Goatis vs. Jesus and Whatnot - The Christianity Debate — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Okay. So, um, God, is that is that how
- 0:02you say that's how it's pronounced?
- 0:05>> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
- 0:07>> Okay. So, you are you're you're like the
- 0:09the primal guy. I've watched a few of
- 0:11your videos. I saw you did one um on on
- 0:15Bryce Crawford um kind of, you know,
- 0:17saying like um oh, you know,
- 0:19Christianity is a man-made religion.
- 0:21It's not natural. Um do you maybe want
- 0:23to like explain like your worldview how
- 0:25it differs from the typical worldview so
- 0:27that you know everybody has like a good
- 0:29basis a good grounding for um what we're
- 0:32going to do?
- 0:33>> Sure. I just base everything on um this
- 0:37actual reality. So no imaginary
- 0:41ideas, abstract ideas.
- 0:45That's what I talked about in the video
- 0:46that you mentioned.
- 0:48Um basically just what science is all
- 0:51about.
- 0:52It's really as simple as that. So may
- 0:54maybe kind of the opposite of
- 0:56>> the way you live your life.
- 0:59>> Well, it's well, it's actually it's
- 1:01interesting because I'm a Catholic
- 1:03Christian. Um, and we we approach
- 1:06Christianity slightly different. We we
- 1:08say that you can actually naturally
- 1:11prove the existence of God. Um, and
- 1:14actually what what you talk about when
- 1:16you say that there's like like a natural
- 1:18order, we would say that that's actually
- 1:20a way that you can you can prove the
- 1:23existence of a god. I mean, I have a
- 1:25like a few arguments that I could run by
- 1:27you to kind of show you that, but but we
- 1:29actually agree with you on certain
- 1:30aspects like no, naturalism is very
- 1:33important. Natural law is very
- 1:35important. Um, but I think we would
- 1:36disagree on on what conclusions we take
- 1:39from that. Like I wouldn't say that um
- 1:41living naturally is doing whatever you
- 1:44desire. Um but more so living naturally
- 1:47is um adhering to what is distinctly
- 1:50human like rationality um and virtue.
- 1:55>> Yeah. Well, I would already disagree
- 1:57with the beginning because you said uh
- 2:00that
- 2:01yeah, you can talk about God existing
- 2:04except if you mean another word because
- 2:07purely scientifically for something to
- 2:09exist, I would have to be able to
- 2:11manipulate the object, material, being
- 2:14whatever it is.
- 2:15>> If I can't do that, I can't even I can't
- 2:18even start talking about the existence
- 2:20of the thing. So if I can do an
- 2:23experiment,
- 2:24test it, observe it, obviously most
- 2:26importantly or sense it in some way,
- 2:29then it's not even a an interesting um
- 2:32topic for me to discuss. Uh
- 2:35>> yeah.
- 2:37>> So So I think I think there are still
- 2:39things that are immaterial that we would
- 2:43still say exist. So for example, like
- 2:45like math um we we would say that that
- 2:47math still exists. Like 2 plus 2 equals
- 2:504. Would you say that math doesn't
- 2:51exist?
- 2:52>> No, it doesn't exist at all.
- 2:55>> Math doesn't exist?
- 2:56>> No, of course not. Because math is an
- 2:58idea. So there's no way for
- 3:00>> Well, ideas still exist.
- 3:02>> No, ideas don't exist. Of course,
- 3:03because ideas are thoughts in your mind.
- 3:07So for example,
- 3:08>> so
- 3:09>> if you would uh go up to a human being
- 3:11in the wild who doesn't speak any
- 3:13language, there's no way for you to show
- 3:16him math, God, money, time, status,
- 3:20marriage. It's impossible because
- 3:23>> it's ideas. So we apply ideas to real
- 3:27objects sometimes. So we put layers over
- 3:30something that is real. So for example
- 3:33in uh Christianity this ideology you
- 3:37would look at a piece of metal and you
- 3:39would say this is holy but I would call
- 3:42that insane no offense to you it's just
- 3:45how I see it.
- 3:46>> Yeah. Yeah. No no no not taken. But what
- 3:48I would say is so so when we posit that
- 3:51something exists maybe maybe we have
- 3:53different definitions of what we mean by
- 3:54exist. So I would say ex ideas still
- 3:58exist because we speak of an idea and an
- 4:01idea is something that still affects
- 4:03reality. So for example like you are a
- 4:05you're a human person and when you have
- 4:08an idea it influences the way that you
- 4:11act. So for example right now you you
- 4:12had the idea to have like come and have
- 4:14a conversation with me. And so that idea
- 4:17existed it it truly did exist and it
- 4:19influenced the way that you were
- 4:20material being um reacted and acted in
- 4:23certain ways. So I would say just
- 4:25because something is immaterial doesn't
- 4:27mean it exists. But we would say that it
- 4:29exists immaterially. It's a non-material
- 4:32existence. I get what you mean. But uh
- 4:34since we're using English and we try to
- 4:36communicate somehow, we just have to go
- 4:39by the definitions and it just doesn't
- 4:42make sense because exist means to be or
- 4:46to be real and real means not imaginary.
- 4:49>> Everything that you talked about is
- 4:50imaginary. Yes, you can enslave people.
- 4:54You can convince them to do something.
- 4:56You can absolutely
- 4:58uh through ideas convince people to do
- 5:00real things in reality. So that's true,
- 5:04but it's still thoughts and I will never
- 5:07be able to sense any of these thoughts.
- 5:10They will never be real. So if that
- 5:13would be the way you define it, there's
- 5:14nothing that we need to discuss about
- 5:17the existence of God. It's just
- 5:20>> it's just not a relevant topic to me
- 5:22unless I can actually manipulate the
- 5:24object.
- 5:26>> Yeah. So So when when you say that it it
- 5:29h you said the definition of exist is to
- 5:31be and for it to um ex like be in
- 5:35reality I think is how you said it. So I
- 5:37would say for example like an immaterial
- 5:38thought it is because we're speaking of
- 5:41it like we say thoughts are blank. I'm
- 5:43thinking of blank. So it it we would say
- 5:45it is it is being in some sense and then
- 5:48also it is being in reality because your
- 5:50thoughts are affecting the way that you
- 5:52act which is a reality. Um another
- 5:54another example you could use is like a
- 5:56desire or an instinct that you have. So
- 5:59so this kind of plays into like you know
- 6:00the naturalism that that you stand with.
- 6:03Um like when you have maybe a sexual
- 6:04desire or you know an appetite of desire
- 6:07that desire itself is going to be
- 6:09something that is immaterial. um it's
- 6:12going to be not not something that you
- 6:13can like pick up and hold or manipulate
- 6:15like you said. Um but it still truly
- 6:17affects the reality around you. So it
- 6:18has some existence, right?
- 6:20>> I I see what you're saying. The thing is
- 6:22that all of these concepts that we use,
- 6:25even nature itself, it always refers to
- 6:28something real, but it's much easier to
- 6:30use these conceptual terms instead of
- 6:33saying my eyes see this and they like
- 6:36it. I smell it with my nose and they
- 6:38like it. It's much easier when we talk
- 6:40to say it's natural for me instead of
- 6:43describing every single step of what's
- 6:46going on with my body. But you can never
- 6:49say that this is actually real. I
- 6:51understand exactly what you're saying,
- 6:52but these are all abstract ideas and
- 6:54concepts and English is a pretty messed
- 6:57up language. It's not very good
- 6:59>> to communicate with English. So, we can
- 7:01we can try to do the best we possibly
- 7:03can. But uh there's one thing that I
- 7:07need to explain just so you understand
- 7:10like if we don't use our imagination at
- 7:12all right now it's very hard for people
- 7:15to do that but really if you really just
- 7:18don't use any abstract ideas no
- 7:20imagination right now we are just uh
- 7:23sitting in different places on earth we
- 7:25have these devices we can somehow
- 7:27communicate you could say but really all
- 7:29that we are doing is making sounds
- 7:32really in reality all that we are doing
- 7:34and so I hear you your sounds, you hear
- 7:37mine. Then we try to interpret them
- 7:39because we learned English a language.
- 7:42Um it could it's really just anything.
- 7:45What we're saying doesn't have any
- 7:46actual meaning naturally. And um the
- 7:51thing is that uh sounds can only
- 7:54transmit, transfer, however you want to
- 7:57call it, beliefs, ideas, so thoughts in
- 8:00our minds. So it's in our minds and then
- 8:02we let them out through speaking.
- 8:06Sometimes we write something down
- 8:08>> whatever it may be and then the other
- 8:10humans can absorb that and that's how
- 8:13writing texts works and everything. I
- 8:14just want to break it down because a lot
- 8:16of people don't really think about this
- 8:18deeply but the thing about it is that
- 8:20you can't actually like when we talk
- 8:23about existence it has to be based on
- 8:25knowledge. I if you want to discuss the
- 8:28existence of God with me, that's all
- 8:29that I will accept. And so what you are
- 8:32doing is you're making sounds and then
- 8:35you want to convince me that there is a
- 8:36God with beliefs, ideas and that's
- 8:39something that I cannot accept because
- 8:42>> we could uh talk here for a million
- 8:44years and I would still not see God. I
- 8:47would still not be able to manipulate
- 8:48this being. So
- 8:51>> that's the thing um because uh actually
- 8:54I have a question for you. How would you
- 8:57convince a human in nature, a completely
- 9:00wild human who doesn't speak any
- 9:02languages
- 9:03that there is a god?
- 9:06Yeah. So, so, so I I'll respond to both
- 9:08of those. The fir the first thing I I
- 9:10want to speak on on the things that you
- 9:12just said about nature or language just
- 9:14being sound. And in a sense that is
- 9:16true. Like if you reduce it to just like
- 9:18the material aspect, the sound waves.
- 9:20Yeah, there is sound. But notice that we
- 9:22are making specific sounds and through
- 9:25those sounds you are able to receive a
- 9:27specific set of information. You always
- 9:29receive the information that I am
- 9:31intending. Now I agree h like human
- 9:33languages are flawed. They're not always
- 9:34perfect. But if I say for example uh the
- 9:38sky like I am transmitting a concrete
- 9:41information to you. When I say sky
- 9:43you're not going to randomly think of a
- 9:45rock. You're going to think of a sky of
- 9:47the sky right? And so so our information
- 9:49transmits real concrete immaterial
- 9:52ideas. And so this sure language is is
- 9:55is you know just sounds but we give
- 9:58specific sounds for specific things. And
- 10:00if you want to say that that's man-made
- 10:02it's not found in nature by all means
- 10:04sure that's okay. Um but it doesn't mean
- 10:07that there's still not an immaterial
- 10:08reality that exists. So we would say
- 10:10even something like truth truth in
- 10:13general you're making a truth claim.
- 10:15you're saying that you know um for
- 10:18example language is just sounds that is
- 10:20a claim. Truth itself is immaterial. So
- 10:23if you're going to convince anybody of
- 10:25that claim you have to first allow them
- 10:28and and make them believe in the fact
- 10:31that truth is something that has any
- 10:32real meaning even though it's immaterial
- 10:34which means that there are immaterial
- 10:36things that exist. Now the second thing
- 10:38that you said um you you brought up like
- 10:41how would you convince someone that God
- 10:43exists in in nature they don't know any
- 10:45languages.
- 10:46I would say that the first thing is that
- 10:50in order to convince someone convincing
- 10:52requires some form of communication and
- 10:55I think that's that's clear. Um so so
- 10:57for example like if let's say I'm
- 11:00talking about something different. I
- 11:01want to convince them that apples exist
- 11:03right? Maybe there's like a Native
- 11:05American they've never seen an apple
- 11:06before. Well, the first thing that I
- 11:08would have to do to convince them that
- 11:09apples exist is either show them an
- 11:12apple, which would be a form of
- 11:14communication, or teach them language
- 11:16and then describe an apple. Um, but
- 11:19let's say maybe I don't have an apple on
- 11:21me. There's no apples within like a 5
- 11:22mile radius. Well, then they would have
- 11:24to be able to understand communication.
- 11:27I would have to be able to communicate
- 11:28with them to actually deliver that idea,
- 11:30even though we know that apples exist.
- 11:32So communication
- 11:34um is still very important to delivering
- 11:36ideas and it doesn't have any effect on
- 11:38whether or not the thing is real or not.
- 11:40>> Here's the thing is that as I explained
- 11:42before that would again be belief. So
- 11:44for example, let's say two human beings
- 11:47stand next to each other back to back.
- 11:49So they don't see what the other one
- 11:51see. So they look in different
- 11:52directions. And uh one says there's a
- 11:56car coming. The other one if they cannot
- 11:58hear let's say some new electric car or
- 12:01something he would have to believe it.
- 12:02There's some other way for him to know
- 12:04he can only believe. So in your example
- 12:07the human would only be able to believe
- 12:09you right? Maybe apples don't exist in
- 12:11that reality right if he imagined that.
- 12:14>> So the only way to know for that kind of
- 12:17a human would be to sense it. So
- 12:19>> for a completely wild human the only you
- 12:23could for example hold up a sharp
- 12:25object. He would be afraid or he would
- 12:27attack you because he would want to
- 12:28defend himself or you could offer him a
- 12:31liver brain and he would see it as a
- 12:33present. He would never take anything
- 12:36else seriously because to him you would
- 12:38only be making sounds. So the sounds
- 12:41cannot prove an apple, a ball, a car,
- 12:44god, nothing. So there's just my point
- 12:46is simply the reason I ask you this is
- 12:48because you cannot convince an actually
- 12:52natural saint human who doesn't use his
- 12:55imagination at all because uh a saint
- 12:58human being completely lives in this
- 13:00reality. He doesn't use his imagination
- 13:02or at least he doesn't base his life on
- 13:04it and an insane human being
- 13:09puts these layers over reality. So, as I
- 13:13said before, you see a piece of metal,
- 13:14you believe that it's a holy cross. You
- 13:18see a structure, you believe that it's a
- 13:20church and you're not allowed to say
- 13:23specific words there. You're not
- 13:25supposed to be allowed there. Blah blah
- 13:28blah. So, it's a special place. So, you
- 13:29put these layers over reality. So,
- 13:32that's what an insane human being does.
- 13:35A sane human being doesn't do any of
- 13:36that. And uh
- 13:40you also said that well about um
- 13:45you need to be able to give me an
- 13:47argument that's based on something real
- 13:49because you said uh yeah
- 13:52>> I can do that. I haven't I haven't even
- 13:53really given my argument yet. Um but
- 13:55more so we're just kind of trying to
- 13:57understand you know the the naturalist
- 13:59standpoint that you take. Um here's
- 14:01here's a hypothetical that I think will
- 14:03maybe aid in this conversation. So
- 14:05you're saying like since you know
- 14:08somebody who doesn't know language, you
- 14:10can't communicate with them, that
- 14:11somehow, you know, diminishes the idea
- 14:12of like immaterial realities. Well, what
- 14:14about like somebody who's blind, right?
- 14:17They can't see at all. They they they
- 14:18have they've never had vision. If you
- 14:20try to describe to that person what the
- 14:23color red is and how red is different
- 14:25than blue, you're going to fail, right?
- 14:28Because they've never seen color. And
- 14:30that's something that you really can
- 14:31only experience. So, you can't describe
- 14:33what a color looks like to somebody
- 14:35who's never seen it all, but that
- 14:37doesn't mean that that color doesn't
- 14:39exist. And so, I would say in a similar
- 14:40way, um just because you can't describe
- 14:44or communicate with someone who doesn't
- 14:45know language, it doesn't take away from
- 14:47the fact that there are real meanings to
- 14:49things and real um immaterial
- 14:52existences. It just means that that
- 14:53person has not experienced language and
- 14:56they need to experience language in
- 14:58order to understand that.
- 14:58>> You can't really describe color sunny.
- 15:02How can you describe red, blue? It's
- 15:04just something that you see or you
- 15:06don't.
- 15:07>> That's the whole point is that since
- 15:09they since they can't see it, there's no
- 15:11way to describe it. But we still say
- 15:12like you agree colors exist, right?
- 15:16>> Well,
- 15:18yeah. It's it's because they see it.
- 15:20Yeah. But they don't. But uh
- 15:21>> Yeah. And so just because you can't
- 15:24>> Yeah, but just because you can't
- 15:25describe something or communicate
- 15:27something to someone doesn't mean that
- 15:29it doesn't exist. So in the same way
- 15:30just because like I can't convince that
- 15:33person
- 15:33>> to them it doesn't
- 15:34>> No but you just said that
- 15:36>> but no you just said that that color
- 15:38exists but we can't communicate that to
- 15:40blind people.
- 15:40>> Yeah because to them it doesn't exist.
- 15:42That's what I mean.
- 15:45>> It doesn't exist to them. What does what
- 15:46does that mean?
- 15:47>> What do you mean? What what what how do
- 15:50you how do you know if anything exists?
- 15:52For example, if I take uh if I put my
- 15:55hand up like this, if you would be
- 15:56standing um next to each other in real
- 15:59life right now, and I I will say, "I'm
- 16:01going to throw God at you now." Would
- 16:03you duck?
- 16:06>> I I wouldn't even know what that means.
- 16:07I don't think you can throw God. I think
- 16:09he's immaterial.
- 16:10>> Okay, whatever. Whatever you imagine. I
- 16:12will throw something imaginary. No,
- 16:15because it doesn't exist. So, but if I
- 16:17would take a stone and I would throw it
- 16:19at you, it would be real. So it's the
- 16:21same yubu duck obviously because you
- 16:24know that it's real. So that that's how
- 16:26we define what is real. So for the blind
- 16:28man there is no way for you to describe
- 16:30the colors because to them they just
- 16:34don't exist. It's as simple as that.
- 16:37>> No I I'm not saying that that tang so so
- 16:40your claim the point that you made
- 16:42against like language and communication
- 16:44and me using like logic to to prove that
- 16:46God exists. He said, "Well, you couldn't
- 16:48prove that to someone who doesn't know
- 16:50language." And so, so the the
- 16:52presupposition there is that if you
- 16:54can't communicate something, um, de
- 16:56facto, it means that that thing doesn't
- 16:58exist. That that was kind of the the the
- 17:00syllogism that you put forward.
- 17:02>> No, it just means
- 17:03>> but but what I'm saying is is that we
- 17:06can come up with things that clearly
- 17:07exist such as like the color red and the
- 17:10color blue, but there are some people
- 17:12who we can never communicate that to,
- 17:14and therefore they don't sense it.
- 17:16That's the whole point. You're just
- 17:18proving my point
- 17:20>> because
- 17:21>> like I said with sounds you can only
- 17:23express your ideas.
- 17:25>> So an idea cannot prove anything. It's
- 17:27impossible.
- 17:29>> I think we could talk about more
- 17:30interesting topics than about the
- 17:32existence of God because
- 17:34unless you can tell me where I can go
- 17:36and find God, it's just a pointless
- 17:39discussion.
- 17:41>> Yeah. So ju just just real quick though,
- 17:44maybe you're you're not understanding my
- 17:46point and I I'm not saying maybe I'm
- 17:47just misunderstanding. It could be
- 17:49either one of us, but but what I'm
- 17:50saying is you agree that red exists,
- 17:53that blue exists, but we cannot
- 17:56communicate that to blind people. And so
- 17:58in the exact same way, just because I
- 18:01can't communicate God's existence to
- 18:03somebody who doesn't know language does
- 18:05not mean that God doesn't exist.
- 18:08>> Yes, it does. Because uh let's say if
- 18:11God would be walking around in reality,
- 18:14the blind man would never know because
- 18:16he cannot see. It's as simple as that.
- 18:19>> That but that doesn't mean that God
- 18:21doesn't exist. It just means that the
- 18:22blind man couldn't see.
- 18:23>> God doesn't exist because there is no
- 18:25God, right? We cannot see
- 18:29him or anything. So So that's it.
- 18:31>> That that's just a that that that's
- 18:32circular. That's like me saying the
- 18:34earth doesn't exist.
- 18:34>> Oh, it was a joke obviously. That's why
- 18:36that's why I was smiling.
- 18:37>> Okay. Okay. Okay. Gotcha.
- 18:38>> I'm just saying gotcha.
- 18:40>> God doesn't exist because it's not uh
- 18:43Yeah. Like you said, it's immaterial.
- 18:44Immaterial. Immaterial means
- 18:46non-existent. When you say that it's
- 18:48immaterial is just a concession anyway.
- 18:52>> No, because I I believe that material is
- 18:54not convertible with existence. In fact,
- 18:57I think that matter is is potential. I
- 18:59don't think that it it's actual.
- 19:03>> Yeah. It it really doesn't matter what
- 19:05you say. You you can uh try to express
- 19:08the sounds. No, I'm just saying look,
- 19:10like I said, we could talk here for a
- 19:12million years, right?
- 19:13>> You can express as many sounds as you
- 19:15want. You could write a lot of texts
- 19:18about it. It will still God will still
- 19:21not appear in this actual reality.
- 19:25So since I base everything on what is
- 19:28real, what we can sense, what is
- 19:30factual, there there's no point for me
- 19:33to discuss this. But there's more
- 19:34there's other interesting topics we can
- 19:36discuss uh with um Christianity.
- 19:40>> I Yeah. Um I I would love to talk about
- 19:44about Christianity in specific. Um real
- 19:46quick though before we do that, this is
- 19:48just something I'm I'm kind of
- 19:49interested to see how you would answer
- 19:50this. Do you think you can prove that
- 19:52things exist in general?
- 19:55>> True. What do you mean? Of course you
- 19:57can. I can prove to you something but
- 19:59not right now because we are
- 20:01communicating through this artificial
- 20:03device. So
- 20:05before the call you said I could even be
- 20:07a AI so you wouldn't even know if it's
- 20:10real.
- 20:11>> But but
- 20:13like is there is there like let's say
- 20:14there's somebody who believes that like
- 20:16everything is an illusion kind of have
- 20:18you seen the Matrix?
- 20:20>> Yeah, sure.
- 20:22>> Yeah. So so like kind of like that. Is
- 20:24there any way to prove that like we
- 20:26actually exist? Or maybe it's just like
- 20:28all like a complete illusion. Is there a
- 20:30way to prove that naturally?
- 20:34>> All that we know is what we sense. So
- 20:36this is again an abstract idea. Where do
- 20:40we come from? Why do we exist? Is this
- 20:42an illusion? Blah blah blah.
- 20:44>> That's all in that we can talk about
- 20:46stuff like that, but it's just when when
- 20:48it comes to the existence of God, this
- 20:49is this is not even relevant to me.
- 20:52Well, well, well, well. I'm just trying
- 20:54to see
- 20:55I'm trying to follow your your logic a
- 20:57little bit because you're you're saying
- 20:59that we can't prove that God exists in
- 21:02this way because it's like an abstract
- 21:03idea, but I think existence itself is
- 21:05somewhat of an abstract idea. That's
- 21:07what like philosophy is for. It's the
- 21:09study of being. So, I'm asking, do you
- 21:10think that we can prove that existence
- 21:12is real at all? That things actually
- 21:14exist rather than not existing? Yeah,
- 21:16but the thing is that uh you're thinking
- 21:19it's just an abstract idea because all
- 21:21that I can know is is what I have in
- 21:24front of me right now. That's all that I
- 21:26can know. Like for example,
- 21:29just to really make the distinction
- 21:31between knowledge and belief. Uh if my
- 21:35neighbor has a white house, right, I
- 21:37come back home, I sit in my room,
- 21:40somebody calls me and asks me for
- 21:42whatever reason, right? What's the color
- 21:44of your neighbor's house? And I say
- 21:46white. I believe that. I cannot know
- 21:48that. I would actually have to see it.
- 21:50It's very unlikely that it's not white,
- 21:52but it could be that he painted it in
- 21:54the last hour. So all that I can know is
- 21:57what I sense. So if you ask me if this
- 22:00could be an illusion, how can we prove
- 22:03if reality exists or something? We just
- 22:06know what we know. That's all that we
- 22:07know. So everything else is a is a
- 22:10thought. It's an abstract idea which
- 22:12come a lot of these ideas come from
- 22:14religions and spiritual uh groups and
- 22:19whatnot.
- 22:20>> Okay. So, so let's say like do you have
- 22:24any apples near you? Can you see any
- 22:26apples?
- 22:26>> Not right now.
- 22:27>> Right now. Okay. So, do apples exist?
- 22:31>> I couldn't possibly say right now
- 22:32because as unlikely
- 22:35that's a little bit
- 22:36>> No, no. What do you mean? As unlikely as
- 22:38it may be, think about it. Something can
- 22:41be super unlikely like I just said, but
- 22:44technically somebody could have removed
- 22:46all of the apples. Like for example, if
- 22:48somebody close to Yeah, it's super
- 22:49unlikely. I know. I get it. But
- 22:51>> yeah, I would say I would never bet
- 22:54anything on that.
- 22:55>> But for example,
- 22:57>> if somebody close to you dies,
- 22:59>> you cannot say that they exist because
- 23:01they are dead, right? The being the
- 23:03being in flesh that you knew is gone.
- 23:06It's out of your senses. So, it's only
- 23:09in your mind, in your memory. That's it.
- 23:11So, abstract ideas, thoughts, concepts,
- 23:14even your memories, that's all. That all
- 23:17doesn't exist anymore. What exists is
- 23:19right now. That's all that exists.
- 23:22I I could believe that I know somebody
- 23:25very well, but as far as I know, they
- 23:29could be dead right now. Something could
- 23:31happen. It's very unlikely, but I could
- 23:33get in a car accident and they may not
- 23:35exist as the being that I knew.
- 23:37>> So now I would never bet anything on
- 23:39apples not existing anymore
- 23:41>> because I have some downstairs. But uh
- 23:46>> yeah. So so I would say in a very
- 23:47similar way like like you would say
- 23:50there's no need like in regular
- 23:52conversation to ever say maybe apples
- 23:54don't exist. Like we can all just kind
- 23:56of like for the sake of speaking say yes
- 23:58apples exist. So I would say in a very
- 24:00similar way, we can show that God exists
- 24:03even though we can't sense him right
- 24:04now. So just because we can't sense him
- 24:06doesn't mean that like like we would say
- 24:08it's extremely unlikely that God doesn't
- 24:10exist because everything would have to
- 24:12be an illusion. So I would say this this
- 24:13that kind of proves my point that um you
- 24:16know you don't have to be actively
- 24:17sensing something for us to say that
- 24:19there's an like really really high
- 24:21likelihood. But the difference is that
- 24:24in this case
- 24:25>> I wouldn't bet anything on it because I
- 24:27have already sensed and ate up myself.
- 24:30So I would just be basing it on that.
- 24:32>> In the case of God I it's not based on
- 24:34my memory. It's just based on nothing.
- 24:38So I would purely religiously blindly
- 24:40have to have faith that there is a god
- 24:44in another dimension or whatever you
- 24:46mean.
- 24:48>> Yeah. So, so I would say I I have never
- 24:51sensed like the divine nature, but we
- 24:54can come to believe in the divine nature
- 24:56or know that the divine nature exists
- 24:59based off of things that we experience
- 25:01in reality. And so, just like with the
- 25:03apples, you don't have to be actively
- 25:06like sensing those things, but we can
- 25:08still say that based off of what we have
- 25:10sensed in the past and what we are
- 25:11sensing right now that we can still
- 25:12understand that that this God like kind
- 25:14of as an extension exists. So, so here's
- 25:16a good analogy. um every time it rains
- 25:20it's wet. Okay, like let's say that
- 25:22we've sensed that in the past and then
- 25:24we sense right now that it's raining.
- 25:27Now we maybe we aren't outside so we
- 25:29don't know that it's actually wet but we
- 25:31can say it's still wet outside even
- 25:34though we're not actively sensing that.
- 25:35And that that would be like an extension
- 25:37using logic. It's called modus ponent um
- 25:39if P then Q P therefore Q. But if it's
- 25:42raining then it is wet. It is raining
- 25:45therefore it is wet. And so just because
- 25:47we aren't sensing that, we can still use
- 25:49logic to come to a specific conclusion
- 25:51with a very very high likelihood.
- 25:53>> I I get what you're saying and I get the
- 25:55the likelihood, but it's just not how I
- 25:59live my life. If you're talking to me,
- 26:01it's just not going to work with me
- 26:03because uh you you it would just be an
- 26:06assumption.
- 26:08>> Well, yeah, but but you could say the
- 26:10same thing about like apples existing,
- 26:12right? like apples have always existed
- 26:14in your memory and there's no reason to
- 26:17believe that they haven't so therefore
- 26:18apples still exist and we can say that
- 26:20with a very high likelihood so I think
- 26:21you can do the same exact thing with
- 26:23>> range very high likelihood assumptions
- 26:26and beliefs I get that but it's just not
- 26:28it's just not a topic when we talk about
- 26:30actual existence
- 26:33>> well I think it I think it's how we
- 26:34understand things because you could even
- 26:35say like why should you trust your
- 26:38senses at all why would you trust your
- 26:40senses instead of not trusting them
- 26:41Right? Like if I'm seeing the color
- 26:43blue, why should I trust my senses that
- 26:46I am seeing blue instead of assuming
- 26:48that they're wrong?
- 26:49>> Yeah. What is the question? Why should
- 26:52you trust?
- 26:53>> So, so why? Yeah. Why should you trust
- 26:55your senses at all?
- 26:57>> This is again an abstract idea. This is
- 26:59something that's irrelevant because we
- 27:02for example
- 27:02>> very relevant. It's relevant because uh
- 27:05it's it's it's just how it is. We are in
- 27:07the in these bodies and we sense things.
- 27:10So if I see meat in front of me and I
- 27:14eat it, I like it. It feels good. It um
- 27:17I become healthier then that's all that
- 27:20matters. So
- 27:22these these these abstract ideas that
- 27:24you're trying trying to apply to reality
- 27:26don't matter.
- 27:29>> Yeah. So when so I I'm I guess I guess
- 27:32I'm just confused is you're saying that
- 27:34it's irrelevant but it see you're saying
- 27:36that since we can't sense God we
- 27:38shouldn't assume that he exists. But
- 27:41then it seems like when I ask you about
- 27:43the senses that that would be relevant
- 27:45because that's how you're saying that
- 27:46you're determining that God doesn't
- 27:47exist because you don't sense him. So I
- 27:49would say like
- 27:50>> if you can't explain why we should trust
- 27:52the senses at all instead of things that
- 27:54are in our mind. Um, it doesn't seem
- 27:56like that's really a good litmus test
- 27:58for things existing.
- 27:59>> But you don't need an explanation for
- 28:01common sense, which is what people would
- 28:03call it. You just sense something and
- 28:06your senses tell you if it's good or bad
- 28:09for you. That's it.
- 28:11>> But why should we?
- 28:12>> They are always right. Yeah. Because
- 28:13they are always right.
- 28:15>> They're always right.
- 28:17>> Yeah.
- 28:18So, what what if your senses, for
- 28:20example, tell you that you should um
- 28:23like have intercourse with a minor?
- 28:26Like, would that mean that they're
- 28:27right?
- 28:28>> This is tricky to discuss on YouTube.
- 28:32>> Well, I think I think it's it's pretty
- 28:34easy to just say no.
- 28:36>> Sure.
- 28:38>> What do you What do you mean what do you
- 28:39mean?
- 28:40>> What What do you mean by a minor anyway?
- 28:43>> Like somebody who's under the age of 18.
- 28:45Like like if your senses are telling you
- 28:46like have intercourse with like a
- 28:4815-year-old, do you think your senses
- 28:49are right?
- 28:52>> You're funny, man.
- 28:54>> So when when does a girl become
- 28:56attractive?
- 28:59>> When does Well, uh I don't I don't know
- 29:01what you mean by that. I
- 29:02>> What do you mean? You said 18. So do
- 29:04girls become attractive at 18?
- 29:07>> Well Well, no. I I'm I'm just I'm just
- 29:09asking you specifically like if you're
- 29:11sensitive. Maybe we can use a different
- 29:13example. Like
- 29:14>> now now I do I do want to hear this. Now
- 29:16this is important. Just answer the
- 29:18question.
- 29:20>> Yeah, I think if I was a 15y old I would
- 29:22be attracted to 15 year olds. Um but I'm
- 29:25>> see that guys who are over 20 are
- 29:27together with younger girls. So this is
- 29:29this is irrelevant. It's not as if your
- 29:31age determines who you find.
- 29:33>> I'm not I'm not I'm not attracted to to
- 29:3615y olds.
- 29:37>> No, that's not what I'm asking. I'm
- 29:39asking at what age does a girl become
- 29:41attractive? Because you said 18.
- 29:44Well, I think attraction is like a
- 29:45subjective thing. I I I I think you're
- 29:48asking something very very specific.
- 29:50Like if I if I'm a 15-year-old, I would
- 29:52be attracted to people my age, but I
- 29:54grew up, so I'm no longer attracted to
- 29:5615y olds.
- 29:57>> Yeah, that's nonsense. When you when you
- 29:59do
- 29:59>> I don't think that's nonsense.
- 30:00>> When people did so-called studies,
- 30:03questionnaires, then all of the guys
- 30:05chose younger girls, never girls their
- 30:08own age, even guys who are over 30. So,
- 30:11this is nonsense. It's not as if when
- 30:13you're 15 you only find 15 year
- 30:15attractive and then all of a sudden it
- 30:17goes away. It's never the case. But
- 30:18that's not even a question. That's not
- 30:19what I'm asking. You said underage is
- 30:2218. So at what age does a girl become
- 30:25attractive then? So she's
- 30:27>> Yeah, just answer that. What are you in
- 30:30your early 20s or what?
- 30:33>> Yeah, I I'm I'm 20.
- 30:34>> Okay.
- 30:36>> So like when when you ask when does a
- 30:38girl become attractive? Like I think
- 30:41that's a subjective thing that that
- 30:42changes depending on who you ask. So I
- 30:44would say
- 30:44>> asking you.
- 30:47>> Yeah. So when I was in second grade like
- 30:50girls started becoming attractive around
- 30:51like second grade, but now I'm 20 and
- 30:54I'm not attracted to those girls at all
- 30:55because that's weird.
- 30:58>> Yes. But I'm just asking you if girls
- 31:01become attractive at 18.
- 31:07>> What? What do you like to me? Yeah,
- 31:09because you said it's weird or something
- 31:13to find underage girls attractive.
- 31:15Something along those lines.
- 31:18>> Yeah, I think it's weird for a
- 31:1920-year-old to be attracted to a second
- 31:21grader. Would you say that? That's
- 31:22>> second grader. Nobody said that, man.
- 31:24Why are you acting dumb?
- 31:25>> I No, because you you asked when like
- 31:28when did like I start thinking that
- 31:30girls were attractive like around.
- 31:31>> Yeah, but uh do they become But yeah,
- 31:33but you said underage. Under 18. So, do
- 31:35they become attractive at 18?
- 31:39when I I I I don't know how else to
- 31:40explain this. Like to me, girls that are
- 31:42under the age of 18 are not attractive.
- 31:45>> So 17, 11 months, 29 days, not
- 31:50attractive.
- 31:53>> Yeah, because I because I'm 20. I'm not
- 31:54attracted to to girls who are 17.
- 31:56>> You're not 20. You understand that age
- 31:58also doesn't exist, right?
- 31:59>> I am 20.
- 32:00>> Well, no, you
- 32:01>> age doesn't exist.
- 32:02>> Well, time doesn't exist. What do you
- 32:03mean? You just count symbols. You just
- 32:05look at some lines and then you imagine
- 32:07that the years go by, but it's not an
- 32:10entity. It's not it's not something you
- 32:12can count.
- 32:14>> Yeah, but I would still say like like
- 32:15like a 5-year-old girl can't like
- 32:17comprehend.
- 32:18>> Yeah. No, nobody says anything about
- 32:205-year-olds. You're trying to twist it
- 32:22around. I never said anything.
- 32:23>> Well, so but but the reason the reason
- 32:24we brought this up, let let me maybe
- 32:26just get us back on.
- 32:27>> Why don't you just No, man. Just answer
- 32:29the question. 70
- 32:32I answered multiple times.
- 32:33>> Okay, then answer. I didn't hear. Okay.
- 32:35Then it cut out.
- 32:36>> Yeah. I wouldn't I wouldn't be attracted
- 32:37to that person if they were underageed.
- 32:39>> So, and one day later, you would be
- 32:43>> um No, I I actually probably wouldn't be
- 32:45attracted to them if they were 18. I I'm
- 32:46more attracted to people that are like
- 32:47my age.
- 32:48>> Really? So, an 18year-old girl in front
- 32:51of you ready to go, you're not
- 32:53attracted. Yeah. Come on, man.
- 32:56>> What do you mean ready to go? What What
- 32:57does that mean? What does ready to go
- 32:59mean?
- 32:59>> What the man? Why do you act Why
- 33:01don't you just say the truth? Everybody
- 33:03knows the truth.
- 33:04>> Say the truth. No, I I am I I I don't
- 33:08know what what truth you're referring
- 33:09to. I'm just attracted to people that
- 33:11are my age. That's that's the answer.
- 33:13>> That's nonsense.
- 33:16It's pathetic that you cannot answer it.
- 33:20>> Maybe you think it's pathetic, but I I
- 33:21answered the question. And maybe you
- 33:23don't like my answer.
- 33:25People that are my age.
- 33:26>> No, it's it's all fine. So, so, so, so,
- 33:29but my my question is, is when we were
- 33:31going back like when we were talking
- 33:32about the senses things, you said that
- 33:34we should trust our senses. What if,
- 33:36what if your senses tell you like maybe
- 33:38to have non-consensual intercourse with
- 33:41someone? Are your senses right then?
- 33:44>> That's even trickier to discuss on
- 33:46YouTube.
- 33:49>> Well, I think the answer should be no.
- 33:51Like, that's bad all the time to have
- 33:53non-consensual intercourse with someone.
- 33:54>> There's no such thing as bad. Uh you you
- 33:58religious people.
- 33:59>> Well, I know I think there's there's
- 34:00such thing I think that's bad. I think
- 34:02that's definitely bad. We can say that.
- 34:03>> Okay. What is bad? Where is bad? Can I
- 34:06see it, touch it, smell it? What is bad?
- 34:09>> Yeah. I I think that bad and good are
- 34:12areological. So, it's like we would say
- 34:14a good knife is a knife that cuts well.
- 34:17Um a good eye is an eye that sees well.
- 34:19And I think a good human is a human that
- 34:21does what is distinctly human. But but I
- 34:23I I would like to get an answer. Should
- 34:25we still trust our senses in all
- 34:26situations?
- 34:28>> Absolutely. No. No exceptions.
- 34:31>> So like if like if your senses tell you
- 34:33to do what we just said, would you would
- 34:35you do it?
- 34:36>> Can't answer that on YouTube, but let
- 34:38let me explain it indirectly.
- 34:40>> Well, no. You can say no. You can say
- 34:42no. That's a pretty easy thing to
- 34:43answer.
- 34:44>> Yeah. Cool.
- 34:46>> Is the is the answer not no?
- 34:48>> Let me explain it indirectly because I
- 34:50also want to upload this on YouTube.
- 34:52Come on.
- 34:54You imagine that there is a good and bad
- 34:57somewhere out there. It's this mystical
- 35:00religious whatever thing and uh you this
- 35:06slave system is based on uh humans
- 35:08believing that what we do in nature the
- 35:10way we are supposed to live that is evil
- 35:14wrong bad. So they twist everything
- 35:16upside down. It's an inverted reality
- 35:18which is why Christianity is just a form
- 35:20of Satanism. Not that I believe in
- 35:22Satan, but I just use it as a joke. And
- 35:25uh but I do actually believe that. And
- 35:28um what is uh good? Good means being
- 35:32weak. So a weak human being is a good
- 35:36human being in the eyes of religions uh
- 35:39society which is also imaginary and uh
- 35:4399% of people around you and this the
- 35:47reason they built the system is simply
- 35:48because then they have nothing to worry
- 35:51about because all of the stuff that you
- 35:52call bad and that you're trying to get
- 35:54me to answer these people who created
- 35:57the system they do all of that and they
- 35:59know that it's good but they want you to
- 36:01believe that it's They know that that's
- 36:03good.
- 36:04>> I'm not saying anything specific. I'm
- 36:06just saying everything that people It's
- 36:09not necessarily everything though. Maybe
- 36:11over 90% of things that people see as
- 36:13bad, that's actually good because all
- 36:16the only way that you can measure what
- 36:18is good and bad. If you want to use
- 36:20those conceptual terms is the way your
- 36:23senses respond to something. So when you
- 36:26said a good eye is what did you say?
- 36:28eye, sharp eye or whatever, just an eye
- 36:32that sees. Well, yeah, that's a that you
- 36:34could call good because it refers to
- 36:37your own body. So, whatever your own
- 36:41body senses, if it feels good, it's
- 36:43good. There's nobody who can tell you
- 36:45that it's bad. There's simply people who
- 36:48thought of religions to make you believe
- 36:50that what's good is bad and what's bad
- 36:52is good. And this is your mindset. But
- 36:54it's not based on your senses because
- 36:56purely based on your knowledge, you know
- 36:59that
- 37:01Yeah. Whatever.
- 37:03>> Yeah. So I I I would say like like would
- 37:06you say a good knife is a knife that
- 37:08cuts well or a knife that doesn't cut
- 37:10well?
- 37:11>> I I would call it good if if I could use
- 37:14it as a good weapon. So the sharper it
- 37:16is, the better it cuts uh the better.
- 37:18>> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And so I would say in
- 37:20the same exact way a good human being is
- 37:23a human that does what is distinct to
- 37:25human nature. So the thing that is
- 37:28distinct to human nature is not just
- 37:31desire, not just the senses but also
- 37:33rationality and control of the will.
- 37:37>> And so I would say that that you you you
- 37:39should be correctly ordering your
- 37:41actions not only to your desires but
- 37:43also to rationality to right reason and
- 37:46ultimately towards your final cause.
- 37:49I agree except for the will part because
- 37:52your will is basically who you are. So
- 37:56if you're self-willed, which is just
- 37:58another word for wild, then you don't
- 38:01fit into this so-called society, the
- 38:03people around you, because you will do
- 38:06what is good for yourself and your
- 38:07family. So the only way that you can
- 38:09live in this slave system is by
- 38:12following whatever Christianity, Islam,
- 38:14Buddhism, it doesn't matter. It's all
- 38:15the same. All of them teach you what's
- 38:17good is bad, what's bad is good and
- 38:19that's the only way that you can do it.
- 38:20Then you you constantly suppress your
- 38:22nature and you try to live together with
- 38:25people and everybody knows that if
- 38:28tomorrow there would be no laws and
- 38:30there are no laws because they don't
- 38:32exist. The police also doesn't exist.
- 38:34It's all imaginary. Then people would be
- 38:37uh stealing, taking what they want. they
- 38:41would be attacking other people like the
- 38:45the natural order would uh simply return
- 38:49and it really kind of already we already
- 38:51have it anyway.
- 38:53But uh the slave population is made to
- 38:57believe that good is bad and bad is
- 38:59good. The ones at the top, not an
- 39:02actually real top, but an imaginary top,
- 39:04they do everything that we see as evil
- 39:07and bad anyway because they know that
- 39:09it's good.
- 39:12Yeah. So, so I would agree that that
- 39:14people at at the top, as you would call
- 39:16them, do evil things, but I don't think
- 39:18that that means that it's actually good.
- 39:20I think it just means that they're evil
- 39:22and they give into temptation. Um, so so
- 39:25like as far as like control over the
- 39:27will, you don't think that there's any
- 39:28situation in which like a person should
- 39:30should restrict some of their actions?
- 39:32Like if if they're they have a desire to
- 39:33do something, it's always good to do
- 39:35that desire.
- 39:36>> Yes. Always.
- 39:38>> Okay. So you kind of brought up like the
- 39:41example of like if we got rid of society
- 39:44like it would kind of be like warfare,
- 39:45anarchy, kind of that that type of
- 39:47thing. Would you say that that's a
- 39:49better way of living where there's like
- 39:51theft and and murder? That's a better
- 39:53way of living than what we have right
- 39:54now.
- 39:55>> Yes, that that would be the best way.
- 39:56That's what I wish for and that's that's
- 39:59all that I want.
- 40:01>> That's all that you want. So, so I I
- 40:04guess I'm just struggling to see how the
- 40:06outcome there is better than the outcome
- 40:08that we have with society where people
- 40:09are getting murdered, they're getting
- 40:11stolen from, they're getting either, you
- 40:12know, non-conventual sexual.
- 40:14>> Okay. Yeah. Yeah. That's that that's a
- 40:16good question. So, we already have that
- 40:18as I said before, we already live in the
- 40:20system except that we don't realize it.
- 40:23We are getting murdered. We are we are
- 40:26people do steal from us, but we call
- 40:28them the police. These are people who
- 40:32have killed more people than most serial
- 40:34killers. So if you would want to apply
- 40:37the concept of serial killers to
- 40:39somebody, those would be serial killers
- 40:41and mass murderers for the most part,
- 40:43right? And so they come into your house,
- 40:46they they often times just kidnap the
- 40:50children, but they call it they go
- 40:52together with the child protective
- 40:55services. They they do that. Then
- 40:59you just don't want to inject something
- 41:02into your children. They come and kidnap
- 41:04them. You defend your children, they
- 41:05kill you. This happens all the time. So
- 41:08they they murder the parents or the
- 41:10father and nothing happens to them. So
- 41:13we already live in this system where
- 41:16people threaten you with torture, which
- 41:18is imprisonment, putting you in a cell
- 41:20or they will murder you. So every every
- 41:23day when people walk around outside,
- 41:26they know that they won't steal. They
- 41:28won't sometimes even lie maybe, although
- 41:30people do lie. They won't um
- 41:34yeah, they they won't do everything
- 41:36that's seen as bad because there's the
- 41:38threat of torture and murder. So this
- 41:40will always be the case because if there
- 41:43is no threat of torture and murder, then
- 41:47pe somebody else will take their place.
- 41:49So for example, if tomorrow let's say
- 41:51everybody would agree that we will live
- 41:54peacefully, we will be all Christian and
- 41:57whatever, then somebody would say that
- 41:59this is a great chance guys let's get
- 42:01together and then they would take the
- 42:02power because somebody will always have
- 42:04the power. So the delusion is to believe
- 42:08that we don't have this system already.
- 42:10we have it. But the police officers, the
- 42:14guys who put on clothes and act as if
- 42:16they are police officers, they just
- 42:18don't realize that they are enslaving
- 42:21themselves. They are slaves themselves.
- 42:23They enslave the other slaves. And um
- 42:26they work for the people at the top.
- 42:29They they don't get what's going on
- 42:31themselves. like this this whole this
- 42:34whole imagination that if there would be
- 42:38no laws or rules there would be whatever
- 42:42you called it anarchy we already have
- 42:44that
- 42:46>> yeah um well I would certainly push back
- 42:48on that like so for example like prison
- 42:50is a conditional oppression it's
- 42:53conditional upon you doing something
- 42:55that's wrong so like for example
- 42:57something like murder I think if you
- 42:59murder someone you deserve to have
- 43:01punishment for that. Um because if there
- 43:04is no punishment for that, if there's no
- 43:05societal boundaries, then everybody will
- 43:08just murder people and then society will
- 43:10collapse and there will be no humans
- 43:11left to have, you know, natural desires
- 43:15and that would be I think you would even
- 43:16agree if there's no humans left that
- 43:18would be the worst, right?
- 43:20>> Yes. But you cannot fulfill your natural
- 43:22desires. The only way you can is if you
- 43:24have power and that's the system they
- 43:25created. Because if that's your logic
- 43:28that murder, whatever stealing is wrong,
- 43:31then they should also not be allowed to
- 43:33do that. But the way it works is that
- 43:35they have the power because they have
- 43:36the weapons. In the US, some people do
- 43:39have weapons thankfully, but overall
- 43:41most people don't. And uh even they
- 43:44don't use them anyway. And uh so so for
- 43:47example, in Florida, I guess that they
- 43:49do the death penalty. So they use
- 43:50different words to describe the same
- 43:52thing. They murder people for murdering
- 43:55other people. But then the question is
- 43:56who murders them? So somebody murders
- 43:59somebody and they they murder him. So
- 44:01who will murder the murderer? Nobody
- 44:03does because this this they have the
- 44:06power so to speak. This this illusion of
- 44:10power. So So you already have this
- 44:14system. We already have the system where
- 44:16we have the threat of torture and murder
- 44:18and they have the power and if they
- 44:21wouldn't then somebody else would.
- 44:22Somebody will always have it. And that's
- 44:24why you back in the day always had big
- 44:27families who would reproduce, they would
- 44:30grow and then they would attack others
- 44:32and try to take uh over and so on. We we
- 44:36have the same thing.
- 44:38Yeah. Nobody does anything about it. You
- 44:39saw in Iran they kill 100 children. No,
- 44:43murder, mass murder. Nobody gives a
- 44:45Nobody does anything because they
- 44:47can commit mass murder, serial killing,
- 44:50and nobody will do anything because they
- 44:52have the power. You you kill one human
- 44:55being. It's all over the news. Monster.
- 44:58He's in this society. Get him. Catch
- 45:01him. They murder 100 people.
- 45:04>> Yeah. You know. Yeah. Who Who murdered
- 45:06100 children in Iran? Who knows? I don't
- 45:09know who who gives a
- 45:10>> My Yeah. So, so the claim here isn't
- 45:13that bad things don't happen in a
- 45:15society. I agree that bad things happen
- 45:17in a society, but it seems as though
- 45:19you're implying that like genocide is a
- 45:21bad thing. When you bring that up,
- 45:23you're like, "Yeah, murdering children
- 45:24is a bad thing." Would Would you agree
- 45:25with that?
- 45:26>> No, that's not what I mean. What I mean
- 45:27is simply that they have the power so
- 45:30they uh they can decide. So, how how
- 45:34many people did they murder? I don't
- 45:35know. Tens of thousands, maybe hundreds
- 45:37thousands.
- 45:38>> Many children. I agree. It's it's a I
- 45:40think that's a bad thing and I think it
- 45:41should be avoided. No, it seems like
- 45:43you're saying they don't see it as bad.
- 45:45>> Well, hold on. But it it but it seems
- 45:46like you're saying that it it shouldn't
- 45:49necessarily be avoided because it
- 45:50happens in both systems.
- 45:53>> What?
- 45:53>> It seems like you're saying it's not
- 45:54necessarily a bad thing.
- 45:57>> No. Well, there's nothing that you will
- 45:59be able to say that I will call good or
- 46:01bad because you're referring to
- 46:04something imaginary, something that
- 46:06doesn't exist. All that I can refer to
- 46:08are my senses. So, for example, if those
- 46:11were my family members, I would say that
- 46:13it was bad. I probably would have cried
- 46:15and I would be really upset and I would
- 46:16probably want to get revenge which is
- 46:19probably the case with tons of parents
- 46:21in Iran. Yeah, it happens everywhere
- 46:24anyway. But obviously we have no rel we
- 46:27have no relation to it. We cannot relate
- 46:30to it because
- 46:32if if your mother for example dies, you
- 46:34will cry and be devastated most likely,
- 46:37right? But if a 100,000 people get uh
- 46:41bombed to death in Iraq, you have no you
- 46:44cannot relate to it.
- 46:47You don't cry. There's nothing because
- 46:49you just hear about it. So it's not real
- 46:51to you.
- 46:52>> No, it's it's real to me. And I I I do
- 46:54get very upset by that. I'm not someone
- 46:56who cries, but I I am very upset by by
- 46:59children dying.
- 47:00>> I don't believe that anybody is as long
- 47:02as they don't sense it.
- 47:05You you don't believe that anybody's
- 47:06upset about that?
- 47:07>> No.
- 47:10>> So you would you say that you're not
- 47:12upset about that?
- 47:13>> No, of course not because I don't know
- 47:14them. If I would be upset about that,
- 47:16then I would be in the corner crying
- 47:18every day because I I assume that's what
- 47:22they say that how many people die every
- 47:24day? Hundreds of thousands or who knows
- 47:26what. I I would just mentally completely
- 47:29break apart if I would care.
- 47:35Yeah. Uh, no, I I do care about that and
- 47:37that's something that makes me very
- 47:38upset and so that's why like I'm a
- 47:40proponent of like medicine research and
- 47:42converting people to Christianity so
- 47:44that they're they they don't like
- 47:45permanently die. So So I I think that
- 47:48like you're saying that that nobody
- 47:50cares about this. It seems like maybe
- 47:51that's just you projecting your own
- 47:53apathy onto the rest of the world when I
- 47:55think I think everybody watching this
- 47:57agrees that like children dying is a bad
- 47:59thing and it does affect them negatively
- 48:00even if they don't know those children.
- 48:02They only do it uh for example people
- 48:04who have so-called followers online they
- 48:07will just do it just to just to look
- 48:10better in the eyes of the religious
- 48:13people because 99% of people follow
- 48:16morals religions. So you will just be
- 48:19seen as a good human being if you say
- 48:21that you care about it but you turn off
- 48:23the camera and you just do whatever you
- 48:26don't actually care.
- 48:29>> Interesting. Okay. Well, um maybe I mean
- 48:32if you completely reject objective
- 48:34morality and being affected by, you
- 48:36know, um what what I would call
- 48:37objectively evil, I don't think there's
- 48:39like that can just be a position that
- 48:40you hold to, but I don't think it's it's
- 48:42a coercive position. I don't think that
- 48:44you could prove that over objective
- 48:46morality. Like you can say, oh, it's
- 48:48something that's made up, but I would
- 48:49say your worldview is also something
- 48:50that you've made up. Um because that's
- 48:52how worldviews work. It's somebody
- 48:54coming to conclusions based off of what
- 48:56they sense inity.
- 48:57>> What you mean by world view? But I'm
- 48:59just I like I said I base it all on what
- 49:01I sense and I just don't sense them. It
- 49:04would be insane if you would actually
- 49:06get affected by something that we don't
- 49:08sense that we simply read about because
- 49:11as I said through sounds and texts we
- 49:14can only absorb uh
- 49:17beliefs, ideas. I got to get something
- 49:20to drink. Will only take two minutes.
- 49:23Yeah. Okay.
- 49:24>> We we were guessing what your drink was.
- 49:26Was it Was it coconut water?
- 49:27>> Yeah.
- 49:29Nice. There we go. That's That's good.
- 49:32Um I I guess the the drink break could
- 49:34be like a good segue to maybe get into
- 49:37um like I haven't even given my argument
- 49:39for why I believe God exists. Do you
- 49:41want me to maybe tell you that and then
- 49:43you can kind of give your thoughts on it
- 49:44after?
- 49:45>> Ah, sure. You can do it.
- 49:47>> Yeah. Yeah. So,
- 49:50um, it'll be that there's there's three
- 49:53premises and one conclusion, and that's
- 49:55basically just things that are being
- 49:57stated that can be contested with, and
- 49:58then the the conclusion is something
- 50:00that logically follows from those
- 50:01conclusions. Um,
- 50:03>> how long is it going to take? Because
- 50:04the the thing is
- 50:06>> 30 seconds.
- 50:07>> Oh, okay. Sure. Don't do it.
- 50:09>> Yeah, it's very brief. Okay. Premise
- 50:11one. Uh, some things without
- 50:13intelligence regularly produce specific
- 50:16effects. So, for example, like fire
- 50:19regularly produces heat and it's
- 50:22specifically heat. Fire does not produce
- 50:24cold. Fire does not produce a rainbow.
- 50:26It it's heat that is specifically and
- 50:28regularly produced um by fire. Um
- 50:32premise two, if something regularly
- 50:34produces a specific result, it is
- 50:36directed towards that result. Um so, um
- 50:41an arrow for example doesn't fly towards
- 50:44a bullseye just completely randomly. an
- 50:46arrow will fly towards a bullseye
- 50:48because it is directed that way by some
- 50:50intelligence. Um, premise three,
- 50:54something without intelligence can only
- 50:56be directed towards a result by an
- 50:59intelligence. So, just like with the
- 51:01arrow, the arrow will not fly on its own
- 51:04because it has no intelligence. It will
- 51:06not go towards anything purposefully
- 51:09without an intelligence behind it. Um,
- 51:11and so there must be an intelligence, a
- 51:12human being that that shoots the arrow
- 51:14and directs it in a specific direction.
- 51:17Therefore, the conclusion is things
- 51:19without intelligence are directed
- 51:22towards their result by some greater
- 51:24intelligence. So fire
- 51:26is directed towards heat in that sense
- 51:29by some intelligence that isn't human
- 51:31beings because we don't direct fire and
- 51:33that's what most people would refer to
- 51:35refer to as God.
- 51:38>> All right. Um, yeah, it's a very
- 51:40abstract. Uh, no, it's a cool story, but
- 51:43like I said, it's just irrelevant to me.
- 51:46Yeah,
- 51:47>> it's irrelevant to you, but but is there
- 51:49anything that you disagree with in
- 51:50there?
- 51:52>> Like, like I said, it's not even
- 51:55relevant to me at all because unless you
- 51:57can tell me where I can go and
- 51:59manipulate this object, God, but you
- 52:02said already, it's immaterial.
- 52:04So uh there's just nothing like there's
- 52:07no sounds on earth that you will ever be
- 52:10able to make to convince me that there
- 52:12is a god since it's your ideas. So that
- 52:15that's why I explained this before. You
- 52:18have a your brain is functioning right.
- 52:21You're alive and you want to express
- 52:23what you believe maybe what you absorbed
- 52:26from other people. That's the case with
- 52:28um Christianity since you in the wild
- 52:32you wouldn't just think, oh, there is a
- 52:34God and this cross is holy and blah blah
- 52:36blah. No, you need to absorb
- 52:39>> we're not talking about Christianity
- 52:41specifically yet. We're just talking
- 52:42about God,
- 52:42>> whatever God. Okay. Yeah. But I'm just
- 52:45saying,
- 52:45>> but but no, so like like the point the
- 52:47point that we're we're saying though,
- 52:48like for example, you believe that truth
- 52:50exists or or you you said that you
- 52:52believe that truth exists, that truth
- 52:53statements exist. But again, we said
- 52:55that that's an immaterial thing. And I
- 52:57would say that something being material
- 52:58is actually like a limitation. So like
- 53:00I'm limited by my material body.
- 53:02>> You you said it before, I didn't
- 53:04respond. Uh actually I don't agree with
- 53:06that because truth truth can only be
- 53:10what you sense. It can never be anything
- 53:11else. Because as I said, if you don't
- 53:14sense it, you don't know if it's true.
- 53:16That's why I gave the examples with the
- 53:18color of the house. If a car is driving
- 53:21at you, if you don't know, meaning you
- 53:24cannot sense it, it's not the truth. It
- 53:27cannot be. So nothing this this it's
- 53:30very important to understand this also
- 53:32for the people watching. You can never
- 53:34get anything true out of a book,
- 53:37lecture, video, not this video, not any
- 53:39video because it's human ideas,
- 53:43thoughts. So you can only you have to be
- 53:47able to test it scientifically. So the
- 53:50only way that the only thing that you
- 53:52could do here is refer to something real
- 53:56such as you could say that you can see
- 53:58God uh every day uh at sunset in this
- 54:03place in Pakistan in this cave
- 54:05somewhere. I I would still not know if
- 54:07it's true. I would have to go there and
- 54:09then I would see. Of course, we know we
- 54:11we can assume we don't know uh if uh
- 54:14that well we can assume that that has
- 54:17never happened because nobody has ever
- 54:18taken a photo or video of God. But uh
- 54:22well here's the thing. Um we talked
- 54:25about the Apple situation earlier,
- 54:27right? And you said, "Well, you can't
- 54:29know for certain that that apples
- 54:31actually exist, but you say it's very
- 54:34likely that they do, right?"
- 54:36>> Yeah. I just said I I would never bet
- 54:38anything on on it because it would be
- 54:41ridiculous.
- 54:42>> So, is it is it true that it's likely
- 54:46that they exist?
- 54:49>> That's a question that's impossible to
- 54:51answer because either something exists
- 54:53or it doesn't.
- 54:55>> Well, it's some it's something that you
- 54:56said. You said that it's it that it's
- 54:58likely that they exist. I'm asking is
- 55:00that statement true? I don't know what
- 55:02exactly I said but uh my overall point
- 55:05is only what you can sense is really
- 55:08what you know. So
- 55:10>> is that statement true?
- 55:13>> What you sense is what you know what
- 55:14what is true that that's what exists. It
- 55:17I don't know what exactly what I said
- 55:18before but what I meant is that I would
- 55:21uh have to of course go and see about
- 55:24the apples but it's just very likely I
- 55:27can assume that if I go I would see the
- 55:29apples. I just cannot know it in the
- 55:31moment. So, so I don't know how I
- 55:34expressed myself, but that's what I
- 55:35mean.
- 55:36>> Yeah, but you're you're making claims
- 55:37right now. So, you're saying like you
- 55:39can only know thing know things through
- 55:40your senses. Is that a true statement?
- 55:45>> What do you mean by that?
- 55:47>> Is it is it is it correct? Is it true?
- 55:49Is it objectively true or is it just
- 55:51like an opinion?
- 55:52>> Yeah, but that's that's that's an idea,
- 55:55right?
- 55:57I'm asking if it's a true a true idea.
- 55:59>> Yeah, but an idea cannot be true or
- 56:02false because it's an idea. You would
- 56:04still have to prove it. So, for example,
- 56:07>> you would have to make an actually
- 56:09specific claim that refers to something
- 56:11real. So, it's something that I can
- 56:14actually sense uh anything that's
- 56:17actually real.
- 56:19So, so you would say that like your
- 56:22position then that you can only know
- 56:25things if you're actively sensing them.
- 56:27That's not necessarily true.
- 56:30>> It's just that you're referring to a
- 56:33statement, a belief, an idea. So, what
- 56:36is true is what you can sense. I cannot
- 56:38sense your idea. It's just it's
- 56:40something that I cannot even answer
- 56:42because it's a statement.
- 56:44>> Except if you define true differently.
- 56:47What?
- 56:48>> Well, state statements are either true
- 56:50or false. Meaning that like they have
- 56:52>> Yeah. If you refer to something real,
- 56:54then you could say that. So,
- 56:56>> yeah. So, I'm asking I'm asking
- 56:57statement would be that I have a mouse
- 56:59here like a computer mouse or of the
- 57:01object
- 57:04if that's what you mean.
- 57:06>> Okay. So, so you just said that the you
- 57:09can you can sense that the mouse is
- 57:11there. Is that true?
- 57:13>> Yeah. Yeah, that's the truth. Yeah,
- 57:14exactly. So, but but is it true that you
- 57:17just said that?
- 57:18>> What do you mean?
- 57:20>> Is it true that you just said that it's
- 57:22true?
- 57:25>> Even though we we can't actively sense
- 57:26it.
- 57:30>> Oh, you mean uh like in the past because
- 57:33it's in my memory.
- 57:34>> Well, well, more so just like any any of
- 57:36the claims that you've you've made.
- 57:38>> You should you should define what you
- 57:39mean by true. Then it would be simpler
- 57:41to understand.
- 57:43>> Yeah. an accurate representation of
- 57:45reality.
- 57:47>> Well, then no, because it would be a
- 57:49memory.
- 57:51>> Well, no, but but just like the ideas or
- 57:53the claims that you're making. So, like
- 57:55for example, when you say that you can
- 57:56only know things through your senses, is
- 57:58that true? Is that an accurate
- 57:59representation of reality or is it
- 58:01possibly not true?
- 58:04>> I already explained that it's it's true.
- 58:07What do you mean?
- 58:08>> Okay. Okay. So it's true but therefore
- 58:10you're saying something is objectively
- 58:12true which is immaterial and therefore
- 58:14immaterial realities exist.
- 58:16>> No not the statement just if I sense
- 58:18something that is the truth. That's what
- 58:19I mean. I think we are kind of talking
- 58:22>> the statement true.
- 58:23>> Is the statement true then?
- 58:25>> No not like I said you would have to
- 58:28define true because I think we are
- 58:29defining a different
- 58:30>> I already did. Okay.
- 58:31>> I already gave you my Okay. What? Okay.
- 58:33I didn't hear it.
- 58:35>> An accurate representation of reality.
- 58:37>> Okay then. No.
- 58:40>> So your entire worldview is not an
- 58:42accurate representation of reality.
- 58:43>> No. Yeah. The world view, the world
- 58:46anyway is imaginary. So anything that
- 58:49has to do with the world.
- 58:51>> Yeah. Because uh think about it.
- 58:53Whenever people talk about the world,
- 58:54they always talk about something
- 58:55imaginary. The world cup, the world
- 58:59records, they are nowhere to be found.
- 59:01They are completely in our minds. Well,
- 59:03where are they? It's completely
- 59:05imaginary.
- 59:06>> World.
- 59:07>> Yeah. For example, the World Cup World
- 59:08Cup.
- 59:09>> Is it real? Yeah. Is it Is it a real
- 59:12>> Yeah, I would say yeah, that the the
- 59:15World Cup is is something that happened.
- 59:16>> That's very interesting. No, of course
- 59:18not because it didn't it it doesn't
- 59:21exist in this reality.
- 59:24>> It's it's it's a over but it still
- 59:27happened.
- 59:27>> No. What do you mean? Football also
- 59:29doesn't exist.
- 59:31>> Football doesn't exist,
- 59:32>> of course. But where is
- 59:35>> Does God exist?
- 59:37Well, obviously not. It's just a it's a
- 59:40character.
- 59:41>> What do Well, okay. So, this is this is
- 59:44Do you 5 seconds ago exist?
- 59:47>> Well, there a time also doesn't exist.
- 59:52>> Okay. But but you do you believe that
- 59:54like the past exists?
- 59:55>> No, of course not. Because like I
- 59:57already
- 59:59after
- 59:59>> No, I already explained that to you
- 1:00:00before. If somebody close to you dies,
- 1:00:03then they are just a me memory because
- 1:00:06the way you knew them in the moment,
- 1:00:10it's it's gone. You just don't know.
- 1:00:12Right now, if you don't see the humans
- 1:00:14that you know, you don't know if they
- 1:00:16exist anymore. It's very unlikely, but
- 1:00:18they could be dead.
- 1:00:21>> Interesting. Okay. Well, so it kind of
- 1:00:23seems that this just leads into like a
- 1:00:25lot of absurdities. Like you can't say
- 1:00:26that any statement is true like
- 1:00:28objectively.
- 1:00:30It
- 1:00:31Well, if I if he define it the way you
- 1:00:34said it, it's it's only what I sense.
- 1:00:38>> So you would say that that you can't
- 1:00:39show that any statement is true.
- 1:00:42>> Yeah. Statement. No. If you mean an
- 1:00:44idea,
- 1:00:47it just depends.
- 1:00:47>> So then so then like what's the point of
- 1:00:50having like any debates or conversations
- 1:00:52because we can't prove that anything
- 1:00:53that we're saying is true.
- 1:00:54>> No, that's that's that's a very good
- 1:00:55point. That that was my whole point at
- 1:00:57the beginning. The only thing that you
- 1:00:59could do is refer to something that is
- 1:01:01real and I would still have to check it
- 1:01:03because uh you can only express your
- 1:01:06ideas and thoughts through sound or by
- 1:01:08writing down and then I can absorb that
- 1:01:10and do the best I possibly can. And so
- 1:01:13for example,
- 1:01:15if this would be a different discussion
- 1:01:16with somebody else and I would say that
- 1:01:18blood is the best uh drink on earth, he
- 1:01:21wouldn't know. He would have to try it.
- 1:01:23But we can at least refer to something
- 1:01:26real that we sense and then the other
- 1:01:29one can absorb the information the
- 1:01:31thoughts and they can do something with
- 1:01:34that. That's the best we can do. But you
- 1:01:36you could you will never be able to
- 1:01:38prove God to me through logic, ideas,
- 1:01:40thoughts.
- 1:01:42>> So I guess my question then is is you
- 1:01:45make YouTube videos where you go out and
- 1:01:46talk about statements, right? You talk
- 1:01:49about like the primal lifestyle. Um but
- 1:01:52you would say that none of those
- 1:01:53statements are true.
- 1:01:54>> No, you people have to go and do do it
- 1:01:58in real life. Yeah. So
- 1:02:00>> that's also a statement. You're saying
- 1:02:01you're saying that people have to go and
- 1:02:02do it. That's also a statement. And so
- 1:02:04you would say that that not even that is
- 1:02:05true.
- 1:02:06>> Yeah. Of course. Because all that all
- 1:02:08that people are doing when they watch my
- 1:02:09videos, they absorb my ideas, my
- 1:02:12beliefs. That's all that I can do. I
- 1:02:14can't give knowledge to people. I
- 1:02:16couldn't realize. Didn't you say that
- 1:02:18ideas? You did didn't you say that ideas
- 1:02:20aren't real either? They don't exist.
- 1:02:22>> They are they are not. That's what I
- 1:02:23mean. It's sounds.
- 1:02:24>> So then how do they
- 1:02:27>> How do they absorb things that don't
- 1:02:28exist?
- 1:02:29>> I explained that you interpret that
- 1:02:32languages don't exist. You interpret
- 1:02:34what the sounds are supposed to mean and
- 1:02:38then you try to get uh you interpret the
- 1:02:41sounds and you try to understand what
- 1:02:44the human being is saying, what kind of
- 1:02:46information he's trying to uh transfer
- 1:02:48or however you would call it and then
- 1:02:51you implement that in real life. So you
- 1:02:54actually do that. That's the only thing
- 1:02:55that I can do with my videos.
- 1:02:58>> Interesting. Okay. Well, um I I guess
- 1:03:02that's that's kind of all the questions
- 1:03:03I have for you. Is there any specific
- 1:03:05things that you want to question me on?
- 1:03:08>> Not necessarily question. I did want to
- 1:03:10discuss one thing which is how uh you
- 1:03:15know Christianity this ideology how it
- 1:03:17inverts everything and how uh for
- 1:03:20example when our senses tell us that uh
- 1:03:24blood tastes really good I assume that
- 1:03:25you've never had it but it's really the
- 1:03:27best tasting food drink on earth
- 1:03:31you do agree that uh in these texts uh
- 1:03:34whoever wrote it they try to make people
- 1:03:36believe that blood is sinful full bad.
- 1:03:42>> So, so I have tried blood. I I don't I'm
- 1:03:44not a fan of how it it tastes. It's kind
- 1:03:46of metallic. I I don't I don't prefer
- 1:03:49it. Um it's it's not something I'm into.
- 1:03:51I prefer like like steak um without the
- 1:03:54blood. Um but I I I do like like raw
- 1:03:57meat at times. Like I think like uh like
- 1:03:59like raw beef is is pretty good. I try
- 1:04:01to avoid like raw raw chicken, but but
- 1:04:03yeah. No, I'm not not fully against raw.
- 1:04:06>> Um
- 1:04:07>> yeah. Um how however um like when it
- 1:04:11comes to like drinking blood
- 1:04:14um typically it's it's like a ritual
- 1:04:16thing. It's less so like like a sinful
- 1:04:20condemnation. So like we we would say
- 1:04:21that there's nothing sinful about
- 1:04:23drinking like blood. Um but but more so
- 1:04:25it's what it symbolizes like it
- 1:04:27symbolizes life and um like like the the
- 1:04:31spirit of life flow flowing through
- 1:04:32someone. And so to drink it could be
- 1:04:35ritually or symbolically a violation of
- 1:04:37that life. Like it would be like taking
- 1:04:39life from someone. But we would we as
- 1:04:41Christians would say there's nothing
- 1:04:42wrong with drinking blood.
- 1:04:44>> Okay? Because the thing is that like n
- 1:04:48over 90% of the Christians that I've
- 1:04:50talked to, they do say that it's they
- 1:04:54they get kind of mad at you when you
- 1:04:56start talking about it. They do see it
- 1:04:57as sinful.
- 1:05:00>> Yeah. Well, well, I don't I'm a Catholic
- 1:05:02and there there's no condemnations
- 1:05:03against drinking blood.
- 1:05:05>> What about uh choosing God, Jesus, uh
- 1:05:10over your father or seeing uh those
- 1:05:13imaginary beings as something higher?
- 1:05:18>> Uh yeah, I do believe that that Jesus is
- 1:05:19is more important than my my father
- 1:05:21because he's God.
- 1:05:22>> That's pretty up, man.
- 1:05:25I still I still have great honor for my
- 1:05:27my father. Um, and I don't believe that
- 1:05:30I I would say in a perfect relationship
- 1:05:31with your father, those should those two
- 1:05:33should not contradict. Like I think your
- 1:05:35father should love Jesus in a way to
- 1:05:37where um like like you honor your father
- 1:05:39and by honoring your father, you honor
- 1:05:41Jesus.
- 1:05:43>> Interesting. Yeah, I just uh there was
- 1:05:46the only thing that I wrote down the
- 1:05:48only thing that I wanted to discuss. Uh
- 1:05:51yeah, there's also the
- 1:05:54repression of uh
- 1:05:57emotions. desires such as anger in
- 1:05:59certain situations,
- 1:06:02um forgiving the enemy, turning the
- 1:06:05cheek and whatnot, stuff like that. Uh
- 1:06:07just it just has a lot to do with
- 1:06:10suppressing
- 1:06:11your feelings, emotions. Uh not always,
- 1:06:14but sometimes.
- 1:06:17>> Yeah. So, so what I would say is that
- 1:06:18like a lot of emotions and desires are
- 1:06:20actually limitations in a certain c like
- 1:06:23a certain sense. Like I would say that
- 1:06:26maybe from like your naturalist
- 1:06:28standpoint, I'd say it's good to be
- 1:06:29free. And if you are constantly limited
- 1:06:32by emotions, you can't control your
- 1:06:33emotions, then I would say that you're
- 1:06:35like in a sense a slave to those
- 1:06:37emotions. Like if you get angry and you
- 1:06:39can't stop yourself from being angry, I
- 1:06:41say you're actually losing like your own
- 1:06:43choice. You're losing your free will.
- 1:06:45But I would say that there's so much
- 1:06:46more power in being able to um choose to
- 1:06:49be angry or choose to be happy or choose
- 1:06:51to be sad and being able to choose
- 1:06:53between these emotions and have control
- 1:06:54over yourself. I'd say that's more of a
- 1:06:56freedom than if you're just like a slave
- 1:06:58to your emotions and your desires.
- 1:07:00>> Control is freedom. It seems like
- 1:07:02opposites. That's interesting.
- 1:07:04>> Controlling controlling yourself, being
- 1:07:06able to use all of your powers. Yeah.
- 1:07:08>> No, I I get it. But uh yeah, I just see
- 1:07:12it as enslavement if you control
- 1:07:14yourself. But we don't need to get we
- 1:07:16don't we don't need to discuss this.
- 1:07:17It's just interesting to hear your
- 1:07:19perspective. What about uh fasting? Uh
- 1:07:23>> starving.
- 1:07:26>> I like fasting. I do it often.
- 1:07:28>> What do you mean you like it? You cannot
- 1:07:30like it.
- 1:07:32Well, well, I I like the um the rewards
- 1:07:36of it. And I I enjoy putting myself
- 1:07:38through difficult things and offering up
- 1:07:41uh pain for for other people. I think
- 1:07:43that's a good thing.
- 1:07:45>> Well, what do you mean for pain for
- 1:07:47other people?
- 1:07:49>> Yeah. So, so I think that that when you
- 1:07:50fast, it can be a way to unite yourself
- 1:07:53with with the suffering of somebody
- 1:07:54else. Um, so for example, it can be like
- 1:07:57it can be petitionary. Um, and so, so
- 1:07:59for example, like imagine like you have
- 1:08:01a friend who who like lost their their
- 1:08:03grandma or something like that. Um, you
- 1:08:05you go and you discuss with them and and
- 1:08:06you you empathize with them and you
- 1:08:08bring yourself into their suffering. So
- 1:08:09I think a way fasting can be a way to do
- 1:08:11that to like unite yourself with the
- 1:08:13suffering of the world and make you more
- 1:08:14more grounded in reality.
- 1:08:16>> Uh very interesting. Yeah. It's uh this
- 1:08:19mentality of weakness which is what I
- 1:08:22described before.
- 1:08:24>> What did I I thought you did fasting.
- 1:08:27>> I did many years ago. Yeah.
- 1:08:32>> What What was your experience like with
- 1:08:33fasting?
- 1:08:34>> It's horrible. I would never do it
- 1:08:36again. It just it just feels horrible.
- 1:08:38You completely have to yeah control
- 1:08:41yourself. You have to go against your
- 1:08:43nature, your instincts because your body
- 1:08:45tells you to eat and you restrict
- 1:08:47yourself. It's it's the worst thing
- 1:08:49ever.
- 1:08:52>> Yeah. Well, I agree. It's it's not fun
- 1:08:53in the moment, but I think the the
- 1:08:55reward of it is is very beneficial.
- 1:08:57Being able to control yourself, I think,
- 1:08:58gives you more freedom in the future. Um
- 1:09:00because then you can choose between
- 1:09:02different things. So like for example um
- 1:09:04like imagine like there's somebody
- 1:09:06always telling you what to do and always
- 1:09:08like forcing you to to choose a specific
- 1:09:10thing. I would say that that's not
- 1:09:11freedom. That's slavery. And so in a
- 1:09:13similar way, if you're allowing your
- 1:09:15your emotions and your desires to tell
- 1:09:17you what to do, you're just as much of a
- 1:09:19slave to those things as you are to
- 1:09:21somebody who's like actually enslaved.
- 1:09:22And I think the only way to escape that
- 1:09:24slavery is through having real
- 1:09:26self-control and being able to practice
- 1:09:27virtue when you please. I would define
- 1:09:30that as complete freedom but we just
- 1:09:32almost see things the opposite way. What
- 1:09:35about uh reproduction? We kind of
- 1:09:38already talked about that but not really
- 1:09:40because um religious people imagine
- 1:09:43marriage. Marriages don't exist and then
- 1:09:45they imagine that in their minds they
- 1:09:47somehow marry somebody because they sign
- 1:09:50some paper or put some ring on a finger
- 1:09:52whatever just some rituals imaginary
- 1:09:55abstract ideas.
- 1:09:58What about uh when you want to reproduce
- 1:10:02with somebody but you believe that
- 1:10:04you're married and you shouldn't or even
- 1:10:06more importantly what about girls and
- 1:10:09guy girls and guys who are like 18 maybe
- 1:10:13younger who want to reproduce already
- 1:10:16but don't do it because they believe
- 1:10:18that they need to wait for marriage.
- 1:10:21>> Yeah. I would say from like a naturalist
- 1:10:24standpoint like obviously I could say
- 1:10:25like you know the the church has said
- 1:10:27this the Bible says but that wouldn't do
- 1:10:29much. So from like a natural perspective
- 1:10:31um I would say that there is an
- 1:10:35inclination and a desire in humans to um
- 1:10:39preserve their bloodline and um that
- 1:10:42there's a pride that's taken when you
- 1:10:44have children and I think that's a
- 1:10:45really good thing. However, if you just
- 1:10:47have a bunch of children with a bunch of
- 1:10:49different women, um then those children
- 1:10:52aren't going to do well and they aren't
- 1:10:53going to glorify you or your bloodline.
- 1:10:56And so, I would say that the best way to
- 1:10:57ensure from a natural standpoint um that
- 1:11:01those children do well and that they
- 1:11:02they thrive and that they honor you and
- 1:11:04your bloodline would be by marrying um
- 1:11:07or just like committing yourself to one
- 1:11:09person and focusing on those children
- 1:11:11and raising them.
- 1:11:12>> Yeah. I just wanted to specifically hear
- 1:11:14about cuz I've heard of cases like this
- 1:11:17where girls really want to or guys also
- 1:11:20really want to reproduce and so they
- 1:11:23have a sort of boyfriend girlfriend but
- 1:11:25they believe that they're not supposed
- 1:11:26to be intimate so they try to do
- 1:11:29whatever they can but they they hold
- 1:11:33themselves back. This is what you would
- 1:11:35call strength because this is what how I
- 1:11:37define um slavery weakness.
- 1:11:42>> Yeah. Yeah. So, I would say I would say
- 1:11:43it's it's self-control. I wouldn't say
- 1:11:45it's weak. I think being able to control
- 1:11:46your desires is a form of strength. Just
- 1:11:49like if if there was something heavy on
- 1:11:50top of you, like pushing you down,
- 1:11:53giving up and letting it crush you would
- 1:11:55be something that is a weakness. But
- 1:11:57being able to stand up and and push back
- 1:11:58against it would be a strength. So, when
- 1:12:01like a desire is pushing down on you and
- 1:12:03and pinning you, if you just give up and
- 1:12:06let the desire overtake you, then I
- 1:12:07would say that's weak. But if you stand
- 1:12:09up against it um and you push against it
- 1:12:11and that would be strength. And so I
- 1:12:12would say somebody who maybe has a
- 1:12:14desire that they they believe is not the
- 1:12:16right thing to do well they they would
- 1:12:18be a stronger person for standing up
- 1:12:19against that rather than getting
- 1:12:20crushed.
- 1:12:22>> Interesting. Yeah. Yeah. We we see
- 1:12:24things the opposite way. It's pretty
- 1:12:26interesting.
- 1:12:28All right. Yeah. No, that that was uh
- 1:12:30all. Uh
- 1:12:32um let me just check if there were any
- 1:12:35points, but I think we pretty much
- 1:12:36discussed everything. Uh
- 1:12:39is there anything else you wanted to
- 1:12:41ask? No.
- 1:12:42>> Yeah, I think I think that's good. I
- 1:12:44think we we covered everything. Um I
- 1:12:45appreciate you coming on and and this
- 1:12:47this was a fun conversation to say.
- 1:12:49>> I uh I did did want to say one thing uh
- 1:12:51to your viewers or whoever is watching
- 1:12:54this. If anything that I said uh
- 1:12:58gave you some thoughts uh if maybe after
- 1:13:02this video you will think about things
- 1:13:04and maybe something that I said makes
- 1:13:06sense to you. I very very strongly
- 1:13:09recommend
- 1:13:11stopping eating seeds that means bread,
- 1:13:13pasta, cookies. They really poison us
- 1:13:16with this stuff. It really clouds your
- 1:13:18mind. I believe that this is the number
- 1:13:20one reason why people even follow
- 1:13:22religions. I don't believe that a human
- 1:13:24being who actually eats liver, brain,
- 1:13:26drinks, blood would even be able to
- 1:13:28because they would be completely
- 1:13:30grounded in reality. So even if you
- 1:13:33don't start eating raw meat, just
- 1:13:35cutting out all seeds, rice and
- 1:13:37everything, lentils because it's
- 1:13:39absolute famine, starvation food, you
- 1:13:42will be able to think a lot clearer if
- 1:13:44you do that. And u I'm not even saying
- 1:13:47that you need to watch my videos or go
- 1:13:48on my channel. This is not a promotion
- 1:13:50of my videos. I'm just really saying it
- 1:13:53uh for your own sake and yeah for people
- 1:13:57because uh people are very lost and u
- 1:14:01insane. Most people are insane. I do
- 1:14:03believe that
- 1:14:05over 90% of people have a light form of
- 1:14:08schizophrenia. That's how messed up it
- 1:14:10is nowadays.
- 1:14:12>> I would agree. Schizophrenia is a a big
- 1:14:15problem.
- 1:14:15>> Um but maybe we would disagree on on who
- 1:14:17it affects. Um, yeah, you guys heard it
- 1:14:20here. Seed seeds are are bad for you. I
- 1:14:23would actually agree. Seed oils probably
- 1:14:25not the best go-to. Um, eat healthy, but
- 1:14:28we probably disagree on on what is
- 1:14:29healthy and what's not healthy.
- 1:14:30>> Well, yeah. Thank you for coming on.
- 1:14:32>> You do eat some uh good food. I guess uh
- 1:14:37one more thing uh I would like to say is
- 1:14:40that uh
- 1:14:43just one question actually. Do you
- 1:14:44believe that focusing on God and Jesus
- 1:14:47uh all those uh main beliefs the faith
- 1:14:50that you have is that the most important
- 1:14:53thing or would it be more important to f
- 1:14:56focus on still what is real and uh you
- 1:14:59know how I define that by what we can
- 1:15:01sense
- 1:15:03>> yeah I would say that that focusing on
- 1:15:05God which I believe is is real um but
- 1:15:08maybe not material I would say yeah
- 1:15:09that's much more important than anything
- 1:15:11else
- 1:15:12>> right because Uh, it's just one thing. A
- 1:15:15lot of your subscribers who probably
- 1:15:18take what you say really seriously, they
- 1:15:20may be in their 20s now, probably pretty
- 1:15:22young, I assume, they will eventually
- 1:15:25have children and their children will
- 1:15:28still deal with real problems.
- 1:15:31No matter if they believe in God or
- 1:15:32Jesus, for example,
- 1:15:34>> their children if they don't eat natural
- 1:15:36foods, if they are not breastfed for
- 1:15:38long enough, they will need braces
- 1:15:41because the skulls will be too narrow.
- 1:15:43Glasses because the eye sockets, they uh
- 1:15:46squeeze the eyeballs and the eyeballs
- 1:15:48become long instead of round the way
- 1:15:50they are supposed to be. And then you
- 1:15:52need glasses to try to deal with the
- 1:15:54symptom of a underdeveloped or deformed
- 1:15:57skull. My point is simp that's just two
- 1:16:00examples. My point is simply that your
- 1:16:02subscribers will still have to deal with
- 1:16:04real issues and these people will not
- 1:16:07have uh much success with women or the
- 1:16:10women with men although women have it
- 1:16:12easier to be fair and a lot of real life
- 1:16:15issues even if they live in the system
- 1:16:18getting a job will be harder is my point
- 1:16:21is simply that real this real life what
- 1:16:24we can sense the real problems that we
- 1:16:26deal with those are all that matter.
- 1:16:30matters. We have opposite views
- 1:16:32obviously. But I just wanted to put that
- 1:16:33out that
- 1:16:35e even if you want to believe in God or
- 1:16:38Jesus whatever if it doesn't affect your
- 1:16:41real life if you don't go against your
- 1:16:43nature which is what this satanic
- 1:16:45religion Christianity promotes then uh
- 1:16:49well at least simply follow your senses
- 1:16:53and really listen completely to what
- 1:16:55your eyeballs your ears uh uh well the
- 1:16:59brain what it actually tells you when
- 1:17:01you sense something even if you want to
- 1:17:04believe in God and so on and heaven
- 1:17:07still at the very least completely
- 1:17:09follow your nature and then you won't
- 1:17:12have to deal with all of the real life
- 1:17:13issues. Eventually you will realize that
- 1:17:16the real life issues are all that
- 1:17:17matters. Yeah, that's all that I want to
- 1:17:19say.
- 1:17:21>> All right. Well, thank you for coming
- 1:17:22on, man. This was this was a good combo.
- 1:17:23>> Yeah, man. Thank you.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Goatis vs. Jesus and Whatnot - The Christianity Debate by Goatis, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 14,220 words across 2,083 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.