conquest pretty
- 38:37easily.
- 38:38Um Napoleon will inherit a large
- 38:40conscript army organized into flexible
- 38:42cores. Each core can move independently
- 38:44for a time and unite with the others for
- 38:46major battles.
- 38:48Napoleon's forces usually moved rapidly
- 38:50concentrating them against isolated
- 38:51enemies seeking this decisive
- 38:53engagements.
- 38:55Um
- 38:56What does success require?
- 38:58Organization, logistics, experienced
- 39:00officers loyal to the vision, high
- 39:02morale, and the human resources made
- 39:05available by a revolutionary state
- 39:07centralized and bureaucratic, right?
- 39:09This is not industrial war yet.
- 39:12Armies have to depend on horses and
- 39:14roads and local food supplies and
- 39:16seasonal conditions. You can't campaign
- 39:17in the winter, it's too cold,
- 39:19or the rainy seasons.
- 39:20However,
- 39:22warfare now would mobilize whole
- 39:23populations, whole economies, and
- 39:26national identities will be grafted onto
- 39:28it on an unprecedented scale.
- 39:30It's wins for the French,
- 39:32right? Nobody's better at it, at least
- 39:34initially, than Napoleon Bonaparte.
- 39:44Okay, a couple of examples.
- 39:47Uh
- 39:48I'll summarize this and try to buffer
- 39:50this particular video and we'll put up
- 39:52number two in a second. Where are we at?
- 39:5440 minutes here.
- 39:56In 1805, Napoleon defeated the combined
- 39:59forces of Russia and Austria at
- 40:01Austerlitz, one of the great victories
- 40:03um
- 40:05of the last 300 years.
- 40:06Um this battle would destroy the third
- 40:09coalition. Your book talks a little bit
- 40:10about them. It confirms the French
- 40:11dominance of Central Europe. Napoleon
- 40:13just wins.
- 40:15In 1806, the Holy Roman Empire itself
- 40:17was dissolved after a thousand years
- 40:19more or less of existing in some kind of
- 40:21form.
- 40:22Um,
- 40:24he reorganized many German states into
- 40:26what he calls the Confederation of the
- 40:27Rhine.
- 40:28Uh, later victories over Prussia and
- 40:31Russia will extend this influence. And
- 40:34then I think there's the treaties of
- 40:35Tilsit in 1807, which will mark the
- 40:37height of European um, Napoleon's
- 40:39mastery of Europe.
- 40:42Um, by 1807 he pretty much dominates the
- 40:45French or the European continent, right?
- 40:47His empire will include territories
- 40:49directly annexed to France, satellite
- 40:51kingdoms ruled by Napoleon's allies or
- 40:53relatives or lackeys, and defeated
- 40:55states forced into cooperation. So, it's
- 40:58not a single outside of French borders
- 41:00uniform structure. Different regions
- 41:02experience different combinations of
- 41:04reform, exploitation, military
- 41:06occupation, and collaboration. But, they
- 41:08all are going to be under the boot of
- 41:10Napoleon's armies.
- 41:13Um, French armies will also carry
- 41:14important revolutionary uh, reforms with
- 41:17them wherever they go.
- 41:18In many regions they um,
- 41:22the new French rulers abolish or weaken
- 41:24feudal dues, they eliminate corporate
- 41:26privileges, they reorganize the church,
- 41:29um, introduce legal equality, and adopt
- 41:32versions of the Napoleonic code.
- 41:35Um, if you're Jewish in parts of Western
- 41:37or Central Europe, French rule brought
- 41:39civil emancipation and removal of the
- 41:41medieval um, not suspicion and
- 41:43anti-Semitism so there, but at least it
- 41:44regularized things under the law.
- 41:47If you're part of the middle classes,
- 41:49standard law and careers in government
- 41:50would create new opportunities for you.
- 41:53This explains why some Europeans
- 41:55initially welcomed um, the French
- 41:57armies. Because French conquest um,
- 42:01feared offer right liberation of birth
- 42:02to credit privilege, clerical power,
- 42:05fragmented administrations, so
- 42:06incompetent, and feudal obligations.
- 42:09Um, but that's only one side of the
- 42:11coin. The other side of it, right, is
- 42:13um, these reforms come with military
- 42:15occupation, censorship, taxation,
- 42:17economic demands.
- 42:20Empires exist to make the mother country
- 42:22rich.
- 42:23In this case, the metropole, the
- 42:25Paris, French.
- 42:26They they want an empire to make
- 42:27themselves rich.
- 42:29So, you get occupation, censorship,
- 42:32taxation,
- 42:33economic demands,
- 42:36um conscription of population to into
- 42:38wars, right? And of course, political
- 42:39subordination.
- 42:41The French are liberating
- 42:46people while denying themselves rule.
- 42:49Right?
- 42:51It'll be this contradiction between
- 42:52liberation and empire that he ends he
- 42:54overextends himself, which will
- 42:56ultimately undermine Napoleonic rule.
- 42:59All right, so that's 45 minutes there.
- 43:03If you have any questions, let me know.
- 43:06I'm going to buffer this
- 43:09and
- 43:10um
- 43:11the second part of this.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of HIST 213 L5 The Age of Napoleon 1 of 2 by Dr. Pearson's History Channel, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 6,302 words across 1,234 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.