YouTube2Text

HEATED DEBATE | JesusandWhatnot vs 7 Atheists | 1v7 — Transcript

by Jesus and Whatnot · 12,012 words · 1,868 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00Hello, [clears throat] Jesus. It's you
  2. 0:02in the flesh.
  3. 0:03>> No, no. It's It's just how TikTok makes
  4. 0:05my name look.
  5. 0:07But
  6. 0:08>> Really?
  7. 0:09>> Yes, but I do believe in Jesus. I
  8. 0:11believe in the triune God. So, I was I
  9. 0:14saw that your your prompt is your God is
  10. 0:16not real.
  11. 0:18I I was wondering if you would want to
  12. 0:19discuss that prompt with me a little
  13. 0:20bit.
  14. 0:22>> Yeah, sure. I mean, for you specifically
  15. 0:25um
  16. 0:26the Christian God is not real
  17. 0:29um because
  18. 0:32Uh what is a good reason? There's so
  19. 0:34many freaking reasons, isn't there?
  20. 0:36Right.
  21. 0:37>> I'll tell you what.
  22. 0:38>> Well
  23. 0:38>> We'll go with
  24. 0:40>> Well
  25. 0:40>> Go with the fact that why isn't he here
  26. 0:42right now talking for himself?
  27. 0:44>> Yeah, well well actually, I think a a
  28. 0:46better way to approach this is is and
  29. 0:49this is out of fairness to you. I don't
  30. 0:50even think it's necessarily your burden
  31. 0:52to prove that my God doesn't exist. I
  32. 0:54think I think actually the burden would
  33. 0:56be on me to prove that my God does
  34. 0:58exist. Um
  35. 1:00And so, I I I think I can I can do that.
  36. 1:02Are you are you familiar with like
  37. 1:05Thomistic thought?
  38. 1:07>> We're not going to do that. We're not
  39. 1:08going to do philosophy.
  40. 1:10>> You're not going to do philosophy? Well,
  41. 1:11but but God is a philosophical topic.
  42. 1:14>> Jesus and whatnot. Listen, I don't like
  43. 1:17you.
  44. 1:17>> Well
  45. 1:18>> Okay?
  46. 1:18>> Well, I I
  47. 1:18>> I'm willing to
  48. 1:20Shh. Be quiet. I'm speaking.
  49. 1:21>> Okay.
  50. 1:22>> I'm willing to Be quiet. I'm willing to
  51. 1:24let you be up here.
  52. 1:25But you're not going to do philosophy.
  53. 1:28And if that makes Do you think that
  54. 1:30makes me dumb? That's totally fine. But
  55. 1:32we're not going to do philosophy. So, if
  56. 1:34you would like to talk about um the
  57. 1:36Bible or morals We could talk about
  58. 1:39morals kind of um
  59. 1:41but we're not going to We're not going
  60. 1:43to do philosophy. Okay?
  61. 1:45>> Yeah, well well respectfully
  62. 1:47morality is a philosophical topic. So,
  63. 1:50it seems strange that you would not want
  64. 1:51to talk about philosophy, but then be
  65. 1:53willing to talk about morals.
  66. 1:55>> John, listen. You know you listen.
  67. 1:58>> I'm just confused.
  68. 1:59>> it. I I grant you that. You Do you want
  69. 2:02to talk about the Bible?
  70. 2:05>> Well, but the prompt is that God doesn't
  71. 2:07exist and I feel like I'd be able to
  72. 2:08provide.
  73. 2:09>> about the Bible?
  74. 2:11>> Well, I want to talk about the prompt
  75. 2:12that you put put up there. And the Bible
  76. 2:15>> about the Bible, you illiterate
  77. 2:17misogynistic
  78. 2:18>> Uh, yes.
  79. 2:19>> What What
  80. 2:20>> Do you want to talk about Oh, you know
  81. 2:21what? Chris is here. Chris would be
  82. 2:23happy to engage with you.
  83. 2:24>> [ __ ] long time. Holy [ __ ]
  84. 2:27>> Hold on. Before you start cuz I'm going
  85. 2:29to
  86. 2:30I got to go in a second.
  87. 2:32Are you going to come to my live
  88. 2:34tonight, Jesus and whatnot? Because I
  89. 2:36feel like everybody keeps coming into my
  90. 2:38live telling me that I should debate
  91. 2:41you, but then
  92. 2:44you never come in.
  93. 2:45>> Well, well, first of all, I I've never
  94. 2:46>> your cronies to my live. So
  95. 2:49>> So So So first of all, I've never heard
  96. 2:50of you. I don't know who you are. But
  97. 2:51also, we're We have an opportunity to
  98. 2:53debate right now, but then you said that
  99. 2:54you aren't willing to discuss
  100. 2:55philosophy, which is the topic of this
  101. 2:58book.
  102. 2:58>> that there are two different women on
  103. 2:59panels and different voices?
  104. 3:02>> Yeah, I I I There's a lot of people
  105. 3:04talking at once. I'm not exactly sure
  106. 3:05who's who. Who Who is Who's the person
  107. 3:08that wants me to talk to them?
  108. 3:10>> Okay. So, your middle school army still
  109. 3:13keeps coming to my live My live,
  110. 3:14Christina the Godless.
  111. 3:15>> Okay, I don't know you.
  112. 3:17>> telling me that you are saying that you
  113. 3:20want to
  114. 3:21talk to me, but then you never come in.
  115. 3:24So, I don't know. Is it because you
  116. 3:25don't like talking to women? Is that
  117. 3:27what it is?
  118. 3:27>> Well, as as as scary as it is to talk to
  119. 3:31a woman,
  120. 3:32um, I've actually never heard of you.
  121. 3:34>> I dress like a nun?
  122. 3:36>> I I I don't know I don't know I don't
  123. 3:38know who you are, respectfully. I've
  124. 3:39never heard of you.
  125. 3:41>> will send you and I will send you
  126. 3:42Actually, I won't cuz I'm not following
  127. 3:44you. But she will send you a um a
  128. 3:46personalized engraved message whenever
  129. 3:50she goes live tonight, right, Christina?
  130. 3:53>> Well, I I again
  131. 3:54>> That would mean I'd have to [ __ ]
  132. 3:55follow him.
  133. 3:56>> I just want to have a conversation about
  134. 3:58the prompt. I'd be willing to talk to
  135. 4:00the host. I'd be willing to talk to you,
  136. 4:01Christina.
  137. 4:02>> about
  138. 4:04[ __ ]
  139. 4:05>> [ __ ]
  140. 4:06>> don't want to talk
  141. 4:07>> talk about I just want to talk about the
  142. 4:08prompt. It's the one that you put up
  143. 4:10there.
  144. 4:10>> Oh, I just want to talk about the prompt
  145. 4:12in all my fill-girl pussy-drying jargon.
  146. 4:15>> No, it's it's it's it's not jargon.
  147. 4:18>> going live, hold on, Joel. What time are
  148. 4:20you going live tonight, Christina?
  149. 4:21>> Well, I don't know who Christina is.
  150. 4:23>> I know Well, we've said her name three
  151. 4:25times. Do you know what time you're
  152. 4:26going live?
  153. 4:28I'm sure you're used to not coming, not
  154. 4:30making people come. It's it's totally
  155. 4:31fine. All right, I got to go back to
  156. 4:33work.
  157. 4:34>> Well, that was that was that was
  158. 4:35>> Chris Chris would Chris would Chris
  159. 4:37would love to talk to you.
  160. 4:38>> I I I'm I'm I'm willing to talk to
  161. 4:40anyone on the panel.
  162. 4:43>> Fine. Perfect. And I appreciate your
  163. 4:45hearing good faith and have a
  164. 4:47conversation. You find philosophy a
  165. 4:51a a convincing road to Christianity, but
  166. 4:54we can double into that and we'll and
  167. 4:56we'll figure it out. Um Chris loves
  168. 4:59philosophy. I'm I love I like philosophy
  169. 5:02as well. It's it's great for
  170. 5:04um critical thinking and I think it's
  171. 5:07great. I don't
  172. 5:09you know, I think it's it's a great way
  173. 5:11to to network around the reality that we
  174. 5:14live in and and I I enjoy it. But
  175. 5:18I don't find it a convincing way for me
  176. 5:20to determine whether a god actually
  177. 5:23exists in reality, but we can get into
  178. 5:25that. So you you can engage and we'll
  179. 5:29see where we go.
  180. 5:30>> Yeah, so I'm glad that seems like a much
  181. 5:32more modest approach. Like you recognize
  182. 5:34that that philosophy is
  183. 5:37um helpful, certainly. It's interesting,
  184. 5:39but maybe you're not fully convinced by
  185. 5:41it.
  186. 5:41Um I I appreciate that that more
  187. 5:43ecumenical and and modest approach to
  188. 5:45that. Thank you for that. Um
  189. 5:47What what I would say is that yes, uh I
  190. 5:50can see where maybe certain
  191. 5:52philosophical topics are unconvincing,
  192. 5:55but I would say that's more so that that
  193. 5:56would be on that would be a fault on the
  194. 5:59the part of the philosopher for not
  195. 6:02accurately explaining and and bringing
  196. 6:04you towards whatever conclusion there
  197. 6:06is. So, it's like, for example, I could
  198. 6:07say like water exists, and that's
  199. 6:09technically a philosophical claim, and
  200. 6:11you would find it convincing based off
  201. 6:13of whatever philosophical description or
  202. 6:15proof that I gave. And you know, like
  203. 6:17you can even appeal to like a
  204. 6:18materialistic worldview, but that would
  205. 6:20still be some sort of some sort sort of
  206. 6:22philosophy. And so, I think that like
  207. 6:24we we we can actually make really
  208. 6:26convincing arguments for God's existence
  209. 6:28using philosophy.
  210. 6:30Um and if it if they aren't convincing
  211. 6:32to a person, it would actually be the
  212. 6:34fault of the philosopher if if if
  213. 6:36everybody's operating in good faith. So,
  214. 6:39um maybe you just haven't had someone
  215. 6:40explain it to you in in the best way,
  216. 6:42and hopefully that's something that I
  217. 6:43can I can do today.
  218. 6:46>> Yeah, sure, but just a
  219. 6:48just a quick one. When when somebody
  220. 6:49says water exists,
  221. 6:51this is also an empirical claim that can
  222. 6:53be demonstrated.
  223. 6:55We can observe it, we can measure it, we
  224. 6:57can
  225. 6:58uh we can look at its properties. Um
  226. 7:02we can dissect it, we can see it's
  227. 7:04ubiquitous,
  228. 7:06uh etc.
  229. 7:08Uh so, the point is these are things
  230. 7:09that we can investigate in reality.
  231. 7:11>> 100% and and that's why I kind of
  232. 7:13brought up like materialism and
  233. 7:15empiricism, but those are still going to
  234. 7:17be like like there's the question, and
  235. 7:19not to become like a presuppositionalist
  236. 7:21on you, that's not the stance that I
  237. 7:22take, but there's still the question of
  238. 7:23like, well, why should we trust the
  239. 7:25empirical data over the opposite of the
  240. 7:27empirical data? Um why should we trust
  241. 7:29what is repeatable over what is not? How
  242. 7:31do we know that material things are real
  243. 7:33and they're not just completely
  244. 7:34illusory? And so, those are still
  245. 7:36philosophical topics. And so, my my
  246. 7:37point wasn't that you can only
  247. 7:39>> on, real quick. Uh
  248. 7:40>> Well, I was say Okay, but I was
  249. 7:42>> say it's all illusory. Yeah, look,
  250. 7:49Okay, I was just in the middle of a
  251. 7:50sentence. I feel like it would be just
  252. 7:51good faith to to let me speak.
  253. 7:54Hey man, well
  254. 8:12Did you not? Yeah, I was saying that
  255. 8:14that that's a stance that some Well,
  256. 8:15hold on Chris Chris Chris, hold on man.
  257. 8:18Chris, no you got to let me talk. If
  258. 8:20we're going to if we're going to have a
  259. 8:20conversation, you got to let me talk,
  260. 8:22man.
  261. 8:23No, this is bad faith. I I
  262. 8:40Yeah, so so Father Reginald
  263. 8:41Garrigou-Lagrange, he talks about this
  264. 8:43in reality that that even if you you
  265. 8:44take like the the the Cartesian like
  266. 8:47cogito, you can actually still come to
  267. 8:49the conclusion based off of like the
  268. 8:51first principles of Thomism.
  269. 8:55Well, no, I can explain them.
  270. 8:59What what do you even mean by the goal,
  271. 9:00like
  272. 9:03Chris, you got to let me talk, man. It
  273. 9:04seems like you're you're just wanting to
  274. 9:06like have some slam dunk on me, but I'm
  275. 9:07interested in a conversation.
  276. 9:14illusionary
  277. 9:17No.
  278. 9:21Um yeah, so so I'm not sure what you
  279. 9:23mean by goal, but I would just like to
  280. 9:25request that we can have a real
  281. 9:26conversation. I'm I'm interested in like
  282. 9:28actually talking. Yeah, and I'm I'm I'm
  283. 9:31I'm I'm leading you to a position to
  284. 9:34show you that in each world, regardless
  285. 9:37if it's illusionary or solipsism or this
  286. 9:42materialistic world, the goal by every
  287. 9:45being is survival.
  288. 9:49>> Yeah, yes. So I I don't even know what
  289. 9:51the point is that you're trying to make.
  290. 9:52I don't think
  291. 9:53>> Am I wrong?
  292. 9:53>> I I
  293. 9:54>> I I'm showing you the point.
  294. 9:56>> I'm showing you that the same the same
  295. 9:59starting point, the axiom that which
  296. 10:01you're going to base your morality from,
  297. 10:04and the the goal at which all biological
  298. 10:07life is heading towards is survival. So
  299. 10:10both of those scenarios would hold true,
  300. 10:13even if this is an illusion.
  301. 10:15It would still be based in what?
  302. 10:18>> Yeah, so so I'm not making a a a
  303. 10:20moral claim or an ethical claim. I'm
  304. 10:22making a claim
  305. 10:24>> a moral claim or an ethical claim. I
  306. 10:26don't see how you're not tracking this,
  307. 10:27Jaw. Listen to what I'm saying.
  308. 10:30>> Yeah, I'm I'm trying to respond to what
  309. 10:31you're saying.
  310. 10:32>> I'm asking you a question. I'm asking
  311. 10:34you
  312. 10:34>> I'm trying to respond to it, but you're
  313. 10:36saying a lot of things, so I have to
  314. 10:37respond to all of them.
  315. 10:38>> to my question, Jaw.
  316. 10:39>> But you're asking a lot of questions, so
  317. 10:40I'm trying to respond to all of them.
  318. 10:42>> This is This is the question I want
  319. 10:43answered, right?
  320. 10:44>> Okay, but I need to respond to all the
  321. 10:45other things that you said, too, cuz
  322. 10:46that's how a conversation works.
  323. 10:48>> Okay.
  324. 10:50Is the goal
  325. 10:51>> Can I respond to those, though?
  326. 10:52>> an illusion
  327. 10:54and in the materialistic world, would
  328. 10:56the goal still be survival?
  329. 11:00>> Yeah, I I don't think the ultimate goal
  330. 11:02of anything is is survival. I don't I
  331. 11:03don't have a teleology that leads to
  332. 11:05like an end of survival. My teleology
  333. 11:08rests in in God. I'd say he's the
  334. 11:09ultimate goal in the sense that you're
  335. 11:11using it.
  336. 11:12>> He's the ultimate goal?
  337. 11:13>> Yeah, so so
  338. 11:14the the proper ordering of all things.
  339. 11:17>> So wait a second, Jaw. Do you not do
  340. 11:20things to further your survival?
  341. 11:24>> Yeah, no. So I'm not saying that you
  342. 11:25can't have means in which you reach the
  343. 11:27greater end, and you can have, you know,
  344. 11:29subordinate means and ends underneath
  345. 11:32that greater umbrella of your final end.
  346. 11:34But I like I'm not saying I'm not trying
  347. 11:36to survive, but that doesn't mean that
  348. 11:37it's my final goal or my final ordering.
  349. 11:40>> Okay, okay, so what is
  350. 11:42your final goal then, Joel?
  351. 11:43>> Chris, could you just take a deep breath
  352. 11:45and have a conversation with me? I I it
  353. 11:46seems like I'm like you're
  354. 11:47>> What is your final goal?
  355. 11:49>> It just seems like it is What I already
  356. 11:51told you that. I just said that like 5
  357. 11:53seconds ago.
  358. 11:55>> Your final goal is God?
  359. 11:57>> Yeah, it it would be a a perfection of
  360. 11:59nature and communion with God through
  361. 12:01the beatific vision.
  362. 12:03And I can
  363. 12:03>> Okay, so
  364. 12:04>> explain that to you, but you have to let
  365. 12:06me actually talk, okay?
  366. 12:08>> Well, it seems like you do. Do you know
  367. 12:09what Do you Do you know what the
  368. 12:11Thomistic doctrine is on the beatific
  369. 12:13vision? Cuz you don't understand it.
  370. 12:15>> yeah, y'all are based off of
  371. 12:17the what the five arguments of Sir
  372. 12:19Thomas Aquinas, which are [ __ ]
  373. 12:21atrocious.
  374. 12:22>> No, no, I'm asking if you if you know
  375. 12:24>> purus, right?
  376. 12:25>> I That is That is something I believe
  377. 12:27in, but I'm asking if you know the
  378. 12:28doctrine of the beatific vision under
  379. 12:30St. Thomas's theology, [clears throat]
  380. 12:31because that
  381. 12:32>> The beatific vision under St. Thomas's
  382. 12:36You mean his little doctrines and little
  383. 12:37like [ __ ] that he wrote?
  384. 12:39>> Yeah, so it seems like you don't even
  385. 12:40understand Thomism, so it seems like you
  386. 12:42do need a an explanation. All right,
  387. 12:44let's just have a conversation with me.
  388. 12:46No, you obviously don't. You obviously
  389. 12:48don't. And it's okay. I just want to
  390. 12:50have a conversation with you.
  391. 12:52>> Okay, it's okay. It's okay, Joel.
  392. 12:55Look, if you say
  393. 12:58that your ultimate goal is God,
  394. 13:02then the only way you can get to God is
  395. 13:05through what? Unalivment?
  396. 13:08>> Um the only way No, I I wouldn't say the
  397. 13:10only way that you can get to God is
  398. 13:12through unalivment. Well,
  399. 13:13>> Okay, can you get Can you get to God on
  400. 13:16this earth
  401. 13:17>> Yeah.
  402. 13:17>> the way that you want to achieve it in
  403. 13:20heaven without unalivment?
  404. 13:23>> Um so it depends on what you mean by the
  405. 13:24way that you want to achieve it. So do
  406. 13:26you Do you want Do you know like Well,
  407. 13:27hold on. Hold on. Chris, you got you got
  408. 13:29to let me Dude, you got to let me
  409. 13:30respond to these questions. No, I'm
  410. 13:32trying to answer it. You're just not
  411. 13:33letting me.
  412. 13:35Hey host host, I think I think maybe you
  413. 13:36could you could step in and maybe let me
  414. 13:38answer a question here.
  415. 13:39>> He he's not going to step in because you
  416. 13:41aren't being disingenuous. You're being
  417. 13:43disingenuous. You know exactly what I'm
  418. 13:46asking you, and I asked you I said to
  419. 13:49achieve the state of heaven that you
  420. 13:52want, which is to be the closest you can
  421. 13:55to God.
  422. 13:56>> Yeah, so
  423. 13:57>> Is to be in heaven, right? In his
  424. 13:59presence. That's what you That's what
  425. 14:00you want. Is there any other way to
  426. 14:03achieve that other than unaliving?
  427. 14:06>> Yeah, so host, could could you maybe
  428. 14:09do do me a favor here and actually, you
  429. 14:11know, maybe set up some rule where I
  430. 14:13actually get a chance to respond.
  431. 14:15Cuz no, cuz there's some there's some
  432. 14:16very very complicated questions.
  433. 14:18>> Let's [snorts] Okay, fine. Let's let him
  434. 14:20respond now. I think go for it.
  435. 14:22>> Yeah. Thank you so much. So,
  436. 14:24the the first thing to note is that that
  437. 14:26Catholics believe in in
  438. 14:27transubstantiation. Are you are you
  439. 14:29aware of that doctrine?
  440. 14:33Chris?
  441. 14:38>> I'm letting you talk.
  442. 14:39>> He's not going to respond to you until
  443. 14:41>> I'm not going to respond
  444. 14:42>> Okay, that's fine.
  445. 14:43>> if you won't answer any of my questions.
  446. 14:45Go the [ __ ] ahead.
  447. 14:46>> Okay, yeah. So, so transubstantiation is
  448. 14:48the the doctrine that
  449. 14:50through the Eucharist Christ is truly
  450. 14:51and substantially present. Um
  451. 14:54And so, what what what Wait, but I I
  452. 14:56>> I just want to make sure I just want to
  453. 14:58make sure is this answering Chris's
  454. 15:00question?
  455. 15:01>> Yes, cuz he asked about how we can
  456. 15:02encounter God and be close to God and
  457. 15:04and I'm telling him
  458. 15:07that No, and he said he was asking if it
  459. 15:09was only through unaliving, and I'm
  460. 15:10telling him the different ways that we
  461. 15:11can be
  462. 15:12>> What I said I said the Okay, so is is
  463. 15:15your relationship with
  464. 15:17God the same as it is um, heaven? Like
  465. 15:21are y'all the same?
  466. 15:23>> Yeah, so it it it at my current stage of
  467. 15:25like purification, like based off of
  468. 15:27like Hebrews 12, no. It is not, uh, the
  469. 15:30same as it will be, but you
  470. 15:32>> saying. So, saying and trying to prove
  471. 15:35your point otherwise would be
  472. 15:37disingenuous.
  473. 15:39>> No.
  474. 15:39>> That's why I'm not answering your
  475. 15:40questions cuz you're not a genuine
  476. 15:42interlocutor.
  477. 15:43>> You're No, you're you're confusing
  478. 15:45you're No, you're you're confused.
  479. 15:46>> I'm going to ask you
  480. 15:48>> haven't gotten to respond, and I was
  481. 15:49told I would be able to respond.
  482. 15:51>> Because you're going off on a tangent of
  483. 15:54nothing.
  484. 15:54>> trying to explain to you our actual
  485. 15:57You're just not You're just not It
  486. 15:59doesn't have to be snappy. We're just
  487. 16:00having a conversation.
  488. 16:01>> yes or no questions.
  489. 16:02>> Yeah, so so you're I'll I'll I'll
  490. 16:04I'll be more I'll be more direct so that
  491. 16:06that maybe you can be satisfied to that
  492. 16:08extent. Um, we would say no, death is
  493. 16:11not the only way that that one can, um,
  494. 16:14receive that closeness. For example, the
  495. 16:15Blessed Virgin Mary, um, was bodily
  496. 16:18assumed into heaven, um, before she ever
  497. 16:20died. So, she was not unalived, um, and
  498. 16:22she had that closeness, and she's now
  499. 16:23crowned queen of heaven.
  500. 16:25Um, and so there there was not that
  501. 16:27death. And so again, I wouldn't say
  502. 16:28that, like, uh,
  503. 16:30what what you're positing on the
  504. 16:31Thomistic position is true.
  505. 16:44We also talk about like Moses and
  506. 16:45Elijah.
  507. 16:45>> your if if your position is saying that
  508. 16:50you can be as close to God as you are in
  509. 16:53heaven, you would be going against your
  510. 16:56own doctrine.
  511. 16:58>> What?
  512. 17:00>> Yeah, you just said it. Hebrews 12
  513. 17:03says that you will be in heaven, and
  514. 17:05you're not the same as you are here. You
  515. 17:07will
  516. 17:07>> What? What? Have you read Hebrews 12?
  517. 17:10>> Uh, I'm not I'm not talking about that.
  518. 17:12I'm talking about what you said.
  519. 17:13>> No, you are. You said You said Hebrews
  520. 17:1412. You haven't read it, obviously.
  521. 17:17>> You said that what I'm referring to you.
  522. 17:20I'm using your logic, Joel.
  523. 17:21>> No. No.
  524. 17:24Just actually listen.
  525. 17:26>> Is that not the Bible verse that you
  526. 17:28brought up to say yes, you
  527. 17:30>> I I I mentioned Hebrews 12. I'll tell
  528. 17:33you. I'll tell you why. So, I brought up
  529. 17:35Hebrews 12 because it talks about
  530. 17:37purification. I was making a statement
  531. 17:38about my my personal purification
  532. 17:40process. I could also mention 1
  533. 17:42Corinthians 3.
  534. 17:43>> pure, right? You're not as pure as you
  535. 17:46are here as you will be in heaven.
  536. 17:48Therefore, your relationship
  537. 17:50>> that's not how you used it just now.
  538. 17:53I
  539. 17:53>> I wasn't quoting the Bible. I was
  540. 17:55quoting what you were saying, Joel.
  541. 17:58>> You You would You would have a much
  542. 17:59happier life if you just talked to
  543. 18:01people like they were humans. There
  544. 18:02There There's no need to be all all
  545. 18:04angry like this. Seriously, man.
  546. 18:06>> What the [ __ ] man? Okay, for one, don't
  547. 18:09tell me to
  548. 18:09>> a deep breath. Seriously, man. I'm just
  549. 18:11trying to have a conversation, but
  550. 18:12you're getting all angry.
  551. 18:14>> You won't answer my questions,
  552. 18:16>> I've actually answered all of them when
  553. 18:17I've been given a chance to answer them.
  554. 18:19Yeah, I have.
  555. 18:20>> You said You said yes, Chris, and then
  556. 18:22you tried to dodge around it. You said
  557. 18:24that the relationship wouldn't be the
  558. 18:26same, and then you were like, "Well,
  559. 18:28Mary was on on in heaven and on her body
  560. 18:32>> and Elijah and Christ himself. Yeah,
  561. 18:34they were bodily assumed.
  562. 18:35>> Moses and Elijah, Joel? Are you Are you
  563. 18:38Are you putting yourself in the same
  564. 18:40like spectrum as those [ __ ] people?
  565. 18:42>> Yeah, so you asked about like a general
  566. 18:44rule, and so I'm telling you that there
  567. 18:46Yes, there is a general rule that
  568. 18:47typically people die before they go to
  569. 18:49heaven, but it's not always the case
  570. 18:51because there are exceptions to the
  571. 18:52general rule. So, I was showing you that
  572. 18:54the the doctrine of the axiom that you
  573. 18:56were trying to apply to my system
  574. 18:58doesn't apply universally to every
  575. 18:59single individual in the system.
  576. 19:01>> Do you think that you'll be one of those
  577. 19:03exceptions, Joel, or do you think you'll
  578. 19:05be like everybody else?
  579. 19:07>> Um I I don't make predictions about my
  580. 19:08salvation.
  581. 19:10>> I don't make predictions. So, you're Are
  582. 19:11you saying that it's possible?
  583. 19:14>> Uh yeah, that would be awesome. But, uh
  584. 19:15it's it's all up to God's will.
  585. 19:17>> thinks he's a prophet. This is the most
  586. 19:19arrogant thing I've ever seen.
  587. 19:21>> Is it? Cuz cuz I was I was actually like
  588. 19:23I I would tell you it's it's uh
  589. 19:25>> That's [ __ ] wild.
  590. 19:26>> It's it's a it's a low. No, I didn't say
  591. 19:28that cuz that's not even what the word
  592. 19:30prophet means. That's not even what the
  593. 19:31word prophet means.
  594. 19:32>> John, I got a I got a I got a question
  595. 19:34for you.
  596. 19:34>> Well, can I ask you some questions
  597. 19:36maybe?
  598. 19:36>> Can you derive Can you derive morality
  599. 19:40>> from anything else but God?
  600. 19:42>> Um no, I Well, I mean it depends on what
  601. 19:44you mean by derive morality.
  602. 19:47>> [laughter]
  603. 19:47>> Chris, what I mean, why is this funny?
  604. 19:51>> Because you're a funny you're funny,
  605. 19:52John.
  606. 19:53>> Yeah, could you just let me speak
  607. 19:54though?
  608. 19:55>> anything from but God?
  609. 19:58>> Anything from but God?
  610. 20:01>> Sorry. That what what Sorry, he he just
  611. 20:03questioned what do you mean by derive?
  612. 20:05So,
  613. 20:06uh we're we're on to semantics right
  614. 20:08now. So,
  615. 20:09>> Yeah.
  616. 20:10>> Do you Do we want to go into what derive
  617. 20:12means or do you understand what he's
  618. 20:15saying? Are you Are we going to agree?
  619. 20:17>> Yeah, so so
  620. 20:18>> morality from anything else but a God?
  621. 20:20>> Yeah, so there's there's two um
  622. 20:23ways that that question could be aimed.
  623. 20:25And I'll I'll answer both of them
  624. 20:26briefly. Um What what we would say is
  625. 20:29that there are ways that somebody who
  626. 20:31doesn't believe in God can come to a
  627. 20:33true understanding of morality. So,
  628. 20:36I I would say everybody on this live
  629. 20:37stream
  630. 20:38has a natural inclination towards what
  631. 20:40we would label as natural law, the way
  632. 20:42that things are naturally ordered. Um
  633. 20:45So, like we would say like a good knife
  634. 20:47is a knife that can cut well. A good eye
  635. 20:49is a an eye that can see well. Um and
  636. 20:52then we would say, following from that,
  637. 20:54a good human is a human that does well
  638. 20:57what is distinctly human, namely
  639. 20:58rationality. Um and so we would say like
  640. 21:01like this overarching uh kind of axiom
  641. 21:04is that um a morally good thing is that
  642. 21:06which is in accordance with right
  643. 21:08reason. And so, I would say that that
  644. 21:10everybody here, like even Aristotle, he
  645. 21:12didn't he didn't believe in God in the
  646. 21:13same way that we do. He had like a
  647. 21:16somewhat of a conception of of God's
  648. 21:17existence.
  649. 21:19Um but but there there were
  650. 21:20hints towards natural law before
  651. 21:22Aristotle. Like you see this in in
  652. 21:24Plato, even a little bit in Zeno. Um
  653. 21:26Socrates, he he mentions, you know,
  654. 21:28teleology and all this stuff. And so, I
  655. 21:30believe that you can like understand
  656. 21:33morality, and you can even ground it in
  657. 21:35natural law through this naturalistic
  658. 21:36sense. But if you're asking about like
  659. 21:38the meta view of how do we ground
  660. 21:42morality? Like why is natural law the
  661. 21:45specific way that it is? Well, then we
  662. 21:47would say that that's grounded in the
  663. 21:49nature of God who is ordered towards
  664. 21:51perfection. And so, we would say that
  665. 21:53the the creation that we we dwell in
  666. 21:56um is ordered towards specific
  667. 21:58perfections
  668. 22:00um because it was created by a being who
  669. 22:04is ordered towards all perfection. And
  670. 22:07and [snorts] so, that that's kind of
  671. 22:07like there's two different ways that
  672. 22:08that could be said, but I would say
  673. 22:09everybody on this live stream can still
  674. 22:11ground their reality in natural law.
  675. 22:13There's no problem with that.
  676. 22:15>> Right, but those are two different
  677. 22:16metaphysical categories.
  678. 22:17>> Hold on, Michael, hold on. Stop.
  679. 22:20All right. So, here's you you actually
  680. 22:23brought up a really good point, Jaw. You
  681. 22:26said a good knife cuts.
  682. 22:29Right?
  683. 22:30What is a What is like a a good What
  684. 22:33does a good lung do? Does a good lung
  685. 22:35breathe?
  686. 22:37>> Uh yeah, a a good lung provides oxygen
  687. 22:39to the brain, to the rest of the body.
  688. 22:42>> Love it. What What would a good brain's
  689. 22:45function look like?
  690. 22:47>> Yeah, it would be a brain that uh
  691. 22:49properly does what is distinct to the
  692. 22:51brain. So, it would be, you know, like
  693. 22:53uh locomotive motion throughout the
  694. 22:54body, you know, um cerebral processes.
  695. 22:58Yeah, I would say all those are
  696. 22:59>> ultimate function would be to keep the
  697. 23:02meat suits alive?
  698. 23:05>> The No, I would say that's the job of of
  699. 23:07the the form of a rational being. I'd
  700. 23:10say that's that's the soul animating the
  701. 23:11body.
  702. 23:13>> Okay, so you believe in a soul?
  703. 23:16>> Yeah, you believe in souls, too.
  704. 23:18In the way that I'm using it. In the way
  705. 23:19that I'm using it, you do.
  706. 23:21>> I I
  707. 23:21I don't.
  708. 23:22>> Do you know Do you know how I define
  709. 23:23soul? Cuz I can give you the definition.
  710. 23:25>> Probably the same way you would like
  711. 23:26define a mind.
  712. 23:27>> No, let let's let him define soul. Go
  713. 23:29ahead.
  714. 23:29>> Yeah, it's so it's not the same as
  715. 23:32your average Christian, I guess.
  716. 23:34>> Yeah, let's hear it. Let's hear it.
  717. 23:35>> Yeah, so so again, I'm a Thomist, which
  718. 23:37means that I I derive my theology from
  719. 23:39St. Thomas Aquinas, who who derived a
  720. 23:40lot of his natural understanding of the
  721. 23:42world from Aristotle and Plato.
  722. 23:44Um and so the way that Aristotle in De
  723. 23:47Anima, uh you can read this I think it's
  724. 23:49chapter seven, possibly. Um he talks
  725. 23:51about a soul is not the same as like
  726. 23:53what a lot of people they think like
  727. 23:55spirit if somebody says soul, but that's
  728. 23:57that's not really what we we talk about.
  729. 23:58We're bipartite. Um and so we we would
  730. 24:00say that the soul is just the form that
  731. 24:03animates a living thing. So we would
  732. 24:06actually say that trees have souls,
  733. 24:08animals have souls, humans have souls um
  734. 24:10because it's a living thing that is
  735. 24:12being animated by its form.
  736. 24:15Um and so like a tree obviously doesn't
  737. 24:17think, it doesn't have a spirit or
  738. 24:18anything like that. It It doesn't have
  739. 24:20like have awareness of its surroundings,
  740. 24:22but it's still alive. It's being
  741. 24:24animated by what we would call a
  742. 24:25vegetative soul. And then there's going
  743. 24:27to be like animals, they would have a
  744. 24:29lower level form than humans, but a
  745. 24:31higher level soul than the vegetative
  746. 24:32souls. It's called a sensible soul,
  747. 24:34where they're aware of their
  748. 24:36surroundings. And then the highest level
  749. 24:38is personal beings. We have rational
  750. 24:40souls that are um you know, like
  751. 24:42animating our whole body. But the the
  752. 24:44higher level forms um assume the powers
  753. 24:47of the lower level form. So we have the
  754. 24:49powers of the vegetative, the of the
  755. 24:50sensible, and the rational. And so we're
  756. 24:52like this higher level form. So so we
  757. 24:54would say yes, souls exist, and souls
  758. 24:57are what distinguish a non-living thing
  759. 24:59from a living thing. Ed- Edward Feser
  760. 25:01has a great book on this.
  761. 25:05>> Uh can I ask a question?
  762. 25:07>> Yeah, but that okay, I I that doesn't
  763. 25:09like
  764. 25:10>> I I still don't know what a soul is,
  765. 25:12I'll be honest.
  766. 25:12>> Yeah, like like like that that doesn't
  767. 25:14prove anything. That's like some JJ K
  768. 25:17[ __ ] okay, is what you just told me.
  769. 25:18You said that I can like an animated
  770. 25:21soul inhabits the body of like
  771. 25:23biological things, and things have
  772. 25:25different processing amounts. It and
  773. 25:28that that literally sounds like some
  774. 25:29anime [ __ ] That's okay.
  775. 25:31>> No, I I don't think it is.
  776. 25:32>> The primary function, that's fine. The
  777. 25:34primary function of the brain,
  778. 25:36biologically, is to keep you alive.
  779. 25:41That's what the brain does.
  780. 25:42>> Yeah, I
  781. 25:43>> [laughter]
  782. 25:43[cough]
  783. 25:44>> So, real quick, hold on, stop, real
  784. 25:45quick.
  785. 25:46>> I thought that's a
  786. 25:46>> Real quick.
  787. 25:47>> interesting thing to say there, um but
  788. 25:49but sure.
  789. 25:50>> I- o- okay, is is that wrong?
  790. 25:53>> Yeah, I I would say that that survival
  791. 25:55would more so be a a consequence of the
  792. 25:58other primary functions uh of the brain.
  793. 26:01>> like what?
  794. 26:01>> You're still yet to define a form, by
  795. 26:03the way. You're still yet to define a
  796. 26:04form.
  797. 26:04>> yeah, so
  798. 26:05>> Yeah, I I I'm willing to do that.
  799. 26:07>> What
  800. 26:08Yeah, so
  801. 26:09>> You're still yet to define a primary
  802. 26:10function.
  803. 26:11>> is to keep you alive. That's what it
  804. 26:14does. It allows natural processes to
  805. 26:16occur in the body through uh electrons
  806. 26:20and all this [ __ ] that fire and make
  807. 26:21your [ __ ] work, okay? It makes your
  808. 26:23lungs work. It makes your heart pump.
  809. 26:25All that stuff. Right? It makes you feel
  810. 26:27pain and pleasure and that stuff. All of
  811. 26:30that. So, if you're saying function,
  812. 26:32right, and you said the function of a
  813. 26:34knife, a good functioning brain would be
  814. 26:38these two things, Joel.
  815. 26:40Survival of self,
  816. 26:41survival of others.
  817. 26:43The survival of others comes from
  818. 26:45because we know that living in packs
  819. 26:47helps you survive. It would be
  820. 26:50disadvantageous for you not to live in
  821. 26:51packs.
  822. 26:52>> Yeah.
  823. 26:53>> The bad functioning brain, Jaw, would be
  824. 26:55one that doesn't care about survival of
  825. 26:57self or doesn't care about the survival
  826. 27:00of others. Those two can have be coupled
  827. 27:03in into one though. That's why we have
  828. 27:04like sociopaths and [ __ ] Now Jaw, let
  829. 27:07me ask you a quick question, buddy.
  830. 27:08>> Well, you've been
  831. 27:09you've been making a lot of points. I
  832. 27:11feel like I should be able to respond.
  833. 27:12You you can't just scream the whole
  834. 27:14time. We're supposed to have a
  835. 27:15conversation, man.
  836. 27:16>> Did you
  837. 27:16Jaw, did you
  838. 27:20pick your brain?
  839. 27:23>> What does this have to do with the topic
  840. 27:24that cuz you you you just made a bunch
  841. 27:26of points. It's it seems like you're
  842. 27:27you're Gish galloping a little bit. Do
  843. 27:29you know what Gish galloping means?
  844. 27:31>> Okay, fine. Fine.
  845. 27:33>> We can let him answer your
  846. 27:35Do you want to Do you want to
  847. 27:37um
  848. 27:38address what Chris was saying before the
  849. 27:39other question?
  850. 27:40>> Yeah. Yeah, of course.
  851. 27:42>> He will
  852. 27:42The other question is not going to go
  853. 27:44away. He will ask you about the picking
  854. 27:45of your brain.
  855. 27:46>> But yeah, fine. Fine. Address the other
  856. 27:48stuff and then
  857. 27:49>> I'm sorry. Can I do a mod thing before
  858. 27:51y'all continue? Um chat, if you do all
  859. 27:55caps, you will be muted. All caps is
  860. 27:57only for mods in case we need to get Z's
  861. 28:01attention. Okay? Thank you.
  862. 28:03>> And by the way, one more thing. After
  863. 28:05[clears throat] you ask your question,
  864. 28:06can I talk with Jaw?
  865. 28:07>> Yeah, you can.
  866. 28:09I just wanted to
  867. 28:10>> Well, we'll we'll see we'll see how how
  868. 28:11much longer I can take this. It's it's
  869. 28:13it's a pretty tiring. But but I would
  870. 28:15love to talk to you. You seem
  871. 28:17>> Hopefully I'll be able to offer you a
  872. 28:18better conversation.
  873. 28:19>> Yes, I I believe you will. It seems like
  874. 28:21you know what you're talking about a
  875. 28:22little bit more than Chris does.
  876. 28:24Um so, it it seems like Chris, the the
  877. 28:27first thing that kind of happened is is
  878. 28:29Chris was upset about my definition of a
  879. 28:31soul. And I'd like to to add some
  880. 28:33clarification. So so what I said is that
  881. 28:35it's the form
  882. 28:36>> metabolism.
  883. 28:37>> I'm sorry. I need I'm sorry. I need to
  884. 28:38interrupt one more time. If y'all
  885. 28:40continue to use all caps, I will turn
  886. 28:42off chat.
  887. 28:43>> Oh, no.
  888. 28:44>> So if y'all would like to do that, keep
  889. 28:46going.
  890. 28:47>> Wow.
  891. 28:48Um okay, so so
  892. 28:51I what I
  893. 28:52I don't know who there's another person
  894. 28:53here named Tiny. I I would appreciate if
  895. 28:55if we could go all one at a time. I
  896. 28:57don't know why I'm defining metabolism
  897. 28:59now.
  898. 28:59>> You're all in timeout now.
  899. 29:01>> No, no, no. What what you were
  900. 29:02describing was metabolism. You weren't
  901. 29:05describing a soul.
  902. 29:06>> Yeah, no. I again, I I told you that I'm
  903. 29:08using the Aristotelian definition. So so
  904. 29:11like the the semantic meaning of
  905. 29:12different words needs to be clarified so
  906. 29:14that we can all have the same
  907. 29:15conversation. That's what I was doing.
  908. 29:17>> I don't grant Aristotelian semantics.
  909. 29:19>> See cuz now now I'm having a
  910. 29:20conversation with with five people at
  911. 29:22the same time and I'm I'm trying to
  912. 29:23still answer Chris's objection.
  913. 29:25>> talked to you at all right now, so don't
  914. 29:27try to say
  915. 29:29that I'm talking to
  916. 29:29>> you're talking to me right now. You're
  917. 29:31doing it right now.
  918. 29:33>> Because because you made because you
  919. 29:35made a claim that's not true.
  920. 29:36>> Yeah. Well, I made a claim that's not
  921. 29:38true cuz you you have been arguing. I'm
  922. 29:40just trying to I'm just trying to answer
  923. 29:41all the people on the panel.
  924. 29:43>> I'm just trying to answer all the people
  925. 29:44on the panel.
  926. 29:45>> I know. You're so you're so you're so
  927. 29:47good faith. I'm not talking to you and Z
  928. 29:50is not talking to you.
  929. 29:51>> Okay.
  930. 29:51>> So go ahead. And by the way, if you want
  931. 29:53to tell your little minions to not use
  932. 29:55all caps, I would appreciate it.
  933. 29:57>> Yeah, um
  934. 29:58>> would you do that?
  935. 29:59>> Would
  936. 30:00I I mean I don't I don't know what what
  937. 30:02you're you're wanting me to say don't
  938. 30:03use all caps?
  939. 30:05>> Yes, could you please tell your friends
  940. 30:07in chat or your followers to not use all
  941. 30:10caps?
  942. 30:12>> Um
  943. 30:14>> Are you willing to do that?
  944. 30:15>> Like words don't make sense to you. The
  945. 30:17[ __ ]
  946. 30:18>> Chris
  947. 30:19com- respect the people
  948. 30:21>> Yeah, sure. I I can say it. Sounds like
  949. 30:22you already said it, but yeah guys, I
  950. 30:24would have I'm just I'm I'm doing it
  951. 30:25right now. I'm doing it right now.
  952. 30:27>> to say it.
  953. 30:28>> Yeah, uh sure sure guys, please please
  954. 30:29don't use all caps. Uh be respectful of
  955. 30:31the the TikTok live that you're on. Um
  956. 30:34we are guests here and and we should act
  957. 30:36as such. Um
  958. 30:37so yeah, just just stop using all caps.
  959. 30:39Listen listen to the the people who are,
  960. 30:41you know, owning the account here. Just
  961. 30:43be respectful.
  962. 30:44>> Thank you.
  963. 30:45>> Of course. Um yeah, so sorry. I I might
  964. 30:48have I might miss a few points that
  965. 30:50Chris made here. Um and I'll do I'll do
  966. 30:52my best to to answer all of them to the
  967. 30:54best of my uh memory. The first thing is
  968. 30:56that Chris seemed to be confused about
  969. 30:57my definition of a soul.
  970. 30:59Um and again, like I like I clarified, I
  971. 31:01use Aristotelian understanding of of
  972. 31:03what a soul is.
  973. 31:04Um so the the soul is going to be the
  974. 31:07form of a living body. And it seemed
  975. 31:09like somebody was wanting me to define
  976. 31:10what a what a form is. A form is going
  977. 31:13to be act relative to matter, at least
  978. 31:15in the sense relative to what we're
  979. 31:17using right now. You know, we could also
  980. 31:18talk about forms that are immaterial.
  981. 31:20But but I think at least for now we can
  982. 31:22talk about material forms. Um and so
  983. 31:24like I think I think it'd be helpful to
  984. 31:27um
  985. 31:27>> I'm so sorry, John. Um I you know, I I'm
  986. 31:31>> So
  987. 31:32>> I your people aren't listening to you,
  988. 31:34either.
  989. 31:35>> Okay, and that's that's okay.
  990. 31:37>> That's why That's why I keep
  991. 31:38interrupting.
  992. 31:39>> Yeah.
  993. 31:40>> Cuz these people are in Please don't
  994. 31:41interrupt me.
  995. 31:42>> Oh [laughter] okay. Well, that seems a
  996. 31:43little hypocritical. I was just in the
  997. 31:45middle of of
  998. 31:46>> I know, I'm a big hypocrite.
  999. 31:47>> Yeah, it's not That's not very nice.
  1000. 31:49>> are in Okay, I'm going to mute you cuz
  1001. 31:50you don't have self-control.
  1002. 31:51>> muted.
  1003. 31:52>> So I So I'm just letting you know
  1004. 31:55that the people that are following you
  1005. 31:58are ignoring and disrespecting these
  1006. 32:01rules for the live. Me I know Whatever
  1007. 32:03they say about me or any any other mod,
  1008. 32:06those are the rules for in here.
  1009. 32:08And they don't care about that, and they
  1010. 32:09don't care that you said not to do that.
  1011. 32:12I just want to make that clear. Please
  1012. 32:13continue.
  1013. 32:15>> Yeah, well, I'm not their dad. They can
  1014. 32:17they can do what they want, but I would
  1015. 32:18urge them not to do uh
  1016. 32:19all caps anymore. But again, I don't
  1017. 32:21really think that's that's much of my
  1018. 32:22responsibility. I've told them not to do
  1019. 32:24it, and they can they can be
  1020. 32:25disrespectful if they please, but um I
  1021. 32:27would I would hope that they wouldn't.
  1022. 32:28Um So again, like I was clarifying with
  1023. 32:31uh
  1024. 32:32forms earlier, um it it's to be act
  1025. 32:35relative to matter, at least in the the
  1026. 32:37relevant sense that we're we're talking
  1027. 32:39about. And so,
  1028. 32:40you can kind of use an analogy that will
  1029. 32:42help you imagine you're you're carving a
  1030. 32:43statue out of marble. The marble is
  1031. 32:46going to be the matter,
  1032. 32:49okay? And then the statue, the shape of
  1033. 32:52the statue, you could say, is going to
  1034. 32:54be the form, right? Uh maybe it's
  1035. 32:56Michelangelo that you're carving into
  1036. 32:57this uh uh statue. It is like a a
  1037. 33:00tribute to him or something like that.
  1038. 33:02Or maybe you're carving Mary or uh St.
  1039. 33:04Augustine or St. Thomas. You're making a
  1040. 33:05statue, whatever you want it to be. Um
  1041. 33:08and so, that is going to be how a form
  1042. 33:11actualizes given matter. And there's
  1043. 33:13also different levels of form. So, um
  1044. 33:16like like we we we we believe in what's
  1045. 33:17called um prime matter, which would be
  1046. 33:19pure potency. It's It's It's matter
  1047. 33:21without a form. It doesn't exist on its
  1048. 33:22own. It needs an actualization to exist.
  1049. 33:25And so, the marble would actually be,
  1050. 33:27you know, some sort of substantial form
  1051. 33:29that actualizes this. Um and that word I
  1052. 33:31just used, substantial form, um needs to
  1053. 33:33be clarified with a distinction between
  1054. 33:35accidental forms. So, a substantial
  1055. 33:37form, um and Edward Feser, again, he
  1056. 33:39does a great job kind of explaining all
  1057. 33:40this stuff. He has a a a really good
  1058. 33:42lecture on what is matter. Um I would
  1059. 33:44highly suggest that you watch it if this
  1060. 33:46is a little bit uh confusing to you. Um
  1061. 33:48but but the difference between like a
  1062. 33:50substantial form and an accidental form,
  1063. 33:52you can imagine like a pile of rocks.
  1064. 33:53Like each rock is going to have its own
  1065. 33:55substantial form because it's a
  1066. 33:56different substance that is not just the
  1067. 33:59sum of its individual parts, right? Um
  1068. 34:02but then if you if you stack a bunch of
  1069. 34:04rocks on top of each other, then you
  1070. 34:06have a pile of rocks. And that would be
  1071. 34:07an accidental form.
  1072. 34:09Because the form is just going to be
  1073. 34:11comprised of the parts that make it up.
  1074. 34:13So, that's the difference between, you
  1075. 34:14know, different forms. What we would say
  1076. 34:16that a soul is, it is a substantial form
  1077. 34:19of a living thing. So, a frog has a
  1078. 34:23substantial form of frogness, which
  1079. 34:26would be a soul, because it's of a
  1080. 34:28living thing. So, soul is more so So a
  1081. 34:30category of form. We don't believe that
  1082. 34:32it's like a spirit or that it's like,
  1083. 34:34you know, some ability to think or be,
  1084. 34:36you know, connected to any other soul or
  1085. 34:39anything like that. It's really just the
  1086. 34:41form that actualizes some some living
  1087. 34:44body.
  1088. 34:48>> So again, it seems to be the case that
  1089. 34:51you're equivocating between a metabolism
  1090. 34:54and a soul. You're saying that there's
  1091. 34:55some sort of extra soul feature to what
  1092. 34:59the body is, but you're just describing
  1093. 35:01an animated force of metabolism and the
  1094. 35:04ability for caloric energy exchange,
  1095. 35:06which doesn't really seem to be like
  1096. 35:08some sort of extra ontological force
  1097. 35:11that's happening there. It seems to be
  1098. 35:12like when you mentioned the statue, the
  1099. 35:15statue doesn't change forms just because
  1100. 35:17it changes shapes. It's still the same
  1101. 35:20form. It's still the marble statue, but
  1102. 35:23it it's it changes its shape, which is
  1103. 35:27an equivocation on form again. This this
  1104. 35:29is outdated metaphysics.
  1105. 35:32>> Yeah, uh so so respectfully, I don't
  1106. 35:34think you understand uh what what
  1107. 35:36equivocation or form means.
  1108. 35:38Well, I'm
  1109. 35:39I'm going to I'm going to I'm going to
  1110. 35:40I'm going to I'm going
  1111. 35:42Yeah, I'll I'll I'll Well, you you can't
  1112. 35:43really It doesn't make much sense to say
  1113. 35:45I don't accept your definition because
  1114. 35:46it's it's the definition that I was
  1115. 35:48using when somebody asked me how I'm
  1116. 35:50using the word form. But I'll I'll I'll
  1117. 35:51explain it for you. I can I can
  1118. 35:57with metabolism. No, no. So so again,
  1119. 36:00but you're you're mis- [clears throat]
  1120. 36:01you're misunderstanding
  1121. 36:02No, so so equivocating would be me using
  1122. 36:05form across multiple different
  1123. 36:07definitions as if it were the same uh
  1124. 36:09meaning. Uh what what you're referring
  1125. 36:11to is not equivocation, but I'll explain
  1126. 36:14to you um what you're wondering about
  1127. 36:16with with these different forms. And you
  1128. 36:18actually can prove um you know, the
  1129. 36:20immateriality of the intellect I think
  1130. 36:22is a really good argument. I don't know
  1131. 36:23if you ever read like James Ross or Saul
  1132. 36:25Kripke.
  1133. 36:26Um Ross, James Ross, he takes this
  1134. 36:28really cool hypothetical that Saul
  1135. 36:30Kripke
  1136. 36:32has and then he goes on to
  1137. 36:34you know kind of prove the immateriality
  1138. 36:36of the intellect. Again, Edward Feser
  1139. 36:38has a great lecture on this. Um but but
  1140. 36:40in sum the argument is going to be that
  1141. 36:43it's premise one
  1142. 36:45thought processes are exact and
  1143. 36:49unambiguous
  1144. 36:51in a way that no matter can be. Um
  1145. 36:54And then the the the conclusion I guess
  1146. 36:57it's really only one premise um is that
  1147. 36:59therefore the
  1148. 37:01>> I'm sorry, stop. Your definition [ __ ] is
  1149. 37:03getting way the [ __ ] off my off my
  1150. 37:05>> Yeah, cuz I'm talking to three people at
  1151. 37:06once.
  1152. 37:07>> No, I don't I don't care. I want you to
  1153. 37:08answer again. It's super simple. John,
  1154. 37:11did you pick your brain?
  1155. 37:12>> Did I Did I Did I pick my brain?
  1156. 37:15>> Yeah, was there a character select
  1157. 37:17screen when you designed your little
  1158. 37:19avatar? Okay, you didn't? Okay, why
  1159. 37:21weren't you born with a brain that
  1160. 37:23doesn't value the survival of self and
  1161. 37:26doesn't value the survival of others?
  1162. 37:28What What's the metric you can say that
  1163. 37:31allows you to have this brain?
  1164. 37:33>> All right, like well, I'd say on like
  1165. 37:35approximate level it would it would be
  1166. 37:37more so like the the generation
  1167. 37:40from like my parents that that you know
  1168. 37:42kind of determined this
  1169. 37:43>> Did you pick your parents? Did you pick
  1170. 37:45your Did you pick
  1171. 37:46>> But but [clears throat] on a
  1172. 37:47No, I did not I did not pick my parents.
  1173. 37:49>> you pick your place of birth?
  1174. 37:51>> I I agree with you that that there's no
  1175. 37:53pre-selection. I I deny that this whole
  1176. 37:55pre-exists though.
  1177. 37:57the body
  1178. 37:58>> Okay, all right, wonderful.
  1179. 37:59>> I believe it's humanity.
  1180. 38:00>> No, you have no reason
  1181. 38:04prior to your existence that you were
  1182. 38:07born with the brain that allowed you to
  1183. 38:09believe in Christianity, born into a
  1184. 38:11household which I'm assuming was
  1185. 38:13Christian.
  1186. 38:14>> Um no, not really. It was It was more
  1187. 38:16more of a secular family, you know, and
  1188. 38:19then they were
  1189. 38:20>> Secular? Did you grow up in the United
  1190. 38:22States?
  1191. 38:23>> I I did grow up in in the United States,
  1192. 38:25but but you need to let me answer the
  1193. 38:26question
  1194. 38:27that you just asked.
  1195. 38:29I we there were there were short areas
  1196. 38:32of time where maybe we would go to
  1197. 38:33church on like Easter or Christmas, but
  1198. 38:35they were non-denominational and and
  1199. 38:37Catholics have like an entirely
  1200. 38:39different belief system really than
  1201. 38:40non-denominational churches.
  1202. 38:41>> Yeah, sure. Sure. That's still That's
  1203. 38:43still That's still That's still That's
  1204. 38:44still That's still Christianity.
  1205. 38:47>> I would I would say I would say
  1206. 38:48non-denominationalism is bordering on
  1207. 38:50non-Christianity actually. So.
  1208. 38:53I would I would have to contest that.
  1209. 38:55>> non-denominational people aren't
  1210. 38:57Christians?
  1211. 38:58>> I would say a lot of non-denominational
  1212. 39:00churches are not Christian churches,
  1213. 39:01yeah.
  1214. 39:02>> They're not Christian churches. Okay.
  1215. 39:05That's a weird position to take.
  1216. 39:06>> I said a lot of them. I didn't make a
  1217. 39:08universal binding rule to all
  1218. 39:10non-denominational Christians.
  1219. 39:11>> Yeah, but like are you going to go to
  1220. 39:13the churches and select which one? Are
  1221. 39:15you the judge of this? Are you the one
  1222. 39:17that's going to be like yeah, they're
  1223. 39:18Christian?
  1224. 39:18>> the magisterium of the
  1225. 39:20I would never I would
  1226. 39:22I I would never go to a
  1227. 39:24non-denominational church. That would be
  1228. 39:26an act of of heresy or schism.
  1229. 39:28>> But But didn't you Didn't you used to go
  1230. 39:30to a non-denominational church?
  1231. 39:32>> Yeah, because I wasn't Catholic yet.
  1232. 39:34That's the whole point.
  1233. 39:35>> of Was that an act of heresy that you
  1234. 39:37were doing back then?
  1235. 39:38>> No, because there's no culpability cuz I
  1236. 39:40wasn't Catholic. I don't understand.
  1237. 39:42Don't Don't Hey, Chris Chris Chris, you
  1238. 39:44don't understand the interdenominational
  1239. 39:46intricacies here. I wouldn't recommend
  1240. 39:50Well, no, but we have There's a whole
  1241. 39:51bunch of things that I need to respond
  1242. 39:52to now because you brought up like a
  1243. 39:53million things.
  1244. 39:54>> We're going to ask this. We're going to
  1245. 39:55ask this and then I'll and then I'll
  1246. 39:57shut up and you can respond to all my
  1247. 39:58questions.
  1248. 39:59>> Well, no, it should be one question at a
  1249. 40:00time. This is like definitionally Gish
  1250. 40:02galloping. That's what you're doing
  1251. 40:03right now.
  1252. 40:03>> No, no, no, listen, listen. You
  1253. 40:05answer them. These are yes or no
  1254. 40:07questions. You answer them without your
  1255. 40:09long ass explanation.
  1256. 40:10>> No, that's [laughter] not how
  1257. 40:11conversations work. You can't You can't
  1258. 40:13limit me to only binary answers.
  1259. 40:17>> Sure, you can.
  1260. 40:17>> No, you can't. That's That's not right,
  1261. 40:19dude. You
  1262. 40:20You don't understand what you're talking
  1263. 40:22about.
  1264. 40:22>> Why? Because it makes your position look
  1265. 40:24dumb? All right, I'm going to ask you a
  1266. 40:26quick question. There's two people born.
  1267. 40:29One is born in Southeast Texas where the
  1268. 40:31likelihood [laughter]
  1269. 40:32of being Christian is 84%.
  1270. 40:34The other one is born in Iran. Which one
  1271. 40:38has the better percentage of being
  1272. 40:40Christian, Jaw?
  1273. 40:41>> Yeah, probably the person in Texas. I
  1274. 40:43would agree with you. Can I respond? Can
  1275. 40:44I
  1276. 40:45>> The quiet. The quiet.
  1277. 40:48Fester on that, boy.
  1278. 40:50>> What?
  1279. 40:50>> I think you got them muted. I don't
  1280. 40:51think they
  1281. 40:51>> Oh, yeah. Your Your moderator muted me,
  1282. 40:53so I wasn't able to respond.
  1283. 40:55>> Go ahead. Jaw, there's two people. One's
  1284. 40:58born in Southeast Texas and the other
  1285. 40:59one's born in Iran. Which one has the
  1286. 41:00better chance of being Christian? Yeah,
  1287. 41:01the other one's born in one has the
  1288. 41:02better chance of being Christian,
  1289. 41:03>> Yeah, so there's a lot of things to
  1290. 41:05address here cuz you brought up multiple
  1291. 41:06points. Um I'll I'll I'll I'll I'll
  1292. 41:09What Why is that funny?
  1293. 41:10>> that, too, Jaw. I would say that, too,
  1294. 41:13too, Jaw.
  1295. 41:13>> I'm con- I'm confused. Why Why did Why
  1296. 41:16did Why did What exactly did you
  1297. 41:18>> Just answer the question. It's super
  1298. 41:19simple.
  1299. 41:20>> I would just like to know what's What's
  1300. 41:21so funny.
  1301. 41:22>> Iran. It's either Texas or Iran.
  1302. 41:25>> Yeah, so So, from a purely So, from a
  1303. 41:28purely statistical standpoint, I would
  1304. 41:30say it's more likely
  1305. 41:32um that maybe someone in Texas becomes
  1306. 41:35Christian. But I don't believe that
  1307. 41:37being Christian is going to be the only
  1308. 41:40qualifier for salvation. I believe it's
  1309. 41:41only Catholic Christians um who will end
  1310. 41:44up being saved because that's the
  1311. 41:45doctrine of the Catholic Church.
  1312. 41:47>> crazy because like there's the
  1313. 41:48likelihood of being Catholic down here
  1314. 41:50is like 73%. Choose Catholicism uh
  1315. 41:53>> Yeah,
  1316. 41:54>> community down here. The rest is like
  1317. 41:55non-denominational and Protestant.
  1318. 41:57They're huge down here. So, if you want
  1319. 41:59to do that, they have a 73% chance of
  1320. 42:02being Catholic here in Southeast Texas.
  1321. 42:06Um and then what like uh like a 0.5% in
  1322. 42:09Iran. Which one do you think is going to
  1323. 42:11have the better chance of being
  1324. 42:12Catholic, Jahl?
  1325. 42:14>> Yes, but probably the people in Texas.
  1326. 42:15I'm not disagreeing with you. But again,
  1327. 42:17I don't believe that simply being
  1328. 42:19nominally Catholic Chris Chris, you got
  1329. 42:21to let me respond, man. This is so bad
  1330. 42:22faith.
  1331. 42:23>> Well, no, because this No, it's not bad
  1332. 42:25faith.
  1333. 42:25>> It is bad faith. I think everybody
  1334. 42:27agrees that it's bad faith. I'm pretty I
  1335. 42:29I don't think
  1336. 42:29>> I don't I don't care what your little
  1337. 42:30cronies believe.
  1338. 42:32>> talking I'm talking about the people on
  1339. 42:33the panel.
  1340. 42:34>> I'm showing you that your religion is
  1341. 42:38based heavily off geography. And you
  1342. 42:41can't recant the statement that you
  1343. 42:42already said. You already said you
  1344. 42:44didn't pick your place of birth. And now
  1345. 42:46my next question to you, Jahl, is what
  1346. 42:49allowed you to be born? What did you do
  1347. 42:54prior your to your existence
  1348. 42:57to have that ability? Is where is the
  1349. 43:00person and Iran did nothing.
  1350. 43:03>> Yeah.
  1351. 43:04>> Same as you.
  1352. 43:04>> So, there's there's a few things to say.
  1353. 43:06Um First of all, we would say that there
  1354. 43:09is um lesser education in a place like
  1355. 43:13Iran versus in America. We we're we're
  1356. 43:16we're very
  1357. 43:16>> Hey, are you are you applying are you
  1358. 43:17going to call him dumb?
  1359. 43:18>> No. No, I'm saying that they have uh
  1360. 43:21less access to to education in Iran. Or
  1361. 43:23you could choose, you know, any any
  1362. 43:25third world country. You could say like
  1363. 43:26Kenya or something. There's lot less ac-
  1364. 43:28access to
  1365. 43:29um
  1366. 43:30like uh good education. And that's very
  1367. 43:33there's very problematic.
  1368. 43:34>> Because of Islam. But but Jahl, Islam
  1369. 43:36exists in Iran and it's prominent. It's
  1370. 43:39huge.
  1371. 43:39>> Yes. I would
  1372. 43:40>> It could have been Christianity.
  1373. 43:42>> I agree.
  1374. 43:42>> And that's also why and that's also why
  1375. 43:44education is terrible, especially for
  1376. 43:45women there cuz of the growth of Islam.
  1377. 43:47>> True. True.
  1378. 43:48>> You're off track. Let Chris keep going.
  1379. 43:49>> Wait. Wait. What? Chris Chris What?
  1380. 43:51Chris keep going. Why is Chris going to
  1381. 43:52keep going? I'm just trying to answer
  1382. 43:54>> Can I Can I He's trying to have a
  1383. 43:55conversation with you.
  1384. 43:56>> No, but I'm trying to answer his
  1385. 43:58questions. I'm just trying to
  1386. 43:59>> He's asking you yes or no questions,
  1387. 44:01Jahl.
  1388. 44:02>> Let you out and let him [ __ ] answer.
  1389. 44:05>> Yeah, sorry about that.
  1390. 44:06>> Yeah, so
  1391. 44:07So, what I would say is like there's
  1392. 44:08there's lesser education in those areas.
  1393. 44:10So like maybe, you know, there's a
  1394. 44:12smaller likelihood that someone in Kenya
  1395. 44:14knows about the the quadratic formula or
  1396. 44:17something like that.
  1397. 44:18Um and so we would say under your view
  1398. 44:21that the quadratic formula, the truth of
  1399. 44:23the quadratic formula, is based off of
  1400. 44:25your geography. But that's that's
  1401. 44:27obviously not true. Truth claims, just
  1402. 44:29because they are believed more in
  1403. 44:31certain areas or understood more in
  1404. 44:33certain areas, uh it doesn't take away
  1405. 44:35from the validity of the truth claim. Um
  1406. 44:38and so just because there is some
  1407. 44:39geographical difference, which we would
  1408. 44:41expect on on even a micro scale, no
  1409. 44:43matter what, like even if everybody had
  1410. 44:45an equal understanding and equal access
  1411. 44:47to the gospel, then we would still
  1412. 44:48expect like within cities like different
  1413. 44:50neighborhoods would choose to believe it
  1414. 44:52more based off of their their inner
  1415. 44:54cultures. And so again, just just
  1416. 44:56because there's a difference in
  1417. 44:57geography isn't going to take away from
  1418. 45:01the the validity of the claim. And so
  1419. 45:02what we're we're talking about here is
  1420. 45:04is your God real, which is a truth
  1421. 45:07claim. So Chris, Chris, you're
  1422. 45:08interrupting again.
  1423. 45:11>> What? You didn't answer my question.
  1424. 45:12>> I very directly answered your question.
  1425. 45:15>> No, you didn't. No, you didn't. All you
  1426. 45:16did was say that people will believe
  1427. 45:19things based off their geography,
  1428. 45:21furthering my point. Listen to what I am
  1429. 45:23saying, Joel, okay? So
  1430. 45:25if you didn't pick your existence, you
  1431. 45:28didn't pick your place of birth, the
  1432. 45:30same argument would apply to the people
  1433. 45:32with the knowledge, right? That's the
  1434. 45:34same argument would apply. And that's
  1435. 45:37what I'm trying to get you to
  1436. 45:38understand, Joel. What did you do prior
  1437. 45:42to your existence to have it? And I'm
  1438. 45:46Look, I'm accepting that Christianity is
  1439. 45:49the truth, that it's a real thing, that
  1440. 45:51Jesus rose from the dead, and all of
  1441. 45:53that [ __ ] Listen, stop. Stop, Joel.
  1442. 45:56Okay? The island of Christianity is the
  1443. 45:59truth. But me and you, for whatever
  1444. 46:02reason, we were put on speedboats,
  1445. 46:05yachts, and jet skis. But the people
  1446. 46:07born in Iran still have the ability to
  1447. 46:10get there, but their journey is just far
  1448. 46:13harder.
  1449. 46:15It has They have weights on their ankles
  1450. 46:17and [ __ ] bloody meat attached to
  1451. 46:19them. And they're walking through
  1452. 46:20treacherous oceans on the bottom without
  1453. 46:23any scuba gear. It is practically
  1454. 46:25impossible. And I am asking you, Jahl,
  1455. 46:28and I want you to answer me honestly.
  1456. 46:31What did you do prior to your existence
  1457. 46:34to have it to where your walk, or ride
  1458. 46:37in the water, if you will, for using the
  1459. 46:39same analogy, was so easy and theirs is
  1460. 46:43so hard?
  1461. 46:44>> So, you're asking me what did I do prior
  1462. 46:46to my existence? Do you think that's a
  1463. 46:48logical question to ask? What did I do
  1464. 46:50prior to existence?
  1465. 46:51>> right. So, so I'm going to show you that
  1466. 46:53>> Chris, does that make sense?
  1467. 46:54>> Yes, it does. It makes a lot of sense.
  1468. 46:56>> what somebody did before they existed?
  1469. 46:59>> Yeah, yeah. So,
  1470. 47:00>> How can you do something before you
  1471. 47:01exist?
  1472. 47:02>> Exactly. That's what I'm trying to show
  1473. 47:04you. You did nothing to deserve that.
  1474. 47:06>> just say that, then?
  1475. 47:07>> You did nothing
  1476. 47:08You did nothing Okay, perfect.
  1477. 47:10>> think I Hold on, Chris. Chris, let me
  1478. 47:12let me answer your your question here.
  1479. 47:14>> Jahl, I'm going to say this and then you
  1480. 47:15can
  1481. 47:16talk.
  1482. 47:16>> just yelling over and over again.
  1483. 47:17>> I'm going to say this and then you can
  1484. 47:18talk.
  1485. 47:19>> No, no, but you've been saying things
  1486. 47:20the whole time.
  1487. 47:22>> What you were worshipping
  1488. 47:23>> Chris. Chris, I I
  1489. 47:25I need
  1490. 47:25>> sounds a lot like
  1491. 47:27>> like God luck or a casino. Because if
  1492. 47:30your base If you don't have a metric to
  1493. 47:32base it off of, you did nothing prior to
  1494. 47:34your existence. This is essentially like
  1495. 47:37you winning the birth theology
  1496. 47:39>> Yeah.
  1497. 47:39>> that allowed you to become this way,
  1498. 47:41Jahl. And if you can't tell me any
  1499. 47:43otherwise, then God luck is the best
  1500. 47:46best answer. Can you give me another
  1501. 47:48answer better than God luck?
  1502. 47:50>> to. Yeah, so there's there's two schools
  1503. 47:52of thought in in the the Catholic
  1504. 47:54Church.
  1505. 47:55>> Another answer better than God luck.
  1506. 47:56That's all I'm asking.
  1507. 47:57>> Yes, yes, there's two schools of thought
  1508. 47:59um within the the the Catholic uh oh I I
  1509. 48:02got
  1510. 48:03>> All right, you have to unmute yourself.
  1511. 48:04>> Yeah, I got I got muted again,
  1512. 48:05apologies. Um yeah, so there's two
  1513. 48:08schools of thought with within the
  1514. 48:09Catholic Church. One is the Thomistic
  1515. 48:11school and the other is the Molinistic
  1516. 48:13school. Um both both of these uh
  1517. 48:15attempted to actually answer the
  1518. 48:17question that that you're asking right
  1519. 48:18now. Um the the Molinists, their answer
  1520. 48:21was that that the graces given, specific
  1521. 48:24graces and blessings um are are
  1522. 48:26preordained by God on account of what he
  1523. 48:28knows the person will do with them. Um
  1524. 48:31so so the Molinists would say um that
  1525. 48:34you know, like a specific person's
  1526. 48:36access to the gospel is preordained
  1527. 48:38based off of, you know, God's
  1528. 48:40understanding of how they would respond
  1529. 48:41to the gospel if it was given to them.
  1530. 48:44Now, I'm not a Molinist, I'm a Thomist.
  1531. 48:46Um and and the Thomists, they point out
  1532. 48:48within that position that that there's a
  1533. 48:49few things um that it that seem
  1534. 48:51problematic that um it would seem to
  1535. 48:53lead to some sort of vicious circle
  1536. 48:55because the only way that somebody could
  1537. 48:56{quote} {unquote} do something with that
  1538. 48:58grace is by previously having the grace,
  1539. 49:01right? Um because ultimately it's it's
  1540. 49:03all going to be preordained. And so
  1541. 49:06uh the the Thomistic school says that
  1542. 49:08the the specific graces that are poured
  1543. 49:10out um would be um based off of
  1544. 49:14uh the the divine goodness and the
  1545. 49:16divine preordering of the world. And
  1546. 49:18then the the providences that that you
  1547. 49:20are talking about are are not
  1548. 49:22pre-caused, we would say, um but rather
  1549. 49:25permitted due to the evils of the world.
  1550. 49:27Um and so that's where like the seminal
  1551. 49:29ratio comes in and you know, other
  1552. 49:31punishments as well. Um and we we
  1553. 49:34wouldn't say however though that like uh
  1554. 49:36cuz you know, we also believe in
  1555. 49:37invincible ignorance where somebody who
  1556. 49:40is not culpable for their uh lack of
  1557. 49:42understanding, right? Like maybe
  1558. 49:44somebody who's never heard the gospel
  1559. 49:46before, we say that they actually can be
  1560. 49:48saved extraordinarily by, you know, some
  1561. 49:51some means uh whether it's the
  1562. 49:52intercession of the blessed virgin or,
  1563. 49:54you know, uh, God's miraculous grace.
  1564. 49:56And so, we would say that that actually
  1565. 49:58>> that I could go to heaven without
  1566. 50:00belief? Like, if I was just a good
  1567. 50:02person, Joel. Like, I uh, give my time
  1568. 50:06to build beds for kids on the weekends.
  1569. 50:08Like, I donate money. I'm a really nice
  1570. 50:11individual when you know me. Um, would I
  1571. 50:14have the chance to go to heaven if I
  1572. 50:16don't believe in God?
  1573. 50:17>> Yeah, so so again, we we don't base
  1574. 50:19things off of merit. That would be like
  1575. 50:22semi-Pelagianism. We don't think that
  1576. 50:23that's what it is. It's not based off of
  1577. 50:25how good of a person you are.
  1578. 50:27>> No, again,
  1579. 50:28no, that's that's also not what I said.
  1580. 50:30That's a straw man of my position,
  1581. 50:31Chris, and I think you know it, too. Um,
  1582. 50:33I brought up invincible ignorance. Um,
  1583. 50:36invincible ignorance is going to be, um,
  1584. 50:38so so for example, here here's here's a
  1585. 50:40good example. We would say that it's
  1586. 50:41necessary for salvation to believe
  1587. 50:43everything that's written in Paul's
  1588. 50:45letters. Um, but there are there are
  1589. 50:47some people who haven't read all of
  1590. 50:48Paul's letters. I would I would urge
  1591. 50:50them to, but they haven't read all of
  1592. 50:51Paul's letters. And so, on account of
  1593. 50:54that person
  1594. 50:55already having this universal rule that
  1595. 50:57they've applied to themselves, this
  1596. 50:58general acceptance of Paul's letters,
  1597. 51:01they can implicitly fulfill the
  1598. 51:03requirement to believe all of Paul's
  1599. 51:04doctrines. Um, and so
  1600. 51:06>> Joel, everything that you have said to
  1601. 51:08me is that people have to have God luck
  1602. 51:11and they have to have free will.
  1603. 51:13>> See, again, this is
  1604. 51:14>> That's that's that's the two arguments
  1605. 51:15that you've given me, Joel.
  1606. 51:16>> No, I think that's a straw man. I think
  1607. 51:18you're aware that it's a straw man.
  1608. 51:19>> No, you No, it's not a straw man. That's
  1609. 51:22what
  1610. 51:22>> That's not even close to what I was
  1611. 51:24saying.
  1612. 51:24>> Yes, it is. You said you Okay, what
  1613. 51:27about people with AUDHD?
  1614. 51:30That people with autism and uh and and
  1615. 51:32ADHD. They have like a 80 to 90% chance
  1616. 51:36of not believing in God. And they didn't
  1617. 51:39pick their brain. So, like, why is that
  1618. 51:42a thing? And God gave me my brain. Why
  1619. 51:45is it that he would condemn
  1620. 51:48like a majority of those people and he
  1621. 51:50made them that way? The same way it
  1622. 51:52applies to geography, Jaw. The same way
  1623. 51:55it applies to the person in Iran, to the
  1624. 51:57person in Southeast Texas. And you can't
  1625. 52:00give me something to base that off of.
  1626. 52:03You give me two school of thoughts and
  1627. 52:06your Thomistic view, which you should
  1628. 52:07uphold to, doesn't make any sense. All
  1629. 52:10it said was God based this off of the
  1630. 52:12determination of luck and his plan. That
  1631. 52:15is insane.
  1632. 52:16>> Yeah, so so Chris, could you could you
  1633. 52:18just
  1634. 52:19>> But that But that's Okay, but that's
  1635. 52:20what we would call something.
  1636. 52:21>> No, look hold on. If you're again,
  1637. 52:23you're just interrupting.
  1638. 52:23>> That's what we would
  1639. 52:24>> Chris.
  1640. 52:25>> No, that's what we would call something
  1641. 52:26the probability unfavorness. When you go
  1642. 52:29and buy a lottery ticket, Jaw, and you
  1643. 52:31buy a lottery ticket and you win the
  1644. 52:33lottery, what do you call that?
  1645. 52:36What do you call something when you win
  1646. 52:38something that's
  1647. 52:38>> I'm trying I'm trying to ex- I'm trying
  1648. 52:40to explain why it's not just luck though
  1649. 52:42and it seems like you're not even You're
  1650. 52:43not even willing to let
  1651. 52:44>> Okay, well okay.
  1652. 52:45>> Chris, please let me respond.
  1653. 52:46>> something that is definitively another
  1654. 52:49metric to judge it off of.
  1655. 52:52>> All you have said was it's a fancy way
  1656. 52:54of luck.
  1657. 52:55>> All right, let's give him a chance. All
  1658. 52:57right.
  1659. 52:58Yeah, th- thank you so much, host. I I I
  1660. 52:59really do appreciate that. Um
  1661. 53:02So so like I was saying with with Paul's
  1662. 53:04letters and I think this will this will
  1663. 53:06actually if Chris is listening, it will
  1664. 53:07it will answer his question for him. Um
  1665. 53:10that that if if somebody, you know, they
  1666. 53:12they have this general rule of oh, I
  1667. 53:13accept Paul's writings, um then even if
  1668. 53:17they don't know everything that Paul
  1669. 53:18wrote, they'll still have an implicit
  1670. 53:19fulfillment of that requirement. And so
  1671. 53:21we we can say that there's um
  1672. 53:24there's these different tiers of what we
  1673. 53:25would consider necessary for salvation.
  1674. 53:28Um we would say that there is going to
  1675. 53:30be things that are necessary by precept,
  1676. 53:33things that are necessary by means per
  1677. 53:35accidents, and then things that are
  1678. 53:36necessary by means per se.
  1679. 53:38The things that are necessary by precept
  1680. 53:40um are are the ones that I just told
  1681. 53:41you. Uh, submission to the Roman
  1682. 53:43Pontiff, um, belief in the sacred
  1683. 53:45scriptures, belief in sacred tradition,
  1684. 53:47those things. And And like we said
  1685. 53:48previously, those can be fulfilled
  1686. 53:49implicitly, um, based off of someone
  1687. 53:51truly seeking the truth.
  1688. 53:54Um, so so so even if if somebody, uh,
  1689. 53:57you know, doesn't have that specific
  1690. 54:00truth, um, based off of their seeking of
  1691. 54:02the truth, it could be, not is
  1692. 54:04necessarily, but could be fulfilled. Um,
  1693. 54:07and then there there's the things that
  1694. 54:08are necessary by means per accidents.
  1695. 54:10Um, so that's going to be stuff like
  1696. 54:11baptism,
  1697. 54:13um, chrismation into the church, um,
  1698. 54:16you know, reception of the Eucharist,
  1699. 54:18because they give you real graces. It's
  1700. 54:20different than just like assenting to a
  1701. 54:21specific belief, but it actually gives
  1702. 54:23you a specific grace that is going to
  1703. 54:25lead towards your salvation and and and
  1704. 54:27lead towards your your sanctification.
  1705. 54:29And so those are the things that are
  1706. 54:30necessary, um, by means per accidents.
  1707. 54:33But those things also can be fulfilled
  1708. 54:34implicitly. So we would say, for
  1709. 54:36example, like a a catechumen who is not
  1710. 54:38yet baptized, hoping to be baptized, um,
  1711. 54:41but then dies on their way to be
  1712. 54:42baptized. Well, that person, we we would
  1713. 54:44actually still hope for their salvation
  1714. 54:46because they were desiring that baptism.
  1715. 54:48Same thing with like a martyr. Um, and
  1716. 54:51so again, we apply this to those things.
  1717. 54:53And And then the final one is things
  1718. 54:54that are necessary by precept, um,
  1719. 54:57or sorry, not necessary by precept,
  1720. 54:59necessary by means per se. These are
  1721. 55:01going to be things that cannot be
  1722. 55:03implicitly fulfilled. They They have to
  1723. 55:05be explicitly fulfilled. It's taken from
  1724. 55:06Hebrews 11:6, and, um, the the statement
  1725. 55:09goes that, um, one must believe that
  1726. 55:12God, one, is, and God, two, rewards the
  1727. 55:15just. Those are the two beliefs that
  1728. 55:17that must be assented to. Um, and then
  1729. 55:19from that follows the rest. So we kind
  1730. 55:21of view it as like a mountain, right? At
  1731. 55:23the top of the mountain, you have the
  1732. 55:24Catholic faith, which is the the
  1733. 55:25fullness of the gospel, the fullness of
  1734. 55:27truth. Um, but then below that, you have
  1735. 55:30maybe, um, people who are not all the
  1736. 55:32way there yet. But as long as they are,
  1737. 55:33you know, truly seeking up that
  1738. 55:35mountain, we can still hope for their
  1739. 55:37salvation, right? If they're making the
  1740. 55:39track up to the top of the mountain. And
  1741. 55:41so, we could say for for you know, like
  1742. 55:43a Muslim who's living in in Iran,
  1743. 55:46um maybe like a 4-year-old Muslim child
  1744. 55:48who's never heard the gospel before, but
  1745. 55:50you know, they they love Allah, they're
  1746. 55:51they're they're trying to seek the
  1747. 55:53truth, they're trying to do good, they
  1748. 55:54believe that God is, and they believe
  1749. 55:56that he rewards the just, um and then
  1750. 55:58they're they're killed by an Israeli
  1751. 55:59missile or something like that. Um we
  1752. 56:02would say, yes, that's absolutely
  1753. 56:03tragic, and that child does not have the
  1754. 56:05same culpability for their sins that we
  1755. 56:07that we would, their their personal
  1756. 56:08sins.
  1757. 56:09>> That's what I was just about to say. Why
  1758. 56:10did you use a child and not like a
  1759. 56:1230-year-old, Jahl?
  1760. 56:15Is that person too far gone into the age
  1761. 56:17gap to give you like his
  1762. 56:18>> No, I just It was just It was It was It
  1763. 56:21was It was just an example that it would
  1764. 56:23be clear to everyone.
  1765. 56:24>> apply Does the same apply to a
  1766. 56:2630-year-old?
  1767. 56:27>> It It certainly can. There can be
  1768. 56:29implicit fulfillment of them as well,
  1769. 56:30but I was just giving an example. That
  1770. 56:32the age was really just to make it as
  1771. 56:34clear as possible for people.
  1772. 56:35>> here's what I'm going to say. I'm going
  1773. 56:37to say this, and I'm going to let you
  1774. 56:38talk to Cames for
  1775. 56:39>> I I I Well, well, we actually I do need
  1776. 56:42to head out because it's been an hour,
  1777. 56:44and I have lunch with my grandparents,
  1778. 56:46unfortunately. I well, fortunately I
  1779. 56:48have to have lunch with them, but it's
  1780. 56:50been too long, so I do I do have to step
  1781. 56:51down.
  1782. 56:52>> Free
  1783. 56:53will and God luck, that's the answers,
  1784. 56:55correct?
  1785. 56:56>> you're you're well aware that's not what
  1786. 56:57it was.
  1787. 56:59>> Chris, do we find
  1788. 57:01Chris, hold on. Chris, he hasn't got
  1789. 57:03long left, and to be fair, there's a lot
  1790. 57:04of people waiting. He's a popular guy,
  1791. 57:07to be fair to him.
  1792. 57:09Um so,
  1793. 57:10is he okay? Have you got a couple of
  1794. 57:11minutes left, or do you mind if some
  1795. 57:14if some of these guys have a couple of
  1796. 57:15minutes with you?
  1797. 57:16>> Yeah, well, I'm unfortunately I was
  1798. 57:17supposed to cut it off at like the
  1799. 57:1845-minute mark, and it's almost been an
  1800. 57:20hour. I would love I would How about I
  1801. 57:22drop you a follow, and then I can come
  1802. 57:23up, and we can have conversations maybe
  1803. 57:25maybe sometime in the future, or or I
  1804. 57:26could have you on my channel. Either
  1805. 57:28way, I'll I'll send you a message here,
  1806. 57:29cuz you You like a cool guy. You seem
  1807. 57:31like you're interested in the truth, so
  1808. 57:32it was it was it was at least fun to be
  1809. 57:33on the panel.
  1810. 57:35>> All right, man. Well, nice nice having
  1811. 57:37you here.
  1812. 57:38Uh yeah, maybe next time. That's cool.
  1813. 57:40>> Yeah, all right. God bless all of you.
  1814. 57:41>> God bless. All right, take care.
  1815. 57:44Take care.
  1816. 57:46Okay, so
  1817. 57:48Hey.
  1818. 57:49>> Wow.
  1819. 57:50Wow, wow, wow, wow, wow.
  1820. 57:52Um
  1821. 57:54that was that was a conversation.
  1822. 57:56Um
  1823. 57:57what what was that? Like a towards the
  1824. 57:59end there, I think there were like seven
  1825. 58:00people
  1826. 58:02seven people in the in the queue. That's
  1827. 58:04unbelievable. Um
  1828. 58:06that was a lot.
  1829. 58:08But but hopefully, you know, and and
  1830. 58:09again, I would like to clarify for
  1831. 58:10people my goal with these debates is
  1832. 58:13never to convince the person I'm talking
  1833. 58:15to. I know that's not going to happen,
  1834. 58:17especially with people like Chris. My
  1835. 58:19goal is to convince the people that are
  1836. 58:21listening.
  1837. 58:23Okay.
  1838. 58:24A good debater does not aim to convince
  1839. 58:25the the person he's talking to, but
  1840. 58:27rather aims to debate the person who's
  1841. 58:28listening.
  1842. 58:30And hopefully, I think I showed the the
  1843. 58:31validity of of the the Thomistic
  1844. 58:33thought.
  1845. 58:34I don't know. Um
  1846. 58:36if you guys want to support the channel,
  1847. 58:38please subscribe and like the video. Um
  1848. 58:40or you could go look at my Substack.
  1849. 58:43My Substack uh is is like the real way
  1850. 58:45that you can support me. It is free. Um
  1851. 58:47I post articles on there, and then
  1852. 58:49there's an option to subscribe for $10 a
  1853. 58:51month. Um and then you get access to a
  1854. 58:53bunch of articles um additional articles
  1855. 58:55that I've written. So, if you actually
  1856. 58:57want to support the channel in a
  1857. 58:58meaningful way, that's the way that you
  1858. 58:59can do it. Um it really really does help
  1859. 59:01out, and it makes it so that I can keep
  1860. 59:02making these videos and keep buying
  1861. 59:04these books, guys. Uh the bookshelves
  1862. 59:06are filling up uh very quickly. We have
  1863. 59:08like I think probably like 50 books on
  1864. 59:10the way. I'm very excited, but um all
  1865. 59:12that being said, I really appreciate
  1866. 59:13every single one of you. Please pray for
  1867. 59:15me, and know that I'm praying for you,
  1868. 59:16and God bless every single one of you.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of HEATED DEBATE | JesusandWhatnot vs 7 Atheists | 1v7 by Jesus and Whatnot, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 12,012 words across 1,868 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.