Hasan Spiker Explains How We Can Revive the Essence of Islam to defeat the West! — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Asalamikum everybody. Welcome back to
- 0:01the on podcast. We're here again with
- 0:04another edition of the show with our one
- 0:06of our favorite guests of all time, but
- 0:08this time in the flesh. We have She As
- 0:10Hassan He's here physically so I
- 0:13can uh be obnoxious and interrupt him.
- 0:16Uh
- 0:17>> please peace
- 0:18>> in a in a less metaphysical and more of
- 0:20a corporeal sense.
- 0:22>> That's outside of my comfort zone. I'm
- 0:24sure
- 0:24>> it is outside of your comfort zone.
- 0:26However, we are we are back home as the
- 0:28first the second generation
- 0:30Anglo-American Muslim man. You're back
- 0:32home to where all it started uh the
- 0:35subcontinent Pakistan. And we have with
- 0:37us uh Hassnan. Hnan's an online uh
- 0:40popular um would you describe yourself
- 0:44as an a student of Islam? Popular on on
- 0:47>> trying to be a student of
- 0:48>> Yeah, student of Islam. Very popular
- 0:49with young people.
- 0:50>> If you just move your mic up a bit
- 0:52closer to yourself, inshallah we should
- 0:54be able to. Apparently, there was a
- 0:56complaint last time around. I wasn't
- 0:57serious enough uh when speaking with the
- 1:00sheh. But this time around, I'll be much
- 1:03more quiet and humble.
- 1:04>> Well, then I heard that's a complaint on
- 1:06every single podcast that you do. So,
- 1:08[laughter]
- 1:09>> yeah, [clears throat] it's a much loved
- 1:11brand. So, keep it up.
- 1:13>> I don't think so, but I I'll try. So,
- 1:15we'll be talking about then you got Shik
- 1:17Assad in the flesh in Pakistan.
- 1:20>> That's a great opportunity. I think we
- 1:22can begin with something more general. M
- 1:25>> so shake in your book um unraveling of
- 1:28intelligibility you make this great
- 1:30point that u even the Muslims they have
- 1:34considered the western ideals or
- 1:36definitions of success and achievements
- 1:38as our own you know idea of measuring
- 1:42our success you know for example you
- 1:44give the example of uh Muslim scholars
- 1:47uh judging our success through the
- 1:49inclusion of women in the workforce
- 1:52>> so now if we cannot take the western
- 1:54ideals as you know our yard stick of
- 1:57success. What would a successful Muslim
- 2:00polity look like in terms of let's say
- 2:03can we really judge a successful Muslim
- 2:05polity through their I don't know space
- 2:08programs or their like political
- 2:10structures or like what first of all
- 2:13what is a successful Muslim polity and
- 2:15how can it be measured in terms of
- 2:17qualitatively since that is the measure
- 2:19we cannot measure it quantitatively.
- 2:21So my general idea that I want to uh
- 2:25point towards is like what does a
- 2:27successful Muslim polity look like and
- 2:29what are and the ways through which we
- 2:32can measure it especially again another
- 2:34caveat in in in a nation state
- 2:37>> era.
- 2:39Well I think the difficulty with us is
- 2:41we're always putting the cut before the
- 2:43horse. Um, and we're always we're always
- 2:46thinking about what a successful policy
- 2:49looks like when the real difficulties
- 2:52that we're facing are much much more
- 2:53fundamental difficulties.
- 2:55>> So, you know, I think the first way to
- 2:58look at how to treat that is by looking
- 3:01exactly at those criteria physics that
- 3:03you were talking about that we are
- 3:06simply living in someone else's
- 3:07metaphysics. we're living in someone
- 3:09else's philosophy but completely unaware
- 3:11that we're doing so because [snorts]
- 3:13as human beings we have to have a
- 3:16metaphysical view on things. It's just
- 3:17the way that we look at look upon the
- 3:19world type of creature that we are. So
- 3:21we look at things in terms of the good.
- 3:24We took look at things in terms of the
- 3:26true and we look at things in terms of
- 3:27the beautiful which are the platonic
- 3:29transcendentals.
- 3:31>> What what what transcendental means is
- 3:33that they are ever present. You can't
- 3:35escape from them. So just as human
- 3:37beings, we're always making ethical
- 3:39evaluations. We're always making
- 3:41evaluations as to the truth of things,
- 3:43which means the essences of things. What
- 3:45what is the essence of the world? And
- 3:47we're always making evaluations in terms
- 3:49of the beautiful as well. And um so
- 3:54we've [snorts]
- 3:55departed from those criteria in order to
- 3:58adopt criteria. And you know why did we
- 4:00do so? I think an oft repeated at least
- 4:04by me and um I think very very apt
- 4:07characterization of why we left that
- 4:09path and ended up doing tak and blind
- 4:12following of someone else without
- 4:14necessarily realizing we're doing so
- 4:17believing their lie that the whole thing
- 4:19that they're offering is neutral and
- 4:20universal when it's anything but is
- 4:23because as Shikh Mustafa Sabri who's the
- 4:25last real Shik Islam of the Ottoman
- 4:27Empire who I have a lot of differences
- 4:28with he's a he hates Iban Arabi for
- 4:30example
- 4:31But you know the two things he says are
- 4:33true and and very I think profound. He
- 4:36says that um we mistook a marshall
- 4:40victory for an intellectual victory.
- 4:43And
- 4:45of course there's you know much greater
- 4:46complexity to it. But I think it it
- 4:48pithily sums up what was really at the
- 4:50core of what happened and it was mostly
- 4:52unconscious.
- 4:54uh but we saw the fruits of uh what
- 4:57scientific investigation could yield in
- 5:00terms of technological progress and we
- 5:02felt that oh gosh I mean what what have
- 5:03we been doing all of this time they've
- 5:05overwhelmed us and it's because we
- 5:07weren't looking at the world in the
- 5:08proper way unbeknownst to us
- 5:12>> modern science is anything but neutral
- 5:14and it's not a way at getting at the
- 5:15inner core or essence of the world it's
- 5:18a way of manipulating the physical world
- 5:21for our own material gain adapt ing
- 5:24means to ends and it's a purely
- 5:26instrumental way of looking at nature.
- 5:28So essentially what happened in the
- 5:30scientific revolution in the 17th
- 5:31century which we think oh it's just
- 5:33science what do you mean it's just
- 5:34science we obviously we need science
- 5:35otherwise we'll fall behind you know
- 5:37we'll be backward but science in the
- 5:39modern sense that that you know has its
- 5:42inception in the scientific revolution
- 5:45replaced a knowledge paradigm which was
- 5:48essentially based on the Muslim
- 5:50knowledge paradigm that you know at the
- 5:52conquest of Teddo in 1080 whatever it
- 5:54was um was was discovered and then
- 5:58became became assimilated so that it
- 5:59went to uh form the first universities
- 6:02in the western world. So you know the
- 6:05works of Avisena the chiff the works of
- 6:09scientific demonstration
- 6:11and the posterior analytics and so on
- 6:14and this was a subordinated model of the
- 6:16sciences crowned by metaphysics
- 6:18>> and what a subordinated model means I
- 6:21mean to it's summed up in a phrase from
- 6:24Iban's metaphysics
- 6:2815 where he says
- 6:30where he says says
- 6:36the principles of every more specific
- 6:39science
- 6:41>> anything which is lower than metaphysics
- 6:42like physics like ethics for whatever
- 6:45are questions in the highest science. So
- 6:48the principles of a lower science, the
- 6:50principles, it's starting points,
- 6:52unnegotiable starting points are
- 6:54questions in the highest science. Right?
- 6:56So that means metaphysics is the arbiter
- 6:58of all of the other science. It doesn't
- 6:59mean, oh, we piously want to put
- 7:01metaphysics on top cuz it's more divine
- 7:03or something. So let's just choose that.
- 7:04No, it's talking about the structure of
- 7:07epistemic justification. metaphysics has
- 7:10to be there because it's the only
- 7:12science of of adequate generality to
- 7:16actually do tus or to actually validate
- 7:20uh the principles of the lower sciences.
- 7:22So what the scientific revolution
- 7:24essentially does is it replaces that
- 7:27whole structure of subordinated sciences
- 7:31which was common to the Muslim world and
- 7:34to the European world and the European
- 7:36world largely took it from the Muslim
- 7:38world and that's just not that's not
- 7:40just a kind of nostalgic kind of
- 7:42triumphalism that is that's historic
- 7:44fact it's not really negotiable um and
- 7:48it replaced it with a system which had
- 7:50basically abolished metaphysics What is
- 7:52metaphysics the science of? It's the
- 7:54science of the realities of things, the
- 7:56essences of things beyond appearances.
- 8:00Okay? And they said we need to get, you
- 8:02know, this this science of, you know,
- 8:04spiritual realities beyond appearances,
- 8:05it's getting us absolutely nowhere.
- 8:07We've been dominated by the Islamic
- 8:09world for a thousand years. And, you
- 8:11know, we're living in in squalor and
- 8:12poverty. And we need and now we're being
- 8:15ripped apart by the Protestant
- 8:17Revolution. you know, we're we're we're
- 8:19renting not in two, in many many pieces
- 8:23into fragments and um we need a new
- 8:26knowledge standard which actually avoids
- 8:29any appeal to the metaphysical or the
- 8:30theological is a neutral universal
- 8:33knowledge standard. So what they did and
- 8:35it sounds conspiratorial but the thing
- 8:37is this is this is backed up by the
- 8:39basic historical fundament um is that in
- 8:43the scientific revolution of the 17th
- 8:45century 17th and 18th century there was
- 8:48a there was a deliberate move to
- 8:52redefine our understanding of the
- 8:54natural world so that our our interest
- 8:57was no longer anything to do with the
- 8:58essence of things. What is nature and
- 9:01what is the typical theological view of
- 9:03nature is nature is a theophony. It's
- 9:06you know it's an appearance of God. It's
- 9:08a manifestation of God. You see the
- 9:09signs of God in nature and you and it's
- 9:12a way to celebrate the theological
- 9:15virtues by um finding them writ large on
- 9:19the horizons in nature. And um that is
- 9:23uh and so
- 9:25in more technical terms they abolished
- 9:28final causes and formal causes from
- 9:30nature. Final causes being purposes and
- 9:33formal causes being essences. So there's
- 9:35no purposes in nature and there are no
- 9:38essences in nature.
- 9:39>> And you know the Bonian knowledge is
- 9:42power. You know, we've been fiddling
- 9:44around all of this time, wasting our
- 9:46time with metaphysical speculation,
- 9:48which has nothing to do with actual
- 9:50experimentation, actual actually
- 9:53benefiting from from our intellectual
- 9:55activity. Of course, in the only terms
- 9:57that he can envision, benefiting, which
- 9:59is material terms. Um, and so all that's
- 10:02left in the four arises healing causes
- 10:04are efficient causes and material
- 10:06causes. Right? So what directly causes
- 10:10an event? what's the proximate cause
- 10:12that brings about an event? We need to
- 10:14study that in order to be able to
- 10:15replicate it, you know, experimentally.
- 10:18And material causes, what is something
- 10:20made of? That's all that we're
- 10:21interested in.
- 10:22>> Um, and so why? Because that makes
- 10:25nature susceptible to a mechanistic
- 10:28treatment, right? And and and that's why
- 10:30mathematics becomes all important,
- 10:33right? Because of its its predictive
- 10:36power, right?
- 10:56UN report.
- 11:23see you there in um and at the same time
- 11:26there's this abolishment of what are
- 11:28called secondary qualities which are
- 11:29really just anything qualitative
- 11:31qualitative from nature and a claim that
- 11:36All that should be legitimately studied
- 11:38in natural science are primary qualities
- 11:40which are basically types of quantity.
- 11:42So that's all that's there. So you see
- 11:45>> this is not a claim about the nature of
- 11:48physicality.
- 11:49>> It's a methodological choice because
- 11:51this is the direction we want to go in.
- 11:54You see people sympathetic to the
- 11:56western view of this or to enlightenment
- 11:58in post- enlightenment thinking would
- 12:00say would ask the question that what
- 12:02motivated them to remove these secondary
- 12:04causes or to remove this subordinated
- 12:06sort of uh model of of of knowledge or
- 12:09approach to knowledge where metaphysics
- 12:11stands at top. And they would argue
- 12:13subsequently they would answer that
- 12:15question by saying that you know it was
- 12:16the dogmas and the dark ages and it was
- 12:19this stifling attitude towards academ
- 12:22academics and towards viewing and
- 12:24observing the physical phenomenon of the
- 12:26world and that's the very sort of
- 12:28atheistic typical position that might be
- 12:30reiterated or regurgitated in Pakistan
- 12:32as to I think as Nan's experienced a lot
- 12:34of it online wouldn't that be the
- 12:36argument that they would regurgitate
- 12:38that the reason why people made a
- 12:40purposeful attempt in trying to subvert
- 12:43the uh the knowledge uh uh paradigm is
- 12:47because they were stifled by the
- 12:49dogmatic
- 12:51views of the church and of religious
- 12:53society and religious thinking and it
- 12:54didn't yield any beneficial or tangible
- 12:58progress in terms of human material
- 13:00comforts.
- 13:01>> That's what they'd argue and which is
- 13:02not entirely unreasonable.
- 13:05>> Yeah. Well, I if we if we go along with
- 13:07certain assumptions, it's not
- 13:08unreasonable. But the thing is that's
- 13:09essentially a Protestant that's that's
- 13:12an example of Protestant propaganda
- 13:14which has resulted in a kind of de facto
- 13:16positivism
- 13:18>> in in the Muslim world. So you know I
- 13:21mean positivism has lots of different
- 13:23meanings but what I mean by it as a kind
- 13:25of umbrella term is the idea that any
- 13:27knowledge claim which is not rooted in
- 13:29empirical experience is not really a
- 13:31knowledge
- 13:32>> or worth having or yeah
- 13:33>> yeah it's not it's not even in principle
- 13:35possible for it to be an instance of
- 13:37objective knowledge which means that
- 13:39everything which is not rooted in in in
- 13:41the empirical experience is relegated to
- 13:44the realm of subjectivity
- 13:46and you might think well I mean
- 13:48obviously all that's real is the
- 13:49empirical world and that's what we can
- 13:51all see and what's what's the problem
- 13:53problem with that is what's included in
- 13:55in not empiricism in in in things which
- 13:58can't be empirically rooted all ethical
- 14:00questions all of them
- 14:01>> how are you going to root the answer to
- 14:03an ethical question in a in an empirical
- 14:05experience there's no way to do it all
- 14:07questions of aesthetics
- 14:09right all questions to do with the
- 14:10beautiful which is actually
- 14:13extremely important
- 14:14>> it's a part it's it's part of every
- 14:16single evaluative state that we have of
- 14:19human beings. We're constantly
- 14:21evaluating beauty and trying to
- 14:23cultivate beauty, distance ourselves
- 14:25from the ugly. And most importantly of
- 14:27all, it's it rules out all metaphysical
- 14:30judgments which are to do with the
- 14:32essence.
- 14:33>> I suspect a workaround would be to
- 14:34gather the best minds of the scientific
- 14:36world and maybe take them to an island
- 14:38retreat, little St. James, for example,
- 14:40and maybe they could
- 14:43they could debate it out and [laughter]
- 14:45hash it out over there, you know, like
- 14:47like gentlemen, like some sort of modern
- 14:50uh you know uh
- 14:53white gold minor red. [laughter]
- 14:56So, was it gold and blue? The minor red
- 14:58over there. How about that? Would that
- 15:00be the way that they would objectively
- 15:02be able to reach ethical conclusions and
- 15:05ideas about beauty and aesthetics and
- 15:08>> moral questions about, you know,
- 15:10>> no, because there's a there's a
- 15:11methodological reframing that needs to
- 15:14happen first. You know, if you're
- 15:15looking in the wrong place, no, no
- 15:17matter how long you look and how hard
- 15:19you look, you're never going to find the
- 15:21thing that you're looking for. uh no the
- 15:23no matter how many times you repeat a
- 15:25lie uh if everyone repeats the lie
- 15:28together it doesn't make it true. So
- 15:30there there is a meth methodological
- 15:34renewal that needs to take place which
- 15:36is mostly from the Muslim side realizing
- 15:38the degree to which we're living in
- 15:40someone else's metaphysics and trying to
- 15:42understand those reasons. Why why did
- 15:45why why did the scientific revolution
- 15:47happen? Again, exactly as you said, the
- 15:49myth is, well, it's because we all
- 15:51suddenly woke up and realized that there
- 15:53was something desperately wrong taking
- 15:55place and we just got it all wrong and
- 15:57someone made a discovery or a few
- 15:59discoveries and it was like, [laughter]
- 16:00oh gosh, we were all, you know, we've
- 16:02realized how stupid we've been all of
- 16:04these thousands of years and it's now so
- 16:06obvious and uh so they think that
- 16:08somehow it the old way was disproved or
- 16:11there was some sort of really in the
- 16:13broadest sense scientific proof.
- 16:14Obviously the word science has been
- 16:16co-opted just to be natural science. But
- 16:17before it just meant objective
- 16:18knowledge. Um and you know where would
- 16:21those scientific proofs in the
- 16:23traditional sense uh take place? It was
- 16:26fundamentally metaphysics. Why the word
- 16:28cientia um and in Greek epistem
- 16:32cientia which became science uh
- 16:34originally most most in terms of the the
- 16:37most certain and and uh and indisputable
- 16:42knowledge was to be had in metaphysics.
- 16:44But uh but why did these things really
- 16:46take place? There's two main reasons.
- 16:48One of them is the Protestant Revolution
- 16:49and Luther's
- 16:51violent violent opposition to
- 16:54scholasticism and that subordinated
- 16:57model that I was talking about. Um and
- 16:59that's because of deeper philosophical
- 17:02problems. uh you know we all know about
- 17:04the nominalist movement which moved away
- 17:06from uh realist metaphysics and you know
- 17:10aquinus was this crowning point of
- 17:11realist metaphysics where everything
- 17:13made sense and then Okam and other
- 17:15nominalists start to cast doubt on that
- 17:17and so on. Well Luther was an alchemist
- 17:20philosopher. He was an alchemist trained
- 17:22philosopher and you know his um his kind
- 17:26of diet tribal pmics he was really a
- 17:29much a very good retroitionician
- 17:32um you know should mask for many people
- 17:34the fact that he had a very very deep
- 17:36philosophical training it just doesn't
- 17:37come to the four and that's quite
- 17:39deliberate because he's trying to reject
- 17:40it but he's rejecting something he
- 17:42understands in that sense it's quite a
- 17:43lot like Muhammad Abdu um who wanted to
- 17:45do a very very similar thing later
- 17:47having you know being not as an ignorant
- 17:49person who didn't understand what he was
- 17:51rejecting. That's really what made him
- 17:53so dangerous. And the the same with
- 17:55Luther. Um and so it was this mixture of
- 17:58empiricism and uh the the then the the
- 18:02huge the the the social impact of Luther
- 18:06as this great reformist figure. Um and
- 18:10why did that empiricism happen in the I
- 18:12mean this is a tangential point which is
- 18:15but it was essentially because of um a
- 18:18dominant aristo arisetilianism in Europe
- 18:22um which wasn't really adequately
- 18:24tempered by other other intellectual
- 18:27currents like in the Muslim world you
- 18:28had you had a a very very powerful Sufi
- 18:31metaphysics which would always correct
- 18:34and kind of temper the excesses of of
- 18:37analoid aristoinism.
- 18:39But um Arisetilianism
- 18:41as opposed to Platonism kind of
- 18:43inexurably leads to being stuck in the
- 18:46empirical and it was just really waiting
- 18:48to happen and that's really why this
- 18:50took place [clears throat] in the and at
- 18:51the same time yes you had the arbitrary
- 18:53power of the Catholic Church
- 18:56>> um not rooted you see you know in in the
- 18:58Islamic world both ruler [snorts] and
- 19:02and are both governed by the Sharia
- 19:05right
- 19:05>> yeah the same umbrella
- 19:07>> yeah there's no There's no arbitrary
- 19:09fiat of the pope who's where's he taking
- 19:11it from you know it's literally
- 19:13arbitrary there's no criteria it's his
- 19:15person so um there were many abuses
- 19:19absolutely no doubt but it's also
- 19:21important to understand and we all kind
- 19:23of nod sagely when we talk about all the
- 19:25abuses of the medieval church tending to
- 19:28know abs absolutely next to nothing um
- 19:30about the the details and the reality is
- 19:32a lot of that is is propagandic
- 19:35propagandistic protestant nonsense for
- 19:37example the idea that there was no
- 19:39social mobility in the middle ages.
- 19:40There are many studies that show that
- 19:42there was far more social mobility in
- 19:45the middle ages than there is in the
- 19:47modern world in the modern western
- 19:49world. You know America a couple of
- 19:51years ago maybe but now I wouldn't doubt
- 19:52it. I completely agree but
- 19:54>> to that they would raise another uh
- 19:56issue is that you know the wonders that
- 19:59have been produced from this uh sort of
- 20:01unbridled um non-subordinated sort of
- 20:04thinking and approach to the sciences to
- 20:06the natural sciences
- 20:07um to the material world to for example
- 20:10the the the scientific method itself
- 20:13>> uh the wonders and the terrors the
- 20:15wonders and terrors and they would tout
- 20:17both of them at the same time
- 20:18>> and in that in like a very savage kind
- 20:21of divine right of kings kind of way
- 20:22they would imply that that this
- 20:25>> is uh evidence that this is the truth
- 20:28from even if even if they are arguing
- 20:30from a religious standpoint they would
- 20:31argue that this is the truth from God
- 20:33that this power is manifested through
- 20:35the scientific method through the
- 20:36reformation information through this uh
- 20:39mode of thinking not subordinated to a
- 20:41church or a religious order or uh a more
- 20:44secular or enlightened way of thinking.
- 20:46I'm using these terms very loosely
- 20:48>> and they would argue in in a religious
- 20:50way they would argue which is ironic
- 20:52obviously but that that this is
- 20:55>> a result of
- 20:57the tr the underlying truth within this
- 20:59particular mode of thinking and that is
- 21:02sort of acknowledged by modern Muslims
- 21:03at least in the subcontinent Pakistan I
- 21:05see that they'll sort of be like yeah I
- 21:06mean that's maybe why Europe succeeded
- 21:09in colonizing us and that mix of wonder
- 21:12wonder and terror produced by the the
- 21:15subsequent industrial age is viewed as
- 21:18the logical or the the end point of uh
- 21:21that whole uh two 300 year process. What
- 21:24would be the sort of the Muslim response
- 21:26or response to that or what would be the
- 21:29correct worldview to have when uh when
- 21:32presented with that sort of idea?
- 21:33>> If I can of course no please but
- 21:35speaking into the mic on this question
- 21:37>> into the mic.
- 21:38>> Um
- 21:39>> really honestly like genuinely face the
- 21:41mic closer.
- 21:43>> Yeah. And loudly please. Okay. Like if
- 21:46you look at the ground realities of the
- 21:47Muslim world as you have said that we
- 21:50were subordinated marshally and then we
- 21:53adopted their you know frameworks of
- 21:55inquiry the intellectual frameworks
- 21:56[clears throat] of inquiry.
- 21:57>> Now it's it's it's a ground reality that
- 22:00their beonian/
- 22:02nian mindset coupled with this social
- 22:05Darwinism
- 22:06>> it helped them you know create
- 22:08[clears throat and snorts] this whole um
- 22:10you know monopoly of sovereignity all
- 22:12around the world. So when we look at
- 22:15that mindset and it the it has helped
- 22:18them create this material hedgemony in
- 22:20the world. Basically they are successful
- 22:22in the material sense if we can just put
- 22:24it in that way. And if their entire
- 22:27worldview is revolves around materiality
- 22:30and the material causality is all there
- 22:32is to to their worldview. Isn't such a
- 22:35society bound to triumph over a society
- 22:38that takes let's say the ethical as its
- 22:41central point? M
- 22:42>> I mean even if you look at the Jews
- 22:45right they have been so successful in
- 22:48integrating themselves into you know the
- 22:49power corridors of how the dunya works
- 22:52it's mainly because of like their idea
- 22:54that their esqueological t- loss
- 22:57revolves around their political
- 22:58governance in the end times. So even
- 23:00their worldview is very
- 23:02>> people ask this by the way people
- 23:04generally like very religious people ask
- 23:05this like how can we compete in the in
- 23:08in in the modern age with
- 23:11>> except by and we
- 23:13>> no no no word of no word of a lie a lot
- 23:16of our state like uh people involved in
- 23:18state craft justify a lot of the devious
- 23:21behaviors they get up to
- 23:23>> with this kind of argumentation they're
- 23:24like how are we supposed to compete with
- 23:26the Europeans
- 23:27>> the Pakistani state would talk like
- 23:29[clears throat] this if Frankly were
- 23:30sitting in a drawing room similar to
- 23:32this you know
- 23:33>> uh they would say stuff like this
- 23:35officers from the government you know we
- 23:36have to
- 23:38>> engage in all kinds of uh shenanigans
- 23:40and espionage.
- 23:41>> So like how do we fight a society that
- 23:43has the material world at its main axum?
- 23:47Like can we like really you know fight
- 23:50them or triumph over them without having
- 23:52some sort of attachment to the dunya and
- 23:55like the material world or like would
- 23:57our idea of success would only be judged
- 24:00in a like can Muslim you know have a
- 24:04certain imagination of success in this
- 24:06tuna yet while remaining distant and
- 24:09detached to the material world like how
- 24:11does
- 24:12>> there a giant tree somewhere at the core
- 24:14of the Muslim world where we can connect
- 24:15our hair into and maybe not have deal
- 24:18with the helicopters at the western, you
- 24:20know, the aerial bombardment. It's like,
- 24:22do we have an avatar like sort of nivist
- 24:25solution?
- 24:27>> Yeah. I mean, I don't I don't think it's
- 24:28a choice between rampant technologisism
- 24:31and ludicism as two extremes. But the
- 24:34issue is we're not really looking at the
- 24:36root causes of our weakness. Uh the root
- 24:38causes of our weakness are exactly
- 24:40because we our civilizational tell us
- 24:42has been lost and what we're doing is
- 24:44fiddling around with band-aids and you
- 24:46know
- 24:46>> Yeah. patchwork.
- 24:47>> Yeah. Yeah. Patchwork here and there,
- 24:49you know, catching up catching up
- 24:51syndrome. You know, they've got this new
- 24:53form of technology. We'll play catch up
- 24:55and we'll do it even better and cheaper.
- 24:56But you know, but it's all in terms of
- 25:00um
- 25:01a constant inferiority complex that we
- 25:04would never would never be an issue if
- 25:06we knew what was important to us in
- 25:09terms of our own criteria. But we've
- 25:11lost that. And so you know our our
- 25:14fundamentally just to put it starkly our
- 25:19criteria very simple uh you know is our
- 25:22civilizational activity just for one of
- 25:25a better word just to keep things uh
- 25:27clear is it uh contributing to
- 25:32cultivating the kilaf in the sense of
- 25:34the vicey of the earth which is a state
- 25:38in which
- 25:40everything in the world. Everything in
- 25:42the created world is
- 25:45put into its proper place. And that
- 25:48sounds a little bit kind of coercive,
- 25:50but what I mean is everything in the
- 25:53material world, everything in the
- 25:54created world beyond the material world
- 25:57is brought into its state of fulfillment
- 26:00and actualization and harmony of the
- 26:03various orders
- 26:05>> by the activity of the perfect man
- 26:10who is the vice gerant, the khalifa,
- 26:13right? Not in the political sense. The
- 26:14political sense is offshoot of that. Um
- 26:17and uh and and and and that most
- 26:21fundamentally amounts to manifesting the
- 26:24inward and the outward reality of the
- 26:26prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam and
- 26:28of prophethood which is our direct
- 26:31connection as human beings with Allah
- 26:32tala.
- 26:34If if if this had been that that had
- 26:38become manifest
- 26:40as widely as it should have been and you
- 26:44know when I say should you know there
- 26:45are esotical realities we are where we
- 26:48are and that was intended by Allah tala
- 26:50>> and a lot of people are you know
- 26:51throwing rotten fruit at the screen
- 26:54right now saying oh you know you're if
- 26:57you're backward and you you just want us
- 26:58to be defeated and accept there there's
- 27:01such a thing as if you're Muslim you
- 27:03believe in it if you're not a Muslim
- 27:04then you don't believe in it. But you
- 27:05know,
- 27:07certain things needed to happen in order
- 27:09for us to enter the times that we're in
- 27:12now. I I don't want to say the end
- 27:14times, but because then they'll think
- 27:16I'm alone, but um but but to we're in a
- 27:19certain period of history and and what
- 27:21it had to what it what it took was
- 27:24>> this unique moment in history where a
- 27:28great civilization
- 27:30turns away for the first time again in
- 27:33human history from a theocentric view of
- 27:37the world
- 27:39>> uh in order to you know really rather
- 27:42luciferically
- 27:45>> affirm its own divinity. No, we are
- 27:48autonomous where we we've seeded
- 27:50ourselves from this imaginary heaven
- 27:52>> and everything is according to our own
- 27:54criteria
- 27:55>> and you know based on that vision of
- 27:58radical autonomy
- 28:00everything else follows and it's all the
- 28:02invention of our minds. It's all
- 28:03convention. It's all but most
- 28:06importantly
- 28:07it is will to power because there are no
- 28:10objective criteria.
- 28:12>> Uh you know the only thing that's
- 28:14objective is that which binds us in
- 28:16terms of the data of the hard sciences.
- 28:18But everything else is up for grabs and
- 28:21if everything is else is up for grabs
- 28:22that's why people become obsessed with
- 28:24power interests as they do today. It's
- 28:25quite ironic become obsessed with power
- 28:27interest because that's all they believe
- 28:29exists
- 28:30>> and so might is going to be raped.
- 28:32Right. Um, so, uh, how do you respond to
- 28:38those people? It's a much, you know, we
- 28:40we're always looking at surface symptoms
- 28:42>> and we're not looking at root causes
- 28:44that if if if the root causes
- 28:47>> had been addressed or at least they
- 28:49let's say they'd never deteriorated the
- 28:51to the point they deteriorated,
- 28:54we would never suff suffer from
- 28:55civilizational inferiority. Look, let me
- 28:57give you an example. you know, the uh
- 29:02the Ottoman polity was was uh was
- 29:08competitive
- 29:09militarily [clears throat]
- 29:11>> right up until the very very end.
- 29:14>> They defeated the British at Gallipoli,
- 29:18>> right? And they were the terror of the
- 29:21world right right up. They were taken
- 29:23very very seriously even though they
- 29:25called them the sick man of Europe and
- 29:26so on but they were a they're a major
- 29:28power. They had what the the third
- 29:31uh underground railway in the in the
- 29:34world and they had the the line going
- 29:35all the way from Istanbul to Medina.
- 29:38>> Uh and now
- 29:40>> and now they in the in the intervening
- 29:42hundred years when we all woke up and
- 29:44realized we need to catch up they
- 29:45couldn't even manage that
- 29:47>> you know. So um and and frankly you know
- 29:53if we had kept the if we had if we had
- 29:56managed to perpetuate we hadn't
- 29:58dismantled all of our traditional
- 30:00knowledge structures
- 30:03we would be doing far far better
- 30:05technologically now
- 30:07>> than we are we in fact are. The reason
- 30:10we're such a mess and it's so
- 30:12embarrassing is because the framework
- 30:15that would have given coherence to our
- 30:17activity in that realm was lost. Right?
- 30:20But if the Ottoman
- 30:22uh policy had persisted up until the
- 30:26present day,
- 30:27it it would be uh very much competitive
- 30:30with the rest of the world in terms of
- 30:32technological progress. And and of
- 30:34course people might say, well, you know,
- 30:36surely what you're saying is that
- 30:37wouldn't be consistent with our values.
- 30:38No, there's a degree of accommodation
- 30:40that has to take place with the, you
- 30:43know, there there is a degree to which
- 30:46it's necessary for Muslims to be
- 30:48competitive. They have to be able to
- 30:50protect themselves
- 30:51>> and um that's within Islamic massid and
- 30:55if that but that's again it's not some
- 30:57sort of anomaly of the modern world. I
- 30:59mean that goes right back to you know
- 31:01the the advent of cannon warfare you
- 31:03know which the Muslims are at the
- 31:04forefront of.
- 31:05So there's nothing
- 31:07>> I think I think most all of the
- 31:09gunpowder empires of the end of the
- 31:11medieval period of the nomadic gunpowder
- 31:12empires was just all Muslims
- 31:14>> most of them
- 31:15>> safi
- 31:16>> all of them all of them Ottomans
- 31:18themselves in the early stages. No, but
- 31:20here that there would also be a
- 31:22complaint here about sort of like of a
- 31:25of a trying to have your cake and eat it
- 31:27as well situation where um Muslims will
- 31:32lay out this whole framework about how
- 31:34metaphysically this whole thing this
- 31:36whole project has gone wrong. Europe is
- 31:38a godless rootless luciferian society
- 31:40and this is the apex of and then the
- 31:42esqueological angle will also come come
- 31:44in and at the end of their analysis
- 31:47there'll be a a subtle sort of caveat
- 31:49but you know we would have to compete
- 31:51the Ottomans would have done it and the
- 31:52Mles would have done it and developing
- 31:54these technologies in self-defense and
- 31:56these and the like it it would it would
- 31:58have been within the realm of
- 31:59reasonability and we would have reached
- 32:01the same conclusions as well. Then where
- 32:03is the the subtle if any the difference
- 32:06that that that that we claim that if we
- 32:08would have reached these similar
- 32:09technological conclusions or even better
- 32:12or even worse or even more terrifying or
- 32:14wondrous in their nature uh in their
- 32:16presentation at least uh then what's the
- 32:19what's the big deal? What's the big um
- 32:22big difference? Is it just the powers
- 32:23that wield these technologies and their
- 32:25worldview? Or is it something about the
- 32:28the the productive process that ends up
- 32:30with a nuclear bomb or with a hydrogen
- 32:32bomb or with a you know with one of
- 32:34these? Uh where does the problem lie?
- 32:38Well, the problem lies in the really
- 32:41most fundamentally in our state as
- 32:44individuals
- 32:46in virtue of the type of education that
- 32:48we receive in virtue of I'd say very
- 32:51very rampant problem in across the
- 32:53Muslim world in the mistaking of culture
- 32:56for religion and sometimes very very
- 33:01very very
- 33:03on a human level destructive practices
- 33:06dehumanizing practices is which become
- 33:09customary are then mistaken for
- 33:11religion.
- 33:12Um and I think it's summed up in the
- 33:15hadith of the prophet sallallaihi
- 33:16wasallam which is that
- 33:19he was speaking to the Sahabah. I'm
- 33:21probably not recounting this very very
- 33:22well. So I say
- 33:25the exact wording I'd like to have in
- 33:27front of me. But he was speaking to the
- 33:29Sahaba and he said at the end of time
- 33:30the Muslims will be overwhelmed by their
- 33:33enemies. And the Sahaba it's hard to
- 33:35imagine for them because of the you know
- 33:37the each of them was a kind of um I mean
- 33:39these were people who were in direct
- 33:42direct witnessing of the revelation and
- 33:45they said is it because of our small
- 33:47numbers at the time and he said no
- 33:48you'll be in huge numbers but you'll be
- 33:53you will be
- 33:54>> the scum of the waters.
- 33:56>> Exactly. I got in a lot of trouble for
- 33:58translating it as scum but that's the
- 33:59exact word is the exact word but it's
- 34:01because it has another meaning. Yes,
- 34:02>> which is related, but you could say um
- 34:05the foam and detritus on the torrent,
- 34:08right? They will be the foam and detus
- 34:10on the
- 34:11>> in and around the Arabian Sea,
- 34:13>> right? So, so you know this is I this
- 34:18can't really be much of a better
- 34:20diagnosis of our state. We because what
- 34:22does it mean? We've totally lost
- 34:23substantiality,
- 34:25right? We're on we're we're we're we're
- 34:27just these these this rubbish on the far
- 34:30be it from all of you on the uh on
- 34:33someone else's torrent, right?
- 34:36>> Someone else's wave.
- 34:37>> That's that's a fascinating reading into
- 34:39it. By the way, the the torrent because
- 34:41the torrent is something that is totally
- 34:43out of the control of the the the pawns
- 34:45scum or the the seafoam.
- 34:47>> Precisely. Exactly. And so we, you know,
- 34:49we we totally l lack our our own
- 34:51substantiality.
- 34:53>> And I think that basically sums up where
- 34:56state I state what what are we
- 34:58constantly doing? We're trying to
- 35:00position ourselves in terms of the
- 35:02latest mode, the latest fashion coming
- 35:04from the west. Whether it's a political
- 35:06fashion or an intellectual fashion or a
- 35:08social fashion, it's oh yeah, now we're
- 35:10going to do that too badly.
- 35:11>> And uh you know, but but it's going to
- 35:13be our own and you know, we we're caught
- 35:16up.
- 35:17>> Yes. So, so I think that's just a we
- 35:20it's very very difficult for us to break
- 35:21out of it. On the other hand,
- 35:24when non-Muslims encounter something
- 35:27really pristine from our tradition,
- 35:30which is not trying to play catchup,
- 35:32which is has its doesn't suffer from an
- 35:34inferiority complex, is doing what it
- 35:37should do, which is, you know, us being
- 35:41nurse that we are, you know, because of
- 35:43our unique status as the last nation
- 35:46following the perfect man, the
- 35:48prophetam, who is the who's the perfect
- 35:50balance between Jamal and Jalal.
- 35:52and and and and the perfect balance of
- 35:54attributes.
- 35:56>> Um, we have the ability to see things.
- 35:59We have a vantage point if we're true to
- 36:01that where we can see what's really
- 36:04going on in the world from a much higher
- 36:06vantage point than any other people,
- 36:08>> if we're true to ourselves, right? So
- 36:10when when non-Muslims encounter that
- 36:13pristine reality as my parents did when
- 36:15they went to Morocco and met Shik
- 36:17Muhammad Hhabib who's one of the last of
- 36:18the last of these really titanic
- 36:20spiritual figures
- 36:22>> uh totally untainted by modernity but
- 36:25not in a kind of reactive way just in
- 36:27terms of pure inheritance of
- 36:29>> and that's so so rare now but Yanni that
- 36:32that can have an extraordinary impact on
- 36:35the west
- 36:36>> we start having the mentality that we
- 36:39can heal and give and and provide the
- 36:42answers to the terrible impass that the
- 36:43west has now arrived at. The internet's
- 36:46been a really fascinating experience in
- 36:48that sense that uh for example the
- 36:51>> live and this is a very cynical sort of
- 36:53analysis but it's the live and constant
- 36:55exposure that the European and Western
- 36:57world have had to the Palestinians
- 36:59>> has been quite a shock for them and has
- 37:02led a lot of them to be humbled and awed
- 37:04by the
- 37:05>> the humility shakur the sort of patience
- 37:08that the Palestinian people have and
- 37:09this obviously inevitably attributed to
- 37:12their um Islamic values and
- 37:15and the like. Obviously, that's not the
- 37:17lesson from the Palestinian plight.
- 37:19[snorts] That's not the main lesson, but
- 37:21it's not something that that has gone
- 37:22unseen to a lot of uh non-Muslim
- 37:25audiences in the world.
- 37:26>> Oh, absolutely. No, I think there's been
- 37:30many people have been very very
- 37:31sincerely moved. I don't think that it's
- 37:33just I mean I think there is an extent
- 37:35to which it's just a kind of leftist
- 37:39>> but um but no,
- 37:40>> no, I don't mean that aspect of it. not
- 37:42the more propaganda is not the more sort
- 37:44of no
- 37:45>> but yeah you're right
- 37:46>> I was see become so cynical that you
- 37:48know
- 37:49>> sik you mentioned that this element of
- 37:52kadur right that we are where we are
- 37:55supposed to be a
- 37:56>> sense and then we have got some
- 37:58prophetic traditions which give us this
- 38:00overall idea of what the Muslim
- 38:04trajectory in this world would be like
- 38:06so I think in terms of like the Muslim
- 38:08liberal and the secular it's like they
- 38:09are playing the catch-up but the other
- 38:11side the ulma class or the people with a
- 38:14certain religious orientation towards
- 38:16the world they have this pacivity that
- 38:19they believe that because this overall
- 38:22let's say Islamic march of history if we
- 38:24can call it that or whatever it's it has
- 38:27already been decided there's like this
- 38:29deal of the spirit running through it of
- 38:31our like fluctuation in fluctuations in
- 38:34history as they look into you know the
- 38:36hadith about the end of times and you
- 38:39know like just like the hadis that you
- 38:42have mentioned. So how do like uh even
- 38:44the people with religious orientation
- 38:46who have this passivity like who are
- 38:48waiting for uh mami oral
- 38:52Islam to come back. So how do they break
- 38:55out of this let's say passivity where
- 38:58>> study engineering or medicine join the
- 39:00Awan or Jamaat Islami participate in the
- 39:03democratic republican process make an
- 39:05Islamic society
- 39:08step two something step three prophet
- 39:11[laughter]
- 39:19>> yeah what's the what's the way out man
- 39:21like he's right there's a fatalism in
- 39:23like a fatalistic sort of attitude with
- 39:25the religious community especially the
- 39:27elder community they would not
- 39:29especially the ones that were more
- 39:30attached to the tradition uh and not
- 39:33attached to these modernist movements
- 39:34the modernist types you know they had
- 39:35their own I they had a century I would
- 39:38say
- 39:39>> which is clearly to an at
- 39:40>> it's over yeah
- 39:41>> it's at an end and um the traditionalist
- 39:44types they stuck to their own guns maybe
- 39:46they had sporadic outbreaks in of
- 39:48political violence or the like but
- 39:50>> they mostly stuck to their guns with you
- 39:52know it's a fallen world and
- 39:54>> uh we have to maintain our own in our
- 39:57own you know in our own hisars in our
- 40:00own circles. What's what's what's the
- 40:03way especially for the lay person who's
- 40:06religiously oriented
- 40:07>> and then also for the scholarly class.
- 40:09>> Well, I don't think there's been a class
- 40:11for 100 years. I think that's a myth.
- 40:13the myth of the
- 40:15>> the existing palamat because uh Yani
- 40:21this is one of the privileges of having
- 40:24spent time with uh a lot of time for
- 40:27many many years with someone who
- 40:30was one one of the few existing aramat
- 40:33who if he had if we sent him back 150
- 40:37years in a time machine he would be
- 40:38accepted as one of the alamat
- 40:41>> um the vast vast majority of people who
- 40:43about by that name. Now, vast vast
- 40:46majority, 99.9%
- 40:48uh would not have been considered
- 40:50beginning
- 40:53um if you sent them back to the 1800s in
- 40:57Fangi Mahal or in um uh the Ottoman
- 41:02world.
- 41:03>> How many YouTube subscribers did those
- 41:05guys have
- 41:08[laughter]
- 41:09>> back in the day?
- 41:10>> How how many they have? Almost none.
- 41:12which I mean entails that they're
- 41:13worthless clearly.
- 41:14>> Clearly,
- 41:15>> but uh but no. Um
- 41:18>> did they have a Twitter beef with Piers
- 41:19Morgan? Any of them? [laughter]
- 41:22>> Had they bravely stood up to his gotcha
- 41:25questions? Cuz that's the litmus test of
- 41:27everything. [laughter] Oh, tra
- 41:31>> and where do they stand on Palestine?
- 41:34>> Sorry.
- 41:34>> Where do they stand on the Palestine
- 41:35issue?
- 41:36>> Well, there you go. That's [laughter]
- 41:38that's the only question worth asking.
- 41:40There something that you said by the way
- 41:41is very offensive in the subcontent
- 41:43culture by the way nobody says that here
- 41:45>> there is a still I think the steam
- 41:47original steam is still there the engine
- 41:50is running on fumes but we still sort of
- 41:53just parrot that sort of statement that
- 41:55the amah will the ama class but that
- 41:59>> we all kind of think it
- 42:01>> we all kind of think it deep down
- 42:03>> there's no they're all positivists they
- 42:05don't have an Islamic worldview
- 42:07>> they've got a little bit of fip and
- 42:09they've got a little bit of Arabic
- 42:10language sciences that's all they have
- 42:12>> the the the presently existing they
- 42:15don't have a an Islamic worldview the a
- 42:18metaphysical outlook which is again that
- 42:20subordinated model of the senses that
- 42:22it's been lost and that's partly because
- 42:24the aat which is the intellectual senses
- 42:26were lost is that desire like an
- 42:29impossible desire to try to revive
- 42:32something that that
- 42:35in its essence it's not it wasn't
- 42:37tangible even then but when it's gone
- 42:39it's gone.
- 42:40>> I don't think that people should try to
- 42:42revise it. Revive it. I think that um
- 42:44it's a a futile exercise in museum
- 42:47curation. Um where you know we've we've
- 42:50lost a living tradition which would give
- 42:52that meaning.
- 42:53>> Yes.
- 42:54>> And it becomes a kind of lapping
- 42:55exercise, right? You know, it's kind of
- 42:57live action roleplay. We get together
- 42:58and put on our turbons and read matune.
- 43:00It's like, oh, we're keeping the
- 43:01tradition going. And it's y I'm not
- 43:04saying that it's uh devoid of any value.
- 43:06Um I don't mean to pour scorn on it. I
- 43:08do think that if you want to
- 43:11do be engaged in the kind of activity
- 43:14that we really need to be doing then you
- 43:16need to master our tradition as best as
- 43:18you know one needs to be become
- 43:20acquainted with the tradition in in as
- 43:22much depth as possible um
- 43:25>> and uh and and not to at all belittle
- 43:27any aspect of tradition we should know
- 43:29kalam we should know all of the
- 43:31traditional Islamic sciences while being
- 43:34cognizant of the fact that it's you know
- 43:36it's far far beyond this idea that some
- 43:38people have that, oh, it's basically
- 43:40just you need to revive the tradition.
- 43:42You and you're going to read a 600-y old
- 43:44Calam book, but you're just going to add
- 43:45a new chapter on like evolution and a
- 43:48new chapter on like, you know,
- 43:50bioeththics and new chapter on
- 43:52nanotechnology and new chapter on, you
- 43:55know, that kind of mentality
- 43:57>> and um that's just it's it's a total
- 44:00misreading, misdiagnosis of the problem
- 44:04>> and failure to to recognize. I think
- 44:06this is the biggest problem that we
- 44:08face. We are now in a postapocalyptic
- 44:13situation. We are we are now in the
- 44:14position of the people who got hit on
- 44:15the head very very hard indeed and they
- 44:18woke up and they couldn't quite remember
- 44:21any what was what happened and who they
- 44:23are and what but they they've got little
- 44:25fragments and little signs of this and
- 44:27that of of of who they were and what
- 44:29they should be doing and but they don't
- 44:31really know and that's our state and and
- 44:33the illusion of an intact class is one
- 44:36of the worst but but they're laughing
- 44:38stocks as well
- 44:40>> why it's not just it's not because and
- 44:42then there's this kind conflict is
- 44:44should we be pious and pretend that
- 44:46they're really amazing because they're
- 44:47our class but actually it's coming from
- 44:49a pretty sincere place the fra knows
- 44:51that they're not the class that's why
- 44:53they're laughing at them
- 44:54>> right because what happened and there's
- 44:57so many different aspects of this one of
- 44:58the things is in the past
- 45:02the brightest person in the family right
- 45:05you would aspire for them let's say just
- 45:07to go to the aar
- 45:09>> because that's the absolute apex who who
- 45:12would be trained as an Ireland. It was
- 45:14the the most talented, the absolutely
- 45:16most ppeacious, most intelligent
- 45:18children would be would go down that
- 45:20path. And you know, again, there's so
- 45:23many different aspects to this, but now
- 45:25of course it's quite the opposite. If
- 45:26you have a bal in the family, if you
- 45:27have someone who's a bit dim in the
- 45:29family, he's mishi, send him off to
- 45:31Sharia, cuz there's no requirements to
- 45:33get in. It's all really easy mad. It's
- 45:36seen as kind of humanity's light, right?
- 45:38again because it's got nothing to do
- 45:39with traditional alum the traditional
- 45:42subordinated uh model of the sciences
- 45:45which is as technical as it is possible
- 45:47for you know for the human brain to
- 45:50uh to as a framework as it possible for
- 45:54the human intellect to envisage. So um
- 45:57and then you know there were certain
- 45:58measures that took place again you know
- 46:01what what Musbury says about mistaking a
- 46:03a marshall victory for an intellectual
- 46:05victory. He says also the reason that
- 46:08the traditional alum fell out of favor
- 46:10was not because they there was in any
- 46:12sense had been shown up to be deficient.
- 46:15It's quite contrary. Because those who
- 46:18were collaborating with the colonial
- 46:20powers in order to gain whatever petty
- 46:24uh positions of power they wanted to be
- 46:26able to gain uh uh formed on their these
- 46:32new positivistic knowledge systems in
- 46:33order to carry favor with those who
- 46:36right
- 46:38from whom they sought various favors and
- 46:40benefits. Um and uh so it's not a
- 46:46again it's uh it's not an issue of there
- 46:50being any understanding of what is being
- 46:52rejected. That's the problem. We don't
- 46:54understand our own tradition. We're
- 46:55always talking about what would be the
- 46:56ideal Islamic state. So we're put we're
- 46:58putting the the cup before the the horse
- 47:01on every and then people say, "Oh,
- 47:02that's quietism or it's not being
- 47:04concerned with the day-to-day." But the
- 47:06reality is, you know, sure, if you're
- 47:08going to, you need a roof over your head
- 47:11right now.
- 47:12>> So, you're going to cobble something
- 47:14together and say, "Oh, I've got a, you
- 47:15know, I did it in a day. I've got a roof
- 47:17over my head." But that's not where you
- 47:19want to live,
- 47:20>> right? No.
- 47:21>> And the only way that you're going to
- 47:22live where you want to live is by going
- 47:23back to the drawing board and
- 47:24understanding what went wrong. Why do
- 47:26you have such poor
- 47:27>> uh building materials at your disposal?
- 47:29Why is everything such a mess?
- 47:31>> A reformation of Islamic thought,
- 47:34>> right? you have highlighted the
- 47:36importance of you know having coherent
- 47:38worldviews to look at things. Now uh
- 47:42again I don't want to delve into like
- 47:44the controversy of the opinion of Shikh
- 47:47Hamla Yusf and Shik Abdul Hakimarat may
- 47:49Allah preserve them both of this
- 47:52observing the Palestinian or even the
- 47:54Syrian cause through a proper worldview
- 47:56where we have this idea of theology of
- 47:59obedience
- 48:00>> you know as it has been called
- 48:02>> where uh when let's say the Palestinians
- 48:05or the Syrians they try to rebel or
- 48:08fight for their cause it is almost seen
- 48:10as you know a rebellion against the
- 48:12divine order.
- 48:14>> So those are some of like you know the
- 48:17let's say the other end of consequences
- 48:19of you know having a worldview and
- 48:22observing everything through them like I
- 48:25guess maybe um I'm not aware of any
- 48:27other perspective on this uh which looks
- 48:30at the Palestinian cause within a
- 48:32worldview other than Shik Hamza Yusf's
- 48:35and and maybe Shikh [snorts] Abdul Man
- 48:37Taha's worldview. So is there a
- 48:40particularly Akbarian view of or
- 48:42Akbarian perspective of viewing the
- 48:45Palestinian issue which let's say cannot
- 48:48be perceived by um any other
- 48:50>> mortalize.
- 48:52>> Yeah. Any other way of looking at
- 48:53>> immortalize?
- 48:55>> Yeah. Yeah. So is there like a
- 48:56particularly Akbarian way of looking at
- 48:58the Palestinian um issue where it's not
- 49:02just reduced to you know quietism or a
- 49:06pacifism
- 49:07>> be even sometimes humiliation like Azi
- 49:10Ysef and and the like would they often
- 49:12even in private gatherings people like
- 49:14that who think like that they often poke
- 49:15fun at the
- 49:18>> or ridicule even in public the the idea
- 49:20of the Syrian people or the Palestinian
- 49:22people attempting these sorts of uh
- 49:24power grabs. let's say
- 49:26>> uh as opposed to capitulating to a power
- 49:29center in the UAE or a Saudi or a Turkey
- 49:32or a Pakistan or wherever wherever in
- 49:34the Muslim world you are and wherever
- 49:36you can find the closest western access
- 49:40>> uh to latch on to or eastern access in
- 49:42the case of Iran. I think uh if anyone
- 49:45is ever unable to speak because of uh
- 49:50standing in in danger of losing
- 49:52something um and they're in the the the
- 49:56they have at least the expectation that
- 49:58they are supposed to be in in class then
- 50:02they need to get out of there as soon as
- 50:04possible and it's an absolute necessity
- 50:06to speak the truth um regardless of the
- 50:10consequences uh because otherwise the
- 50:13the Muslim Muslims simply lack guidance
- 50:17and leadership. Where else are they
- 50:19going to find it? However, you know, I I
- 50:21think there's also a danger of um very
- 50:24very simplistic as we were discussing
- 50:26earlier kind of leftistwani katharsis
- 50:30that you say the right you condemn the
- 50:31right thing on in a podcast and like you
- 50:34cry [laughter] and stuff and then you
- 50:36know it's like wow he's so amazing he's
- 50:37a hero and it's like what was achieved
- 50:40guys yanni what was achieved so there's
- 50:43a balance I I I agree that it's
- 50:45absolutely outrageous um that certain
- 50:48individuals were uh quiet at a time when
- 50:52they should have spoken up. There's no
- 50:54justification for it. and uh and and you
- 50:58know but but with that with that
- 51:02condemnation should should also come a
- 51:06confession that the reason that we're in
- 51:08this state the reason that we're
- 51:10powerless the reason that we're begging
- 51:12at the table of international justice
- 51:15from Mcavelians we're begging them for
- 51:18fair treatment and for them to apply
- 51:20international law
- 51:22>> which we don't realize is structurally
- 51:24impossible there's no possibility of the
- 51:26application of international law.
- 51:27They're all mavalians. Their might is
- 51:29racists. They're laughing at us, right?
- 51:33Um and the fact that we have to be in a
- 51:35begging position. [clears throat]
- 51:37Um I think is um you know that
- 51:43condemnation needs to come with a
- 51:44confession that you know we're in a pit
- 51:46pit pitiable state because of our
- 51:50imaginary amat class which went extinct
- 51:53150 years ago failed.
- 51:54>> Yeah. An extreme form of that like
- 51:56there's a really funny thing that I was
- 51:57shared in one of the groups I'm on is
- 51:59the uh it was the politics and poetics
- 52:01on the ruins of Gaza.
- 52:04uh it was a symposium that was uh
- 52:07conducted on the 16th of December 2025
- 52:09in the University of Chicago. Like they
- 52:11haven't even waited for the actual
- 52:13destruction to happen and the politics
- 52:16and poetics of the ruins of Gaza has
- 52:18already the art and the the the the left
- 52:22politics is already coming out of it.
- 52:24>> Yeah. Yeah,
- 52:24>> the performative sort of very like low
- 52:26life scum sort of
- 52:28>> um yeah what's the appeal here in
- 52:30Pakistan like so Pakistan when it has to
- 52:33for example justify its positions on
- 52:35Palestine it'll say that oh you know we
- 52:36appealed to the UN and we submitted the
- 52:38right document or whatever and even in
- 52:41many of those cases by the way Muslim
- 52:42states did not perform but this appeal
- 52:45to international authority
- 52:47>> it's not just the impetance of the lack
- 52:49of our our material capabilities it's
- 52:52also I suspect that primarily this u um
- 52:56we're running around like headless
- 52:57chickens not knowing what we're uh
- 53:00civilization is supposed to be.
- 53:03>> I think we're exactly as you say simply
- 53:06just we're very naive. We we never look
- 53:08into what international law purports to
- 53:10be. Um you know the fact that it's
- 53:12rooted in natural law. What is natural
- 53:15law? What are the alternatives? Why is
- 53:18natural law constantly in a a losing
- 53:21battle with its main rival
- 53:22machavelianism?
- 53:23>> Yes.
- 53:24>> Um it's because of the the the
- 53:26metaphysical structural metaphysical
- 53:28problems and deficiencies which from our
- 53:31perspective which for the for the west
- 53:33constitute the height of of progress in
- 53:35human sophistication. Um which is
- 53:38basically again in unavoidably the
- 53:40extent to which well what is ethics? How
- 53:43are we supposed to behave and how does
- 53:45that then translate into a framework of
- 53:47international law? Um is politics rooted
- 53:51as it is in the sub in the subordinated
- 53:53model of the sciences which again
- 53:55dominated both the west and the Islamic
- 53:56world in ethics and then what determines
- 53:59ethics? What determines the good? How do
- 54:01you define the good? How do we as
- 54:03Muslims define the good? Right? That's
- 54:05the fundamental question of ethics.
- 54:07Ethics must be rooted in metaphysics.
- 54:10Right? in a traditional Islamic
- 54:13worldview
- 54:15but but but but the good in the secular
- 54:17world is defined in all sorts of
- 54:19different ways. So you know by epicurans
- 54:22originally and then it translated into
- 54:25the empiricists like lock and so on. The
- 54:27the good is pleasure.
- 54:29>> Yes.
- 54:30>> The good is the pleasurable
- 54:31>> maximization of the the
- 54:33>> and then the utilitarians it becomes the
- 54:35maximalization you know society at
- 54:38large. So um but it's still
- 54:41fundamentally that hedonistic what's
- 54:42called a hedenistic uh understanding of
- 54:45the good.
- 54:46>> Um and so you know what is that rooted
- 54:49in metaphysically
- 54:51hedonism? Always it's rooted in in
- 54:53empiricism. Why? Because if your if
- 54:57you're an empiricist and you believe
- 54:58that all your true knowledge claims your
- 55:00objective knowledge claims are not
- 55:01merely subjective have to be rooted in
- 55:03empirical reality. Well, it's impossible
- 55:06to root uh anything but a hedonistic
- 55:09ethics in empirical reality because
- 55:13pleasure is at least quantifiable and so
- 55:17that becomes your only candidate.
- 55:18>> Yes.
- 55:19>> And if pleasure is your only candidate
- 55:22for a hedonistic ethics. Can you see how
- 55:24macavelianism is going to very soon take
- 55:27over? You know there are a lot of Muslim
- 55:30liberal thinking you know public figures
- 55:32thinkers they argue that you know
- 55:34>> what's really all that bad about that
- 55:37>> they do argue that now I hear that
- 55:39sometimes am I crazy but they say that
- 55:41what's all that to you know minimizing
- 55:43pain maximizing pleasure the two gods of
- 55:45hedonism and
- 55:46>> you know worldview like that where we
- 55:48could maximize and then they add like a
- 55:50little utilitarian sort of spice to it
- 55:52like we can maximize it for the largest
- 55:54number of people in the best outcome
- 55:55possible.
- 55:56>> There's nothing wrong with that. just
- 55:57just go along to get along type thing
- 55:58that this is what they'll say basically
- 56:00>> there's nothing wrong with it but it's
- 56:01just the most superficial surface level
- 56:04of human flourishing and it totally
- 56:07ignores everything that really matters
- 56:09to human beings and what they don't
- 56:10realize is that it comes from a million
- 56:12and Benthamite you know Mill and Bentham
- 56:15they're obviously very close because of
- 56:16John Stewart Mill's father was a close
- 56:18associate of Bentham um but um you know
- 56:22again the as I endlessly repeat I'm sure
- 56:25it becomes very boring a you problem
- 56:27where like you are unable to appreciate
- 56:29that this steak is a stake and instead
- 56:31it is a line of zeros and ones and you
- 56:33know what I mean
- 56:34>> it's a me problem
- 56:35>> this is a you like if if one is if one
- 56:38sort of uh you know removes themselves
- 56:40from this sort of thinking and allows
- 56:42themselves to enjoy the processes and
- 56:45the excitements of AI and
- 56:47>> oh yeah
- 56:47>> whatever
- 56:48>> I love it
- 56:49>> whatever slop that they're serving up
- 56:50now and
- 56:52>> it's not that bad you know [laughter]
- 56:56Absolutely. I I agree. It's it's uh it's
- 56:59extremely enjoyable to rot in one's pod
- 57:02in the modern world. [laughter]
- 57:03Absolutely. It's fantastic. Order the
- 57:04food and uh just sit there watching
- 57:07movies and playing video games. It's
- 57:09fantastic.
- 57:10>> But um and you know, rotting on on fried
- 57:14chicken and so on. But uh no it's uh you
- 57:18know
- 57:20precisely it's about looking at the
- 57:22metaphysical assumptions which underly
- 57:25um uh let's say those surface level
- 57:28truths. So we all want to maximize uh
- 57:31happiness for as many people as possible
- 57:33of course but what are the evaluative
- 57:35criteria which uh which determine our
- 57:38notion of human flourishing. Yes. And
- 57:40that's why it goes back to Mill um and
- 57:44you know who's obviously the most
- 57:45important architect of utilitarianism
- 57:48um and and and also you know the most
- 57:52well he's the most important theorist of
- 57:54liberalism
- 57:56and he is the most important architect
- 57:59of modern feminism as well and they all
- 58:01the these all really go together very
- 58:03nicely um again because of the
- 58:05metaphysical assumptions underlying
- 58:07them. So you know in on in on liberty
- 58:10his famous work um Mill uh talks about
- 58:15the harm principle. Now the harm
- 58:18principle is very important for us as as
- 58:22modern Muslims because it's basically
- 58:24the only thing we really believe in as
- 58:25an objective ethical principle because
- 58:28we have no idea what our own traditional
- 58:30ethical framework would say about
- 58:31anything. M
- 58:32>> and so we we we tend to just you know be
- 58:36passive inhalers of of whatever
- 58:38sentiments happen to dominate on the
- 58:40western street and you know the average
- 58:43western person the only thing they they
- 58:45would standardly tell you there's no
- 58:46objective morality of course cuz like
- 58:49what would determine that that's just
- 58:50dogmatic but you know what I live by is
- 58:54as long as you're not hurting anyone
- 58:55else as long as you're not hurting
- 58:56anyone you can do anything you want
- 58:58right that's the harm principle
- 59:00>> but what's the what's the what's the
- 59:01hidden dogmatism in the harm principle.
- 59:04It's an empiricist dogma. There's
- 59:06nothing neutral about it.
- 59:07>> Yeah. The bodily
- 59:08>> it's the definition of harm.
- 59:09>> Yeah.
- 59:10>> And it's the it's the it's the dogmatic
- 59:12exclusion of any possibility of
- 59:14objective moral
- 59:16>> or spiritual harm.
- 59:18>> So it's only bodily harm. Maybe slander,
- 59:20maybe harm to your reputation. You could
- 59:21sue some someone or something. But but
- 59:23the but [snorts] but that that is again
- 59:26determined by Mill's unwavering
- 59:29empiricism. And he says in
- 59:33um uh on liberty the the only
- 59:37justification. So it's this kind of
- 59:39negative this principle of negative
- 59:41liberty which is non-inference.
- 59:44You know liberty is just non-inference.
- 59:46You can do whatever you want. They put
- 59:47it as crudely as that
- 59:49>> and
- 59:50>> do what th will.
- 59:51>> Yeah. And the job of the state and the
- 59:52job of your friends and the job of you
- 59:54know the the critical mass of society is
- 59:57to facilitate as much arbitrary
- 1:00:00individual freedom as possible without
- 1:00:02let or hindrance. So you as long as no
- 1:00:04one's harming anyone else. And that's
- 1:00:06because of the definition of the good.
- 1:00:08What does Mill say? He says it serves
- 1:00:11everyone better
- 1:00:13>> uh to let everyone get on with he's very
- 1:00:16eloquent. He doesn't say it like that.
- 1:00:18Let everyone get on with pursuing
- 1:00:22in their their life's course their own
- 1:00:25conception of the good. So So modern
- 1:00:28liberal society.
- 1:00:29>> So it's like bowling alone with the
- 1:00:31safety guards on. [laughter]
- 1:00:34>> Exactly.
- 1:00:34>> You know it's the you remember that
- 1:00:35bowling alone. What was it? What was
- 1:00:37that book called?
- 1:00:38>> Bowling alone.
- 1:00:39>> Bowling alone.
- 1:00:40>> Yeah. Bowling alone but with this the
- 1:00:41safety guards on because you can't even
- 1:00:43>> Exactly. cuz that's
- 1:00:44>> going like a gutter ball would be
- 1:00:47>> it would be
- 1:00:48>> exactly
- 1:00:48>> it would be harmful to the the ego or
- 1:00:50whatever.
- 1:00:51>> Exactly.
- 1:00:51>> And then you wouldn't get an animation
- 1:00:52of the pins, you know.
- 1:00:55>> So you you've again emphasized the
- 1:00:56importance of the Muslim ethical
- 1:00:59framework which stands in sharp contrast
- 1:01:01to the modern you know understanding of
- 1:01:04ethics and politics. But in actuality
- 1:01:08like the entire world order it again
- 1:01:11revolves around this Makavelian approach
- 1:01:13to politics
- 1:01:14>> inevitably.
- 1:01:15>> Yeah. Inevitably. So when Muslim want
- 1:01:17Muslims want to do politics and if they
- 1:01:21want to do politics there is no other
- 1:01:23way to do it except through that
- 1:01:26realistian
- 1:01:28you know approach. And if they take that
- 1:01:30approach they end up compromising their
- 1:01:32Muslim ethos.
- 1:01:33>> So isn't this like a dilemma that they
- 1:01:34face? What's the dilemma? Don't
- 1:01:36compromise your Muslim ethos
- 1:01:38>> and lose.
- 1:01:40>> We've already lost. We've already lost
- 1:01:42on that plane. And we're playing
- 1:01:44catchup. And And we're playing catchup
- 1:01:46in such a way that we must compromise
- 1:01:48our Muslim ethos. So how is how is
- 1:01:50victory ever possible? Victory for who?
- 1:01:52When we're not ourselves anymore.
- 1:01:54>> Subhan Allah.
- 1:01:55>> Yeah.
- 1:01:55>> So
- 1:01:56>> so denaturing ourselves to the point
- 1:01:58that we are not recognizable as Muslims,
- 1:02:01then winning then it's not winning, is
- 1:02:03it? It's not winning as Muslims. Yeah,
- 1:02:05>> it's not winning.
- 1:02:06>> Yeah, it's not it's not winning. We won
- 1:02:08for a thousand years, but
- 1:02:10>> that was enough. We should So, we should
- 1:02:12get over this idea of this uh this this
- 1:02:15this conquest binary sort of 01 winning
- 1:02:18and losing.
- 1:02:18>> We have the spiritual sovereignty. We
- 1:02:21possess the metaphysical sovereignty and
- 1:02:24the spiritual sovereignty by nature
- 1:02:28intrinsically rather
- 1:02:30>> and we can access that anytime we want
- 1:02:33you know
- 1:02:40it's a promise in the Quran
- 1:02:44that's the condition right you will
- 1:02:46prevail if you're right but but
- 1:02:49intrinsically
- 1:02:51intrinsically and the reality is in this
- 1:02:54world and in the next if we were true to
- 1:02:57ourselves we would prevail. So when when
- 1:03:00advising rulers and and and and people
- 1:03:03who and when advising advisers to rulers
- 1:03:06in and around our society, [snorts]
- 1:03:08>> is it that that they're shortsighted and
- 1:03:11they act out of uh uh in the best case
- 1:03:14when they act out of a genuine desire to
- 1:03:16better Muslim society, but they end up
- 1:03:19compromising Muslim Muslim ethos. The
- 1:03:22advice to them should be be patient, let
- 1:03:25it go, take the take the loss, be able
- 1:03:29to
- 1:03:30be able to bear this uh material burden,
- 1:03:35you know, with grace because the
- 1:03:37politician doesn't think like that. The
- 1:03:38political figure doesn't think like
- 1:03:39that. They think of very short-term, you
- 1:03:42know,
- 1:03:43>> of course, I'm not advocating any kind
- 1:03:45of uh pacivity at all. I'm not saying
- 1:03:48that short-term projects, you know,
- 1:03:50proximate gain shouldn't be pursued, but
- 1:03:52I'm saying that the most fundamental
- 1:03:53thing that should be pursued is a
- 1:03:55fundamental
- 1:03:57re discovery and rrooting of our
- 1:04:00[snorts] worldview.
- 1:04:02Um and uh that can only take place if
- 1:04:05there's an awful lot of deconstruction
- 1:04:07not that I like to use the word but that
- 1:04:08actually has to take place is Moana
- 1:04:12removing obstacles because our main
- 1:04:13problem is we're thinking in terms of
- 1:04:15frameworks which are alien to us that we
- 1:04:18don't really understand and not at all
- 1:04:19they're actually quite antithetical to
- 1:04:21our real and so those need to be
- 1:04:23dismantled not not wholesale there are
- 1:04:25things that absolutely many things that
- 1:04:27can be kept
- 1:04:29>> but uh it's the it's the governing
- 1:04:31spirit um that needs to be rediscovered
- 1:04:34and that is I'll put it in very stark
- 1:04:36and simple terms. It is the I know
- 1:04:38people don't like it to be too simple
- 1:04:40but it's the reality. It's the
- 1:04:42rediscovery of the spiritual presence,
- 1:04:47the spiritual depth of the prophet
- 1:04:49sallallahu alaihi wasallam.
- 1:04:51>> That was the the most devastating thing
- 1:04:53that happened to us was us becoming a
- 1:04:56textualist religion,
- 1:04:58>> a legalistic religion. It's about
- 1:05:00bobbing up and down up and down and
- 1:05:02ticking boxes of Sharia. And then there
- 1:05:05these whole domains you know the the
- 1:05:07Islamic secular which um you know you
- 1:05:10just got on with it and and uh you know
- 1:05:12whatever whatever works whatever is the
- 1:05:14zeitgeist whatever prevails cuz again
- 1:05:16the secular assumption that somehow this
- 1:05:18is all just up for grabs you you you
- 1:05:21choose how you want to proceed because
- 1:05:23the the dean has nothing to say about
- 1:05:25it. So there's this loss of holism and
- 1:05:28so instead of becoming a religion based
- 1:05:32on embodying
- 1:05:34mirroring imaging the perfect man
- 1:05:36spiritually in terms of that spiritual
- 1:05:38aulgence
- 1:05:40>> that's why you had people like and you
- 1:05:42had people like Sha and you had people
- 1:05:45these are these were honey luminous
- 1:05:49individuals who transformed people
- 1:05:51around them and that's that's what's
- 1:05:53been lost
- 1:05:54>> and if we have those individuals as we
- 1:05:56used to on every street corner, we'd be
- 1:05:58a very very different people
- 1:05:59>> and the and and the non-Muslims who
- 1:06:01encountered us would be like as they
- 1:06:02were
- 1:06:04>> would be totally mbah.
- 1:06:05>> But that's not the case anymore. They
- 1:06:07look at us and they see a kind of
- 1:06:09darkness and they see a kind of
- 1:06:12>> something creepy and a bit disturbing
- 1:06:14because that's our state.
- 1:06:16>> Yeah.
- 1:06:16>> We've turned away from
- 1:06:18>> everything that makes us who we purport
- 1:06:21to be. H I mean there's this uh
- 1:06:24Pakistani Muslim philosopher Emma Jawad
- 1:06:26he had this uh saying that like we have
- 1:06:30the same Quran and we have the same a
- 1:06:31hadik but the model that represented
- 1:06:34them that has been lost.
- 1:06:35>> Exactly.
- 1:06:36>> So
- 1:06:37are there again again that's a that's a
- 1:06:40real problem that we do not have that
- 1:06:42models that the youth or the Muslims
- 1:06:44could look up to. So in in terms of like
- 1:06:47the political sphere all around the
- 1:06:49globe, do do you feel that um there
- 1:06:52might be any individual or any group
- 1:06:54that has at least tried to embody that
- 1:06:58you know
- 1:06:59>> and why is it the Taliban?
- 1:07:04[laughter]
- 1:07:04>> Yeah. So like are there any groups or
- 1:07:06like any particular individual who has
- 1:07:08actually tried and succeeded to some
- 1:07:10extent?
- 1:07:11>> What model?
- 1:07:12Um I mean if we can talk about the ensan
- 1:07:17camel the perfect man as a let's say as
- 1:07:19an institution or as as an individual.
- 1:07:21Do we have any examples in the modern
- 1:07:23world from like the Muslim world?
- 1:07:26>> There are many many examples. I mean the
- 1:07:29thing is whatever I say I'm I'm digging
- 1:07:31my own grave because you know so
- 1:07:34[laughter]
- 1:07:35there's there's going to be some
- 1:07:36deficiency in in one domain or another.
- 1:07:38That's our state. Um and you know people
- 1:07:43I feel very safe with but people
- 1:07:45immediately say political quietism
- 1:07:47political which I don't actually I don't
- 1:07:49accept that that's the case. It's not
- 1:07:51what I've seen. But uh I would say the
- 1:07:53Baloise for example in in Tim in Yemen
- 1:07:58>> I think that um they are they are
- 1:08:01absolutely on the right path
- 1:08:03>> um because what they're trying to do is
- 1:08:06to wonder a better word to channel to
- 1:08:09manifest and they all sound like kind of
- 1:08:11dodgy [laughter] occult words
- 1:08:13the the the the spiritual reality of the
- 1:08:15prophetam we went wrong when we started
- 1:08:18to look at the prophetam as a kind of
- 1:08:20cute uncle kind of cosmic cosmic postman
- 1:08:23type guy who was he was really nice and
- 1:08:25he came and now he's gone and you know
- 1:08:28he gave us the book that we have and we
- 1:08:30just have to read it and and follow the
- 1:08:32book. It's true. Don't think I'm of
- 1:08:35course the book but
- 1:08:37>> but the the the the dimensions of depth
- 1:08:40of the book the spiritual openings that
- 1:08:42that that can be accessed that the the
- 1:08:45the oceans of of meaning and of
- 1:08:48spiritual depth and and of access to
- 1:08:51numinosity of that book that the there
- 1:08:54has to be a human key. The human key is
- 1:08:58the uswah of the prophet Islam which is
- 1:09:01not just a list of outward
- 1:09:02characteristics. It's a spiritual
- 1:09:04reality. The moment we rejected that
- 1:09:08notion, we lost everything.
- 1:09:11>> The the prophetam was a presence.
- 1:09:14>> We're supposed to say, "Oh, no. That was
- 1:09:16just for that time." Yeah. The Sahaba
- 1:09:18did, you know, on everything to do with
- 1:09:20the prophet Islam and the did as well.
- 1:09:24But then uh 30 years later it became
- 1:09:26haram complete shake immediately just
- 1:09:29there was a cut off point
- 1:09:30>> that doesn't make any sense you know the
- 1:09:32prophetam said he gave a prayer which
- 1:09:36saysith
- 1:09:39accepted by everyone now called
- 1:09:42right
- 1:09:50he gave this to one of the sahaba to say
- 1:09:53Not in his presence.
- 1:09:56Right.
- 1:10:08And I im Ahmed, right? But then it's
- 1:10:11like half an hour later like, "Oh, no,
- 1:10:13no. Prophetam's dead." You know,
- 1:10:17>> yes, his body's dead, but don't we as
- 1:10:19Muslims believe that people go into a
- 1:10:20bar and they're alive? I was just
- 1:10:22wondering like is that a strange
- 1:10:24esoteric belief that you believe in life
- 1:10:26after death? Is it
- 1:10:29um there's another hadith which is
- 1:10:31slightly less strong but many would say
- 1:10:33it's saying
- 1:10:39right so uh don't we believe in a anyway
- 1:10:42>> anyways yeah
- 1:10:43>> yeah I thought we believed in anyway so
- 1:10:45you know
- 1:10:47normative beliefs for a thousand years
- 1:10:51suddenly cast in doubt in a uh in a
- 1:10:54strikingly Protestant manner
- 1:10:57you know,
- 1:10:58>> uh and um and then we everything
- 1:11:02collapses and we're told the best of my
- 1:11:05um is this generation and then the ones
- 1:11:07immediately following them following
- 1:11:09them and yet our narrative is oh we went
- 1:11:12terribly wrong for all of history until
- 1:11:15the 18th century and nudged
- 1:11:17>> right and then we got it right suddenly
- 1:11:20but you know everyone else was a
- 1:11:21mushriick I mean come on does anyone
- 1:11:23really believe that
- 1:11:24>> the prophet
- 1:11:25says the best of my um is this and then
- 1:11:28that generation then that generation
- 1:11:30>> right and I don't fear shik for my
- 1:11:32community I feel I fe I fear their love
- 1:11:34of dy and then the whole religion
- 1:11:36becomes about fear of shik in the 18th
- 1:11:39century
- 1:11:41no one can really believe that who's
- 1:11:43sincere Muslim in my humble opinion
- 1:11:47[laughter]
- 1:11:54[clears throat] Um yeah that was
- 1:11:56offensive to multiple communities in
- 1:11:58Pakistan. Your insistence that the
- 1:12:00prophet's corporeal form has passed to
- 1:12:03the Braille wheels. Your insistence on
- 1:12:05critiquing Naji the the najid davawa to
- 1:12:10the alis as well as the liberal
- 1:12:12community in Pakistan.
- 1:12:14Um
- 1:12:16it's fascinating all around
- 1:12:20I think is uh
- 1:12:22>> I'm thinking about what else
- 1:12:24>> I didn't mean his corporeal form has
- 1:12:25passed in that sense.
- 1:12:27>> No, of course not.
- 1:12:28>> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:12:29>> Of course not.
- 1:12:30>> Like the shada. Of course.
- 1:12:31>> Yes.
- 1:12:34>> Sal. Yeah.
- 1:12:38>> Yeah. I never I never understood why
- 1:12:40that became such a big deal. by the way
- 1:12:42never understood as a lay person like
- 1:12:44because we believe in the bers and
- 1:12:46nobody's actually really you know gone
- 1:12:50>> yeah of course um no I mean um I'm not
- 1:12:53advocating braille theism or debandism
- 1:12:56or this or that I think these are all
- 1:12:58reactionary postcolonial movements the
- 1:13:01the um you know I'm I'm a fangi mahalist
- 1:13:04really
- 1:13:05>> yeah [laughter]
- 1:13:08that's where the back stops
- 1:13:10kalas Anything after the Indian mutiny
- 1:13:12it's not really
- 1:13:15>> anything after the Indian mutiny is not
- 1:13:16your your jam.
- 1:13:18>> No I mean it's all over it's a basket
- 1:13:20case after that.
- 1:13:22>> No but say is seen as one of the
- 1:13:24founding fathers of Pakistan.
- 1:13:25>> Yeah. Sorry about that. [laughter]
- 1:13:29>> I just insulted a few
- 1:13:32>> are you are you not able are you not
- 1:13:33able to sympathize with say Khan and
- 1:13:35that kind of that kind of
- 1:13:37>> No. just from a human like not even from
- 1:13:39a religious person
- 1:13:42like I get it.
- 1:13:44>> No, I totally get it. No, I do get it. I
- 1:13:46100% get it. The thing is uh the west at
- 1:13:48that time was very very impressive. It's
- 1:13:50the same thing that when Alawi was sent
- 1:13:53by Hassan from Alad to Paris and wrote
- 1:13:56that book. No, he didn't write a book
- 1:13:58called The Imm in Paris, but he wrote
- 1:13:59his own book and then Yeah. Um and uh
- 1:14:03you know, he was like, you know, the
- 1:14:04wide boulevards and it was clean and the
- 1:14:06you know, women going around with their
- 1:14:08their umbrellas and their lovely dresses
- 1:14:10and the lovely boutiques and and
- 1:14:13petisseries.
- 1:14:15It was all and the trams and it was all
- 1:14:17just
- 1:14:18>> and the Algerians and
- 1:14:20>> what he
- 1:14:20>> in Paris the Algerians and the Moroccans
- 1:14:23and
- 1:14:26the
- 1:14:26>> Pakistani immigrants running the shops.
- 1:14:27No, that was
- 1:14:28>> I don't think they arrived yet. That was
- 1:14:29a bit later.
- 1:14:31>> He came too early. They came too
- 1:14:33[laughter] early. He missed out on the
- 1:14:35best of Paris.
- 1:14:36>> No, but the steam engines and you know
- 1:14:38the the engineering
- 1:14:39>> license cigarette shops and
- 1:14:41>> Yeah. No, I think it was really
- 1:14:42impressive and um [laughter]
- 1:14:44it it was not the west of today. Y
- 1:14:47>> did you not stop over at the UK to visit
- 1:14:49our chicken shops? [laughter]
- 1:14:53>> I think that would have been a very
- 1:14:54different if they they'd arrived in
- 1:14:56let's say Brixton of today
- 1:14:58>> and come back with the Adidas track
- 1:15:00suits. [laughter]
- 1:15:02>> Yeah, exactly. You wouldn't have had to
- 1:15:04say at Ahmed Khan, I don't think. No,
- 1:15:06[laughter]
- 1:15:07>> I I can understand the appeal of the
- 1:15:10time.
- 1:15:11>> No, but yeah. So, so 18th century Europe
- 1:15:14is very impressive and and I with Khan
- 1:15:17always even as a child I always sort of
- 1:15:19sympathize with him on a human level,
- 1:15:20not on a religious level obviously. It
- 1:15:23was a complete absurdity what they were
- 1:15:26uh what those people were arguing with
- 1:15:27that movement argued and it has
- 1:15:29unfortunately become a part of the
- 1:15:31fabric of Pakistani society really in in
- 1:15:33the cultural academic sort of
- 1:15:34intellectual imagination you find it
- 1:15:36everywhere
- 1:15:38>> uh but on a human level I could
- 1:15:39sympathize I mean you've just this 1857
- 1:15:42is just an astounding defeat from here
- 1:15:44all the way to the Sudan and
- 1:15:47>> you know the 1800s were were a that was
- 1:15:49a bad century the 19th century
- 1:15:51>> you
- 1:15:52Um, so I can imagine why they were
- 1:15:55forced to sort of reimagine or reconcile
- 1:15:57or reposition themselves is like side
- 1:16:01eyeing me.
- 1:16:02>> He's like judging me for [laughter]
- 1:16:04humanizing
- 1:16:06>> those movements. But I mean
- 1:16:07intellectually obviously it's
- 1:16:08irreconcilable. Didn't work out and here
- 1:16:10we are today
- 1:16:12>> and we're not we're not better off for
- 1:16:14any of it.
- 1:16:15>> Absolutely. I think a major like player
- 1:16:18that has you know uh a major point that
- 1:16:22has been in the discourse since a long
- 1:16:23time has been the idea of science and
- 1:16:26even like uh in the Muslim world we have
- 1:16:28tried to prove many a times that there
- 1:16:30has not been a decline in the Muslim
- 1:16:32world even like the gazali decline
- 1:16:35narrative and all like we still fighting
- 1:16:37that in Pakistan even though like even
- 1:16:40the western academia is way over it. So
- 1:16:42what is this? Um I get the fascination
- 1:16:45with science because it it has seen as
- 1:16:47this hallmark or benchmark of uh again
- 1:16:50as we started of success in dunia. M
- 1:16:53>> but how do we figure out uh again I
- 1:16:57would not like to call it a dilemma that
- 1:17:00can we be anything in this world without
- 1:17:03you know instrumentalizing
- 1:17:05or um dominating nature because that has
- 1:17:09what has you know brought about all
- 1:17:11these weapons and this these nuclear
- 1:17:13arsenals and you know these technologies
- 1:17:15of dominance. M
- 1:17:17>> so is there a way to sustain ourselves
- 1:17:20in in in this world without having this
- 1:17:22fascination with science and its
- 1:17:25instrumentalization as in into weaponry.
- 1:17:29You can have a fascination with it. Um
- 1:17:32none of this entails the necessity of
- 1:17:34adopting lism at all. But what we need
- 1:17:38to do is reintegrate. Not reintegrate,
- 1:17:40but integrate what is necessary
- 1:17:43defensively
- 1:17:44um and competitively
- 1:17:48um not to be totally dominated
- 1:17:52um uh into a subordinated model of the
- 1:17:57sciences in which metaphysics and
- 1:17:59theology and spirituality
- 1:18:02>> and then it will temper some of the
- 1:18:05excesses of modern science in terms of
- 1:18:07our ethical convictions. M
- 1:18:10>> not convictions because they sound nice
- 1:18:12or they sound happy clappy but because
- 1:18:14they're rooted in our objective
- 1:18:17scientific view of the world because
- 1:18:19remember the term science has been
- 1:18:20co-opted very very recently even up
- 1:18:22until the end of the 19th century and
- 1:18:24even even though it's kind of quaint but
- 1:18:26even to today I think in the university
- 1:18:28of abodine there's one left where it's
- 1:18:30still called the faculty of natural
- 1:18:32philosophy right
- 1:18:34>> um because that's that's a throwback to
- 1:18:36the days in which empirical science was
- 1:18:38rooted in that subordinated model of the
- 1:18:40sciences. Uh as I said, you know,
- 1:18:43Cientia is about as far away in the
- 1:18:46traditional medieval sense of
- 1:18:48demonstrative science is about as far
- 1:18:50away from our conception of science
- 1:18:52today, which is basically probabilistic
- 1:18:54inductive models
- 1:18:56>> um geared of the nature of the physical
- 1:19:00world. geared towards adapting means to
- 1:19:02end in order to produce uh you know um
- 1:19:06experimentally in order to produce
- 1:19:08technology
- 1:19:09>> which goes right back to you know those
- 1:19:11changes we were discussing in the
- 1:19:13scientific revolution um and it's
- 1:19:16precisely the same it's exactly the same
- 1:19:18definition of ciia for someone like
- 1:19:21Thomas Aquinus and
- 1:19:24uh for us and again the same change has
- 1:19:27happened the same co-opting of the term
- 1:19:30Because today it's not known to
- 1:19:31everyone. I don't know what it's like in
- 1:19:32Pakistan, but in the Arab world,
- 1:19:35we would think though the immediately it
- 1:19:37must be Alazi and Razi they're talking
- 1:19:39about. No, they're usually talking about
- 1:19:40Steven Hawking
- 1:19:41>> when they say, right? And means modern
- 1:19:44science.
- 1:19:45>> What does it mean? What what's
- 1:19:48in our tradition?
- 1:19:53Okay. It's an attribute which taken on
- 1:19:56by the knowing subject, the human
- 1:19:59intellect. Um that entails that
- 1:20:02necessitates in that knowing act an
- 1:20:05instance of discrimination.
- 1:20:08>> You know it is this thing not that
- 1:20:10thing.
- 1:20:11>> This is true not that thing. Okay.
- 1:20:15In which the contradictory for it to be
- 1:20:17otherwise
- 1:20:18>> is impossible. Strictly impossible.
- 1:20:20Okay. So it's absolutely certain. Now
- 1:20:23that doesn't do it being empirical. In
- 1:20:26fact, the original definition says or a
- 1:20:29more precise definition says
- 1:20:32>> which actually roots out it rules out
- 1:20:35any appeal to the empirical. It's
- 1:20:36between.
- 1:20:37>> So that means that the original meaning
- 1:20:40of science is something prior to
- 1:20:42empirical experience. It's actually
- 1:20:44presupposed by empirical experience.
- 1:20:46It's in the realm of the metaphysical.
- 1:20:48>> It's in the realm of the ethical. And so
- 1:20:50what do we mean by uh metaphysical?
- 1:20:54We're talking about the most fundamental
- 1:20:57definitions of things, the essences of
- 1:20:59things like what is human nature? Don't
- 1:21:02you think it would be useful just to
- 1:21:03give one example of metaphysical
- 1:21:05question to know what human nature is
- 1:21:07since we're human beings carrying out
- 1:21:09all of this kind of inquiry? That would
- 1:21:10be a good starting point. For example,
- 1:21:12so it's metaphysics which looks at that
- 1:21:14very very foundational level. And that's
- 1:21:17exactly what the modern world dismisses
- 1:21:19as merely subjective.
- 1:21:22>> I think the shakes quite comprehensively
- 1:21:24explained the all the subjects of and
- 1:21:26the points of discussion. I think any
- 1:21:28further questioning would be uh unfair
- 1:21:31at this point
- 1:21:32>> cuz they've just come off an airplane,
- 1:21:34you know. So let be.
- 1:21:36>> Alhamdulillah.
- 1:21:37>> Thank you so much for your time. Thank
- 1:21:38you so much. And um whenever you guys
- 1:21:41are in town uh and you want to be rudely
- 1:21:44interrupted or you know you want any
- 1:21:47obnoxious references thrown at you, Star
- 1:21:49Wars, you know, anything, film, TV,
- 1:21:52whatever,
- 1:21:52>> look forward to it.
- 1:21:53>> I'm here inshallah.
- 1:21:54>> Beautiful.
- 1:21:54>> You guys know the place now, so feel
- 1:21:56free to drop by.
- 1:21:58>> Inshallah. Lovely. Thank you.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Hasan Spiker Explains How We Can Revive the Essence of Islam to defeat the West! by Eon Podcast Reloaded, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 13,819 words across 2,153 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.