High Anxieties - The Mathematics of Chaos - BBC documentary — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:06What has ultimately always stood behind
- 0:08our conviction that the world is a
- 0:11knowable and therefore controllable
- 0:13place is that the mathematics which
- 0:15governs the world said so.
- 0:22[Music]
- 0:33[Music]
- 0:46But what happens when that assurance is
- 0:48taken away? When the mathematics begins
- 0:50to tell us that perhaps the world isn't
- 0:52as predictable and controllable as we
- 0:54once thought? that our old assurances
- 0:57might be wrong.
- 0:58Financial markets across the globe are
- 1:00in turmoil this afternoon as another big
- 1:02bank collapses.
- 1:05And when the disasters of today begin to
- 1:07fuel fears for tomorrow,
- 1:12there is a growing awareness of the fact
- 1:15that uh the world in which we live is uh
- 1:20impredictable, chaotic. One of the most
- 1:22powerful hurricans on record hits the
- 1:24Gulf Coast
- 1:25is now plowing it way.
- 1:27We thought we could control everything.
- 1:28Now we feel we can control nothing. And
- 1:30and that comes out of this notion that
- 1:32there is chaos in the world that you you
- 1:34can never know enough to be able to
- 1:35really predict it, let alone control it.
- 1:38From simple models and the mathematics
- 1:40which control them is coming a challenge
- 1:43to our old worldview.
- 1:46There's a simple human need to have a
- 1:47forecast about the future. There's a
- 1:49there's a deep desire if you like to be
- 1:51able to control the future and a very
- 1:53very deep reluctance to accept the
- 1:55really modern advances in mathematics
- 1:57which suggests that there are high
- 1:59levels of fundamental unpredictability.
- 2:02America's mortgage crisis fears for the
- 2:04future of two huge companies after their
- 2:06shields from the impact of the latest
- 2:09hurricane. Hundreds of lives have been
- 2:11lost.
- 2:11It used to be that our dreams of the
- 2:13future were of a bright and open place.
- 2:17What happened to us that our vision of
- 2:19the future is no longer bright but dark?
- 2:24[Music]
- 2:27People are really really hit and they're
- 2:29really depressed and there's nowhere to
- 2:31turn. Where did it all begin? You know,
- 2:34what's the answer? It's like it was a a
- 2:36big design, a global type of effect.
- 2:39Well, you have anxiety attacks. Uh you
- 2:42have nightmares. Who can we blame this
- 2:43on? Anybody? Can anybody tell me
- 2:50the the key kind of psychological
- 2:52experience of anxiety
- 2:55is a fear that something is awful is
- 2:57something awful is going to happen. A
- 2:59kind of dread and uncertainty.
- 3:03This film is a history of that anxiety
- 3:06and the mathematics which created it.
- 3:09[Music]
- 3:12We are in the midst of a huge cultural
- 3:14change. Only 50 years ago, experts had a
- 3:17whole vocabulary for describing the
- 3:18world, which already sounds very foreign
- 3:20to us. They talked about a command and
- 3:22control economy, of engineering, the
- 3:24weather, of central planning.
- 3:27No one today thinks the world can be
- 3:28described in such terms. Today, we're
- 3:31much more likely to talk about disorder,
- 3:34instability, turbulence, tipping points,
- 3:36the butterfly effect. This is the
- 3:38vocabulary which has come to us from the
- 3:40mathematics of the last 50 years. And it
- 3:43is this mathematics which is in the
- 3:45process of completely altering our
- 3:48understanding of the fundamental nature
- 3:50of the world we live in. And I believe
- 3:53is giving us a whole new vocabulary for
- 3:56talking about our anxieties about that
- 3:59world.
- 4:01[Music]
- 4:07[Music]
- 4:10Looking back, we can see what was not
- 4:13obvious then. Those mathematical
- 4:15discoveries which would eventually
- 4:17undermine the optimistic view of the
- 4:19world and set us on our way to the
- 4:22anxieties of today.
- 4:32The mathematical roots of our modern
- 4:34anxiety have their beginnings here in
- 4:36Paris in 1885.
- 4:39The city was preparing to celebrate the
- 4:41optimistic worldview of science and
- 4:43reason. There was to be a grand
- 4:45exhibition to celebrate progress and
- 4:46democracy. It was the centinery of the
- 4:49republic
- 4:51and towering over it all was to be the
- 4:53world's tallest building, a symbol of
- 4:56everything that they believed in. A
- 4:58perfect hymn in iron to the rational and
- 5:01ordered worldview of Newtonian science.
- 5:08Newtonian mathematics describes a place
- 5:11that follows clear rules of cause and
- 5:13effect which make it predictable and
- 5:16therefore ultimately controllable.
- 5:19In the hands of one of Newton's greatest
- 5:21followers, the French atheist and
- 5:23mathematician Pierre Simon Llas. It
- 5:26became a set of beliefs about the nature
- 5:29of everything. An almost religious
- 5:31belief that the world could be
- 5:33understood as a machine.
- 5:37There was this strong notion that the
- 5:40world should be mechanistic and
- 5:43deterministic.
- 5:44David Ruell is a theoretical physicist
- 5:47and one of the principal discoverers of
- 5:49chaos mathematics.
- 5:51Newton and Llas saw the world as a
- 5:55machine and um everybody did to the
- 6:00extent that they were scientists. They
- 6:03wanted uh to have um determinism.
- 6:09In a mechanistic world, nothing happens
- 6:11without a cause. Nothing is
- 6:13unexplainable.
- 6:15In this world, if you understood the
- 6:17mathematical rules, you understood the
- 6:20world. Everything was predictable.
- 6:23Science could guarantee safety and
- 6:25progress.
- 6:28So that you could have this lelassian
- 6:30what was sometimes called a sort of
- 6:31clockwork view of of of the universe
- 6:34where you know if if enough people did
- 6:36enough sums then
- 6:39everything would be understood because
- 6:41they thought they knew how how things
- 6:43how systems behaved. They thought
- 6:45everything did in the end behave nicely.
- 6:47They knew disasters happened. Um they
- 6:51were perfectly well aware of that but
- 6:53actually they thought there was the
- 6:56mathematics would be able to explain it
- 6:58completely.
- 7:02[Music]
- 7:04And this was ultimately what underpinned
- 7:06their optimism and ours and made the
- 7:09future seem so open.
- 7:15But beneath the surface of optimism that
- 7:17the world was conquerable and
- 7:19controllable was an undercurrent of
- 7:21worry that perhaps the world was not as
- 7:23tame and safe as they wished to believe.
- 7:28[Music]
- 7:32Right at the heart of Newtonian
- 7:33mechanics was a problem which if it
- 7:35couldn't be solved endangered the whole
- 7:38belief that ultimately everything was
- 7:40mathematically predictable because it
- 7:43was to do with the one thing Newton was
- 7:45supposed to have absolutely solved.
- 7:49the orbits of the solar system.
- 7:54[Music]
- 8:03See, the genius of Newton's equations is
- 8:05that if you have two bodies, one
- 8:07orbiting the other, like the Earth going
- 8:09around the Sun, the equations of motion
- 8:11allow you to tell the exact nature of
- 8:13their orbits and to predict precisely
- 8:16where both bodies will be at any time in
- 8:18the future. The claim of Newton and
- 8:21Llass is that you simply scale that up
- 8:24and you can predict everything about the
- 8:26universe. Once you've got a solution,
- 8:28you you can say to me, well, um uh I'd
- 8:31like to know where that body is going to
- 8:32be at such and such a time. And that
- 8:34could be at any time in the future or
- 8:36any time in the past. I can just plug in
- 8:39the numbers, the time that you want, and
- 8:41out will come the answer, and it'll give
- 8:43me essentially the coordinates and and
- 8:46uh velocity of where that body will be.
- 8:49The same mathematics that govern the
- 8:52orbits of the planets also governed
- 8:54motion here on Earth.
- 8:57It was the bedrock of Newtonian science
- 8:59that if two objects began in almost
- 9:02identical orbits, they would continue in
- 9:05almost identical orbits. The difference
- 9:07between them never growing. So if you
- 9:10knew the orbit of one, you could predict
- 9:13the orbit of the other.
- 9:16[Music]
- 9:18And in theory, that's fine. In practice,
- 9:21what happens is that as soon as you add
- 9:23just one more body, just three, suddenly
- 9:27you cannot solve the equations and you
- 9:29cannot predict anything.
- 9:35Every major mathematician from Newton
- 9:37onwards had hoped that one day what they
- 9:39called the threebody problem would be
- 9:41solved.
- 9:42But then in 1889, a French mathematician
- 9:45called Enri Pankare discovered there was
- 9:48no way of predicting the orbits. In some
- 9:51cases, no matter how similar the paths
- 9:53were at the start, if there was any
- 9:56difference at all, eventually one would
- 9:58fly off on a different and totally
- 10:01unexpected and unpredictable path.
- 10:04Prediction, Bank lamented, becomes
- 10:06impossible.
- 10:12He saw something behaving in a way that
- 10:15he didn't expect and he realized it was
- 10:18to do with the initial conditions and
- 10:21what we now call sensitivity to initial
- 10:23conditions. And that's what was
- 10:25unexpected that if you just tweaked
- 10:27something a very little bit, you could
- 10:29get a huge difference in outcomes. That
- 10:33was where he actually discovered what we
- 10:34now call mathematical chaos.
- 10:39Quankare had glimpsed a profound truth
- 10:41about the planets and their orbits. What
- 10:43disturbed him was that he realized this
- 10:45unpredictable behavior might be present
- 10:48throughout nature. He realized a small
- 10:50disturbance, no more than the flapping
- 10:52of a butterflyy's wings, might be enough
- 10:55to create a storm where none was
- 10:56predicted. This was a very different
- 10:59world to Newton's.
- 11:03And I think the interesting thing is is
- 11:05the fact that he was so himself even the
- 11:09sort of greatest mathematician around at
- 11:11the time was still immersed in that view
- 11:14of thinking that things would all work
- 11:16out nicely that everything in the end
- 11:18behaved properly. And he was horrified
- 11:20when he discovered the way these
- 11:22solutions worked out and you could get
- 11:24this this what we now call chaotic
- 11:26behavior. Um it was quite shocking to
- 11:28him.
- 11:30[Music]
- 11:34Juankare's discovery struck at the root
- 11:36of a view of the world which neither he
- 11:38nor his contemporaries were yet willing
- 11:40to give up.
- 11:43The world in which he was living and
- 11:45moving was still very much one that was
- 11:47embedded in that lelassian view.
- 11:52This very strange behavior that he
- 11:54discovered was sort of glossed over by
- 11:55the commentators. People were just not
- 11:59ready to hear that their world was not
- 12:01as orderly as they'd always believed.
- 12:07Then in 1914 in Sievo, a tiny
- 12:11disturbance did push the whole world
- 12:13system from its course.
- 12:21This was the tiny disturbance that
- 12:24started the uncontrolled storm.
- 12:39[Music]
- 12:46[Music]
- 12:47In hindsight, we can see how appallingly
- 12:50precient Wankare's discovery had been.
- 12:53But at the time, the rest of the world
- 12:55was just not ready to listen. They were
- 12:58still determined to believe that they
- 13:00lived in a Newtonian world where even
- 13:02the complexities of human affairs could
- 13:04be predicted and the war would be over
- 13:07by Christmas.
- 13:10When World War I broke out, they all
- 13:12wheeled out their artillery, confident
- 13:14reality could be made to follow their
- 13:17plans.
- 13:18After all, the same mathematics which
- 13:21predicted the orbits of the planets also
- 13:23governed the firing of artillery.
- 13:26The mathematics of ballistics told them
- 13:28exactly where the shells would land.
- 13:31Of course, at the beginning of the 20th
- 13:33century, ballistics was essentially
- 13:35firing at a stationary object and you
- 13:38might have to fire over something. So,
- 13:39you might not be able to see what you
- 13:41were firing at. So, the mathematicians
- 13:42had had sort of sorted it out. They had
- 13:45range tables and so on.
- 13:46The magic of science. this uh uh
- 13:49predictability of things through
- 13:52mathematics. Science is not just uh uh
- 13:55proving theorems. It's to give us some
- 13:58power over nature about uh what happens.
- 14:03predicting an eclipses. This kind of
- 14:07power uh building um steam engines is
- 14:11also power and science was built in part
- 14:16uh about that.
- 14:19The tragedy of the war was that no
- 14:21matter what carnage unfolded, they
- 14:23believed there was not only a science of
- 14:25ballistics but a science of war, a way
- 14:28of predicting how many men per mile of
- 14:31front would win the objective. They
- 14:33thought if they understood the science
- 14:35of war, they could control its outcome.
- 14:38They could simply overpower the chaos.
- 14:42In the end, they weren't fighting each
- 14:44other. Both sides were fighting the
- 14:46chaos of reality.
- 14:48In the end, the chaos defeated them all,
- 14:52and 10 million men died.
- 14:55[Music]
- 15:00Tanker's notion that a small unnoticed
- 15:02disturbance could eventually cause an
- 15:05unstoppable storm was the first
- 15:08discovery to tell us the world is less
- 15:10predictable and controllable than we'd
- 15:12like it to be. One of the mathematical
- 15:15roots of modern anxiety.
- 15:19[Music]
- 15:21The second was uncovered in Russia by
- 15:23Alexander Leapenov.
- 15:26He was studying the transition from
- 15:27stability to instability in fluids, but
- 15:31doing so during the great upheavalss of
- 15:33World War I and the Russian Revolution.
- 15:43Leapenov was studying the way a fluid or
- 15:45gas becomes turbulent. It was one of the
- 15:48most intractable problems in all of
- 15:50physics. And he was trying to put a
- 15:53number on that transition from order to
- 15:55chaos.
- 15:57[Music]
- 15:59He was trying to understand how systems
- 16:01seem to maintain their order, almost
- 16:04resisting change, but then reach a
- 16:06critical point at which they seem to
- 16:08flip suddenly from smooth to turbulent,
- 16:11from order to chaos. What we now call
- 16:14tipping points. This move away from the
- 16:17idea that the world is ultimately
- 16:18predictable to one where it's
- 16:20unpredictable
- 16:22is mostly associated at least in the
- 16:24climate and environmental world with
- 16:25this idea of a tipping point. So this
- 16:27idea that you push the system and it
- 16:28goes basically how far it moves, how far
- 16:31it changes.
- 16:32Professor Peter Cox is one of the UK's
- 16:35top climate change experts and an
- 16:37adviser to the government.
- 16:38In that case, you imagine a system, say
- 16:41you're rolling a ball up a hill. You
- 16:43know, if you roll the ball up a hill
- 16:44here and you let it go, it's going to go
- 16:45back down this way. But say there's a
- 16:46there's a peak on the hill, you roll it
- 16:49up so far at this point, it can go
- 16:51either way. And then, of course, if
- 16:52you're at the top of a hill, you can
- 16:54push it an infinite decimal amount and
- 16:56it'll it'll be off. And there's no
- 16:58relationship between the ultimate
- 17:00displacement and how hard you push it.
- 17:02So, it's essentially an unstable system.
- 17:06Leaponov's work had begun to put a
- 17:08number on this moment of instability.
- 17:10The moment when the ball at the top of
- 17:12the hill is pushed over. When the
- 17:14orderly plume of smoke suddenly becomes
- 17:17turbulent.
- 17:22Most people when you ask them what is
- 17:24dangerous is is falling off a cliff,
- 17:26right? I mean, and that's the equivalent
- 17:27of a tipping point, right? It's where
- 17:29the system changes and you can't go
- 17:31back.
- 17:33But while Leapanov was still trying to
- 17:35understand instability, his life was
- 17:38approaching its own tipping point when
- 17:40the chaos of the Russian Revolution and
- 17:42World War I overwhelmed him personally.
- 17:47Tens of thousands of war wounded had
- 17:49been pouring back from the front and
- 17:51brought with them an epidemic of
- 17:53tuberculosis.
- 17:55When his wife became infected, Leapanov
- 17:57tried desperately to save her.
- 18:02But on October the 31st, 1917, she died
- 18:06in his arms.
- 18:13Hours later, the same day, he put a
- 18:16bullet through his brain.
- 18:22[Music]
- 18:27Wankare had discovered that our world
- 18:29might not be as predictable and
- 18:30controllable as we had thought.
- 18:33Leaponov's work had put a number on the
- 18:35moment of transition from order to chaos
- 18:38and opened the door to the modern idea
- 18:39of the tipping point.
- 18:42Between them, they had discovered what
- 18:43could have been the beginnings of a new
- 18:45and profound understanding of the world.
- 18:48That chaos is a part of the system, not
- 18:51just its breakdown. But Leaponov was
- 18:54dead.
- 18:55Pankare never took his work any further.
- 18:58And the rest of us, we wanted only to
- 19:00believe that chaos and unpredictability
- 19:03were just a nightmare from which we
- 19:04could wake. We stood at the place where
- 19:07a clearer understanding branched off.
- 19:10But we did not take it.
- 19:13The war had shaken our old faith.
- 19:15Somehow it had to be renewed.
- 19:19And to do that, a new icon of belief had
- 19:22to be found.
- 19:25Henry Ford's assembly line was that
- 19:28icon. It became both the symbol and the
- 19:30means by which we believed we could
- 19:32engineer a world of stability,
- 19:35predictability, and prosperity.
- 19:38We began to see the world, particularly
- 19:40the human world, the economy, in its
- 19:43image.
- 19:45No longer a world which might veer out
- 19:47of control, but one perfectly balanced,
- 19:50stable, at equilibrium, which had the
- 19:54dependable and changeless nature of a
- 19:56machine.
- 20:02They fell back to classical physics to
- 20:05equilibrium systems where if you like
- 20:07there is a fixed amount to spread.
- 20:10Professor Paul Orrod was for a decade
- 20:13director of economics at the Henley
- 20:14Center for Forecasting and is today a
- 20:16respected author and consultant.
- 20:20And they use the mathematics of that to
- 20:22try to explain and account for a very
- 20:24elaborate theory uh of how economies
- 20:27would actually allocate resources a most
- 20:29efficient way. But it was a fixed set of
- 20:32resources they were concentrating on and
- 20:34an equilibrium concept which they
- 20:36borrowed from classical physics before
- 20:38Puare made his discoveries.
- 20:41Once we had imagined the economy as a
- 20:43machine, it was a small step to believe
- 20:46we could engineer it, maybe even control
- 20:49it. The idea of an equilibrium system um
- 20:53became really quite embedded in
- 20:54economics as a description not merely of
- 20:56the market economies of the west but
- 20:59also of an idealized centrally planned
- 21:01economy running like a machine um in
- 21:03complete equilibrium.
- 21:06And for a while it worked. In the
- 21:09roaring 20s the cars rolled from the
- 21:11assembly lines and the tractors plowed
- 21:14the land. Once again, the plowman
- 21:16followed the herder
- 21:19and the pioneer came to the plane.
- 21:21A wave of optimism flowed from the
- 21:23factories and fields of the new world.
- 21:25We had the manpower. We invented new
- 21:28machinery.
- 21:30The world was our market.
- 21:34And we seemed to be back in control,
- 21:38but only for a while.
- 21:43We may have wanted to see the world and
- 21:45the economy as a machine, stable,
- 21:48unchanging, at equilibrium.
- 21:51But how we wish the world to be and how
- 21:54it actually is are not the same.
- 21:58[Music]
- 22:05This is the massive Fisher car body
- 22:07factory in Detroit. Once it was part of
- 22:10the seemingly indestructible US auto
- 22:12industry, part of the good times, which
- 22:15we thought would never end.
- 22:18But in 1929, they did.
- 22:22But the winds still blow and the sun
- 22:24still bakes the land. We must practice
- 22:27control and conservation. We are to save
- 22:29the rest of the grass.
- 22:31Without warning, the world reached not
- 22:33one but two tipping points. The climate
- 22:36and the economy both lurched without
- 22:38warning, without obvious cause, from
- 22:40equilibrium to chaos. The nightmares of
- 22:43the Great Depression and the dust bowl
- 22:45were upon us. The Great Depression of
- 22:47the 30s was a major problem for
- 22:50equilibrium economics. The the market
- 22:52for labor for hiring and firing people
- 22:54wasn't in equilibrium because one in
- 22:56four people didn't have jobs.
- 22:59And yet even this was not enough to get
- 23:01us to give up our faith in the world of
- 23:03order, equilibrium, and control.
- 23:06According to the equilibrium view of the
- 23:08world, there couldn't be anything
- 23:09inherently wrong or unstable with an
- 23:11economy. People themselves must have
- 23:14caused the breakdown.
- 23:17[Music]
- 23:21But the basic argument and it still
- 23:22remains the same today is that people
- 23:25were a sense weren't really um involunt
- 23:28they weren't they weren't unemployed
- 23:30because they'd been sacked. They were
- 23:32choosing to take it's incredible but
- 23:33this is true. Uh they were choosing to
- 23:35take leisure and be unemployed rather
- 23:38than work. That was the core of the
- 23:41explanation that that people were making
- 23:42a rational choice uh between consumption
- 23:45and leisure. So essentially the great
- 23:47depression was essentially an extended
- 23:49holiday for tens of millions of
- 23:51Americans.
- 23:52But certainly many uh you know major
- 23:55academic economists including uh some
- 23:57Nobel Prize winners subscribed to this
- 23:59theory.
- 24:03[Music]
- 24:07The experts at the time found it
- 24:09impossible to imagine that the dust bowl
- 24:12or the depression were in part caused by
- 24:14inherent instabilities or tipping points
- 24:16in the systems themselves.
- 24:18Another decade of reckless use, the
- 24:21grasslands will truly be the great
- 24:23American desert.
- 24:25There were no tipping points. The cause
- 24:27we decided was reassuringly simple and
- 24:30mechanical.
- 24:32[Music]
- 24:35I think when we were thinking in a more
- 24:37linear way about the world, we tended to
- 24:38look for causes that fitted outcomes.
- 24:42Um, actually, if you're talking about
- 24:44instability, of course, I mean, say
- 24:45you've got a pencil balanced on its end.
- 24:47Doesn't really matter which breeze blew
- 24:49it over. Something was going to blow it
- 24:50over. So, you could say, well, that
- 24:52particular eddy caused this thing to
- 24:54tip. But really, the only thing that
- 24:56matters is it going to tip anyway. It
- 24:57was unstable. And then so when you get
- 24:59to the view of the world having these
- 25:01bifocations tipping points then um you
- 25:05in a sense the causality is less
- 25:07critical. It's just that the system is
- 25:09going to change.
- 25:10But while we were adapting to changes in
- 25:12environment we paid the price of feeling
- 25:15insecure.
- 25:17Despite all the chaos and turbulence of
- 25:19the 30s, despite the blighted lives and
- 25:22misery, economists and scientists
- 25:25continued to see the world as they
- 25:27always had, believing that the
- 25:29uncontrolled would one day be brought
- 25:31within our grasp.
- 25:38It was the invention of the computer at
- 25:40the end of the war which suddenly seemed
- 25:42to promise a level of understanding and
- 25:44control we had never had.
- 25:49If the assembly line had been the icon
- 25:51of the 20s, here was the new icon of
- 25:54power, prediction, and control.
- 25:57Scene 64, take two.
- 26:02In the 40s and 50s, we got our first
- 26:04glimpse of that icon at work when the
- 26:06military unveiled the top secret
- 26:08technology that had helped win the war.
- 26:10This machine is as complicated as it
- 26:13looks.
- 26:14The Iniac was the first all electronic
- 26:16high-speed computer which was ever built
- 26:19in the whole world. The only difference
- 26:21between a human being and the Iniac is
- 26:23that the Iniac is much faster.
- 26:26The very first job the technology of
- 26:28tomorrow had been given was the old
- 26:30military task of calculating the angles,
- 26:32elevations, and velocities of the firing
- 26:34tables.
- 26:36But it was soon essential to a new and
- 26:39frightening power.
- 26:40[Music]
- 26:43We do all firing tables for the army and
- 26:46all bombing tables for the air force.
- 26:52Whenever a gun is pointed towards an
- 26:54enemy, we have done some computations to
- 26:57tell the artilleryman how to direct his
- 26:59gun in order to hit a certain target.
- 27:01Test was scheduled to observe results.
- 27:04Not only was the computer calculating
- 27:06the aiming and launching of the bomb, it
- 27:09was also the only way of doing the vast
- 27:11calculations necessary to understand the
- 27:13explosion itself.
- 27:17Pointed towards an enemy.
- 27:20[Music]
- 27:22instance all the firing tables to an
- 27:24atomic gun
- 27:26yield 15 kotons.
- 27:28Unlike the situation with an implosion
- 27:30weapon, the scientists were here able to
- 27:32observe fireball growth from a body of
- 27:34fishable material.
- 27:38Science is not just uh proving theorems.
- 27:41It's give us some power over nature.
- 27:48The old Newtonian magic of ballistics
- 27:51was married to the godlike power of the
- 27:53nuclear age. If we could control such
- 27:57power, was there anything we couldn't
- 27:59predict and control?
- 28:03It's hard for us to imagine, I think,
- 28:05what the effect of the of the atomic
- 28:09bomb must have must have been at at the
- 28:12time. um that something seemingly so
- 28:15small actually could have such a
- 28:18devastating uh truly horrifying and
- 28:20devastating effect
- 28:23and we could control it so that you know
- 28:26we we had control over it.
- 28:31[Music]
- 28:35The nuclear age brought with it fears
- 28:38but also a feeling of tremendous power
- 28:40and possibility.
- 28:42I think there was a kind of an
- 28:44optimistic peak if you like in terms of
- 28:47what we thought technology and science
- 28:48could do probably in the middle part of
- 28:50the 20th century in the 50s. So, and I
- 28:52suspect that was associated with all
- 28:54sorts of technological developments but
- 28:55also with a sort of cultural
- 28:57optimism that came probably after the
- 28:59second world war. The idea that
- 29:00technology was going to solve a lot of
- 29:01the problems that we had previously in
- 29:03the 1950s. The future was going to be a
- 29:05planned utopia of wide boulevards and
- 29:09shining skyscrapers where we'd all be
- 29:11happy and prosperous.
- 29:13And the engine of this new prosperity
- 29:15and certainty was to be the computer.
- 29:19Just as the telescope had let us see the
- 29:22heavens and the microscope, the building
- 29:24blocks of life, so the computer promised
- 29:26to let us see into and maybe even
- 29:29control another dimension, the future.
- 29:33James Lovelock remembers those heady
- 29:35times.
- 29:37There was that wonderful sense of
- 29:38certainty in those days about
- 29:40everything. Look what we've got. This,
- 29:43you know, the future is terrific. We can
- 29:45do all these things. And it was
- 29:47wonderful. Everything was so simple and
- 29:49so possible. The sky was the limit.
- 29:54Suddenly, we could do computations the
- 29:55unaded mind never could solve problems
- 29:58we had never solved. Just build a bigger
- 30:01computer. And even the unpredictable
- 30:04would be predicted.
- 30:06No more dust bowls. Now we would predict
- 30:09and control the weather.
- 30:12No more economic crashes. With the
- 30:14calculating power of the computer,
- 30:16policy makers believed they could now
- 30:18predict and control the economy
- 30:20affecting the lives of millions.
- 30:25They believe that they'd finally now got
- 30:27the theory, got the um statistical tools
- 30:30with the power of the computer to once
- 30:33and for all understand how the economy
- 30:35really did operate. Policy makers
- 30:38believe that these were if you like laws
- 30:40of economics in the same way that there
- 30:42are laws of physics. I mean after the
- 30:44traumas of the 30s and the war of the
- 30:47you know the in the ' 40s uh the western
- 30:49economies performed spectacularly well
- 30:51for a very long period of time. Uh it
- 30:53was totally unprecedented prosperity,
- 30:55very low unemployment and you know
- 30:58everybody exuded confidence
- 31:01turning in the direction of a new world
- 31:03that symbolizes man's dreams,
- 31:05prophecies, hopes and aspirations. In
- 31:08the distance we see it
- 31:09government and corporate films
- 31:10confidently portrayed a future of
- 31:13equilibrium, stability, progress and
- 31:15prosperity.
- 31:17But at the same time that scientists
- 31:19were confidently predicting this
- 31:21flawless future, a meteorologist called
- 31:24Ed Loren discovered something in 1962
- 31:28radically at odds with it.
- 31:31While the military were focused on
- 31:32trying to predict the weather dayto-day
- 31:35using vast computers to do it, Loren's
- 31:38using an early desk computer built a
- 31:41simplified model to look at the
- 31:43underlying mathematics to see if the
- 31:45weather had hidden patterns.
- 31:47Lorenz's discovery came when he ran his
- 31:50model first with one set of numbers and
- 31:52then again with what he thought were the
- 31:55same numbers but which the computer had
- 31:57rounded off making them minutely
- 32:00different.
- 32:02He put in what he thought were identical
- 32:05numbers but the the the starting numbers
- 32:08were different by just a tiny tiny
- 32:11amount. So there was no reason for him
- 32:13to think that it would actually end up
- 32:16being very different.
- 32:18What Loren found was that the tiny
- 32:21differences in his starting numbers
- 32:23instead of having no effect dramatically
- 32:26changed his results.
- 32:28Things look like they're all carrying on
- 32:30very nicely and then they suddenly all
- 32:31behave in a very odd way. Um and the
- 32:34numbers um don't do what you think
- 32:37they're going to do. You know, you
- 32:38imagine these two paths going along just
- 32:41and they're they're just nudging each
- 32:44other and it it becomes a sudden point
- 32:46where suddenly one of them goes off, but
- 32:49actually that happened. The fact that
- 32:51that was going to happen was right back
- 32:53here. It wasn't where it happened.
- 32:58One of the most fundamental assumptions
- 32:59which every scientist from Newton
- 33:01onwards had made was that a small error
- 33:04in a large system just disappears. it
- 33:06has no consequence. Like a small
- 33:08imperfection in a single part on a long
- 33:11assembly line would make no significant
- 33:13difference to the final outcome. It is
- 33:15this critical assumption which Ed
- 33:18Lorenz's work turned on its head.
- 33:21Lorenz's accidental discovery had
- 33:24tremendous implications for the real
- 33:26world. He could suddenly see that when a
- 33:28system changed, it needn't be because at
- 33:31that moment something had caused it to
- 33:33change.
- 33:34It could be that the seeds of its
- 33:36destruction had been there slowly
- 33:38growing, hidden in the mathematics all
- 33:40along. The moment the system diverged
- 33:43was the end result of a tiny,
- 33:45unnoticeable change a long time ago.
- 33:50Loren had rediscovered what had nearly
- 33:53glimpsed. He called it the butterfly
- 33:56effect.
- 34:04So if you have a butterfly flapping its
- 34:07wings, the effect will be very tiny. At
- 34:10the beginning, you will see nothing and
- 34:13then after a while it will change some
- 34:16fluctuations in the air, some
- 34:19fluctuations in turbulence and then if
- 34:22you wait long enough like 6 months, it
- 34:25may have uh tremendous effects.
- 34:29The computer which had been heralded as
- 34:31the engine of stability and certainty
- 34:34had become the engine of instability and
- 34:36uncertainty.
- 34:39So computers allowed us to explore
- 34:41things that we used to throw these terms
- 34:42away. You know mathematics say well
- 34:44that's too hard or let's assume it's not
- 34:46important. We can't do that bit. So
- 34:47let's assume it's not important. And you
- 34:48end up with a linear system which
- 34:50reinforces your view that the world is
- 34:52this kind of quiet place generally
- 34:53speaking where where nothing really
- 34:55surprising happens and we'll be fine and
- 34:57we just need to know how it works and we
- 34:58can work everything out to to something
- 35:01where you the computer allows you to put
- 35:02back in these terms and Lent was
- 35:04basically putting in terms of previously
- 35:05it would have thrown away and it turns
- 35:06out they changed the system alto
- 35:08together in ter certainly it's
- 35:09predictability it's just a brilliant
- 35:12demonstration accidental demonstration
- 35:13of chaos really in the system
- 35:15it is the function of the United States
- 35:17weather bureau to gather other
- 35:18information on such conditions.
- 35:20The question was how much chaos was
- 35:22there in the system
- 35:23and to give advanced warning when human
- 35:25life and property are threatened by high
- 35:27water.
- 35:28How many aspects of nature did this new
- 35:30mathematics apply to? Was the unstable
- 35:33turbulence of natural phenomena simply
- 35:35because they were complicated in which
- 35:38case one day we would sort them out? Or
- 35:41were they governed by the sensitivity to
- 35:43initial conditions of the butterfly
- 35:44effect?
- 35:47Beneath the smoke, the fire will
- 35:50continue to move unchecked through the
- 35:52night.
- 35:53Just how chaotic should we expect the
- 35:55world to be?
- 36:02[Music]
- 36:07And by the late60s, these suddenly
- 36:09seemed very pertinent questions.
- 36:14[Music]
- 36:15In these turbulent times, just as
- 36:17Leaponov had been drawn to study
- 36:19instability during the Russian
- 36:20Revolution, mathematician David Ruel was
- 36:23drawn to study the onset of turbulence.
- 36:29[Music]
- 36:31We proposed that hydrodnamic turbulence
- 36:36was associated where there is this
- 36:38sensitive dependence on initial
- 36:40condition but it happens
- 36:45almost everywhere that it happens all
- 36:47the time.
- 36:48Turbulence was thought to arise because
- 36:51of the sheer complexity of the
- 36:52phenomenon. Ruel through a combination
- 36:55of experiments and mathematics proved
- 36:58that turbulence was not the result of
- 37:00complexity but was caused by the
- 37:02mathematics of sensitivity to initial
- 37:04conditions.
- 37:09The butterfly effect and turbulence were
- 37:12everywhere.
- 37:17This is not completely a coincidence
- 37:19that I got interested in this problem in
- 37:221968.
- 37:24These were the May 68 events.
- 37:28This was uh an atmosphere where
- 37:31questions were asked that uh uh would
- 37:34not normally be asked. The times became
- 37:36right because the mathematics was there,
- 37:39because the computers were there and
- 37:42suddenly there was this um enormously
- 37:46interesting experience of interacting
- 37:49with people in different disciplines.
- 37:53Mathematically, turbulence and chaos
- 37:56were established and psychologically
- 37:58were making it harder to pretend the
- 38:00world was still Newtonian. The language
- 38:03of chaos was beginning to enter our
- 38:05vocabulary.
- 38:07The notion of chaos has been around
- 38:09since the the early part of the 20th
- 38:10century and before that. Actually, it
- 38:12wasn't called chaos until later, I
- 38:13guess, in the 70s. And that's when
- 38:15people really grasped it. You know, this
- 38:16idea that there was this thing that we
- 38:17could call something that that was that
- 38:20was indicative of what we could see in
- 38:22the world that we could use to excuse
- 38:23all sorts of things we couldn't predict.
- 38:26By the late 60s and 70s, the optimism of
- 38:28the ' 50s was in retreat. Once again,
- 38:31the man-made world spun out of control.
- 38:34There was social, political, and
- 38:35economic turmoil from Paris to Detroit.
- 38:39And while ordinary people were shocked
- 38:40by the events, what was shocking for the
- 38:43experts was their failure to predict
- 38:45them.
- 38:46So, it was a terrible shock when it
- 38:47didn't. It was really very hard for them
- 38:50to take. People thought they'd
- 38:51understood it and it turned out not to
- 38:53be true. in the late 60s and
- 38:55increasingly we moved into the 1970s.
- 38:58All these laws broke down really quite
- 39:00spectacularly because they weren't laws.
- 39:02They were simply statistical
- 39:04relationships which happened to hold for
- 39:06a relatively short period of time.
- 39:09Economists had thought they had
- 39:10understood the laws that governed how
- 39:12the economy worked and thought this then
- 39:14gave them the power to predict what
- 39:16would happen.
- 39:19And what's clear is that forecasts only
- 39:22work when in a sense almost anybody
- 39:24could make a good forecast when the
- 39:25economy stay when it's going along very
- 39:27nicely. Anybody can make a reasonable
- 39:29projection then and be reasonably
- 39:31correct. What forecasts are very bad at
- 39:33when you precisely need them when
- 39:35there's a major turnaround when there's
- 39:37a recession and the track record on
- 39:39forecasting recessions is really
- 39:41appalling. It's essentially
- 39:42non-existent. The turbulence of the
- 39:441970s convinced the economists as well
- 39:47as the environmentalists that their
- 39:49faith in large-scale prediction and
- 39:50control was just wrong. They came to
- 39:52accept they would no more be able to
- 39:53control the economy than they could the
- 39:55weather. The era of command and control
- 39:58was over. But there was a second more
- 40:00controversial part of the mathematics
- 40:02upon which they fundamentally disagreed.
- 40:10Rule and others had found that even very
- 40:13simple systems such as pendulums driven
- 40:16by a motor or double pendulums where two
- 40:18are connected together could give rise
- 40:21to highly complex chaotic behavior.
- 40:29And now as they used these simple
- 40:31systems to explore further, they began
- 40:34to discover the rules of this chaotic
- 40:36world.
- 40:36[Music]
- 40:40They found that the more connected and
- 40:41interlin systems became, the more likely
- 40:44they were to become chaotic and
- 40:45turbulent. And that the more you pumped
- 40:48the system, the faster you ran it, the
- 40:50more chaotic it would become.
- 40:54[Music]
- 40:58And yet in the real world, this is
- 41:01exactly what began to happen on October
- 41:04the 27th, 1986. Computers connected the
- 41:07world's financial systems together into
- 41:09a single global economy and the modern
- 41:12free market was born.
- 41:20There was a lack of confidence more in
- 41:22in planning. That's what came came about
- 41:24the idea that you could discover these
- 41:26relationships and quite rightly a lot of
- 41:28skepticism crept in from policy makers
- 41:31and the idea that we could somehow
- 41:32quantify this. So in a sense we then
- 41:34went back to first principles and said
- 41:36well if we leave it to markets you know
- 41:39markets will in sense you know solve the
- 41:41problem um and we needn't be as
- 41:44interventionist
- 41:48at the same time the computer was
- 41:49allowing us to understand this
- 41:51interconnected world. It was also
- 41:53building it and driving it faster and
- 41:56faster.
- 41:58And so there was a feeling just
- 41:59empirically that the idea of leaving it
- 42:01the market was very soundly based that
- 42:04it wasn't just justified in equilibrium
- 42:06theory but markets clearly were
- 42:08delivering and they did dramatic results
- 42:10in terms of prosperity increases in
- 42:12lifespan.
- 42:14This is the point where the
- 42:16environmentalists and the economists
- 42:17start to diverge from each other because
- 42:19for the economists it's all about bigger
- 42:22faster global. They'd learned the lesson
- 42:25that the economy was not something they
- 42:27could just control. Instead, they
- 42:28started to see it as a kind of natural
- 42:31system that you absolutely must not
- 42:34regulate, which fed right into the new
- 42:37free market ideology, which declared you
- 42:40cannot buck the market.
- 42:45The global financial economy began to
- 42:47grow as never before.
- 42:49I got it.
- 42:50But as it did, so did its
- 42:52unpredictability.
- 42:55From the point of view of stability,
- 42:58control, predictability, it is a bad
- 43:01idea to drive a system to its limit to
- 43:06uh warm up the atmosphere uh to uh make
- 43:12more to put more complication in the
- 43:15economy. I think the issue of growth is
- 43:18obviously is it's at the heart of
- 43:20economics, but it's also at the heart of
- 43:22the climate problem.
- 43:23The more you uh mess up with a nonlinear
- 43:27system, the more likely it's to become
- 43:30chaotic.
- 43:31The records of the meteorologist give
- 43:33cause for concern.
- 43:34At the moment, we have economics. Forget
- 43:36about the environment. We dump stuff in
- 43:38the environment. We use it. We have
- 43:39envir environmental change and climate
- 43:41change, which is like driven by humans
- 43:43but doesn't react back on them. That's
- 43:45quite at odds with really the way the
- 43:47world operates, which is that eventually
- 43:49your economic growth could be stopped by
- 43:50the impact you have on the environment
- 43:51because environment is the source of our
- 43:53wealth.
- 43:56Ignoring the warnings of the new maths,
- 43:58we instead stoked the system for all we
- 44:00were worth. The free market economists
- 44:03assured us their model said we could
- 44:05simply leave the markets to their own
- 44:07devices and they would magically find
- 44:10their natural equilibrium. the empirical
- 44:12models that economists use to make
- 44:14forecasts of the economy which the
- 44:16general public relate to. In a sense,
- 44:19these are throwbacks. These are
- 44:21dinosaurs to the models of the 60s when
- 44:24they appear to work.
- 44:26[Music]
- 44:28They're still searching even now, if you
- 44:30like, for empirical regularities which
- 44:33they believe will enable them to make
- 44:35successful predictions of the economy.
- 44:37you know, one little tweak, one little
- 44:38clever bit, we can really discover what
- 44:41this law actually is. And the forecast
- 44:43still rely ultimately on that same
- 44:45approach. Uh, and it doesn't work now,
- 44:47and it never will do.
- 44:48We live in a world that is increasingly
- 44:52uh going away from uh anything like an
- 44:56equilibrium or a steady state. I mean,
- 44:59you want now to have growth 2% 3% more.
- 45:06And this means uh exponential growth,
- 45:09something that we know cannot last
- 45:11forever.
- 45:15[Music]
- 45:18If something grows exponentially, it
- 45:21must break down at some point.
- 45:24That is something that can be predicted
- 45:27with safety. The process must end
- 45:30somewhere. How it will end, I don't
- 45:32know.
- 45:35Our leaders tell you that we need uh two
- 45:39or 3%
- 45:41uh growth per year and uh this is
- 45:45necessary for the well-being. Of course
- 45:48uh it may be necessary but it cannot be
- 45:50maintained forever.
- 45:55Exponential growth is basically a linear
- 45:58thing and uh
- 46:00the claim is that nonlinearities will
- 46:04put a stop to this uh exponential
- 46:08growth. That is for sure.
- 46:11[Music]
- 46:22For over a century now, we have not
- 46:24wanted to hear that the promises of
- 46:26prediction and control might be
- 46:28bankrupt,
- 46:30not even wanting to admit the evidence
- 46:32of our own eyes.
- 46:40[Music]
- 46:50This is the Detroit Public Schools book
- 46:52depository where the promises to the
- 46:54next generation were stored. This is
- 46:57what has happened to it. Trees growing
- 47:01out of the rotting remains of
- 47:02yesterday's dreams.
- 47:10[Music]
- 47:21All life is interrelated.
- 47:23We are caught in an inescapable network
- 47:25of mutuality tied in a single garment of
- 47:29destiny. Whatever affects one directly
- 47:32affects all indirectly.
- 47:34As long as there is poverty in this
- 47:36world, no man can be totally rich, even
- 47:39if he has a billion dollars.
- 47:42Martin Luther King, 1961. The American
- 47:45Blind.
- 47:55The dream is gone. Someone finally woke
- 47:57up. I guess
- 48:00American dream is [ __ ] The American
- 48:03dream is if you believe whatever Mr.
- 48:06George Bush says, he's full of crap.
- 48:09There's no more dream. You know, you're
- 48:12afraid to dream now.
- 48:16Try to work a minimum wage job, paying
- 48:18your gas, your mortgage, food. You can't
- 48:20do it. And I I don't have no savings
- 48:23account. No. You know what I'm saying? I
- 48:24just live by the day. Basically, you
- 48:26can't you can't get ahead around here.
- 48:30How do you tell your child we have
- 48:31nowhere to live? How can you tell your
- 48:34child we're not going to have anywhere
- 48:36to live?
- 48:36Wake up in the morning and tell your
- 48:37kid, "Oh, I you can't eat dinner today
- 48:39because there's no money for it." That's
- 48:41unheard of. Because we can't pay our
- 48:43bills now. And it happens though by the
- 48:47day around here.
- 48:50[Music]
- 48:51Why is he getting thrown out of his
- 48:52house? I don't understand it. Because
- 48:54this is not making enough money. I mean,
- 48:55it's bottom line. the the loan. You
- 48:58didn't default on your loan. The loan
- 49:00defaulted on you.
- 49:01You're late making a payment. They
- 49:02charge you extra because you're late. I
- 49:03don't have money to begin with. How you
- 49:05going to charge me more to be late? Cuz
- 49:06I I ain't got the money. That's my
- 49:08penalty. Don't make no sense to me. It
- 49:10don't
- 49:14[Music]
- 49:16There is no community. It's basically
- 49:18everybody for himself around here.
- 49:21I don't know.
- 49:22Just no community?
- 49:23No. No, there is. How can there be a
- 49:25community? Look, that's empty. That's
- 49:27empty. That's empty. Where's the
- 49:29neighbors at? There is none.
- 49:30I mean, you got two on the corner, one
- 49:32on this corner there. You skip two
- 49:34houses, the next three houses are vacant
- 49:36across the street, then you have some
- 49:37down the street. So, it's been very
- 49:39badly hit the area.
- 49:43Today, the rate of change is increasing
- 49:45and our ability to predict has
- 49:47decreased. Is it any wonder we have
- 49:49become more anxious?
- 49:52I would say that the sorts of ideas that
- 49:55you're talking about in terms of chaos
- 49:58theory and butterfly effect and global
- 50:01warming and all those kind of things
- 50:03that are happening that are causing
- 50:04people anxiety. It's not just the words.
- 50:07It actually has an impact on how people
- 50:09think about their lives. It it has an
- 50:11effect on what people look for in life
- 50:13and on how they kind of frame their
- 50:15thoughts and ideas about themselves and
- 50:18what they can control and what they
- 50:19can't control. What worries me is that
- 50:21this is really quite a nihilistic kind
- 50:23of vocabulary. It's a kind of a
- 50:28it doesn't give people a sense that
- 50:30there is something that they can do.
- 50:36[Applause]
- 50:40The problem with the mathematics of
- 50:41chaos is that it doesn't offer us a new
- 50:44plan for how to achieve what we want.
- 50:47prediction and control.
- 50:52It takes away what we want to believe,
- 50:54denies us the old icons of salvation, of
- 50:57freedom through growth, and gives us
- 50:59nothing comforting in return.
- 51:13We're all living in a much less
- 51:15predictable, more unstable world. The
- 51:17question is what we want to do about it.
- 51:20On the one hand, the economists insist
- 51:23that because we can't regulate and
- 51:25control the economy the way we used to
- 51:26think we could, our only salvation lies
- 51:29in obeying the market and going for
- 51:31growth. Anything else they insist will
- 51:34lead to economic chaos and collapse.
- 51:38On the other hand, the environmentalists
- 51:40say that it is precisely this unbridled
- 51:44economic growth which will push the
- 51:46world's natural systems to their own
- 51:48chaos and collapse from which there will
- 51:50be no coming back.
- 51:54For most of the last 100 years, despite
- 51:57the warnings from mathematics and
- 51:58history, we have refused to see reality
- 52:01as it is.
- 52:11This is a picture generated by the
- 52:12mathematics of that reality. It is
- 52:15called a leapon map. It shows not the
- 52:18orderly and predictable reality we
- 52:20always wanted, but an unstable and
- 52:22chaotic one. It is a distant descendant
- 52:25of Leaponov's original work.
- 52:28The map shows regions of stability and
- 52:31others of chaos in a system. Between
- 52:34them are the points where the system can
- 52:35abruptly tip from one to the other.
- 52:41[Music]
- 52:47No one wanted to believe the economy
- 52:49could lurch from boom times to bust, but
- 52:52it has.
- 52:53No one wants to believe the climate
- 52:55could be approaching its own
- 52:56catastrophe. But when it does, it will
- 52:59affect us all, the rich, the poor, the
- 53:02guilty, and the innocent.
- 53:06[Music]
- 53:15You know, in the climate system, there's
- 53:17this idea that there might be a tipping
- 53:18point associated with a certain warming
- 53:21pushing yourself up this hill with
- 53:22warming where the the Greenland ice
- 53:24sheet would melt. And we know on the
- 53:26other side in the long term, we've got a
- 53:277 m sea level rise to deal with
- 53:32in other tipping points. Um, for
- 53:35example, the possibility that the Amazon
- 53:37rainforest could be badly affected by
- 53:39climate change that could happen quite
- 53:40quickly associated with fires and things
- 53:42like that.
- 53:48As far as human systems are concerned
- 53:49and adaptation, the rate of change is at
- 53:52least as important as the final end
- 53:54point. You know, it's really it's we're
- 53:56limited how fast we can react.
- 53:58The question now is if we have any time
- 54:00left for self-d delusion. a lot of ice
- 54:03up there in Greenland.
- 54:05James Lovelock is the godfather of the
- 54:07environmental movement. He fears that
- 54:09even today we still haven't really
- 54:11learned the lessons of the mathematics
- 54:13and we still want to believe in
- 54:14prediction and control.
- 54:19This is the flaw of the great climate
- 54:22models we have at the moment. They all
- 54:24imply that if you could reduce the
- 54:26carbon dioxide, bring it back, stabilize
- 54:30it at some level, all would be well, we
- 54:33could handle the situation. I think this
- 54:35is nonsense.
- 54:36[Music]
- 54:41I think once you the system has started
- 54:43to slide, there's no going back.
- 54:46[Music]
- 54:49And I like to think of it not so much as
- 54:51a tipping point, but as a slope that
- 54:54gets ever steeper and at some point it
- 54:57gets so steep you can't hang on any
- 54:59longer.
- 55:00That's what you would see instead of a
- 55:02tip.
- 55:02A tipping point. Yes,
- 55:03it sounds worse.
- 55:06Well, it is bad. It's very bad. And the
- 55:08tipping point all implies that well,
- 55:10maybe you could tip it back. The slope
- 55:13implies you can't. It's gone too far.
- 55:20If you look at the earth's history, the
- 55:23climate goes along more or less steadily
- 55:25at some state, either very cold as in an
- 55:27ice age, and then it comes to a point
- 55:30where it slides over, then goes up to a
- 55:33stable state, uh, the interglacial. It
- 55:36also in the past has gone upwards to
- 55:40another stable state, a hot state. And
- 55:42it did so 55 million years ago when
- 55:45about the same amount of carbon dioxide
- 55:47went into the atmosphere as we are
- 55:49putting in. And it jumped 5° quite
- 55:52suddenly.
- 55:54And as you say, you can't you can't pull
- 55:57a a lever somewhere and make it go back.
- 56:00Well, it took 200,000 years for it to go
- 56:03back after the 55 million year ago
- 56:06event. And yet the carbon dioxide went
- 56:09down.
- 56:10But it didn't go. The temperature
- 56:12didn't. It stayed up for that long.
- 56:15Which undermines the whole notion of
- 56:17control, doesn't it?
- 56:18It does. It does indeed. And I think
- 56:21it's a false notion. At least I think
- 56:23they should think about it being a false
- 56:26notion. I can't be certain in what I'm
- 56:29saying. only if I come on very strong is
- 56:32because I am so concerned about their
- 56:34certainty about their models and the way
- 56:37politicians are taking it and letting
- 56:40them form the basis of policy. I think
- 56:42that's almost absurd.
- 56:45Your image of the slope
- 56:48where do you think we we or the the
- 56:51system we're in is on that
- 56:54I wish I knew. I I suspect we're just
- 56:56about to drop off. uh uh uh but I'm I
- 57:00may be wrong. We may be a little bit
- 57:02further back up the slope, but I'm not
- 57:04sure don't see how we can do much about
- 57:06it. I think one of the crucial bits of
- 57:09the system which everyone knows would
- 57:12change is the floating ice in the Arctic
- 57:14Ocean, as you probably know, last summer
- 57:1760% of it went. And they think that in
- 57:20not many years, perhaps little as five,
- 57:22perhaps as much as 15, it'll all be
- 57:24gone. When it does, you can work out in
- 57:26the back of an envelope what difference
- 57:28this makes to the heat load of the
- 57:30Earth, and you'll find it's about equal
- 57:32to all of the CO2 we've added to the
- 57:35atmosphere to date. In other words,
- 57:37heating doubles when uh by the time that
- 57:40ice goes, do you think there's any going
- 57:42back? Can we put that ice back? No. No
- 57:45way.
- 57:53We can't put things back. Can't make
- 57:55right what is already wrong. We're still
- 57:58on the road to chaos, but are once again
- 58:01standing at that place where possible
- 58:03futures divide. Only this time, we have
- 58:06had a 100 years to learn the lessons of
- 58:08the mathematics.
- 58:10Perhaps this time we will be able to do
- 58:12what we could not back then. Face
- 58:15reality as it is. For that reality is
- 58:19staring us in the face.
- 58:24[Music]
- 58:33[Music]
- 58:39Marcus Dottoy continues his journey
- 58:41through the story of maths here on BBC 4
- 58:43at 9 on Monday. But next tonight, it's
- 58:46comedy hour and time for that Mitchell
- 58:48and Web look.
- 58:50[Music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of High Anxieties - The Mathematics of Chaos - BBC documentary by Gnosis Documentaries, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 8,205 words across 1,354 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.