Gli eroi del Risorgimento: Mazzini, Garibaldi, Benso di Cavour — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Welcome. In this video lesson, we will
- 0:03talk about the most important figures
- 0:05of the Italian Risorgimento, the period
- 0:07preceding and leading up to the
- 0:09creation of the Kingdom of Italy. So,
- 0:12roughly, we are looking at the years
- 0:15between 1815 and 1870. But before I
- 0:20tell you who these three figures are, I
- 0:22invite you to take notes on this video
- 0:24lesson using the Cornell method. For
- 0:27this, if you haven't seen the lesson on
- 0:29the Cornell method, go back and watch
- 0:31it. If you have already seen it, get
- 0:34some paper, a pen, a ruler, create the
- 0:36Cornell diagram, and continue following
- 0:39this lesson by trying to take notes.
- 0:42Well, as we were saying, who are these
- 0:44three great figures of the Italian
- 0:46Risorgimento? I am referring to
- 0:49Giuseppe Mazzini, Giuseppe Garibaldi,
- 0:51and Camillo Benso di Cavour. They are
- 0:56three very different characters with
- 0:58very different histories and cultural
- 1:00backgrounds, yet they are united by the
- 1:02historical events they experienced
- 1:04regarding Italy. Mazzini is the
- 1:08ideologue of the Risorgimento, the one
- 1:10who dictated the moral vision of a
- 1:12united Italy, and his thought shaped
- 1:15generations of patriots. Garibaldi is
- 1:18the Hero of the Two Worlds, a guerrilla
- 1:20fighter, a man of action, a man of
- 1:22adventure, a person who was in many
- 1:24ways reckless and imprudent, with
- 1:26little political conscience to tell the
- 1:28truth, but we can say he was the
- 1:30fighting soul of the Risorgimento. The
- 1:33third figure is Camillo Benso, Count of
- 1:36Cavour. And he is of an entirely
- 1:38different temper. He is a fine
- 1:40politician, an excellent diplomat, a
- 1:42cynic, a pragmatist; he handles
- 1:44politics like few others, and he
- 1:46managed to achieve everything possible
- 1:49in that historical period. Let's start,
- 1:53however, with Giuseppe Mazzini.
- 1:55Giuseppe Mazzini was born in Genoa on
- 1:58June 22, 1805, into a cultured
- 2:01middle-class family. His father was a
- 2:04doctor, his mother was very religious,
- 2:06and they encouraged him toward legal
- 2:08studies, so much so that he earned a
- 2:10law degree at the University of Genoa.
- 2:13While still very young, around the year
- 2:15of his graduation, he joined the
- 2:17Carbonari. His first conspiratorial
- 2:21experience, let's say, didn't go very
- 2:23well because he was arrested; but
- 2:25beyond the arrest, he realized that the
- 2:27Carbonari's methods didn't suit him:
- 2:30for him, it didn't work because it was
- 2:32too aristocratic an association. It
- 2:35drew inspiration from foreign models,
- 2:37seeking to obtain a Constitution on
- 2:39principle without taking into account
- 2:41the specific conditions of Italy. It
- 2:45didn't draw inspiration from the people
- 2:47at all and, as we said, was an elitist
- 2:49movement, which is why he broke
- 2:51permanently with the Carbonari to then
- 2:53create his own association. What are
- 2:56the ideas that characterize him? In
- 2:58other words, why didn't he get along
- 2:59with the Carbonari? I mean, he has a
- 3:02vision of the only form of legitimate
- 3:04power created by Democracy and the
- 3:06Republic. Meaning, for him, national
- 3:10unity must be created through a popular
- 3:13insurrection. He says that every people
- 3:17has the right to their own homeland, so
- 3:19he emphasizes the people and not the
- 3:21monarch. Okay? Um, he therefore thinks
- 3:25it is the people who must act to create
- 3:28this unity. And he sees God, people,
- 3:31humanity, fraternity, and brotherhood
- 3:34as his points of reference. He refuses
- 3:38any compromise with the monarchy,
- 3:40whether with that of Charles Albert or
- 3:42later Victor Emmanuel, but also with
- 3:44European monarchies, which will lead
- 3:46him to be politically very isolated and
- 3:49sought after almost everywhere. In 1831
- 3:54, while in exile, he founded Young
- 3:56Italy in Marseille, which is a secret
- 3:58association through which he tries to
- 4:00create a movement of popular
- 4:02insurrection; he communicates his ideas
- 4:05, that is, he spreads propaganda
- 4:07through pamphlets, clandestine
- 4:08proclamations, and letters, managing to
- 4:11create a widespread network throughout
- 4:13Italy. He manages to have them open in
- 4:17various cities, mainly large cities,
- 4:19where there is at least a university,
- 4:22because his ideas, as we will see, are
- 4:24very refined and educated. Um, he
- 4:26manages to have several clandestine
- 4:28circles opened in different Italian
- 4:30cities; how does the method work,
- 4:32practically? He sends one of his most
- 4:35loyal followers into a city, who begins
- 4:37to create a network of supporters,
- 4:39creating a circle. Then, some of these
- 4:43followers will detach from the original
- 4:45cell to create another in a pyramidal
- 4:47system. Well, this will lead Young
- 4:51Italy to have branches in all the major
- 4:53Italian cities. Shortly after, that is,
- 4:562 years later, they will organize the
- 4:58first insurrectional movements. And
- 5:00it's a huge blow, truly a blow for
- 5:02Mazzini, because let's be honest,
- 5:04nothing will go right for him. In 1833,
- 5:07the uprisings in Piedmont begin, only
- 5:09to be crushed. In 1844, the Bandiera
- 5:12brothers will try to create an
- 5:14insurrection in Calabria and will be
- 5:16executed by firing squad. In 1845, the
- 5:18members of his association, Young Italy
- 5:21, will try again with an uprising in
- 5:23Emilia-Romagna. There, too, they will
- 5:27be killed by Austrian troops. So,
- 5:30clearly, Mazzini is, let's say, very
- 5:33demoralized. When Charles Albert fights
- 5:38the First War of Independence in 1848,
- 5:40Mazzini will want to bring his
- 5:42democrats and republicans there, but
- 5:44Charles Albert will absolutely have
- 5:46none of it and will keep the democrats
- 5:48and republicans far from the front and
- 5:50far from the army. This marks a rupture
- 5:55between Mazzini, if one were even
- 5:57needed, and Charles Albert, and later
- 5:59Victor Emmanuel as well. There is
- 6:03therefore a real break because Mazzini
- 6:05will realize that Piedmont does not
- 6:06want an Italy of the people, but
- 6:08fundamentally wants to extend its own
- 6:10rule. Thus he began to conspire against
- 6:13the Savoy monarchy. His network was
- 6:17discovered, and he was sentenced to
- 6:18death. He wasn't physically in Italy,
- 6:21but the sentence meant that if he were
- 6:23to set foot in Italy again, he would be
- 6:26arrested and then executed. For this
- 6:28reason, he had to go into permanent
- 6:30exile, traveling between France,
- 6:32Switzerland, and England, where he
- 6:35lived, so to speak, a moment of deep
- 6:37anguish, believing he had truly gotten
- 6:39everything wrong. After a few years,
- 6:44however, he returned, this time
- 6:46creating a new association, Young
- 6:48Europe, in which he proposed an
- 6:49international alliance of democratic
- 6:51movements and solidarity among
- 6:53oppressed peoples who must rebel
- 6:55against foreign rule or their own
- 6:57sovereigns when they do not grant a
- 6:59Constitution or are not attentive to
- 7:01the needs of the people. So, his
- 7:05movement and his ideas went from being
- 7:07national to becoming international, or
- 7:10at any rate, European. Mazzini likely
- 7:14had a great moment of happiness in 1849
- 7:17, when the Roman Republic was created;
- 7:19he went to Rome, provided a
- 7:21Constitution, and led the Roman
- 7:23Republic. Alas, an experience that
- 7:28would last only a few months, and
- 7:30indeed, after about two or three months
- 7:32, he had to leave Italy once again. So,
- 7:35we will see that this man spent more
- 7:37time abroad than in Italy, and we are
- 7:39talking about one of the fathers of
- 7:41unified Italy. And we can say that
- 7:44Mazzini was unlucky, at least until
- 7:461850. Yes, we can say that, because his
- 7:49insurrectionary movements were not
- 7:51suited to the Italian context. He was
- 7:55probably too far ahead of his time; he
- 7:57was already thinking about a grassroots
- 7:59movement when there was barely an
- 8:01Italian middle class with political
- 8:03awareness, so he was probably too far
- 8:05ahead for his time, and perhaps I might
- 8:08add, even for our own time. So his
- 8:11ideas were extraordinarily ahead of
- 8:13their time, yet he lacked the support
- 8:16of the popular masses, who did not
- 8:18understand his message or viewed with
- 8:20suspicion the attempt to overturn a
- 8:22regime, the monarchical regime, that
- 8:24had lasted in Italy for several
- 8:26centuries. Mazzini probably
- 8:29overestimated the masses and, above all
- 8:31, the Italian people. Furthermore, he
- 8:34stood in opposition both to the
- 8:36European powers with his Young Europe,
- 8:38and also to the Church, and he always
- 8:40refused to compromise with both Italian
- 8:42and foreign monarchies. For this reason
- 8:46, essentially, he was politically very
- 8:48isolated. Nevertheless, his ideas
- 8:51shaped a generation of patriots, and if
- 8:54Italy has, so to speak, its own moral
- 8:56code, and if Italy was eventually
- 8:58created in a certain way, we also owe
- 9:01that to the ideas of Mazzini. The
- 9:04second figure is Giuseppe Garibaldi,
- 9:06slightly younger, just two years apart.
- 9:09He was born in Nice on July 4, 1807,
- 9:11into a family of sailors, which gave
- 9:14him a maritime background; he was a
- 9:16merchant marine captain with a free and
- 9:18adventurous spirit. In short, he was
- 9:21always in need of adventure and sought
- 9:23it out everywhere. He listened to and
- 9:27read Mazzini—or rather, he read his
- 9:29proclamations and messages—and fell
- 9:32in love with Mazzinian ideas, which led
- 9:34him to join Young Italy in 1833. He
- 9:39participated in the uprisings in
- 9:41Piedmont, was sentenced to death by the
- 9:43Kingdom of Sardinia precisely for his
- 9:45involvement, and had to go into exile
- 9:47to escape the sentence. He would spend
- 9:5214 years of exile in South America
- 9:54fighting against Brazilian and
- 9:56Uruguayan regimes. He fought alongside
- 10:02republican, popular, and liberal
- 10:04movements against governments he
- 10:05considered despotic, as these ideas
- 10:08came directly from Mazzini. In 1848, he
- 10:13returned to Italy when Charles Albert
- 10:15decided to undertake what would be
- 10:17called the First War of Independence,
- 10:20and he offered his help to Charles
- 10:22Albert. He said, "Look, I know what I'm
- 10:25doing, allow me to help you." Charles
- 10:27Albert initially refused; he didn't
- 10:29trust a revolutionary, after all, he
- 10:31had been sentenced to death, right? He
- 10:34was a Mazzinian, so Charles Albert
- 10:36viewed him with great suspicion, but
- 10:38eventually, he agreed to have his
- 10:40support for the cause, and Garibaldi
- 10:43would lead a group of volunteers in
- 10:45operations against Austria, and to be
- 10:47fair, he performed very well. He was an
- 10:51expert in military tactics. As we
- 10:54mentioned, in 1849 he would participate
- 10:56in the Roman Republic and defend it
- 10:59against external attacks. However, it
- 11:03was mostly against the French, but this
- 11:06defense did not succeed; Rome was
- 11:08besieged, there was heroic resistance,
- 11:10several people died, but eventually,
- 11:13Rome fell. In these circumstances, his
- 11:18beloved companion near Ravenna, Anita
- 11:20Garibaldi, his wife and partner in a
- 11:22thousand battles, would also die, as
- 11:24his wife had fought with him both in
- 11:27South America and in Italy. Anita would
- 11:31die during this retreat from Rome.
- 11:35Let's say Garibaldi was extremely good
- 11:37at creating his own legend. Well, some
- 11:41things are a bit romanticized, but he
- 11:43really was a very capable person. He
- 11:50had developed enviable guerrilla
- 11:52techniques, especially in Uruguay and
- 11:54Brazil, and he had created the myth of
- 11:56the romantic warrior around himself,
- 11:59and his marriage to Anita was also,
- 12:01well, it was romantic, right? He was
- 12:07talked about a lot, so he was able to
- 12:09build this personal legend around
- 12:11himself, made of some invented things,
- 12:13but, well, many true things as well.
- 12:16For example, he survived a shipwreck,
- 12:18or in Brazil, he was captured by royal
- 12:20troops, was tortured for a long time,
- 12:23and then managed to escape. During a
- 12:25battle, he was pierced in the throat by
- 12:28an arrow, and his partner—I don't
- 12:30know if they were married yet, but
- 12:32anyway, Anita—literally dragged him
- 12:34to safety. And Anita, well, we've
- 12:36talked about her several times, maybe
- 12:38let's give a few details. Anita was the
- 12:40wife of a shoemaker; she was 18 when
- 12:43Garibaldi first saw her. They spoke,
- 12:46they probably met a few times, they
- 12:48fell in love, and at a certain point,
- 12:51Anita left her husband to run away with
- 12:53Garibaldi. Um, there are, let's say,
- 12:57mutual benefits or reasons why the two
- 13:00fell in love. Garibaldi saw in her a
- 13:03woman highly skilled in the arts of
- 13:05combat. She knew how to ride a horse
- 13:08much better than some of Garibaldi's
- 13:09soldiers. She knew how to shoot very
- 13:12well, and Anita saw in Garibaldi the
- 13:14possibility of a better life. There was
- 13:16an age gap; she was 18, he was 32—do
- 13:19the math. Um, she saw in him a great
- 13:22hero, so she followed him, and she
- 13:24followed him until her death. They had
- 13:26four children together, and it seems
- 13:28that even when she was pregnant, she
- 13:30followed her husband into battle. Um,
- 13:32so we said: Garibaldi was a great
- 13:34military man, a great fighter, assisted
- 13:37as long as he could by his wife, until
- 13:40death parted them. However, from a
- 13:43political point of view, he was very
- 13:45naive, and it seems he was also
- 13:47influenced by Cavour, especially when
- 13:49he conquered Southern Italy and then
- 13:51handed it over to Victor Emmanuel. We
- 13:56can therefore say that, while he was
- 13:58tactically very skillful, his political
- 14:01vision was weak and lacked autonomy; he
- 14:03was a person, as we said, rash and
- 14:05imprudent, and in short, Cavour would
- 14:07understand this weak point of his and
- 14:10use it to his own advantage—or rather
- 14:12, not exactly Cavour's, but to the
- 14:14advantage of the Kingdom of Sardinia.
- 14:18Let's get to the third character,
- 14:20Camillo Benso, Count of Cavour. Um, he
- 14:22is the smallest of the three. He was
- 14:25born on August 10, 1810, in Turin and
- 14:28is the son of one of the richest
- 14:30families in Piedmont, right? His father
- 14:32was a marquis. He would also become one
- 14:35in his turn later on. Um, he would
- 14:37attend the Military Academy and be
- 14:39enlisted, but he would not participate
- 14:41in any battle because he worked in the
- 14:43civil engineering corps, so he was
- 14:45primarily employed in engineering or
- 14:47defensive activities. At a certain
- 14:49point, however, he leaves the army to
- 14:51dedicate himself to agricultural
- 14:53entrepreneurship, and there too he
- 14:55proves to be a skilled innovator, very
- 14:57adept at finding new forms, making
- 14:59agriculture increasingly closer to what
- 15:02we can define as industrial agriculture
- 15:04, very attentive to production, very
- 15:06attentive to techniques, in short. He
- 15:09will found the newspaper Il
- 15:10Risorgimento in 1847, in which he
- 15:13spreads liberal ideas. Well, how does
- 15:16one go from being a skilled
- 15:18agricultural entrepreneur to a
- 15:19political figure? Well, in 1848 he is
- 15:22elected to the Chamber, and a few years
- 15:25later, in 1850, he becomes Minister of
- 15:28Agriculture and Commerce. But it is
- 15:30only the first step, because he has
- 15:32great ambitions. When he is Minister of
- 15:34Agriculture and Commerce, he promotes
- 15:37laws on free trade and economic
- 15:38innovation; in short, he makes a name
- 15:41for himself, but above all, he begins
- 15:43to forge parliamentary alliances. And
- 15:45it is thanks to these alliances that,
- 15:48in 1852, he will succeed in getting
- 15:50himself elected Prime Minister. What
- 15:53does he do in this year? 1852 is a
- 15:57turning point for him; he manages to
- 15:59bring together the center-right and the
- 16:01center-left and to gain the support of
- 16:03both of these factions, so in November
- 16:061852 he will become Prime Minister,
- 16:08thus achieving great success and also
- 16:10obtaining a stable parliamentary
- 16:12majority. What is his method? He is a
- 16:17very pragmatic person; he is not
- 16:19influenced by ideologies. If he needs
- 16:21support, he creates that support; he is
- 16:24a realist, isn't he? He has an
- 16:26entrepreneurial mindset and also
- 16:28approaches politics with an
- 16:30entrepreneurial mindset, and he has
- 16:32extraordinary tactical flexibility; he
- 16:34adapts means to objectives, forging
- 16:36alliances even with people with whom he
- 16:39wouldn't normally get along, but if it
- 16:41can be useful to his cause, well, it's
- 16:43worth creating an alliance. He will
- 16:47know how to do this in Parliament, in
- 16:49the Kingdom of Sardinia, with other
- 16:51Italian monarchies, and even—as we
- 16:54will see in a future video lesson—
- 16:56with foreign powers. His strength is
- 17:00precisely this strategic vision, this
- 17:02capacity for long-term planning. And
- 17:05then he is very skilled not only in
- 17:07understanding internal dynamics and
- 17:09grasping, for example, the weaknesses
- 17:11and strengths of those around him;
- 17:13let's think, for example, of what he
- 17:15did with Garibaldi, okay? But he is
- 17:16also very skilled at understanding how
- 17:19to move within the European context. He
- 17:22anticipates the mechanisms of
- 17:23capitalism and the liberal state. What
- 17:26does he do? He uses everything he can
- 17:30legally use—that is, all the power
- 17:32his office allows him—to reach his
- 17:34objectives. So, he is an extraordinary
- 17:39politician. Certainly, he has some weak
- 17:41points. For example, he has an elitist
- 17:43vision of the unification of Italy; he
- 17:45does not consider Southern Italy—that
- 17:48is, he does not understand the dynamics
- 17:50of Southern Italy. He wants the Kingdom
- 17:53of Sardinia to expand fundamentally,
- 17:55and he can no longer quite grasp the
- 17:57dynamics of other territories, nor does
- 17:59he think the people should have a say.
- 18:03In fact, the unification of Italy was
- 18:05driven from above without mass
- 18:07participation, and it has a difficult
- 18:09relationship with democracy because it
- 18:12is very distrustful of popular power.
- 18:16We have thus seen the strengths and
- 18:17weaknesses of these three figures. We
- 18:20have reached the end. What do Mazzini,
- 18:23Garibaldi, and Camillo Benso di Cavour
- 18:25still have in common? Well, they are
- 18:27united by a paradoxical and cruel end.
- 18:31Giuseppe Mazzini would live longer
- 18:33abroad than in Italy. He would manage
- 18:36to return to Italy in disguise, posing
- 18:38as a doctor with fake documents in 1872
- 18:41. Meanwhile, the Kingdom of Italy had
- 18:45been created; there was a sketch of a
- 18:47united Italy, he returned in secret,
- 18:50and would die after a few months, if
- 18:52I'm not mistaken, 23 days. He would die
- 18:55at the home of friends due to, I
- 18:57believe, kidney disease, or at any rate
- 18:59, health issues. He would be in Italy
- 19:03clandestinely because he was
- 19:05fundamentally still under a death
- 19:07sentence, he had to hide, and he would
- 19:09be poor; that is, he would live and die
- 19:11in poverty. Giuseppe Garibaldi also
- 19:15faced a cruel end because, after
- 19:16conquering half of Italy and handing
- 19:19Southern Italy over to the House of
- 19:21Savoy, to Victor Emmanuel, he would
- 19:23suffer the insult of being considered
- 19:25an enemy of the homeland. That is,
- 19:27paradoxically, he who helped build it
- 19:29would become an internal enemy and
- 19:31opponent and therefore, as it were, he
- 19:33would live—because he is the one who
- 19:36lived the longest—he would live his
- 19:38last years knowing he was considered an
- 19:40enemy of that very kingdom he helped
- 19:42found. Camillo Benso di Cavour, three
- 19:44months after the unification of Italy,
- 19:47would die of health issues, likely from
- 19:49malarial fever. So, Italy had unified,
- 19:53and he was still in government just
- 19:55when his practical imprint and
- 19:57political touch were needed to build
- 19:59and organize this kingdom. Meanwhile,
- 20:03riots broke out in Southern Italy. And
- 20:06right at that moment, Camillo Benso di
- 20:08Cavour died. So, as we have seen, these
- 20:12are three linked figures who more or
- 20:14less lived during the same period. All
- 20:17three participated in the events that
- 20:19led to the unification of Italy, and
- 20:21all three met a rather cruel end. Well,
- 20:25at the end of this video lesson, I will
- 20:28give you the solution; I will show you
- 20:30a Cornell diagram of what we have
- 20:31discussed. That is all, thank you for
- 20:35your attention. Enjoy the rest of your
- 20:37studies. In this video lesson, we
- 20:40discussed three figures who defined the
- 20:42Italian Risorgimento and made the
- 20:45unification of Italy possible between
- 20:471815 and 1870. Giuseppe Mazzini was the
- 20:51ideologue of the Risorgimento, born in
- 20:53Genoa in 1805. He developed the
- 20:55theoretical principles of the Italian
- 20:57Risorgimento. With Young Italy, he
- 21:00spread republican and democratic ideals
- 21:02, firmly believing in popular
- 21:04insurrection. Too far ahead of his time
- 21:07, he lived more abroad than in Italy
- 21:10and died poor and in hiding. Giuseppe
- 21:12Garibaldi, the Hero of the Two Worlds,
- 21:14was born in Nice in 1807. He embodied
- 21:17the courage, action, and fighting
- 21:19spirit of the Risorgimento. After 14
- 21:21years of exile in South America, he
- 21:23returned to conquer Southern Italy with
- 21:26his legendary guerrilla tactics.
- 21:28Militarily skilled, but politically
- 21:30naive, he was skillfully maneuvered by
- 21:32Cavour. Camillo Benzo di Cavour, the
- 21:35count from Turin born in 1810,
- 21:37represented the political realism of
- 21:40the Risorgimento. Prime Minister from
- 21:431852, with his extraordinary diplomatic
- 21:46skill and entrepreneurial mindset, he
- 21:48built Italy through strategic alliances
- 21:51and pragmatic compromises. Destiny
- 21:54reserved a cruel and paradoxical end
- 21:56for all three of them. Mazzini died in
- 21:59Pisa while living in hiding. Garibaldi
- 22:02was considered an enemy of the nation
- 22:04he had helped to create. Cavour died a
- 22:06few months after the birth of the
- 22:08Kingdom of Italy. Three men, three
- 22:11approaches, three different
- 22:12personalities united by great history.
- 22:15M.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Gli eroi del Risorgimento: Mazzini, Garibaldi, Benso di Cavour by profbrunogio, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,404 words across 537 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.