HEGEL - La dialectique — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:08Hello everyone.
- 0:12In my video dedicated to Spinoza, I
- 0:14mentioned that I had taken my time
- 0:16before making that video because you
- 0:18don't tackle a monument of philosophy
- 0:20like Spinoza without being prepared.
- 0:25Today, I am releasing a video on Hegel,
- 0:28and if that precaution was valid for
- 0:30Spinoza, it becomes indispensable when
- 0:33it comes to Hegel.
- 0:36Making a video on a thinker of this
- 0:40caliber is taking a huge risk.
- 0:44It means assuming from the start that we
- 0:47won't have time to say everything, and
- 0:50that saying "the whole" of Hegel's
- 0:52philosophy is as complicated as saying "
- 0:55the whole" in general.
- 0:58Because, as it happens, Hegel's
- 1:00philosophy also intends to be a
- 1:02philosophy of totality.
- 1:06So, instead of taking detours, instead
- 1:09of using overly abstract language, I
- 1:12have made the methodological choice to
- 1:15introduce you to Hegel's thought through
- 1:18what I consider to be his fundamental
- 1:21concept.
- 1:24The fundamental concept, in my view, of
- 1:27Hegelian philosophy is the concept of
- 1:29dialectic.
- 1:32Now, when I define dialectic as a
- 1:34concept, I am already making a first
- 1:37approximation, perhaps even a first
- 1:39error.
- 1:41But that’s okay because, as you will see
- 1:44, with Hegel, error is a part of
- 1:46knowledge.
- 1:48Why is the dialectic not, strictly
- 1:50speaking, a concept?
- 1:53Because a concept refers to a general
- 1:56idea; it refers to an abstraction.
- 2:00For example, the concept of freedom, the
- 2:03concept of happiness, the concept of law
- 2:06.
- 2:08Whereas the dialectic refers not to an
- 2:11idea, but rather to a mode of operation
- 2:15, a dynamic process.
- 2:19The dialectic designates the way reality
- 2:23behaves.
- 2:26Now, it may seem surprising to speak of
- 2:28the behavior of reality, as if reality
- 2:31were endowed with intentions, as if it
- 2:33were endowed with a personality.
- 2:37Does Hegel personify the real? No. But
- 2:40he identifies in reality a principle,
- 2:44which is the rational principle, and for
- 2:47which the dialectic constitutes its
- 2:50implementation in the material world.
- 2:55We will obviously come back to all this
- 2:58, but first, I must open a parenthesis
- 3:00by briefly evoking the dialectic in
- 3:02Ancient Greece.
- 3:05For Socrates, the dialectic designates a
- 3:08mode of reasoning based on the principle
- 3:11of refutation.
- 3:14The dialectic is a method that allows
- 3:17one to subject the interlocutor to a
- 3:20series of contradictions, a series of
- 3:23refutations, and which allows, at the
- 3:26end of the refutation process, to reach
- 3:29a truth, to reach solid knowledge that
- 3:33has triumphed over the test of
- 3:35contradiction.
- 3:39And this is something we still use today
- 3:42, notably in the scientific method,
- 3:45where we test hypotheses and discard all
- 3:48those that prove to be false, that prove
- 3:50to be invalid, and by doing so, we
- 3:53retain what has managed to withstand the
- 3:56test of contradiction.
- 4:00We can therefore say that dialectics is
- 4:02a method that consists of reaching the
- 4:05truth through the successive elimination
- 4:07of the false.
- 4:10If I had to oversimplify, I would say
- 4:13that it is similar to reasoning by
- 4:15elimination.
- 4:16You know, in that famous game show, you
- 4:18are asked a question and you have four
- 4:20possible answers.
- 4:23And often, when you don't know the
- 4:25answer, you proceed by elimination.
- 4:28Proceeding by elimination, that is to
- 4:31say proceeding by recognizing what is
- 4:33false, that is dialectics in the
- 4:35Socratic sense: dialectics as a method
- 4:38of discussion leading to the truth by
- 4:40refuting the false.
- 4:43Except that in this video, we are going
- 4:45to talk about dialectics in Hegel.
- 4:48And for Hegel, dialectics is not limited
- 4:52to this method of reasoning or
- 4:54investigating the truth.
- 4:58Dialectics encompasses much more.
- 5:01Hegelian dialectics encompasses
- 5:02everything that exists.
- 5:05It encompasses all of reality.
- 5:08Which means that for Hegel, everything
- 5:10is dialectical.
- 5:13Both material reality and spiritual
- 5:17reality, that is to say, thought, ideas
- 5:21, and the mind.
- 5:26And if we had to briefly define
- 5:29dialectics in Hegel, we could say that
- 5:32dialectics designates the process
- 5:35whereby everything that exists always
- 5:38passes through its opposite.
- 5:42That is the key element of the
- 5:44definition of dialectics in Hegel.
- 5:47Everything that exists always passes
- 5:49through its opposite.
- 5:51So, as I know this will likely seem a
- 5:54bit abstract, I won't waste time; I'm
- 5:56going to give you an extremely concrete
- 5:59first example right away.
- 6:02We will take the example of a student
- 6:04who decides to go to business school.
- 6:08He has his diploma in hand and tells
- 6:10himself, "Well, now I can finally choose
- 6:12what I want to do."
- 6:14And so he chooses business school.
- 6:17And then the first semester goes by and
- 6:19our student starts to feel that it
- 6:21doesn't please him that much after all.
- 6:25He is bored, he feels that he is not cut
- 6:27out for it.
- 6:30But since he has been taught
- 6:32responsibility, he goes to the end of
- 6:34his year and completes it.
- 6:37And where his parents are very proud of
- 6:40him for completing his year, he finds
- 6:42himself with a form of unease, a form of
- 6:45frustration.
- 6:47Certainly, he made it through the year,
- 6:49but he took no pleasure in what he was
- 6:51doing.
- 6:52He felt no satisfaction, no sense of
- 6:54glory.
- 6:57And he even wonders if he didn't make a
- 6:59mistake.
- 7:01So, he is going to spend his summer
- 7:02thinking it over.
- 7:04And there, he will be torn between two
- 7:07contradictory desires.
- 7:10The first desire will be to quit his
- 7:12studies to do something he loves.
- 7:16The second option being to continue, to
- 7:19persevere on a path he is beginning to
- 7:22suspect won't make him happy.
- 7:26Not wanting to disappoint his parents,
- 7:28and not wanting to take reckless risks
- 7:31with his future, he decides to go back
- 7:33for a second year.
- 7:37And there, everything goes wrong because
- 7:39the more time passes, the more our
- 7:41student realizes that he isn't cut out
- 7:43for this.
- 7:45The more our student realizes that he is
- 7:47wasting his time.
- 7:50But still driven by his sense of
- 7:52responsibility, our student finishes the
- 7:55year, passes his second year, and his
- 7:57parents are very proud of him and
- 7:59everyone congratulates him on his
- 8:01success.
- 8:04Except that our student doesn't feel
- 8:05like he has succeeded.
- 8:08He still feels like he has wasted his
- 8:10time.
- 8:11And it is at that moment that he makes
- 8:12his decision.
- 8:14He decides to quit his business studies
- 8:18and pursue his passion, which is music.
- 8:23Obviously, his parents are scandalized.
- 8:27They don't understand this decision;
- 8:29they oppose it.
- 8:31But there is nothing to be done; our
- 8:33student has decided he will not go back
- 8:35to business school.
- 8:37The moral of this story is that our
- 8:40student had to go through two years of
- 8:43constraint, two years of suffering, to
- 8:47finally realize that his true calling
- 8:50lay elsewhere.
- 8:53It took two years for him to make the
- 8:55decision to change direction and live by
- 8:57his passion.
- 9:01The dialectic is the fact that our
- 9:04student had to go through that to
- 9:06realize he wasn't cut out for it, to
- 9:09realize his path wasn't there.
- 9:14So, of course, some of you will say, "
- 9:17But he knew it from the start."
- 9:20Deep down, he knew it very well.
- 9:24Yes, perhaps he did know it deep down.
- 9:28But that knowledge still had to reach
- 9:31his conscious mind.
- 9:35That knowledge still had to manifest
- 9:38itself.
- 9:40And manifest itself to such a point that
- 9:43it could no longer be denied, manifest
- 9:46with such evidence that, at that moment
- 9:48, the decision becomes inevitable.
- 9:53The dialectic is the process by which I
- 9:56experience what is not me; I experience
- 9:59contradiction.
- 10:02And everything that exists obeys this
- 10:05relentless law of dialectics.
- 10:09I will take a second example.
- 10:11I will take the example of the
- 10:13adolescent.
- 10:15What is an adolescent?
- 10:17It is an individual in transition.
- 10:20Why in transition?
- 10:22Because adolescence is a transitional
- 10:25period between childhood and adulthood.
- 10:29And what do we observe very often in
- 10:30adolescents? Not always, but frequently
- 10:34, it's a desire to no longer be treated
- 10:37like a child.
- 10:39It is a desire to be recognized as a
- 10:41full-fledged individual.
- 10:44An individual who possesses their own
- 10:47identity, tastes, and free will.
- 10:51It is obviously no coincidence that
- 10:53adolescents are the most sensitive to
- 10:56fashion because fashion gives us a sense
- 10:58of identity-based belonging.
- 11:01It is therefore a mediation toward the
- 11:03construction of individual identity.
- 11:06And notice how the adolescent is in
- 11:09opposition to traditional models, and
- 11:11particularly to the authoritarian model
- 11:13of their parents.
- 11:17The adolescent builds themselves through
- 11:19opposition to parental authority.
- 11:23This can manifest in extremely concrete
- 11:26ways, like dyeing their hair green,
- 11:28dressing outrageously, well, everything
- 11:31that adolescents know how to do to stand
- 11:34out.
- 11:37And the parent who finds themselves
- 11:39confronted with the adolescent crisis—
- 11:41and the word crisis is interesting since
- 11:43it refers precisely to the idea of
- 11:45mutation.
- 11:47A parent confronted with this, well,
- 11:50they have two options.
- 11:53The first option is to want to prevent
- 11:56this crisis, to want to contain it.
- 12:02So, for example, they will order their
- 12:05child to bleach their hair, to dress a
- 12:08bit more classically, and to please stop
- 12:12trying to be interesting.
- 12:16That is the first reaction.
- 12:19The second reaction consists of
- 12:22realizing that what defines adolescence
- 12:25is precisely opposition.
- 12:29It is opposition as a means of
- 12:31self-assertion and individual
- 12:33construction.
- 12:36Starting from there, the fact that an
- 12:38adolescent acts like an adolescent
- 12:39should not be considered a problem to be
- 12:41solved.
- 12:43The adolescent must go through this to
- 12:46build themselves and become the adult
- 12:49they are destined to be.
- 12:52One cannot oppose a stage that is
- 12:55inevitable.
- 12:57One cannot oppose something that must
- 13:00happen anyway.
- 13:02Because if they do not go through this
- 13:04stage, the adolescent will never become
- 13:07an adult.
- 13:09They need to go through this experience
- 13:11of contradiction to become who they are
- 13:13.
- 13:14They need to confront this otherness
- 13:17they refute in order to then be able to
- 13:20reconcile with it.
- 13:23This is generally why we get along much
- 13:25better with our parents when we become
- 13:27adults, that is to say, when we leave
- 13:28home.
- 13:31So the idea is that adolescence, as a
- 13:34period marked by the search for
- 13:36opposition, is absolutely essential.
- 13:41Preventing an unavoidable stage from
- 13:44happening creates more problems than it
- 13:46solves.
- 13:48And this type of opposition pattern can
- 13:52be applied to absolutely everything,
- 13:54everything involved in an evolutionary
- 13:57process.
- 13:59It works, for example, with romantic
- 14:02relationships.
- 14:05What happens in a romantic relationship
- 14:07?
- 14:09Two people meet, they like each other,
- 14:11they decide to take their relationship
- 14:14further, possibly to live together.
- 14:18And then, after a certain amount of time
- 14:20, the first annoyances will start to
- 14:22appear.
- 14:24We start to notice the other person's
- 14:27flaws, eventually seeing nothing but
- 14:30that.
- 14:31We end up being irritated by the other
- 14:34person's faults.
- 14:36And then the first arguments and
- 14:38conflicts will arrive.
- 14:41Sometimes, these conflicts will be
- 14:43resolved.
- 14:45But sometimes, these conflicts will be
- 14:47destructive.
- 14:49Leading the two people to separate and
- 14:52perhaps not want to hear from each other
- 14:54anymore.
- 14:56So we block the ex on Facebook, we
- 14:59delete their number, we avoid the places
- 15:02they frequent because, deep down, we
- 15:05still harbor a kind of resentment.
- 15:10This corresponds to the stage of
- 15:13refutation, to the stage of
- 15:15contradiction.
- 15:17We want to deny the person with whom we
- 15:19spent part of our lives.
- 15:22But it is a completely futile desire
- 15:25because this person we seek to
- 15:27symbolically eliminate from our life
- 15:29continues to exist.
- 15:32Not only do they still live outside of
- 15:35us, but they also live inside us.
- 15:40The person will have left a trace of
- 15:44their passage in us, whether through
- 15:47photos, memories, or the influence they
- 15:51had on us.
- 15:54Because, whether we like it or not, the
- 15:57relationships we have with others
- 15:59influence us and modify our personality
- 16:01.
- 16:03Spending time with someone means giving
- 16:05them the opportunity to influence us.
- 16:09So the person we seek to deny, to
- 16:11exclude, to remove from our life, we see
- 16:13it is a lost cause because they will
- 16:16remain there.
- 16:19And this is where we arrive at the third
- 16:22stage of the dialectical process, which
- 16:25consists of reconciliation.
- 16:28It is the act of telling oneself that
- 16:30this person we no longer want to hear
- 16:33about still brought us something.
- 16:36They contributed in part to making us
- 16:39who we are.
- 16:42So, wanting to deny this person would be
- 16:45like wanting to deny a part of oneself.
- 16:49Yet, wanting to deny a part of oneself
- 16:52is destructive.
- 16:54And human beings cannot live
- 16:56indefinitely in self-destruction.
- 16:59Reconciliation or forgiveness is the way
- 17:03to move beyond contradiction.
- 17:08To forgive is to consider that
- 17:11everything that happened had to happen,
- 17:14and to understand why it had to happen.
- 17:19We understand that the conflict was
- 17:21ultimately inevitable, but just because
- 17:23it was inevitable doesn't mean
- 17:25everything ends with that conflict.
- 17:30Just because the conflict had to happen
- 17:33doesn't mean we can't move past it.
- 17:37And by reconciling, even virtually, with
- 17:40the person we are in conflict with, we
- 17:43reach the third stage of dialectics: the
- 17:46stage of reconciliation, the stage of
- 17:50unification.
- 17:52Hegel uses a specific German word to
- 17:55describe this process.
- 17:57It is what he calls Aufhebung.
- 18:00And Aufhebung is a word that means three
- 18:03things at once.
- 18:05Aufhebung simultaneously means to
- 18:07abolish, to preserve, and to transcend.
- 18:12And that is the heart of dialectics.
- 18:14An abolishing, a preservation, and a
- 18:17transcendence.
- 18:19Why?
- 18:21Because when I am in conflict with
- 18:23someone or something, perhaps even
- 18:26myself, I have a desire to abolish.
- 18:28I have a desire to refute the other.
- 18:32But at the same time as I refute them, I
- 18:35preserve within me what they brought to
- 18:37me.
- 18:38I preserve within me the trace of their
- 18:41presence.
- 18:42As we just saw with the example of a
- 18:45separating couple, I cannot undo the
- 18:47experience I had with the other. I
- 18:50cannot press a reset button without the
- 18:53relationship being kept in history.
- 18:57So there is preservation.
- 18:59There is transcendence when I overcome
- 19:01the contradiction.
- 19:04When the contradiction is no longer the
- 19:07alpha and omega of the relationship, but
- 19:09simply a stage in the relationship—a
- 19:12stage I can move beyond.
- 19:17Dialectics refers to this inescapable
- 19:20pattern of a triple movement, usually
- 19:23summarized as thesis, antithesis, and
- 19:26synthesis.
- 19:29The essential point at stake in the
- 19:32dialectical notion is this idea of
- 19:34perpetual movement—a movement that
- 19:37passes through opposition, through
- 19:39contradiction, and makes contradiction
- 19:42an absolutely driving and determining
- 19:44force in all evolution.
- 19:48Now, I must make a very important
- 19:50clarification here, because if I don't,
- 19:54I risk giving you the wrong idea about
- 19:57what dialectics means to Hegel.
- 20:01I have been speaking of dialectics as a
- 20:04process that animates reality, that
- 20:07animates everything that exists.
- 20:10But what must be remembered is that
- 20:13dialectics also concerns inner life.
- 20:19Dialectics also functions for matters of
- 20:21thought, consciousness, and the spirit.
- 20:26Meaning that our ideas themselves are
- 20:29subject to this dialectical pattern and
- 20:31to this evolution, which also proceeds
- 20:34through contradiction.
- 20:37Our thoughts do not escape the
- 20:38dialectical process.
- 20:41And to illustrate this, I’m going to use
- 20:44an example I quite like, which is the
- 20:46car trip example.
- 20:49Imagine you’re invited to a party with
- 20:51friends.
- 20:52You’re driving there, and you’re not
- 20:54going alone. You have someone in the
- 20:57passenger seat.
- 20:59And this passenger tells you they know a
- 21:01faster way than the one you’re about to
- 21:04take.
- 21:06They know a route that saves time.
- 21:09At that point, you have two options.
- 21:11Either you answer, "No, no thanks, I'm
- 21:14fine.
- 21:15I know the way, I'm used to it."
- 21:17Otherwise, you have the option to try,
- 21:21to experience this alternative that is
- 21:24being suggested to you, to possibly
- 21:27compare, to possibly verify if you were
- 21:30right or wrong.
- 21:34Let's assume you choose to follow your
- 21:36own route.
- 21:39It’s very possible that you were right.
- 21:43It’s very possible that your route was
- 21:45the shortest.
- 21:49But the problem is that, having not
- 21:51experienced the other route, having not
- 21:54experienced the contradiction, well, you
- 21:56cannot be absolutely sure.
- 22:00You are living at that moment in the
- 22:03certainty of your knowledge, you are
- 22:05living at that moment in belief.
- 22:10But this belief, you haven't exposed it
- 22:12to the fire of contradiction.
- 22:14You haven't put it to the test of
- 22:17refutation.
- 22:20Which means that even if you are right
- 22:23in the facts, even if your route is
- 22:25actually shorter, you won’t have seized
- 22:27the opportunity you were offered to
- 22:30verify it.
- 22:32And so, your knowledge isn’t really
- 22:35knowledge at all.
- 22:37Now, let’s imagine the second option.
- 22:41You choose to follow your friend's
- 22:42suggestion and take their route.
- 22:46And there, you realize that in fact,
- 22:49well, instead of saving time, you’ve
- 22:52lost some.
- 22:53Does that mean, however, that you have
- 22:56wasted your time?
- 22:58Well, no. You won’t have wasted your
- 23:00time.
- 23:01You won’t have lost 5 minutes.
- 23:04You will have invested 5 minutes in
- 23:06verifying an idea.
- 23:09You will have invested 5 minutes in the
- 23:12experience of contradiction, which will
- 23:15have allowed you to improve your
- 23:17knowledge.
- 23:19Which will have allowed you to solidify
- 23:21what you knew.
- 23:23The knowledge you possess at the end of
- 23:26your trip is therefore not your initial
- 23:28knowledge.
- 23:30It is your initial knowledge augmented
- 23:33by a new piece of insight.
- 23:36So, it is no longer your initial
- 23:37knowledge.
- 23:39It is a more refined knowledge.
- 23:42It is more complete knowledge.
- 23:44And that is the idea of the dialectic.
- 23:47You should know that an experience which
- 23:50, at first glance, teaches you nothing
- 23:53or, at first glance, only confirms what
- 23:56you already knew, in reality, changes
- 23:58what you knew.
- 24:01The confirmation of knowledge changes
- 24:04the nature of that knowledge.
- 24:08And that is the reason why absolutely
- 24:11wanting to protect one's beliefs,
- 24:13wanting to shelter them from refutation
- 24:16, is the worst thing one can do.
- 24:20It is the worst thing one can do because
- 24:23at that moment, we no longer put our
- 24:24knowledge in a position to improve.
- 24:28The concept of dialectics is inseparable
- 24:31from the idea of evolution.
- 24:34Everything that exists evolves.
- 24:36Nothing is ever identical to itself.
- 24:41And it is when we understand that
- 24:43evolution is not simply a parameter of
- 24:45existence but the very engine of
- 24:48everything that exists, it is when we
- 24:50understand this idea that we understand
- 24:52that everything is dialectical.
- 24:58Imagine we teach a child mathematics.
- 25:01So, we start by teaching them to count.
- 25:04Therefore, we start at zero.
- 25:07And then, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, and so on.
- 25:11We are going to teach them whole numbers
- 25:13.
- 25:14More precisely, natural numbers, that is
- 25:16to say, positive ones.
- 25:19But when we teach this to a child, we do
- 25:22not tell them that they are learning
- 25:24natural numbers.
- 25:26We tell them that they are just learning
- 25:29numbers, period.
- 25:31So, from a totally objective point of
- 25:33view, we are lying to this child since
- 25:36we make them believe that numbers are
- 25:39summarized by, reduced to, natural
- 25:41numbers.
- 25:43Why do we do that?
- 25:45We do that because we are aware that we
- 25:48cannot ask them to retain, at their age
- 25:50, concepts as complex as natural
- 25:53integers or negative numbers.
- 25:56And we would find it pedagogically
- 25:58absurd to teach them negative numbers at
- 26:01this stage of their learning.
- 26:05They will therefore go through a first
- 26:07stage, natural numbers, to then discover
- 26:09that there are other sets of numbers.
- 26:13And it is only when they have acquired,
- 26:16when they have recorded this first stage
- 26:19, that they will be able to move on to
- 26:22the next stage and realize that what
- 26:25they had believed to be the totality of
- 26:28truth, when they notice that what they
- 26:31believed to be true was only partially
- 26:34true, at that moment, they will be able
- 26:37to move to the next stage of learning.
- 26:41And so they will learn, for example,
- 26:43negative numbers.
- 26:45They needed to go through error, that is
- 26:49to say, partiality.
- 26:51An error is never totally an error from
- 26:53the Hegelian point of view.
- 26:56An error is partial knowledge, it is
- 26:59incomplete knowledge.
- 27:02Therefore, error is not to be
- 27:04disqualified as such.
- 27:07Error must be embraced and acknowledged
- 27:09because it is the condition for the
- 27:11progress of knowledge.
- 27:15Dialectics tells us that we do not enter
- 27:18into truth immediately, with a single
- 27:21leap.
- 27:22We reach the truth at the end of a
- 27:25process that involves a series of
- 27:27contradictions to what we believed to be
- 27:30true.
- 27:32So for Hegel, it is necessary to be
- 27:34wrong.
- 27:35It is necessary to go through error.
- 27:38Because error is not the opposite of
- 27:41truth; error is a step on the path to
- 27:44truth.
- 27:46So, at this point, one might ask the
- 27:48question: why go through it at all?
- 27:51Wouldn't it be simpler to arrive
- 27:53directly at the right answer?
- 27:56Did we really need to deny the existence
- 27:59of negative numbers in order to then
- 28:02learn and use them?
- 28:06Do I need to take the wrong road to
- 28:08realize that, ultimately, the road I
- 28:10thought was the right one was indeed the
- 28:13wrong one?
- 28:15Do I really need to go through it?
- 28:17Isn't it simpler to receive the truth
- 28:21from someone who possesses it and apply
- 28:24it, accepting it as the truth?
- 28:27Wouldn't that be, fundamentally, much
- 28:29easier for everyone?
- 28:32Obviously, I think that at the same time
- 28:34as I formulate my question, you are
- 28:36deducing the answer yourself.
- 28:39It is that if I do that, it assumes far
- 28:43too many things that make me abandon my
- 28:46power of verification, my power of
- 28:49personal learning.
- 28:53And this, Hegel refutes.
- 28:56For Hegel, we must not receive knowledge
- 28:58from an external authority.
- 29:03So, what this means, from a Hegelian
- 29:05point of view, is that knowledge is
- 29:07always the fruit of an individual
- 29:09experience.
- 29:11At the level of the individual,
- 29:13knowledge proceeds from personal
- 29:15experience.
- 29:17So what do we call an experience?
- 29:19For Hegel, experience is everything we
- 29:22live through.
- 29:24Gaining practice in a field, meeting
- 29:27people, reading books—all of this is
- 29:30part of personal experience.
- 29:33Our reflections, our introspections, our
- 29:37meditations—all of this is also part of
- 29:40personal experience.
- 29:43Everything we live through is part of
- 29:46personal experience.
- 29:48And everything we live through
- 29:50contributes to the process of knowledge
- 29:52.
- 29:54When you meet someone, you will learn to
- 29:57get to know that person.
- 30:00And then, after a certain time, you will
- 30:02perhaps reach a new stage in the
- 30:04relationship.
- 30:05For example, you will discover the
- 30:07person's flaws.
- 30:09And naturally, I call "flaws" here what
- 30:12constitutes a flaw in your eyes.
- 30:14At that moment, perhaps you will
- 30:17experience disappointment.
- 30:19Disappointment, because you may have
- 30:21built up an image of that person in your
- 30:23mind.
- 30:25And when you realize that this person
- 30:28does not exactly coincide with the image
- 30:31you had of them, you will be
- 30:33disappointed.
- 30:36But ultimately, this disappointment is
- 30:37only a disappointment from your point of
- 30:39view.
- 30:41It is you who had placed expectations on
- 30:44this person that they were, so to speak
- 30:46, unable to meet.
- 30:49You will experience disappointment, and
- 30:51this experience in itself will represent
- 30:53a learning opportunity.
- 30:57It will represent an evolution of who
- 30:59you are and what you know.
- 31:03For if you pay attention to this feeling
- 31:06of disappointment, you will tell
- 31:09yourself that, after all, this person
- 31:12has the right to be who they are, and
- 31:15that perhaps you do not have the right
- 31:18to demand that this person be what you
- 31:21wanted them to be.
- 31:24This seemingly negative experience—
- 31:27negative from your perspective—is
- 31:29therefore not solely negative.
- 31:33It is not solely negative because it
- 31:35will have brought something positive.
- 31:39It will have brought you the awareness
- 31:41and understanding that a person is who
- 31:44they are, regardless of your desires.
- 31:48And for Hegel, that is decisive.
- 31:52That is what makes all the difference.
- 31:54Because a negative experience always has
- 31:57a positive flip side, and the positive
- 32:00flip side of a negative experience is
- 32:02what that experience teaches us.
- 32:07The negative experience teaches us
- 32:09something, and that is how it is
- 32:11positive in the end.
- 32:14It is not positive when you are going
- 32:16through it; it becomes positive once you
- 32:18have understood it.
- 32:21And when you have understood that it was
- 32:23necessary for you to reach that
- 32:25understanding.
- 32:28What Hegel tells us is that
- 32:30understanding does not happen
- 32:33immediately; it always happens
- 32:35indirectly, in stages.
- 32:39And the stages that lead to
- 32:41understanding are always painful because
- 32:44they contradict what we thought we knew
- 32:47, what we believed, or what we desired.
- 32:51That is dialectics, and that is the
- 32:54virtue of dialectics.
- 32:57The virtue of dialectics is that it
- 33:00allows us to understand that a negative
- 33:03experience is never entirely negative.
- 33:07It always has a positive side, and it is
- 33:09up to us to recognize this positive side
- 33:12.
- 33:13Even if, in reality, Hegel explains that
- 33:16it is not really us who chooses to
- 33:18become aware of it.
- 33:21It is rather this consciousness itself
- 33:23that imposes itself upon us.
- 33:25But that matters little.
- 33:27What matters is understanding that
- 33:29dialectics is a process that governs
- 33:31everything.
- 33:33And when I say it governs everything, I
- 33:36mean it governs both material phenomena
- 33:39and mental phenomena.
- 33:42Thoughts.
- 33:45We build our knowledge through the
- 33:47negation of our previous knowledge,
- 33:49through negation, through the refutation
- 33:51of what we believed to be true.
- 33:55For the nature of belief is that it
- 33:57always presents itself to us in the form
- 34:00of knowledge.
- 34:02No one thinks that their belief is
- 34:05irrational or absurd.
- 34:07Everyone has good reasons to believe
- 34:09what they believe.
- 34:10Therefore, knowledge is always knowledge
- 34:13from the point of view of the individual
- 34:16experiencing it.
- 34:18And it is only when this knowledge is
- 34:21contradicted by an experience or a
- 34:24series of experiences that the
- 34:26individual, thanks to their
- 34:29consciousness, will be able to reflect
- 34:32on their prior knowledge and realize
- 34:35that, in the end, it was not completely
- 34:38valid.
- 34:40It was not entirely false, but it was
- 34:43missing something.
- 34:46And that requires a great deal of
- 34:48humility: accepting that one has been
- 34:51mistaken, or accepting that one had not
- 34:54seen everything or taken everything into
- 34:57account, and that certain parameters had
- 35:00escaped us; and that we had to miss them
- 35:03in order to realize that we did not
- 35:06master them all.
- 35:10Dialectics is therefore a process that
- 35:13concerns both material and immaterial
- 35:16phenomena.
- 35:19For now, let us simply retain this idea
- 35:23, both simple yet very subtle, that
- 35:26everything that unfolds its existence in
- 35:30time goes through stages that contradict
- 35:33one another and yet form a coherent
- 35:37whole.
- 35:38When we understand this principle of
- 35:41dialectics, we become much more
- 35:43indulgent toward error, because then we
- 35:46are aware that error is always the
- 35:48condition for truth, that error is
- 35:51necessary in order to transcend it,
- 35:53provided we show enough humility to
- 35:56recognize an error when we have
- 35:58committed one.
- 36:02He who refuses to experience this
- 36:04dialectical process refuses at the same
- 36:07time to recognize this process at work
- 36:09in everything that exists.
- 36:13He who does not evolve proves that he is
- 36:15learning nothing.
- 36:18He who refuses to experience evolution
- 36:21refuses to understand that everything
- 36:23evolves.
- 36:26Now, what has the function of
- 36:29recognizing this?
- 36:31It is precisely consciousness.
- 36:35Consciousness is what we are endowed
- 36:37with that allows us both to know that
- 36:40the world exists but also to understand
- 36:43how the world evolves, how events occur
- 36:46.
- 36:48The role of consciousness is to
- 36:49recognize and identify this.
- 36:52To be conscious in the Hegelian sense
- 36:55means to be attentive to the processes,
- 36:59sometimes contradictory, sometimes
- 37:02paradoxical, that lead to an event.
- 37:06And understanding is an event.
- 37:10Understanding how the world evolves is
- 37:12giving oneself the opportunity to
- 37:14understand how consciousness itself
- 37:17evolves.
- 37:19It is understanding how our thoughts are
- 37:22built over time, how our opinions evolve
- 37:25in favor of one or another.
- 37:29And it is understanding that behind each
- 37:31of our mistakes, there is one step
- 37:33closer to the truth, one step closer to
- 37:36what Hegel calls the realm of the spirit
- 37:38.
- 37:40So, what does consciousness do?
- 37:42Consciousness experiences the world, and
- 37:46by experiencing the world, it
- 37:48experiences itself.
- 37:51It experiences the way in which it
- 37:53reacts to the world.
- 37:56It experiences the fact that it tenses
- 37:59up when faced with another thought, a
- 38:01thought that opposes it.
- 38:04It also experiences the fact that it is
- 38:07sometimes capable of accepting
- 38:09contradiction as an element of evolution
- 38:11, as an element that will help it
- 38:13progress.
- 38:15It experiences its own humility when it
- 38:19agrees to be changed by new information
- 38:22, or it experiences its own resistance
- 38:25and the fact that it does not want to
- 38:28evolve, that it wants to remain alone
- 38:31with itself.
- 38:34We often make our self-esteem dependent
- 38:36on our ideas, our values, our opinions.
- 38:41And if we realize that one of our
- 38:43beliefs can be refuted, we will rarely
- 38:46welcome that with a smile.
- 38:50We will instead tend to defend our
- 38:53opinion to the end.
- 38:55A bit like a kamikaze who would want at
- 38:57all costs to kill his enemy before dying
- 39:00himself.
- 39:02That is the reaction of the ego.
- 39:05It is the ego that identifies with this
- 39:07thought that wants to survive.
- 39:10And it is perfectly right as an ego to
- 39:12want to survive.
- 39:15Except that the more the ego seeks to
- 39:17survive, the more the truth in the
- 39:20Hegelian sense, that is to say the
- 39:22process by which we improve our
- 39:24knowledge, the more the truth is in
- 39:26peril.
- 39:28The ego and the truth do not fight for
- 39:31the same thing.
- 39:33Moreover, one could say that truth in
- 39:35itself never fights.
- 39:38Truth reveals itself, but the ego fights
- 39:40.
- 39:41And a contradicted ego is not an ego
- 39:43that questions itself.
- 39:46A contradicted ego is an ego that
- 39:48defends itself, that engages in what
- 39:50Hegel calls a life-and-death struggle.
- 39:54The life-and-death struggle is the only
- 39:58strategy the ego can adopt in case of
- 40:01refutation; it is the strategy of
- 40:04survival.
- 40:06What Hegel tells us is that
- 40:08consciousness must die at each new
- 40:11contradiction to be reborn enriched by
- 40:14this contradiction.
- 40:18Evolution is the engine of existence.
- 40:22And to evolve is to give oneself the
- 40:24possibility to reorient.
- 40:27To evolve is not to deny what one is.
- 40:32To evolve is to give oneself the
- 40:34possibility to become what one is.
- 40:38For Hegel, there is no failure in the
- 40:41sense that there is nothing to regret
- 40:43about having been in error.
- 40:47There is no need to regret having been
- 40:49in error, since error is a piece of the
- 40:52truth, and that piece of truth can only
- 40:54grow if we accept that it was only
- 40:56partial.
- 40:59It is only at the scale of the absolute
- 41:01that a truth can become a truth.
- 41:05But as far as our human experience is
- 41:07concerned, we are never in the truth.
- 41:11We are always in partial truth; we are
- 41:14always in the half-true, the half-false
- 41:17.
- 41:19And this missing part of the truth is
- 41:21only obtained when we recognize that we
- 41:23are lacking it.
- 41:26The subtitle of Hegel's Phenomenology of
- 41:29Spirit is "science of the experience of
- 41:32consciousness."
- 41:34And dialectics allows us to understand
- 41:36the principle of this experience of
- 41:38consciousness.
- 41:41An experience that moves us from one
- 41:43contradiction to another.
- 41:45The world being plural, the world being
- 41:48diverse, everything that is not us
- 41:51opposes us.
- 41:53Everything that is not us contradicts us
- 41:56.
- 41:57And I challenge you to find even a
- 42:00single person who absolutely, entirely
- 42:03shares all your thoughts, all your
- 42:06beliefs, all your desires.
- 42:10I am not taking much of a risk by
- 42:12issuing this challenge, because that
- 42:14doesn't exist, simply for the fact that
- 42:16no two individuals are strictly
- 42:18identical.
- 42:20The world is marked by diversity,
- 42:22therefore the world is marked by
- 42:25otherness.
- 42:26Which means that, potentially, every new
- 42:29experience can be an experience of
- 42:32contradiction.
- 42:34And a contradiction, in the Hegelian
- 42:36sense, is not at all negative; quite the
- 42:38contrary.
- 42:41Contradiction is experienced
- 42:43subjectively in a negative way before
- 42:45being understood as part of a global
- 42:48evolution process, and thus being
- 42:51perceived in its positive light.
- 42:55Every new experience potentially brings
- 42:58us face to face with contradiction, that
- 43:00is to say, with an opportunity to
- 43:02improve ourselves.
- 43:05If you find yourself confronted with an
- 43:08otherness that you do not oppose, that
- 43:11can happen.
- 43:13In that case, does it mean that Hegelian
- 43:15dialectics is being challenged?
- 43:18Does it mean that there are cases where
- 43:20perhaps it does not apply?
- 43:23No. It means something much simpler,
- 43:26which is that this otherness was perhaps
- 43:30not actually an otherness.
- 43:34It may have been an otherness that you
- 43:36had already experienced.
- 43:39And in that case, this otherness is no
- 43:42longer really one.
- 43:44This otherness, you have incorporated it
- 43:46into yourself.
- 43:48You have assimilated it.
- 43:50And so, you do not have the feeling of
- 43:52dealing with an opposition.
- 43:55You have the feeling of dealing with
- 43:57something that you have already
- 43:58encountered.
- 44:01That you have already accepted.
- 44:06The various consciousnesses that
- 44:08interact daily are perhaps not
- 44:10adversaries, perhaps not meant to oppose
- 44:13each other and fight to the death.
- 44:17Perhaps the various consciousnesses are
- 44:20simply here to recognize in others a
- 44:23part of the whole and thus expand their
- 44:27field of consciousness.
- 44:31In Hegel's work, dialectics lead to the
- 44:33expansion of our field of consciousness
- 44:36.
- 44:37And to expand this field of
- 44:39consciousness, it is necessary to go
- 44:41through opposition.
- 44:44I used the example of the car trip
- 44:46earlier.
- 44:49You need to experience the car trip
- 44:51yourself to know if your route is
- 44:52actually shorter or not than the one
- 44:55proposed to you.
- 44:57You sometimes need to oppose an
- 45:00authority in order to build yourself on
- 45:03an identity level.
- 45:06Having a contradictory spirit for an
- 45:09adolescent is almost a tautology.
- 45:12It is almost the very principle of what
- 45:14happens during adolescence.
- 45:17The adolescent is forced to live through
- 45:20their adolescence.
- 45:23And it is only because they will have
- 45:25lived through their adolescence that
- 45:26they can move past the adolescent stage
- 45:28.
- 45:30That they will be able to look at photos
- 45:32from their adolescence, telling
- 45:34themselves, "But that was ridiculous.
- 45:38I didn't realize.
- 45:40I'm embarrassed."
- 45:42Well, one doesn't have to be embarrassed
- 45:43.
- 45:45But one can simply smile with a
- 45:47benevolent smile toward the young being
- 45:50one once was, saying, "Well, I had to go
- 45:52through that stage.
- 45:55It's not a big deal.
- 45:57It's part of the natural order of things
- 45:59."
- 46:02And so at 25, when he says, a bit
- 46:05condescendingly, that he was quite
- 46:08foolish, that he had no taste, that he
- 46:11followed trends like a sheep, at that
- 46:14moment, this 25-year-old man will feel
- 46:17that this is it.
- 46:21This is it, he is in the truth, he is in
- 46:23knowledge, he is in understanding.
- 46:26He thinks he is definitively right.
- 46:30And what will happen 10 years later?
- 46:33Well, he will look at the photos from
- 46:35the time when he was 25.
- 46:38He will think back on his choices, his
- 46:41lifestyle, what he did, undertook, and
- 46:44failed at when he was 25.
- 46:47And there, well, here we go again.
- 46:49He will say to himself, "What was I like
- 46:51!
- 46:52How pretentious I was, what was I
- 46:53thinking!"
- 46:57And this is how this individual's
- 46:59evolution will be built over time,
- 47:02through the successive recognition of
- 47:05what he once was and the refutation of
- 47:07what he once was as a condition for
- 47:10evolution.
- 47:15Hegel clearly tells us that we can only
- 47:17truly evolve if we are convinced at
- 47:18every moment that we are in the truth.
- 47:23We need to believe we are in the truth
- 47:25for contradiction to be effective.
- 47:29Living through the different stages of
- 47:32our life means taking risks, it means
- 47:35putting ourselves in danger, it means
- 47:37accepting the evidence of contradiction
- 47:40as a beneficial test.
- 47:43It is to understand, as Nietzsche said,
- 47:46that what does not kill us makes us
- 47:48stronger and that what hurts us elevates
- 47:51us.
- 47:52Dialectics is the idea that nothing
- 47:55replaces experience and that experience
- 47:57, by definition, is made of everything
- 48:00and its opposite.
- 48:02And that it is through the opposite that
- 48:04we gain access to the whole.
- 48:07It is through contradiction that we
- 48:10constantly transcend the state we are in
- 48:13.
- 48:14It is only through the experience of the
- 48:17world and the awareness of our
- 48:20experience of the world, the
- 48:22consciousness of being conscious of our
- 48:26experience of the world, it is only at
- 48:29this price that we can fulfill ourselves
- 48:32, become complete, become what we are,
- 48:35become what we are destined to be.
- 48:40Thank you.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of HEGEL - La dialectique by Le Précepteur, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 6,045 words across 1,082 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.