Her Brothers Took the Estate — She Got the Old Country Schoolhouse, What She Found Was Worth More — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Her brothers took everything their
- 0:01father left behind,
- 0:03the 240 acres of Blue Ridge mountain
- 0:06land outside Mars Hill, North Carolina.
- 0:10The Honeycutt manor house with its wide
- 0:12front porch above Spring Creek,
- 0:15the Wells Fargo investment portfolio her
- 0:17grandfather had built,
- 0:19the hunting lodge up on Roan Mountain,
- 0:21the Charleston Beach house, the family
- 0:23silver and the wide flat board pine
- 0:25floor of the Mars Hill estate.
- 0:29All Sylvie Honeycutt received was a 126
- 0:32year old one room Appalachian
- 0:33schoolhouse on a 1.6 acre parcel at the
- 0:36head of Spring Creek that her brothers
- 0:38had been planning to demolish for years.
- 0:41They laughed when they heard her
- 0:42inheritance.
- 0:43To them, it was a collapsing log shed on
- 0:46the side of a Madison County mountain
- 0:48road worth perhaps $210,000
- 0:51on a generous day, less the cost of
- 0:54pulling the chestnut logs down.
- 0:57But what neither of them knew was that
- 0:58hidden beneath the chestnut log floor of
- 1:00that schoolhouse was something Sylvie's
- 1:03grandmother had been protecting for 56
- 1:05years, something that would expose a
- 1:07quiet four generation Honeycutt
- 1:10obligation nobody outside the
- 1:11schoolhouse had known about,
- 1:14something that would answer a question
- 1:15Sylvie had carried since she was 14.
- 1:19And by the time she understood what the
- 1:21schoolhouse really held, she would
- 1:23realize that her father had given her
- 1:25the only share that mattered.
- 1:27And what she found inside the
- 1:28schoolhouse was worth more than every
- 1:30acre her brothers had inherited.
- 1:33Before we begin, take a moment to
- 1:34subscribe and let us know in the
- 1:36comments where you're watching from.
- 1:38We love seeing how far these stories
- 1:40travel.
- 1:42Sylvie Honeycutt was 23 years old the
- 1:44cold December morning the family
- 1:45attorney read her father's will. She sat
- 1:48at the far end of a long pine conference
- 1:50table in a small wood paneled law office
- 1:52on Main Street in Mars Hill, North
- 1:55Carolina, wearing the only black dress
- 1:57she owned and a heather gray cable knit
- 2:00wool
- 2:00she had inherited from her grandmother
- 2:02beneath an open walnut-brown waxed wool
- 2:05field coat.
- 2:07Across the table sat her oldest brother,
- 2:09Rone Honeycutt, 39, a Charlotte
- 2:12commercial real estate broker who had
- 2:14driven up the mountain the night before
- 2:16in a charcoal Range Rover, and beside
- 2:18Rone sat his wife of 14 years, Bria
- 2:21Honeycutt, who had not stopped looking
- 2:23at her phone since she had sat down.
- 2:26Beside Bria sat Sylvie's other brother,
- 2:28Tate Honeycutt, 35, an Atlanta
- 2:30investment banker who had flown into
- 2:32Asheville Regional that morning in a
- 2:34slate-gray wool overcoat.
- 2:37Neither brother had spoken to Sylvie
- 2:38since the funeral. The attorney, Mr.
- 2:41Cabell Cantrell, was 71, the same age
- 2:44her father had been, and had been
- 2:47Granville Honeycutt's hunting partner on
- 2:49Spring Creek every November since 1971.
- 2:53Mr. Cantrell read the will in the slow,
- 2:56careful Madison County voice of a man
- 2:58who had read 3,000 wills and had learned
- 3:01a long time ago to let the document
- 3:03speak for itself.
- 3:05Nobody cried that December morning.
- 3:07Sylvie watched her brothers' faces as
- 3:09the attorney moved down the document.
- 3:11The 240 mountain acres above Spring
- 3:14Creek divided equally between Rone and
- 3:16Tate.
- 3:18The Honeycutt manor house, to Rone.
- 3:20The Rone mountain hunting lodge, to
- 3:22Tate.
- 3:23The Wells Fargo portfolio, divided
- 3:25equally.
- 3:27The Charleston beach house, to Rone.
- 3:30The shop building on Main Street, to
- 3:32Tate. The Honeycutt cattle herd, to
- 3:34Tate.
- 3:35The maple-sugar timber tract on Big
- 3:37Pine, to Rone.
- 3:39Rone's silver pen moved down a notepad
- 3:42in his lap.
- 3:43Bria, who had finally looked up from her
- 3:45phone, was running her thumb down a
- 3:47calculator.
- 3:49Tate leaned back in his chair and
- 3:51laughed once, softly. Then Mr. Cantrell
- 3:54turned a page and read the small
- 3:56bequest. To my daughter Sylvie Adelaide
- 3:59Honeycutt. I leave the 1.6-acre parcel
- 4:02at the head of Spring Creek, including
- 4:05the 1898 one-room, hewn, chestnut-log
- 4:08schoolhouse and all attached structures
- 4:11built by my grandfather, Asa Honeycutt,
- 4:13in the autumn of 1898
- 4:16and all contents thereof.
- 4:18Mr. Cantrell paused. He pushed his
- 4:21reading glasses up onto the bridge of
- 4:23his forehead.
- 4:24He folded his hands across the document.
- 4:28Roan let out a single short laugh.
- 4:31He left her the schoolhouse, he said.
- 4:34Dad left her the log shed on the creek.
- 4:37Bria tapped her phone face down on the
- 4:38table.
- 4:39The structure was condemned by the
- 4:41county in 2020.
- 4:43The Knoxville developer offered 210 as
- 4:46is, less demo.
- 4:48Net to her, maybe 150 after the parcels
- 4:51cleared.
- 4:52Tate checked the gold watch at his
- 4:54wrist. Congratulations, Syl. You got the
- 4:56schoolhouse.
- 4:58Mr. Cantrell did not laugh.
- 5:01He held his gaze on Sylvie over the
- 5:03brass rims of his reading glasses for a
- 5:04long moment.
- 5:06And there was something in his eyes Roan
- 5:08and Tate did not see.
- 5:10A look like a man who had been waiting
- 5:12nine years to see how this particular
- 5:14moment would land.
- 5:15He cleared his throat and read through
- 5:17the rest of the administrative
- 5:18paragraphs and the witness signature
- 5:20blocks.
- 5:22Sylvie signed her acceptance.
- 5:24Roan signed his.
- 5:25Tate signed his.
- 5:27The meeting was over in 36 minutes.
- 5:31What Roan and Tate did not know,
- 5:33what nobody at that pine table except
- 5:35Mr. Cabell Cantrell knew, was that
- 5:38Sylvie Honeycutt had been raised in that
- 5:39schoolhouse from the time she was four
- 5:41years old.
- 5:43Her grandmother, Adelaide Honeycutt,
- 5:45born Adelaide Buckner and known her
- 5:47whole life as Addie, had carried her on
- 5:49every Saturday and every summer
- 5:51afternoon of her childhood and had
- 5:53taught her the heritage Appalachian
- 5:55school teaching trade hand by hand,
- 5:57exactly the way Addie herself had been
- 6:00taught at the same hewn chestnut floor
- 6:02by her her mother, Cornelia Buckner, and
- 6:04by Asa Honeycutt himself in his last
- 6:07years.
- 6:09The schoolhouse had been the only place
- 6:10in the whole Honeycutt holding where
- 6:13Sylvie had ever felt completely at home.
- 6:16Neither brother had ever set foot
- 6:17through the schoolhouse door past the
- 6:19age of 10. Rone, who was 16 years older
- 6:23than Sylvie, had been at the McCallie
- 6:25School in Chattanooga from the time
- 6:27Sylvie was three.
- 6:29Tate, who was 12 years older,
- 6:31had hated the smell of split oak basket
- 6:33reed and beeswax candles
- 6:36and had stopped coming up to the
- 6:37schoolhouse after the autumn he turned
- 6:39nine.
- 6:40The schoolhouse had been her
- 6:42grandmother's domain. After Addie died
- 6:44when Sylvie was 16, the schoolhouse had
- 6:47been padlocked by her father and not
- 6:49opened by anyone again.
- 6:51Sylvie's mother, Dorothea Honeycutt, had
- 6:54died of ovarian cancer the year Sylvie
- 6:56was 14 after a 16-month fight that had
- 6:59emptied the Honeycutt manor house of
- 7:01every sound except the hum of the
- 7:02hospice equipment in the back sitting
- 7:05room. Her father, Granville Honeycutt,
- 7:0871 at his death, had been a quiet,
- 7:10careful Madison County mountain man who
- 7:13had spoken to Sylvie perhaps 350 words a
- 7:16year for the nine years between his
- 7:18wife's death and his own.
- 7:21Most of those words had been about the
- 7:23weather and the cattle.
- 7:25Granville had not been called. He had
- 7:28been broken twice over, first by
- 7:30Dorothea's death and again by his mother
- 7:32Addie's death two years later, and the
- 7:34second breaking had taken something out
- 7:36of him that he had never put back.
- 7:40Sylvie had grown up between her father's
- 7:41silence and her grandmother's slow
- 7:43patient afternoons in the schoolhouse,
- 7:46and the silence and the schoolhouse had
- 7:48divided her childhood into two distinct
- 7:50halves, the half she endured and the
- 7:52half she lived.
- 7:55Addie Honeycutt had been the master
- 7:57heritage school teacher at the Spring
- 7:59Creek Schoolhouse in Madison County for
- 8:0156 years, from 1962 when she took over
- 8:04the trade from her mother Cornelia
- 8:06Buckner until her death in 2018.
- 8:10Addie had inherited the schoolhouse in
- 8:12the trade from a line that went back
- 8:14four generations to Asa Honeycutt,
- 8:17born 1872 in the head of Spring Creek
- 8:19Hollow to a Scots-Irish Appalachian
- 8:22family that had been in the southern
- 8:23mountains since 1750.
- 8:26Asa had been the first Honeycutt to
- 8:28leave the mountain. He had taken the
- 8:30train down to Asheville at 16 and
- 8:32studied under the heritage Appalachian
- 8:34school teacher Mr. Hiram Wallin at the
- 8:36Asheville Normal School for seven years.
- 8:39Then walked back up to Spring Creek in
- 8:411898 and built his own one-room
- 8:44schoolhouse on the 1.6 acre parcel at
- 8:47the head of the hollow that autumn.
- 8:49He had hewn the chestnut logs himself,
- 8:52set the river stone foundation with
- 8:54stones he had carried out of Spring
- 8:55Creek across two summers,
- 8:57and laid the chestnut log walls and the
- 8:59slate roof with the help of seven local
- 9:02Madison County brothers.
- 9:04The first lesson Asa taught on that
- 9:06chestnut floor was a reading lesson from
- 9:08the Bible to seven Madison County
- 9:10children in October of 1898.
- 9:13And the schoolhouse had taught children
- 9:15without missing a season from then until
- 9:18October of 2018.
- 9:20By four, Sylvie could recite from memory
- 9:22the first verse of Barbara Allen, the
- 9:25child ballad number 84 her
- 9:27great-grandfather Asa had transcribed in
- 9:291898 from a Wallin family rendition that
- 9:32had come down from Scotland to the
- 9:34Madison County Hollows through five
- 9:37generations.
- 9:38Addie had taught her the ballads of the
- 9:40trade.
- 9:41The difference between the child
- 9:42ballads, the original Scottish and
- 9:44English ballads brought across the
- 9:46Atlantic by the 18th century settlers,
- 9:49Barbara Allen, the House Carpenter,
- 9:51Pretty Polly, and the Appalachian songs,
- 9:54the songs born in the mountains
- 9:55themselves, Shady Grove, Pretty Sorrow,
- 9:59Banks of the Ohio.
- 10:00Addie had taught her the shape note
- 10:02solfège of the Sacred Harp hymnal, fa
- 10:04sol la mi fa sol la,
- 10:06the four note scale the Madison County
- 10:08church singers had used since 1844.
- 10:12And the mountain craft trades of the
- 10:13schoolhouse curriculum, white oak split
- 10:15basket weaving, draw knife wood carving.
- 10:19The herbal mountain medicines, yarrow
- 10:21for fever, ginseng for the slow
- 10:23strength,
- 10:24bloodroot for the spring tonic.
- 10:27Sassafras for the blood and the Cherokee
- 10:29place names the mountains carried, Lusca
- 10:31the head of the creek, Nantahala the
- 10:34noonday sun, Cataloochee the wave in the
- 10:36water.
- 10:38By six, Sylvie could weave a small white
- 10:40oak basket from start to finish in three
- 10:43hours.
- 10:44By eight, Sylvie could lead the seven
- 10:47schoolhouse children in a shape note
- 10:48rendition of Wondrous Love in three part
- 10:51harmony,
- 10:52beating time with her right hand the way
- 10:54Addie had taught her.
- 10:56By 11, Sylvie was teaching the youngest
- 10:58schoolhouse children herself,
- 11:01leading the Saturday morning child
- 11:02ballad lessons, conducting the shape
- 11:04note rounds.
- 11:06Patience, honey girl, Addie would say.
- 11:09Patience, the lesson does not come to
- 11:11your hand fast.
- 11:13Your hand goes to the lesson slow,
- 11:15verse by verse.
- 11:17The ballad is patient.
- 11:19So are you.
- 11:21The first full Saturday morning Sylvie
- 11:23taught entirely on her own. Five Madison
- 11:25County children, an hour and a half of
- 11:28Barbara Allen with shape note rounds, 20
- 11:30minutes of basket weaving, a half hour
- 11:33of Cherokee place names was October of
- 11:352014 when she was 10.
- 11:38Addie had watched from the back bench
- 11:40without a word. She had not needed
- 11:42words.
- 11:43Sylvie had glowed for a month.
- 11:47Addie taught her the failures too. There
- 11:49was a thing she called the over
- 11:51conducted ballad. It was a child ballad
- 11:53lesson Sylvie had led with too rigid a
- 11:55beat. The verse is correct.
- 11:58The harmony complete.
- 12:00But where the strict beat had stripped
- 12:01the lilt from the line that the original
- 12:03Scottish singers had carried in the
- 12:05music since 1750.
- 12:07By the third verse, the children would
- 12:09have heard the lilt as a metronome
- 12:11rather than as a breath.
- 12:13And the
- 12:13would have gone dead in their mouths,
- 12:15and a ballad that should have lasted
- 12:17them their lives would have become a
- 12:19school exercise. If you conduct the
- 12:21ballad too rigid, honey girl, Addie
- 12:23said, on the back bench after Sylvie's
- 12:26too strict beat Barbara Allen with the
- 12:28four schoolhouse children one autumn
- 12:30afternoon, the verses will sound correct
- 12:32for a Saturday.
- 12:34By the next Saturday, the children will
- 12:36not be able to sing it back to you.
- 12:38The lilt is the ballad, the beat is not.
- 12:41Do you understand what we are losing?
- 12:44Sylvie had nodded. She was 13 that
- 12:46autumn.
- 12:48From that morning forward, she conducted
- 12:49the child ballads in the breath rhythm
- 12:51Cornelia had set in 1962
- 12:54and the lilt stayed in the verse and she
- 12:56never taught an over conducted ballad
- 12:58again.
- 12:59Addie taught her to read the schoolhouse
- 13:01benches with her bare feet. The seven
- 13:04Madison County chestnut benches that ran
- 13:06the length of the schoolhouse floor had
- 13:09been hewn by Asa from a single 1898
- 13:12chestnut and sat on the chestnut log
- 13:14floor for 126
- 13:17autumns of barefoot Appalachian
- 13:19children.
- 13:20Walk the benches in your bare feet,
- 13:22honey girl.
- 13:23Your bare feet.
- 13:25If a bench board feels worn smooth, that
- 13:27is a board 10,000 mountain children sat
- 13:30on through their Barbara Allen lessons.
- 13:33The benches remember every lesson. Walk
- 13:35them. The benches will teach you the
- 13:37trade.
- 13:38By 13, Sylvie could walk the schoolhouse
- 13:40benches in her bare feet in the cool
- 13:42October light and call with her eyes
- 13:45closed which child ballad each bench
- 13:48board had heard 10,000 times.
- 13:50By 15, Sylvie was leading the Saturday
- 13:53morning schoolhouse on her own.
- 13:55Six Madison County children every
- 13:57Saturday from October through April. The
- 14:00full child ballad cycle across four
- 14:02years.
- 14:03The Shape Note Sacred Harp hymnal across
- 14:06two.
- 14:07White oak basket weaving across three.
- 14:10Draw knife chestnut carving across two.
- 14:13And the Cherokee place names across the
- 14:14long quiet afternoons of late winter.
- 14:17The trade had become her voice.
- 14:20She did not yet think of it as a trade.
- 14:22To her, it was simply what one did on
- 14:25Saturday mornings and summer afternoons
- 14:27in a chestnut log building at the head
- 14:29of a Madison County hollow with one's
- 14:31grandmother.
- 14:33There were stories from the trade Addie
- 14:35would tell while her hands worked the
- 14:37willow loom.
- 14:39The story about Mr. Roland Wallin, the
- 14:42Madison County buck dancer who had
- 14:44brought his fiddle to the schoolhouse
- 14:45every Saturday afternoon from 1968
- 14:48through 2011, paid in homemade apple
- 14:51butter and chestnut flour bread.
- 14:54Never a check. He had wept on the
- 14:56chestnut floor the autumn of 2011 when
- 14:59Addie told him she had to take down the
- 15:00cane bottom rocker his wife had made for
- 15:02the front bench because the cane had
- 15:05finally broken through, not over the
- 15:07rocker, but over the slow disappearance
- 15:09of a Madison County buck dance culture
- 15:11he had known his whole life. The story
- 15:14of an autumn in 1989 when a Vietnamese
- 15:16refugee girl named Linh Tran had walked
- 15:19up the mountain road in late September
- 15:21asking work, and Addie had given her an
- 15:24autumn's wage and taught her the child
- 15:26ballad cycle in 14 weeks.
- 15:29Mrs. Tran had gone on to teach
- 15:31Appalachian heritage music at East
- 15:33Tennessee State University for 26 years.
- 15:37There was the story Addie would always
- 15:39come back to,
- 15:41the spring of 1937.
- 15:43The federal government had voted in 1934
- 15:46to create the Great Smoky Mountains
- 15:48National Park,
- 15:49and by the spring of 1937 the boundary
- 15:52survey had begun moving up the western
- 15:54Madison County valleys toward the head
- 15:56of Spring Creek.
- 15:5847 Appalachian mountain families across
- 16:01Big Pine,
- 16:03Little Creek,
- 16:04Cataloochee, and the Upper Tellico were
- 16:06about to be removed from their
- 16:08homesteads by federal order to create
- 16:10the park.
- 16:11Asa Honeycutt had been 65 years old that
- 16:14spring.
- 16:15He had walked down the mountain road on
- 16:17the of April 3rd, 1937 with a borrowed
- 16:20wax cylinder recording machine on his
- 16:22back from the Library of Congress in
- 16:24Washington, secured through Mr.
- 16:27Hiram Wallin's correspondence with the
- 16:29new federal folklorist, Mr. Alan Lomax,
- 16:32and he had not climbed back to the
- 16:34schoolhouse for 6 months.
- 16:36He had walked from homestead to
- 16:38homestead across the 47 displaced family
- 16:41hollows and recorded each family's oral
- 16:43history,
- 16:45their child ballad renditions, their
- 16:47fiddle tunes, their Cherokee place
- 16:49names,
- 16:50their stories of their grandfathers and
- 16:52their great-grandmothers, 187 wax
- 16:55cylinders of Southern Appalachian
- 16:57heritage recorded between April and
- 16:59October of 1937.
- 17:02By November, every one of the 47
- 17:04families had been moved off the mountain
- 17:06by federal marshals and the hollows had
- 17:09been emptied.
- 17:10The wax cylinders were the only sound
- 17:12left of them. The next spring, the
- 17:14Asheville Citizen ran a front-page
- 17:16feature on April 14th, 1938 with the
- 17:19headline, Asa Honeycutt Schoolhouse
- 17:21Preserves the Song of 47 Mountain
- 17:23Families before Park forces them out.
- 17:27Mr. Alan Lomax himself drove up to
- 17:29Spring Creek on May 14th, 1938 to thank
- 17:33Asa in person. He stood for a long
- 17:35minute on the chestnut floor without
- 17:37speaking and then took Asa's hand and
- 17:40pressed a folded list into it.
- 17:42On the list had been the 47 family
- 17:44names.
- 17:45The list was a request the spoken words
- 17:47could not have asked.
- 17:49Sylvie had heard this story many times.
- 17:52She had not understood until much later
- 17:54what Addie and Granville had done with
- 17:56that list. Addie told her stories that
- 17:59were really lessons.
- 18:00Once when Sylvie was 11 and had asked
- 18:03why her grandmother bothered teaching
- 18:04child ballad number 84 to 7 Madison
- 18:08County children on a chestnut bench in
- 18:102015 when YouTube had 10,000 renditions
- 18:13of the same ballad available with a
- 18:15single click.
- 18:17Addie had set down the white oak split
- 18:19she was soaking, turned to her
- 18:21and said an internet recording is a copy
- 18:25honey girl.
- 18:26A Saturday morning Barbara Allen in this
- 18:28schoolhouse is a memory.
- 18:31When a Madison County child sings the
- 18:32verse to her own grandchild 50 years
- 18:35from now she will not be singing the
- 18:37YouTube.
- 18:38She will be singing the patience of a
- 18:40woman who sat on this chestnut bench and
- 18:42taught her the lilt slowly
- 18:44in the rhythm her great grandfather
- 18:46brought up the mountain from Asheville.
- 18:49There are children in this county who
- 18:50still want to know that someone they can
- 18:52name taught them the song they will
- 18:54carry to their own children.
- 18:56The Saturdays are for them.
- 18:58That is the trade.
- 19:00Sylvie had understood this without being
- 19:02able to say it.
- 19:04The ballads were a memory. If you are
- 19:06enjoying this story take a moment to
- 19:08subscribe. It helps us keep making
- 19:11stories like this one.
- 19:12And tell us in the comments have you
- 19:14ever heard a song or a story passed down
- 19:17through your family by a single human
- 19:18voice
- 19:19and felt the difference of it move
- 19:21through you?
- 19:22Addie died in October of 2018
- 19:25in her own bed in the small caretaker's
- 19:27cabin attached to the south side of the
- 19:29schoolhouse of a stroke in her sleep at
- 19:32the age of 79.
- 19:34Sylvie was 16. Granville Honeycutt had
- 19:38buried his mother in the small Honeycutt
- 19:40family cemetery on the rise above Spring
- 19:42Creek
- 19:43and had walked up to the schoolhouse the
- 19:45next morning and padlocked the chestnut
- 19:47door himself.
- 19:49For seven years the schoolhouse had
- 19:51stood untouched.
- 19:52Sylvie had been told gently but firmly
- 19:55that the schoolhouse was closed.
- 19:58She had walked past it every season of
- 20:00her remaining childhood and looked at
- 20:02the padlocked chestnut door and the
- 20:04seven empty benches visible through the
- 20:06wavy old window glass and the chestnut
- 20:08floor fading behind the schoolhouse
- 20:10window and she had made herself a
- 20:12promise without yet having the words for
- 20:15it.
- 20:17The week of her father's funeral Rone
- 20:19had told her on the wide front porch of
- 20:21the Honeycutt manor house that the
- 20:22property would be listed for sale by
- 20:24spring, and that she should plan on
- 20:26being out by April 1st.
- 20:29Roan had not asked her where she planned
- 20:30to live.
- 20:32Sylvie had not answered him. She had
- 20:34stood on the porch with her hands in the
- 20:36pockets of the walnut field coat and
- 20:38watched her brother's rented black Range
- 20:40Rovers roll down the long gravel drive
- 20:43toward the mountain road.
- 20:45The Wednesday after the will reading,
- 20:48Sylvie drove out the mountain road in
- 20:49her 1991 Jeep Cherokee, the only thing
- 20:53she had bought entirely with her own
- 20:56money. Paid $1,750
- 20:59in cash to a retired Madison County
- 21:02logger outside Hot Springs, and she
- 21:04parked at the gravel turnaround at the
- 21:06head of Spring Creek.
- 21:08She had not been inside the schoolhouse
- 21:10in 7 years.
- 21:11She had only ever stood at the padlocked
- 21:13chestnut door and looked at the heavy
- 21:16iron padlock and the small brass key her
- 21:18grandmother had hung on a leather thong
- 21:20above the door that Granville had taken
- 21:22down the morning Addie was buried.
- 21:24She did not have the key.
- 21:26Mr. Cabell Cantrell had handed her the
- 21:29key in a small envelope after the will
- 21:31reading, sealed with red wax. She had
- 21:34slipped the envelope into the inner
- 21:35pocket of her field coat and driven up
- 21:38the mountain road home.
- 21:40She had not broken the seal until that
- 21:41morning at her kitchen table in the
- 21:43cold, early light before the wood stove
- 21:45caught.
- 21:47She walked across the frozen gravel in
- 21:49the cool December light and stood at the
- 21:51padlocked chestnut door and breathed for
- 21:54a long minute. She fitted the small
- 21:56brass key to the heavy iron padlock and
- 21:58turned.
- 21:59The lock gave. She lifted it off the
- 22:02hasp and set it on the worn chestnut
- 22:04threshold.
- 22:05She pushed the chestnut door open with
- 22:07the flat of her hand. It swung inward on
- 22:10its old wrought iron hinges with a soft
- 22:12scrape.
- 22:13The schoolhouse was still there.
- 22:16The seven Madison County chestnut
- 22:17benches running the length of the
- 22:19chestnut log floor in three even rows.
- 22:22The slate blackboard at the front of the
- 22:24room, the chalk tray
- 22:26the slate still bearing the last lesson
- 22:28Addie had written in October of 2018.
- 22:31Verses 14 of Barbara Allen, Shape Note
- 22:34Wondrous Love, white oak basket sides.
- 22:38The pot belly stove at the center of the
- 22:40floor on its iron flag.
- 22:42A small willow loom on its chestnut
- 22:44frame against the south wall.
- 22:46The chestnut and leather rocker by the
- 22:48front bench where Addie had sat with the
- 22:50youngest children.
- 22:51The handmade chestnut writing desk at
- 22:53the back of the room where Addie had
- 22:56kept the lesson book.
- 22:57The wide board chestnut floor running
- 22:59the full 32 ft of the schoolhouse.
- 23:02Polished gold by a century and a quarter
- 23:04of barefoot Madison County children, the
- 23:07slight shallow grooves of generations of
- 23:09small bare feet worn into the chestnut
- 23:11at the bench foot spots.
- 23:13The smell at the door was old beeswax
- 23:15candle and dried yarrow leaf and pot
- 23:18belly wood smoke and the cold mountain
- 23:20smell of Spring Creek water rising up
- 23:23through the chestnut floor from the
- 23:24river stone foundation. Sylvie stepped
- 23:27inside and stood at the back of the
- 23:28chestnut floor for a long minute and
- 23:31breathed.
- 23:32She walked the length of the chestnut
- 23:33floor in her bare feet, her boots and
- 23:36her socks she had left on the threshold
- 23:38outside the door.
- 23:40The chestnut was cool and the cool ran
- 23:42up through her bare soles and she felt
- 23:45by old memory in her body
- 23:47the warm spots and the cool spots and
- 23:49the slight shallow grooves where Addie
- 23:51had stood for 56 years and the deeper
- 23:54grooves where Cornelia had stood for 30
- 23:56years before her.
- 23:58And the deepest worn spot of all at
- 24:01the dead center of the chestnut floor,
- 24:03where Asa himself had stood to
- 24:07teach every Saturday lesson he ever gave
- 24:09for 50 years.
- 24:11The chestnut remembered.
- 24:13A memory came back. Addie, the autumn
- 24:15Sylvie was nine, kneeling at the dead
- 24:18center of the chestnut floor and laying
- 24:20her flat palm on a single floorboard
- 24:22where the chestnut grain ran slightly
- 24:24darker than the boards beside it.
- 24:27Your great grandfather Asa was a careful
- 24:29man, honey girl. When he laid this floor
- 24:31in 1898, he cut a hidden hatch into the
- 24:34floor at the dead center spot where he
- 24:36taught every Saturday morning lesson he
- 24:39ever gave.
- 24:40He told me about it the week before he
- 24:42died in 1949.
- 24:44He said it was where the schoolhouse
- 24:46kept what could not be lost.
- 24:48I never lifted the board.
- 24:51Sylvie had been nine. She had forgotten
- 24:54the story for 14 years.
- 24:57She knelt at the dead center of the
- 24:59chestnut floor.
- 25:01The chestnut floorboard ran flush with
- 25:02the boards on either side, almost
- 25:04invisible against the grain, with a
- 25:06small iron ring set into one corner that
- 25:09her bare feet had walked over a thousand
- 25:11times without seeing.
- 25:13She slipped her finger through the iron
- 25:15ring and lifted.
- 25:17The chestnut floorboard came up, heavy,
- 25:203 in thick. Beneath it was a stone lined
- 25:23cavity about 3 ft deep and 20 in across,
- 25:26set into the river stone foundation.
- 25:29At the bottom of the cavity, in the back
- 25:31corner, sat a tin box the size of a
- 25:33brick.
- 25:34The lid stamped Asa, 1898.
- 25:37Beneath the tin box, taking up the rest
- 25:39of the cavity, was a wooden trap door 3
- 25:42ft by 16 in set into a chestnut frame,
- 25:45sealed at every seam with deep brown
- 25:47wax, bearing the honey cut thistle
- 25:50imprint.
- 25:51She lifted the tin box out first, two
- 25:53handed, and set it on the worn chestnut
- 25:56floor in the gray December light.
- 25:58She lifted the lid.
- 26:00A heavy oil cloth bundle inside fell
- 26:02open across her hands to reveal 215
- 26:06gold coins stacked in even rows.
- 26:09Liberty half eagles and quarter eagles
- 26:11and a small handful of Saint Gaudens
- 26:13double eagles in better condition than
- 26:15any she had ever seen.
- 26:18The coin dealer in Asheville would later
- 26:20weigh the lot at 26,800.
- 26:24Beneath the bundle, a small leather
- 26:26bound notebook held Asa's original 1898
- 26:29schoolhouse curriculum.
- 26:31Every child ballad by transcription
- 26:33date.
- 26:34Every shaped note hymn by Sacred Harp
- 26:36page number. Every white oak basket and
- 26:39chestnut carving lesson by week of the
- 26:41school year in his careful Asheville
- 26:43normal school hand.
- 26:46Then the leather bound lesson book,
- 26:48Addie's own ledger.
- 26:49Every Saturday morning she had taught
- 26:51from 1962 through 2018 recorded in 290
- 26:56pages of tight slanted script.
- 26:58Beneath the ledger an old sepia
- 27:00photograph showing Asa Honeycutt in 1898
- 27:03in front of the just finished
- 27:05schoolhouse.
- 27:06A small chestnut paddle in his hand, a
- 27:08seven year old girl in a pinafore,
- 27:11Addie's mother Cornelia standing beside
- 27:13him at the chestnut door.
- 27:15Pressed flat behind the photograph she
- 27:17found a yellowed newspaper clipping she
- 27:19had not seen on the first pass. The
- 27:21clipping was from the Asheville Citizen
- 27:24dated April 14th 1938.
- 27:27The headline read Asa Honeycutt
- 27:29schoolhouse preserves the song of 47
- 27:31mountain families before park forces
- 27:33them out.
- 27:35And on top of everything sealed with
- 27:37deep brown wax a folded letter with
- 27:40Sylvie's name across the front.
- 27:43Sylvie broke the wax with her thumbnail.
- 27:45She sat down on the cold chestnut floor
- 27:47at the dead center of the schoolhouse in
- 27:49the gray December light from the wavy
- 27:51old front window and read the letter
- 27:53through.
- 27:54October 11th 2018 Sylvie, by the time
- 27:57you find this I will be gone and the
- 27:59schoolhouse will have stood quiet long
- 28:01enough that your father will have known
- 28:03to give it to you.
- 28:05My great grandfather Asa set this money
- 28:07beneath the floor in 1898 because he did
- 28:10not trust any Madison County bank with
- 28:13his Spring Creek school master money.
- 28:16He told me about it the week before he
- 28:17died in 1949 and made me promise not to
- 28:20lift the board.
- 28:22I have kept the promise.
- 28:24The schoolhouse fed us through every
- 28:26year of my life and most of yours.
- 28:29Your brothers will sell what they can
- 28:31but this box they cannot sell
- 28:34because they do not know it is here.
- 28:36The curriculum is Aesop's. The lesson
- 28:38book is the record.
- 28:41Teach again if it suits you, honey girl.
- 28:44The schoolhouse is yours.
- 28:46Adelaide Honeycutt, Master Heritage
- 28:48School Teacher, 11 October 2018.
- 28:52Sylvie closed the letter into the inside
- 28:54pocket of the heather gray cardigan.
- 28:56She did not cry. She walked to the dead
- 28:59center of the chestnut floor where Addie
- 29:01had taught Saturday morning lessons for
- 29:0356 years, and laid her flat palm on the
- 29:06worn polished chestnut,
- 29:08and felt the 60 years of body warmth
- 29:10Addie had pressed into the grain,
- 29:13the slight shallow groove of the
- 29:14standing spot under her flat hand, the
- 29:17smell of dry beeswax and yarrow leaf
- 29:19rising up from the floor into the cold
- 29:21air.
- 29:22The chestnut was cool. The groove was
- 29:25perfect.
- 29:26Into the gray December light over Spring
- 29:28Creek, she said quietly,
- 29:31Thank you, Miss Honeycutt.
- 29:34I will teach again.
- 29:37She read the newspaper clipping again.
- 29:39The article described the 6-month wax
- 29:42cylinder recording project in detail.
- 29:45It listed every displaced family by
- 29:47name.
- 29:48The Sutton family at the head of Big
- 29:49Pine, the Wallen family at the head of
- 29:52Little Creek, the Cantrell family at
- 29:54Upper Cataloochee,
- 29:56the Penland family at the head of the
- 29:58Tellico,
- 29:59the Buckner family at the head of the
- 30:01Hickory Nut,
- 30:03the Greenlee family at the South Fork of
- 30:04Spring Creek.
- 30:06The article ended with a quote from Mr.
- 30:08Alan Lomax of the Library of Congress.
- 30:11Whoever walked up these hollows last
- 30:13spring with a wax cylinder machine on
- 30:15his back saved the song of 47
- 30:18Appalachian families before the federal
- 30:20marshals took their hollows.
- 30:23We will spend the rest of our lives
- 30:25wondering what we owe him, and we will
- 30:27spend the rest of our lives playing his
- 30:29cylinders as long as our radios still
- 30:31play.
- 30:33Sylvie read the clipping twice. She
- 30:34folded it slowly. She put it in the
- 30:36inside pocket of the cardigan beside the
- 30:39letter. She turned back to the cavity.
- 30:42The wax-sealed trapdoor under where the
- 30:44tin box had sat remained.
- 30:47She lifted it carefully out and set it
- 30:48on the chestnut floor beside her, then
- 30:51looked back down. The trapdoor had been
- 30:53a hatch, not the bottom of the cavity.
- 30:56Below where it had sat ran a narrow
- 30:58stone stair down into the dark, the air
- 31:01rising up from it cool and faintly sweet
- 31:03with the smell of beeswax and old
- 31:06chestnut wood.
- 31:08She studied the wax seals along the
- 31:09trapdoor's edge, eight of them, each
- 31:12impressed with the honeycombed thistle,
- 31:15the wax brittle but unbroken. She lifted
- 31:18the kerosene lantern from its hook on
- 31:19the chestnut wall and lit the wick.
- 31:22She started down the stair, one hand
- 31:25braced against the river stone.
- 31:27The cellar archive opened at the bottom
- 31:29of 14 stone steps into a single
- 31:31low-ceilinged river stone room, 12 ft by
- 31:3420.
- 31:35The stone walls thick with the white
- 31:37bloom of cellar mold, the floor laid in
- 31:39worn Madison County bluestone.
- 31:42Along all four walls, on chestnut
- 31:44shelves built into the stone, stood the
- 31:47Honeycut Folk Song Archive.
- 31:50187
- 31:51wax cylinder field recordings spaced
- 31:54along the upper shelves, each cylinder
- 31:56in its original cardboard tube, each
- 31:59tube hand labeled in Ace's 1937
- 32:02schoolmaster hand.
- 32:04On the middle shelves stood 47
- 32:06leather-bound original handwritten child
- 32:08ballad transcription volumes.
- 32:10Each volume titled in gold, embossed
- 32:13Asheville Normal School hand on the
- 32:14spine, containing Ace's word-for-word
- 32:18transcriptions of the ballad lyrics he
- 32:20had collected across 46 years.
- 32:22On the lower shelves stood 380
- 32:26hand-carved woodblock printing plates.
- 32:29Each plate the master template for one
- 32:30of Ace's lesson books on Appalachian
- 32:32heritage crafts.
- 32:34The last cylinder recording dated
- 32:36October of 1942.
- 32:38The archive had not been opened in 83
- 32:41years.
- 32:42Sylvie stood at the bottom of the stair
- 32:44with the kerosene lantern in her hand,
- 32:46and the amber light catching the 187 wax
- 32:49cylinders, and the 47 leather bound
- 32:51ballad volumes, and the 380 hand carved
- 32:55wood block plates, and she breathed.
- 32:58On a small chestnut table at the center
- 33:00of the cellar lay a single folded oil
- 33:02cloth bundle. She unwrapped it
- 33:04carefully.
- 33:06Inside lay Ace's complete 1898-1942
- 33:10Heritage Appalachian map of Madison,
- 33:13Yancey, and Mitchell Counties.
- 33:1512 sheets of cotton drafting paper, hand
- 33:18drawn and signed, showing the exact
- 33:21location of 187
- 33:23Appalachian heritage sites, the
- 33:26surviving Cherokee place name markers,
- 33:29the heritage ginseng and bloodroot beds,
- 33:32the Wallen family chestnut grove
- 33:33cemeteries, the historic Sutton family
- 33:36ballad singing porches.
- 33:3847 of the 187
- 33:41sites had been inside the new Great
- 33:43Smoky Mountains Park boundary in 1937
- 33:46and had been administratively closed.
- 33:49The map was the complete cultural
- 33:51register of pre-park Southern
- 33:53Appalachian Mountain heritage.
- 33:55Sylvie held the 12 sheets for a long
- 33:57minute in the kerosene lantern light.
- 33:59She folded them carefully back into the
- 34:01oil cloth and laid them on the chestnut
- 34:03table.
- 34:05She climbed the stone stair.
- 34:07She lowered the trap door back into its
- 34:09chestnut frame.
- 34:11She sat on the chestnut floor at the
- 34:13center spot and did not move for a long
- 34:15time.
- 34:17She drove the Cherokee the next morning
- 34:19down the mountain road to the Honeycutt
- 34:21Manor House.
- 34:22She turned the key her father had given
- 34:24her the previous October in the heavy
- 34:26oak front door and stepped inside.
- 34:29The house had gone cold without the wood
- 34:30stoves lit.
- 34:33She passed through the front parlor and
- 34:34the dining room and the library,
- 34:36every room still smelling faintly of the
- 34:39cedar shavings Dorothea had kept in the
- 34:41linen presses, and walked back to the
- 34:43small back study where her father had
- 34:45kept his desk for 45 years.
- 34:48The desk was a heavy chestnut roll top
- 34:50her grandfather Buford Honeycutt had
- 34:52built in 1948.
- 34:55The roll top was rolled down. She slid
- 34:57it up.
- 34:58On the worn green leather writing
- 34:59surface set squarely at the center sat a
- 35:02single sealed envelope, her name on the
- 35:04front in her father's slow careful hand.
- 35:08She lifted the envelope. The flap was
- 35:10sealed with the same deep brown wax as
- 35:12Addie's letter in the cellar trap door.
- 35:15Granville had used the same wax stick.
- 35:18Sylvie broke the wax with her thumbnail
- 35:20and read.
- 35:22Sylvie, if you are reading this, you
- 35:24have found the schoolhouse.
- 35:26And if you have found the schoolhouse,
- 35:27you have found the floor cavity. And if
- 35:30you have found the cavity, you have
- 35:31found the cellar trap door. And if you
- 35:33have found the trap door, you have found
- 35:35the folk song archive.
- 35:37The Smithsonian Folkways Recordings
- 35:39division has been looking for Asa's wax
- 35:42cylinder collection for 40 years. They
- 35:45will pay you for the cylinders.
- 35:47The cultural map is more important.
- 35:50Unchaper Hill and the Cherokee Eastern
- 35:52Band Cultural Office have been searching
- 35:55for Asa's heritage site locations for 30
- 35:57years.
- 35:58They will pay you almost nothing for the
- 36:00map because what is on the map cannot be
- 36:03measured in money.
- 36:05Your grandmother and I sold one gold
- 36:07coin every winter for 47 years
- 36:10anonymously through an Asheville
- 36:12intermediary to private collectors. We
- 36:15used the funds to anonymously endow 47
- 36:18full scholarships at Mars Hill College
- 36:20between 1968 and 2014.
- 36:24One a year. One for each of the 47
- 36:27Appalachian mountain families Asa
- 36:28documented before the park forced them
- 36:31out.
- 36:32We did not tell your brothers.
- 36:34Your mother knew. I have left you the
- 36:36schoolhouse because the schoolhouse is
- 36:39the only thing in this whole estate your
- 36:41grandmother would have wanted you to
- 36:42have.
- 36:44The Smithsonian Folkways director is
- 36:46named Dr. Hadrien Wallen, your
- 36:49grandmother's cousin's son.
- 36:51He is expecting your call.
- 36:53I am not a man of words. I am sorry I
- 36:56was not a man of more words for you.
- 36:58I have left you what was your
- 37:00grandmother's,
- 37:01Granville Honeycutt, your father.
- 37:04September 26th, 2024, Sylvie sat for a
- 37:08long time at her father's chestnut roll
- 37:10top in the late December afternoon
- 37:12light.
- 37:13Then she folded the letter into the
- 37:15inside pocket of the heather gray
- 37:16cardigan beside the first letter and the
- 37:19clipping.
- 37:20She closed the roll top.
- 37:22She drove back up the mountain road to
- 37:24the schoolhouse and locked the chestnut
- 37:25door behind her. She drove the Cherokee
- 37:28the next Monday down the mountain to the
- 37:30Mars Hill Community Federal Bank on Main
- 37:32Street with the tin box on the passenger
- 37:34seat.
- 37:35Mrs. Greer Wallen, a second cousin of
- 37:38her grandmother, the branch manager for
- 37:4029 years, weighed the coins on the
- 37:42bank's brass scale, called the dealer in
- 37:45Asheville, and confirmed 26,800.
- 37:49Sylvie deposited 25,900
- 37:52and walked back to the Cherokee with 900
- 37:55folded into the inside pocket of the
- 37:57cardigan.
- 37:58Mrs. Wallen had not said anything when
- 38:01she saw the dealer's total.
- 38:03She had just looked at Sylvie for a long
- 38:05moment over the brass scale and signed
- 38:08the receipt.
- 38:10She called Dr. Hadrien Wallen at the
- 38:12Smithsonian Folkways Recordings the
- 38:14following Wednesday.
- 38:16Dr. Wallen drove down from Washington
- 38:18the next Saturday with a climate
- 38:20controlled archive van and three audio
- 38:22archivist assistants.
- 38:24They spent 10 hours in the cellar
- 38:25cataloging the 187
- 38:28wax cylinders and the 47 leather bound
- 38:31ballad volumes and the 380 wood block
- 38:34plates.
- 38:36Dr. Wallen offered, on behalf of the
- 38:38Smithsonian, $6,400,000
- 38:42for the complete archive to be kept
- 38:44intact in perpetuity as the Honeycut
- 38:47Mountain Heritage collection at
- 38:49Smithsonian folk ways with Sylvie named
- 38:52as the donor.
- 38:53The terms allowed Sylvie to retain the
- 38:55original 1898 Ace of Schoolhouse
- 38:58curriculum notebook in the Spring Creek
- 39:00Schoolhouse for display.
- 39:02Sylvie took Dr. Wallen's hand on it at
- 39:04the Chestnut Floor Center spot.
- 39:07The first Smithsonian check when it
- 39:09cleared in March paid for everything
- 39:11that came next. She called the
- 39:13University of North Carolina at Chapel
- 39:15Hill the following Thursday.
- 39:17A senior Appalachian Studies professor
- 39:20named Dr. Cornelia Greenleaf drove up
- 39:22from Chapel Hill the next Saturday with
- 39:24five graduate students. They spent 12
- 39:27hours in the schoolhouse photographing
- 39:29the 12 sheets of Ace's cultural map and
- 39:32then drove with Sylvie in a convoy of
- 39:34three vehicles to each of the 187
- 39:38mapped locations across Madison, Yancey,
- 39:41and Mitchell Counties.
- 39:43138 of the 187
- 39:46heritage sites were still standing. The
- 39:49cultural map became the founding
- 39:51document of Unk's expanded Honeycut
- 39:54Mountain Heritage Preservation Program.
- 39:57The first Unk's research grant when it
- 40:00cleared in April, 1.1 million dollars
- 40:03across 10 years paid for the
- 40:05schoolhouse's first winter of operating
- 40:07costs.
- 40:09The first month was refitting the
- 40:10schoolhouse.
- 40:12The slate roof had taken seven years of
- 40:14Madison County weather and was missing
- 40:1626 slates.
- 40:18The front window had two panes cracked
- 40:21and the putty crumbling on the rest.
- 40:24The seven chestnut benches needed light
- 40:26sanding and a careful refinish with
- 40:29beeswax polish.
- 40:31The pot belly stove needed a new flue
- 40:33pipe. Sylvie ordered 220 fresh slate
- 40:36roofing tiles from a quarry near
- 40:38Asheboro for $800.
- 40:41She found a retired Madison County
- 40:43school teacher named Mr. Hollis Roberts,
- 40:4681, who came up the mountain road on a
- 40:49Wednesday, and showed her how to reset
- 40:51the chestnut benches without splitting
- 40:53the floor planks.
- 40:55She replaced the cracked panes and
- 40:56puttied the rest across two evenings.
- 40:59She refinished the seven benches by hand
- 41:01in three coats of beeswax polish over a
- 41:04weekend.
- 41:05She lit the potbelly stove with fresh
- 41:07chestnut kindling and read aloud the
- 41:10first three verses of Barbara Allen
- 41:12across the empty schoolhouse in late
- 41:14January just to feel the rhythm again.
- 41:17The lilt held.
- 41:19The caretaker's cabin attached to the
- 41:20south side of the schoolhouse became
- 41:22hers a piece at a time across that first
- 41:24winter.
- 41:25She brought down the folding bed from
- 41:27the manor house back bedroom before her
- 41:29brother's real estate agent could
- 41:30photograph it.
- 41:32She brought down a small two-burner
- 41:34kerosene stove.
- 41:36A farm sale outside Marshall yielded a
- 41:38small kitchen table for $22.
- 41:41A thrift shop on Main Street in Mars
- 41:43Hill yielded a wool quilt for 14.
- 41:46Mr. Hollis Roberts came back that next
- 41:48Sunday with a small cast iron parlor
- 41:51stove he had pulled out of his own back
- 41:52shed and installed it himself in the
- 41:55corner of the cabin, vented through the
- 41:56chestnut wall and would not take pay.
- 42:00Your grandmother taught me Child Ballad
- 42:02Number 84 on this chestnut floor in
- 42:041965.
- 42:06He said, Just bring me coffee.
- 42:09She lay awake that first night on the
- 42:11folding bed by the south facing window
- 42:13of the cabin,
- 42:14the cast iron parlor stove ticking in
- 42:16the corner as it cooled,
- 42:18the chestnut walls absorbing the
- 42:20December cold,
- 42:21the slow even sound of Spring Creek
- 42:23running over its stones below the
- 42:25schoolhouse foundation,
- 42:27the faint stars visible through the
- 42:28cabin window above the leafless chestnut
- 42:31on the far bank.
- 42:33The roof above her was hers for the
- 42:35first time in her 23 years.
- 42:39Things found their places.
- 42:41The heather gray cable knit cardigan
- 42:43went on a peg above the kitchen table.
- 42:45Asa's empty tin box sat on the chestnut
- 42:48shelf above the front door.
- 42:50The small brass AH chalk bell took its
- 42:52old position on the slate blackboard
- 42:54ledge.
- 42:55A new lesson book went on the kitchen
- 42:57table and Sylvie began entering her own
- 42:59Saturday mornings, February 1st, 2025.
- 43:04First Honeycut Saturday of the new
- 43:05season.
- 43:07Six Madison County children.
- 43:10Verse one of Barbara Allen, Shape Note
- 43:13Wondrous Love in three parts.
- 43:15White Oak Basket Bottoms.
- 43:18$1 per child.
- 43:20Mr. Hollis Roberts came every Saturday
- 43:23morning. He drove up the mountain road
- 43:25in his sand-colored 1968 Mercedes 220D
- 43:29he had owned for 56 years
- 43:31with a thermos and a paper sack of his
- 43:33wife's apple and walnut cookies.
- 43:36He took a cup at the kitchen table, set
- 43:38the cookies on the slate ledge, said
- 43:40Addie would have liked this,
- 43:42and drove home.
- 43:43In her second year, the University of
- 43:45North Carolina at Chapel Hill expanded
- 43:48the Honeycut Mountain Heritage
- 43:49Preservation Program into a working
- 43:51partnership with the Spring Creek
- 43:53Schoolhouse.
- 43:54They needed a single-source Heritage
- 43:56Appalachian Education Center to host
- 43:58quarterly Heritage Craft and ballad
- 44:01singing workshops for Madison County
- 44:03children.
- 44:0447 workshops per year,
- 44:06one for each of the 47 displaced family
- 44:09hollows Asa had documented, and Addie
- 44:12and Granville had quietly endowed across
- 44:1447 autumns.
- 44:16They named their terms at the Chestnut
- 44:18Floor,
- 44:19a standing order of 47 quarterly
- 44:21workshops per year at $1,800
- 44:24per workshop for 10 years.
- 44:27Sylvie took Dr. Greenleaf's hand on it.
- 44:31The first uncle check, when it cleared
- 44:33in March, paid for her second winter at
- 44:35the schoolhouse.
- 44:37The Saturday children grew.
- 44:39Mrs. Penland's great-granddaughter,
- 44:41descendant of the Penland family at the
- 44:42head of the teleco, drove up from
- 44:44Knoxville in March of that first year
- 44:46with a jar of her grandmother's
- 44:48blackberry preserves and a story she had
- 44:50been carrying since she was a girl.
- 44:53Sylvie made her coffee at the cabin
- 44:55kitchen table and listened.
- 44:57Her great grandmother had been one of
- 44:58the 47 Appalachian women Asa had
- 45:01recorded on the wax cylinders in the
- 45:03spring of 1937
- 45:05verses 3 through 6 of Pretty Polly sung
- 45:08at the kitchen table the night before
- 45:09the federal marshals had come.
- 45:11She had been one of the 47 Mars Hill
- 45:14College scholars Addie and Granville had
- 45:16endowed in 1968. She came back in
- 45:19November and brought her three
- 45:20granddaughters for the full winter
- 45:22Saturday cycle.
- 45:24Mr. Cabell Cantrell drove up one
- 45:26Saturday in April with the original 1898
- 45:29hand painted Spring Creek Country
- 45:31Schoolhouse
- 45:33EST 1898 Madison CO and C sign that he
- 45:38had bought at Asa's estate sale in 1949
- 45:42and had been keeping in his law office
- 45:44hallway for 75 years. He sat it on the
- 45:47chestnut bench and refused even coffee.
- 45:50A Blue Ridge Heritage magazine ran a
- 45:52feature and Saturday children began
- 45:55coming up the mountain from across the
- 45:56southern Appalachians until she raised
- 45:59her Saturday tuition from $1 a child to
- 46:02five and was still booked 13 Saturdays
- 46:06out.
- 46:06By the second autumn she had a habit of
- 46:08sitting on the chestnut front step of
- 46:10the schoolhouse in the last hour of
- 46:12daylight
- 46:13with the coffee mug warm in both hands.
- 46:16Spring Creek ran low and clear past the
- 46:18schoolhouse foundation. The maples up
- 46:21the hollow turned a deep crimson of mid
- 46:23October.
- 46:24The big pine ridge gone smoke gray
- 46:26across the valley.
- 46:28She thought of Addie, of Asa whom she
- 46:30had never met but whose hand had taught
- 46:33Child Ballad number 84 on the same
- 46:35chestnut floor beneath her bare feet.
- 46:38Of her father Granville whose decision
- 46:40in September of 2024 had handed her the
- 46:43only inheritance she had ever wanted of
- 46:46the 47 Appalachian families on the
- 46:48spring of 1937 ridge line.
- 46:51Of the 47 Mars Hill College scholars
- 46:54Addie had quietly endowed and of the
- 46:56long unbroken row of voices on the
- 46:59chestnut floor that had finally come
- 47:01down to her own.
- 47:04That's the thing about the trade our
- 47:05grandmothers teach us to keep.
- 47:08do not always know when we are six years
- 47:10old and sitting on a chestnut bench with
- 47:12our small hand on our grandmother's hand
- 47:15and our small voice on the verse of
- 47:17Barbara Allen that the singing is itself
- 47:20the trade.
- 47:21We learn it slowly, verse by verse.
- 47:24And then seven years after the old woman
- 47:27dies, we lift a board she would not lift
- 47:30and find what she has left for us
- 47:32and we understand what she has been
- 47:34teaching us.
- 47:35She had been teaching us that a Saturday
- 47:37morning ballad is a memory the voice
- 47:40keeps to the next voice.
- 47:42She had been teaching us that the trade
- 47:44is the patience.
- 47:46The trade is the hand that learned, the
- 47:48hand that teaches, and the hand that
- 47:50comes after.
- 47:51And sometimes the trade is also the hand
- 47:54that quietly endows 47 Mars Hill College
- 47:57scholarships across 47 Madison County
- 48:00autumns and never tells anyone whose
- 48:02hand it was.
- 48:04Her brothers got the estate.
- 48:06Her brothers got the manor house and the
- 48:08Wells Fargo portfolio and the Charleston
- 48:10Beach house
- 48:12and the Roane Mountain Lodge and the
- 48:14cattle herd.
- 48:15They got everything you could measure
- 48:16with money and they laughed at the log
- 48:18shed on the side of the mountain road on
- 48:20the way out the door.
- 48:23What they did not get was the trade.
- 48:26What they did not get was the
- 48:27grandmother. What they did not get was
- 48:30the 47 Appalachian families on the
- 48:32spring of 1937 Federal Marshall Ridge
- 48:35Line.
- 48:36What they did not get was the 187
- 48:40wax cylinders in the cellar.
- 48:42What they did not get was the hand that
- 48:45came after.
- 48:47Sylvie Honeycutt was 23 years old and
- 48:50her father had just died.
- 48:53She had $1 to her name
- 48:55and she spent it on a crumbling old
- 48:56one-room schoolhouse on a 1.6 acre
- 48:59parcel at the head of Spring Creek in
- 49:01Madison County, North Carolina.
- 49:04It was the best one dollar she ever
- 49:06spent.
- 49:07If this story moved you, share it with
- 49:10someone who needs to hear it.
- 49:12And tell us in the comments, has anyone
- 49:14in your family ever quietly carried a
- 49:16kindness like that
- 49:18one nobody else knew about?
- 49:20We would love to read your stories. See
- 49:22you on the next Quiet Road.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Her Brothers Took the Estate — She Got the Old Country Schoolhouse, What She Found Was Worth More by AC Harrison Stories, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,787 words across 1,336 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.