Harvard Scientist's Mother Dies—Then Her Son Describes the Impossible Joan Borysenko Shared Death — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:01What happened when your mom died?
- 0:05>> So, back in 1989,
- 0:08I was just about retiring from Harvard
- 0:12Medical School. I also ran a cancer
- 0:15clinic and a clinic for people with
- 0:18stress-related illness. Then I was also
- 0:22a mother with two sons at home and
- 0:25married. And
- 0:28I had a mother who is now my very
- 0:33favorite person, but who was my nemesis.
- 0:38So,
- 0:39my mother
- 0:41[laughter]
- 0:42she was like the textbook critical
- 0:45mother.
- 0:46Everything I did was wrong, how I looked
- 0:49was wrong, what I said was wrong.
- 0:52The fact that
- 0:55I was you know, I have my my doctorate
- 0:58from Harvard Medical School and then the
- 1:00three postdoctoral fellowships and
- 1:03that's where I worked.
- 1:05That to my mother was not a good thing
- 1:08because
- 1:09having having a husband, you know, in
- 1:12her generation was like they don't like
- 1:15smart women. Keep your mouth shut. And
- 1:19so
- 1:20it's like why why am I doing this? She
- 1:23says, you've got the stuff. You're cute
- 1:26enough. You could get a a handsome rich
- 1:28husband. Why do you want to be a
- 1:31scientist? So, at every level we worked
- 1:35complete opposites.
- 1:38And so now let's fast forward to the end
- 1:43of my mother's life.
- 1:45So, my mother was dying at the age of
- 1:4981.
- 1:51And she was dying in the very hospital
- 1:54where I worked. And so
- 1:58this was the
- 1:59time
- 2:01like my god, it's my own mother and my
- 2:05job is extending compassion,
- 2:09understanding people,
- 2:11um
- 2:12letting go of judgments,
- 2:15and here is my own mother who is dying.
- 2:18So
- 2:20now we get to the point
- 2:23that she's pretty near the end of her
- 2:26life. On the last day of her life,
- 2:29she was having a you know an interior
- 2:33episode of bleeding
- 2:35and the family had gathered to say
- 2:38goodbye,
- 2:39but they took her away to nuclear
- 2:42medicine early in the morning to have a
- 2:44scan
- 2:46and by afternoon she had not yet
- 2:48returned.
- 2:49So the family looks at me and says, hey,
- 2:52you're wearing a white coat. You work
- 2:55here. Go track her down. Maybe she died
- 2:58and you know nobody told us or so I go
- 3:03and nuclear medicine where she was
- 3:05having the scan was in the basement of
- 3:07the hospital.
- 3:09Her room was on the seventh floor.
- 3:12So I go down.
- 3:14It's late afternoon. Things are ready to
- 3:17close. You know, stays open for a while,
- 3:21but
- 3:22uh she had been on a gurney in the
- 3:25corridor all day and
- 3:28this was at a hospital that prided
- 3:30itself on compassionate care.
- 3:33So I went to find the doctor in charge
- 3:37and it had been a very busy day and he
- 3:39was very apologetic
- 3:42and uh
- 3:44I say to him, you know, the family is
- 3:47waiting to say goodbye. She's not going
- 3:49to live very much longer.
- 3:52Do you really have to have this scan?
- 3:56And
- 3:56he looks at me and he said,
- 3:59well, we have to have a diagnosis
- 4:02and my, you know, my mother who's like
- 4:04bleeding out and white as a sheep,
- 4:08marshals the last of her energy. She
- 4:10kind of pushes herself up. She looks
- 4:13that doctor in the eyeball and she says,
- 4:16she was very funny.
- 4:18She says, what?
- 4:20All you needed was a diagnosis? Why
- 4:23didn't you ask me? Well, this like the
- 4:26doctor is like, oh my god. [laughter]
- 4:30And she looks him and she says
- 4:33something equivalent to
- 4:36I'm dying. How's that for a diagnosis?
- 4:41Doctor, you know, he doesn't know what
- 4:43to say. He's not trained for that. So
- 4:47I say to him, I think she's right and
- 4:51this is no place for her to be and I
- 4:54would like to take her back to her room.
- 4:57To this day, I really don't understand
- 5:00why that was allowed. Um
- 5:03you know, but had a point. So he said,
- 5:06okay, she can go back to her room.
- 5:10And
- 5:11so my mother looks at me
- 5:14and says, that's great, Johnny. Take
- 5:17take me back. And the doctor said, no,
- 5:19no, no, no.
- 5:20Uh you can't.
- 5:22Hospital rules. I have to call an
- 5:25orderly to take her back. And my mother
- 5:28looks at me and says something like, the
- 5:31hell with him, Johnny. Just steal the
- 5:33body. And there I am. I've got the
- 5:36gurney. I'm running down the corridor
- 5:39with my dying mother thinking like, oh
- 5:42my god. I have a name badge. They're
- 5:44going to somebody is going to report me.
- 5:47[laughter]
- 5:48So
- 5:50we get into the elevator and we're in
- 5:52the basement
- 5:54and my mother looks at me and she says,
- 5:57Johnny, I bet you thought I never loved
- 6:00you and I hope that you can
- 6:03forgive me. I
- 6:05if I criticized everything in you,
- 6:09then you'd be perfect and have the
- 6:10perfect life.
- 6:12And I'm sorry because I realized that
- 6:15was wrong. And so,
- 6:18you know, I looked at her and I said, of
- 6:20course
- 6:21I can forgive you.
- 6:23Can you forgive me? Because
- 6:26I was a dutiful daughter,
- 6:29but I wasn't a loving one.
- 6:31And
- 6:33so she forgave me. And that was it.
- 6:35Seven floors, we forgave each other. The
- 6:38door opened.
- 6:40And you know, I'm now wheeling her back
- 6:42to her room.
- 6:44And
- 6:45I said something to her that I would
- 6:48never have said in any other
- 6:50circumstance
- 6:52because she would have considered it
- 6:54foolish, she would have laughed at me.
- 6:56And I said,
- 6:58Mom, I'd like to exchange a soul quality
- 7:01with you.
- 7:03I've always admired your courage
- 7:06because she was she was a courageous
- 7:09person. Whatever happened, she could
- 7:12handle it. And I was much more fragile.
- 7:16I just still am, just a different
- 7:18nature.
- 7:19And she said to me, yes, I will give you
- 7:22my courage.
- 7:24And I would like to have your
- 7:26compassion.
- 7:28And that one
- 7:29really surprised me. I thought, my god,
- 7:33she sees my compassion. It's something
- 7:36she admires.
- 7:38And so I said, yes,
- 7:41you can have my compassion.
- 7:43And
- 7:44I brought her back
- 7:47um to to her room. The nurse helped her
- 7:51like, you know, get get back into bed.
- 7:55And then she asked if she could spend
- 8:00time um
- 8:02with each person alone. So we'd all go
- 8:04to the sun room.
- 8:06She said her goodbye to
- 8:08who was there.
- 8:10And then finally we got to the point
- 8:13that there were just three of us left.
- 8:15My son Justin who was 20 at that time
- 8:20and my brother and
- 8:23you know we were all with her and then
- 8:25she would look at us and she would say
- 8:28I cannot die with all the love in this
- 8:32room. Could you please all just get out
- 8:34of there? And we would all go to the
- 8:36sunroom and then a few minutes would
- 8:39pass and we'd all come
- 8:41trooping back. [laughter]
- 8:44And
- 8:45then we got to a point
- 8:49you know
- 8:51kind of
- 8:52must have been
- 8:54early evening when
- 8:57the doctor came in and said to my mother
- 9:01are you are you in pain? And she said
- 9:03she was.
- 9:05And he said I could give you another
- 9:07dose of morphine
- 9:09but it will repress your breathing and
- 9:12you will
- 9:13likely lose consciousness.
- 9:16And so she said yes please give me the
- 9:19morphine. And at that point we all
- 9:22realized the the vigil had become begun
- 9:26that she would go at some point
- 9:30probably you know within the next 24
- 9:33hours or so.
- 9:35And so
- 9:36we we agreed we'd kind of take turns one
- 9:39of us would go and rest in the sunroom.
- 9:42So we got to the point where Justin and
- 9:45I my son and I were in the room.
- 9:48We were sitting on opposite sides of her
- 9:52bed.
- 9:53And the the
- 9:56first thing he did was so
- 9:59so beautiful.
- 10:01He said
- 10:02actually this was before the final
- 10:04morphine shot. He said to my mother
- 10:08you've given me so many gifts.
- 10:13And I thought, my God,
- 10:16my sense of humor was going on. I
- 10:18thought, well, that's like the old joke.
- 10:22Why does a grandparent and a grandchild
- 10:25have so much love? Answer, they have a
- 10:28common enemy.
- 10:30[laughter] So
- 10:34I think everybody before they die needs
- 10:37to hear that they've made other people's
- 10:40lives better.
- 10:41And so he told her the many ways that
- 10:45she had made his life better.
- 10:48And then he got into the bed with her
- 10:51and held her, which was
- 10:54such a beautiful thing. And
- 10:57you know, then after that the doctor
- 11:00came with the morphine. And
- 11:03so it was probably around
- 11:073:00 in the morning
- 11:09that
- 11:10I was sitting on the opposite side of
- 11:13her bed with Justin.
- 11:16And I was perfectly wide awake.
- 11:20And
- 11:22I have to say, by the way, that I was an
- 11:25aficionado of waking and dream states
- 11:29because I'd been studying lucid dreaming
- 11:32for five or six years.
- 11:35And I was very well aware of what it is
- 11:38like when you wake up inside of a dream.
- 11:42And I had been cultivating my own
- 11:45ability to do that. So I understood what
- 11:48it was to have a lucid dream and to be
- 11:51awake within the dream.
- 11:54And what I had was not a lucid dream. I
- 11:57can tell you that. I very different.
- 12:00So I'm sitting there and suddenly I feel
- 12:04like a physical shock, [snorts]
- 12:07like, oh, what what is this?
- 12:10And suddenly I'm having a vision.
- 12:14And in the vision
- 12:16I am a pregnant mother who is in the
- 12:20process of giving birth.
- 12:23But I'm also the baby being born. And I
- 12:28have the capacity to witness this. It's
- 12:30happening, but I'm also, you know, in
- 12:34like normal waking consciousness
- 12:36watching it happen.
- 12:38And I'm laughing to myself and I'm
- 12:41thinking, aha,
- 12:42I'm both the mother and the baby.
- 12:46And I said that's the nature of the
- 12:48divine that there's really only one of
- 12:52us here
- 12:54just taking all these different parts.
- 12:57And that experience is what, you know,
- 13:00the famous philosopher William James
- 13:03called a noetic experience.
- 13:06You simply know that it's true. There's
- 13:09no question in your mind that this this
- 13:13is true.
- 13:15And so
- 13:17I'm I'm having this experience of being
- 13:19the mother and the baby.
- 13:22And then my consciousness
- 13:24switches into being
- 13:27just the baby.
- 13:29And there's a kind of prolonged period
- 13:31of coming through the birth canal and
- 13:35how difficult that is for the baby
- 13:39leaving the womb and the pressure and
- 13:42all of you know, all of that.
- 13:44And then next thing is baby is coming
- 13:48out of the birth canal into the light.
- 13:51And so
- 13:53I have an experience of divine light.
- 13:56And that there simply aren't any words
- 13:59for what that light feels like. It's
- 14:03simply pure unconditional love.
- 14:07And the light,
- 14:08you know, I it it it I was a being of
- 14:11light that greeted me.
- 14:14It was
- 14:16pure mercy and loving kindness. Just
- 14:20pure mercy. The way I I
- 14:23explain this often and this I felt like
- 14:27the light had seen everything about me,
- 14:29all of my mistakes, all of my judgments,
- 14:33all of my pettiness, all of my, you
- 14:36know, stuff.
- 14:39And
- 14:40I was
- 14:41completely loved in spite of all of
- 14:44that. And in fact, the sense that I had
- 14:48was that this this light was like a
- 14:52cheerleader for the evolution of my
- 14:54soul.
- 14:56The only thing was
- 14:58I was being tended. How could I grow?
- 15:01How could I become
- 15:03pure love and that I already was pure
- 15:06love?
- 15:08And
- 15:09you know, my analytical mind was still
- 15:12working. I was thinking like, whoa, holy
- 15:15moly, what is this being of light? And I
- 15:19said, well, it could be a projection of
- 15:22my own soul, my own higher nature.
- 15:26I said, certainly not God. It's a more
- 15:29limited expression. I didn't think that
- 15:33source it said that it was the source
- 15:35itself.
- 15:37But I was also
- 15:39um very willing to say
- 15:42no wonder people call it a being of
- 15:44light that I'll have to leave it at
- 15:47that.
- 15:48And then
- 15:50that being of light
- 15:52showed me
- 15:54about seven, maybe eight, seven or eight
- 15:58vignettes. I wish that I had written
- 16:00them all down.
- 16:02And it was a life review
- 16:05of vignettes from my mother and myself.
- 16:09And
- 16:11so it would show me an interaction
- 16:15which on the outside of it looked
- 16:18unfortunate or difficult or angry or
- 16:23unresolved,
- 16:25something that was emotionally
- 16:26difficult, but I would see it from
- 16:30another perspective and I saw, oh,
- 16:34both of us grew in some way from this
- 16:37interaction.
- 16:39Each one was different and I could see
- 16:42that our evolution was intertwined
- 16:46and that what was difficult
- 16:49had a totally different explanation
- 16:54that we do not see from where we where
- 16:57we are [laughter]
- 16:59in in our bodies.
- 17:01And then
- 17:02it was
- 17:04the the experience played out. It was
- 17:08like the real was over, all of these
- 17:11vignettes finished
- 17:13and it was simply ended. And so I said,
- 17:17well,
- 17:18that's, you know, that's the end. What
- 17:21an amazing experience.
- 17:23And so I opened my eyes and much
- 17:28to my surprise, the way I put it is I
- 17:31had double vision.
- 17:33I could see both light and form
- 17:37and I saw that everything was made of
- 17:39the energy of light. The whole room was
- 17:42made of of light and I thought, my god,
- 17:45this is like what my high school
- 17:46chemistry teacher taught us. She would
- 17:49like knock on the desk and say, that
- 17:52looks solid,
- 17:54but it's it's there's more space than
- 17:56solidity. It's atoms and and energy that
- 18:00moves. It just moves in a way that our
- 18:04eyes can't see it. And I saw it and I
- 18:08saw the movement. I saw, oh my god,
- 18:11everything is actually one because it
- 18:14takes these temporary solid forms, but
- 18:19you can see it
- 18:21and interacting and the energy moving.
- 18:24And you know, I saw Oh, by the way, the
- 18:28last thing I
- 18:31thought
- 18:32it's not even that you think these
- 18:34things. You don't think. You know these
- 18:36things. There's no thinking process
- 18:40um in the actual experience. There's
- 18:43thinking, you know, when myself looks at
- 18:45it and tries to analyze it, but not in
- 18:48the experience itself.
- 18:50The last thing before I opened my eyes
- 18:54was
- 18:55the most deep
- 18:58deep gratitude
- 19:01for the circularity of the experience
- 19:04with my mother
- 19:05that she had birthed me into this life
- 19:09and that I had just birthed her out of
- 19:12this life. And of course, she had in
- 19:14fact died
- 19:16during that um she was gone.
- 19:20And so the room is filled with light.
- 19:24She's gone. If you've ever been with
- 19:27somebody who has died,
- 19:29they're gone. There's no way to really
- 19:32explain that. It's like the life force
- 19:35has departed.
- 19:37And
- 19:38yet, you know, the molecules are still
- 19:41there. Everything is is made of energy
- 19:45and light. And I look across her now
- 19:48empty body to my son.
- 19:51And there he is sitting there
- 19:54in my child is
- 19:56made of light.
- 19:58And he has a halo.
- 20:00And you know, and I think
- 20:03these
- 20:05Renaissance painters
- 20:08if the seeing of the halo is simply the
- 20:12way that everyone looks
- 20:15if you have the eyes to see, if you're
- 20:17having an experience like that,
- 20:20it's like an artifact of the light. So
- 20:23there's my child sitting there with a
- 20:25halo, and he's weeping. And tiny
- 20:30tiny little rainbows are coming out of
- 20:34the tears
- 20:36that are coming down his face.
- 20:39And he's transfigured.
- 20:41It's like a look of such
- 20:44bliss, such bliss.
- 20:47And so he catches my eye and he says,
- 20:51Mom,
- 20:52the room is filled with light. Can you
- 20:56see it? And I said, yes, I see it too.
- 21:00And
- 21:01I thought,
- 21:03well, this is something. Justin and I
- 21:05were not dying.
- 21:07And the fact that we both went into the
- 21:11light with my mother, how are you going
- 21:13to explain that?
- 21:15And
- 21:16[snorts]
- 21:17I know with this I walked around the
- 21:20bed. I walked around my mother's dead
- 21:22body and I sat next to my son.
- 21:26And he looks at me and he can hardly
- 21:29speak. He is
- 21:32he just can't believe it. And the first
- 21:35words out of his mouth were,
- 21:38this
- 21:39is Grandma's last gift.
- 21:42She's holding open the door to eternity
- 21:45so that we can have a glimpse.
- 21:49And
- 21:50then he looks at me and he said,
- 21:55he said I had a vision. And he's never
- 21:58told me what the vision was.
- 22:01What he did say, he said what I
- 22:04understood
- 22:06from this
- 22:07is that
- 22:09your mother
- 22:11was a very great being.
- 22:14She was an evolved soul. And she took a
- 22:18role in this life much smaller than who
- 22:22she was. And he kept repeating that. Who
- 22:25would do that
- 22:27for someone else? Who
- 22:30who such a great being would come
- 22:33and
- 22:34be
- 22:35such a
- 22:36regular ordinary person
- 22:40in this life? And he was he was amazed
- 22:42by it. He was trying to process this and
- 22:45kept repeating it. What a gift. What a
- 22:48gift. What a gift she gave to you. She
- 22:51gave you a lifetime.
- 22:54And
- 22:55and he said
- 22:57she gave you that lifetime because
- 23:00you're meant to be a teacher of love.
- 23:03And if love had just come to you,
- 23:06you wouldn't have been able to teach it.
- 23:09You needed some resistance, something to
- 23:12bump up
- 23:14around
- 23:15in order for you to understand the
- 23:18necessity of love and what what love
- 23:21what love is.
- 23:23And he just
- 23:24kept crying. And then we both had such a
- 23:29bolt of joy
- 23:32at that time. People from that time
- 23:34might remember the Ren and Stimpy
- 23:37cartoon.
- 23:38And they had a little song they sang
- 23:41called Happy Happy, Joy Joy. And just
- 23:45then lifted me up.
- 23:48And we danced around my mother's body
- 23:52singing Happy Happy, Joy Joy.
- 23:56[laughter]
- 23:57But after that, I thought to myself,
- 24:01this really is my mother's last gift.
- 24:04This is an experience
- 24:07that is meant to be shared with people.
- 24:10And
- 24:12this was at a time that people were not
- 24:15reporting what's now called shared death
- 24:18experiences.
- 24:21Um
- 24:21back at that time, I think
- 24:24Raymond Moody was talking about empathic
- 24:28death experiences.
- 24:31And this was very important to me as a
- 24:33scientist
- 24:36[clears throat] because
- 24:37I was a scientist
- 24:40and I also made room for spirituality. I
- 24:44had to walk a tightrope because
- 24:47that's not the kind of thing that you do
- 24:49in academia. I was very careful about
- 24:52what I said.
- 24:54But
- 24:55I remember talking about near death
- 24:58experiences at one point
- 25:01in a lecture
- 25:03and being challenged by several
- 25:06physicians in the room
- 25:08who said no, you know, it's an artifact
- 25:12of dying brain cells.
- 25:14And
- 25:15as a scientist, let me tell you, I am a
- 25:18stickler. I'm very careful with
- 25:20statistics, with research design,
- 25:24um with interpreting data.
- 25:27But
- 25:28this is not the kind of experience
- 25:32that you can understand scientifically.
- 25:35It just is a realm that science doesn't
- 25:39doesn't know how to
- 25:41really research. There's no research you
- 25:44can do.
- 25:45And I want to say that
- 25:47even to this day
- 25:49very often the way I go to sleep at
- 25:52night
- 25:53is I start in that hospital room
- 25:57and then
- 25:58I imagine that being of light
- 26:02and
- 26:04go to sleep
- 26:06in that sense of
- 26:09there's nothing else I can call it but
- 26:11divine love, divine love and mercy.
- 26:15And like
- 26:16people who've had near death experiences
- 26:20and say it's changed the way that I live
- 26:23my life.
- 26:25Well, it has.
- 26:38>> [music]
- 26:42>> Hello.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Harvard Scientist's Mother Dies—Then Her Son Describes the Impossible Joan Borysenko Shared Death by When You Die, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,240 words across 587 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.