Harnessing Trade Cooperation to Deliver Green Industrialization and Climate Goals — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Bir de.
- 0:02>> Sekiz olacaklar.
- 3:58>> Bonjour bonjour.
- 4:00>> On ne se voit pas
- 4:22>> Hi, how are you?
- 4:24>> Claudia.
- 4:25>> Yes, yes.
- 4:26And
- 4:48>> [laughter]
- 7:30>> Okay.
- 7:34Okay.
- 7:36Hello.
- 7:37>> Is there a fridge for the water up in
- 7:39here?
- 7:55>> Hello.
- 8:05>> All right, we're going to get started,
- 8:06ladies and gentlemen. It looks like a
- 8:08lot of people got stuck in traffic or
- 8:10they're just sleeping this morning.
- 8:12But other people will be waiting for the
- 8:16the amphitheater afterwards, so we will
- 8:18start.
- 8:25While the panelists are taking their
- 8:26seats on the podium
- 8:37>> Good morning. Good morning
- 8:40Good morning.
- 8:44Very good to meet you.
- 8:45>> Just for the record, guys, this is time
- 8:47taken from your speech [laughter]
- 8:50because the timer has started.
- 8:53There you go. This is always get people
- 8:55going.
- 8:58Thank you so much. Good morning,
- 9:00everyone. My name is Chantal Line
- 9:01Carpentier. I'm the head of trade,
- 9:03environment, climate change, and
- 9:04sustainable development at UN Trade and
- 9:06Development. And it's a pleasure for me
- 9:08to open this session this morning on
- 9:10Access Six
- 9:13Activation Group 24, harnessing trade
- 9:15cooperation to deliver green
- 9:16industrialization and climate goals.
- 9:19And we have the pleasure to have with us
- 9:22Lara Van Druten, special advisor to the
- 9:24climate
- 9:25high-level champion for COP 31, Samia
- 9:29to open this session. Thank you.
- 9:37>> Hey, good morning all on this
- 9:39gray, very early morning.
- 9:42On behalf of
- 9:44Samia
- 9:46I really am quite delighted to to
- 9:49welcome everyone today to this
- 9:51high-level session and
- 9:54on harnessing climate cooperation. I
- 9:56think cooperation is really a subject
- 9:59that sits very close to the heart of our
- 10:02COP 31 climate climate champion.
- 10:07One of the things I found fascinating
- 10:08about the last couple of days and
- 10:10everything that I've heard is this new
- 10:12kind of battle cry that I've heard. And
- 10:15the battle cry is something along the
- 10:16lines of implementalia.
- 10:19And I thought that was a pretty good one
- 10:22because what it really does is it really
- 10:25sets the stage as it were for on the one
- 10:27hand and really ensuring that what we
- 10:30doing is going past the pledges and the
- 10:32commitments and really focusing on
- 10:34implementation. And on the other hand
- 10:37really highlighting how we have this
- 10:38enormous opportunity over the the next
- 10:41coming days to
- 10:43to harness all of the energy that we
- 10:45have in the cop environment, to to
- 10:48harness all of the passion and all of
- 10:50the
- 10:51the goodwill in order to to make a
- 10:53difference. And when it comes to
- 10:55partnerships, I think really the key to
- 10:56making a difference is really
- 10:58partnerships and collaboration and
- 11:00working together. And it's probably one
- 11:02of the hardest things to do. But if you
- 11:05get it right, then you really have the
- 11:08potential to ensure that 1 + 1 is 3.
- 11:11So from that perspective, I wish you
- 11:13today lots and lots and lots of
- 11:15implementalia. And
- 11:18I also wish you today
- 11:20really a formulation in which 1 + 1 does
- 11:22equal 3. Thank you very much.
- 11:24>> Thank you, Lara. It's a pleasure.
- 11:27And with this, ladies and gentlemen,
- 11:30again, good morning.
- 11:32Let me first thank the government of
- 11:34Turkey for hosting COP 31 and for its
- 11:37very warm welcome here in Antalya. And I
- 11:40really like that implementalia
- 11:42principle. We will try to put that into
- 11:44effect.
- 11:45I also want to thank the climate
- 11:46champion and the climate action agenda
- 11:48team for hosting us today in this great
- 11:51place.
- 11:53As well as bringing the partners of of
- 11:55this planet together. We had a few
- 11:57meetings online, but it's nice to be
- 11:58able to to see each other. Too bad we
- 12:00can't be in a circle and talk to each
- 12:02other, but we'll get to we'll get to
- 12:04that at some point, I guess.
- 12:05I also want to thank the organization
- 12:07that helped prepare the session, the
- 12:08forum trade environment and the SDG test
- 12:11uh Yasmin,
- 12:13uh the International Trade Center, who
- 12:14is our airman, the UN Convene Net Zero
- 12:18Export Credit Agencies Alliance,
- 12:21with Remco,
- 12:22um hosted by UNEFI, and we also have the
- 12:25representative of Turkey, the Trade
- 12:27Ministry. Who am I forgetting? Uh Eiko
- 12:30from the WTO, and Gabriel uh from uh the
- 12:34the
- 12:35embassy the embassy the mission of
- 12:38Philippines to the United Nations. WTO,
- 12:41I get that.
- 12:42Um so basically, what is this uh past
- 12:45the plan for accelerated action for
- 12:47those of you that are not aware? These
- 12:49awards started under the action agenda.
- 12:52Uh we reconfigure at COP 30 to be more
- 12:55uh of action-oriented and bringing the
- 12:57non-state actors uh together to
- 13:00implement the agenda.
- 13:02So we're not part of the negotiation.
- 13:03This is part of implementation.
- 13:06Uh it give access to climate. The whole
- 13:07idea here is that uh for too many years,
- 13:11trade was not at the table on in helping
- 13:14us advance um uh the climate. And what
- 13:18we
- 13:19uh are positing is that trade can speed
- 13:21up the shift uh to
- 13:24implement that. Yeah.
- 13:25It gave access to climate relevant
- 13:27goods, services, technologies, and
- 13:28knowledge. It can strengthen productive
- 13:30capacities, diversify economies, build
- 13:33green, blue, and circular value chain to
- 13:35help the the resilience of countries.
- 13:38But not all countries have benefited
- 13:40yet. Many developing countries struggle
- 13:43to build sustainable industrial
- 13:45capacities and to join emerging
- 13:47sustainable value chains. Sustainability
- 13:49standard and market requirement keep
- 13:51changing, and it's a very complex
- 13:54environment. And as we've been
- 13:55discussing over the past few days, we
- 13:58need to ensure integrity of the
- 14:01carbonization process while
- 14:03decomplexifying the process and lowering
- 14:06the cost of it.
- 14:08And of course, this affects mostly small
- 14:11and medium enterprises. Um they face the
- 14:14hardest path. They often lack the
- 14:15information, technology, skills, and
- 14:18finance to comply, and they may find it
- 14:21hard to show they are ready for
- 14:22investment or that they have
- 14:24decarbonized indeed,
- 14:26leaving them out of the market. Trade
- 14:28cooperation, capacity building, and
- 14:30knowledge sharing can help close this
- 14:32gap.
- 14:33A key step is also to increase
- 14:34coordination between trade,
- 14:36environmental ministries, business
- 14:38support organization, financial
- 14:40institution, and buyers. And we had
- 14:43several session yesterday during the
- 14:44trade day,
- 14:46trade and finance day that was organized
- 14:47with the partners,
- 14:49the trade ministry here in Turkey and
- 14:51the host country.
- 14:52And many of these issues have been
- 14:56brought up that we want to integrate as
- 14:58well into this plan for accelerated
- 15:00solution on harnessing trade policy for
- 15:03nationally determined contribution, low
- 15:05economic diversification, and climate
- 15:07resilience.
- 15:09We have three objectives this morning.
- 15:10First, to identify practical pathways
- 15:12for policy recommendations.
- 15:15We want to see how countries can
- 15:16integrate trade and climate objective
- 15:18into national development and climate
- 15:20strategies and use trade policy to
- 15:22support the NDCs implementation,
- 15:25sustainable industrialization and
- 15:27resilience.
- 15:28And this include concrete ways to help
- 15:30our SMEs overcome barriers and finance,
- 15:33technology, skills, and market access.
- 15:35Second, to showcase what works. We had a
- 15:38session yesterday on this. We will hear
- 15:40from the Philippines in developing its
- 15:42trade and climate strategy out Turkey
- 15:44and also how Turkey is using trade to
- 15:47support climate action.
- 15:49We will also hear about initiative from
- 15:50UNCTAD, ITC, TESS, UNEPFI, and the WTO
- 15:54about partnership export credit agencies
- 15:57and financial institution that fund the
- 16:00clean energy and sustainable trade.
- 16:02And third,
- 16:04to strengthen collaboration. We aim to
- 16:06find opportunity to scale up
- 16:09in
- 16:10to scale up capacity building and
- 16:12technical assistance and to mobilize
- 16:14finance, technology, and international
- 16:16cooperation for implementalia.
- 16:19From our side, as the past lead, UNCTAD
- 16:21can report significant progress in
- 16:23advancing our commitment this year.
- 16:25For those who don't know, our our
- 16:27support
- 16:29um to African countries build on
- 16:30earliest UNCTAD and UN ECA support
- 16:34for greening national uh AfCFTA
- 16:36strategies, the Af a continental free
- 16:38trade agreement in Africa that support
- 16:41led to pilot consultation on trade and
- 16:43NDCs in the Gambia and Madagascar
- 16:46in late not 2024. In 2025 and 2026 we
- 16:50moved from pilot to results.
- 16:52First, we release a revision of our
- 16:54guide for trade policy to advance
- 16:56national climate plan
- 16:57informed by the feedback from the
- 16:59pilots.
- 17:01We expanded then to Senegal. In February
- 17:03this year, stakeholder identified
- 17:05climate strategic sectors including
- 17:07fisheries, renewable energy, mining and
- 17:09tourism as adopted and implemented road
- 17:12map for those sectors.
- 17:15And third, because of growing demand uh
- 17:17for understanding the trading climate
- 17:19relationship because as you probably
- 17:22know, most of the people that come to
- 17:23COP come from the environmental
- 17:24ministries tra traditionally. And now
- 17:27that the trade is rising on the agenda,
- 17:28they want to understand the linkages
- 17:30between trade and climate. So we built a
- 17:33e-learning course that has been taken
- 17:35now by 786 participants from 114
- 17:38countries, mostly developing countries
- 17:41um and over the two uh period, 1,200 uh
- 17:45delegates have taken the class.
- 17:46We're now going to release the class in
- 17:49French
- 17:50and we'll be partnering with others at
- 17:51the regional level and on specific topic
- 17:54to offer this e-learning.
- 17:57We will train uh next month the national
- 18:00committee on trade and climate in the
- 18:01Gambia and help the second Senegal
- 18:03prepare its joint proposal and we plan
- 18:06to continue the fundraising effort to
- 18:08turn these road map into results. So
- 18:10maybe we could talk with our colleagues
- 18:12here on this. And of course, the main
- 18:14challenge for everyone remains um
- 18:17uh fundings.
- 18:19So basically we have an hour now, much
- 18:22less, 44 minutes. Um so let's get to it.
- 18:24Each panelist has three minutes to
- 18:26explain what is it that they've been
- 18:28doing to continue to this plan for
- 18:30accelerated solution. And Gabrielle, if
- 18:32you don't mind, I will start with you.
- 18:34How has the Philippines translated its
- 18:36climate uh development priorities into
- 18:39national strategies and how do you use
- 18:41that to inform your engagement in Geneva
- 18:44and here at the cop?
- 18:45Over to you.
- 18:46>> Yeah, thank you Chancellor Lena. Good
- 18:47morning to everyone. Thank you to the
- 18:48organizers for the invitation. Uh this
- 18:51is my first cop, so I feel like I'm on
- 18:53the job training. I I did the uh Bonn
- 18:55conference in June.
- 18:56And I'm reminded of uh
- 18:59an invitation extended to you actually
- 19:01in the WTO for a thematic session on
- 19:03trade related climate measures where you
- 19:06really emphasize the work that you and
- 19:07Claudia are doing uh in terms of pushing
- 19:10for the integration of trade tools in
- 19:13NDCs. So I think uh I think you you
- 19:16highlighted the issue of complexity.
- 19:19In our case, I think it's a work in
- 19:20progress. Um we really became much more
- 19:24engaged, I would say over the last three
- 19:25or four years. I think
- 19:27this is related to several factors. Uh
- 19:30of course, one is defensive interest.
- 19:32You have increased complexities in terms
- 19:34of market access and market
- 19:36requirements. A lot of
- 19:38uh you know the the the language there
- 19:41is about uh unilateral trade measures or
- 19:43barriers to trade.
- 19:45Uh but we also see the opportunities in
- 19:47terms of greener trade. So we saw that
- 19:50there's a balance between the two.
- 19:52Um and I think uh that led us to give
- 19:55more attention to a lot of these
- 19:57measures.
- 19:58Uh we we commissioned a study in 2022
- 20:022023
- 20:03that spurred a lot of the action on our
- 20:06side. So we developed uh in the WTO
- 20:08context
- 20:09an interagency mechanism involving our
- 20:12energy, environment,
- 20:14trade people.
- 20:16Um and that enabled us to be more
- 20:18actively engaged in WTO processes and
- 20:21some of the plurilateral dialogues on
- 20:23plastics, on trade, environmentally
- 20:25sustainable
- 20:26discussions.
- 20:28And I think that laid the groundwork for
- 20:30some of the work that that's evolved. We
- 20:32worked with ITC on a climate
- 20:34competitiveness project
- 20:36that was funded by the EU and now we're
- 20:38working with Tess with Yasmin here to my
- 20:40left on a project focused on integrating
- 20:44trade and climate.
- 20:46And I think
- 20:47there's been positive feedback. There's
- 20:49a positive feedback loop in terms of our
- 20:51engagement. We've had successes on
- 20:53renewables, for instance, at the
- 20:55national level. We're bringing some of
- 20:57those success stories into the WTO
- 20:59context on environmental goods and
- 21:01services.
- 21:03The approach that the plurilateral
- 21:05dialogue in the WTO, which has focused
- 21:07on value chain approaches, we're now
- 21:09bringing that down to the national
- 21:11level.
- 21:12So the strategy we're working on is is
- 21:14proposing a pilot on on four areas,
- 21:18renewables, electronics, creative
- 21:20industries and and agriculture.
- 21:23Really looking at what are the touch
- 21:24points where trade fits into the value
- 21:28chains and how we can reduce frictions
- 21:31for trade and investment.
- 21:32We're getting people to talk basically
- 21:34in Manila on these issues and I think
- 21:36that's an important first step.
- 21:39And we're I think trying to look at, you
- 21:41know, in the WTO context we have Ho here
- 21:43who will maybe touch on a lot of the
- 21:45discussions, the buzzwords,
- 21:48measurement, reporting, verification of
- 21:51embedded emissions. We're very far away
- 21:53from that in the Philippines, but we're
- 21:54now discussing the concept behind it,
- 21:57the need
- 21:59and what is required to build the soft
- 22:01infrastructure. I think there are also
- 22:03knowledge gaps because, you know, we
- 22:05have Article 6 cooperation in the UNFCCC
- 22:09and some of the underlying
- 22:10infrastructure with that I think can be
- 22:13applied to discussions on MRVs on the
- 22:16trade side.
- 22:18So we need to fill those gaps
- 22:19institutionally and we're trying to fill
- 22:21some of those gaps at the national
- 22:23level.
- 22:24So it's an encouraging sign where we
- 22:27have buy in from
- 22:28our high level officials as well as our
- 22:30technical experts. And I think it's
- 22:32something that others need to to also
- 22:34consider and we hope some of these
- 22:37partial successes will lead to
- 22:40uh you know multilateral successes.
- 22:42Thank you.
- 22:43>> Thank you so much
- 22:44indeed. Thank you for mentioning the
- 22:46trade and investment have to come
- 22:48together. This is also what we're
- 22:49finding in Senegal and and
- 22:51the Gambia. And also this the the the
- 22:54necessity to bring the trade, the
- 22:56environment and the line ministries
- 22:58together.
- 22:59Uh and then to select key priority
- 23:01sectors um and then they can become
- 23:04that's the only way they can become
- 23:05investable, right? Um now moving right
- 23:08along to
- 23:10Elif our our host. Um here in the Turkey
- 23:14would could you share with us the
- 23:15progress and challenge in using trade
- 23:17for climate action from from from your
- 23:20side? And maybe you want to sprinkle in
- 23:22some of their lessons from yesterday on
- 23:24the trade day as well?
- 23:29>> Uh thank you very much Chantaleen for
- 23:31the question and for for providing us
- 23:33the opportunity to express our
- 23:37experiences and
- 23:38the challenges that we can discuss on
- 23:40on.
- 23:41Uh
- 23:42well as as Ministry of Trade it's a
- 23:45pleasure for us to contribute to the
- 23:47interaction
- 23:49between climate policies and trade and
- 23:51having having been able to organize and
- 23:54finance and trade day that we had
- 23:58four main sessions and one high level
- 24:01panel. It has been very enriching and I
- 24:03would like to thank you to all our
- 24:05partners, to WTO, UNCTAD and ITC and of
- 24:08course
- 24:10co-presidency for for letting us able to
- 24:13do that.
- 24:15Uh so as Ministry of Trade actually we
- 24:17have already linked trade and climate
- 24:20policies
- 24:22back
- 24:23back in 2021.
- 24:25We have adopted our green deal action
- 24:27plan. As Ministry of Trade, um um we
- 24:30have been coordinating um
- 24:33the green deal um the effects of the
- 24:36green deal policies.
- 24:37Uh and we have been working with all the
- 24:40other ministries and also with our
- 24:42private sector in order to understand uh
- 24:46the main green transition policies, how
- 24:49we should adapt as uh as a government uh
- 24:52institutions and how our exporters uh
- 24:55need to react to those
- 24:58uh changes. So that's
- 25:00that's a thing that actually we have
- 25:02been doing since back then and
- 25:06uh all our ministries have been adopting
- 25:09um
- 25:10uh their their policy strategies, action
- 25:13plans and many legislations have been
- 25:15adopted since then. Uh
- 25:17and and it's it's a thing that actually
- 25:20as Ministry of Trade we we look at as a
- 25:22comprehensive and holistic
- 25:25uh in a very holistic approach. Uh
- 25:29so uh we see that there are many
- 25:31linkages in between uh different
- 25:33policies. So uh that holistic approach
- 25:36is actually helping us to understand and
- 25:37develop the right policies.
- 25:40Uh with respect to um
- 25:42uh and we have recently updated our
- 25:44action plan actually and it has been
- 25:46released adopted uh
- 25:48on on the second day of COP 31.
- 25:52Uh with respect to the
- 25:55uh our uh our engagement with
- 25:58with the private sector on the business
- 26:00side
- 26:01uh
- 26:01uh we are also in close contact with our
- 26:04exporters.
- 26:05So um
- 26:07we are trying to explain what's coming
- 26:09ahead. So which types of investments
- 26:12they need to do, what kind of uh um
- 26:15um rules for market access are coming
- 26:18up.
- 26:19Uh so we are trying to increase the
- 26:22awareness among our private sector for
- 26:25them to understand uh what's coming up.
- 26:27So the main challenge here is that um
- 26:31there is there been a little bit of
- 26:34resistance on
- 26:36understanding the need
- 26:38of doing that. It had been
- 26:41voluntary
- 26:42for a long time. All the climate
- 26:44policies and the investments,
- 26:46environmental investments have been
- 26:48rather voluntary. And most of the big
- 26:51companies have been doing their
- 26:54investments and making
- 26:57strategies accordingly given their
- 26:59sustainability goals. But for the SMEs,
- 27:02it had been really voluntary. So we are
- 27:04trying to understand explain them that
- 27:07it's not anymore voluntary. They have to
- 27:09do something to that for that. So one of
- 27:12the challenges actually they are just
- 27:14waiting until the very end until the end
- 27:17that they could
- 27:18not move and access to the markets to
- 27:21make the investment. So that's a
- 27:23challenge. And another thing is they
- 27:25they are trying to understand
- 27:28all the regulations and the the
- 27:30comprehensive
- 27:32types of things that they have to do. So
- 27:34but actually but we have we we have
- 27:38moved along the road and
- 27:41they have been considerable amount of
- 27:45improvement in that regard. But the
- 27:48we we we have to go ahead on this.
- 27:52Maybe another thing is is the
- 27:55this new type of economy is also really
- 27:59important which also has a direct effect
- 28:01on trade is the
- 28:03the new technologies, new types of
- 28:05materials that we are going through
- 28:08for the green transition
- 28:10is really important. And and that has
- 28:13direct effect on trade especially with
- 28:16respect to critical raw materials and
- 28:18secondary raw materials. So there have
- 28:21there I think we need to have a balance
- 28:24to keep this climate goals as climate
- 28:27goals and not turn them to
- 28:31a tool for competitiveness.
- 28:34But
- 28:35we we need to also in order to enhance
- 28:38this
- 28:39climate ambition through
- 28:42circular economy transition, we have to
- 28:45keep it
- 28:46for instance, we have to let the flow of
- 28:48materials, but we shouldn't
- 28:50let them to be
- 28:53creating climate problems. So for
- 28:56instance, just maybe concrete example on
- 28:58this is to
- 29:01make it
- 29:02to bring new classifications for waste
- 29:04for end of waste criteria or
- 29:06classification of secondhand goods and
- 29:11waste. That type of concrete examples
- 29:13should be
- 29:15taken
- 29:16and yeah, thank you.
- 29:18>> Totally agree with you and this is
- 29:19something we're working very closely on.
- 29:21You know, some countries will label it
- 29:23as waste and it gets to another country.
- 29:25It's it's a secondary and then it gets
- 29:27caught caught at the border at the
- 29:29custom and then it wait there for
- 29:31months. So indeed this is HS code for
- 29:33some of these recycled materials,
- 29:35secondary and materials very important.
- 29:37But also this idea of all of government
- 29:40policy coherence across very important
- 29:42and also the role of private sector and
- 29:44bringing the private sector indeed very
- 29:46important.
- 29:48Aiko,
- 29:50and I'm going to come back to
- 29:51I almost want to jump to because we talk
- 29:53about MSMEs, but Aiko,
- 29:55what is happening at the WTO to help us
- 29:58do this?
- 29:59Tell us.
- 30:00>> Right. I I have a slideshow with 14
- 30:03slides in it, but I I I will and that's
- 30:06the abbreviated version, but I'm not
- 30:08going to use it, okay? So I was told
- 30:10that 3 minutes. So I'll speak about 3
- 30:12publications in 3 minutes and hopefully
- 30:15that will give you
- 30:17a full overview. So first publication,
- 30:20which is trade and environment at WTO,
- 30:22which Petra, my colleague in the second
- 30:26row has. So please take a copy.
- 30:28And why am I showing this publication?
- 30:30Because everything in the WTO happens
- 30:34and is grounded through committees and
- 30:36through bodies. And who sits on the
- 30:39committees and bodies are my good friend
- 30:41here, Gabriela, on the one side, and the
- 30:43Kia delegation, of course, is also
- 30:45sitting on it. These are the members,
- 30:48and it's the member-driven organization.
- 30:51So the first thing you learn when you
- 30:52join the WTO, it's a member-driven
- 30:54organization.
- 30:55And that's the last thing you also hear
- 30:57when you leave the WTO is a
- 30:59member-driven organization. And we're in
- 31:01the WTO is also a member-driven
- 31:03organization. And is member-driven for a
- 31:05very good reason because trade policies
- 31:09are designed nationally. They're
- 31:11designed by governments, and that is a
- 31:14sovereign right of every country, and
- 31:17they are the ones who decide on their
- 31:18trade policy.
- 31:20But trade policy is complex. Trade
- 31:22policy is not one instrument. Trade
- 31:24policy is many, many, many instruments.
- 31:27So my first publication will explain to
- 31:30you the whole framework of the WTO, how
- 31:32it actually works, how are decisions
- 31:35actually taken, and where are issues on
- 31:37trade and environment actually
- 31:38discussed. And it gets more granular
- 31:41into what are the discussions about. And
- 31:43hopefully some of these discussions do
- 31:46lead to solutions,
- 31:48be it
- 31:49solutions at the policy front in terms
- 31:52of changes at the the trade policies of
- 31:56of countries. But underlying all of this
- 31:58is the WTO systems of rules which are
- 32:02essentially about more transparency,
- 32:05more predictability, more certainty, and
- 32:07movement towards a rules-based system to
- 32:10reduce the need for arbitrary
- 32:13decisions or unilateral decisions by
- 32:16governments, which I think is critical
- 32:18today when it comes to climate, critical
- 32:21to trade, and critical to the
- 32:23interconnection between trade and
- 32:24climate. So that's that's one piece. The
- 32:27second piece is what are the actual
- 32:29trade policies that we can be thinking
- 32:32about when we think about solutions for
- 32:34climate. And then brings me to my second
- 32:36second
- 32:37Trade Policy Tools for Climate Action.
- 32:40Now, this is not a member publication.
- 32:43This is a secretariat publication.
- 32:46Important to make that distinction as
- 32:47well because the secretariat, apart from
- 32:50facilitating its members, also provide
- 32:53knowledge. And that's one of the
- 32:55knowledge tools that we have developed
- 32:57to try to understand this question that
- 32:59you've posed Chanteline, which is on how
- 33:02can you actually use trade policy to
- 33:04support climate action.
- 33:06So we took a rather pragmatic approach.
- 33:09We looked at all the notifications that
- 33:11governments were already providing to
- 33:13the WTO, and they provide a lot of
- 33:16notifications to the WTO. A vast number
- 33:19of them are environment related. And if
- 33:21you just look at climate related
- 33:24notifications, they are on the rise. For
- 33:26many of the things that Elif have
- 33:28mentioned,
- 33:29you see the move from more voluntary
- 33:32efforts to much more mandatory. So and
- 33:36once that happens, it becomes part of
- 33:37the regulatory infrastructure of a
- 33:39country. If it falls within the scope of
- 33:42the WTO agreement, it becomes notified
- 33:44to the WTO. So it's important to
- 33:46understand what's happening in that
- 33:48landscape if we're going to develop
- 33:50solutions. And what are these things
- 33:52about? They're about tariffs, they're
- 33:54about subsidies, they're about
- 33:55government procurement, about standards
- 33:58and regulations, international standards
- 34:00and regulations for instance. It's about
- 34:02services and it's about some
- 34:04particularly
- 34:06important sectors, be it steel, be it
- 34:09agriculture, some of the heavy emitting
- 34:11sectors. So that's in a nutshell what
- 34:14this publication tries to do. Understand
- 34:17the different types of trade policies
- 34:19and how governments are already using
- 34:21them to provide solutions. And then the
- 34:23last publication I have is
- 34:26this one, which is
- 34:28some policy insights from one of the
- 34:30initiatives at the WTO, which is TESSD,
- 34:34not to be confused with TESS.
- 34:37The D is very important. It's the
- 34:39structured discussions at the WTO. It's
- 34:42not an organization. It's actually the
- 34:44WTO members themselves coordinating
- 34:47themselves into a forum where they are
- 34:50discussing between themselves different
- 34:53challenges, different frictions, but
- 34:55ultimately possible solutions that they
- 34:57can take
- 34:59to further use trade policy for climate
- 35:01action. So that's in a nutshell what
- 35:04we're doing and all solutions from WTO
- 35:07are member driven and member
- 35:09implemented. Thank you.
- 35:11>> remember and Ngozi would be very proud
- 35:12of you to have shown all these
- 35:13publications.
- 35:15I I remember. Thank you for telling us
- 35:18this, Ayoko, because I think the WTO,
- 35:21there's a lot of work that we don't see
- 35:22in the TBT and the in the SPS committee
- 35:26where there's transparency and this
- 35:27advanced notification so countries can
- 35:30hash it out before it becomes law. And
- 35:32so it reduced these complexity that
- 35:34we've been talking about, but we don't
- 35:36hear about it. We hear about the big
- 35:37lines. So there is a huge part of the
- 35:39WTO that should not be reformed because
- 35:42that part actually worked very well,
- 35:44right? And it it's actually reducing
- 35:46these complexity we've been talking
- 35:48about.
- 35:49Thank you for this. I'd like to move now
- 35:51on to Erman Akson to my left, good
- 35:54friend, Chief Queen Inclusive Value
- 35:56Chain Section at the International Trade
- 35:58Centre. And we're going to that we're
- 36:00going to bring us back to the MSMEs. So
- 36:03drawing on your work on ITC
- 36:06and ITC's work on SMEs in developing
- 36:08countries, how can we help them and how
- 36:12do you help them to bring
- 36:14you know if mention how hard it is
- 36:16sometime to convince the small and
- 36:17medium enterprise and they may they may
- 36:19be waiting till the last minute because
- 36:21they just they have so much more
- 36:23investment to be made and maybe this is
- 36:24not the prime investment they want to
- 36:26make.
- 36:27Tell us how how what do they need? How
- 36:30do you help them and how do we move
- 36:32forward on this?
- 36:34>> Thank you, Chantal Line, for the
- 36:35invitation to be part of this panel.
- 36:37Good morning, everybody, and it's a
- 36:39pleasure for us to to be here.
- 36:42I would like to also say thank you to
- 36:43the Ministry of Turkey for a
- 36:45fantastically organized trade, finance,
- 36:48and environment day yesterday. We had a
- 36:51session on SMEs in particular, but we
- 36:54also had sessions on finance and
- 36:56investment, and we also had a very
- 36:58important point about how policies
- 37:01enable and facilitate
- 37:03development.
- 37:04I think these are the three points I
- 37:07want to to raise.
- 37:08First, SMEs, small and medium
- 37:11enterprises, represent 90% of the
- 37:14businesses. They are important. They are
- 37:17important for development. They are
- 37:18important for inclusion. They are
- 37:20important for the implementation of the
- 37:23climate commitments.
- 37:25SMEs, however,
- 37:27are one of the most vulnerable segments
- 37:30in the economy. They are vulnerable to
- 37:33climate shocks. They're vulnerable to
- 37:36value chain disruptions, to logistic
- 37:39shocks, and of course, they're
- 37:41vulnerable to price or economic shocks.
- 37:44And this is why
- 37:46we need to have SME specific
- 37:49policies
- 37:51or we need to integrate SME needs and
- 37:53requirements into the different trade
- 37:56and environment policies that we are
- 37:58working on.
- 37:59And I think this is in particular
- 38:01important.
- 38:03We have been working with the Ministries
- 38:05of Environment, the Ministry of Economy,
- 38:08and the Ministry of Trade and Finance
- 38:10across several
- 38:12countries to enable the inclusion of SME
- 38:16needs and requirements, to understand
- 38:18how the policies can respond at that,
- 38:21but also integrate SMEs as a driver of
- 38:24solutions. And this is important in this
- 38:28sense.
- 38:29The effort we do together with WTO,
- 38:31together with UNCTAD, together with the
- 38:33UNFCCC and the and the parties in having
- 38:37this dialogue on trade and environment
- 38:39is part of that. And I really welcome
- 38:42this. We welcome the efforts that
- 38:43started in Bonn
- 38:45and that will continue for the next
- 38:47three years. It is important in
- 38:50practical terms
- 38:52to include a special focus and integrate
- 38:55SME perspectives and contributions, for
- 38:58example, into the NDC
- 39:01and the implementation of the NDC
- 39:03commitments.
- 39:04With regards to specific needs,
- 39:07requirements and contributions from from
- 39:09the small and medium enterprises, I
- 39:11think it is about building business
- 39:15continuity. And this is what we have
- 39:17learned over the last 20 30 years of
- 39:20work with SMEs. Business continuity
- 39:23applies for all, but for SMEs, it's
- 39:26first and foremost about enabling
- 39:29adaptation, working with them so they
- 39:31can be more resilient and they can
- 39:33actually
- 39:34continue
- 39:35in their contributions and in the in the
- 39:37business.
- 39:39It is also about working with SMEs to
- 39:41adopt sustainable practices. It's about
- 39:44resource efficiency. So resource
- 39:47efficiency, circular economy is
- 39:50extremely important, but it's also a way
- 39:52of making the business more efficient as
- 39:55well as contributing to the climate
- 39:57commitments. So there's also a business
- 39:59sense into the sustainability and
- 40:02climate objective. However, it's not
- 40:04that simple.
- 40:06If the markets do not actually respond
- 40:10to that, if the markets do not provide
- 40:13the value necessary so that the
- 40:15investments
- 40:17required are profitable and worth it,
- 40:20then we have a problem. So we also need
- 40:22to work in generating the business and
- 40:24the market demand, but also the market
- 40:26retribution for those greener goods
- 40:30that SMEs are and can invest in.
- 40:34Of course, there are plenty of market
- 40:35opportunities in in relation to to green
- 40:38and green markets, but we need to to
- 40:40work on on that. It's also about
- 40:42transparency and traceability. It's also
- 40:45about data access. Many of the
- 40:46requirements that
- 40:48was mentioning require increased I would
- 40:52say diligence and due diligence on this.
- 40:55But if we do not support with platforms
- 40:57some of them public publicly led, others
- 41:00also by the private sector, how are we
- 41:03going to have access to that data and
- 41:05how are we going to enable SMEs to to
- 41:07trade and participate in a way that
- 41:10contributes to the green and greener
- 41:12objectives?
- 41:13Last but not least,
- 41:15access to finance and investment
- 41:18because without this it is impossible
- 41:20for SMEs in particular to implement what
- 41:24they need to do and to profits and or
- 41:26benefit from the opportunities that are
- 41:29available. And finance and investment is
- 41:31not straightforward in the sense that we
- 41:35need to adapt the instruments, we need
- 41:37to adapt the mechanisms to the specific
- 41:40needs of SMEs.
- 41:42And I think this is also a very
- 41:44important message and implication for
- 41:46policy.
- 41:47It is implication for the investment of
- 41:49finance providers. How do we factor SME
- 41:54requirements, SME opportunities, but
- 41:56also SME needs? I will stop there and I
- 42:01look forward to continuing the dialogue.
- 42:02Thank you.
- 42:04>> Thank you so much, Hernan. And indeed,
- 42:07really appreciate
- 42:09this idea that the the technical
- 42:11[clears throat] assistance, if you want,
- 42:12needs to be adapted to SMEs. And and
- 42:15it's important that I think Vanessa
- 42:17yesterday from ITC also mentioned that
- 42:20we need to look at the whole value chain
- 42:21and many of these SMEs are needed.
- 42:24They're needed for the value chain to
- 42:25work because they they provide the the
- 42:27component and parts that ended up end up
- 42:30in all of our products.
- 42:32And so if they don't succeed, the
- 42:33economy doesn't succeed either. You said
- 42:35what, 80% 90% of them of the business
- 42:38are SMEs. And
- 42:41and this whole idea that
- 42:42the technical assistance but also the
- 42:44financing need to be adapted. And I
- 42:45think Vanessa mentioned that you're
- 42:47creating some sort of a technical
- 42:49assistance and and capacity and and and
- 42:52special window for SMEs as well. But
- 42:55our next speaker perfectly timed
- 42:58[laughter]
- 42:59is Remco Fischer.
- 43:00He's the climate change lead at UNEP FI,
- 43:03Financial Initiative.
- 43:05And will tell us about how can we find
- 43:08facilitate this financing for for SMEs
- 43:11but also for this transition. I want to
- 43:14say to everyone that we will then have
- 43:16Yasmin. She will bring all this back
- 43:18together and then I go to you. So
- 43:19prepare your questions.
- 43:21>> Thank you. I've got I'm here luckily.
- 43:24Thank thanks very much Chantal Line and
- 43:26also to my fellow analysts and to the
- 43:28climate champions team for for
- 43:29facilitating all of this. It was a very
- 43:31beautiful segue I have to say there. So
- 43:34so double thanks for that. I'm not a
- 43:36trade person just to put that up front.
- 43:39I'm a finance person.
- 43:40But the two connect as as we're seeing
- 43:42right now and as at UNEP FI which is
- 43:46where I work we are a UNEP run network
- 43:49of 500 financial institutions. And it's
- 43:52mostly the private sector in in
- 43:55financial institutions, commercial
- 43:56banks, commercial insurance,
- 44:00few development finance institutions as
- 44:02well but the focus is private finance.
- 44:05And
- 44:07at some and and what we find what we try
- 44:09to do there is instill in financial
- 44:14institutions a greater drive towards
- 44:16sustainability. And we've done this a
- 44:18lot on climate change. We've done this a
- 44:19lot with with net zero commitments. We
- 44:22mobilize hundreds of financial
- 44:23institutions to set such net net zero
- 44:25commitments.
- 44:27But we realized at some point trade
- 44:29trade is also really important. And so
- 44:31when we asked ourselves well what does
- 44:33trade finance look like and who are the
- 44:34key actors in trade finance? And very
- 44:36quickly you come to the conclusion well
- 44:38that's the ECAs, the export credit
- 44:39agencies. And we said well could we not
- 44:41be working with the ECAs in the same way
- 44:44that we're working on climate progress,
- 44:47on progress towards net zero by 2050
- 44:50with the ECAs in the same way that we're
- 44:53working with the commercial banks, with
- 44:54the commercial insurance companies, with
- 44:55the institutional investors. So I wanted
- 44:58to highlight three things as to
- 45:00as to what why this work was important
- 45:02to us. Number one and what what we see
- 45:05happening. Number one, ECAs are super
- 45:08powerful in unlocking private capital.
- 45:11In fact, that's their mandate. And if
- 45:13you go back to the climate finance
- 45:15negotiations here or you take a step
- 45:17back and you and you ask yourself,
- 45:19what's the bigger challenge at play
- 45:21here? One of the bigger challenges is we
- 45:23don't have enough financing for climate.
- 45:25And still at this point we have, if you
- 45:28look at the climate financial flows,
- 45:30sort of 50/50 at the moment total, 50
- 45:32public, 50 private. We need to get to
- 45:34some place like 95 to 5 or 99 to 1%
- 45:38basically or 95 90 percent 99 percent of
- 45:42the financing comes from the from the
- 45:44private finance. And ECAs are critical
- 45:46in that because that's that's what they
- 45:47do through they work through as as many
- 45:50of you will know
- 45:52guarantees, insurance,
- 45:54and other mechanisms to precisely
- 45:56unblock private capital, unblock
- 46:00entrepreneurship
- 46:01by the exporter, by the importer.
- 46:04And and and and that is really critical
- 46:06and and they have a a role to play in
- 46:08that. And and and and the reason why
- 46:10this is especially important in climate
- 46:12change is because a lot of the
- 46:13investments that we need for climate
- 46:14change
- 46:15in clean energy, infrastructure,
- 46:17industrial decarbonization are capital
- 46:19intensive.
- 46:21They involve trade.
- 46:23They have complex risks very often. And
- 46:25they take place in markets where
- 46:27commercial finance alone wouldn't be
- 46:30forthcoming. And and the ECAs can make
- 46:33all the difference
- 46:35there. So they can make things bankable,
- 46:39crowding private capital in a trade
- 46:41context. And that's exactly what we
- 46:43need. Another thing, another observation
- 46:45that I'll make is that we see ECAs
- 46:47increasingly playing that role
- 46:48specifically with a climate focus. For
- 46:51one example, here in in in Turkey I've
- 46:54been told is a electrified railway
- 46:57railway
- 46:58project worth 2.6 billion.
- 47:01I'm going to butcher the name a little
- 47:03bit. It's it's the the cars
- 47:10you can you can probably translate this
- 47:11a little bit later on. I apologize for
- 47:13that.
- 47:14We're a number of the member
- 47:16so we created the net net zero export
- 47:18credit agencies alliance to as the
- 47:20vehicle for this. A number of the
- 47:22members of that alliance have provided
- 47:24the the the the risk sharing for that
- 47:27and have brought in other private sector
- 47:30financial institutions to provide
- 47:32of the financing. And number number
- 47:35three is we need to scale this. We're
- 47:39seeing kind of anecdotal evidence of
- 47:41ECAs working on these topics, working
- 47:44together with other parts of the
- 47:45financial system
- 47:47and obviously exporters, importers
- 47:51on these topics. But we need to make
- 47:53this what now is anecdotal maybe
- 47:56experiences and evidence
- 47:58mainstream, upscale. That's the point of
- 48:01this alliance of the UN convened net
- 48:04zero export credit agencies alliance
- 48:06that that we convened. I don't have PDFs
- 48:09to hold up.
- 48:10But we we we we launched the second
- 48:13progress report. We have a virtual PDF
- 48:16some somewhere in the in the internet.
- 48:18We launched the this this alliance
- 48:20launched its second progress report just
- 48:21yesterday and it showed how the the
- 48:24proportion of ECA portfolios
- 48:28that that
- 48:29are under a net zero mandate have gone
- 48:33up but by
- 48:35and now covering almost 400 billion of
- 48:38such
- 48:39of such exposures. What we want to do
- 48:41next and to conclude is
- 48:44we need to grow this group. It's a small
- 48:45group. It's a small leadership group.
- 48:46There's only 10 ECAs at the moment
- 48:48involved. We want to triple it,
- 48:50quadruple it if possible in the in the
- 48:52in the in the time to come. And we want
- 48:54to increasingly also connect continue
- 48:57connecting these efforts with other
- 48:59efforts as part of the financial
- 49:01services industry, banks, insurance
- 49:03companies, so that we have better risk
- 49:05sharing. Because that's what we need for
- 49:07public-private capital mobilization for
- 49:09climate.
- 49:10>> Thank you so much, Remco. And it
- 49:13reminiscence of yesterday's panel where
- 49:15we actually had the Exim Bank of Turkey
- 49:18that mentioned actually the work that
- 49:20they're doing. And what was interesting
- 49:22also is that we also had the National
- 49:24Development Bank of Uganda and
- 49:26mentioning how the National Development
- 49:28Bank also has an impact, but also how it
- 49:30supports the national bank system that
- 49:33needs to be deepened as well, um and not
- 49:36bypassing them, but working through
- 49:38them, by strengthening them. So very
- 49:40interesting work
- 49:42there that we can continue to be doing
- 49:44together. I now would like to go to
- 49:47Yasmin. She's excellent. She's the
- 49:49senior policy advisor to Trade, Climate,
- 49:51Sustainable Development at the other
- 49:53test, [laughter]
- 49:54the one without the D. Um and bring us
- 49:58all this together, Yasmin, what we've
- 50:00heard so far and what is it that we need
- 50:02to do to make this better. And you guys
- 50:04also serve as secretariat to the
- 50:06Integrated Forum on Climate Change and
- 50:08Trade. So bring all these pieces
- 50:10together and then I'll come in for for
- 50:11questions. Okay, I got you. Yeah.
- 50:13>> Thank you for your trust, Chantalene,
- 50:15that I'm able to bring this all
- 50:17together.
- 50:18Um and yes, we're tests without the D.
- 50:21And we work in we are based in Geneva
- 50:25and we work very collaboratively with
- 50:28all of the
- 50:31panelists here and their representative
- 50:34institutions from missions to WTO, to
- 50:37UNEP, UNCTAD, and and all of the
- 50:41colleagues
- 50:43on the panel here.
- 50:45Let me try to wrap up and link to the
- 50:47work that we do as well under this
- 50:49initiative and more broadly.
- 50:51What I've heard so far at what could be
- 50:54the blockages or points of challenge in
- 50:57order to advance cooperation on the
- 50:59trade and climate nexus from the various
- 51:02uh
- 51:03colleagues so far, I've identified three
- 51:06areas.
- 51:07One is developing countries in the
- 51:11earlier days of the conversation about
- 51:13trade and climate when it intensified in
- 51:17the past few years. They were more into
- 51:20the defensive
- 51:22interest mode rather than having a
- 51:24proactive agenda putting it on the
- 51:26table.
- 51:28And the reason what we saw as a reason
- 51:31behind this is silos at the national
- 51:33level between trade, climate, energy,
- 51:37agriculture, ministries, or other
- 51:39sectors that are at the nexus in their
- 51:42context on
- 51:44on trade and and climate. So part of the
- 51:47work that we do is to help build break
- 51:51that silos at the national level and
- 51:53support develop developing countries
- 51:55develop trade-related climate strategies
- 51:58that are looking at mitigation,
- 52:01adaptation, and climate resilient and
- 52:03sustainable development priorities of
- 52:05the country.
- 52:07And we started with the our pilot
- 52:10project with the Philippines.
- 52:12And one quick reflection
- 52:14as an outsider, I'm not
- 52:16I'm not from the Philippines, but I've
- 52:19attended the workshops so far. And what
- 52:22I can tell you that the first workshop
- 52:25when ministries arrived in the room,
- 52:28there was this look of what okay, what
- 52:30are we what are we doing? Okay, what
- 52:33what what are we supposed to do? Where
- 52:36is the link? Why are we here?
- 52:38And then
- 52:39throughout the time, the second
- 52:40workshop, it completely flipped.
- 52:43It was like okay, these are our
- 52:45priorities. Yes, in the well in the in
- 52:49the energy sector, you're looking for
- 52:51energy security. You have a potential
- 52:53for renewable energy, but from a
- 52:56trade perspective, these are the
- 52:57challenges that we are facing in order
- 52:59to have this renewable energy at an
- 53:01affordable cost. And then the two
- 53:03started talking together and then
- 53:05these linkages started building.
- 53:08So
- 53:09what we learned as a lesson from this is
- 53:12that more dialogues between the
- 53:15different ministries on this nexus
- 53:17towards building a more of like a
- 53:19strategic plan to advance the priorities
- 53:22of the country is needed and Philippines
- 53:25I would say is is showing leadership by
- 53:28doing this. So thank you Gabi and and
- 53:31the team at the national level for that.
- 53:34We're now taking this work with the
- 53:36lessons a lot of the lessons learned
- 53:39that we had from the Philippines to
- 53:41Kenya.
- 53:43We are planning on starting this work
- 53:45soon hopefully please pray for us.
- 53:48The second challenge is information
- 53:52knowledge gaps which many of also the my
- 53:55colleagues here spoke about.
- 53:58So the way we dealt with this challenge
- 54:01is that we from one part collaborated
- 54:05and supported UNCTAD initiative
- 54:08in having an e-learning course.
- 54:11So thank you Chantal Line.
- 54:13But also at TESS we tried to identify
- 54:17the issues where the trade and climate
- 54:21nexus in terms of trade policy and trade
- 54:23cooperation
- 54:24are needed the most right now. These
- 54:28themes can change later.
- 54:30So we started by establishing expert
- 54:32groups on one we have one on critical
- 54:35minerals that we are co-convening with
- 54:38Chantal Line and team and
- 54:42and UNCTAD.
- 54:43And the what we are looking here is that
- 54:46to examine a specific problem is that
- 54:49countries
- 54:50have rightfully different interests when
- 54:53it comes to critical minerals and
- 54:55driving clean energy transition
- 54:58be it supply security, be it development
- 55:00beneficiation or value addition or a
- 55:03third category which is sustainability.
- 55:06So how can TReNDS policy reconcile these
- 55:09very legitimate different interests in a
- 55:12less
- 55:13bringing tensions down and driving more
- 55:16cooperation.
- 55:18So the expert group has
- 55:22held three meetings so far and we hope
- 55:23to advance and we have other expert
- 55:26groups that will tackle adaptation,
- 55:28finance and other themes of importance.
- 55:30My last point is
- 55:33all of this needs to eventually find a
- 55:35home where
- 55:38high level
- 55:40leadership can take it forward. One part
- 55:44is the multilateral institutions, IGOs
- 55:46of course that happens on a daily basis
- 55:50through missions and delegations. But
- 55:52what we've also observed that having
- 55:54more less formal spaces for more frank
- 55:58discussions or for more straightforward
- 56:01opportunities for collaboration
- 56:05can be also useful to to create more
- 56:08momentum and bring more positive
- 56:10conversations into the multilateral
- 56:12spaces. So we are we are proud to be the
- 56:16secretariat of the coalition of trade
- 56:17ministers on climate. It involves 60
- 56:20plus ministers of trade so far. They
- 56:23just published an op-ed yesterday about
- 56:25their views on how to drive cooperation
- 56:27on trade and climate. I invite you to
- 56:29see it at on climate home news.
- 56:32And
- 56:33we also we are also the secretariat of
- 56:36the integrated forum on climate change
- 56:38and trade which was just announced by
- 56:41Brazil
- 56:42last COP and we look forward to
- 56:44advancing supporting them in advancing
- 56:47the work. I hope I was successful,
- 56:49Chantal Line. Thank you so much.
- 56:51>> It's impressive. Yeah, rounded it up and
- 56:54then at the same time and explaining
- 56:56what TReNDS does. We have six minutes. I
- 56:58have three questions. We're going to
- 57:00have to be quick on the question because
- 57:02I want to come back to answers. So
- 57:04Annie, you want to be first and then I
- 57:06go to Marcus and then the gentleman next
- 57:08to you. Uh, do we have one? Yeah.
- 57:16>> Thank you very much. Professor
- 57:18Marie-Claire Cordonier Segger and I'm
- 57:21hold the chair in Sustainable
- 57:23Development Law and Policy in the
- 57:24University of Cambridge. My question is
- 57:26probably quite obvious. Um, we have an
- 57:29e-learning training platform on trade,
- 57:32sustainable development with about
- 57:3439,000 young learners especially in
- 57:36highly climate vulnerable countries and
- 57:39we would love to be able to send them
- 57:40somewhere more specific that they would
- 57:43learn to go deeper after a three-week
- 57:45course. And I wonder if those types of
- 57:48linkages with academics that are doing
- 57:51maybe the education side more writ broad
- 57:53might be of interest to a few of you on
- 57:56the panel
- 57:57to whom we could send our learners when
- 57:59they want to go further faster.
- 58:01>> Academics are for us. Yes, please.
- 58:03[laughter] And good to see you. Marcus.
- 58:05>> Thank you so much, Chantal Line. Uh,
- 58:07Marcus Gehring. I'm a sustainable
- 58:09development lawyer working for the
- 58:11Centre for International Sustainable
- 58:12Development Law and there's my question.
- 58:14Shouldn't we also look at the law side
- 58:17of the interconnections?
- 58:20In my view, the NDCs should be
- 58:23investment gold for investors
- 58:26but only less than 10% of current NDCs
- 58:31mention trade or investment. Why is
- 58:34that? Why is the wonderful work that
- 58:36UNCTAD does on NDCs
- 58:39related to trade not picked up by more
- 58:42governments?
- 58:43>> Good question. We wish we had more money
- 58:46to make that happen. Uh,
- 58:47I have the gentleman but also Annie, I
- 58:49think you wanted to intervene or no?
- 58:53Or no?
- 58:54Okay, gentleman.
- 58:55>> Yeah. I have a question that I think
- 58:56might be of interest for Annie as well.
- 58:58Um, so uh my name is Francesco Lombardi.
- 59:00I work at the Climate NGO uh Bellona
- 59:02Europa is a Brussels-based European
- 59:05Climate NGO and I focus on the CBM. Um,
- 59:08so I would like to ask a question mainly
- 59:09to the non-EU representatives so from
- 59:11Turkey and and Philippines.
- 59:13With Turkey announcing the CBAM, its own
- 59:16CBAM, I believe that this is one step
- 59:19towards a CBAM that can be a sort of an
- 59:22opportunity to create more carbon
- 59:24pricing systems around the world and
- 59:26therefore the decarbonisation which is
- 59:29in the end the last goal. So my question
- 59:31is yeah yeah. Now the question is
- 59:33Gabrielle you mentioned MRV, how does
- 59:35this relate to
- 59:38let's say both countries when it comes
- 59:39to MRV coordination and and you know
- 59:43carbon accounting and standards and all
- 59:46that. Yeah.
- 59:47>> Can you pass the microphone to Annie?
- 59:49Thank you.
- 59:50>> Thank you. I perhaps I can I can
- 59:52supplement that.
- 59:55Standards are the basis of trade.
- 59:57They're the basis of trust
- 1:00:00and my organisation Responsible Steel
- 1:00:02has been working on standards for the
- 1:00:03last 10 years for steel.
- 1:00:06As
- 1:00:07policymakers try to support
- 1:00:10their steel industry to decarbonise
- 1:00:12they're making their own standards
- 1:00:15to to support their own policies.
- 1:00:18And that means we are facing a
- 1:00:20proliferation of standards around the
- 1:00:22world
- 1:00:23on particularly on the carbon intensity
- 1:00:25of steel.
- 1:00:27And I think you'll see this replicated
- 1:00:28in many many other sectors.
- 1:00:32As a private standard that is a
- 1:00:35multi-stakeholder standard Responsible
- 1:00:36Steel has been working with
- 1:00:38national standards and other private
- 1:00:40standards to try and bring alignment and
- 1:00:42interoperability.
- 1:00:44We've been working with the Chinese
- 1:00:47Iron and Steel Association and we've
- 1:00:49been working with the Brussels
- 1:00:50Brussels-based low emission steel
- 1:00:52standard. So we're developing
- 1:00:54interoperability mechanisms and next
- 1:00:56year we're undertaking what I think will
- 1:00:58be the world's first
- 1:00:59steel interoperability pilot
- 1:01:03in China
- 1:01:04and this will be kind of proving that
- 1:01:06this thing is possible. So I would I
- 1:01:08would love to hear from the panel where
- 1:01:10they think this can help
- 1:01:12bring um bring forward trade in net zero
- 1:01:16goods this as a as a as a blueprint um
- 1:01:19for the for the future. Thank you.
- 1:01:20>> you so much, Andy. We have two minutes
- 1:01:22and two four questions. So do we want to
- 1:01:25help with further the training of these
- 1:01:27students, uh the law side, um the CBAM,
- 1:01:32and interoperability, which we had not
- 1:01:34mentioned on the panel very
- 1:01:35surprisingly. Um
- 1:01:37Elif, can I get to start with you?
- 1:01:39>> Yeah, of course.
- 1:01:41Uh with regards to maybe I start with I
- 1:01:43mean I
- 1:01:44with regards to CBAM, uh
- 1:01:46we we have just recently adopted our
- 1:01:49emissions trading system. And uh in our
- 1:01:52climate law uh
- 1:01:54which has been adopted in July 2025
- 1:01:58um um we also aim to have a CBAM because
- 1:02:02it's CBAM is actually a natural result
- 1:02:06of an emissions trading system. So in
- 1:02:08our Green Deal action plan, actually we
- 1:02:10aim to start preparatory work
- 1:02:13uh
- 1:02:13for a possible CBAM that we want to
- 1:02:16adopt. And uh of course our primary
- 1:02:18objective would be uh to protect the
- 1:02:21competitiveness of our industry while
- 1:02:23ensuring climate uh mitigation goals.
- 1:02:26And in doing this, we would of course
- 1:02:28ensure the interoperability and uh
- 1:02:32we we aim not to disrupt trade and we
- 1:02:35are that's what we are we have been
- 1:02:36discussing uh with the EU currently.
- 1:02:39>> Thank you. And I know that Turkey is
- 1:02:41working very closely with the EU. Yeah.
- 1:02:43Um Gabriel, you want to come in on this
- 1:02:45quickly? Maybe your final word as well
- 1:02:47in 30 seconds.
- 1:02:48>> Yeah, 30 seconds. We're differently
- 1:02:50placed in Turkey. We don't have heavy
- 1:02:52industry. We don't have the same trading
- 1:02:54relationship that Turkey has with the
- 1:02:56EU. Um but we are looking at the
- 1:02:59downstream implications. We do export
- 1:03:01intermediate goods.
- 1:03:03Um and and we've only recently developed
- 1:03:05our our
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Harnessing Trade Cooperation to Deliver Green Industrialization and Climate Goals by UNFCCC Global Climate Action, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 8,380 words across 1,441 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.