YouTube2Text

GPT-6 ASTRA vs CLAUDE FABLE 5.1 (INSANE CHESS MATCH) — Transcript

by GothamChess · 4,770 words · 750 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:01Ladies and gentlemen,
  2. 0:03whether you have been watching my
  3. 0:04content for years now or have only
  4. 0:07recently gotten into it,
  5. 0:09you should know
  6. 0:10or you should remember
  7. 0:12that there was a time when I would pair
  8. 0:14the most popular LLMs in the world
  9. 0:18against each other in chess.
  10. 0:20And the results were hilarious because
  11. 0:22they sucked.
  12. 0:24Uh they played tons of illegal moves,
  13. 0:26which I allowed for the most part. Uh
  14. 0:29then they uh got into arguments with
  15. 0:31each other other and with me.
  16. 0:34All of that is gone now.
  17. 0:37Now,
  18. 0:39we have very capable
  19. 0:41AIs. And in this video,
  20. 0:45I will be sharing with you a game
  21. 0:47between GPT-6 Astra and Claude Fable.
  22. 0:51Now, I actually had a thumbnail ready
  23. 0:52for this video weeks ago, and then
  24. 0:54Claude Opus came out, the the newest
  25. 0:56one, or whatever. I I don't know.
  26. 0:59So, I will pair them as well. But, uh
  27. 1:01this game took over 2 hours.
  28. 1:04There was uh
  29. 1:05one illegal move, I think, in like 70
  30. 1:08moves, which was incredibly impressive.
  31. 1:11It was just a really high-quality game
  32. 1:12of chess.
  33. 1:13So, sit back, relax, enjoy yourselves.
  34. 1:15Uh some of you were I made a video on
  35. 1:18GPT-6 Astra already.
  36. 1:20Uh and some of you were commenting on
  37. 1:22that video and saying that it's just
  38. 1:24talking to Stockfish.
  39. 1:25No. Neither one of them are using uh an
  40. 1:29engine.
  41. 1:30Uh I asked.
  42. 1:32I mean, they could lie to me, I guess.
  43. 1:34Uh they they claim they are doing the
  44. 1:36reasoning themselves. Now, I don't know
  45. 1:38how to dig deeper into that, but So,
  46. 1:39first things first,
  47. 1:41Claude Fable with the white pieces is
  48. 1:42only one game, cuz this game took so
  49. 1:44long. Uh if you are enjoying this
  50. 1:47content, I can make more of it. Uh I I
  51. 1:49will make more of it. Uh just let me
  52. 1:50know in the comments. So,
  53. 1:52Claude Fable opens the game with E4,
  54. 1:54okay? Uh and GPT-6 responds with pawn to
  55. 1:57c5, the Sicilian defense. When you allow
  56. 1:59the LLMs uh to just play on their own,
  57. 2:02the first 10 or so moves
  58. 2:04will be well-known opening theory
  59. 2:06because they are pulling from
  60. 2:09resources, from opening databases,
  61. 2:11maybe. So, they're not going to play a
  62. 2:13sideline of the Sicilian defense like
  63. 2:15the Alapin or the Wing Gambit. No,
  64. 2:18they're going to play knight f3 because
  65. 2:19this is what, you know, Kasparov played.
  66. 2:21Like, this is what all the goat, you
  67. 2:22know, the goats of chess play and then
  68. 2:24d4. And now black has many Sicilians,
  69. 2:27but this is the most popular, d6.
  70. 2:30And then d4, pawn takes, knight takes,
  71. 2:33knight f6 is what we call the main line,
  72. 2:35meaning this is what is played most
  73. 2:37often in this position. Now, here white
  74. 2:40can play knight c3
  75. 2:41or go for a sideline like with f3 or
  76. 2:43bishop d3 or whatever, but you're going
  77. 2:45to get this. And now this is the final
  78. 2:47moment where black can choose a path.
  79. 2:50Black can choose the most popular path
  80. 2:51and the most well-known path, the
  81. 2:53Najdorf Sicilian, one of the most
  82. 2:54reliable. Black can play knight c6,
  83. 2:56which is known as the classical
  84. 2:57Sicilian, very interesting Sicilian as
  85. 2:59well, but
  86. 3:01slightly less good than the Najdorf,
  87. 3:03like very slightly. And then there's the
  88. 3:04Dragon Sicilian,
  89. 3:06which is less good than both of them,
  90. 3:08but it's still completely playable. And
  91. 3:09then there's other stuff you can play.
  92. 3:11Uh, it plays a6, obviously. And so now
  93. 3:15white has uh no less than like 20
  94. 3:17possible moves here uh on the on move
  95. 3:19six of the Najdorf. The historic main
  96. 3:21line is the move bishop to e3.
  97. 3:24Uh, you can also play bishop e2, but in
  98. 3:26general uh putting your bishops on e3
  99. 3:28and then playing like queen d2,
  100. 3:30uh trying to go long castle,
  101. 3:33that's the way that, you know, uh it is
  102. 3:34played. So, bishop e3.
  103. 3:36>> [clears throat]
  104. 3:36>> Now, black
  105. 3:38really chooses where to put this e-pawn,
  106. 3:40either e6 or e5. That's kind of the
  107. 3:42major question in this opening. They
  108. 3:43play e5, normal. And now this knight can
  109. 3:46retreat anywhere, but it retreats to the
  110. 3:47most popular square, which is knight to
  111. 3:49b3.
  112. 3:50Black develops the bishop. In the
  113. 3:51Najdorf Sicilian, everything is about
  114. 3:53the D5 square, so we need to control
  115. 3:54that square and maybe we try to play D5
  116. 3:56ourselves. We have F3.
  117. 3:59Okay, black cannot play D5 immediately
  118. 4:01because the resulting big exchange
  119. 4:04like this like let's say queen takes
  120. 4:06would result in a position
  121. 4:08where white would very quickly generate
  122. 4:09some sort of attack
  123. 4:11on the structure and the lack of
  124. 4:13development in the black position.
  125. 4:16Don't have [cough and clears throat] to
  126. 4:16worry about that. Oh my goodness.
  127. 4:20I didn't want to clear my throat
  128. 4:21aggressively into the microphone. Queen
  129. 4:23D2 and decides castle on opposite sides.
  130. 4:26So
  131. 4:27so far
  132. 4:28Fable and Astra have not made a single
  133. 4:31illegal move and [snorts] we are heading
  134. 4:33for the
  135. 4:35I mean the most combative type of
  136. 4:37battleground in chess.
  137. 4:39The Sicilian defense which is one of the
  138. 4:41most aggressive openings and castling on
  139. 4:44opposite sides which in chess indicates
  140. 4:47that there will be a pawn storm of epic
  141. 4:50proportions against the enemy king cuz
  142. 4:52you can just throw all your pawns
  143. 4:53forward, right? In case you don't know
  144. 4:55that.
  145. 4:56This video might hit the algorithm. We
  146. 4:57might have people watching for the first
  147. 4:59time. If you are watching for the first
  148. 5:00time leave a comment.
  149. 5:03Hello. Welcome to the world of chess.
  150. 5:05Sometimes these videos that cross
  151. 5:07different subjects, you know, they get
  152. 5:09recommended to you because the algorithm
  153. 5:11I don't know. It they get pops up chess.
  154. 5:14You play chess 25 years ago or something
  155. 5:15like that and
  156. 5:17now you're back in the world of chess.
  157. 5:19So
  158. 5:20write a comment. Welcome to the chess
  159. 5:21world. Knight BD7. You don't have to
  160. 5:23write welcome to the chess world. That
  161. 5:25would be weird.
  162. 5:26Now G4 from Fable B5 from Astra G5 from
  163. 5:34Fable attacking the knight. Now how
  164. 5:35about this gangster move? Of course you
  165. 5:36can move the knight, right? I mean it's
  166. 5:38it's under attack.
  167. 5:41What if I counterattack?
  168. 5:44So now this knight is hanging and this
  169. 5:46knight is hanging. If I take the bishop,
  170. 5:49well, that's nice. You lose your queen
  171. 5:50and it's check. So, you don't actually
  172. 5:52get to win that queen back.
  173. 5:54Uh taking is fine.
  174. 5:56And then after takes, you would take the
  175. 5:58pawn so it doesn't take anything else
  176. 6:01and then you go like this. So, this is
  177. 6:02possible.
  178. 6:03This is certainly possible. Position is
  179. 6:06very, very complicated and I think it's
  180. 6:08even been reached before.
  181. 6:10And that's the keyword, possible. In
  182. 6:12chess, sometimes you could do two or
  183. 6:13three different things. You the game can
  184. 6:15go in a couple of different directions.
  185. 6:16White can retreat the knight to E2.
  186. 6:18White can also retreat the knight uh
  187. 6:20well, not retreat. White can get out of
  188. 6:22danger by going to A4, which is a little
  189. 6:24bit more aggressive. Knight B1 is a bad
  190. 6:26move because the knight cannot leave
  191. 6:28anymore. So, it has no mobility. Plus,
  192. 6:30your king is a little stuck. And then
  193. 6:32black can play A5, A4, etc. Anyway,
  194. 6:34knight E2 is played.
  195. 6:37Uh and then Astra also retreats the
  196. 6:39knight.
  197. 6:40And so, this is around like when the
  198. 6:43sides started thinking on their own.
  199. 6:45Uh and it was fascinating because again,
  200. 6:47white's plan in this position is to
  201. 6:49attack.
  202. 6:52And so, Fable played F4. Maybe they are
  203. 6:55still pulling from some opening
  204. 6:56database, but this is perfect. This is
  205. 6:58exactly what you should do. Now, Astra
  206. 7:00has multiple options. Take the pawn
  207. 7:02because if you don't take the pawn, the
  208. 7:04pawn will go to F5 and that really looks
  209. 7:06dangerous. Two pawns that close, you
  210. 7:08know, I'm thinking the pawn gets to F6,
  211. 7:10I sacrifice a pawn, I open up the lines
  212. 7:12to your king. Black's king looking very
  213. 7:15delicate. If you take though, of course,
  214. 7:17you allow a knight to come out to F4 and
  215. 7:18then maybe the bishop is going to point
  216. 7:20at your king and the rook and the knight
  217. 7:21and like
  218. 7:23it's also very scary.
  219. 7:25Astra thinks for a while, continues the
  220. 7:27king the queen side attack. It wants to
  221. 7:29play A4, it wants to play B3, it also
  222. 7:31wants to open up the position. So, so
  223. 7:33it's really it's like one move is going
  224. 7:35to decide this game.
  225. 7:37We have F5.
  226. 7:39So, now the bishop is locked in. Now,
  227. 7:40black has a choice. Again, every move
  228. 7:43there's a choice. Black can take the
  229. 7:44knight.
  230. 7:45If you take the knight,
  231. 7:47it it it it actually matters which way
  232. 7:49white takes, but regardless, the idea
  233. 7:51would be for black to play A4. This is
  234. 7:53better because you provide more of a
  235. 7:55shelter for your king, even though for a
  236. 7:57moment you're exposed. A4 and actually,
  237. 8:00what's incredible is that in this
  238. 8:01position, in this whole position, you
  239. 8:04don't take the pawn. You play knight C1.
  240. 8:08And the idea of knight C1 is to defend
  241. 8:11your A2 square.
  242. 8:12So, if black plays something like queen
  243. 8:14A5,
  244. 8:15what you're actually Well, really what
  245. 8:16you're hoping for is that here, you hide
  246. 8:18behind the pawns. This is pretty sick.
  247. 8:21And your king is completely safe. And if
  248. 8:23black tries to play queen A5, you just
  249. 8:25go here. You are trying to get your pawn
  250. 8:27taken with the pawn.
  251. 8:28And you want to create something like
  252. 8:30this.
  253. 8:31I mean, I have no idea if Fable would
  254. 8:33have been able to figure this out, but
  255. 8:34like this is alien-level thinking. I
  256. 8:36would have never understood this.
  257. 8:38Instead of that, Astra And by the way,
  258. 8:40you can ignore this. You can play A4.
  259. 8:42Pawn takes bishop. Pawn takes knight.
  260. 8:45You can take with check.
  261. 8:47And you can still do this whole thing.
  262. 8:49You can still try to hide your king
  263. 8:51behind the pawn. Anyway,
  264. 8:54Astra goes here.
  265. 8:56Gets the bishop out of the way. Puts the
  266. 8:57bishop on C4.
  267. 8:59Uh Fable plays the best move, which is
  268. 9:02knight to G3.
  269. 9:03Oh, I apologize. No, knight to G3 was
  270. 9:05the best move, but it didn't play knight
  271. 9:07to G3. It played king to B1. And now A4
  272. 9:11is going to be well met by putting this
  273. 9:12knight on C1,
  274. 9:14right?
  275. 9:15Where the king used to be, protecting
  276. 9:17A2. That's what happens. Boom, boom.
  277. 9:19And so, now here, Astra has to play one
  278. 9:22move. This is an incredibly complicated
  279. 9:25position. Both sides have lined up their
  280. 9:27forces. We don't have a single illegal
  281. 9:29move made. Guys, the earlier videos of
  282. 9:31GPT versus Claude were so stupid.
  283. 9:36This is actually pretty good stuff. Now
  284. 9:37again, some of you who understand a
  285. 9:39little bit more or who hate everything
  286. 9:42and are big skeptics are going to say
  287. 9:43they're just using, you know, engines. I
  288. 9:46I don't think so. They're not playing
  289. 9:47all the best moves. Case in point is
  290. 9:49coming right here. The top move of the
  291. 9:51engine here that Stockfish is showing
  292. 9:53for black
  293. 9:55is the unfathomable pawn to D5.
  294. 10:00The idea of that move is sacrificing a
  295. 10:03pawn
  296. 10:04to clear the D6 square for [snorts] the
  297. 10:07knight
  298. 10:08which will play defense and maybe
  299. 10:10offense. And if white plays F6 to
  300. 10:13sacrifice material like pawn takes and
  301. 10:15then to open up the position, something
  302. 10:17like this.
  303. 10:18Apparently, this is just equal. This
  304. 10:21position is 000. I mean, I I don't
  305. 10:23actually think it's equal. I think the
  306. 10:24computer cannot decide who is better.
  307. 10:27This is a wild position and black should
  308. 10:30sacrifice this rook because actually the
  309. 10:32king is completely saved then and then
  310. 10:34the bishop could be used to attack and
  311. 10:36etc. etc. Totally insane stuff here. So,
  312. 10:39maybe if Fable had like 10 minutes, it
  313. 10:42could have Or sorry, if Astra had 10
  314. 10:43minutes, it could have figured this out.
  315. 10:44Instead, it plays knight C7
  316. 10:46with the idea to bring the knight, I
  317. 10:47guess, over here. And now the sides
  318. 10:49start making mistakes. First of all,
  319. 10:52white is just much better here if white
  320. 10:54just plays F6. So, if you just attack
  321. 10:55the king, sack the pawn, or play rook G1
  322. 10:58and then F6, or knight G3 with the idea
  323. 11:01to bring the queen and the knight. What
  324. 11:04you shouldn't do here, you really
  325. 11:05shouldn't play this move, is take the
  326. 11:07free pawn. Yes, that is a free pawn, but
  327. 11:10it is a danger to you and your position
  328. 11:13and suddenly black is actually better
  329. 11:15because of the counter-attacking move
  330. 11:18D5. Very different than the previous D5.
  331. 11:21Now the B file is open and now the
  332. 11:24bishop attacks the queen and the pawn
  333. 11:25can get to D4. This is very, very bad.
  334. 11:28Now Fable scrambles back. Fable is up a
  335. 11:31pawn. The best move here for black is
  336. 11:33also so difficult to spot.
  337. 11:36It It doesn't make a lot of sense when
  338. 11:38you look at it. The best move is queen
  339. 11:41b8.
  340. 11:43Just in the middle of all this, just go
  341. 11:45queen b8. And you know what the idea of
  342. 11:46queen b8 is? You would think it's a3,
  343. 11:48bishop a3. No, the idea of queen b8 is
  344. 11:50just queen b7 and rook b8. Line up the
  345. 11:53queen and the rook using the open b file
  346. 11:55that white just gave. You have to be
  347. 11:57very careful taking a pawn when you are
  348. 11:59on opposite sides castled.
  349. 12:01Or just in general
  350. 12:03on the same side that you have castled
  351. 12:05but they haven't. Doesn't have to be
  352. 12:07opposite sides. Their king could be in
  353. 12:08the middle, right?
  354. 12:09Be very, very careful. Now, obviously
  355. 12:11this doesn't happen. Astra plays d4,
  356. 12:13which is still a very reasonable move
  357. 12:15pushing the pawn. I mean, these moves
  358. 12:17are moves that I think a 1500 would
  359. 12:19play, maybe even an 1800. Queen b8 is a
  360. 12:21weird move. The bishop goes back to d2.
  361. 12:24Black brings a knight forward to c5 and
  362. 12:26now white is better again. But why is
  363. 12:28white better?
  364. 12:30Black has played very logically. Black
  365. 12:31is threatening to take this pawn. Why is
  366. 12:33white better? Now white needs to play
  367. 12:35the pawn sacrifice. Your attack is over
  368. 12:37there. It has arrived on the shores of
  369. 12:39your opponent. You have to seize back
  370. 12:40control of the game. You have to go f6.
  371. 12:44This is the top move of the computer.
  372. 12:46Pawn takes f6, pawn takes f6, rook g1,
  373. 12:48queen h4, queen g3, etc. Instead, I was
  374. 12:51flabbergasted with this move. When When
  375. 12:54Fable
  376. 12:55wrote this move out, I was like, oh,
  377. 12:58now's the time where it's going to play
  378. 12:59like a Like we're overdue. I
  379. 13:01mean, I know I'm using these tokens or
  380. 13:02whatever, but like it it's got to play
  381. 13:04like a at some point. It played
  382. 13:06knight takes d4.
  383. 13:12That was the second choice of the
  384. 13:14engine.
  385. 13:15Fable calculated in this position
  386. 13:19that the bishops
  387. 13:21can see each other.
  388. 13:25And if pawn takes D4, there's bishop C4.
  389. 13:31If queen takes D4,
  390. 13:33you move the bishop and the queen is
  391. 13:36stuck.
  392. 13:37And then I'm going to win the bishop
  393. 13:38back on the next move.
  394. 13:41And if bishop takes F1, instead of
  395. 13:43taking the bishop, you go knight C6.
  396. 13:46Zwischenzug. Attack the queen and the
  397. 13:48bishop. Take with check and then take.
  398. 13:53Which is why, after some thought, Astro
  399. 13:57was like, "Nah,
  400. 13:58I'm not going to do that." Bishop takes
  401. 14:00A2, sacrificing my bishop, and then
  402. 14:03winning back the knight. The problem is,
  403. 14:05it's plus six.
  404. 14:07Apparently, this little sequence of
  405. 14:09moves lands Fabel in a completely
  406. 14:11winning position. Because still the
  407. 14:13queen is trapped and you are winning if
  408. 14:15you play bishop to B4.
  409. 14:17Bishop to B4 and the queen has no moves.
  410. 14:21And then the queen has to go here and
  411. 14:23now you simply take, take, get this
  412. 14:26bishop and you are winning. It looks for
  413. 14:28a moment like you might not be, but
  414. 14:29yeah, what I mean, black is busted.
  415. 14:31Black is simply out of options.
  416. 14:34But that's not what happens. That's not
  417. 14:36what happens. They are playing much
  418. 14:37better than they once did, but not
  419. 14:38perfectly. Bishop E3, queen takes E4,
  420. 14:40the rook is hanging in the corner. Now,
  421. 14:43the winning move here for white is still
  422. 14:46F6. It's still F6. Why is it F6?
  423. 14:50It's the mechanics of the position.
  424. 14:52Black is threatening a rook.
  425. 14:55Okay? White can take the knight and
  426. 14:57invite bishop takes, etc., and you know,
  427. 14:59some sort of slightly better end game
  428. 15:01position.
  429. 15:02But the move F6
  430. 15:05has to do with this rook.
  431. 15:07Because you are setting up rook to G1
  432. 15:10check. So, F6, the queen can take the
  433. 15:13rook. But if it does, this is hanging
  434. 15:16and then you will win two pieces and
  435. 15:18have a pawn on E7.
  436. 15:20But the problem is, even if this
  437. 15:22happens, black's in a lot of trouble
  438. 15:24because you are going to play rook to g1
  439. 15:25check and they are never going to win
  440. 15:27your rook. So the move f6 actually has
  441. 15:29to do with the threat on your rook as
  442. 15:32well.
  443. 15:33Anyway, they are not 3,000 level yet. So
  444. 15:36we have bishop takes knight and they
  445. 15:38calculate Claude calculates queen takes
  446. 15:40queen, rook takes, bishop takes bishop,
  447. 15:43rook takes pawn and simply retreating
  448. 15:45and Claude is like, "I'm up a pawn."
  449. 15:49It's not up. It is up a pawn and no
  450. 15:51illegal moves have been made yet, which
  451. 15:53is incredible.
  452. 15:54Now I'm thinking, "Okay, it's the end
  453. 15:56game." Historically, they always do
  454. 15:59stupid things in the end game because
  455. 16:00they just forget. They can't possibly
  456. 16:02remember. But now
  457. 16:05they they they are doing a better job
  458. 16:07memorizing, you know? Like they they are
  459. 16:08actually right. So
  460. 16:11uh Astra plays a3, which is a pretty
  461. 16:13reasonable move. The idea, of course, is
  462. 16:16to open up the king and if you don't
  463. 16:17allow your king to be opened up, well,
  464. 16:19then this pawn is two squares away from
  465. 16:21promoting at any time. It's a very
  466. 16:23dangerous pawn. And it's not clear if
  467. 16:25it's an asset or a liability just yet.
  468. 16:26The king can't get off the back rank,
  469. 16:28but, you know,
  470. 16:29it's still looking pretty good.
  471. 16:32So
  472. 16:33rook e8.
  473. 16:35I mean, this isn't This is amazing. The
  474. 16:37fact that these two are still playing
  475. 16:39completely seamless game. The best move
  476. 16:41for white is actually to trade the rook
  477. 16:43and simply to develop the bishop. That's
  478. 16:45exactly what happens. Fable trades the
  479. 16:47rooks and here the best move would have
  480. 16:49been bishop to c4 because you would have
  481. 16:52been pinning the pawn to the king. You
  482. 16:53would have been threatening pawn to g6.
  483. 16:54It's also This move counters the
  484. 16:56redevelopment of the knight. It's just
  485. 16:58It's just the best move.
  486. 17:00The second best move is to be a little
  487. 17:02bit more defensive.
  488. 17:04I don't know if these things just have a
  489. 17:05script where they consistently are
  490. 17:07playing the second move of Stockfish.
  491. 17:08Like that would be really hilarious
  492. 17:10if Astra and Fable
  493. 17:13actually do look at an engine, but they
  494. 17:15they always play the best move to
  495. 17:16pretend like they know how to play chess
  496. 17:18and then when asked about it they say
  497. 17:20uh-uh, that would be really funny.
  498. 17:22That would mirror human behavior. I just
  499. 17:24don't I mean I don't know. There might
  500. 17:25be more qualified
  501. 17:26software engineers that watch my videos
  502. 17:28that could be like no, they're totally
  503. 17:29doing that. They're just like BSing you
  504. 17:31and then I but I mean
  505. 17:33they did make some pretty catastrophic
  506. 17:34mistakes too, so I don't know.
  507. 17:36Knight to D5. Now we see the problem,
  508. 17:38right? The knight is now very active
  509. 17:40and rook D1.
  510. 17:42Almost looks like we've blundered a
  511. 17:44fork.
  512. 17:45And again, I'm I'm totally ready for
  513. 17:47them to play illegal moves. I'm totally
  514. 17:49ready for them. Like for example, bishop
  515. 17:50H2 is a free pawn.
  516. 17:52But it's a mistake because you would
  517. 17:53play bishop to B5. You would be
  518. 17:55attacking the rook and you would be
  519. 17:56attacking the knight and black can
  520. 17:58defend like with rook E5, but then you
  521. 18:00would go here and black cannot stop back
  522. 18:01rank checkmate. So black would lose the
  523. 18:03knight.
  524. 18:04So knight E3 instead, attacking the
  525. 18:06rook.
  526. 18:07Rook E1 pins the knight to the rook. I'm
  527. 18:09a little bit worried here for black. I
  528. 18:10feel like the the coordination is bad
  529. 18:12and
  530. 18:12uh you know, with black here if a move
  531. 18:14like king F8 happens, you got to
  532. 18:16understand the way white is going to win
  533. 18:17this position is just by pushing the
  534. 18:18pawns.
  535. 18:19White can play C4, B5, C5, B6, C6
  536. 18:23and just go cuz
  537. 18:25black has to stay guarding the knight.
  538. 18:27So rook E1, bishop to F4 is played.
  539. 18:30Uh and Fabel plays G6 which is
  540. 18:33reasonable.
  541. 18:34It's a reasonable move. You're going to
  542. 18:36have a big trade at the end. The rook is
  543. 18:37going to be hanging. We have pawn takes,
  544. 18:39we have pawn takes, we have pawn takes
  545. 18:40and we have bishop takes. This is
  546. 18:42amazing. They haven't forgotten any
  547. 18:44pieces.
  548. 18:45Everybody has been traded. White
  549. 18:46maintains a one pawn up advantage.
  550. 18:49The reason why this position according
  551. 18:50to Stockfish is still equal, it's cuz
  552. 18:52it's impossible to capitalize on this
  553. 18:53advantage for white at high level.
  554. 18:56Like first of all, you are heading for
  555. 18:58opposite color bishop end game.
  556. 19:00That's very well known drawing
  557. 19:01territory.
  558. 19:03Uh and you know, white's king is very
  559. 19:05weak and white's knight is very passive,
  560. 19:06so it kind of offsets
  561. 19:09the advantage that you you know, might
  562. 19:10have. Like uh you know, rook d8, rook d1
  563. 19:12is always possible. Anyway, rook e6
  564. 19:15bishop goes back.
  565. 19:16And when the bishop went back, I was
  566. 19:18like,
  567. 19:20"I think I know what's about to happen."
  568. 19:23But no way, right? Cuz they've been
  569. 19:25really impressing me.
  570. 19:27Bishop c4 is a threat.
  571. 19:30Bishop c4 is not normally a threat
  572. 19:32because the knight would just take the
  573. 19:33bishop, but the knight is pinned.
  574. 19:36And then the rook would be pinned.
  575. 19:38This would be an absolute pin, and this
  576. 19:40one's relative. You just simply win
  577. 19:42material. So here,
  578. 19:43you you have to go king f7 cuz your rook
  579. 19:46is protected. Then you can move the
  580. 19:48knight. You also can just like move the
  581. 19:50king somewhere else or move the rook
  582. 19:51somewhere else.
  583. 19:52If if black goes rook h6 here and takes
  584. 19:54the pawn, it it it's it's it's a draw. I
  585. 19:56mean, it's going to be a draw very soon.
  586. 19:59And then Astra typed out this.
  587. 20:04And I was thinking like, "Really? Is
  588. 20:07Claude actually going to spot this
  589. 20:08tactic?" And it did.
  590. 20:11It spotted bishop to c4. And it wrote
  591. 20:14out like, "Oh, I'm pinning the rook to
  592. 20:15the king." And you know, because of this
  593. 20:17pin, like this all works out. And here,
  594. 20:19uh we got knight c4 and rook e6, and now
  595. 20:21white is completely winning.
  596. 20:23This is This is amazing. This took over
  597. 20:25an hour and a half. I mean, they were
  598. 20:27thinking 2 3 minutes at a time at some
  599. 20:28point. Again, the reason this is winning
  600. 20:31now
  601. 20:32is because of the material swap.
  602. 20:34Uh rook remaining on a board of just a
  603. 20:37knight and a bishop, I mean, it's it's
  604. 20:38the king, right? The rook is the king.
  605. 20:40And these pawns are going to promote
  606. 20:42into queens very easily because they are
  607. 20:44connected. This pawn now is no longer an
  608. 20:47asset. It was an asset when the back
  609. 20:49rank could be attacked like this, but it
  610. 20:50can't. This is the only thing remaining
  611. 20:52that black has, and the only way that it
  612. 20:54promotes here is if white is a raging
  613. 20:56Uh so, knight to b2, that's also
  614. 20:59not a very good move. I mean, the
  615. 21:00knights should try to stay more active
  616. 21:02and in the middle. You should try to
  617. 21:03kind of bait the the king out to you
  618. 21:05know, like here. And then, you know,
  619. 21:07maybe you fork the king.
  620. 21:09Just just like by example, you know,
  621. 21:12there could be this.
  622. 21:13And all of a sudden there's a knight
  623. 21:14fork. You just you need the king out in
  624. 21:17the open to be able to fork it. So,
  625. 21:18knight to B2, okay? Rook A6,
  626. 21:21rook A3.
  627. 21:23I was actually impressed that that Fable
  628. 21:26remembered there was a pawn there, okay?
  629. 21:28King F7, and now it's easy. Now it's
  630. 21:30easy. We play rook A5, etc.
  631. 21:33Knight to B4 was the move. King F6. I
  632. 21:35don't like this next move by white, but
  633. 21:38it's fine.
  634. 21:39Knight to D3. I would just try to trap
  635. 21:41the knight. I would play like king C1.
  636. 21:43Now the knight can't escape, and then I
  637. 21:45would play like knight C6, get rid of
  638. 21:47the bishop, win the knight. Anyway,
  639. 21:49knight D3, knight takes, pawn takes, and
  640. 21:51this this is easy now. Well, it it's
  641. 21:53been easy, right? I mean, since uh
  642. 21:56since the rook was won, white wins this
  643. 21:58position by bringing the king a little
  644. 22:00closer to just make sure this doesn't
  645. 22:01happen, and joining forces with the king
  646. 22:04and
  647. 22:05the two pawns and the rook.
  648. 22:07Black goes king E6.
  649. 22:09Fable will go king C2.
  650. 22:11Uh before we continue, I would like to
  651. 22:13say in this position Fable made the one
  652. 22:16and only illegal move of the entire
  653. 22:18game.
  654. 22:19Now, does that mean that Fable loses?
  655. 22:23I feel like that's a little bit harsh
  656. 22:24given that like 2 years ago they were
  657. 22:27literally
  658. 22:28diarrheaing all over the chessboard.
  659. 22:31It played rook takes D3, and I I typed
  660. 22:34in rook takes D3, and Astra was like,
  661. 22:35"Uh you can't do that. You got a pawn on
  662. 22:36B3." And then Claude was like, "Oh, my
  663. 22:38fault, my fault." So, like, I mean,
  664. 22:41does that count? I don't know.
  665. 22:44Anyway,
  666. 22:45uh rook A7, bishop D4, and then here to
  667. 22:48my shock, to my horror,
  668. 22:50uh instead of because look,
  669. 22:53white still has to win.
  670. 22:55White still has to show that they
  671. 22:56understand the technique. You could
  672. 22:57easily lose a pawn here with white and
  673. 22:59lose a lot of your advantage.
  674. 23:01But then Astra blocked the check with
  675. 23:03Bishop C5.
  676. 23:06And I was thinking
  677. 23:08you think Claude is going to spot pawn
  678. 23:09to B4 attacking the bishop?
  679. 23:11It did. It went B4.
  680. 23:14How about this?
  681. 23:18Astra resigned.
  682. 23:23Astra
  683. 23:24the previous models did not resign. It
  684. 23:26resigned and said
  685. 23:28your move B4 wins the bishop pin the
  686. 23:32pinned bishop on C5. Good game.
  687. 23:39Wow.
  688. 23:41Now, I just hope you understand if you
  689. 23:42were in an end game
  690. 23:44and uh you know, the position looks
  691. 23:46something like this.
  692. 23:47You know, again, kind of similar but
  693. 23:50like
  694. 23:51uh
  695. 23:51something like this.
  696. 23:53Like bishop here, it's possible to not
  697. 23:55lose. You could get stalemated.
  698. 23:58It is possible. So, you don't always
  699. 24:00want to resign in that cool.
  700. 24:03But I'll allow it. B4 Astra resigns to
  701. 24:06Fable
  702. 24:08uh in a yeah, I mean in in a game that
  703. 24:11featured one illegal move in
  704. 24:1390-something turns combined
  705. 24:18and overall like a very decent game of
  706. 24:21chess.
  707. 24:22All things considered. Clearly high
  708. 24:24intermediate
  709. 24:26early advanced territory. The big
  710. 24:28evaluation shifts in this game were also
  711. 24:30pretty hard to exploit like the moment
  712. 24:33that it was plus five
  713. 24:36you know, right here early on like in
  714. 24:38this position when it when it was kind
  715. 24:39of plus five and you know, white needed
  716. 24:40to find this F6 move or
  717. 24:42uh you know, when whenever this big
  718. 24:44advantage happened. Right here.
  719. 24:46Instead of Bishop E3, white needed to
  720. 24:48play Bishop B4. I mean
  721. 24:52I I'm still impressed.
  722. 24:54Now, I've already I've already made
  723. 24:56Astra play against Opus.
  724. 24:59Uh 5.5. So, that will be a future video.
  725. 25:04And
  726. 25:05yeah, maybe I'll even make Fable play
  727. 25:07Opus because there's no model yet on the
  728. 25:11other side. Yeah, I mean we got to run
  729. 25:14back the AI chess championship if they
  730. 25:16actually know how to play chess, you
  731. 25:18know. Google did that the Kaggle thing I
  732. 25:20participated in I think that was last
  733. 25:22year. So, man, maybe we got to run that
  734. 25:24back cuz yeah, this is pretty wild. That
  735. 25:27is all I have for you today.
  736. 25:29Uh as always if you are still here shout
  737. 25:31out to those of you that I've met on
  738. 25:32book launch week. It's been really
  739. 25:34incredible
  740. 25:35and yeah, there's already so many
  741. 25:38positive reviews coming out of how to
  742. 25:40win at chess next level. I'm glad you're
  743. 25:42all enjoying yourselves. Um yeah, and
  744. 25:45I'm very I'm very grateful
  745. 25:47for the last 6 months. I know I've been
  746. 25:49talking about it a lot, but it's finally
  747. 25:50here and now it's time to write how to
  748. 25:52win at chess master level.
  749. 25:55So,
  750. 25:56get out of here.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of GPT-6 ASTRA vs CLAUDE FABLE 5.1 (INSANE CHESS MATCH) by GothamChess, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,770 words across 750 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.