Harvest of Loneliness, Interview with Vivian Price — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:05you are watching dhtv from california state university dominguez hills
- 0:11we have learned in this course that the u.s federal government supports both corporate and
- 0:14business needs for inexpensive workers and high profits since its inception the united states
- 0:20has maintained groups of rightless workers this course has viewed the historical experience of the
- 0:26different directions of humanity red white black yellow and brown we have studied the experience of
- 0:33the immigrant as slaves colonial subjects racial and ethnic minorities and undocumented workers
- 0:40and the resounding theme throughout the study is that the federal government
- 0:44ensures people without rights for business the united states practices exclusionary citizenship
- 0:51it began with indentured servants then it moved to slavery it is now called undocumented immigration
- 0:57which is a contracted form of labor we have witnessed disenfranchisement and dispossession
- 1:02of the immigrant worker sprinkled with white racism now the fear of the other the fear of
- 1:07the immigrant translates into policy that prevents people from achieving social justice and equality
- 1:14whites and europeans were extended open immigration they came as voluntary immigrants
- 1:19meanwhile restricted immigration was created for everyone else africans endured enslavement asians
- 1:26experienced exclusion native people and mexicans have to and have had to deal with conquest
- 1:32aristide zolberg writes that the united states immigration and natural naturalization law is
- 1:38about creating a nation by design so to help us understand how we are a nation by design
- 1:44we are blessed to have as our guest today today's program dr vivian price let me just share with you
- 1:50about professor price she's just amazing she's a filmmaker an educator and activist and after
- 1:56earning her ma in history at university of texas austin she worked in factories she worked in a
- 2:02refinery and she was a construction electrician and before returning to school to get her phd
- 2:09she is presently she has a doctorate in politics and society from uc irvine and she is presently
- 2:16associate professor in interdisciplinary studies at california state university dominguez hills
- 2:22she is a coordinator of labor studies and she is presently the secretary treasurer of our local
- 2:27chapter of the california faculty association and is a delegate to the los angeles county federation
- 2:32of labor now what is so amazing is she is involved in many projects and her latest project includes
- 2:38the trades women trades women's archive project which is a new media piece
- 2:44the trades women address the next generation her film she has i think three films right did you
- 2:50have is hammering it out on transnational trades women both are distributed by women make movies
- 2:57and she is proud to be a co-director of harvest of loneliness dr price welcome thank you very much
- 3:04for uh coming and blessing us with your expertise so we are honored but let's start out by uh
- 3:10sharing with us how you became involved in history and how you became involved in labor studies
- 3:16well i too am an immigrant um and what your introductory remarks are something that's uh very
- 3:22important to me too uh the immigrant immigration policy the united states affected my family as
- 3:29well in fact my grandparents were killed because the quota for people who were born in hungary
- 3:37was filled when my grandfather was trying to escape nazi germany
- 3:45so there's a a lot of um information you know that that we have to understand
- 3:52in terms of seeing the movements the shifts and and kinds of exclusionary policies that we we've
- 4:02um you know encountered we that we've experienced so being an immigrant and being somebody who also
- 4:10had a feeling from my childhood of um wanting to understand why there was so much injustice
- 4:16in the world from my own family's experience i um i i was raised in a jewish household where
- 4:25really it was more about never again for the jews but compassion for other people but i
- 4:30thought it was really important to understand you know more about various cultures and moving
- 4:38to los angeles in a very multicultural society from new york which was also very multicultural
- 4:44i've had the opportunity to really work with a lot of different people whether it was in factories or
- 4:50in the university and i met gilbert gonzalez who was a professor of chicano studies and still is
- 4:58at uc irvine and was working on the research and and became a book guest workers or colonized labor
- 5:07about the baracero program and i had done a number of films which you mentioned about gender
- 5:13and labor and this is actually also a book about gender and labor also about you know immigration
- 5:21policy and i was so struck by how um powerful his book was in terms of understanding uh the latino
- 5:30experience the mexican-american experience in the united states that i thought this would make
- 5:34a great film and gil agreed and so we started our venture wow fantastic um inform us on you there's
- 5:43a here in the university there's interdisciplinary studies and pace could you share with us what
- 5:49interdisciplinary studies is and pace and how it has benefited students all right great thank you
- 5:56interdisciplinary studies is we call it ids for short and it's a program for returning adults
- 6:04to finish or complete their uh studies and get their bachelor's degree
- 6:09and you know transfer to uh dominguez hills all of our classes are online or in the evening or on the
- 6:18um you have a weekends right after this right i do so thanks for fitting it in you know thank you
- 6:26and we have wonderful students a lot of our students are you know across the board in
- 6:31terms of age ranging from you know sort of the traditional college age of in their 20s
- 6:38through their 70s through their 70s yeah and so we have very interesting
- 6:43populations in our in our program and then we pace is a program program for adult college
- 6:50education so that's that's what pace means programs for adult college education right
- 6:54right and sometimes people say program for accelerated college education but it came out of
- 6:59wayne state back in the 1970s when people thought really we need a progressive program that honors
- 7:06the experiences of adult learners and and and has a progressive political agenda that that opens
- 7:14people's eyes to multiculturalism to economic oppression and and that's really where pace and
- 7:20ideas come from labor studies also was founded on on this campus we have the only four-year um
- 7:29uh bachelor's degree in southern california the coordinator for labor studies so share with us
- 7:34the importance of labor studies right i i jumped the gun here that's quite all right that's right
- 7:39because you you are coordinating many different uh programs through labor studies right right yeah i
- 7:47i'm i work in interdisciplinary studies and in labor studies so our labor studies program is a
- 7:53four-year program and we take transfer students to a lot of our students are also cross enrolled they
- 8:00are part of the community college and this is something that your listeners may not know
- 8:06if you're taking six units at a community college in the same semester you can take three units
- 8:13here we can take one class at dominguez hills with instructor permission for only ten dollars amazing
- 8:21so say that again yes yes i will ten dollars right right so um we call it cross enrollment and if
- 8:29so if you're enrolled in a class in a community college right so let me let me back up and say if
- 8:34you're if you're already a dominguez hill student this does not apply to you okay but if you have
- 8:38cousins or brothers and sisters or or you know people who are going to community college let them
- 8:44know about it or if you're if you are a community college student and have not applied to dominguez
- 8:49yet if you're taking any classes six units of any any subject matter at the same semester
- 8:58you can apply there's a cross enrollment form and you can email me about it you know or
- 9:05if you well there is a web there is a website for uh labor studies right right we have can
- 9:10you put up the website for labor studies it's uh dh well yeah they're okay now that's
- 9:16that's that'll that'll work ids that's the ids okay there's the labor studies okay and
- 9:21then the dh labor studies.org is our also our gets you to both programs too at any rate um
- 9:30yeah so if you email one of us or go to our our webpage and contact us we'll let you know
- 9:37a little bit more detail about how to do that across this moment because it's really a wonderful
- 9:42thing yeah and of course the other thing about labor studies we have wonderful faculty that teach
- 9:50workers rights and contracts and negotiation and labor law and a number of other related
- 9:55subjects in chicana studies africana studies sociology and then we have our fifth annual labor
- 10:02social and environmental justice fair coming up and you've been do well it's fifth annual so the
- 10:07last five years you've provided a great service to the university um last year's of course was
- 10:13the fourth annual this is going to be the fifth uh well we have somebody uh that's calling in
- 10:19right now all right but we'll talk about how the fairs came about who do we have on
- 10:28it's uh levmar calling from corona thank you for for participating
- 10:35hi how are you doing pretty good yeah i had a question down in that i noticed when i was
- 10:40watching the documentary where it looked like the mexican government didn't support its people
- 10:47either through the netherlands program or also through the battering program has that changed
- 10:50now or does it continue to be the same where where the politics in mexico still kind of
- 10:56cater to the american businesses well thank you leonardo for asking that question um i think what
- 11:03i'd like to do is if if we can postpone answering that question until we get to
- 11:08the documentary uh right now we're discussing um uh about social environmental justice fair
- 11:15and then we will come back to to your question if that would be okay for you
- 11:19i'll be perfect thank you hold on just stay online we're going to get to you right very important
- 11:25question it's a very important question but let us take care of of this and then we're going to
- 11:29get into specific segments of the documentary so we can discuss the issues that you raise
- 11:37great thank you so let's let's talk about um this year's fair well tell us how the fairs came about
- 11:43okay i was lucky that one of our students in the labor studies program
- 11:49was very active on campus and he was involved in student government his name is scott hill
- 11:55scott hill yes i had him for a class for a mexican identity so he he said to me you know dr price not
- 12:02that many people know about labor studies and it's a great program we should do something how about
- 12:07an event on campus like a labor fair where we bring trade unions to come to the campus and our
- 12:14students can learn more about labor and i thought that was a terrific idea and that we should also
- 12:19expand it to thinking about other ways of looking at social justice and community organizations
- 12:25and then as things grew we sort of got involved in earth day and environmental
- 12:31justice and we really see that these things all go together community the environment and labor
- 12:39and what's wonderful about the fair is that it's student organized i have a class and this is a
- 12:44class which is every year available to students the labor studies practicum where students learn
- 12:52about organizing they read about organizing they read about leadership and then they also
- 12:58reach out to the organizations to artists to musicians we're doing theater the
- 13:03oppressed so it's a it's a cultural as well as informational event students also get some
- 13:10resources like internships and jobs through the fair yeah if um if let's take a look at
- 13:16last year's poster i don't know if you can get the uh the image up and then the crew if you could put
- 13:22down uh on on the bottom thirds the fifth annual labor social and there we go now uh here in in
- 13:30now i didn't see i don't know if you have one for this year that we have we're working on you're
- 13:35working on it right now but it says here you know join us volunteer get a booth you network with 50
- 13:40plus social justice organizations uh which which organizations are right so in labor we always have
- 13:49the united food and commercial workers come sometimes the international workers of the world
- 13:54come iw yeah the southern california district of the ilw the longshore we have the electricians and
- 14:04my union california faculty association and then you know there's i don't want to leave anybody
- 14:09out california state employees association many different unions so it really spans seiu which
- 14:16spans also county workers and city workers many different organizations come then community groups
- 14:23we have groups from the east yard wilmington that are dealing with environmental issues as well as
- 14:30issues of the children the youth in the area watts community strategy center comes the youth justice
- 14:38coalition and then we have artists and artists artists you have any guest speakers we're working
- 14:45on a number of guest speakers they're still to be announced okay that's fine yes yeah with these
- 14:51interactive workshops sure that right and again this is we're just really solidifying the program
- 14:57because it is a class and i don't you know i like to get my students to decide what things
- 15:04are going to happen but in the past for example we've had people from the writers guild come
- 15:10and talk about you know labor relations in the studios we've had a film showcase and
- 15:15we'll probably do that again where i was just contacted by cuentame who's they have a new
- 15:22film called immigrants for sale which is about the detention centers and the interests that are
- 15:28involved in kind of lobbying against immigration well then maybe we can get somebody uh from gundam
- 15:32to come to this program that's right that's right you think if i give them two weeks notice that i
- 15:43thank you very much i knew that i knew that you would help out here um yes um well with
- 15:49with regards to this this program here how my students benefit all right so let me see the date
- 15:55is april 25th okay um it's it'll be uh basically from nine to four p.m and if your students come
- 16:05they actually could volunteer we have a lot of different ways people can volunteer and
- 16:10um maybe they'll get extra credit uh well the class will be over by then but i guess i can give
- 16:16them post i can give them after the fact just it's possible anything is possible yes of course but
- 16:22aside from that just the experience the experience of meeting other students on campus and having an
- 16:28event you know that's all day that that might be you know some students can't come in the morning
- 16:34some can't come in in the evening so it leaves a lot of room for people to you know fit into the
- 16:40time slots and if they contact us if you know i think dhlaberstudies.org they can contact me
- 16:48i think my email is on this as well v price at csudh.edu there's campus tours we bring
- 16:56several hundred high school students they can work with high school students that's fantastic
- 16:59if they're already doing some community work they might offer a community organization
- 17:04to come maybe they're working with a labor union maybe there are artists or musicians who want to
- 17:09perform or offer their services or just help with registration or parking there's
- 17:14many ways that people can be part of this and it's it's a very satisfying event you get to see
- 17:21people in action doing things that are fun and interesting festive atmosphere it's the last three
- 17:27one them that i was able to attend or you know observe because i'm always working and then i take
- 17:33my students take get a break right but yes they've been great you're also a secretary treasury of our
- 17:40local chapter of california faculty association share with us what's going on well i think that
- 17:46one of the biggest things is that um our campus as well as many campuses throughout the country
- 17:51as well as the csu system um have inequities that are you know we're constantly trying to
- 18:00ameliorate if not transform and one of the big ones is the situation of lectures and since
- 18:07lectures are 60 of the teaching faculty on this campus uh that's a very important issue for us and
- 18:15lecturers are oftentimes not represented in the senate um so we're
- 18:22we're supporting a measure right now so that there's a lecturer's voice in the senate
- 18:27there's a question of getting your contract early and on time getting paid on time oh yeah
- 18:34things like this i mean all of us who work for a living
- 18:38have working class issues have workers issues and and the union is here to defend everybody
- 18:46for tenure track people this is really a important question because it lectures rights are also
- 18:54affecting everybody else the tenure track tenure track folks have to pick up the burden
- 19:00of working on committees or doing that you know shared governance as you know more of the
- 19:08work is put on fewer and fewer people so it's very important for us to fight
- 19:16you know in solidarity definitely so there and there are other issues as well of course you
- 19:20know students are facing this question of if you haven't graduated and you have more than 150 units
- 19:28they would like the administration is trying to float um the option of paying full tuition
- 19:34which is something like fifteen thousand dollars and that affects faculty as well as students so
- 19:41we're really trying to investigate that and students are very alarmed about that because
- 19:45there's all kinds of reasons i mean if you're just biding your time that's one thing but if
- 19:50you're you know you've switched majors and now you've discovered labor studies
- 19:55and you're you know you need to finish out that major why should you have to pay fifteen thousand
- 20:00dollars because you have discovered this you know later or rather than earlier in your educational
- 20:07career and then plus not only are you uh involved with the faculty association but you're also large
- 20:13involved with a larger umbrella organization of the los angeles county federation of labor
- 20:19share with us something about the importance of that institution or that organization right um
- 20:24i'm a proud delegate to the federation of labor which is in l.a we have the fine leadership of
- 20:33maria elena de razo who is our secretary treasurer of that institution every month
- 20:39we come together uh right now we meet at the musicians hall in la
- 20:43and it's janitors it's nurses it's sag-aftra it's um teachers k-12 and you know across the spectrum
- 20:52we get to meet one another the activists and the representatives of all these different unions we
- 20:57find out what our issues are how we can help each other firefighters as well right and then
- 21:03so for example the letter carriers are talking to us about what's happening to the post office and
- 21:10uh they just let us know that you know the letter carriers are actually
- 21:14nine percent of the gdp of this country and they're the biggest employer of veterans
- 21:22and um they're you know right now they're really in the process of being laid off i think they want
- 21:28to lay off at least 10 percent of all the workers in the post office how is that going to affect the
- 21:33public not everybody uses email and not everything can be delivered and one one example that they
- 21:38said is you know medication that a lot of us get our medication through the mail because it's
- 21:45cheaper that medication will be delayed in in you know its receipts so we get very well informed by
- 21:52what's going on fantastic and what's shared there and there's a lot of but there's going to be a lot
- 21:56of activities really going going on soon right march 16th there's going to be a nationwide um
- 22:05a nationwide protest about the letter carriers yes all right now what's fascinating is of
- 22:11course you've well you've you've done you've dedicated yourself to creating a just society
- 22:17um tell us about trade women's archive project okay i'll i'll keep this brief because we've got
- 22:24yeah well i don't know you decide when you want to leave i have to teach you another class and i'm
- 22:30i'm opening up this class really i'm i want to be there at one
- 22:34okay i'll tell you what then let's let's just say one word about the truth
- 22:40having been an electrician i saw firsthand about you know what it's like to
- 22:48enter a trade and be in an environment where it's sort of a father and son uh you know give
- 22:55this trade to the next generation an inheritance a working-class inheritance and for people of
- 23:00color for immigrants for women to break into that well-paid skilled area it's difficult yes
- 23:09and um and there's a lot of strategies people have employed to try to survive and again
- 23:15create solidarity uh build bridges within those environments so um i've done those two films
- 23:22one is about uh women in l.a who were part of the trades women movement another one was about women
- 23:31in internationally who have been working building residences and and um all kinds of edifices uh for
- 23:41thousands of years for example in india and that you know it's very interesting to look
- 23:45at the history where families work together and my most recent project is in our university we have
- 23:53put together an archive of many different people's papers of some of us who have
- 23:59retired from the trades some of the people that are still in the trades and now we have a a uh
- 24:05an archive site we're using a web portal which is tradeswomanarchives.com okay i think we have
- 24:15no yes trade women's we have that they could put up that website tradewomen'sarchives.com yes
- 24:23tradeswomanarchives.com and that's where people can go online and share their
- 24:30images and their stories their documents um and i've gone to a number of different cities and
- 24:36had some workshops with people women doing this um you know recording their stories and
- 24:43and scanning their photos and writing captions and so it's an exciting project because it's sort of a
- 24:50model of how other marginalized communities can create their own archives their own history
- 24:55because we don't want our histories uh to be uh you know to disappear whereas the archives of the
- 25:04powerful oftentimes are preserved um many of us don't you know don't have a place to put our our
- 25:13documents and our images that we've collected over the years and i'm sure that in this collection
- 25:18there are immigrant women that have been involved right right and i've interviewed a number of them
- 25:24fantastic well then let's get to harvest of empire tell us about the film and your experience uh um
- 25:30right co-directing it yeah so um harvest of empire is actually the the latest harvest of loneliness
- 25:39quite a few harvests we're using the harvest of empire book from exactly and there's a new
- 25:44documentary yes so harvest of loneliness was a really eye-opening experience for me
- 25:51i although i had studied somewhat about the bracero program and read gil's book
- 25:58going out in the field going to stockton and to some of the you know to the berkeley the bay area
- 26:06as well as to mexico and to places in southern california whether it was jerome park in irvine
- 26:14we went to places where braceros were organizing many of them were organizing because only you know
- 26:21one facet of injustice of this program this guest worker program so-called guest worker program
- 26:28was that in the 40s when they brought people in they held back 10 percent of their check saying
- 26:35well you've got to go back home when you go back we'll give you your 10 percent of your wages
- 26:40and then that money never did get back to the workers so ironically you know there had been
- 26:47a supreme court case and many different cases to try for people to recover that money which
- 26:53they won but the money still hasn't been you know discovered the mexican government has put aside
- 27:02a certain amount of money because in the end you know it was a several mexican banks that got the
- 27:09money from wells fargo transferred um to these banks and so the mexican government um created
- 27:17a a small amount to disperse to people who could find their pay stubs their contracts their mikas
- 27:26but a lot of people have you know don't keep their pay stubs from you know 60 years ago or whatever
- 27:32so it's really amazing how many people did and what they have done is they've
- 27:36organized in different areas tried to put their documents together and apply for money and it was
- 27:42through this these different organizing sectors that we were able to interview people
- 27:47and ask them about their experiences well let's let's go to a film clip from the documentary that
- 27:53highlights the recruitment of braceros and their arrival to the us uh so can we put up that film
- 28:00film clip they were brought in on a train people would get off of the train naturally board a bus
- 28:08and there was an opening back here where the bus would park and the people would come across
- 28:12so when they got over here they were in very dire conditions health-wise
- 28:51there was about seven of us that were hired out of high school so i had to then 16 17.
- 28:57this sounds horrible but they had to be fumigated at the border individuality disappears in a cloud
- 29:03of ddt dust yeah i did that for three days and then i said no i can't do this anymore because
- 29:09it was degrading to the people and then you know there were some that had all their clothing and
- 29:14etc very neatly stacked and you had to ruffle through it and spray it and that was a bad deal
- 29:25for perhaps the first time in his life he gets a thorough physical examination
- 29:29partly for his protection and partly to make sure his american employer
- 29:33will get his money's worth it was very degrading you have to remember that this is a captive group
- 29:39you know you're going to do what you do with them and they have no say-so avian medicos
- 29:51caviar
- 29:58they had blood drawn they were given an x-ray
- 30:05they were giving a very cursory examination of the tonsils in the teeth
- 31:11the first time that i actually visited the reception center
- 31:15the manager of the of the center said it would be okay for me to go into the hall where the
- 31:23selecting as they called it was going on that day the fellow representing some growers association
- 31:31up in northern california was happy enough to have me stand by his side while he demonstrated
- 31:38the way he did his uh so-called selecting well there were these hundreds of men lined up
- 31:46outside and they would shuffle past this guy who uh commented on why he was selecting one guy
- 31:55and rejecting another guy and it all had to do with whether they measured up to his
- 32:02criteria for what he considered to be a good bracero these had to be men who were apparently
- 32:10timid docile unlettered impoverished anybody who was well dressed or well spoken would be rejected
- 32:26el centro california
- 32:40foreign
- 32:55i found it unspeakably appalling i thought that it must be something like this in the
- 33:01slave markets of charleston or new orleans or baltimore or wherever they were selecting
- 33:21all right that's a fascinating experience but we have phone calls and we've got students
- 33:26asking questions so let's take the phone calls this is uh lazier calling from from los angeles
- 33:33thank you lazada hi um miss price thank you for um dedicating your time to us and sharing your
- 33:41experiences i noticed that um you you seem to be a jack of all trades a master of none and i wanted
- 33:50to know if that was strategic on your part as far as integrating into the labor force to understand
- 33:57the different aspects or the different um trials that each of um each person's that
- 34:04would be employed in these different departments or um labor would experience if it if it was
- 34:11strategic because you went from electrician to an educator and you seem to be all over the place
- 34:19but i want to know if it was strategic and then my second question in reference to the becerras
- 34:25i did have an opportunity to view that documentary and after i saw it
- 34:32um everything became more clear to me as far as what was going on with them
- 34:38and correct me if i'm wrong i think wells fargo had a hand in having these people's
- 34:44money and when i learned that i went straight to the bank closed the account and i told them
- 34:48whenever you give the monies back where it's due i'll come back and i even encourage my
- 34:53family members to close their accounts from wells fargo because they had a hand in that um in those
- 35:01monies that are owed to them the ten percent so those you know those are my two questions
- 35:08great questions um well first of all i wish it had been strategic it was more about survival
- 35:16and and also choices you know i um let's put it this way back when i got my masters in history
- 35:26it was a recession and i did want to teach and it was really hard to find a job so
- 35:34but i was also a political activist and that's when i decided to start working in factories and
- 35:40then i really had to learn how to be a factory worker because i was used to having freedom of
- 35:47speech and when you work in a factory oftentimes you don't so when i would speak up about safety
- 35:55conditions or conditions on the line i would get fired so i had to learn a lot about survival
- 36:05but at any rate i i think looking back i'm i'm proud of having so much experience
- 36:12and being able to draw from those experiences i feel very fortunate to have a compassion and being
- 36:20able to empathize with people in many different walks of life because of my own experiences
- 36:25regarding wells fargo if you there is a supreme court case
- 36:29and and perhaps we could make that available to to students the opinion on that case
- 36:37presumably wells fargo returned the money they they did return the money not
- 36:45to the people but they transferred it to two banks in mexico and i think i i don't want
- 36:53to state the names of those banks because i i'm offhand i don't you know don't want to make sure
- 36:57i want to make sure that they're the correct one names but again we can get that information to you
- 37:05there were so many people involved um i i think i really appreciate your sense of feeling
- 37:11that somebody should be held accountable for this transgression of people not getting their money
- 37:20and really this leads us to the next question of what about the mexican government and their
- 37:25uh questions yeah because you know banks are usually regulated by governments and
- 37:32you you would think that the mexican you know government would have
- 37:36uh compelled the banks to make those uh transfers to the their rightful owners the braceros
- 37:44and i think that it's because of that that they've taken on some of the responsibility now
- 37:51in the film we show that what we learned was that really the mexican consulate
- 37:58was brought in to help recruit workers in mexico to
- 38:06help categorize workers in terms of whether they were from different parts of
- 38:13mexico and were better off you know skilled at picking lemons or oranges
- 38:19the book that the textbook that the students are reading that we're using for the course traces
- 38:23the uh at least that that kind of experience right and then we we interviewed one of the uh leaders
- 38:32of the of a migrant camp um a migration center um in huamas who also talks about this in in the film
- 38:41um at any rate or maybe he maybe that hit the cutting room floor i don't know but he he was
- 38:48the the fellow that spoke about working in uh johamus also told us this that they really had
- 38:57you know that the mexican government was very much involved in really helping create the conditions
- 39:04to allow people to help the growers in the united states and um so in a way it was sort of taxpayers
- 39:12money from mexico that helped fund fund and then also calavita brings up in her book of
- 39:20the notion that the mexican government insisted on not on having the labor come from central
- 39:26mexico not along the border because in that way they would they would gain they would gain
- 39:31also some monetary benefits from that right and and even as far south as the yucatan people came
- 39:39and the thing about it too is what people people think um well they want it to work right so
- 39:46uh what's wrong with that well um what we also try to show is that people had to fund their
- 39:54own journey and while the growers were benefiting from this people had to sell land or sell a cow or
- 40:04and go into debt they had to um you know put forward a mordida a bribe to try to get on
- 40:11the list or get a good place on the list and this was this was coming out of the family's
- 40:17hide right and and and really got them into debt too so the mexican government was very
- 40:24much involved in the recruitment from different parts of mexico in you know distributing flyers
- 40:31and creating the list and setting up the migration centers but it didn't fund any or or even
- 40:39develop any places for people to stay overnight to eat you know the people would be at the migration
- 40:46centers uh for sometimes weeks or months starving and there was there were no barracks there was
- 40:55nothing there for people so uh you know this is kind of outrageous and then when the people
- 41:02came to the united states it was unions were not allowed right people were not represented
- 41:08as workers and they were under contract that looked good on paper but actually
- 41:14they were not guaranteed any kind of wage they really were it was really up to
- 41:18nobody was doing oversight and we heard that from some of the inspectors that said
- 41:23you know this was something that again looked good on paper but if you don't regulate it
- 41:29if you don't inspect and see well what kind of food are people getting that they're charged for
- 41:34while they're not working in the fields you know maybe it's raining and they can't work
- 41:38they're still having to pay for their wages for their food for the blanket for insurance
- 41:45and uh and if the the only representative who could speak on behalf of the workers was the
- 41:50mexican council and another thing that we try to show in the film is what they would say is
- 41:56you know be quiet don't say anything you know represent us well so that we can get send more
- 42:03people here and you know just be lucky be happy you have a job and really this is very good and so
- 42:11and and it's not that these were bad people but people were put into these different positions
- 42:18and really compelled to to take these kinds of positions
- 42:24and plus the i mean these kinds of say these kinds of things me and the attitude amongst
- 42:30growers as well as state representatives was they were not they did not treat
- 42:34mexicans as humans or they they had this approach that they were non-human they would that's why
- 42:39the term [ __ ] went back they called them wets or whatever is these these uh epithelies that uh just
- 42:46are throughout the 1950s during this absolutely and and that was the nice that was the nice word
- 42:55and again i mean a lot of people say well there were some nice growers there was and you know
- 43:02there were nice slave owners too i mean it's not that it was the individual people that were good
- 43:07or bad um or prejudiced or not but the whole system really was created in order to exploit
- 43:16people to create a vulnerable workforce that people could take growers could take advantage
- 43:21of and build the economy and not to defend the rights of the workers and just institutionalize
- 43:27the prejudice exactly um we have a couple more phone calls well thank you lazida for
- 43:32asking those questions amanda for calling from santa barbara oh stanford thank you monda
- 43:39hi a professor um thank you dr price for a very moving documentary um i've seen this documentary
- 43:45before when i took a class sociology of work here at dominguez hills as well and i come originally
- 43:51from the sound king valley where my family some of my family did work in the field up there and i was
- 44:00particularly interested in the fumigation process that they made the viscerals go
- 44:05through and i was curious if you found any um health factors or health risks that some of the
- 44:11former viseros had have because of going through that process and if they've even sought any kind
- 44:18of legal recourse because of that um you know excellent question and i i can't tell you too much
- 44:29um it's been well documented you know that this uh that ddt was used to supposedly de-louse people
- 44:44and uh this is not the first time or the last time that ddt was used i think they started in
- 44:49the 1920s right and and um there was a a really interesting story of a woman who refused to
- 44:56have be fumigated that way and um you know she was arrested and but she started a protest and
- 45:04which was somewhat successful at that time but it still was a practice that came back into being and
- 45:14you know ddt has also been used when it was outlawed in the united states
- 45:18it was shipped to countries in the global south to use on their fields as well so unfortunately
- 45:29we have a long history in the united states of manufacturing deadly chemicals and then
- 45:36having people you know control them and then exporting them in this case
- 45:42they were used on on vulnerable workforce coming into the united states while we interviewed people
- 45:49about the experience we never really found out about the repercussions on their health uh
- 45:55that's a that would be a very important study and i i it's possible that someone has done that uh
- 46:02i i really can't answer any more than that thank you monda and do you have any additional comments
- 46:10do you have any okay karen karen caller from long beach thank you karen oh yes hello professor frog
- 46:16how you doing here good i actually had um the same process as the last caller mom
- 46:25um so i guess i've got two points or two questions um say for example after going through the
- 46:33the uh selling land and and paying the bribes to be accepted as a bracero actually let me turn down
- 46:41my sound on one thing and then maybe i could hear this better sorry um is is there any correlation
- 46:49say between the braceros once they went through that awful humiliating process and the selection
- 46:56that perhaps were got back to their friends and family etc and the reason why some people may have
- 47:05immigrated in illegally is because they did not either have land to sell have money to
- 47:12pay the bribes or because they did not want to go through that same process as legal bursaries
- 47:18well that's you know does that make sense
- 47:23you're right on target you're hitting it this is this is one of the experiences that many had
- 47:28i think also it's mentioned in um the textbook that you're reading
- 47:33of what happened to certain peoples why the operation [ __ ] was put in motion was to get the
- 47:39growers to stop using uh undocumented because they needed the workers with whatever way the workers
- 47:44could come in yeah and and it's true people while i mean first of all the border is this arbitrary
- 47:55space right as a lot of people like to say we didn't cross the border the border crossed us so
- 48:02uh gil likes to tell the story that um when his family crossed it was an open border in the teens
- 48:11and 20s people crossed went back and forth it was not patrolled you know the way it became so
- 48:21this is a long history of people coming back and forth where there's work they would
- 48:28cross the border when it becomes militarized and policed then it interferes with people's ability
- 48:35to go back and forth and then it becomes something criminalized right to go across the border and so
- 48:42it it it changes the meaning of what people are doing and then um in order you know for
- 48:49for folks to come they either have to try to go through a legal process which controls their
- 48:56ability to find work and to set their own terms for work like the bracero program which was a form
- 49:04of contract labor that made people very vulnerable and in many ways people who who cross the border
- 49:10without documents at that time or since then have sometimes been more successful at getting better
- 49:18wages or better working conditions or better jobs because they weren't under the control of this
- 49:24mandated you know growers get to decide everything and interpret the contract for themselves
- 49:32uh so yeah i think that people your you know your question is do people come different you know
- 49:38a different way because they didn't have land or they they were desperate yes the answer is
- 49:44and also people were rejected they were rejected and you can see from the selection process
- 49:49if they looked like they weren't you know their hands weren't calloused enough or they looked
- 49:55too intellectual they look like troublemakers like labor organizers um they would be rejected
- 50:00no and and so those people would also you know be crossing the board well hopefully karen is karen's
- 50:05still on or do we lose karen oh no no i'm here but if i could just ask one more question yes yes
- 50:14say if someone was rejected and sent back to mexico then perhaps
- 50:19then maybe they just came illegally but then uh then that leads me to my next
- 50:26question is how did the legal bursaries feel towards the illegal migrants um which perhaps
- 50:33may have shown up to work the same field i mean how how how did they feel about each other
- 50:40or did they did did a legal bracero even know that the person working next to him may have been
- 50:47an illegal migrant i i think there was a scene and you covered a scene or there was a particular
- 50:54person that was talking about right well there are a number of different situations i mean
- 50:59you know the growers would try to get braceros because they could pay them less so
- 51:07they would try to keep people separate and this is what i think that you're talking about
- 51:11there were there were people who maybe were undocumented or maybe they were documented
- 51:16and i mean they were people that were already living in um california or one of the 27
- 51:23states that brazero worked worked in and they had they had their papers
- 51:28but they would be hired as foremen or they'd be hired as pushers for the braceros so these people
- 51:35might even be related they might be from the same town they might have they might be cousins
- 51:39but you know once again they were put in certain positions it and uh so there would be hostility
- 51:47by the braceros towards folks that were pushing them if they treated them badly but not so much
- 51:55you know because they were legal or illegal it was just about how they were treated and
- 52:01you know and everybody wanted to try to make a living you know it but
- 52:08the system was set up in a way where if you were a bracero you had one position some people might
- 52:15be lucky and like braceros were not supposed to work on equipment they weren't supposed to run
- 52:21tractors that was part of the contract that was supposed to be a job that was for domestic workers
- 52:26many of whom were mexican-american who maybe some of them had been on strike and had been well you
- 52:33know merchants of labor from uh exposed that right right anderson garland that was trying to organize
- 52:40farm workers and they found that the bracero program was used to break strikes right so um
- 52:47in some cases the braceros were were asked to run equipment and then that would cross
- 52:52the hostility too so this i see that one of the questions about um from our our viewers
- 52:59susan yeah and since i have to leave in about a minute i'm just going to answer that this really
- 53:05karen's question merges right into your question people were set against one another especially
- 53:11you know it's not so much about race in this case although race certainly played a part but it was
- 53:17more about if you were a domestic worker or if you were a worker that was in the bracero program
- 53:26people in the united states had tried to form unions the 30s was a time when people were
- 53:32trying to organize in the beginning of the 40s the baracetta program was introduced as a strike
- 53:37breaking program and so the domestic workers were not supposed to have to compete in fact
- 53:45the department of labor made the claim that any domestic worker who wanted a job would
- 53:49still be able to be hired first again this is something we tried to cover in the film but
- 53:55this wasn't necessarily case there wasn't the supervision the oversight the inspectors and
- 54:01they're still not the inspectors in the field to regulate the conditions so that farmworkers
- 54:06are treated like human beings with dignity so the bracero program hurt workers across the board
- 54:16it may have benefited the growers it may have benefited some individuals
- 54:21in some small way but in many ways it degraded the conditions of farm workers
- 54:28and and and it created more of a pathway for undocumented workers to be forced to you
- 54:35know resort to because the mexican economy was also really degraded at the same time
- 54:43a lot to think about yes well no thank you very much we have been blessed the students
- 54:48thank you very much for for participating great questions vivian price feel comfortable with us
- 54:54um let's go to a film clip as as we say goodbye to vivian um whatever film clip you guys got
- 55:00available and then we'll come back and then i'll take i'll take uh everybody's questions
- 55:04and and phone calls but thank you very much for the privilege thank you so much i'm honored
- 55:47you
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Harvest of Loneliness, Interview with Vivian Price by csuDHTV, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 8,100 words across 481 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.