Harvard i-lab | Startup Secrets Part 3: Business Model - Michael Skok — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00[Music]
- 0:11Okay, I think we'll get started um so we
- 0:14can have time to get through all of
- 0:16Michael's material tonight on it in a
- 0:18timely manner. Um, for all of you who
- 0:20have been here before, you know Michael
- 0:22Scott. He's running a five session
- 0:24series on startup secrets, how to give
- 0:27yourself an unfair competitive
- 0:29advantage. Tonight's discussion is going
- 0:31to be around business model analysis.
- 0:33And I know he's brought a number of his
- 0:36portfolio companies to present as well.
- 0:38Um, so it's going to be a lively
- 0:39session. I'm really looking forward to
- 0:41it. Um, without further ado, I'm going
- 0:43to hand you over to Michael and his team
- 0:46of people.
- 0:49Well, welcome everybody. We should have
- 0:50a lot of fun this evening. We're going
- 0:52to talk about one as as Jody says of the
- 0:56multiple things that we put on the
- 0:57original topic and that being business
- 0:59model. For those of you who've been at
- 1:01the other sessions, this will feel like
- 1:03it's in context. For those of you who
- 1:04haven't been, I just want to get a show
- 1:06of hands who's new here. Therefore, I
- 1:08can try to cover some of the background.
- 1:10Okay. Quite a number of new people
- 1:11actually. Okay. Okay, so I will tell you
- 1:13this right before I get going in which
- 1:15case the value proposition session which
- 1:18is up on the website
- 1:20contracapist.com provides the background
- 1:22to what is it that you do and how do you
- 1:26do it uniquely well for who that's the
- 1:29simplification of a very long one hour
- 1:32monologue by me. Uh so there you go. You
- 1:35skipped the one hour. You've got the the
- 1:37essence of it. And based on the value
- 1:40proposition, the business model is all
- 1:42about figuring out how you take that to
- 1:44market as a viable financial sales
- 1:48marketing and uh even service and
- 1:51support model. So even though you've
- 1:53missed that, just think about whatever
- 1:55idea it is you've got, we're going to
- 1:56figure out how to build a business model
- 1:58around it today. If you missed the
- 2:00company formation piece, that was really
- 2:01around building the team and obviously
- 2:04hiring the people to make that a
- 2:06successful basis to take your enterprise
- 2:09u and execute and next session is very
- 2:12much the other side of the coin to the
- 2:15business model because business model is
- 2:17so closely aligned to go to market
- 2:19strategy. So that gives you a little bit
- 2:21of context for those who haven't been
- 2:22here. All right, first of all, I just
- 2:24like to make some introductions. Uh
- 2:26we've got a number of the portfolio
- 2:27companies being kind enough to come in
- 2:28as case studies this evening and also to
- 2:30help out in the workshop. So you've got
- 2:31real executives who have real day jobs,
- 2:34real entrepreneurs who have real ideas
- 2:36that can help you as you try to take
- 2:38yours uh and figure out what your
- 2:39business model is. So first of all like
- 2:41to introduce the active endpoints uh two
- 2:44representatives here, Mark Taber and
- 2:46Eric Egson. If you just like stand up.
- 2:48Mark's our CEO and Eric heads up sales.
- 2:50Thank you guys for coming.
- 2:53[Applause]
- 2:54And then akibban we have uh David
- 2:57McFarland and Oristat the CEO and
- 2:59founder
- 3:01[Applause]
- 3:02respectively. And then from Demandware
- 3:05who uh is represented by Jamus Driscoll,
- 3:07I just say before he says anything
- 3:10they're on the road show and so he's
- 3:11basically been told not to say anything.
- 3:13Say nothing. I don't exist. I was never
- 3:15here.
- 3:18So, unfortunately, we can't use his case
- 3:20study, but he's assured me we'll use one
- 3:21when they get through the road trip.
- 3:22But, um, thank you for coming. He'll be
- 3:24part of at least the workshop so he can
- 3:25engage with you. Uh, and then I'm lucky
- 3:27to have two of my partners here tonight,
- 3:29too. Not quite sure why they're here
- 3:31except to check that I don't say
- 3:32something out of order, but uh, Jim
- 3:34Moran from
- 3:36[Applause]
- 3:39Northridge. And then we also have
- 3:41Carichel Roberts who's also brought some
- 3:43special guests with him.
- 3:45Car Michael. No. Okay. Well, we have I'm
- 3:49going to get him right now. Don't worry.
- 3:50We'll introduce him when he comes in.
- 3:51He's brought another of his companies
- 3:53actually because uh Jim and I mostly
- 3:56work on software, but we did want to
- 3:58make sure that people who are not
- 3:59focused on software have a sense that
- 4:01these business model techniques that
- 4:02we're going to talk about tonight
- 4:04actually do apply to many different
- 4:06kinds of ventures. And so, in fact, he's
- 4:08going to talk about one of his companies
- 4:09called MCT10, which is in the material
- 4:11space. Very good. So let's jump in with
- 4:14our agenda. As I said, this is all about
- 4:16building a business model. And I'm
- 4:18particularly going to focus on just four
- 4:20things. First of all, finding a
- 4:21disruptive business model. You can all
- 4:23go and discuss what a business model is.
- 4:25You can read about it many different
- 4:26ways. But if you're a startup, the
- 4:28really important thing you're going to
- 4:30try to do is bring disruptive innovation
- 4:33into the marketplace. And that shouldn't
- 4:34just be about technology. The business
- 4:36model is a fundamental piece of it. But
- 4:38how do you find that? Well, I'm going to
- 4:40show you three key things. First of all,
- 4:43finding your core differentiation. That
- 4:45is absolutely critical to building a
- 4:47business model. Secondly, what are the
- 4:49multipliers that will help you spread
- 4:52that value proposition in an effective
- 4:54way getting great market share, great
- 4:56reach, and ultimately great revenue. And
- 4:59then third, very importantly, how do you
- 5:02take the cost out of the equation uh
- 5:04with levers? And levers, as you'll see,
- 5:07are things that can be highly
- 5:08advantageous to companies that figure
- 5:10out how to use them in their business
- 5:12model. And then last, I'm going to give
- 5:14you a very quick insight into how that
- 5:16plays out in the life cycle of working
- 5:18with your customers. And particularly
- 5:20important here is an example I'm going
- 5:22to bring to light for you of how this
- 5:24plays out in the software world, but
- 5:26again, I would say it's applicable to
- 5:28many different areas. I mentioned
- 5:30earlier that um this is really one side
- 5:32of the coin. The other side of it is go
- 5:34to market. So you will feel in some
- 5:36cases like I'm transgressing a little
- 5:38bit into what does it take to go to
- 5:39market but that's because there's clear
- 5:41linkages here and then the most
- 5:42important thing about tonight is of
- 5:44course the workshop and we're going to
- 5:45have a lot of fun with that. We've got
- 5:4610 teams again tonight uh and 10 helpers
- 5:49and Jody's organized for us to have the
- 5:51whiteboards to see around the room so
- 5:53everybody can go write their business
- 5:55models up and come in and present them
- 5:56and we'll have the usual voting at the
- 5:58end. Excellent. Well, with that in mind,
- 6:01I'm going to get the boring stuff right
- 6:02out the way right away.
- 6:04Everybody can go read this on the web.
- 6:06There are actually some great books on
- 6:07it. The basics of business models are
- 6:09around creating the value. So that's
- 6:12things like creating your product or
- 6:13service, delivering it. That's things
- 6:15like obviously how you take it to market
- 6:17and then how you harness or monetize or
- 6:20capture the
- 6:21value. But we're here for a reason. We
- 6:24want to talk about startups. And if
- 6:26you're a startup, I want you to start
- 6:27thinking about business models
- 6:29creatively right away. Don't take
- 6:31somebody else's business model as my
- 6:32first piece of advice to you. There are
- 6:34plenty of business models around. In
- 6:36fact, it will be true to say that the
- 6:38best example of business models of a
- 6:41business model probably hasn't been
- 6:42invented yet. And that's what I hope
- 6:44we'll get from you is the next
- 6:46generation of interesting business
- 6:48models because this is all about how can
- 6:50you make a breakthrough here. It's not
- 6:52about picking somebody else's business
- 6:54model and just applying it to your
- 6:55situation. the chances are at that point
- 6:57you're adding very little value in your
- 6:59startup and you're probably not making
- 7:00any major impact. So I really want you
- 7:03to think about this literally as how do
- 7:05you change the game? If you could come
- 7:07in for example to a marketplace and
- 7:10literally rewrite the rules on your own
- 7:12game and cause somebody else to have an
- 7:15innovator's dilemma. Imagine how
- 7:16powerful that would be. I would argue
- 7:18that that is at least as important as
- 7:21having a disruptive technology. There
- 7:23are many examples like that. What I
- 7:25encourage you to do is to think about
- 7:27whatever it is you're bringing to market
- 7:29in those kinds of ways. Don't let
- 7:31somebody else write the rules. You write
- 7:33them. In fact, define the whole new game
- 7:36the way that you can. So, what's an
- 7:38example? I'm really going to date
- 7:40myself. I put an exclamation mark here.
- 7:43Um, 20 years ago, believe it or not,
- 7:46there was this little company called
- 7:47Semantic. It's a multi-billion dollar
- 7:48company today. That's the good news. But
- 7:50the bad news is at the time we were
- 7:53actually a struggling company in many
- 7:55ways and I would say that with uh tongue
- 7:59and cheek because you know obviously
- 8:00it's become very successful but I think
- 8:03we had more than 20 products. We had
- 8:04everything from add-ins for uh Lotus 123
- 8:08if those of you remember back to that
- 8:10was the first spreadsheet to uh we had
- 8:12languages you know think C, think Pascal
- 8:15on the Mac. Uh we had all sorts of
- 8:17products. We had a database, we had a
- 8:18word processor. I mean, it was just
- 8:19unbelievable. And I'm particularly being
- 8:21brought um uh this is all being brought
- 8:24back to me right now because we're about
- 8:25to have a 20-year reunion for the first
- 8:2720 years of Semantic this weekend. And
- 8:29all these products and so forth have
- 8:31been coming to light. And so this
- 8:32example just stuck in my mind and it's
- 8:35really a business model example. The
- 8:38product that was selling best on the
- 8:39Macintosh back then was something called
- 8:41Semantic Antivirus for Mac. And believe
- 8:44it or not, the Mac was plagued with
- 8:45viruses in those days. system 6 or 7 or
- 8:48whatever it was at the time was was
- 8:50really an issue and it was a very
- 8:51successful product for us and we were
- 8:53selling it as a licensed product. a you
- 8:55know whatever it was dollars perpetual
- 8:58license you bought it through uh the
- 9:00time you know your local retailer and
- 9:03because it was a chart topping product
- 9:05you'd have said at that point great
- 9:06we've got that business model nailed we
- 9:07know how to produce that product package
- 9:09it distribute it sell it it's the top of
- 9:10the charts what should we do when we
- 9:13introduce the PC
- 9:14version the answer is why don't you just
- 9:17copy the business model I just told you
- 9:19I think that's a really bad idea and so
- 9:22we also stopped and thought about Uh and
- 9:25initially we got it slightly right in
- 9:28that we decided it was important to
- 9:30introduce the PC model with more of a
- 9:33flavor of an upgrade service and an
- 9:35update service because there were many
- 9:37more viruses coming out for the PC. And
- 9:40so in fact we were having to get people
- 9:41updates initially once a quarter. Then
- 9:44we realized wow it's happening sort of
- 9:45once a month. Then we realized hey this
- 9:47is happening regularly. It's probably
- 9:49hard to believe this. At the time, there
- 9:50were probably a maximum of about 100
- 9:53viruses on the planet uh when this came
- 9:55out. Now there are, you know, tens of
- 9:57thousands and they come out very
- 9:58regular. So, of course, what we did was
- 10:01we flipped it all on its head. We
- 10:03actually decided the software was worth
- 10:05nothing because we needed to get that
- 10:07out there as a platform for people to be
- 10:09able to get the virus definitions
- 10:11downloaded to prevent the viruses. And
- 10:13so, the real value was not in the
- 10:15software at all. the real value was in
- 10:17having the virus definition before it
- 10:18ever attacked anybody's machine. And so
- 10:21that literally was the turning point if
- 10:24you were to ask me personally, I think
- 10:26you ask pretty much anybody at Sam at
- 10:28the time on the fortunes of that company
- 10:31because we suddenly created a
- 10:32subscription model that was not a nice
- 10:35to have. It was essential for
- 10:37enterprises and they didn't care about
- 10:38the software. They cared about the
- 10:40person who had that virus definition
- 10:41first. And suddenly we had a very
- 10:43predictable business because every time
- 10:45a virus came out we knew people were
- 10:47going to want to download it. Therefore
- 10:48we knew they were going to want the
- 10:49subscription to be up to date. Therefore
- 10:50we knew they were going to pay monthly.
- 10:52Therefore we could see what our revenue
- 10:53was going to be. And it was very very
- 10:56gamechanging. So that's an example from
- 10:59a product
- 11:01standpoint. Any questions on that before
- 11:03I go forward? So did you after that
- 11:05change the Mac model? Yes. Yes we did.
- 11:09Uh and in fact uh I'll give credit to
- 11:12one of my sales guys here uh who was one
- 11:14of the first guys who actually even
- 11:16flipped the entire product line on its
- 11:18head and said you know what we're
- 11:20selling a bunch of things like backup
- 11:21for example and Norton utilities was
- 11:23another product we sold but people
- 11:25really don't want to pay for the
- 11:26software what they're really doing is
- 11:27trying to get data security and prevent
- 11:30data loss and so forth so we came up
- 11:32with what he called and he really
- 11:33deserves the credit for it a total
- 11:35solution to data security and in the UK
- 11:38for example we took full page ads in the
- 11:40Financial Times and we went to an
- 11:42extraordinary length to get people to
- 11:44understand that what's the most
- 11:45important thing to them that they're
- 11:46actually producing with all this
- 11:48software. It's their data. It's their
- 11:49information. So, they really should put
- 11:51that top in terms of creating data
- 11:53protection. And suddenly, as a result of
- 11:55that uh thinking, we actually started
- 11:57selling a data protection service and we
- 11:59bundled all of our products together in
- 12:00what we called the total solution and
- 12:02sales just took off. And if I would go
- 12:05into it even one more level of detail
- 12:06for you, I'd tell you this, which is we
- 12:08used to on average sell one to one and a
- 12:11half products per major enterprise per
- 12:14seat. And by bundling five or six
- 12:17products together, the actual natural
- 12:19average of that turned out to be 2.6. So
- 12:21in other words, we went from 1.5 to 2.6
- 12:24the value uh just by bundling that
- 12:26correctly and by taking the game up to
- 12:28being a data security uh and information
- 12:31protection game. extraordinarily
- 12:33successful uh and my investors at the
- 12:35time who were quite concerned to say the
- 12:37least about us going and taking full
- 12:39page ads out in in major newspapers uh
- 12:42very quickly lost their concern and saw
- 12:44tremendous
- 12:46results. Okay, so next example this is
- 12:49not a technology example. This is
- 12:51absolutely a pure play business example.
- 12:54At the time I was based in the UK and I
- 12:57was observing that every major product
- 12:59that came into the UK from a US
- 13:01publisher was largely failing. Failing
- 13:04because they didn't have the investment
- 13:06in management, marketing, distribution,
- 13:08sales, services, and support. And why?
- 13:11Because if you look at the US market,
- 13:13it's 10 times roughly bigger than the UK
- 13:15market. So let's say you're a $10
- 13:16million company in the US. You may have
- 13:19some at that point relative critical
- 13:21max, even $20 million going to the UK.
- 13:24tenth the size and market you could be
- 13:26maybe a $2 million company doesn't
- 13:28really give you much room to invest in
- 13:29marketing or management or distribution
- 13:31or translation localization all these
- 13:32other things so it was very tough for us
- 13:35companies to be successful and they
- 13:37typically went to just distributors and
- 13:38said here we've got a great product you
- 13:40know put it in distribution well
- 13:41products don't sell themselves and so
- 13:44without the marketing and support or
- 13:45translation in some cases it was very
- 13:47unsuccessful so I decided to come up
- 13:50with a business model that basically
- 13:52enabled us companies companies to bring
- 13:54them to bring their products to us as
- 13:57one entity, European Software
- 13:58Publishing. And because we had multiple
- 14:00products, we could get the critical mass
- 14:03in all the things I just put up on the
- 14:04on the management all the way through to
- 14:06distribution. And as a result of that,
- 14:08we were able to provide, for example,
- 14:11introductions to the top uh times 100
- 14:14companies. That's equivalent 41,000. And
- 14:17if we'd already got that connection on
- 14:19one product, when we took on another
- 14:20product, it be very easy to open the
- 14:21door and say, "Okay, here's the next
- 14:23product." We do it very selectively. So
- 14:24it wasn't like a, you know, a long
- 14:27list. It was very successful financially
- 14:29for the US companies, too, because we
- 14:32would get these companies to about 20
- 14:33to$30 million. In other words, highly
- 14:37scaled, highly profitable at that point.
- 14:39And then we would enable them to acquire
- 14:40them back. But it was also acquired back
- 14:43on a basis that there was something
- 14:45called pooling of interest in those
- 14:46days. But just think of it as a tax
- 14:48efficient way to do it. It was
- 14:49non-dilutive. So it cost them nothing in
- 14:51terms of earnings per share if you will.
- 14:54And it was ultimately uh acquiring
- 14:56something that had growing earnings. So
- 14:58the minute they acquired it, it was
- 14:59adding to their top line as well as
- 15:01their bottom line as therefore to their
- 15:03overall stakeholder value. So it was
- 15:04like incubating if you will these
- 15:06companies till they got to the point
- 15:08that they were successful and then
- 15:09acquiring them back on this
- 15:10anti-dilutive basis on this just highly
- 15:12profitable basis and uh as an example
- 15:15semantic itself which is one of the
- 15:17companies that we brought over uh was a
- 15:20huge win uh I put this picture up there
- 15:23because I say it's a huge win but then
- 15:25my wife always reminds me that the two
- 15:27bibles that it took is that they were
- 15:29huge thick things to conclude that deal
- 15:31was the pain involved in it. So there
- 15:33was a lot involved in doing that but the
- 15:35win-win here for investors for the early
- 15:37investors was a 97x on their money to
- 15:40give you a sense of it. Um and yet
- 15:42Semantic themselves doubled the value on
- 15:44an on a accretive basis acquiring the
- 15:47company. So the day after the
- 15:48acquisition was acquired was announced
- 15:51the company's share price went up and
- 15:52also more importantly the continuing
- 15:54earning streams continued to contribute
- 15:57and semantic in the UK was their most
- 15:59profitable uh business outside of the US
- 16:01at the time. So everybody won. We we
- 16:04made customers happy. We obviously made
- 16:06our shareholders happy. And in the
- 16:08middle of this thing, we made semantic
- 16:10uh as an entity more successful. That
- 16:13had nothing to do with technology.
- 16:14Absolutely nothing. Although, by the
- 16:16way, I was very passionate about
- 16:17Semantic products and stayed on and and
- 16:19continue to actually uh really enjoy
- 16:22working with them. But my point is here,
- 16:24this is an example of something that you
- 16:26should be thinking about even if you've
- 16:28got a breakthrough technology. What are
- 16:29the things that will make a win-win for
- 16:31you? So tonight I'm going to talk to you
- 16:33about that and hopefully give you enough
- 16:35examples about it. I don't think I need
- 16:37to say more about this, but um I've
- 16:40hopefully made it clear to you that it
- 16:41is at least as important. But now I want
- 16:43to give you a a specific reason why the
- 16:46business model is as important as
- 16:47technology. So before I give you the
- 16:50answer, can anybody tell me why in
- 16:52financial terms business model should be
- 16:55considered as important as technology?
- 16:57Any thoughts?
- 17:00I've given you some examples, but can
- 17:01anybody give me? Products don't sell
- 17:03themselves. Sorry. Go ahead. Products
- 17:05don't sell themselves. So, no matter how
- 17:07good your technology doesn't matter.
- 17:09Yeah, you're on exactly the right track.
- 17:11Products don't sell themselves. People
- 17:13don't even know about them. How are they
- 17:14going to even find them even if they are
- 17:16great? So, what does it cost to for
- 17:18people to find out about your product?
- 17:20Is that relatively the same as
- 17:21developing the product? Is it more? Is
- 17:23it less? Anybody?
- 17:26Somebody heard saying more.
- 17:29A show of hands. Who thinks it's more?
- 17:31This is an easy way to Okay. Well, those
- 17:34of you who said
- 17:36more, you're right. The staggering thing
- 17:39is how much more? It's usually double.
- 17:42If you look at a software company, for
- 17:43example, P&L, you'll see that on
- 17:45average, companies will settle out at
- 17:47around 15 to 20% of their P&L being
- 17:51spent on R&D and 30 to 40%, in other
- 17:54words, double on sales and marketing. So
- 17:57what I'm pointing out to you here is
- 17:58even if you've got a brilliant product,
- 18:00how it'll end up playing out in your
- 18:02business model is that double the amount
- 18:04that you're spending on your product is
- 18:05going to be spent just as u was
- 18:07volunteered from the back there on
- 18:10taking it to market. And that's what
- 18:11this business model is all about. It's
- 18:13about how you get multipliers and levers
- 18:16to actually take the cost out and the
- 18:18revenue
- 18:19up. And in fact, I'll go one step
- 18:21further. I will say that the perfect
- 18:23startup storm by the time you finish
- 18:26this session and the next session should
- 18:27be very easy for you to define. It
- 18:29should be a disruptive business model
- 18:31with a disruptive technology and then
- 18:33you obviously focusing on a new market
- 18:35opportunity or target segment with an
- 18:37innovative way to get it there. You get
- 18:39those three things, you have my
- 18:40attention. Now, I'm not saying by the
- 18:42way that great companies don't get
- 18:44formed with one or even two of those,
- 18:45but if you have all three, you really
- 18:47have the perfect startup store.
- 18:49So, let's get you started on thinking
- 18:51about some of these
- 18:53models. Excuse me while I reattach my
- 18:59mic. These models here are just a
- 19:01sampling of the ones that I went to pick
- 19:03up. The wonderful thing about them and
- 19:05the reason I picked them is many of
- 19:06these companies didn't exist, you know,
- 19:08five or 10 years ago. Uh, one of the
- 19:10fastest growing companies uh ever is
- 19:13Groupon and they came up with a
- 19:14completely new business model. Um, one
- 19:17of my favorites which I used for a while
- 19:18and didn't understand their business
- 19:20model until I sort of thought about it
- 19:21was Mint. It's not a company that's
- 19:24actually trying to make money out of the
- 19:25software the way Intuit did to process
- 19:27your um, finances. It's actually a lead
- 19:30genen business that's actually driving
- 19:32lead generation to many of the financial
- 19:34services providers. And in our own
- 19:36portfolio, even though um Jamus can't
- 19:38talk about it, Demandware has a very
- 19:41innovative business model which written
- 19:43in the S1 is all about revenue share.
- 19:45And I could say no more than that. Uh
- 19:48but it's an example of what I think I'm
- 19:51making a point of here and that is every
- 19:52one of these companies is at least in
- 19:55part being successful because of a
- 19:57disruptive business model. And we will
- 20:00talk about some of these examples, but
- 20:02they might be things that you've never
- 20:04even thought about associated with
- 20:05technology before. Such as, for example,
- 20:07how do you do crowd sourcing? There's an
- 20:09innovative company in Boston called
- 20:11Utest that's actually taking people from
- 20:14around the world to test mobile phones
- 20:17uh in all the different environments
- 20:18around the world. You might say, well,
- 20:20why is that a big deal in a business
- 20:21model? Well, think about the
- 20:22alternative. There are so many different
- 20:24phone types with so many different
- 20:26carriers that can be used in so many
- 20:27different places. There's no possible
- 20:29way you could recreate an environment
- 20:31that would test all the different
- 20:32scenarios for mobile phones and mobile
- 20:34applications. But if you crowdsource it
- 20:35all around the world, you can get a real
- 20:37sampling of what might be the way to
- 20:39test things. So their business model
- 20:42actually not only solves that problem,
- 20:43but actually of course leverages lowcost
- 20:46labor around the world as a lever to
- 20:48help them be very effective in their
- 20:50test. So, I would say any one of these
- 20:53examples is one of many I could have
- 20:56picked to again hopefully get you
- 20:58thinking about what could you do to be
- 21:01disruptive. So, what are the sample
- 21:03questions I'd recommend you start with?
- 21:05Well, amazingly, people come in and they
- 21:07almost invariably say, "We have a
- 21:10product." Yes, you may have a product,
- 21:12but is it really a product or is there a
- 21:15process associated with that product
- 21:16being used? In which case, is the
- 21:18process more valuable than the product?
- 21:20Do you really only have software or do
- 21:22you have to have services to actually
- 21:23make this successful? In which case, is
- 21:25the service more important than the
- 21:26software? In open source, you will find
- 21:29that the software is free. So, unless
- 21:31you have services, there's no value. In
- 21:33is it open or proprietary and and so on
- 21:35and so forth. Here's one I'll pick out
- 21:37for you, which I think is rapidly
- 21:39emerging as an interesting new business
- 21:41model. As we get networks of people
- 21:43working around these products and
- 21:45services, we're collecting tremendous
- 21:47amounts of data on people. And in fact,
- 21:49the best example of that is probably
- 21:51going to be one of the most interesting
- 21:52new IPOs this year. That's Facebook.
- 21:54Facebook's value is not its software. I
- 21:57mean, it's great software. It's
- 21:58impressive that PHP scaled to be able to
- 22:00do, you know, uh to serve hundreds of
- 22:03millions of users. But that's not what
- 22:04we're paying for. We're paying for
- 22:06ability to connect to people. And guess
- 22:08what they're monetizing? They're
- 22:09monetizing the fact that we've all
- 22:10connected and told them what we are
- 22:12doing all day so they can figure out
- 22:13what really is valuable to them. the
- 22:15data behind that that enables them to
- 22:17target us more effectively. So their
- 22:19value is in their content or their data.
- 22:21Maybe they would say simply their data.
- 22:23My point being here this is an example
- 22:26of where I would encourage you to
- 22:28question early what is the set of values
- 22:31that is at the core of your business. So
- 22:34let's go to exactly that. Your first key
- 22:37question should be what is your core
- 22:39value? Those of you who haven't heard me
- 22:41talk before, I've said this many times.
- 22:43I was one of those students who needed
- 22:45pneumonics to remember anything. So,
- 22:47you'll find I use pneumonics everywhere.
- 22:49Um, I could have said corny, but just
- 22:52forgive me. This is a way that hopefully
- 22:54you'll remember these things. The core
- 22:56of your capabilities should be literally
- 22:58what is it that you've got of really
- 23:00exceptional value at the center of your
- 23:03proposition that you could build around
- 23:05that you could create a model around.
- 23:07And when you tell me it's core, nine
- 23:09times out of 10 when I'm sitting with an
- 23:11entrepreneur and I really question it,
- 23:12they haven't defined the core. They've
- 23:14defined a bunch of stuff and when we
- 23:16really press hard, we can actually get
- 23:18even more focused. So I'll often hear,
- 23:20oh, we've got a great software product.
- 23:22Okay, let's talk about what that product
- 23:24does and for who. And then when we
- 23:26really get down to it, we'll find out
- 23:27that a small piece of what somebody's
- 23:29actually building is really the core
- 23:31innovation. So uh in the case that we're
- 23:35going to talk about tonight with a keep
- 23:37you'll find out that they actually are
- 23:39in the database business but the core of
- 23:41their innovation is actually a very
- 23:43critical new piece of how you process
- 23:46data and they didn't need to recreate
- 23:48the entire database infrastructure.
- 23:49They're leveraging a lot of open source
- 23:51to do
- 23:52that. So let's have a look at some
- 23:54examples from the ones we just talked
- 23:56about. I already gave you a sense of how
- 23:57to think about core uh in the example of
- 24:00Facebook. their real uh innovation is
- 24:02probably the user network but if you
- 24:03went to the core I think it's data and
- 24:06what they do with that data obviously in
- 24:07in terms of using it for advertising as
- 24:09a business model is really interesting
- 24:11now they may change that they may decide
- 24:12that at some point there are other
- 24:14values but if they hadn't got that call
- 24:16right early on I think it would have
- 24:17been very difficult another one I think
- 24:20that's that's just gone public so it's
- 24:21topical would be Yelp Yelp could have
- 24:24been thought about as community could
- 24:26have been monetized in many different
- 24:27ways but in the end the content's become
- 24:29really the core of the value there.
- 24:31Again, if you look at what's going on
- 24:33now in uh the world of the net in
- 24:36particular, a lot of times what people
- 24:38are building is some form of
- 24:41userenerated content around the network.
- 24:43And there are many ways you can monetize
- 24:45that. But I would say to you the most
- 24:47important thing you should do is again
- 24:49instead of just saying well how could I
- 24:51monetize it and just say oh advertising
- 24:53is the thing before you do that say well
- 24:55who else am I competing with? And if
- 24:57everybody's advertising, sorry, using
- 24:59advertising in the same way as you are,
- 25:01you probably don't have a competitive
- 25:02advantage. So try to flip it. Try to
- 25:05create an innovator's dilemma. You think
- 25:07about what Christensen has has talked
- 25:08about many years, which is creating some
- 25:11way to do something that can't be
- 25:12followed as opposed to just following
- 25:14what everybody else has done. And so
- 25:16when you think about monetizing your
- 25:18core, think about where others are most
- 25:20vulnerable of where you could do
- 25:22something that again changed the game.
- 25:24go back to that metaphor and rewrote the
- 25:26rules and gave you some way of
- 25:27monetizing that was really tough for
- 25:29others to follow. I'm a huge proponent
- 25:31of open source. If you haven't figured
- 25:32that out, do a lot of investments in
- 25:34that space. And the reason I love it is
- 25:35that it's tough to compete with free,
- 25:37which is really what open source is is
- 25:39at its core. But it's very easy for open
- 25:43source companies therefore to attack
- 25:45existing marketplaces with an offering
- 25:47that is delivering the same value at no
- 25:50cost and focused on making the customer
- 25:52successful with support because the
- 25:54customer loves that and the competitor
- 25:56can't compete with free. So think of
- 25:58things in those ways whatever whatever
- 26:00it is that you're addressing. And if
- 26:02open source helps you think about it I'm
- 26:04happy to talk to you more about why we
- 26:05we love that as a business
- 26:07model. Okay. So core is first point. Now
- 26:10I'm going to introduce you to the next
- 26:11two concepts multipliers and levers and
- 26:14they work around your core. So these are
- 26:16not you know separate to it. Once you
- 26:18know what your core value is, how can
- 26:21you multiply it? Meaning increase the
- 26:23revenue, increase the reach of customers
- 26:25you get to or increase the coverage or
- 26:28market share that you get. That's really
- 26:29what multipliers are all about. And I'm
- 26:31going to bring these to life with some
- 26:32examples in a minute. On the other side,
- 26:35levers reduce the costs, reduce the
- 26:38time, and reduce the resources involved
- 26:41in producing your product or getting it
- 26:43to market or in capturing that value.
- 26:46And if you get both of these things
- 26:47working for you, as the diagram
- 26:50suggests, they really can create
- 26:52extraordinary value on top of your
- 26:54business model, the core of your value
- 26:57proposition. So, what are some examples?
- 26:59As you all know, my experience comes
- 27:01from software.
- 27:03Let me pause the question. What did you
- 27:05mean by reduce resources? I thought you
- 27:07need to have a lot of resources to be a
- 27:10product. Great question. So the question
- 27:13just so everybody heard it is what did I
- 27:15mean by reducing resources when we just
- 27:17said that for example taking products to
- 27:19market requires a lot of resources. What
- 27:21I mean is how could you reduce the
- 27:23resources that are required to take it
- 27:25to market. So, I'll give you a simple
- 27:26example. Just I'm going to preview what
- 27:28I'm about to talk about, but if you
- 27:30could create viral marketing where your
- 27:32user was actually selling for you,
- 27:36that's obviously going to reduce your
- 27:37cost. Does that make sense? So, that's
- 27:38an example of a lever. And by the way,
- 27:40people talk about viral marketing all
- 27:42the time. It's a very tough thing to
- 27:44define. There are all sorts of models
- 27:45people have and coefficients they create
- 27:46and everything else. I'll give you a
- 27:47really example of important example of
- 27:49viral
- 27:50marketing. Reference selling. If you
- 27:54really love something and you refer it
- 27:55to somebody else, that's that's the
- 27:57beginning of viral marketing right
- 27:58there. So making happy customers is the
- 28:01beginning of viral marketing and
- 28:02figuring out how to get very happy
- 28:04customer armed with the right way to
- 28:06reference sell just giving them the
- 28:08basics of of uh you know what what
- 28:11typically is in most people which is
- 28:12they want to justify the purchase
- 28:14they've already made if they like it
- 28:15anyway. So give them the tools to do
- 28:18that and then of course you can do all
- 28:20sorts of offers and things uh to promote
- 28:22it. Anyway, did that answer your
- 28:23question? Great. Any other questions
- 28:26before I move
- 28:27on? Okay. So uh for examples I as I said
- 28:31I meant software so I'm going to use
- 28:33these as as u talking points but I think
- 28:35these apply to many different
- 28:36businesses. So the first category that
- 28:39we're talking about is exactly what we
- 28:40just uh discussed which is sales and
- 28:42marketing. It's usually such a huge part
- 28:44of the P&L that if you can start to get
- 28:46a multiplier working for you here, it's
- 28:49very valuable. And things that make may
- 28:51make a difference here are things like
- 28:52tiered pricing. So in other words, if
- 28:55you sell a product at one price in all
- 28:57flavors, that's possibly the exactly the
- 29:00right thing to do for simplicity sake.
- 29:02But wouldn't it be better if you could
- 29:03get people to get it free first of all?
- 29:05set was literally frictionless to start
- 29:07off with and then upgrade and upsell and
- 29:10add value and obviously add capabilities
- 29:12and so forth going forward because every
- 29:14time you acquire a customer as long as
- 29:16you keep them the ability to upsell is
- 29:18obviously a lot less expensive than
- 29:20creating a whole new customer
- 29:22relationship. So I know that sounds
- 29:23obvious but that's right there an
- 29:25example of a multiplier and it's a
- 29:26reason why tiered pricing and models
- 29:28like premium can be so helpful. The
- 29:31other typical multiplier you'll hear is
- 29:33channels. This is definitely applicable
- 29:35to almost any business. You could go out
- 29:37and create a Salesforce for every
- 29:39product, I'm sure. But wouldn't it be
- 29:41more effective to use somebody else's
- 29:43Salesforce, to use somebody who's
- 29:44already got the customer relationship,
- 29:45who's already written the contracts with
- 29:47major uh part um uh enterprises and just
- 29:50leverage those. I can tell you that's
- 29:52one of the biggest challenges for
- 29:54startups is that just the contracting
- 29:56process alone in the Fortune 1000 is
- 29:59horrifying. I'm seeing a few smiles at
- 30:01the front here because we constantly sit
- 30:03in boardrooms with you know the forecast
- 30:05and we know that the the deal is closed
- 30:07but the contract is still to come and
- 30:09we're like okay is it EMC we're dealing
- 30:12with or is it HP and you know everybody
- 30:14knows their stories there. The point is
- 30:16the channel in many instances will
- 30:19already have the relationship with that
- 30:22end customer. And so if they've already
- 30:23written the contracts and they can just
- 30:25add this as an addendum or slide it in
- 30:27on an existing contract, you just took
- 30:28all that friction out, reduced your cost
- 30:30of selling and obviously are able to get
- 30:32a multiplier in your business. So next
- 30:35example would be in the product. Most
- 30:37people think about products in a very
- 30:39straightforward way uh as being, you
- 30:41know, it's obvious that this is going to
- 30:43be great value and therefore people
- 30:45should want to buy it. That should be
- 30:47the case, but you can get a lot smarter
- 30:49than that. I'm going to introduce two
- 30:50concepts to you tonight. Slippery
- 30:53products. Yes, I said slippery. It's
- 30:55another of my pneummonics. Um, which is
- 30:58another way of saying frictionfree and
- 31:00what I call Russian doll packaging. And
- 31:03I think you'll have some fun with these
- 31:04tonight when you get to the workshop. uh
- 31:06but the last of which is technology
- 31:08stacks and again I'll give you a simple
- 31:10example of it and this is how you can
- 31:11insert yourself into somebody else's
- 31:13technology stack to get a multiplier out
- 31:15of going to market with them. So let's
- 31:17look at the levers. How do we take the
- 31:19cost out? Well, the world has changed
- 31:21dramatically since that 20-year-old
- 31:23example I was telling you about at
- 31:24semantic where we used to have to sell
- 31:25through two-tier distribution and we
- 31:27used to have to spiff salespeople at at
- 31:29these ridiculously large distributors
- 31:31that sold thousands of products and so
- 31:34we had to get their attention. And now
- 31:36you can get anybody's attention anytime
- 31:38you want on the web and focus on doing
- 31:40it in a very cost-effective way with
- 31:42inbound marketing using inside sales for
- 31:45example and creating things such as we
- 31:46were talking about like viral campaigns
- 31:48that dramatically takes down the cost of
- 31:50selling a marketing that wasn't even an
- 31:51option when I started this industry and
- 31:54so I would use it and I would spend time
- 31:56thinking right from the get-go about how
- 31:58would you get your awareness your
- 32:00interest your understanding up uh using
- 32:02web and lowcost techniques like
- 32:05And that's why I said this is one side
- 32:06of the coin, the other side being go to
- 32:08market that we'll talk about in the next
- 32:09session. The second example is less
- 32:12obvious and people typically think about
- 32:15this too late in the game. So I'm
- 32:16encouraging you to think about it right
- 32:17up front which is how do you take the
- 32:19cost out of producing your product,
- 32:21creating your product and supporting it.
- 32:24And there are many ways you can do this.
- 32:26You can do it through offshoring or
- 32:28outsourcing or crowd sourcing in that
- 32:30example we talked about or something
- 32:32called co-creation which I'm going to
- 32:34give you an example of tonight and again
- 32:36technology stacks. So probably a lot of
- 32:39words up there. All I'll say is every
- 32:41one of them can be thought of as a
- 32:42potential lever. I don't think I need to
- 32:44explain every one of them but I will
- 32:45pick as I said co-creation to go into as
- 32:48a differentiation.
- 32:50And then here's the last piece of this
- 32:52startup secret, which is you really want
- 32:54to find examples of things that work
- 32:57together. You've got a killer strategy
- 32:59on your hands. If you can figure out how
- 33:01you can get focused on your core, find a
- 33:03partner to work with who will give you a
- 33:06multiplier to market and a lever in
- 33:09taking the cost out of uh either
- 33:10building or delivering or supporting
- 33:12your product. And so two examples of
- 33:14that uh that I'd like to walk you
- 33:15through now. First of all, one in
- 33:17creating value, then another in
- 33:18delivering and capturing
- 33:22it. So, what is
- 33:24co-creating? Well, the idea here is
- 33:27pretty simple and it's going to come to
- 33:28light in a software world, I think,
- 33:30fairly easily. You could sit as a single
- 33:34organization and build your product with
- 33:36one development team. Or you could say,
- 33:39what is at the core of our product? And
- 33:42let's take an example that would make it
- 33:44easy for everybody to think of.
- 33:47Linux, it's an operating system, but at
- 33:50the absolute core of Linux is literally
- 33:52a kernel. And Linus thought about that
- 33:54and realized that the problem with
- 33:55existing operating systems was they've
- 33:57got huge and bloated. And why they got
- 33:59bloated? Because basically people had to
- 34:01have different versions of them for
- 34:02every single different kind of laptop or
- 34:05PC or server and every kind of device
- 34:07driver and everything else that went
- 34:08associated along with it was yet another
- 34:11piece that had to be added onto it. So
- 34:13he wrote a brilliant call, super fast,
- 34:15super efficient, but he made it possible
- 34:16in a modular way for people to add onto
- 34:18it using open source, created a
- 34:20community, and got people thinking about
- 34:23how could they extend the product. And
- 34:25as a result of that, people like IBM,
- 34:28who was literally at the time nowhere in
- 34:31the operating system business, in fact,
- 34:33you could argue was really struggling
- 34:34with many different operating systems,
- 34:36AS400, the Z series on the main frames,
- 34:38etc. were able to take Linux and unify
- 34:42their entire platform strategy with it
- 34:44and they themselves using open APIs uh
- 34:47and the open source nature of this were
- 34:50able to write all the drivers for all of
- 34:51their different products and get what
- 34:53they needed which is a unified operating
- 34:55system. What that did to Linux was
- 34:57unbelievable. It literally accelerated,
- 34:59actually I should have Carlos telling
- 35:00the story since he's been involved in it
- 35:02firsthand, but it literally accelerated
- 35:04the adoption of a single operating
- 35:06system that swept through the enterprise
- 35:08very quickly because it was free, open-
- 35:10source, and instantly much more uh
- 35:13valuable to people as they were able to
- 35:15focus on their differentiation and
- 35:16people started building on top of it. So
- 35:19that's an example and it's an open
- 35:20source example. But if I jump to the top
- 35:22and I give you just a little bit of
- 35:25thinking around uh extensibility, this
- 35:28is a simple concept. If you build
- 35:30something that everybody wants to add
- 35:33value to, needless to say, that's going
- 35:35to multiply your value. I'm going to
- 35:38start at the most basic level that you
- 35:39can think of. Imagine you went to the
- 35:41kitchen and you put on a a pot of
- 35:42boiling water and you knew that
- 35:44everybody wanted
- 35:46soup. The first thing they're going to
- 35:47need is the pot of boiling water. If
- 35:49you're the only guy who's got the pot of
- 35:50boiling water, people are going to come
- 35:51to you and put the ingredients in. The
- 35:53good news is they can add the stock to
- 35:55start off with and if they decide, oh,
- 35:58they want to add vegetables to that,
- 35:59they could add vegetables, but maybe
- 36:00some people don't want that. So, they'll
- 36:01take a ladle out of it and they'll
- 36:02create their own version derivative of
- 36:04it and they'll add, you know, not
- 36:06vegetables, but maybe meat to it because
- 36:08that's the way they are. The next guy
- 36:09comes along wants to add pasta to it.
- 36:11The point is somebody thought about that
- 36:14in a very basic way, and it's exactly
- 36:15what I'd encourage you to do with your
- 36:17product. They said, "What is the core
- 36:18thing at the base of soup?" boiling
- 36:22water. Think about your value prop in
- 36:25that same way. And then think about how
- 36:27easy would it be for people to come in
- 36:28and take a label and take some out and
- 36:30create their own version of it or add to
- 36:33it. If you can find ways to do that,
- 36:35that's why I love extensible open APIs
- 36:37for software, for example, which is just
- 36:39a fabulous way for people to do this.
- 36:40And if you can do that really early on,
- 36:43you'll be very successful. Here's the
- 36:45next little detail but a super important
- 36:47one. If you do it in a way that
- 36:49internally you test that right away. So
- 36:52in other words, let's say you're
- 36:53building an application but the
- 36:54application requires certain core
- 36:56services like for example user input,
- 36:59user validation and so forth. Why would
- 37:01you write those as uh capabilities in
- 37:04your platform that you had to build on
- 37:06internally? So you had your team of apps
- 37:09builders who know what the app
- 37:10application logic should be but they
- 37:12have to internally build on the APIs for
- 37:15user validation user input user
- 37:17experience etc. Immediately you're
- 37:19creating a customer internally that is
- 37:21testing your openness and your
- 37:22extensibility of those APIs. And when I
- 37:25see software companies who do that, they
- 37:26build on themselves. I watch product
- 37:28development go way way way quicker. And
- 37:30I've seen it over and over again. Demand
- 37:32where actually although Jamus can't talk
- 37:34has done it superbly well internally.
- 37:35They do exactly that with their
- 37:36e-commerce application. Disagree. So
- 37:40it's a small tip but it's a good
- 37:42starting point. figure out how even
- 37:44internally you can build around your
- 37:45core and you can have customers uh from
- 37:48you know one part of your organization
- 37:50working on another piece of the
- 37:51capability elsewhere. It's literally
- 37:53eating your own cooking being your own
- 37:55customer. Summarizing this I would say
- 37:58as follows. You can get smart about
- 38:01creation by thinking about who are all
- 38:03the other people can contribute and if
- 38:05you can find a way to actually incent
- 38:07them to get value out of co-creating
- 38:09with you, you're in a great starting
- 38:11point. It's going to be both a lever in
- 38:13terms of taking your cost down. It's
- 38:15going to be a multiplier in terms of
- 38:16those people obviously spreading the
- 38:19word. Okay. Now, let's talk about
- 38:22another example of levers and
- 38:23multipliers in delivering and capturing
- 38:25value. Uh delivering and capturing
- 38:27value. Here is one which is pulled from
- 38:31a list of 20 I could have talked about
- 38:34which again is a favorite for me. It's
- 38:36as simple as a strategic partnership and
- 38:39yet it's as significant as to be a major
- 38:42lever or multiplier for again almost
- 38:44every software company I work with
- 38:46figuring this out. And I'm going to give
- 38:48you a specific example of what what
- 38:51might make a great strategic partnership
- 38:53where both levers and multipliers around
- 38:56the core can make a difference. So if
- 38:58you are a software company, you'll know
- 38:59this without me telling you. You have to
- 39:02figure out what are the key capabilities
- 39:03that you're going to build around and it
- 39:05always involves basic things like
- 39:06compute and network and storage and
- 39:08database. I could have added 20 things
- 39:09in here. You probably don't have those
- 39:11as distinctions unless you're a security
- 39:13company or a database company. Um and
- 39:15you want to go ultimately expose
- 39:17applications and services at the top of
- 39:18it. If your core capability can fit into
- 39:21somebody else's stack right in the
- 39:23middle and fill a gap for them. For
- 39:24example, if you are able to be a load
- 39:27balancer that enables people to scale
- 39:29out and you do that on top of people's
- 39:31database storage capabilities, then why
- 39:34not fit into their stack? Why not go
- 39:35build for their capabilities so that you
- 39:37literally neatly can integrate and
- 39:39create a much more fulfilled product
- 39:41experience for anybody who's trying to
- 39:43build applications at scale that need
- 39:45load balancing. Well, obviously that's
- 39:47what the opportunity is in a in a whole
- 39:49product strategic partnership. And whole
- 39:51product is a Jeffrey Moore term. As you
- 39:53know, I'm a student of his. he'll be
- 39:54here at the end of the series and it
- 39:56really describes how you deliver a
- 39:57complete solution to your customer. So
- 39:59if you've only got a piece of it, you
- 40:00can find partners, you've got the rest
- 40:02of it. I would say this is a great
- 40:04example of a multiplier that can work
- 40:06for you. What happens when you do this
- 40:09is best uh discovered described with an
- 40:12example. Uh in one of the companies I
- 40:15started in the analytics world, we had a
- 40:18capability to do what we called real
- 40:19time inline analytics. What the hell did
- 40:21that mean? It meant that before that
- 40:23point, everybody who was doing analytics
- 40:25was typically getting reports, you know,
- 40:27a week after things happened or maybe a
- 40:29month after in some cases. And we said,
- 40:31guess what? Before you even transact
- 40:33with a customer, wouldn't it be helpful
- 40:34to find out if they're a profitable
- 40:36customer to deal with, what their
- 40:37preferences are, what the things are
- 40:39that they might also want to buy from
- 40:40you. And that required real-time inline
- 40:42analytics. But the trouble with that is
- 40:44analytics is a tiny piece of the
- 40:46challenge of getting that data putting
- 40:48in a database uh cleaning it with what's
- 40:51called ETL systems and then getting to a
- 40:54place where you could actually do what
- 40:55we did which was the real-time inline
- 40:56analytics and then on top of that you
- 40:58had all things people wanted to do with
- 40:59them like present them and you know even
- 41:01um analyze them further in Excel etc. So
- 41:04we realized the big giant in this space
- 41:05was IBM. So guess what? We did an
- 41:08unbelievably obvious thing which was we
- 41:11wrote right into the core of IBM stack
- 41:13and made sure we worked better than
- 41:15anybody else did with IBM's DB2 products
- 41:17and also their web sphere products and
- 41:19their middleware and also with their
- 41:21tooling even. And the result was not
- 41:24terribly surprising. We ended up getting
- 41:26huge revenue uplift not just because
- 41:28people were able to sell our products at
- 41:30IBM but because it brought credibility
- 41:31to us that IBM was actually partnering
- 41:34with us and was taking our products to
- 41:36market. It opened all the doors. And on
- 41:38the other side of things, of course, it
- 41:40dramatically reduced our time to market
- 41:42because we weren't writing all their
- 41:43technology around us and reduced our
- 41:45development costs. Excuse me. And
- 41:47ultimately resulted in them acquiring
- 41:49the company, which in many instances, by
- 41:52the way, even though it wasn't our
- 41:54intention, is a great backs stop for a
- 41:56small company to have had that strategic
- 41:58partnership be so successful that you
- 42:00know that if nothing else plays out in
- 42:02your own, you know, ultimate success,
- 42:05somebody's going to have you. so well
- 42:06integrated they'd be a no-brainer for
- 42:07them to acquire you. So I think
- 42:09strategic partnerships and example being
- 42:11a whole product strategic partnership
- 42:13are great levers, great multipliers and
- 42:14great back stops for for small
- 42:17companies. One little detail and the
- 42:21devil often is in the details and
- 42:24certainly it's true with uh startup
- 42:26companies. I hear people all the time
- 42:28say, "Oh, it's fantastic. I've got this
- 42:30new big company really interested in me
- 42:32and they're going to co-sell
- 42:33everything." Okay, who's incentive to
- 42:36co-sell it? If they don't have their
- 42:37salesforce incentive to do it, they
- 42:39might be getting more advantage out of
- 42:40you than you are out of them. There are
- 42:42always details like that. It's really
- 42:44worth paying attention to. If you get
- 42:45them to resell it, might be great, but
- 42:47if they suddenly bring you a thousand
- 42:49customers and you've got all the support
- 42:50cost, you might actually find you're
- 42:52losing
- 42:53money. Likewise, I often see small
- 42:55companies make this mistake, too. They
- 42:57go and write OEM deals and they think
- 42:59they've got tremendous distribution
- 43:01reach, but they've got no upsell
- 43:03capabilities. They basically just gave
- 43:04away the golden goose. Huge mistake. So,
- 43:08here are some things you can do. The
- 43:10first is actually a strategy not just to
- 43:12OEM uh but also for in general helping
- 43:15you with your product and how you get
- 43:17multipliers and leverage out of them.
- 43:19It's what I call building a Russian
- 43:20doll. It's going to be very obvious, I
- 43:23hope, where you might do this and then
- 43:25I'm going to get uh one of our companies
- 43:27come and talk about how they do this.
- 43:30Come up with a version that's free.
- 43:32Then find some way to give limited
- 43:34access to it for a different price, some
- 43:37upsell. Give a personal edition out once
- 43:40it gets used by lots of people. Make a
- 43:42workg groupoup edition. If lots of work
- 43:44groups start using it, make a corporate
- 43:46edition. Once it goes global, make an
- 43:48enterprise edition. It isn't that hard.
- 43:50But you'd be amazed how many times this
- 43:52is the difference between, for example,
- 43:54an OEM deal working or not. If you know
- 43:56you've got all those additions and you
- 43:58just do an OEM edition, for example, on
- 44:00the personal edition or the workg
- 44:02groupoup edition, you know, you can go
- 44:03back and sell all the capabilities the
- 44:05corporate edition or the enterprise
- 44:06edition. And therefore, getting the
- 44:08reach from the OEM made tremendous sense
- 44:10because you can do the upsell, but don't
- 44:13go in there without that in your back
- 44:14pocket. Know up front what you're going
- 44:16in there with. Know exactly up front
- 44:18what you're going to do as an upsell.
- 44:20And then to the point about going to
- 44:22market in general, this strategy works
- 44:24out for lots of other reasons. You'll
- 44:27find that it's a great way of giving a
- 44:28digestible starting point to people.
- 44:30It's a great way of allowing people, as
- 44:32I said, to taste a small piece of the
- 44:34value. Uh, and if they if you can do
- 44:36that free, that's a great strategy in
- 44:38many instances. And then it gives you
- 44:40all these upsell options. And it gives
- 44:42you tremendous channel flexibility not
- 44:44just with OEMs but you can go to for
- 44:45example different channels for a
- 44:47personal edition than you would for
- 44:49example for an enterprise edition or you
- 44:51can go to VA who want to build around
- 44:52for example or systems integrators who
- 44:54want to build around a very small piece
- 44:56of your core functionality because they
- 44:58want to differentiate with all the
- 44:59capabilities they might bring in a
- 45:01vertical market. Let's say they you go
- 45:03to a VA for example that takes just the
- 45:05core and takes it to to a medical market
- 45:07and yet another one who takes the core
- 45:09and goes after the financial market.
- 45:11That's a great strategy that can play
- 45:13out if you do Russian doll packaging. In
- 45:15other words, if you figure out how to
- 45:16get these capabilities, but if all you
- 45:18come out with is one galactic edition,
- 45:20which has everything for everybody in
- 45:22every market, it's going to be really
- 45:24hard for people to deal with you. And
- 45:26you'll be again amazed how many times
- 45:27the biggest problem when we see startups
- 45:29is they try to put every feature for
- 45:31every person into the first product. And
- 45:34we all know that the result of that is
- 45:35it usually collapses under its own
- 45:37weight. So some of you will have read
- 45:39Eric Reese's book on minimum viable
- 45:40product. Minimum viable product is one
- 45:43example of what I'm talking about. I'm
- 45:44really talking about the business model
- 45:45associated with it. That's the
- 45:47technology piece. This is how do you
- 45:49create the business flexibility around
- 45:51it by packaging it in a way that you can
- 45:53go to market in different ways. Okay.
- 45:55I'd like to introduce a keeper now,
- 45:57David McFarland, to give his example of
- 45:59how he's created somewhat of a uh good
- 46:03example not just in open source uh but
- 46:05also with packaging different options
- 46:07and giving himself this this uh
- 46:09capability. David, you'd like to come
- 46:10and join us.
- 46:13So um uh just an opportunity to maybe
- 46:16walk you through how we've actually uh
- 46:19taken several of these capabilities and
- 46:20combined them in this uh uh in this uh
- 46:22go to market strategy. Just a reminder,
- 46:25some of you may know from the prior
- 46:26meetings, but at the very core of what
- 46:28Keem does, what our keep our secret
- 46:30sources, and it was this man in the
- 46:31middle here who invented it, uh, is
- 46:33something we call table grouping. Simply
- 46:35put, we understand how an application
- 46:36uses data, and then we group that data
- 46:39together, and the net result is that
- 46:41transactions and queries run 10 to 100
- 46:43times faster. It's a huge breakthrough
- 46:45uh, in terms of capability. So, what
- 46:47we've done is that we've taken that core
- 46:49capability and we've released that as an
- 46:51open-source product. The idea is to
- 46:53drive as much viral business as
- 46:55possible. It's developers who drive
- 46:57these technology decisions. It's the
- 46:59developers that is the 10,000 100,000
- 47:02strong uh salesforce that we can use to
- 47:05compete with the likes of Oracles. What
- 47:07we've also done is allowed those
- 47:10developer communities to extend our
- 47:12product by integrating it into uh their
- 47:15uh own development environment. So for
- 47:17for Ruby and Hibernate, we integrate
- 47:19into their environment. So it becomes a
- 47:21value ad to their stack and again they
- 47:23drive it through their own distribution
- 47:25and they own that value and they drive
- 47:27that value. But what we did is we
- 47:29created a pluggable architecture and as
- 47:31a pluggable architecture it means that
- 47:33we can add critical additional
- 47:35components that will add unique value to
- 47:37the product. So the first is something
- 47:39we call my SQL replication. It just
- 47:41means that you can take this and now
- 47:42plug it into a pre-existing MySQL
- 47:45application. If you built something on
- 47:46the LAMP stack, it's not scaling well,
- 47:48it's running slowly, you can take this
- 47:50aon stack, plug it in, redirect the
- 47:52queries, uh, and we'll run those queries
- 47:53really quickly for you. And that's just
- 47:55one example, but the key point here is
- 47:56to have a whole series of these
- 47:58capabilities that you can add and extend
- 48:00the product with, which is what we've
- 48:02done. And you can also use that in terms
- 48:03of a multi-ter pricing strategy. And
- 48:06then finally, as you build community out
- 48:08there in the market, we've added a
- 48:10series of electronic services that you
- 48:12can add, things that you can deliver as
- 48:14a SAS capability back out to that
- 48:16market. It makes it easy for them to
- 48:18adopt, but it also kind of locks them in
- 48:20to your service and your brand. And even
- 48:22within those uh additions, there are
- 48:24certain community aspects like the
- 48:25grouping algorithms. You get lots of
- 48:27people to combine together to contribute
- 48:29to different grouping strategies that
- 48:31then can be shared across the community.
- 48:32So those are just some of the examples
- 48:34of how we extend it. Perfect. Thank you,
- 48:36David. And I'll just leave that up for
- 48:37one second. I think he's used pretty
- 48:38much every example that I've already
- 48:40said tonight. There's effectively a core
- 48:42that is very clearly defined. And he's
- 48:44actually made it open source so people
- 48:46can extend it. And he's also said, look,
- 48:48we're going to have several additions in
- 48:49that Russian gold model. So we can sell
- 48:51this through many different channels and
- 48:53sell different capabilities. And he's
- 48:55also said, we're going to have upsell
- 48:56and cross-ell capabilities from that.
- 48:59And in effect, he's got cost being taken
- 49:01out through open source and co-creation.
- 49:03He's got multipliers being created
- 49:04obviously through the community and he's
- 49:06got obviously multiple options uh
- 49:08through the Russian build packaging. So
- 49:10it it's a great example and I can tell
- 49:12you that would it be fair to say well
- 49:14you tell me I shouldn't need the
- 49:15witness. Have how much time have you
- 49:17spent on the business model as a CEO
- 49:19relative to other things in your
- 49:20business like building the product?
- 49:23Well, the one thing I would say is like,
- 49:25you know, from the very inception of the
- 49:26product, we had these ideas in mind. So,
- 49:29one of the things that was very
- 49:30important that I would say to people is
- 49:31that you really want to think about how
- 49:33you're going to package this value up
- 49:34and deliver it to the market. It isn't
- 49:36necessarily that it was hugely
- 49:38timeconuming for us to do that, but it
- 49:39was really important that you think
- 49:41about it right up front and you don't
- 49:43wait to the end of the development cycle
- 49:44to apply it. That's a terrific point.
- 49:47What David's saying just to underline it
- 49:48is if you develop the product in a
- 49:50monolithic fashion then obviously going
- 49:52to be really hard if you later decide
- 49:53you want to slice it up and sell it in
- 49:54different ways. So thinking about the
- 49:57business model as early as you're
- 49:58starting your product development is
- 50:00actually not too early. It's exactly
- 50:02right. So thank you David. Great point
- 50:04David.
- 50:06Okay. Apple made a launch today. No
- 50:08Steve Jobs. So I'm going to have to do
- 50:10as the poor substitute. One more thing
- 50:12and actually I think it's a really
- 50:14fundamental thing. There is actually a
- 50:16tendency for people to think about these
- 50:18things i.e. business models as
- 50:20snapshots. Uh but in fact what you
- 50:23really want to do is think about on an
- 50:25ongoing basis. How is it your product or
- 50:27service is sold? And so I'm going to
- 50:29take you through a series of things that
- 50:31will give you a sense of the product
- 50:32life cycle. And it starts with something
- 50:35that I've always really enjoyed watching
- 50:38companies who get it right do. And that
- 50:40is creating what I call slippery
- 50:42products.
- 50:45When I told my daughter this, she said,
- 50:47"Dad, what have slippers got to do with
- 50:48products?" Kind of missed the point, but
- 50:50anyway, we'll see if we can get it
- 50:51across tonight. Okay. Uh, the first
- 50:55thing is creating a product that is
- 50:57simple to use. Obviously, the simpler it
- 50:58is, the more likely it is for people to
- 51:00instantly get it. The second is low to
- 51:04no initial cost. That takes more
- 51:06friction out of it. The third is
- 51:09installs easily. You'd be shocked how
- 51:11many times, even if something's free as
- 51:13an app on your iPhone, think about it.
- 51:15If it takes a while for you to install
- 51:17it and it actually isn't immediately
- 51:19functional, it doesn't have some
- 51:20component or it doesn't fill in too much
- 51:22data or whatever it is to get it going,
- 51:24you're not going to use it. And then how
- 51:26does it prove its value really quickly?
- 51:29If it instantly delivers something back
- 51:31to you before you have to put a lot of
- 51:32stuff into it, you're going to start
- 51:34using it. Next on the list is obviously,
- 51:38does it play well with others? In the
- 51:40enterprise, this is incredibly important
- 51:41because if it disrupts everything, even
- 51:43if it's free and it's incredibly easy to
- 51:45use and you're getting value from it,
- 51:46but you have to replace everything
- 51:48before you can use that, it's going to
- 51:49be really
- 51:51tough. Next is obviously ease of use.
- 51:54But I say this and yet it's amazing how
- 51:56many people spend zero time up front
- 51:59thinking about user experience. The user
- 52:02experience is everything. It's usually
- 52:03what dep describes obviously defines
- 52:06excuse me how often it gets used, how it
- 52:09gets circulated and so forth. And so pay
- 52:11attention to that up front. From a
- 52:13business standpoint, we've been talking
- 52:15about this. The customer is going to
- 52:16look at payback and ROI. And so make it
- 52:19obvious. Make it obvious right up front
- 52:21why this pays for itself, why it
- 52:22justifies itself. In the end, my
- 52:25favorite one is the why. Why not? Why
- 52:29customers can't live without this should
- 52:30be what they should be thinking. Not why
- 52:33might they try it, but why can they
- 52:35literally not live without it? That's
- 52:36back to that gain pain equation. For
- 52:38those of you who are here, if you give
- 52:39them so much gain and there's no pain
- 52:41because it's so slippery, friction free
- 52:43to adopt this product, they're going to
- 52:44buy it. So I would actually say one of
- 52:47the most important elements of the
- 52:49business model is in fact creating
- 52:51slippery products. It's creating
- 52:53friction-free products. And oftentimes
- 52:55people say, well, R&D's got nothing to
- 52:57do with the business model. I say it's
- 52:58got a ton to do with it. We just talked
- 53:00about one example which David gave,
- 53:01which is about how you chunk it up. But
- 53:03actually, if you right from the get-go
- 53:05figure out what your business model is
- 53:07and you decide to create a slippery
- 53:08product, you can take a ton of the
- 53:10friction, in other words, the cost out
- 53:12of marketing, distribution, sales,
- 53:14service, and support. So, it's worth
- 53:16taking that thought really early on into
- 53:19your thinking as you define your
- 53:21business
- 53:22model. And to help bring this to life,
- 53:24I'm going to introduce Mark Taber, our
- 53:27CEO from Active Endpoints. And as Mark
- 53:29comes up, I'm going to tell you a little
- 53:31bit of story to set him up because uh I
- 53:34actually inherited this investment and
- 53:35that's never an easy thing when you're a
- 53:38partner in a venture firm. Um I didn't
- 53:40inherit Mark. I was lucky enough to go
- 53:42recruit him. But uh it was a middleware
- 53:44product. It was a tiny piece of a
- 53:47product actually. They had something
- 53:47called a Beetle engine. Yeah. You don't
- 53:50need to know what that is. I'll just
- 53:51tell you it was a feature. Uh, and so it
- 53:53wasn't even a whole product. And Mark
- 53:55came on and the first thing he said to
- 53:57me when we were we're going through
- 53:58recruiting is, I don't want to talk to
- 54:00you about the product. I want to talk to
- 54:00you about the business model. I've got a
- 54:02vision for how I could take this thing
- 54:03to market in and he didn't use the word
- 54:05slippery although I think I've coaxed
- 54:07him into using it now uh way. And it's
- 54:09turned out that he's figured out how to
- 54:11sell complex very difficult stuff to
- 54:14sell anyway in any more way uh in an
- 54:17exciting way. typically selling, you
- 54:19know, something of of the order of tens
- 54:21or hundreds of thousands of dollars
- 54:22worth of value over the phone. This is a
- 54:24company that's doing millions of dollars
- 54:26of revenue, has has literally been
- 54:28growing at at phenomenal rates every
- 54:30year without having a single outside
- 54:34salesperson. Extraordinary. So Mark, how
- 54:36did you do that? Yeah. So in actuality,
- 54:39we we did structure the whole company
- 54:42out of this concept of making it simple
- 54:45and how we bring it to market. process
- 54:47automation, which is what we do, it's
- 54:50been around for a long time. Business
- 54:52process management, the corporate IT
- 54:54people have been, you know, able to
- 54:57accomplish things for their users for a
- 54:59long time, but it's it's way too hard.
- 55:02And so the concept of active endpoints
- 55:04has been how can we enable the business
- 55:07user to make their life simpler by doing
- 55:10these things themselves. And so the
- 55:13example that I that I've shown here is
- 55:16how can we make the life of a
- 55:18salesperson easier. They interact with
- 55:20an application. Most of them use
- 55:23something called Salesforce.com which is
- 55:25really just a database to collect
- 55:26information. But salespeople don't want
- 55:29to write reports. They they don't want
- 55:31to gather the information. And because
- 55:33of that, they frequently miss common
- 55:36things that they that they know they
- 55:38should do, but they just forget and and
- 55:40they don't do it consistently over time.
- 55:43So what we did was we invented some
- 55:45technology to allow a business user to
- 55:49do their own automation. So in fact you
- 55:51could use a mobile phone and the
- 55:53texttospech
- 55:55uh capability speech to text capability
- 55:58that is for example in an iPhone using
- 56:00Siri you can talk into the phone say
- 56:03show me my meetings today. A guide will
- 56:06come up and you can just speak into it
- 56:08what happened at the meeting. You can
- 56:10hit a button if you want a thank you
- 56:12email to go out or whatever whatever it
- 56:14is you normally do after a meeting. if
- 56:16you want to set up a follow-up or
- 56:18something like that, it will
- 56:19automatically happen in the background.
- 56:21And so this this is it's great in the
- 56:24fact that we've done it, but the real
- 56:26innovation is the fact that we allow the
- 56:28business user to do it themselves. And
- 56:31so we took that concept and really our
- 56:34entire go to market really everything
- 56:36about the technology and what we do
- 56:39encompasses this comp, you know, this
- 56:41concept of slippery, though I didn't
- 56:43know the acronym until yesterday,
- 56:44Michael. Uh but you know it
- 56:48was but it but it's exactly what it's
- 56:51exactly what we do. We tried to make
- 56:53this this product as easy to use as
- 56:56possible. We tried to make it as
- 56:58frictionless as possible. So in fact you
- 57:01could just go to our website you can
- 57:03just enable yourself. You can try it.
- 57:05You can use it. You can interact it. You
- 57:07interact with it. You can get a free
- 57:09version of it uh to use. I have Eric
- 57:12Edggerson our head of sales. Maybe you
- 57:14want to share like a you know how some
- 57:16of our customers are doing that. Sure.
- 57:18Sure. Mark, I'll just u mention one
- 57:20customer. Plymouth Rock Energy down in
- 57:22the New York City area. Traditionally
- 57:24had been an old line supplier of coal
- 57:26and oil to large facilities. That
- 57:29business isn't such a great business
- 57:30anymore. So they've transformed
- 57:32themselves into a broker of energy
- 57:35including electricity and natural gas.
- 57:37Uh and they use Salesforce.com for all
- 57:40of their new customer signups. So they
- 57:42had to customize Salesforce.com
- 57:44tremendously. Uh when you sign up a new
- 57:46customer as an energy broker, you have
- 57:47to specify the supplier, who the
- 57:49distribution channel is going to be,
- 57:51whether they're going to pay a premium
- 57:52for green energy sources. Uh and it
- 57:55turned out for the Salesforce.com users,
- 57:56the sales rep signing up a new uh
- 57:59customer, it was a very complex process.
- 58:00They had to go through the Salesforce
- 58:02screens. So we met a gentleman down at a
- 58:05Salesforce.com
- 58:07um event in New York City on a
- 58:09Wednesday. The following Monday, we gave
- 58:10him a demo via a go to meeting, via a
- 58:13web meeting. Uh he was able to get on
- 58:15our cloud hosted product, uh started
- 58:18building his little process wizard the
- 58:21next day that his sales reps could use
- 58:24uh to go through this complex process of
- 58:26onboarding a new customer. Uh by the end
- 58:28of the week, he had it working and the
- 58:30following Monday placed the order with
- 58:31us. So, you know, going back to some of
- 58:33the points, you can probably map what
- 58:34happened there into these points, but
- 58:36installs easily. He was able to sign up
- 58:38on the web. could prove value in just a
- 58:40couple of days by creating a wizard that
- 58:43walked their users through these complex
- 58:44um processes. And what else do I want to
- 58:47say? Plays well with others. Having the
- 58:50Salesforce.com integration has been
- 58:52tremendously valuable to us, Michael. I
- 58:54would call it both a lever because it
- 58:56reduces our marketing cost tremendously.
- 58:58We know who our market is and we're able
- 58:59to get to them through Salesforce and
- 59:01it's a multiplier um because uh we're
- 59:04able to increase revenue by selling
- 59:06users. Last one was we sell it per user
- 59:08per month. The guy was concerned he's
- 59:10only going to have 15 users to start
- 59:12out. We said that's fine. You can buy 15
- 59:14user license. When you add 10 more next
- 59:16year, you just buy 10 more licenses.
- 59:19Great. Thank you guys very much. And I
- 59:21think you know you can pick lots of
- 59:23companies. The the reason I chose active
- 59:25endpoints is it would be a horribly
- 59:26complex sale normally to be able to sell
- 59:28middleware. And all of their competitors
- 59:29by the way, people like IBM are going in
- 59:31with three-legged sales sorry three
- 59:33person sales calls. Six-legged sales
- 59:35calls hopefully. uh and they're spending
- 59:38a lot of money and they're having as a
- 59:39result to charge orders of magnitude in
- 59:41some cases more for their products and
- 59:42services. And this company has taken
- 59:44market share away on a consistent basis
- 59:47been doubling year on year in some cases
- 59:49in in their product sales through this
- 59:51slippery product concept. And thanks to
- 59:53the team for being so innovative
- 59:55approaching it that way where we're at
- 59:56the technology at the core of it. It's
- 59:58interesting but in a very highly
- 1:00:00competitive
- 1:00:01market. So let's put it all together. Um
- 1:00:04I want to give you a a very clear metric
- 1:00:06which you've probably seen. If you
- 1:00:07haven't, you certainly should know about
- 1:00:09and that is this notion of coming um up
- 1:00:11with an understanding of if your
- 1:00:13business model is working or not. And
- 1:00:15for startups, the metric that people now
- 1:00:17are getting used to is lifetime value.
- 1:00:20That is how can you how much can you get
- 1:00:22from a customer over the lifetime of
- 1:00:23working with them divided by the cost of
- 1:00:26acquiring that customer. And in general,
- 1:00:28if your lifetime value from a customer
- 1:00:31isn't around three or greater the time
- 1:00:34times the cost of acquiring that
- 1:00:36customer, you probably don't have a
- 1:00:37profitable business model. And
- 1:00:39unfortunately in startups, most times
- 1:00:41people don't really spend time to think
- 1:00:43about this up front either. But all the
- 1:00:45multipliers and levers that I talk to
- 1:00:47you about should be factored into what
- 1:00:49is it that you're doing to obviously
- 1:00:51increase on the one hand the lifetime
- 1:00:52value. How can you get more out of
- 1:00:54customers over time with for example
- 1:00:56that Russian doll packaging we're
- 1:00:57talking about more and more versions or
- 1:00:59additions or in reducing the cost of
- 1:01:02acquiring the customer in the ways we
- 1:01:04just talked about with things like
- 1:01:05strategic partnerships and there are
- 1:01:08many examples um that I didn't go
- 1:01:10through like channels and so forth that
- 1:01:12can give you reach and take cost out
- 1:01:13too. In the end though, when you boil it
- 1:01:16all down, you should find that this
- 1:01:17ratio plays out, as I said, to roughly
- 1:01:20three or more times uh value, the value
- 1:01:23you're capturing than the cost you're
- 1:01:25implying uh to get that customer
- 1:01:28successful. Now, that model's been, I'd
- 1:01:31say, pretty successfully adopted by many
- 1:01:34of my customers, but I noticed something
- 1:01:36over the last few years as it's become
- 1:01:38accepted that's been missing. And so I
- 1:01:40want to introduce this because what we
- 1:01:42found is almost every startup just as
- 1:01:45you heard Eric describe gets in at one
- 1:01:48point and then has a relationship to
- 1:01:50maintain the customer to get the full
- 1:01:52value. And I find most people ignore
- 1:01:55that latter set of re-engagement with
- 1:01:57the customer. So I'm going to give you a
- 1:01:58sense of what you really need to think
- 1:02:00through. This refinement to me to keep
- 1:02:03it interesting is a matter of life and
- 1:02:05death.
- 1:02:09I'm going to talk about a customer life
- 1:02:10cycle in a very simple methodology to
- 1:02:12start off with. See, try
- 1:02:17buy. Think about it for a second. That's
- 1:02:19basically what happens when you look for
- 1:02:20products. You see it, you try it, you
- 1:02:22buy it, you run it, fly, and ultimately
- 1:02:25it dies some kind of death. And that
- 1:02:28cycle is typically described by people
- 1:02:30in this kind of a bell curve. And the
- 1:02:32problem with it, at least in the
- 1:02:33software business and many B2B
- 1:02:35businesses, is if it really looks like
- 1:02:37this, you have a long costly customer
- 1:02:39acquisition cost, a slow payback period,
- 1:02:42and very short lifetime value. And if
- 1:02:45that's really what your business model
- 1:02:46looks like, in my opinion, you're in
- 1:02:48trouble. And unfortunately, it's what a
- 1:02:50lot of startups I see exactly have as a
- 1:02:53business model. And so, I'm going to try
- 1:02:55to help you think about ways that you
- 1:02:56could get beyond that.
- 1:02:58We'll talk about this more in the go to
- 1:03:01market session next week. But one of the
- 1:03:03first things u I always see when I do
- 1:03:05postmortems with companies is that they
- 1:03:07haven't broken these stages down from
- 1:03:08the simplistic C drive by fly model that
- 1:03:10I talked to you about into much more
- 1:03:12granular stages. And granular stages
- 1:03:15just to give you an example of this
- 1:03:16would be awareness. How do you even
- 1:03:18discover somebody interest? How do you
- 1:03:20get their interest? How do you get them
- 1:03:22to understand what your capabilities
- 1:03:23are? Then engage with you then try it.
- 1:03:25Then purchase it. And I could go I could
- 1:03:27probably pick 30 or 40 more if I really
- 1:03:29wanted to break it down. We'll talk
- 1:03:31about more of this as I said next week.
- 1:03:33But just for now, think about this as
- 1:03:35follows. Once I've bought the product,
- 1:03:38how do I stay engaged with you? What is
- 1:03:40it that I do to repurchase? So, I'm
- 1:03:43going to introduce an obvious constant
- 1:03:45obvious idea here, and that is how do
- 1:03:48you re-engage the customer after they've
- 1:03:49bought? How do you actually get them to
- 1:03:51retry the next capability that you
- 1:03:54introduce? either the upgrade or the
- 1:03:56update or the whole new version that you
- 1:03:58just came out with. So in this cycle of
- 1:04:03re-engagement and repurchasing it, there
- 1:04:05are a lot of steps that are basically
- 1:04:07the same as you did when you first
- 1:04:08introduced the product or connect with
- 1:04:11the customer. And if you get them right,
- 1:04:13it turns out you really dramatically
- 1:04:15change the cycle. In fact, what you
- 1:04:17really want to do is of course have the
- 1:04:18cycle occurring over and over again.
- 1:04:20customer keeps coming back to you as
- 1:04:21your preferred supplier or as your
- 1:04:24trusted source as or as a person where
- 1:04:26they'll buy the next set of
- 1:04:27capabilities. And if you can do that
- 1:04:29successfully, what you'll find you can
- 1:04:31do is dramatically extend the life cycle
- 1:04:34of the customer. Uh and if you use
- 1:04:37things like slippery products that we
- 1:04:39just talked about, you'll have a much
- 1:04:40more um simple experience up front and
- 1:04:44take all the friction out. you'll have a
- 1:04:46much rapid more rapid adoption with that
- 1:04:48Russian gold packaging as an example of
- 1:04:50how you might do that. And then very
- 1:04:52importantly, you'll have a much extended
- 1:04:53life cycle because you'll find ways to
- 1:04:55re-engage the customer over and over
- 1:04:57again. So, it's a lot to take in. And
- 1:05:00what I felt like I should do is give you
- 1:05:02an example of how actually you can avoid
- 1:05:05the death that happens here uh in the
- 1:05:07software world with an example of
- 1:05:09exactly this. So how are you going to
- 1:05:11have uh a long happy life is is really
- 1:05:15the question in the software world. Well
- 1:05:18when I started out as I said I'm dating
- 1:05:21myself it was the only person who
- 1:05:23installed stuff they were the only
- 1:05:25people who customized it. There were
- 1:05:26infrequent upgrades. Most of the stuff
- 1:05:29actually sat on shelfware as we called
- 1:05:30it. It was all proprietary and people
- 1:05:32licensed it on a perpetual basis. The
- 1:05:34poster child for this probably would
- 1:05:36have been Oracle uh quite frankly. Um,
- 1:05:40but it's all changed. And in fact, if
- 1:05:42you use all the techniques we've just
- 1:05:43said, what you can use is the web to
- 1:05:45make it easy for people to trial stuff.
- 1:05:47You can then make it easily uh
- 1:05:49self-service as you just heard, you
- 1:05:52know, Eric give that example. The
- 1:05:53customer didn't have to come in for
- 1:05:54training or figure out how to configure
- 1:05:56or install the thing. They were just
- 1:05:58using it on the web live trying it in
- 1:06:00their own situation. It can be on
- 1:06:02demand, so there's absolutely nothing
- 1:06:03for them to actually buy initially. It
- 1:06:05can be available literally over the
- 1:06:07cloud. And software as a service is very
- 1:06:10much the post child for that. And
- 1:06:12obviously if you make it open source or
- 1:06:14extensible in some way they can extend
- 1:06:15it or add to those capabilities
- 1:06:16themselves. And ultimately through a
- 1:06:19subscription model they can buy it as
- 1:06:21they need it and pay for it as they use
- 1:06:23it. The result of all of that is what
- 1:06:27this extended life cycle. It creates
- 1:06:29this incredibly easy basis for people to
- 1:06:32try things adopt them and then buy them
- 1:06:34as they need them. and then on a
- 1:06:36subscription basis keep reusing them and
- 1:06:38underneath it the engine for it is very
- 1:06:41important for you to think about which
- 1:06:42is how do you keep engaging the customer
- 1:06:45and I'll say again what I obvious often
- 1:06:48observe with startups is they think
- 1:06:50they've got the customer and they think
- 1:06:52that just continuing to introduce new
- 1:06:53innovations is the answer maybe u you
- 1:06:56might have that kind of customer but how
- 1:06:58many times have you downloaded an iPhone
- 1:06:59app recently for example and then never
- 1:07:01used it
- 1:07:02again show of hands
- 1:07:05Okay, a lot of you. That's exactly what
- 1:07:07I mean by this green circle. I will tell
- 1:07:09you that that's a big problem for mobile
- 1:07:12app developers and it's just a bigger
- 1:07:14problem for almost every example of
- 1:07:16software in B2B or or other worlds too.
- 1:07:20So, you really got to think about this
- 1:07:21blue circles I put up there, this notion
- 1:07:23of acquiring, not just acquiring, but
- 1:07:26re-engaging customers. So, let's bring
- 1:07:28that back to the the um the model that I
- 1:07:30said earlier and just add that extra
- 1:07:32layer. What this is about is not just
- 1:07:35the levers and multipliers around your
- 1:07:37core but also thinking about how you not
- 1:07:40just acquire the customer but re-engage
- 1:07:42them and continuously stay in touch with
- 1:07:44them so that you don't get that iPhone
- 1:07:46app dying but in fact you find some way
- 1:07:48to to reconnect with them. It might be a
- 1:07:50new map that you send them out if it's
- 1:07:52GPS or it might be some new set of
- 1:07:54content that you send them out if it's a
- 1:07:55recommendation service or it might be
- 1:07:57some new data that you send them out
- 1:07:58that makes it obvious for them how they
- 1:08:00can connect if it's a dating
- 1:08:01application. Those things turn out to be
- 1:08:04the difference between products that
- 1:08:05have long life cycles that engage the
- 1:08:07customers that get more lifetime value
- 1:08:09out of them than anything else. And so I
- 1:08:11reinvented that acronym and called it
- 1:08:13customer cost of customer acquisition
- 1:08:16and re-engagement. It's the R there. And
- 1:08:18instead of it being lifetime value, it's
- 1:08:21life cycle value. That's the L, the C in
- 1:08:24there. And it really is important to
- 1:08:26think about LCV, the life cycle value of
- 1:08:29your customer. what can you get out of
- 1:08:30them over and over again, not just once.
- 1:08:32Uh and also what does it cost you to
- 1:08:34re-engage? So when I describe this to
- 1:08:36startups, I find that most people have
- 1:08:39uh challenges initially getting what do
- 1:08:40I mean by those kinds of things. So
- 1:08:42here's an
- 1:08:43example. Re-engagement costs are
- 1:08:46typically things like support. Support
- 1:08:48should absolutely be factored into it.
- 1:08:50It's not just sales and marketing.
- 1:08:52Keeping your customers often involves
- 1:08:53customer service. And if you're in a B2B
- 1:08:56environment and you're selling anything
- 1:08:57like a complex product, it often
- 1:08:59involves professional services. So all
- 1:09:00of those costs should be factored in to
- 1:09:02the the CAC, the cost of acquiring and
- 1:09:06re-engaging
- 1:09:08customers. Any questions before I move
- 1:09:10on? We're nearly at the end. So to get
- 1:09:12you to your workshop. Okay. So now you
- 1:09:15have a model which I think is really
- 1:09:18quite compelling to be able to work with
- 1:09:20things. And for those of you who were
- 1:09:21here when we talked through the value
- 1:09:23proposition on gain pain, it also is
- 1:09:26exactly the same concept and principle
- 1:09:30as we talked about in gain pain. They're
- 1:09:32just two views of the same problem. For
- 1:09:35those of you were there for this
- 1:09:36workshop, we talked about how could you
- 1:09:38take the pain out of a customer getting
- 1:09:41to grips with your product and give them
- 1:09:43all visibility into the game. Well,
- 1:09:45think about it for a second. That is how
- 1:09:46the customer will view it. What you're
- 1:09:48going to view on the other side is the
- 1:09:50measurement of how much cost is it
- 1:09:52taking for you to actually get the
- 1:09:53customer to adopt the product. That's
- 1:09:55the CC. And how much can you get from
- 1:09:57that customer as they get those gains
- 1:09:59over time throughout that life cycle.
- 1:10:01That's the LCB. So they're just two
- 1:10:03sides of the same principle. And they
- 1:10:05work around this whole notion of the
- 1:10:07core of your value proposition. So good
- 1:10:09business models, you will constantly be
- 1:10:11going back. I can I could make this
- 1:10:12single template a basis for discussion
- 1:10:15in every startup. What have we done to
- 1:10:17take the pain out? How is that reducing
- 1:10:19our cost of acquiring the customer? What
- 1:10:21have we done to make it obvious to the
- 1:10:22customer what gain they get right up
- 1:10:24front? How can we make that work over
- 1:10:26time to be a very large lifetime value,
- 1:10:29life cycle value of a
- 1:10:31customer? So with that, I'm going to
- 1:10:33summarize and get us onto our workshop.
- 1:10:35I have a question. I guess I um I was it
- 1:10:40was unclear to me the concept around the
- 1:10:42Russian goals. Um is the message that it
- 1:10:46you're recommending to have various
- 1:10:49versions of of a product a single user
- 1:10:52or small business and enterprise or I
- 1:10:55guess the counter for that is what
- 1:10:56happens if your product is only geared
- 1:10:58towards enterprise large companies and
- 1:11:01you know a a single individual average
- 1:11:04customer wouldn't have much value out of
- 1:11:05that. Am I missing something? No, you're
- 1:11:07not. You've actually got a great example
- 1:11:09to challenge me on. So if your product
- 1:11:11just to repeat the question, does the
- 1:11:13Russian bull strategy work? For example,
- 1:11:15if you've got a product that's only
- 1:11:17valuable if you sell it to an entire
- 1:11:18enterprise fairly, the answer is yes, I
- 1:11:21believe it does because very rarely will
- 1:11:23you be able to get an entire enterprise
- 1:11:24to adopt a product in one go. It's just
- 1:11:26indigestible. I mean, I've made this
- 1:11:29mistake as a young entrepreneur. I've
- 1:11:30tried to go sell people like FISA an
- 1:11:32entire salesforce package for analytics
- 1:11:35and say, "Hey, why don't you buy this
- 1:11:37whole thing because your entire sales
- 1:11:38force will get value out of it if you
- 1:11:39can all see all the data on all the
- 1:11:42products yourself." It's not going to
- 1:11:43work because it's so difficult to get a
- 1:11:46big enterprise to adopt any change. You
- 1:11:49have huge pain in doing that and it's
- 1:11:51going to take you months in a sales
- 1:11:53cycle and you're going to spend a lot of
- 1:11:54money doing it. But even though the
- 1:11:56value might be the whole sales force, if
- 1:11:58you gave them something right off the
- 1:11:59bat, which is look, here is some data on
- 1:12:03the benchmark of just one of your sales
- 1:12:05teams, maybe even, you know, a small
- 1:12:07region for example, of how they're
- 1:12:09relatively performing in terms of their
- 1:12:11sales effectiveness. That's immediately
- 1:12:13valuable to them and that small team can
- 1:12:15adopt it very quickly. If that team sees
- 1:12:17success with it, they'll recommend it
- 1:12:18elsewhere. And pretty soon you'll get
- 1:12:20obviously largest regions will hopefully
- 1:12:21hold groups divisions or theaters as
- 1:12:24they call them large companies adopting.
- 1:12:26So the reason I always think about it is
- 1:12:28that it's all down to the same paying
- 1:12:31game equation. You got to take the
- 1:12:33upfront cost out of getting that
- 1:12:35customer and you got to make it really
- 1:12:36digestible and easy for the customer. So
- 1:12:38if you don't want to call it Russian
- 1:12:40doll, you want to call it, you know,
- 1:12:40chunking up the elephant, I don't care.
- 1:12:42The point is find digestible ways to get
- 1:12:45that first intro introduction to your
- 1:12:48customer to be as painless and slippery
- 1:12:50as possible. Um, and then obviously it's
- 1:12:53it's a great product that you can keep
- 1:12:54re-engaging and that's why this piece is
- 1:12:56so critical. You can keep re-engaging
- 1:12:58them, adding more value, opening up more
- 1:13:00and more of the the uh the dolls if you
- 1:13:02will, exposing more value, then you will
- 1:13:04get more and more lifetime value out of
- 1:13:05that customer. Does that answer your
- 1:13:06question? Yeah, it's it sounds like it's
- 1:13:08a way to also gradually build your
- 1:13:10credibility. Absolutely.
- 1:13:13It's absolutely the biggest challenge
- 1:13:15startups have and it's amazing how many
- 1:13:17times we struggle this is just that one
- 1:13:19word you use credibility and I think I
- 1:13:21mentioned it on one of my slides often
- 1:13:23times a strategic partnership is at the
- 1:13:26top of the list providing a company
- 1:13:28credibility uh an example from our
- 1:13:30portfolio just to give people another
- 1:13:32real world case study was we had a a
- 1:13:35great entrepreneur we backed him again
- 1:13:36actually Ashtosh in a storage world came
- 1:13:40up with a concept in a company called um
- 1:13:42app IQ to make it possible for people to
- 1:13:45store data independent of the underlying
- 1:13:47uh infrastructure. So in other words,
- 1:13:49you matter whether you know storage from
- 1:13:51IBM or EMC or Fuji or whatever. Uh the
- 1:13:54application above could use that like
- 1:13:56storage in a less cost effective manner.
- 1:13:58It's a brilliant idea. But the problem
- 1:13:59is applications are mission critical
- 1:14:02storage is sold by big companies.
- 1:14:04There's only about five of them in the
- 1:14:05world who who own that marketplace. And
- 1:14:08how the heck was a little company going
- 1:14:09to get in the middle of those two
- 1:14:11things? He did a genius thing and found
- 1:14:13a way to make it possible for that to
- 1:14:15become effectively very simple for
- 1:14:18people, painless for people to try and
- 1:14:20then he went and did a deal with one of
- 1:14:22the major vendors and then it made it
- 1:14:24obvious that all the other four needed
- 1:14:26to play otherwise they wouldn't be
- 1:14:27competitive and pretty soon he owned
- 1:14:29that marketplace and had a great exit
- 1:14:30and ended up being CTO of storage at HP
- 1:14:33and now we're back in his latest startup
- 1:14:34activity and he's doing it all over
- 1:14:36again. uh but he really understands this
- 1:14:38very very well. Maybe I'll get up to one
- 1:14:40of the workshops. Does that answer your
- 1:14:42question? Thank you. Any other questions
- 1:14:43from people before we summarize
- 1:14:46here? Okay. So, as you go after your
- 1:14:50workshop, what I want to try to get you
- 1:14:51thinking about is what is your
- 1:14:53disruptive model going to be? How can
- 1:14:55you make it as significant as your
- 1:14:57technology? Can you focus on a core
- 1:14:59differentiation? Not 20 things that you
- 1:15:01do, but hopefully one. and what will be
- 1:15:04the multipliers and leverage that you
- 1:15:06will give it with innovations like we've
- 1:15:08talked about this evening co-creation or
- 1:15:10strategic partners uh or Russian gold
- 1:15:13packaging or slippery products and then
- 1:15:15how will you measure that not just once
- 1:15:18but over the extended customer life
- 1:15:20cycle with LCB and CC.
- 1:15:23So I I hope everybody had some fun this
- 1:15:25evening. I I must say I continue to be
- 1:15:27blown away by what a great group this is
- 1:15:29because if you look at some of the
- 1:15:30things we were trying to do and we were
- 1:15:32trying to figure out you know could you
- 1:15:33come up with a core value problem. A
- 1:15:35number of you took some pretty bold
- 1:15:36moves to not declare it as the obvious
- 1:15:38thing the technology but you focused on
- 1:15:40things like data or data and analytics
- 1:15:42or content in one case. You were quick
- 1:15:44to figure out what your multipliers and
- 1:15:46your levers were. Some of you found some
- 1:15:48really great ways to make partnerships
- 1:15:50that were win-win that would work on
- 1:15:52both sides of of that. So multipliers
- 1:15:54and levers and then a lot of you were
- 1:15:56talking very clearly about just as you
- 1:15:58heard how important the slippery product
- 1:15:59concept is to make it easy for people to
- 1:16:01get instant value out of this and and
- 1:16:04instantly they're obviously start
- 1:16:05spinning the wheel. Um, a few people
- 1:16:07definitely picked up on this life cycle
- 1:16:09concept and this notion of keeping
- 1:16:10people engaged and I heard some good
- 1:16:11examples of that. And overall, although
- 1:16:14we didn't try to get you down to, you
- 1:16:15know, actually calculating your uh, life
- 1:16:17cycle value and your customer
- 1:16:19acquisition and re-engagement cost, I
- 1:16:21felt like a lot of you grasped this so
- 1:16:23well that you would have no problem
- 1:16:24doing those kinds of things. So, I want
- 1:16:26to take my hats off to all of you and
- 1:16:27say congratulations. Thank you.
- 1:16:33[Music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Harvard i-lab | Startup Secrets Part 3: Business Model - Michael Skok by Harvard Innovation Labs, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 15,611 words across 2,241 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.