Herding Behavior: How following the crowd leads us astray — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00thus it might be that one family camped
- 0:03near a spring and another camped for the
- 0:05spring and for company and a third
- 0:08because two families had pioneered the
- 0:10place and found it good and when the Sun
- 0:13went down perhaps 20 families and 20
- 0:16cars were there this quote from John
- 0:19Steinbeck's classic The Grapes of Wrath
- 0:21paints a powerful reality about human
- 0:24nature it depicts humans as the social
- 0:27animals that we are reminding us that in
- 0:30times of uncertainty people are afraid
- 0:33and when we're afraid we rely upon the
- 0:36herd to guide us sure the crowds
- 0:39guidance can be a useful crutch to lean
- 0:41upon but what happens when we use it too
- 0:44often when we're just lazy the concept
- 0:48we're teasing out here is known as
- 0:49herding behavior and we can define it as
- 0:52people doing what others do instead of
- 0:55using their own information to make
- 0:57decisions this happens often we see a
- 1:01large number of people acting in the
- 1:02same way and we think there is no way
- 1:05that they could all be wrong they must
- 1:07know something that we don't we start to
- 1:09base our decisions off of the assumption
- 1:12that everyone else has done their
- 1:13research or knows something that we
- 1:15don't know but that's not always the
- 1:17case consider the following example
- 1:20offered by Robert Shiller an economist
- 1:22at Yale suppose two restaurants open
- 1:25next door to each other restaurant a and
- 1:27restaurant be the very first customer
- 1:30sees two empty restaurants and must
- 1:32choose which one to eat at based only on
- 1:34their appearance let's say she chooses
- 1:37restaurant a the second customer sees
- 1:41one person eating at restaurant a and an
- 1:43empty restaurant B she makes her choice
- 1:46based on two things first the appearance
- 1:49of each restaurant that's her own
- 1:51information and secondly the fact that
- 1:54the first customer chose restaurant a
- 1:57that's external information if the
- 2:00second customer chooses to go to
- 2:02restaurant a then the third customer
- 2:04will see two people eating at restaurant
- 2:07a and an empty restaurant B I think you
- 2:10see where this is going as people
- 2:12continue to join
- 2:13the crowd they prompt others to do the
- 2:15same eventually each customer might end
- 2:18up at restaurant a which could actually
- 2:20be the poorer restaurant what's happened
- 2:24is people have ignored their own
- 2:26information and that creates a distorted
- 2:29signal chain we think that everyone has
- 2:32made an informed decision and that
- 2:34decision appears to have value but in
- 2:37reality everyone has based their
- 2:39decisions on the decisions made by
- 2:41others and because of this our decision
- 2:44contains no real valuable information
- 2:48these chains of behavior are sometimes
- 2:51called informational Cascades and they
- 2:53help us explain everything from standard
- 2:55conformity to fads and booms and crashes
- 2:58speaking of booms and crashes you might
- 3:01remember the financial crisis of 2008
- 3:04while an event as cataclysmic and
- 3:06complex as that cannot be explained by
- 3:09one behavioral failure
- 3:10research suggests that hurting behavior
- 3:13may have played a role in
- 3:14decision-making by investment managers
- 3:17investors concerned with their own
- 3:19reputation have shown to mimic the
- 3:21investment decisions of other managers
- 3:23ignoring their own private information
- 3:26it's worth returning to the idea that in
- 3:29times of uncertainty people are afraid
- 3:31and when we're afraid we rely upon the
- 3:34herd to guide us as the financial world
- 3:37collapsed in 2008 and uncertainty loomed
- 3:40above us all there's no question that
- 3:42our herd mentality kicked in and it
- 3:45probably played a role in our
- 3:46decision-making whether or not we're
- 3:49aware of it our reliance upon the herd
- 3:51plants the seeds which will influence
- 3:53the stores we shop at the restaurants we
- 3:55try out and even the universities we
- 3:58choose to attend the solution is not to
- 4:02avoid all external information rather
- 4:05the idea is to become more aware of the
- 4:08information we're using to make
- 4:09decisions especially when we're
- 4:12observing what other people are doing
- 4:13the herd is not synonymous with bad
- 4:17however our over-reliance on the herd
- 4:20prompts ignorance and distorts the
- 4:22information we use to make decisions
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Herding Behavior: How following the crowd leads us astray by Intermittent Diversion, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 680 words across 104 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.