YouTube2Text

'GREATER ISRAEL': Mehdi Unpacks Israel’s Goals in Iran and Lebanon — Transcript

by Zeteo · 7,697 words · 1,172 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:02Good morning, good afternoon, good
  2. 0:03evening friends. Hope you're doing well.
  3. 0:04Hope you had a lovely weekend. Welcome
  4. 0:06to another edition of your weekly Ask
  5. 0:08the Editor.
  6. 0:09Let's get another location check.
  7. 0:11Wherever you're listening from, we
  8. 0:12always love to hear it. We're always
  9. 0:14getting amazing answers. I think every
  10. 0:16week we've gotten more and more diverse
  11. 0:18locations. So, please in the chat,
  12. 0:19whether you're on Substack, YouTube, let
  13. 0:22us know where you're listening from.
  14. 0:24Maddy, how are you doing today?
  15. 0:26I'm good. I'm in Washington, D.C. where
  16. 0:27we're waiting for a tornado uh to hit us
  17. 0:30today at some point. So, if we lose
  18. 0:31power
  19. 0:33in the middle of this live, it's because
  20. 0:34of the tornado, not because of anything
  21. 0:36Zeteo did to the internet.
  22. 0:38I I'm curious, Maddy. I don't know if
  23. 0:40you've had this experience. I feel like
  24. 0:41I've heard from people, not that
  25. 0:43credible sources, but enough sources
  26. 0:45that like with the sort of dogification
  27. 0:48of the government, including NOAA, um
  28. 0:50the weather app feels way out of whack
  29. 0:53lately. Not to be like, you know, a
  30. 0:55weather conspiracy theorist, No, no,
  31. 0:57we're We're all We're all weather
  32. 0:58conspiracy theorists now. We're all
  33. 1:00conspiracy theorists now, and not just
  34. 1:02Epstein conspiracy theorists, we're
  35. 1:03weather conspiracy theorists. I think
  36. 1:04you're I think you've hit the nail on
  37. 1:05its head. I've been wondering why all
  38. 1:07the weather sites and the weather apps
  39. 1:08on the phone, Apple, Google, BBC, the
  40. 1:11rest, all of them And And look, there's
  41. 1:13there's a there's definitely been an
  42. 1:14assault on the data behind the scenes.
  43. 1:15You mentioned NOAA, the National Oceanic
  44. 1:18Atmospheric, whatever it stands for,
  45. 1:20administration, which handles a lot of
  46. 1:21this stuff. They are gutting all of the
  47. 1:23institutions that deal with climate and
  48. 1:24weather. They don't like facts. Even
  49. 1:26though they go on about facts not caring
  50. 1:27about your feelings, they put their
  51. 1:28feelings above facts.
  52. 1:31And I will note, this is not
  53. 1:32anti-weather person. I love all you
  54. 1:34weather men and women, and I'm sorry
  55. 1:35that your job is probably a little
  56. 1:36harder because of all this, too.
  57. 1:38We're already getting a bunch of
  58. 1:39locations in the chat. Thank everyone.
  59. 1:40We're getting Sweden, Mumbai,
  60. 1:42Mauritania, Abu Dhabi, West Sussex,
  61. 1:45Canada, Poland, Kentucky, Ohio, Vermont,
  62. 1:48Michigan, Argentina, Turkey, Kuala
  63. 1:50Lumpur, Philadelphia.
  64. 1:51>> Wow. This
  65. 1:53This warms my heart that Zeteo audience
  66. 1:55members Zeteo subscribers are all over
  67. 1:57the world. Uh thank you for watching. If
  68. 1:59you're just watching on YouTube, make
  69. 2:00sure you actually become a subscriber,
  70. 2:01not just to the YouTube channel, but to
  71. 2:03zeteo.com. Become a subscriber to our
  72. 2:05media outfit, support independent
  73. 2:07journalism. And for the person who's in
  74. 2:09Abu Dhabi, I never thought I'd say this,
  75. 2:11but I hope you're safe in a war zone
  76. 2:12now. I hope you're watching from a safe
  77. 2:13location.
  78. 2:15So, let's talk about it. Let's talk
  79. 2:16about it. Great transition.
  80. 2:18We are now beyond week two into this
  81. 2:20war. We're beyond the 12-day war mark um
  82. 2:22of of of wars past, so to speak.
  83. 2:26And Trump right now is somehow still
  84. 2:28pretending things are going okay. Um in
  85. 2:31fact, he's pretending that he's winning
  86. 2:32and that things are going exactly
  87. 2:34according to plan. What the plan is,
  88. 2:35we're not quite sure. Um
  89. 2:38despite that, Iran is holding strong. Um
  90. 2:41as we saw from Swin's reporting first
  91. 2:42draft this morning, despite Trump's
  92. 2:44calls for help for the Strait of Hormuz,
  93. 2:47allies are not responding and picking up
  94. 2:48that call. Medhi, what's going on?
  95. 2:51Yeah, it's a good question. I did an
  96. 2:52interview with the BBC today, which is
  97. 2:54airing later today, and and the host
  98. 2:55Evan Davis said, "Well, you know,
  99. 2:56Trump's a canny man. He knows when he's
  100. 2:58losing and he'll pull back like he did
  101. 3:00in Minneapolis." I'm not sure that's
  102. 3:01always the case. I have I'm I'm old
  103. 3:03enough to remember the pandemic where he
  104. 3:05just kept lying about we've beaten the
  105. 3:07virus, we've defeated it, the numbers
  106. 3:08are gone, it's disappeared, we'll open
  107. 3:10at Easter. He's doing the same kind of
  108. 3:12nonsensical rhetoric now with the war.
  109. 3:14We've beaten Iran, they're decimated,
  110. 3:15they're gone, the military's gone. This
  111. 3:18is the one time I think uh in in modern
  112. 3:20Trump history, if we can call it that,
  113. 3:22where the gaslighting and the bullying
  114. 3:25of people into accepting an alternative
  115. 3:26reality, the lying, um it's not working.
  116. 3:30It's clearly not working because the
  117. 3:31entire world is watching. And the entire
  118. 3:33world can see that Iran is firing
  119. 3:35rockets and drones and missiles. Iran is
  120. 3:37keeping the Strait of Hormuz closed. So,
  121. 3:39when Donald Trump says, as he said at
  122. 3:41the weekend, "I've destroyed 100% of
  123. 3:42Iran's military," that's an insane thing
  124. 3:44to say in general. We've all become numb
  125. 3:47to Trump's insane statements, but the
  126. 3:48rest of the world is saying, "What?" I
  127. 3:50mean, American credibility is at an
  128. 3:52all-time low, not just because
  129. 3:53militarily we haven't been able to
  130. 3:55defeat Iran within a few days as was the
  131. 3:57plan, but also because Trump is just
  132. 3:59flailing. He goes from telling the
  133. 4:01British, you know what, we don't need
  134. 4:03your help anymore. You're too late,
  135. 4:04we've already won, which is what he said
  136. 4:05to Keir Starmer last week. Now
  137. 4:07apparently they're reaching out to the
  138. 4:08Brits and all the Europeans saying, you
  139. 4:09must help us. He put out a post on Truth
  140. 4:12Social saying, we need international
  141. 4:13countries to step up and open up the
  142. 4:15Strait of Hormuz. Why would they step up
  143. 4:16when you've insulted them, you've
  144. 4:18bullied them, you've lied about them, to
  145. 4:20war without consulting with them.
  146. 4:22Suddenly Trump discovers that you need
  147. 4:24the rest of the world, that America
  148. 4:26alone is not enough when you're fighting
  149. 4:27in the Middle East, as his predecessors
  150. 4:29discovered in Afghanistan, in Iraq, and
  151. 4:31Libya. So, it's a disaster for America,
  152. 4:35it's a disaster for Trump, it's a
  153. 4:36disaster of course most of all for the
  154. 4:37region.
  155. 4:38But it is an insult to our intelligence
  156. 4:40to see these regular posts where he
  157. 4:41claims, I've won. And then he says also
  158. 4:44sociopathic things like he said
  159. 4:45yesterday, you know, I might bomb Kharg
  160. 4:47Island again just for fun. Again, I
  161. 4:50think George W. Bush is a man who should
  162. 4:52be at The Hague being prosecuted for war
  163. 4:54crimes in Iraq, but even George W. Bush
  164. 4:56didn't say stuff like that.
  165. 4:58Yeah. Yeah, before I move on, YouTubers,
  166. 5:00I see you guys already have a ton of
  167. 5:01questions. Subsackers, remember if you
  168. 5:03have any questions, thoughts, please put
  169. 5:05them in the chat. We'll get to them very
  170. 5:06shortly.
  171. 5:07As you're talking, Medhi, I think of how
  172. 5:09often, I mean, you're talking about
  173. 5:10modern Trump history, in the past 10-11
  174. 5:12years, there's always this moment where
  175. 5:14it's like, oh, golly, I wonder how
  176. 5:15Trump's going to wiggle out of this one.
  177. 5:17And of course, he always somehow does or
  178. 5:19we allow him to, etc., etc.
  179. 5:22Right now, what feels slightly different
  180. 5:24is that up to this point, of course, a
  181. 5:27lot of countries, a lot of allies and
  182. 5:28and non-allies have always been annoyed
  183. 5:30but frustrated by Trump and America
  184. 5:33generally, I know, even during the Biden
  185. 5:34administration, but they never did much.
  186. 5:37Right now, it seems like countries are
  187. 5:39actively, if not doing something, at
  188. 5:42least rejecting Trump's, you know,
  189. 5:44appeals for help.
  190. 5:46I wonder how you sort of think of this
  191. 5:49moment in sort of potentially shifting
  192. 5:52um European and Gulf countries calculus
  193. 5:54on on where they turn to for world
  194. 5:56powers because I think
  195. 5:58you know, I I I I I guess I ask this
  196. 6:00specifically because there's so many
  197. 6:02people in these countries who are kind
  198. 6:04of
  199. 6:05themselves like really frustrated or
  200. 6:07annoyed by America too or or at risk
  201. 6:09because they're in the Gulf countries. I
  202. 6:11think you have to unpack two different
  203. 6:12things, Prem. One is first of all, the
  204. 6:15democratic dysfunction, right? So in
  205. 6:16Western democracies, we know that
  206. 6:17governments are out of tune with their
  207. 6:19people. We know they've been out of tune
  208. 6:20with their people on Gaza and the
  209. 6:21genocide and arming Israel. Even in a
  210. 6:23country like Germany, the most
  211. 6:24pro-Israel country in the world, more
  212. 6:25than the US even some might say. Even in
  213. 6:27a country like Germany, German public
  214. 6:28opinion has turned against the genocide.
  215. 6:30Uh German uh public doesn't want blind
  216. 6:32support for Israel. And the German
  217. 6:34government doesn't reflect that. The
  218. 6:35German media class doesn't reflect that.
  219. 6:37Um and similarly uh in the UK uh with
  220. 6:41Iran, the British public doesn't want
  221. 6:42any British involvement in this war, but
  222. 6:44Starmer's agreed to support for
  223. 6:45defensive strikes. I don't know what a
  224. 6:46defensive strike is when you launch a
  225. 6:48war of aggression against another
  226. 6:49country. So there's been a democratic
  227. 6:51dysfunction for a while amongst the
  228. 6:52democracies. And then you get to the
  229. 6:54dictatorships. You get to the Gulf
  230. 6:55dictatorships, the Middle East
  231. 6:56dictatorships, where the public have
  232. 6:57been anti-Israel for a while. They don't
  233. 6:59see Iran as the big threat in the
  234. 7:00region. They see Israel as the big
  235. 7:02threat in the region. And the government
  236. 7:03again don't reflect that because they
  237. 7:05are not democratic at all. Um they don't
  238. 7:07even have to pretend to reflect public
  239. 7:09opinion. So uh that's one point. The
  240. 7:11second point is to distinguish between
  241. 7:13the short-term and the long-term. Right?
  242. 7:15In the short-term, I don't think you're
  243. 7:16going to see people saying there's any
  244. 7:17big change. But in the long-term, of
  245. 7:18course there's going to be change.
  246. 7:19Inevitably, there will be change. So
  247. 7:21take the UAE for example. There was a
  248. 7:23minister from the UAE did an interview.
  249. 7:24Can't remember with who over the
  250. 7:25weekend. I saw a clip.
  251. 7:27She was asked, you know, is this going
  252. 7:29to make you reevaluate your relationship
  253. 7:30with the US, with Israel, Abraham
  254. 7:31Accords? No, no, no. We're going to
  255. 7:33double down on our allies. Great. I'm
  256. 7:35sure they will in the short-term. Right
  257. 7:37now they're being used to host attacks
  258. 7:38on Iran as the Iranians keep pointing
  259. 7:40out. But in the long-term, are you
  260. 7:41telling me the Gulf countries are not
  261. 7:42taking any steps now to hedge against
  262. 7:45future wars? Are you telling me they're
  263. 7:46not reaching out to the Chinese and the
  264. 7:48Russians? They're not thinking through
  265. 7:49what their defense relationship looks
  266. 7:51like with the US were to Iran to attack
  267. 7:52them every year now for the rest of
  268. 7:54their lives? Of course they are. It
  269. 7:56would be insane for them not to be
  270. 7:57taking those steps. Also, you have to
  271. 7:58separate the different Gulf countries.
  272. 8:00Um the New York Times reported over the
  273. 8:01weekend that MBS, the Crown Prince of
  274. 8:03Saudi Arabia, has been speaking with
  275. 8:05Trump regularly and telling him to bomb
  276. 8:06Iran harder. Um
  277. 8:08Saudis publicly saying they've had no
  278. 8:10role in this war. They haven't
  279. 8:11encouraged the war. Um the Saudis and
  280. 8:13the Iranians had a rapprochement a few
  281. 8:14years ago, but here is reporting from
  282. 8:16the time suggesting the Saudi government
  283. 8:18is encouraging Trump to bomb like crazy.
  284. 8:20So, you have the Saudis and the Emirates
  285. 8:22who've always wanted to take Iran off
  286. 8:23the table. And the Qataris, the
  287. 8:25Bahrainis, uh definitely the Omanis have
  288. 8:29never taken that stance with Iran. So, I
  289. 8:31think different Gulf countries are
  290. 8:32probably enduring this war in different
  291. 8:33ways. When I speak to people in uh Qatar
  292. 8:35who I know from my Al Jazeera days, um
  293. 8:38they're remarkably uh as angry at Israel
  294. 8:41and America as they are at Iran for
  295. 8:42being bombed right now uh because they
  296. 8:44believe that America and Israel dragged
  297. 8:46them into this war. Um and then I would
  298. 8:48say, you know,
  299. 8:50the Chinese and the Russians are just
  300. 8:51watching. Even if these countries are
  301. 8:52not re-evaluating their relationships,
  302. 8:54they're going to make their moves. Uh
  303. 8:55and the Europeans, by the way, just to
  304. 8:57head back to the Europeans and the
  305. 8:57Canadians,
  306. 8:59they took such a strong stance on
  307. 9:00Greenland. They got so offended that
  308. 9:03Trump was going to take Greenland. But
  309. 9:04when he launches a war of aggression
  310. 9:05against Iran, oh, then they lose their
  311. 9:07tongues. Mark Carney comes out and says,
  312. 9:09"Oh, well, we support the war." Uh then
  313. 9:11he kind of has to do a U-turn on that.
  314. 9:12Says, "I'm not going to commit Canadian
  315. 9:13troops." This is Mark Carney who gave
  316. 9:15the big Davos speech. And then of course
  317. 9:17in Britain, have you seen some of these
  318. 9:18British ministers are asked, "Is it Is
  319. 9:20America in violation of international
  320. 9:21law?" Well, that's for the Americans to
  321. 9:23work out. We can't comment on
  322. 9:25international law. They were happy to
  323. 9:26comment on international law when it was
  324. 9:27the Russians violating international
  325. 9:29law.
  326. 9:31On the Gulf, I mean, I'm glad you're
  327. 9:33bringing up that we know we ought not
  328. 9:34treat them monolithically. I think one
  329. 9:36reason that it comes up to my mind is
  330. 9:38that
  331. 9:39in some respects, you know, of course
  332. 9:40they have their own motivations and and
  333. 9:42rationale, but there was this sort of
  334. 9:44agreement with the US that, you know, we
  335. 9:46would treat Israel with a relative
  336. 9:48offhand treatment um despite what our
  337. 9:51population might think. We'll host
  338. 9:53security bases and we will be safe. Our
  339. 9:56cities, our shining cities will be safe.
  340. 9:59And that has clearly been breached to
  341. 10:00the point that a lot of these Gulf
  342. 10:02countries could see that when it comes
  343. 10:05down to Israel or them, the US has a
  344. 10:08clear answer. And I guess that's why I
  345. 10:10wonder in the medium-term outlook. But I
  346. 10:13also want to get to another thing that
  347. 10:14you mentioned, which is the sort of
  348. 10:16defensive posturing that some of these
  349. 10:17countries justify um this war at.
  350. 10:20Lebanon, we need to talk about Lebanon.
  351. 10:23I mean
  352. 10:24Israel's massive escalation into into
  353. 10:28Lebanon, I mean reinvasion we should
  354. 10:30call it, has reached a new height. I
  355. 10:31mean just yesterday I think they they
  356. 10:33said as they were massively escalating,
  357. 10:35they said they were enhancing their
  358. 10:37defensive posture.
  359. 10:39What have you been making of Lebanon
  360. 10:41over the past few weeks, Maddy? I mean
  361. 10:43it's Orwellian the way Israel talks
  362. 10:44about Lebanon, but also the way of
  363. 10:45course the media talks about Lebanon. I
  364. 10:47don't know if you've seen some of the
  365. 10:48headlines from non-Zeteo sources, which
  366. 10:50is why I encourage people to sign up to
  367. 10:51Zeteo to get actual honest headlines.
  368. 10:53You see some of the headlines in The
  369. 10:54Times, from the BBC, from CNN. Israel
  370. 10:57moves into Lebanon. Israel's incursion
  371. 10:59into Lebanon. Israel pushes into
  372. 11:01Lebanon. No, as you say, Israel is
  373. 11:03invading and reinvading Lebanon. It's
  374. 11:04illegal what Israel is doing, violating
  375. 11:07uh Israeli Lebanese sovereignty. They've
  376. 11:09now said that they're going to go in all
  377. 11:11the way up to the Litani River. They're
  378. 11:12going to make Southern Lebanon theirs
  379. 11:14again. Remember they invaded and
  380. 11:16occupied Southern Lebanon from 1982 to
  381. 11:182000. Hezbollah was created, people
  382. 11:20forget, in response to the 1982 Israeli
  383. 11:23invasion of Southern Lebanon, which they
  384. 11:25held onto for 18 years in defiance of
  385. 11:27multiple UN resolutions. Um they want to
  386. 11:29do that again. There are people in
  387. 11:30Israel, if you watch television, you
  388. 11:32will see Israeli generals and pundits
  389. 11:34saying, let's take it, let's create I
  390. 11:36think one general uh one retired general
  391. 11:37said on Israeli TV on Friday or
  392. 11:39Saturday, uh I saw a clip,
  393. 11:41uh we'll turn it into a kill zone, kill
  394. 11:43anything that moves, depopulate the
  395. 11:45place. They've already deep They've
  396. 11:46already um uh left almost a million
  397. 11:48Lebanese homeless over the last couple
  398. 11:50of weeks, displaced them from their
  399. 11:51homes. Apparently, there's another half
  400. 11:53a million still in southern Lebanon who
  401. 11:54could be pushed out. There are about 150
  402. 11:56towns and villages that could be
  403. 11:57quote-unquote wiped off the map by the
  404. 11:59Israeli army. They're they're mobilizing
  405. 12:01a massive force, I think half a million
  406. 12:02reservists. And uh you know, people say,
  407. 12:05oh well, Lebanon, you know, that's
  408. 12:06that's about Hezbollah dragging Israel
  409. 12:09into the war. I should remind everyone,
  410. 12:11during the period of the ceasefire
  411. 12:13between Hezbollah between Lebanon and
  412. 12:14Israel that was signed at the end of
  413. 12:162024, Israel violated that ceasefire
  414. 12:1810,000 times via air, 1,500 times via
  415. 12:22land. So, there was no ceasefire on the
  416. 12:25Israeli side. It wasn't just Hezbollah
  417. 12:27that dragged Israel into the war. Israel
  418. 12:28never never, as usual, uh stuck to the
  419. 12:31ceasefire.
  420. 12:33Uh well, we have a lot of questions
  421. 12:35related to all this, actually, which is
  422. 12:37good. Thank you, everyone, for for
  423. 12:39commenting your questions. Sebastian
  424. 12:41Simon on Substack says that we need our
  425. 12:43daily meditation, and so let's get into
  426. 12:46your questions. Um first, AZ2049 from
  427. 12:50YouTube, uh thank you for your
  428. 12:51contribution, we appreciate it. They
  429. 12:53ask, could Trump be planning to avoid
  430. 12:55the midterm elections by putting the
  431. 12:56country under an emergency state if Iran
  432. 12:59attacks the US directly?
  433. 13:02Yeah, that's a good question. It's a
  434. 13:02scary question, but we shouldn't just
  435. 13:04dismiss it. This is a president who sat
  436. 13:06in the Oval Office next to Zelenskyy a
  437. 13:08few months ago. I clocked this, some
  438. 13:10others did, a lot of people missed it.
  439. 13:12And journalists asked Zelenskyy, why
  440. 13:13aren't you holding elections? And
  441. 13:14Zelenskyy said, how can I hold
  442. 13:16elections? We're under occupation, we're
  443. 13:17in a war. I can't hold elections while
  444. 13:19we're in the state of emergency. And
  445. 13:21Trump immediately caught that and
  446. 13:23immediately turned to the press and
  447. 13:24said, oh, you're saying that if you're
  448. 13:25in a war, you don't have to hold
  449. 13:27elections? And people chuckled and Trump
  450. 13:29chuckled, but classically with Trump,
  451. 13:31you never know if he's fully serious,
  452. 13:33half serious, serious at all. I take him
  453. 13:36seriously on such things. His brain,
  454. 13:37whatever is in there, was whirring
  455. 13:39clearly that this could be an excuse. We
  456. 13:41know he doesn't want to hold free and
  457. 13:43fair elections. We know in the past he's
  458. 13:45talked about delaying elections,
  459. 13:46postponing elections. I don't think the
  460. 13:48war as it currently stands would give
  461. 13:50him any grounds to do that, but God
  462. 13:51forbid there was any kind of terrorist
  463. 13:53attack in this country. God forbid there
  464. 13:55was a repeat of a 9/11 that they claimed
  465. 13:57was orchestrated by Iran. Then yes, I
  466. 13:59can see him pushing for that, of course.
  467. 14:01Anyone who thinks he wouldn't do that is
  468. 14:02crazy. They haven't been paying
  469. 14:03attention to Donald Trump. They haven't
  470. 14:04been paying attention to the Republican
  471. 14:06Party. People don't know this, but Rudy
  472. 14:07Giuliani in 2001 went to the authorities
  473. 14:11and said, I want to stay on as mayor.
  474. 14:13His term was up. He said, delay the
  475. 14:14elections, let me stay on longer because
  476. 14:16of 9/11. And that was overruled at the
  477. 14:18time. He wasn't able to do that legally.
  478. 14:20But the aspiration was there to use a
  479. 14:22terrorist attack to stay in office. And
  480. 14:24no, I wouldn't put it past us, Donald
  481. 14:25Trump, or Peter Hoekstra, or any of the
  482. 14:27people in this administration to
  483. 14:28use an attack on on quote-unquote the
  484. 14:30homeland to try and justify either
  485. 14:32delaying, postponing, or changing the
  486. 14:34midterm elections, which they're going
  487. 14:35to lose badly, and they know it.
  488. 14:38This next question from In Defense of
  489. 14:40the of the Genre 10:22. Thank you for
  490. 14:43your contribution as well. It's one that
  491. 14:44we've been grappling with for the past 2
  492. 14:46and 1/2 years and and far beyond, of
  493. 14:48course.
  494. 14:49And it's troubling because the Israeli
  495. 14:50government has only gotten more vicious
  496. 14:52in its behavior. But they ask, how can
  497. 14:54we educate people on the difference
  498. 14:56between the Israeli government and the
  499. 14:59people generally?
  500. 15:01Yeah, it's a it's a one of the thorniest
  501. 15:02questions of our time. We talk about
  502. 15:05Israel. It's a very emotive subject.
  503. 15:07There's an NBC poll out today which
  504. 15:08shows the American public have been
  505. 15:09turning on Israel as well, especially
  506. 15:11Democrats and independents. But what do
  507. 15:12we mean when we say Israel? Do we mean
  508. 15:14the country? Do we mean the government?
  509. 15:15Do we mean the people? And it's a very
  510. 15:17thorny discussion because number one,
  511. 15:20the Israeli government is a
  512. 15:21democratically elected government, so in
  513. 15:23a sense they're representing their
  514. 15:24people.
  515. 15:25Um, and of course the polling shows that
  516. 15:27the Israeli public is very much behind
  517. 15:29the Iran war, was very much behind the
  518. 15:31Gaza genocide. In fact, uh, is so
  519. 15:33hawkish that their polls show that
  520. 15:34majorities of Israeli Jews have said,
  521. 15:36"We don't need to worry about suffering
  522. 15:38in these places."
  523. 15:39When they're asked, "Do you think we're
  524. 15:40taking too many precautions?" The
  525. 15:42Israeli military, they say, "Nah, it's
  526. 15:43fine. It's good." That's what the
  527. 15:44polling shows from the Israel Democracy
  528. 15:46Institute that does polling of Israeli
  529. 15:48Jews and Israeli Palestinian citizens of
  530. 15:50Israel. So, it's a real problem in that
  531. 15:52sense. Uh, and of course,
  532. 15:54um, you know, when we talk about any
  533. 15:55country, are we talking about the people
  534. 15:56or the government? When people say, "I
  535. 15:58hate America." Do they mean Americans or
  536. 15:59do they mean the Bush administration,
  537. 16:00the Trump administration, the Biden
  538. 16:01administration? I think we need to be
  539. 16:03very, very clear about the fact, uh,
  540. 16:05that, uh,
  541. 16:06certainly Jewish people around the world
  542. 16:09cannot be held responsible for the
  543. 16:10Israeli government, right? That's
  544. 16:12fundamental. And I know most definitions
  545. 16:14of anti-Semitism make it very clear that
  546. 16:16you should not conflate Jewish people
  547. 16:18around the world with Israel. Now, a lot
  548. 16:20of Palestinians will point out that a
  549. 16:22lot of Jewish community organizations,
  550. 16:23synagogues, etc., choose to identify
  551. 16:25themselves with Israel and with Zionism.
  552. 16:27And that is a problem. I'm not I'm not
  553. 16:28disputing that. Uh, you know, there was
  554. 16:30a recent horrific attack on a synagogue
  555. 16:31in Michigan. Uh, thankfully no one was
  556. 16:33killed except the attacker, uh, a
  557. 16:35naturalized American citizen from
  558. 16:36Lebanon. The story reporting about his
  559. 16:38family having been killed in Lebanon.
  560. 16:39Was this a revenge attack, etc.? Was he
  561. 16:41mentally ill? The usual question. Um,
  562. 16:44and some people I saw online pointing
  563. 16:46out that, "Oh, well, this uh, Temple
  564. 16:48Israel in Michigan, uh, they have, you
  565. 16:50know, they have lots of pages on their
  566. 16:51website supporting Israel and hosting
  567. 16:53IDF soldiers." I'm not agreeing with
  568. 16:55that. I would prefer synagogues in
  569. 16:56America not to associate themselves with
  570. 16:58a government of a country that's been
  571. 17:00indicted at the ICC and being
  572. 17:02investigated at the ICJ. Having said
  573. 17:03that, there's no excuse for attacking a
  574. 17:06synagogue. There's no way you you you
  575. 17:07attack a house of worship, no matter
  576. 17:09what your politics are. So, I think you
  577. 17:10can walk and chew gum at the same time.
  578. 17:12I think you can say that Jews and Jewish
  579. 17:14institutions and Jewish places of
  580. 17:15worship are off-limits and should not be
  581. 17:17conflated with the government of Israel.
  582. 17:19At the same time, we can also
  583. 17:20acknowledge that some people in the
  584. 17:22Jewish community do happily conflate the
  585. 17:24two. Jonathan Greenblatt, head of the
  586. 17:26ADL, very recklessly and irresponsibly,
  587. 17:28in my view, conflates uh Jewish
  588. 17:30organizations, Jewish people with
  589. 17:31Zionism, with Israel. I think that's a
  590. 17:33mistake. It's dangerous. It only
  591. 17:34emboldens the anti-Semites. But doesn't
  592. 17:36mean the rest of us have to fall into
  593. 17:37that trap.
  594. 17:39I think this does lead into this broader
  595. 17:41conversation about blowback and about
  596. 17:44what happens when symbols become
  597. 17:46attached to war. And I think this leads
  598. 17:48to a a good transition to Tins Illysian
  599. 17:50YouTube, who, you know, we've talked a
  600. 17:52lot, you and I, Matty, about the hubris
  601. 17:54of America's behavior, of its of its war
  602. 17:56prosecuting. Tins Illysian asks, "How do
  603. 17:58we get countries whose living population
  604. 17:59hasn't felt war on their shores, like
  605. 18:02the US and the UK, to understand the
  606. 18:05on-the-ground realities of this war?"
  607. 18:09It's a great question. We live very far
  608. 18:10away, right? We're sitting in
  609. 18:11comfortable studios thousands of miles
  610. 18:13away. Obviously, the UK endured World
  611. 18:15War II, endured the Blitz, but most of
  612. 18:17that generation is now gone. Uh the US
  613. 18:19doesn't even have that. The US has
  614. 18:20always been blessed with these two
  615. 18:22oceans uh that protect it from any kind
  616. 18:24of foreign occupation or direct aerial
  617. 18:26bombardment. Obviously, there was Pearl
  618. 18:27Harbor, but that even that wasn't on the
  619. 18:29US mainland. Uh and I think Look, yeah,
  620. 18:32Americans haven't experienced war for a
  621. 18:33long time. But look, let me just say
  622. 18:35this.
  623. 18:36It's remarkable that an American public
  624. 18:38that got behind the war on terror, the
  625. 18:40war on Iraq, the war against Libya, that
  626. 18:42has been pretty gung-ho and hawkish for
  627. 18:44every previous American war, have been
  628. 18:46very easy to kind of manipulate and get
  629. 18:47into line by a by a kind of gung-ho
  630. 18:49media, nationalistic, uh belligerent, uh
  631. 18:52patri- over-patriotic media,
  632. 18:54um jingoistic media. This time round
  633. 18:57isn't falling for it. I think the
  634. 18:58American public may have finally learned
  635. 18:59the lessons of all the endless wars, uh
  636. 19:02and seeing the body bags coming back in
  637. 19:03previous wars. We have 13 American
  638. 19:05service members, I believe, killed so
  639. 19:06far. Um and that number's only going to
  640. 19:09go up, sadly, and Trump knows it. And
  641. 19:11the American public, if you ask me in
  642. 19:13the most remarkable part of this war, it
  643. 19:15is American public opinion. I would have
  644. 19:17thought by now, the cynic in me would
  645. 19:19have thought by now, the American public
  646. 19:21would have got behind this war because
  647. 19:22American public always gets behind
  648. 19:23American wars. As soon as troops are
  649. 19:24deployed, as soon as the Americans are
  650. 19:26in combat, the American public, even if
  651. 19:27they're skeptical of the wars as they
  652. 19:28were about Iraq, get behind the war.
  653. 19:31They haven't. We're now over 2 weeks
  654. 19:32into this war, and a majority of
  655. 19:34Americans are still very much against
  656. 19:35this war. We did a poll last week, as
  657. 19:36you know, Prem, with Drop Site, and that
  658. 19:39poll came back showing a you know, the
  659. 19:40American public was split on whether
  660. 19:42Trump is even fighting this war for
  661. 19:43America or for Israel. Majority of
  662. 19:45Americans thought that he was doing it
  663. 19:46partly to distract from the Epstein
  664. 19:47files. So, I think the American public
  665. 19:49are pretty savvy right now on this
  666. 19:50issue.
  667. 19:52The public and the media do seem to be a
  668. 19:54lot more skeptical and cautious from
  669. 19:56years past. I got a message by Arman
  670. 19:595095. Thank you for your contribution as
  671. 20:01well.
  672. 20:02Given that reality, Medhi, they ask, "Do
  673. 20:04you think Trump is completely trapped in
  674. 20:07this conflict of his own creation and
  675. 20:09Israel's?"
  676. 20:11Yeah, it's a good word, trapped. Uh, if
  677. 20:12you look at Robert Pape, who I hope to
  678. 20:14interview soon, University of Chicago,
  679. 20:16uh, scholar of wars, historian of air
  680. 20:18wars in particular. Uh, he's been doing
  681. 20:20the rounds and talking about, uh, the
  682. 20:22escalation trap, talking about the fact
  683. 20:24that you can get trapped in wars in a
  684. 20:27ways that you don't realize. You go in
  685. 20:29thinking it's a in and out, one day, two
  686. 20:31day thing, and then the enemy responds
  687. 20:33in a way that you hadn't planned for,
  688. 20:35which is clearly the case this time
  689. 20:36round, and then rather than backing
  690. 20:37down, you escalate, you double down, and
  691. 20:39the enemy doubles down. And before you
  692. 20:41know it, you're in the quagmire. You're
  693. 20:43in the, uh, never-ending war. You're in
  694. 20:45Afghanistan, America's longest war,
  695. 20:46which didn't begin as the longest war. I
  696. 20:49think the the trapping is very, very,
  697. 20:51uh, good point. I think Trump is trapped
  698. 20:52right now. He could just declare victory
  699. 20:54like George Bush and, you know, say, "I
  700. 20:55won. I I killed Soleimani, and I
  701. 20:58degraded their weapon." And he he he'd
  702. 20:59get away with it with his base, at
  703. 21:00least. He could do that. He isn't.
  704. 21:02Partly because I think he knows that
  705. 21:04whatever he does now, the Israelis are
  706. 21:05not stopping. The Israelis have made it
  707. 21:06clear, they're going to at least end of
  708. 21:08April. They've got thousands more
  709. 21:09targets, civilian targets they want to
  710. 21:11hit. Many more Iranians they're going to
  711. 21:13kill. And you know, this has always been
  712. 21:14a case since the beginning of this war
  713. 21:16that we haven't been doing this
  714. 21:17independently. We've been doing it with
  715. 21:18the Israelis who have been leading the
  716. 21:20way. There was reporting at the weekend
  717. 21:21in one of the papers that they asked
  718. 21:23Netanyahu, you know, don't bomb these
  719. 21:25oil depots and Netanyahu did it anyway.
  720. 21:26So, in that sense, he's not just trapped
  721. 21:28in a war that the Iranians now have a
  722. 21:31say over when it ends. He's trapped in a
  723. 21:33war that the Israelis clearly are doing
  724. 21:34what they want to and not paying
  725. 21:36attention to any American requests.
  726. 21:38To that end, SurfCity_Sylon,
  727. 21:41thank you for your contribution and your
  728. 21:42question. They ask, what is a good name?
  729. 21:45What is Netanyahu's end goal? He's old
  730. 21:48and globally unpopular. What does he see
  731. 21:51happening to Israel in 1, 5, or 10
  732. 21:54years?
  733. 21:55I don't think he cares about global
  734. 21:57popularity. I think as long as he knows
  735. 21:58he has the American government on board,
  736. 22:00he's fine, he's safe, he's safe from ICC
  737. 22:02arrest warrants. All these European
  738. 22:04countries that were supposed to get full
  739. 22:05status warrants have not done that. He's
  740. 22:06flown over European airspace, no one has
  741. 22:08stopped him from doing that.
  742. 22:09As long as he has the American
  743. 22:10government in his corner, he's fine.
  744. 22:13He is in his I think he's in his 70s
  745. 22:14now, although he never ages. There's
  746. 22:16been lots of rumors that he was dead on
  747. 22:18the internet. He put out a kind of jokey
  748. 22:19video
  749. 22:21getting coffee saying, "Oh look, I've
  750. 22:22got six fingers."
  751. 22:24Although I saw somebody put up an AI
  752. 22:25video of Mojtaba Khamenei getting coffee
  753. 22:27just to prove that you could do anything
  754. 22:28with AI. I think his goal is greater
  755. 22:32Israel. I think we haven't talked about
  756. 22:33this enough. We need to talk much more
  757. 22:35about this. He did an interview a few
  758. 22:36months ago with an Israeli paper where
  759. 22:37he said he endorsed a greater Israel
  760. 22:39vision. It's not something just Smotrich
  761. 22:41or Ben-Gvir or the religious right in
  762. 22:42Israel believe in. It's something
  763. 22:43Benjamin Netanyahu believes in. This is
  764. 22:45what he thinks his legacy will be,
  765. 22:46giving Israel new and further and secure
  766. 22:48borders
  767. 22:49in places like Lebanon, in places like
  768. 22:51Syria, in places like
  769. 22:54you know, this is a guy Think about
  770. 22:56where Israel's borders are right now.
  771. 22:57Israel is a much bigger country right
  772. 22:59now on Netanyahu's watch. They have much
  773. 23:00more of Syria than they have before.
  774. 23:02They want to go right up to the Litani
  775. 23:04River. The education minister Kish said
  776. 23:06last week, it's going to be our new
  777. 23:07yellow line. You know, the yellow line
  778. 23:09in Gaza that the ceasefire gave them
  779. 23:11that allows them just to keep 20% of
  780. 23:12Gaza. They're going to do the same thing
  781. 23:14in in Lebanon. So, at the end of this,
  782. 23:16if there is an end, they're going to
  783. 23:17have much more territory in Lebanon, in
  784. 23:19Syria, in Gaza, obviously in the West
  785. 23:21Bank, which they are de facto annexing.
  786. 23:23And that is what he thinks his legacy
  787. 23:24will be. He's already Israel's
  788. 23:25longest-serving prime minister. He's
  789. 23:26also trying to dodge jail. Let's not
  790. 23:28forget. Like, his number one goal is to
  791. 23:29stay and avoid prosecution.
  792. 23:33The greater Israel thing is so
  793. 23:35frustrating to me because it feels like
  794. 23:37maybe 2023 when people were just
  795. 23:38starting to cover Project 2024. I was
  796. 23:40like, "Ah, you know, that's not going to
  797. 23:42happen." Or who knows where that came
  798. 23:43from.
  799. 23:44>> 2029, you mean. But yes.
  800. 23:45Or right. But no, but like how the media
  801. 23:48covered Project 2024 initially, which
  802. 23:50was like, "Oh, that's just a few
  803. 23:51>> it Project 2024, but Oh, right. Well, of
  804. 23:53course. Of course. Right, exactly. And
  805. 23:55it's like, "Oh, that was just, you know,
  806. 23:56a few
  807. 23:57hard-right members."
  808. 23:59Uh yeah. But it's like, "No, no, no.
  809. 24:01This is the genesis is very clear of
  810. 24:03where this is coming from, where this is
  811. 24:04going." I I don't know what you think
  812. 24:06about how the media has been covering
  813. 24:07greater Israel up to this point as just
  814. 24:09like a
  815. 24:10>> First of all, theory or First of all,
  816. 24:12apologies for the Ramadan brain. We're
  817. 24:14all getting our dates and names wrong
  818. 24:15today.
  819. 24:16Um
  820. 24:17Project 2025, you're right, is a very
  821. 24:18good analogy. When Project 2025 was
  822. 24:20being discussed, people dismissed it as,
  823. 24:22"Ah, this is just kind of in the
  824. 24:23extremes. It's not mainstream Trumpism.
  825. 24:25Trump hasn't even read it. This is kind
  826. 24:27of, you know, what the what the
  827. 24:28ideologues want, not what they're
  828. 24:29actually going to do." And then they've
  829. 24:30done a lot of Project 2025. Um yeah,
  830. 24:32same thing with greater Israel. I mean,
  831. 24:34there's a bigger issue with greater
  832. 24:35Israel, which is that most people don't
  833. 24:36even know it exists. Yeah.
  834. 24:37>> even heard of the phrase because the
  835. 24:38American media is so bad at covering the
  836. 24:40Middle East. And most people don't even
  837. 24:41talk about it. And when they do, yes,
  838. 24:43they do this dismissive, "It's just
  839. 24:44fringe characters. It's Smotrich. It's
  840. 24:46Ben-Gvir. It's not mainstream Israeli
  841. 24:48policy." And obviously supporters of
  842. 24:50Israel in this country, the AIPACs, the
  843. 24:51ADLs, they'll never allow people to
  844. 24:53believe that this is the project. But
  845. 24:54it's always been in project. I mean, I
  846. 24:56was doing some I was doing some
  847. 24:58reading and researching on Lebanon. And
  848. 25:00if you go back a hundred years, David
  849. 25:02Ben-Gurion,
  850. 25:03well before the creation of Israel, was
  851. 25:05talking about how the Litani River
  852. 25:06should be the northern border of Israel.
  853. 25:09That was
  854. 25:1020-30 years before the creation of
  855. 25:11Israel. Even after the creation of
  856. 25:13Israel, Moshe Sharett, who was Israeli
  857. 25:15Prime Minister in the early 50s, was
  858. 25:16recording messages from his general
  859. 25:18saying this is what we got to keep we
  860. 25:19got to keep up southern Lebanon. So,
  861. 25:21this idea that they haven't always
  862. 25:22planned to take more territory in the
  863. 25:23region is absurd. It's it's out there.
  864. 25:25It's in black and white. And of course,
  865. 25:26we have an American official, Mike
  866. 25:28Huckabee, who I can never decide is he
  867. 25:30US ambassador to Israel or Israel's
  868. 25:31ambassador to the US. He made it very
  869. 25:33clear in the Tucker Carlson interview
  870. 25:34recently that he's fine with it. Yeah,
  871. 25:35the Bible allows them to take what they
  872. 25:37want.
  873. 25:40Well, on Netanyahu's long-term goals and
  874. 25:42avoidance, there's of course back to
  875. 25:44Trump and how he made see to avoid
  876. 25:46consequences. Al Durst and thank you for
  877. 25:48your contribution. They she asks, Trump
  878. 25:50may cancel midterms. Could corporate
  879. 25:53Democrats in office help him to prevent
  880. 25:55being wiped by using Iran war as an
  881. 25:57excuse? Of course, we've seen how some
  882. 25:58corporate moderate Democrats have been
  883. 26:00twiddling their thumbs kind of
  884. 26:02you know, riding the fence on Iran. Some
  885. 26:05of them actually are very happy with
  886. 26:06what's going on. What do you make of
  887. 26:07that? So, interestingly, this is the
  888. 26:10power of pressure. People think public
  889. 26:11pressure doesn't work, it does work. A
  890. 26:13lot of Democrats who clearly wanted to
  891. 26:14back Trump's war and backed to the
  892. 26:1612-day war last year, they were actually
  893. 26:18pressured into shifting their position.
  894. 26:19Look at Jared Moskowitz from Florida,
  895. 26:22who's got a primary challenger who's
  896. 26:23anti-war. He's very pro-Israel moderate
  897. 26:26Democrat and he was going to vote
  898. 26:28against the war powers resolution,
  899. 26:29switched his vote at the last minute. I
  900. 26:31think because of public pressure,
  901. 26:32because of pressure from the base,
  902. 26:33pressure from the media. A lot of
  903. 26:35Democrats who privately I'm sure are
  904. 26:37backing Netanyahu and Trump's war, are
  905. 26:39publicly not saying it because they know
  906. 26:40where the base is. They've looked at the
  907. 26:41polling. So, that's good. That's good
  908. 26:43news. I mean, we can't change what they
  909. 26:44feel in their hearts, but as long as
  910. 26:46publicly they're not coming out for this
  911. 26:48war, good. There is one guy, of Of
  912. 26:50one guy in the Senate who is very
  913. 26:53proudly gungho pro this war.
  914. 26:56America's worst senator, a man who's
  915. 26:58trying to match Kirsten Cinema and
  916. 27:01Joe Manchin for the title of worst
  917. 27:03Democratic senator of my lifetime, which
  918. 27:04is John Fetterman of Pennsylvania, who
  919. 27:06now basically lives on Fox and just does
  920. 27:09interviews about how much he loves the
  921. 27:10war. He wants to kill everyone in Iran,
  922. 27:12every leader, kill them all, bomb them
  923. 27:13all.
  924. 27:14Doesn't care about international law,
  925. 27:15doesn't care about war crimes. John
  926. 27:18Fetterman is the worst, but clearly
  927. 27:20others who share Fetterman's views, but
  928. 27:21aren't as crass, crude, or as dumb as
  929. 27:23him to say it out loud. Fetterman
  930. 27:25doesn't have to worry about election for
  931. 27:26another what, 3 years? This is a problem
  932. 27:27with 6-year Senate terms, insulates them
  933. 27:29from public opinion. If there was
  934. 27:31election tomorrow in Pennsylvania, he
  935. 27:33would lose, obviously.
  936. 27:35So, it's a problem. Democrats may give
  937. 27:37Trump a wrath. They may vote for funding
  938. 27:39for this war. I interviewed Ben Rhodes
  939. 27:41last week. If you haven't watched it,
  940. 27:42please go to the Zeteo.com, check out
  941. 27:44the interview with Ben Rhodes, former
  942. 27:45Deputy National Security Advisor under
  943. 27:46Obama. He said primary, any Democrat who
  944. 27:49funds this war. That's Ben Rhodes, not
  945. 27:50some crazy far lefty former
  946. 27:52administration official saying, "You
  947. 27:53cannot be in this party and fund this
  948. 27:55war." And he included Chuck Schumer in
  949. 27:57that. So, I do think Democrats are in
  950. 27:59some ways getting their act together,
  951. 28:00but you know what Democrats can do, they
  952. 28:02can always let the side down at any
  953. 28:03time.
  954. 28:05We do have I will say I I I agree that
  955. 28:07definitely the the corporate pro pro-war
  956. 28:09Democrats have been at least
  957. 28:10rhetorically shifted in in their
  958. 28:12positions and in some of their votes
  959. 28:13recently. You have Republicans kind of
  960. 28:15consistent or constantly shifting their
  961. 28:17responses to our questions about if
  962. 28:19we're at war at all. There's one person
  963. 28:21though who we haven't been hearing from
  964. 28:22a lot lately, Chrissy C F S {dash} M E
  965. 28:26{question mark}. Thank you for your
  966. 28:27question.
  967. 28:28Do you think of J.D. Vance would be
  968. 28:30better or worse to manage the mess we
  969. 28:33are in right now? Oh, oh, worse. I
  970. 28:36People who think J.D. Vance is going to
  971. 28:38be some kind of
  972. 28:39I am a very anti-Trump person, one of
  973. 28:41the most anti-Trump people in this
  974. 28:42country. But the idea that if Donald
  975. 28:44Trump disappeared tomorrow, things would
  976. 28:45be better off cuz J.D. Vance is vice The
  977. 28:47only good thing about J.D. Vance, Prem,
  978. 28:49is that I believe, and I may be proven
  979. 28:51wrong in 2028. I'm not good at
  980. 28:52predictions anymore. But I believe he's
  981. 28:54eminently beatable at the ballot box,
  982. 28:56right? As an election candidate, I
  983. 28:58believe he's a much weaker proposition
  984. 29:00than Donald Trump. He does not have
  985. 29:01Trump's charisma. He does not have
  986. 29:02Trump's humor. He doesn't have Trump's
  987. 29:05the the loyalty that Trump commands from
  988. 29:06the base. He doesn't have it, right? Um
  989. 29:09so, he's much easier to beat if he ends
  990. 29:12up being the '28 candidate, which I'm
  991. 29:13not sure he will be. Um that's one
  992. 29:15thing. Number two,
  993. 29:17as a president, he could be worse than
  994. 29:19Trump because he's got all the kind of
  995. 29:22evilness of Trump, all the kind of
  996. 29:24awfulness of Trump, and
  997. 29:25authoritarianism, but less of the
  998. 29:27incompetency, less of the craziness,
  999. 29:29less of the loose-lippedness. He would
  1000. 29:30be a more efficient fascist than Donald
  1001. 29:33Trump. Of course, he's a product. He's a
  1002. 29:35he's a kind of creature of the big tech
  1003. 29:37oligarchs, of Peter Thiel and Elon Musk
  1004. 29:39and all of those guys who would love to
  1005. 29:41have J.D. Vance as president doing their
  1006. 29:43bidding. So, in many ways, Vance will be
  1007. 29:45worse. On the specific issue of the war,
  1008. 29:47point number three, is he anti-war? I
  1009. 29:49mean, does he believe in anything? He
  1010. 29:51ran as a very anti-war Republican. He
  1011. 29:54was very, very opposed to doing anything
  1012. 29:56about Iran on the campaign trail. There
  1013. 29:58are even more clips of J.D. Vance than
  1014. 29:59there are of Donald Trump saying we
  1015. 30:00shouldn't go to war in the Middle East,
  1016. 30:02we shouldn't go to war in Iran, it's a
  1017. 30:03waste of money and time. He did a bunch
  1018. 30:05of podcasts saying that, won over a lot
  1019. 30:07of people, the Rogans, the Theo Vons,
  1020. 30:09with this BS, and they're all now got
  1021. 30:10buyer's remorse, haven't they?
  1022. 30:12Conveniently too late. Um but then at
  1023. 30:15the beginning of this war, he they
  1024. 30:17leaked his people leaked that Vance was
  1025. 30:19saying we should go big. Uh now they're
  1026. 30:21leaking. Politico was reporting, I think
  1027. 30:23on Friday or Saturday, that Vance's
  1028. 30:25people are saying, "Oh, he's very
  1029. 30:26skeptical of this war. That's why he's
  1030. 30:27quiet right now." Come on. Come on. If
  1031. 30:30you're skeptical of the war, resign. You
  1032. 30:32know what people used to do in the old
  1033. 30:32days? When they really objected to a
  1034. 30:34government policy in Britain or America
  1035. 30:36or wherever it was, they quit. They
  1036. 30:38resigned on principle. No one does that
  1037. 30:39anymore cuz we have people who have no
  1038. 30:41principles in office. But he could
  1039. 30:42always quit, or he could come out and
  1040. 30:44say, "You know what? I'm uneasy about
  1041. 30:45this."
  1042. 30:46It's I think he's just
  1043. 30:47positioning himself for 2028. He wants
  1044. 30:50to be able to be clear of the wreckage
  1045. 30:51if this thing is a disaster, which it
  1046. 30:53looks like it is. If the rival is Marco
  1047. 30:55Rubio, you know, in recent days we've
  1048. 30:56talked about Marco Rubio being the
  1049. 30:57favorite. Donald Trump's been asking
  1050. 30:59people, "Who should I pick? Rubio or
  1051. 31:01Vance as my heir?" Rubio's also the is
  1052. 31:03obviously the face of this war. He's the
  1053. 31:05Secretary of State. He was very pro it.
  1054. 31:07He's the face of the Venezuela
  1055. 31:08intervention as well, and maybe the next
  1056. 31:10war in Cuba. So, Vance thinks that you
  1057. 31:12know, there's going to be a bigger
  1058. 31:13anti-war movement on the on the right,
  1059. 31:15and you know, he's allied with people
  1060. 31:17like Tucker Carlson and others. Then it
  1061. 31:19makes sense for him to go quiet right
  1062. 31:20now. It's hilarious that he's gone
  1063. 31:22quiet. What a coward. This is the guy
  1064. 31:23who used to troll all of us journalists,
  1065. 31:25myself included, every day. And he's
  1066. 31:27gone quiet. I don't think he's going to
  1067. 31:28recover from this, by the way, cuz when
  1068. 31:29he eventually returns to social media,
  1069. 31:31no one's going to let him forget this.
  1070. 31:33Um but, you know, he's gone into hiding
  1071. 31:34because he wants some kind of
  1072. 31:35deniability. I'm not sure he gets it.
  1073. 31:37Because think about it, Prem, if this
  1074. 31:39war is a disaster, it won't be enough
  1075. 31:40for him just to say, "Well, you know,
  1076. 31:42you you didn't see me pushing it." He'll
  1077. 31:43also have to condemn Trump. Is any 2028
  1078. 31:46GOP presidential contender going to be
  1079. 31:48able to condemn Trump? And that's all
  1080. 31:50assuming that Trump steps aside in 2028,
  1081. 31:53which is a big if.
  1082. 31:55It's all very cynical, and that last
  1083. 31:57part is very bleak. I think a final
  1084. 31:58question here that that hopefully can
  1085. 32:00give us something. Justin_64
  1086. 32:02from YouTube, how do you deal with
  1087. 32:04nihilistic people who give up and think
  1088. 32:06they have no power in changing politics?
  1089. 32:08>> Oh, great question. Um
  1090. 32:11you don't give up because they're not
  1091. 32:13just nihilistic, they're fascists. That
  1092. 32:15argument, the
  1093. 32:17the entire con of authoritarianism is
  1094. 32:20that you are powerless, that your
  1095. 32:23indifference and apathy is all that
  1096. 32:25matters and is all that's going to is
  1097. 32:27it's going to be exploited, right? The
  1098. 32:29The fascist, the authoritarian,
  1099. 32:30celebrates our passivity, our
  1100. 32:32indifference, our complacency, and our
  1101. 32:36our our lack of engagement. And we
  1102. 32:39shouldn't give them that victory.
  1103. 32:41Authoritarianism thrives on people
  1104. 32:43believing that they are powerless when
  1105. 32:45they are not. We are not powerless. We
  1106. 32:47do have power. Our choices matter. Our
  1107. 32:49voices matter. Our presence matter. Our
  1108. 32:51engagement matters. Our lobbying
  1109. 32:53matters. Our campaigning matters. Our
  1110. 32:54organizing matters. Everything we do
  1111. 32:57matters in this moment. The people who
  1112. 32:58say it doesn't matter are the people who
  1113. 33:01want you to stay at home. They want you
  1114. 33:02to log off. They want you not to pay
  1115. 33:04attention because that is how the
  1116. 33:05fascist win. That is how the great word
  1117. 33:08nihilist win. They don't want you to
  1118. 33:10pick right over left, Republicans over
  1119. 33:11Democrats. They want you to believe
  1120. 33:13plague on all their houses. I want
  1121. 33:15nothing to do with politics. Meanwhile,
  1122. 33:16they got democratic politics.
  1123. 33:20And I'll just add I think a big way to
  1124. 33:22combat this nihilism is of course with
  1125. 33:24communities like these. And I will want
  1126. 33:27to add that we recently, this weekend,
  1127. 33:29just launched a new WhatsApp chat for
  1128. 33:31Zeteo where we can all be part of a
  1129. 33:33community. I know sometimes, you know,
  1130. 33:35you guys get too many emails, too many
  1131. 33:36things in your inbox. Our WhatsApp chat
  1132. 33:38is another way for you guys to get all
  1133. 33:40of our stories that we're going to keep
  1134. 33:41working on on all the questions you guys
  1135. 33:44asked today and so much more.
  1136. 33:45>> Good reminder.
  1137. 33:46>> Yes, so you can find the WhatsApp chat
  1138. 33:47on our website. It was also sent out via
  1139. 33:49email as well. And if you didn't get
  1140. 33:51that email, then that means maybe you
  1141. 33:52should be subscribing to Zeteo. So
  1142. 33:54please Zeteo.com to subscribe.
  1143. 33:57>> and if you do become a paid subscriber,
  1144. 33:58you get discounts to the merch that Prem
  1145. 34:00and I are so wonderfully modeling each
  1146. 34:01week on Ask the Editor. Go to
  1147. 34:03shop.zeteo.com. If you're paid
  1148. 34:05subscriber, you get a big discount on
  1149. 34:06all of our merch, hoodies, mugs, water
  1150. 34:09bottles, baseball caps, beanies. We've
  1151. 34:11got it all.
  1152. 34:13And you also get discounts to special
  1153. 34:14events such as one that's happening
  1154. 34:16soon, right, Matti? Yes, New York, April
  1155. 34:199th. Mark your calendars if you're on
  1156. 34:20the East Coast. I'll be sitting down
  1157. 34:21with Riz Ahmed, my former schoolmate,
  1158. 34:24Oscar winner, Emmy winner. He's got a
  1159. 34:26new movie out, Hamlet. He's got a new TV
  1160. 34:28show out, Bait. We'll also to politics.
  1161. 34:30We'll talk culture. We'll talk
  1162. 34:32representation, we'll take your
  1163. 34:33questions from the audience. It's in New
  1164. 34:35York, April 9th. Uh head to our website
  1165. 34:37to get tickets or check your email.
  1166. 34:39There's some discounted codes in there.
  1167. 34:41Thank you everyone for being here. I'm
  1168. 34:42sorry we couldn't get all your
  1169. 34:43questions. There were so many today.
  1170. 34:45We'll get to them next time. Thank you
  1171. 34:46so much. Take care. See you guys soon.
  1172. 34:49Bye-bye.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of 'GREATER ISRAEL': Mehdi Unpacks Israel’s Goals in Iran and Lebanon by Zeteo, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,697 words across 1,172 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.